Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolutions (Resumed).
Contributions 1–182 of 544. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
We have no less an authority than that of the most distinguished mathematician on the Front Government Bench, President de Valera, for the proposition that the taxable capacity of this country compares with that of Great Britain as does 66 to 1, and I would remind the House that to question any of the obiter dicta of that important person is high treason. In fact, it is forecast in the leading article of the Irish Press that anyone who criticises that gentleman or his policy would, in any other country, be adjudged guilty of sabotage and deserve to be tried for a criminal offence. I do not know whether this is a shadow forecasting a coming event, but that distinguished journal over which the President presides so effectively calls on this House and the country to institute the Soviet system of sabotage trials for anyone who contradicts him. Bowing before that mighty sanction then, I adopt the 66 to 1 and, on that basis, our expenditure for Supply Services and Central Fund services this year amounts to £2,219,184,000, and our poor and decrepit neighbour, Great Britain, is managing to struggle along on £900,000,000.
That figure is in itself astonishing, but, under the modern Budget practice of this country, we have taken to accumulating Budget surpluses by the dexterous device of borrowing so much as is necessary to produce the desired result, and this year we are informed that we propose to borrow £1,970,000. Let me here again apply the yardstick of 66 to 1. I imagine that the audience of Mr. Chamberlain in Westminster would be somewhat dismayed if he announced that he calculated on having a surplus and then added in parenthesis: "After I have borrowed £130,020,000."
I can conceive the confusion that would break out in the French Chamber of Deputies if the French Minister for Finance got up and said he was glad to inform the House that he had a comfortable surplus, paused, and then added, "After I have borrowed 13,000,000,000 francs." Nevertheless, we are called upon in this country to join in the universal rejoicing when we make our proportionate borrowing here. We have a surplus, and will have a surplus, to rejoice the multitude when we have borrowed the Irish equivalent of 13,000,000,000 francs. However, this borrowing is a harmless thing, we are told. This borrowing is to finance export bounties, a non-recurrent item, and, therefore, something which may be properly borrowed for and treated as a capital item in our account.
My mind goes back to the happy days of 1933 when unemployment was a nonrecurrent item. We all remember it was going to be done away with. It was urgent that we should start housing schemes wherein to house the returning emigrants as they rushed back from the United States of America to share in the universal prosperity here. Last night, that budding statesman, Deputy Smith of Cavan, turned in anger on the Labour Party and said:
"We cannot solve the unemployment problem. How could you solve it if you had to do it?"
If unemployment, which was merely a passing symptom of the unhealthy state of the nation, resultant on the inability of Fianna Fáil to administer our affairs up to then, has not proved to be a passing fancy, are we not wise to contemplate the permanence of export bounties in our financial system? The plain fact is that unemployment continues and grows as a result of Fianna Fáil policy, and export bounties continue and grow as a result of Fianna Fáil policy. If the Fianna Fáil Government were to remain a permament factor in our affairs, this borrowing could not be justified, and we have to judge this Minister on his own record and on his own claims; but it is quite as true to say of this borrowing —if we assume, as I think we must assume, that the Minister had in mind that he intended to return to office— that he is borrowing this money to finance the reductions he has made in the food taxes.
This House will remember that the food taxes which the Minister proposes to remove were put on by the Minister not many years ago. He now proposes to take them off, and he proposes to take them off, because it has been driven in upon him that it is impossible for the people to continue to pay them. Are we not forced to a desperate expedient in this country when, in order to keep food in the mouths of the people, we have to borrow money? The sum the Minister intends to borrow is about the same as that which he proposes to take off in food taxes—4d. a lb. from tea, 10½d. a cwt. from flour, ¼d. a lb. from sugar, and 2d. a lb. from butter. I have referred to the export bounties, and I have suggested that if we assume that this Government were to continue, and God forbid that it should, we would be obliged to assume that these export bounties were a permanent charge. So far, the only transaction which this Government has made with a view to removing penal tariffs on our exports has been to induce the British Government to remove the tariff on horses. That was a concession we all welcomed, but our welcome became tempered when we discovered that the real effect of that concession was to remove the penal tariff from the horse on to the hen. Now, when we come to examine the concessions made in food taxes, we discover to our amazement that the taxes which have been taken off are the taxes which the Minister himself put on not very long ago, and that, as he makes the gesture of taking them off tea, flour, sugar and butter, he puts them on again on bacon.
Comment on this
And the Minister in putting this tax on bacon, just as he reduced the old age pensions by a subterfuge, attempts to put the tax on bacon by a subterfuge. Bacon to-day is making in the British market, about 90/- a cwt. Bacon is being sold to the Irish consumer at about 120/- a cwt., and the Irish producer is getting for his pigs an average price of 67/- a cwt. On the basis of 67/- for pigs, a bacon curer would make a comfortable profit, not to speak of paying his expenses, if he sold bacon at 95/- a cwt. They are getting an average of 120/- and, for smoked bacon, they are getting up to 130/- per cwt. from the consumers in this country. That is being done in conspiracy with the Minister for Agriculture in order to relieve the Exchequer of export bounties which the Minister would otherwise have to pay and for which the Minister for Finance would otherwise have to provide money. The Minister for Agriculture protests ignorance of this deception. I now say that this transaction is carried on with the knowledge and connivance of the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance in order to relieve the Exchequer of bounties that would otherwise have to be paid on exports of bacon to the British market. By raising the price of bacon to the people, the Exchequer is relieved of that burden, while the relief thus obtained is flourished about this House as a concession in respect of food taxes. Every Deputy who comes from the country knows the relation that bacon bears to fresh meat in the diet of the people——
Comment on this
Would the Deputy be good enough to tell us what revenue account secures any gain from bacon prices?
Comment on this
I shall tell the Minister very quickly. The Minister is trying to fool his own Party and he may succeed, but he will not fool the intelligent section of the House. The fund in which this money should appear but does not appear, because the Finance Accounts are at present being drawn for the purpose of deceiving the people, is the export bounties fund. On the other side, there ought to be an item of revenue or an item of deficit. The item of revenue or of deficit is out of the accounts and the amount that ought to appear as export bounties is out of the account.
Comment on this
It is an interesting fact, to which I draw attention, that the observations which I have been making have drawn the Minister into disorderly interruption after I have been speaking for only ten minutes. He spoke for two hours and seven minutes yesterday, weaving his web of deception. Now, when the exposé comes, he cannot keep quiet for ten minutes. I ask the House to pay special attention to that fact, and I ask them to investigate this matter as closely as possible so that the truth can be established beyond all doubt or question. The bacon curers are being aided and abetted by the Government in charging the consumers of this country an excessive price in order to compensate themselves for the failure of the Minister for Finance to provide money to pay an export bounty on the bacon which his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, requires and compels them to send to the British market every month. Remember, every bacon factory in this State applies for a bacon quota and is given a quota in Great Britain. It has got to fill that quota in the British market, fair weather and foul, no matter what price it gets. And if it does not fill that quota, its business is whittled away and given to somebody else——
Comment on this
——so that the bacon is sent to Great Britain by order of the Minister for Agriculture. The loss is made up partly out of the hypothetical Prices Fund, which belongs to the producer and which is being robbed from him, and, partly, from the excess price charged to the Irish consumer of bacon. This problem is going to be covered by a campaign of confusion and a smoke-cloud of misrepresentation for the reason that bacon is a commodity that is sold in many forms. You have salted bacon; you have green bacon; you have dried pale-cured bacon; and you have smoked bacon. All these bacons are susceptible to different cutting and different preparation for the market. Each cut and each quality has a different price. In rural Ireland, a large proportion of the bacon consumed is salted bacon. In the cities and towns, part of the bacon consumed is green bacon, but most of it is pale, dried bacon, and the smoked bacon, cut in what is called the Wiltshire cut. The net result of all this is that the people of this country are paying, as I reckon, about 3/9 a stone, or 3½d. per lb., more for their bacon than they would have to pay if the exports to Great Britain received their bounty from the Treasury and not out of the pockets of the producers or consumers of this country.
