In Committee on Finance. - Pigs and Bacon Bill, 1937—Financial Resolution.
Contributions 1–164 of 336. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1937 ›
It is obvious that the discussion on the Financial (Ways and Means) Resolution would cover the same ground as the debate on the Pigs and Bacon Bill. To obviate duplication of debate it is customary in such circumstances to cover the Financial Resolution and the Second Stage of the Bill in one debate. The Minister might at the outset, if he so desires, explain the provisions of the measure without formally moving that the Bill be now read a Second Time. At the conclusion of the debate two questions would be put. May I take it that the House agrees to this procedure?
Comment on this
Yes, without prejudice to taking a different view in the different circumstances that may arise in regard to another Bill.
Comment on this
Quite. It is possible that in some instances a Financial Resolution might be so limited in scope as not to warrant the discussion of the provisions of the Bill on such resolution.
Comment on this
I move:
(1) That there shall be charged and levied levies on certain pigs and carcases of pigs purchased by licensees and registered minor curers during such periods as may be specified in that behalf by statute.
(2) That the said levies shall be paid to the Pigs Marketing Board by licensees and registered minor curers, and shall be applied by the said board in making payments to licensees and registered minor curers in respect of bacon produced by them.
(3) That the said levies shall be charged, levied and paid at such rates as may be fixed by statute, and that provision shall be made by statute for collecting and enforcing payment of the said levies.
(4) That in this resolution the expressions "licensees" and "registered minor curers" have the same respective meanings as in the Pigs and Bacon Act, 1935 ((No. 24 of 1935).
With regard to the charging of levies and so on on pigs and carcases, it is a renewal of the provisions of the 1935 Act. In moving the Second Reading I would like to say that the Bill is largely concerned with amendments of the 1935 Act. Under the 1935 Act (Part II), bringing Part II into operation was critical in this way that from that time, minor curers will have two years to continue as minor curers, after which period they will either elect to become licensed curers —and if their premises are then suitable, they would automatically become licensed curers—or, alternatively, they would go completely out of business. As the original Act has been almost two years in operation, and as Part II was only brought into operation on the 1st April, 1937, the two years' waiting period is being cut down to one year, and the minor curers will either become licensed curers on the 1st April, 1938, or go out of business.
Comment on this
Nineteen. The next matter in this Bill is the stamping of bacon. In the original Act, provisions were made for the stamping. It has been found from experience that stamping the bacon leaving the premises creates a certain amount of smudging and gives rather an unsightly appearance to the bacon. It is proposed now to go back to the original arrangement of stamping the carcases, which stamping is at least better than the post-cured stamping that was provided for in the original Act. It may be possible, as time goes on, to improve the method of stamping the carcases when we get some more experience in these matters. Part III of the Bill deals with the Bacon Marketing Board. There are provisions in this amending Bill which must come into operation after some preparation. Therefore we cannot immediately repeal the relevant sections of the original Act. It is provided here that the original Act will remain in operation in all cases until the amending Act comes into operation. Therefore provision is made for the appointed day. That appointed day will be made in consultation with the board.
The next question that arises is in the life of the boards. The only point that I want to raise here is the point of the representation of the producers on the Pigs Marketing Board. As far as the Bacon Marketing Board is concerned, I do not think it would make a great difference whether it was a two-year or a three-year term. But in the case of the Pigs Marketing Board a difficulty has arisen in this way: there is no pig producers' society or association. If there was a good society such as say, the Beet Growers' Association, which represents the beet-growers, we could straightaway have such an association to nominate the members of this board as representatives of the producers. But as there is no such association, it is provided in the original Act that the Minister for Agriculture would nominate three members to represent the producers on the Pigs Marketing Board. The term was given as three years.
I should say that I do not think it is advisable if a member is satisfactory as representing the producers, that he should be removed and replaced after one term of office. Then a difficulty arises. After six years, two terms of office, one does not like putting the whole lot off at the same time, so that means that some will have to be there for nine years. I think it is not advisable that any representatives of producers, more particularly as they are nominated by the Minister, should regard it as a life job, and for that reason I propose to shorten the terms of office to two years, so that it can be taken as a general practice that after two terms of office a change will be made in order that we may give another part of the country representation. I have been criticised by people in certain parts of the country for overlooking their claims to representation on the board, and the only way we can get over that is by making changes occasionally in the personnel.
The next matter that arises is with regard to a bacon production quota order. Up to the present the board made the bacon production quota order; that is, the total number of pigs that could be killed by all the factories in a period. Usually that period was a month, but I will refer to it now as a period. It did happen that in certain legal proceedings the factory which was being prosecuted could claim to have the whole certificate produced before the court, and it was not considered advisable by the board that the public should know the particulars contained in that certificate, that everybody should know what each factory was getting by way of a production sub-quota. It is now provided that a certificate will be issued to each curer each month, and that will be sufcient evidence in case there should be any court proceedings of any kind with regard to over-production or any matter of that sort.
It is also provided that the board may make a supplementary production quota order during the period. Up to the present, having once made an order for a period, there was no power under the Act to alter that, and I cannot say if we have had any instance in which it would have been very desirable to alter it. At any rate, we can all see that circumstances may arise which would prove that the board were wrong in their estimate of the number of pigs available, that they might have put the estimate too low or too high. They might find in practice that they could not get the number of pigs, or that there was a big surplus of pigs and they could not take them off the farmers' hands. In such circumstances they could make a supplementary order increasing or reducing the original order. It is provided that that can be done if half the period has passed.
The Bacon Board have in their orders to strike a figure of yield in the dead-weight pork. This cannot be a uniform figure. Some factories have a process of curing which might give a better yield than others and, therefore, a uniform figure is not very fair to every factory. Under the amending Bill it is proposed that the board might calculate what the average percentage for that particular factory is and might take that figure into their calculations in future so that there will be a given figure for each factory in future and that figure will be taken according to the method of curing pursued by each factory.
There is also provided an external sales quota. Up to the present, when the Bacon Board made an order stating what the production quota for the period would be, each factory got its percentage of that production quota, based on the figure of the corresponding month in 1935. In addition to the home sales which the factory was allotted in that way, it also had the amount which was allotted to the factory by my Department under the export quota to Great Britain. If any factory wished to build up a trade outside Great Britain, in America, France or other places, that factory could only do so by taking from its home sales and there was no great inducement, therefore, to a factory to build up a foreign trade if it had at the same time to reduce home sales and lose a market it had already established here. Under the amending Bill a factory in future will get its home sales quota, its quota for export to Great Britain and, in addition, any external sales it may be able to make. The factory must ask for an external sales quota and, if that is not filled, there are certain penalties attached. There will be, we hope, an inducement to factories to build up this foreign trade outside Great Britain.
