We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolutions (Resumed).

Contributions 384–544 of 544. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

In part of his speech the Minister commented a good deal on the administration of the last Government. He stated that certain sums had been paid to England that need not have been paid. He mentioned certain sums that he said might have been saved to the farmers if the previous Government had refused to pay the annuities to Britain. Let us consider that statement. What assurance has the Minister in 1937 that if a previous Administration took the steps that Fianna Fáil has taken, the result would not be the same? Can he give us any assurance that the British would not have collected all the outstanding amounts as they are collecting them to-day? The Minister went along glibly and stated that if these payments had not been made since 1922 £47,839,000 would have been saved. How does he know that? If we go on the basis of what has happened since Fianna Fáil withheld the annuities, to the £47,000,000 would have to be added what is being paid by way of subsidies and bounties since this Government took office. The President boasted at one time that his Government started the economic war by firing the first shot. Since then, as the Minister boasted last night, subsidies and bounties have cost £10,889,000. Supposing the economic war was started in 1923—and the Minister regrets it was not started then— and if the British Government had collected the unpaid annuities as effectively as they are doing it now, and if the Government had to provide bounties at the same rate as the Minister is providing them in order to get into the British market, then instead of £47,000,000, an additional £30,000,000 would have been paid under that heading, making £70,000,000. That is the kind of loose talk the Minister comes along with on the eve of a general election.

I would like the Minister to take himself away from the surroundings of Dublin, from Leinster House or Government Buildings, and to go down amongst the small farmers. Let him come down to a fair or a market in County Roscommon any day he likes and tell the farmers that they are better off than ever and that there is evidence of prosperity all round them. If the Minister comes to that part of the country I will introduce him to people who were supporters of his three or four years ago, but from whom I am afraid he would want to have protection to-day. There is no use in the Minister for Finance coming here and saying that the housing problem could be solved if we had all the money that Deputy Cosgrave's Government paid to Great Britain. Since the Minister retained the money the British have been collecting every penny of it, and not only collecting it but, in the words of the President, doing so in a way that causes greater hardship. The Minister still thinks that it would have been good policy to start that racket in 1923, and that the housing problem would now be solved, despite the fact that we would have to pay £10,000,000, as has been done within the last three years, in bounties and subsidies. The Minister has a short memory when it suits him. He did not tell us about the £35,000,000 that the civil war cost. His memory is short about that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not a bit. What did it cost?

Comment on this

The Minister ought to find that out from the files. He should not be asking me. He is a member of the Government and the responsibility is his. I think it is bad taste on the part of Ministers to ask ordinary Deputies what are the figures for this or for that purpose. The Government has all the information. I am entitled to ask Ministers for it and they should be able to give it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We know about it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This does not arise now.

Comment on this

I read one of the most extraordinary statements that I remember for a long time recently in a lecture delivered by the Minister for Agriculture. It was not an impromptu statement. A man might make a statement in that way that would not be correct. Very often people say things impromptu that would be better left unsaid, just as they often omit things that should be said. The Minister is reported in the Irish Press to have delivered this lecture in Wynn's Hotel. He was speaking of grain growing and went back to 1840. He stated that Great Britain removed the Corn Laws and made it an absolute economic impossibility for our country to produce grain; that the people then turned to live stock and live-stock products which they could produce in competition with the world. Was there ever a greater condemnation of the Fianna Fáil Party?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why?

Comment on this

In 1840 it was found absolutely uneconomic, even with transport communication then in such a backward state, to produce grain in competition, but there was one thing the Minister said they could do—and he was right there—and that was to produce live stock and live-stock products with any other country. That was economic and the people found that out. I would like the Minister to make a comparison of the standard of living of the people then and now. Would the Minister try to root that up? Does he want to bring us back to what was found to be absolutely uneconomic and to get away from what we are able to produce in competition with the world? It was a remarkable statement.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It was perfectly true.

Comment on this

The Minister should let that sink into his own mind, and should try to influence people like the Minister for Finance, because he stated last year that a better market than ever was opening for us in Great Britain, a market for store cattle.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is a pity the whole lecture did not sink into the Deputy's mind.

Comment on this

I will be able to quote it for the Minister on another occasion. Any member of the Fianna Fáil Party who talks of increasing tillage, or endeavours to show that the store cattle trade is better than the fat cattle trade, does not know what he is talking about. That is what the Minister for Finance thinks about it and that is the type of thing that has put this country where it is. Mind you, it does not matter what the Minister for Finance thinks, what the Minister for Agriculture thinks, or what questions he puts to Deputy O'Neill, the difference of 2d. in the price of the 4lb. loaf has not been explained to this country. The Minister does not think Fianna Fáil is responsible for any of it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce admitted here that there were mills in this country that were not producing economically and that were not showing a profit commensurate with the profit they should be expected to show, the Minister says he could not see what steps could be taken to remedy the situation.

On the whole, I have not any evidence that there is prosperity in the country. I saw in Roscommon last week what I did not see there before— the sheriff's posse gathering in cattle for the annuities. The Minister, in his Budget speech, tells us that the Government has been very kind and, as it were, very lavish with the local authorities, and he mentioned certain sums of money that had been made available to local authorities, amounting, I think, to £4,011,000. He draws some extraordinary conclusions from this. For instance, he said that sums of £1,616,000 and £1,844,000 were advanced from the Exchequer to the Guarantee Fund to relieve local authorities of an embarrassing situation—a situation which Fianna Fáil and nobody else had created. He goes on to say that advances of £550,000 were made on the security of the funded land annuity arrears, and that he was now taking in that total sum of £4,011,000 as an asset to the Government.

Further, he said that the Government's liabilities have been enormously increased by the fact that they had undertaken the halved annuity. Of course, they have, but the Minister did not tell us that they have the revenue of the other half. Is that not right?

Comment on this

Is that not set out in the White Paper?

Comment on this

Exactly, but the Minister did not set it out in this speech. This speech endeavoured to show us that the Government had taken on a certain liability which was never theirs before, and one would imagine from reading it that they had nothing to meet that but ordinary taxation. Of course, they had. They took the halved annuity responsibility, and collected the other half and held on to it and passed an Act to ensure that they would do so. There is no point whatever in endeavouring to show to this House and to the country that a new liability has been taken on when an equal revenue is availed of against it. On the whole, we have nothing to be grateful for in this Budget. I do not know whether the people in the country were expecting any reliefs, but, considering the promises which the Minister for Finance made before he became Minister and the way in which the people were let down, I do not suppose there will be anybody disappointed over it, but it is certainly a very sad commentary on the Fianna Fáil plan. Our taxation has gone up and prices have soared for every commodity the people have to buy. While the manufacturer has the statutory protection of law with regard to quotas and tariffs, the purchaser has absolutely no protection, and, even though at the moment live-stock prices are good, the people are not able to buy as much as they were this time 12 months ago. I think the Budget, on the whole, disappointing, and I think there are no people in the country to whom it is more disappointing than the Fianna Fáil people themselves.

Comment on this

Some three or four years ago, when the economic war started in this country, we heard from Deputies opposite that the country was going completely bankrupt within six months. We were told that there would be no hope of any finances being collected, no hope of anything being done, and that the country was going to go bankrupt. What is the position to-day? Despite enormous expenditure for social services that were completely ignored during the term when the Party opposite were in office, despite enormous expenditure in the shape of provision for housing and restoring the old age pensions that were stolen from the people, we find ourselves in this position to-day, that we are able to give a reduction of 4d. in the duties on tea, to reduce the duties on sugar by £12,000, to abolish the customs duty on wheat costing £170,000 more, and to provide £200,000 extra for widows' and orphans' pensions and other social services. That is the position to-day, and it is on that that anyone must judge the financial position of the country to-day. If Deputies opposite wish to come nearer to it, I will take the financial position in Cork County. The position last month with regard to rate collection in Cork County was that we had 8 per cent. more of the rates collected than we had last year, and, in addition to that, we had £20,000 more of the arrears brought in. To put it precisely, we had £48,000 more collected on 20th March, 1937, than we had on 20th March, 1936.

That is the actual situation so far as the ordinary people down the country are concerned. When I look at the amazing promises made by the Party opposite, I am taken back to the 1932-33 election when we had similar amazing promises made by Deputy Cosgrave and his Party. They were going to reduce the annuities by half and, not alone that, they were not going to demand them for five or six years in order to enable the people to recover from the six months or nine months of the tough time the farmers had gone through up to then. They were able to promise because they knew well they would never be asked to keep their promises, and because they knew that the people of this country had such experience of them that they were finished with them. When I turn to the Fine Gael programme of to-day. I wonder which of the policies and which of the programmes is going to be adopted. If, by any miracle—and it would take a miracle to accomplish it— the Party opposite came back to office, I wonder whether it is Deputy Dillon's policy of abolishing the wheat and beet schemes that is going to be carried out, or the policy of those Deputies who do not agree with him. Deputy Dillon, at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis, said that wheat and beet were all cod and should be done away with, but there happened to be a few farmers there, which is rather an extraordinary thing, and one of them immediately stated that he disagreed entirely with Deputy Dillon as regards beet. He was Colonel Wemys Quin, of Wexford, and he said that the farmers in his part of the country were "yowling" for beet, and would grow twice as much if allowed, that it was a paying concern, that he could not get the acreage but that, if he could not get the acreage, he would grow it. That was a statement made by one of the few farmers who happened to be there. Then they are going to fix 5d. a gallon for milk.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is Government policy that is now under discussion, not Fine Gael policy.

Comment on this

I am making a comparison.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What we are discussing now is the policy of the Government. The policy of other Parties does not arise for consideration on this Resolution.

Comment on this

I am only giving a comparison between the Budget and the alternative put forward by the Party opposite.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be interesting but it is not relevant.

Comment on this

I agree with you that, considering that they will never get an opportunity of putting their programme into force, it is not worth considering their policy. It is rather peculiar that the Party who were satisfied that the farmers should get 2d. per gallon for their milk and that voted in favour of giving the farmer only 2d. per gallon two years ago should make such an amazing change of front as to guarantee him 5d. per gallon on condition, of course, that he will work for them in the election. The Party opposite are now in favour of complete derating of agricultural land. Yet, they published the report of this Commission of Inquiry——

Comment on this

Would you not be in favour of derating?

Comment on this

I got a better thing; I got the annuities halved.

Comment on this

I thought you could do with a little more.

Comment on this

We will take all we can get but there is no use in blowing hot and cold. There is no use in your saying that you are going to give complete derating and, at the same time, packing a jury of very important men and paying them for six months out of the public purse to bring in a report that derating was absolutely useless to the farmers.

Comment on this

Did not the Fianna Fáil Party move a motion here in favour of derating?

Comment on this

It did and we corkscrewed £750,000 out of Deputy Cosgrave and his Party—more than the Party opposite has accomplished since they went into opposition.

Comment on this

Do not run away from the farmer.

Comment on this

There is one matter on which I should like to be enlightened, since the discussion has concerned itself so much with the growing of wheat and the price of bread. How is it that the Dublin millers are able to put in tenders for contracts at lower prices than those at which, apparently, the Cork millers could afford to sell flour? I should like to hear some explanation of that in view of the statements we have heard regarding the cost of milling flour. I am also grateful to the Minister for Finance for the abolition of the levy on farmers' butter. It was about time that was done. That is a relief to small farmers who have no creameries in their areas and who are working under hard conditions. If there is relief to be given in any direction, it should be given to that particular class of farmer who cannot avail of Government schemes.

During the last four months we have been listening to statements as to the ability of the country to carry on and pay its way. We can now compare these statements with the working out of the accounts for the past 12 months and with the manner in which relief can now be given. We hear complaints as to the enormous burden of taxation, but I did not see a Deputy on the opposite side on any single occasion on which increased social services were proposed, which certainly meant an increased burden of taxation, standing up to oppose them. When we hear Deputies complaining of the burden of taxation, I wonder how they are going to get the £17,000,000 which it will cost to put their programme into operation and clap that on top of the existing taxation. I wonder why Deputies on the opposite side had not the courage to vote against these increased social services when the motions to establish them were brought in. I did not hear any Deputy calling a division on the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Bill. I did not hear any Deputy calling for a division on the motion to provide increased money for housing. They were all delighted. Every Deputy who spoke on these occasions—and they were rather long-winded—thanked the Minister for bringing in the proposals and spoke about benefits being conferred on very deserving classes of the community. They were all, apparently, very grateful that the agricultural community and, particularly, the worst paid class of that community—the agricultural labourers—were at last going to get from a Fianna Fáil Government what had been denied them for ten years by Cumann na nGaedheal. Every one of them came along to vote that the unfortunate agricultural labourers should get, at least, a decent house in which to live and that the Government should contribute 60 per cent. of the cost of this house and an acre of land. Surely, if they have any sense of responsibility, they took into consideration the cost of that proposal. Surely they knew that a Government could not provide 60 per cent. of the cost of these houses without finding money somewhere. They were equally delighted in regard to the Government's proposals for grants for reconstruction of houses. They were equally delighted in that particular thing. The Government proposed to give farmers £40 of a free grant towards reconstructing their houses—a thing that had been refused to me on several occasions when I was on those benches over there and when Deputy Mulcahy was over here as Minister for Local Government. Deputy Mulcahy would not dream of doing it at that time, but Deputies opposite were very glad when it was done, and each one of them praised the Minister when these proposals were brought in here.

As far as we can judge by the returns, the country has not been bankrupted by looking after the poor a little better than they were looked after before. The country has lost nothing by it. In fact, we did so well that, as I have pointed out, we were able to reduce the taxes which, again, fall on the poorer classes of the community, namely, tea, sugar and butter. We were able to reduce the taxes on those commodities by a considerable amount, and we hear any amount of talk about the high cost of living and what it is costing. We were told here a couple of years ago that the wheat scheme would bankrupt the country. What do we find to-day? We find that the foreign wheat which is being brought in here at present is thought less of than the native wheat produced here, for which we were able to pay our farmers and from which our farmers got some benefit. In plain language, our insurance policy in respect of wheat is paid. Deputy Dillon, of course, at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis said that the wheat policy was all "cod" and that you would not find any farmer who was growing 200 acres of wheat, and that they would get out of it at the first opportunity. We wonder how many Deputies opposite agree with him. We wonder what Deputy Minch would say to that. Deputy Dillon also spoke about the beet question. Well, Deputy Dillon never grew it. He has no knowledge of it. His proudest boast in this House is that he never grew either wheat or beet. It would appear that he never grew anything. Apparently, he did not even grow brains.

