Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolutions (Resumed).
Contributions 183–383 of 544. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
If the Deputy wants to get the figure which will compare with the present live register——
Comment on this
I am not on that point, and the Minister knows I am not. I do not agree that the method used for compiling unemployment figures shows the true facts. Indeed, at one time the Minister declared that the statistics were prepared specially in order to shield the actual figures. The Minister has changed the method of compiling those figures very considerably and very often during the last five years. I want the Minister to get his director of statistics to give him an answer to this poser. According to the Minister, he has put 75,000 people into industrial employment; there are X additional thousands engaged in agriculture; there are 45,000 engaged on rotation work; there are 93,000 odd signing the register for employment and 80,000 have left for Great Britain. How many altogether would that mean?
Comment on this
I will accept that figure—350,000 on a falling population. How does the Minister reconcile those figures with the existing position in the country? The Minister's plan was right, but something went wrong because, according to the Minister's statement, coupled with the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary, there is no need now to send to America for the emigrants, as he has already filled more jobs than were supposed to be vacant in this country.
Comment on this
We will leave all the supposition to the Minister. He is quite capable of supposing anything. I want him to face this fact. In a country where, according to him, industrial development is going ahead so rapidly, where employment is opening up so quickly and where prosperity has come upon us so suddenly, why did 28,000 people leave for Britain within the last 12 months? Were they fleeing from prosperity—running away from it? Yesterday, Deputy Kennedy, who apparently completely misconceived what I was at, said that I had not heard of the number of those people who had to come back from Great Britain because they could not get work and I had not heard of the number remaining in Great Britain on relief. Then the position is that they preferred to go to Britain and take a chance of getting employment there or, having got there and failed to get employment, they preferred to remain on outdoor relief in Britain rather than stay at home and share the national prosperity we are told about by the Minister. I have seldom heard such absolute nonsense, such bunkum, such bosh, and the Minister knows well it is that.
The man responsible for all that, after five years, instead of admitting he has not been able to grapple with the problem, that he has not only not succeeded in finding employment, but that he has actually increased unemployment to the extent of tens of thousands of persons, has the effrontery to tell this House and the country, to tell those living in poverty and misery, that they are more prosperous and better off than ever they were before. He actually denies —and I am not surprised at the denial, because it would not surprise me what the Minister would deny—that he ever told the people that he had a plan that would absorb the unemployed. The President told them the very same thing and, when it was pointed out to the President that no country in the world had succeeded in completely wiping out unemployment, what was the President's reply? He said:—
"But we have a solution for the problem of unemployment such as no other country in the world has, and if there was a Christian Government in office in this country there would be no unemployment."
Of course the Minister, as usual, went one better than that. He has been five years in office and he has succeeded in driving out of this country more people than were unemployed when he came into office.
Comment on this
He may have put 75,000 into work, but he must have put 175,000 out of work in order to get the figures we have here.
Comment on this
The man who is prepared to state here that there are only half the number of unemployed now in this country that there were in 1931, to state that the farmers are more prosperous to-day than they were in 1931, to state that there are more people employed on the land than in 1931, is either completely ignorant of the position in the country or he is a complete and absolute liar.
Comment on this
I deny absolutely and emphatically the Minister's statement. I say that the Minister is either absolutely ignorant or he is deliberately lying to the House.
Comment on this
I will insist on making my speech. The Minister spoke for considerably over an hour.
Comment on this
The Minister, considering the type of speech he made, was listened to with remarkable restraint in this House. If the Minister attempted to make that speech to the unemployed in Gardiner Street or outside some of the labour exchanges, he would get more interruptions than that.
Comment on this
I am prepared to go down any day with the Deputy and we will see who will come off best.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would have a better idea and more practice in stirring up intimidation than I would. We are told about more prosperity. Where is the prosperity for the man with a wife and four, five or ten children getting 12/6 a week unemployment assistance? When this House fixed that rate Deputies will remember that flour was only 1/6 a stone, while to-day it is from 2/8 to 3/2 a stone in the country. Will the Minister deny that? Does he deny there has been a very substantial increase in the cost of living over the last four years?
Comment on this
The Ministers themselves are apparently feeling the breeze, because they are coming to conclusions completely different from the opinions they held in 1931-32. Then they were perfectly satisfied with the low cost of living and that Minsters could carry out their duties and do their jobs perfectly at £1,000 a year. Now they are satisfied that, as a result of the increased cost of living in this country, Ministers' salaries must be increased.