I have tried to find out from small farmers, and workers in this city and elsewhere, how these food taxes react on their personal home accounts because I want to bring this business down from the headlines of the Irish Press to the dinner tables of my own neighbours in County Mayo and the workingmen and women of this city and the other cities of the State. Take the case of a man living in a labourer's cottage who might buy two stones of flour, ½lb. of tea, ¼st. of sugar, 7lb. of bacon and 1lb. of butter. Before these amendments were made in the taxes on these foodstuffs, that parcel would have cost the workman about 16/5. That would have been the cost about a month ago. Since then, the price of bacon has steadily risen and I do not think I exaggerate when I say that the average price of bacon would be about 1/3 to-day. I believe that it is substantially more than that. That man would get 1d. a stone off the flour—2/2 a sack. He would get 2d. off the ½lb. of tea, 1d. off the ¼st. of sugar, and his bacon would be increased about 1/3 for the ½st., while his butter would be 2d. per lb. cheaper. He would, therefore, be paying about 17/- for what cost him 16/5 a month ago. Every 1d. conferred upon him by these reductions of taxation is more than eaten up by the increased cost of bacon brought about by the subterfuge which I have described. Assessing that in terms of actual facts, we find that a man is paying a comparatively large sum on a very modest purchase of food. On 2st. of flour he is paying about 9d. That arises in this way: that there is only one miller in this country who is milling flour in Ireland and in England. The House will excuse me if I mention the name of the firm, for that is a thing that is not customary here. I refer to the name of Messrs. Rank. If Messrs. Rank buy a cargo of wheat 30 miles from Limerick, they order that vessel to put into Limerick and discharge half the cargo there, and then they order it out and to put into Liverpool and discharge the other half of the cargo in Liverpool. What happens? The wheat mills in Liverpool will sell that wheat as flour 10/- a sack cheaper than the flour from the same class of wheat milled in Limerick. The man to whom I refer, a workingman living in Dublin, will pay 10/- a sack more for the flour milled in Limerick than the workingman in Liverpool will pay for flour milled in Liverpool from the same wheat and by the same firm. This concession—taking the tax off the wheat—will reduce the price of the sack of flour by 2/2. That represents a concession of 10½d. a cwt. on flour or a reduction of about 1½d. or 1¼d. per stone. I put the reduction at 1d. per stone, because I do not believe that the millers will pass on the whole benefit to the Irish consumers.
On the ½lb. of tea there is about half the duty taken off because the cheaper tea, Java tea, bulks largest. Java is a low-grade tea. The Assams and other teas from the Commonwealth of Nations are a higher grade. Java tea is lower. I assume that the cheaper tea consists of the lower-grade Java or Sumatra tea. A ½st. of sugar will cost 7d. in taxation; 7lb. of bacon will cost the workingman about 1/3 additional. The tax on his butter is being reduced. Here we have a man who is purchasing 17/- worth of food and we find that that man will have to pay at least 3/8 in taxes out of that 17/-. I do not know whether such an arrangement commends itself to the Deputies here. If you have a man who is earning 21/- a week being called upon to pay 3/8 taxes on his food— never mind what he is paying on clothes, household utensils and everything else taxed by the Government— you must admit that that tax is inequitable, unjust and oppressive. The Minister, however, does not seem to think so. He speaks with exultation of the increased yield of taxes. Since when has it become a matter of congratulation in any sane country in the world that the rate of taxation is rising——
Comment on this
No, excuse me, it is the rate that is rising in a most extraordinary way, or to paraphrase the matter, in a Fianna Fáil way, which means the same thing. But it is impossible to explain that to the Minister. The Minister for Finance said yesterday that the operation of many customs duties stopped imports altogether. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said these duties stopped the influx of commodities altogether and that they yield no revenue; that the tendency was to wipe out that revenue from the duty. Grant them that and turn to the yield of customs and you find that the revenue on what is still coming in is £1,750,000 greater than it was. When that is known we can see in a greater or lesser degree how we are making contributions to the revenue. The Minister himself admitted yesterday that he is collecting an immense revenue on plate glass alone——
Comment on this
There are 86 pages in the Minister's Budget speech and surely he does not want me to wade through all that now.
Comment on this
The Deputy quoted me as saying that I collected an immense revenue from plate glass. Will the Deputy refer me to where I made that statement?
Comment on this
The Minister boasted about getting an immense revenue from plate glass. The Minister for Industry and Commerce himself boasted that he put a duty on flannelette; that the revenue coming from that would go into the Exchequer and that if I did not like it I could jump it.
Comment on this
The revenues collected— more than £10,000,000—come entirely from the pockets of the people of this country. Over and above that, we know that tariffs of 50 per cent., 60 per cent. and 70 per cent are keeping out large quantities of merchandise. The consumers are being compelled to pay the manufacturers inside this country a charge that they allege to be an economic price for the products of their factories and the increased cost of all this has to be borne by the people. We are told that the revenue from tobacco has greatly increased. I would refer the Minister to a speech made on one occasion at a general meeting of the Imperial Tobacco Company in which the chairman of that company pointed out that one of the most remarkable facts was found by them to be that the more intense unemployment became the higher went the sales of tobacco. That is not a difficult thing to understand——
Comment on this
But it is a fact. It is a well-established fact and it is perfectly natural that the tendency of men who have nothing to do and nothing to occupy their time will be to smoke more tobacco during the day than if they were at work. That is an established fact. Motor taxes, the Minister tells us, have produced an increased yield. I would ask Deputy Brian Brady how many farmer constituents of his in West Donegal bought motor cars in the last 12 months? Does any Deputy in this House who represents a constituency populated mainly by small farmers accept the statement of the Minister for Finance that increased revenue from taxes is an indication of increasing prosperity throughout the country? I would remind the House that the best estimate of our national income is £150,000,000 per annum. Now, the Government is spending £35,000,000 and the local authorities £5,250,000. That makes an annual charge on the people of £40,250,000, while our national income is about £150,000,000. Is that a state of affairs which leaves the Minister for Finance satisfied in his mind as to the economic condition of this country?
The great trouble is this, that the Minister for Finance and most of his colleagues have made their residence in the City of Dublin for the past five years and they are steadily, as is the fate of such men, getting out of touch with the country, the affairs of which they are supposed to be running. They are deceived as they see crowds standing twirling their canes in cinema queues waiting to get in to a crowded cinema or a crowded restaurant in our city, forgetting that the vast majority of our people do not patronise the O'Connell Street cinemas nor yet the down-town restaurants. Ministers are greatly impressed by the fact that Dublin is not as hard hit as people would suggest the country generally is. That is not a strange phenomenon. The same thing happened in Australia. If these people would take counsel with the economists who saw Australia when she was breaking up, they would be told that while the rural part of Australia was withering and dying and the country starting on the road that led to eventual bankruptcy, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide and the other great cities of Australia appeared to boom.
That was due to two reasons. As the country withered, the cities began to grow. The people fled from the country into the cities and, as the people came into the City of Dublin and the City of Cork, as we know they have from the census returns, Henry Street grew no longer, Talbot Street grew no longer, the shops in South Great George's Street did not get any bigger, but there were more people buying in them than bought heretofore. As they grew the shops in the rural towns began to close and the small towns of Ireland began to dwindle. Those who are living in those small towns and those who frequent the small shops see them perishing, while the Minister makes his contribution to the prosperity of the cinemas and the restaurants of Dublin. It is poor consolation to them to be told that Dublin is doing very well. They may take that as a factor, and I think it is comparatively true, but it does not alter the fact that the people in the country are doing very badly.
I do not know if the Minister in his literary excursions has had recently brought to his attention a book called "Gone with the Wind." There is in that book the philosophical rumination of an adventurer who is asked what brought him to Georgia in the throes of the civil war, and his reply was:
"Young lady, as you grow older you will come to learn there are two times when men can make money; one is when a nation is building, and the other is as it sinks into decay."
There are plenty of people at present flapping their way into this country from foreign climes to share in the spoils of the decay of the country, and if there may be a spurious prosperity in some of our cities while our country decays, that ought to be no consolation to responsible men or women in this House.
It is the duty of men and women here, who know the true condition of the country, to tell our metropolitan Minister for Finance that all is not so well in Ballydehob as it appears to be in O'Connell Street. Does the Minister for Finance ever consult his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he contemplates the economic welfare of our people? Does he ever ask him are the people buying more stuff? Are the essentials that our people ordinarily use being used in greater quantities than before? Surely that is the true barometer of how the country stands? If he had asked that simple question, I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce would have given the Minister for Finance some surprising information. He might have told him that in 1935 our people used 168,000 pairs less of shoes and boots than they used in 1931. Does the Minister for Industry and Commerce deny that?