When we examine that position of affairs, I wonder if we had not the wheat schemes and if we had not the wheat and beet policy, where would we find ourselves? We would be dependent on a foreign market for anything we grow. That evidently does not agree with Deputy Dillon's policy as he outlined it here to-day. We wonder which of the Parties opposite is going to succeed. Is it Deputy Dillon's Party or Deputy Minch's Party in regard to wheat, or how many different Parties are going to form the new Government when they come along? Are they going to last as long, or are they going to have as many defections from their ranks as they have had in the last two or three years? Are we going to have Deputy MacDermot joining them to day and running away from them to-morrow, and somebody else coming in immediately afterwards, and so on?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is miles away from what we are discussing.

Comment on this

I admit, Sir, that it is somewhat away from the subject, but perhaps I might be allowed some latitude in view of the hopelessness of the alternative that has been offered to the people by Deputies over there. I am very glad to see that Deputy Mulcahy is here, but it must be remembered that he led Deputies over there and walked boldly into the Lobby and demanded a division on a programme that 2d. a gallon was enough for the farmers to get for their milk two years ago. Apparently he was present at a famous Ard-Fheis that was held last month at which they solemnly declared they would give 5d.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot get away from the matter before us. It is Government policy that is before us.

Comment on this

I know, Sir, that we are discussing Government policy, and I am only making a comparison between the Government policy as it has been outlined and the alternative that has been put up by the Party opposite.

Comment on this

There is no comparison.

Comment on this

I admit that. There is no comparison at all.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy hear the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce say that the farmers were better off to-day, even in Cork? Would he deal with that?

Comment on this

I regret that Deputy Mulcahy was absent when I did deal with it. I pointed out that our rates position—and he should know a lot about rates considering that he was for ten years Minister for Local Government—was better in Cork by £48,000 than it was before.

Comment on this

That is good.

Comment on this

Surely to Heaven, that position has not come up out of the stones? The annuities position also in Cork County, despite the efforts of General Mulcahy and the rest of them, and all the generals in the job, past and present, improved so well that we were able to reduce our rates by 8d. in the £. That was a big change. It was a rather astonishing change in the condition of affairs in Cork. I notice that Deputy Mulcahy is leaving the House. I suppose he could not wait any longer, but perhaps he may return. However, when we do get down to this position and when we realise the way things are, it is foolish for the people opposite to talk in the way they do. For instance, I have often been challenged by Deputies over there in words to the effect that they would like to hear me make such-and-such a statement at the fair. I have not any objection to say those things at the fairs or anywhere else. The price of cattle is better than in 1932. I am sure that the farmers in Midleton Fair on the last fair-day, for instance, realised the success of our policy. I do not think we gave them any special subsidy coming on to the election in order to drive up the price of cattle by £3 or £4 a head, or was it a dispensation of Providence that did it? I suppose it must have been a special dispensation. When we get down further to the position and examine the condition of affairs that did exist here and that, admittedly, existed here and that Deputies opposite, or ex-Deputies, as they now are, opposite, did admit existed, in their constituencies in 1929, 1930 and 1931, the true position can be seen. For instance, we had Deputy Carey coming down to Midleton at that time and moving a resolution to be sent up to the Minister for Agriculture in which it was stated that the Minister for Agriculture should collect no further rates in that constituency in 1929 because the farmers could not pay them. In 1929, the farmers in East Cork were bankrupt and could not pay their annuities. If we are to accept the statement and the resolution passed by the Midleton Urban Council and sent up here to the Minister at that time, the farmers were ruined at that time. I represent the constituency and I have a fairly good knowledge of it. I have a fairly good knowledge of the condition of things that existed there at that time.

Let us take the condition of affairs in regard to barley. I remember, in 1931, being brought down with the President to Bennett's mills in Midleton. There were over 80 farmers with their horses and carts loaded with barley, and they were told to take the barley home, that there was no market for it, that Mr. Bennett did not want it. In 1936, what was the position? The moment the old engine whistled in the haggard you had three or four motor cars up to the door. You were asked, "Have you any barley, and what is your price?" The visitors proclaimed themselves to be buyers, and they assured the farmer that they would send bags and lorries to take away the stuff from the yard. Why, they would almost thresh it for you! That is a big change in the position of the farmers, and it makes a big contrast with some of the statements we heard from the Opposition to-day.

If Deputies opposite had any honesty they would admit the facts. Can they ever agree upon a definite policy? I do not believe you could get four of them to agree on any particular policy. You will never get Deputy Dillon and Deputy Minch to agree in regard to the growing of wheat, and you will never get Deputy Bennett and Deputy Mulcahy to agree on what should be done in relation to milk. Deputy Bennett showed his independence on a famous occasion when Deputy Mulcahy wanted to bring the price of milk down to 2d. Deputy Bennett walked into the Lobby with us and he said he could never face the Limerick farmers if he agreed to pay them only 2d. a gallon for milk. I am glad Deputy Bennett has driven the would-be Government so far as to get them to guarantee 5d. for milk. I am sure the Deputy will get extra votes at the election because of his attitude.

There has been a most amazing change of front on the part of the Opposition in regard to derating. I have here the report of the Derating Commission, signed by ten most worthy gentlemen, who considered the question over a period of four or five months at the request of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. They tell us that derating would be absolutely useless for the farmers. It is really a most astonishing document and I observe that Deputy W. J. Broderick has appended his signature, thus giving in black and white his then opinion. I wonder what attitude he adopts towards derating to-day? I think Deputies Cosgrave and Mulcahy should have enlightened those who were at the recent Ard-Fheis when the famous resolution about the derating of agricultural land came on. They should have made some reference to the report of the commission they set up.

We hear people complaining of over-taxation. Deputies opposite also complained of it, and yet they tell us that if they were in office they would put £17,000,000 additional by way of taxation in order to meet, I suppose, derating and other things, and they suggest that the country could bear it. Where is the use of talking that kind of trash and then telling us in the next breath about people being ruined and robbed? Three years ago they said the people were bankrupt. Their latest proposal is a testimony to the soundness of the financial position. Three years ago Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was telling us that we were sure to have a bad harvest. We had definite statements about the bankruptcy and the ruination of the country. Even last year we were told there was no hope of collecting the amount we required. This year we are able, not alone to increase our social services, but to reduce taxation. Deputies opposite are now so assured of the financial soundness of the country that they maintain we could collect £17,000,000 more for the purpose of carrying out their new programme.

I can heartily congratulate the Minister for Finance on the manner in which he has worked out the finances of the Free State during the last four years and on the reliefs he finds himself now able to give. If the position were otherwise, I would tell him just as quickly. I wish Fine Gael Deputies would talk a little sense. Deputy O'Neill complains of the price of bread; he says it is too much for the poor. It is rather a peculiar condition of affairs to have him saying that, when one recollects the letters he has written to the Press within the last three months encouraging the bakers to organise to look for more. Apparently that is part of the job. I suggest that Deputies should not carry on with that kind of humbug.

Comment on this

The speech to which we have just listened compares very favourably with the speeches of the Minister for Finance and of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the House to-day. Deputy Corry's speech, however, was a general attack on this Party for what they did and for what they did not do. I would advise the Deputy before he starts to criticise our policy to give some thought to the plan that his Party were to bring into operation after the general election five years ago. At that time they went to the people of this country and promised them a reduction of £2,000,000 a year in taxation and 52 weeks' work per annum for every unemployed man in the country. What is the position to-day? We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when speaking on the unemployment question, making comparisons to-day between this country and Denmark and some other countries. I hold that no comparison can be made as to the position of unemployment in this country with the position in any other country. You have a state of affairs in this country for the past four or five years, a state which is inflicted by the Government of the country on the people of the country. You have the economic war with Great Britain which has resulted in the destruction of the agricultural community. That so-called economic war has destroyed the means of living of the agricultural community and the agricultural workers. The state of the country was never so bad economically for the last 50 years as it has been since 1932. Yet, after that period of five years the Minister for Finance, opening his Budget statement, says:—

"At the date of last year's Budget I should have been well content with a total revenue from taxation and otherwise of £30,191,500, but as in fact £31,034,710 poured into us, I cannot be blamed if I find the retrospect over the past 12 months a not unagreeable one from the Exchequer standpoint."

Why have those enormous sums over the estimated amount poured into the Minister for Finance? It is because every article that the people of this country have to buy now is taxed by the Government. There is an exorbitant tax on commodities, and this year again more tariffs are coming on. I agree with the industrial side of the policy of this Government, but I hold that it is not right that the people of this country should be asked to pay considerably more for the products of new factories in this country than they had to pay for the imported article before these industries were established. I think that is very unjust.

We are very thankful for the benefit gained by the small farmers in the remission of the tariff or levy on farmers' butter. No doubt it will be a great help to the farmers this summer as will also be the remission of the levy on creamery butter. But what is the position of the ordinary workers of the country to-day with regard to the plan put before the country by Fianna Fáil? On Monday evening last I was speaking to some men employed on relief schemes at 19/6 per week. Out of that 19/6 they have to maintain a wife and family and pay rent and rates on their houses. I wonder how it is that the Government can imagine that the workers of the country are able to maintain themselves and their families on such a deplorable wage? I know these men are working on a relief scheme. But even so, the Government should give some headline as to the rate of wages to be paid in the country. The rate of wages paid their workmen by the Cork County Council is 35/- a week. But side by side with that wage of 35/- a week, workers on relief schemes are getting 19/6 for a week of five days. I think it is a disgraceful state of affairs that any worker in this country should be asked to work five days for £1 less 6d. stopped off that for insurance, leaving the man only 19/6 to maintain himself, his wife and family for the week.

We hear a good deal of talk about the great volume of housing that the present Government are carrying out. We are told over and over again that the workers of the country had to wait ten years for those houses to be built for them. But when people speak about that I would ask them and Deputies on the other side of the House to cast their minds back to the time when the Party on this side of the House were establishing law and order here and when the men now on the Government side put this country to the enormous cost of the civil war which inflicted a loss of £45,000,000 on the country. The Cumann na nGaedheal Party coming into office had to build what the members of the present Government had been destroying. Surely if things like housing and other matters of that kind were not tackled the Government of that period were not to blame for that. After ten years of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government we had the Fianna Fáil Party coming in here five years ago. This State, which had been put into a good financial position by the late Government, was handed over to the Fianna Fáil Government in 1932 in a sound and healthy state. What has Fianna Fáil done with it since? Fianna Fáil in 1932 went to the country with a policy and a plan. They proposed to retain the annuities and to do lots of other things. They were not long in office when the economic war with Great Britain broke out—as a direct result of the Fianna Fáil policy. After 12 months we had another general election in 1933. In the course of that election the Fianna Fáil Government promised that if they were returned to power, the economic war would be settled in a very short time. I think that period was fixed by some of them at three weeks. That is now over four years ago. The economic war still goes on, and, judging by the replies given by President de Valera to Deputy MacDermot some days ago, no one need hope for a settlement of that economic war by the present Government.

There is one section of the people the licensed vintners, whose case I wish to bring before the House. I suppose it is hardly very popular to say anything in favour of that section of the community, we hear so much about temperance in these days. I am very sorry that the Minister for Finance could not see his way to ease the burden on these people, especially in view of the fact, as he tells us, that the country is now so prosperous and that revenue is pouring in to the Exchequer in such large amounts. Some relief should be given to that section of the people. The licensed vintners are composed of very hard-working, industrious people who earn a very hard-won living. Then, of course, there is the case of the poor, hard-working man who likes his pint of stout at a reasonable price. He has now to pay 9d. for it. I suppose it is unpopular now to take any kind of liquor, but I think the Minister would be doing a great day's work if he gave some little remission of this tax. After all, the poor man cannot afford to drink refined liquors such as whiskey, brandy and wines, and he likes a pint of stout. I think he is entitled to it. Why should he not have a drink as well as any other man in the country? He cannot afford to have it at the present time when the price is 9d. I think the Minister should have given some little remission in this tax.

In conclusion, I wish to say that I consider this a bad Budget. We have a total bill of something like £35,000,000 which the people will have to find for the next 12 months. Never before in the history of this State were the people taxed as they are at present. On the eve of a general election I thought that we would have received more in the way of remissions from the Minister for Finance. I hope that when, next year, Budget-time comes around, the people will have in office a Government which will bring in a Budget in accordance with the capacity of the people to pay.

Comment on this

Whilst no doubt this Budget could be criticised strongly from many aspects, taking all the circumstances into consideration, my personal opinion is that no impartial man could vote against it. I do not intend to say very much, but as Deputy O'Neill raised some important questions, I think it only right that they should not be allowed to pass without some analysis in any case. He made one good point undoubtedly in regard to the pig and bacon industry, that too much control was given to the factories. My personal opinion is that the factories are really laughing up their sleeves at the farmers and are taking advantage of the Minister's order.

Comment on this

They are taking more than an advantage.

Comment on this

I also hold that the best friend the farmer has is the ordinary buyer at the country fair. I have personal experience of sending pigs to the factory. I was not expert enough to mark them for such-and-such a grade, but the results I got were appalling. I asked two special friends afterwards to come and mark them, and after that I got somewhat better results. The colossal profit which the factories make, when one considers the price which the farmers receive for their pigs, is something that no Government could stand over. The Minister's intentions were undoubtedly good, and my personal belief is that the Minister is a man who would give his life-blood for the farmers. He has, however, set up boards to administer this scheme, and the control is out of his hands. Someone may say: "Why not put a man in every factory to supervise the scheme?" but can any man define once and for all what the profits should be? That is a question upon which many men will differ. Say, for instance, that the State takes over immediately all the factories of the country. At what price, then, do you think the bacon could be put on the breakfast table? That is a very interesting question.

As regards wheat production, I upheld the wheat scheme on a great national principle. In one sense, if we deny our ability to grow wheat, we deny our ability to provide for our own existence. Deputy O'Neill is very well up in questions concerning the price of bread, and farmers in West Cork understand that thoroughly. If, however, no wheat were grown in Ireland this year, can anybody guarantee that the price of bread would be lower this time twelvemonths? Then is the country not faced with a far greater danger? We live in a country which is an island, and nobody knows what to-morrow or the next year may bring. I am sure many Deputies while at school studied Professor Baldwin's book on agriculture. He laid down as the ideal system of tillage four acres of wheat in each 100 acres of land. That would provide the full quota for 6,000,000 people. The position is that at the present day some farmers with 100 acres of land grow 20 acres of wheat. I personally have 110 acres, and I have 22 acres of wheat. I admit that my land could not stand the growing of wheat at that rate, but if I only grew four acres per annum it would stand it. We must establish an equilibrium in tillage, and you can then guarantee a wheat scheme.

