We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Dara Céim (d'aththógaint).

Contributions 93–182 of 182. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Ní bhaineann an scéal sin leis an díospóireacht seo.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Eamonn Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

Deineadh tagairt do Bhaile Mhúirne, áit atá san nGaeltacht. Tá eolas agam ar an nGaeltacht agus deirim-se gur fearr an cuidiú atá an Rialtas seo ag tabhairt do mhuintir na Gaeltachta ná an cuidiú a thug an dream eile dóibh nuair a bhí siad i réim. Is iad na daoine is boichte atá i gceist agam anois. I rith na bliana seo caithte, do caitheadh £88,583 ar bhainne a tugadh saor do chlanna bochta.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Cionnus a bhaineann sé sin leis an mBunreacht?

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Eamonn Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

Ní bhaineann sé leis, ach deineadh tagairt do bhochtanas na tíre san ndíospóireacht seo agus shíleas go raibh sé ceart agam freagra do thabhairt do sna Teachtaí ar an dtaobh thall. Ar na Teachtaí a dhein tagairt don scéal seo, bhí an Teachta Ua Murchadha, agus bhí an Teachta Ua Laoghaire ag tabhairt congnaimh dó.

Comment on this
Daniel O'Leary Domhnall Ua Laoghaire Cumann na nGaedheal

Níor ghá aon chongnamh do thabhairt do mar do thuig sé féin an scéal go maith.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Eamonn Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

Ní fheadar ar thuig sé. Dubhairt tú, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, ná raibh baint ag an scéal seo leis an mBunreacht agus aontuím leat agus fágfaidh mé súd mar atá sé. Taithnigheann an Dréacht-Bhunreacht seo go mór liom. Sé an fáth go dtaithnigheann sé liom ná go bhfuil rudaí áirithe ag baint leis go mba cheart a bheith ag baint le Bunreacht ar bith le haghaidh na tíre seo. Ar an gcéad dul síos, tá sé Gaedhealach agus tug-tar an chéad aít do theangain ár sinnsear. Tugaim fé ndeara ar Airteagal 18, a bhaineann leis an Seanad, na focla seo:

"An Ghaedhilg agus an tSaoidheacht náisiúnta, Oideachas agus pé garma a léireochthar le dligheadh chun críche an rolla seo."

Chímíd go bhfuil an chéad áit tugtha don teangain náisiúnta. Is mór an dul chun cinn sin agus is ceart an chéad áit do thabhairt don Ghaedhilg san Dara Tigh, chó maith leis an gCéad Tigh. Dá mhéid a chloisim de sna cainnteanna o lucht na taoibhe eile ag cáineadh an Dréacht-Bhunreachta so an rud is mó atá buailte isteach im' aigne ná fuil ar siubhal acu ach lagiarracht chun Bunreacht na hEireann do chur os cóir na ndaoine mar rud nár cheart dóibh aon tsuim a chur ann.

Anois fáth eile go bhfuilim sásta leis an nDréacht so iseadh go bhfuil léargus ceart Críostamhail ann. Tír iseadh í seo go bhfuil dílseacht fé leith ag na daoine don chlainn, don phósadh agus don creideamh agus is ceart go mbeadh áit fé leith dó-san i mBun-Dligheadh na tíre seo. B'é teagasc na bhfeallsúnaidhthe nótálta poilitidheachta ó aimsir na sean-Ghréige anuas gurbh í an chlann préamh cheart an Stáit agus an Stát ná beadh bunuithe ar an slighe sin ná beadh rí ná rath air.

Annsin tá le feiscint sa Dréacht-Bhunreacht so an smaoineadh gurbh iad na daoine na máighistrí. Thríd síos tá sé soiléir gurbh é a theastuigh ó lucht a cheaptha ná toil agus údarás na ndaoine bheith in uachtar. Má bhí daonfhlathacht riamh ann beidh sé in Éirinn againn nuair a bheidh an Dréacht so rithte. Beidh údarás na ndaoine i mbun is i mbarr gach nidh a bhaineas le rialú na tíre. Tá na teachtaí eile ag iarraidh a dhéanamh amach mar dheadh, ná beidh san Uachtarán ach deactóir. Ní chreideann siad féin é sin ach is amhlaidh atá siad ag iarraidh eagla a chur ar na daoine. D'fhéadfaí a rádh go mbeidh trí cinn de dhualgaisí ar an Uachtarán. Má bhíonn a mhalairt de thuairim ag an nDáil agus ag an Seanad i dtaobh cad is bille airgid ann agus má loirgeann an Seanad breith agus réidhteach air sin cuirfidh an tUachtarán fé bhrághaid Chomhairle an Stáit é, agus cé bheidh na gComhairleoirí Stáit: An Taoiseach, an Tánaiste, an Prímh-Bhreithimh, Uachtarán na hArd-Chúirte, Cathaoirleach na Dála agus Cathaoirleach an tSeanaid, Atúrnae an Stáit srl Cá bhfuil an deachtóireacht annsin? Ní chuireann an tUachtarán a thuairim féin i bhfeidhm ar na daoine, agus deachtóir iseadh duine a chuireann a thuairim agus a thoil féin i bhfeidhm is cuma an ceart no mí-cheart é.

Maidir le huimhir a dó, má cheapann an tUachtarán ná fuil bille áirithe ar aon dul le téarmaí agus le sprid an Bhunreachta, ragha sé i gcomhairle le Comhairle an Stáit féachaint an ceart é chur fé bhraghaid na Cúirte Uachtaraighe agus tabharfaid sin a mbreith ar an scéal. Cá bhfuil an deachtóireacht ag baint leis sin? Ní féidir a rádh go bhféadfaidh an tUachtarán an lámh láidir d'imirt ar an breithimh sa Chúirt sin.

Maidir le h-uimhir a trí, má ceaptar gur ceart Bille a chur fé bhrághaid na ndaoine mar gheall ar a thábhacht don náisiún, má chuireann an chuid is mó de bhaill na Seanaide nó trian den Dáil athchuinge isteach go dtí an tUachtarán ag iarraidh air an Bille do chose go dtí go mbeidh caoi ag na daoine a mbreith do thabhairt air agus má cheapann Comhairle an Stáit gur ceart é chur fé bhrághaid na ndaoine agus má dheineann an tUachtarán é sin an féidir a rádh gur deachtóireacht é sin? Ní headh go deimhin ach a mhalairt, agus dá bhrí sin, na daoine a deir go mbeidh an t-Uachtarán 'na Dheachtóir, níl ar súil aca ach baochaint agus ráiméis.

Anois maidir le hAirteagal (4) Éire is ainm don Stáit. Do chuala an Teachta Mac Diarmuda á rádh indé gur ceart an ainm Ireland do bhaisteadh ar an Stát. Ba mhór an náire é sin mar do bhí an ainm Éire ar an Stát so sar a raibh aon trácht ar Ireland. Éire na nGaedheal no seo. Nuair a bhí ainm na tíre seo in airde fadó nuair ba mhór le rádh muinntir na tíre seo maidir le saoidheacht, maidir le cultúr, oideachas agus teagasc, sé Éire an ainm a bhí ar an dtír seo. “Is mise Éire is sinne mé na an Chailleach Béara,” adubhairt Pádraig Mac Piarais. Níor taithaigh an t-ainm “Saorstát Éireann” liom riamh, níor samhluigheadh dom gurab é an ciall o bhí leis na Stát gan Saoirse iomlán, d'ainneoin an méid adubhairt na Teachtaí thall. Gidh ná fuil smacht éifeachtach againn ar na Sé Condaethe sa tuaisceard ní orainn an milleán sin, ach ar na Teachtaí ar an dtaobh eile.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Ceist eile 'seadh sin nach mbaineann leis an mBunreacht.

Comment on this
Daniel O'Leary Domhnall Ua Laoghaire Cumann na nGaedheal

Cad a thug sibh isteach?

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Eamonn Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

Muintire na tíre a chuir annso sinne.

Comment on this
Daniel O'Leary Domhnall Ua Laoghaire Cumann na nGaedheal

An Connradh.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Eamonn Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

B'féidir go dtiocfimíd isteach arís níos láidre, gidh go bhfuil ganntanas agus bochtannas sa tír, do réir na Theachtaí thall. I gceann tamaill, beidh seans ag na daoine a dtuairim do nochtú ar an gceist seo, ach ós rud é ná fuil baint aige leis an mBunreacht, fágfaidh mé an scéal mar atá. Dubhairt an Teachta O Súilleabháin ná beadh caoi cheart ag muintir na tíre a mbreith do thabhairt san olltoghachán ar chursaí economice na tíre toisc iad do bheith fighte fuaighte le ceist an Bhunreachta. Ná beidh faill ag na daoine a mbreith do thabhairt ar an dhá rud? Ná fuil cead acu a nguthanna do thabhairt don Rialtas agus guth do thabhairt in aghaidh an Bhunreachta. Deirimse go mbeidh caoi níos fearr acu a mbreith do thabhairt ar an mBunreacht so agus ar a n-aigne do dhéanamh suas maidir le cursaí na tíre ná bhí acu nuair a cuireadh an Sean Bhunreacht os comhair an phobail. Is cuimhin liom an t-am san. Cuireadh an Dréacht-Bhunreacht os comhair na daoine maidin an Olltoghacháin.

Mar adubhairt, táim lán-tsásta leis an mBunreacht agus táim cinnte go bhfuil saol nua roimh mhuintir na tíre fé. Níl aon eagla orm ná glachfar go fonnmhar leis nuair a cuirfear os comhair na daoine é. Bunreacht Gaedhealach 'seadh é a chuireann toil agus údarás na ndaoine in uachtar.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am very slow to intervene in this debate because any remarks that I may make may be considered as detracting from the value of, may be taken as belittling the value of, the Constitution—that would be thought to belittle the value of the Constitution at present before us. I am slow to intervene, more so because I think that we could be employed in far better work at the moment than in discussing this Constitution. I think that there are many more pressing problems asking for solution at the present moment than the problem that this Constitution will solve, or than any Constitution could solve, problems that could be solved within the four corners of the present Constitution—not that I like the present Constitution. There is also this reason: I think it is very bad to put so much into the present Constitution, to make a rigid Constitution now when so much of the ideals and hopes and aspirations of our people are in flux. I think we ought to wait and give these things time to take shape before we frame for ourselves a rigid Constitution of this kind. I also think it is rather inopportune that we should ask the people to decide upon the fundamental law of the State at the same time as we are asking them to decide what Party is to be put first in power to operate that fundamental law. You will not be able to separate the two questions in the minds of the people, and the people will not be able to give that full attention and that full care to the consideration of the various items of that fundamental law that will be put before them. They will be influenced, consciously or unconsciously, by the political arguments that will be put before them at the same time, and therefore it is not giving a fair chance to the Constitution itself, bad or mediocre or good as it may be. It is not giving a fair chance to the people to express an opinion on it. Political and partisan views will be expressed more in the voting papers, in whatever form papers will be offered to the people in respect of the Constitution, than would be otherwise if it were offered to the people at a time when calmness, quietness and normal conditions would prevail.

There is another argument. The spokesmen of the present Government never tire telling us, and no doubt there will be a spate of that rhetoric within the coming six weeks or so, that they are going to return with an enhanced majority, that they are going to return with a majority that will make them independent of all Parties in the House. If they believe that, why not wait until they come back with that enhanced majority, and then submit this Constitution to the people when the people, in normal conditions, will have an opportunity for considering it? I am not going to pursue the false hope that they are expressing, but it is relevant to refer to it.

There are a few matters with reference to the Constitution itself which I suppose it may be relevant to refer to. We are told in Article 5 that "Eire is a sovereign, independent, democratic State." Well, one would think that that would be amplified or extended in some fashion. What kind of State is it going to be? There are several very well recognised forms of State. There are limited monarchies, there are republics, federated and confederated republics. What kind of State is it going to be? The limited monarchy in England is a sovereign State. Is this State going to be a limited monarchy? The Republic of America is a sovereign, democratic State. Is this State going to be a republic? No doubt the people of Germany would say that their State is a democratic State for, notwithstanding whatever may be said regarding it, they did elect Rudolph Hitler— the people of Germany did elect him. There was an election and he was elected. Is it going to be a totalitarian State like Germany? What State is it going to be like? Or what exactly is one to read into Article 5? Is one to read it that Eire is a sovereign, independent, democratic, limited monarchy, a republic or a confederated republic? What can I substitute in place of the word State in that Article? In other Constitutions we find some definite form that the State will take. Why are we afraid to say here what form it is going to take? We were told by the President that we are going to be: "Dilis do'n mbrat na bopalachta." I think these were his words. Is this Constitution going to be the swaddling clothes of the expected republic, or is it going to be the winding sheet of the republic? So far as this Constitution and Fianna Fáil Administration are concerned, I think it is going to be the winding sheet of the republic, and, so far as the present Administration is concerned, speaking a funeral oration over it in Irish will not make it open its lovely blue eyes to this new mother Éire found for it. The State Éire is to extend over all Ireland. That may be optimistic but it certainly is not realistic.

The President himself told us yesterday that he did not expect that our writ was going to run in the Six Counties. It is foolish for us then to say that the State Éire includes the Six Counties. If my Irish history is anyway correct, we did at one time claim that we had some governmental control over Scotland, or portion of Scotland. Could we include Scotland in Éire, and would it have any effect? It would have much the same effect as including the Six Counties. Of course, it is possibly a way of hiding what we want to do, but to my mind we ought to say that Éire is a sovereign, independent dominion, republic or kingdom, and have done with it. To say that it is a sovereign, independent, democratic State and not to indicate what form the State is to take is certainly endeavouring to deceive ourselves and probably succeeding.

Deputy Lavery told us that we were creating a new dynasty. Of all the Parties that should speak with reference to the creation of a new dynasty the Party that Deputy Lavery belongs to should be the last to speak of that. They did not create a new dynasty. They found one already made, and they incorporated it in the Constitution that they gave us. If we did create a new dynasty it would have this advantage, that it would be an Irish dynasty. So far as we are concerned, the dynasty that they introduced could be qualified by only one word, a word that probably Shakespeare would not balk at using. If I were to use it I would probably be reprimanded by you, Sir, for doing so, but it finds a place in the English dictionary as a good Anglo-Saxon word. That is the only word to qualify it.

There has been a good deal of reference to the privileged position that the Irish language is to have under this Constitution. Article 8 says "the Irish language as the national language is the first official language." I can conceive of only one official language. I cannot conceive of two official languages. "The English language is recognised as a second official language." One may be permitted to use it, but to say that English is the second official language does not seem to me to be right sense. The third provision in Article 8 says "Provision may, however, be made by law for the exclusive use of either of the said languages for any one or more official purposes, either throughout the State or in any part thereof." That seems to me to be a concession to certain people who, we say, are included in Éire, but who, in fact, are not included in Éire. Is that a concession to the Six Counties, or is it not? Within the Twenty-Six Counties if there are people who object to have Irish as the official language, does this mean that permission is given for the other language—English—to be used? What is it a concession to? It is quite possible in that connection that we can cuddle our friends in Northern Ireland and make them very amenable. But, if I were giving advice to the Executive Council on the Constitution, I would suggest that they give them a bear's hug, which is probably a thing they would appreciate better.