The next point which arises has reference to compensation for certain minor curers and curers who did not qualify as minor curers, who ceased to produce bacon on 1st April, 1937. Perhaps it is no harm to remind the House of the different categories into which curers were placed under the original Act. When the original Act came in, every curer who had cured 2,200 cwt. of bacon in the previous year was entitled to get a licence and become a licensee. Every curer who was entitled to a licence under the original Act did apply and did get one. We had something like 30 licences as a result of the original Act. Those who cured less than 2,200 cwt. of bacon, but still cured fairly continuously, who cured bacon for eight months out of the preceding 12 months, qualified as minor curers. There were 19 who qualified in that manner. They are still minor curers and they may qualify, if they fulfil certain conditions, to become licensed curers on the 1st April, 1938. There were other curers left and, under the original Act, they were just put outside the Act and they had to go out of business. I refer now to any curer who did not cure 2,200 cwts. of bacon in the year previous to the original Act or any curer who did not cure for eight out of the 12 months during that year. Well, no provision was made for these people. In this amending Bill, provision is made to compensate all such people: first of all, to compensate those who did not qualify either as licensees or minor curers. They will be compensated on a certain basis about which I shall speak in a moment. Minor curers, if they wish, may also take compensation, because it was felt that a minor curer might not have the necessary capital to put his premises in the order that would be necessary to have a licence on the 1st April, 1938; and if a minor curer preferred to take compensation and go out, he would get compensation under this clause, or, alternatively, if he wishes he can apply for a licence, get his premises into the proper order, and become a licensee. There is nothing in this Bill or in the original Act to prevent him doing so, if he so desires.
The basis of compensation, as laid down in the Bill, may be somewhat confusing. It is laid down in this way: First of all, we take the average profits of all curers over a certain period, and we take that as the basis of compensation. Now, that being taken as the basis of compensation, a board is set up to fix the arbitration in case there is any disagreement between the Bacon Board and the curer who is going out. It does not mean, however—which appears to be the impression of some people who have read this Bill—that they are to get only two years' profits. It means that an arbitration board come in, they are told that the average profits of a bacon curer are so and so—7 per cent., 8 per cent., 10 per cent., or whatever it may be—and then I take it that the question this board will put to themselves will be this: If a firm is making 7 per cent. profit, what is it worth to buy it out?—is it worth ten times that, or 12 times that, or whatever it is?—and on that basis, then, the compensation is fixed. The compensation, of course, is paid by the Bacon Marketing Board.
Comment on this
The Deputy can make that point later on. Now, with regard to regulating a trade such as the bacon trade, it is estimated by some people— I have no idea of the exact figure, because we cannot get the returns— that those small people who are going out may have been dealing with somewhere between 40,000 and 50,000 pigs in the year. If all those people are bought out, those pigs, naturally, will come to the factories that remain, and it is quite natural to expect that, if those pigs come to the factories that remain, these remaining factories will be able to do their business at a somewhat lower cost per pig than they have been able to do their business up to the present.
Comment on this
There is one question that I should like to ask the Minister. Was it not the policy of the Government, before they came into office, to decentralise industry?
Comment on this
You have an application from a firm in Macroom who are prepared to put their own money into a bacon factory.
Comment on this
I would ask the Deputy not to interrupt me with a political speech. He can make that speech later on.
Comment on this
Well, the Deputy can make it later on. With regard to the basis of compensation, I should like to say that the period on which the production of these small factories will be taken in calculating the compensation will be the period during which excise levy was collected, so that there will be a perfect check on the business done by these small people during that period. I should say that, under the original Act, the Pigs Marketing Board were entitled to take over a factory, let it, work it, sell it, or do any of these things usually provided for in such legislation. Under this Act there is, if you like, a reciprocal arrangement: that is, that a licensee may, if he wishes, apply to the Bacon Marketing Board to be bought out, and if the board come to an agreement with him, the matter can be put through in that way.
Comment on this
Yes, any licensee, big or small. I can tell the Deputy that there is no danger.
Comment on this
Not the slightest. I foresaw immediately what the Deputy evidently sees now, but there is no danger.
Comment on this
Well, I was able to see a little farther than the Deputy—that is all.
Comment on this
The next point is that, up to the moment, the Pigs Marketing Board, in making their orders, had to fix a price for all classes of pigs, and that was very difficult in the case of certain classes of pigs, such as old sows, old boars, and so on. Under this Bill, they may exempt certain classes from the Act and leave them to fetch whatever price they may be worth.
Comment on this
Did anybody ever hear anything like that? Well, I hope Deputy Smith, the Deputy from Monaghan, will intervene on this Bill, because it is the grandest thing that ever happened——
Comment on this
The Deputy has Monaghan on the brain, and he will get Monaghan on more than the brain before long.
Comment on this
The next point is the purchasing of pigs. If a producer notifies the chairman of the board that he cannot have his pigs delivered to a factory and that he wishes to have them delivered direct to a factory, the chairman may notify the factory to take these pigs direct and pay the fixed price. I think that every Deputy knows what is the reason for the insertion of that section. The reason is that certain factories, at any rate—not all, as far as I know, but certain factories—were accused of being in collusion with dealers who were buying pigs around the country below the fixed price, and the accusation was made that the proper price appeared in the factories' books. There appeared to have been collusion in these cases between the dealer and the the factory and the accusation was made that, in fact, the factory was not giving the fixed price for pigs. Many suggestions that were made for dealing with that very difficult problem were considered and, in the end, I thought that this was, at least, the most practicable of any of the suggestions that were made for dealing with that evil. Undoubtedly, it is a method that cannot be applied to all factories at the same time. It would take a huge organisation, under the chairman, to do it; but at least it can be applied to certain factories and at certain times where there are complaints that such a practice is taking place, and I think it is the best way to deal with that problem.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain to me how a farmer in Carndonagh can ship one pig from there to Ballybofey?
Comment on this
I do not say that he can go whistle but the Deputy is leaving him to go whistle now.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows all about Donegal and Deputy Blaney knows nothing about it!
Comment on this
In all seriousness does that mean that if a producer feels he is going to be exploited by dealers he can apply to have his pigs taken direct?
Comment on this
Yes. It is well that the Deputy prefaced his remarks by the phrase "in all seriousness," because frivolous interruptions do not serve any purpose when there is a serious problem to be dealt with. A farmer may have pigs to sell and the factory may say to him that they have more pigs than they can deal with. At the same time the farmer knows that the factory is taking pigs from dealers and that dealers are coming out to him saying that they will take his pigs. He can then apply to the board to direct the factory to take them at the fixed price.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of raising these points afterwards. These are the main questions which have to be explained. There are other points which can be dealt with on the Committee Stage as they arise.
Comment on this
It will be interesting to see how Deputy Smith of Cavan and Deputy Rice of Monaghan vote on this Bill. This Bill has been drafted by curers. It is designed for curers and it has been imposed on the Minister by the curers. In this matter, the curers of this country are dominated by a big international concern and I undertake to prove to the House, at this moment, that the machinery of this Bill is going to be used by Henry Denny and Sons, a big international concern, to get complete control of bacon production in this country. The object is to strangle every pig producer in this country, to exploit the producer of bacon in this country.
