Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Dara Céim (d'aththógaint).
Contributions 1–92 of 182. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When I was speaking last evening I had not the advantage of having before me the exact text of some of the statements for which Deputy Lavery made himself responsible in the course of the debate last evening. I have since, however, had an opportunity of perusing his speech, and as a result of that I have to marvel at the audacity with which Deputy Lavery was consistently inconsistent. For instance, in dealing with the position of the new President he says: "The functions he exercises if he (the King) is Commander-in-Chief of the forces, if he signs Bills in order that they may become law—if he does all these formal things, it is because he is a tradition and a symbol. It is quite another thing for this State, where there is no such tradition, to take the cue from that traditional institution to appoint a President merely for the purpose of doing these formal acts." The formal act in this case is appending his signature to a Bill which is the final enactory act and the promulgating of the statute.
The other formal thing is that the President can act as commander-in-chief of the defence forces. But, scarcely three minutes later, Deputy Lavery, in dealing with the same high office, the office of President of the State, says:
"As I say, the President may hold the same views or different views from the head of the Government. In either case, he may be a source of danger to the State because he is supreme commander of the forces."
That position has no longer become a purely formal one, as Deputy Lavery held it to have been about 200 words before. In the course of three minutes, it has become a position in which the President may be a source of danger to the State. Then—
"he must sign Bills before they become law; he must promulgate the law,"
says Deputy Lavery three minutes after he has informed this House that the signing of a Bill and promulgation of a law is a purely formal act. The fact that there is a person to sign the Bill has created a source of danger to the State, according to Deputy Lavery three minutes after he has proclaimed that the act is merely a formal one. Then he goes on to say:
"He has the right of pardon and commutation and, above all, he is not answerable to either House in the exercise of his powers."
Let me again remind the House of what Deputy Lavery said in this latter part of his speech dealing with the position of President. He said: "He may be a source of danger to the State because he is the supreme commander of the defence forces. He must sign Bills before they become law; he must promulgate the law. He has the right of pardon and commutation and, above all, he is not answerable to either House in the exercise of his powers." I find it very difficult to believe that a gentleman with the high public reputation that Deputy Lavery enjoys could have made a statement of that sort, categorically dealing with aspects of the Presidency which may become a source of danger to the State, and including in that category the fact that the President was to be supreme commander of the forces and that he must sign Bills before they become law and that he has the right of pardon if he had read the Constitution. The fact that the President has these three rights under the Constitution, according to Deputy Lavery, constitutes him a source of danger to the State.
I say that I find it hard to believe that a gentleman who enjoys the public reputation that he enjoys should have made himself responsible for making such statements in so important a debate as this if he had read the Constitution. If he had read the Constitution and, consequently, made these statements knowing that, in fact, there is no foundation in the text of the Constitution for them, then I can only assume that Deputy Lavery has lent himself and lent his high legal reputation to the service and use of the Opposition for the purpose of bamboozling the public in regard to this matter. There cannot be any other explanation. Either Deputy Lavery did not read the Constitution, or Deputy Lavery is consciously, and for the propose of the Opposition in this debate, lending himself in order to mislead and deceive the public. It is a shameful thing that a person who, as I say, enjoys a high public reputation should lend himself to a trick of that sort.
Let us see what the position is in regard to the supreme command of the forces. If Deputies will turn to Article 13 they will find that Section 4 of that Article provides that "the supreme command of the defence forces is hereby vested in the President." That is the section which deals with the command of the defence forces. But Section 5 of the same Article goes on to say "the exercise of the supreme command of the defence forces shall be regulated by law." It is clear that for a certain purpose the supreme command of the defence forces is vested in the President. Why? In order definitely and for all time to take the Army in this country out of the arena of politics. The President, according to this Constitution, is to be the non-political head of the State. Notwithstanding the suggestions that have been made here in the course of the debate, that that is not practically possible, I say that there is no serious force in the objection, and I do believe that we shall see that ideal realised. We have, Sir, a non-political judiciary. Several members of that judiciary have served in this House as members of a political party both under the present Administration and under the Administration of our predecessors. Is there any person here who will get up and say that the conduct of these judges since they were elevated to high office has been other than non-political and non-partisan?
Comment on this
They had to undergo election. The former Chief Justice of this State was elected as member of a Dublin City constituency, and appeared in this House as Attorney-General for a political party and the Government——
Comment on this
I will not be overpessimistic about this point if the Minister will allow me to say——
Comment on this
I would like to remind the Minister of what happens in America where the judges have to be elected.
Comment on this
Yes, but the position is entirely different here. I am perfectly certain that the one sure way for the President to secure re-election ——
Comment on this
——will be to abstain from active participation in Party politics during the period that he holds office, and show that he will not be a partisan and that he will be, what under this Constitution he is intended to be, the head of the State, charged with a solemn duty to safeguard and secure the liberty of every citizen irrespective of Party.
I was going on to show that the reason why the President is to be in supreme command of the Army is in order that the Army might definitely be taken out of Party politics. He is to be the people's President and to represent all the people in the State, and the people will understand as he is to be the titular head of the Army that the Army is to be the people's Army and is there to defend the rights of every citizen under this Constitution. That is the position as the Constitution envisages it.
What of the position in which the Army has been placed by those who criticise us for selecting the first citizen in the land to be the supreme commander of the Army? What is the present position of the Army? If it is undesirable that the supreme command should be vested in the President, what is to be said with regard to the present position of the Army which under Section 5 of the Defence Forces (Temporary Provisions) Act of 1923 is vested in that political body known as the Executive Council, which not merely has to undergo election by the people but subsequent nomination and, in the case of the President, subsequent election and nomination by a vote of this House? Here is the present position of the Army. "The command-in-chief of and all executive and administrative powers in relation to the forces including the power to delegate authority to such persons as may be thought fit shall be vested in the Executive Council and exercised through and in the name of the Minister for Defence." I am interpolating "for defence" there. The section continues, "the Minister who shall not however allocate to himself any executive military command and who may not be a member of the forces on full pay." What effective difference is there between the command of the Army as at present embodied, and which by the statute is vested in the Executive Council, and as it will be under the new Constitution where the supreme command will be vested, as I have said, in the President and where it is provided that the exercise of the supreme command is to be regulated by law?
How can the President in such circumstances, even if he has dictatorial ambitions, utilise the Army in order to realise such ambitions? But Deputy Lavery, who is a learned lawyer and who, not for the first time, has considered constitutional matters and not for the first time has considered the position of the Army and the defence forces under the existing Constitution, comes along here and says that the position under the new Constitution, which if anything is an improvement on the present existing Constitution or, at all events, on all fours with it, would become in certain circumstances a source of danger to the State. Again, I say that Deputy Lavery could not have studied these Articles if he made that statement in sincerity and in good faith. He could not have read this Draft Constitution carefully, nor could he have read the statutes relating to the present command of the Army and the disposition of the defence forces if he made that statement in good faith.
Then another attribute of the President, which Deputy Lavery alleges would constitute the President a source of danger to the State, is that he has the right of pardon and commutation. Undoubtedly, the President has that right. It is conferred on him, I think, by Section 6 of Article 13, which reads:
"The right of pardon and the power to commute punishment imposed by any court exercising criminal jurisdiction are hereby vested in the President."
That is provided for in Section 6 of Article 13 of the Draft Constitution, and with this saver—
"but such power of commutation may, except in capital cases, also be conferred by law on other authorities."
The saver, so far as the aspect of the law which I am at present discussing is concerned, is not of great importance. But what is of great importance is Section 9 of Article 13, which goes on to say:
"The powers and functions conferred on the President by this Constitution shall be exercisable and performable by him only on the advice of the Government, save where it is provided that he shall act in his absolute discretion or after consultation with or in relation to the Council of State, or on the advice or nomination of, or in receipt of any other communication from any other person or body."
The House will notice the provisos and savers in this section—
"save where it is provided that he shall act in his absolute discretion."
Otherwise the powers and functions conferred on the President shall be exercisable and performable by him only on the advice of the Government. If Deputies are interested in this matter, I would ask them to turn to Section 6 of Article 13 and they will not find any proviso in the text of that Article empowering the President to act in his absolute discretion.
If the right of pardon and the power of commutation are vested in the President by Section 6 of Article 13, according to Article 9 those functions are exercisable and performable by him only on the advice of the Government, and the Government are responsible to this House and to the people for whatsoever advice they might give to the President in a matter of this kind. Is not that the present position? Deputy Lavery, who can conceive a source of danger in the fact that the President, elected by the people, has the right of pardon and the power of commutation, did not see any objection to having that right vested in the nominal representative of another power and another authority. A former Governor-General had the right of pardon and the power of commutation. A former Governor-General exercised it, as the President under the new Constitution will exercise it, on the advice, and only on the advice of the Executive Council, the Government of the day.
What difference is there between the two positions? If there is no difference between the two, what justification is there for Deputy Lavery, a person who enjoys a deservedly high reputation as a lawyer and as a public man, getting up here and endeavouring to arouse uneasiness in the public mind because the head of the State, as the symbol of the people's authority, is the source of mercy and consideration in the State? Again I say that Deputy Lavery must not have read this Constitution. Deputy Lavery is a lawyer. His high legal reputation should not be used in order to bamboozle and deceive the people as to what really is involved in this important document.
Let me come to another aspect of this matter. I referred to that part of Deputy Lavery's speech which was delivered about three minutes anterior in time to the portion in which he described the office of President of the State as a source of danger to the State. I come back to that portion of the speech in which he says that if the President signs a Bill in order that it may become law, he does merely a formal thing. I wonder has Deputy Lavery—I am not a lawyer, I am a layman—read and studied this Constitution and is it his considered opinion that under it the President, when he signs a Bill, does a mere formal thing? That may be the position in England, but it certainly is not the position of the President under the new Constitution, because the President's signature under that new Constitution is of the utmost public importance. It carries with it two public guarantees.
We all of us know the confusion which has been created in one of the leading communities of the world, one of the most powerful and one of the wealthiest States, by the fact that laws which were passed by the Legislature were afterwards declared by the Supreme Court to be unconstitutional. We know the confusion which that possibility creates in the public mind. We know the uncertainty which, in consequence of such a possibility, permeates business circles. We know how the whole course of trade and industry might be impeded and held up by the fact that an important measure touching the economic interests of a large number of citizens, even while it is in operation and even though it has been in operation for some appreciable time, might be declared by a judicial authority to be unconstitutional. It is a difficulty which those who have to frame written Constitutions must deal with. They are writing the fundamental law of the State and if the State is to develop and if the law is to be accepted and the whole machinery is to work, people at any rate must have a reasonable assurance that the laws under which they live are valid laws and will prevail.
That difficulty has been faced in this Constitution in this way, by the power which is given to the President and by the duty and responsibility which are imposed upon him before he signs a law of being reasonably certain in his own mind that it is not contrary to the Constitution. It does put the President undoubtedly in a position of great power, but I think no less power and no less authority is necessary if the democratic régime is going to survive in this country. One of the criticisms most frequently levelled against democracies is that they are so slow and that they are so uncertain; that when decisions are taken by democracies they may be reversed, or, where the democracy has a written Constitution, that some other people, some other court and some other organ not at all amenable to the people may step in and overthrow or override the decisions of the Legislature.
At the same time, if we are to have constitutional government at all, even the Legislature must be bound by the Constitution, and one of the functions and duties and responsibilities which is reposed in the President under this Constitution is that before he appends his signature to the law, if he has any doubt in his mind about it—and a doubt must for him create the prima facie case—that the proposed enactment may be repugnant to the Constitution—he must refer the matter to the Supreme Court and if the Supreme Court, having decided the issue within a reasonable period of time, find that the enactment is not contrary to the Constitution, he signs the law and his signature to that law is no mere formal act. It is the guarantee that, at any rate, that law was not contrary to the Constitution.