Comment on this
Well, then, I can only say that the Minister is in a very fortunate position if the increase in the cost of living does not affect him. Probably he is the only person in this State whose financial position is such that he is not affected by the increased cost of living. In this connection, however, let me say at once that I do not at all object to the Ministers being paid decent salaries. I never did, and if the Minister brings in a Bill to-morrow to pay adequate salaries to Ministers, I can assure him that he will have no opposition from me. I do not want anybody to suggest for a moment that I am trying to make capital out of that point. What we have to advert to, however, is the fact that the Minister and his colleagues—every one of them, and the Minister himself in particular —for a period of two years, at every cross-roads in this country, vilified and blackguarded the Ministers of the previous Government on account of what was being paid to them in the way of salaries. The Minister and his colleagues talked about the measures they have taken to protect the farmers. He has been talking about the rising prices in the country and the prosperous prospect that is before the farmers of this country. Well, I was talking to three farmers in the County Waterford on last Sunday, and they were giving me some idea of what agriculture has gone through for the last four years. I said to those men: "After all, there is a good price now for sheep, and a good price for cattle." What was the answer I got from one of them? He said: "You might as well tell me that there is a good price for gold, because we have not the sheep or the cattle." Let me give the Minister another idea with regard to the prospects of agriculture. There is a gentleman in my own constituency—I shall give his name and address to the Minister afterwards, if he wants it— who has 800 sheep.
Comment on this
Now, that shows how much the Minister is affected by the position in the country. It just shows all he knows about it.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy ever study the agricultural statistics? He will find there the number——
Comment on this
The trouble with the Minister is that he is living in Merrion Street and that he probably would not know the difference between an acre of mangolds and an acre of turnips, or an acre of wheat for that matter. The Minister is living in Merrion Street, but I am living amongst the farmers and meeting them every day in the week.
Comment on this
Yes, in Nenagh. I suppose the Minister thinks that it is as rare to meet a farmer in the streets of Nenagh as it is in Dublin.
Comment on this
Well, apparently, the Minister does not want to hear what I have to say. I am glad to see that his colleague is coming in. I am prepared to give the name and address of the gentleman to whom I have referred to the Minister or to anybody else. This man has been buying sheep—speculating in sheep, or gambling in them if you like—for the last eight or nine months, and he told me last year that he had over 800 sheep. I asked him: "How are you feeding them?" He said: "On turnips." Now, it takes a lot of turnips to feed 800 sheep. I asked him where he was getting the turnips, and he said that he could get sufficient turnips to feed 5,000 sheep if he had them. He finished the story by saying that he could get the turnips almost for a song. Now, does the Minister realise what that means? It means that there are farmers who have turnips growing in North Tipperary fit to feed 5,000 sheep, but they themselves have nothing to eat the turnips. They have no stock of their own.
Comment on this
It may have happened under other Governments, but the Minister says that we are prosperous now, and therefore it should not be happening now. Does the Deputy not believe me? I am prepared to bet him an even pound, and I shall produce the name and address of the gentleman concerned for him. If necessary, I shall produce the gentleman himself.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows nothing about it. He may know something about Kilkenny, but not about North Tipperary. Perhaps he will agree with the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the farmers in and around Kilkenny are more prosperous than they were five years ago—that they are better off?
Comment on this
The Deputy would not agree with the Minister about that, because he knows a lot more about it than the Minister does and he knows that the unemployed and the poor of this country were brought nearer to the starvation level last year and that there was more widespread and actual poverty in the towns in this country last year than in any year in my memory.
Comment on this
Wexford and Galway are two agricultural counties, and what answer did they give you at the by-elections?
Comment on this
The Minister says that people died of starvation in previous years in County Cork. Does he deny that there was more actual and widespread poverty in this country last year than in other years?
Comment on this
I was attending more important business last year than listening to the Deputy.
Comment on this
Look at the answer that Wexford and Galway gave last year, and there will be no doubt about the answer they will give at the next election either—speaking for Galway, at any rate.
Comment on this
I suppose the Deputy has to make the best use of his tongue that he can for the short time he will be here.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is entitled to make his speech. He has been subjected to a regular fire of interruptions, and I think it would be much better to allow him to make his speech.