Comment on this
I shall prove that and we shall see whether Deputies opposite are prepared to go into the Lobby to support a procedure to implement which that Bill has been drafted by the curers and presented to that innocent man, the Minister, to come in here and flounder through with it.
Comment on this
I have not the slightest intention of floundering but I shall make some of the curers in this country flounder before I am finished with them. Let us examine one of the brilliant suggestions that the Minister for Agriculture has adopted as his solution of the problem which he admits exists. He says that he is now satisfied that the curers have fraudulently acted in collusion with dummy dealers— not genuine pig dealers, and I ask the House to draw a special distinction between genuine pig dealers and the dummies employed by the factories to which the Minister refers. The Minister admits to this House that he is satisfied that certain bacon curers——
Comment on this
He said that he is asking the House to enact legislation to deal with an evil. Now, he would not ask the House to deal with an evil if the evil did not exist and the evil is that fraudulent bacon curers sent out fraudulent representatives into the fairs and instructed these representatives to blackmail people who have a couple of pigs at the fair into giving them the pigs at a cheap price. Having got the pigs at a cheap price, they brought them into the factory and fraudulently put them through their books as if they paid a fixed price for them. He admits that the evil exists and he throws up his hands in despair and says "I cannot stop it: I must introduce new legislation." His remedy for that is that he is going to say if a man has a number of pigs for sale and feels that he is being blackmailed in that way, he can write to the pigs board and say "I have pigs for sale and I cannot get the fixed price for them; name a factory to which I will sell." He can say moryah, "I want to send them to a certain factory" and then the Pigs Board will issue an order to that factory to purchase the pigs. In certain circumstances, it might be that they would name another factory if the first factory had exhausted its production quota.
Comment on this
That is when the first factory had exhausted its production quota. Some factory had to be named and you could not order any factory to break the law by exceeding its quota. Let us assume that a pig producer in the Carndonagh district—and I ask Deputy Blayney to consider this—has a pair of pigs, that he wants to sell them and that the dealer offers half the value of the pigs in Cardonagh fair. That man goes home to his house, writes to the Minister and says: "I want to dispose of these pigs" and the Minister says: "Bring them to Ballybofey" How in the name of Heaven is a man from the Malin district to get his pigs from Malin to Ballybofey? How can he do it?
Comment on this
I am prepared to teach you your business as I am always prepared the moment your mind is open, but I have first got to prise the Minister's mind open. There is a solution for this problem. Of course Deputies on the other benches who know nothing about the problem jeer and laugh. It is a problem that applies almost exclusively to West Cork and Donegal.
Comment on this
Monaghan does not present the same difficulties. What is required in Monaghan, and what I understand the Pigs Marketing Board are engaged in providing, is a bacon factory.
Comment on this
Deputy Haslett can intervene and make any suggestion that he wants at the proper time.
Comment on this
So far as Donegal is concerned, it can be solved comparatively easy. It can be solved with the assistance of a body of men, whom the Minister is at present conspiring with the curers to wipe out of existence. There is only one solution for the problem in Donegal which will effectively protect the rights of bacon producers and that is to establish live pig markets in various centres in Donegal, get into communication with the Pig Dealers' Association, arrange with them to have pig dealers in these centres on fair days, facilitate the export of pigs alive or to have them taken by the factories at the fixed price.
Comment on this
I have reason to believe that you did not try it effectively. Did you seek the co-operation of the pig dealers in the matter?
Comment on this
Who is going to run this business? There is a Pigs Marketing Board and a Bacon Marketing Board and this is designed to give these boards certain rights to do certain acts. If you provide live pig markets in Donegal to facilitate competition people will get the value of their pigs. If you do not provide competition, nothing you can do will protect the people from exploitation by unscrupulous curers. There is nothing you can do, because you may give the producers all sorts of statutory rights and liberties but owing to their peculiar circumstances they are not able to avail of them. Nobody who knows anything of the country suggests that a man with a pair of pigs can economically transfer that pair of pigs over 40 or 50 miles to the nearest factory. Unless you can get a lorry of pigs or a wagon of pigs it is hopelessly uneconomic to attempt to transfer them over long distances. It is all very well for the Minister to talk about people getting together. The facilities for getting together are not available. My pigs may be ready for the April fair. My next door neighbour's pigs may not be ready until the May fair. If I keep my pigs until May they will be too heavy, and will go into grade C. If my neighbour sells his pigs when mine are ready they will be too light, and will not be graded at all. The very essence of a country fair is that pigs are segregated into various classes. One man will be buying fat heavy pigs; another man will be buying porkers; another man will be buying light pigs. All the pigs of the countryside are automatically segregated, competition operates, and the people get the very highest price. If there is any attempt made at a ring, the people can bring their pigs home and take them to some other fair in another direction a week or ten days later. That is the only remedy. Let us not dwell unduly on that aspect of the situation, because it is of comparatively minor importance. This Bill is a Bill which has been provided by the curers and imposed upon the Minister, because the Minister had delivered himself over to the curers. He has swallowed their line of attack, hook, line and sinker, and he is now completely in their hands.
Comment on this
Just stop that talk and let us hear what it is all about.
Comment on this
There are two proposals in this Bill—one proposal designed to limit the minor curer, and another enabling the Pigs Marketing Board to buy out any existing licensed curer. There are 19 minor curers in this country, and there are supposed to be 30 licensees. At first glance people would say that there are 30 independent firms curing bacon. Nothing could be further from the truth. Those licensees are interlocked by all sorts of business and ordinary relationships. Three of those firms, at least, all belong to one family. Henry Denny and Son control the business premises in Waterford. They control the business premises in Sligo. Is not that so? I do not know how many others they control. When it is said that there are 30 licensees, in fact what the Minister means is that there are 30 licensed premises, but many of them are owned by the same person or the same corporation. A great many Deputies in this House think that Henry Denny and Son is an Irish firm. It is not. It is a big international combine, the bulk of whose business is done in Denmark, and the amount of business it does in this country is only a drop in the bucket.
What is the history of this plan to wipe out the minor curer? What happened was this. This Bill originally got its first justification in the British quota. The moment the British put a quota on imports of bacon from this country, it became necessary to set up some machinery here to allocate that quota amongst the curers in this country—the curers and the pig producers.
What happened? The first thing that happened was that a kind of general appeal—tariff reform and economic self-sufficiency—was made to the Minister to do away with so much of our quota as permitted the export of live pigs, and to absorb practically all the quota in exports of bacon because it was necessary to promote Irish manufacture. The result of that was that the Irish producer was forced into the position of producing nothing but the exact type of pig that the Irish curer was prepared to use. Now, many of us who come from pig-producing counties know that in certain counties the farmers find it more economic to produce a big heavy pig. The nature of the food they had, and the type of farming they carried on, fitted in better with the production of a big heavy pig than with the production of the comparatively slow-growing, long, lean Irish white. There was a splendid market in Birmingham and the midlands of England for those big, fat, heavy pigs, which were known in the trade as cutters. There was no use for the Irish factories at all so long as we could ship live pigs. When the pig dealers came into the fair there would be a dealer there for the cutters; there would be a dealer for the bacon pig; there would be a dealer for the store pig; and if you brought your pigs to the market, no matter what category they fell into, you were sure to find a group of men in the fair anxious to bid for them. The first result then of the quota business was that the trade for cutters was completely wiped out, because the pig dealers were practically prohibited from exporting any live pigs at all, and they could not sell a cutter in this country.
