Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Dara Céim (Resumed).
Contributions 194–417 of 417. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
That is why the procedure of a Bill has been adopted as the method for doing it. It is not a Bill. This is not going to be enacted by this Parliament. This Parliament, I think, could not enact it. If Deputy Costello were here, I should like to put him this question. The courts here have expressed certain opinions in dealing with certain cases and made certain suggestions as to their views about the powers here to pass Acts in relation to the terms of the Treaty. We were not going to risk a Constitution like this, even though it was the right way to judge a Constitution like this, being enacted here and being operated with such possible views held by the courts. What we are doing is, we are going back to the sovereign authority, to the Irish people, or that section of the Irish people whom we can consult on the matter. We go back to them and ask them to enact it. It is they who will enact it and, as I said in my introductory speech, when they enact it there is a provision that any judge, or anybody else, who is not prepared to function under it can resign and get out.
Now, in connection with this going to the people, I believe that I have been accused of heresy. Blasphemy and heresy are the smallest things I understand that are in this Constitution. It is very interesting to think that, although this has been several days before the country and in the hands of ecclesiastical and other authorities, we should not have heard a word about this except from the theologians on the opposite benches. We had to wait for them to discover the blasphemy and the heresy. I forget whether it was Deputy Fitzgerald or Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney who said that one Article was heresy. I believe that Deputy Fitzgerald complained that there was blasphemy in it. I want everybody to realise what this Constitution states about authority. In the Preamble, and in the Article that refers to that, there is a clear, unequivocal statement that authority comes from God. That is fundamental. It does not matter what view a group of Catholic theologians may take as to how it comes to the immediate rulers. What we have here is clear at any rate—that authority is from God. That is fundamental Catholic doctrine, and it is here. It is true doctrine. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney raised a question with regard to Article 6 which states: "All powers of government legislative, executive and judicial, derive, under God, from the people, whose right it is to designate the rulers of the State and, in final appeal, to decide all questions of national policy, according to the requirements of the common good." He said that statement is not true. Just listen to that—"that statement is not true." What does that mean?
It means, he says, that all legislative, executive and judicial powers are derived from the people. Now, that is magnificent coming from a lawyer who has suddenly become a theologian. He read a document, and although it is explicitly stated in the document "derived under God" the phrase "under God" is eliminated by him and you are to read it as if it were not there at all. The poor man must have got his information very quickly. He must have got muddled. He was possibly handed a document that he did not understand. Otherwise, I do not see why he went on in that line at all. The fact is that there is a difference of opinion amongst theologians. But all agree on one point, that authority comes from God. They all agree that the rulers are not immediately designated by God. The question on which they differ is how the authority does come to the rulers and the part the people play in it. If we want to discuss that in detail we can take up our theologians opposite when we come to the Committee Stage. But I want everybody to realise that what we have here is that authority comes from the author of Nature, from God.
Now we are going back. I would like to point out that. We indicated in that paragraph that the function of the people is to designate the rulers to decide questions in accordance with the common good. One of the things the people will decide is the form of government, and we are going back to the authority that is there for us, the people, to ask them to decide the form of government. They will also have to decide as a separate question, who are the people who are to possess and exercise authority. Another question has been raised in this connection. It is said it is unfair to put this question to the people at the same time as a general election. Yet almost in the same breath you will get people who are complaining that the Referendum or the election of a President involves expense.
We are to take it, of course, from this that the people cannot have two ideas in their heads at the same time; that they cannot possibly think of two separate questions at one time. One question is what are the institutions of the State to be? What is the form of government and what the State institutions are to be? We are told that they cannot carry that idea and examine it and at the same time have an idea as to the kind of government they want in office. Well, that is only in line with what we have heard from Deputy Costello, to whom I may refer as the principal speaker on the opposite side. The Deputy said that 99 per cent. of the people did not know anything about this Constitution and did not bother about it. Now 99 percent. is a fairly high fraction. Then we are to take it that the people of this country who have been for 15 years agitated and disturbed about this constitutional matter, the people who have in certain elections been appealed to mainly on the ground of changing certain points in the Constitution, are completely careless and heedless and do not know that such a document as this is in existence. We are to believe that they do not know that we are here as a Parliament discussing it although every paper in the country has been printing pages of the speeches delivered here for three days.
The man who stands up and makes a statement of that kind, and then expects that to be taken as a serious contribution to the discussion of this document, surprises me. I wonder what he thinks of us all. He said that 99 percent. of the people know nothing about it, and he said that there are 90 percent. of them who do not know what the Constitution is. That shows ignorance of what our people think, and that is the sort of ignorance that put some Deputies here on the benches which they now occupy. They imagine that the average man in the street has not a fair knowledge of——
Comment on this
Would the President not acknowledge that the people to-day are more concerned with economic questions than with the Constitution?
Comment on this
There is no contradiction between the people being interested and anxious about economic affairs and also being anxious about this Draft Constitution—no contradiction whatever. We have been for months talking of economic matters. Nearly all our legislation is connected with economic matters. This Constitution is a fundamental thing with regard to the life of the community as a whole. This is a thing which is vital if we are to make economic progress, and vital if this community is to act as a progressive community and to move towards any definite end at all as an organised unit. This Constitution is fundamental. It is more essential to the economic advantage of the State that its fundamental law and its institutions should work properly than any single economic issue that might be mentioned.
Comment on this
I wish some Deputies would stay out of this House and not be making a disgrace of themselves and others here. I have been talking about this and going back to the fundamental position, namely, that this Constitution has been drafted with the best help that I could get. Somebody had to prepare the Draft. It has been prepared, and the main lines have been carefully examined by Departments who have special knowledge of the working of these institutions in the past. It is presented here to a very competent body, who have been asked to turn their attention to it and to consider it from a non-political standpoint. This Constitution should be drafted by the Government as if they were the Opposition, and should be discussed and considered by the Opposition as if they were the Government. That is the way I have tried to look at it. Notwithstanding the suggestions from the opposite side, I have tried, and my colleagues on these benches have tried, to look at it in this way, and it is with this idea before our minds that it has been drafted and presented here.
Comment on this
It has been drafted with the view of getting for this country institutions which will work no matter what individuals happen to occupy the posts, because I hope, at least, that this Constitution will have a period of life which will be much longer than that of any of us in this House. I have shown how this was carefully prepared and presented to you as a Draft Constitution. This is a body that is competent to discuss it and to see it discussed. Notwithstanding the fact that it does make one almost close one's mind when one hears from the benches opposite arguments that are clearly wrong—and it is hard to keep an open mind when one sees the attitude taken up by those who are discussing it—however, the hope and desire to get the best out of it will still persist. I say that, notwithstanding that it is difficult to keep an open mind when you have arguments addressed to you—arguments that cannot stand for one moment.
Now, I will pass on from the question of how this Draft Constitution is presented. I simply repeat the conclusion that this Draft is carefully drawn; it is before the people here through their representatives, all of whom are competent to discuss it, and I hope we will get some measure of agreement on it before the end. If not, we are prepared to take the majority view here as determining it and then send it to the people for their approval or rejection. Finally, it is not this Parliament that is to enact it. On the last stage here the motion will be, not "that this measure do now pass," as if this body were enacting it; the proposal will be "that this Draft Constitution, as amended," whatever way it is amended,"shall go to the people for them to enact it."
Now, trying to pick up the big things in connection with the debate for the last couple of days, I think most people here will admit that, leaving aside the small things which can be dealt with better on the Committee Stage, the whole debate has ranged on two main questions— the powers of the President and the status of women. I think it is not unfair to say that that has been the main trend of the debate. Well, it is a certain tribute to the document containing all these pages and all these Articles, submitted to a test which few documents of the kind are likely to be subjected to, with lawyers and others scanning it in its every word to find out whether there was not something that could be pounced upon so as to disparage the document, to find that, after all that has been done before the people, there has been nothing revealed, nothing of an extraordinary nature found, and that there have been simply two matters on which the debate has been concentrated from the opposite side.
