Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Dara Céim.
Contributions 146–293 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I desire to second the motion moved by Deputy Mulcahy. I would like at the outset to say that I am not terribly concerned about this Constitution. There are matters that are much more urgent, much more important and of much more concern to the people of this country than the Draft of the Constitution that we have before us to-day. The President, in the course of his speech, which lasted about two and a half hours, told us what he would like to do and what he would like to have; but he did not make any reference to the condition of affairs which has been brought about as a result of his activities during the past five years. We listened to the President making for two and a half hours the most ineffective and unconvincing speech he ever delivered in this House. The President, of course, realises now what everybody in the country knows that the country is not interested in this Constitution. The people are not concerned with it. That was very obvious from the President's speech. The President was not ever able to hold the attention of the members of his own Party. They were continually slipping in and out and those who remained on the benches were half asleep or not interested in the debate.
Comment on this
Very well so. Deputy Tom Kelly had only his eyes closed. He was not asleep. The President was absolutely unconvincing and hesitant in his speech—a very unusual thing with the President. The only time he got into his stride was when he got back to the pious resolutions in the Constitution.
The President talked about his concern for the mothers of this country, about having conditions under which there would be no necessity for the mothers to go out and work. The President, through his policy, has been responsible for forcing more of the mothers to seek employment than ever before in the history of the country. The President, the man who told the people that he had a solution for the problem of unemployment, that he had plans that would put the fathers at work so that the mothers could stay at home and look after their homes; the man who, when he was told that no country in the world had completely succeeded in abolishing unemployment, said: "Oh, yes, but we have a solution such as no other country has," to-day tells us: "We have not succeeded; it is a difficult matter and no country has done it."
The President has given the greater part of his time for the last three, four or five years to the drafting of the document now before us. He spent his time drafting a document for which there was no demand, which the people did not ask for. Instead of carrying out his promises so to make this country as to put the people in a prosperous condition, so to make this country that at least our people could get enough to eat, the time that should be devoted to that is devoted by the President in his study framing this Constitution, and he continues with that work. The head of the State, notwithstanding the fact that we have over 100,000 persons unemployed, notwithstanding that the women, the young women that he blathers about here to-day, are going in their thousands and tens of thousands to seek a livelihood in other countries that they cannot get at home, writes his Constitution. He talks about the sanctity of the home, about keeping the mothers at home and building everything upon the family.
While the President writes his Constitution and talks about that, down in my own county the relieving officers are busily engaged writing something else. I am glad the President has come in. He talked a lot and was very concerned about the family life. While he was writing his Constitution the relieving officers in my county, as a matter of fact in Nenagh on last Saturday week, were writing dockets of admission to the county home at Thurles for Pat So-and-So and his wife and seven children, and John So-and-So with a wife and five children. I have these documents here. One of them is addressed to the matron of the county home, and it reads: "John —— is a person in the county eligible for relief. He is a labourer and cannot be effectively relieved at less cost to the rates otherwise than in the above-mentioned institution." Those two men, in common with others, on last Saturday week, at 9 o'clock at night, and 25 miles from the county homes were handed these documents for themselves and their wives and children. The President, whose administration has brought about that state of affairs, comes here and tells us about the sanctity of the home and the family.
Those cases could be multiplied all over the country and here in the City of Dublin. And we are expected to be concerned about a Constitution that nobody has asked for and that the President knows now, if he did not some time ago, the people are not concerned about. What has been the effect of the President's policy? Has it not forced more mothers than ever before to seek employment, to leave their homes to try in some way to get that existence that the lack of work for their husbands and their sons has denied them? The President tells us he is going to work until he sees carried out the pious resolutions that are enshrined in this Constitution. If the President is going to work for that, he will have to work in a direction totally different from that which he has followed during the past five years. The result of his policy has been not to reduce unemployment but to increase it.
The President talks about the inadequate strength of the women and children. I am afraid he knows very little about it. Their strength is adequate in many cases because they are undernourished and under-fed, because they are not getting enough to eat and because they cannot afford to be properly clad and properly shod. The President tells us that 99 per cent. of the women would agree with this Constitution if they read and understood it. Let me tell him that 99 per cent. of the women and children are more concerned with the price of flour than they are with this Constitution. That aspect presents a graver problem to them, and there is nothing in this Constitution that is going to give one loaf extra to any family in this country.
We are expected here, at the end of the lifetime of this Parliament and on the brink of a general election, to give our time to this Constitution, to take it seriously and give serious debate to it. Will the President at some future time—he did not in his two and a half hours' speech—tell this country what is in this Constitution that is going to reduce the number of unemployed below 100,000? Will he tell the House of what use is this Constitution to the 80,000 boys and girls who have been forced to emigrate to Great Britain within recent years? Is there anything in this Constitution to stop emigration or reduce unemployment? There is not, and the House and the President and the country know it. But it is much easier for the President and his Ministers to talk about Constitutions than it is to face up to hard facts, to questions of economics, to face up to the question of solving the unemployment problem. He told us that he had a solution for it that no other country in the world had. It is a good job for the workers in other countries that their rulers have not the same solution as the President. There is to-day in this country, notwithstanding the emigration, and many other things, more destitution than ever there was.
Comment on this
I am prepared to prove it. I have here the cases of two decent working men who got tickets for the county home, and I can bring more to the Deputy if he wants them. These men, with their wives and families, had to enter the county home. If that is not evidence of destitution, I do not know what is.
Comment on this
On a point of order, will the Deputy say how many of these tickets had to be distributed in Tipperary by reason of——
Comment on this
Would Deputy Morrissey tell us how many were rendered destitute when the red flag was hoisted over the burned factory and when he walked into the town of Roscrea?
Comment on this
Deputy Fogarty's friends and political associates in South Tipperary would give him much more information about the red flag in Tipperary and the burning of the creamery there than any member on this side of the House, and I will be more specific if the Deputy wants it.
Comment on this
I merely want to say that that statement is untrue. There is no necessity to go further. I invite the Deputy to repeat that statement outside the House, to use the exact words he has used here.
Comment on this
Can you deny that you walked in under the red flag into Roscrea town with your brother? Is not that so?
Comment on this
I invite Deputy Fogarty to go down to Tipperary and repeat there what he has stated in this House regarding the burning of the factory. I challenge him to do it outside this House. The Deputy will be silent now, and he will be silent outside also.
Comment on this
However, I wish to get back to the point on which I was. I want to find out from the President, before the debates on this Constitution are ended, why he has chosen to give his time to the drafting of this Constitution rather than to producing the solution for unemployment that he promised. Is he prepared to state to the House here whether there is anything in this Constitution to stop the flight of the people from this country? Is he prepared to state here and now if there is anything in this Constitution that is going to give employment to the people of this country who are looking for employment? Is the President prepared to prove to the House, if he can do it, that all his talk about the families and the mothers and the home is not mere empty humbug?—because, let me repeat it, and let me finish on this note, Sir, the President's policy and the policy of his Government has succeeded in driving more mothers from their homes to seek livelihoods for themselves and their children than ever happened in the history of this country before. Those are the facts, and these are the questions that the people of this country want to have answered; and all the President's blarney, and all his talk about the constitutional issues, and all his talk about calling this country "Eire" instead of Saorstát Eireann, is not going to alter the facts, and it is not going to fool the people this time.
The President has failed. The President and his Government have failed lamentably. Far from improving the conditions of the people of this country, they have driven the people to a state of destitution such as they never experienced before in living memory; but because the Government are now facing up to a general election, we have this Constitution, and we have the Constitution thrown at the people on the same day as the general election. It is just an attempt to get the people's minds away from the hard facts of the case; but let the President remember that on the day of the general election the people will be more concerned with what they have to eat than with what will be the form of the new President or the new Governor-General, or whatever he is going to be.
Comment on this
Sir, I wish to move the following motion standing in my name:
To delete all words after the word "That" and substitute the words "the Second Reading of Bunreacht na hEireann be deferred to a date not sooner than January 1st, 1938, so that a special Governmental Department be set up for the purpose of uniting and co-ordinating all the anti-Partition forces in Ireland, North and South, irrespective of political or religious outlook, organising the Irish race abroad for their assistance and support, focussing through the home and foreign Press world opinion on this grave national issue, and pressing the English Government to reopen negotiations on the reunification of Ireland, and so that, if and when a solution of the problem is found, Bunreacht na hEireann can be submitted to the whole people of Ireland for ratification or otherwise.
What prompted me to table that motion, Sir, was more or less what I read in the newspapers over the last month or more. Since the campaign for the general election opened a chorus has gone up in nearly every constituency and from every constituency, of Deputies vying with one another as to which of them would proclaim the loudest that the unity of Ireland is essential and must be striven for, and that the quicker the unity of Ireland is achieved the better. Not only have Deputies of all Parties said that, but some of them have even gone a little further and said that in the new Constitution there is the framework for a united Ireland.
There is also another very important factor in connection with this to which I should like to draw the attention of Deputies in this House, and that is that, speaking on the subject of Partition, in Monaghan, about ten or 12 days ago, Deputy Cosgrave, the Leader of the Opposition, having made what I thought was a very critical onslaught on the Government, said—these may not be exactly his words—"I grant that there is more unanimity on the subject of a united Ireland in this country than there is on any other subject before the country at the present day." Not only was it necessary for him to reiterate that in Monaghan, but in the very last Ard Fheis of Fine Gael the first item that appeared in their programme was that they regarded the reunion of Ireland as the predominant national issue, and that they regarded it as their paramount duty to prepare for it. That is the attitude of the Opposition towards the question of the unity of Ireland to-day.
The Labour Party have proclaimed that policy from their platforms also. They have proclaimed that the real crux in Ireland at the moment is the separation of the North from the South. Individually and collectively, I think the Labour Party have stood for that from 1905, and even from further back than that, and I do not believe that the members of the present Government Party ever have deviated one iota during the course of the politics of the past 16 years from the principle of a united Ireland. There are others in this country who do not hold the same political creed as we do, but who also believe in the unity of Ireland. There are people who have been termed Unionists— people who have been engaged in business and in the commercial life of this country—and these people have been holding meetings all over the country, too, and the burden of their speeches also is that, until Ireland is united, commercial and financial success will not and cannot be achieved. They hold that until there is one Government for all of Ireland real financial success cannot be achieved.
I believe that the unity of Ireland cannot be, and will not be, brought about by the efforts of any one political party in this country, and it is with the hope that the Government might take the initiative in co-ordinating all these forces, to which I have referred, and which have the unity of Ireland as their objective, that I have put down this motion. I believe that a Government in office in Southern Ireland, backed up by the unanimous support of every organisation that has claims to be national in Southern Ireland, even by other organisation that have an interest or a stake in this country, could, if that effort were made, and if the effort were made sincerely and honestly, achieve the unity we all desire.
I believe that, if we could achieve unity amongst all sections down here, it would be possible, in a short space of time, to get some effective results with regard to the unity of all Ireland. I believe, further, that, if one half of the energy that was expended in the years that are gone had been put into the idea of a united Ireland, we would be further on the road towards our ideal than we are at present.