To go back to the last administration, I said on one occasion when I was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party that if the Government at that time had adopted one-quarter of the principles outlined in Professor Baldwin's little book on agriculture, it would be very hard indeed, apart from the main political issues, to get them out of power at all. The one mistake they made was this. I travelled over several parts of the country, part of Tipperary, most of West Cork and North Cork, and to my mind 1928 was the last good year in which a farmer could say that he was able to put £50, £60 or £100 aside in the bank. From 1928 onwards I found that there was a certain amount of grumbling amongst the farmers. The depression had set in, as it were. In 1929 or 1930 the price of black oats had fallen to 3/6 per cwt. At that time there was much grumbling throughout the country. The natural instinct of the farmers is to ask: "Can we do any better? Will we chance another Government?" That will always be the position. At that time I was of opinion that if the then Government encouraged the cultivation of more crops it would be much harder to upset them than it was in 1932. To my mind, there are bigger questions to be tackled than have been outlined by many Deputies, ex-Ministers, and, possibly, Ministers too. The greatest food for thought is provided by the statement of the Minister given on page 52 of the manuscript of his speech:—

"The foreign assets of our banks are, as far as I can judge, the only reliable thermometer of national wealth and, as revealed by the Currency Commission Report, they are down by £11,000,000 in the last five years."

There is food for thought in that sentence. The ordinary man in the street will ask himself "does this mean that we are still in the hands of the old moneyed interests, or does it mean that those interests are turning out to be more Irish than the Irish themselves, and keeping their money here?" If it does, we shall all take our hats off to them and welcome them in, because I hold that there are only two courses to take—to invite them, through patriotic motives, to bring back here the money that was invested abroad, or else to create a new system. Further on in his Budget statement the Minister says: "Shall I be accused of facetiousness if I remark that at this period ‘the only really reliable thermometer of national wealth' must have been in grave danger of bursting—or perhaps it was merely the fantastic thesis which exploded." That is correct. Early in 1922 I knew pretty wealthy men who at that time took their money out of this country. I asked them why. "How," they said, "can we trust the wreckers and breakers of the Civil War period?" I said: "The nation must come first. We will leave the rest to history. There is no question about it that in the past there were great men on both sides." I, personally, differed from one whom I now consider to have been the greatest revolutionary leader of all time—the late Michael Collins. I said to those people: "Is that the reason that you desert Ireland?""It is," they said, "until we see further." Taking the land of Ireland, its value in pre-war days was given by a great authority at £1,000,000,000. I wonder can any speaker say how the wealth is divided. I have gone, for instance, to 22 or 23 farmers in my parish, and tried to ascertain from them whether they had any money in the bank or in investments. My calculation was that no more than five out of the 22 or 23 had any, and their amounts would be small.

Another factor which had a great bearing on the position of lands in good areas was the financial swindle after the Great War. We all realise that in 1920 the farmers were wealthy; they were at peak point. A good sow and a litter of bonhams would make £40, and a cow £60, and the unfortunate thing was that it was easy to get money to invest in land. What happened next was that those men found themselves in the position that they had to pay back £ for £. That, in my opinion, left the farmers in parts of Cork, and in Tipperary and Meath, in a bad position. Those are really the things which we as a nation should consider. I believe that we all, irrespective of Party, stand for Ireland as a nation. I could give instances of areas near Bandon where the farmers are in that position, and they have been struggling ever since. The capital is not there. My point is that the farmer is the people; he is the nation. If he fails, the whole country fails and the nation goes down. We may speak about dictators in foreign countries. On the Alps I remember a time when a farmer or a peasant had not a cow or a horse. There was one condition laid down: "Will you work?" If he said "Yes," everything else was supplied, and in that way the country was raised from a seventh or eighth rate power to be a first rate world power.

In regard to the question of unemployment, a good deal has been done; the intention was good, but I would say that unemployment assistance has been the curse of this country. Everything possible should be done before creating around the people an atmosphere of idleness. An active man does not really want that, but, if you give him unemployment assistance and leave him alone for a few years, he will get into an atmosphere of idleness and sit in the corner. How can that be remedied? Let us be reasonable? It would be an utter impossibility for the Minister to do so with the resources at his disposal. Is there any possible hope? I say that there is. Let there be one system or another. Let the £9,000,000 or £11,000,000 that came back since 1932 be thrown into the country in a patriotic way. Then every farm in Ireland which is to-day employing one or two men can employ five. I refer to farms of 100 to 150 acres.

Many men will say that it is not the Governments but the great financiers who can really tell you what employment you have, what factories you have, and, in fact, how many children you are going to have. That may be laughed at, but deeper thinking men than I am would not laugh at it. Even Lord Beaverbrook in England has written on the subject. Was not that the explanation why every Labour Government which sat in England was overthrown at elections? The people of this country should not get it into their heads that any republican movement is going to injure their property. The other opinion should exist, but unfortunately the statement given in the Budget outlined a position which really was not true. There are many things which it is not necessary to go into. In any case I am not capable of going into the figures, but there is one question to which I would ask the Minister to give special attention, and not to be unscrupulous about it. There is no earthly doubt about it that the farmer to-day is—I would go the length of saying—robbed by the factories. It is not directly the Minister's fault, it is the machinery they are taking advantage of.

Deputy O'Neill made a great case in regard to bread, but when that is analysed I think it will be seen that he was taking a bit of an advantage, having regard to the present world price of wheat. My personal opinion is this: that you are going to have Armageddon sooner than many people think. The die is cast, and one system in Europe must kill the other. There is going to be a re-marking of Europe, and it will come to the point how are we going to fare when that takes place? The nationalists of this country are looking forward to that day. The one great hope for the country is that we should all pull in the one direction. Let us have healthy criticism, but at the same time let us all stand united for the nation that was and is and will be.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Minister for Finance is not present in the House because I would have liked to congratulate him on the complacency with which he has persuaded himself, if nobody else, that this is a satisfactory Budget. I admit it is a balanced Budget. According to the Minister, it has been balanced three times. There is first an apparent balance given to us in the figures: Revenue, £31,034,710; expenditure, £31,227,688, showing a deficiency of £192,978. These are the first figures that the Minister gives in his retrospect on last year's working. Later, he gives what he calls an adjusted balance. After certain adjustments he arrives at a surplus of £1,144,523. Lest perhaps that figure might appear too good, he proceeds to make a third balance, what he calls a clear surplus, which, after making provision for certain items of borrowing, etc., is £464,844. Now, I presume there could be a fourth balance, which some people might call the true balance, cr there might be a fifth balance which might differ from the first four balances. It is possible that I myself, with the figures, could make a sixth balance, and that we would still have a balanced Budget, but, despite that, it would have no bearing whatever on the condition of the people in this State. Successive Ministers can go on balancing their Budgets as long as we are in a position to borrow, when necessary. Some wiseacre said many years ago that you could almost prove anything by figures.

The Minister in his Budget statement said: "The condition of the people has improved steadily so that to-day we are much better off than we were five years ago." If the conclusion of the Minister as regards the solvency of the country and our capacity to bear taxation is based on no better foundation than that statement, then many people in the country will be sceptical of many of his other Budget statements. Let us for a moment look back over this wonderful era of prosperity that we are supposed to have lived through during the last five years. Can we be told what section of the people it is that has become prosperous so suddenly? It may be that, in the City of Dublin, where you have so many of the professional classes, many foreigners and others, you would find some people who might be called prosperous, but if you go 20 or 30 miles outside Dublin and, in a haphazard way, meet a native of this country and ask him "Are you fairly prosperous?" I venture to say the reply will be in the negative.

The farmers, I suppose, comprise the biggest section amongst our people. The Minister, in his Budget statement, dealt at some length with the question of the annuities and other matters that concern farmers. This question of the annuities has a very big effect on a farmer's prosperity, as well as what he has to pay in the way of general taxation. The farmer's position is something like this: A certain sum of money was due by him. The payment of it was disputed, and as a consequence of the dispute certain issues were raised which I do not want to go into. The sum in dispute was in or about £3,000,000. The Minister says that he has improved the farmer's condition tremendously, and that the country has prospered tremendously because of the improvement in the farmer's position since he, or somebody on his behalf, ratted in the payment of the £3,000,000. Since that dispute started the farmer's position has been this: He has been discharging his obligations in respect of that disputed sum of £3,000,000; in addition, he has been discharging obligations which he himself did not enter into but which somebody else entered into in the way of local loans, pensions and other payments.

The farmer has been directly discharging these combined liabilities to the tune of about £22,000,000 over the last four years, while at the same time he has been paying into the Exchequer here interest on money which neither the Exchequer nor this Government lent to him, and which, at the farmer's expense, appears to be a lucky windfall for the present Minister for Finance. Prior to 1923, the Government in this State never lent the tenant farmers of Ireland as much as one halfpenny, but other people did. We refuse to pay the other people. They are taking it off us, and this Government which did not lend us any money asks us to hand into their pool a sum which they say is only half of what was due to other people. We are asked to pat the Minister on the back for all that.

Deputy Corry referred to the wonderful price paid for cattle recently, due, he said, to the Government's policy. That, of course, was by way of emphasising all that the Minister for Finance had said in his Budget statement about the prosperity of the country. The Deputy said that he was at Midleton fair the other day, and that a farmer came up to him and said that the price that was being paid for cattle was top-hole. I admit that cattle prices have improved lately, but I am not thanking the Minister for Finance for that. A couple of farmers came to me, as they came to Deputy Corry, and I think they also were inclined to praise the Minister for Finance for the improvement that has lately taken place in the prices offered for cattle. One farmer said to me, "Prices have gone up. Is not £8 a great price for that beast?" I said it was, but that £11 10s. would be a better price. That was the price that should be in his pocket if the £3 10s., which went to other people in lieu of a debt, was taken off the farmer's cattle.

There has been a good deal of reference to farming economy. I was glad to hear Deputy Hales candidly admit that there was a danger in the wheat policy, which is so frequently spoken of in this House. Deputy Hales is in the happy position now that he can speak with an open mind, although he is probably in more intimate association with the Government Party than any Deputy outside that Party. I expect that there is really very little difference between Deputy Hales' real opinions and the Deputies of the Party with which he is in what I might call some sort of association. I believe myself that his views are practically the views of that Party, and that if there was any difference of opinion between Deputy Hales and that Party, it was on a very minor matter. Deputy Hales was honest enough to point out to Ministers to-day the danger of that particular policy: that it was not as feasible as the Minister for Agriculture would seek to persuade us suddenly to go in for any extensive growing of wheat.

That is probably not particularly apropos to a Budget discussion, but it has been referred to by other speakers. The Minister himself, in his Budget speech, did, if one might say so, temporarily depart from the usual practice of Budget speeches by referring to matters which really were not financial. Therefore, it may be permitted to an ordinary Deputy to a small extent anyhow, to speak of general policy which may not be actually financial. We were forced by the speeches of the Minister and others to get on to the subject of wheat. Deputy Hales said he could not grow wheat. He said he had 20 acres of it, and he candidly admitted that he would have to stop it—that four acres would be sufficient, as his land would go out of condition. On many occasions here we have been told of the number of acres of wheat grown a hundred years ago, how the people were fed, and the money that was made.

Somebody has already remarked that nothing was said about the conditions of the people who grew the wheat. If we go back into history, we will find that when wheat was grown at the fairly good price of 2/6 per stone, when people were burning the sods of the land to produce the wheat, many of the growers of wheat were living on potatoes and milk. Their produce of wheat was being exported and therein lay the success possibly, if there was any success, in the growing of wheat at the period —that we were exporting it.

There must be an export for any agricultural produce in this country if we are going to make a success of it, because our consumption of anything we might grow is comparatively small. In certain circumstances, we can increase our production in everything. We have fertile land which is only half developed; no Government has fully developed it. Production can be raised all round, but we must have an export trade, and we will never export wheat. If there was a lesson to be learned from growing wheat, it could have been learned from the people a hundred years ago. You have only to go to my county, which was in two divisions, one contiguous to the market where wheat was easily marketed, and another portion far removed from the market, where wheat was not grown to such an extent—in fact, in some places it was not grown at all. Even the Minister for Finance, who, I suppose, will not claim to be an expert on land, can go down to the County Limerick and see the land on which wheat was grown extensively a hundred years ago and the land on which wheat was not grown to any extent, and I will guarantee that he will be honest enough to say that he could see the difference even now in the land. We are in danger of the same thing happening again. Deputy Hales was honest enough to admit that.

Comment on this

So that the Deputy is opposed to wheat growing?

Comment on this

I am not opposed to growing anything or producing anything that can be more economically produced than other things. As far as wheat growing is concerned, I certainly have no objection to it. In fact, I would help any farmer to grow wheat who wants to grow it and who thinks it is a better paying proposition than any other item of agriculture. But I do say that, if it had not been for the interference of the Government in our old economic system of agriculture, there would not have been the tendency to grow wheat that there has been, even with the subsidy. The subsidy would not be sufficiently attractive, if things were normal, to persuade any number of people to go in for wheat growing. I say definitely that if cattle prices were normal—they are improving in price—and if the British tariff were taken off cattle, so that people would get the real world price, which is the British price, your acreage of wheat would fall off next year; because there is no farmer who would not see clearly that one item of agriculture pays him better than another, and it is not wheat. In answer to the Minister, I say that I am not opposed to the growing of wheat. Possibly in my time I have grown more wheat than any other Deputy— but not in this country—and I know a lot about growing it.

I know that it is not an economic proposition to grow it in this country, as against other things that we can produce. As the Minister admitted, I know that there was an era of depression over the world a few years ago, and that we felt that depression less than the majority of countries. One of the reasons given for our immunity from the full consequences of that depression was that our agricultural policy was founded upon the principle of live stock. That made us more secure than other countries from the effects of the depression. We had the Minister for Agriculture speaking last week almost blessing the fact that we were short of cattle, and that we had not sufficient for the British quota.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The economic position does enter into the question of taxation and expenditure, but matters that properly arise on an Estimate should not be debated in detail on the Budget. There will be an opportunity of addressing remarks to the Minister for Agriculture on his Department within a week or so.

Comment on this

I agree, Sir, and I will get away from that subject. I will have an opportunity of discussing it with the Minister on another occasion. The Minister for Agriculture was here a short time ago, and we had quite a pleasant conversation between himself and Deputies on this side, discussing some of the good things in this Budget. As I am discussing wheat, I might as well come to the remission of the duty. There is a remission in this Budget. It is one of the things we are thankful for, but that we are not gloating over. The remission of the duty on wheat will cost £170,000, seeing that the import duty of 6d. per cwt. or 10/- a ton comes off. I have been endeavouring to arrive at the effect of the remission, and various estimates have been made. One Deputy put it at 1/3 per sack, but the Minister contradicted that. I am going to put it at 1/3 per sack of flour.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Bennett was in the House when his leader, Deputy Dillon, was speaking. Deputy Dillon said it made a difference of 2/2½ a sack.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with what Deputy Dillon said. He may be right or he may be wrong, but, from any information I can get, and any calculations I made, I think about 1/3 per sack represents the benefit given by the Budget. The Minister sometimes congratulates me on my calculations. The Minister, like myself, is pretty good at mental arithmetic, and I make it out at about ¾d. a stone, or 1/3 per 20 stone.