Article 13 (10) states:—

"Subject to this Constitution, additional powers and functions may be conferred on the President by law."

That seems an innocuous kind of provision; but one can easily visualise a state of affairs in which it would be a very dangerous power. One can easily visualise a time when a President would be elected who would be, so far as political ideals are concerned, in conformity with the Government. That Government, holding a majority in the Dáil, could confer powers on the President by law; then with a Seanad with limited powers and a Council of State which he may consult but on whose advice he need not act what is to prevent a President in these circumstances, three years after the passing of the Constitution, abolishing the Oireachtas? I do not think there is anything in the Constitution to prevent him from doing it. Additional powers may be conferred on him by law. The legislation can be enacted here by a majority. The Seanad is limited in its powers and, after three years, he can act without referring that law to the people. Is there anything in the Constitution to prevent the President under such a set of circumstances from absolutely dissolving the Oireachtas? I would remind the people who give those very extensive powers that when they speak about the excessive use of those powers in Continental countries, they forget that some of these people in Continental countries who are using those powers in a dictatorial fashion were actually elected by the people. We should not place ourselves in the position of having a democratic President who may be in a position to do away with the machinery of Parliament.

Putting the President above the law may be very useful, but I did not expect to find such a dyed-in-the-wool democrat as the Minister for Finance pleading for the continuation of the tag, "The King can do no wrong," in this Constitution. There is no reason why the head of the State should not be amenable to law. The Minister for Finance knows perfectly well that putting the King outside the law simply meant that "the King can do no wrong." Making the head of the State not amenable to the law is a continuation of the old bogey, the divine right of Kings, "the King can do no wrong." I did not expect to find that in this ultra-democratic Constitution and that we would have a pro-democratic Minister for Finance defending it.

The Minister for Finance told us a few other interesting things. He told us that the President's signature is a guarantee that an Act of the Oireachtas is not in conflict with the Constitution. The President, of course, before he signs a Bill can submit it to the courts for a declaration as to whether anything in it is repugnant to the Constitution. But, once he signs it, I understood from the Minister for Finance that that is a guarantee to the citizen that nothing in it is repugnant to the Constitution. That is a very dangerous provision, in my opinion. At present I think there is a provision by which any citizen can test the validity of any Act passed by this Parliament in the law courts to see whether it is valid or invalid. The Minister for Finance told us that it was not merely his signature the President was putting to it as his signature, but that by it he was indicating to the citizens that there was nothing in the Act repugnant to the Constitution. There should be some provision by which a citizen would be entitled to take the opinion of the courts as to the validity or the repugnancy of any Act to the Constitution.

There is one thing in which, possibly, I am more interested than anything I have referred to so far, and which may be raised on Article 45. Much play has been made about the family, about the rights of women, and about the right of preserving family life and such things. But one would expect that in the fundamental law of the country, which justly respects private property and the rights of the family and the maintenance of family life, there would be some statement as to live. The only of all citizens to live. The only private property of a certain section of the community is the labour of their hands or heads. If the labour of their hands cannot be utilised, they are condemned either to a dragging existence or to death. One would expect to find in Bunreacht na hEireann some reference to this. At the beginning of Article 45 we find this most extraordinary statement:—

"The principles of social policy set forth in this Article are intended for the general guidance of the Oireachtas. The application of those principles in the making of laws shall be the exclusive care of the Oireachtas and shall not be cognisable by any court under any of the provisions of this Constitution."

In other words, they are pious aspirations so far as social legislation and social conditions are concerned. I should have thought that there would be expressly set out in a Constitution of this kind the right of all citizens either to work or maintenance. That is one of the most serious omissions in this Constitution. It is one of the most serious omissions in this Constitution, and even although subsequent legislation guided by this may be enacted, this Constitution says that all it suggests here are merely pious aspirations for the guidance of the Oireachtas. I do not wish to stress any further any of these points. I have endeavoured to indicate what seem to me to be flaws in this Constitution. That is the greatest flaw of the lot. There is no provision made by which citizens who, it is alleged, have similar rights to other citizens, will find any means of existence provided for them. One would expect to find in a Constitution a provision somewhat of this kind, on these lines, perhaps somewhat better worded: "that every citizen shall be afforded an opportunity of sustaining life and the lives of those dependent upon them by labour, physical or mental, and where such is not available that the State shall maintain him and his dependents in frugal comfort." That is a provision that should find expression in a Constitution of this kind. I commend this provision, or something similar to it, to the consideration of the President and the members of the Executive Council. I also say that this is not an opportune time to put before the people, with an election coming on, the fundamental law of the country when, whether they like it or not, people will be influenced by political arguments and political prejudices.

Comment on this

I am very pleased to hear from the Labour Benches a speech of the type to which we have just listened. I say that because there was a note of sincerity running right through that speech, and unquestionably there was a straightforward expression of uneasiness and anxiety with regard to the possibilities of this particular instrument. There was expressed, too, a note of fear with regard to the powers it is proposed to put into the hands of a single political individual. I welcome the statement to the effect that a great portion of this lengthy document of 115 pages is just so many pious aspirations strung together without any serious attempt to implement, or put into operation, such pious aspirations. As one speaker said already, the Constitution should not be something like a Fianna Fáil election poster. The Constitution, if it is to be taken seriously —and the Constitution should be taken seriously—and if it is to get close study and interest from all Parties and sections—should be devoid of all meaningless phraseology. If a Constitution is to be read, studied and examined in the homes of the people, as the President asked in his broadcast message, then very definitely the Constitution should be free from all evasiveness and free from ambiguity, and should be set forth in the plainest and simplest language. The outstanding feature of this document is its very evasiveness and the clumsy attempts to hide what is really there. There are certain big things that matter in every Constitution. One is the type of State we are going to have, whether it will be a monarchy or a republic or a State associated by its Constitution with other States. That is definitely one of the things that matter to each one of us, no matter for which of these States we stand. That is one of the things that should be set forth most fully and should be stood over most bravely. A person going through this document with a magnifying glass and with the mind of a constitutional lawyer will get one cause for uneasiness removed. Because he will see within that document that one of the things it does, in fact, is to keep up the association of this country with other nations in the Commonwealth. But would the ordinary citizen, unversed in the peculiar acrobatic tactics of the author of that document, be able to find this section and interpret its meaning? On the very face of it, there is a laboured attempt to mislead the ordinary citizen. To the ordinary citizen who wants to study every line of it there is revealed a want of candour and a want of frankness which is stamped on every clause of that instrument. When I read through the 115 pages of that document for the first time, I regarded it as a kind of political curate's egg, good in spots. The closer I studied it, and the more I listened to the views of the author, the more I began to feel that the good spots were remarkably absent, or that the egg was so thoroughly scrambled that every bit of it was tainted and that it was hard to get at the good spots.

There are things in this Constitution that are good, and it is a remarkable fact that the outstanding case of merit in this Constitution is where it is proposed to undo the work that was done in recent years by the present Government. One of the things in this Constitution, and in fact I am inclined to say the only thing in this Constitution that got full and frank, free and impartial consideration was the re-establishment of the Seanad. The re-establishment of the Seanad and the reconverting of this Parliament into a bi-cameral legislature is one of the remarkably good things in this Constitution. There we are undoing belatedly the damage that was done by the present Government. We are also re-establishing the principle of direct university representation in the Parliament of this country. None of us need have very long memories to recollect the type of speeches that were made from the Government Benches when the Fianna Fáil Government was abolishing the Seanad. When we had visions of the danger of a unicameral House, and when we listened to the speeches from the Government Benches, we were told how undemocratic university representation was and what an evil thing it was in a democratic State. Were those people sincere then or are they sincere now? Were they preaching the truth that was in them then, or are they preaching the truth that is in them now? But I accept the Seanad as one of the good features of this document for this reason, that these 115 pages of the Constitution were produced, drafted, drawn up and given to us without the consideration of any individual outside a small select group of politicians. It is quite clear that more attention was paid to the constitution of the Seanad or the revival of the Seanad than was paid to the Constitution of this country. When it came to evolving a Second House we had invitations sent out to all Parties, all classes of society, to participate in that work, to give their aid and their counsel and to express their views. When those views were expressed, the result of the combined opinion of all these was that a Second House should be established. That is the attention, that is the consideration, and that is the non-political manner in which the Seanad was reconstituted.

But when it came to the more important thing, when it came to the Constitution under which, presumably, we will live and die and children will be born, what happened there? The greatest political fanatic in the whole country did it, and he alone, and no outside view was expressed, no outside voice was heard, and we have here a document that is the normal birth of such a brain. We have a document before us, the only outstanding feature in which is that the whole 115 pages and the whole 60 or 70 Articles are so many props, so many bricks, to build an edifice for one man to sit in. The whole document we have here is building a throne for one individual, and that throne is to be built by materials stolen from the Parliament of the people, and the powers that are passed into the hands of that individual are powers to be filched from the Government and the Parliament of the people.

We listened to arguments yesterday about the powers that are to be conferred on this new all-highest, and at one awkward corner in the discussions yesterday we had the President attempting to rub down the worried nerves of people who were anxious about that particular clause. What line did he take? When that point was made and when it was indicated that the new President, in addition to his powers and functions, would have other powers and functions conferred on him by law, and that those might be, in a legal sense, unlimited, the President's line of argument at that time was "No. Such a thing could not be done. That is merely a clause inserted in order to make provision for such a thing as a new university, so that the President might have power to appoint visitors to such a new university."

A few hours later, when a point was made by Deputy Lavery that there were certain functions reserved for the King and that the President would be powerless to have anything to do or say with those reserved functions, Deputy Lavery was contradicted by the President. The Deputy asked the President to point out, in this document, where he had those powers, and the President's answer was to refer Deputy Lavery to the particular Article that laid down that the President would have any further powers conferred on him by law; in other words, in addition to the powers here given to an individual, the powers that might be given to him by a friendly or allied Government or by an obedient majority Party in this House. Such powers were definitely unlimited. So we are to pass this document in haste in order to make it possible for an autocrat or dictator, partly through the machinery of this document as it stands, and partly by the legislation of a docile or servile Government, to have powers conferred on an individual in this country that the country would even shirk giving to an executive group. The individual who is to get those powers is to be immune from all law except high treason or high crime for the full period of seven years, and he is to be answerable for the performance of his duties to no person or persons inside or outside Parliament. Parliament cannot reduce by one penny his salary, income or allowances for the full period of seven years.

This weapon that was used on many a platform for the past two years is the charter of liberty for the people. When it is here before us in all its ugly nakedness we find that the only real change that is proposed to be made in the powers of the Parliament or the powers of the people is in the direction of taking from the people and taking from Parliament powers which they enjoy at the moment. This President, this new functionary, is to take precedence over every other person in the State. He is to be elected for seven years. He is the only individual in the whole State, after his term of seven years is up, who will have the right of self-nomination for re-election. All others must get so many Deputies or Senators, or so many borough or county councils to nominate them. He and he alone is to have the exclusive right of self-nomination. He is to be immune from all the laws of the land. The law is good enough for you or for me, the law is good enough for the man and woman outside, but this particular individual, during his seven years, can commit any or every crime and there is no law made by Irishmen that can touch him.

He is above the law, immune from the law, unanswerable to the people, unchecked by Parliament. The Parliament is merely to supply the funds but not to question his actions. He may or may not dissolve the Parliament on the advice of a Premier who has lost the confidence of the Parliament. If there happens to be a Premier over there who is beaten on a vote of no confidence by, we will say, four-fifths of the members of this Parliament, the system at the moment, the normal system in every democratic country, is that the majority of people in that Parliament then elect that man's successor and the new President either carries on or dissolves. But there is a special provision made here that he may or may not dissolve Dáil Eireann on the advice of a Premier who has lost the confidence of Dáil Eireann. It is not the Dáil that is going to decide whether or not there will be a dissolution of the Dáil. It is not the newly-elected Premier who will decide whether or not there will be a dissolution of the Dáil. It is this individual, this functionary, this all-highest, who, we are told, is above and outside politics, who will decide— and he alone will decide—how this House will conduct its business.

He is to be Commander-in-Chief of the Army, and the powers he will exercise under that title will be whatever powers are given to him by law, and those powers are unlimited. He will not only have a stranglehold on Parliament, but he will have the operative command-in-chief of the Army. You have got to visualise things, just not as they are at the present moment, just not as they are with you people over there the majority Party, and the Opposition over here a minority Party. If you pass that Constitution, it will be, or should be, a Constitution for the rest of our lives, a Constitution, as far as we can see, for all time. What Government Deputies, as well as Opposition Deputies, have got to ask themselves—not thinking in terms of President de Valera or Deputy Cosgrave—is whether it is safe to give anybody that comes along, or that may come along, such awful powers to strangle your Parliament, and to grab your Army, as can be given in this document.

Now this individual is to be elected by the votes of the people. We have all read history, and we all know that in this as well as in other countries it is the experience of all to be applauded one day and spat on the next, and that the popular life of any individual can be written in the same number of years as you have fingers on your hand: that the popular life of any individual is strictly limited. It is all very well to give these powers to a man on the crest of a popular wave, but you have got to remember that, once given, they cannot be withdrawn, and that when the day comes that both Deputies and public are up against that particular man as intensely as they can be, not one of the powers given can be withdrawn or limited or curtailed without the particular type of cumbersome and unwieldy machinery in which he has a say as well as anybody else. It stands to reason. We have all gone through elections and we all understand how election work is done. It is nonsense to talk of this individual as being outside and above politics. Who can get there except the most successful politician? Who can get there except the most active or most prominent politician? No individual could get there. On an adult suffrage vote no one could be elected without the entire support of one of the great political Parties in this country. It would be a political impossibility for anybody to be elected to the position of President except with the active support of one of the great political machines, and, to get the support of that great political machine, he must be a prominent political leader. That being so, the man who gets to the position of President in this country will be a prominent and leading politician.