I should like to say, however, that, unlike Deputy Morrissey, Deputy Mulcahy, and other Deputies, I do not wish to cavil at this Constitution at all. I realise quite well the hard work and the labour that must have been put into the production of a document of that kind, and I may say that, as a follower of President de Valera I bow my head to no Deputy in this House in loyalty to him; and I say that I do not think it is fair or right for any Deputy in this House, from whatever Party he may come, to characterise a document such as this as so much humbug and nonsense. I do not believe that that is right. I do say, too, that another characteristic of the fair-play which has been given Deputies in this House is the instruction that has been given by the President to the people of this country in the coming election, that the fate of the Government does not hang on the fate of the Constitution. "You can vote for Government candidates," the President said in Clare, "and you can vote against the Constitution if you like. Vice versa, you can vote for the Constitution and against the Government candidates if you like. The fate of the Government does not hang on the fate of this Constitution.”
I, too, believe and hold that a Constitution such as this should not be considered as Party document. After all, everybody has got to live under this Constitution and, if the day does come in the near future when we have an united Ireland, and when another 1,250,000 people are added to the population of this State, surely it is not an unreasonable request, or an unreasonable motion to put down, that some effort should be made and that some attention should be drawn to the fact that an effort might be made to secure some way by which they would have a voice in the Constitution under which they might be expected to live later on? I know it is impossible at the present moment. I know that the laws of this Parliament affect only the Twenty-Six Counties of Southern Ireland, but I know in addition that there is a minority in Northern Ireland of 500,000 people whose eyes are always yearningly looking to the day when their deliverance can take place.
Every time I have read a speech in which I have seen the sentence recurring that there must be no coercion of Ulster, my reply invariably has been that if there must be no coercion of Ulster, there should be no coercion by 700,000 people there of the substantial minority of 500,000 people. I should like Deputies to visualise this for themselves, and I do not think I am asking for anything unreasonable. If everyone in Southern Ireland were perfectly united on this question and if pressure were put upon the English to reopen negotiations, if in addition we had that demand backed by the minority in Northern Ireland, and if, as I have stated here in this motion, we had our people in America, England, Scotland and all over the globe supporting that demand, I am not so pessimistic as to think that the British would turn down that demand.
People may say that you cannot force the British to negotiate, but I remember one occasion, as does Deputy Cosgrave and many other Deputies who were connected with the old fight, when negotiations were about to be opened with the British and the reply came across the water that they would never sit down to negotiate with murder. They even went so far as to name three men with whom it was an impossibility for them to negotiate, the three men being Michael Collins, General Mulcahy and Cathal Brugha. That all vanished before the force of public opinion. That all vanished when the eyes of the world were concentrated on the question, mainly through the efforts of President de Valera in the United States and of other men who took it on themselves to speak for their homeland although they were domiciled in foreign countries. The British negotiated with the people to whom they objected, and they were glad afterwards that they negotiated with them. I hold—perhaps I may be wrong or over-optimistic—that the pressure of public opinion, forced home by a united Southern Ireland and backed up by the support of the people whom we are seeking to liberate, would enable us to obtain a satisfactory solution of this Northern problem. It is not the first time that this was mooted. It is a strange thing that one of the factors that weighed with me in putting down this motion was a book which I read a short time ago written by an eminent English journalist, Hugh Martin, with an introduction by another eminent English journalist, Sir Philip Gibbs. Away back in 1921 when things were pretty hot, this method of procedure was first suggested in that book. I quote from page 203 of the book, "Ireland in Insurrection," in which, speaking for the English people, he said:
"There is nothing for it on our side but to put our pride in our pocket and to say quite frankly and with as much grace as we can muster: ‘Ireland, my dear, you have proved your case; from henceforth you are free. Come now and let us reason together about the future.' And this will have to be said to Ireland as a whole, not to any artificial fraction of Ireland that we choose for our own purpose or from any mistaken sense of loyalty to the remaining fraction, to set up and call ‘Ireland.' Ireland is an island in the Atlantic Ocean inhabited by the Irish."
That was from an English author, and I am still, as I said, optimistic enough to believe that the English could be brought to negotiate on the question of the partition of this country. Many golden opportunities have been lost in connection with this matter, and I am putting this forward as a detailed resolution, not as a direct negative like that of Deputy MacDermot. If Deputy MacDermot's motion were carried here it would simply mean going back to where we were, with no alternative of any kind. To the same extent Deputy Mulcahy's motion was vitiated in a large measure by the speech delivered by Deputy Morrissey, who comes along with the comment on the measure: "This Constitution will not put a loaf on anybody's table." I should not like any Deputy to take up an attitude of that kind. A loaf could have been put on the table of the people of Ireland had they accepted certain things offered to them in the past. They did not accept them, and the loaf did not come off the table.
In looking up some old papers and Press cuttings recently, I saw where one great opportunity of reuniting the country was missed at the time of the Treaty. It was reaffirmed by President de Valera in 1923 in a letter to the Irish Independent, and upon the basis of that letter I would say that Ireland could successfully negotiate a settlement even now. It was an appeal for unity on the Ulster question, and I could have almost embodied that letter in my amendment to-day. As regards the Ulster question the President said:
"Our proposals were that the fullest measure of local autonomy, consistent with the unity of Ireland as a whole, should be granted to the aggregate of those areas in which, by a majority vote, the residents demanded a separate Parliament. We were prepared to take as the unit of area for the plebiscite either the constituencies prior to the Act for 1920 or any smaller unit such as the poor law guardian or the district council areas. By that proposal Derry City and the greater parts of the Counties Tyrone and Fermanagh as well as South Armagh and South Down would be represented directly in the National Parliament. On no plea could the ‘Ulster' minority demand anything more."
I am quoting from the letter written by the President, dated 20th July, 1923, and published in the Irish Independent. Surely to goodness there is nothing unreasonable about that. Two Partition Acts were passed for this country. One was a direct Act of Parliament passed in Britain in 1920 by Mr. Lloyd George, under which the country was split in two divisions. The other—I do not want to say this by way of recrimination, and I do not want to go back into any of the controversial subjects that we have debated over and over again— unfortunately took place in December, 1925, the time of the Ultimate Financial Agreement; the time, too, of the collapse of the Boundary Commission. We all remember what occurred then. That opportunity was missed, and many other opportunities were missed. I must say this, in referring to the quotation that I have given from President de Valera, that at that time when the Treaty was discussed and this was put in as an alternative it was misrepresented all over the country and never got the fair chance that it was entitled to have at that time.
Now we can do it. We are here in this Dáil as the bigger Party in the Dáil. We are here as the Government Party in the Dáil, with the resources of Southern Ireland at our command. We are here, and the people expect us to go ahead. Perhaps we are not going quickly enough. The people who returned us returned us under no delusions whatever; the ultimate objective, the final objective of the policy of Fianna Fáil was a republic for a united Ireland. My objection to this Constitution is that it seems to me, if I may say so with all respect, that we are putting the cart before the horse. The major issue in Ireland at the moment is to get our nation first and let the people of all Ireland draft a Constitution afterwards. This is not the first time that I mentioned this matter. In certain other places, unfortunately, I was not successful. I put up a resolution and made suggestions to certain people that an all-Ireland convention could be called together, on the initiative of the Government, consisting of—I was pretty generous in the representation. I do not think I left out any body or anything—all the organisations in Ireland that pretend to be national or pretend to have the welfare of this country at heart. We would have had them from Fine Gael, from Fianna Fáil, from Labour, North and South. I hope and trust that the words which I included in that motion, "irrespective of political or religious outlook," will be well taken into consideration. We would have had Labour, North and South; public boards, corporations, farmers unions, the Ports and Docks Boards of Dublin and Belfast, the corporations of Cork, Dublin, Waterford, Drogheda and Clonmel, professional and commercial interests, southern Unionists, the universities of Belfast, Dublin, Cork and Galway. I think that that would have been a pretty representative meeting if it could have been brought about. There may have been difficulties in bringing such a thing about, but I do not think that the difficulties would have been insuperable.
This is possibly the last opportunity. I may have of speaking in this House on the subject of the partition of Ireland. Deputy Morrissey became very eloquent a few moments ago in the House upon the economic subject, and about not a loaf being put on the table by this Constitution. After all, I am afraid Deputy Morrissey is looking at only one side of this problem. It is my view—I am more convinced of this than I have ever been convinced of anything before—that it is a physical impossibility for anybody, I do not care who it is, man or woman, to make this country the successful financial and commercial entity that it ought to be while two Governments are functioning here. That is my belief. I can assure Deputies of this House, and I am speaking with the sincerest conviction, that even in Ulster there are people to-day who formerly went all out on the Unionist ticket, and they are beginning to think along different lines now. In the City of Belfast they have already established a "Justice for Ulster" league. They are not getting justice from across the water. Things have developed on those lines. I am sure Deputies in this House do not look on Partition from the proper angle.
The other day, in the Ulster Parliament, Lord Craigavon, the Prime Minister, got up and told the Deputies there, if I may so call them: "Mr. Baldwin is Prime Minister of Northern Ireland and not I." When the Constitution introduced by President de Valera, drafted by President de Valera, was brought up for debate in the Ulster Parliament, the same answer was given: "You have to deal with Mr. Baldwin and his Cabinet." I wonder do Deputies here recognise or realise for a moment that that thing which postures as a Parliament in Belfast is not a Parliament as such? There it is, ruling six counties of territory, which in my opinion have been ceded to England. We cannot call this a nation until we get back that territory. That Parliament is governed by a joint Exchequer Board in England, four men, of whom only one is representative of Ulster. That is the type of thing we are told must stay and will always stay. We are told it is the wish of the people of Ulster to accept it. To quote from Lord Craigavon's speech the other day. "Parliament," he said, "was forced on us by the English Government, that we did not want and that we do not want." It was forced upon them as a political exigency by the English. The tragedy of it is this: Here are we in this Parliament; there they are in what should be a Parliament but is not. Here we are arguing upon very minor matters, while that territory has been given away to another country, with 1,250,000 of its population, its mineral resources, its trade and its commerce and everything attached thereto.
It is no pleasure for me to get up and say those things, but I know that they will be met in the straightforward and manly way in which the President always meets criticisms of this kind. I could sit here and keep quiet. I could sit here as a Government Deputy, but after all, like others in this House, I come from an area known as the Six-County area, and I want to say with all the force at my command that time is a precious thing as far as the unification of this country is concerned. Take the education in the schools of Ulster and compare it with the education in the schools in Southern Ireland. In another 16 years —this has now been in operation 16 years—I shudder to think what the mentality will be or what the type of individual will be that will call himself a nationalist in Northern Ireland.
One day longer than the 1st of January, 1938, I would not ask the President to postpone this Constitution. We have waited 750 years, and surely we can wait six months more. Surely we can make this last effort to round up all the opinion that there is in this country behind President de Valera and his Government; take the initiative on that, and put it up to the English again on the basis of a plebiscite to be taken in the areas I suggest. Apparently Deputy Cosgrave has taken an interest in this matter for some months back, because I remember here one evening he came in with a resolution that negotiations be reopened with the English on a more comprehensive basis than that of the land annuities. The Minister for Industry and Commerce interrupted and said: "Including partition"? Deputy Cosgrave said: "Yes, including partition." The speech delivered by Deputy Morrissey now would not lead anybody to believe that the Opposition was sincere in the very first phrase that they had in the programme which they put before their last Ard Fheis: "To prepare the way for the achievement of a united Ireland, convinced that the reunion of Ireland is the predominant national issue." It is the predominant national issue. Nothing else counts; nothing else matters. I say deliberately and I say advisedly that even if the Twenty-Six Counties of Southern Ireland were a land flowing with milk and honey, even if you had here every blessing, every comfort, everything that could possibly be called prosperity, comfort and happiness, it would not be an Irish nation and it could not be an Irish nation. For that reason amongst others I have tabled this motion.