A writer dealing with this bogey of the Presidential powers said it was a bogey so contemptible as to be dismissed. I think that any fair-minded person listening to what has been said about it, and reading the Articles themselves, will come to the same conclusion, that it is so contemptible in its character that it can be put aside and not bothered with. However, apparently those on the opposite side think that there are 90 per cent., of the people who do not know what a Constitution is, that 90 per cent. of the people form a fairly big bulk to be operated on, and that if they know nothing about a Constitution, nothing about its terms, that they can be deceived, and, therefore, it is a good thing to go to the people and go with the cry "‘They are about to establish a dictatorship; that is what Fianna Fáil are doing; that is what this Constitution proposes to do." They think that would be good politics.
I have again a much higher opinion of the intelligence of the average person in the country than they appear to have, and I would like Deputies on the opposite benches to go down after a while to the cross-roads and try to tell some of the people who would be interested in this that dictatorial powers are going to be given to the President. They will find that a good deal of the sophistry which has been indulged in is as apparent to the man at the cross-roads as it is to any intelligent person in this House, just as apparent. The powers of the President are well defined and clear. There are powers in the executive domain, in the legislative domain. The powers in the executive domain are clearly limited. They are limited by the fact that he acts on the advice of the President of the Executive Council or of the Government. He has to act on the advice of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
All his appointments are made on the directions or the instructions—for that is what it comes to—of the Government. But we are told by Deputy McGilligan, a lawyer whose business it is, in fact, to study constitutions, and who told us he has been going over them trying to compare the powers given here with the powers in other constitutions, that there is nothing to compel, that there is no way we have to compel, the President to act if he is unwilling to act. Not merely must the President be unwilling, but the Council of State also, because there is an Article which deals with that matter. Any Deputies who have a copy of the Constitution can look at page 24—I will take the English version; it is even more definite in the Irish—and they will see:—
The Council of State may make such provision as to them may seem meet for the exercise and performance of the powers and functions of the President under this Constitution in any contingency in which the President or a Commission appointed under this Article fails or is unable to exercise and perform the said powers and functions or any of them and which is not provided for by the foregoing provisions of this Article.
Now, it is clearly provided for there that if the President should fail, the Council of State can do it, and, therefore, you have a means of compelling the President to do it. But, of course, this wonderful man, who is able to get the whole Parliament to vote him full power and is able to get the Council of State to give him full power and has nothing but yes-men in the Chief Justice, in the head of the Government, in the Attorney-General and everybody else, will be able to do as he likes. They are all yes-men, and this wonderful man, this superman who is to come upon the earth and be a President, is going to be of such a character that everybody about him is going immediately to kneel at his feet and offer him all these powers.
In these circumstances, of course, if we get such a person on this earth, there would be no need of a Parliament or anything else. Nobody would go to the trouble of electing or bothering about a Parliament if they could hand over powers to a man like that. Not merely the Parliament, but the whole people will put him into that position. This is the dictator we are to look for. The people are going to elect him, and then the representatives of the people are going immediately to abdicate and give to him all their powers. If such a thing could happen, there is no Constitution that can stop it. If some remarkable person is going to come to this island and the Parliament will give him all their powers and the judges and others will be purely yes-men—if such a thing can happen, it is very vain for anybody to try to frame a Constitution.
We are told that a Constitution should be framed, not on the principle that it is to be worked by ordinary beings under ordinary circumstances, but that when we are framing a Constitution we must let our imaginations run riot, and we have to think out carefully all the extravagant things that might possibly happen and we have to provide for them. For instance, the sky might fall; we might have an earthquake; we might have some extraordinary genius before whom all the people are going to bow down; and all that has to be provided for, and we have to provide a Constitution to meet these circumstances.
I do not take that view. I say that it should be viewed from the normal point of view, that we should view it as working under normal conditions, and I think, as I have said before, that the best way to frame this would be, largely, for the Opposition, who have previously been a Government, to take the view that they were still a Government, and for us over here who, at this moment happen to be a Government, to take the view that we were in opposition. If we were to take that view, we would be getting much nearer the mark than by letting our imaginations run riot and letting our minds be influenced by all the horrible things we can imagine and which were put before our minds.
This Constitution has not been framed on such a basis. It has been framed on the basis that we were going to have generally normal conditions, because if things are so abnormal that they are going to sweep these things away, then we cannot provide against them. What we can provide for is the normal and the general, and this Constitution has been framed on that basis: to meet ordinary conditions and to be operated by ordinary human beings. As I said when I spoke about it the first time, it has been framed from a severely practical point of view, and it is because it has been prepared from a severely practical point of view that we have not been content to make broad, general statements which were incapable, and have been proved to be incapable, of being put into practice. You had grand and very fine professions of principle in parts of the old Constitution. Did they last? They did not. They were not able to stand up against the stress of reality.
If you put them in again, they will not be able, possibly, to stand up against the stress of reality. What is being aimed at here is to produce a document which will stand up against the ordinary stresses which the experience of the last 16 years here should have shown to both sides are likely to have to be borne. It is meant to bear up against the ordinary, severe stresses by practical operation. It is not a theoretic document. It is a practical document from beginning to end. I have to repeat what I said formerly—unfortunately one has to repeat certain things—that it is not being narrowed down to a mere framework, merely giving you the institutions of the State. That is the view that some people hold of what it should be. This is intended to do more. It is intended to offer directions in which the State, as a whole, should move. There are directive principles there, and fundamental principles are stated there with the necessary qualifications to enable them to be stated truly. You cannot talk, for instance, about the liberty of the person being inviolable, when you know that, in fact, you have to have laws which interfere with his liberty. You cannot talk about the dwelling of a person being inviolable when you know, in fact, that there may be circumstances in which a dwelling has to be forcibly entered. What you have got to provide against is that, if his liberty is to be taken away from him, or if his home is to be forcibly entered, these things will be done in accordance with the due process of law and not according to the arbitrary will of an individual.
In the same way, when we talk about the question of private property, which has been referred to on the opposite benches, we state the principle that the right of private property shall not be taken away; but there is the general, social right as well as the individual right. There is the good of the community as a whole, and there is the individual; and what is stated here is that, consistent with the recognition of the right of private property, there is also recognition on the part of the State of the right for the common good—that the common good each time would be the test, and a nation's Parliament and the institutions set up are to be the judges of what is for the common good. For the common good, you can delimit the use of that property; but of course we are told from the opposite benches that that is Communistic. When a person accepts the right to private property, by the very fact that he accepts that right, he is not a Communist; and, what is more, these principles are principles which are deducible from the natural law. These principles are deducible from the natural law and are so deducible, and can be deduced, and have been deduced, by pagan philosophers even before the coming of Our Lord at all on earth. You could not state one of these if you did not state the other, because one of them alone would be untrue. You have to state the two.
In the same way, with regard to individual liberty, with regard to the inviolability of the home, with regard to these rights of individuals—these rights also have to be co-ordinated with reference to the common good. You have to take the two aspects, put them side by side, and try to get the proper balance between them, before you are able to arrive at real truth. Deputy McGilligan tells us that, in order to administer any of these, we would need to have a court of Archbishops. It is possible that, by their special training in matters of this particular sort, they might be a better court for that purpose than the Supreme Court. Yet it is very interesting that, when I said that I was looking around for something better than the Supreme Court, I immediately was scoffed at. Of course we are told a Constitution must be interpreted by the courts, and why should I look for any other body? And we have somebody who has studied all the Constitutions of the world, as far as they could be got, and he pooh-poohs the idea that any court other than the Supreme Court should be thought of for the purpose of interpreting the Constitution. He knows perfectly well that in other countries, special courts—in some cases, even the Legislature itself— have been taken as the interpreters of the Constitution. He knows that, even where there is a Supreme Court, as there is in the United States of America, some of the best judges of those courts, when asked to decide as a constitutional court, have said, and put it as the foreground of their work and interpretation, that, ordinarily, the view of the Legislature in interpreting their Constitution should be their guide: that there is a presumption, and should be a presumption, that they are doing their work reasonably and fairly, and that it is only in cases where there is clearly and definitely a departure, not merely from the letter of the Constitution, but from the spirit of the Constitution, that they should hold differently.