Now, a man cannot shed his political convictions and inclination like a Scotch partridge changes its colours. A man may say: "I am above and over politics," but he is just as much a rabid politician the day after he gets on that throne as he was on the day before he ascended it, and he will never ascend it without being a Party man until the last vote is polled. Now, the day after his election, one of two things happens. He may have a Government whose political label is similar to his own, and that will be the Government that will legislate what further powers, if any, that man is to get. Presumably, he was their late leader. Presumably, he was the big bashaw of that Party up to a week or so before. His word was law. The place each of them occupied in the political sun was due, to a great extent, to his successful leadership. Those will be the men who will decide what powers he will have—what further powers he will have—with regard to the Constitution and to what extent his command in the Army will operate. Any one of us and every one of us knows that in that set of circumstances his powers will be greatly increased over and above what is indicated there. Having increased them for that individual, they are powerless to alter them for his successors, and powerless, without a very unwieldy type of machinery, to limit them either during his tenure of office or subsequently. The alternative is this: that you have that highly political President elected and you have a Government of an opposite political colour, and you must have that every now and then. I believe that the position will be definitely worse and more dangerous in that situation. He has powers to withhold sanctions or to force the Government to proceed through certain very devious and difficult ways in order to get their legislation through. He can, in fact, paralyse the legislation of that Government. There is nothing that I read into that document to say that he is bound in any event by the advice of the advisory council, but having listened to that advisory council, and having let them talk, he can then absolutely paralyse the elected Executive of the State.

It may be that he can justify that paralysis because he can satisfy himself that they are going in a direction that, he believes, interferes with, or is dangerous, or not in the best interests of the people. I will give everybody this much credit, that whatever stand we all take, each one of us is convinced in our own minds that we are doing the right thing by the people of this country. Yet, see how obstinate we are, and we are all equally convinced that we are right, and conscientiously right, and right in honour. Now, that man, if he is to subscribe to the oath he takes, has got to use his brains and ability on behalf of the people who elected him, and if he is a strong-willed man with an opinion of his own, and if he is the type of man that is capable of convincing himself, at all events, that he is right in whatever attitude he takes, even when he takes opposite attitudes in different weeks, then, surely, there is grave potential danger in having such an individual over the elected Executive of your Parliament and over the elected Parliament of the people.

There is one significant thing about this debate and I welcome it. I have never seen it before in this House. We have proposed legislation brought in by the leader of a Government. We have an amendment asking for delay or for postponement of that legislation from the political Opposition. That is a normal feature. That is what happens in the case of almost every Bill. But then you have a Deputy of the President's Party tabling another motion also asking to have that legislation postponed. We have that seconded by another Deputy elected as a follower of the President and elected as a member of that Party. In addition, we have another motion down asking for delay from a member sitting on the Independent Benches. Furthermore, we have a Labour Deputy, speaking presumably on behalf of his Party, warning the Government and the Dáil as to the dangers inherent in that document, warning us that it is unwise and dangerous to give such powers over Parliament and the people to any single individual, no matter whether popularly elected or otherwise. We have seen Governments doing unwise and foolish things. A Government consists of ten or 12 men taking counsel with one another and yet, very hasty, very foolish, very unwise things have been done by Governments. Well, it would be wiser, far wiser to give vastly greater powers, practically unlimited powers, to any group of men than to give even moderate power to an individual. I would warn you again in giving these powers: do not think in terms of persons. What powers you are inclined to give now, to the person you are thinking of now, will be conferred on anybody in ten, 15 or 20 years time.

The underlying idea in this amendment to the Constitution is that when it goes through, Parliament, at least, will be powerless to amend it. Amended it will be some time, but, as Deputy O'Sullivan said, amended it will be following a deadlock. When that deadlock occurs between this all-highest and Parliament, either in the near or distant future, the situation may be met by an amendment to the Constitution or it may be met by the establishment of a dictatorship. If the command of the Army is on one side and the confidence of the people on the other, then there is a situation precipitated that is charged with nothing but danger and evil to the future of the country. Why invite or make possible a situation of that kind? Even if it is only remotely possible, why bring such a situation within the sphere of possibility? Is the office of President of this country not a high enough office for any individual? Outside that, are there not plenty duties to be carried out by the ceremonial head of the State, over and above those assigned to that individual, which would keep him busy enough, that would keep him engaged, that would take social and other duties off the shoulders of the Premier, who will have a lot of important work to do in the legislative field, without conferring or making it possible to confer all the powers that this Draft is conferring on an individual?

We have dictatorships here and there in Europe. Is any one of these defensible or made more desirable on the ground that the leader or the dictator was first popularly elected? I do not know. There may be one or two, but I do not know of any dictator in any of the dictatorial countries that was not first of all the product of popular election, of mass voting, of broad choice, of the enthusiastic selection of the democratic people in that country. Then, in their moment of frenzy, excitement and enthusiasm, they gave him a Government of his own, with authority to that Government to give him further powers, and they ended up where they never thought they had even begun to go. Everyone of them, or at least the bulk of them, was first elected by the popular vote. Powers were given to a docile and obedient Government to define by law what further powers that elected Government should give to the President, and that obedient, docile and servile Government increased these powers so widely that it was only a short step to handing over all control to the dictator. Then you had Parliaments brushed aside one by one, and the individuals remained. The Parliaments were gone or, as far as they remained, they were only just the ballet called together to applaud the prima donna. That, at least, is one of the possibilities and one of the things that must stare out of that document at everybody who examines it impartially.

We, over here, have been accused of political bias. Will you hurl that accusation at the Labour Party? You have got a service from that Party during your five and a half years of office that no Government ever got from any Party not subject to the Government Whip directly. Will you level that accusation at the members who were elected as members of your own Party who have spoken in this House? Would each one of you not ask your neighbour or ask yourselves in private: is it wise to give such powers, we shall say, to Deputy Cosgrave or to Deputy Norton? Ask yourselves what you would say if that proposal came from a Cosgrave, a Norton, or an O'Duffy Government and you were asked to pass it here. Would you not be all in full cry, everyone of you? Some of you in Irish, most of you in English, would be in full cry against this proposal to establish a dictatorship in this island of ours. There is a clause in that document which says: "This is a democratic State." It must have been the wisdom of the lawyers that put in that clause, because, if it were not there, nobody reading that document would know it.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Aire um Oideachas (Tomás O Deirg) Fianna Fáil

Is iongantach an rud gur féidir leis an Teachta O hUigín codladh ina leabaidh san oídche agus an méid sgannraithe atá air roimh dheachtóireacht fén mBunreacht seo. Da mba rud é go mba mhaith linn deachtóireacht do chur ar bun, ní bheadh am ná ocáid níos feiliúnaí chun é sin do dhéanamh ná an tám atá anois ann. Níl acht an Dáil againn; nil Seanad ná Seanascal ná rí i gcursaibh inmheadmacha againn agus, i ngach rud a bhaineas le saol na tíre, tá a lán comhachta ag furmhór na Dála agus, dá bhrí sin, ag an Rialtas. Dlí ar bith go mba mhaith leo a chur i bhfeidhm, thiocfadh leo é do dhéanamh láithreach bonn. Thiocfadh leo deachtóireacht do chur ar bun anois láithreach dá mba mhian leo. Taisbeánann sin nach bhfuil mórán céille ag dul leis an bport a bhí dha sheinnt ag an dTeachta O hUigín. Níl aon chúis imnidhe ann. Ba cheart go mbeadh níos mó faitchíosa ar an dTeachta anois, agus an Rialtas atá ann— dubhairt sé nach raibh aon mhuinighin aige as baill áirithe den Rialtas—ná a bheadh air nuair a bhéas an Bunreacht seo i bhfeidhm. Ba dhóich le duine go raibh an tUachtarán togtha cheana féin agus go raibh gach rud leagtha amach againn i dtaobh na hUachtaranachta. Caithfidh sé gur beag muinighin atá ag an dTeachta as muintir na hEireann má shaoileann sé go nglacadh sead le socrú mar sin, nó go dtoghfadh siad duine ar bith nach bhfuil oiriúnach don oifig agus nach mbeadh ullamh an Bunreacht d'oibriú d'réir dlí. Ní thig leis an Uachtarán dul thar an dlí. Shaoilfeadh duine ó chaint an Teachta go dtiocfadh leis an Uachtarán a rogha rud do dhéanamh, ach ní mar sin atá an sceál in aon chor. Is cuma cad a deireann lucht cáinte an Bhunreachta—thig leo é do rá gach uair sa ló—tá fhios ag an domhan agus ag éinne go bhfuil ciall aige agus a léigheann an Bunreacht seo nach féidir leis an Uachtarán dul lasmuich den Bhunreacht. Ar an gcéad dul síos, caithfidh sé a chomhachta fén mBunreacht fheimiú ar chomhairle an Rialtais, go mór-mór sa rudai a bhí i gceist ag an dTeachta—rudaí a bhaineann le náisiún eile agus le caidreamh idirnáisiúnta. Caithfidh sé comhairle do ghlacadh ón Rialtas agus ní thig leis aon rud eile do dhéanamh ach dul ar an gcomhairle sin.

Tá a lán cur síos freisin ar an fóráiltatá sa Bhunreacht mar gheall ar na chomhachta is féidir cur le comhachta an Uachtaráin. Is leis an Oireachtas amháin na comhachta sin do thabhairt, má fhaghann an tUachtarán, comhachta eile, caithfidh sé iad d'oibriú do réir dlí, cosúil leis na rudaí eile a bhaineas le na dhual gaisí.

Do labhair an Teachta O hUigín mar gheall ar an Uachtarán a bheith i gceannas an Airm agus ba dhóigh le duine go mbeadh an tUachtarán i ndon an tArm do chur amach amárach agus a rá le muintir na hEireann "beidh mé im' Uachtarán feasta. Ní bheidh aon Dáil agus ní bheidh aon Seanad, nó aon Oireachtas chor ar bith ann." Ní thig leis an Uachtarán é sin do dhéanamh. Ní foláir dó oibriú do réir forálacha an Bhunreachta. In Airteagal 13 (4), gidh go ndeirtear annsan go bhfuil an tArm fé cheanas an Uachtaráin, deirtear ann, freisin, nach féidir leis é do rialú ach tríd an dlí. Caithfidh an dlí do chur tríd an Oireachtas ag leagadh amach an modh ina n'oibreachthar árd-cheannas an Airm. Níl aon chiall, dá bhrí sin, san méid adubhradh fé sin: go mbeidh comhacht ag an Uachtarán dul lasmuich den dlí agus comhachta neadleatha do thógáil dó féin agus dul amach i gceannas an Airm gan cead ón Rialtas nó ón dlí. Ní thig leis é sin do déanamh i gceist a bhaineann leis an Airm níos mó ná is féidir leis é do dhéanamh i gceisteanna a bhaineas le caidreamh idirnáisiúnta.

Maidir le cheisteanna eile a bhaineas leis an Uachtarán agus na comhachta eile atá leagtha amach dó fén mBunreacht seo, caithfidh sé, uair eannta eigin, comhairle do ghlacadh ó Chomhairle an Stáit agus uair eannta eile, dul do reir chomhairle an Rialtais; ach, ar aon chuma, caithfidh sé oibriú do réir na forálacha atá curtha síos sa Bhunreacht.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Ach, féach: "Is ón Uachtarán a bheidh a ghairm——"

Comment on this

Ba cheart don Teachta cead do thabhairt dom-sa labhairt gan cur isteach orm. Más mian leis labhairt im' dhiaidh, beidh sé i ndon é sin do dhéanamh agus fáilte.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

——Ach cuimhnigh air seo: "Is ón Uachtarán a bheidh——"

Comment on this

A Chinn Comhairle, bhfuil cead agam labhairt gan daoine bheith ag cur isteach orm mar seo?

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Ba cheart don Aire an rud atá i gceist agam do scrúdú.

Comment on this

Dubhairt an Teachta O hUigín go rabhamar ag baint comhachta atá ag na daoine fé láthair agus go bhfuilimíd dhá thabhairt d'fhear nua—fear ceannais an Stáit, ach ní mar sin atá; níl pioc de'n fhirinne san scéal sin. Nuair a deireann sé gur féidir leis an Uachtarán é seo agus é suid do dhéanamh gan cead ó éinne, cad tuige nach dtaisbeánann sé don Dáil cionnus mar féidir leis na rudaí seo do dhéanamh. Tá sé ag caint ar nós an Papa. Aon rud a deireann sé, is lom-firinneach é toisc gur éisean a deireann é. Más mar sin atá an scéal, níl aon mhaith a bheith ag cur trioblóide orainn féin mar gheall air.

Má tá lochtanna san Dréacht-Bhunreacht seo, is féidir iad do leasú agus do cheartú. Ní dubhairt éinne ar son an Rialtas go raibh an Bunreacht chó-cruinn, beacht san nach féidir é d'fheabhasú agus do leasú ina lán caoi. Ní féidir a thuille molta do thabhairt don mBunreacht ná a rá nár bhféidir leis an lucht táinsimh agus lucht cáinte níos mó ná dhá nó trí point do thógáil—ceist comhachta an Uachtaráin, ceist cirt na mban agus cúpla mion-poinnte eile. Ní féidir leis an Uachtarán áthrú do dhéanamh ar rud ar bith. Níl aon comhacht fén mBunreacht seo ag éinne dlí do dhéanamh ach ag an Oireachtas. Ní féidir leis an Uachtarán dlí do dhéanamh. Ní féidir le dream nó duine ar bith dlí do dhéanamh ach amháin an tOireachtas. Agus, freisin, nuair a bheidh an Bunreacht leasuithe agus rithte tríd an Dáil agus curtha os comhair na ndaoine, má glacann furmhór na daoine leis, ní bheidh sé ar chumas an Uachtaráin leasú do dhéanamh nó a ainm do chur fé leasú, ar son aon Rialtas, gan an cheist do chur fé Reifreann os comhair na ndaoine. Má glacann furmhór na ndaoine leis an leasú sin, caithfidh an tUachtarán glacadh leis fosta.

Is féidir a rá go bhfuil breis comh achta ag an Uachtarán fén mBunreacht ná mar bhí ag an Seanascal ach caithfidh gach duine admháil go gcaithfidh duine eigin do chur in ionad an tSeanascail mar priomh-shaoránac agus príomh-dhuine an Stáit. Toghfar ag na daoine é. Bun-prionsiobal den mBunreacht 'seadh an t-údarás a bheith ag na daoine agus is ceart comhachta feileamhnacha do thabhairt d'fhear a toghfar mar seo ag na daoine. Dá dtogadh ag an Oireachtas é, thiocfadh linn é chur chun siúl am ar bith go mba maith linn, ach fhaid is tógtar é ag muintir na tíre is ceart comhacht speisialta bheith aige. Má tógfidh na daoine duine cosúil leis an duine a bhí i gceist ag an dTeachta o hUigín, beidh iongnadh orm—go mór mhór mar go mbeidh seans ag an Teachta agus a dhream chur ina luighe ar na daoine go bhfuil na "comhachta uathbhásaighe" seo ag an Uachtarán agus go mbeidh sé baoghalach na comhachta seo do thabhairt do dhuine ar bith ach duine ciallmhar a oibreoidh i gceart iad, agus laistigh d'fhorálacha an Bhunreachta, is cuma cén Rialtas atá i réim.