Comment on this
Observe that while the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not attempt to challenge that figure——
Comment on this
I am talking of shoes manufactured in Ireland, plus shoes manufactured in Great Britain, of all descriptions, and I say that the reduction in consumption of shoes imported and manufactured in Ireland by our people amounts to 168,000 pairs. There was that number less in 1935 than in 1931. Now let us turn to wearing apparel. What about wearing apparel—are they using more of that? The Minister for Industry and Commerce, if his capacity to blush survives, would blush becomingly and say, "No, we were using £594,000 worth less apparel in 1935 than we used in 1931." I ask Deputies to note this, that while I am in a position to quote the number of pairs of shoes and boots, when I speak of wearing apparel, the only figures available to me are the figures relating to its monetary value. I submit that the cost of wearing apparel in this country has substantially increased, so that the bulk of the wearing apparel consumed by our people is very much more reduced than those figures I have given would suggest.
There are Deputies living in the country who know from their own observation that what I say is true. Anyone living in the West of Ireland to-day who sees respectable men and their families, who were a few years ago comfortable and prosperous, coming in in second-hand clothes and raggedy garments that they would not have dreamt of wearing to a market five years ago——
Comment on this
——realises the conditions to which our people have been reduced. The Minister knows so little about the ordinary, everyday life of our people that it would really be a kindness if he would not attempt to interpret what is happening in rural Ireland at the present time. He knows as little about it as he knows about what is happening in Peking.
Comment on this
I know a good deal about them. I have seen my neighbours driven into them by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I have seen the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance laughing as they heard of my neighbours, the people who live about me, being forced from decent garments into second-hand clothes and into the rags they are at present wearing. It is nothing to laugh at if you see these things on the backs of people who were accustomed to be decently dressed, on the backs of people whom you have known since you were a child. It is nothing to laugh at at all, and I am glad to see there are Deputies on the Government Benches who do not laugh at it. There are Deputies here who live amongst the people in the country, and I am sure they take no pleasure in seeing those people driven back to the poverty out of which our fathers took them 50 years ago.
It took Fianna Fáil Ministers and the likes of them to drive those people back to the level that had been reached when our fathers drove the landlords out of the country and made the people independent in their holdings. It is the ambition of the present Government to make peasants of the children of people whom our fathers rescued from peasantry. The small farmers of Ireland were peasants. We made them farmers, we made them independent landholders. The Fianna Fáil Government are now driving their children back to peasantry, and they will not succeed in that business if we can stop them.
The income of our farmers has dropped in the last four years from £64,000,000 to £40,000,000. Those are the figures published by the Minister's Department. In face of all those facts, we have two gentlemen who know as much about rural Ireland as they know about Peking, gentlemen who spend their lives and substance in the city, jeering from their Front Bench here at the condition of the people whom they have reduced to the state of poverty in which they are living. I notice with satisfaction that there are some Deputies sitting on the back benches of Fianna Fáil who have at least not sunk to the indecency of jeering at people whom they are reducing to that condition.
Comment on this
The Minister can laugh and laugh well. I regret I have not with me an article written by a detached observer who went to see the condition of the people in Bantry, County Cork.
Comment on this
Yes. I will quote for the Minister, not the representative of any newspaper in this city, but a Deputy from his own benches, representing the constituency of West Cork, who got up in the town of Macroom and said publicly that the people in the hillside country around Macroom were starving and that something would have to be done for them, and he never denied it. He said it at the Ard Fheis of the Fianna Fáil organisation, and there was not a single man or woman with the brazen-faced audacity to get up and contradict him.
Comment on this
No. God forbid that I should be, but I read it in the kept newspaper of the Minister and his Party, and it was there that I saw it.
Comment on this
Yes. The Deputy read about Adrigoole, and he read the cheap and fraudulent falsehoods that were published about Adrigoole. He heard the falsehood nailed, not once, but half a dozen times in this House, and the Deputy is still waiting for the present Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who now has all the files and all the information at his disposal, to repeat that slander, even once, since he came into office, but the Minister for Local Government and Public Health has never dared to do so. I challenge him now to produce the files on Adrigoole and, with his present responsibility as Minister for Local Government and Public Health, to repeat the allegations, now that he is a Minister, that he made as a Deputy, and I will bet that he cannot do it because he has got the information now and dare not now attempt to put that fraud over on the people again or, if he did so, he knows that he would be held up to be something that I hope he is not, and that is a fraudulent liar.
Comment on this
The Deputy, possibly, was more mature then than he is now, and it would have done no harm to produce them.
Comment on this
I want now, Sir, to say a word about the condition of people in this country who, carrying on that good tradition of pride that was handed down to them, are now living in many cases, I believe, under conditions of as severe privation as those described in Bantry, but who are too proud to let their neighbours know of their position.
Comment on this
If things are as bad as the Deputy says, why did his Party not move the writ for the by-election?
Comment on this
I know of people in this country who are poor and who have been hungry, but who do not care to have it said by their neighbours that they are on the rates or objects of charity.
Comment on this
If Deputies or Ministers opposite want to speak afterwards, they can do so, but they cannot break me off the line of argument which I am going to pursue to the end, by interruptions of that kind. We will face an election very shortly——
Comment on this
—— and when we do, I trust that the people will give the verdict that I anticipate they will give. I have drawn the attention of the Minister and of the Government to the condition of the people in this country generally, outside O'Connell Street and its immediate neighbourhood. I now invite the Minister's attention to the fact that, from the railway station of Ballaghaderreen alone, there have gone, in emigration since Christmas, an average of 80 boys and girls every week. They have gone from one small sideline station alone since Christmas—80 a week—and that is being reproduced in railway stations all over the Province of Connacht, all over the west of the Province of Munster, and all over Donegal. I direct the attention of the Government to the fact that, although our population is falling, our unemployment figures are higher by thousands than they were when the Minister came into office.
Comment on this
I direct the attention of the Minister to the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is at present defending in this House the voting of the greatest sum ever voted in this House, in the history of Saorstát Eireann, for the relief of urgent unemployment. I cordially endorse that attempt to solve the problem, and I am satisfied that every penny is urgently necessary, but I wish to direct the attention of the House to the fact that to-day, five years after the plan was put into operation, more money is more urgently required to provide for a larger number of unemployed in a smaller population, with a greater tide of emigration flowing, than has ever been the case since Saorstát Eireann was established, and while the Minister was trying to tear it down.
Do those facts bring any light to the mind of the Minister for Finance? Side by side with those facts, I want to put the galling circumstances in which the small farmer of this country at present finds himself. When I speak of the small farmer, I mean the three-cow man. During the last few weeks the price of cattle has improved and one would have expected the small farmer to come out with his beast, glad of the opportunity of getting some return on his labours at last—only to be told that the cattle which should now be selling as profitable two-year-olds are rotting as calves into the graves prepared for them by Doctor Ryan, the Minister for Agriculture. The cattle are gone. Gruesome as it may be for the Minister for Industry and Commerce and disagreeable as it may be to his fastidious nose, it is tragic to the people who cannot get the profit on those cattle to pay their way. Eggs are selling in rural Ireland at the present moment for 5/- the long hundred, while Indian meal is costing 10/2. Pigs are selling at 67/- a cwt., while bacon is fetching up to 130/- a cwt. from the bacon curers of this country.
I say now, as I have said before, that while every other country in the world is growing richer, this country grows poor. This country grows poor in the vast majority of its population. While every other country in the world is learning, or has learned, the lesson that economic self-sufficiency means a reduced standard of living for the people and eventual disaster for the country that attempts it— while every country in the world is working with their neighbours to release themselves from the toils of that accursed doctrine, this country is gathering that doctrine to its bosom and is trying up the limbs of the whole State with it. Economic self-sufficiency is the mad hatter of modern economics, and it is not surprising to discover such a thing as a mad hatter in economics presiding at the Executive Council tables of the Fianna Fáil Government. So long as this Government continues along the line of general policy which it at present pursues, no frantic attempt on its part, by borrowing or by other subterfuge, can effectively stop the holes in its crazy path. The country can be kept afloat from year to year, and every rational man knows that it takes a long time to dissipate the accumulated wealth of any country.
At the present time, all the symptoms in this country are of decreasing wealth and of future hardship. We have, I suppose, £300,000,000 invested abroad. It will take a long time to spend that amount of money, but I say that the productivity of this country is being steadily reduced, and I say that the inevitable consequence of the present line of policy pursued by the Government will be to drive our people back to a peasant standard of life, and I say that, rather than do that, any remedy should be resorted to. There is only one effective remedy for the present situation. We have got to get a market for our agricultural products. We have got to secure, for the people who live on the land, a profitable market in which to dispose of their agricultural surplus. Out of the profits thus derived, we have got to secure a fair wage for the labouring man on the land and a pool out of which industry can draw a fair profit for the products it is equipped to produce. We cannot have industry in this country, as we ought to have, unless the agricultural community have money wherewith to buy the products of that industry. The situation in the boot business and in the readymade clothing business is evidential of the growing incapacity of our rural population to buy our industrial products. If that develops, it will do untold damage to the industry of this country because if the industrialists of this country once learn the lesson that even with a prohibitive tariff, that even with quotas, industry can go bankrupt for want of an internal demand, you will so intimidate industrialists, that it will become virtually impossible to get anybody to risk their capital and their time in promoting industry which is so vitally necessary to the healthy life of the country as a whole.