The next performance was that the whole system of Bacon Marketing Boards and Pigs Marketing Boards was established under the Pigs and Bacon Act, and it was proposed that everybody should be represented on those boards. The first sign, I say, of the resolution of the curers to use the machinery of the Pigs and Bacon Act for the purpose of exploiting trade in this matter was that they strongly opposed the admission of any representation for the pig dealers. Anyone who knows the pig trade in this country knows that the pig dealers are an exceptionally decent body of men. They have been an exceptionally useful body of men at all times. They know the English trade in and out, and they were always ready to snatch any advantage that was going on the English market for the benefit of the pig producers of this country. They were absolutely excluded from the two boards which controlled their entire livelihood. Mind you, that was the body of men who knew more about the pig trade than any other person in this country, including all the officials of the Department of Agriculture. They had been in the pig trade; their fathers had been in the pig trade; they had known it for generations. But they were completely denied all representation. They had no right to make their voices heard on either board.
The next performance was that the joint refusal of the curers to allow any pig dealer to be on either board, and the pressure on the Minister, virtually wiped out the exports of pigs— operated practically to abolish the pig dealer at the fairs, that is, the pig dealer as we knew him; the man who went in and bought a wagon or a couple of wagons of pigs and sent them to England and sold them there. What happened? You began to find that at the fairs there was nobody but a few agents of the factories, and if you did not sell your pigs to them you did not sell them at all, because the ordinary pig dealer would not get an export quota to ship the pigs if he bought them. That meant that the fairs began to dwindle.
In the old days you went to the fair and if the price offered by one man did not please you you waited for another man to come up and bid. Now there are only about half a dozen men in the fair, all in the employment—directly or indirectly—of the curer, and if you refused the bid of the first man the other five would not come near you and you were left standing up. What happened then? We discovered that the minor curers—with whom we ordinarily never dealt before—were very handy. If you could not get a pig jobber to buy your pigs it was much handier to bring your pigs to the nearest place, get them slaughtered and weighed and get paid the fixed price. So we started going to the minor curers; whereupon the pig curers called a council amongst themselves and said: "We have smashed the pig jobber and put him out of operation, believing that that would bring all the pigs into our factories. Instead of doing that, our destruction of the pig dealers has resulted in driving the pigs, not into our factories, but into the minor curers' factories, and if we are not very careful we are going to have 19 more competitors in the field.
"We have spent the last five years or thereabouts trying to get a stranglehold on the 30 licensed factories that exist in the country. We have built up an elaborate interlocking network of vested interests which virtually control all the bacon factories in the interest of two or three powerful combinations. Now, we are going to have 19 new factories built up because by our destruction of the live pig trade we have been driving the pigs into these small factories." What do these curers do? They come in and tell the Minister that, for the sake of efficiency, it would be highly desirable, having slaughtered the pig dealers, to wipe out the minor curers. They have the effrontery to demand that that foolish man will get up in this House and ask this House to wipe out the minor curers with the producers' money in order to provide a monopoly for the big curers' ring.
Comment on this
What is the change in this Bill regarding minor curers.
Comment on this
Mind you, I think the poor man is honest. He is really like Little Red Riding Hood. He is tripping over to see grandma and, when she gets him, she will rise up and eat him——
Comment on this
Stop this claptrap and tell me what is the difference.
Comment on this
You will not tell me straight what difference there is.
Comment on this
There is a provision in this Bill that the minor curer who elects to go out of business may have his compensation assessed by an arbitrator and will be paid out of the Bacon Marketing Fund.
Comment on this
Most emphatically. I say that if Henry Denny & Son want to buy out competition let them put their hands down in their own pocket and buy out the minor curers. There is no reason why they should put their hand into my pocket in order to buy out the minor curer. That is what this Bill proposes to allow them to do.
What the deuce do Henry Denny & Son care how much money is spent by the Bacon Marketing Board in buying out the minor curers so long as they get them out of the way? Henry Denny & Son levy so much on each pig brought into the bacon factory. They do that for the Bacon Marketing Board. That is likewise done by O'Mara, Slattery and the other curers. Out of these funds, Henry Denny & Son are going to pay the minor curer his compensation. Then, what is going to happen. The ring which controls the Bacon Marketing Board will go to one of these minor curers and say, "We think you ought to go out of business. We think you are curing an awkward number of pigs and we know we can cure them better and more cheaply than you can. What about it?" Some independent-minded minor curer will throw a cleaver at that gentleman and put him out. What will happen? That minor curer depends for his supply of pigs on a certain locality. The ring will put 20 buyers into that locality for the following 12 months and, whatever that minor curer bids for pigs, they will bid 2/- more.
Comment on this
You certainly ought to drop it and safeguard the position of the minor curer by giving him the quota he is entitled to get instead of handing his quota over to the major curer. Will you guarantee to the minor curers the quota they are entitled to get and drop the compensation? I answered the Minister's question. Let him answer mine. Will he guarantee to these minor curers the quota they are entitled to get for all time?
Comment on this
No amendment is necessary to guarantee to these people a permanent production quota?
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know what he is talking about. I must guarantee under the Bill that they will get licences.
Comment on this
I am not talking about licences. I am asking the Minister will he now guarantee to the minor curers a quota which will provide for the continuance of the trade they are doing?
Comment on this
That is the trouble. The Minister has been cornered by the curers. I am anxious to assure him of the undivided support of this side of the House in any steps he may deem it necessary to take to defend the interests of the pig producers against this unscrupulous ring, but I implore him to open his eyes to the fact that he is being made the tool of this ring. I am asking him to fight them. If he will fight them, he will get all the support he wants in the interests of the producers. At present, he is being tricked into placing not only the producer but, ultimately, the consumer in the hands of this ring. When he has done that, there will be no way of delivering the people from the clutches of this ring save by nationalisation. What I want to do is to prevent that happening and to keep the machinery of production and curing in operation. The whole object of these people is to abolish it and to establish a cut-throat monopoly.