I think I indicated, on the Second Reading speech, that at one time I was thinking of whether or not it might not be possible to put a cannon of interpretation here, specially designed as a direction and indication to the Supreme Court that, in dealing with a document of this sort—particularly when you have in parts of it phrases such as "as far as you can," and so on—that would necessarily be left to the Legislature and that a canon of interpretation would be inserted which would indicate to them, broadly, the lines on which they should act when they were coming to a judgment as to whether a particular Act was against the Constitution or not. Believing, however, that our Supreme Court here would take, in matters of that sort, the view that some of the best judges in the United States of America have taken in regard to their Constitution, I thought it was far better not to put in anything that might possibly be restricting their judgment or, possibly, cause them to fail to use their general common sense and appreciation of the fact that the Legislature, in doing these things, ought ordinarily to be expected to be acting in accordance with the intent of the instrument itself. I finally decided that it would be better not to put it in. It would be very difficult to draft it and, in the long run, putting it in might not be so good. I do not accept and I do not think that any Constitutional lawyer would say that the Supreme Court interpreting this document would interpret it exactly in the same way and with the same canons of interpretation, if you like, as he would interpret an ordinary Act of Parliament.
I have digressed considerably from the point I was about to make in regard to the President. I was taken off it to point out that Deputy McGilligan had evidently not read this "novel document." It is extraordinary how novel it can be according to some Deputies at one time, and how commonplace and so much a reflection of the other document it can be at another time. The Deputy evidently had not read it or, if he read it, failed to see the significance of the fact that if the President refused to do something which he is supposed to do by this Constitution, it can be done in his name by the competent body, namely the Council of State. Let me refer again to his powers and try if I can to end this thing once and for all. The appointments which the President will make under this Constitution, every one of them— except the appointment of seven people on a purely consultative body, the Council of State—will be made on the advice of somebody. There is no section that I know of in this instrument—and I should be glad to have it pointed out to me if I have, through any oversight, forgotten any part of it —under which there is any appointment made by the President except on the advice of somebody else. In other words, the selection of the person to be appointed is made either by the Taoiseach, the Dáil, the Executive or the Government. How then can anybody pretend or continue to pretend that a man who cannot choose is a dictator?
I do not know if there is any modern definition of the word "dictator." I have not looked up the dictionary definition of it, but everyone knows that a dictator is a person who himself wills certain things to start with. Having willed a certain thing, he decrees and executes it. Where is the instance in regard to any of these appointments, where the President fulfils any of these obvious requisites for a dictator? He has no will in regard to these appointments. The only question that can arise is whether he will sign the document or not, and if he does not sign the document it will be signed for him by the Council of State, whether he wills it or not. He does not decree anything except in a formal way. He certainly puts it in the Iris Oifigiúil and if he fails to do that, it will be done for him by the Council of State. He does not—and let nobody pretend that he does—in regard to these functions exercise any power which is not more or less of a formal character.
I had better, perhaps, come to the legislative functions. He has in the legislative sphere important functions, but surely it does not lie in the mouths of Deputies on the opposite benches, who have been all the time talking about the power that is vested in this Front Bench, to say that there should not be checks on legislation which might be contrary to the common interest or the general welfare? Have they not been crying out for the last few years that there must be checks? Now when we mention one, they have turned the other way. Now it is a check, if you please, on the people's Parliament. There was, apparently, no people's Parliament up to the present! It can only be a people's Parliament when there is a check put upon it! When it was here acting as such, it was a dictatorship, the dictatorship of a Party! We had them describing with horror how, by a single vote here, we could come in in the morning, pass a Bill overnight, and all your bank balances would be wiped out. A speech something in that style was made by the leader of the Opposition on a previous occasion. We could come in here, take the judges and make them "yes-men." We could do all these things, because there was no check like the check of a Second House. Now when we introduce a Second House, which to a certain extent is a check, and when we establish a check by having somebody who has also the authority of the people for the very definite specific functions he exercises, we are told that it is a check on the people's Parliament. If it is a check, it is a check which the people themselves have deliberately arranged for. This man, whoever he may be, will be deliberately chosen with the knowledge that he is entrusted with the very big responsibility of being a check in certain instances.
What are the instances? There is the case of the Money Bill which I spoke about. I do not suggest—it has happened only once, I think, in a large number of years—that there would ever be a dispute about whether the certificate of the Ceann Comhairle, in a case like that, was properly given, but no one is infallible and when an emergency of that kind can be provided for, it is wise to do it. Here you have an appeal. If the Second House, which is limited in the manner in which it can deal with a Bill once it is certified as a Money Bill, thinks that it should not have been so certified, it can make an appeal. The President cannot take the initiative in the matter. The Seanad is the body which must make the appeal to him and ask him to have a Committee of Privileges set up to investigate the question as to whether the Bill that was certified as a Money Bill by the Ceann Comhairle was in fact such. What harm can there be in having that appeal? What dictatorial powers does he exercise there? If there is an appeal by the Second House he can consider the question. Why is it that he is not compelled automatically to accede to it? For this reason: that there might possibly be frivolous appeals—frivolous attempts by the Second House to interfere with the ordinary operation of the First House, the House of Representatives.
You have that extra check; it is not merely a check by the Seanad. The President hears the views of a number of sensible men who are not "yes-men." Nearly all of them have got powers quite independent of the President, except six or seven who can be introduced by him. The proposition here is that the President should have the power of consulting these, and that he might have the power of making the Council of State as representative as possible. It might happen, as an example, that there might be no member of the Opposition, that there might be no member of the Labour Party, in the position that he could get in under the heading that he had formerly held offices which would entitle him to come in. Therefore, it is advisable that he should have a certain number. It is not a question of a vote being taken. I do not think a Council of State ought to be operated by any President on the question of a vote. Clearly, if there was a legal matter being discussed, he would, if he felt that there was no politics coming in and making lawyers say differently from what they would say if they were advising a client or advising the Government. When talking about lawyers, let me say that the Articles in this have been passed by lawyers, and that the difference between the lawyers who have passed this and the lawyers who are criticising it has been mainly that the lawyers who have passed this have no part whatever in the politics of the situation.
Comment on this
They have responsibility, the same responsibility that made the former Attorney-General, when he was Attorney-General, advise the Government to do a thing that was upheld by the courts even when he went out as a politician.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it regular for the President to put in issue the merits of civil servants? If that course is to be pursued, then it must be open to the Opposition to draw those civil servants——
Comment on this
I wish to submit a point of order, and I intend to do so. If that course is to be pursued, it must be open to us on this side to draw the President's advisers into the debate and criticise their capacity to advise.
Comment on this
The point put to me was whether it is usual or lawful to draw civil servants' qualifications or actions into the debate here. It is not, and I have not heard the actions of civil servants criticised by the President.
Comment on this
I have not referred to it specifically, at any rate. Perhaps the Deputy, by some sort of generalisation, may be entitled to say that I did. We have law advisers. That is known. When the previous Executive were there they had the same. It is not uncommon to be asked the question, "What do your law advisers say on this matter?" Am I wrong, a Chinn Comhairle, in saying that we have behind this document the support of the legal advisers of the Government? What is out of order in that? I was saying that this document—as well as the interpretations which I give it—has behind it the authority of people who are just as competent as any of the lawyers who have spoken from the opposite benches. In addition to that, there is this difference between them—and it is apparent from the views which have been expressed by lawyers on the opposite benches—that the people who have given it on this side have not had and could not have had any political interest in giving it, because they are outside politics at the moment, anyhow.
Comment on this
And he is responsible in the last resort for giving the Government advice on legal matters. The Attorney-General is entitled to get, either from the Civil Service or outside the Civil Service, the best legal advice, if he is ever in any doubt. If there is ever a question on which he wants to get further advice from lawyers outside, he is entitled to ask them to advise as they would advise a client.
Comment on this
That is the business of the Attorney-General, and what the Attorney-General does or does not do is his own business. I am not going to answer any question as to whether he has or has not done so.
Comment on this
He has adopted the practice which is usual in all those cases, namely, that where he has no doubt himself, and where there is no reasonable reason for a doubt, he gives the advice. If he thinks there is a matter on which there is a possibility of difference of opinion, and upon which it may be well to get other advice, he has the right to get that other advice. I am presenting it here with full authority from the Government Benches as a document which has been carefully examined by the different Departments, by the different lawyers. I am only a layman, and there are gentlemen on the opposite benches who are lawyers; lest they should fool the people by getting them to think that, because they as lawyers are speaking against this, their opinion outweighs my opinion and interpretation as a layman, I am putting it before the country that my opinion as a layman is completely and absolutely reinforced by the law advisers of the Government.