There is no use imagining that we can build up industry by strangling our international trade alone. You cannot build up anything in this country by strangling international trade. Deputies ought to face the problem as to whether they are prepared to defend tariff walls with dead bodies or not. Rearmament, I think it is universally agreed, leads to war. I say that the doctrine of economic self-sufficiency must lead to war as well. If economic self-sufficiency is to become the order of the day all over the world, war is as inevitable as dawn is after night. We ought to make it clear that we are not prepared to co-operate in a world conspiracy to maintain prohibitive tariff barriers by the system of strangling international trade with the dead bodies of Irishmen or men of any other nationality. There is no other means of producing real economic self-sufficiency except by being ready to maintain tariff walls with bayonets and dead bodies. Unless we are prepared to face that, we cannot work out in this country any sane economic programme at all. If we are prepared to face that, we can devise a method of using the tariff instrument in such a way as will not destroy international trade but as will make it possible for decent industry to be established in this country and eventually to take its place as part of the exporting business as well as supplying the home market.
If you want to sell abroad you have got to buy abroad. That is just as true of Great Britain, America, France or Italy as it is true of Ireland. You cannot sell abroad if you do not buy abroad; you cannot buy abroad if you do not sell abroad. The prudent course is to do both one and the other in moderation and to bear in mind the economic resources of the country for which we are responsible. Extravagant or doctrinaire free trade is just as dangerous in the present state of the world as extravagant or doctrinaire self-sufficiency. Common sense is the only solution to the problems which at present confront mankind and it is the extremists on both sides who are the danger at present to peace and prosperity, not only in this country but in every country where such extremists are to be found.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking me the highly intelligent question which has been put to me more than once by the Irish Press:“How are you going to settle the economic war?”
Comment on this
If the Deputy asks me what particular trade agreements I would make, he might as well ask me what is the colour of an engine driver's beard.
Comment on this
I should like to be fair to Deputy Moore. Would the Deputy be good enough first of all to recite for me, not the terms of the trade agreements that would be made by Fianna Fáil, but the terms of the trade agreements that have been made by Fianna Fáil? That should be an easy thing to do. I am not asking him to think out the terms of a trade agreement and communicate them to the House. All I ask the Deputy to do is to repeat from memory the terms of the trade agreements already entered into by his own Party and for which he himself has voted. That is a comparatively easy thing.
Comment on this
It is silly to ask childish debating society questions in the middle of a debate on a question of this kind. Any rational man can get up and say what are the terms of a trade agreement which he would be prepared to support if they were brought before the House.
Comment on this
I have no doubt it suits the Minister's limited intellect, but I am treating this matter from the standpoint of a rational man. The Deputy must realise that if you accept the general principle that far from desiring to work towards economic self-sufficiency, you want to work away from it, as far as you can, if your objective is to build up industry and agriculture in this country for the purpose of maintaining, developing and increasing international trade, there is a distinct cleavage between these philosophies. If I say to the Deputy, as I do say, that an absolute essential to improve the standard of living in this country is to improve and expand the national trade, the Deputy will readily point out to me that in so far as he is a supporter of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, he believes that the ideal towards which the State should work is the maximum degree of economic self-sufficiency that it is possible by legislation to attain. That is the difference between us.
Comment on this
The Deputy might as well see no virtue in tying a loincloth about his waist and dancing on the hill of Tara. Neither do I, and it seems to me quite irrelevant. I suggest to the Deputy that, unless our objective in trade should be along the lines I have mentioned, the cost of living that our people are at present bearing must be reduced by either of two expedients—reducing the money cost of the goods they have to buy to keep body and soul together, or alternatively, securing a price for the goods they have to sell commensurate with the world price of commodities which they have to buy. I have not said, and I do not now suggest, that it is possible for the Minister for Industry and Commerce to control the price of wheat in Manitoba. What I condemn the Government for doing is that on the top of this burden they have piled on taxes and, while world prices are rising, they, through their political folly, have held down the price of anything that we have to sell to the level which obtained before increasing world prices began. You cannot segregate this country from the rest of the world. If you allowed economic trends to operate here as they operate in the rest of the world, the price of all we had to sell would rise——
Comment on this
——in proportion to the price of everything we had to buy. But if you destroy the natural markets in which this country can get the benefit of a rise in price, you have an artificially low price for what we have to sell and the normal rising price for the other commodities in the outside world, always bearing in mind that if our normal markets were left available to us now our products would rise in the same proportion as the other primary products were rising all the world over. That must be perfectly clear to Deputy Moore. When wheat was cheap, hogs were cheap. When corn was cheap in America, hogs were cheap in America, and the world price of bacon tended to go very low. As the price of corn rose, the price of hogs rose and the price of bacon rose, but the economic war went on. The result of it is that you have us operating on a market where we are willing sellers and the other side are indifferent buyers, with the result that they can levy on us every penny of the tariffs they want to get out of us, and consequently reduce the return on what we have to sell. At the same time you had this immense rise in the cost of primary products, and, on top of that, the taxation which is being heaped on this high price by the Government of this country.
I say that the position is like that of the man who is tied to two maple trees by his two legs. He can stand a certain amount of pressure, but if the distance between the tops of those two maple trees becomes wide enough he will be torn in two, and that is what is happening to the people of this country at the present time. There may have been a time in the 18th century when the proletariat could be crucified in the cause of bureaucracy or economics. That age is gone, and anybody who attempts to crucify humanity, in the words of Mr. Jennings Bryan, on a cross of gold—or a cross of politics—is going to precipitate a revolution. The people will not starve in order to carve a political dignity for a political leader, or in order to preserve the gold content of the British pound. The British people learned that; the American people learned it, and the people all over the world have learned that you cannot massacre people in that way. We are the only people who do not seem to have learned it, and it is true that the forbearance of our people so far has been perfectly astonishing. They have pulled their stakes and fled to England to look for work there, rather than clamour for it here or take whatever softness they could get out of the various social services which are provided. That cannot go on for ever, and even if it did it would mean destruction for this country. I think Deputy Moore will agree with that. There is no use in imagining that we can maintain the economic life of this country if we do not import and export to an ever-increasing degree. I say that to-day that is consistent with the healthy development of life in this country. I say that to-day that is going to produce a higher standard of living for our people. I say that to-day that is going to produce larger and better prices for our industrialists, for our agriculturists, and for our labouring men and women no matter in what walk of life they find themselves. The alternative is to continue the same mad course which has been pursued up to now by the Fianna Fáil Government and to make a desert of this country. If you make a desert of this country, as you are at present doing, the result of it is going to be that the people will fly the country or else upset the State. So far as I can see, the trend is going to be that our people will fly the country in despair; that we will have progressive deterioration and diminunition of our population; that the burdens at present being taken on the backs of the community—taken willingly by the community—will become proportionately greater as our population dwindles in the years to come, and that we will slowly get into a steady vortex of declining prosperity, the end of which will be reached when the State is no longer in a position to meet its commitments.
The last word I have to say is this; it will take a considerable time to bring this country to the stage where the State cannot meet its commitments. If that stage is ever reached in this country, no man or no combination of men will be able to get this country out of it. As I reminded the House many a time, Newfoundland reached that position and was able to turn to Great Britain, the mother country, to take her out; Great Britain is now doing it. But this country is a mother country, a sovereign independent State, with no one to turn to but itself. If this country is allowed to go to the stage where the State is unable to meet its liabilities, no man and no combination of men will be able to get it out. It is for that reason that I welcome the general election which is coming on in the course of the next few months, because it will provide the people of this country with an opportunity of taking now the steps that can be taken to make an end of the peril that besets this country, in the knowledge that unless those steps are taken now the people of this country will not be able to take them when a full realisation of the disaster is upon them.