I know somebody will get up and say that I am living too much in the past. Perhaps I have been living too much in the past during the course of my public life, but I always believed that it was best for the people to learn from the past. I always thought that the mistakes of the past were a guide for the future, and that the people should get inspirations from the past. I read with interest the other day that steps have been taken in the County Wexford to carry out in a fitting way the 140th anniversary of the '98 rebellion. There were two counties that made a fight worthy of any name in '98. One was Antrim and the other Wexford. I would be false to everything that I believe in if I did not say that in the City of Belfast republicanism was first launched. It was there it had its birth. The Protestant young men of Belfast have handed on to us the republican creed that we profess to take to our hearts. From that standpoint, too, I was actuated in tabling this motion—that some effort should be made to unite our country before this Constitution becomes law. The task of doing that will be getting more difficult every day. The youth in Armagh, Dungannon, Newry and Belfast who are getting their education in these days are being taught all about Trafalgar and Waterloo instead of the glories of the Yellow Ford and Benburb. Unless something is done to alter that, these young boys and girls will grow up without a national faith or a national outlook. The position is serious from that standpoint and that standpoint alone if this nation is going to live. What is the use in going about the country at election time—we have been doing it since the Treaty was passed—and saying that we stand for a united Ireland and the abolition of Partition? I noticed that another voice to join that chorus in Westmeath the other day was Deputy Fagan, but now I say is the time to do something if we are really serious in trying to take such action as will have the effect of abolishing Partition. With a united country behind the President, let the Government take the initiative to make the Partition of Ireland at least practical politics to be discussed between this country and England.
I deliberately put into my motion the words "organising the Irish race abroad for their assistance and support". When President de Valera was in Geneva a couple of years ago I noticed that amongst the activities going on there we had one of our Cabinet Ministers appointed Chairman of a committee which was set up to decide something between Bolivia and Paraguay. He also got mixed up in something between China and Japan. That is inevitable, I suppose, if you go to the League of Nations and take part in the work of those committees. I would like to know what the position is as regards Ireland at the League of Nations, or is it possible for this question of the division of our country to be raised there at all? Surely to goodness, if we have a Government functioning here, and claiming the right to own the territory of the whole country, we ought to be able to make this question practical politics: to see that we get back the Province that was taken away from us.
In the first Bill that was put through the English Parliament in 1920, separating the North of Ireland from the South, not one single Irishman, Nationalist or Unionist, voted for it. It was imposed, in the words of Mr. Lloyd George, on Ireland as a compulsory settlement rather than give way on the big issue of the republic. Mr. Lloyd George's justification, according to himself, for putting that measure through the English House of Commons was that if a plebiscite was taken amongst the people of Ireland on the big issue, they would say that they wanted an Irish Republic. Those words which were used by Mr. Lloyd George are on the records in Hansard. Therefore, in order to stop the growing force of the movement that then existed and in order to placate world opinion, the 1920 Act was imposed on the country. In the words of Lord Craigavon the other day, they got a Parliament in the North that they did not want, while we are functioning here as a Parliament for the Twenty-Six Counties of Southern Ireland. Mr. Lloyd George could sit back in his chair and smile to himself as to how he outwitted the Irish, but he never would come to close quarters with the proposition put up to him at the time of the Treaty by President de Valera to take a plebiscite of the Ulster counties.
I have mentioned in my motion that every available form of pressure at home and abroad should be got together now to back the demand to the British to reopen negotiations on the question of the unity of this country. I do not think even the economic issues that Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Professor O'Sullivan talk so much about are more important than this. In my opinion, they are not. I remember reading a speech made some time ago by Deputy O'Sullivan in which he said that we were only keeping this thing here for talking about it, for going around the country and referring to it when it pleases us. I am glad to see, however, that it has now become a useful article for reference by Deputy Cosgrave and the members of the Opposition Party. All I will say on that is that they can never do much harm by claiming that this country is ours, that it should be reunited and that Partition is wrong.
The speech which Deputy MacDermot made in moving his amendment was one of the most barren that I ever listened to. It had nothing constructive in it. It offered no alternative, good, bad or indifferent. It was a simple negative: "We will not have this Constitution; take it out of the way, we do not want it." As regards Northern Ireland, there is one other matter that I would like to refer to. I witnessed the fury that Deputy Morrissey worked himself into as regards emigration. Nobody wants emigration either in Southern or Northern Ireland. If Deputy Morrissey will take a trip up to Belfast and go down the quays, he will see there the special sheds and special accommodation that had to be provided recently for the export of the Protestant young men and young girls of Ulster to the colonies or wherever else they liked to go. I say without fear of contradiction that the main cause of all that emigration, of all the poverty, and of anything else that is wrong politically, nationally and economically with the country is due to the partition of Ireland.
We have the position that there are two Governments functioning, that the English are allowed to subsidise the North against the South without protest, without the whole of world opinion being focussed against it, and I would say, if such a thing were occurring, that it would be equally wrong to finance the South against the North. I believe that if we take our courage in our hands, and if the President will take the initiative, the cure for everything is to come to close quarters with this question, and having done that, to do our best as a united country, plus the minority in Ulster, to bring it to a satisfactory conclusion and give the people of Ulster a voice and a vote in whatever Constitution we want them to join with us.
Comment on this
I desire to second the amendment simply to realise and get analysed and digested the plans put forward by him for a united Ireland. I realise that at a moment like this the responsibility is great. It is laying down things for the future which possibly will decide definitely one way or the other whether the road to be travelled is to be one of eternal peace and stability or, on the contrary, whether men will take their choice. My principal objection would be on those lines: that the Dáil declines to give a Second Reading to Bunreacht na hEireann, which, while purporting to be a vehicle whereby an all-Ireland nation can be established, offers no basis whereby the overwhelming majority of Nationalists within the shores of Ireland can be united and marshalled to uphold and seek international recognition for the Republic of Ireland. There is one thing as far as Deputy Donnelly is concerned—that he is like the man of whom Emerson wrote long ago in his essays who possessed an inner soul. A man is only a man while he adheres to the soul that ticks within, and if, through external or other influences, he departs from that, he is a man no longer. The big question, in my opinion, is to visualise what really will be the position when the Constitution is passed and when the election is over. Will you have a position, for instance, under Article 1 of the Constitution that you will have a certain number of men working or standing for the nation who will come under Article 38 of that Constitution, and possibly be imprisoned by Eire? When this is enacted you will have certain men going on different lines, working out methods of policy to achieve the unity of the nation. This is a loss, a waste of energy — these different sections working in conflict with each other.
In Article 29 of the proposed Constitution you have the expression "a group or league of nations". That certainly is the Commonwealth of Nations. In Article 29 (4) the words "organ, instrument or method of procedure" certainly, in my opinion, definitely refer to the King. The Executive Authority (External Relations) Act, passed last December automatically becomes law.
The President and the Government can argue that there is nothing in this to stop any man from going ahead and using constitutional methods to bring in the North. That certainly will be done in a haphazard, aimless, indefinite way. A certain number of men will advocate conciliation, conference and consent. Finally, we will get others who will possibly go further and introduce a certain amount of violence. It is clear that those men who will stand for Article 1 will be put into jail under Article 38. A great General once said, when asked what was in his mind, "What is in my mind does not matter if I could only know what is in the mind of those opposite." Do we think at this stage we can lay down something which can avoid all the evils which I see are going to follow? As long as grass grows and water runs there will always be people in this country going on until they come into violent action.
On the merits of the two Constitutions, my view is that the President is losing an opportunity that has not occurred since the defeat of Hugh O'Neill at Kinsale. The Constitution of 1922 was drafted after the Great War. England had conquered the known world and ruled the waves. At that time men were unnerved after the strain. The unfortunate thing about it was that it was rushed. Now, after so many years of cool thought and meditation we should ask ourselves are we willingly, freely and knowingly going to go the distance that we should go? What difference will it make if once and for all we make the issue clear and proclaim the Republic of Ireland? If we do not make that issue clear you will have simply this difference: that by apparent or by silent consent the Irish race will stand divided and smashed at home and abroad. Doing the other thing—proclaiming the Republic—you make England keep Partition there by force of arms and you will let the world see that she is doing it. That is a position which the people of England would not be able to stand over long in the present position of Europe and the world.
The President at one time said one noble and great thing. He said that to be brave is to be wise. The unfortunate thing is that we have a waste of energy because of a lack of unified action. The honest and sincere men will automatically drop out. Other men will keep on the road in different ways trying to solve the problem of the North. There has been a point raised by Deputy Morrissey about what he calls want in the country. All Deputies here, I am sure, agree that there is a higher principle than that. I personally agree that it is finance which controls the nations of the world, and what the people of this country need is the direction and control of finance in the country. Lord Beaverbrook proved that that was the position in England, and he proved that every Labour Government would be upset by a few strokes of the pen by the people who had financial control. This, however, is not the time nor the place to go into that matter. To create internal wealth and to keep the population, because the population is the real wealth and the key of all in the end, are the things that are needed. That wealth —population—is the one thing that will solve all problems. It is the same as the steam-engine. When a valve is leaking the steam is wasted and you are hopeless. But once the engine is perfectly running these evils are stopped.
The present Government is partly responsible for the present non-circulation of money. This was a power that we surrendered in 1927. In the present circulation of currency there is not a hope of maintaining the population. Hence we can never have a sufficiency of steam power to solve all our troubles. I think it is not fair for the Opposition to put all the blame on the present Government. I think they should have something more manly to put before the people. There was no circulation of money amongst the farmers in this country since 1928. Money has since been getting scarcer. We did not take our gloves off to England as we should have done. The past can prove what a united Ireland could do. Before we came to be split up we were united and we reached a position in which there was no stopping us. That is a position, I am afraid, that unfortunately we will never reach again. And I am afraid the present position will remain as it is. Of course, the King stands for external affairs in this Constitution, and he will still be King of Ireland. That is the position. Now, when we go to the cross-roads during the election campaign, let us be honest about the 32-county republic.
Deputy Donnelly has certainly given us an outline of his ideas and plans. My personal view is that they will all fail, but it would be moral and justifiable to give them a chance. I am giving my personal view and putting my cards on the table, and here I am for Ireland. It will be for England then and for the North to take the initiative against us, and the world would see once and for all the position we claim. Otherwise, the position will be that we are consenting to it. The forces which could have been united and energetic forces will be wasted against one another. Men's minds will be deluded and saddened. The men who love Ireland and who are prepared to give all for her will lie down in despair, and there will not be any inspiration for the youth to follow them.
I do not wish to go into the Articles of the Constitution. That really is for lawyers. One thing I wish to say, and it is this, that it is very hard to improve on the men who wrote the national gospel. The men who wrote that gospel in 1916 were clear, simple and honest. They invoked the blessing of the Blessed Trinity on our sacred cause. Even in the matter of the rights of women they took the right road. Possibly the Article in the draft Constitution in this connection may be a slip by the President, but I know the women folk have taken this matter up seriously. Really there is nothing in it. How great and wise the men of 1916 were when they avoided falling into a slip in this matter.