Comment on this
I want to call your attention, Sir, to the fact that the Minister for Agriculture said that persons died of starvation in the County Cork. That is a damnable statement and the Minister knows it is untrue.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not say that the Minister knows his statement is untrue. I take it that the Deputy is withdrawing that remark.
Comment on this
There can be no qualification. When a Deputy says that another Deputy in this House makes a statement that he knows to be untrue, that should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
It is not in order for one Deputy to charge another Deputy with making a statement that he knows is untrue. The Deputy should withdraw the statement.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir, I withdraw, but at the same time I want to draw the Chair's attention to the fact that a very serious statement was made here to the effect that people died of starvation in County Cork, and that statement is untrue.
Comment on this
Does the Minister still persist in saying that persons died of starvation in County Cork?
Comment on this
I am on my feet, and I will not hear any Deputy while I am on my feet. This is a place to make serious statements, and if the Minister made it, the Chair has no control over that. Deputy O'Neill can make a statement after this in direct contradiction of that statement.
Comment on this
The statement has been made by a man who claims to have some responsibility as a Minister.
Comment on this
There is no harm, in this case, in the interjection of the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister for Finance was challenged here in the House, earlier in the afternoon, to bring in the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who had the files in that matter at his disposal, and get him to say it here in this House.
Comment on this
I must ask you, Sir, to see that I am allowed to make my speech without this continued interruption. I have been subjected to a great deal of interruption. I am not surprised at it, of course, because the Ministers opposite and their back benchers find it very hard to listen to the truth.
Comment on this
I must confess that the Deputy has what is sadly lacking in most other members of his Party— patience and a sense of humour. I might add that the Deputy probably knows a good deal more on the subject than either the Minister or most of the back benchers.
Comment on this
Go ahead and we shall try to have a sense of humour.
Comment on this
The Minister wound up his speech by telling the people that the Government were justly proud of the results of their five years' work. It is easy to make the Minister proud apparently. He is proud of the fact that they have imposed a burden of taxation on the poor people of this country never before equalled. Even after this Budget becomes law the poor of this country will bear a greater proportion of national taxation than ever they bore before. Every article that goes into a workingman's house is taxed to-day.
Comment on this
The mere fact that the Minister says "nonsense" only goes to prove that what I have said is true. The Minister is proud of the fact that 80,000 of our boys and girls have had to fly from the prosperity in this country, to offer their services to the enemy on the other side. Many of them, according to Deputy Kennedy of the Fianna Fáil Party, prefer even to get poor relief in Britain than to remain at home to partake of the prosperity that Fianna Fáil has brought to the country. And the Minister is proud of it! There are 93,000 people on the unemployment register in this country notwithstanding the operation of the Period Order, notwithstanding the thousands that are employed on what is called their rotation scheme, but which could be more aptly and correctly named the starvation scheme. The people are happy and prosperous according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on two days' work per week, three days' work per week, and four days' work per week, at rates which vary from 11/6 per week to 19/- and 20/- per week on rotation work. The unemployed are so happy in this country, and employment is available in such a measure, that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance was able to say here in this House two years ago that any member of this House who dared to stand between an unemployed workingman and a wage of 21/- per week would be torn limb from limb. Nobody in this House ever uttered such a condemnation of the Minister and his Department as is contained in the phrase that the unemployed have been reduced to such a condition that if anybody attempted to stop them from working for 21/- per week he would be torn limb from limb. That is the prosperity that this Government has brought to us, and the Minister who, I say, is primarily concerned, has fled so far from his promises that not only has he failed to keep them, but now denies that he ever made them. He has the audacity to say in this House that they never told the unemployed of this country that they had a plan for the solution of unemployment.
Comment on this
The Minister did not deny it? The Minister denied at the beginning of my speech that there was a plan to solve unemployment, that he had promised to find employment not only for all those who were idle at home, but to provide so many jobs that he would have to call on those who emigrated.
Comment on this
So the Minister, after having had an opportunity of consulting with his colleagues, is trying to mend his hand.
Comment on this
This, no doubt, comes from the Minister's close association with the President for the last four years, but the Minister has not the President's technique for leaving a way out at both ends. At the end of a period, after consultation with his two colleagues——
Comment on this
The trouble about Deputy Morrissey is that he gives himself away in the middle instead of getting out at both ends.
Comment on this
The contempt which I hold for the gentleman who has just interrupted could not be given full expression to in this House. I do say, Sir, that the Minister for Finance is given a liberty in this House that at times almost develops into licence.