Rinne an Teachta Ó hÓgáin léirmheas maith ar an mBunreacht, chó maith leis an Teachta Lavery. Is féidir linn a rá, pe'ca aontuimíd nó nach n-aontuimíd leo, go raibh puinte ina ndubhairt siad gur fiú iad do mheas, do bhreithniú agus do scrúdú. Shílfeá o chaint an Teachta Ó hUigín go raibh breith tugtha ag an Dáil ar an gceist seo cheana, gidh go bhfuil a fhios aige go ndubhairt an tUachtarán indé go mbeidh sé lán-tsásta aon moladh no leasú ó aon Teachta do bhreithniú, má tá ciall nó bunús leis. Dubhairt an Teachta Ó hUigín gur olc an rud an t-olltoghachán agus an plebiscite i gcóir an Bhunreachta a bheith ar an lá chéadna. Sin pointe is fiú do mheas ach tá a lán costais ag baint le hobair mar seo agus im thuairim pearsanta, ba dheacair na daoine do mhealladh chun an Bunreacht do dheimhniú no d'iompodh síos, dá mba rud é nach raibh an dá rud ar an lá céanna, toisc nach mbaineann forálacha an Bhunreachta go minic le gnáth-shaol na ndaoine i gcoitchinne. Gidh go mb'fhéidir go mbeidh an cheist pholitíochta ag teacht isteach, is dóich liom gur maith an rud go mbeidh na guthadóirí in don a rá go bhfuil siad i bhfábhar an Bhunreachta nó nach bhfuil nuair atá siad ag vótáil san Olltoghacháin. Is dóich liom go dtuigfidh siad go mbeidh siad saor a rá go bhfuil siad ar son, no in aghaidh, an Bhunreachta, is cuma cén dream pholitíochta go bhfuil siad ag cuidiú leo. Má bheireann siad a nguthanna don Rialtas, ní fáth é sin nach dtabharfadh siad vóta in aghaidh an Bhunreachta, más é a dtoil é no vice versa. Maidir leis an argóint gur ceart dúinn fanúint leath-bhliain sul a gcuirfimíd an Bunreacht os comhair na ndaoine, is féidir le duine ar bith a amharcas ar an sean-Bhunreacht a fheiceáil go bhfuil sé strócaithe o thús deire, go bhfuil leath na n-airtiogal leasuithe agus go bhfuil cuid mhaith aca curtha ar neamh-ní ar fad. Mar sin, is mithid Bunreacht nua do chur ar bun.

Dubhairt an Teachta O hOgáin gurb é an Bunreacht seo bás na Poblachta. Ní féidir a rá deir sé go rugadh an Phoblacht san nDréacht-Bhunreacht seo. Abramaois an rud adubhairt na daoine thall 15 bliana o shoin—nárb é seo an choiscéim deiridh den Náisiúntacht agus gur féidir le haon dream dul níos fuide má's toil leo. Acht dream ar bith a thiocfas inár ndiaidh, is féidir leo glacadh leis an mBunreacht seo, agus le forálacha iomlána an Bhunreachta seo, má tá Bunreacht i gcóir iomlán na tíre uatha, chó maith le forálacha aon Bhunreachta eile. Ní abraim ach gur mór an choiscéim ar aghaidh an Bunreacht seo. Níl aon dabht ná gur oiriúnach an Bunreacht é seo mar bhun-chloch d'Ehirinn iomlán, más gá é Bunreacht iseadh é in a bhfuil neamh-spleachas, agus saoirse. Duine ar bith a léigheas an Bunreacht seo, chífidh sé nach bhfuil an méid den tsean-"liberalism" a bhí san sean-Bhunreacht ag baint leis an Bunreacht seo, ach o thaobh meoin na tíre, agus o thaobh stair agus tréithe na ndaoine, tá sé i bhfad níos feiliúnaí don náisiún.

Bhí eagla ar an dTheachta go rabhamar ag géilleadh do mhuintir na Sé Contaethe nuair a dubhramar go mbeidh comhacht againn glacadh le teanga eile seachas an Ghaedhilg mar theanga oifigiúll in áiteanna áirithe. Ní ceart é sin. Is do na daoine sa Stát seo nach bhfuil eolas acu ar an nGaedhilg atáimíd ag geilleadh—daoine nach bhfuil i ndon a gcuid oibre ná obair na tíre do dhéanamh tré Ghaedhilg. Tá an Ghaedhilg ina teangain oifigiúil ach tá a fhios againn nach bhfuil an Ghaedhilg ag formhór na dTeachtaí ná ag cuid de na Stát-Sheirbhísigh ná ag cuid eile de na daoine, agus sé sin an fáth nach bhfuil an Ghaedhilg go hoblagáideach i ngach áit agus i ngach caoi a bhaineas le hobair an náisiúin. I ndiaidh a chéile, beimíd i ndon, le cuidiú Dé féachaint chuige go ndéanfar obair an Stáit tríd an nGaedhilg sna ceanntracha Gaelacha san Iarthar, agus fiú amháin i mBaile Atha Cliath, agus sa Dáil nuair a bheas na meastacháin ós ar gcomhair, cuir i gcás, no nuair a bhéas adhbhar dlí áirithe mar seo fá dhíospóireacht. Sa chaoi sin, is féidir linn deagh-shompla do thabhairt don tír agus a theasbáint go bhfuilimíd i ndáiríribh agus gur teanga beo í an Ghaedhilg atá chó feiliúnach chun an obair do dhéanamh agus atá an Béarla.

Ní thig le duine ar bith a chruthú go bhfuil blas na deachtóireachta ar an mBunreacht seo. Níl blas na deachtóireachta ná blas na cumannachta ná blas iasachta eile air. Chun forálacha an Bhunreachta do thuisgint agus do mheas, ba chóir caighdeán no tomhas éigin do bheith againn chun iad do scrúdú i gceart. Sé an chéad tomhas ba chóir a bheith againn ná: an bhfuilid sásúil i gcoitinne le bheith mar bhun-phrionsabail i ndlí bunúsach na tíre. An bhfuilid feiliúnach i ngach slí, cuir i gcás do Stát neaspleách 'na mbeidh dúil láidir ó chroidhe ag á muintir deimhniú solamanta do dhéanamh gur aca siúd, na daoine féin, fá dheoidh, atá an chumhacht i ngach ceist a bhaineas le polasaí náisiúnta ná eadarnáisiúnta agus gurbh iad féin na máistri ar gach Rialtas agus comhacht riaghla san tír seo. Níl aon rud leagtha amach níos soiléire san Dréacht-Bhunreacht, im' thuairim-se, ná gur ag na daoine atá an chomhacht ar fad agus go dtig leo pé ar bith cinéal Rialtais is rogha leo féin do bhunú annseo.

An dara pointe: An oibreoidh an Bunreacht? D'ainneoin a bhfuil ráite ag na Teachtaí thall, ní raibh siad i ndon ach cúpla pointe do lochtú, mar adubhras chéana. Is féidir linn a thaisbeánt go bhfuil cosca san mBunreacht a choimeádfaidh an tUachtarán agus gach gléas eile laistigh den dlí. Caithfidh siad uilig a gcuid oibre do dhéanamh do réir dlí agus laistigh d'fhorálacha an Bhunreachta. Rinne Teachtaí gearán toisc go dtoghfaí an tUachtarán go ceann seacht mblian. Sé mo thuairim gur ceart seal fada do thabhairt dó i dtreo go mbeidh leanúnachas leis an obair agus go mbeidh sé go buan-tseasmhach. Tá an rud céanna le rá i dtaobh Comhairle an Stáit. Is insan slí sin a gheobhaimíd aontacht, seasmhacht, agus leanúnachas san obair.

Na daoine bhí ag cáineadh an Bhunreachta, ní dhearnadar aon tagairt don chomhacht chun comhairlí gairme-bheatha do chur ar bun. Táimíd ag tabhairt faill do na daoine san Stát ag a bhfuil an tuairim go bhfuil a lán rudaí mí-cheart san domhan go bhfeádfaí a leigheas thre'n gléas san, na comhairlí gairme-bheatha, a chuirfidh suim san saol chó-dhaonnach agus in obair economaice agus a leithéid, na comhairli sín do chur ar bun chun deire do chur leis an easaontas i gcúrsaí economaice agus tráchtála má's féidir é do dhéanamh ins an tslighe sin.

Deir Teachtaí ar an dtaobh thall nach n-oibreoidh an Bunreacht, ach ní féidir le duine sin a rá go dtí go mbeidh sé fé lán-tseol. Tá 15 bliana de thaithighe againn ar rialú na tíre agus ba chóir go mbeimís i ndon job níos fearr do dhéanamh den Bhunreacht seo ná mar rinneadh den tsean-Bhunreacht.

An tríú tomhas: Caithfimíd na forálacha do mheas o thaobh meoin agus bun-tréithre agus stair an náisiúin. An bhfuil na bun-fhorálacha go dílis, ceart, agus feiliúnach do bhun-treithre na nGaedheal? Is dóich liom go bhfuil ár meanma náisiúnta agus na tréithe fé leith a bhaineas le muintir na hEireann le feiceáil go soléir ar gach leathanach den Dréacht-Bhunreacht. Tá cur síos ann ar phréamhacha an náisiúin—an creideamh, an teanga, an teaghlach, an t-oideachas, an mhaoin phríobháideach agus a leithéid. Táin cinnte go dtaithneofai na n-Airteagal so le n'ár muinntir, go gcuirfidís spéis agus suim ionnta, agus go mbeidís dílis dóbhtha. Tár éis na céadta blian de chruatan tá an lámh uachtair againn anois agus ba chóir dúinn na rudaí seo a thug misneach dúinn san aimsir géarchrádha do láidriú chó maith agus is féidir linn. Tá an Bunreacht bunuithe ar chuspóirí cirt, carthannachta agus Críostúlachta—rudaí bhaineas leis an náisiún seo níos mó ná le haon náisiún eile ar dhruim an domhain. Na forálacha atá leagtha amach san mBunreacht, siad cuspóirí an Rialtais iad agus tugadh a lán machtnaimh agus cúraim dóibh. Cuirfear i bhfeidhm iad chun leasa na ndaoine agus chun maitheasa na tíre. Táim cinnte go mbeidh siad mar shompla do thíortha eile ar fud an domhain atá scaoilte agus atá in easaontas fé lathair toisc gan aon fheallsúnacht fíor ná cuspóir spioradálta bheith aca. Tabharfaimíd sompla dhóibh agus taisbeánfaimíd dóibh gur féidir linn obair mhaith do dhéanamh do na daoine i gcúrsaí sóisealachta agus economaice, gan dearmad do dhéanamh ar an saol saoidheachta. Is maith an rud go bhfuil tagairt déanta don tsaol saoidheachta san gcéad Airteagal den Bhunreacht. Tá sé leaghtha amach go gcaithfai forbairt do dhéanamh chun an saol saoidheachta do chur chun chinn. Táim deimhnitheach go mbeidh an cuspóir sin in ár gcuimhne i gcomhnaí agus go ndéanfaimíd iarracht ar é do chur i bhfeidhm agus do choimeád i bhfeidhm. Ar an tslí sin, beidh Bunreacht seasmhach agus cóir againn—Bunreacht a bheidh sásúil do na daoine i ngach slí. Gidh go mbeidh sé buan, beidh sé in ár gcumas é d'athrú o ham go am, díreach mar a bheidh sé in ár gcumas leasuithe do dhéanamh annseo is annsiúd ann sna seachtmhainí atá romhainn.

Comment on this
Michael Óg McFadden Mícheál Og MacPháidín Cumann na nGaedheal

Amuigh shiar san Ghaeltacht, an áit a rugadh agus ar tógadh mé, is beag suim a chuirtear anois i n-Achtanna agus i reachtanna no i mBunreachtanna. Is mó go mór atá imirce an aosa óig ag cur bhuadhartha agus imnidhe ar na daoine bochta ag smuaineadh gach lá ar na buacaillí agus na cailiní atá ag imtheacht uainn go h-Albain agus go Sasain siocair nach dtig leo slighebheatha a bhaint amach 'na dtír féin. Is dinear dén ghaoith é do mhuinntir na Gaedhealtacha an Bunreacht so. Acht caithfear Bunreacht éigin a bheith ann agus badh mhaith linn go léir ceann maith a bheith againn. Mar sin de, glacaim go fonnmhar leis an chuireadh a thug an tUachtarán nuair chraoibh-scaoil sé an chainnt fán Bhunreacht seachtain go hAoine seo a chuaidh thart. Seo an rud a dubhairt an tUachtarán: "Ar na Dáilirí a bhfuil an Ghaedhilg aca, iarraim go dúthrachtach an chabhair sin agus an chomhairle sin a thabhairt dúinn, agus an Ghaedhilg a chleachtadh nuair a bhéas an Bunreacht fa dhiospóireacht sa Dáil." Dubhairt an tUachtarán fosta go mbéidhfí fíorbhuidheach den mhuinntir a bhéarfadh comhairle nó moladh ar bith le feabhas a chur ar Ghaedhilg an Bhunreachta; isé sin ar an iarracht seo le deagh-thús a chur leis an fhás nua atá i n-ann don Ghaedhilg. Deirtear nach bhfuil saoi gan locht agus, da bhrigh sin, is annamh obair na saoi gan locht Níl an Bunreacht so saor ó lochtannaí, acht creidim go dtig é a cheartú mar theid sé fríd an Dáil. Tá poinntí maithe ann mar bhí sa tsean Bhunreacht acht tá poinntí eile ann nach bhfuil ar mo mhian.

Sa chead dul síos, caithfidh mé an t-Uachtarán a mholadh ar shon an Bhunreacht a chumadh agus a chur roimh an Dáil i nGaedhilic. Bheirim an moladh so do go fonnmhar no tá sé tuillte aige. Is mór an chéim ar aghaidh do'n teangaidh an chéim seo agus tá bród orm mar gheall air sin. Acht cé go n-abrain seo, caithfidh mé innse dó nach bhfuil an Ghaedhilic atá san Bhunreacht saor ó locht. Níor cheart sin a bheith amhlaidh agus é luaidhte thiar i ndeireadh an Bhunreachta gurabh é an téics Gaedhilige an ceann a mbéadh éifeacht dlighe aige. Ma táthar le téics Gaedhilge an Bhunreachta a achtadh, is ceart agus is cóir an Ghaedhilig atá ann a bheith ar fheabhas ar fad agus é bheith aisdrighthe i gceart da thaobh chiall na cainnte már cumadh ar tús é. Ní béidh sé ar mo chumas an iarraidh seo na lúbthacha ar lár uilig do dtug mé fa dear a luadh annso acht tá súil agam go ndeanfar tseán-iarracht le Gaedhilic an Bhunreachta a cheartú sul a gcuirtear i bhféidhm é. Sé an reacht so an ceann is mó tábhacht dá mbéidh againn i riaghlú na tíre san am atá le theacht agus badh cheart dó a bheith saor ó locht.