Comment on this
If any serious work is to be done in this country this year, I think it will be necessary to get the general election over quickly, because apparently we are going to be treated to a spate of oratory here on every possible occasion, which will be merely practising for the hustings and have no relevancy to the matters under discussion. This discussion here to-day on the financial statement of the year should be one of the most important debates in the House. It gives us an opportunity of reviewing, in relation to the financial situation, the economic progress or otherwise of the country during the past 12 months. I submit that it is taking the duties of an Opposition much too lightly to skip all that, and to pour out this torrent of abuse, and rhetoric and nonsense which we have just had from Deputy Dillon. I am sure Deputies of the Party opposite, as I said once before, must on occasion be appalled by the position into which they have been led by Deputy Dillon. Their position, in so far as one can understand it from their speeches, is that their electoral hopes are based upon their ability to prove that the economic conditions of this country are worse than they were or, as Deputy Dillon stated, worse than in any other country in the world. Not merely are they content not to explore the facts for the purpose of ascertaining whether there is any justification for their contention, but they are now in a position in which they are hoping—and hoping wildly— that economic conditions will deteriorate, that some national catastrophe will occur, because the electoral prospects of their Party are based upon that.
Comment on this
If that is nonsense I shall be glad to be informed by Deputy O'Leary or any Deputy opposite what other explanation there can be for the speech which we had just now from Deputy Dillon, and the type of speech which we get regularly from Front Bench members of that Party. Every fact which Deputy Dillon adverted to was twisted by him in order to support his contention that those appalling economic conditions exist here. In adopting that course, he must have known that Deputies on this side of the House, or any intelligent citizen, can get the facts accurately in official publications or otherwise. He could not possibly hope to mislead the House as to the accuracy of the facts I stated, so that the only conclusion we are forced to is this: that he was resorting to the only method open to him in order to produce here if he could the economic conditions he desires to see; that is, economic conditions so bad for our people that they will be induced to turn against the Government.
Fortunately, at the present time, the Party opposite have no real power to influence the course of economic conditions here except whatever power they may get from their oratory. Whatever damage they can do by their speeches in attacking the credit of the State and misleading the people as to its economic condition, they will use. That is the only power they have, and they are using that power to the utmost limit in the hope that people will be discouraged, that investors will be prevented from putting their money into Irish industry, and that the progress which has been going on for the past three or four years will be slowed up in consequence. That is what Deputy Dillon is aiming to do, and that was the purpose of the speech which he delivered here to-day. He is not likely to succeeded in his aim. He has not succeeded up to this. People found out Deputy Dillon long ago, and they are not likely to be deceived by him now.
Let us, however, for the purpose of completing the process of debunking Deputy Dillon, take the statements which he has made here in the most dramatic tones, with all the rhetorical exuberance of which he is capable and examine them coldly and calmly. Economic conditions in the Free State are, he said, worse than in any other country in the world. I do not know of any easy criterion, of any easily applicable standard for determining the economic conditions of any country, but there are various things to which people advert when they set out to examine these matters. Unemployment is one. The number of persons registered as unemployed in this country at the present time is about 90,000. It is a big number. I do not for the moment propose to examine the cause of the existence of that amount of unemployment. I merely mention it in relation to Deputy Dillon's statement that the economic conditions here are worse than in any other country in the world.
Comment on this
I am prepared to take any standard the Deputy cares to suggest, but I am taking unemployment in the first instance. I know that the number of persons registered as unemployed in the 26 countries comprising the Irish Free State, in relation to our population is about half the number registered as unemployed in the six north-eastern countries. If the number of unemployed there is, therefore, to be the standard adopted to judge economic conditions here, we are not half as bad as they are in Northern Ireland, and we are slightly better than they are in Great Britain.
Comment on this
The Deputy can make the calculation for himself. Take the total number of registered unemployed here and find out what percentage of our total population that constitutes. He can do the same in relation to the British statistics. I saw recently in a paper that one-tenth of the entire population of Canada are on public relief. Some few weeks ago the National Council of the Danish Farmers' Association sent a petition to their Government, on behalf of the 100,000 farmers who are members of that association, in which they described the agricultural situation in Denmark as the worst known there for many generations. In Denmark there is a population only slightly larger than our own, and the number of registered unemployed there on March 5 was 145,000, about 50 per cent. more than here.
Comment on this
Are the figures in relation to unemployed calculated there in the same way as they are here?
Comment on this
They are in this respect. I agree that the total number of unemployed here in relation to the total number anywhere else is one that is likely to be misleading because there are classes of people included on our register who are not included on the others, but we will not go into that for the moment. I merely note the trend of events. In each week of this year the number of unemployed in this country has been from 30,000 to 40,000 less than the corresponding week of last year.
Comment on this
I will deal with the question of emigration later. In Denmark, the number of registered unemployed on the 5th March was 26,000 greater than in the corresponding week of last year. Deputies can take any standard they like, and by any standard I am prepared to dispose of their arguments.
Comment on this
So far as Denmark is concerned, the facts I have stated—the views expressed by the National Council of the Danish Farmers' Association, and the number of unemployed in relation to population and the growth in the number of unemployed— would indicate that economic conditions there are worse than they are here. There is no economic war on in Denmark or Great Britain. Danish agricultural goods have, in fact, certain privileges in the British market. There are no currency difficulties. In fact, so far as there is a differential in the value of Danish and British currency, it is in favour of Danish exports. Therefore, no arguments can be advanced to explain the economic conditions prevailing in that country similar to the arguments used by Deputy Dillon who, of course, puts the blame for all our evils on this so-called economic war. One can examine the conditions in France, Belgium, and a number of other countries, and he will find by the ordinary accepted standards that the economic conditions in those countries are certainly no worse than they are here: in many cases they are definitely worse, but, taking them on the whole, they cannot be described as better.
We have got to face here this fact, that by every standard and any standard our economic conditions are definitely improving. We have had a lot of talk about emigration. Emigration has been for a long time a serious factor in the economic life of this country. With the exception of a short period in 1931, 1932 and 1933, there has been an outward flow of population, and emigration, though other reasons may also operate, is due to economic causes in the last resort. I do not say that we can regard the existence of this outward flow of the population as an indication that there is some economic evil to be remedied: something wrong with the economic structure which has to be put right. Now, what is the obvious solution for emigration? It is to find more employment, and more remunerative employment, at home for the people who are now emigrating than they are likely to find abroad. I do not say that we will succeed overnight in producing conditions here which will stop emigration, because there are other than economic factors operating. As Deputies are aware, a number of those going to Great Britain at the present time are leaving employment here. No doubt a large number are going in the hope of getting employment. That is due to the abnormal conditions existing in certain respects in Great Britain at the present time. I am prepared to admit, however, that the continuance of emigration is evidence that the work that we set out to do in the improvement of the economic structure of this country has not been completed, and that much more has to be done before we can regard the economic structure as fundamentally sound. But, what is the alternative to the work that we are doing? Emigration existed before Fianna Fáil came into office. In the ten years prior to 1931, 250,000 people left this country according to the statistics, and the statistics underestimated the total, to find—mainly in the United States and also in other countries—opportunities of employment, or more remunerative employment, than they could find at home. That emigration, however, was quite understandable, having regard to the decline in economic conditions here. Remember, our statistics show that, between 1929 and 1931, for the three years immediately preceding the change of Government, there was a steady decline in every type of employment here.
Comment on this
Precisely. The Deputy himself stated that the number of unemployed at the moment is considerably larger than it was in 1931. A mere reference to these facts will show that that could not have been the case. Between 1929 and 1931 the number of people employed in agriculture declined. Is that fact contested?
Comment on this
The Minister will admit that in these particular years there was a world-wide decline?
Comment on this
Cumann na nGaedheal or the Government were not responsible for the world depression, but they were responsible for their inactivity in that world depression, for their failure to take measures to protect the people of the country against the consequences of that depression. During that period, and without any action by the Government then in office to rectify the conditions, there was a decline in the number of persons employed in agriculture and in industry. I will remind Deputy Morrissey of something. Does he remember in 1929 there was a Bill introduced by Deputy McGilligan, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, to reduce the contribution payable for unemployment insurance? He and I opposed that Bill—he much more strongly than I did.
Comment on this
Much more strongly. He contended that, if there was a prospect of a surplus accruing on the Unemployment Insurance Fund, that surplus should be devoted to improving the rates of benefit payable rather than towards reducing the contribution. There was not, in fact, a surplus at the time. There was a substantial debt due by the fund to the Exchequer but, in so far as the debt had been gradually reducing, the Minister for Industry and Commerce at that time, Deputy McGilligan, thought that he could take the risk of cutting the contribution. He took the risk at the wrong time because, instead of employment increasing as he had gambled upon, employment began to decrease, and instead of the debt remaining stationary or becoming less, it increased rapidly, and in 1932 the Unemployment Insurance Fund was heavily in debt and the debt had been increasing rapidly in each of the three years previous to that. In 1932 we increased the contribution but, at the same time, we took from the fund £250,000 as a contribution towards the cost of unemployment assistance. In each year since that, the revenue to the fund has substantially grown. In each year since that, expenditure from the fund for the payment of unemployment insurance benefit has decreased, and to-day we can face a situation when the fund is free from debt, and we can contemplate the possibility of a surplus accruing there at the rate of £200,000 per year for the first time since this State was established. I merely mention that as an indication of how economic conditions have changed here.