Comment on this
There is no power in the Chair to give any more liberty to the Minister than to any other Deputy. There are, of course, limitations to the observation of the Chair, but, as far as the Chair can carry out the Standing Orders, the Chair gives no more latitude to the Minister for Finance or to any other Minister than to any Deputy.
Comment on this
I did not intend to imply any partiality on the part of the Chair. Nobody realises more than I do the impossibility of getting the Minister for Finance to have respect for any forms of decency in this House, or outside it, for that matter. Fortunately for you, Sir, whilst it is the duty of the Chair to preserve order, the Chair is not called upon to be a judge of what is decent or what is in good taste. I am entitled to give expression to my views in this House. That is a right that I have availed of both in the House and outside. Neither the sneers nor the intimidation of Ministers or anybody else have prevented me giving expression to these views.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I call attention to the fact that the Deputy has reflected on the decency or otherwise of conduct outside this House. Is that in order?
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance never seems to be able to get the faintest idea of the contents of the book of Standing Orders, although he has been studying them for the last five years.
Comment on this
With all your power, Sir, you could not put me sufficiently far away from that gentleman.
Comment on this
I know you will. You have always tried to do it, and so did the Minister for Finance. You have been doing it every time you went to my constituency. You have tried it on every occasion, but if it is any interest to the Minister, you are not going to succeed. I hope to be in the country, and to meet many of the Ministers. I hope to have the pleasure some time of hearing the Minister for Industry and Commerce telling the people in Tipperary that they are more prosperous than before he came into office; telling the unemployed at the labour exchanges that they are happy and prosperous; and telling those who are on the rotation work that themselves and their families can get enough to eat on 13/7 per week. Of course, the Minister will not tell them that.
Comment on this
Mind you, if I had known that, I would not have said that the Minister would not tell them. That is the only chance they have of hearing it, because there is one thing which the Minister will not tell them, and that is what is correct and true.
Comment on this
Whatever else we may enter into competition with you on, we will not enter into competition with you in regard to promises and misrepresentation. We would be hopelessly beaten from the start.
Comment on this
After that election programme? After that £17,000,000? Do you expect us to do better than that?
Comment on this
That programme and that policy have given you a lot of worry. I would agree that the Minister has good reason to worry; before three months are out he will have far more reason to worry. I would offer the Minister a friendly advice; it is this—that the sooner he goes to the country the better for himself and his Party.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and I challenge the Minister to go to the country within the next month or in June.
Comment on this
Let me tell the Minister that he has no hope, fortunately for this country, of coming back here whenever the election is held, but he has less hope the further off he puts it. You can go on for a certain time deceiving the people, and you succeed up to a point, but mind you the people have found it out. Deputy Jordan of course has not found that out yet, and, while I hope for the defeat of the Fianna Fáil Party, personally I do not hope for the defeat of Deputy Jordan. He would be missed from the House.
Comment on this
Thank you very much. I am sorry that the ruling of the Chair prevents me from saying a few things to you, but I am grateful for the compliment you have paid me.
Comment on this
The Deputy has often said a few things to me—perhaps not in the House—that I do not think the Chair would pass. I do suggest to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that at least he ought to tell the truth when he comes before this House on an occasion which he himself, in starting off his speech, told us was a serious occasion and should have been so treated by Deputy Dillon. The Minister indulged in a tissue of mis-statements from the beginning to the end of his speech, and he knew that he was not putting a true picture before the House. He coloured that picture as far as it was humanly possible to do so. I will grant him this, that when it comes to audacity and misrepresentation and the complete ignoring of facts there is not a man in this House who could hold a candle to him.
Comment on this
A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, when the Minister for Agriculture came into this House about ten minutes ago he made the grossly untrue statement that people had died from starvation in the County Cork. There is no truth whatever in that statement. Nobody at any time since the famine years died of starvation in West Cork, but I do say that at the present time there are people in West Cork who are nearer starvation than they ever were since black '47, owing to the operation of the Fianna Fáil policy. I cannot help thinking that the Fianna Fáil Government was influenced by the condition of affairs prevailing in places like West Cork, West Kerry, and along the western seaboard generally, in framing this present Budget. This is a Budget which has been framed to deceive the eye with regard to the elementary necessities of life. This morning we could all see that this Budget was placarded in some of the newspapers' posters as a bread and butter Budget; in other words a Budget which was going to bring relief to the poorest of our people. I see before me here a heading in the Irish Times which says:
"Welcome Relief to Harassed Housewives."