Comment on this
Yes—the very best. When we come to examine this in detail it will be found in the long run that there are very few things in it that will need modification. Let me continue with the dictatorial President. I have been talking about his legislative functions. I have pointed out in connection with Money Bills that he is merely a court of appeal; in fact, he is not a court of appeal in the proper sense, because he does not decide; he is simply a medium. If there is a question in dispute it must be referred to a competent body, namely, a committee of privileges picked from each House. Again, if anybody wants to suggest a better committee of privileges I have an open mind. As has been the case in regard to a number of other things, the actual way decided upon here has been the result very often of rejections of other methods which we thought of as solving the difficulty. It will be found that the suggestions rejected were ones which we had very good reasons for rejecting.
There is the position of emergency legislation. If we were to come here and propose that this Dáil were to have power to curtail the power of the Second House, and say: "You must have, in a certain time, a certain Bill through," we would receive very serious opposition. Is it not quite obvious, if you are going to have a second chamber at all, and if it is to exercise any of those functions which are usually associated with a second chamber, the primary chamber ought not to be in a position—except in the very rarest circumstances, which would have to be clear to everybody to be such—to curtail the power of the Seanad and say: "You must meet this evening and have this passed by 10 o'clock"? It is clear that to give the primary chamber such power would be practically to wipe out the second chamber. I can imagine people saying: "You cannot give that power to the Dáil." I admit that, if you give them that, you give them tremendous power.
Why do we give it to them? Because there may be occasions in which the very safety of the State, the welfare of our whole people, may depend upon getting a thing done quickly. Can you depend upon the goodwill and the commonsense of the Seanad alone to do that? I would say generally "Yes", and I would expect that that power which is provided for there would perhaps not be exercised once in a lifetime. But it may be. Am I now transgressing and running in the same direction as Deputy McGilligan wanted us to go in making provision for this extraordinary thing? I may be accused of that. It would not be an unreasonable argument to say that I am trying to provide here for something which is very unlikely, and that we can leave it to the good sense of the Second House to accommodate the First, and to be as sensible of the emergency as the First House or as the Government.
I can understand the argument— and it is one which weighs very much with me—that the Second House can be so depended on. I will take it that, generally, if there was such an emergency, the first thing the head of the Government would do would be to try to see the Chairman of the Seanad and say: "Will you try to get the Seanad to meet, and let us get this thing over quickly, because, if there is delay, immense harm will be done to the community?" Ordinarily, that will work. It ought to work anyhow. But in case it did not, you are giving the primary House the power of overcoming the opposition, if it were offered, and you are only asking that there should be some impartial person who is not in the political arena, so that the head of the Government could go to him and say: "Here is the situation." He will already be acquainted with the general circumstances. "If we do not pass this Bill by to-morrow, such and such will be the consequences." The President will have heard the views of other people who are, again, outside the ruck of party politics. If he is able to persuade the President in those circumstances, then it can be done with the President's consent. That is one place where the President has considerable power and considerable responsibility. But, again, this is a thing which is not likely to come into operation except in rare cases, and if anything can be found fault with, it is not that the President has to come into it. What you have to find fault with is the power that is given to the First House to override, even with the President's consent, the Second House.
Therefore you are not conferring on the President any dictatorial powers. If you are conferring them on anybody you are conferring them on the primary House, the House of the people's representatives. It is pretended that by giving the President a certain power of check you are giving dictatorial powers. If you like, even with this check, you should not give these powers to the primary House, but do not let us hear any more of the pretence that we are giving by that dictatorial powers to the President.
It is very interesting and most amusing when you hear the leader of the Opposition making that plea, that you are giving the President powers at the expense of the Parliament. Technically it is incorrect, because he himself is part of the Parliament. If you mean giving him power at the expense of the people's representatives, he is a representative of the people, too, so that that would not be correct. So if you say you are giving him powers at the expense of the people's representatives in the primary House, then I say that comes very badly from the man who was all the time telling of the danger to the country of a single Chamber, which might put its will into operation overnight by a vote in which it had a majority of only one. Where are his further functions? If a Bill is passing through, he can say this appears to me to be contrary to the Constitution; but can he say because it is contrary to the Constitution it shall not become law? He cannot. All he can do is refer it to the Supreme Court and have a decision upon that matter. But, of course, if it is the idea that they are all "yes-men"——
Comment on this
Well, the Deputy is not infallible and he is not always in the House. It was said here in the House.
Comment on this
The point was made on the question of going to the Supreme Court, that they were yes-men. He may have intended that that should apply to the other, but it was clearly the Supreme Court in the context. I suppose I am fallible as well as the Deputy. It may be a question between us then. But to my recollection, and it surprised me very much——
Comment on this
In connection with the Council of State, what about the judges in the Council of State? In the Council of State there will be people who are ex-presidents. When the statement was made there immediately came to my mind a picture of the President of the Supreme Court, the President of the High Court, ex-presidents and other people all being yes-men.
Comment on this
Sometimes I do make mistakes, but, unlike the Deputy, if I am not perfectly certain, I am always willing to admit it, as I have done now.
Comment on this
Let us continue with the examination of the President's functions. In regard to Bills that are said to be contrary to the Constitution his function is simply one of reference to the Supreme Court. In regard to ordinary Bills the pretence is made that if the two Houses pass a Bill he can interfere. He cannot. The only case where he can interfere in regard to a Bill passed by the two Houses is if he thought it was contrary to the Constitution he can send it for a certain time to be examined by the Supreme Court. He can do that certainly, but with regard to ordinary legislation he has to sign it. There is only the case in which the President comes in actively in regard to ordinary legislation with another big power. That is where the matter in question is so grave that it is regarded by the majority of the Seanad and at least one-third of the members of the Dáil of such a grave character that if it passes without having the people's will expressed upon it, it would be a wrong use of a parliamentary majority in the lower House. But he must be satisfied that it is a grave matter, and no President is likely to be so foolish as to refer to the people a Bill unless there is grave doubt. If he were a wise man at all he would want to be almost certain that the people were opposed to it before he would have a referendum. What he does is: He says the matter in this Bill is of such grave importance that the people ought to determine upon it. What is he doing? He is seeing that the Bill is referred to the sovereign authority. Surely the people themselves, when they are referred to, are a higher authority than their representatives. The only objection that I can see to referring it to the people is that it is an expensive process. Therefore it would not ordinarily be used; because anybody who would use it wilfully and carelessly, without full appreciation of the circumstances, would lose the good opinion of the people. That is one of the checks you have on the President's powers all the time, that he is put there trusted by the people, that they expect him to carry out his trust properly, and that if he abuses it they will let him know their opinion very quickly.
I am asking where there is this extraordinary dictatorial power. Mind you, it is not that he comes in and some how interferes, but that he has some dictatorial power. Where is it? We hear these vague things; that he has this great power; that it is too much to give to one man—all these things are conjured up. Let us find out where it is. It is not in any of these I have spoken of. But, it is said, there is a little paragraph hidden away quietly, that paragraph which says that, subject to the Constitution, the President may, by law, get extra powers and provides that, if he does, by law, get these extra powers, these powers must be exercised either on the advice of the Executive Council, or after consultation with the Council of State.
Take the worst—take the widest possible meaning you can have in that and let us see what it comes to. When I was asked about it the first time, I said that, in addition to the express powers you gave to the President, in order to have a certain amount of similarity in the method by which things were to be done that you did want to have some means by which the Parliament, the two Houses, might, by law, confer upon the President the power of doing things other than those expressly provided for here; but that they could not be repugnant to what is provided here. I was trying to think of what particular type of function you could possibly want, and the first one that occurred to me was that the former Governor-General had, before his office disappeared, on the advice of the Executive Council, to appoint visitors to a university. I gave that as an example. Later on Deputy Lavery made a mis-statement or misinterpretation. It was not so much a misinterpretation, because it could not be a question of misinterpretation. I do not want to be misunderstood in my reference to Deputy Lavery, and I do not want to say that he wilfully mis-stated it or anything of that sort; but the statement could not be a misinterpretation of what is in the document. It was simply a mis-statement of it. The suggestion was that the President was purely to be a person confined to internal affairs. I said, not necessarily so; as long as the present relationship is maintained, yes.