Comment on this

No. I am taking Deputy Dillon's figures.

Comment on this

Will you take my figure of ¾d. a stone or 1/3 a sack? I believe that that figure will be borne out by all authorities. When the poor housewife down the country, who is paying 8/- for a stone of flour, is handed back d. change, she will be told that the Minister for Finance gave her that, and she will say: "God bless him; is he not a grand man?" Some of them will say that. That is one effect of the remission. I do not know how it will affect the loaf. I cannot divide ¾d. on a stone of flour to get the effect on the price of a loaf. I can dissect one portion of the cost of the loaf, but the rest is beyond me. While I can make secret calculations it surpasses my ability to say how it will affect the price of the loaf. Deputy O'Neill made some interesting calculations about bread and flour generally, and Ministers entered into the jollity of the exchanges, because they thought they were getting "one over" on someone on this side. When Deputy O'Neill said that the difference between the price of bread here and in London was 2d. in the 4lb. loaf, the Minister for Agriculture agreed with him. The admission that the loaf was 2d. dearer here than across the Border was a good one to have from the Minister. The only difference between them was what it meant in millions to the people of this country.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making such an excellent speech that I would like him to be absolutely correct. I think the difference between the London and the Dublin prices was 2d. It was not the difference between prices this side of the Border and the other side.

Comment on this

It is one side of the Border, as London is outside the Border. The Minister is now admitting that the difference between London and the Dublin prices is 2d. per loaf. It would nearly pay a man with a family to go for a week-end to London and save the 2d. in the price of the loaf.

Comment on this

Is that what the Deputy used to do in 1928?

Comment on this

In 1928, sometimes during the course of the year, I was able to spare the cost of the third-class fare to Euston and have a little money for a holiday for 16 or 31 days. I have not been able to do that latterly.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy do that in 1928 when the British loaf was much cheaper than it is now?

Comment on this

How much cheaper? I do not know how many loaves are consumed and I do not know what the loss to the State would be. It is commonly said that we consume 2,600,000 sacks of flour in this State. If we relate flour to bread the loss of 2d. a pair on bread is equivalent to 15/- on a sack of flour.

Comment on this

The price is on the 4lb. loaf.

Comment on this

That is equivalent to a loss of 15/-, and if we relate that to sacks, 2,600,000 of which are consumed here, what is the resulting sum we pay over and above the price paid in London? I am leaving the Border out because the Minister does not like it. A comparison between London and Dublin is good enough for me. Taking 2,600,000 sacks at 15/- a sack, that would represent nearly £2,000,000 that we are paying for our daily bread over what is being paid in London. It may not be as much as that, but that is the position relating the cost of flour to the loaf. In the Minister's favour I should mention this, that some people convert the bag of flour into bread with rye and other mixtures. The difference may not be so great in their case, but it certainly is a big sum.

Comment on this

But the Deputy is already beginning to see how fantastic Deputy O'Neill's logic was.

Comment on this

I do not see the fallacy of it. The Minister might help me like the Minister for Agriculture helped me. He at least agrees that there is a difference of 2d. in the 4lb. loaf.

Comment on this

And that is equivalent to 15/- a sack, but there I stop.

Comment on this

The Minister agrees that that is the equivalent of 15/- a sack, and there are 2,600,000 sacks used in this State. If my powers of calculation have not departed from me, having agreed that there is a difference of 2d. in the 4lb. loaf, that that is equivalent to 15/- a sack, and that we consume 2,600,000 sacks, that surely means that we are at the loss of £2,000,000, less some little sum.

Comment on this

I should like to help the Deputy. If the Deputy's powers of cognition can grasp this, he will agree with me that at least 2,600,000 sacks of flour are not made into baker's bread in this country, and that is where his calculation breaks down.

Comment on this

I will leave that to the Minister. I said, when I started my remarks, that there was a certain section in the country who did not eat baker's bread.

Comment on this

More than half the people of this country.

Comment on this

I am satisfied. Half the people eat baker's bread, so that they lose only £1,000,000. The Minister agrees that that £1,000,000 is gone?

Comment on this

Oh, I am not going so far. Anyhow, the Deputy has dropped £1,000,000.

Comment on this

The Minister agrees that half the people eat baker's bread, and there is a difference of 2d. in the 4lb. loaf which meant 15/- a sack. He agrees that there are 2,600,000 sacks used here. That is pretty close to the £2,000,000, if they all eat baker's bread, but they do not. Only half of them eat it, so I give the Minister his £1,000,000, and we are losing £1,000,000 straight away. The unfortunate people who cook in a range or bastible are losing the rest. I gave that point to the Minister before he thought of it. I said that there were some people who did not eat loaf bread and that their loss was something less than that of the people who eat loaf bread. There is something less than £2,000,000. We will have the £1,000,000 for argument's sake and say £1,500,000. I will take another £100,000 off and say £1,400,000. Will that satisfy the Minister? The loss is there and admitted by two Ministers in this House.

Comment on this

The Deputy will soon be giving me the whole £2,000,000 if he goes on.

Comment on this

I think I have got enough out of the Minister's admission that there is £1,000,000 and the best part of another £1,000,000 of a difference in the price of bread made from flour here compared with London. We are thankful for the remission. It is something. It means 1/3 a sack, or ¾d. a stone, and we are thankful for every small help we can get; but, as I say, we are not gloating over it. There is still a difference of 2d. a loaf, representing a couple of million pounds over what it ought to be.

As regards the 4d. off tea, it is a big remission and most people are grateful for the concession. It will not be the Minister's fault if it does not add to the general prosperity which the Minister says exists. Personally, I do not believe it will add much, but I am thankful for it. I think, however, that the Minister might possibly have helped us as much by remitting the duty on something else. I am being candid with the Minister because he has been fairly candid with me, and I say that I and most other people are very grateful for the remission, but I do not believe it is going to add to the prosperity of the people to the extent that the Minister intended. I know that he is perfectly honest in his intention, but, even after the announcement of the remission, we see already the tendency on the part of people selling tea to explain their position to the people. They have practically prepared the people not to expect too much. The Minister is not to blame for that. We all know the tendency of such people and I hope the Minister will be able to counteract it in some way. There is a general practice amongst people in the country to buy tea at a certain price. They have been accustomed to buy tea at 2/-, 2/6 or 3/- and the curious thing is that, in some of the poorer parts of Connemara and Limerick, it is the very poor people who buy the 3/- tea. This will not make a bit of difference to them, because they will still ask for 2/-, 2/6 or 3/- tea, and it will merely be a matter of blending.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy must have read my speech on the 1932 Budget.

Comment on this

Probably I did, and I agree with the Minister. The Minister and I, although on opposite sides, have often agreed on things, and I am sure that if we were not so politically averse from one another, we would probably agree to a much greater extent than people think. The Minister agrees with me as to the £1,000,000 in respect of flour, and I am inclined to agree with the Minister that this remission could have been made more usefully in respect of other things.

Comment on this

What I am going to suggest to the Deputy is that he did not believe what his Party was saying then, even though he voted with them.

Comment on this

I am not good at ancient history. I can think quickly, and my mental calculations are sometimes quick, but I am getting old, and my memory is not as clear as the Minister's. I will admit that I do not remember things that happened five or six years ago as clearly as I ought to, and I am not going to argue on the things I am not perfectly clear on.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not grieve at such forgetfulness, and wishes it were more prevalent.

Comment on this

Everybody will be pleased at the concessions which the Minister has made, particularly in regard to the reduction in the price of butter. This is the one real tax the remission of which I believe will reach the consumer, but I should like the Minister for Agriculture to relate some other time what effect it will have on the producers of butter. I do not believe it will have much effect, but some people think it might.

I do not think there are any more items on which one might comment favourably, except that I might, at the risk of wearying the House, comment on some of the things that make up the balancing of this Budget. The Minister was not here when I said that he had balanced it three times in the course of his statement. I suggested that it might be balanced four or five times, and that even I, or anybody else, could make a balance.

Comment on this

Anybody could balance that Budget.

Comment on this

The Minister was good enough to quote what I said last year —that the farmer did not desire that any assistance offered to him should be handed on to posterity. I repeat that statement. I see that provision is still made for borrowing in this respect. The Minister took my hint last year. The Minister and I are getting on—he actually took the hint I gave him and did not use that money last year. He found he could do without it, and he did not charge us anything for the subsidies. He proposes to do it this year, and, in case he might, I am going to draw his attention again to the fact that I do not think it desirable to borrow £1,269,000 for subsidies for the farmer. While it is, and must be, desirable to try to keep him on his feet in certain circumstances, I would remind the Minister that there is a balance still in his hands out of what the farmer is paying which would help him to pay these moneys.

I do not suppose the Minister desires me to enter more fully into the question of the annuities and whether or not the farmer is getting the best end of the transaction. Having had such a pleasant interlude with the Minister during my remarks, I close, as I commenced, by congratulating him on the complacency with which he has tried to persuade us that this is a satisfactory Budget.

Comment on this
Denis Allen Mr. Allen

This Budget will, I think, be recognised as a sound Budget. The proof of that is that the Minister for Finance has been able to reduce taxation. We have, for the past five hours, been listening to the wails and lamentations of the Party opposite on the cost of living and, especially, on the cost of flour and bread. I wonder what the lamentations of Deputies would be like if Irish-grown wheat were responsible for the price of bread to-day. I am sure they would have torn down this House before now and driven the Government out of office if Irish wheat were 34/- a barrel. Deputy Morrissey, Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Dillon have been complaining about this matter for four years, since the Minister for Agriculture brought in his wheat-growing policy. They have held that the growing of wheat in Ireland was responsible for raising the cost of living. We have heard Deputy Dillon particularly dilate upon that. I wonder if Deputies opposite would be satisfied if the Irish farmer were getting 34/- a barrel for his wheat. We know they would not. Two-thirds or three-fourths of the Deputies on the opposite benches would not be satisfied to give the farmer an economic price for any of his staple products. They were not satisfied five years ago when the Minister for Agriculture introduced a measure to give a fair, economic price to the farmer for his milk and butter. They split on that. One-third of them went into the Lobby with Fianna Fáil, and the remainder followed Deputy Cosgrave into the Lobby against that Bill. That was their policy at that time and I am sure it is their policy to-day. They are not satisfied to give the farmer an economic price for any article he produces—whether bacon, butter, wheat or even beef. There is a wail already in certain sections of the Press which support the Opposition that beef is costing too much because the price of cattle has gone up a few pounds per head, or a few shillings per cwt. What would have happened if Irish cattle had been the same price during the past few years? We were getting beef here for some years at much under the cost of production. New, cattle are paying the cost of production and, as soon as they reach the world price in this country, a wail is started. The only argument the Opposition have been able to fall back upon for the past four or five years is that the cost of living was going up. Their one objection is to the farmer in Ireland getting an economic price for what he produces. It does not matter what price the Canadian, Australian, New Zealand or Argentine farmer gets in this country for his produce. There is no objection to that by the Party opposite. The Minister has, this year, produced a Budget that will meet with general satisfaction. The proof that the country is in a sound economic position is the fact that the Minister is able to reduce taxation and is raising less money for the service of the State than he had to raise last year. He needs less money and, knowing the state of the revenue during the last financial year, he is able to give certain concessions to the taxpayer this year. He has proved, if proof were needed—as it is not—that the policy of this Government has been a sound policy and has put this country on its feet.

I have been listening for some months to Deputies on the Opposition Benches talking about the great time we had before this Government came into power. They say that there was prosperity in the country in 1929, 1930 and 1931. In one part of their election programme—I do not know whether it is permissible to mention their election programme or not, but I shall only advert to it for a moment—they propose to raise £3,000,000 as a recovery loan and lend it out at, I think, 3 per cent. That is a confession on the part of the Party opposite that the total damage done to the farmer is £3,000,000. Previously, we heard it estimated variously at from £100,000,000 up to £1,000,000,000. Now we find it is only £3,000,000, and they are going to lend this money to the farmers at 3 per cent., which is 2 per cent. less than the farmers can get money at the moment. That is one of the concessions they are going to give the farmers —£3,000,000 for all they have lost. They talk about the prosperity in 1930 and 1931. I should like Deputy Morrissey or some other Deputy to tell us about the prosperity of 1930-31 when the then Minister for Finance had to bring in a Supplementary Budget. What went wrong with his finances then? What went wrong with the machinery of State when his Estimates, introduced in March, proved so disastrous about October of that year that he had to come in here and look for another half million pounds? He had to increase the income-tax and put on a petrol tax in the middle of the financial year. It is an unheard of thing to have a Supplementary Budget in any country. The reason for that course was that there was no prosperity at the time. That was due to the fact that the economic policy of the Government at that time was a wrong policy. The taxes were not yielding the income the Minister estimated in March. We want no further proof than that. That is why this Party are the Government of the country and that is why Fine Gael are in the position they are now in—a position in which they will remain until they reverse their policy. We had not all the prosperity they try to lead the country to believe we had in those years. We all remember that very well and we know what these people were during those years. There is no use in reverting back to that now. If proof were needed, every one of us can produce proof of the economic conditions that existed at that time. It was mainly because of those economic conditions that this Party was put into office as a Government and the Party opposite was thrown into the wilderness and outer darkness. That happened mainly for the reason I have stated. I think the Opposition will want to change their policy and their programme before the people of this country will give them any support in the future. Deputy Dillon was wailing here to-day about the condition of the country. I believe myself that every single word of his speech was deliberately meant to injure this country. He could have spoken as he did for no other purpose except to injure the country in every possible way. That is what the speaker meant to do. It is time he stopped that. Deputy Dillon ought to know that no sensible person in the country takes any interest in what he says. It would be much better for the Deputy's Party and for the Deputy himself if he talked less than he does. I would like again to congratulate the Minister and to assure him that the general opinion in the country is that his Budget is a sound one.