The preamble to this Constitution is a grand, beautiful and noble one, if we are all sincere about it and if every man has assented to that principle. Many Deputies have some time or other read in the old Shamrock about Mick McQuaid and Kit Kulkin. Kit was a very pious hypocrite. I hope that will not be the case here. The invocation of the Holy Trinity saved us in the past and will undoubtedly and unquestionably save us again if we have the moral courage to declare it in all appropriate things. However, I cannot compel the Government to do what I want them to do, and as far as I am concerned I will, for the remainder of my days, work constitutionally for the restoration of the Republic. The future as I visualise it is not rosy anyway; it is sad. There are men in this country who are reckless, wild, foolish and misguided. But we were all that at one time. In 1916, we were all called vagabonds, scoundrels, wild men, reckless men. Eventually, by 1921 we became great and we were praised as Christian men. Until 1922, both sides of the House were united, but in 1922 one side of the House became wild, reckless, mad, misguided men again.
As time went on we changed, and we who were called mad and reckless became again great men. But now we have another set of vagabonds, and the very vicious circle is completed. What is really wrong with the whole thing? That is a matter really worth thinking over seriously. I will give a figurative definition or illustration, and it is this—we have gone off the road. If you took the greatest and soundest physical athlete and you trained him down in Kildare. On a dark night, with no lights, you asked him to run a journey 20 miles away, and you put side by side with him and against him an old man and that old man weak and feeble, and you told the old man to keep to the road and that that road would take him on a distance of 20 miles. You told the young athlete that he must keep to the fields. The destination of both is the republic. The old man keeps on the main straight road. Which of them do you think will get there first? The man in the fields would eventually find himself going in a circle and coming back to the point where he started, so the man on the road would get there first.
The source of all our troubles and evils and sorrows will remain until we make a resolute effort to settle the question once and for all in the name of God and for the honour of Ireland. Where eventually will you find the great civilisation of the West? You may go through France, Spain, Germany and Italy, but eventually you will find it in the little cottages amongst the peasants. Ireland was a great country when England and other nations had not even reached the outskirts of civilisation. Ireland is regarded as the greatest moral nation in the world and rightly so. For many centuries she has struggled for her independence, and I believe she is approaching the time when her ambition will be achieved.
So far as the people of the North are concerned, they made a bold resistance up to 300 years ago. That portion of Ireland was the very head of the island in more senses than one, but it is beheaded now, merely at the request of a minority who, for the moment, are in a position of authority. We should utilise every effort until that portion of our country is restored to us. I am sure you will all agree that Europe to-day is awaiting a new re-mapping. In our schooldays we were told about the great Empire on which the sun never sets. Is it ever to be undone? I believe that it will be undone, and I believe God in His time will select His instrument to carry out the undoing, whether that instrument be a dictator or otherwise.
As this proposed Constitution stands. I would not vote for it. I am supporting Deputy Donnelly in the hope that this question which he puts forward will be earnestly considered and that good results will accrue from it.
Comment on this
The President, in his speech this afternoon introducing the Constitution, adopted, in some parts of that speech at least, an attitude of sweet reasonableness. He called on all Deputies in the House, to whatever Party they might belong, to come together and endeavour to secure in this new Constitution an instrument as ideal as could be attained for the government of our country. One would be able more easily to believe in the entire sincerity of that appeal if the Constitution had been prepared and presented to this House at some other time and in some other way. So far as this House knows, the Constitution is the work of the President himself. Certainly no person or body in this House outside himself, or possibly members of his own Party or Government, were invited to contribute anything to its preparation. That, I think, is an unusual method of preparing a Constitution. When this State first came into being, the Constitutions of the drafted by a commission set up to examine the Constitution was world, to pool their collective knowledge and wisdom and to try to devise a Constitution which would be acceptable, if not to the entire nation, at least to the majority of the people. That precedent might have been followed if it were really considered necessary at this particular moment to press upon the country a different Constitution. Well, that has not been done. Instead, the Constitution has been prepared, possibly by one man, certainly without consultation with any of the many interests in the nation that would be able to give assistance in the preparation of it.
The Constitution was presented to the people something less than ten days ago. No word or hint of its contents was known, I think, to any members of this House, certainly not to any members other than members of the Government Party, until it was produced. We had from the President an exposition of the document before it was published. An appeal was made by the President over the radio to the people to come together, and they were asked to approve the Constitution before they had ever seen it. They have now had a short opportunity of examining it. In the few days that have passed since it was produced certain criticisms have been offered in the public Press. I do not think I am putting it too far when I say that the President has shown himself singularly intolerant of that criticism. I do not think that there was anything in the rather mild criticism which was offered by Deputy Costello in the Irish Independent, and by the other jurists who have written articles upon it. I think the President might have taken the line that these were intended to be helpful criticisms. But he has not taken that line.
He has suggested that they are carping, that they tend to destroy and hinder, and that they are not offered in a spirit of endeavouring to obtain for the country as perfect an instrument as is possible. His speech here this afternoon, although some parts of it were informed by the spirit of an appeal to people to come in and help to work up the Constitution, certainly did not seem to be designed to that end, so far as other parts of it are concerned. As a lawyer, I myself enter upon this debate with some trepidation, because, although in the opening part of the President's remarks, he appealed to the lawyers to come in and help with their special knowledge and skill in these matters, towards the conclusion of his speech when, no doubt, he had worked himself up to a certain extent, he told the House, and I suppose he intends to tell the country, that he is not bothering about the lawyers; that he does not care what the lawyers may think of this Constitution; that they can call it what they like; but that the is not bothering what the lawyers may think. I think I have quoted the President's words with substantial accuracy.
Comment on this
I may not be giving the exact words, but in that particular connection, I think I am quoting the President with substantial accuracy.
Comment on this
It had to do with the point of whether the Bill before the House was to be regarded as an amendment to the Constitution or a revolution. I think I am correct in that.
Comment on this
The President wants you to take two hours and a half, as he did, to elaborate the point.
Comment on this
Oh, no! I want to be fair. I think that that was the President's point. In effect, he said that although the lawyers might hold certain opinions with regard to this Constitution, he and his Party were not bothering about the lawyers or about what the lawyers think; that the people were sovereign, and that it was to the sovereign people they would appeal; that they were not bothering about what the lawyers think; that the lawyers would have to swallow it if the people wanted it.
I think that is a fair statement of what the President said. However, notwithstanding the things to which I have referred, such as the manner in which this Constitution has been presented to the House and to the country, and the experience we have had with regard to certain matters, I think it is important to point out to this House where this proposed Constitution may be a serious source of danger if it be enacted. In the first place, I think it will be generally agreed that the Constitution ought to be a simple, straightforward statement of the fundamental law and that it ought to deal as briefly and as succinetly as possible with the fundamentals of the law of the State: that it ought not to go further; that it ought not to be an essay on social policy or a statement of ideals; or that it ought not to state matters of detail regarding the ordinary rights of citizens with regard to the ordinary law. I think it will be agreed that the Constitution ought to confine itself to the fundamentals of the law of the State.
Now, we have here a Draft Constitution of something like 60 Articles, consisting of some Articles which are not intended to be law at all, and other Articles, which, certainly, could not be considered or applied in any ordinary court of law because of their vagueness and generally. The President, in various parts of his speech, made impassioned appeals for various social policies which, he considers, should be enshrined in this Draft Constitution, and which are enshrined in it. Well, of course, it is not by appeals of that sort that you can make people think better of a thing to which they are opposed. So far as the general idea of the social ideals, for which the President appealed, is concerned, I suppose that everybody in this House and everybody in the country, and, possibly, everybody in the world, would probably agree with it; but I am sure the President himself will realise that there is also the question of whether the introduction of generalities of that kind might not, perhaps, be a source of danger instead of a help. The president himself pointed out that you cannot say what are the fundamental rights; and it is only by opening up that question that you can show to people, who take a different view from the farmers of the Constitution, what may turn out to be exceedingly dangerous.
Even if the present Government think that they could administer this Constitution in the spirit in which they framed it, that does not mean that hereafter they, or somebody else, may not administer it in a very different fashion. Where you find fundamental laws stated, and then made subject to certain qualifications you may find afterwards that the qualification may have a very different meaning from what was originally intended. I can give three instances. One of the fundamental rights laid down by the Draft Constitution, in Article 40, is the right of free expression of opinion; that is, that sub head 6 (i) guarantees the right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions. Having stated that right, however, the Constitution goes on to provide that organs of public opinion, such as the radio, the Press, the cinema—the three organs of public opinion—shall not be used to undermine public order or morality or the authority of the State. Now, the freedom of the Press used to be regarded as the basis of any free Constitution, but now we find that, by positive enactment in the Draft Constitution, laws may be made ensuring that the Press, not to mention the other organs of public opinion, shall not be used to undermine the authority of the State.
Now, as I have said, that may be, perhaps, an admirable idea in itself; but is it not easy to see how such a power could be used by a Government which wished to restrain a Press which was critical of it. When is it to be said that the authority of the State is being undermined? If the Government is being attacked, even by fair criticism, in the Press, does not that article give to whatever Government has the majority in the Dáil, and which has, possibly, the sympathy of the new President to be set up under this Constitution, the power to restrict and attack the power and the liberty of the Press, not to speak of the other organs of opinion?
I pass now to a succeeding sub head of that Article—sub-head (iii)—which deals with the right of the citizens to form associations and unions. There, the right of the citizens to form associations and unions is guaranteed. Having done that, however, the qualification follows that laws may be enacted for the regulation and control in the public interest of the exercise of the foregoing right.
That means that our trade unions are to be subject again, by express provision of the Constitution, to legislation affecting their actions. Then you have a provision for laws regulating the manner in which the right of forming associations and unions and the right of free assembly may be exercised, but it says, further, that such laws shall contain no political, religious, or class discrimination. All of these are admirable ideas in themselves; but how easily are they not capable of being applied by a Government which may be anti-Labour and which may desire to restrict or damage the operations of trade unions. I suggest that in that Article there is a menace to trade unionism and I suggest, further, that the Constitution is no place for the statement of such rights, if fundamental rights—if they are fundamental—cannot be stated without qualifications such as these.
The third instance to which I wish to refer is even more serious. Article 43, sub-head (2º) recognises the fundamental right to private property, and the State guarantees to pass no law attempting to abolish the right of private ownership. Having acknowledged that right, however, the Article then goes on to say that the State may, as occasion requires, delimit by law the exercise of the said rights with a view to reconciling their exercise with the exigencies of the common good. I suggest that those words could quite properly find their place in any Communist Constitution. There is the fullest right given there by express enactment, if the exigencies of the common good are deemed by the Government to require it, to take away private property and to take it away without compensation. Accordingly it should be understood, if I read the Constitution aright, that it provides that private property may be confiscated without compensation. Is it desirable that the fundamental law of the State should say so? Is it desirable that the fundamental law of the State should contain any provision which is capable of being so read? That it is capable of being so read is brought out to some extent by Article 44, sub-head 5, which provides that the property of any religious denomination or any educational institution shall not be diverted—"diverted" is an excellent word— save for necessary works of public utility and on payment of compensation. This draft accordingly provides that an educational institution may have its right protected and not have it diverted without compensation but the private individual is to have no such right. Apparently by express enactment, his property may be confiscated without compensation. As I say, that is a provision which might properly find its place in any Constitution drawn up for a Communist State. Such a provision would not be out of place in the Constitution of any Communist State.