If this policy is pursued, all the minor curers will go. They will be compensated out of the Bacon Marketing Board funds. When the minor curers have all gone, you will have the curing of bacon in this country in the hands of about 20 firms who will have control of about 30 licences. The curing establishment of one of these firms, Henry Denny & Son, does about 50 per cent. of the entire business. Another of these firms does about 10 per cent. and the remaining 40 per cent. is divided amongst the others. In my judgment, Henry Denny & Son are in a position practically to dictate terms to any other firm in the country. That is due to their immense resources not only within this country but outside the country. Having eliminated the minor curer, they will proceed to the final destruction of the pig dealer. You will find that the next proposal will be that all export of pigs will be reserved for the curers, that curers will be the only persons authorised to buy pigs in this country and that they must be given the entire quota for both bacon exports and pig exports. If that happens, you will destroy every pig fair in every small town in Ireland. If you destroy the pig fairs, the first result will be that you will destroy the small towns. The second result will be that the pig producers of this country will be reduced to the same position as that to which the meat producers of the Western States of America were reduced when the meat packers of America succeeded in establishing a monopoly in the stock-yards. You will bring your pig to the factory and you will be completely in the factory's hands as to the price they will give you. There are Deputies here who say: "But is the price not fixed, and is the grade not fixed and everything else?" That is perfectly true, but I put this to Deputies: Suppose you have a ten-acre man, a small, simple man, who has a couple of pigs which mean a lot to him; he knows nothing about grading, about veterinary inspection or about the complicated method of weighing and preparing for the scale and so on, and he will probably not be let into the factory. He does not know his statutory rights, and that man will in fact get what the factory chooses to give him. It is true that if you have a wise man who is a bit of a crank and who knows his rights, he will get his due because he will insist on his statutory rights and insist on watching the weighing, the grading and everything else; but the vast majority, after they deliver their pigs into the hands of people like the curers, will be dealt with in whatever way the curers choose to deal with them.
The only guarantee the small man has is that if he brings out a good pair of pigs that attract the attention of every potential buyer, he knows that if two or three buyers come to him after he gets into the fair and bid him for his pigs, he has something everybody wants. He knows that he ought to be stiff and stand his ground, and that the first bid he got at five o'clock in the morning, as soon as the sun came up, was too low and that if he stands his ground he can get 10/- to 15/- more. That is the way he gets the value of his pig and it is a most effective and efficient machine for ensuring that the small producer gets the true value of what he has to offer. Deprive him of that open competition in the fairs and markets and you deliver him into the hands of what, in my judgment, is the most unscrupulous vested interest in this country. Mind you, it is a vested interest which no amount of inspection and no amount of legislation will control, and if you give them the powers proposed to be conferred on them in this Bill, so surely as we are in this Dáil, it will become vitally necessary to nationalise this industry within five years.
Mind you, the dangers I have already outlined are not themselves the end of the story, because if you create conditions in the pig producing industry which result in the people being unable to get an economic price for their pigs, what will happen? We have in this country quite a different type of mentality from that obtaining in Great Britain or America. In Great Britain or America it would create a revolution—the farmers would rise up and storm the factories —but here that will not happen. What will happen here is that the people will get out of producing pigs. Observe the danger there. The people will drop producing pigs—they will slaughter the sows and simply give it up. We have a quota on the British market and it is putting us to the pin of our collar to fill it. If we slaughter any considerable quantity of pigs and get out of the business, we will be unable to fill that quota and if we fail to fill it this year, our quota for next year will be reduced and the balance will be handed over to Denmark. Once Denmark gets it she will not surrender it. If we fall below the quantity of pigs and bacon which the British are prepared to take from us in any calendar year, they will only allot us a reduced quota in the years thereafter, so that the danger is immense. This infernal ring does not care a hoot because the most powerful vested interest in it is Henry Denny & Son, and if the quota is taken from Ireland and given to Denmark, they will have it still because they are curing more bacon in Denmark than they are curing in Ireland.
I am thinking of the small man. There are in West Cork good friends of mine who are killing a thousand or two thousand pigs. Those men are able business men and pretty well capable of looking after themselves. They are not half as vulnerable as the small man. The big man, killing 100, 500 or 1,000 pigs, can hop in and out of the market, according as conditions demand. Sometimes he will go into bonhams when it pays; sometimes you find him buying strong stores and turning them over very quickly when it pays, but the small man who keeps a sow and sells all the bonhams except two, and fattens them, has to keep them until they are ready for market, no matter what way the market goes. The small man who buys a pair, or two pair, of bonhams has to keep them, no matter what way the market goes, until they are fat, and these are the people who will be absolutely massacred by the proposals contained in this Bill. Observe that in this measure it is proposed that any licensee can be bought out by the Board. The Minister says there is not the slightest danger of that ever happening.
Comment on this
I said that I foresee the danger the Deputy sees, but that I can see a bit further.
Comment on this
Why is it that at this moment Henry Denny is trying to buy factories in the country? He is buying all the Minister's own licences. Is the Minister aware of that? He has already bought at least one licence, to my knowledge, in Mayo.
Comment on this
Not with the Minister's consent, so the Deputy is wrong.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is perfectly right. I entirely agree with him. Does he realise that this provision authorising the Bacon Marketing Board to buy out licences which he has, by policy, created, is going to have exactly the same effect? Does he not know that Henry Denny and Company control that board? The board consists of curers, and does the Minister not know that on that board the presiding genius is the representative of Henry Denny & Son?
Comment on this
I do not think it is fair to talk about a particular firm like that.
Comment on this
I thoroughly agree with the Minister. I turned this over in my mind for a long time, but, really, when vested interests become sufficiently arrogant and menacing, the time has come to square off and state them. I have to state them. These vested interests have gone so far as to threaten me. They calmly announce that they are going to impose penalties on me because I am too awkward. I do not say that Henry Denny & Son have done it, but certain vested interests connected with the bacon-curing industry have done it. I want to make that clear. I do not allege that Henry Denny & Son have done so, but I do say that interests connected with the bacon-curing industry have done it, and when that stage arrives public men have either to come out and point out the villain of the piece in an enterprise of this kind or get nowhere. So far as I am concerned, I have not the least intention of being blackmailed into silence by the bacon curers, or any other vested interest in this country. It is, however, as well for Deputies to realise that circumstances are such that I can afford to defy the blackmail. There are other people in the country who would find it a great strain on their financial resources to resist the kind of blackmail that is being brought to bear on them, and it is by fortuitous circumstances that I am in a position to resist it.
The Minister very rightly says that it ought not to be the practice to name firms. What can we do? There are four or five firms concerned and they own the Bacon Marketing Board. They are the only people on it and I say that this very thing, which the Minister sees going on and which he himself disapproves of, because he does not want consolidation of the licences, is being facilitated by the provision he himself has put into his own Bill. If it is true that one firm dominates this——
Comment on this
It is rather late. It is necessary to tell the House that one firm controls 50 per cent. of the production in this country, making it dominant. It is almost hypocrisy to bandy the name of the firm in that way, and then tack another name on it. At least, if Messrs. Denny want to complain, they have now got grounds for complaining, as I named them. I suppose I could have avoided that by naming the firm which does 50 per cent. of the business. They are the dominant element on the board. They are in a position to secure the adherence and support of the minor elements on the board; and you are going to give them, by law, the power to buy one another out. They are to buy one another out with my money. Was any such proposal ever put before a Parliament in any country? I forget how many members there are on the Bacon Marketing Board. Perhaps the Minister will tell me how many bacon curers are on the board.
Comment on this
Those seven curers may, in fact, control three-fourths of the licences in the country. Then they can do one of two things. They can say: "Let us amalgamate and get together; I will buy all your licences out of the levies made on the pigs." It is a very nice proposition. Why should they not? It is heads you win, tails you lose. They can do it.
