Central Fund Bill, 1937—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 164–315 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1937 ›
The Deputy seems always anxious to help, but let us have just one thing at a time. As I was saying, Deputy Mulcahy described them as backyard workshops, but he has ceased to describe them as backyard workshops. He does not now want to know where are the 500 factories. The Deputy is well aware that the factories are there. The policy adopted by the Deputy and his Party now is to do everything possible to undermine the success of these industries. On every occasion when a Bill is brought in here seeking to give adequate protection to an industry that has started, it is suggested by Deputies opposite that all our factories are not being worked for the benefit of the Irish people but rather for the benefit of a lot of aliens. Nobody knows where those particular factories are, except Deputy Mulcahy. We are told that these factories have been established merely for the purpose of giving these people increased profits and that the workers are getting very little out of them. I would advise Deputy Mulcahy to read the balance sheet of the Industrial Credit Corporation and to observe there how many industries that institution has helped to float, not alone for the benefit of the workers who get employment there, but for the benefit of the Irish citizens who have a certain amount of capital invested.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy Mulcahy to read it very carefully and not construe the plusses into minuses as he has construed felt hats into paper hats. I would ask the Deputy to read it very carefully and digest it. I believe there are still some Deputies on the opposite benches who would like to see this country developing normally towards a prosperous and happy future. On the other hand, there are some Deputies there who do not want anything like that. That was exemplified recently here when a Deputy said that if we could only settle the economic war he would fall into line with us.
Comment on this
He declared that if we settled the economic war he would do everything except vote for us or support us in the election. Anything that might tend to bring us credit as a political Party is something that you people over there must oppose. You try to destroy everything that we build up for the benefit of the people. Anything constructive we do, you endeavour to pull it down for fear it would give us an extra lease of life as a political Party, and, at the same time, render the possibility of Cumann na nGaedheal or Fine Gael coming back as a Government less likely than ever.
Comment on this
I hope that Deputy O'Leary, when he goes on the hustings very shortly, will repeat that remark. I hope his interjection will be published—that you are quite happy where you are.
Comment on this
We are getting our stuff in all right; we are showing you up properly, and we are not getting tired either.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton spoke a couple of days ago on this matter, and instead of discussing the existing situation in the country he brought in a lot of extraneous matter, including the Spanish war. There is one thing to which I would like to make special reference. The Deputy attacked the community who are of the same faith to which I belong. He said that these people were all Communists, and if they were not actually Communists they were spreading Communist propaganda. I want to place on the records of this House a strong protest against any such suggestion. I want to say that any person who professes any religion cannot be a Communist, and I want to emphasise that people of my persuasion cannot be and are not Communists. Any suggestion to the effect that they are is absolutely untrue, and it is also an absolutely untrue thing to say that they are spreading Communist propaganda. The people of my faith in this country are good citizens who recognise their responsibility to the State and they are prepared to share the joys and the sorrows of their fellow-citizens. They have shown that in the past when they have taken their part in the struggle for this country's independence.
There are many people who hold Unionist views and independent views. Deputies on the opposite benches have had the support of those people; the Deputies on these benches have not had that support. I think it is most uncalled for that Deputy Belton should introduce such a matter into the debates in this House. I want to express my appreciation to those Deputies who protested against it, especially Deputy Norton, the leader of the Labour Party. I think it is a scandalous thing for any Deputy to try to introduce religious differences. The efforts of all the people in this country, no matter what their political views may be, should be directed towards building up the prosperity of the State and helping in every way towards the betterment of the conditions of people less fortunate. We should see if we cannot get together to improve things rather than bring about the introduction of dangerous elements into the life of the country which might result in a situation such as exists at the present time in Spain. Having made my protest, I want to leave the matter at that and I will revert to the subject under discussion.
Again I want to say that the Government have, as the Central Fund Bill shows, improved social services for the majority of the people. It is not a Government, as has been stated by Deputy Dillon, anxious to strip the poor. That expression on the part of Deputy Dillon typifies the mentality of Deputies opposite, who declare that we are out to strip the poor. When we took office the poor were very poor; they had not even the maintenance they are having now. The Government's efforts are directed towards normal developments with a view to absorbing people into the industrial and agricultural life of the country. They desire to give the people who have money to invest an opportunity of investing it in their own land and so contribute to the uplifting of the country in every way.
The matter of emigration is thrown in our faces. We admit there is emigration and we regret it, but there will always be emigration when you have abnormal conditions attracting people. In the meantime it is our business to improve the conditions of the working man, to improve the conditions of the man in industry. When Deputy Norton was speaking he forgot to mention that while there is a lot of agreement on all sides of the House that certain agricultural workers are getting very low rates of wages, in fact too low, a board is to be set up to inquire into all that and to regulate it on a better basis. That board has not yet got to work, although I believe nominations have been made in practically every area and efforts are being made to deal with the situation as far as agricultural wages are concerned. Then we have trade boards to inquire into and suggest regulations to control employment in every industry. The Government are not out to create what Deputy O'Leary interjected—sweat shops.
Comment on this
In every country where there is industrial development you will find unscrupulous employers and it is up to us to find these people and to make them toe the line. There probably have been sweat shops in this country; they were here before the existence of Fianna Fáil. The elimination of them will become easier when the industries which are now becoming recognised industries are co-ordinated and regulated and rules laid down for them. The Conditions of Employment Act will stop the sweatshop system. We take credit for introducing that Act and we are prepared to enforce it. Deputy Norton said he was aware as regards industries that very little, if any, employment was given to adult males. I have had association with some and I have visited other industries which have been started and I must say that, in my opinion, a great deal of continual and good employment has been given to adult male workers between the ages of 30 and 50. I am not going to go through the list but there are industries where only adult labour can be employed.
The last thing I want to say is that when Deputy Norton spoke about the 45,000 men on relief work for an average of three and a half days at 13/6 per week, he must have been speaking of particular rural areas. I can only speak of Dublin, and that situation does not confront us there. I am satisfied that portion of the 45,000 men referred to by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in that reply included men in Dublin City and County. But in the city here the complaint is that a man who is receiving under 18/6 a week relief has practically no chance of employment on these relief schemes, because preference is given to men on the higher rate of relief. Consequently, I cannot see a man drawing 21/-, 22/- or 24/- relief going to work for 13/6. That could not apply to Dublin. There is something wrong with the argument there.
Comment on this
Possibly the Deputy was attempting to make a good political or debating point, but what he said was that there were 45,000 men on relief work and that an average of three and a half days per week was given to these men—some of them four days, and some of them three days—and that, therefore, the wages paid to these 45,000 men amounted to 12/6 or 13/6 per week. I say the Deputy was wrong.
Comment on this
That is not a correct interpretation of the point made by Deputy Norton. The point he made in connection with the 45,000 was, what would become of them when the temporary part-time work is finished? He did not quote that number in connection with relief of 12/6 as against 13/6 earnings. He might have answered himself by saying that they would be relieved by the Employment Period Orders.