Comment on this
The relationship provided for in the Act of last December. Those Acts are taken over by the Constitution. The ordinary laws are taken over. As long as that position is maintained, the President will only exercise those functions that are given to him which have relation to internal affairs. What you do here is, you give power to the Executive Council to use any organ or instrument, whether it is a league of nations, or any new group, or the King—if that is what the Deputy wants me to say—as long as that relationship is maintained you can use it. But there is nothing to prevent you any time, by law, changing that situation. Therefore, if you change it, you can equally by law give to the President these external functions as well as the internal functions. It is not correct, therefore, to say that this confines the President to internal functions. Law can confine him to it. It can be confined by law. But this Constitution itself does not do it. This Constitution gives full power to the Parliament to use it for external affairs if they want to. If the Parliament and the people want to change the connection between this country and Britain, and if they want to change the Act of December last, they can do it. I should like to see the person who will tell me that the Irish people have not the right to do it. They can do it. It is provided here that they can. If they want to, the Parliament can give to the President the functions which, under the existing circumstances, with the Act of last December in operation, are not to be done by the President. It is wrong to make the statement that Deputy Lavery made, that the President is purely for home affairs. No. He can be for home or external affairs, according as Parliament and the people decide.
Comment on this
You can have either one, as the Irish people want, and as the interests of the Irish people determine, and that is the way it should be—whichever you want to have; either use the Act of last December, if it is the King is used by that, or if that is changed to-morrow, and you have some other method of getting these things done, that method can be used. If you want to cut it altogether, you can do it by this Constitution. If you want to have a league of nations, and there is a new league put up and you want to go into close association with it, and it is agreed, in the general interest, that some other method should be used so as to do it, you can do it, provided the Parliament and the people agree.
Therefore, there is full liberty given here in this Constitution for the use of the President in external as well as internal affairs. But I am told: "If you give that power to the President by that Article, then you can give him any power." That is nice reasoning. If the President is given one sort of power, he can get any power—well, that is nice logic. The President is given powers. You can add to the existing powers, or rather you can add the ones that are definitely designed for him and definitely specified in this Constitution. You can add those other powers—but that does not mean to say you can add any other powers—the other powers—those powers which are specified, those functions which are specified in the Act of December, 1936. You can confer on the President those functions which are provided for in that, or to be operated otherwise.
Comment on this
Is that a bit of information for you? Because we want to have that discussed separately and independently by the people; so that when the people think that that line of action should be taken they can do that, and that when it is being done by the Parliament we can have under this Constitution a Parliament of all the people's representatives, without anybody who is a member of that Parliament necessarily committing himself to any line of foreign policy, as you have in other Parliaments. That is the difference between this Constitution and the others. This Constitution puts in its proper place the question of external relations and makes it a matter for us to deal with as a matter of foreign policy, as it would be dealt with in any other country.
I gave the example of the United State and the question of its association with the League of Nations. That is a burning question and has been a burning question in America, one way or another, since 1919. The people of America have had different views upon it. What would you think if they were to introduce and make, through the Constitution, the question of entrance into the American Congress depend on the fact that any section entering it had to take either view in regard to that matter; in other words, if they had to make it a part of the American Constitution, say, that the United States should be a member of the League of Nations? If that were in their Constitution and there was an obligation on those who entered the Congress to accept that, then you would have the United States in somewhat the same position that we have been trying to get out of in this country for a number of years. To get out of that position, and put the question of external relations into its proper position as a question of foreign policy, has been mainly the underlying thought in the drafting of this Constitution. I was talking about the provision to add to the President's powers those powers which are mentioned, which are of a formal type. It is here in the Constitution that these must be exercised on the advice of the Government. He cannot do these things of his own will. He has to do them on the advice of the Government. But Deputy McGilligan says:
"That is not enough; it is not enough that he should be advised to do these things. He must have his signature attested or at least implemented in another way by having a member of the Executive named with it. You must not merely have his name on the document but you must have it countersigned."
Deputy McGilligan had a grand opportunity when Minister for External Affairs of putting that principle into practice. He did not do it. He had to wait until our time to do it. That principle could have been put into operation by him if he wanted to do so. At least, he might have tried to see it was done. I am not aware he did. It was extraordinary that there was no need of that in the case of an authority which was not elected by the Irish people but they have to safeguard it now when there is a man going to be elected by the Irish people themselves. That man is going to take their advice and he is not going to take any conflicting advice that he could get. There is no danger of any conflict of that sort. But they had to wait until the person elected by the Irish people, who has only one set of advisers to advise him on that particular matter. He is to have his signature attested by that particular officer who is to be a member of the Government. If his signature is wrongly affixed you may be perfectly certain that the Government will have a manner of dealing with it and that the Parliament of the people will have a manner of dealing with it. He, no more than anybody else, can exercise functions or give law to something which is not law. Now, I was continuing on that issue that because he got certain powers he can get all powers. I hope I have shown to the Dáil that these extra powers are prescribed and that consultation with the Executive cannot give him any other matters because it is explicitly stated that whoever acts in regard to external affairs is bound to act on the advice and authority of the Government of the day. What extra powers can we give him?
Comment on this
I will tell the President. Every extra power that the President's mind is capable of conceiving——
Comment on this
My mind is not capable of conceiving these powers. The exact functions which the Executive is exercising were told us by Deputy McGilligan
Comment on this
The President asked me to tell him and he will not let me answer when I start to tell him.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has answered, and he said anything my mind could think of. Now, the answer is this. Deputy McGilligan, when he was talking about the Constitution a few moments ago here, said that after all when you go through them, once they are past the democratic principle, they are confined within very narrow lines. They have been examined time after time on various operations. They are in three main classes, and the functions that the President can exercise in these matters are very limited. We have them all. If there is any place where they are all taken in, it is in the Government of the day. If there is any place where anything is outstanding, or anything lying about, these are all caught up into one net, the central net, into which all authority is brought to the elected Government which is chosen by the people's representatives and which is responsible to the primary House day after day.
Comment on this
The Parliament can abdicate and say that "anything the President likes to bring in, we will say ‘yes' to it." So can the people in the extraordinary circumstances that we are told the country is going to produce: everybody is going to say "Let his will be supreme." When that happens there is nothing that you can provide against. When you envisage the circumstances that the elected Government, elected by the representatives of the people, is, as we are told, going to abdicate; when the House of Representatives is going to abdicate; when everybody is going to abdicate—if you envisage these circumstances, I cannot help you.
Comment on this
Deputies over there are talking very loudly for the last three years. They have not abdicated.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the members behind the President. That body of members over there has abdicated.
Comment on this
When you are trying to work up another thesis, when you want to say there is going to be a clash, it is a different matter. I should imagine how Deputy Fitzgerald would catch on to this—that the person has power, he wants to get more of it, and here now we are going to assume that everybody elected by the people is going to be a "yes-man"; that the Parliament is going to abdicate, and that the people are going to stand for it. If Parliament were to do that, the people may not support them.
Comment on this
The Deputy had his chance and he will have his chance in Committee. We are getting ready to meet him in Committee, and then we can see exactly what powers are being given. I have gone over the gamut of his powers in the executive field and in the administrative field, and in not one of them can you suggest that he has dictatorial powers. He has quite the opposite. He is deprived of any power of action except reference; except in so far as he puts his name to a document sent to him his action is confined to a certain matter for decision by somebody else. He cannot decide himself. The Deputy knows that perfectly well.
We next come along to this other matter, this question of the rights of women. This is the second wheel of the cart in which this whole thing has been going on for two or three days. This Draft Constitution is said to be taking away the rights of women. Deputy McGilligan was frank enough, at any rate, to admit that in so far as there appeared to be a taking away of the rights from women they were taking away the rights from men as well.
Comment on this
As far as I understand, the Deputy said there was power to take them away from men as well as from women.
Comment on this
It may have been very clear to the Deputy, but I think I should save myself from making, possibly, a mistake about it, though I, too, agree that it appeared to me to be clear.
Comment on this
I am going to use my own words. It refers to me; the word "appeared" clearly refers to me, and I, in this case, am the judge. It appears—I will repeat it—from the statement which was made by Deputy McGilligan, that this power of taking away rights is not a power merely, as those who want to pretend that there is some special attack on women would have us believe, in relation to women, but is for women and men, and, therefore, they are on a basis of equality there. Is that so?