I mbrollach an Bhunreachta, gan a dul thairis, tá an oiread sin earráideacha agus go mbéadh amhras ar dhuine go bhfuil an chuid eile de comh lochtach céadna. Tá sé ráidhte go soiléir san téics Sacs-Bhérla go dtig gach ughdarás on Tríonóid Ro-Naomhtha. Duine ar bith a bhfuil ciall do Ghaedhilic aige agus a bhfuil an Teagasc Críostaidhe a d'fhogluim sé nuair a bhí sé óg ar a theanga go fóill aige, tá fhios aige gur aon Dia amháin i dTrí Pearsanna an Tríonoid Ro-Naomhtha agus nuair a thráchtamuid ar an Tríonóid Ro-Naomhtha mar tá sé luaidhte san Bunreacht ní smaointimid ar an ainm Thríonóid mar ainm acht ar Dhia amháin. Da bhrigh sin, badh cheart don fhorainm a bheith fhirinnstin. Ós rud é gur luadh mé an Teagasc Críostaidhe, caithfidh mé a rádh gurab é "ceart" an focal atá ann ar an fhocal "justice" i mBéarla. Sé an rud atá san Bhunreacht an focal "ionnrácas." Is mar so a d'fhóghluim mé-fhéin na ceithre príomh-shúbhailcí: "Críonnacht, ceart, neart, agus measardhacht."

Badh mhaith liom rud eile a rádh fosda go bhfuil seo síos ar dheireadh bhrollach an Bhunreachta: "Atámuid leis seo ag gabhail an Bhunreachta so chugainn agus da achtú agus da tiodhlachadh duinn fhéin." Sé mo báramhail nach mar sin a ba cheart é a chur síos de bhrigh go bhfuil an bhrígh ins na briathra sin ag dul ar aghaidh go síor gan stad. Measaim gur fearr "Gabhamuid chugainn""achtamuid" agus "bheirimid" a rádh in ionad an rud atá curtha síos ins an Bhúnreacht. Bheirim fa dear go bhfuil an rud céadna síos ins na h-Airteagail a bhaineas leis an dearbhadh atá ar an Uachtarán agus oifigeacha eile an Stáit a dheanamh. Badh mhaith linn uilíg an chuid a bh'fearr den Ghaedhilic a bheith san chead Bhunreacht Gaedhilige dár cuireadh romhainn san Dáil seo. Badh mhaith linn go mbeadh sé mar oighridheacht liteardha ag gach glún da dtiocfaidh ár ndiaidh le maoidheamh agus le mórtas a dheanamh as mar badh dual do Ghaedhil.

Tá rud eile san Bhunreacht nach bhfuil mé sásta leis agus caithfidh mé tagairt dó. Is minic a chuala mé an t-Uachtarán agus lucht Fianna Fáil ag maoidheamh gurab iad san an t-aon chumann amháin a bhí réidh i gcómhnaidhe le na cheart fhéin a thabhairt do'n duine choitcheannta agus comhthrom na Féinne a thabhairt do'n fhear bhocht agus san Bunreacht so tá sé ráidhte gur ionann na Saoránaigh uilíg i láthair an dlighe. Acht ma bhreathnuighthear an Bhunreacht go cúramach, gheobhthar amach go bhfuil dá chineal dlighe ann, ceann fa choinne an duine shaidhbhir agus ceann fa choinne an duine bhoicht. 'Nois, cad tuige a n-abraim sin? Cruitheochaidh mé go bhfuil an ceart agam. Admhuighthear nach féidir saoirse an duine choitcheannta a chur i bhfeidhm agus a choimhead i gceart mar bhfuil na cúirteanna agus na breithimh saor agus gan baint a bheith aca leis an Rialtas agus cúmhacht os a gceann ag an Uachtarán nó ag an Taoiseach no aon oifigeach eile de'n Stát. Deirtear san Airteagal 35 den Bhunreacht seo "Beidh gach breitheamh saor maidir le feadhmanna breitheamhain d'oibriú." Is maith ciallmhar an t-Airteagal é sin acht is léir duinn go léir nach bhfuil aon bhreitheamh neamh-spleadhach mar bhfuil a phosta buan tseasmhach agus is fa choinne sin a cuiread isteach san Bhunreacht Airteagal 35, mír 4 (1). Acht tá rud eile againn le deanamh ma's mian linn na breithimh a dheanamh neamhspleadhach. Caithfear a shocrú nach mbéidh cead ag an Rialtas turasdal breithimh ar bith a laghdú fhad as bhéas sé i n-oifig.

Admhuigheann an tUachtarán go bhfuil an ceart agam fa'n dá phoinnte seo no bheir an Bunreacht postanna seasmhacha do bhreithimh de'n Chúirt Uacdaraigh agus de bhreithimh de'n árd-Chúirt, Art. 35, mír 4 (1), agus tá turasdal gan laghadú ag na breithimh chéadna da réir Art. 35, mír 5. Ach siad na hÁrd-Chúirteanna cúirteanna na ndaoine mór, cúirteanna na ndaoine saidhbhir, agus ma tá an tUachtarán chomh réidh sin le ceart agus saoirse lucht an airgid a choimhead agus a chosnú cad chuige nár chuir sé san Bhunreacht na riaghalacha céadna fa dtaob de cúirteanna na ndaoine mbocht —an Cuirt Chuardha agus an Cúirt Dúithche?

Is beag baint atá ag muinntir na Gaeltachta leis na cúirteanna acht leis an Chúirt Dúithche amháin agus más ceart saoirse breitheamh na n-Árd-Chuirt a choimhead, is mó an riachtanas atá ann saoirse breitheamh na mion-chúirt a chosnú. Bionn an mhaoin agus an chumhacht ag an duine saidhbhir i gcómhnuidhe a cheart féin a bhaint amach acht nuair a sheasas an bhochtán ós comhair na Cúirte Dúithche agus oifigeach an Stáit ag cur an dlighe air, níl coimirce faoi Dhia aige acht ionnracas agus neamhspleachas an Bhreithimh. Tá súil agam go gcuimhneochaidh an t-Uachtarán ar so. Bhí Dives i n-uachdar fáda go leór i gcúrsaí dlighe ins an tír seo agus, do réir mo thuairim-se, is mithid a cheart a thabhairt do Lasurus bocht fa dheire thiar thall.

Comment on this

I rith na díspóireachta ar an nDréacht Bunreachta so, tá ár gcáirde thall ag cur síos ar stáid na tíre fé láthair, ar an méid daoine atá diomhaoin ar seo agus ar siúd. Sé an Teachta O Maolchatha is mó a lean an bealach sin. Dubhairt an Teachta O hOgain go mba cheart don Dáil cúram éigin a bheith idir laimh aice seachas an Bunreacht so, de bhrígh go bhfuil an oiread san daoine ar ceal oibe agus mar sin de. Ní bhaineann an Dréacht so an greim as bheul énne agus ar aon cuma ní thuigim cad é an bhainnt atá ag na nidhthibh seo le Bunreacht. Fé mar a thuigim-se an sceul, níl i mBunreacht sa gceud dul síos ach gléus nó úrlais chun Riaghaltas a cheapadh, chun cúrsaí na tíre do ríaradh is do stiuradh mar is dual is mar is cuibhe.

Dubhairt an Teachta O hUigín ná raibh, ar éigin, nídh ar bith sa Dréacht so ach iarracht dul amugha is dalla an phúicín a chur ar an bpobal. Dár ndóig, ní fíor dó san agus éinne a deireann a leithéid sin níl sé ach ag leigint air mar ní dóibh liom gur léigheas aon nídh riamh atá chomh soiléir so-thuighthe i Saos-Bhéarla agus i nGaedhilg leis an Dréacht seo.

I nídh chomh tábhachtach le Bunreacht, ní h-iongmadh go mbeadh tuairmí éagsamhla ag daoine. Ní cúis ghearáin againne ar an dtaobh so den dtigh go bhfuil malairt tuairmí ag ar gcáirde thall seachas mar atá againne ach is é t-adhbhar gearáin atá againn—agus fáth againn leis—nách bhfuilid ag cur a mbaramhla i n-úil go stuamda is go réasúnta. Ní mar sin atá mar go minic táid ag cur a mí-dtaithneamh den mBunreacht so i n-úil le tarcuisne is le masla agus ar uairibh le feirg. Is doigh liom-sa nách bhfuil aon nídh ar suibhal acha acht magadh.

Dhein an tUachtarán athchuinge ortha cabhrú leis an Riaghaltas chun an Bunreacht so a dhéanamh chómh maith agus is féidir. Dubhairt sé gur cheart an scéal só a phlé lasmuich de phoilitidheacht agus dubhairt freisin go mbeadh sé sásta glacadh le haon tuairim ion-mholta a thiocfadh ón dtaobh thall. Is beag áird a tugadh air agus is suarach ar fad a bhfuil de chabhair á fhághail aige ón dtaobh san. Ní hiad dlighthe na Mídeach is na bPeirseánach atá siorruidhthe sa Dréacht so. Má tá locht ar aon tairisgintí atá ann is féidir, fé mar adubhairt an tAire Oideachais, iad a leigheas.

Is é an chúis chlamsáin is mó atá ag lucht Fine Gael fé an mBunreacht so ná go bhfuiltear chun deachtóir a cheapadh mar Uachtarán. Deirim-se seo agus tugaim mo dhubh-shlán d'éinne dhár gcáirde thall é bhréagnú gurab é toil an phobail agus nách é toil an Uachtaráin a bheas fé réim gach tráth fé gach airteagal is alt den mBunreacht so. Agus déanfadh sin a dheimhniú ón nDreacht féin. Ba dhóigh le héinne a bheadh ag éisteacht le óráidithe Fine Gael gur duine ar ar thóil féin a bheas san Uachtarán nuadh. Is fuiriste é sin a bhréagnú ón nDréacht so. Tógaimís cur i gcás Airteagal a 12. alt a 9:—

"Ní cead don Uachtarán imtheacht ó Eirinn le linn é bheith in oifig, ach amháin le toil an Riaghaltais."

Comment on this

Ach tá cead ag na mílte daoine imtheacht as an tír.

Comment on this

Do léigheas é sin chun thaisbeánt gur toil na ndaoine atá in uachtar.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Cad déarfá mar gheall ar Airteagail 40?

Comment on this

Tá caint i dtaobh Airteagail 13, agus deirtear go bhfuil an iomarca chomhachta dhá thabhairt don Uachtarán, ach tá fó-alt anna ann a deireann:

(2) "Tig leis an Uachtarán uair ar bith, tar éis comhairle do ghlacadh leis an gComhairle Stáit, teachtaireacht do chur ós comhair an Náisiúin i dtaobh aon nídh den tsórt sin."

(3) "Acht i ngach cás díobh sin ní foláir an Riaghaltas do bheith sásta roimh ré leis an dteachtaireacht nó leis an aithease."

Nach ró-léir uaidh sin go bhfuil ar an Uachtarán geilleadh do thoil an Riaghaltais? Uí foláir don Uachtarán cead fháil ón Riaghaltas sul a dtéigheann sé chun an microphone chun teachtaireacht do chraobhsgaoileadh— cuir i gcás.

Comment on this

Chun "Hello, America," do rá?

Comment on this

Tá alán cainte maidir le Airteagail 13. Seo a deireann sé in alt a 10, mir a 1:

(1) "Fá chuimsiughodh an Bhunreachta seo, féadfar tuilleadh cumhacht agus feadhmanna do thabhairt don Uachtarán le dligheadh."

Ach má seadh, tá mír a 2º ann a deireann:—

"Ní cead don Uachtarán aon chumhacht ná feidhm díobh sin d'oibriughadh ná do chomhlíonadh acht amháin ar chomhairle an Rioghaltais, nó tar éis comhairle do ghlacadh leis an gComhairle Stáit, fé mar cinnfear leis an dligheadh sin."

Admhuím go bhfuil fó-radh annsan gur bhfearr liom é do bheith as. Bfearr liom na focla "tar éis comhairle do ghlacadh leis an gComhairle Stáit" do bheith as agus na focla "ar chomhairle an Riaghaltais" amháin do bheith ann.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearoid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Tá an ceart agat.

Comment on this

Bféidir go bhfuil agus bféidir nach bhfuil. Cá bhfuil an deachtóireacht sna? An dóigh le héinne thall go gcuirfead Hitler nó Mussoliní ceangail den tsaghas san ortha féin? Im thuairimsé, tá ceangal no gcúig gcaol ar an Uachtarán a bheas ann agus níl sa chainnt seo fé dheachtóireacht acht bladhman.

Tá comhachtaí áirithe ag an Uachtarán agus is ceart agus is cóir go mbeadh mar is é cosantóir an Bhunreachta é acht má seadh, níl cead aige na comhachtaí sin a ghlacadh chuige féin.

Tá tóir mhór á thógaint ag Fine Gael fé Airt. a 13, alt a 8, mír a 3º:—

"Ní cead caingean i gCúrsaí dlighidh ná ceartais, ná cúis dlighidh ar bith eile, cibé cúis sibhíalta, nó cúis choirtheach í, do chur ar an Uachtarán le linn é bheith in oifig."

Deir Fine Gael go gcuireann an mhír seo an tUachtarán a bheas lasmuich den dlighe; go bhfuil cead aige a rogha rud a dhéanamh, bheith na réabóir roilge más mian leis sin gan eagla an dlighe. Tá freagra beacht ar an ngearán san le fáil in Airt. a 12, alt a 10, mír a 1º. Sé seo é:

"Ar agra dhá dtrian ar a laighead de lán-chomhaltas Sheanad Eireann, is féidir an t-Uachtarán tháinseamh, as ucht tréasa mar minighthear é san Bhunreacht seo, nó as ucht mórchoirthe eile nó mór-mhí-iomchair eile."

Nach leor é sin mar chúirt chun an tUachtarán a thriail má dheineann sé coir? Cad is gadh dhá chúirt nó dhá thriail? Níl a leithéid sin de thriail leagtha amach i gcomhair éinne eile sa Stát acht an tUachtarán, agus is dóigh liomsa gur leor mar chúirt í.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Nach féidir leis an dara bean do ghlacadh dó féin agus í do phosadh?

Comment on this

Dá mbeadh sé chó-dithchéilleach sin——

Comment on this

Cá bhfuil sé sin sa Bhunreacht?

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Níor bhféidir leis an Rí Sasana é do dhéanamh acht tiocfidh leis an Uachtarán é do dhéanamh.