The other important function which the President has under this Constitution is this, that upon him there is cast the responsibility of seeing that, if a fundamental change is to be made in the law which, in his view, is of such moment, importance and effect as to, I should say, upset the real balance in the Constitution, and if the majority of the Second House and a substantial section of the Lower House have also taken that view, the whole matter is referred to the people, who express their views upon it; and the President's signature to a law is a guarantee that, in fact, either he does not believe that or that he, believing it, has not got the necessary support in the other two organs of the Constitution to enable him to take a referendum of the people. Therefore, it is not true to describe the President of the new State as a mere formal functionary. He has important constitutional duties to discharge, and the fact that he appends his signature to the law is a guarantee that he has, indeed, discharged them.
Let me come back again, Sir, to that part of Deputy Lavery's speech in which he was painting the new President as a bogeyman for the delectation of his colleagues on the Opposition Benches and of such people as might be so foolish as not to read and study this Constitution for themselves. For, Sir, the Constitution is drafted so lucidly and so clearly that those who do take the trouble to study the document as a whole will not be deceived by statements such as Deputy Lavery has made himself responsible for. I come back, however——
Comment on this
I am dealing with Deputy Lavery's speech. In the short compass of six lines, Deputy Lavery has made himself responsible——
Comment on this
For all this. Precisely—for all this—because Deputy Lavery contended himself with making bald statements and not adducing one title of evidence to support his case. Deputy Lavery and Deputy McGuire, as lawyers, ought to know what would happen to them if they went into court and made a pure ex parte statement and did not produce a title of evidence in support of it.
Comment on this
I said, Sir, that in the short compass of about four lines Deputy Lavery has made himself responsible for no less than five misstatements, but I come to one, which is not a misstatement, but which has been included simply to heighten the horrific picture of the powers of the President which Deputy Lavery was endeavouring to put before the people of this country; and that is that the President has the right of pardon and is above the law. Now, Sir, it is an extraordinary thing that Deputy Lavery, who feels that there is a menace to the State in the fact that the head of the State should be above the law, does not object himself to the immunity which, under the existing Constitution, certain other people enjoy in respect of the law. I have heard statements made in this House, particularly by one Deputy from the Opposition Benches, which, if they were made outside, would involve that Deputy in a charge for criminal libel. I have heard Deputy James Dillon get up and charge Ministers of this House with nothing short of corruption, and Deputy Dillon, in that regard, has been above the law. An action for libel would not lie against him or against Deputy Patrick McGilligan in regard to statements which they make inside this House, and which they are careful to make inside this House. Why is that? It is because that according to Article 18 of the Constitution, these Deputies, so long as they are members of the Oireachtas—and they must be members of the Oireachtas so long as they are Deputies—enjoy a certain immunity. Article 18 says:—
"Every member of the Oireachtas shall, except in case of treason, felony, or breach of the peace, be privileged from arrest in going to and returning from, and while within the precincts of Dáil Eireann, and shall not, in respect of any utterance in Dáil Eireann, be amenable to any action or proceeding in any court other than Dáil Eireann itself."
So they are above the law—they are above the law of libel and slander— and so long as their utterances are made in Dáil Eireann they are outside the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts. They are subject, of course, to Dáil Eireann itself, and can be made amenable in the Court of Dáil Eireann, because Article 18 clearly does contemplate that, for certain purposes, Dáil Eireann might constitute itself a court to try, say, Deputy Dillon or Deputy Patrick McGilligan.
Further, Sir, not merely under the existing Constitution are persons above the law, but institutions and things are above the law, because Article 19 lays it down that:
"All official reports and publications of the Oireachtas or of Dáil Eireann shall be privileged, and utterances made in Dáil Eireann, wherever published, shall be priviledged."
So, not merely are Deputies above the law, but in regard to utterances of theirs delivered in Dáil Eireann which, if they were not delivered in Dáil Eireann, would, if published in any newspaper, make that newspaper liable to be sued, a special privilege is conferred upon the newspaper, and that is the present position in regard to some of the minor institutions, or rather some of the institutions of the State.
Comment on this
Well, possibly I was thinking of the individuals, and not of the institutions. However, not merely do Deputies enjoy a certain immunity and are they above the law in certain respects, but Ministers of State also are above the law in certain other respects, or may be above the law in certain circumstances. We are not responsible for having drafted the Ministers and Secretaries Act of 1924. That was drafted and enacted in the time of our predecessors, but it contains a provision to the following effect:—
"Ministers may sue and, subject to the fiat of the Attorney-General having been in each case first granted, be sued under style or name aforesaid, and may acquire, hold and dispose of land for the purposes of the functions, powers or duties of the Department of State of which he is head or of any branch thereof."
So that, in certain circumstances, Ministers may be immune, not merely from the consequences of utterances made in the Dáil, but from the consequences of certain of their acts. If they can prevail upon the Attorney-General —if they were so ill-advised and so wrong as to try to prevail upon the Attorney-General not to issue his fiat, in certain cases Ministers cannot be sued. They are above the law, just as in certain circumstances it is proposed to place the head of the State above the law. That immunity was formerly a far-reaching one. Prior, I think, to the passage of the Transport Act or the Road Traffic Act—I am not sure which—of 1934, the Minister for Finance could not have been sued. If a vehicle belonging to him were to kill a pedestrian in the street, an action for damages even would not lie against him, and any payment that might be made to the dependents or personal representatives of a pedestrian killed in such circumstances would have been made as an act of grace. It would not have been made because the Minister was responsible under the law; in fact, he was not.
We, all of us, know the old principle that an indictment against the Crown does not lie, and the position is the same as regards the judges.
Comment on this
But as long as a person was Minister of the Crown an indictment against him did not lie. Why should the head of the State, why should the people's President, be put in a less privileged position?
Comment on this
Yes, and the divine right of peoples if the Deputy wants it that way. We may go to whatever extremes, right or left, we wish, but ultimately the circle closes. In any event, the gentlemen who could not see anything wrong in permitting the representative of the Crown to be above the law come along now and say, as true democrats, that the people's President, the symbol of the people's authority, the guardian of the people's constitutional liberties, should not be placed by our Constitution at least upon the same plane as the Constitution which they drafted, and of which they got the people to approve, placed the representative of the British King. And, Sir, what ill consequences have flown from the fact that the Governor-General and the Ministers of the King in this country have hitherto enjoyed the immunities to which I have referred? We are dealing now with constitutional theories. Deputy O'Sullivan laughs. Deputy O'Sullivan even taunted us with the fact that we were Ministers of the King. We were until December last.
Comment on this
We were until December last, when the functions of the Sovereign in our internal affairs completely vanished. One of the grounds upon which the Opposition are prepared to criticise this Constitution is that it confers certain immunity upon the person chosen by the people to be the head of their State. We are told that this is going to be a source of danger to the State. But is it, in fact, true that the head of the State is placed in so privileged a position as to be above the law? I have said that I could not believe that Deputy Lavery had read this Constitution, for, if he did, he could not have made himself responsible for some of the statements to which he has given the support of his public reputation. Under Section 10 of Article 12 it is laid down that the President may be impeached at the instance of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of Seanad Eireann for treason as defined in this Constitution, or other high crimes or misdemeanours. If Deputy Dillon or Deputy McGilligan may be tried by the High Court of Dáil Eireann under the existing Constitution in respect of any utterances in Dáil Eireann, surely the High Court of the Oireachtas is as competent and is as suitable a tribunal before which to impeach a President who may be guilty of treason as defined in this Constitution or other high crimes or misdemeanours?
Provision is made in the Constitution, which, I think, it will not be necessary to avail of, but, should it be so necessary, will be availed of, to make the President amenable to certain aspects of the law, those aspects of the law which touch his administration and conduct in the high constitutional office to which he has been called. If he is guilty of the supreme crime of treason against the State or other crimes or misdemeanours of equal gravity, provision is made here in the Constitution to make the President amenable to the law. But for the lesser offences, would it be a seeming thing that the person who has been chosen by the people to be the keystone of their State, to be the apex of their political organisation, to be the symbol of their authority, should be hailed before the ordinary courts of the law and made answerable to those courts for minor crimes and offences in respect to which you grant immunity to the judges of those courts? If it is wrong that the President of the State should be granted the immunity which is conferred upon him by Section 8 of Article 13 of the Constitution, surely it is equally wrong that judges should be granted a similar immunity, that Ministers of the Crown should be granted a similar immunity, and that in respect of the most despicable crime in the whole calendar, the crime of slander, immunity should be granted to certain Deputies of this House—to all Deputies of this House, only there are some who are more careful of their neighbours' reputation than to be guilty of the crime. That is the position.
Comment on this
I should like, before I sit down, just to deal briefly with the amendment which is before the House in the name of Deputy Donnelly. I am as interested as Deputy Donnelly in this problem of Partition. I am as concerned as he is that Partition should be undone and our country reunited. Therefore, if Deputy Donnelly's amendment would, in fact, do anything to restore the political unity of our country, I should have a great deal of sympathy with it. But, let us study the amendment and particularly the reasons which are set out in it—the purposes for which Deputy Donnelly asks that the Second Reading of the Constitution be deferred to a date not sooner than 1st January, 1938. The first of these is that a special Governmental Department be set up for the purpose of uniting and co-ordinating all the anti-Partition forces in Ireland, North and South. If this Constitution is passed, will it make it any more difficult to set up such a special Governmental Department?
But would it be practicable, in fact, to set up such a special Governmental Department to-day for the purpose of uniting and co-ordinating all the anti-Partition forces in Ireland North and South, irrespective of political or religious outlook? The purpose is an ambitious, is a comprehensive, one. I presume it would mean that this Governmental Department would take upon itself to encroach upon the territory of another administrative unit in the country; it would get in touch with public representatives there, irrespective of political or religious outlook, and co-ordinate and unite them for the purpose—in so far as any purpose is expressed here—of focussing world opinion on this grave national issue, and pressing the English Government to reopen negotiations on the reunification of Ireland. Does Deputy Donnelly, or any person who really understands the position as it exists in the North to-day, think that any Governmental Department, any Department established under the authority and with the support of this Dail, has the slightest chance of doing anything practical or effective to unite or co-ordinate all the anti-Partition forces in Ireland North and South, irrespective of political or religious outlook?
How would Deputy Donnelly, for instance, deal with the people who do not acknowledge the authority of this Dáil at all? How would he deal with those who, possibly, might be broadly classified as having the same political outlook as we have in so far as they would seek to reunify the country, but who feel at this moment that their best chance of doing anything to serve this country is to go and sit in the Northern Parliament? Again, how would he deal with those others who, while they would be prepared to accept the authority of this Dáil, at the same time would not seek election to the Northern Parliament? How does he think that it would be possible for any Department set up, as I said before, under the authority of this Dáil, to unite and co-ordinate people holding these three divergent views? I think Deputy Donnelly ought to have told us how this union and coordination was to be brought about, before he asked the Dáil to take the very serious and grave step of deferring the Second Reading of this Constitution until a date not sooner than 1st January, 1938. At least, I think he ought to have been in a position to say to this Dáil, when he was bringing in this resolution, that he had received assurances from people who might not merely not have the same political, but not even the same religious outlook as the great majority of us here, that they would be prepared to act in union and in coordination with each other, and in cooperation with this Governmental Department in order to bring Partition to an end. It is easy to put those fine, florid phrases down on paper——
Comment on this
——but it is much more difficult to try to devise machinery which will give practical effect to them.