That makes us think that there is something very substantial in the reliefs boasted of in this Budget statement. Let us study them in relation to facts, and particularly in relation to figures. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking in the House this afternoon, said it was now a fact that there was no tax on bread in this country.
I do not know exactly what a tax means. There is nothing which comes directly into the Exchequer as a result of the price of bread, but I think if we examine closely the price of bread in the Free State to-day it will be seen that in hidden taxation on bread alone there is more than five times the amount of the whole of the relief afforded in the Budget reductions on sugar, tea and butter. The price of bread in this country to-day is 2d. per 4lb. loaf higher than it is in Great Britain. In this country we consume 2,600,000 sacks of flour each year. Roughly, the consumption of flour is about one sack per head of the population per annum. Twopence on the 41b. loaf means 15/- on the sack of flour. I think, if you take 2,600,000 sacks of flour and multiply that figure by 15/-, you will come to the conclusion that the poor people of this country are paying on that one staple commodity, bread, over £2,000,000 more than they should pay or more than is paid in Great Britain for the same amount of bread. I submit that that is very serious taxation on the staple food of the poorest people of this country. Here, according to this Budget statement, the reduction on tea is going to mean £325,000; the reduction on sugar, £121,000; and the reduction in the wheat tax, £170,000; making a total reduction of £616,000. At the same time this country is paying over £2,000,000 in increased taxation on bread alone.
Comment on this
It is taxation of the people, because it is 15/- per sack on 2,600,000 sacks of flour.
Comment on this
You can call it "taxation" if you like. As I said, it is not tax gathered in by the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
So that is the value to be put on the Deputy's statement? His words do not mean what they are intended to convey?
Comment on this
It is no comfort to a poor person in West Cork to tell him: "You are paying 11½d. for your batch loaf here, while the working man in England is paying 9½d. It is not a tax of 2d.; it is an increased price." What comfort is that to him?
Comment on this
I am dealing with the present day Budget introduced by the Minister last night, and I am not deviating from that.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister said that should be past history, because we could quote some of his statements at that time?
Comment on this
This is a very serious matter indeed. It is a matter which has not yet fully sunk into the minds of the people of this country. They do not realise what they are paying for this whole wheat policy, for this whole milk policy; they do not realise that they are paying for it at the rate of over £2,000,000.
Comment on this
It is a very serious thing that the Almighty put the Irish Sea there, so that we would not all be living in England and getting their bread 2d. per 4lb. loaf cheaper.
Comment on this
I want to take some of the gilt off the Minister's gingerbread. The Minister is allowing the people the wonderful concession of £170,000 by removing the tax on imported wheat. What does that mean? It means 1/3 per sack in the cost of flour, or 1/3 per 99 pairs of bread.
Comment on this
I have been told by a very good milling authority that this concession only means a reduction of 1/3 per 20 stone of flour.
Comment on this
I just want to put the Deputy right. Does the Deputy not realise that 20 stone of wheat will not make 20 stone of flour?
Comment on this
Well, it would have to to bear out the Deputy's argument.
Comment on this
They told me in Cork, and we have as good millers in Cork as you will get anywhere, that at the present time it only meant 1/3 per sack. The main consideration for the people of this country is that they are paying for their 4lb. batch loaf 2d. per lb. more than they should be paying. They are paying 11½d. for a 4lb. batch loaf. Even at that price the bakers are not making a profit.
Comment on this
I accept that as a fact, but what is the cause of it?
Comment on this
I have asked time and again what is the cause of it, and I can get no answer from the Government. Deputy McMenamin refers me to a question which he addressed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday. He asked the Minister:
"Whether in view of the difference between the cost of bakers' flour in Great Britain and the Irish Free State he will state how this difference, in terms of shillings per sack, may be attributed to the higher cost per sack, due to (1) admixture of Irish-grown wheat, (2) import duty on overseas wheat, (3) higher port charges and loading costs in Irish ports, and (4) to the higher wages paid to Irish mill workers compared to mill workers in Britain."
The Minister replied:—
"It is not possible within the compass of a reply to a Parliamentary Question to furnish detailed information on the points to which the Deputy refers, with an adequate explanation of the various factors which should be borne in mind in the consideration of this subject; but I would refer him to the report of the Prices Commission on their investigation into the prices charged for wheaten flour by persons manufacturing such commodity in Saorstát Eireann."