Comment on this

Bheadh sin in aghaidh an chreidimh agus bheadh comhacht agan oireachtas táinseamh do dheanamh air. Má phósann sé an dara bean is féidir an dlí do chur air.

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Cad é an t-Airteagail?

Comment on this

Airteagail a 12, Alt a 10 (1). Siné mo fhreagra. Sid é é:—

"Ar agra dha dtrian ar a luighead de lán-chomhaltas Eireann, is féidir an tUachtarán do thainseamh, as ucht tréasa mar minighthear é in san Bhunreacht so, nó as ucht morchoirthe eile no mor-mhi-iomchair eile."

Comment on this
Gearóid O'Sullivan Gearóid O Súilleabháin Cumann na nGaedheal

Ní freagra é sin, ach bféidir nach ndéanfaidh sé é.

Comment on this

Gan amhras, más dóigh leis an dTeachta nach "mór-mhí-iomchair" a leithéid sin de ghníomh, ní hiongnadh an tuairim sin aige, acht táim cinnte nach bhfuil an Teachta acht ag magadh.

Ní aontuím le gach moladh dá bhfuil sa Bhunreacht so. Cuir i gcás an moladh atá i nAirt. a 12, alt a 4, mír a 4º:—

"Tig le haon duine atá nó a bhí ina Uachtarán é féin d'ainmniugnadh d'oifig an Uachtaráin."

Admhuím ná taithneann sé sin liom. Dheimhnigheann Airt. a 5 gur Stát daonfhlathach Eire. I Stát daonfhlathach, ní dóigh liom gur ceart cead is comhacht a bheith ag aon duine é féin d'ainmniú le h-aghaidh puist ar bith sa tír. Tá dhá shlí eile leagtha amach i gcóir ainmniucháin agus, im thuairim, is leor iad.

Rud eile dhé, bronntar comhachtaí áirithe ar an Uachtarán fé Airt. a 26 maidir le Billí a chur fé bhreith na Cúirte Uachtagraighe. Dé bhrí gur ar an Uachtarán seachas éinne eile a luigheann an dualgas an Bunreacht a chosaint, is a choimhdeadh, is ceart an chomhacht san a bheith aige. Acht b'fhearr, dar liom, dá gcuireadh sé é féin i n-úil sul a mbeadh Bille rithte in san dá Thig den Oireachtas. B'fhearr dá gcuireadh sé é féin i núil díreach tar éis rith den Dara Céim, mar, fé'n am so, tuigfidh cách cad é an fuadar atá fé'n Riaghaltas agus cád é brígh agus éifeacht agus cuspóirí an Bhille atá fé cheist. Má fhanann an tUachtarán na thost nó go mbeidh Bille rithte, tar éis diospóireachta ratha b'fhéidir, in san dá Thig agus má chuireann sé fé bhreith na Cúirte Uachtaraighe annsan é, agus má chuireann an Chuirt ar neamhnidh é bheadh adhbhar acrainn ann idir an Uachtarán agus an Oireachtas. Agus fós ní bheadh an pobal sásta mar bheadh sé le radh aca ná raibh An Dáil i n-a leithéid sin d'ócáid acht ag cur ama amú. Toisc lucht na Cúirte Uachtaraighe bheith na ballaibh den gComhairle Stáit, b'fhearr dá gcuireadh an tUachtarán an scéal lom díreach fé bhreith na Cúirte gan bacaint leis an gComhairle.

Dubhairt an Teachta O hUigín ná raibh sa Bunreacht so acht áis chun duine áirithe a choróiniú agus ba léir gurabé Uachtarán na hArd Chomhairle a bhí i gceist aige. Nách aisteach sin? Deir Fine Gael lá go bhfuil an tír briste, bruighte, bascaithe ag Riaghaltas Fianna Fáil, nách bhfuil meas madra ag an bpobal ar an ndream san agus indiú deir an Teachta O hUigín gurabé Uachtarán Fianna Fáil a thoghfas an pobal nuair a gheibhid caoi chuige sin. Tá an dá thuairim sin i naghaidh a chéile. Acht is cuma le Fine Gael, déarfaidh siad aon lá go bhfuil dhá nidh atá díreach i naghaidh chéile comh-thréorach nuair is mian leo bob a bualadh ar an bpobal.

Gléas iongantach an Bunreacht so. Tá grádh Dé is grádh tíre suidhte ann. Tá ceart is cóir is cothrom do chách suidhte ann, agus tabharfad-sa bhóta go fonnmhar chun é chur i bhfeidhm.

Comment on this

I suppose it will be chalked up to the much despised legal profession as an additional bad mark that I, after this flood of Gaelic oratory, should face realities and address this House in the English tongue. As a lawyer, however much despised by the President, it is my duty to face realities. We have to face the reality that this draft amendment to the Constitution which we are debating will affect, if it passes into law, the lives and perhaps the liberties of every section of the community, and of that community at least 90 per cent. are ignorant of the Irish language. The other 10 per cent. are ignorant of the Irish language in its technical and proper sense—5 per cent. of them anyway. It is reported of Napoleon that he said: "I shall not go down to posterity by the battles I have fought, but by the codes I have given to France." The President, in introducing this draft amendment to the Constitution. apparently has endeavoured to emulate the great Napoleon. Like Napoleon, he wants to go down in history not because of the battles he has fought but of the Constitution which he has given to this country. This draft amendment to the Constitution, as is notorious, is the work of one man. It is, in my opinion, nothing other than a trick upon the Irish people. This draft amendment to the Constitution has been under consideration by the President behind closed doors, with not even his Executive Council taken into his counsels in connection with the proposals that are now contained in that draft. It is submitted to this Dáil within a very short time of its expiring.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would be good enough to give the Dáil the authority for the outrageous statement he has just made?

Comment on this

The Minister occupied the attention of the House for a considerable length of time——

Comment on this

That is another outrageous statement.

Comment on this

——in making outrageous statements, and I think he might at least keep quiet for a few moments. This draft amendment to the Constitution is submitted to the Dáil just as the life of this Dáil is expiring. It will be submitted to the people, as we understand it, by a farcical plebiscite that is to take place on the same day as the general election. Let us face realities on this matter. Ninety-nine per cent. of the people of the country at the moment do not know there is such a thing as a Constitution being enacted here in this House, and do not care, and 90 per cent. of them do not know what a Constitution is. Yet we are told and expected to believe that when this draft amendment is rushed through this House and submitted to the people by a plebiscite—to a people who have not the faintest notion what it is all about—it will then emerge, if it merges into the law of this State, as something sanctified, as something that never emerged in the history of this State before nor ever will emerge again. The very fact that this amendment to the Constitution has been brought out as the work of one man is a complete condemnation of the system enshrined in that document. I am not quoting my own opinions. May I refer to the opinion of a reverend and learned clergyman who wrote in the Irish Ecclesiastical Record of January of this year, 1937, on the principles of Constitution-making? That was some months before this draft amendment to the Constitution saw the light. Perhaps the President in his cogitations on this document may have seen those words of warning. If he did, he took no notice of them. I am quoting from page 18 of the Irish Ecclesiastical Record of January, 1937:

"Constitution-making is not a merely secular matter, just as it is not a matter for a Party politician, or indeed for any single individual who is not a super-man. It is a task for a commission of experts, experts in practical politics, in moral science, in political theory, in knowledge of contemporary States and other forms of government. A constitution may be sketched by an individual, of course, but it should be finally and definitely drafted only after consultation with the various experts, and in deference to their criticisms and recommendations."

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell the House how the Constitution of 1922 was drafted?

Comment on this

That aspect of the matter has not been given the weight that it deserves in connection with this Constitution. We are asked to debate in this House in a few short days, immediately, or almost immediately, before a general election, a document of this sort, practically every Article of which bristles with difficulties and possible errors. And then, if you please, it is to be sanctified by a plebiscite, by people who do not know what it means and who, in the existing conditions and the necessity of the case, have not the remotest idea of what it does mean.

We were told here by the President yesterday that he invites the assistance of the lawyers on this side of the House. The Minister for Education told us to-day that the President had already indicated that he invited amendments and suggestions, but added the significant addendum, "provided that they had sense and substance." That is to say, whether our suggestions or amendments have substance or not, there is only one man who is to say, irrespective of the question, whether or not, in fact, there is sense and substance in our suggestions. If they do not fit in with the President's own ideas, his schemes and his theories, then they have ceased to have any sense or substance in them. I wrote, as the President has advertised for me, an article on this subject in the Irish Independent a few days after the Constitution was given into our hands. He went down to Ennis and described the things that I said practically as nonsense, and he was reduced to the last refuge of a person who is devoid of argument to say that the person who had stated the things that I had stated did not know what he was talking about. That, as I say, is the last refuge of a person who is devoid of any substance in his contentions or in counter-argument to counter suggestions put forward to his ideas. He asked for the suggestions of lawyers yesterday from this side of the House and for help in making this a perfect Constitution. Almost in the same breath he uttered his contempt for the lawyers and for the legal profession. The lawyers and the legal profession can look with equanimity upon the President, his Government and Party doing without the lawyers. This will mean a rich harvest for those of us who make our living at the Bar. If this Constitution is persisted in, as it stands at the moment, we who expect to be making our living for some years at the Irish Bar can look forward to making a rich harvest from this draft amendment to the Constitution.

The President has no use for lawyers. He told the American people about this Constitution before he told the people's representatives here in Ireland what the Constitution was about. He addressed America over the radio. Did he forget or know that the American Declaration of Independence was drafted by a lawyer? Did he forget or did he know that the American Constitution was drafted by lawyers and adopted by a Convention of 55, 31 of whom were lawyers or men trained in the law? Did he forget the famous Federalist essay contributed by Jay, the first Chief Justice of the United States of America, or Alexander Hamilton, the father of the American Constitution and the founder of the United States of America? Has he forgotten about the world wide reputation of Chief Justice Marshall? Does he not recollect the names of the Adamses, the Jeffersons and the Monroes, all lawyers, and has he forgotten how Abraham Lincoln pulled his country together from the rift that was caused by the American Civil War?

I hesitate to refer to any English lawyers in case I might offend the Irish susceptibilities of the President. Magna Carta was won by the Barons from King John. It was drafted by lawyers. The principles of independence and freedom which came down and are now the dearest heritage of the British people, as well as of the very large number who have inherited the principles of freedom from the English system, were all developed and given practical expression to by English lawyers and by the development of the English common law. Perhaps the President would recollect or remember the names of Justinian and Grotius, and perhaps when he has done that he will at least have some respect for Irish lawyers, and may turn to the Irish Bar to help him if he wants to make a Constitution which will not be, as it cannot be, a perfect Constitution, but which, at least, will be in some respects as legal a document and as perfect a document as the brains of the Irish Bar and the experience of Irish constitutional lawyers can make it.

The President can have a present of his sneers at the lawyers. He is treating the Irish people in just the same way that he has treated the lawyers. This is a Constitution drafted by him to be put before the people in the turmoil of a general election without any possible hope of educating Irish public opinion on the implications that are in this Draft Constitution, on what it will mean to them, or as to how they will stand under it. If we did what our natural inclinations would suggest that we ought to do, namely, to say that we have not been consulted in this matter: that we, as the representatives of the Irish people in an Irish Parliament, are given no adequate time to discuss this matter or to bring the implications of it before our constituents, we would say: "Take your Constitution, and do what you like with it." If we did that we would be doing no more than what we would have a perfect right to do in the circumstances in which we find ourselves with this draft amendment to the Constitution given into our hands a little over a week ago. But we felt that it was our duty to our constituents and to the people as a whole, irrespective of Party, to point out to them in outline only the dangers that are inherent and implicit in the amendments and draft proposals to the Constitution which are before the House at the present time.

I have listened to the various discussions and speeches made here on what is, and what is not, in the Constitution. The spokesmen from the Ministerial side, from the President down, made no effort to justify the proposals that are in this measure. Their efforts were directed, in so far as they had any sense or substance in them at all, to merely answering the criticisms that were put forward from this side of the House. The President devoted a considerable portion of his speech yesterday answering some of the criticisms that I put forward merely from the legal point of view on these draft proposals. He said they were put forward by a politician and a lawyer who did not know what he was talking about, but the President took a long time to explain away some of the criticisms that were put forward. He made no case for the substantive proposals in these draft amendments to the Constitution.

We have pointed out the dangers that lie in the institution of the President that is proposed to be set up under these proposals. We got no justification from the President or any of his spokesmen here for the creation of any such functionary in the circumstances in which we find ourselves to-day. What is the necessity or the justification for his election by popular vote? We have pointed out the dangers that may arise from the powers to be given or, worse still, that may be given under this Constitution to the President. But, leaving that aside, what is the justification for the appointment of this functionary by popular vote? The President was at great pains yesterday to explain that he was nothing more than a rubber stamp in a vast number of instances that he enumerated at great length. Why, then, should there be the expense and the consequent disturbance of political life that will be caused by an additional popular election in this country?

I think the time is not very far away when the ordinary people will react from the number of elections which are being imposed upon them. We have general elections, municipal elections, county council elections, and now we are to have a Seanad election and we are to have another election for the President. What is the justification for the election of this functionary by popular vote? Is it merely as a cloak? Is it merely for the purpose of justifying that flambuoyant phrase that comes so trippingly from the President's tongue— the guardian of the people's rights? Because he is elected by popular vote, therefore he has the title deeds to be that extraordinary entity, the guardian of the people's rights. Before this debate ends I hope we shall have some justification for the proposal we have here, because up to this we have had none.

What is the justification for the variety of institutions by which this man is surrounded—this ridiculous Council of State, whose only practical function in the Constitution is to declare the President an idiot? That is the only power they have in the Draft as it stands at present. They solemnly sit there and are entitled to be heard. They are entitled to talk and to be heard. But the President may waft them and their advice aside and act on his own absolute discretion. Possibly the worm will turn if the Draft is allowed to stand, and this Council of State will some day declare: "We are satisfied, and it has been declared to our satisfaction within the meaning of Article 14 of the Constitution that the President is incapacitated from carrying on his powers and therefore he must go off and we will set up this commission to carry on his powers." That may be a very useful function for the Council of State to have, if this extraordinary system embodied in these draft proposals is ever, unfortunately, enacted into law.