Comment on this

I am not going to indulge in any wailings about the state of the country, and neither do I intend to introduce any matters that would be more appropriate to the Vote for Industry and Commerce which will come up for discussion at a later date. I want first to say, by way of preface to what I intend to be a very short speech, that I cannot understand the mentality of persons such as Deputy Allen, who has just spoken, and stated very deliberately that Deputy Dillon's comments on this Budget were deliberately framed to injure the country and the credit of this country. I know Deputy Allen is a Deputy of very fine and decent feelings and I feel sure he does not intend to convey that the only meaning he can read into these remarks of Deputy Dillon was that the Deputy had set out to injure the country. This is either a deliberative Assembly or it is not. This country can be ruled by either of two methods —by constitutional methods or by force of arms. If you stop up the safety valve of constitutional agitation and discussion in a legislative assembly, then your next step is dictatorship or the rule of the gun. The latter two are, to me, very distasteful and I will never be found advocating either of these two methods. I am sure that neither would Deputy Allen.

I listened very carefully yesterday to the whole of the Minister's speech introducing the Budget. Amongst other faults that I found with the speech was where he intentionally kept the whole House waiting for considerably over two hours before letting us know exactly what the proposals in his Budget were. To me, it appeared a good electioneering speech—nothing more or less. Apart from his methods of delivery which, in my view, were conceived more to irritate the Opposition than to do any good for the country as a whole, there is in one portion of the Minister's statement, page 42 of the typescript, this peculiar passage:—

"Yet the condition of the people has been improving steadily; so that to-day they are much better off than during the five years which preceded the advent of the present Government."

Now that is a statement which I think should be carefully examined not alone by Deputies of this House but by every thinking person in the community, by every thinking person whose vote sends a Deputy to this House. The evidences of prosperity given by the Minister are not, in my view, in any way convincing. He may, of course, convince a number of persons in the country that there is increased prosperity. But these persons are, in the main, people who have some capital invested in the highly-tariffed new industries. Undoubtedly, there has been an increase in the sales of high-priced motor-cars. If that is taken as an indication of prosperity one must go further into that phase of the prosperity or alleged prosperity of which the Minister speaks, and examine it. Who are the persons who are purchasing those cars? Who are the persons who by the way are purchasing what might be termed other luxury commodities? It will be found that the general mass of the people do not share that prosperity of which the Minister speaks.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy mention some of the luxury commodities he has in mind?

Comment on this

Motor-cars.

Comment on this

What are the other luxury commodities?

Comment on this

The Minister will tell us all about that when replying. When I am finished the Minister can speak. The Minister has got away with it all through this debate, but I am not going to give way to him now.

Comment on this

I do not want to see the position misrepresented. I want Deputy Anthony to tell me what are the other luxury commodities about which he speaks.

Comment on this

The evidences of prosperity given by the Minister in his Budget statement are not, to my mind, convincing. They are convincing, perhaps, to certain elements in the community, but not to 75 per cent. of the community. They are convincing to the 25 per cent. of the community who are getting rich at the expense of the other 75 per cent. In other words, the poor are getting gradually poorer and the rich are getting gradually richer. That 25 per cent. of people with money and interests in tariffed industries are certainly getting richer. I ask the Minister for evidence of prosperity. Are we to take as evidence of prosperity, the butter or bacon or the other commodities used in the homes of the working-class people? Are we to take it, for instance, that the numbers of strikes and other labour disturbances in the country are evidence of prosperity? To me, and to every thinking student, or to any person who gives the matter any thought, the high prices of those commodities used on the tables of the working-class people, and the efforts of the working-class people to get level with soaring prices, are not evidences of prosperity. These prices are rising day by day in the case of the commodities I have mentioned.

All commodities used in the household have risen. Yet we are told by the Minister that people are better off now than they were during the ten years or the five years which preceded the advent to power of the present Government. That statement of the Minister's is a statement I challenge, and it is a statement that will be challenged by any housewife. If the Minister moves around among the working classes, or even amongst the middle-class people, or if he asks any housewife what she thinks of the prosperity of which he speaks, he will know the true position in the country. The housewife cannot balance her budget in the legerdemain way in which the Minister has balanced his.

The Minister's Budget reminds me of the case of a man who, on Monday morning, had 20/- in his pocket. Of that 20/-, 19/- was extracted by a thief, and the man finds himself poorer by 19/- on Tuesday morning than he was on Monday morning. On the following Wednesday or Thursday the thief restores 2/- of the stolen money. The person from whom it was stolen is by then certainly 2/- better off than he was on Tuesday morning. That is the process of legerdemain in which the Minister has indulged in framing his Budget. If there is one citizen in the country who can give the Minister a better explanation of his Budget, it is the ordinary housewife in this country. When the housewife goes in to purchase flour, bacon, butter, eggs, fowl, or any of the other things that we can purchase in this country, she will find that she will want not only a supplementary budget like the one of which Deputy Allen spoke, but she will need several supplementary budgets from the person who provides for that working-class home.

I have to ask the Minister: does he consider it evidence of prosperity to find in the City of Dublin and to find in the City of Cork—for which I can speak with more authority than for Dublin—and not alone in those two big cities, but in every portion of the country, strikes taking place every day? I ask him again is it because of pure cussedness on the part of the working people that they are going on strike? Is it for the fun of walking the streets of Dublin, Cork, Limerick or Waterford that they are going on strike? Is it not rather that economic circumstances are forcing them to look for higher wages? Do they not need higher wages in order to meet the increased cost of living? My view is that it is not for pure cussedness that these men are on strike. It is because, as I have just indicated, that owing to the policy of the Government, various commodities have gone up in price until they are now almost outside the reach of ordinary people to buy. I am speaking now for fully 75 per cent. of our people.

We heard figures given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and with them he apparently intended to prove that there were never so many persons in employment and never so small a number of persons unemployed in this country as now. The evidence of my eyes alone shows me that in Cork City there are queues upon queues of men lining up every day at the labour exchanges and thousands of men walking the streets unemployed. I have never seen so many persons walking the streets of Cork City unemployed and depending for a meagre existence, if one can call it such, on the money paid by way of relief schemes and through unemployment assistance. The Minister must be aware that numbers of persons are applying daily in Dublin as well as in Cork for home assistance. They find that unemployment assistance does not suffice to buy even the necessaries of life.

The Minister claims that in certain avenues of industrial activity the people's status as a whole has been improved. What I have said ought to convince the Minister, if he can be convinced at all, that in that connection he is sadly mistaken. Five or six years ago we were better off than we are to-day. Deputy Allen spoke of promises set out in some election literature distributed by the Fine Gael organisation, and he said that these promises could not be fulfilled. How could he be so shamefaced as to forget the famous Fianna Fáil plan? The last people in this House who should talk about promises are the members of the Fianna Fáil Government. Being slightly optimistic after reading that famous plan, I almost got weak sight watching out for the ships that were going to bring the emigrants back to Ireland, going to bring back those who were leaving the Western States of America and the bigger cities, such as New York and Boston, in order to be absorbed into employment here, in addition to the number of people who would be ordinarily employed before their arrival. We were told that all of them, including, no doubt, the 93,000, would be absorbed into employment. Therefore, I think the less said by anybody on the Government Benches about promises and plans, the better.

I have seen no general evidence of prosperity. I will admit that here and there we can see increased activity; it is in patches, but there is no such thing as a general revival in trade. There never can be such a revival until there are further developments of the pacts that have taken place recently between this country and Great Britain. Any apparent prosperity that there may be has been brought about as the result of these pacts. I submit that it is because of these pacts that the apparent prosperity exists. How much better would it be if the Minister came to the House and said that he was in favour of dropping our piecemeal pacts and had now decided to arrange with our neighbours for a full and complete settlement of the trouble that has landed this country where it is to-day. I commend that suggestion to the Minister.

If he does come back to office, which I very gravely doubt, and I humbly say God forfend, because I do not think the country will be able to last another five years with that kind of Government—indeed, I can see the crash coming—but if he does come back, I hope he will take to heart that advice coming from Cork, to be a whole-hogger in making a decent, honourable and lasting settlement, and then he can with justification say to the House that he has been enabled to produce a Budget which could not be done by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1937.

Comment on this

I would like to say a few words about this Budget. I did not take the Minister seriously in his Budget statement, not as seriously as some other Deputies seemed to take him, for the reason that to me the Minister did not appear to take himself seriously. He was simply smiling as if he were aware he was humbugging the House with the fine face he was putting on a very bad job. He has got the country into a ruinous state and he made a great attempt to prove that it was the other way about. He cited many instances, such as the prosperity of the banks. The banks are, of course, prosperous. They do not throw away their money just because there happen to be a few bad years. But if the farmer went to these banks to look for a loan, I know the kind of reception he would get. They will advance no money to the farmers at the present time. If there is a great deal of money being spent on cigarettes and motor cars and such things, it is because, as Deputy Anthony has said, some 20 or 25 per cent., or perhaps less, of the people are profiteering and, therefore, they can afford to spend money on luxuries. That is what is happening, and the more extravagant they are the shorter will be the period until the crash comes, and the greater will be the crash when it does come.

The Minister does not seem to know how the country people are living. I doubt if any of the occupants of the Government Front Bench understand the position. They go by some signs of prosperity on the part of the banks and the profiteers. I do not say that the bankers are profiteering, but they are careful men and they are sure to take care of their institutions. There would not be so much money lodged in the banks if they were lending the same as they used to lend to the farmers. They are not advancing money to the farmers. The money, therefore, is lying there. It has always been a sign of bad times when money is left lying in the banks. When the farmers and people who have been working on the land are flying away from the land as fast as they can, I wonder will the bankers and the profiteers keep the State going? Where is the money coming from? It can only come out of the pockets of the poor people. It is they who will have to supply all this Government expenditure and all the means of maintaining this apparent prosperity of which the Minister boasts. That cannot go on for all time.

The Minister referred to the credit of the State and the instance he gave us was the small yield on investments, on Government loans and things of that kind. I agree with the Minister in regard to that matter, but financiers are very cute men. They know that the present orgy of expenditure will not go on for ever. They know that Fianna Fáil will not be in office for ever, and they know that when they go there is a chance that they will become a decent Opposition and that there is not one chance in a thousand they will revert to the gun and that they will try again to upset the State. They know that once that Party has started to advance in a certain direction, they will be inclined to move further in the same direction. I wish to congratulate the Minister on the fact that his Party are moving along that road. It gave confidence to the people, even though the country is suffering, and the result is that everybody has more confidence to-day than when the country was prosperous. That explains why Government funds are higher in price now than they were some years ago. The people did not know what was going to happen some years ago when the Minister and his colleagues were out to upset the State. Everybody is looking forward to a change in that direction. Everybody feels that the country is going to settle down, that the country will learn from the mistakes that have been made for the last few years and that they will change things in future. Unless there is a change, the prospect looks very black for the country.

The Minister credits as assets to the State what he has taken from the farmers. He is taking away certain liabilities from the State and he has transferred them to the farmers. They are being collected in the shape of penal tariffs on the produce of the unfortunate farmers of the State. These moneys the State always formerly paid, and should always pay, unless the Minister made some arrangement that nobody should have to pay them. He should have come to the aid of the farmers seeing that they have been compelled to pay this money which was a liability of the State. How can he credit that as an asset to the State? To make the matter more glaring, the Coal-Cattle Pact, the Horse-Sugar Pact, and all these other pacts, simply mean that the Government has agreed with the British Government to collect the annuities from the farmers. By what right does the Minister seek to collect any part of these annuities, which the British have already collected from the farmers twice over? That item helps to swell his Budget, too.

I should like if the Minister would tell us what moral right he has to collect that money and how he claims any credit for that as an asset to revenue. That £2,000,000 was simply filched from the farmers. They paid this sum twice over in British tariffs, and then because the money that is collected by our Government is spent in one way or another and because other people are spending it on luxuries, the Minister holds up that fact as a proof that the country is prosperous. The sort of prosperity that is being shown in the country to-day is a prosperity that will bring about the ruin and downfall of the State if it is not changed. The sooner the Minister realises that the better. The sooner he brings an end to the economic war the better for the State and for the Government. Every year that this economic war continues will cost the country dearly. It will take seven years at least to repair the damage of one year. Farms have been left derelict and all our good cattle have been sold. There is nothing left only trash, because the people had to live and they had to sell every good beast they possessed because they could not find sale for the poorer animals. Even this year they could not sell anything except the pick of the cattle, and in a few years they will have nothing left to sell.

I need hardly refer to the cost of living, because it has been dealt with extensively already. I happen to live convenient to the Border and I could give the Minister very enlightening figures if I wanted to go into them. It is sufficient to tell him that the only industry that we have along the Border is the smuggling industry. It was never thriving so well as at the present time. In face of that fact, how can anybody get up and say that the cost of living is no higher here than elsewhere and that we are getting as high a price for our produce as farmers are getting elsewhere? If these were the facts the smuggling would be all the other way. Everybody is smuggling out what they have to sell, and smuggling in what they have to buy. What does that prove? Would these people take the risk attached to smuggling if they did not stand to gain substantially? The Minister knows the risk that is attached to smuggling. He knows that people will not take the risk unless they hope to have some gain and the gain must be very substantial when they are prepared to take such a serious risk. That, of course, proves the truth of the arguments put up in this House from these benches. Necessaries of life, clothing and everything else, are being smuggled in over the Border. Why should they not be smuggled in if the people have not sufficient money to pay the prices which are charged in the Twenty-Six Counties? It is not right to expect that they should go naked.

The Minister also helped to increase his Budget by going back as far as the year 1914 to collect arrears of income-tax. A sum of £1,200,000 was collected in arrears away back to 1914. That was given as proof of the prosperity of the State, owing to Fianna Fáil policy. Did Fianna Fáil do anything for the State away back in 1914? If £1,200,000 has been collected for arrears of income-tax due away back in those years, what right has Fianna Fáil to claim credit for that or to claim that they have a surplus because of that? The Minister cannot count on that £1,200,000 as an annual revenue to the State. In preparing his Budget he should take these things into account. Money has been raised in many ways, but the sources from which this money is being extracted are being dried up and they will not be available in future.

The Minister also claimed that he could borrow for bounties. That question is arguable. He might be able to borrow on certain conditions. If the economic war were going to be a temporary matter, he would be entitled to borrow. If, on the other hand, it is to be permanent, how can the Minister continue borrowing? How can the State continue to borrow year after year for something which is regarded as normal revenue? Supposing Fianna Fáil are to remain in office. I would like if the Minister would tell us what their policy is in regard to the economic war. Do they propose ever to settle it? If they do not propose to settle it, what right has he to say that they are entitled to borrow in order to pay bounties to offset to some extent the losses which the people are suffering through penal tariffs? It is apparent that there is no justification for borrowing if the economic war is going to be a permanent feature. The Minister might at least tell us what their plan would be with regard to the economic war if they were again returned, which is not at all likely. If the economic war is to continue, perhaps he will tell us how he would be justified in borrowing money for those bounties.