Comment on this
There is power, I believe, to license new concerns. Is the Minister going to use it?
Comment on this
I thought of it. God help these men, they are as innocent as children. Let me put this case. What use is the provision to issue new licences to a body of men to sell bacon, if Henry Denny is already in occupation of the business in Sligo? What good is the new licence? I say you can remedy this whole thing by nationalising the industry and taking over the whole thing. That is what is going to happen. That is what I have just said —that if you let this happen, five years from to-day your only remedy will be to take over the whole thing and nationalise it. It is no remedy to imagine that by issuing new licences, making confusion worse confounded, you are going to remedy the mess you have created. What will happen is that, if you are going on with this, it will create so stinking a scandal that you will have to take that board over and make it a Government concern. If you are out to socialise the bacon industry, come out and do so. Then we will know where we are. I am opposed to that policy. I think it is going to operate in the worst interests of the producers, the worst interests of the consumers, and in the worst interests of the country as a whole.
I say the proper method is to allow competition to obtain, to secure for our people adequate markets, to take care of any pigs or bacon produced, and then to allow competition to operate so as to raise the price to the highest economic level possible for the pig producer, and to lower the price to the lowest reasonable economic level for the consumer. I do not mean that you ought to give bacon to the consumer for 10d. per lb. and pay the producer 90/- per cwt. for pigs. It cannot be done. I want the producer to get a fair price, considering the price of foodstuffs and his overhead charges. I am prepared to support the Minister in going to the country and telling the consumer that he will have to pay a fair price for bacon based on the price paid to the producer for pigs. I am not prepared to go to the country and tell the consumer that he must pay an inflated price for bacon in order to sell cheap bacon to the British consumer, which we are at present doing. Remember, the way the machinery of this Board has been misused in the past is a warning of what is going to be done in the future. Does the House realise that the hypothetical price fund has been used, and is being used, for the purpose of subsidising exports to Great Britain?
Comment on this
Deputy Smith was on this committee. Does he realise that the hypothetical price fund was to be used for the purpose of subsidising exports to Great Britain and relieving the Exchequer of subsidies which would otherwise have to be paid?
Comment on this
I was hoping that you would try to prove what you told us you set out to prove, but you have not. I am open to be convinced, but you have not offered the slightest inkling of it.
Comment on this
It is not easy to convince everybody. I am not quite sure that the Deputy is prepared to be convinced. Suppose the Deputy believes I am right, I do not think he will go into the Lobby with me. I think what he will do is vote reluctantly with the Minister and then go and implore the Minister to do something on the Committee Stage to mend his hand. That is the simple truth and the Deputy knows it. Nothing I can say will induce him to vote according to his conscience, if I convert him. What he will do is, he will vote with the Minister and then try to prevail on the Minister in the interval. As surely as we are in this House, three things are going to happen if this Bill passes. You are going to destroy the pig dealers, who are the only body who can effectively help the Minister out of some of the difficulties that have arisen in connection with the pig trade. You are going to destroy the fairs and markets and deliver the producer of pigs into the hands of the bacon curers. You will create a situation of such a kind that, within five years from to-day there will either be a revolution amongst the pig producers, or there will be no pigs produced at all, because people will go out of the production of pigs. I warn you that, if in existing circumstances, you drive the people out of pig production, you can never get them back into it; because you lose the British market, which will be handed away to the other countries who are willing and anxious to ship bacon to Great Britain. Once they have that market they will not surrender it, and we will not be able to get it back.
No useful purpose is going to be served by this Bill. The Minister has not said a single word which could possibly justify such a measure. Its sole active principle is that the big curers are going to be permitted to buy out the small curers with my money and your money, with the money of every man who produces a pig in this country. No such audacious or unscrupulous proposal was ever made in this country before. I believe the Minister has been misled into recommending such proposals. I believe the Minister has put his confidence in the Bacon Marketing Board and the Pigs Marketing Board and that he is being betrayed. I challenge him now to produce to the House a record of the profits made by the bacon curers for the last three years, and to compare that with any other three years in their history. I ask him to compare the profits made by the bacon factories in the last three years with the profits made by these same factories at the height of the European War. I ask him has he seen the balance sheet of the bacon companies?
Comment on this
Have you, before you came into this House to present this Bill to us, taken the precaution of finding out how the powers you conferred upon this board have been used during the last two or three years? Have you seen the profits made by the bacon curers, while you knew that the pig producers could not make both ends meet? While you knew that the consumers were paying a far higher price for bacon here than they were asked to pay in Great Britain; while you knew that no man rearing pigs could do it economically, have you inquired what profits the bacon curers were making? Surely the Minister ought to do that before he comes and asks us to give them wider and greater powers than they had before. This is a rotten Bill. It is a Bill for which no person who holds himself out as a representative of the people should vote. It is delivering the pig producers of this country into the hands of the most unscrupulous ring in this country. I most strongly urge the Minister to withdraw this Bill, to reconsider it and to examine the records of the companies into whose hands it is proposed to commit the pig producers of this State. I ask him to see if better and more effective steps cannot be taken to provide for whatever difficulty he may have in mind.
Comment on this
I think this Bill provides a very good opportunity for Deputies to give account as to how the Bill passed here a couple of years ago is operating in the country. This Bill, like all Bills that are Bills by reference, is an extremely difficult Bill to speak on or to understand. I thought that possibly 40 years' experience in the production of pigs would warrant one to claim that he knew something about the business. But I am doubtful now, after hearing the speeches of the Minister and other Deputies in this House, whether there really is sympathy here for the pig producers. One thing has to be borne in mind and that is that there are very different circumstances in the way of pig production and pig marketing in the different parts of the country. Deputy Dillon has made a very strong appeal for a class of men in his district—the pig dealers. I am not saying that possibly Deputy Dillon is not right in that, because that is a class of people that he comes up against. But, frankly, I have no case to make for these men because they do not exist in my part of the country. There is no such thing there as the people that Deputy Dillon has told us about, the pig dealers.
Comment on this
I am telling the House about things as they are in my district. I would be very glad if we could do anything to improve the business of pig producing and pig marketing. Deputy Dillon has made a very strong case for the type of market about which he told us. We never had such a market in our part of the country. I am aware that a very determined effort was made some years ago in Ballybay and other towns in Monaghan to establish a pig market but the effort failed. Our problem in Monaghan does not seem to be the same problem as obtains in other districts. For instance, there is the problem of handling the pig. At the moment and for the last year that has not been a problem because our factories cannot get enough pigs. At the time when the original Bill was introduced we had a glut of pigs in our district. In the following year we had some glut too, but since then the production of pork pigs has so fallen off that that problem has disappeared and we are now very strongly faced with another problem.