Comment on this
Deputy Keyes is dealing with two points. Deputy Norton also made that point in his speech for the Minister for Finance to deal with, and I presume the Minister will deal with it. I am talking of the point he made which gave me the impression anyway that the average amount of wages earned by men on relief work was from 12/6 to 13/6 per week. I say that that is not the case in Dublin and I do not believe it is the case in Limerick.
Comment on this
The point I want to deal with is that, as far as Dublin is concerned, and the Lord Mayor knows the position as well as I do, the great grievance is that there are a great number of men on relief who get under 18/6 per week and that there is no work for these men because preference is given to men getting higher rates of relief. If these men could get work they claim that they would get 30/- and over per week—it goes up as high as 40/-. As far as relief work in Dublin is concerned there is no question of the whole of the 45,000 existing on 12/6 per week. It is quite possible that there are rural areas where it applies. I should not like that to go without contradiction as far as Dublin is concerned.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton has been accused of being unfair to the Government this morning. To a certain extent he has. The outstanding piece of unfairness to the Government on the part of Deputy Norton, in relation to people suffering from unemployment, is that he has not given them credit for proposing to give them in a week or two this new Constitution which is going to cure everything. Of course, we have been informed by the Minister for Finance that this new Constitution is to be treated as a New Testament given to us at the hands of a new Messiah that will not only be acceptable to the newer natives of this country but, on closer acquaintance, will be acceptable even to Orangemen.
Comment on this
To that extent, Deputy Norton has been unfair to the Government, but to the extent that the Minister puts a particular gloss on the Constitution, he may, perhaps, be excused. I would advise Deputy Norton not to start describing the Fine Gael policy on industry. There is only one man in this country capable of doing that. Deputy Norton from time to time plays the part of the small boy to the Fianna Fáil leaders and Government. In this particular case he would appear to be too small a boy entirely. There is only one man able adequately to deal with the Fine Gael industrial policy on the lines which Deputy Norton would like. Yesterday he was describing in an Irish court that Ireland was a province of Great Britain for the purpose of his industry, and he is the man who writes the leading articles for the Government Press so Deputy Norton ought to drop that. If he is taking an interest in statistics and serving up the Minister for Industry and Commerce with facts and figures relating to industry, it is time for him to take a broader outlook than that in reference to the one industry he refers to—the clothing industry. There are some things happening in that industry which it would be worth his while to ponder over, but he might go further and get at the root of things.
He talked a lot about emigration, and about improving the conditions, agriculturally and industrially of this country. As far as we can understand by statements made long ago, Deputy Norton has been in close contact with the Government in the development of their policy, and has, no doubt, scrutinised what the results of that policy have been. I want to refer one or two fundamental things to him which he might discuss with, say, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister spoke on the Central Fund Bill and made a comparison of what happened in the years 1929 and 1931 in relation to agriculture and industry, what is happening now, and he also dealt with the question of emigration. When he spoke on the Vote on Account the Minister stated emphatically that there was more employment in agriculture last year than in the year 1931. When I was dealing with a criticism of that statement he further reiterated that in agriculture there was more employment in 1936 than in 1931. In contrast to that, when speaking on the Central Fund Bill he stated that between 1929 and 1931 the number of persons employed in agriculture decreased by 23,000. We had rather full discussions on various occasions on the Vote on Account, on the barefaced misstatement of facts—quite a series of them —served up to this House in debate by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I want to deal with the misstatement of fact that between 1929 and 1931 the number of persons engaged in agriculture decreased by 23,000, and the statement that, as compared with that period, there was an improvement in agricultural conditions and increased employment in 1936. Public documents, the Agricultural Statistics for 1929 to 1933, and Parliamentary replies subsequent to the issue of that volume, give particulars of the males employed in agriculture, and, as far as we know, these are the only figures he has with regard to employment in agriculture.
I take the various classes that he records. They are divided into six classes. The first class is that of persons 14 to 18 years old, being members of farmers' families, permanent labourers and temporary labourers; then those 18 years and upwards, members of farmers' families, permanent labourers and temporary labourers. In members of farmers' families, from 14 to 18 years, between 1929 and 1931 there was an increase of 1,326 in that class; between 1934 and 1936, to take the most recent period, and the same number of years, there was a decrease of 2,928; of permanent labourers, between 14 and 18 years, between 1929 and 1931, there was a decrease of 1,013; between 1934 and 1936 there was an increase of 190; of temporary labourers, between 14 and 18 years, there was a decrease of 661 between 1929 and 1931, and between 1934 and 1936 a decrease of 279. If we take the total number of persons between 14 and 18 years, between 1929 and 1931, there was a decrease of about 350, and between 1934 and 1936 a decrease of 3,017. We then come to those 18 years and upwards, members of farmers' families, and between 1929 and 1931 there was a decrease of 7,838, and between 1934 and 1936 a decrease of 13,285. Permanent labourers, 18 years and upwards, between 1929 and 1931, increased by 1,082, but between 1934 and 1936 there was a decrease of 252. Temporary labourers, 18 years and upwards, between 1929 and 1931 increased by 3,036, but between 1934 and 1936 there was a decrease of 2,404. Taking the total number of persons, 18 years and upwards, there was a decrease of 3,000 between 1929 and 1931, and a decrease of 16,021 between 1934 and 1936, so that we have a period from 1929 to 1931 during which the Minister claims there was a decrease of 23,000 persons in agriculture, when the figures recorded by him are 3,448, at a time when there was an increase in adult permanent employment and an increase in adult temporary employment in spite of the fact that there was a period of agricultural depression which is now being found out by the Fianna Fáil Party as having been the biggest agricultural depression in the history of the world. During that period there was an increase in the number of permanent adult males employed in agriculture, an increase in the number of temporary adult males employed in agriculture, or a total decrease, including members of farmers' families, of 3,448; but in a similar period, 1934 to 1936, when the new policy with regard to agriculture that Deputy Norton was so enthusiastic about operated, the total decrease was 23,400.
Imagine the circumstances in which this House is expected to carry on intelligent discussion on important subjects, and in an economic condition in the country that was painted by part of the speech of Deputy Norton when, deliberately, on the part of the Minister, misstatements are made with regard to the employing capacity of agriculture between 1929 and 1931 and now between 1934 and 1936. If there was anything to be said for the industrial, the agricultural and the general policies being pursued by the Ministry at the present time, should we not expect that after having had three years to launch their policies, they would show an additional carrying power for males employed in the agricultural industry? Instead of that, year by year agriculture is shown to be less capable of supporting a male population. When the Minister comes to emigration he says that it is the females who are going out of the country. Does not that imply that there is less female employment in agriculture to-day? It simply means that if there has been a decrease in the last two years in the number of males who got employment in agriculture, there is if possible a bigger decrease in the number of females who are getting employment on the land.
Then, we had the type of speech which we heard from Deputy Briscoe, and the type of speech which we heard from Deputy Norton. On the subject of what? On the policy of the Opposition. What can be said with regard to the years up to 1931 is that, when in the face of the seriousness of the world depression the League of Nations set up a special committee to examine the causes and the results, they found themselves after that examination compelled to write the following, as shown on page 13 of their report issued on 14th May, 1931:
"It has already been pointed out that Europe suffered less than most other parts of the world, especially up to the autumn of last year. The national income of countries largely dependent on the production and export of cereals has been reduced more than that of manufacturing countries. Countries such as Denmark and Ireland, whose principal exports are animal food products, were relatively slightly affected by the depression until the autumn of 1930. The fall in the prices of animal foodstuffs up to that date was not great, and was largely offset by a reduction in the prices of fodder."