The Minister put the best face possible on his Budget, but when examined and analysed it will be found that there are many weak points in it. The country knows the position. The country is in a bad plight. Some people are doing well, but I do not think it is anything to take pride out of that some people are prosperous and spending money on luxuries. It would be much better if the people in some parts of the country had the necessaries of life and were not starving. It would be better if the people of West Cork, and, indeed, the people of West Cavan, had the necessaries of life, and had the necessary food for their children. That would be much better than having extravagant spending going on. It is nothing to boast of that certain financiers and certain profiteers are prosperous. That is no sign of general prosperity in the country. Those people will not keep the nation going if the people on the land are driven off. The people on the land are flying away in their thousands—away to Scotland, England and even to Northern Ireland, and the Minister is aware of it. The movement of the people shows where prosperity lies. The people of this country do not hate their own country. They do not fly from it because they dislike it, but in order to escape poverty and depression.

The people on the land see no hope. There is no hope, except one—that this economic war will end. Personally, I do not mind much who ends it. If the Fianna Fáil Government ended it before the election, I would not mind which Party was returned. But they have no intention of doing so. They never gave any indication of having any good intention with regard to this economic war. The country cannot prosper until that war is settled. Neither wheat nor beet is any substitute for mixed farming. We have been told about the promises given by the Fine Gael Party. I should like to congratulate the Fianna Fáil Party upon showing at least some responsibility. There was a time when they showed very little responsibility; it is a good thing to see that they are developing some kind of conscience, and do not like to see wild promises made.

Comment on this

They like to forget them.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party made no promises which they are not able to carry out. They have examined their programme carefully, and they will be able to give effect to it. Money will be spent in the right direction, and in the way which will give the greatest benefit. Money which is being wasted now will be saved; there will be less expenditure because there will be no foolish expenditure. When the Fine Gael Party comes back, they will not have to be challenged about their promises, because they will carry them out. They will not stand up and tell the people on the other side of the House that these promises were only statements. I hope that the Minister, when he goes to the country this time, will make no election "statements," but will regard his promises as binding.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his Budget speech yesterday referred to the tax remissions granted last year, and claimed that the total revenue is explainable only on the basis of a general increase in prosperity. He said:—

"This view is strengthened by the fact that in general the returns from the duties and taxes greatly surpassed our expectations. Thus, tobacco duties gave £4,422,000 against an estimate of £4,240,000; the beer duties produced £3,219,000, the highest for a number of years."

Mind you, I do not take that as a sign of prosperity, because I always heard that when people are in trouble they smoke more, and as a rule they take an extra drink. I think the Minister might look at it from that point of view —that that is exactly what is taking place in the country. I am sure the Minister will not deny that, because we have been listening to it for years. I should like to invite the Minister to any fair in the country to discuss the question of the prosperity of the people of this country. I should like to know, from him if he would go down to any fair in the country and tell the farmers there that they are more prosperous to-day than they were five years ago.

I quoted here the other night the case of a farmer who came into my shop in Cork within the past three weeks to cash a cheque for £4 10s. I asked him what the cheque was for. He said it was a Government cheque, and was a free grant for draining an acre of ground. I met the chap's mother afterwards. They have two mountain farms, and I asked her how many cows they had. She said they had 20 cows between the two places, 11 on one and nine on the other; in addition they kept dry cattle and sheep. Is not that an instance of Government policy, that they send down their inspector and allow those people £4 10s. of a free grant, while as a result of the economic war they are robbing those unfortunate people of £4 5s. on every beast over two or three years old that they sell? A great many people really do not seem to realise what is happening; others do recognise it. This chap seemed to be delighted because he got a grant of £4 10s., but when I drew his attention to the fact that he was losing £4 5s. on every beast over two or three years old he began to think.

Comment on this

How many beasts over two or three years old would he sell?

Comment on this

If you will set up the commission which I have been asking you to set up during the past two or three years I will get you that information on oath. I am sure the Minister would agree that that would be more accurate than anything I could tell him here?

Comment on this

Yes; certainly.

Comment on this

I would say at least ten beasts.

Comment on this

How many beasts did the Deputy say they had on that farm?

Comment on this

Eleven cows on one farm, and nine on the other.

Comment on this

And ten were over three years old.

Comment on this

They might be over ten years old.

Comment on this

All right.

Comment on this

In any case they had 20 cows. If you wish, their ages might be anything from three to 20 years.

Comment on this

And they lost £4 10s. on the 22-year old beast.

Comment on this

The Minister misunderstands me.

Comment on this

That is a joke. You misunderstand him.

Comment on this

I will get him to understand me before I am finished. Those people who had 20 cows would rear at least ten to 15 cattle every year, and as the years went by they would probably have from ten to 15 cattle for sale each year. As a result of Government policy, those people will be losing £4 5s. on each of those cattle. Does the Minister understand that?

Comment on this

I am always willing to learn.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The debate should be carried on in the third person.

Comment on this

I was making my speech and the Minister interrupted me. Is the Minister satisfied now with my information?

Comment on this

I think I have got enough out of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Talking about the prosperity of the farmers, on Tuesday last I met a farmer who lives four or five miles from my place. He voted Fianna Fáil at the last election.

Comment on this

We heard about that fellow before.

Comment on this

He will not vote for your Party at the next election. This man happened to be at a funeral after the last general election. He met a few friends, and after they had a few toshiní he got soft and made an open confession! He said to a friend of mine: “I voted against you at the election.” My friend said to him: “Take care, Jerry, that it was not against yourself you voted.” I met poor Jerry in Macroom and I said to him: “Jerry, did such a thing happen?”“Yes,” he said, “and I have lost at least £100 over it.” If the Minister doubts my words I can give him the man's name, and have him examined before that commission that I have been asking the Minister for the last two or three years to set up to inquire into the conditions of farmers in the Gaeltacht.

With regard to the cost of living, the cry everywhere is that people cannot carry on. Everything going into their homes is taxed to the very limit. At the general elections in 1932 and 1933 the allowances paid to Ministers was one of the planks in the Government programme. Now the Ministers have come to this House and have asked it to set up a commission to investigate the allowances which are payable to themselves. At one time they considered that £500 a year was more than anyone in this country was worth, but the Ministers themselves have £1,000 a year, free of income tax, plus other concessions. But now they are looking for £1,700 a year. I am not going to discuss the justice or the injustice of that, but what I do want to say is that when politicians go before the people they ought to be honest with them. When they make promises to the people they should fulfil them.

The Party opposite talked a lot about the 1/- that was taken off the old age pensioners by Mr. Blythe, but, as has already been explained in this House, the increase in the cost of living that has come about since the present Government came into office has meant a greater loss to the old age pensioners than the 1/- that Mr. Blythe took off. We have had the experience of the poor people of this country getting free beef. That is now being taken from them in order to find the money to pay Ministers increased allowances. Deputy Hales spoke on the question of wheat growing. I am one of those who believe in mixed farming. Deputy Hales made it clear that he was growing wheat, but said that he could not continue to grow 21 acres of it. Those who have had experience of wheat growing know that the land will not stand the growing of wheat unless it is properly manured.

Comment on this

My point was that if every farmer with 100 acres grew four acres of wheat it would fill the quota.

Comment on this

What Deputy Hales said on that has been misrepresented by Deputies on the opposite side just as Deputy O'Leary is misrepresenting it now.

Comment on this

I do not want to misrepresent anything in this House.

Comment on this

The Deputy has misrepresented the question with regard to Ministers' salaries.

Comment on this

The Party opposite have not been honest with the people, and that is what is going to put them out of office. Deputy Hales said that he was growing twenty-one acres of wheat but could not continue to grow it. No farmer could continue to do so unless he was in a position to manure the land. That is the argument that has always been put up from this side of the House. The present Minister for Agriculture used that argument when he sat on these benches. He said that you wanted the cattle to consume the surplus grain. What is the position now with regard to the grain market which the Government, with a great flourish of trumpets, set out to create? It is this, that the Minister for Agriculture has to admit that they are not in a position to supply the British market which they said was gone, and gone for ever. Is it any wonder, in view of the fact that for three years the Government put into effect the policy of slaughtering calves. In the last three years they gave a bounty on 500,000 calf skins. If those calves had been reared in the usual way they would be three-year old cattle now, and would be worth at least £15 each. What a loss the slaughter of those calves has been to the people of this State!

The Party opposite deceived the people at the last general election. They told them that the British market was gone and gone for ever, and that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was depending on one market. The Government Party have now to admit in this House that the British market is the one and only market that offers any hope to the farmers of this country. A gentleman who has retired from politics and found a comfortable job for himself as the result of his political activities said on one occasion that it took 100 years to build up the cattle industry in this country but that it would not take 100 years to destroy it. Now the Minister says that the cattle industry must be preserved in this country. But there is a sum of £80,000 provided in the Estimates this year for the bounty on calf-skins. I suggested to the Minister for Agriculture that he should withdraw that bounty so as to discourage the people from killing calves, and I think that is a reasonable demand. At one time we used to be described as the dumb-driven donkeys on the back benches of Cumann na nGaedheal. If there are no dumb-driven donkeys on the back benches of Fianna Fáil to-night it is because there is nobody on these benches. During the election in 1933 the Government said that if they got a majority over all Parties they would settle the economic war. The President stated in Galway during the election: "Give us a majority and we will make a good settlement." Will the President come into the House to-night and tell the people what he has done to bring about that settlement? He was on a visit to Great Britain some time ago and met a British Minister there. Did he tell the people of this country what happened at that conference? No, he did not. The only thing we found out was that there was a concession of £50,000 given with regard to horses. But until it was found out, the President did not tell the people that the British Government were going to take that £50,000 from the poorer people here out of the butter and eggs which they send to Great Britain.

At one time, when there was much talk of secret agreements, I asked the President who was responsible for the Coal-Cattle Pact and who signed it. He said nobody signed it. Fancy the President of this State standing over an agreement which nobody signed. I ask him now, who was responsible for this settlement? Will he take the responsibility for it? As has been stated by Deputy Cosgrave, when our people went across to make a settlement they stood over and took the responsibility for it and did not throw the responsibility on anybody else. That is an old game of the President's. He sent over people to negotiate an agreement and when they came back he turned round and charged them with being traitors to this country. But to-day the Minister for Finance and others quote those people, some of whose lives they have been responsible for taking. I have talked so often on this question that probably I might be accused of taking up the time of the House. I again make the appeal which I have made for the last three or four years, an appeal which has been made from my own parish by supporters of the Government when they sent up a document to the Minister for Agriculture some time ago asking him to set up a commission. The only thing the Minister did in reply to that statement was to acknowledge it. I ask the Minister for Finance now to investigate the facts set out in that statement and in the correspondence sent by the parish priest of that parish to the Minister for Agriculture, and then he will be in a better position to judge of the conditions which they have brought on the farmers of this country.

Comment on this

To my mind, this Budget is a very bad Budget. We have heard it stated this evening by Ministers and Fianna Fáil back benchers that the country is more prosperous than it was five years ago. I beg to differ with that statement. I have as much experience from going through the country as any Minister or Deputy and, like other Deputies, I have letters coming to me daily asking: "What is going to happen to the farmers and the agricultural labourers?" We have been told by Fianna Fáil back-benchers that cattle are now selling at good prices, and that there is a big change in the country. Before the election in 1932 I happened to be in a country fair when supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party came before the people asking for their votes. In that fair stall-fed cattle were making 38/- per cwt. To-day, in County Wexford, the average price for stall-fed cattle is 32/-. At that time feeding stuffs could be bought much more cheaply than now. The people were able to get maize and other foreign feeding stuffs much cheaper. Now we are told that 32/- per cwt. is an economic price for stall-fed cattle. I tell them now what they told the people then. They told the people then that farmers were slaves to produce beef at 38/- a cwt. "Put Fianna Fáil into power," they said, "and we guarantee that we will provide markets where you will get 50/- per cwt., live weight, for your stall-fed cattle." That promise, like many other Fianna Fáil promises, has fallen to the ground.

Deputies are aware that County Wexford is a tillage county. I, myself, as a farmer have forgotten more about growing wheat than many of our Ministers will ever learn. I am not against the growing of wheat, but I am against people racking their land for two or three years. To grow wheat you must have rotation of crops. You must be prepared to follow the wheat crop with a green crop. You must go in for mixed farming and have cattle to eat these roots, and you must have a market for these cattle. If it were not for the policy of Fianna Fáil, two-year-old cattle would be £4 5s. per head more than they are to-day. Whether it is the fault of the Free State Government or the British Government, the tariff on cattle over two years old is £4 5s. When I asked the President to settle the economic war, he asked me did I want to surrender. Now he has surrendered. He made a coal-cattle pact with Great Britain, and made it much easier for them to collect the money in dispute. Before that we used to see on all our dead walls and the hoardings in our streets, "Burn everything British but British coal. No surrender."

They surrendered when they made a trade agreement. They then made it much easier for Great Britain to collect the money in dispute. Now we are told by Fianna Fáil that but for the Opposition the economic war would be settled long ago. That means that the British take advice from the Fine Gael Party. In 1933, we were told by Fianna Fáil that they started the economic war, and that if again returned to power they would make a settlement. They have been five years in power, but they have made no settlement. They made another trade agreement with Great Britain some time ago, the new Coal-Cattle Pact, and the British tariffs were taken off horses. We were glad of that, but we never expected that the poor, hard-working farmers here would be asked to pay other tariffs. The sooner the Government recognises the necessity of settling the economic war the better for themselves and for the country. It has been stated that the country is very prosperous. Farmers in the Fianna Fáil Party know as well as I do that it is not prosperous. When the farmers are not prosperous they are not in a position to pay a living wage to agricultural workers. If the staple industry in the country is not prosperous, the country cannot be prosperous. We would all like to see the new industries thriving, and to give them every assistance, but new industries cannot be built up in a bankrupt country. There has been a lot of talk about the new houses that have been built. We give them credit for that. But what is the use of putting tenants into these new houses at rack rents? Where is the wherewithal to come from to pay a rent of 2/4 a week for a house when agricultural labourers, in many cases, are only getting 9/-, or 10/- a week? When these people get the necessaries of life they would want houses free of rent.