This Bill sets out to compensate the minor curers. That, of course, means putting them out of business. That is a class of legislation of which we have had a good deal in the last few years. I think public representatives should be very careful before they pursue that line to any great extent. Enterprise in this country ought to be encouraged, and the policy of the Government is, I think, in many ways along the line of helping enterprise. But, unconsciously, by Bills such as this, we may curb enterprise. Take the minor curers mentioned in this Bill; take the case of the minor curers who have failed to cure the specified number of pigs in eight months or to fill their quotas. I suggest to the Minister that this is not the time to determine that question. If that provision is persisted in, a grievous wrong will be done and some of the minor curers, through no fault of their own, will be made suffer. The minor curers, through no fault of their own, were unable to get the pigs. If we are to apply this test in the zero time we would be doing a grave injustice to a number of decent men who have done their best and we will confer no compensating benefit on any other interest in the country.
As representative for Monaghan I would like just to put our peculiar position before the Minister and before this House. I am not saying that my view point is infallible but I am trying to put before the House things as I see them. We attempted in the original Bill to revolutionise the whole system of breeding pigs, feeding pigs, marketing pigs and to deal with the price of pigs. We have tried to do all these things. On top of that the price of feeding stuff has so soared that our people in Monaghan have practically gone out of pig production. The remedy that some of us suggested in some respects would have been more gradual, and if our views were allowed to prevail, that would possibly have encouraged our producers to hold on more tenaciously to pig production, even though they found that at a particular moment it was not a paying proposition. Our experience is that when we go into any town in any part of our area we are besieged every time by the consumers who say to us "Look at what we have to pay for bacon; you people who are feeding pigs are making fortunes, look at what we are paying." I am not to be taken as saying this in any ulterior way. I have been with the Minister on this matter. I was glad to act on a committee with him in order to get some stabilisation of prices. I know that the average consumer is asking why should there be such a difference between what the producer is getting and what the consumer is paying. Possibly, an answer could be given to that but up to the present there has been none.
In former years a good many of our people fed their pigs on potatoes, but they have found this year that there has been such a good trade for potatoes it would not pay to boil them to produce bacon. Then you turn to the new mixture, and the cost of that is so prohibitive that it does not pay to feed it for pig production. Then the people feel when they have corn of their own that it is better to take what they can get for their cereals and let the pig trade go for the present. What happens then is that the "suckers," as we call them, are brought into the market and sold off, and so they are not being brought on for the production of bacon. I am stressing that side of the business. I put it to the Minister with all the earnestness I can command that it is very unfair now to judge minor curers on their production during an abnormal period.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy understands the Bill. They are not to be judged now. It is on the 1935 production.
Comment on this
Yes, but everything depends on production in 1935.
Comment on this
In the district of Clones there is a minor curer, and the people there feel the pressure of the times very much. Clones was, up to comparatively recent years, a great railway centre, but it is now a pocket of the Free State jutting into Northern Ireland. In that way the business of a great many of the people is cut off, and they are complaining that we are neglecting them there, that we are not giving them any factories, and that the minor curer who is there, because he cannot get enough to fill his quota, is in danger of going out of business. How far the people are justified in making that complaint I am not in a position to say; I simply leave that to the Minister. That point that the Minister mentioned was one that seemed to me always to be a vulnerable one in the original Act. That is, that agents of curers may be sent out and that there might be collusion between them. There is the problem in outlying districts that if production exceeds the normal demand there may be cases where people will be sat on by curers, who simply will not take their pigs. It is a good thing to have a remedy for that, and I think on the whole the suggestion is not a bad one.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy McMenamin was here when the Minister was speaking, but he told us that he is taking power, if there are pigs that the local factory is not taking or cannot take, to ensure that the Pigs Marketing Board will be in a position to order those pigs to be taken. The problem, of course, will be in relation to the transport of those pigs. In any case, that part of the original Act is open to corrupt practice. At the moment there is competition as to who will get the pigs to fill the quota because the supply is so very small.
The census of live stock which will be taken on the farms on the 1st June will, I think, be a revelation. To anyone who is interested, and I take it that all the Deputies are, in the progress of our country, it is a source of great regret that the population of any of our live stock should be going down, and especially the pig population, because on that a great many of our people depend. It has been the sheet anchor of small farmers, labourers, and other people who have interested themselves in pig rearing.
I think all these things ought now to be reviewed, and the Minister should take advantage of this Bill in order to do it. I put forward these suggestions in all good faith, and I hope that when the Minister is considering these matters he will put us in a position so that we may realise where we stand in regard to the pig industry. The pig industry is one which it is not hard to get into and carry on, if we can get the feeding-stuff and if we can command a price. The complaint made by a great many of our people is as to how the difference comes in between the price which we get for our pig and the price the consumer pays for his bacon.
On the question of compensation, of course if minor curers want to go voluntarily out of business and they are compensated, well, that is a principle that has been enshrined in this type of legislation, and should be. As to who will pay the compensation, there is a feeling amongst the producers that it ought to be those who are getting the most out of it. I trust the Minister and the Department will examine these things in the light, not alone of Deputy Dillon's and Deputy McMenamin's districts, or the district of Cork, but will take us all into consideration, North and South throughout the Saorstát.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has drawn a very alarming picture of what is likely to happen if this Bill goes through. Surely the resources of civilisation are not exhausted, and I cannot see any Government allowing such a state of affairs to obtain. While he was speaking, I just remembered that rings can be formed in other ways than by bacon curers. If you ask any farmer in the South of Ireland what the condition of the pig market was many years ago, when the pig dealers, for whom Deputy Dillon speaks so strongly, were in control, I think you would get another angle of the situation. As the Deputy spoke, I must say I was impressed with the danger of monopolies. I saw a monopoly working in the pig industry in the South of Ireland many years ago, and at that time it was impossible for any unfortunate farmer to get an economic price at all. He had to accept any price the Pig Dealers' Association approved. Any man who brought pigs to a fair had to take anything the pig buyers would offer. He had no chance to sell his pigs to anybody outside and, unless he agreed to accept whatever price a buyer offered him, he had to take his pigs home.
As Deputy Dillon spoke, I remembered those times and I recollected the complaints of the people. I often heard the people at the fairs telling each other the price they got for their pigs and the bad way they were treated. They were told to take what they were offered or else bring their pigs home. Remembering that time, I was impressed with the Deputy's fear that like conditions would obtain in the future, but from another angle, and that if the curers got control perhaps the people would again find themselves in a similar position. I remember well the fierce conflict that raged in the South of Ireland between Henry Denny & Sons and the Pig Buyers' Association. There was a miniature war in Waterford, and the trouble and unrest at the time gives one furiously to think that there might be a danger, if the people found themselves in a similar position in the future, that they would resent it very strongly. I take it that it is the duty of the Government to prevent such a state of affairs arising. I am sure the Minister is wise enough to see that the bacon industry is not going to pass into the hands of a monopoly, that every effort will be made to see that the producers get a fair price and that at the other end of the scale the consumer will not be asked to pay too much.