Comment on this
We want to be clear about it. The whole suggestion is that we are trying to put women in an inferior status, to give women an inferior status to men.
Comment on this
I have met many times representatives of women's organisations and I have been acquainted with their views on a number of those matters, and one of the things they are asking for is that they should be put on a basis of equality so far as civil rights are concerned. I say that this Constitution puts them on a basis of equality as regards their political rights. There is not a single Article in this which takes away from women any right which they have. Our citizenship law is the most liberal in the world in regard to the position of women.
Comment on this
And I am talking about the Constitution. I thought we were debating the Constitution.
Comment on this
You had your chance and now let me start to try to show you are not right. I say this Constitution does not take away from any women's rights. I say that categorically. I am told that in relation to another Constitution it appears not to be so good. The other Constitution, Article 3 of it, came in under a very special set of circumstances. It was dealing with a very special situation. It was the first time that we were getting any body of citizens. No body of citizens had been defined as citizens of this State, of Saorstát Eireann. They had to be defined for the first time. You were getting this defined and we defined it in a certain way and at the time the Constitution was passed Saorstát Eireann was applicable to the whole of Ireland and it brought into the definition people who were domiciled in the country for a certain period before the coming into operation of the Constitution.
We had people in the North of Ireland who were brought in under that. A month after its passage there was, according to the agreement, power to opt out, and the people in the North opted out and left us with a rather complicated citizenship position. That citizenship position was rectified by our Citizenship Act. It is a complicated Act. And because the intention is that this Constitution should be capable of being operated as for the whole country, and because we do not want to lose any rights that we had before, whilst we are getting the rights for the whole of Ireland we are anxious, naturally, to get in and give the right of citizenship to all those who had the right before. You cannot say that in simple terms. The moment that the reintegration which is provided for in the sense that if it comes about it can operate——
Comment on this
The Constitution gives the basis, the first necessary basis for anything, and that is to get order down here and loyalty, complete loyalty here. You cannot express the citizenship position in any simple way suitable for incorporation in this Constitution. It is not unusual to leave the question of the loss and acquisition of citizenship to law. There are some States that leave it in that position and where, as in our case, the definition would be at all complicated, it is right to leave it to law. Does any one of us think that it is likely in this year of grace that we are going to turn back the clock and deprive women of the rights which they possess at the moment?
Comment on this
No, not if you can help it. That is the attitude of everybody. No one wants to deprive them of any rights. The Citizenship Act is there and, unless the people of Ireland and this Parliament want to deprive them of their rights, there will be no suggestion of it. I would like to know what security can anybody, man or woman, any class of the community, get against the will of the people as a whole or the will of the people's Parliament? They cannot get it under any constitution which is not a rigid one, and a rigid constitution is always changed by revolution. You can change this Constitution by a vote of the people at any time. This is not a rigid Constitution in that sense. You have a simple way of changing it. It may be a little bit costly, I admit, but if there is a big question at issue the cost would be only a trifle. But you can settle the issue and change the Constitution by a vote of the people.
We find, therefore, in this, immediately and directly, a definition of the class of citizens. It is in the law, being carried over in the law, and the day when you can get a simple definition of citizenship, such as that all who are born in this island and those who are born of parents who were born in this island—once you can get a simple definition which will fit the situation at the time, then you can insert it into the Constitution; but at present to deal with the complicated situation you want something like an Act, and the Act may be possible. It can possibly be simplified, but in my opinion it is better in our circumstances to follow the example of those countries which leave the definition of citizenship to the Parliament and to Acts of Parliament rather than to the Constitution itself. We are in this position, that we have passed the citizenship law; there is a law in existence. It is not as if we were going out into the void with no definite class of citizens who could be called our citizens. They are well defined and this takes them over, but there is a possibility of a time coming in which you can get your whole body of citizens simply stated in a form suitable for insertion in the Constitution. That time has not come yet.
With regard to women and the phrase, "without distinction of sex," to my mind, anyhow, so far as they are concerned, that is a phrase that may have been applicable just after the time that they got, under the British law, the vote. As far as we are concerned here at any time, there has been no suggestion that women should be denied the franchise. There has been no suggestion from any side, or from any section of the people even; no threat of any kind has been made since we began to rule ourselves, from 1919 onwards—no suggestion from any quarter whatever that women should be denied the franchise, and the fullest powers were given to them. As I said here on the last occasion, women can vote for any office. They can vote at any election —at a referendum election, presidential election, Seanad election, or Dáil election. They can hold any office in this State. That being so, I say that this does not deprive women of any of the rights they have got, and I state that proposition categorically.
It is said, however: "Oh, but they may be deprived of their rights. You deprive them of their rights in the sense that you do not see that they cannot be deprived of their rights." I say that you cannot provide against the people depriving any section of the people of their rights if they want to do so. However, I think it is like Deputy McGilligan, who went on the line that we should frame our Constitution to meet extraordinary and abnormal circumstances. He seems to think that the question should be approached from the viewpoint of the abnormal and the extraordinary. Quite frankly, I say that it has not been approached in that spirit, because I do not believe that it would be the right spirit in which to approach the matter; because if you did, you would be making a Constitution to deal with a lot of absurd exceptions instead of the work that a Constitution has to do, namely, the ordinary work from day to day. In so far as the political rights of women are concerned, I state, then, that this Constitution does not, itself, in any way, interfere with the status of women in the community, and the proof of it is that, under this Constitution, they can hold any office, vote for any election, and there is no distinction made between them and men so far as political action is concerned.
Now we come to one of the Articles which has been brought in, in this connection. One of the Articles says that all citizens are, as human persons, equal before the law. In fact, that is the only sense in which there is equality anywhere. Inequalities are in nature. Inequalities must exist in any organised community. It is essential. You cannot get on without it. You create inequalities here the moment you put one section in office as an Executive while the others are not. You create inequalities the moment you order an army. You create inequalities the moment you have a group of people and have to put a foreman over them. As human persons, they are all equal, but you have to face inequalities in nature, and it is absurd to say that the abstract proposition, that all citizens are equal, is right. It is equally wrong to state that you can give equal opportunities to everybody. It cannot be done.
Comment on this
No. It cannot be done. You cannot give equal opportunities to everybody, because unless you narrow the meaning of opportunity down until it has no longer its ordinary meaning, the people who, by nature, have been put in certain positions or given certain endowments, are given at the very start an unequal opportunity, and it is nonsense, and it is not facing realities, to say that there are not inequalities. It would be absolutely absurd to strain the phrase that all people are equal in that way. You may try to level up the inequalities. It is a very laudable and proper aim to try, as far as possible, to level up the inequalities. It is a very proper thing to do. The workers try to do it when they try to end piece-work and when they say that they will not have piece-work, because under that method of working, if you have unrestricted competition, the piece-worker, if he is a good craftsman and a better worker, perhaps, than others, would be able to get into a better position than one who was not. We have accepted that, however, because, taking it all around, it would work badly for the community generally; and therefore, in order to enable the weaker members to level up the inequalities which exist as a result of different capacities, we deliberately bring in an artificial idea, and that is that there should be no piece-work.
Comment on this
I say that equality of opportunity is not possible. Do you mean to tell me that Deputy Dillon was in the same position and had only the same opportunities as some person who, let us say, was born down in a tenement and had not got the same opportunities of education?
Comment on this
That man starts at a disadvantage. There is no use in not facing the fact that nature does not work by giving equality. We have not got it. What we have got to aim at is to try to get it.
Comment on this
If you say to me, "Do you give up trying to level the inequalities?" my answer is: "No, certainly not." The aim of society ought to be——
Comment on this
Exactly. It ought to try. But there is a difference between trying to do a thing—trying to reach an ideal—and talking about that ideal as if, by the wave of a wand, it could be achieved, or as if it were a natural thing to be achieved. There is in these Articles opportunity for a good deal of thought and debate, and we will all be the better for it when we have debated these Articles out.
Comment on this
Oh, no. According to the Minister for Defence, every man at a chapel gate in the country knows more about the Constitution than we do.