To get back to where I was. In 1931 this State was facing a situation in which the value of agricultural exports had declined over two years by no less than £13,000,000. We hear a lot about the fall in the value of our agricultural production between 1929 and 1934. Deputies opposite always ignored the fact that more than half of that total decline took place before the end of 1931. There was that substantial decline in the value of agricultural production and of agricultural exports, that decline in agricultural employment, that decline in industrial production and in industrial employment in 1931. If, at the present time, economic conditions in this country are the worst in the world, as Deputy Dillon contended, they were obviously worse in 1931, because since then there has been an increase in the number of persons employed in agriculture, a substantial increase in the number of persons employed in industry, a substantial increase in the value and in the volume of industrial production, a substantial increase in the volume of many classes of agricultural production. Can these facts be contested? Is there a single statement I have made the accuracy of which can be contested on any grounds?
Comment on this
If in 1931 there was no emigration, if in 1931 there were decreasing numbers in industry and in agriculture, and if since then there has been emigration, and if since then there has been an increase in employment of about 75,000 persons, is it not reasonable to assume that the number of persons unemployed in 1931 must have been considerably more than the number unemployed to-day? I will admit that I cannot prove that statement because, if there is one thing upon which the Party opposite deserve to be congratulated in respect of their activity while in office, it is the skill with which they concealed the unemployment existing in the country at that time.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey shakes his head but, when in opposition, Deputy Morrissey, as a member of the Labour Party, continually raised that question in debates, asked Parliamentary Questions, and otherwise endeavoured to extract from members of the then Government information as to the volume of unemployment, but could not get the information. The whole machinery of the employment branch of the Department of Industry and Commerce was so organised, and the information allowed to reach the statistics department was so controlled, that not merely did there not exist an accurate number of the unemployed, but not even the information upon which an estimate could be made. Before 1934, nobody could say with accuracy what the total number of unemployed was. On the basis of the information obtained by the census of 1926 one could make a rough estimate that, if all the persons who are now registered upon the live register had been registered in 1926, all the same classes, and with the same inducement to keep registered, the live register at that time would have been about 200,000. That is a rough estimate—it is my estimate—and I offer it for whatever value can be given to it.
I will again repeat my contention: that if, since 1931, there has been emigration on the scale stated by Deputy Dillon, if at the same time there has been an increase in industrial employment of about 75,000 persons, and if at the same time there has been an increase in agricultural employment, then the number of unemployed to-day must be less than it was in 1931, must be substantially less—it must be less than half what it was in 1931. That is what I contend. However, Deputies opposite will be disappointed and disgusted to hear that there are 75,000 more people in employment than in 1931. I know that is not going to help their electoral prospects. As Irishmen, in the secrecy of their hearts they may rejoice at the information, but as politicians they are disappointed. Look at the smiles on the faces over there, they are so cheerful to hear that 75,000 more Irish people have got work.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Neill is nearly weeping. The fact cannot be contested that these people are paying money into the Unemployment Insurance Fund. A sum of 1/7 per week is paid into that fund by every person employed. Deputy O'Neill, or nobody else, can convince me that people who are unemployed are paying that 1/7 just to keep our statistics up. The money is coming in; it is being paid by people in employment. A stamp has been put upon the card of every workingman for every week's work he gets, and, on the basis of these stamps, in each week of 1936 the number of persons employed in insurable occupations was, on the average, 56,000 greater than in 1931. Outside those employed in these occupations, there are persons employed in agriculture, in domestic service, in railway transportation, and other occupations, and the numbers of such persons have also increased.
Comment on this
In agriculture there was an increase as compared with 1931. The number of persons employed in agriculture is counted on the 1st June every year, the figures are published, and the Deputy can, if he wishes, carry out a simple sum in arithmetic and he will find that my statement is correct.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is wrong. I ask him to look at the figures which I gave, and as to the reasonable accuracy of which I am prepared to contend. I admit that the method of carrying out the enumeration of agricultural workers is not so precise that the possibility of error does not exist. The possibility of error is undoubtedly there, but, one year against another, the figures give an indication of the trend of employment, which has been upwards. There are now 250,000 acres under wheat, where previously there were 20,000 acres; there are 80,000 acres under beet, where there were 20,000 acres; and other forms of tillage production have also increased as that is a form of production that gives the most agricultural employment.
Comment on this
Whatever the trend of agricultural prices may have been, the fact is, that the volume of agricultural production is upwards, and if the volume is upwards, the number of persons employed in effecting that production must also have increased. Agricultural prices fell rapidly from 1929 to 1934. The fall in agricultural prices which took place all over the world was accentuated here by the economic war. Deputy Dillon speaks as if it were he made the discovery that the economic war did us no good. He announced that as a bright idea of his own, as if it never occurred to anyone else.
Comment on this
No. When the British Government put on punitive tariffs on our exports they intended to wreck this country. They did not intend to do it any good. They intended to do as much damage as they could do to economic organisation, and they thought, as a result of the tariffs, that they could put this country into the position that in a few months we would be compelled to accept their dictation on anything. They were led to believe that from speeches made by Deputies opposite. They were wrong. Even in that matter Deputies opposite could not give sound advice. We were able to weather the storm. We were able to carry on, in circumstances of considerable stringency I admit, but we carried on despite these punitive tariffs, until we got over the worst of that period of reorganisation. From 1934 to this year there has been a steady improvement in agricultural conditions, an upward trend in agricultural prices; a trend which, I grant, has been slower in consequence of the tariffs than it would be but, nevertheless, an upward trend and, in addition, there has been a substantial increase in the production of agricultural goods for consumption at home, at prices guaranteed by the Government. I know that Deputy Dillon objects to that. He tries to argue, as he argued before, that the people of this country are being in some way unduly burdened by the various measures adopted by the Government to secure economic prices for agricultural goods. Deputy Dillon talks here in that strain because his speeches then have some chance of being reported. When talking in the cities he deplores the rise in agricultural prices, and how hard it is on the workingman, but when he is in the rural areas, he deplores the low prices for agricultural produce, and how hard they hit the farmers.
Comment on this
The increased price to the consumer was designed deliberately to make an economic price for the producer, and Deputies opposite who talk about a levy on creamery butter, and how much dearer Irish butter is in this country than in Great Britain, do not dare to go and tell the farmers that they voted against that measure—not all of them. Deputy Bennett and other Deputies representing creamery districts voted for it. The rest, having no interest in the business, voted against it and try to forget about it. We do not see in the published programme of the Fine Gael Party any announcement that the Dairy Prices (Stabilisation) Act will be repealed. Is it the intention of the Party opposite to repeal it if they get into office?
Comment on this
Is it the intention of the Party opposite to repeal that Act? Is there any Deputy on the opposite benches with the courage to answer that question?
Comment on this
Will the Minister say how far he is going in the present Budget to repeal some of the things that are there, and to replace them with some other kind of machinery?
Comment on this
If Deputies on the opposite benches cannot answer my question without having a consultation, I invite them to have a consultation and to tell the House whether it is part of their programme to repeal that Act, even though Deputy Dillon denounced it so eloquently. We got some type of argument from Deputy Dillon. He talked about a tax on flour. He does not know what he is talking about. The only tax was a very small one, made on imported wheat, and it is abolished from to-day. It will make a slight difference in the price of imported wheat, although in fact, as one miller stated this morning, the day to day fluctuations in the price of wheat often exceed the actual amount of the tax. At present there is no tax levied upon anybody who consumes flour or bread in this country.
Comment on this
There was a difference of 9/6 between the price of straight-run flour, as it is called in Great Britain, and bakers' flour, as it is known here. Deputy Dillon, on his own argument, will admit that the difference should be reduced to 7/- in consequence of the repeal of the duty on imported wheat from to-day.