Comment on this
The next reason which Deputy Donnelly advances for deferring the Second Reading of this Constitution is that our attention should be devoted to organising the Irish race abroad for their assistance and support, and focussing, through the home and foreign Press, world opinion on this grave national issue. How, Sir, could world opinion be better focussed on this grave national issue than it has been during the last ten days by the publication of this draft Constitution, which includes, among other Articles, Articles 1, 2 and 3? I think that more has been done by the publication of this Constitution to direct world attention to the fact that our country has been divided than could be done by any Governmental Department or Governmental agency. Yet, notwithstanding the fact that this draft Constitution has, in such a signal way, drawn the attention of the world and of the Irish race at home and abroad to the fact that our country is partitioned, Deputy Donnelly asks us to defer consideration of it until a date not sooner than 1st January, 1938.
The fourth reason put forward is that we should press the English Government to reopen negotiations on the reunification of Ireland. I think Deputy Donnelly ought to have been much more explicit than in fact he was in dealing with that aspect of his motion when he was speaking in this House. He ought to have told us what exactly he means by this proposal to press the English Government to reopen negotiations on the reunification of Ireland. In every discussion which the present Government has had with the British Government in regard to matters affecting the relations between this country and Great Britain, the fact has been stressed that there will be no really satisfactory solution of the difficulties until this question of Partition is met and solved to the satisfaction of the whole people of Ireland. The matter has been kept continuously before the minds of British statesmen, and I think that any person who studies their Press, who studies their pronouncements, must have but one opinion, and that is that they themselves are sufficiently aware of the vital importance of trying to find a solution for this very vexed problem. But that solution is not going to be hastened, and no greater pressure could be brought to bear upon British statesmen to solve it by giving effect to the terms of Deputy Donnelly's amendment.
I do not see how such statesmen could be thrown into such a state of panic if we deferred giving a Second Reading to this Draft Constitution until a date "not sooner than January 1st, 1938," that they would be prepared to reopen negotiations on the reunification of Ireland. I think it is much more likely that the passage of this Constitution would make them consider the problem of Partition much more seriously than would its deferment to a date "not sooner than January 1st, 1938," and therefore I think that while Deputy Donnelly may have been quite justified in putting down this motion in order to call attention to the existence of the Partition problem, nevertheless I cannot see that any practical good will come from the Dáil adopting and giving effect to it. I am perfectly certain that when Deputy Donnelly studies the position for himself he will see that there is no use pressing an amendment of that sort.
I am sorry that I have detained the House so long in regard to this matter. I have had to deal with some of the statements for which Deputy Lavery made himself responsible. I hope, however, that I have not dealt with him in such a way as to intensify the asperities which sometimes exist in this House. I hope that if the debate on the Constitution is to be continued that, instead of playing the old political game of trying to create bogies and point to dangers and pitfalls where in fact they do not exist; that instead of surrounding this Constitution with fictitious objections, those who do feel and who still carry in their hearts some remnant of the spirit that inspired them in 1916-21 will come along and say that "after all, we know that this is the sort of Constitution that we would like to have been able to draft and put before the people in 1922; this is the sort of Constitution that we thought when we signed the Treaty we should be able to get for the people; this is the sort of Constitution which contains no symbol of British authority; this is a Constitution drafted, as I said yesterday, for Irishmen by Irishmen, and we will co-operate with the Government in making it as sound and as good as possible." It has been our responsibility and it has been our lot to prepare the original draft. It has been drafted as carefully as men could do who had considerable experience behind them, by men who have gone through a rather trying time during the past four or five years. We have seen the dangers to which democracy may be exposed if there is not a proper balance of power and authority in the Constitution. We have tried so far as we can to secure the people and the State against such dangers. I hope that those who sit on the opposite benches will appreciate the spirit in which this Draft Constitution is offered to them: that instead, as I say, of trying to create bogies, that they will come along and deal with the facts of the Constitution, which has its merits and no doubt its defects also. Let us hope that we shall all try to enhance its merits and remedy its defects, so that we may make this Constitution, which is to be the fundamental law of the State, one which will give us stability in internal affairs, one which will enable us to restore peace and concord among our own people, one which will give us a rule of order to guide us in the future—in short, a Constitution to which all our people will subscribe and which they will accept as binding upon them as loyal citizens of the motherland.
Comment on this
After the very concise and conciliatory speech of the ex-Minister of the Crown who has just sat down—ex- only since last December —of the ex-Minister of the King who has just sat down, ex- only since last December, I feel chary about discussing the Constitution at all. In view of the gentle spirit with which the Opposition has been dealt with and of the fact that we have been asked to consider this Constitution in a non-Party atmosphere, it is very difficult, I confess, to live up to the high standards that have been set us by the Minister—his conciseness, clarity of exposition and clarity of expression. I hope, Sir, that he did not raise a new constitutional issue. I cannot recall all that happened last December, but I hope sufficient provision was made to carry him over from being a Minister of the Crown to being a Minister of State. I hope that that was properly looked after and that he is now a Minister of something. That is a matter that does not quite arise at the moment, but I was a little uneasy about his position. I did get the suspicion— I do not know if it was well-founded— I hope not—that there was an effort being made, judging by the length of the speech we have listened to, to create an artificial interest in this Constitution that it otherwise lacks. It is very hard to understand the speech of the Minister under any other supposition. For, the fact is, that this Constitution that proclaims all sorts of things has not evoked the slightest interest in the country for which it has been promulgated.
We have been asked by the President to consider this in a non-Party fashion, not to make it an election issue. That is the last thing the Government would think of doing! They really want the people of this country to concentrate on the real facts that the people ought to concentrate on, the economic issues and the development of the country, but the last thing the Government would desire would be to make this Constitution a Party issue at the elections, and so divert their attention from these matters! For that reason, fully carrying out that spirit as the Minister who has just sat down has carried it out, we have the President going down to Clare to a Fianna Fáil Convention and orating there on the Constitution. At two other conventions we had two Ministers who also dealt with the Constitution. I admit, according to the views of the Government, that nothing could be more above Party, nothing more national, than a Fianna Fáil Convention. The best proof of the non-Party attitude was the line taken up by the President. He asks us to do these things. I might have been a little surprised if I had not very long experience of the President, if I did not know that the President's words very often mean the very opposite of what they seem to mean on a first examination. The non-Party atmosphere! Full criticism and full co-operation!
We see an extraordinary display of pettishness—I cannot use any higher term—when there is an attempt to point out some very patent omissions, some very patent faults, in this Constitution. People are railed at and told that they are deceiving the people; that they are prostituting their high position in a great profession to Party interests merely because an attempt is made to bring before the people and the Dáil certain grave faults in this Constitution. We have had repeated in the House here by the President himself and by his Minister—the ex-Minister of the Crown and the ex-President of the Crown—that any important criticisms that were put before the country and before the House could only be explained by a desire on the part of those putting them forward to deceive the people. Yet an attitude of high reasonableness is adopted by the very people who resent the slightest criticism of anything that they do or of anything in this Constitution. That is all called the spirit of democracy!
I do not think the country thinks this is an important measure. I know it does not. My experience for the last six months, when there was talk about this Constitution coming forward, when everybody expected to see it week after week, is that there was not the slightest interest in the Constitution. Since the text has been published, down the country and here in the city I find no display of interest in this Constitution by the great bulk of the people. We know perfectly well that when there is anything of any importance on in the Dáil, the approaches to Leinster House are crowded and there is difficulty in finding places in the strangers' gallery and in the ordinary gallery. The absence of any such demonstration of that kind, any such physical attendance of the people at the entrance to the Dáil is symptomatic of the profound interest of the people of this city and of the people of the country in this Constitution! There is no interest in this Constitution in the country. When dealing with an ex-Minister of the Crown like the President I do not like to use the word rigmarole. But if he had not been in such an exalted position—and we heard to-day from the Minister for Finance how exalted the position of a Minister of the Crown is—I would almost call it a rigmarole to which we had to listen.
It is impossible to believe that the President expects the people to take this thing seriously. The people, as I say, do not take it seriously. The President asked us to do certain things. He asks for a detailed, careful, non-Party, judicious examination of this Constitution and he adopts measures to secure that any deliberate or full consideration of it by us or by the people is impossible. If he wanted any such consideration, why does he bring it in now on the eve of a general election? Why did he not bring it in two years ago? Why not postpone it for another 12 months until the election is over, so that people can be interested in the details of the Constitution, if they feel so inclined?
How can they be interested in the details of the Constitution at the present time? Everybody who knows this country knows that they are much more interested in the general election and the result of it than they are in this pettifogging amendment of the Constitution brought forward here. They are not interested in this amendment of the Constitution. It is wrong that it should be brought forward now. The pretence is that we are going to have the verdict of the people on this Constitution. We are going to have nothing of the kind. In present conditions, it is impossible that you can get the real verdict of the people on this Constitution. The bulk of them are not going to bother their heads about it one way or the other. They may vote for or against it, but whether they vote for or against it, it will not be as a result of having examined the Constitution or of the interest displayed in it.
The President, by fixing this debate now, by putting the decision to the people on the same day as the general election, as I understand he is going to do—whether it is on the same day or not does not matter so long as the election looms ahead or looms there with the Constitution— has seen to it that the people will not give this Constitution the consideration that he professes it deserves. Many will simply ignore it. Then the claim will be put forward that this Constitution has got the fiat of the people; that the people consented to the shackles this Constitution puts upon them. Nothing could be further from the truth than such a contention.
Any referendum under present conditions with a general election on vital issues, in which the people are much more interested than they are in this Constitution coming on, is a mere sham and adds nothing to the authority that an instrument like it has. He has taken every step—and it is very difficult to believe that in doing so he was not acting deliberately— that would militate against his professed desires in this particular matter. We had him yesterday deliberately adopting an attitude of sweet reasonableness in proposing a measure that is not reasonable and a course of conduct as regards that measure that is the opposite of reasonable, namely, asking the people to consider it at the present time.
Yesterday we had a striking example of the difference between the professions of the President, on the one hand, and his practices and actions on the other hand. He made an appeal to the lawyers to help him with this Constitution. It was quite obvious that he was quite genuine! The only condition he would require—but he did not state it—was, that they would agree with him. If they stated that it was splendid, that all the criticism levelled at it in the Press was wrong, then they were men learned in the law and good sound patriots. That is what he meant by asking their help. Their help to amend the Constitution meant praise for everything in it, not a word of criticism. I admit that the President always did love that sort of liberty. I will admit further that he will not impose anything on any body so long as that body does what he wants. The lawyers will have his full approval and nobody could be more hearty of approval in circumstances of that kind. A learned man in his profession is the person who is blind to the faults of this Constitution. A good Irishman and a sound patriot is a man who follows the President to the destruction of the interests of the country.
He told us that when drawing up this Constitution he was not thinking of the lawyers. I will say for him that he never had much use for lawyers or courts, Supreme or otherwise. He confessed yesterday that he did not think they were up to much, even the Supreme Court, so far as protecting the fundamental rights of the people is concerned. He would like something better. He is always striving for the ideal he can never get. He tells us that he did not think of the lawyers. He had only the plain people of Ireland before his mind. Did he consult them about this Constitution? Was there a tittle of an indication of what is in this Constitution before it was published? He will say he is going to consult the people; they are going to have a choice; they can reject this Constitution if they like. Is that consultation—to fling a document of this kind at the people and say, "Take it or leave it"? That is what he calls consultation; that is looking to the wishes of the people by flinging it at them in circumstances that prevent them considering them. They cannot, as I have said, possibly consider this Constitution. They are much more interested in other matters; their minds are full of other things. Therefore, there is no consultation with the people, though he professes such a profound desire to consult their wishes and fall in with their desire. As far as we can judge, every word of the President's yesterday backs this opinion up. What has been the attitude really adopted? Consulting the Irish people? Completely unnecessary. The obvious way for the President to consult the Irish people is to look into his own heart, and when he knows what is there he knows what the Irish people want. Then he retires to his study. I do not know that he even consults the Cabinet—he may have. Listening to the President one would think he did not consult them, but listening to the Minister for Finance one could see that there was a kind of effort made there to say, "We have some responsibility for it, too."