They thought it necessary to report: "Countries such as Denmark and Ireland, whose principal exports are animal food products....," so that this country, pursuing the traditional policy of its farming community here, and with that policy assisted by the Government policy at the time, got a certificate up to date in the year 1931 that the policy which was being pursued here at that time had protected the people of this country from being hit by the fall in the price of agricultural products as much as they would have been hit if a different policy had been pursued. What better certificate could have been given for the position which existed at that particular time? Now, we have the leader of the Labour Party sneering at the Party which at that time pursued the policy which saved the people those extreme losses. He speaks as a person who has been a fortnightly collaborator, back to 1922, with the Government which is responsible——
Comment on this
I have no desire to trouble either the mind of Deputy Donnelly or of the Minister, or of you, Sir, by going back to that. Deputy Norton has been a collaborator with the Government in his fortnightly conferences and in his support in this House back to 1932 in a policy which, between 1934 and 1936, reduced the employment in agriculture by those figures. He now listens to the Minister for Industry and Commerce misrepresenting the position, and not only misrepresenting the position but giving figures here before this House which are untruthful with regard to agricultural employment. I ask the Deputy to turn his attention to those figures in the first place, and to the causes that have brought them about, to see the Minister's prevarications and misstatements and the reasons why the Minister is forced to make those statements, because if he follows that line of thought he will do a lot more to assist the workers in the clothing industry and in the furniture industry than he apparently realises at the present time. The Deputy speaks of the boot industry. It is saturated. Not only is the boot industry saturated to-day but a large percentage of the people of this country who have to depend on the boots produced in this country have their feet saturated to-day. Boots in this country are getting dearer and worse. The average price of boots in 1935, the last year for which we have been given figures from the Department of Industry and Commerce, was higher than it was in any year since Fianna Fáil come into office.
Comment on this
A higher price does not necessarily mean a better article? Surely the Deputy is not arguing that?
Comment on this
They are paying a higher price for fewer articles. Deputy Norton is concerned with the boot industry. He says there was very serious unemployment in it this year. Those who know the industry, either from the retail or the manufacturing side, know that by this time next year there is going to be increasing unemployment in it. There was very serious unemployment in the boot industry in January, and I would advise the Minister as well as the Deputy to go further into the position with regard to the boot industry, and the thoughts that are in the minds of the retailers and the manufacturers in regard to it. One of the reiterated untruths—reiterated barefacedly year after year by the Minister for Industry and Commerce— is that our people are better shod now than ever before.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce in 1935 declared that the people of this country were using 500,000 pairs of boots and shoes more than they were using in 1931. I want to draw the Minister's attention, as well as the attention of Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Norton, to the figures that have been published in xxiii of Trade and Shipping Statistics, 1935, showing that in spite of the reiterated statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that our people were better shod, were using more boots and shoes in this country than ever before, in the year 1932 we were down 47,000 dozen pairs on the previous year; 16,000 dozen pairs in 1933 as compared with 1931; 19,000 dozen pairs in 1934 as compared with 1931; and 14,000 dozen pairs in 1935 as compared with 1931, and it will be found, as I stated, that in the year 1935 the price the people were paying for the average pair of boots and shoes they put on was higher than in any of the intervening years since 1932.
As I say, boots were getting dearer in this country and getting worse, and the tendency during 1936 has been to make them dearer and worse; the tendency in 1936 has been further to reduce the consuming capacity of our people, so that they are less able to meet their boot bill, less able to meet their clothing bill, their hosiery bill, their sugar confectionery bill, and a number of other items of which, as has been pointed out from year to year, the people are buying less. If there is anything threatening the future of our industry it is the causes that are reducing the consuming capacity of our people, that are making them consume to-day less clothing, less boots, less of those necessaries of life than they were able to consume before Fianna Fáil and Deputy Norton together started to improve our agricultural and industrial policy.
The Deputy spoke of emigration. Again, the subject of emigration was dealt with by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and, again, barefaced untruthful statements were given to the House on that subject by him. In dealing with the Central Fund Bill, after his performance with regard to employment in agriculture, he stated that the total emigration in the five years 1932, 1933, 1934, 1935 and 1936, added together, was approximately 40,000 persons. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, on 11th November last, gave figures of the net migration inwards and outwards from 1927 to 1936, and for the four years ended June, 1936, the net outward migration was 53,790 persons, and the Minister tells us that for five years it was 40,000 persons. If we look at the emigration figures as we looked at the position with regard to agriculture, comparing the periods 1929-1931 with the period 1934-36, what do we find? We find that for the years 1929, 1930 and 1931 the total emigration was 33,100 odd.
Comment on this
I have the official returns here, and I find I was giving the Deputies too much credit. From June, 1929, to June, 1932, the last three years of the pre-Fianna Fáil Administration——
Comment on this
I am dealing with prevarications and the impostures of the Minister for Industry and Commerce on economic matters relating to the periods 1929-1931 and 1934-1936, and I am telling the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Finance and Deputy Norton that, for the three years of pre-Fianna Fáil administration, the total net migration outwards was 9,000 persons.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy is entitled to make his speech in his own way, so far as it is relevant to the debate.
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned, he can tell all the half-truths he likes. I only ask him to tell the whole truth.
Comment on this
I want to compare the period the Minister for Industry and Commerce complained about, from 1929 to 1931, where he indicated there was a fall in agricultural and industrial employment here and the years we have just passed, when all the previous policies were, let us say, reversed. For the three years ended June, 1932, the total net migration outwards, that is, the total emigration from this country, was 9,390. Let us take the three years ended June, 1936. The total emigration in that period was 50,512, and Deputy Norton, sneering at an alleged description of Fine Gael industrial policy, asks us what are we going to do industrially, or in any other way, to maintain and improve the magnificent state of affairs that exists here at present. He admits that emigration is increasing. He makes no attempt to examine the misrepresentations of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the reasons for these misrepresentations are the fundamental facts with regard to what is wrong with the economy of this country at present, that is, the way agriculture is being destroyed. The facts exist under his nose that, in the year 1933, emigration was 9,517; in 1934, 17,284, and in 1935, 23,711. The figures made available from the British immigration figures show that, as Deputy Norton says, the position is getting worse. The fundamental thing that is wrong with industrial development here, its present-day condition and its hope for the future, lies in the fact that agricultural employment is being destroyed, that agricultural income is being wiped out.