I am quite well aware of the argument put forward by Deputy Haslett that complaints are prevalent throughout the country as to the price obtained by the producer. The people are asking us all: "How is it that there is such a discrepancy between the price the producer is getting for the pig and the price we are asked to pay for the bacon?" Of course, I take it that that is a matter for the Prices Commission. Undoubtedly, however, an effort should be made to meet it. In regard to the Bill itself, we have to realise that in this age we must endeavour to regulate our production to cope with consumption. What has happened always in the pig market is that when prices rise everybody rushes into the production of pigs, with the result that there is over-production and the prices drop, and then everybody stops producing pigs again. I think that we would all be in agreement that the only way to cope with that is to endeavour in some way to regulate production so that it will meet with consumption, and to endeavour to stabilise prices.
Comment on this
I am surprised that Deputy Goulding should libel the pig-buyers in the way he has done when he stood up to speak of the prices they gave for pigs in the olden days. As far as I remember, the pig-buyers always gave the last shilling they could afford, and the competition was so keen that they even gave more than they could afford. The pig-buyers of Ireland are the finest and decentest body of men we have in the country, and why they are to be put out of business for the benefit of a combine controlled from London is a thing that I cannot understand. I cannot understand why any Government should put these men out of their business—men who have reared families by means of the pig trade for as long a time as I can remember.
Comment on this
They and their fathers and their grandfathers before them were always in the trade, and I do not see why the Government should have put them out of business.
Comment on this
This Bill has nothing to do with it. It was the Dáil that put them out.
Comment on this
Why should any such Bill as this be introduced at the instance of a certain clique and combine?
Comment on this
It was the Dáil, including Deputy Desmond, that put them out.
Comment on this
——but an open market and open fairs in Munster or in any part of Ireland. Since you took the fairs and markets away, what has been the condition of the villages?
Comment on this
I would not interfere with the trade of these men in a hundred years. I would let their trade go on without interference, just as I would let the cattle trade, the horse trade, or any other trade, go on without interference. As I said before, the farmer got the last shilling they could afford from those dealers. Now they are getting whatever the combine likes to give them for their pigs, and the consumer has to pay the very highest price for his bacon. Where is the profit going? Who is getting it? Do you think you are encouraging the industry by paying the farmer the price he gets for his pig to-day in view of the price he has to pay for meal? There is a better pig industry in the North of Ireland for the last five years than there is in all Ireland now, and that is because they have cheap meal and an open market, and we cannot compete in any way with them. Now you are going to tie up the farmer, the producer, and to tie the cattle dealer and the pig buyer so that he cannot interfere in any way, and those men that you have up here —I suppose they are the Pigs Board— can control the prices and do anything they like with the trade. I think it is an absolute disgrace for any Government to interfere with that trade at all.
Comment on this
It was not the Government; it was the Deputy's Party.
Comment on this
I wish to assure the Minister, and I think Deputy Dillon has already assured him, that we have no motive in this except to preserve this industry in so far as we can do so.
Comment on this
Deputy Haslett has also spoken in that way. There is no doubt about that. Deputy Dillon, of course, spoke rather strongly on this, and I take it that that was inspired by the fact that he is living, as it were, inside the centre of this industry and knows more about it than any man in the street or, probably, than any man in this House. The Minister knows more than any of us in this House know about it, or than anyone else. So far as I am concerned, I realise that it is impossible, or at least very difficult, in a Bill of this kind, or in any Bill, to interfere with an industry and successfully manage it. It is very hard to produce a watertight machine to deal successfully with an industry in all its branches. In this case here, the Minister and ourselves and all of us have got two people to consider. We have got the producer on the one hand and the curer on the other hand. The problem for this House, in taking it upon ourselves to legislate for those two people, is to produce a machine that will hold the balance of justice as fairly and equitably between those two parties as is possible. If we cannot do that by our joint wisdom, then I think we should not touch this industry at all. Of course, however, by the earlier Bill, we have done that already, and hence we are compelled, if there is any crisis in the industry, to go further. I quite frankly admit that the Minister and his officials, in taking the step they took in the earlier Bill, were, so to speak, so far as many branches of this thing are concerned, taking a step in the dark. Naturally they were. It was quite new. It was quite new to everybody— to the Minister himself and to his officials—and, naturally, many defects were bound to be discovered by experience. That is bound to happen. No human being could foresee what difficulties would be created by certain bodies and elements in an industry like that. If there were any loopholes to be discovered in certain sections of a Bill like that, somebody would be sure to find them out and get inside them and take advantage of them.
Now, on the one hand, you had the producer. He was a simple, small farmer. He had not the tricks of the other side, and let me say this—and I do not mean to give any offence—that, watching these pig buyers coming into court for the last 20 years or so, I always thought they were the trickiest and ablest body of men I ever saw coming into court. I do not mean any offence at all in saying that. I thought them the greatest experts I ever saw in a witness box. I only want to put a picture before the House of what is involved. These are the two parties involved, the producers and the buyers. Is the Minister satisfied, or is any Deputy of this House satisfied, that the pig producer, under this Bill, is getting a fair crack of the whip? There is not a Deputy in this House, nor any man or woman outside this House, who knows anything about the industry, but must admit that they are not. That is clear. We are bound to have this difficulty in this Bill because, naturally, with this House coming into these things for the first time and not knowing how this would operate, there were bound to be imperfections.
Now, who was the more likely to get inside whatever loopholes existed in the last Bill? Was it not this body of men to whom I have referred? I defy contradiction when I say that they are as mentally alive and as keen a body of men as ever lived, so far as the industry is concerned. That is my experience. Their training and experience have made them so. What chance has the small farmer, whether man or woman, to compete with that body of men, and more particularly with the experts among them? I say that among the men engaged in this industry in this country, there are as great experts as exist, in my opinion, anywhere in this country or anywhere else—I do not care where they are.
Who is likely to win in that tussle? There is only one side can win and these are the people who have the money. The Minister, of course, knows that. The question is how do they win? Have we machinery in the Bill to overcome that? There is no use in referring to areas such as Donegal, Cavan or Waterford. We are dealing with a national industry. You cannot go into every hole and corner. You must get the machine into such shape that it will be so flexible as to catch up with any misconduct, or rather any mishandling or maltreatment of those engaged in the industry. The machinery must be so flexible, in all its relevant parts, that if anything such as Deputy Haslett stated occurred in Clones happens anywhere, the Department will be able to catch up with it.
Let us take the question of price, which has been the main cause of this Bill. The man in the street, in fact, everybody—and Deputy Goulding says it happens in Waterford—will ask where is the money going? What is the cause of the difference between the price of pork and the price of bacon? Nobody, perhaps, except the Minister, knows it. The public do not know anything about what is happening at all. The public are not aware that over and above the price per cwt., graded or live weight, paid by the purchaser, the purchaser has to pay 12/- per cwt. or an average of between 15/- and £1 per pig as a levy. That is not understood by the man or woman who buys a pound of bacon. They do not understand that that 15/- or £1 per pig must go on to the price of bacon. The small curer who has not an export quota must pay that 15/- or £1 and he does not get one penny of it back. Of course, he must get it back in the price charged for the bacon.