Comment on this
Let us say 2/-. That will reduce it to 7/6. The Tariff Commission, which was established by our predecessors, examined the flour milling position from 1927 to 1929, and agreed that the cost of producing flour in this country was, roughly speaking, about 5/- a sack greater than in Great Britain, first, because we have to buy wheat in smaller quantities, and also because of the advantage that British millers have in being able to import wheat in the holds of large passenger liners, and also the small size of the units here. There is another difference of 2/6, or some part of 2/6, explainable, because of the additional charges millers have to make in consequence of the regulations made by the Department of Agriculture concerning the installation of storage accommodation and kiln-drying equipment. I am not satisfied that the whole of the 2/6 is explainable by the increased charges properly recovered against the price of flour by Irish millers; but I have to have advertence to this fact, that the great majority of the Irish mills are not making profits of 2/- a sack or anything like it. There was published only a few weeks ago the balance sheet and annual statement of an important new mill established in a midland county. On a capital of something like £60,000 or £70,000, they were able to show a profit of some £200 on the year's trading, and no dividend could be distributed. Another mill in a western county, with which Deputies are acquainted, is making, according to their figures, a profit of not more than 5d. per sack, and a large number of mills are making profits which could not be regarded by anybody as unduly high. There are, however, certain mills advantageously situated, and in a position to get their grain into their machinery at costs lower than those which other mills have to meet, which are possibly making much larger profits, but here is the problem. The problem is how to reduce the price for these mills without putting out of existence all these other mills scattered through the country.
Comment on this
There was a proposal put forward by the Prices Commission which was that we should impose a tax on the output of these larger mills and use the produce of that tax to subsidise the smaller mills. It was a proposal that did not commend itself to the Government, and I think very few people who gave full consideration to what was involved in that proposal would have supported it.
Comment on this
I do not say that. The location of a mill is often an important matter in relation to its costs, and from the point of view of the national economy, and particularly the wheat policy of the Government, the continued existence of mills in the wheat growing areas is a matter of importance, and a matter of importance to the farmers in those areas. If we were to allow competition to have full play, we would keep in existence only the large port mills and necessitate the closing down of the inland mills and that might be a bad policy. To what extent the price of flour charged by the port mills could be reduced, without wiping out whatever legitimate profit these mills may be getting, I cannot say, but there is a problem there which can be solved only by such an extensive rationalisation of production and central control and ownership of the machinery of production that the problem cannot be easily removed, and a solution applied without very considerable reactions in other directions.
At the most, at the very most, the unexplained item in the cost of flour is 2/- a sack. It is not more than that. At the present time, it cannot be contended that any part of the increased cost of flour is due to the wheat growing policy. The guaranteed price for Irish wheat is 27/6 a barrel. The price of Australian wheat is about 30/-, and of Manitoba about 34/-. The circumstances which induced the Government to guarantee a price for wheat, and to set up a machinery to ensure that the farmers got that price, have been completely reversed during the course of the past year. At the time when the wheat growing scheme was embarked upon, and the guaranteed price first fixed, the price of foreign wheat was in or about 13/- or 15/- a barrel. It was almost half what we regarded as the minimum price at which it would pay to grow wheat here. At the present time, the price of foreign wheat has risen so sharply and so extensively that it is, in fact, dearer than Irish wheat, and, in the course of the present year, if that situation should continue, the minimum price for Irish wheat will in fact be inoperative because our farmers will be getting the economic price of their produce, that is, the price which would represent its true value in relation to world prices for imported wheat.
Comment on this
There are four factors which might operate to raise the price of flour. There is the price of wheat; there is the cost of production; and there is the cost of labour. The price of wheat has risen, and risen very sharply. Every increase in the price of flour, every increase in the price of bread during the past 12 months was due to one cause, and one cause only, and that was the increase in the world price of wheat. That increase was occasioned, so far as one can judge, by two main causes, firstly, an actual scarcity, or rather, fears of a scarcity, following upon bad crop reports from South America and other countries and, secondly, the large purchases made by Italy and Germany as part of their war preparation plans.
Comment on this
There is the actual higher cost of production here than in Great Britain, put by the Tariff Commission at about 5/- a sack, and it is probably somewhat more than that now because of the additional obligations of the millers in the matter of storage capacity and kiln-drying equipment. There is the cost of labour. The standard rate of wages here is higher than in Great Britain, but I do not think a mere statement of that fact would give a true picture of the situation, because the workers in the English mills have certain advantages, certain facilities and conditions of employment which the workers in Irish mills do not get. In any event, the labour cost in the production of a sack of flour is quite small, as Deputies are aware, and it would take a very substantial rise in wages or increase in labour costs to affect seriously the price of flour.
There is the fourth factor—the possible excess profits which certain millers are taking. Three of these factors were steady and only one factor has been variable, that is the price of wheat, and to what extent that rapid increase in the world price of wheat which occurred during last year is likely to continue, I can offer no opinion, but at the moment the indications are that it will continue, and in these circumstances, some special action may have to be taken in order to prevent an undue increase in the price of flour; but if, on the other hand, the indications to which I have referred are misleading and the price of wheat should fall, the full benefit of that reduction in the price of wheat will be passed on at once to the consumers of bread, in consequence of the controlled machinery which has been set up, and it is in operation under the Bread (Control of Prices) Act.
The statement has been made here that the consumption of certain classes of goods is declining and that that declining consumption is proof of deteriorating economic conditions and reduced purchasing power amongst the people. We can examine that contention from two angles. In the first instance, we can ask ourselves is there any evidence of reduced purchasing power being available to our people. All the evidence is to the contrary. It is true that there was a decline in agricultural prices, a decline in the reward secured by farmers for their labour, and consequently there would have been a substantial diminution in the purchasing power of the farmers, if other factors had not operated. These other factors are well known. The land annuities were reduced by half—the rent which the farmer had to pay on his land was cut by half; in addition, there was an increased contribution to the agricultural grant. Certain outgoings of the farmer were, therefore, reduced and, consequently, his costs of production were lower, enabling him to get the same return from the same production, even though prices were reduced. I agree, however, that there was a diminution of purchasing power amongst the farmers.
But the increase in the production of industry has more than offset that. The total production of goods by industrial concerns has increased very substantially since 1931 and the total output of the country—industry and agriculture—has not diminished. As I have pointed out, more people are employed in agriculture and in industry than were employed and, judged by any other method, there is no evidence which would lead one to conclude that there has been a diminution in purchasing power. Whether that purchasing power is being used for the purchase of boots and shoes, readymade clothing, tobacco, beer or motor cars is another matter.
Even if one turns to the figures showing the actual consumption of certain of these products in specific years, one can find no evidence to support that contention. I admit at once that it is entirely misleading to examine the figures for one year and put them against only one other year. All sorts of factors operate to influence the figures for imports or production in one year as against another. One cannot say what stock of goods was carried over in shops or warehouses at the end of the year as against the stock of goods carried forward at the beginning of the year. One cannot know to what extent purchases in one year were influenced by a favourable market position or the fear of increased Government imposts or something of that kind. In 1935, for example, restrictions were placed upon the importation of rubber-soled boots and shoes—what are called the primsole or sand shoe. Those goods had been imported in very considerable quantity in previous years—to such an extent that they were interfering considerably with the sale of boots and shoes made from leather. They were imported mainly from Japan and sometimes they were imported at extraordinarily low prices.
Comment on this
When the Minister says "in previous years," he means in one or two years prior to 1935.
Comment on this
Right back to 1931. In 1931, of deliberate policy, the import of these goods was restricted so that the demand would be turned, to some extent, to the boots and shoes of leather which were being made here. In that year, we were not making these rubber goods for ourselves. Rubber-soled boots and shoes of Irish manufacture can now be procured. Owing to these circumstances, the figure quoted for the total number of pairs of boots and shoes imported has no significance unless related to that fact. If Deputy Dillon took, as he should have taken, the imports and production of boots and shoes of leather and compared them with the figure for 1931, he would have got a different result. In one year as against another, there would, undoubtedly, be a fluctuation but there is no evidence of any decline in a consumption of those ordinary classes of goods—boots and shoes, wearing apparel, and things of that kind.
Comment on this
And there is evidence of increased consumption of certain luxury products like tobacco, beer, motor cars—although I do not suppose the number of persons who actually "consume" motor cars is very high— while there is also evidence of increased attendance at cinemas, football matches and similar sports. Over a wide range of revenue figures, there is to be obtained evidence of increased expenditure by the people. The increased expenditure has, in fact, made possible the reductions in taxation being effected this year. It is because the existing taxes, levied at the same rate, gave more last year than the previous year and are estimated to give more this year than they gave last year that a reduction in the rate of taxation was made possible.