I want to put a final figure before the Minister for Finance and Deputy Norton which shows that, between 1929 and 1931, our export trade, which consisted mainly of agricultural produce, fell below the 1929 figure by £13,135,000. Of the countries we are associated with, New Zealand began to improve after 1931; Canada began to improve after 1932; Australia began to improve after 1931, and South Africa began to improve after 1932. Our principal competitor in the British market, Denmark, in whose class we were from the economic point of view and in the eyes of the Economic Commission set up by the League of Nations to investigate world depression in 1931, began to improve in its exports after December, 1932. In spite of that fact, we have gone along since the end of 1931 and whereas, in the depression period previously, we suffered from a cumulative fall in exports below the 1929 figure of £13,135,000, that fall has gone below the 1931 figure by £74,938,000 or approximately £75,000,000. The policy that brought about that is the policy of the Fianna Fáil Benches combined with the Labour Benches. Yet, the real trouble there, for all Deputy Norton's mouthings this morning, is contained in a single word. Will the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce cease misrepresenting the position or are we to have these misrepresentations? Are we to have these utterly untruthful statements made here in the House and in the country in the hope that people will be gulled or lulled into not realising them? Deputy Norton spoke of national self-sufficiency. Our national self-sufficiency is branded to-day by the fact that we are swallowing 12 months old New Zealand butter at 1/5 to 1/6 a lb. while our own fresh Irish butter is being sent to the people in Britain with whom we are supposed to be carrying on an economic war, at a price of about 6d. a lb., taking into account the subsidy that is being given to the shippers, and that butter is going down English throats at 9½d. per lb. I often heard of people swallowing their own words, but when the Fianna Fáil Party go into the dining-room, as they do to-day, and feel the first effects of the New Zealand butter against their throats will they realise——
Comment on this
What about Chinese bacon that was being imported in the time of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government?
Comment on this
——they are not only swallowing their own words but swallowing this butter at 1/5 to 1/6 a lb. while Irish butter is being exported from our ports at 6d. a lb. The Minister for Finance can indulge in his levity but national self-sufficiency in Ireland to-day means swallowing 12 months old New Zealand butter and paying for it 1/5 to 1/6 a lb while sending our own butter across to Great Britain to the people with whom we are supposed to be carrying on an economic war, delivering it to them for 6d. a lb. and slipping it down the throats of the consumers there at 9½d. or 10d. a lb. No wonder we are reduced to that condition when we have Ministers getting up in this House, twisting and prevaricating and making untruthful statements with regard to the economic condition of the people. Meantime every class in this country is suffering. The industries, about which Deputy Norton speaks and that have been set up during the present régime, are suffering. Some of the industrialists connected with them are getting a rich-quick touch and making exorbitant profits in the hope that when the rainy day does come and when the price of our prevarication, the price of our sins, is to be much heavier than swallowing New Zealand butter, they at any rate will have got the greater part of the money they put into Irish industry back. They will have got it back from the people who have to live on a very considerably reduced income. They will have got back these profits at the cost of tremendous loss and comparatively tremendous suffering to the people. But these industrialists, at any rate, may be safe, when the bad day comes for the industries about which Deputy Norton speaks. All the seeds of industrial decay are contained in the figures before the House to-day. That will mean not only industrial decay for the industries that have been pushed into existence while these losses were going on, but the seeds of industrial decay for the industries that weathered the rule of British government—the alien and unfriendly Government—we had in this country. The sooner Deputy Norton goes deeper into the situation than he did in these superficial figures with regard to clothing, the better he will help the clothing factories, the better he will help the capitalists who own these factories, the better he will help the workers in these factories and the better he will guarantee the future of the workers in these factories. If we better he will guarantee the future of the workers in these factories. If we are to continue with these misrepresentations and this lying nonsense, and if our people can be blinded any longer in this way we are going to have further depopulation of our countryside, a depopulation that will be expressed in deeper figures in the way of agricultural unemployment. There will be crowds of people further crowding around our labour exchanges, but the eyes of the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be more and more shut to what is happening at these exchanges, and we are to have a fuller stream of emigration going on to build up industries in other countries if the Government's ruinous policy is persisted in.
Comment on this
As the Minister's Department amongst its other activities is responsible for the financing of relief schemes, I would like to direct his attention, to the effect this policy is having on local authorities in the country. Perhaps the better way to do that would be to give you an illustration of what is occurring in Cork City. Under the scheme financed by the Minister who is present, certain sums of money are made available for the relief of unemployment. That has been one of the outstanding features of the Fianna Fáil administration. But the pill is slightly sugared, and indeed more than slightly sugared, because it has been the practice, so far at any rate, for most of those local authorities to accept those so-called free grants which are made conditional on the various local authorities levying on themselves to the extent of many thousands of pounds. I would like to illustrate my point by telling the House what has occurred in Cork City. In order to qualify for the first Government grant the Cork Corporation decided to borrow £9,800 on a ten years term. The Department concerned were not satisfied with that term, and it was suggested by them that the term should be three years. Eventually that Department agreed to a five years term, which, I am sure the Minister will agree, is not sufficiently long for a local authority. I will deal with the Department concerned on a more appropriate occasion when the Vote for that Department arises.
Comment on this
I would like, if I may, to interrupt the Deputy for a moment. I understood that all stages of the Central Fund were to be disposed of yesterday. That was not done. If I do not get adequate time to reply to-day it may be necessary to have a meeting of the Dáil and to bring back Deputies next week to hear that reply.
Comment on this
The Minister is not quite playing the game after all. Am I to understand that the Minister objects to time being taken to dispose of the misrepresentations and the untruthful statements about the economic conditions in the country that have been made from the Government Benches?
Comment on this
I object to the policy of deliberate obstruction embarked on this morning by speakers from the Opposition Benches.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I should like to point out that only one Deputy from these benches has spoken this morning.
Comment on this
I was proceeding to give him a concrete example of the effects of the policy of his Department and of his Government on local administration. I was proceeding to state that, in order to qualify for the first grant, the Cork Corporation decided to borrow £8,900. On this basis, the Corporation struck a rate of 22/- in the £. About a week or two after their meeting, a further offer of £26,475 came along from the Department to the Corporation and they were asked to add to that a sum of £8,000, for which, again, a loan must be sought. The position of other local authorities is similar to that of Cork Corporation. They do not wish to turn down any of these schemes, because, if they did, they would be charged with neglecting the unemployed and not making any effort to ameliorate the lot of these unfortunate people. Even Christian feeling, alone, would dictate to them that they should do their best, even at some sacrifice, to relieve the abnormal amount of unemployment. At the same time, the local authorities feel that they are being made to pay twice.
On these relief schemes, the practice is for the first preference to be exercised in favour of those persons who are drawing £1 per week dole through the medium of the labour exchanges. If we take it that 1,000 persons would be employed in Cork or Dublin—I use that figure merely to illustrate my point—the Central Fund would be relieved to the extent of £1,000. In Cork City, as also in Dublin, Waterford, Limerick and Dun Laoghaire, a sum of 1/6 in the £ is levied in order to meet the requirements of the Unemployment Assistance Act. The City of Cork alone contributes something like £17,000 per annum in this way. No further illustration is needed to show that the ratepayers are forced to pay twice. That is a position which the Minister for Finance must, at some future date, take into consideration. It is all very fine holding out this bait to local authorities at election times and saying that the onus is on these authorities to accept or refuse. The Minister must know that that puts the local authorities in a very nasty position, indeed. When the ratepayers are taxed to the limit of their endurance, along comes another offer from the Government of a so-called free grant to the local authorities. The feeling in Cork is that that practice should be stopped or, at least, varied.