That does not give us very much information. I am not the Government, I am not the Prices Commission, I am not either the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I have not any access to what controls their minds. I speak as a man coming from the country, from what one may call the hinterland of West Cork, living there amongst very simple people. They, through me, would like to ask the Government, and it is the Government's business to explain, why they have to pay for their 4lb. batch loaf 2d. per lb. more than they should be paying for it.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy was going to explain it. That is all right.
Comment on this
I only wanted to find out what the Deputy was going to say. If he wants to adopt that particular attitude I will tell him whether it is all right or not.
Comment on this
In respect to foodstuffs, the Minister is supposed to be giving remissions under this Budget totalling £616,000, but for bread alone the people are paying £2,000,000 a year more than they should be paying.
Comment on this
I was thinking that you were going to hold the Government responsible.
Comment on this
It took me a long time to get that answer, but I have got it.
Comment on this
And this is called a "Bread and butter Budget." I will make this admission to the Minister for Agriculture, that the 2d. per lb. off butter is a really good concession. I for one welcome that. I do, however, want to deal with the Government's fictitious and flagrant claim of making a reduction in the cost of foodstuffs. There is ¼d. a lb. off sugar. I want to tell the Minister that I will come back to the bread business again.
Comment on this
The high cost of living is going to blow the Government and the Ministers out of their places.
Comment on this
They did not get a chance of voting in West Cork lately.
Comment on this
I repeat again that the people of this country are paying for their 4lb. batch loaf 2d. per lb. more than they should be paying. That is what they have got under a Fianna Fáil Government with its wheat schemes, prices control and all the rest of it.
Comment on this
The argument is that on bread alone you are taxing the people to the extent of £2,000,000 more than they should be paying while posing that you are taking the miserable sum of £170,000 off in the case of a tax on imported wheat. The Minister has taken 1/4d. per lb. off sugar. That represents a sum of about £120,000. How much sugar do we use in this country in a year?
Comment on this
The Minister boasted yesterday that when Fianna Fáil came into power we were importing 80,000 tons of sugar and producing 20,000 tons, but that now we were producing 80,000 tons and importing 20,000 tons. Up to yesterday the price of sugar in this country was 3¾d. per lb. I take it that, with the Budget concession, the price to the consuming public will be 3½d. The price the working man has to pay for his sugar in England is 2d. per lb. Even with the Budget concession, the people here will have to pay 3½d. per lb. for their sugar.
Comment on this
I do not think it is. I am looking at the net cost to the consumer. The price will be 3½d. per lb. How much a stone is that? Roughly, 2/-, or 16/- per cwt. That is £16 a ton on 100,000 lbs. of sugar. That is a nice tax on the people of this country—£16 a ton on 100,000 tons of sugar consumed in this country every year taken out of the pockets of the consumer.
Comment on this
I deny that the way the Deputy built it up is right. Multiplying anything by four is different from multiplying it by two.
Comment on this
I am taking rough figures. At all events, it is certainly over £1,000,000 per year. With £2,000,000 for the increased cost of bread, over £1,000,000 for the increased cost of sugar, sugar and bread alone are costing this country over £3,000,000 per year more. That is the bread and butter Budget which gave the poor people concessions on tea, sugar and wheat amounting to £616,000. I do not want to pursue the matter further. I simply got up to show the bunk and humbug and the fraudulent claims made by the Minister for Finance in introducing the Budget and telling the people he was going to reduce the cost of living and the cost of food to the poor people. The cost of food in this country is greater than ever it was since the highest peak point of the war. In these two staple articles of sugar and bread alone the people are paying, on my computation, more than £3,000,000. There is another matter which closely concerns this country, and which chiefly concerns the poorest of our people, because they are the best of our pig producers. What is the price of bacon to-day? It was quoted by the Cork curers last Monday as a sum of 146/- per cwt. for smoked middles. In the London market the Irish Wiltshire side—there is very little difference between them—was quoted from 90/- to 95/-.
Comment on this
It is not fair to be interrupting the Deputy like this. The Minister will have an opportunity of answering later on. You cannot discuss a matter like this across the floor of the House.
Comment on this
I agree, but Deputy O'Leary is not at all immune from interrupting, or his colleague. I suggest that Deputy O'Neill be allowed to continue his statement without any further interruptions.