This Budget is not giving any relief to the working man. To take 6d. a cwt. off foreign wheat is not going to make the poor man's loaf cheaper. We have been told by Fianna Fáil that Irish wheat is cheaper than foreign wheat. How is it that the 4lb. loaf is dearer here by 2d. than it is in Great Britain? The Government should see to it that the people of this country get a living in their own land. In connection with the new industries, we were told that when Fianna Fáil was returned to power the exiles would be brought home from England and America. Very rosy promises were made, but we know what is happening—that our people are still going to England. Why are they going? Is it because the country is prosperous? No, they are going because they cannot get a living in their own land. I ask the Government to give this country a chance. It is not necessary to be a lover of England to trade with England, or to be saying that if there is another round we will starve them out. When this country was at its best, and when our surplus produce was going to England, we could not send as much of our produce as would give London two breakfasts a week, not to talk of starving it out. During the debate it was stated from the Fianna Fáil Benches that the English farmers were badly off, and that the British Government had to give a subsidy of 5/- per cwt. on home-fed beef while the farmers wanted 10/- a cwt. If English farmers are badly off, then God help the poor Irish farmers, who have to foot the taxes on their produce in the shape of tariffs. The sooner the Minister for Finance realises that this country cannot stand the strain that is being imposed upon it the better it will be for all concerned. We are not better off than we were five years ago, but we are better off than we were two years ago, because we are getting better prices for our stock, although we are not getting the cost of production. Pigs seem to be making a fair price, but any man who feeds a small number of pigs and keeps a correct account of the cost, knows that there is no money to be made from pigs. Why? The cost of offals is too dear. When we milled our own offals we were told by Fianna Fáil that we would have cheap feeding. Offals are now much dearer. When replying, I hope the Minister will tell the people what he intends to do for them.

Comment on this

I want to say, on behalf of the Labour Party, that we are thankful for the reductions in taxation, so far as they affect food, but, at the same time, I say that the reductions have only touched the fringe of the ordinary man's household expenses on necessaries. Deputy Norton referred yesterday to the price of bread, coal, bacon, beef, mutton and necessaries of that kind, and I suggest to the Minister that very soon the Government will have to do something to enable the prices of these things to be reduced. The high cost of living is being felt all over the country by the working classes, and particularly by those who are unemployed or in receipt of unemployment assistance. After all, if the Government can pass legislation through this House to enable a certain price to be obtained for the produce of the farmers, I suggest that they can also do something to prevent middlemen from making profits at the expense of the working people. I wish to apply my remarks to that part of the Minister's Budget statement which deals with the growing liability of local authorities, and I want to say at the outset that I do not agree that the question should be dismissed so lightly. I am prepared to admit that a good deal of the liability that local authorities undertake to-day arises, as he said, from housing, but I suggest that there are other liabilities of local authorities which have been increased because of Government policy. In the course of his remarks the Minister stated that local authorities had increased liabilities in recent years by practically £9,000,000; to be correct £8,863,186.

Comment on this

Gross.

Comment on this

The Minister stated and, of course, he was correct in doing so, that the Government are contributing to the sinking fund and interest for a good deal of that sum. That is quite true, but he continued:

"Furthermore, the increase in net liability is not an increase in dead-weight debt. It is offset by the value of the rents which the local authorities derive from their house property. Even if these do not cover quite all the outgoings, there is a balance left after defraying the cost of repairs, insurance and management, which is available to reduce the amount that has to be found out of rates to meet the net charges on the loans. Capitalising the rents in question on a 35-year basis at 4 per cent., the increase since 1932 in dead-weight liability due to the Housing Acts is approximately £1,400,000."

I do not think the Minister knows the real position, but his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, does, and I think if he were in a position to examine the exact position as far as local authorities are concerned he would not have made a statement of that kind. I am prepared to admit that the Government have been pretty liberal as far as housing grants are concerned. Their contribution on the average house in an urban area would be about £11 a year, but the Minister is evidently not aware that a good many of the urban authorities, if not all, are making a contribution of from £3 to £5 per house per year. That is a pretty high impost on local authorities, especially on small local authorities.

Comment on this

They own the houses.

Comment on this

I admit that, but they are incurring a great liability, because, as his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, knows, local authorities are experiencing great difficulty in collecting rents from numbers of people who have been transferred from slum areas, because, in a great many of cases, the people who lived in slum areas up to the time the new houses were built were paying an average rent of 1/6 to 2/- a week. The average rent now in towns similar to some of the towns I am identified with is 4/- to 4/6 per week. A number of those people are unemployed, and they find it very difficult to get the difference between the rent they were paying and the rent they are now called upon to pay, so that, along with the fact that local authorities are making a contribution of £3 to £5 per house per year, they are also faced with arrears on these houses which are growing rapidly. That is a matter that is engaging the attention of, and causing a great deal of annoyance to, local authorities at present, and, while a contribution of £11 might be a small matter to the Government, a contribution of £5 per house in an urban area, where a penny in the £ would realise about £40 or £50, is a very serious matter.

The town of Wexford, with which I am identified, had a scheme of houses last year. They were good houses, built under good conditions and built as cheaply as they could be, and that one scheme alone, apart altogether from the schemes that went before it, is costing the Wexford Corporation 9d. in the £. That is a very serious matter for a local authority. It is all very well to juggle with millions here, but when a local authority has to put on an impost of 9d. in the £ in the rates for the year, the local ratepayers never think of looking up the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance to find out whether they were paying £10,000,000 or £1,400,000. I do not think, therefore, that the Minister was right in dismissing it so lightly.

Another impost on local authorities within the last year is the question of the provision of employment under the rotation schemes. That is also a very serious matter and one might say that the local authority is being, shall I say, intimidated so far as that is concerned. That may be a strong term to use, but I cannot think of any other for the moment. An intimation is sent down to a local authority that a certain amount of money is available for them provided they put up a certain amount. That is all very well. No local authority which has the interests of the unemployed at heart, and I suggest that every local authority is anxious to do all in its power to help the unemployed, can refuse a grant of that kind, even though the acceptance of it is certain to put a large impost upon the local ratepayers. Take the town of Wexford. Last year our commitments in this direction cost us 5d. in the £. That was for a loan over a period of five years. Quite recently we got an intimation from the Minister for Local Government that another amount of money would be available during the present year, and that for that we will have to raise a sum in the rates of this year. That sum that was mentioned is going to cost the Wexford ratepayers 7d. in the £, so that, between housing and our contribution to help to relieve unemployment, the town of Wexford will be saddled during the present year with a sum of 1/9 in the £.

That is not the end of the story. Wexford town, being over 7,000 in population, has also to contribute to the unemployment assistance fund, and might I say, in passing, that notwithstanding the fact that the Government have reduced that Vote by over £500,000, none of the contributing bodies has got any relief in that connection. The amount of money which Wexford has to contribute is 9d. in the £, and it really works out at 10d. in the £ because we have to pay that on the gross valuation of the borough. There are certain reliefs given by way of local taxation, so that a 9d. rate would not bring in the amount of money required by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It is, therefore, necessary to strike a rate of 10d. in the £ so that, for employment and housing, the amount paid by the Wexford ratepayers totals 2/7 in the £ and that only covers a period of one or two years. I suggest to the Minister that that is a rather high impost.

There are certain ratepayers, of course, able to meet a demand of that kind, but when one considers that every increase in rates is promptly passed on by the landlord to the tenant, I think the Minister will admit that it is something which the ordinary working man or ordinary person cannot meet. The amount received from local bodies all over the country last year as a contribution towards the unemployment assistance fund, according to statistics published, was £197,260 3s. 7d. I suggest that, in view of the new policy, that is the rotation policy, adopted by the Ministry, that also is a contribution towards the employment of these people on rotational schemes. I think that local authorities should get some consideration in so far as this rate for unemployment assistance is concerned, and I would ask the Minister to consider it. After all, if the fund is being relieved in consequence of the rotational scheme, and if, in order to relieve that fund, the local authorities have to pay a contribution over and above the 9d. rate, surely there should be some relief, and surely the local ratepayers should get the same relief in proportion as the Government gets through the medium of the unemployment assistance fund.

I listened to the Minister for Industry and Commerce this evening talking about unemployment, and I am prepared to admit that a number of men have been put into employment in consequence of the Government's policy, but I am not going to accept the figure he gives of 75,000 men having found employment within the last year or two. I should like to know where they have been put into employment, and I think we ought to have more particulars than the Minister was prepared to give this evening. I do not think anybody would swallow that story that 75,000 people had been put into work. It appears to be judged by the amount of contributions that have been paid into the unemployment insurance fund, but we all know that a large amount of that has been contributed to by men who have been on one day's, two days' or three day's work during the past couple of years.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy——

Comment on this

I may be wrong, but I am not misstating it deliberately.

Comment on this

I am anxious to put this to the Deputy for the purpose of securing any information he may have on the matter. I do not think there has been any person employed for one day.

Comment on this

Perhaps that was an exaggeration.

Comment on this

We will find out where the 75,000 came from.

Comment on this

That is what I am really anxious to know. I would be just as glad as the Government to know that that was the fact, but I do not know from what angle we can examine it to find out where they went. From the remarks of the Minister which led up to that statement, we were led to infer that he was calculating that figure on the amount of money paid into the unemployment insurance fund, and if that is so, it has been contributed to largely by people on relief works who are working only two days or three days a week, and I do not think that by any stretch of the imagination the Minister can put that forward as putting men into industry.

I have nothing else to say, but I would suggest to the Minister that he should not continue to ask large contributions from local authorities to finance the rotational scheme. I want to say this, on behalf of the last Government, that they gave grants freely without any contribution from local funds. I think it is only fair that that should be said. They did that repeatedly. I know that in the last few years of their existence they did not give any grants, but when they did give them, they gave them without putting a large liability upon the local ratepayers.

Comment on this

The difference between the two was this: £150,000 in 1931-32, and £1,500,000 this year.

Comment on this

There were other differences.

Comment on this

I admit all that, but, after all, the Minister, in his Budget statement of last year and other years, and members of his Ministry in the course of certain statements made by them, stated that they have set out to cure the unemployment situation. I think the local authorities are doing just as much as, if not more than, the Government itself to appease the unemployment situation, because the amount they are asked to contribute is out of all proportion to what they should be asked to contribute. The contribution of the Government is infinitesimal compared with the amount of money the local authorities have been called upon to put up. People may think that statement—that the amount of money is infinitesimal—a bit of an exaggeration, but I am speaking by comparison. After all, if you put 5d., 6d. or 7d., or, as in the case I have quoted, 1/- on the rates in one year to help the unemployed, I think that is rather a large impost. Nobody expected, when Fianna Fáil set out to cure unemployment, that local authorities would be asked to contribute an amount of that size.

Comment on this

Speaking in an impartial spirit, I should say that this must be a wonderfully great little country that is able to produce a revenue of well over £31,000,000. I think that is very creditable indeed. Of course, one must consider, at the same time, that expenditure is equal to, if not greater than, the revenue, and when you consider the resources of the country and the position of the people, it certainly displays a great spirit. Sometimes I wonder how it comes, judging, say, by the figures of the last election—I think 700,000 votes for Fianna Fáil and something like 560,000 for Fine Gael—those 500,000 people are so loyal that they carry out their civic duties to such an extent as to be, in a large measure, responsible for producing such a revenue. Considering that such taunts as "West Britons" and "traitors" and such terms have been hurled at these people, it is a great tribute to their civic spirit that the Minister for Finance has been in a position to realise such a revenue. I hope the Minister and the members of his Party will take note of that fact, and that any speeches they make in the future, especially during the approaching general election, will be tempered by the spirit of charity which we hope to see developed a little more within the ranks of that Party.

Comment on this

Other Parties should have it, too.

Comment on this

Of course, you people were the pioneers of it, and the older cock-birds amongst them were the worst. With regard to the position in general, I should always like to view a Budget in an open way. I am one of those who know what this country can do and what it cannot do. I am not one of those who ask the impossible, and I think the time has arrived when a limit should be put to what the people of this country are to be asked to subscribe. When one goes through the figures that make up this £31,000,000, one is almost surprised at the enormous amount the Minister has got during the past year by way of customs duties imposed on articles imported into this country. If my memory serves me right, the amount is almost one-third, or more, of the total revenue. That means that every article imported and used in this country carries with it an extra tax, and that, of itself, goes to increase the cost of living, goes to increase the expenses in running industries, and goes to increase the cost of the most necessary service at the moment which the Minister and his Government have in view, the provision of good housing accommodation for the people.

Dealing with the whole question of expenditure, I should like to say that this country is fast approaching the day when there will be very few people in the country who will not be dependent on the Government for their living, to a greater or lesser extent. That is an aspect of the situation that does not appeal to me. It is a position which is the very negation of the war-cry of the old Sinn Féin Party, "Ourselves alone." There is not much self-reliance when such a policy is allowed to develop as it has been developing during the last three or four years, and it is one which, unless it is arrested, will have a very bad influence upon the morale of the people. There is no doubt that there is a very large percentage of our people in that position, and that percentage is increasing every day in the week.

With regard to the statement of the Minister as to unemployment and the amount of money voted for unemployment assistance, housing, etc., I do not want to delay the House too long in dealing with that aspect of the Budget, but this I do say, that the Minister and the members of his Party claim that they have provided certain sums for the relief of unemployment, and they have undoubtedly provided large sums of money. They must, however, admit, as Deputy Corish has mentioned, that they have imposed a duty upon the local authorities to provide a very substantial sum for the purpose of contributing towards the relief of unemployment. Take, for instance, the £2,000,000 which the Minister has given for relief schemes. It would be interesting to know what percentage of that amount finds its way back into the coffers of the national Exchequer by the savings effected through the Unemployment Assistance Act. The Minister and the members of his Party make great play with the amount of money they give in respect of relief grants, but everybody knows that the conditions governing employment on these relief schemes are, firstly, that the persons in receipt of the largest sum by way of unemployment assistance have prior claim to work on these schemes. Now let me make myself clear on this matter. I do not want to put the Minister in a false position; if I am wrong I would be thankful if he would correct me, and if I am right I would like the Minister to admit it. Let us assume, for the purpose of argument, that when certain of these schemes down the country have been passed they are then proceeded with. Now, take one scheme of minor relief works. There are probably 50 men on that scheme, 30 of whom might possibly have been drawing 10/- or 11/- a week under the Unemployment Assistance Act. Now under the rotational system at present in vogue these men get three days' work a week which, at 4/- a day, would amount to 12/-. Of course, in an urban area the figures would be different from a rural area.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong in his figures.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance, let us say, pays out that 12/- a week, but he gets out of paying the 10/- or 11/- because of the fact that he is no longer paying benefit under the Unemployment Assistance Act. In addition to that saving, there is the amount of the stamps on a man's card, because if a man works only one day in the week his card has to be stamped. In that way the Minister actually gets increased revenue by way of the stamps plus the 25 per cent. contribution by the local authority. I understand these grants are conditional upon the local authority subscribing at least 25 per cent. of the money required to carry the scheme through. I think that in the initial stages of the minor relief schemes the amount which the local authority had to contribute was 50 per cent. This was subsequently reduced to 33? per cent., and now I understand the figure is down to 25 per cent. of the cost of carrying out the scheme. For that reason, it could be argued in a great many cases that the Minister is actually making a saving on these schemes, and the £1,500,000 or £2,000,000 which the Minister talks about spending on minor relief works is not the great Government contribution at all that the Minister makes it out to be, because of what has to be provided locally. There is a saving to the Minister under the Unemployment Assistance Act. That reinforces my argument that, instead of these men being given three days a week employment, they should be given a full week's work.