Another matter to which the President referred, in the course of his speech, that I considered made it rather difficult to approach the problem in the way in which he expressed his desire that it should be approached, was his reference to so much of the new Constitution as is borrowed from the existing Constitution. I should have thought that if he did desire that all parties should approach the consideration of the Constitution in the spirit of an endeavour to arrive at the best that could be obtained, he might have been less grudging in acknowledging his indebtedness to the existing Constitution. All he would say was that where he had done it, it was as a concession, not because he liked to do it, but because he desired to avoid raising opposition and as a concession. If he has taken from the old Constitution the very framework of the proposed Constitution, apart from the innovation of the new position of President, I think he has gone very far in his concessions. The framework of the new Constitution is based entirely on the exiting Constitution and the novelty which it introduces is based on the British Constitution. The nearest parallel which can be found to the office of President in the new Constitution is the King in the British Constitution. However, so far as the main framework is concerned, it is based on the existing Constitution.
The Oireachtas until recently consisted of three parts—the Dáil, the Seanad and the Governor-General. It is true that we have spent many days in this House, first of all abolishing the Seanad, and then abolishing the Governor-General. Now they are to be restored. The Seanad is to be restored with a different method of nomination, but it will still be a substantially similar body to the one destroyed. It may be, of course, that the object of its destruction was to get rid of the existing member of the Seanad. It may be that what the President really desired was to replace members of the Seanad with people of a different category. I do not know but, at any rate, we spent days here destroying that Seanad in order now to replace it by a Seanad whose constitution and whose powers are very similar. We did the same with the Governor-General. We are now to have him replaced by a new functionary, the President, who, although he takes the place of the Governor-General, has very much wider powers. I think it may be said that, apart from certain pronouncements on social policy which it necessarily contains, the only important feature of the new Constitution is this new position of President. I do think it is not an improvement. Already several people, who cannot be considered to have any political feelings of opposition towards the President or his Government, have adverted to this proposed institution without favour. I do not know what is to be said for it. As I say, it resembles very strongly in many particulars the position of His Majesty the King in the British Constitution, but, of course, there the King is a survival of an old régime. The functions which he exercises—if he is Commander-in-Chief of the Forces, if he signs Bills in order that they may become law—if he does all these formal things, it is because he is a tradition and a symbol. It is quite another thing for this State, where there is no such tradition, to take the cue from that traditional institution to appoint a President merely for the purpose of doing these formal acts.
Further he is not limited to these formalities. The danger that I foresee in this institution of President is this: like the Prime Minister he is elected by the people directly. The head of the Government is elected to this House, and is appointed by this House to be the head of the Government. You have then two persons who may think either the same or differently in political matters. It is useless to speak of the President in our existing circumstances as being a person above politics. That is futile. Anybody who knows the conditions in this country must realise that no man is going to secure a majority of the entire electorate of this country unless he has a powerful organisation behind him, unless he is a Party politician in the fullest sense of the word, and unless he has the support of a political organisation. As I say, the President may hold the same views or different views from the head of the Government. In either case he may be a source of danger to the State. He is the supreme commander of the defence forces. He must sign Bills before they become law. He must promulgate the law. He has the right of pardon and commutation, and, above all, he is not answerable to either House in the exercise of his powers. It is in that phrase that the novelty of this institution becomes apparent.
At present, we have a President of the Executive Council who in himself unites the functions which, practically speaking, will be dischargeable by two persons under the new Constitution. At least, the President of the Executive Council is directly responsible to the Dáil. It is now proposed to put in between him and that responsibility a person who is not responsible to the Dáil. The functionary who is to be created under this Constitution is not to be answerable to either House for the exercise of his powers, whether he acts on his own discretion, whether he acts after consultation with the Council of State, whether he acts in accordance with their advice or contrary to it, or whether he acts on the advice of the Government. In no case is he responsible to the Oireachtas. Neither is he amenable to the courts. There is an express provision that during his term of office no action, civil or criminal, is to be brought against him. Why is such an office to be created in this democratic State? Under a democratic Constitution you are proposing to set up a person who will be above the law. I heard nothing from the President in justification of that proposal. Apart from clashes that may come between this high personage and the Dáil, the clashes that may arise between him and the Prime Minister and the head of the Government can be easily foreseen.
What is the necessity for it? I myself can see none. I cannot see why the principle of parliamentary government—a democratic institution such as the Dáil, with the necessary check provided by a properly constituted Seanad—is not all that this country requires. Why this complication of institutions? That brings us, perhaps, to what would be the best justification for such an office,if there can be a justification. If the President is to be head of State, one would imagine that he would be the person who would represent the State externally, that he would be the person who would appoint our diplomatic representatives, that he would be the person who would enter into relations with foreign States and monarchs, that he would be the person who would look after our external affairs. But that is precisely the thing which he is not to do. He is to be kept strictly apart from everything external. He is to be the head of the House, but only at home. In fact, the position of the President appears to be almost exactly analogous to the position which the Constitution provides for women in the home.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy state the Articles of the Constitution upon which he bases that statement he has just made?
Comment on this
The statement that the President is not to have association with external affairs? Certainly. First of all he is not to leave Eire during his term of office except with the consent of the Government. Article 29 (4) says:
"The Executive power of Eire in or in connection with its external relations shall, in accordance with Article 28 of this Constitution, be exercised by or on the authority of the Government."
Comment on this
The position is perfectly clear on the Draft as it stands, but, if anything were needed to make it more clear, the President himself, in his speech this afternoon, made it abundantly clear, because, although he did not refer to our external position in detail, he did refer to it as the existing circumstances. In referring to Article 29 (4), sub-head (2) he stated that it was drawn with a view to the existing circumstances, and that it would not have been suggested to him or, he thought, to any other person except for those existing circumstances. Under those existing Circumstances——
Comment on this
——the external relations of the State are to be dealt with by the Government by availing of or adopting any organ, instrument or method of procedure used or adopted for the like purpose by the members of any group or league of nations with which Eire is or becomes associated for the purpose of international co-operation in matters of common concern.
Comment on this
Does that debar the President from ever having anything to do with external affairs? That is the thesis, I take it.
Comment on this
The President has not followed me. What I said was that as the Constitution stands at the moment. I was going to deal with that in a moment, because it occurs to me that, possibly, the Article which the President suggested this afternoon was intended only to deal with routine matters, namely, the power to confer additional functions upon him was intended to give him external powers. Perhaps the cat is out of the bag now. The President stated explicitly this afternoon that this Article 13 (10), to which Deputy Dillon drew attention and on which he asked for an explanation, was intended to deal only with routine matters. Are we to understand now that it is intended, under that Article, to confer upon the President power to deal with foreign monarchs and States in our external relations?
Comment on this
That will be one of the functions. There is no reason why, if the law were to decide the other, it would be contrary to this Constitution.
Comment on this
I repeat the proposition I made when the Minister for Finance intervened, which is that, as the Constitution stands, and if you like under existing circumstances, the President under the Constitution will be in the same position as the President wishes to put the women of this country into, namely, they are to be in the home and are to stay in the home.
Comment on this
It is quite true, of course, that under this Draft Constitution additional powers and functions can be given to the President. That is quite true. I omitted to refer to it, because we had the assurance of the President this afternoon that it was intended to operate only on matters of routine. Now it seems that under ordinary legislation the Dáil—possibly, as I have said before, in sympathy with the President—may confer on him any powers it likes to deal externally with foreign nations. Whichever way the matter lies, the position of the President remains equally objectionable, because if it is intended to confer upon him powers of that kind by recourse to this Article, then there can be no other limit to the powers which ordinary legislation can give him, at least there is none in the Article. Of course, the President asks the lawyers to help him on the construction of that Article as to whether the words, "subject to this Constitution" will restrict it in any way. I do not know in what way it would restrict it. I do not know whether or not the President, or any lawyer advising the President, would suggest that, if the Oireachtas were to pass a law authorising the President to deal with foreign States in his own discretion, that would be contrary to the Constitution. I imagine it would not.
Comment on this
I do not know. Possibly those are matters for debate and discussion afterwards. At present the point I am making is that the office of President is one which does not appear to be called for by any need in this State. I do not know why it is invented. I can only suppose that it is by reason of some hang-over from the British ideals of constitutional government; that the mind of the draftsman was influenced consciously or subconsciously by the spectacle of the King and his advisers, the Privy Council. I am quite sure that that was not a conscious mental operation, but it might well have been subconscious. At any rate the result is remarkable; we have in the President, in that respect at least, a remarkable similarity to the King with his advisers, the Privy Council. The President has said that it was not his intention to affect the rights of women by this Draft Constitution. If he says it was not his intention I suppose that must be accepted, but I certainly think there can be no doubt that in this, as in other matters I have referred to, the Legislature, acting under this Constitution, would certainly be justified in saying that it was endeavouring to restrict the rights of women.
Comment on this
The first Article in question is Article 40, dealing with personal rights:
"1. All citizens shall, as human persons, be held equal before the law.
This shall not be held to mean that the State shall not in its enactments have due regard to differences of capacity, physical and moral, and of social function."
Now I suppose that the difference in the sexes is perhaps one of the most marked distinctions occurring between human persons as regards physical capacity, and also, possibly, as regards social function. The State is invited to make legislation which will distinguish between the sexes.
Comment on this
It is not a question of what the President will do. The President may, while he is head of the Government, not affect women's rights. It may be that he does not purpose to pass legislation for the purpose of carrying out social legislation to keep them in the home and to prevent them going out to earn their living. It may be that that is not his intention, but certainly it would be much better from the feminist point of view if these clauses which were apparently put in—if the President is to be believed, and, of course, I accept what he says—for their protection and advancement were not there. They certainly have not that result, and could not have that result upon any impartial mind reading these Articles, certainly not of any person who has touched on this matter—Deputy Costello has been referred to, and Professor Berriedale Keith who has also written an article on the subject. The President apparently has seen the report of a number of meetings of women's organisations the members of which are greatly perturbed about this. They may be all wrong, and possibly their minds will be set at rest by such alterations as the President may make in his Draft Constitution. Certainly unless these people are very obtuse and unable to understand the meaning of words——
Comment on this
—and I am prepared to range myself with them, because reading this Constitution I would have no hesitation in saying that, so far as the position of women in the State is concerned, these clauses are reactionary and retrograde. That is a matter that can be dealt with hereafter, but that is the way the matter stands at present, and it is certainly not one or two or three persons who have formed that impression after reading this clause.