The President retires to his study, looks into his own heart and produces this. Then the Irish people are to say whether they will have it or not, "take it or leave it." They have to take it or leave it, but if they do take it, the shackles that are in this Constitution will be bound on them for a long time. That is democracy! That is looking after the interests of the people! That is letting the Irish people express their views! A plain, simple man coming forward in plain, simple language that everybody interprets differently puts forth his views on fundamental matters before the ordinary people of Ireland. And of course, suffering from his ordinary complaint, the poor man is misunderstood and his words are misinterpreted ! Nobody can understand him! Of course it is always their fault that they cannot understand him! It is not always through want of intelligence that they are at fault; they wilfully misunderstand him. It is a hard, wicked world, Sir. I wonder why he does not retire to the garden and eat worms, everybody is so bent on misinterpreting his plain, obvious words and wishes. But the plain words seem to mean something different from what he says he intends. Yet to call these words in question is almost high treason, though luckily not so provided for in the Constitution. But there are Articles in the Constitution which if passed would prevent the Press calling these things in question. Understand that the people must be educated to have a proper respect for the Government, so we may be accustomed in the future to find that the Press had better get into a proper frame of mind and get to understand the real wishes of the President behind his words. But unfortunately it is not with the wishes of the President that we are concerned just now. It is with the words that are being put before us in this Draft Constitution. We had the familiar bleat from the President in Clare recently and here yesterday that he is being misinterpreted and misunderstood. Is it not time that the President was able to make some one statement that was clear to somebody except himself? The President has had pretty fair practice in the making of statements, and he ought to be able to express his views now so that the ordinary person might understand him.
We on this side have a certain amount of difficulty in discussing this instrument. I feel, and I think the people feel, that the whole thing is a deception. It is undoubtedly a matter of importance for the official Opposition Party how far they should lend any countenance to what is a deception of the people. The people at the present moment are faced with a deception. This is intended to be a red herring across the path of the ordinary people to divert their minds from the ordinary things which they are to face. Let any member of the Government Party speak for 2½ hours, 3½ hours, or even 4½ hours, and indicate to us what problem, national or economic, that faces this country at the present moment is brought a single inch nearer solution by the enactment of this amendment of the Constitution? I do not ask that the Constitution should solve these things. The answer will be easy enough, and we will be told that that is not the business of the Constitution. But I want to know how this Constitution helps and what contribution it gives towards solving these problems. These are weighty problems. And when these weighty problems are waiting to be considered we are asked to divert the attention of this House and the attention of the country from really important matters affecting the people to trifles of this kind so far as the good is concerned, but not trifles, unfortunately, where everything is concerned, because there are matters in this Constitution that give ground for a certain amount of grave uneasiness.
We have been told about the urgency of this matter. What is the urgency? We are told by the President that this is most urgent. Why? Why is it necessary that this discredited Party and its dying Parliament should bring forward as its last act this particular matter? Could it not wait until the country has pronounced on the policy of the Government as a whole? Could it not wait until the country has pronounced judgment on this Dáil and on the Government Party? What is the urgency? There is none, Sir, except the imminence of the general election and to divert the attention of the people, so far as the Government can do it, from the really serious problems that the people have to face. That is the only urgency, and that is why we are getting this instrument now at the eleventh hour or the half-past-eleventh hour. You will not get a genuine verdict of the people on this. In the circumstances it is impossible. You cannot. Is it a fair thing to put a matter of this kind, not a simple matter that can be dealt with definitely, but to put a conglomeration of principles and powers before the people and say: "Take it or leave it?"
I believe in the Two-Chamber Legislature. That is not there at present. I admit, as far as the Second Chamber is concerned, this is much the same kind of Constitution, and there is much the same method of electing it the Second Chamber as that which the President condemned and damned a short time ago. It is not an ideal Constitution, of course. Some time ago the President wanted an ideal Constitution and would have nothing else. Yesterday he almost suggested that it is we who are demanding the ideal Constitution. We protested against any such desire, knowing it could not be got. Supposing I am an ordinary elector in the country, and I am in favour of two Houses of Parliament. Very good. If I am in favour of that and want it, I must also submit to the new super-Governor - General. That is not a proper thing to put as a referendum before the people, for it is a constitutional law and so will bind you for a long time and will be extremely difficult to change. It will be most difficult to get people to take part in these referenda in the future. We shall have a spate of them. It will be really a difficult thing in the future to alter the Constitution by one iota. The referenda will become more frequent, real nuisances, and people will ignore them. The necessary majority probably will be there, but can you get it? We can get only a machined verdict. I can understand a straight, simple issue being put before the people in one or two sentences in which you are to say whether you are in favour of what is proposed or against it.
But to put forward a whole Constitution of this kind and say that if you want a Second House you will have to swallow the super-Governor-General— that is most unreasonable. And remember the permanency. This is not an ordinary law. So far as it is in the power of the President, he has tried to make it permanent. He has copper-fastened it down upon the Irish people so that it will be extremely difficult for them in future to shake themselves free from the shackles he is now placing upon them.
I shall not discuss the trivialities and the puerilities that there are in this Constitution, but there are a couple of things with which I should like to deal. I cannot help dealing, first of all, with one particular matter in the speech of the ex-Minister for the Crown. Here is the statement: "It is easy to put these florid phrases down on paper, but much more difficult to devise machinery to give them practical effect." I wonder was he referring to certain Articles in this Amendment of the Constitution? It would look as if he were, because the Constitution itself almost provides in one particular case that "we are putting these things down on paper but we cannot give them practical effect." The Minister is quite right. It is very easy to put general principles down on paper, but it is extremely difficult to devise machinery to give them practical effect.
In Article 45 we have this extraordinary statement:—
"The principles of social policy set forth in this Article are intended for the general guidance of the Oireachtas. The application of those principles in the making of laws shall be the exclusive care of the Oireachtas, and shall not be cognisable by any court under any of the provisions of this Constitution."
It is extremely difficult to devise machinery to give practical effect to certain things, but it is extremely easy, as the ex-Minister of the Crown would say, to put them down on paper. I admit, if you take a number of these principles individually they are excellent. They are certainly harmless, and some of them are splendid. I could say that some of them might be taken out of a Papal Encyclical. They are very sound.
But my difficulty is this, that even Papal Encyclicals are rather difficult to interpret. People have an extraordinary habit of taking what they like out of documents of that sort. I have seen an Encyclical directed against Communism so interpreted as to be almost a demand for Communism. Similarly this Constitution may be variously interpreted. You have a set of principles here, no doubt excellent and splendid, but I find myself face to face with this difficulty, that they can be interpreted and accepted in practice by the most extreme individualist, on the one hand, and a rather advanced Communist on the other hand—as a matter of practice. I have no doubt the courts will find it easy to interpret these things, and I have no doubt the Oireachtas will find great guidance in these particular matters.
As regards Article 45, I understand its social principles are not very seriously meant by the President, because I think he told us yesterday that they are more or less like the headline of a Party programme. Anything more futile than the headline of the Fianna Fáil Party programme I cannot imagine, and it is an insult to these principles to put them on that level. When you come to the principles dealing with the rights of private property, not one of them could I quarrel with; they are absolutely sound, but, taking them as a whole, I cannot make up my mind whether they are an incitement or otherwise. I am not saying that of them in the context from which they may have come originally. As the Minister for Finance will put it, it is easy to put down these things in black and white, but it is so hard to carry them out.
There is another objection, and it is a more serious objection, I will frankly confess. There is this danger: there are serious menaces threatening society. With these I have often dealt, and I have a very uneasy feeling that there are a certain number of people in high positions in the State of this country who think they have done all that is necessary against this menace when they have put down a few principles on paper. They think that the menace is scotched; that the bulwark is set up, and that the mere setting down of these things relieves them of the responsibility of facing the real problem of how to deal with those things. That is the real danger and you have it illustrated in another portion of this Constitution.
I can quite understand some of the motives that are responsible for Article 4, which is very unlike the Minister for Finance in one respect —it is very brief. "The name of the State is Eire." I can understand the emotion that led to that change. If I were a cynic, I might say I can understand that the man who puts forward proposals for the new powers of the Governor-General that we find in this amendment of the Constitution is desirous to knock out the word "free," but, I take it, his desire was to express Irish unity. But is there not a danger? Supposing we are internationally recognised, as we are as a State, the unit that is recognised is this State. The unit that will be recognised is this State where this State has jurisdiction, and that is the Twenty-Six Counties. Internationally, therefore, Ireland and the Twenty-Six Counties become identified and instead of bringing the Six Counties into Ireland, you put them out of Ireland internationally. Ireland and the Twenty-Six Counties under this proposal become identified. The Six Counties are expelled from Ireland. They were in it before; you had that common name, but now all that will be changed. That is the danger of thinking you have solved problems by writing a few sentences on paper. That is one of the objections I have to things of that kind. They blind you to the real issues.
There are certain matters that cause grave uneasiness. With one of them we are very seriously concerned and we will have to propose an amendment. One of the matters to which the President directed his attention yesterday was the rights of women. I am prepared to make that a test case so far as his sincerity is concerned—I mean his sincerity in his explanation yesterday—or his capacity to interpret this document that he evolved out of his heart and brain and now puts before us and says everybody can understand. I cannot grasp why it is that the President cannot see that he has destroyed the constitutional bulwark of women's rights. He said yesterday that this Constitution does not deprive them of any rights they have.
They had the vote yesterday. They have it to-day. The professions were open to them yesterday and the professions are open to them to-day. Quite so. The Constitution does not do away with these things, but it makes possible laws that will do away with these things and that will still be in conformity with the Constitution. That is the real issue, and the President knows it, and he is throwing dust in the eyes of the people by saying that we are taking nothing away from them. He is taking away their constitutional guarantees and he knows, as the head of a Government, that that actual provision, which he deletes owing to the sensitiveness on his part with regard to the rights and privileges of women, actually has been the guardian of their rights and privileges. It has prevented governments from discriminating against them, and the President knows that very well. When efforts were made to discriminate against them, these very words, which the President now proposes to delete, were their salvation so far as their rights were concerned.
Reading the report of his speech yesterday and also his speech in Clare, the President conveyed to me the impression of a man suffering from a bad conscience because he was caught out. He was slipping this thing nicely and quietly through, and because it was pointed out to him by the ex-Attorney-General and by the women's organisations that the effect of this would be to discriminate against women, we had an immediate display of temper by the President and an evasion of the issue. The issue is not whether the Constitution deprives them of certain rights which they have now, but the issue is that it makes it possible for ordinary law to do so, and that is the issue the President cannot evade. That is the issue which should be kept before him so far as this matter is concerned. Take even the question of the vote. It is provided that the Dáil shall be elected by every citizen of the State, so far as they are not disqualified by law; but what is to prevent the Oireachtas passing a law disqualifying women on account of their sex? There is nothing to prevent it. It would be quite in conformity with the Constitution to do so. There is absolutely nothing in the Constitution to prevent their doing that. Then there are other Articles dealing with this matter.