Comment on this
I will say to Deputy McGilligan—and he knows it very well —that you may have a thing that is quite succinct and you could write an essay on it.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan had an excellent opportunity of making constitutional matters clear either here or elsewhere, but, judging by his contribution to-night, I am afraid he has not done very well in that line. Now, with regard to this question of the modification of that general proposition: First of all, it is modified, as you notice, by putting in the words "human persons". It is only in regard to their equality as human persons that you can make the same proposition. It is only as human persons that there is equality. In all the other ways, you have differentiations right through, but I have seen people try to argue from that statement that, not merely should people be treated as human beings, impartially, in courts of law, but there has been an attempt to strain that in a completely wrong direction and to suggest that, because you have that statement, all your laws must be of such a character that they will be universal; in other words, that you cannot distinguish between capacity or function or any of the things we distinguish between from day to day.
We are constantly making distinctions. We have to do it. If we are going to have anything like distributive justice at all, we need to do it. We cannot deal with these matters as if we were all on a dead level. We have definitely to take into account various sections and the way in which these Acts will impinge upon them and affect them. We are doing it constitutionally and are laying down that it shall not be held by the courts to debar the Legislature from doing what it obviously must do, that is, in its Acts, take full account of different functions, different capacities and so on.
Comment on this
It is metaphysics through the medium of Irish, because I confess that I cannot understand it. It is not capable of being understood.
Comment on this
I doubt it. I have at least that much respect for the Deputy's intelligence. He knows full well what I am talking about. I am showing that that first part of the proposition, to be accurate, has to be stated in the form in which it is stated, and secondly, that that proposition, proposed in the strict form in which it is stated, has to be clearly safeguarded from being applied in a sense in which it should not be applied. That is to say, this is my attempt to state these propositions in a form in which they are true, and not in a form in which they are false. There is no attack upon women, none whatever. The Deputy will tell us that you could possibly strain this and use it against women. You can use it against any section if you want to strain it. In fact, it is only an enabling power to see that Parliament is not debarred by the first part of the proposition from doing the things it has to do.
Again, there is equality. There is no discrimination against one sex in that particular matter. To go further, we have this Article about the home. Perhaps I had better read that, as it is here, until we see this terrible sin which I am supposed to have committed. Article 41, Section 2 (1), reads:
"In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved."
I should like to know who is the woman who is going to tell us that there is an attack on womankind in that?
"In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved."
Is that proposition true or false? Is it a thing that should be recognised by the State or not? It is a recognition of a fact that is universally recognised and unless the word "home" seems to hurt, I see nothing in that statement to which any woman could object.
Comment on this
It is in connection with the family. The Deputy will find it in Article 41. I shall read it again.
Comment on this
If Deputies think that they can fool women with this, they have less respect for them than I have.
Comment on this
"In particular, the State recognises that by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved." I know that there has been a cheap jibe thrown from time to time at women telling them that they should be in the home. Because that jibe has been hurled at women, am I to be prevented in a document such as this in giving a tribute where tribute is due?
Comment on this
It is in the Article dealing with the family, and clearly in the next sentence what it means is clucidated further: "The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home".
Comment on this
An excellent principle, a good, sound, solid principle. That is that mothers should not be forced by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home. Clearly it is necessary that the duties of the home which devolve mainly upon mothers, should be carried out. That is a tribute, in the first place, to the work which mothers do, and, secondly, it is a statement that the State shall endeavour by the means understood, the natural means, that it considers best to secure that purpose, and "best" includes justice as well, so if it is going to do it, it is implied in all this that the methods should be in accordance with justice. "The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home." That is one of the Articles which has been used by the Opposition and by those who have listened to them to say that this is an attack upon women. Deputy McGilligan thinks apparently that he can work upon the want of understanding or want of knowledge of the 99 per cent. that Deputy talks about, that these can be worked upon because they will not take the trouble to read the Constitution and that they will take the interpretation that he and Deputy Costello put upon it.
Comment on this
We shall deal with the various Articles as they come. I say this is one of the Articles which has been made the basis of the charge, that I have some particular idea in my mind to deprive women of their rights. I say there is nothing in that Article which anybody who reads it, who does not import into it something that is not normally there, and who does not try to interpret the word "home" by harping back to some cheap sneer by people whose attitude has not been my attitude, can justifiably challenge. I defy anybody here or elsewhere to give an example of a case where I have ever done anything either in public or private that would suggest that I wished to deprive women of their rights. I say it is a false statement; there is no truth in it, and anybody who says so here or outside is not telling the truth.
Comment on this
We shall deal with that Article in its proper place. We have another Article which has been made the basis of an attack upon this document, and as further indicating a personal attitude, if you please. We have Article 45 (4), dealing with the directive principles.
Comment on this
It has no effect at all, and yet although it has no effect at all, it is a mortal sin as far as I am concerned.
Comment on this
It is wonderful the way you can shift from one foot to the other. When the dictatorship scare started, the presidential office was going to be a dictatorship. When that is exposed they have to go somewhere else; then the head of the Government was going to be a dictatorship. Before long, the whole House is going to be a dictatorship. Before long the people as a whole are going to be a dictatorship. Indeed, Deputy Costello went very close to it—so it was reported to me anyhow. I have not got his exact words.
Comment on this
It was reported to me anyhow, from notes, that the Deputy seemed to talk about the tyranny of democracy.
Comment on this
What I talked about was that there was no greater tyranny than tyranny masquerading under the cloak of democracy.
Comment on this
That is a careful statement. Anybody can say that anything is masquerading. I could say, for instance, that the lawyers over there who have been talking about this were only masquerading as lawyers and were really politicians.
Comment on this
I said what was a real reproach from my heart to them, that I knew if they approached this from the technical and legal point of view, and confined themselves to that——
Comment on this
I said they could give us wonderful help, but I regret that I found their very words could convict them absolutely of putting the lawyer aside and appearing, for the purpose of this debate, not as the lawyer who was calmly either advising a client or judging a case. I should be very sorry if any of the lawyers who spoke here on this matter would talk on the bench as they have been talking on this Bill, because it would be a sorry day for us.
Comment on this
They have been trained as advocates—trained to support for the time being whatever case they want to try to push forward.
Comment on this
I have made no comparison with myself. I am making none whatever. If anybody honestly shows that there is in this something different from what I take to be in it, I hope I will be able to keep an open mind.
Comment on this
Let me finish this. I am going to finish this thing anyhow. Deputy Dillon, to start with, says it is of no account. The community as a whole when it adopts this Constitution will adopt certain social objectives, and will indicate certain lines along which their representative in Parliament will try to proceed in order to reach the goal. Now, it is clear that as it can only be defined as an objective, and as it can only be upon directive lines, you cannot let anybody except the Legislature itself interpret it, and therefore it is between the Legislature and the people. The people having said, "This is the goal," the legislators will be open at any time to being asked by the people, "How far are you proceeding in this direction? Are you going forward or backward?" It is in that context that we have this section:—
The State pledges itself to safeguard with especial care the economic interests of the weaker sections of the community, and, where necessary, to contribute to the support of the infirm, the widow, the orphan and the aged.
Surely Deputy Dillon will not carry his ideas so far as to deny that there are weaker sections in the community——
Comment on this
——who, notwithstanding any opportunities they may have been given, are still behind in this race of competition, a race which if left to itself, would mean the elimination of all but the specially fit. There are weaker sections in the community, and it is the duty of the community to protect them. I was talking about piecework in connection with labour a few moments ago; because of the fact that you could not allow to go unchecked this fierce competition between those who had special capabilities, and the average person, trade unions, and so on, had to come along to protect the weaker sections of the community. The weaker sections of the community ought to be the object of care of the community as a whole, and we say here that the State pledges itself to safeguard with especial care the weaker sections of the community.