The President concluded his speech by saying that it was agreed that there was a need for a new Constitution. I do not know why he should think that there was any urgent need for a Constitution. Of course, the recent action of the Government have increased the need for a new Constitution, because, having destroyed the Seanad, a new Constitution to replace it was certainly desirable: but, apart from the actions of the Government in the last two years in destroying the Seanad and in removing University representation: apart from these two fundamental attacks made by them upon the existing Constitution; it is not easy to see why there is any urgent need at present for a new one, and certainly there is no need for a Constitution prepared and presented as this one has been. No doubt, we will be told that we can debate the Constitution fully, but I would remind the House that it has been presented here to a Dáil that is under sentence of death, a Dáil that certainly has not more than a few months of life to run, and, if members of the Government are to be believed, something like a few weeks. In that time we are asked to consider, with the urgent economic necessities of the nation as they have been spoken about by Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Mulcahy, and with an election imminent, this House is asked to sit back and debate a document which the President has been preparing for I do not know how many years, and which first saw the light ten days ago. The first clause of it was unknown to any member of the House until after the President's broadcast to America.
Comment on this
I am prepared to vote for the Second Reading of this proposed Draft Constitution, but I admit that I would do so with much more enthusiasm if I thought that, within my own lifetime, its provisions were likely to be applied to the whole of Ireland. As far as I can find out, there is no great enthusiasm for the acceptance of this Constitution in the country at the present time. In my opinion, the people as a whole are much more concerned about their own constitutions and other material matters than they are about the contents of this document. I suggest very seriously to the President that, if this Constitution is to get the consideration which a document of the kind is entitled to receive, or is to get serious consideration of any kind from the people of this country, it should not be submitted to them for their consideration at the same time as that in which we are engaged in a political or Party struggle upon perhaps less important matters. If a document of this kind were submitted to the people at a time other than that at which a general election was being held, I think it would create far more enthusiasm in the minds of the people, and would get far more consideration than it is likely to get from the people when they are engaged on the task of voting for the election of Deputies to this House. I think that the decision of the Government to submit a Constitution to the people on the same date as that on which a general election is taking place is one which should be carefully reconsidered, if the President has any desire to get the people to deal with the matter on its merits.
I share, to some extent, the views expressed by Deputy Lavery. I think he put his views to the House very clearly and without any prejudice. He referred to Section 43 of this Constitution which guarantees the right of the private property owner. He quoted in support of his contention the section of that Article which proposes to delimit the rights of the private property owner, and suggested that would be a proper section to be contained in a Constitution put before the people by a Communist Party or Communist Government. I do not share the Deputy's view on that, but it is an extraordinary thing that while the Government are prepared to insert an Article of that kind in this carefully considered Constitution they do not propose to give any guarantee, and I use the word guarantee deliberately, to the individual citizen regarding his right to work, his right to live and his right to a decent livelihood. Article 45 in the proposed Constitution has some bearing on the rights of the individual citizen, but I think if the individual citizen, in a Christian State, has any right under the Constitution, he is entitled to receive in unqualified language in the Constitution of a democratically governed country a guarantee of the right to work, the right to live and the right to a decent livelihood, and, if he cannot get work the right to a decent standard of maintenance. That is a provision which, I think, the present Government which calls itself a democratic Government and a workers' Government, if you please, should have inserted in this Constitution.
I fully agree with Deputy Dillon as to the danger in Section 10, Article 13. I think that Deputy Lavery elaborated it in a way which calls for a detailed explanation from the President, when replying to the criticisms on this Constitution. I hope the President will elaborate it, more especially in view of the admission which he made to Deputy Lavery when that Deputy was speaking. Deputy Lavery, of course, compared the position of the President in this proposed Constitution to the position of His Majesty the King, as described by Deputy Lavery. Now His Majesty the King of the country that Deputy Lavery seemed to have in mind is not elected by the people on a free vote. We have this difference at any rate. Here the President under the proposed Constitution will be elected by the people in a free election. There is that difference, and I am sure Deputy Lavery would be the first to admit it, between the President under the proposed Constitution and the person referred to as His Majesty the King—His Majesty the King of England, I presume.
"Subject to this Constitution additional powers and functions may be conferred on the President by law."
The President to be elected by the terms of the Constitution will have certain powers given to him by the Parliament which puts the Constitution, either as it reads now or as amended, into operation. I do not believe that any Parliament should without a particular reference to the people give the President any additional powers. I am certainly suspicious of giving any additional powers to the President of this State except such additional powers are to be given to him by way of Referendum, or unless this particular clause is amended in such a way as to make it obligatory to enable any additional powers to be given to the President by a vote of either three-fourths or four-fifths of this Dáil. I do not think it should be possible for the powers of the President to be increased by a small majority vote of this House.
Comment on this
I know there is a provision there, but I am not concerned as to the position or views of the Seanad in a matter of this kind.
Comment on this
I am not a student of international law, but I think Continental precedents can be quoted to show that countries which are now governed in a very anti-democratic way have stolen powers for the President in the past by the insertion of a clause of this kind in a Constitution. At any rate, I am prepared to vote for the deletion of this particular sub-section of Article 13 rather than leave it in the Constitution as it stands unless better safeguards are going to be provided against the Dáil giving extraordinary powers to a future President. If the President is to be a figurehead, I certainly say that there is no objection to amending the law in such a way as to empower him to appoint a representative to a university. But, on the admission of the President to Deputy Lavery, it is possible to give more powers than that. I am not prepared to give a person, who is supposed to hold only nominal powers, authority under a sub-section of this kind in the Constitution to take extraordinary powers without reference to the people.
The President, who will be elected by the people under the terms of this Constitution, whenever it comes into operation, will be possibly what is commonly known as a soldier-statesman. Our experience in this country up to the present time of the soldier-statesman or soldier-politician, if you like, makes it quite clear to members of the Labour Party like myself, at any rate, that that type of person has not made it possible to bring about greater unity in this country, especially amongst the sections of the people who were united in the past. It is the soldier-statesman or soldier-politician type of person in this House and outside who has made the unity of the nationalists of this country impossible up to the present, at any rate. I am not prepared to give the power asked for in this sub-section to any person with an outlook of that kind. We may have a President in the future who will be a figurehead, but he will not be a person, I am afraid, who will forget the history of the civil war or of the recent past. We should be very careful about giving powers of an unlimited kind to persons of that type. I would not, for instance—and I hope I will be excused for mentioning the name— give powers of the loose kind contained in the sub-section to a person like General O'Duffy, or to any person with a wild outlook, either on the past or the future, of that particular type.
As I say, the general outline of the Constitution is acceptable to me, and I am prepared to vote in favour of a Second Reading being given to the Draft. But I seriously suggest, and it is the view of the members of our Party, that this Constitution should be submitted to the people, for ratification or otherwise, on a different day from that on which they will be called upon to enter into an ordinary Party political discussion; that they will not be given a fair chance of considering the document on its merits; that it will not be considered in the way in which we think it should be considered, and the way in which it deserves to be considered.
Comment on this
The Opposition have taken a rather unusual course in regard to this debate, as can be seen if we study the text of the amendment which they have put down. Deputy Lavery told us how this Constitution touches the rights of every citizen. We have been told how the liberty of the subject will be affected by it. One would have thought that, in putting down an amendment to the Second Reading, which is generally taken as an indication of opposition to the principle contained in any measure or any proposal, the amendment would have been what is known as a reasoned amendment, in that it would have set out as concisely as possible the grounds upon which the Opposition think they are called upon to oppose the proposal which is put before this House for consideration.
Comment on this
On the contrary, there are two reasoned amendments on the Order Paper. Is it that reason has deserted the Opposition?
Comment on this
Is it that there is no principle in the Opposition; that they are a house divided against themselves; that in their hearts those of them who were associated with us from 1916 to 1921 really approve of the Draft Constitution and, if it were not for the Party tail, might come into the same Lobby and stand with us for it before the country?
Comment on this
Is that the possible explanation for this amendment—an amendment which in my view is entirely an irrational one and a most impracticable one? It asks the Dáil to decline to give a Second Reading to Bunreacht na hEireann until six months after the reassembly of Dáil Eireann following the next general election. It does not say why. Deputy Mulcahy in his speech——
Comment on this
The Deputy was so completely irrelevant in moving that amendment that the Chair had virtually to tell him to sit down.
Comment on this
Not once did the Deputy advance a substantial reason why the House should adopt his amendment. Or is it this reason? Having listened to the speeches of the eminent lawyer who has just sat down, having listened to the speech of Deputy Lavery, is it possible that this may be the true explanation of it—that they have begun to distrust their legal advisers in matters relating to the Constitution? Because, if I may say so, the Opposition have been very unfortunate in their experience in this regard, for when they have brought constitutional issues to the courts, when they have had a former Attorney-General leading and Deputy Lavery on occasions supporting him, even when they have been appearing together to prove——
Comment on this
When constitutional issues, as I said, have been before the courts, their experience has been very unfortunate, because not merely have they been thrown out of the courts, but costs have been given against them. I am not surprised, having listened to the speech of Deputy Lavery, that when they read through this Constitution, and when they had to make up their own minds as to what their attitude would be in regard to it, that they decided, at any rate whatever else they would do, that they were not going to put down in black and white on paper reasons grounded on constitutional principles for opposing it.
Though we have had, I think, three speeches from the Opposition Benches in the course of this debate, there has been only one that really attempted to deal substantially with the situation, or, shall I say, that really the only speaker who touched upon the Draft Constitution at all was Deputy Lavery? But the Deputy is an astute advocate for a bad cause, because he began by trying to prejudice the issue. He complained of the manner in which this Constitution had been drafted, and he contrasted it with the way in which the existing Constitution, the document under which the State is at present governed, was originally drawn up.
He said there had been got together a committee which drafted the existing Constitution, but the Deputy did not tell us what was the result of the labours of that committee. That would have been much more interesting from the point of view of the Irish people at the present time. Deputy Lavery did not tell us what fate befell the Constitutions which were drafted by the committee which sat in 1922. It may be Deputy Lavery was not in a position to tell us. But there is Deputy Fitzgerald on the opposite benches, and there is Deputy Mulcahy on the opposite benches, and even if they were unwilling to disclose to the people what actually happened at that time, we have it on the records of this House. That document was taken across to the other side and submitted to the veto of the English Cabinet. Articles in it which really represented the traditional viewpoint of this people were cut out of it.
Comment on this
The Articles which represented the traditional principles of the Irish people were cut out of the existing Articles of that Constitution. There were other Articles which we have since cut our put in then to replace those taken out. The consequence was that, so far as a large part of this Constitution is concerned, we were until 1932 living under a Constitution which had been drafted for Irishmen by Englishmen. To-day the Constitution which is now before the House and which will be before the country is a Constitution which has been drafted by Irishmen for Irishmen.
Comment on this
I understand Deputy Mulcahy's mentality perfectly. The Deputy remembers the fable of "the fox which lost a tail." The Deputy had his tail cut off in 1922. He was one of the people who told us, when the Articles of Agreement for the Treaty were before the Dáil, that ours could be made an Irish Constitution, that there would be no oath in it, and that a number of other distasteful elements which we have had since to take out, were not to be in it. I have the fullest sympathy for the Deputy in his present position, because it was quite clear from his speech to-day that the one thing he did not commit himself to was to express opposition to this Constitution. I have the fullest sympathy for him, and those of us who were his comrades from 1916 to 1921, and who know what he did in those years, feel sympathy for him.
Comment on this
I am dealing now entirely with the manner in which this whole Constitution was drafted, and I am showing the results of it. As I said, their labours and the labours of that band of patriotic Irishmen were completely nullified by the position of subordination in which those who signed the Treaty were placed in 1922.