Not merely is there nothing to safeguard or preserve their rights, but there are pointers in the Constitution to show that the President does intend to interfere with their rights. His speech yesterday shows that. It shows not merely that there is nothing to safeguard and guarantee their rights, but that they may actually look forward to legislation that will interfere with the rights they enjoy at the present moment. If there were any doubt as to the purpose behind the omission of these words: "No distinction of sex" from the Constitution, that doubt must have been removed by the President's speech yesterday and by his speech in Clare. Then why did he do it? Because it was a reminiscence, we are told, of the time when women had not rights. Yesterday he donned the robe of chivalry. He was filching their rights from them, but he did it in a most sanctimonious way. Well, he always does wrong things in a sanctimonious way. Whenever he does wrong, he always does it under the mantle of righteousness.
With many of the principles he enunciates, many of the people naturally will be in agreement, but that does not justify him in doing what he is doing here and in trying to slip it through quietly and then losing his temper when these things are pointed out to him, and say that it is an attempt to deceive the people just because we are pointing out the only possible explanation of what is in the Bill. I say, not merely is there a possibility of laws discriminating against women being passed—that is there as a result of the omission of certain phrases—but it is asked for by other provisions of the Bill and is foreshadowed by the President's speech. I wonder whether the women are satisfied with the expressions of the President yesterday and with the noble sentiments which he expressed and about which he almost broke down in giving them? Will that be any guarantee for them? What they want are not his promises. What they want are the legal guarantees that should be in a Constitution of this kind, and they have not got them. We know all about promises. Every class in this State has fallen down on the promises of the President, and they have found out what these promises have meant—the civil servants, the Republicans, the women—practically every class—their name will be legion. We cannot legislate on what is at the back of the President's mind for two reasons: first, because the law is what is written down, and secondly, because we never know what is at the back of the President's mind. He gets up and tells us that he intends by this provision so-and-so, but that is no use. It is what is in the provision that counts, and that is what we have before us. If he did not draft it properly—and I am afraid he did draft what was in his mind and that it was quite deliberate on his part to leave out this phrase— he should have been glad when the mistake was pointed out to him, instead of pettishly turning on his critics and accusing everybody of bad faith because they had the temerity to point out the wrong features in this document that has been drafted, as far as one can see, without even consultation with the Executive Council. They may have been shown it and their formal approval obtained.
We are told—I wonder how much we gain by it—but it is the fact that we are told—that there is now a sovereign, independent, democratic State. Well, if it remains so, the credit will not be the President's and it will not be as a result of this amendment to the Constitution which we are now discussing. It is a democratic, sovereign State at the present moment—I hope it will keep sovereign—but I fear that we are taking a distinct step—constitutionally a step—or one of the steps towards ceasing to be a democratic State. Now we have the liberty of the individual guaranted. The President struck it out. It was there in the old Constitution. Why did he not leave it there and let the courts interpret what it means? What harm was it doing? The President knew perfectly well—it was not by accident, as he confesses himself, that he struck it out, and let us not be under the impression that it was because it did not express the truth. This document has many other things that are palpably untrue, and yet we are told that it is the President's squeamishness for exactitude and truth that induced him to take away the protection of the rights of the individual and the protection for the individual as well. It is the same way with other Articles. There are changes that, at first sight, might seem to be minor changes. The courts are deprived of a great deal of the power they have at present to protect the individual. There is the question of the right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions. The Press is free at the moment. The courts are able to protect them, but how in the world will the courts protect them when we see this Article in the Constitution which deals with the Press? It says that the State guarantees the right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions, but then it goes on to say that, the education of public opinion being, however, a matter of such grave import to the common good, the State shall endeavour to ensure that organs of public opinion, such as the radio, the Press, and the cinema, while preserving their rightful liberty of expression, shall not be used to undermine public order or morality or the authority of the State. Those are splendid sentiments, and I am not quarrelling with the sound doctrine of these sentiments. Far be it from me, but I would feel much easier in my mind if I did not know that two of the most undemocratic States in Europe, two of the most autocratic States in Europe at the present moment, are autocratically ruled because they took in hand the "proper" political education of their people, because they got control of the Press, the radio and the cinema. Why, that is the great instrument that Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany have in their hands at the present moment! It is on that education of the people that they base a great deal of their authority and a great deal of their power. These things could have been left as they are and let the courts protect the people and see that there was no undue licence so far as these agencies are concerned.
There are many things in the Constitution that need not surprise us. By now the House must be familiar with the President's real contempt of Parliament and Parliamentary institutions. If I might use a word that he used yesterday, this document "enshrines" his contempt for Parliamentary institutions. He does not understand Parliaments. He does not understand the spirit of Parliaments. He does not understand the spirit of real discussion, or real agreement come to as the result of discussion. He does not understand the conditions that make Parliamentary government possible. It is nothing strange if this document reeks with real hostility to Parliamentary institutions, as it undoubtedly does. Much has been said about the powers of the new Governor-General, the super Governor-General. One thing is clear —that any powers he has got do not come to him at the expense of any outside authority. They only come to him at the expense of the liberty of the people and at the expense of the powers of Parliament. But, Sir, we can expect nothing else from a man who has always shown supreme contempt, not merely for Parliamentary institutions, but for the Dáil itself. The other matter that was discussed—and I am sorry the ex-Minister of the Crown did not clarify the position——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I gathered from the Deputy's speech that he referred to ex-Ministers of the Crown. We do not know who they are. We should like to know who they are. I submit that it is not in order to refer to any of our Ministers here as ex-Ministers of the Crown. He may be referring to Lloyd George or somebody like that.
Comment on this
He said that up to last December he was a Minister of the Crown and that now he is an ex-Minister of the Crown.
Comment on this
He never said that he was an ex-Minister of the Crown.
Comment on this
I cannot appeal to you, Sir, in the Chair for corroboration of my statement, but you were present in the House in another capacity when the Minister said that. May I ask you to cast your mind back to the time when you were sitting on the benches? That is the point of order, that the Minister never said that he was an ex-Minister of the Crown.
Comment on this
That is not the point of order. I have raised the point that throughout your speech you have made references to ex-Ministers of the Crown. We do not know who they are and we want to know. I submit that if you are referring to any Minister here you should not refer to him as an ex-Minister of the Crown.
Comment on this
The proper title of a Minister is Minister of the Department for which he is responsible. Ministers must be referred to as Ministers of the Departments of which they are the political heads. That is the proper title for a Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance here at one time described himself as an ex-Minister of the Crown. That is the title he took to himself. I submit that I cannot be precluded from using the title which he took to himself, with a great deal of pride and with an evident desire to show how extraordinarily important Ministers of the Crown were and what great people they were—even above the law. I know that he thinks he is still above the law. He thinks that he could have run down people on the street and not be held responsible for his action—whether in his private capacity or as a Minister of the Crown I do not know. That is the view he put before us. It was he introduced the phrase. I can assure Deputy Kelly that if it hurts his susceptibilities, I shall not refer to it again.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it seems to me desirable that this matter should be clarified. I quite accept your ruling, Sir, that when referring to an individual Minister, it is proper to call him the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Defence or whatever Minister he may be. I submit, however, that it is perfectly in order to allude to Ministers in general, as Ministers of the Crown unless and until this country is declared a republic.
Comment on this
I submit that under Standing Orders if a Minister is referred to he should be referred to as the Minister of the Department for which he is responsible and not as an ex-Minister of the Crown. Our Ministers never were that and never will be.
Comment on this
I have already indicated that Standing Orders provide that Ministers of this State should be referred to as Ministers of the Department over which they preside as the political heads. With regard to Deputy MacDermot's point, I am afraid that he must seek a higher authority elsewhere for that.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance stated emphatically here that he was a representative of the Crown. I doubt very much that he is.
Comment on this
Let us discuss the super-Governor-General. I hope that a point of order will not be raised because I refer to him in that particular way. I think Deputies all know the individual to whom I refer, called the President. Undoubtedly, that is one of the striking features in this amendment of the Constitution. We had the injured innocence of the President yesterday and the Minister for Finance to-day pointing out that really we were traducing the democratic ideas and intentions of the Government in suggesting that there was anything undemocratic, any danger so far as the future of the State was concerned, in these powers. I am not quite sure whether Deputies were influenced by the dilemma, or at least the circle, in which the President found himself. You had to give to the President, the Governor-General, increased powers because you elected him, and I gather that you elected him because you wanted to give him increased powers. I have not the slightest doubt that an argument of that kind will appeal to the President. But the powers proposed to be vested in that First Citizen by this instrument are dangerous. When I say that they are dangerous, I do not mean that at the present moment a dictatorship is established by this instrument. When we are discussing constitutional matters, that is not what we have to look to. We have to look to the possible and probable development of what we are doing. What I have to complain of, and what I think others have to complain of in the case of the President, is that he approaches constitutional questions without any sense of political development. He has no idea that things can develop. It is the last thing that enters into his head. It is a purely mathematical hard mind, and there is no question of development there.
We are taking a step; we are not establishing a dictatorship. Two developments are possible. It is quite possible that in the course of years the following development may happen: when the political mentor of the President, the Abbé Siéyés, whose type of mind is like his own, was drawing up one of his many perfect constitutions —because he was essentially a constitution-making machine—he did provide a position as head of State for the great Napoleon, who strongly objected. One of Napoleon's phrases was that he did not want to be the fat pig, and he struck him out of the constitution. The other phrase was that he did not want to be the "royal lounger." I quite admit it is possible that the head of State here may develop into the "royal lounger." But it is only one of two possible developments. The other development is much more serious. The other development is that he may develop either in his own person a dictatorship or he may help to create a dictatorship here.
Let us envisage two cases. What I object to is this: here you have power without responsibility. There is no responsibility except the person's own conscience. Now, in legislating, in drawing up constitutions, we cannot take account of what people's consciences are liable to inspire them to do. We know perfectly well that conscience can inspire a man to do most extraordinary things. When I speak of responsibility. I mean he is not responsible for his official acts in any way, to the country or to the House or to anybody. Still, he has power. I think it is a mistake to divorce power and responsibility in that way in what professes—it may be possible in other forms of State—to be a democratic State. Let us assume that there is a clash. Let us assume that the high ideals of the President are not carried out and that a Party man is elected. What else is likely to happen I cannot say. Am I to imagine that the present President and his Government will look all over the country for an unknown citizen of great virtue, who had nothing to do with politics, and put him forward as the candidate, the innocent, a kind of Parsifal coming forward to us, and to be put forward on account of his belonging to no political organisation and no political Party? Supposing that idea fails. What chance he would have of getting elected I do not know unless he had a political machine behind him. In any case, you are going to get a Party man.
Let us assume there is a clash. Remember, there is no coincidence between the term of office of the Government and that of the Governor-General. There may be a President in office for five years of his term of office, with a Government of an entirely different policy. There you have a clash. It is useless to ignore the power that the President will have to make the work of that Government impossible. He can hold up the Government, at every hand's turn practically, in a variety of ways. Deadlocks will be the order of the day, and deadlocks can only lead to one thing in politics, a coup d'état. You are asking for it, and it has nearly always happened. When you have had divisions of power of this kind it has been very frequent that a deadlock has been reached, a coup d'état carried through, and a dictatorship established. You will find that in the history of the first French Republic, of the second French Republic, and of the recent German Republic. That is the great danger. With our political inexperience in this country we cannot hope to escape what other countries have suffered from.
That is one danger. As to the second danger, let us assume there is agreement between the two of them, that a Parliament like this, drawing to its close, with a Government in power that is discredited through the country, still desirous of clinging to office, with a conscience that can justify them in taking, and in fact compels them to take, any measures that will secure their continuance in office—for the good of the country! Let us assume that position. I listened to the Minister for Finance in his long oration about the powers of the Governor-General. One of the matters that he dealt with was the Army and the Governor-General's position as regards the Army. Now, Sir, what this Constitution may say is one thing, but, having listened carefully to him, I have not the remotest idea of what the Minister for Finance wanted the attitude or the power of the Governor-General to be in regard to the Army.