There is another matter which I do not propose to raise on this Bill because it can be more properly raised on the Local Government Estimate. In the majority of cases, the material used for road-making under these schemes is mastic concrete——
Comment on this
I mention the matter merely in passing. It should be one of the first considerations of the Minister for Finance and his Parliamentary Secretary, who is an engineer by profession, to find what is the most economic method of road-surfacing in the long run. It is my considered opinion that a few years hence the problem will be to find employment for the persons who are now ordinarily employed on the roads. I pass from that to emphasise a very important point which the Minister must be aware of. I refer to the rather ominous figure which was not mentioned until this week but of which I had information some months ago—that the amount due by the various local authorities on foot of debts and borrowed money up to the 31st March, 1936, was the huge sum of £24,480,000. I am sure the Minister will admit that, for this small country, that figure is almost alarming.
I should like to refer also to the boot industry, which was touched upon by Deputy Mulcahy a few moments ago. A couple of years ago, I said in this House, on the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce, that, even at that period, we were about to reach saturation point in the production of boots. We have in Cork one of the oldest boot factories in Saorstát Eireann. I was glad to read some time ago in the Press that the Minister for Industry and Commerce almost guaranteed—at least, he gave some kind of undertaking—at a meeting of the Federation of Irish Industries or some such body that, as far as he was concerned, no encouragement—I think those were the words he used—would be given to the establishment of any more boot factories in this country. I was very glad to read that statement because there would be no use in having a dozen factories producing boots when half a dozen factories would be sufficient to produce all the boots required by the people of the Free State. It would be well if the Minister for Finance would indicate to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that he should make that position quite clear in the country.
Comment on this
The Cork factory would be able to stand up if all the others were closed down. They have a better tradition in Cork as regards the making of boots than they have in Dublin or any other part of the country.
Comment on this
We carried on on a 12½ per cent. or 15 per cent. tariff, and we were doing well. It was the people who were not quite so efficient as the people in Cork who wanted a higher tariff, and they got it. We were able to carry on in Cork with a very low tariff, due to the efficiency of the operatives. The same cannot be said for Dublin. I want, again, to direct the Minister's attention to the matter I have just raised. I am sure that if he will indicate to the Parliamentary Secretary, who takes an interest in these things, and whose function it is to suggest these schemes to the Minister, that longer-term loans should be provided in such cases as I have mentioned, he will see that it is done. As happened in Cork, meetings will probably have to be held in other places to meet the demands made because further loans are offered. The rate-payers will be asked to raise further moneys, and the ratepayers are at breaking point so far as capacity to contribute is concerned.
Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Byrne rose.
Comment on this
——and the Government is bound to have at least one spokesman in the person of the Minister. If we are going to finish this Bill to-day, and I take it that is the wish of the House, the Chair will endeavour as far as possible to give fair play to those who have only one spokesman. The Minister, I suppose, will require half an hour to reply.
Comment on this
The Deputy will please sit down. The Chair is not dictating. The Chair was given to understand that it was the wish on both sides of the House that this Bill should be concluded to-day. The Chair is simply endeavouring to indicate the way that it might be concluded to-day. The Government is bound to have one speaker.
Comment on this
We desire to get this Bill through all its stages to-day. We had only one speaker on the Bill, and he did not get in until the debate had been in progress for about an hour and a half. I do not think there is any other member on this side who desires to speak.
Comment on this
If the Minister is given half an hour or 35 minutes to reply I am perfectly willing to waive my right to speak in favour of a member from some other part of the House.
Comment on this
I assure the House that I will not occupy its time for more than three or four minutes. When Deputy Briscoe was speaking he made reference to the fact that I should know conditions in the City of Dublin and of how unemployment funds are administered here. I just want to say that during all this week there was a deputation of the Unemployed Workers' Rights Association in the gallery. They interviewed as many members of the Dáil as they possibly could. They protested that the allowances which they are given to live on while unemployed are totally inadequate. We had the Bray marchers to the City of Dublin during the week. There was the question of a promised grant for Bray in order to relieve unemployment. Those men marched here and held a meeting at which they stated their case. They asked me to appeal to the Minister so that something may be done to speed up whatever work is to be carried out in that area.
I am making an appeal to the Minister in the interests of the unemployed in Dublin. People are coming from every area in the county, and from outside of it, seeking employment in the City of Dublin, employment that is not here for them unfortunately. We have thousands signing up at Gardiner Street who have not yet got even one day's employment on the relief schemes passed since December. Grants are made by the Government on a 50-50 basis. The corporation contribute 50 per cent. of the cost of these schemes, and Dublin is in precisely the same position as Cork to which reference has been made by Deputy Anthony. In connection with these relief schemes, as Deputy Anthony said, it is only the men who are drawing £1 a week at the labour exchanges who are called on for this relief work. As soon as they get employment, they cease, of course, to draw £1 a week so that the national exchequer benefits in that way. There is no corresponding advantage so far as the rates of the City of Dublin are concerned. I should say that neither the rate-payers nor the corporation offer any objection to that. Their one wish is that something more could be done to provide employment for those in need of employment in the City of Dublin.
You have men in the city who have been unemployed for some considerable time—single men drawing 9/- a week, others drawing 15/- a week and others nothing at all, and not one of them has got a day's work through these unemployment relief grants. They are protesting strongly against that. We saw in the newspapers the other day that the free beef vouchers which used to be given to those men are now being withdrawn from them.
Comment on this
I did not say single men. I know a man and his wife getting only 14/- a week, and he has not had one day's work on these relief schemes.
Comment on this
If there is a man with a wife in Dublin who is only getting 14/- a week he must have some other means as well, though they may not be very much. The work on relief schemes, as the Deputy knows, is reserved for married men, and, preferably, for married men with children.
Comment on this
I am speaking of a married man with a wife and no child. He has not got one day's work through these relief grants, and now the beef voucher has been withdrawn. While that is so the cost of bread, butter, sugar, beef and potatoes has gone up considerably as was indicated recently in reply to a question put down by a member of the Labour Party. As I have already stated, the people on behalf of whom I am speaking, were in the gallery all the week. They ask that something should be done for them. I hope that during the adjournment something will be done to relieve the hardship they are suffering from. We all know what the position is during this very severe weather in the poorer quarters of the city—people there with no money to buy food, clothes or boots.
There has been a good deal said about emigration. There is no use hiding the fact that there are thousands in the City of Dublin to-day who, if they got the chance, would emigrate. Because of the hardships they are bearing at present, if they had the means they would go down to the boat to-night to get to England to take up work there. With the help of some friends, and of certain institutions, I have made arrangements to provide a number of these men with their fares to enable them to get away. Emigration is desired by the vast majority of our unemployed young men always, of course, with the desire to come back when things improve here.
Comment on this
There is one feature of the discussion on this Bill that I regret, and that is the reluctance of members on the Government Benches to recognise the extent of the emigration drift amongst males as well as females. Deputy Briscoe, apparently by way of explanation, seemed to indicate that it was mostly females who were leaving.