We have been told by Deputy Lavery that there has been no consultation with the many interests involved in the drafting of this Constitution now before the House. What consultation took place with the Irish interests involved when the Constitution which is soon to be superseded was being drafted? What consultation was there with the representatives of the Army of the Republic at that time? What consultation was there with the representatives on the other side of the Dáil at that time? Fully half of the great majority of the Irish people—if we are to take into consideration those who inhabit the Six Counties—were ignored when the Constitution soon to be superseded was being drafted. Now we come here to-day and we are told that there was no consultation with the many interests involved when this Draft was being drafted. There was greater need for consultation in 1922 than there is to-day.
Comment on this
There was greater need in 1922, because we were inexperienced men, and the country was inexperienced in the responsibilities of self-government at that time. Half a generation has passed since, and we have the experience of those of us who were then young, enthusiastic, but have now grown older and, possibly, wiser, and are more capable of assessing our responsibilities to our own people——
Comment on this
——and better able to weigh the considerations which always must be borne in mind when trying to draft a document which, if it is to continue to be the fundamental law of the State, must appeal to the greatest possible number of the people, and must receive as great a measure of agreement as possible. It is in the light of the experience of the past 15 years that this new Constitution has been drafted. If there was not such a lot of time given for consultation with outside interests, as Deputy Lavery seems to think there ought to have been, at any rate the position to-day is immeasurably better than it was in 1922, because now we have at least had 15 years' experience of self-government behind us to guide us in preparing the Draft. Therefore, on that ground alone, the Draft Constitution which is now before the House is a much better Constitution than the Constitution under which this country has been ruled since 1922.
The next criticism which Deputy Lavery, made—and it was a very shallow point indeed to try to make— was that the President had appealed to the people to approve the Constitution before they had ever seen it. That was quite clearly a sort of specious trick that might work if it were tried before a jury, a not too intelligent jury, in the law courts; but it will not work here, and it will not work with the Irish people. It may be a very clever thing, but it is a very meretricious thing as well, because the point is this, that the President made that appeal to the Irish people on the eve of the publication of the Draft Constitution, and the appeal was, in fact, that the people would study the Constitution carefully—and it was put in these terms: That when the people had studied the Constitution carefully and when it had been fully debated here in the Dáil and the arguments for and against it weighed in the country, that then they might see their way, being convinced of the merits of the Constitution, to approve of it. But Deputy Lavery wants to make it appear that some slick trick is being worked upon the people. He has said that the President asked the people, appealed to the people, to approve of the Constitution before they had ever seen it. The Constitution has been before the people now for almost a fortnight— but it has not been put to them for approval yet. It will be debated here in the Dáil, I suppose, for some weeks further; but, in any event, the Constitution under which we live now——
Comment on this
——is terrible; I quite agree. I am sure it appalls a learned lawyer like Deputy O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
Look at it, with all the pen strokes drawn through it, with all the deletions; why, it is impossible almost to read it.
Comment on this
Let me get back to the point. We are now being criticised and the President is being accused of certain things. What is tantamount to an accusation of sharp practice has been levelled against him by Deputy Lavery, who is old enough to remember when this Constitution was issued to the people. It was issued on the morning of the General Election in 1922. Now, that was sharp practice, if you like.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Leary wishes to say that he cannot stand this and then walk out, I am prepared to sit down and let him do it. He has pulled that stunt three or four times.
Comment on this
I suggest I am right in interrupting to the extent of asking where was the President, the Vice-President or the Minister then.
Comment on this
I was at the point that at any rate the country is going to have a full opportunity of studying and listening to the arguments for and against this Constitution. There is going to be no snap election about it and it is therefore interesting to hear Deputy Lavery saying it is very unsuitable, and he thinks it a rather shady thing to do, to ask the people to approve the Constitution at a general election. The Deputy is not kind, I would not like to say he is disloyal, to his colleagues, because they published their Constitution on the morning of a general election. They asked the people to approve of it and they took the result of that election as an approval of the Constitution which we have before us.
Comment on this
They took it as approval of the Constitution we have before us, and that cannot be contradicted.
Comment on this
I shall have to sit down if Deputy O'Sullivan, who never wastes his eloquence in this House, does not keep silent.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan should allow the Minister to make his statement. There is no interruption relevant except on a point of order. That is a very close ruling. The Minister should be allowed to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin also seems to feel, like Deputy Lavery, that there is some grievance. He appears to think he has some grievance, some substantial ground upon which to object to the Constitution because we are submitting it to the people on the day of a general election. I understand, from what I have heard recently, that Deputy Davin has figured in the public life of this country for a long time, according to Deputy O'Higgins prior even to 1922. He was, I am sure, as he is to-day, a very able and influential member of the Labour Party. But I do not remember, and on this I am subject to correction, that the then official spokesmen of the Labour Party, colleagues of Deputy Davin, raised any objection in 1922 to the procedure of submitting the Constitution to the people for their approval on the day of the general election. I think, therefore, they put themselves out of court, the Opposition and Deputy Davin and Deputy Lavery, in that regard. If that was right in 1922 it cannot be so very wrong now.
I am not to be taken as endorsing what was done in 1922, but there is a difference between the procedure proposed to be followed in 1937 and the procedure which was adopted in 1922. As the President made clear last Sunday, the people can pass their judgement upon this Constitution and approve or disapprove of it whether they vote for the Fianna Fáil candidates or not. There are two entirely separate issues before the people. There will be the issue as to whether you are satisfied with our administration during the past five years, and whether you are prepared to entrust us with the government of the country again for another term of five years— and if you are you will vote for us— and then, on a separate paper, by an entirely separate act of will, you can approve or disapprove of the Constitution. That was not the position in 1922. Oh, no. Then all the prestige of leading and prominent figures in Irish public life at the time was thrown into the balance with the Constitution, and if you voted for them, and if you believed that in voting for them you were voting, as you were told you were voting, for peace and the ultimate unification of the country, then, ipso facto, you voted for the Constitution.
If you disapprove so strongly of any feature, any aspect or any characteristic of our policy, or administration, or conduct during the past five years, you can vote against the Government and still vote for the Constitution. I think I apprehend rightly what the views of the people are with regard to our administration, and I feel that the majority of the people will vote for us, but I also hope —and I am sure it must be the hope of everyone who wants to see stabilised government in this country— that every person who believes in Article 1 of the Draft Constitution, who believes with us, and we have been told often enough from the other side that the position as set out in this Article is indeed the case, that the Irish nation has a right to affirm "its inalienable, indefeasible and sovereign right to choose its own form of government, to determine its relations with other nations, and to develop its life, political, economic and cultural, in accordance with its own genius and traditions," will vote approving of this Constitution, irrespective of whether he votes for the Fianna Fáil candidates or not in this election. If we can secure a general acceptance of that principle, and if we can write that principle down as the fundamental law of this State, I believe the prayer of the preamble will be answered, that we shall restore unity in this country, that we shall have stability in government, and that we shall ultimately establish concord with other nations.
Let me go on to consider some other of the criticisms which were advanced by Deputy Lavery. He said that this new Constitution would be a danger if enacted. I must confess that he did not state the grounds upon which he had come to that conclusion and, therefore, I am not able to controvert Deputy Lavery in that regard as fully as I should like. If I knew why he had, as I said, come to the conclusion that the Constitution would be a danger if enacted, if, instead of having his simple bald statement, his simple fiat that it was so and would be so, we had his reasons for it we might be able to join issue with him more closely. But, Sir, could any Constitution be a greater danger to the people than the one under which we live at present, under which there is absolutely no curb, upon the untrammelled power of the Executive? We have seen the Seanad swept away; we have seen the Governor-General disappear; and we have had to interpolate in the Constitution an unreasoning, inelastic, irrational, illogical, mathematical formula in order to secure the tenure of our judges. We have still power under this Constitution to amend every Article in it still further, without any appeal to the people and without any mandate from the people.
This, Sir, is the Constitution under which we live. Under the new Constitution, there is a quite definite attempt to secure such a balance of power in the State that the people will always be supreme and that no one organ, whether it be the Government, as it is called in the new Constitution, the President, the Seanad or the Council of State, will be able to get outside the terms of that Constitution and violate the liberties of the people, unless the people themselves are misguided enough, as a result of a referendum, to place what have been termed dictatorial powers in the hands of the President, the Taoiseach, the Government or the Legislature. But at the present moment the position is this, that we are the most absolute Government in Europe; and that is the position which Deputy Lavery wishes to continue in this State, and he does not think that a danger. He cannot see any danger in that position, but he can see a danger if we bring in a Constitution which will sub-divide the powers and functions of government in this country in a way in which all who have thought on these matters liberally think that power should be subdivided, so that it cannot be concentrated in one hand with the danger that it may be abused.
Why does Deputy Lavery wish to see the present position continued? Why does the Irish Independent wish to see the present position continued? Why does every person who was behind the movement to create a totalitarian State in this country wish to see the present position continued? Because they know that if this Constitution of 1922 be not superseded by a more rational and more democratic law, if they could get a snatch majority, if they could stampede the country, as some were trying to stampede it in 1934, then the Dáil and everything else democratic could be wiped out and we would have here, naked and unashamed as we have it in some States on the Continent to-day, government of the people by a party for a party.
Comment on this
Yes, I do believe it because the attack and criticism of some people outside in regard to this Constitution has been concentrated on the one organ in it that stands as the custodian of the people's constitutional liberties, as the guardian and protector of the people's constitutional liberties in this draft document. It is not for nothing that the paper which signalised itself, just 21 years ago, by calling out for the blood of the signatories to the Proclamation of 1916 have dubbed this Presidential office "a peacock's throne," and referred to it as "this job." They wish to bring that high office into disrepute with the people and the reason they wish to do it is because there are behind that organ, which stood behind General O'Duffy when he was trying to create a Fascist movement in this country, the self-same interests as have produced Fascist Governments in other countries. There is big money and there is a monopolist tendency.
Comment on this
We have listened to Deputy Lavery telling us that the President was intolerant of criticism which was intended to be helpful criticism. This is the sort of criticism we have got from one quarter since this document was published.
Comment on this
The Minister will easily see what may arise from this—criticism of every organ of the Press in reference to the Bunreacht. That would not lead to concord or agreement.
Comment on this
I will not continue any more on that line except that I must again come to the question of the freedom of the Press. Deputy Lavery was very eloquent about the freedom of the Press. He referred to Article 40 and called our attention to paragraph 6 (1) which guarantees liberty to the citizens for exercise of the following rights, subject to public order and morality: "The right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions." It is then stated:
"The education of public opinion being, however, a matter of such grave import to the common good, the State shall endeavour to ensure that organs of public opinion, such as the radio, the Press, the cinema, while preserving their rightful liberty of expression, shall not be used to undermine public order or morality or the authority of the State."
One would think from the terms in which Deputy Lavery criticised that Article that it was a complete innovation in the constitutional law of this State. If Deputies opposite desire to leave their pasts behind them, that is no reason why they should be permitted to forget them. Once again, let me refer to the document under which we live. In this masterpiece of legal drafting, this document which was passed when we had not merely one House in the Oireachtas but two Houses, not merely a Dáil consisting of young irresponsible hot heads but a Seanad of grave and reverend seigneurs, we have the following:—
"It shall not be lawful to print, publish, distribute, sell or offer or expose for sale any book, newspaper, magazine, periodical, pamphlet, leaflet, circular or other document which is issued or published on behalf of an unlawful association."