Comment on this

The Deputy's figures are all wrong.

Comment on this

Is the Minister denying that in an urban area where the wages are £2 8s. a week or 8/- a day he gets three days' work under the rotational system and all the man receives for the week is 24/-? Now, that man who gets the 24/- is a married man with a wife and perhaps four or five children, say, under the age of 16 years. Under the Unemployment Assistance Act such a man would receive, I understand, in an urban centre over 16/- a week.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

I am speaking of an urban centre like Dundalk where the population exceeds 7,000. In such areas he will get 1/- or 2/- per head for each child. The whole benefit added together will realise, according to the number in the family, from 20/- to 25/- a week.

Comment on this

Not in a small urban area.

Comment on this

I am speaking now of an area like Dundalk with a population of over 15,000. There are men in Dundalk who under the Unemployment Assistance Act are drawing from 16/- to 20/- a week. I am arguing that whereas the whole of the 25 per cent. contributed by the local authority comes out of the funds of the area, the moneys advanced by the Minister in some way find their way back to the Exchequer through the savings effected under the Unemployment Assistance Act and the stamps.

Comment on this

I am simply telling the Deputy that if he is basing his case on the figures he has given to the House now, his figures are hopelessly wrong and his case falls.

Comment on this

Let me now take the case of the rural areas. A man living outside an urban centre who has occasion to make application for relief, is entitled, if he has a family of three or four children, to something ranging from 11/- to 12/- a week. The Minister must admit that. But if that man gets employment for three days a week he will only draw 10/-.

Comment on this

I am telling the Deputy that no person receives relief at 10/- a week in a rural area. Under the rotational system such a man must get more than 14/- a week. That is more than three days' work.

Comment on this

Even so. Take the Minister's figure at 14/- a week, the Minister gets 10/- of this saved under the unemployment Assistance Act, and then there is the stamping of the man's card plus the 25 per cent. subscribed by the local authority.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

I am not going to argue that with the Minister now. I want to say this—that I do not want the members of the Executive Council and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party during the coming general election to go about the country telling the people what they have done to relieve unemployment. They have not done what they promised to do nor what they were supposed to do. I am one of those who is always ready to give credit where credit is due. I appreciate any good work done by the Government. I also realise the difficulties faced by those who set themselves out to find a solution for the problem of unemployment. I remember that during the last two general elections when the Minister and the members of his Party were telling the people that they could easily solve the problem of unemployment, getting up and telling the electors that no Government could solve it. I went so far as to say that it was not the duty of any Government to solve it, because where governments tried to solve unemployment they rather made it worse. All we hear about this £2,500,000 for unemployment does not make such a rosy picture as Fianna Fáil would make it out to be. The Government are imposing very big burdens on the local authority. They asked them at the initial stage of these schemes to subscribe 50 per cent., then 33 per cent. and now 25 per cent. of the cost of the schemes. Those offers of relief schemes have been hurled at members of public bodies in the hope that these local bodies would refuse these grants. That would give the Fianna Fáil Party good election propaganda. But that sort of thing is really nothing short of intimidation. Those public bodies always came to the rescue of the unemployed, independent of any action taken by this or any other Government. Are we to be told now that the local authorities are not doing their duty?

I am not now going into the question of housing or the points brought forward by Deputy Corish. It is a bit unpopular at present to criticise in any way the housing policy of the Government. I know this question is receiving the serious attention of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. Deputy Corish told us that the housing schemes are all right. In spite of that, I am afraid that during the next four or five years there is going to be a heavy load placed on the local authorities as a result of the tenants of those houses not paying their rents and not being in a position to pay them. I know that at the present time there is being intimidation used by the Ministers themselves who are trying to get the local authorities to let houses at a certain rent. Certain people would give away houses for nothing. Anything to get votes! I am not one of those who want to impose obligations on the workers in the hope of securing a few additional votes here and there. Where there is hardship to be borne, I am one of those who would spread that hardship or burden over as many shoulders as possible.

Now, as regards this question of the revenue of the country and the position of the country, I want to refer again to the fact that, notwithstanding all the boasting of the Fianna Fáil Government, from the President down, the last 12 months, in my opinion, have convinced the members of the Government that this country cannot carry on successfully unless we preserve a good trade relationship with our neighbour across the water. All the talk about the economic war being over and won is all moonshine. The fact of the matter is that the Government have had to come down from their high horse and make a settlement with the British Government. I do not say this is any tantalising way, and I am not out to belittle the efforts of the Government, but I do say that what the Government have done during the past year could equally have been done during previous years, and thereby save the enormous losses that have been imposed upon a very considerable section of our people.

I believe the President, the members of the Executive Council and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party have a terrible responsibility on their shoulders for the losses, the hardships and the miseries they have wantonly inflicted upon a very large section of our people. I am one of those men who believe that no hardship that can be avoided should be inflicted for the mere sake of inflicting it. Therefore, seeing, as the Government has now seen, that it is in the best interests of the people of this country that good trade relationship should exist between the Governments of the two countries, there is no reason why this Government and the English Government could not make a decent settlement of the whole position that has existed for the past four years.

If the Government have found it necessary to make the latest Coal-Cattle Pact, whereby the British have taken more cattle and we have taken more of their coal, and if they found it necessary to make an arrangement whereby the ‘British will allow our horses in free for certain other concessions, surely it should be possible to make an agreement that would cover everything? At the present time the position is somewhat Gilbertian: it is amusing if it were not so tragic. The position is somewhat akin to that existing during the Great War, when the British people themselves had to line up in queues to get a little sugar and other necessaries of life, while we in this country enjoyed everything to the full. The position seems to be reversed by reason of our Government's policy. Mr. Englishman can get a pound of prime Irish bacon or prime Irish butter at very reasonable prices, while Irish Paddy in his own country has to pay an excessive price, and if Irish butter is not there, he has to do without butter of any kind.

Under the agreement made by our Government with the British Government in regard to the filling of quotas of bacon and butter, we have to supply the British market with the best Irish bacon and the best Irish butter to the exclusion of our own fellow-countrymen. That cannot be denied. Everybody knows that some four or five weeks ago in certain towns in this State there was not a pound of Irish butter to be got. I am aware that in my neighbouring town of Newry, only ten or 12 miles away, a man could get plenty of pure Irish creamery at 11d. to 1/- a lb. whereas the people in the Free State, where the butter was manufactured, could not get it for 1/5 a lb.—indeed, could not get it for love or money.

If that is fighting the enemy, if a policy of that nature is fighting the enemy—as the saying goes, starving out John Bull—then it is the newest way of carrying on a war that I ever heard of. Yet, that is the position. I maintain it is a humiliating position, especially when one considers the record of the President. He never surrendered, we are told. As a matter of fact, he has been surrendering every year for the past four years. He and his Party have made surrender after surrender, and I am not blaming them. Greater men than they have had to compromise. I do not agree with the statement of the President when he says that compromise means surrender. It does not. I think the leader of the Labour Party will bear me out in that. For instance, there was never a strike yet settled without a compromise. The employers did not take up the attitude that the President has taken up. They never said: "If we compromise it means surrender." The Labour leaders have never said: "If we compromise it means surrender." Like wise men, they know that if they do not compromise it means that they are going to inflict untold hardships upon those whose interests they have been selected to safeguard. No matter what the Labour leader may say in public, when it comes to a question of safeguarding his fellowmen who have selected him to look after their interests, he always chooses the lesser of two evils and compromises without any serious loss of honour to himself or those whose interests he is looking after.

There is no use in the President saying that compromise means surrender. It does not. Already he has made agreements with the British Government and there is no reason why an agreement should not be arrived at in regard to cattle and all other agricultural produce that at the moment carries penal tariffs before entering the British market. We have carried on very well under such adverse circumstances and the fact that we have carried on so well is due, in my opinion, to the loyalty and co-operation, in the main, of those who are politically opposed to the present Government. That cannot be denied. Although many people are opposed politically to the Government, yet they have such a sense of civic spirit that, whilst they criticise the Government, they nevertheless are prepared to carry out their civic duties.

We have been told by men of the type of Deputy Corry that certain of us have advised the people not to pay and to endeavour to thwart the Government. That comes badly from any member of the Fianna Fáil Party. For years we have been sick listening to the propaganda carried on by Fianna Fáil when they were skulking outside the doors of this House. Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches, display a very poor taste in some of their statements when one considers the co-operation that the present Government are receiving from those in opposition. A tribute was paid to Opposition supporters by the Minister for Industry and Commerce about a month ago when he stated that were it not for the loyal co-operation received from those politically opposed to the Government, it would be impossible for the Government to carry out the industrial schemes that they have carried out during the last three years. The Minister's supporters would do well to ponder over that statement.

I say here and now that I am not one of those who would like to decry a Government that is in power. I am not one of those who go out on a platform and declare something terrible is going to happen this country. I know this country has great resources, that the people can suffer and have suffered in the past. They can endure much whenever a principle is at stake, but let it be an understandable principle. There is no principle at stake now. Seeing that the President has made so many agreements with the British, there is no reason why he should not make the one that will finish once and for all the existing outstanding differences between the two countries.

I should like, before I sit down, to refer to the question of bacon as it affects the people in the town adjacent to the Border. There is no doubt about the fact that at the present time that whole trade has gone away altogether. Were it not that the farmers in those areas are not absolutely at the mercy of the factories, were it not for the fact that there do exist, fortunately for the farmers there, people known as pig-buyers—a very decent class of people, who have got a very bad "hunt" for the past four or five years—were it not for those people going around to the farmers and buying their pigs and giving them fair value, I do not know what would happen. Where only the factory is concerned, the pigs go to the factory and the farmer is at the mercy of the factory. The farmer has nobody to look after his interests. His pigs can be graded, according to the advertised prices, as Grade A, Grade B, Grades C, D, E, and so on—the whole 26 letters in the alphabet, one might say —and there is nobody to see to the farmer's interests.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think the Minister for Finance is responsible for the factories.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, it is one of the things that come under the head of bounties and subsidies.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I see no bounty for bacon in it.

Comment on this

Well, Sir, I submit that it is ancillary to the question—incidental to it.

Comment on this

It is ancillary to eggs.

Comment on this

At any rate, the factories would not be much good if you had not the export trade. I think it is the duty of the Minister for Finance to do something to ease that situation. Now, with regard to the reliefs that have been given, we were all delighted, naturally, about the 4d. a lb. off tea, and about the duty off the farmers' butter. There again, however, one does not like to speak too plainly, but everybody knows that the greatest farce that ever was invented was the levy of 4d. a lb. on farmers' butter. What it amounted to was that the law-abiding people suffered. The man who wanted to obey the law suffered, but the clever fellow, who wanted to evade the law, managed to get over it. That is one of the greatest grievances I have against the present Government—that, having passed Acts of Parliament, they have not got the courage to enforce them. The decent man gets fleeced, and the other fellow gets away. The law-abiding person paid that 4d., and the other gentleman, who wanted to evade the law, managed to get over it, and it usually happened that when, once in a blue moon, the honest man tried to get away with that 4d., he was immediately pounced upon and taken to court.

It is a good thing, at any rate, that that was done away with, because it seems to indicate that the Government has gone back to the principle of self-reliance. What better industry can there be than the industry of the farmer working in his own home? What greater industry could you have than the farmer working in his own home? The Minister is very interested in having factories established all over the country, but the farmer who made his own butter was engaged in an industry, and every farmer's house was a factory in that sense. As I say, it is a good job that the Minister has taken that thing away, because it was one of the things that has imposed great hardship on people who were ever ready and willing to earn an honest living without Government assistance and, above all, without Government interference; and I am sure that the members of the Government themselves have realised that it was a good thing to remove that 4d. a lb.

Again, one might consider this Budget as a "wind-up" Budget. One may take it that the Government have been listening to the vox populi, as they say. The different Fianna Fáil clubs all over the country must have been sending in some letters, during the last three or four months, to the members of the Executive Council calling attention to the state of public opinion in the country and calling attention to the rising tide of public opinion against the high cost of living, and I am sure that the voice of the people, in that sense, has been ringing in the ears of the Ministers, day and night, during the last couple of months. There is no doubt about it, and I think that that has been, in the main, responsible for this policy. It has been due to the main Opposition in this House and to the speeches delivered by the members of the Opposition and, if I might say so, also to the speeches delivered by the members of the Labour Party up and down the country. That is what brought the Government down from their high horse and made them shell out a little of the loot that has been gathered from the people in the last four or five years. They remind me of the people in a ship with a mutinous crew: no matter what happens, they must be mindful of the loot, and to pacify the mutineers, they must give away some of the loot. So it is with the Government. They have now to give back to the people of this country a little of the loot they have taken from the people in the last three or four years. The cry of “Up the republic” has no effect to-day, and the cry of “Down with England” has no effect on the working classes in the last few years. You have had your innings, and we will get our turn now; and all I can say is that, undoubtedly, we will not rub it in to you as you have rubbed it in to us.

Comment on this

If Galway and Wexford are any indication, you will not be here to do so.

Comment on this

There is a change coming, and the Government has been wise in time in taking off the 4d. from tea, the ¼d. off sugar, and reducing the price of the butter to the people by 2d. In that way they will satisfy many of their supporters in the country and, possibly, reduce some of the cost of living. I would like to speak for quite a long time, as Deputy Anthony has said, about the question of strikes in this country—about the question of strikes and the cost of living and so forth. I should like to speak about it for a long time, but I hope that in the future, wiser counsels will prevail, and we hope that the Minister, should he be Minister for Finance in the next Government, will be in a position to state to the House that his revenue has gone up over £31,000,000 and that the people are in a position to make up that revenue, but again I say that, personally, I am rather apprehensive with regard to the growing number of people in this country who, at the moment, have to depend for a living on the Government. They are the biggest employers. If I wanted to go into the figures quoted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he spoke about the 75,000 people in employment, I think I could show that the Minister is the biggest employer himself. I think that about 25,000 are engaged in housing and relief schemes, and, although I am personally interested in house building, still I do not think it was ever looked upon as industrial employment in the ordinary sense of the word. I move to report progress.

Comment on this