Comment on this
The gist of the Deputy's remarks would seem to indicate that the departure of females from the country would not be a serious loss to the country. I regret that such an attitude should be adopted by any member of the House. The emigration from the country of either males or females is certainly a very regrettable feature.
Comment on this
Speaking for myself, I saw bus-loads of young people coming into the City of Limerick to avail of the cheap fares to London in connection with the rugby international. They travelled to London but did not return. There is a very definite exodus of both men and women from this country to Great Britain to seek employment there. That is a matter that, perhaps, the Government cannot completely cure.
Nobody in this House is prepared to give more credit to the Government than I for the efforts they have made to deal with the unemployment problem, but I think it is a fatuous and futile attitude for the Government to take up, to say that because they have done certain things they are entitled to ignore the fact that the efforts they have so far made to solve the problem have not been successful in dealing with this menace —the biggest menace of all—of unemployment, and which is exemplified by this exodus of our employable men and women. That is the best proof that their efforts have failed so far, and it is futile for the Government to ignore it. That is the biggest problem before the Government and it is going to continue to be the biggest problem before the Government, and there is no use in the Government sticking their heads in the sand and refusing to recognise the writing on the wall. Undoubtedly, they have made efforts, but I hold that some of their efforts are misguided and are calculated to lead to emigration. I go the length of stating that, wittingly or unwittingly, they are driving people out of this country by the scandalous wages paid to men on these rotational schemes of work, schemes put forward as a panacea to try to help the workers over hard times. I say that the effect of these schemes is merely to urge the people out of the country. It is an urge to drive them out.
Deputy Briscoe was not fair to Deputy Norton, whom he accused of being unfair to the Government. Deputy Briscoe's views of Deputy Norton's statement, perhaps unintentionally, were a twisting of what Deputy Norton said. Deputy Norton spoke of the hardships inflicted by a Government rotational scheme of work whereby a man is only able to earn about 13/6 a week because he will only be allowed to work three or four days a week.
That is the general interpretation of the schemes throughout the country, so far as I know, and I hardly think that any member of the Government will express himself as being satisfied with a scheme in the country districts whereby a man is only allowed to work, for three or four days a week, at a maximum wage of 13/6. I say that that cannot be more than a device to save the funds of the labour exchanges, and if the Government were sincere and if they had not sufficient money to meet the problem in its entirety, it would be very much more decent to give these men a stretch of work of three or four weeks' duration and then let them go to the labour exchange for the period during which employment could not be given to them. It is not fair to send these men to work for a couple of days of the week so that you may be able to say that everybody is working and nobody is unemployed, but the net result of these schemes is that these men cannot go to the labour exchange. It is just a scheme for saving money, and it is causing endless dissatisfaction throughout the country. Any engineer who has estimated for work in connection with these relief schemes, estimates on the basis of regular, normal work. I have discussed the matter with engineers who have had to do with these schemes, and they cannot get 50 per cent. of a return. From any angle you view the matter, I suggest that it is nothing more than waste of public funds and that it is an urge to drive people across the Channel when they hear of big wages being paid over there, whereas if they could get three weeks' continuous work here and could then go back to the employment exchange until work is provided for them again, they would remain here and would not cross the Channel in search of work. They are not going over there in a spirit of adventure, as Deputy Moore or some other Deputy suggested. They are being driven over there through sheer necessity, and that is one of the points I should like the Minister to deal with when he is replying. I should like him to deal in his reply with this matter which he and the Government Benches, generally speaking, have tolerated and allowed to creep in, and that is this indefensible scheme of rotational employment, and I would appeal to the Minister urgently to have the rotational scheme withdrawn and scrapped as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I do not intend, Sir,—I am sorry that Deputy Belton is going, as I have a word to say about him—I do not intend to deal with what I think is purely a question of administration, and that is the application of the rotational principle to employment schemes. A full opportunity will be given the House, on Vote 69, to discuss that matter in detail and to deal with any objections or criticisms which can justly be lodged against it. I do think, however, that I ought to say something in regard to the intervention of Deputy Alfred Byrne into the debate. Deputy Byrne made a plea for consideration of the House of the position of those single men in Dublin City who are in receipt of unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
I am very sorry. If I do not know what Deputy Byrne spoke about, and if he himself does not know what he spoke about, I am afraid this debate is going to be rather befogged.
Comment on this
I have no desire to misrepresent Deputy Byrne. I understood that his intervention in this debate was on behalf of those people who were in receipt of unemployment assistance, and particularly those who were on the lower scales of unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
I spoke for the unemployed as a whole—every one of them —who are on an inadequate allowance at the moment.
Comment on this
I understood the Deputy was concerned primarily with the position of those unmarried men, without dependents, who are in receipt, in Dublin City, of assistance at the rate of 9/-.
Comment on this
I spoke, generally, for all the unemployed of the city, who are being treated scandalously.
Comment on this
I see. Well, we will come to that in time, but will the Deputy permit me to clear up my misconceptions?
Comment on this
When I expressed the assumption that Deputy Byrne was speaking for single men, without dependents, who were in receipt of 9/- a week unemployment assistance, he said, "no," that was not so—that he was speaking for those in receipt of nothing at all.
Comment on this
But the Deputy said "no"—that he was speaking for those in receipt of nothing at all.
Comment on this
Now the Deputy is speaking of all the unemployed. He is opening those generous, all-embracing arms of his——
Comment on this
——and he is extending his rather notable hands towards them. All the unemployed in Dublin City are taken to Deputy Byrne's bosom.
Comment on this
And in the county—in fact, there is no limit to the consideration which Deputy Byrne extends to everybody in this country. At any rate, we have agreement in this: that he is speaking now for all the unemployed, not merely for those in Dublin City, but for the unemployed elsewhere, and he is protesting that not enough is being done for the unemployed, and that he is anxious that more should be done for them. Now, what is the principle upon which the Government has proceeded in this matter? The first thing to be considered is that when we asked the Dublin Corporation to put up schemes which could be undertaken during the current year and during next year, the first fact that emerged was that there was a very limited quantity of work available in Dublin. And the principle upon which the Government went in allocating that work was that those who were in most need of it should get first preference. If you have to choose between single men, between those who are in receipt of unemployment assistance and those who are in receipt of nothing at all, although it might seem paradoxical to say it, the fact is that you must of necessity choose those who are in receipt of unemployment assistance, and the reason for that is that people who are unemployed and who are in receipt neither of home assistance nor of unemployment assistance, must be, almost invariably, people who can maintain themselves without the help of home assistance or unemployment assistance, except in very peculiar circumstances. The next thing is, if you are going to choose people in receipt of unemployment assistance, which of those people will you choose, if you have a definitely limited quantity of work available for that class of relief? Naturally if you have any concern for the interests of the people, you are going to choose those who are most in need of this work. You are not going to choose single young men without dependents. You are going to choose married men and, if you have to make a choice between certain categories of married men, you are going to choose married men with dependents. That is the first principle on which the Government has operated in this matter——
Comment on this
——whenever the work is limited in quantity. It is definitely limited in quantity in Dublin, limited by mainly two or three considerations, limited, first of all, by the fact that you require a large organisation to undertake work of this sort and, secondly, by the fact that the amount of work that is required in Dublin City to-day is not so considerable as people think, and that so much of it as is required is definitely of a specialised character for the execution of which you require men with specialised training. Of course, a third consideration is the financial one, the one which the Government has put last. In Dublin City, I can say that our efforts to provide employment have not been limited by financial considerations but have been limited by the very definite insuperable fact that the amount of work in the city is limited and, in allocating that work, as I have said before, we have invariably acted on the principle that those who need it most must have it first.