I suppose the association was unlawful because it was contrary to public order. I do not know whether Deputies opposite join issue with us on the contention that, this being the Constitution of a Catholic State, it is only right we should not permit, since we have the responsibility in these matters, anything which would be contrary to public morality to be published or broadcast or exhibited any more than we would permit it if it were contrary to public order. What right has Deputy Lavery who, if my recollection is correct, participated in enforcing this Section 23 of Article 2 (1) during 1931, or Deputy Costello, or any member of the Opposition who walked into the division lobby to carry through the Constitutional amendment which wrote the section I have just read into our Constitution——
Comment on this
I disagree. Ours may not be so comprehensive as theirs. We refer to "organs of public opinion such as...the Press," and "the Press" may be generally construed to mean weekly or daily publications, but this other Article goes on to refer to "any book, newspaper, magazine, periodical, pamphlet, leaflet, circular or other document which is issued or published on behalf of an unlawful organisation."
Comment on this
Apart altogether from the fact that they wrote that into the Constitution in 1931, it comes very strange from a member of a Party which passed the Censorship Act, which also forbids the publication, circulation and printing of documents, books, periodicals, newspapers and pamphlets—in fact, the whole category of letterpress—which might be contrary to public morality——
Comment on this
Perhaps I may interrupt the Minister for a moment. I am not adopting Deputy Lavery's argument but, if it be true, as he says, that there is any danger of the Article prohibiting attacks on the authority of the State being construed as including attacks on the Government of the day, the Article should be altered. I am not saying that I take that view but that is Deputy Lavery's point.
Comment on this
It is quite clear that the qualifications and reservations mentioned where the rights of citizens are set out in this document must be in the broadest and most general terms. Wherever there has been a reservation or a qualification made as to a general right conferred or a general obligation imposed upon any person, the reservation or qualification is put in in order to cover an existing situation. One feature in this Constitution which has disappeared wholly from the Constitution of 1922 is the doctrine of repugnancy which is now brought in a certain limited and circumscribed way. I am sure the country would hold us blameworthy and culpable if we were put ourselves in the position that, if we adopted, say the Censorship Act, or if we passed a law forbidding the exhibition of indecent films or the broadcasting of indecent songs or dealing with other things which might happen, or if we were to refuse to give a free hand to incitement to treason or murder, and the President, conscientiously carrying out the duties imposed upon him by this Constitution felt himself called upon to refer the text of the law to the Supreme Court—the Supreme Court, being bound to interpret the law so as to give the widest possible liberty to the subject, then were to be obliged to say that, while the law ought to be passed in the interest of public morality or decency, nevertheless under the Constitution, as drafted, the law was ultra vires and the Oireachtas could not enact it. Yet, that is the position for which Deputy Lavery has been arguing—that we should not even take the precaution of saying that, where these rights are given, they shall be exercised subject to public order and morality and that in respect of the three great educative agents and instruments of propaganda —the radio, the cinema and the Press —which may be productive and, I think, on the whole, have been productive of good but which might be capable of being used for evil ends, we should not even have the power in our Constitution to secure that they would not be perverted to evil ends and used to corrupt, demoralise and divide our people. One thing an organised State cannot permit is treason amongst its own subjects, which is tantamount to suicide. Would Deputy MacDermot or any other Deputy say that a Government, charged first of all with the protection of the State, with the maintenance of the State and with the safeguarding of the State, would be justified in tolerating even a newspaper preaching treason against the State?
Comment on this
Now, the next thing is the right to form associations. Deputy Lavery was very eloquent about that. He talked about the right of citizens to form associations and unions, and he quoted the reservation to that to the effect that laws may be enacted for the regulation and control in the public interest of the exercise of the foregoing right. He tried to so distort and misrepresent the true purpose of that reservation in such a way as to make it appear that, under this Article, the right to form trade unions could be prevented. Of course, I think the Deputy stretched his point so far in that matter as to defeat himself, because I think that every person of common sense and intelligence would see that it would be quite impossible, so long as we have a democratic electorate in this country, for any Government to prevent citizens from organising to protect their lawful interests, whether economic or political interests, and that no Government would dare to do it so long as the heart and mind of the people were right. If the people are not prepared to stand for tyranny, no Government, under the new Constitution, can tyrannise over them for long, and therefore no Government could enact legislation which would prevent the organisation of trade unions, provided, once again, that they were organised for the legitimate purpose of advancing the economic and, if you like, the political interests of their members. Members of the present Government as well as of the past Government know the history of the attempts that have been made in other countries to prevent the formation of trade unions. We are aware that a much stronger Government in a much more powerful country than we are, and that is Great Britain, tried to suppress trade unionism over 100 years ago, and we know that they were powerless to suppress it; and that was at a time when the workers were far worse off and much less educated, and with less knowledge of the need for co-operation in these matters, than they are to-day. It would be quite impossible, therefore, for any Government, dependent on the suffrages of a democratic electorate, to endeavour to curtail unduly, or illicitly or inequitably, the right of people to form free associations.
Now, to get back to the point about the reservation that has been put in there. The people who criticise the insertion of this reservation in Article 40 of the new Constitution are the very people who, in Section 19 of Article 2A of the present Constitution, proclaimed as unlawful every association "which does any of the following things." and so on, and thereby virtually outlawed the members of such associations as were there defined. Accordingly, whoever else may be out of court in criticising this reservation, at any rate, those who put that section in the old Constitution are certainly out of court in criticising it.
Similarly, Deputy Lavery has criticised the third paragraph of Section 6 sub-section (1) of Article 40 of the new Constitution, which is the paragraph which enunciates the rights of citizens to assemble peacefully without arms. Again, he made the point that we were going to destroy the right of free public meeting under our reservation; but, Sir, again we have Section 24 of Article 2A which was written in 1931 in the Constitution of 1922, and drafted by some of the lawyers who, at the present moment, are members of the Party opposite, and who, at that time, were the principal advisers of the Government. What does that section say? It says that:
"Whenever it appears to the Executive Council that the holding of public meetings in or in the vicinity of any particular building or any particular road or street is likely to lead to a breach of the peace or to be prejudicial to the maintenance of law and order, the Executive Council may issue a proclamation prohibiting the holding in or within a specified area...during a specified period...from the date of the proclamation of either...any public meeting whatsoever or any public meeting held otherwise than under specified conditions or for specified objects."
That is what is in our present Constitution—written in in the most specific terms.
Comment on this
Yes, and being operated to-night, and being operated for this purpose: that we will not allow a meeting of an unlawful organisation to take place in defiance of the Government of the people.
Comment on this
——because I see a prodigal son here about whom I should like to say a few words, and it would not be a question of the fatted calf either.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy had better go back to his holidays. However, I ought not to ask him to anticipate the general election, as he will have a prolonged holiday after that.
Comment on this
Now, Sir, Deputy Lavery, again following the lead which has been given him already in certain organs of the Press, turned his batteries on the new office of President, and he said that he felt that the creation of that office was no improvement over the existing position. He said that in Great Britain the King is called upon to discharge certain functions, but he does these things because he is a traditional symbol. Now, I do not know exactly what was the point which Deputy Lavery wished to convey. Is it that he thinks we are better off as we are, when we have an untrammelled Single Chamber Government—which, we are told, when the Bill abolishing the Seanad and the Bill deleting certain references to the King were before this House, was in a position of absolute uncontrolled authority—or is it that Deputy Lavery was pleading that we should do, as has been done in other countries, that we should adopt the Crown of Great Britain as the symbol of our nationality and our independent Statehood?
In that case the Crown would be here as a symbol discharging some functions which are more or less archaic. It would have the vestigial remnants of certain old powers which in fact have long become obsolete, were we content to go on in such an atmosphere of make-believe. The Crown elsewhere, and the throne in other countries used formerly, and I believe possibly does still in Great Britain, perform these useful functions. I do not think that there the Crown's duty consists entirely of signing on the dotted line. We have heard that during a previous reign—a reign with the greater part of which we are all familiar—that the Crown in Great Britain on numerous occasions in connection with very important matters exercised a great deal of influence upon the course of affairs. In fact, we have been told that it changed, in regard to the relations between this country and Great Britain, the whole course of history. We have in the Constitution, as it stands at present, no office and no function which could possibly exercise any like influence on our affairs. The people are left like a sheep without a shepherd. There is nobody to look after their interests. The majority of this Dáil, if it were content to dissolve itself, could appoint —and this is a fact which should weigh with Deputies on the other side who seem to be so afraid of dictators—a dictator for life. As far as the existing Constitution is concerned, nothing could prevent that except, possibly, a revulsion of public feeling, which I think would destroy any of us who endeavoured to overthrow democracy in that way. But public feeling may not be so much alive in future to the dangers inherent in that position as it is to-day. What has happened on the Continent may pass out of man's memory, and if the Constitution remains in its present position, it would be quite possible for some unscrupulous body of men to take advantage of that situation to get the control of the Government of this country into their hands, and to retain it as long as they had control over the fiscal, military and economic resources of the State. The position even in Great Britain is to-day in that regard, in my view, rather an unsound one from the point of view of British liberties.
Comment on this
In any event if the Crown there has prestige and tradition behind it, which it has not here, and wanting which it could never in this country fulfil useful functions, the beneficial functions which it does fulfil in Great Britain.
Comment on this
No. Deputy Lavery was asking us why we could not follow theirs in which he said the Crown was merely a symbol and an old tradition. That is the view of this eminent Irish constitutional lawyer, but it is one with which I think most of the British constitutional lawyers would completely disagree.
Deputy Lavery says that we should take over this institution which, he says, does nothing except sign on the dotted line in Great Britain, as the apex of our whole political organisation in this country. All of us know what happened in the last 15 years. Was there ever once when the office of Governor-General was associated with any useful or valuable act for this country? It could not do anything even if a crisis arose; it could not act or operate in any way to try to get the country to come together. I hope that one of the things which the President will do will be to get united and concerted action in times of crisis, to try to smooth away the differences which have divided us in the past 15 years. Certainly, that could not be done by any person who claimed to act, no matter how nominally or insignificantly, as the representative of an outside power. I do not know what may happen elsewhere, but I am perfectly certain that if modern democracy is to continue, there must be within the democratic Constitution some office which will discharge the function and perform the duties which this Constitution will confer upon the new President.
Comment on this
I have an example of many countries where democracy has been a failure, where it did not obtain.
Comment on this
Have you an example of any country which has been pulled out of the failure of democracy by having a President with these powers?
Comment on this
I shall continue to deal with Deputy Lavery's points if Deputy McGilligan will permit me to do so. I know that he was not here to listen to Deputy Lavery's speech. If he had heard Deputy Lavery, I am sure he could not contain himself just as he cannot contain himself listening to me.
Comment on this
One of the points which Deputy Lavery made was that the President under the new Constitution was to be above the law. I had the temerity to ask him to cite me the Article upon which that point of view was based. He also said that the President would be debarred from acting in external affairs. I am going to deal with one point first, the point that the President is to be above the law, that he would be able to act in defiance of the Government and of the two Houses of the Oireachtas. I do not think that Deputy Lavery could have read the Constitution. I move the adjournment of the debate.