We have 150 pages of a Draft Constitution in which there are 63 Articles. Analysed, what do they mean? They mean that this State in future is going to be governed, so far as its internal affairs are concerned, by two men—the President and the Prime Minister. The draft proposals in this Constitution analysed come to that and nothing else. You have the President and you have the Prime Minister and the Government is a mere cypher in the background. The solidarity of the Executive Council as it is supposed to exist, the functions of the Government as they are supposed to exist under the Constitution at the moment, are put into the background. They are not swept aside—that would be too drastic—but they are put into the background. The people who are to be with this functionary—the Prime Minister—are to be members of the Government. They are not even to be Executive Ministers. They are not dignified in the Irish or English version of the Draft Constitution as Ministers—they are merely members of the Government. There is a Prime Minister, but no other Minister, according to the Draft as it stands. There is a Prime Minister who is a Taoiseach and the word "Taoiseach" has been translated over the German wireless as Fuehrer during the last few days. There is a Prime Minister and a Fuehrer or Taoiseach, whichever you like to call him. There is no Minister —there is a member of the Government, or members of the Government, and each and every one of the members of that Government can be dismissed without a moment's notice at the will and pleasure of the Prime Minister, Taoiseach or Fuehrer, whichever you like to call him. The Prime Minister is the only man in the Government. The others do not count—they are hardly even mentioned in these draft proposals of the new Constitution.

Under the existing Constitution, the President of the Executive Council is merely a member of the Executive Council. The Executive Council is the Government of this State with collective responsibility, and each and every Minister has a dignity and responsibility. Preserved here in one of the Articles in these draft proposals is the semblance of collective responsibility. We have to keep the goods in the shop window. Analysed, it means that the Prime Minister has complete control over each and every one of the members of the Government. He can dismiss them very much easier than the Executive Council dismissed the Secretary of the Department of Local Government a few months ago. It took all the Ministers to do that. Now it only takes the Prime Minister at his will and pleasure, without a meeting of the Executive Council, without coming to the Dáil, whose servant he is supposed to be. We have the Prime Minister there, one man, and we have the Uachtarán, or President, another man.

Comment on this

We also dismissed O'Duffy.

Comment on this

And sent him a wrong dismissal—a dismissal under an Act which was repealed.

Comment on this

The fact that you dismissed O'Duffy may be a matter of amusement for the Vice-President, who also dismissed Mr. McCarron.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

There is no distinction in justice between the dismissal of General O'Duffy and Mr. McCarron. It is only one of degree. They were both acts of injustice by the Vice-President.

Comment on this

Did we not do you a great turn? Did we not give you a leader?

Comment on this

If the Vice-President, as a member of a collective authority, knows his Executive Council is responsible——

Comment on this

We gave you a leader—a Fuehrer.

Comment on this

We will look forward with amusement to the Vice-President being translated into Uachtarán of this State and to having the President of the Executive Council for the President. There we will have the perfect system envisaged by the framer of this draft. That brings me to this point, that these draft proposals are so framed by the framer of them that he is free to make up his mind whether he will be Prime Minister or President. If he is going to be Prime Minister, he has the whip hand and will put in somebody as President over whom he will have the whip hand. If he is President he will see that whoever is Prime Minister will be subordinate and subservient to him. That is the scheme embodied in the draft proposals which is to be submitted in this farcical way to a plebiscite of the people. We have heard speeches referring to the dangers inherent in this office of President. There is the graver danger that there are two men envisaged in this. It may be that you will have this clash of personalities and wills in years to come between the person who is President and the person who is Prime Minister; that you will have an equally serious situation if you have the position where the President is the dominant personality and the Prime Minister the "yes" man; and an equally serious situation if you have the Prime Minister the dominant personality and the President the "yes" man.

The scheme is one for dictatorial powers, come what may, to whoever is President, whether it is the present President of the Executive Council or somebody else. Under the proposal to have the President of this State elected by popular suffrage, it inevitably follows that the President must be the centre of political activity in the future. He must have a political Party of his own or else he must be allied to one or other of the big political parties which must subsist in this State for years to come. Either he must have his own Party or be allied to one of the other political Parties. From the very conception of this Constitution if it comes into operation, you will have the Presidency as a political office and you will have the unique spectacle of this dignified guardian of the people's rights being stopped in the street, as some of us who are members of the Dáil are stopped in the street by our supporters and told: "I worked for you at the last election; will you get me a job?" This is the dignified guardian of the people's rights. The President will either direct the political activity of his "yes" man, the Prime Minister, or he will do it on his own. Whichever way this Constitution works out it is not going to work out for the general good of the people who are being asked to vote, in a few weeks' time, for this new Constitution. They are asked to do so without having the remotest idea of what it is or what its provisions are. If we tell the people of the country to vote against it we are being attacked as unpatriotic. If we tell them to vote for it we will not be doing our duty to the people. At any rate, we will be told that these proposals have the blessings of the plain people of Ireland and that they express the will of the plain people of Ireland. I tell the House there is not a greater tyranny than the tyranny which masquerades under the cloak of democracy. That is the sort of tyranny that is embodied in that document before the House, a tyranny which masquerades under the cloak of democracy.

Comment on this

What about the tyranny that masquerades under a blue shirt?

Comment on this

I wish I had time to deal in detail with this Constitution. We are only allowed a short space of time to touch on the fringe of this document. I would like to go into the question of the effect of Section 10 of Article 13 in reference to the dictatorial powers that may be assumed or given in the Constitution to the President in collaboration with the Prime Minister in the circumstances that I have outlined. Under Article 13, Section 10, the Prime Minister of this State may be turned into a dictator. In the very short space of time at my disposal now——

Comment on this

The Deputy has another three-quarters of an hour——

Comment on this

He has said more in the half hour he has been speaking than the Minister for Finance said in two and a half hours yesterday.

Comment on this

Why does not the Minister move the closure?

Comment on this

I am encouraging the Deputy to go on. The longer he speaks the better pleased I am.

Comment on this

I want to refer Deputies who are interested in this matter to Article 37 of the Draft Constitution. That has not been referred to yet. That Article is one of great significance. In the Constitution of this State there was provision made, following the American headlines, for the division of powers, executive, legislative and judicial. Where is that provision in this document? I notice that the President, who is so fond of using the radio to America, has considerably departed from the principles of the American Constitution in the document that we are dealing with this evening. One would expect, indeed I had expected, that we would have seen a tremendous similarity between the draft proposals that would emerge from the President's office and the American Constitution. The greatest surprise I found was that there was hardly a single item in this Draft Constitution even remotely resembling the symbols or practice of the American Constitution. In the existing Constitution we provided that the judicial power in the Irish Free State would be vested in the judges. That provision was put in to safeguard the democratic rights and liberties of the people.

This great, democratic document we have before us to-day provides that the judicial power is not to lie with the judges. Article 37 provides that though the taxpayer may have the pleasure of paying for his judges,

"Nothing in this Constitution shall operate to invalidate the exercise of limited functions and powers of a judicial nature, in matters other than criminal matters, by any person or body of persons duly authorised by law to exercise such functions and powers, notwithstanding that such person or such body of persons is not a judge or a court appointed or established as such under this Constitution."

We want to make civil servants judges. We want to set up bureaucracy in this democratic State—bureaucracy in excelsis. What can you do with the President under that power? You can pass a law providing that the President can decide anything he likes except matters of criminal law. He may issue letters of cachet lodging persons in jail without trial and there is nothing in this Constitution to prevent him. He may adopt the precedent set by the Government in connection with their collection of the land annuities and provide authority whereby a civil servant may issue a decree. It may be provided that anything the President says is law; it may be provided that whether a citizen owes money or not, the President's decree, irrespective of recourse to the courts, may be absolute. There is nothing to prevent a law being passed under a threat from the Prime Minister that if the Dáil does not pass it, “I will sack the whole gang, the whole lot of you.” This Draft Constitution allows the President to raise taxes on the people, on any and every article, without consideration by the Dáil.

I could spend the rest of to-night and to-morrow showing how this Article 37 confers powers on the President, powers which may be used in reference to these matters—dictatorial powers for the so-called guardian of the people's liberties. The outstanding conclusion that must be come to is that the scheme of this Constitution is two-men. It is a two-man Government and a two-man country; the Dáil, the Seanad, the people and everything else sink into insignificance, in comparison with the authority, the position and the power that is given to these two people under this proposed draft to amend the Constitution.

Let me say in passing, or rather let me emphasise this—that we are not here as a Constituent Assembly. We are here as a Parliament passing this law and we are here as one of the members of the British Commonwealth of Nations. We are here proposing to pass this draft amendment to the Constitution, not a new Constitution, as the President would like the people to believe. We are proposing to pass these amendments to the Constitution under the powers contained in the existing Constitution. This Bill or this proposed law, whatever one calls it, that we are considering at the moment is nothing but ordinary legislation within the meaning of Article 51 of the existing Constitution. I would like to throw another brick into the placid pool of the President's political fantasy by asking him would he consider—I would not ask him for the world to consult a lawyer—whether this Draft Constitution is a Constitution at all and whether as an ordinary Bill it can be repealed by an ordinary Bill by a subsequent Parliament here? The President can chew upon that either with or without a lawyer.

Now, there are some very serious matters that I have to refer to in connection with the draft proposals, other than these very vicious powers that are or may be given to the President under this Constitution as it stands. I do not want to go in detail into all this; I can only deal with the very fringe of the topics that ought to be dealt with, and to which the attention of the public ought to be very specifically directed. I apparently hurt the President by my reference to his dealings with women's rights under his proposals in this Constitution. It was in reference to that that he told me I did not know what I was talking about. He alleges that if I can convince him that he is wrong in his proposals, that he is mistaken in his view that he has not in any way, by his proposals in this draft amendment of the Constitution, derogated from the status or rights of women as enjoyed constitutionally at the moment, he will be prepared to reconsider the matter. I do not believe for one single instant that the President is open to conviction. He dare not admit that he is wrong; he will not admit it. I do not suppose he would consult a lawyer either.

He cast aside my opinions as those of a politician, or, alternatively, as those of a person who does not know what he is talking about, or alternatively, as those of a mere nuisance, and he cast aside Deputy Lavery's opinions somewhat in the very undignified fashion in which the Minister for Finance endeavoured to do it yesterday and to-day. He cast those opinions aside in a very undignified and extremely unconvincing fashion. having regard to Deputy Lavery's position at the Bar. The well-known habits of the Minister for Finance to lose himself in verbosity were amply displayed. I propose to demonstrate, not for the President, because I have no hope of doing so, but to those who are interested in the matter, that the rights and status of women under these proposals are liable to suffer a very serious setback, and that their status under the Constitution, if this becomes the Constitution of this State, is seriously jeopardised, or may be seriously jeopardised.

None of the speakers on the opposite benches, including the President, who has been chewing on these proposals for years past and puts them forward as his own draft, apparently realises what ought and what ought not to go into the Constitution. Deputy Lavery indicated yesterday the matters that ought to go into the fundamental law of a country. Generally speaking, the less in a Constitution the better. A Constitution provides for the erection of the necessary machinery of the State, and the only other thing that it ought to provide are safeguards for certain essential privileges and liberties of the citizens of the State. Nothing else ought to go in, no verbosity or flapdoodle or boloney. But what ought to be there, and what is not in this Constitution, are effective guarantees for the rights and liberties of the ordinary citizen of this State. They are conspicuous either by their absence, or by the manner in which they have been surrounded, in the public interest if you please, by certain alleged safeguards.

The President said yesterday that he took out from Articles 3 and 14 of the existing Constitution the very significant words "without distinction of sex." He gave an explanation of why he took those words out, an explanation which failed to convey any significance whatever to my mind. He said he took them out because they were a sort of insult to women, and then he proceeded constitutionally to insult the same women in his own proposals. Deputy Lavery has pointed out the defects in this connection implicitly in Article 40. There is a very much more fundamental matter to be considered in connection with other Articles of the Constitution. The only place in these proposals for a Constitution in which citizenship is referred to, does not confer any right on any citizen of this State, man, woman or child, to be a citizen of the State.

In these proposals for a new Constitution, nowhere is there a constitutional guarantee to an Irish-born person, a person born in Ireland, that he is a citizen of this State. If he is born in Ireland, or of Irish descent, there is no constitutional guarantee that he will not be deprived by law of that right that he has as a natural right. The only provision we have as regards citizenship in these proposals is that contained in Article 9:—

"The acquisition and loss of Irish nationality and citizenship shall be determined in accordance with law."

An Irish-born person, a person born in Ireland, has no right to the Irish nationality that he ought to have by the mere fact of his being born in Ireland. He may be deprived of that right by a law passed by a sectional Government or by a class Government that may be elected here at some future time.

Of course, as the law stands at the moment, passed under the existing provisions of the Constitution, we have provision made for citizenship for Irish-born persons and persons of Irish descent and others. That law can be changed and it will not be a breach of the proposed Constitution. There again, I want to emphasise that the President has not apparently realised the necessity for putting into this Constitution the things that ought to be there. Constitutional guarantees of citizenship and nationality—they are not there; they are not there for men much less for women. A woman can be deprived of her citizenship by an ordinary law passed by the Parliament here that cannot be set aside as a breach of any constitutional right guaranteed by the new Constitution. That is the first fundamental matter that has not been adverted to. No person has a constitutional right to citizenship or Irish nationality; it is not guarded in any way.

Now we come to Article 16, which is the Article to provide for membership of Dáil Eireann. The President said he knocked out the significant words "without distinction of sex" from the two Articles of the existing Constitution to which I have referred because he did not want to insult women, did not want to remind them that they had only emerged from a period when they had not the right either to vote or to be in Parliament. In the Article of the Draft Constitution he has provided a means by which they can be deprived of the rights which they obtained only such a very short time ago. Article 16, paragraph (1), sub-clause (i) provides that:—

"Every citizen who has reached the age of twenty-one years, and who is not placed under disability or incapacity by this Constitution or by law, shall be eligible for membership of Dáil Eireann."

Under that provision of this proposed Constitution a disability or incapacity may be created by law and there is no constitutional safeguard against the creation by law of a disability or an incapacity for a woman to become a member of Parliament. She has no constitutional right under that Article to be a member of the Dáil. No person has a right to be a citizen. Every citizen shall vote, but he may be put under an incapacity and a woman, though she may be a citizen, may be put under an incapacity by reason of her sex.

Articles 41 and 45 merely supplement the point I am now making, and rather tend to indicate, in my opinion, that it was not done inadvertently. Then, the next sub-clause of the Article provides for the vote for members of Parliament. It says: "Every citizen who has reached the age of 21 and who is not disqualified by law... shall have the right to vote." Does not that make it possible for women to be disqualified by law from having a vote? I should like to hear the President, with or without the advice of every lawyer he can put his hands upon, telling me how he answers that argument? He will not be able to answer it, and I doubt if he will have the courage to accept the amendments which we propose to put down, providing constitutional guarantees that Irish-born citizens will not be deprived of Irish nationality and their citizenship by an ordinary law passed in the ordinary way by the Oireachtas.