Why should this problem of employment in Dublin be considered as a national concern? Surely the position of the unemployed man, if you are going to take first principles first, is first of all, the concern of that man's immediate neighbour. If you extend that, surely the position of the unemployed man is of more concern to the community of which he is immediately a member than of more remote communities in other parts of the country. As far as the position of the Dublin unemployed is concerned, it is first of all a consideration for Dublin City as a community and for the corporation which is responsible for the administration of that city. It is only when the corporation has failed to do its duty, or has exhausted all its resources in that regard, that those who speak for the corporation are entitled to come to the central Government and ask for their assistance in dealing with unemployment in the city.
Deputy Byrne stated that he was concerned with the position of all the unemployed in this country. What is the position of the State in regard to this matter? That it has provided no less a sum than £1,500,000, which is provided by the general taxpayer. The great bulk of that money is provided by the indirect taxpayer of this country and the indirect taxpayers of this country are not the wealthy element in this country. The richest community in this State is the community which inhabits the City of Dublin. Inside the boundaries of that city you have the greatest aggregation of wealth that this country knows. Inside this city there is spent out of the national taxes. I should say about £12,000,000 a year. Inside this city there are the headquarters of the biggest industries in the country. Inside this city you have grouped the wealthiest people of this country, the big ratepayers of Dublin City. If there is an unemployment problem in Dublin City, are not the ratepayers of Dublin City in a better position to tackle that problem than the taxpayers of the Twenty-Six Counties who have to con- tribute largely to the upkeep of the Civil Service, the Guards and the Army, contribute money the greater part of which is spent in Dublin City? When Deputy Alfred Byrne comes here and says that he is concerned about the unemployed of the whole country I would ask him when he next goes on the hustings is he going to say that Dublin City is going to discharge its obligations to the unemployed, that the ratepayers will have to contribute another 1/- or 2/- in the £ in order that Dublin City may do its duty to its own unemployed? I trust he will not come here afterwards to urge that we should tax the farmers and the agricultural labourers, about whom we have heard so many moans from the Opposition Benches, in order that we may relieve Dublin City of some of its obligations to the unemployed.
Comment on this
When the Deputy gets up here and says that he does not want us to tax these people, I would ask him where are we to get this money if we are not going to tax the agricultural community? The greater part of the £1,500,000 spent on the employment works and of the £1,121,000 which has been provided for the Unemployment Assistance Vote has to be taken from the agricultural community and from those who live outside Dublin City. Of the 3,000,000 people almost, who inhabit the State, 2,500,000 live outside the boundaries of Dublin City. It is they who will have to provide the greater part of this sum. If the Deputy's concern for all the unemployed is, as he said, so genuine, so sincere as he protests it to be, one thing he will do will be this. He will go back and say to the Dublin Corporation: "We must do all that we possibly can for our people who are unemployed in order that the Government may be able to provide for the unemployed in other communities which are not so rich and wealthy as Dublin." That is what the Deputy would do. Do we hear of his doing that? Oh, no. His stock-in-trade in this matter is cheap sympathy for all the unemployed. He gets up here and smugly talks about the unemployed for whom his heart is so full.
We have heard of the difficulties and of the deficiencies of the scheme. Of course, the scheme has its difficulties and its deficiencies, but these difficulties and deficiencies are conditioned by the economic position of the community, by the fact that even in the most prosperous times we are a poor community, by the fact that even in the most prosperous times we cannot provide work for all our people, that even in the days when we were supposed to be wallowing and rolling in wealth, even in 1920 and 1921, there was emigration from this country. These are the inescapable economic facts which cannot be waived and which cannot be overcome by merely getting up and saying that more should be done for the unemployed. Deputy Norton alleged that the Government was not doing its duty, because he said that men between the ages of 30 and 45 years were leaving this country and were finding employment in Great Britain. I am very doubtful of that statement. I do not think that, in general, men between the ages of 30 and 45, who had been unemployed possibly for a considerable time go to Britain, or that men within that category get employment in Britain or get it easily. There may be, here and there, occasional exceptions—that will happen—but, in general, if the temporary efflux of population from this country to Great Britain is as great as we have been told, if people are going as freely as we have been told, if the efflux is as free in its flow as we have been told, then those who are going to employ our people in Great Britain are going to take the young, the vigorous and trainable men, who have not yet reached the category between 30 and 45 years of age.
I asked Deputy Norton, when he was on his feet, instead of talking merely about the problem of finding employment for men of mature years, men of settled habit of mind and body, such as those are who are between the ages of 30 and 45 years, to give the House the benefit of his wisdom and advice, and to tell us how he would cure it, what steps he or the Labour Party for whom he speaks would take to provide employment for men between 30 and 45 years. He has told us by implication that the new industries, which he admits have been established in this State in very great numbers during the last four years, the new factories and workshops which have sprung up all over the country, and whose existence is no longer questionable, let alone deniable, are giving employment merely to the young men of this country. I asked him what particular industries would he start that would give employment primarily to men between 30 and 45 years. If the Government is to be criticised by Deputy Norton, if any importance is to be attached to the criticism of Deputy Norton in this regard, if he really believes that his criticism is justified, it can only be because he himself knows some plan and some industry in which employment would be given primarily to men between 30 and 45 years.
Comment on this
We did not say we would do it over-night. It may be that eventually we will be able to give more employment to men between 30 and 45 years, but it will not be skilled employment—let us be clear about that. It is very well known that ability to acquire skill and knowledge in an industry decreases very rapidly as one grows older, and when new industries were being established here, established at some cost to the people, it was only natural that those who were going to be responsible for the success of these industries would take into their employment persons who could be most readily trained in the trades with which the industries were associated. That is why, at the outset, these new industries are giving employment to young people generally, to the younger men in this generation.
There is no harm in giving employment to the younger men in this generation, because the very nature of our population trend indicates that it is the wiser course to ensure, if one can, that employment is given to our younger men in preference to those of more mature years.
We want to give them an early opportunity to establish themselves in those industries, to give them employment where that employment is likely to be permanent, where they are likely to mature as tradesmen and skilled operatives, so that they may be able to build a home for themselves at the earliest opportunity. It is easier to train them, in the first instance, and they can acquire additional skill once they have qualified themselves for permanent employment in the new industries. The time may come when these industries will be giving employment which is distributed over a very wide range of ages. The older men will stay on, continue. I hope there will be men of 30, 40 and 50 years, and maybe a little more, employed in these industries. It all depends on whether or not social conditions in this State are such that they can retire from active labour at an earlier age than now. None of us can forecast the future, but I hope the time will come when men will be employed in those industries up to the very time when they are able, due to better social services or better social positions, to retire from active labour at a much earlier age than now. And as they retire, their places will be taken in those industries, not by men of 30 and 45 years, but by young men who have the aptitude to learn that trade or that particular industry.