Comment on this
On a point of order, what personage is Deputy O'Sullivan alluding to as the Governor-General?
Comment on this
Glorious points of order! So important! I will allude to anybody I like as anything I like if he is not a member of this House.
Comment on this
Or at least he will be an official of this State. The Deputy might at least be truthful.
Comment on this
I am told to be truthful, and he says there is doubt as to whom I mean! Well, "the royal lounger," if you like. Let us get a solution. I do not want to hurt the susceptibilities of the incoming President. I will refer to him as "the President" in future.
Comment on this
That is my difficulty. Let us assume a position in which the President is in full agreement with the Government. Let us take a concrete example; let us suppose it is President de Valera, and that the Premier—may I refer to him as the Premier?
Comment on this
Let us suppose they are in full agreement, and that the Premier happens to be, say, the present Vice-President, and that we have in power the magnificent Party that attends this Dáil so well when important constitutional measures are under discussion, that Party of "Yes-men."
Comment on this
Oh, but mind you, two-and-a-half hours or two-and-three-quarter hours from the President, and two hours odd—very odd— from the Minister for Finance, was not a bad contribution from the Government Benches.
Comment on this
Let us suppose this happens, does anybody imagine that the then President de Valera cannot induce the then Premier to give him, according to law, Article 13, paragraph 5, full real command over the Army? I could not gather from the Minister for Finance, I confess, what his position is to be. At one time I thought he was contending that the real command of the Army ought to be with the Governor-General; that it was not to be a mere nominal affair. A few minutes afterwards he was referring to it as a mere symbolical command. I certainly cannot make out what it is.
Remember, furthermore—I say it with all respect to the exposition that we got yesterday from the President —Article 13 (10) says:—
"subject to this Constitution additional powers and functions may be conferred upon the President by law."
Now, Sir, the President made great play with the words "subject to this Constitution." Let us see what barrier that puts to him or puts to the Dáil by ordinary law to confer new great powers upon the President. It simply means this, that every power that man can get that is not prohibited by this Constitution can be given to the President. It is a kind of residuary power that we have to give. Yesterday in the Dáil we saw how rapidly that sort of thing can develop. The President, following an interruption by Deputy Dillon, said that all that he had in mind was the matter of appointments such as the appointment of visitors to universities and so on. But in a short space of a couple of hours he had already expanded his ambitions, and we find that this President is to be given the power to receive and present credentials to diplomatic Ministers and people of that kind. If in the short space of a couple of hours we had that rather remarkable development, I ask you what may happen in six months?
If you had a subservient Dáil, and the President wants to get power into his hands and has a subservient Party in this House, what is to prevent him getting it? That is enormous power that is given to practically destroy the Constitution so far as the reality is concerned. I could not quite follow the Minister for Finance when he dealt with the powers of the Governor-General. One time he seemed anxious to exalt them and another time to minimise them. The danger is there in these Articles and various other Articles. The President is not going to get away from that danger by giving us what are his pious intentions. His intentions are expressed in very pious language, but such intentions, unfortunately, have the habit of not being carried out.
I ask the House to consider these things. First of all this is an instrument of deception. The pretence that the people are going in any real sense to ratify or reject it is a deception also. In present circumstances there is no such reality before us. Proper and full consideration of this instrument by the people is impossible. With the general election pending, it is out of the question. All the powers given the Governor-General, the rights filched from women and from the ordinary citizens, cannot be camouflaged or covered over by the callous and cynical humanitarianism voiced by the President.
There are certain things in respect to which we are left where we were. Status! Where are we? What this instrument says practically comes to this: We are where we were, but we are afraid to say it. As regards the liberties and the powers of the people what does this Constitution give them that is not there at present? It tells the people: "You have certain powers, and we tell you that you have them, that is in so far as this instrument does not take them away from you." Finally, what grave problem that faces this country is brought one foot nearer solution by the passing of this Constitution. There is every reason why this should be postponed until there is sufficient time after the elections for the people to calmly consider it. It is impossible for the people to do that at present, and for that reason I ask the House to support the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not propose to say very much. I was pleased to hear the President yesterday introduce the Constitution in our native language, but I was disappointed myself because I could not follow him. I hope that whatever Government is returned after the elections will give the Irish language its proper place in our national life. Objection has been taken by the Opposition that the Constitution proposes to confer dictatorial powers on whoever may be elected as head of the State. I do not know whether that position is ambitioned by President de Valera, by the leader of the Opposition, by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan or by the popular Lord Mayor of Dublin. I would be pleased to see a leader from amongst the Opposition Party going before the electorate, seeking that position. I do think the time has come to end all the damnable nonsense that has been going on here in this House for the past five or six years or perhaps longer, on such issues as "Who fired the first shot in the civil war?" or as to "Who fired the first shot in the economic war?" The time for these recriminations has passed, and in my opinion the two big political Parties should become united and do their utmost to unite the country. Some may say that the President has not gone far enough in this Constitution. They may think that he should have declared a republic for the 32 counties.
I have been in the struggle for Irish freedom for the past 50 or 60 years, and I would like to see the determination to do that enshrined in this Constitution, but at the same time I see that there is a barrier there. There is a gulf there, and I fear the time has not yet come for a Government elected by the votes of our people, and it is the people who are the bosses of the whole situation, to declare a republic. We are not yet in a position to do that for the 32 counties. We hear a good deal from loud voiced people on this question. I doubt very much if President de Valera declared a republic in the morning that he would get very much support from those people. They would be as mute as mice in their feather beds if there was any danger threatening our country.
The one thing that perturbs my mind in this Constitution is the right of property owners. I do not see one word in it to safeguard their rights. It seems to me that under this Constitution this Government or any succeeding Government will have the right to acquire the property of any individual without any compensation whatsoever. I do not mean to convey that that is the intention of the present Government, but the danger is there. Deputy Lavery pointed out last night that that danger exists and it should be removed.
The President invited the members of the Opposition Party to put forward constructive ideas, and said he would closely examine the whole situation. I have listened carefully to all the speeches made, and no such constructive or helpful ideas have been given to the Government in that respect. Listening to the speeches last night and this afternoon reminds me that a general election is looming up in the near future. In fact, you would fancy you were at the cross-roads or at the chapel gate when listening to the speakers trying to make the best possible case for themselves or their representatives.
There is another matter to which I wish to refer. Article 15 states: "The right to raise and maintain military or armed forces is vested exclusively in the Oireachtas." With that I thoroughly agree. The Article goes on to state: "No military or armed force, other than a military or armed force raised and maintained by the Oireachtas, shall be raised or maintained for any purpose whatsoever." We have an armed force at present under the control of the Minister for Defence. We have an army of which the country should be proud. But that army may be totally inadequate in case of a foreign invasion of the country, of which there is every sign and indication. I should like to see every young man of military age in this country given a military training. In case of emergency, we could then fall back on the youth of Ireland, as we did in 1916, to defend that proclamation which was issued by the men who are now dead and gone, to defend our national rights and our country and to give it the freedom which we all wish to see it given.
At the present moment there are a great number of young men behind prison bars in this country, perhaps through no fault of their own; young men who were instructed in the use of firearms by the late Government and the present Government for one purpose and one purpose only, to secure the independence of our country. This Constitution will be before the electorate in the very near future and it is for them to accept or reject it. The President is not here now, but before that general election comes along, I appeal to his representative who is here, the Vice-President, to use all his influence with the Executive Council to open the prison gates and release those men. The only charge, so far as I can see, against them is perhaps that they love their country not wisely but too well. I do not for one moment agree that a second army should spring up in this country. I should like to see the Army under the control of the Executive Council. I doubt very much whether the newly-elected President will have power over the Army. Whether power over the Army is given to him, I cannot see.
A great deal has been said in this debate about the unity of Ireland, for which we all wish, and as regards the peace for which we are all longing. As far as I can see, the only thing which will bring about unity is for Southern Ireland to put its own house in good order and set a good example to those religious bigots in Northern Ireland who are holding aloof at the present moment. These religious bigots are the barrier to unity at the present moment. That is the only thing which will induce the North to come into our national Parliament. All doubts should now be removed on that head as under this Constitution freedom of worship to every individual of every denomination is guaranteed. No more convincing proof of that could be given to these objectionable religious bigots than that which is enshrined in this Constitution.
Reference has been made to powers of dictatorship being given to our future President. Surely, the Irish people are not so blind or so dense as to elect a dictator in this country. That would be a most appalling thing. All down through the Golden Ages that was one of the characteristics of our people—to insist on freedom of speech and freedom of religious worship for all classes of the community.
This Constitution has, to my mind, boiled down to this. It has been drafted carefully and after serious consideration, not to-day or yesterday perhaps, but over a number of years past. I do not know whether the President has submitted it to the members of the Executive Council or not, but I take it for granted that the draft of the Constitution has been submitted for the careful consideration of every member of the Executive Council and that it has got the approval of every member of the Government. It is sheer nonsense to think that the President of the Executive Council had, at the back of his mind, aimed at taking dictatorial powers. I, for one, do not believe that for a moment. I honestly believe even if it were his ambition to go to the country as President under this new Constitution, that these false impressions would be dispelled from the mind of every voter who would go to vote for him. I cannot visualise for a moment that men who are out for the good of their country—and we have Deputies on all sides of this House who were prepared to make the supreme sacrifice of their lives for the freedom of Ireland—will go now to the public and ask for the support of the electors to set up a dictatorship in this country. God forbid that I should ever see the day that such a situation should arise!
I am supporting this Constitution. I am voting for it here. Indeed, I am happy to have the privilege of being elected a member of the Farmers' Party of East Cork, whose trust I have never betrayed. I take this opportunity and privilege of voting for this most democratic Constitution with no word inscribed in it as regards Communistic ideas or principles. Further than that I do not wish to go. I say that this new Constitution will bring new life into this country. The old national spirit that was always in our people will welcome that Constitution, and it will open the doors for those men who have held to the same political ideas and views the same as well all have. Let it go forth that we are supporting and accepting this Constitution which will do more for the peace and unity of the people of Southern Ireland than has been done by any man in recent times.
As regards the unemployment question, we were told last evening that at the present moment there are 100,000 unemployed persons in the country. Well, the unemployed will remain always with us, as well as with the people of every other country in the world. We have thousands of our boys and girls going to foreign lands at the present moment seeking the livelihood which, perhaps, they could not get at home. We must, however, remember that it is a characteristic of our race that our young people did always have a love of travel and the ambition to go to foreign countries. I think it would be inadvisable for any Government, present or future, to try to put a stop to these young people. Some of these become dissatisfied, perhaps, with their present surroundings. Others of them have the ambition to improve their positions in life. For the last 60 years —or, I might say, for the last 100 years—millions of our young people have, under the old landlord régime, been forced out of our country to seek a living in Australia, New Zealand, and, in short, in every habitable country under God's sun. However, that is a thing of which we should feel proud. Many of these people and their descendants to-day, in the great Republic of the West, in the far-back blocks of Australia, and in nearly every quarter of the world, hold high positions of which every one at home should feel proud. Now we are told there are 100,000 unemployed——
Comment on this
Would Deputy Kent help me by showing me the relevancy of this to An Bunreacht na hÉireann?
Comment on this
I am only just pointing out that I heard this thing mentioned last night, and its relevancy is this, that under the new Constitution there would be no remedy whatsoever as regards the unemployed or as regards the emigration of our young people.