Comment on this
I am not immune from interrupting, but I paid the penalty for it if I have interrupted.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that the price of bacon quoted to me last Monday was 146/- per cwt., and that the price of the smoked side in the London market from Irish curers was from 90/- to 95/- In other words, roughly 56/- per cwt., or 6d. per lb. in favour of the English merchant as compared with the price quoted to me only a few miles from the factory in Cork. How is that possible? Is it fair that the persons to whom we sell bacon in Cork have to pay 6d. per lb. more than the Cockney has to pay to the provision merchant in London? Perhaps the Minister will tell us what the farmers in West Cork got for the bacon quoted to me at 146/- per cwt. Did he get 67/-? He was very lucky if he did. I think these matters of prices are very important factors and matters which very properly should be raised in connection with the Budget, especially when the boast is made that we are reducing the cost of living to the poor person. Sixpence per lb. is put on the bacon sold to the person buying in Cork as compared with the person buying in London or Birmingham. That is a very serious matter, especially when you consider that the best of that bacon is bought from the Irish farmers at a sum not exceeding 67/- per cwt.
These are problems which the Government ought to take charge of. If we are going to have concessions, do not let us have concessions, such as are boasted of, in matters of small amounts like those here. Having taken control of the ordinary daily trade of the country, let the Minister see, if food is going to be produced, that it is produced at the lowest possible price for the people in the country. If there are any higher prices to be paid, they ought to be paid by the people outside with whom we are at war. Imagine fighting an economic war with an alien race and sending them over the best Irish mild-cured bacon at 6d. per lb. less than we are giving it to our own people at home! The whole position is very ridiculous. This grand bread and butter Budget resolves itself down to the fact that the people are taxed more than ever they were for ordinary elementary food items. I have shown in regard to bread, bacon, and sugar, that this country is grossly overtaxed and that this Budget, instead of giving any relief, continues and aggravates a condition of affairs which is adding very much to the cost of living and which is becoming daily more serious. As far as I can see, it is going to have a very serious effect on labour conditions in this country and on the general standard of living of our people.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Minister for Agriculture was not here when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was endeavouring to explain the difference between the price of flour across the water and the price here, because the Minister for Agriculture might be able to assist the Minister for Industry and Commerce in some way. It would certainly be an enlightenment for the Minister for Agriculture to hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce endeavouring to explain away the difference. At any rate, it would obviate the necessity of the Minister for Agriculture trying to get the information from Deputy O'Neill across the floor of the House. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was not able to explain the difference, notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Agriculture thinks that Deputy O'Neill should be able to tell the House what is the cost. The Minister for Industry and Commerce could not tell the cost. He gave us a figure of 5/- and said it always cost something like 5/- more here. Eventually, he brought himself down to 2/6, and then bungled and could not get any further, so that the whole thing remains where it was.
There is certainly something wrong with the Fianna Fáil policy. It was very evident when the Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke to-day. The Minister for Industry and Commerce always speaks with a certain amount of arrogance and assurance which was sadly lacking to-day. There was, however, one characteristic note in his speech to-day. The Minister in his speeches usually says: "These are the facts which the statistics reveal; I have not got the statistics, but you can get them in the Library." The peculiar thing is that he never brings the figures with him into the House. He quoted certain figures to-day which were contradicted from this side of the House. We have the figures here. The Minister quoted figures which were not correct. That is his usual role. He says:
"That is the position; that is what the figures reveal; you can go to the Library and find them; the position is that my Department is continually turning out statistics; but you do not pay any heed to them."
The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated to-day that there were fewer unemployed in this country than in 1931, and that there was more remunerative employment to be had now. Deputy Morrissey met him fairly on that point. Last night the Minister for Finance told us that the position existing here is a very happy one. If that is so, it is an extraordinary commentary on such a statement, that the House immediately afterwards settled down to discuss unemployment relief schemes and rotational schemes. That was a sad commentary on the Fianna Fáil plan. When introducing his Budget the Minister as usual surrounded his speech with verbosity, some of which was very hard to understand. Perhaps I often tried, and possibly got away occasionally with an impromptu joke but, on a serious occasion like the introduction of a Budget, how the Minister could endeavour to tell in this House what he thinks are jokes and to laugh at them himself beats me. Seriously, I think the Minister ought to drop that habit because it does not shed any lustre on the Minister or on the House. Mind you, they were very crude jokes, and if the Minister realised how little appreciated they were, even on his own side of the House, he would drop them.