How does Deputy Norton, who is supposed to have some knowledge of economics, think—to touch on another point which he himself raised in the first instance—he would be able to deal with the problem created by the fact that Great Britain has declared that she is prepared to spend £1,500,000 inside four years upon a particular policy?
Comment on this
I beg your pardon, £1,500,000,000, upon a particular policy inside four years? How does Deputy Norton suggest we ought to counteract that?
Comment on this
What has been put up to us is this, that we should counteract the pull, in the words of Deputy McGilligan, which this spending policy of Great Britain will exercise upon our young and active population. We cannot control British policy in regard to rearmament. That is something which arises in Britain's own interests and from Britain's own fears and we cannot possibly persuade her not to spend that £1,500,000,000 or control or curtail her activities in that regard by one farthing. She is going to spend that money whether we like it or not. Does Deputy Norton or any other Deputy wants us to enter into competition in what Deputy Norton described as inflationary expenditure? Is that the remedy which the Labour Party are offering the country to cure the conditions which Deputy Norton admits may be created in this country by reason of the fact that Great Britain is going to spend £1,500,000,000 on rearmament? Are we going to start spending pound for pound with Great Britain in order to keep our people here?
Has the Deputy any realisation of what our actual resources are? What is our actual capacity for spending, if we had the objects upon which money could be spent? What is our actual capacity for spending upon any object, or upon any policy, or for any purpose? I say that the total capital resources which we have abroad may not amount to more than one-tenth of what Great Britain proposes to spend in four years on rearmament. I certainly would say this—it is a guess in any event—that our capital investments abroad would not amount to more than one-sixth of that. Does Deputy Norton suggest that we should take the whole of our investments abroad and the whole of the savings of our people? Because, remember this, anything which our people have not invested abroad they are using here. In so far as our people have savings, they either put them into industry here or put them into industry abroad. The capital resources which they have here have already been fully employed. Does Deputy Norton suggest that we ought to take whatever steps we can to bring back that £250,000,000 which is abroad, and spend every penny piece of it in an attempt to counteract the pull on our population which will be exercised by the spending policy of Great Britain in regard to that £1,500,000,000?
Comment on this
I am showing how this talk of Deputy Norton's is all claptrap. I asked Deputy Norton, when he was on his feet condemning the Government for not doing something to counteract this £1,500,000,000 expenditure in Great Britain, to tell us how he would counteract it. I am asking the representatives of the Labour Party to tell us what the Labour Party would do in this regard. Would they bring home this £250,000,000? Do they think they could bring it home?
Comment on this
They are supposed to be students of economics. Has any country in Europe, even those countries whose Governments have the most dictatorial powers, been able to keep in the country any liquid capital which its inhabitants wish to get outside it? The one thing you cannot do, no matter how you try it, is to prevent the flow of liquid capital. Here is between £150,000,000 and £250,000,000, which is not under our control at all, which is outside this country. Does Deputy Norton suggest that we should try, by some sort of legislative process, by some process of law, by some coercion, whatever the instrument of coercion may be, to bring back that sum of between £150,000,000 and £250,000,000 and then start spending every penny of it in order to keep our people at home? Will he tell us the works upon which it is to be expended if it is to be expended on reproductive work? Will he tell us the works upon which it is to be expended if it is not to be expended on reproductive work? I do not believe that you can possibly spend anything like that sum upon the creation of new capital goods in this country which could be usefully employed in the manufacture of consumption goods. I do not think that you can possibly spend that sum, and if you cannot spend it, is Deputy Norton's cure for this problem that we should start in, like the drones in the hive, consuming it ourselves and importing from Great Britain the wherewithal to enable our people to live in luxurious idleness at home?
Comment on this
It is doing what the Labour Party never does—facing up to the hard facts of the situation.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton said that the rotational schemes were devised mainly to deprive workers of unemployment assistance. He wants to know if that is the best effort that can be made. What are the facts? I do not know whether Deputy Norton has taken the trouble to look at the figures which express the facts as they are set out in the volume of Estimates for the coming year. There in Vote 69 he will see that this year we are providing £1,500,000 for employment schemes. If he turns to page 275, he will see the figures for unemployment insurance and unemployment assistance and he will find that we are providing £1,121,000 for unemployment assistance as against £1,500,000 last year. Those are the facts upon which Deputy Norton basis his contention that the rotational schemes are devised mainly to deprive workers of unemployment assistance. We are spending £1,500,000 on work the main purpose of which, according to Deputy Norton, is to secure a saving of £379,000 in unemployment assistance. That is the sole purpose, according to Deputy Norton, of spending £1,500,000. Not a word about the fact that we are anxious to provide, and that all we ever contracted to do——
Comment on this
——was to provide work instead of maintenance. That is what we are doing. It was clearly recognised, and I made it clear in the debates which have taken place on this question of the provision of employment for the unemployed, that it would take at least five times as much to keep a person fully employed as to provide him with unemployment assistance or maintenance. So far as we can, and within the capacity of this State, we are substituting, in regard to the greatest possible number of people, the provision of work, and of useful work—useful from the social, from the moral as well as from the economic point of view—the greatest possible amount of work for the greatest possible number of people, in substitution for unemployment payments. Remember that every man we take off unemployment assistance is costing us five times as much.
Comment on this
There are the figures. We are spending £1,500,000 in providing work, and against that £1,500,000 we are saving £376,000. What are the reasonable deductions? The Deputy knows that his statement is not true.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that in every area no person is getting less in wages than at least 40 per cent. more than he would get in unemployment assistance. In most of the areas, the number on the unemployed register is not sufficient to compel us to pay even so little as that. We heard about Dublin City. What is the position there? A person who has 16/- or £1 a week unemployment assistance will get three or four days' work at 10/- a day.
Comment on this
The Dublin Corporation can cure all that, and Deputy Alfred Byrne, possibly, can do more to change that situation than any other member of the corporation.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Act to prevent the Dublin Guardians giving home assistance to a man with 15/- unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
Then it is up to the Deputy to see that the Dublin Corporation increases its engineering staff and makes the necessary provisions to carry through its schemes. If the Deputy wants to give work, then the problem for the Dublin Corporation is to provide more schemes on which these men can be employed.
Comment on this
That is not our fault. The Dublin Corporation was asked to put up the most comprehensive schemes that could be put forward.
Comment on this
What do we find? The amount of employment which they were able to suggest to us that should be helped, assisted and financed out of the unemployment schemes, was not sufficient to do more than to provide work for married men with dependent children. If the Deputy wants to deal with the other categories, married men without dependent children, or if he wants to deal with single men without dependents, it is his job in the first place to go and expand the Dublin Corporation staff, and to put his thinking cap on and to think out schemes, such as slum clearances, sewerage improvements, public health schemes, and schemes to improve the general amenities of the City of Dublin, which will absorb not merely married men without dependents, but single men without dependents. When the Deputy does that, and it is his job, and that of the corporation, then he can come here and criticise what the Government is doing.