Comment on this
I may not be relevant, but I only wish to point out to the Government that it is only through their own fault that there are so many unemployed in the country. If the Government only took their courage in their hands they would find enough employment for all our young people who are now emigrating or unemployed. Between reafforestation, water schemes, tourist schemes, turf cutting and other works of a reproductive character there is a big field of employment. I will not go further than that. I do not know whether I have any further remarks to make, only just this, that as regards the ownership of private property I have one suggestion to offer to the Government. I ask them to safeguard the interests of the private owners. Under the Articles of this Constitution there is no guarantee whatsoever whether this or a future Government will be given powers to evict private owners and to take over by compulsory measures private property belonging to the people of this country. I would like if the President, when replying, would give us an assurance on that matter. The President mentioned something about the employment of our womenfolk. I know personally many and many a case where the mother has been compelled through economic reasons to go out to work in order to help to make a livelihood for the family. The President, in speaking last night, did not mention what means he had in mind to do away with that necessity. How is he going to get over it? We must all remember that wives and young families in this country at the present moment have to work from dawn to dark in order to bring in the necessaries of life to the home. It will not detract from any young farmer's wife or labourer's wife to help in making a livelihood for the family. The youth of this country, the boys and girls who perhaps are not in a position physically to go to work in the factories, are glad enough to earn the means of subsistence at farm work. But that is a different question altogether. We have all had to work in our younger days, and it takes from no man to do a little work on his farm or on the acre attached to his cottage; it merely adds to the physique of youth.
The President did not mention how he was going to remedy the existing state of affairs, and I would ask him to make some allusion to it when he is concluding this debate. I am glad to have the privilege of voting for this Constitution, which I am prepared to support in this House and outside. I hope it will be the means of bringing about a new Ireland, of bringing prosperity to our people of all denominations, and when we go forth to look for a republic for the 32 counties I sincerely hope that all our soldiers will be prepared to toe the line, to shoulder their rifles and proclaim to Ireland that they are willing to lay down their lives if necessary, just the same as did the men in 1916, in order to establish our State.
Comment on this
So much of the discussion both inside and outside this House in relation to the Dréacht Bunreacht has turned on its possible effect on the status of women that it seems to me it would be unfitting that this debate should close without a woman's voice being heard in connection with the matter. Deputies are aware, and Deputy O'Sullivan has again reminded us, that many women's societies are perturbed by certain Articles in the Draft Constitution, and we have been told that should this measure go through the House unamended the status of women in the State will be definitely lowered. This attitude has been taken up by, among others, the National University Women Graduates' Association, to which I owe a particular allegiance. They have given expression to their fears, and in a statement from a meeting they held on Monday last (supplied to the Press and published in the Irish Press of yesterday), I find, after enumeration of the various women speakers, each of whose names has a national significance, the following:
"The omission of the principle of equal rights and equal opportunities, enunciated in the proclamation of the republic in 1916 and confirmed in Article 3 of the Constitution of Saorstát Eireann, was deplored as sinister and retrogressive. Articles 40, 41 and 45, which leave the door open for reactionary legislation against women in every department, were discussed with particular care.
"Measures were then proposed to secure their deletion and the restoration of Article 3."
Other women's societies, such as the Joint Committee of Women's Societies and Social Workers and the Women Workers' Union, have also expressed their fears as to the possible effects of Articles 40, 41 and 45.
On the other hand, we have had an unequivocal declaration from the President that there is nothing in the Constitution which detracts from the rights which women possess in this country. Clearly then, the framers of the Constitution had no intention in their minds to interfere in the slightest way with the rights of women, and I am very glad to have that assurance. But since it happens that the opinion of the women's organisations has been backed by the opinions of two very authoritative lawyers, Deputy Lavery and Deputy Costello, and there seems to be a fear, by reason of the ambi-guilty of certain phrases, that in future times, whatever be the intentions of the framers of the Constitution, these might lead to a lowering of the status of women, I welcome very much what the President stated last night. He said, in reply to Deputy Costello, that if he were convinced that Deputy Costello or any other Deputy was making a good case, he would be willing to let the jury decide it and, if the case were sustained, to amend the Constitution. I would be glad if the President would give us an assurance that he will look once more into these Articles and satisfy himself that by no error of draftsmanship, by no ambiguity in the Irish or English versions, could any interpretation be given by future courts that would lessen the status of women. It might happen that, although we know the intentions of the framers of the Constitution—we have had them very clearly expressed—at some future time it might come before others who might be inclined to interpret those clauses differently from what they were meant by the framers to mean.
Deputy Lavery said a very strange thing last night. I considered it strange because it came from Deputy Lavery, a man for whose opinion we all must have respect. He said the President wanted women put in this position, that they ought to be in the home and stay there. The Deputy took care not to quote any Article from the Constitution which, by any possible turning or twisting, would bear such an interpretation. I expect, however, that he was referring to Article 41. Article 41 refers to the family, and the sub-sections can only be read in conjunction with each other. What Deputy Lavery did not read to the House, I am going to read:
"The State recognises the family as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of society, and as a moral institution possessing inalienable and imprescriptible rights, antecedent and superior to all positive law.
"The State, therefore, guarantees to protect the family, in its constitution and authority, as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the nation and the State.
"In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved.
"The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home."
That is a principle that has been already accepted by this House. We accepted it when we passed the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act.
I, for one, never heard a speech that moved me more than that made by Deputy Dillon on that occasion. I feel it was the same principle that inspired the framing of the section to which I have referred. I sincerely hope that not a comma of this noble declaration will be altered. I think it is due to women who have so bravely carried on the battle for civilisation, and who have had to bear the hardest part, that the State should give them this recognition. Do we not all know that the price of each human life is some woman's agony? Do we not know that the rearing of each child is purchased at the cost of some woman's sleepless nights and hardworking days, and are we not all aware of the life of sacrifice that each woman has to experience to launch her family on the world? Why, then, should we begrudge to women that the State should honour them for their contribution to the State's support and its common good?
In the Sunday Independent of last week there was a very interesting article which has a bearing on the question we are now discussing. It was an account of an interview which Mrs. James McNeill had with the wife of the Polish Consul-General here. I hope that most Deputies read the article, because it has a bearing on this matter we are now discussing. It shows what the people of Poland have achieved and what they, and especially the Polish women, did for the uplift and education of their race. The following is an extract from the interview:—
"Poland had more than once kept the vigil for Christendom. Trebly partitioned between Austria, Russia and Prussia, Poland, from the end of the 18th century up to the Great War, and the Peace of Versailles, had to endure the bitter experience of alien rule, alien persecution of religion, language, nationality. During that time Polish children had to attend State schools, in which they could neither speak nor hear their native tongue; in which their native customs were derided, their history suppressed, their religion ignored. It was the Polish home and, in particular, the Polish mother, that preserved our language and the love of faith and fatherland in Polish hearts. She taught Polish to her children and spoke it with them. She taught them the truths of the Catholic Faith and made them practise it devoutly. She taught them the history of their native land. She filled them with love for their religion and their country, and the courage to die, if necessary, in their defence. When Poland became free once more at the end of the Great War, the fact that the whole nation had one faith and one language was a strongly unifying factor. Polish women were, to a large extent, responsible for that fortunate circumstance."
It is to Irish mothers and Irish homes that we owe the fact that we have won, to the extent to which we have won it, success in the long fight we have had for our faith and nationality, and I am very glad that Article 41 has recognised the services of women in the home. It does not mean— and I for one would protest most actively against it if it did mean— to close the door to work for women in any other sphere. That is not the intention at all. It will be found that women will work better in the homes if they have been educated and if they have had contact with outside life. Therefore, I hope that this Article will remain as it stands and that women will avail of it and draw from it its full substance and advantage. I hope they will insist that the education of girls shall have some relation to the work they will have to do for the "common good" in the home, and be a preparation for it. I have read somewhere in a Belgian paper, where they have paid great attention to all these things, that the woman in the home has to be mistress of 14 professions. She has to be a bit of a doctor; she has to be a cook; she has to be a dressmaker; she has to be a nurse; she has to be a carpenter, very often; above all, she has to be an educator, and so on. Therefore, the education of woman is very important, and I am very glad that the Minister for Education is here to listen to me, and I hope that he will see to it that some far-sighted woman will be in the administrative side of the Education Department. I believe that such a course of education for women, even if it requires revolution, would be of inestimable benefit. The home should be made as comfortable as possible, and therefore I shall say what I said before, and that is that in the Housing Board there should be a woman to tell the men how to plan houses that shall make housework easier, how to plan the home so that the needless waste of energy may be obviated, the maximum of comfort secured.
Another Article which seems to have caused some misgiving is Article 45. I think it was very necessary. Strangely enough, it was only the other day I read in a newspaper something that convinced me that such an Article was very necessary, and that it was the desire of women themselves that they should be protected. I shall read it for the House. This is an extract from an account of a meeting of women telephonists who were attending the Post Office Workers' Conference at Whitley Bay, and who stated emphatically that they would not agree to night work. The extract reads as follows:—
"Miss D.A. Pearce, of London, said that under no conditions at all would they work until half-past eight, let alone any other time at night, and her statement was loudly cheered; complaint was made of the effect on telephonists' nerves of the special buzzer used for emergency calls. Miss Doris Curnow, of London, said the girls felt that the red warning light was sufficient without a buzzer as loud as a siren. In one or two London exchanges girls had been carried out with hysteria owing to the sounding of the buzzer when they were working at high pressure."
That shows that the nervous system of women needs to be specially protected, and I think that Article 45, which gives them a constitutional right to that protection, should not be interfered with.
Now, with regard to the restoration of Article 3 in the Constitution as it at present stands, I myself would be more enthusiastic about it if I felt it were a real protection to women, but I found an advertisement in a paper this morning from the Board of Works asking for an assistant architect, and in that advertisement it was made public that there was a difference of £1 a week in the salaries to be paid to a man and a woman. It is quite clear that, in such a case, a woman would have the same professional education and equipment as a man, and certainly, in face of the competition, she would have a harder struggle and would even have to be better than a man. Why, then, should she be paid £1 a week less than a man? You have the same thing occurring in other spheres and in other Departments of State. Woman is supposed to be equal with man, but in every Estimate you will find a difference of about £100 in the pay of women in the State service as compared with that of men. If it were a question of special pay for married men, of course, one could see that the idea behind that was the supporting of the family, but there should not be this difference between men and women, as such, and I say that it is time to stop it. Accordingly, I do not think that Article 3 was of such great use when it made that possible.
Comment on this
Sir, Deputy Mrs. Concannon deserves to be, and is, in fact, listened to with respect in this House. She spoke in moving accents of the benefits to be conferred on women by Article 41 of the document at present before us, and she welcomed the announcement that an opportunity was to be given to the mother of a family to discharge her primary duty in peace, and that was to preside over that family, to hold it together, and to constitute herself the centre of its life. Those are sentiments to which I expect every Deputy of this Dáil will cordially subscribe. It is very easy to set them out in draft Constitutions, but there is rather a grim contrast between Deputy Mrs. Concannon's optimistic hopes and Deputy Kent's deplorable observations. Deputy Kent, who says that he is going to vote for the Constitution, and who admires President de Valera, says that he feels bound in honesty to say that he knows many families in this country the mothers of which are driven out to work by hard economic necessity because their husbands cannot find work to do. Now, does not Deputy Mrs. Concannon think that there is something wrong somewhere when she can be brought into this House to sing the praises of a Constitution drafted to guarantee to the people what Deputy Kent tells us here has been taken away from the people by the man who drew this Constitution?
Deputy Mrs. Concannon moved on to Article 45. There also she found a charter of liberty for women enshrined. I wonder did she read the first paragraph of that Article! She rejoiced at the constitutional rights that had been conferred upon women by Article 45. The first paragraph of that Article specifically declares that it confers no constitutional rights on any woman. That paragraph reads as follows
The principles of social policy set forth in this Article are intended for the general guidance of the Oireachtas. The application of those principles in the making of laws shall be the exclusive care of the Oireachtas, and shall not be cognisable by any court under any of the provisions of this Constitution.