Comment on this
We will come to that. We will have plenty of time for the next couple of weeks to talk those things out. There are weaker sections of the community. The women, or those who speak for them, seem to think they are so weak that, although they are a majority of the voting strength in the country, somehow or other they are going to be deprived of fundamental political rights. That and equality do not go very well together. There are, from the economic point of view, weaker sections whose interests need to be safeguarded and protected. We pledge ourselves here, the people as a whole, as a community, pledge themselves, and their representatives are bound to take especial care of those weaker sections—the widow, the orphan, the aged and the infirm. Some genius of a lawyer—or would-be lawyer or pseudo-lawyer, because I do not think that any real lawyer said this —tried to suggest that, because we speak of certain classes here, there is some rule of interpretation which tells us that we are not to look after other sections at all. There is some idea that, because we enumerate those, we cannot protect any other sections —that the others are excluded. That is absurd. The meaning there is quite clear and nobody can doubt it. Secondly, "the State shall endeavour to ensure that the inadequate strength of women and the tender age of children shall not be abused." Deputy Costello is smiling.
Comment on this
I am sure you did. You got great amusement when you halloed and you saw that the chase had started. Is not that the fun you got out of it?
Comment on this
"The inadequate strength of women." Well, there are women who compete with men and can swim the Channel, women who in long air tests show that they have the same physical strength as men, or at least a strength that is as good as that of men. I have not denied it. I have never denied that there are exceptional women who are as strong as the strongest men, but I do not think that any woman is going to suggest that her average strength for hard work— manual labour—is equal to that of the average man. I do not believe it is. I would be very sorry indeed to see a state of society in which women were forced to do the same sort of work as men. We know very well that there is nothing in this Constitution which suggests that women are to be excluded from any occupation, but there is in it a suggestion as to the general aim of our social policy, and the general aim of our social policy ought to be not to impose burdens beyond those which they can bear on any section of the community and not to force women, by economic necessity, into occupations which are not suitable to their sex. Similarly, not to impose on children or on others, by the necessity of living, tasks which they are not suited to bear. We have, for instance, to differentiate in the case of the army. I think there are laws passed by our predecessors which differentiate. For instance, I do not think that women can go into the army. Deputy Dillon will say, of course, that it is denying women equality of liberty.
Comment on this
Because you are talking about denying women equality of opportunity. When the Deputy spoke about equality of opportunity, I knew, of course, it did not exist. Is the Deputy going to suggest that in order to give equality of opportunity we should open the ranks of the army to women? I have often been asking myself why it is that some people have been spreading the idea that I was somehow or other opposed to or have reactionary views about women. I have not, as far as I know, and I challenge anybody to show it, in public or private.
Comment on this
Wait until the Cumann na mBán get on your trail. You will not let the ladies into the Army.
Comment on this
That may be the beginning of all my trouble. In 1916 it is true that some Cumann na mBán section offered to serve with us. I do not remember whether it was directly or through some officer. I said we have anxieties of a certain kind here and I do not want to add to them at the moment by getting untrained women, women who were clearly untrained for soldiering. I did not want them as soldiers in any case. I am not saying for a moment that they may not fight as well as men. That was not the question I had to decide, but I said I did not want them. I did appreciate their services but I did not want them to accept any such work at the time. I said we may have some people wounded, and I would be very glad indeed if we can get some women to take over the dispensary in Grand Canal Street. I think I also indicated that we would have to take some of the men out of the firing line for the purpose of cooking food and that sort of thing. Perhaps that is the origin of the suggestion that I wanted to put women in the kitchen. I think any sensible woman will admit, in these circumstances, that it was not disregard for women's rights that impelled me to act like that. That is the only thing I can remember that could give rise to the suggestion about women in the kitchen.
The only other case of this kind in which a suggestion could be made that I have not given women equal opportunities is in regard to women going up for election. In a constituency Parties do not put up anybody for election unless they hope the constituency will be won by that particular person. Nobody who has responsibility in the selection of candidates would put up a person who would not get support, whether it was a man or a woman. It is possible that I may have said in a case of that sort it would have been better to select candidate A, who happened to be a man, rather than candidate B, who happened to be a woman.
As far as I know, that is the sum total of all my offending in regard to having any reactionary ideas about women. My line of approach is not one of prejudice against women or women's rights. There is no truth whatever in it. It cannot be suggested that it is if I say that the average strength of women is not the same as the average strength of men. You could very legitimately say, for instance, that stoking a furnace on a trans-Atlantic liner is not a job that women, by economic necessity, should be forced to take.
Again I say there is not anything whatever that I know to sustain the charge that we are here depriving women of their rights. What is the Article?
Comment on this
It is now two dictators. We have the President and the head of the Government. The Article reads: "Every citizen who has reached the age of 21 years, and who is not placed under disability or incapacity by this Constitution or by law, shall be eligible for membership of Dáil Eireann." Who is disqualified by law! I suppose that is the point.
Comment on this
"Who is not placed under disability or incapacity by this Constitution or by law." The law might place women under incapacity.
Comment on this
I say that a law can be passed under Article 61 placing women under incapacity to vote.
Comment on this
That applies to other people as well as women. This in itself is not directed against women. Will the Deputy admit that?
Comment on this
The Deputy admits that there is no discrimination against women as women in this. Is not that fair? The Deputy is anxious to watch as the guardian of the women. He wants to see that there is no loophole by which Parliament could possibly interfere with women's rights.
Comment on this
I completely share the Deputy's view. I do not want this Constitution to deprive women of any rights which in justice and in nature they should have. Undoubtedly by this as it stands nobody who is not disqualified by law is interfered with. The Deputy will understand that in our electoral laws and other laws there are classes of people who are disqualified. There are people of unsound mind. It is a common form in these laws. It is in the old Constitution too.
Comment on this
You do not get this Article in the old Constitution. You left out the words "without distinction of sex." The Minister for Defence does not know as much as the chapelgate man knows about Article 14.
Comment on this
This is one of the cases where, with the beautiful phrases of the old Constitution ringing in my ears, or the draftsman's cars, we took the phrase "disqualified by law.""Disqualified by law" is used in the electoral Acts and in other Acts referring to three or four classes of people. You have got people of unsound mind. You have got people who are bankrupt. You have got people who are prisoners. There were four classes in one of those laws —those who were guilty of corrupt practices. The intention of this phrase as it stands here was to cover them. It is possible—I have an open mind on it—that you may strain that and say that the extraordinary thing could happen, and that half of the electorate was going to be disqualified. In this State we are rather peculiar. We have more men than women.
Comment on this
That is so, unfortunately. They are being attracted by higher money. It may be possible to stop it artificially, but we do not want to deprive people of a livelihood till we are certain that they have got a livelihood here. I do not want this to be strained at all beyond the intention for which it was put in here. That is the sort of thing that I should like to get from the lawyers on the opposite benches. That is the purpose of discussing this thing here in Committee. I assure them that if there is any single point in this where they can put forward an amendment which will enable this thing to be restricted to the intention and not to be capable of widening, I will be only too happy, as I am anxious that this should finally be as perfect an instrument as discussion in Committee can make it. That is honest. I will have this examined. I think what has been suggested is absurd. I think it is something that will be altogether unlikely in the nature of things to happen—that we should go back now and try to deprive women of their votes or anything of that sort; but if it is capable of that I will meet it. I will be only too willing to do it. It is the sort of thing I want to discover. I have asked every Government Department to sean this draft before the Committee Stage to see if, from their knowledge, there is anything in this that if left in would make it a less perfect instrument than we want it to be. When it has gone through, I hope it will be regarded as the work, not of an individual or even of the group of men who helped me in this, but that it will be the offering of this Irish Dáil to the people as the instrument of fundamental law in this State.
Comment on this
The State is defined in the first part. I have distinguished between the nation and the State. The provision regarding the nation refers to the whole Irish nation, and it claims that the Parliament and so on have a de jure right over the whole country, but that in fact it is not possible to exercise that right at the moment, and, therefore, that the State coming into existence—the Parliament and so on—will be one which can exercise jurisdiction only over the Twenty-Six Counties. Therefore Eire in practical application——
Comment on this
I should like to call attention to the fact that the motion must be put before 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows quite well what the point is. The State in common parlance, and even on the map, may be represented, people outside may represent it, as only referring to the present area, but, as far as we are concerned, the State has a de jure right and should refer to the whole of Ireland. In practice, we are not able to exercise our authority beyond the particular area; in other words, it is like “Saorstát Eireann.”
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I do not know how long the Opposition would like to have for consideration of amendments. I suppose they would be outraged if I suggested that we should take the Committee Stage on Tuesday week.
Comment on this
I should like to have it on Tuesday week. We will have a better opportunity then of looking over the points made to see if there is anything in them.