When you come to Article 40, what I have just said is merely reinforced by the consideration of the provisions contained in Articles 40 and 45. We found that incapacity and disqualification may be created by law, and that deprivation of citizenship may be provided for by law. The President says that he has set headlines for future generations of legislators to follow in these pious aspirations that he has enshrined, towards the end of his proposed Constitution, in Article 45. Here, however, is the headline as regards women. Article 40 says that all citizens shall be held equal before the law. Characteristically, the next sentence is added: "This shall not be held to mean that the State shall not in its enactments have due regard to differences of capacity, physical and moral, and of social function." In effect, the President says: "All citizens shall be held equal before the law, but I do not want you to take that too seriously; I do not want you to take that too literally, because I must add the following addendum"; and then we are told—presidentially characteristic—that this shall not be held to mean that the State shall not have due regard to differences of capacity—it sounds very like the capacity of women to do certain things —physical and moral, and of social function. Certainly, when reading it for the first time, it seemed to me to fit in completely with the idea that it was intended to allow—and I emphasise the word "allow"—women, if it were thought fit, or any section of women, to be deprived of their right to vote or their right to be members of Dáil Eireann. This phrase about the difference of function had a curiously familiar ring about it when I heard it first, and it was some little time before I realised where I had heard it previously. I wondered where I had heard this phrase about the difference of capacity and difference of function before, and then I remembered Lord Balfour and the Imperial Conference of 1926, and I recalled where the phrase came from, and I remembered Deputy MacDermot's reference in connection with it.

Comment on this

Was not Deputy Costello the father of that?

Comment on this

In 1926 the Dominions were asserting their rights as co-equal States of a League of free nations. Lord Balfour was the president of the committee that sat to consider these constitutional matters, and, out of his philosophical ingenuity, he devised the famous—the world-famous declaration of equality of status. Well, we had sufficient experience to know that words meant nothing even then. We still think that words, in this Constitution, if I may say so in parenthesis, still mean nothing. At any rate, we found that the principle of equality of status was affirmed, but later on the astute Lord Balfour says that: "Of course, equality of status does not mean equality of function." Accordingly, when I saw this phrase about the differences of capacity and of social function in this draft Constitution, I wondered why it rang so familiarly to my ears, and here we find that it was got from Lord Balfour. Here is the phrase from the Report of the Imperial Conference of 1926: "Equality of status is thus the root principle governing our inter-Imperial relations, but the principles of equality do not universally extend to function." Now we have the philosophical Lord Balfour copied by the equally philosophical, but more mathematical, President of our State.

Comment on this

The Irish phrase came from the Book of Kells.

Comment on this

Now we have the equality of status pared down, as regards women, in Article 40, just as Lord Balfour tried to pare down the declaration of equality of status that had been given by the British Commonwealth of Nations. At that time, however, the people representing the Irish nation at that Conference were not to be taken in by that sort of rubbish and verbosity, and I said: "That is all very fine—that phrase about equality of status—but come along now and put it into practice"—and in the succeeding Imperial Conferences we had it put into practice. In the same way, I want to see Article 40 functioning. I want to see it in practice. When Article 45 speaks of the inadequate strength of women, I want to know how is that going to be operated, and I want to know why it has not been operated up to this. It says in that Article:—

"The State shall endeavour to ensure that the inadequate strength of women and the tender age of children shall not be abused, and that women or children shall not be forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their sex, age or strength."

The President is going to leave that sort of verbosity and flap-doodle behind him as a headline for his successors. I say, there is the head-line set for you, and why have you not been carrying it out? The President has been five years in office, and what has he done to ensure that the inadequate strength of women should be safeguarded, and that those unfortunate women whose husbands are drunkards should not have to go out to work for their families, and that those women who have good and sober husbands who cannot get work, should not also have to go out and work for the maintenance of their families?

I want to see these Articles in practical operation, and I will not take account of those high-falutin', flambuoyant utterances. I want the principles of social justice put in practice, and not merely set down in flambuoyant terms, about the rights of property and the equality of citizens before the law, and all the rest of it— not set down in such terms as would allow them to be interpreted by a possibly Communistic Government in the future in a way to suit themselves.

Comment on this

What about the phrase that it is no part of the duty of a Government to provide work for the citizens?

Comment on this

I have drawn attention to the infirmities that exist in this Constitution as regards women's status. In my opinion—and I do not state it merely from the point of view of one who thinks that his opinion is infallible; I state it because I believe it to be accurate and because I have the support of legal opinion of greater eminence and experience than my own —in my opinion, there are inherent defects in these provisions of the Draft Constitution with regard to the status of women. What is the President going to do about that now? What is he going to do as regards the status of women? What is he going to do about the liberty of the Press? He said yesterday that he did not believe that the liberty of the individual was inviolable. Of course, he does not believe that it is inviolable; he took it out. Not merely did he take out that sanctified phrase, that solemn utterance in our Constitution, but he proceeded to take jolly good care that if this is passed into law the liberty of the individual will be subject to the whim and will of the President. The liberty of the person was at least stated to be inviolable. At least, we could resort to that argument in court when questions of constitutionality were at issue. At least we could argue that these words were there. They are taken out now—because they are not true, the President says.

He must have, in connection with organs of public opinion, his veto—in the public interest, if you please, in the interests of President de Valera, I suggest, or in the interests of any other politician who may succeed him. Every politician thinks that his particular views and fancies coincide with the public interest. This phrase may be resorted to merely for the purpose of proving, if proof were required—and none is required according to the President—that the liberty of the person is not inviolable, that the freedom of the Press that was supposed to be enjoyed in this country can be encroached upon at the whim and will of a politician, and that all that can be justified in the name of democracy. Again I must repeat what I said at the beginning of my observations, that there is no tyranny so great as a tyranny masquerading as democracy.

Comment on this

That from the author of Article 2A!

Comment on this

The right of citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions is supposed to be safeguarded but the tag is added, just as the tag was added in another instance, about the education of public opinion. Public opinion must be educated until it coincides with the whim, will and pleasure, the peculiar views and the constitutional pirouetting of the particular President, whether he is the framer of this Constitution, the framer of some other amendment or the exponent of some particular theory. The radio, the Press and the cinema are to be controlled so that they will not undermine public order, public order being equivalent to the ideals of the particular politician who happens to control the State at the moment. I suppose it was because the President wanted to control the radio and wanted to educate public opinion that he used the radio last night. What were we told over the radio last night, over this free Irish air? We were told, in order that public opinion might be educated at 10.30 last night, that when the President made his speech the gallery of the Dáil was crowded, that there was a packed gallery, that people could not get seats; the fact being that there were plenty of seats and that the gallery did not get full until the Opposition started to criticise the Constitution. The gallery came to hear the criticisms, not to hear the Presidential pirouetting. What did it give, this radio, in the interests of the education of public opinion? In fact, it gave the entire time devoted to the announcement of what had happened in the Dáil that day, to what the President had said. The President finished his speech at a quarter past six or shortly before it. The announcement over the radio, for the purpose of educating public opinion, was made at 10.30 or a few moments afterwards. Not a single syllable or sentence went over the air of this nation, taken from the speech of anybody else between 6.30 and 10.30, not a line from the speeches of anybody other than the sublime utterances of the President of the Executive Council. That is the way the organs of public opinion are going to be used under this Constitution. That is the way public opinion is going to be educated. That is the liberty that the Press is going to enjoy, directly or indirectly, by law or intimidation outside the law, if this Constitution goes through as it stands at the moment.

The Labour Party are going to vote for the Second Reading of this Constitution. Have they adverted to the fact that they have no guarantee, no constitutional guarantee of their right to form trade unions? It is stated there, of course, that citizens have that right, because we must keep the goods in the shop window. We are all familiar with the sight of whiskey bottles full of coloured water in shop windows and these guarantees are as worthless as the bottles of whiskey one sees in publicans' windows. The right to form unions is guaranteed, but what way is that right to form a trades union, either of employees or employers, going to be exercised? It is going to be exercised in accordance with law.

There are many other matters to which I should like to refer but I want to emphasise a matter to which I drew attention before, because whether it is by reason of the fact that I am one of those much despised lawyers or not, I have considerable respect for the liberty of the subject and the writ of habeas corpus. The writ of habeas corpus is gravely cut down in this democratic Constitution, for what reason I know not. The original jurisdiction which the High Court has at the moment to deal with questions of constitutionality or otherwise is transferred to the Supreme Court. If a law is passed which appears to be unconstitutional and that a citizen of the State is imprisoned illegally, the High Court, to whom alone is given the right to grant a writ of habeas corpus has no right to interfere until the Supreme Court has satisfied itself whether that law is constitutional or unconstitutional.

I should like to advert to the change that is taking place in the status of the Attorney-General. The Attorney-General, it is proposed, shall share the same fate as the members of the Government but he has this advantage: that whereas members of the Government lose their names and are no longer Minister under the Constitution, he at least keeps his name. He is still Attorney-General, but a shoeblack may be Attorney-General. Even Deputy Corry could be Attorney-General. There is no provision in the Constitution providing for any qualifications for the Attorney-General but whoever he is, he should have, at least under the Constitution, certainly in the legislation of this country, a position independent of the Executive. He ought to be allowed to exercise his functions irrespective of the political opinions of the Prime Minister or the Fuehrer. Under this Constitution he will be nothing other than a person subservient to the will of the Prime Minister. He is at present appointed by the Executive Council; now he is to be appointed, in substance, by the Prime Minister and be dismissed by the Prime Minister. The other members of the Cabinet or Government as it is called—it can hardly be a Cabinet after this goes through—have nothing to say to the appointment of the chief law officer, the person whose duty it is to look after the rights of the people. He has no independence of status. He holds office at the will and pleasure of a politician. Dare he give an opinion contrary to the opinion of that particular individual and out he goes. That is one of the most reactionary proposals in the entire Constitution but it is in line with what is the general scheme of this Constitution.

The President yesterday, with tears in his voice, almost begged somebody to tell him how to get a better tribunal that would decide on the interpretation which ought to be placed on this Constitution. He said he could think of nothing else but the courts to interpret the Constitution. Any person other than the President would have imagined that the only body competent to interpret a legal document would be the courts, but according to the President it is the last resort. The Supreme Court of this country is the only body he could think of to interpret this Constitution. Will anybody tell him a better body to interpret the Constitution than the Supreme Court? I will tell him—and I will end on this, because it is all in line with the fundamental framework and intention of this Constitution—the President himself. There is no person—I was almost saying in heaven or on earth— who will be able to interpret this Constitution in the way that the President will want it interpreted. He is the only one who would satisfy his ideals of a perfect tribunal to interpret the Constitution. Perhaps he would, in his leisure moments, now that he has got rid of this five-year job of drafting this Constitution, set down as his last will and testament— and enshrine it if he likes in a message to the nation by the new President when he is appointed—what he meant by every word and every line of this Constitution. That last will and testament would be even more interesting as a document than this document which we are considering at the present time.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

I must thank Deputy Costello for handing us the next general election on a plate.

Comment on this

Is the Minister referring to the cost of living?

Comment on this

We were inclined to be optimistic about the next general election——

Comment on this

Then do not talk about plates.

Comment on this

——having consulted the people of Galway and Wexford, but we thought there might be some little doubt about it until we heard Deputy Costello telling us that not alone were we going to get the Taoiseach and the Government at the next general election, but that after it, when the Constitution was put into force, Fianna Fáil was going to select the President. I am sure the organisation of the United Ireland Party—or whatever it calls itself down throughout the country — will not thank Deputy Costello for such an expression of despair before they are beaten. Deputy Costello has presented us with a second dictator. It is a pity he was not here all of to-day and yesterday when his Party concentrated upon making out that the new President to be elected under the Constitution was to be the sole and absolute dictator; that he could do anything he liked. Deputy Costello has raised another one. We are going to have two; the Taoiseach is also going to be an absolute dictator, so we are going to have two dictators in the country. Which is going to dictate to which? After having denounced, in all the moods and tenses, the two dictators that we are going to have at the one time, Deputy Costello made the best possible case for a dictatorship. He made the case that was being made in the organ of his Party when they were running General O'Duffy as dictator. They had not got the courage to go out and organise the Blueshirts, and nominate a dictator from the old Party. They had not got the courage to nominate Deputy Cosgrave as one. They nominated General O'Duffy, and when he did not succeed they kicked him out.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Those matters are irrelevant.

Comment on this

The argument that was being used then for installing our late friend as dictator was that this business of counting the heads, this business of consulting the ignorant people of this country, was out of date; that we should be more in step with modern affairs, and select the gentleman in favour of whom Deputy Cosgrave stepped down so as to place him in leadership.

Comment on this

It is not fair to discuss a man who is not here.

Comment on this

Those people would hit a woman!

Comment on this

We do not have to go back to the rantings of the United Ireland Party in 1934 for arguments in favour of dictatorships. What more contemptible utterance was ever made about the Irish people than that which Deputy Costello made here to-day, when he said that, notwithstanding the fact that this Constitution has been published for ten days, and will be before the people for the next several weeks or several months, they will not know what is in it. He said it is nothing but a trick on the Irish people; that the Constitution will be sanctified by a people who do not know what it means. I can tell him this much: I would take my chance on getting any man outside any chapel gate or at any fair, and he would offer a better explanation of the Constitution than Deputy Costello. The vast majority of the men and women of this country are going to show that at the coming general election and plebiscite. I want to say also that this Constitution and its legality are not going to be judged upon by a person like Deputy Costello, who has the British legal point of view on what the Irish people should do. Once it is put into operation, sanctified by the Irish people and made the law of this land, people like Deputy Costello will have to toe the line in regard to it.

Comment on this

That is an awful threat!

Comment on this

Or they will be put against the wall, I suppose.

Comment on this

It is going to be sanctified by the Irish people, and only the Irish people will be able to change it. Deputy Costello referred to a farcical plebiscite, and said that the people would not know what was in the Constitution. According to him, the people are so ignorant that a matter which has been under public discussion for several months will be unknown to them. They will put a tip on his knuckle when the plebiscite comes along. What about the Constitution which, about 15 years ago, was thrown at the Irish people on the morning of an election, not I per cent. of them having had an opportunity of even reading it before the election came off? What about having that Constitution afterwards spoken of as having been sanctified by the people, and action of a most drastic character taken by a few men on the head of it, without consulting the Deputies or the Parliament of the people?

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

On 28th June, 1922.

Comment on this

When was the drastic action taken?

Comment on this

On 8th December, 1922, if the Deputy wants to know.

Comment on this

On 28th June, 1922, there was a Parliament in this country under a Constitution that had been passed by the majority of the representatives. It was swept away by eight men on the plea that they had put the existing Constitution before the people. They did, on the morning of the poll, when nobody in the country had a chance to read it. There is one thing which the new President will be able to do. Deputy Costello wanted to know what functions this personage was going to carry out.

Comment on this

I did not; I never asked that question at all.

Comment on this

There is one thing which the new President can do. If the Executive Council try to sweep away this Constitution when it has been established by the people, or try to put through a law which would be an amendment of the Constitution, he can say: "No; you must go to the people." I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this