Does Deputy Mrs. Concannon still rejoice in the security of the constitutional guarantee she enjoys under that Article? I would like that lady not to be deluded by highfalutin, but to try and concentrate on the hard facts which affect mothers like herself in this country who get no solace at all from highfalutin in a Constitution when they have got to go to work in mud because their husbands cannot bring home on Saturday night the wherewithal to feed the children which they bore.
Deputy Mrs. Concannon's speech is notable for one feature, and that is the note of reality which it brings to this debate. Look around at the constituent Assembly that is supposed to be framing the fundamental law of this country. Eleven Fianna Fáil Deputies mournfully dozing on the benches! That is typical of the whole country, which takes no more interest in this ráméis than they do in the Persian Koran. Faced, as are the people at the present time, with the task of living and surviving, they are to be fed with the Constitution. President de Valera comes in here and beams, calls on the House to consult with him, to give him their unbiassed help in improving this document, then fades from the Chamber and is seen no more. We are now supposed to be discussing with the President of the Executive Council the terms of this document, the fundamental law of the country, and he has not put his nose inside the House to-day.
Comment on this
Is it not all moonshine? Deputy Donnelly suggests that we should adjourn consideration of this document until such time as partition is solved. I could imagine if the Fianna Fáil Party were in opposition they would all say what Deputy Donnelly said. They would all clamour for whatever cheap publicity could be got for themselves by a demonstration of that kind, but having for the time being the responsibility of office on their shoulders, they are constrained to get up and say: "What can we do by the Constitution to solve that problem?" Nothing. All we can do to solve that problem is to promote and uphold good government in this country. Everything that Fianna Fáil could do to exasperate and perpetuate the partition of this country they have spent the last five years in doing. Now, at the end of that time we are told in ringing accents that this document is the greatest contribution that could be possibly made to the solution of partition. This document is the contribution of the Minister for Finance to the solution of the problem of partition. It is difficult, in face of these facts, to attempt a serious discussion of a document of this kind. Personally I do not think that this document matters a row of pins. What matters to the future of this country is if it has good government. If it has good government, the rights and the liberties of the people will be protected. If it has bad government, these rights and liberties will be prostituted.
I do think that it might be well to direct attention to three or four net points in this document. The first and most interesting, to my mind, is Article 5, which declares that this State is a sovereign, independent and democratic State. It is. It was made so by the predecessors in office of this Government. It was handed over to this Government a sovereign, independent and democratic State, and every member of the Fianna Fáil Party stumped this country to denounce as a traitor and West Briton anyone who said so. Now that declaration is incorporated in the fundamental law. Well might the Minister for Finance say that men frequently change their minds! Here we have an instance of a whole Party changing their minds and swallowing all they have ever said in regard to that matter and declaring it to be the national duty of this House to incorporate in our fundamental law a statement which they at one time declared it to be treason to make. Yesterday the President, when referring to Article 13, was asked by me to explain paragraph 10. He said that paragraph 10 was designed to provide facilities for routine work that it might appear necessary to authorise the President to do. He even particularised the types of jobs that might be given to him. Two hours later he told Deputy Lavery that that was not the purpose he had in mind at all.
The President is a man who has changed his mind frequently in this country. He has changed his mind, as is evidenced by Article 5, as to the true political status of this country. He has now discovered that it is a sovereign, democratic, independent State. He has changed his mind about the Military Tribunal. He at one time declared that it was the most damnable invention of the human mind for the oppression of our fellow-citizens. He is now incorporating it in the fundamental law of the country. He has changed his mind also in regard to the I.R.A. He was entertaining them in his study about 12 months ago with the object of forming a united front against the Opposition in this House. He has now proclaimed them an illegal body. If these striking changes of mind can take place and if such persons can attain to preeminence in this country as the head of the Government, does this House think it wise to leave the powers contained in paragraph 10 of Article 13 within the scope of the authority of any Government of this country? Does this House know what the meaning of the word "President" will be so long as paragraph 10 of Article 13 remains the fundamental law of the country? Paragraph 13 makes it possible to constitute this person who is to be President an absolute dictator and leaves the door wide open for any change any passing Government may see fit to make.
Article 41 I have already referred to. Article 41 purports in its course to declare and establish the sanctity of marriage. That, I believe, is a purpose that will command the assent of every Deputy in this House, but I feel bound to point out that in an attempt to assert fundamental matters of that kind care in the choice of language becomes very necessary, and we have in paragraph 2 of paragraph 3 of that Article a declaration that no law shall be enacted to provide for the grant of a dissolution of marriage. At first glance that would seem to represent accurately the almost unanimous view of our people, but on a closer examination I think the President should concern himself to find out whether that declaration, if it be enacted into the fundamental law of this country, can be reconciled with the Pauline privilege in regard to marriages. Can it be reconciled with certain circumstances that can arise in which a marriage, which in the eyes of the civil law of certain States is valid, but which in the eyes of the Church in this country is invalid, can be regulated? I suggest that a situation may arise under that in which there would be an obligation on a Catholic priest to administer the sacrament of matrimony to persons who, in the light of that document, would be indissolubly married according to the civil law.
Highfalutin, in addition to being deceiving, was very dangerous. There is no difference of opinion amongst any sections in this country as to the fundamental law in these matters—no substantial difference, in any case— but great damage can be done by trying to career away with loosely drafted documents dealing with such fundamental matters. The way in which this document has been prepared reflects little credit on the Government responsible for introducing it to this country. No adequate time has been given to examine it with the care that it ought to receive, and there may be various other lacunae in the Draft which could give rise to very serious difficulty in the hereafter. That at least appears to me to be one of them. However, my primary interest in this business is exactly the spirit shown by Deputy Mrs. Concannon here to-day. She has been carried away by the highfalutin, and, carried away by it, she lets herself be blinded to what is in fact going on all round. You cannot feed hungry people with Constitutions. You cannot stop the flood of emigrants with a paper dam. While this country is being asked to work itself into a frenzy of excitement over a document of this kind, we who live in the country see our neighbours getting poorer, see the mothers of families, as Deputy Kent has said, driven out to hard manual labour by a necessity that has been thrust upon them by this Government; see every day as we come in the train to Dáil Eireann groups on the platforms such as we used to see 25 or 30 years ago, caoining the departing emigrants.
We are expected, in that state of affairs, to work ourselves up to enthusiasm over a new Constitution; a new Constitution which changes nothing fundamental in our existence, which, by loose drafting, if we are to believe the President of the Executive Council, contains in it formidable potential dangers for the people who have learned hardship and who are threatened with greater hardship, for a country that is sinking deeper and deeper into destitution, for families that have hanging over them the threat of destruction by poverty. Is there any common sense left in this House at all?
Surely our first charge, as the temporal Government of this country, is the happiness of our own people. Everything we do here is contributing to their unhappiness and to their undoing, and the compensation we offer them is a Constitution. Surely we ought to wake up to some sense of reality. Surely we ought to go down the country amongst our own people, see how they are living, and learn what they want to make life better than it has been heretofore. This Constitution can do nothing whatever towards that end. It is towards that end we ought to be working in this House, and it is towards that end we are not working now. That is why this Constitution disgusts me. It is as irrelevant as a nursery rhyme, and it revolts me that, in the condition of our people, the mind of the country and the mind of this House should be thrust by this Government under a grotesquely irrelevant Constitution, while the people are perishing on the land.
Comment on this
Bhíos ag éisteacht leis an Teachta Ó Diolúin ag cur síos ar an mBunreacht seo agus a rá ná raibh aon dul chun chinn ann, ach caithfidh a rá ná cuireann aon nidh adeireann an Teachta Ó Diolúin íontas ar bith orm. Bhíos ag éisteacht fós leis an Teachta Ó Suilleabháin ag cur síos ar an mBunreacht seo. In ionad an Bunreacht do phlé is ag tabhairt fén Uachtarán a bhí sé ar feadh an ama uilig, beagnach. Is don Uachtarán atá againn fé láthair atáim ag déanamh tagairt anois. Tugaim fé ndeara go bhfuil na daoine ar an dtaobh tháll ar buile mar gheall ar an mBunreacht.
Comment on this
Tá siad ar buile mar gheall air agus sé an fáth go bhfuil an fhearg sin ortha ná gur fearr an Bunreacht seo ná mar a cheapadar agus gur oiriúnaí don náisiún seo é ná mar bhí an Sean-Bhunreacht. Tá na Teachtaí thall ag leigint ortha ná fuil aon deifríocht idir an Bunreacht so, Bunreacht na hÉireann, agus an seanacheann a bhí againn. Cuirfidh mé Airteagal (1) den tSean-Bhunreacht i gcomparáid le hAirteagal (1) den Bhunreacht so. Sé adeir Airteagal (1) den tSean-Bhunreacht ná:—
"Ball có-ionann iseadh Saorstát Eireann den Chuideachta Náisiún a dhineann suas an Có-chiníochas Briotáineach."
Deir Airteagal (1) den Bhunreacht nua:—
"Deimhnigheann náisiún na hÉireann leis seo a gceart do-shannta, do-chumhscuighthe, uachtar-cheannais chun cibé cinéal Riaghaltais is rogha leo féin do bhunughadh, chun a gcaidreamh le náisiúnaibh eile do chinneadh, agus chun forbairt do dhéanamh ar a saoghal i gcúrsai poilitidheachta is geilleagair is saoidheachta, do réir dhúthchais is gnás a sinnsear."
Im' thuairim-se, is mór an deifríocht atá idir an dhá rud. Taisbeánann sin go bhfuil sé ar aigne againn ár gcúrsaí féin do stiúriú díreach mar is mian linn, gan leigint do dhuine ar bith lasmuich nó do dhuine atá i gceannas lasmuich den tír seo do chur isteach orainn.
Bhí an Teachta Ó Súilleabháin, agus ina dhiaidh, an Teachta Ó Diolúin, ag iarraidh a dhéanamh amach ná raibh aon tsuim ag muintir na tíre san mBunreacht so. Dubhairt an Teachta Ó Súilleabháin ná raibh morán daoine anso chun bheith ag éisteacht leis an díospóireacht seo. Bhíos annseo indé nuair a cuireadh tús ar an ndíospóireacht, agus bhí an Tigh lán de Dháilirí agus an galairí thuas lan de dhaoine, agus is dócha gur chun bheith ag éisteacht leis an díospóireacht ar an mBunreacht a tháinigeadar anso.
Bhíos ag éisteacht leis an Teachta Ua Maolchatha ag cur síos ar an mBunreacht agus dubhairt sé gur chun na daoine a dalladh a thugamar isteach an Dréacht-Bhunreacht roimh an Olltoghchán. Tuigeann na daoine an scéal i gceart mar tá siad cliste ar cheisteanna mar seo agus níl sé chó furusta dallóg do chur ortha agus mar ceapann an Teachta Ua Maolchatha. Bhí sé ag cur síos ar bhochtanas agus ganntanas na tíre agus rinne sé tagairt do leitir do léigh an Teachta Ua Laoghaire amach sa Tigh le déanaí. Is dócha gur minic a léighfear sin sul a thiocfaidh an t-Olltoghchán. Nuair a tharraing sé an pictúir sin—pictúir bochtanais agus dealbhais—nach maith nár chuir sé san bpictúir an bochtanas bhí ann nuair fuair daoine bás sa chondae céanna.
Comment on this
Tá an ceart céanna agam tagairt do dhéanamh dosna rudaí seo agus a bhí ag an dTeachta Ua Maolchatha tagairt do dhéanamh do bhochtanas na tíre.