Deputies know how the reduction was effected. It was considered by the Government—I think most people will admit that, in this matter, the Government were right—that the whole benefit of the surplus which was anticipated to accrue should be given for the purpose of reducing the cost of living, because it was felt that, in that way, every class of the community could be benefited and, particularly, those classes of the community who were likely to be hardest hit by the rise in prices which took place during the past 12 months and which may continue during the course of the present year. I am not going to deal with the question of bacon prices. The Minister for Agriculture is concerned with the position that has arisen and is taking certain action. What that action will be or what the results of it are likely to be, I do not know. In any event, it is necessary for the Dáil to face up to the fact that if pig production is to be made economic for farmers and is to be fostered and encouraged amongst farmers, then measures will have to be adopted which will secure to the farmers an economic price for their pigs. There is no way by which there can be secured that economic price while, at the same time, the price of bacon to the consumers can be brought down to the levels which it once reached. When bacon was at its cheapest here, pig production did not pay and the farmers were getting out of pig production. In fact, we were not able to fill the export quota secured by trade negotiations. It is desirable we should keep up our exports and fill our quotas because we can always increase production but, if we let our exports fall off and fail to meet our quota obligations, then these quotas may be reduced by the importing countries in succeeding years. It is good business policy to provide for the future, to keep up exports and to encourage increased production when increased production can be put, as it is now, upon a paying basis to the producers. Deputies on the opposite side are talking with two voices. They go to the town dweller—the purchaser of bacon—and they deplore the price. They go to the producer—the seller of the pig—and say he is getting too little. They make these two contradictory types of speeches in the vain hope that the town dweller will not read the speeches they make in the country and that the dweller in the country will not read the speeches they make in the town. In fact, they do and, because they do, they are not likely to be taken very seriously one way or the other.
From a number of other angles, there is evidence that the economic strength of the country has increased, that the structure upon which our future prosperity must be based is becoming stronger, that our resources are being enlarged, that the ability of our people to meet the cost of enlarged social services or more adequate provision for various classes of public work of one kind or another, is being increased. That evidence is available in the statistics published by the Government. I do not think that the accuracy of these statistics will be challenged by anybody——
Comment on this
It is able to provide with very limited resources, made available by the Minister for Finance for that purpose—which, I hope, will be increased—a good deal of statistical information about conditions in this country of such accuracy and so presented that the praise of statisticians all over the world is forthcoming for it. That information is available to Deputies. But side by side with that there is other information. There is information available from the banks, the railways, and the ordinary industrial concerns in the country. I invite Deputies to have regard to these facts supplied from an unprejudiced source before they make their speeches here. In the face of these facts they must come to one conclusion only and that is that the economic conditions here are getting better. There is no doubt about that. They are not as good as they will be when our programme has proceeded further. They are not as good as they might have been if conditions had been easier than they were in the course of the last three or four years. It is our aim to make the economic conditions better. They can be made better. Each year records a certain amount of progress achieved; a certain number of men taken out of the ranks of the destitute and put into the ranks of those who are able to support themselves. That is an achievement of which the Government justly feels proud. We might at one time have hopes of making more rapid progress than has been accomplished. We could not have foreseen the difficulties which arose in the course of the past four years. Achievement always falls short of anticipation. We anticipated more than we achieved. But we have achieved so much that there can be no two minds as to the wisdom of the policy pursued by us. It is because of the wisdom of the policy pursued by us that we have now the spectacle of the Party opposite becoming the most vehement advocates of that policy. They have committed themselves to that policy if by any mischance or any error on the part of the people they should be returned to office. Side by side with their advocacy of that policy there is in their election programme a lot of nonsense, but Deputies opposite should avail of this occasion to give us a lot more information concerning that election programme of theirs.
Comment on this
They are not interested in that. They have made a promise to derate agricultural land——
Comment on this
They have promised to reduce the age for qualifying for the old age pensions. They have promised a large number of other things, the total cost of which will be £17,000,000.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance says that all these things will cost about £8,000,000. Let us take that as the amount which all these will cost. They have added to that this promise side by side with it to reduce taxation. This is now a golden opportunity for them to tell the House how that is to be done. They are in duty bound to give the House that information, not that it will make any difference in the election but for the sake of fact that if they have any vital secret now as to how that can be done they should tell the House what that secret is.
Comment on this
Very well, if election speeches are irrelevant I will cease but if I were at the present moment in the position of the Opposition——
Comment on this
——discussing a Budget statement made by the Minister for Finance and if I disagreed with anything in that statement I would not merely express that disagreement but put forward alternative constructive proposals and endeavour to show how those proposals can be given effect to. That is what the Opposition should have done but the Opposition have been a much greater failure as an Opposition than as a Government and that is saying a lot. If they want to retrieve their failure as an Opposition so that they may hope to get back in the next Dáil, even as an Opposition, they should put forward constructive proposals and not mere abuse of Ministers. They should put forward an alternative policy and a practical policy to that of the Government. I know their £17,000,000 policy is a policy which nobody will take seriously.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce was ignorant of the conditions in the country, outside the City of Dublin. Having listened now to the Minister's speech I do not think the word that should be applied to his speech is the word "ignorant."
Comment on this
The Minister should have come to this House, speaking on the last Budget to be introduced by the present Government, to apologise to the House and, through the House, to the people of this country and in particular to the unemployed. The Minister, in the most cynical way, with a complete disregard for truth and with a complete disregard for the misery he has brought upon thousands of unemployed in this country, tells us that the country is going from prosperity to prosperity. This country is immeasurably better off to-day, he tells us, than it was five years ago. There is less want, there is less unemployment and there is less destitution, he tells us. Does the Minister realise that this country is so prosperous that 80,000 people have fled from that prosperity in the last four years?
Comment on this
There was double that amount of emigration when Deputy Morrissey's friends were in office.
Comment on this
Listen to the Minister's statement this evening. He talked about 75,000 people being put into employment. He said that more people have been employed in industry and more people have been employed in agriculture and that the agricultural output is greater and agriculture more prosperous than it was. The man who is primarily responsible for the task of looking after unemployment in this country, the man who told the people of this country that he had a plan to completely absorb the unemployed in this country, that that plan had been scrutinised and examined in detail, gave his personal word and guaranteed that if his Party were returned, not only would he absorb the unemployed but the exiles would have to be brought back from America to fill the vacancies in agriculture and industry.
Comment on this
Yes, a statement made in York Street in 1932, a statement made in the Minister's own constituency. Does he deny it?
Comment on this
In one respect the Minister is unequalled by any person in this House—in his complete and absolute brazenness and in his complete and absolute disregard for the truth.
Comment on this
This is hurting the Minister because he is hearing the truth and because he is being brought back to a sense of his responsibilities and because he is going to be faced with those statements of his that are absolutely untrue and that are untrue to the knowledge of everybody in this House.
Comment on this
Is it within the capacity of the Chair to keep the Minister for Finance in order? I know it is a difficult task. The Ministers for Finance and for Industry and Commerce are annoyed because they know the facts. The Minister invites us to consult the banks as to this alleged prosperity, as to the fact that there are more in employment, and as to the fact, as he says, that the number of unemployed in this country are fewer by half than they were five years ago. I invite Deputy Corish who is closer to the unemployed and who knows more about them than the Minister to support the Minister in that statement. I do not suggest to the Minister that he should go to the banks, to the railway companies and to industrial concerns to find out about the unemployed. I suggest that he should go to his own labour exchanges; I suggest that he go to the queues of unemployed who are lining up there morning after morning.
Comment on this
But why should they want unemployment assistance if they are in employment? If these people have so much employment why should they have to go to the labour exchanges to draw unemployment assistance?
Comment on this
The Minister said he put 75,000 additional persons into industry. Deputy Hugo Flinn claims that there are 45,000 people on rotation work. I observe the Ministers having a consultation on this—it must be serious. We have, therefore, 75,000 persons, 45,000 persons and 80,000 persons who, in four and a half years, have gone to Great Britain. I do not know how many thousands have been laid off on unemployment assistance as a result of the Minister's First Period Order of this year. In addition, there are still 93,000 signing —and all that with a falling population. If, and I do not think it is seriously contested, 80,000 have gone in the last four and a half years to Great Britain, if there are 75,000 put into industrial employment over and above what were already there, if there are more employed in agriculture than there were five years ago, and if there are 45,000 on rotation work, where does the Minister get the 93,000 that are still signing, on a falling population?
Comment on this
The Minister has sought to accuse me of inconsistency on this question of unemployment. The only thing the Minister can allege against me is that in this matter I have been perfectly consistent both during the period of office of the present Government and the period of office of its predecessor. Never in his wildest days while in opposition did the Minister ever allege there were more than 70,000 unemployed. The Minister knows as well as I do that in the census the number shown was 78,000. Does the Minister contest that?