We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Pigs and Bacon Bill, 1937—Financial Resolution.

Contributions 165–336 of 336. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Pigs and Bacon Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 10 of 1937 ›

Well, I shall be glad to be corrected.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is so wrong that his whole argument is fallacious. Whether the curer sells it at home or exports it, he gets the same amount back. The Deputy's argument is altogether wrong.

Comment on this

I accept that, but that is the explanation I got of it. Of course, the Minister's explanation only makes the case worse. There is no justification then for the price of bacon. That makes the case worse as far as the price of bacon is concerned.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There is a come-back now in the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

What is the justification then for the price of bacon? I have given the explanation I got but according to the Minister that is wrong. That makes the price of bacon even more unjustifiable. The explanation which I got seemed a fairly sound one, that the small curer who had no export quota had to pay 15/- to £1 per pig over and above the price which he paid the producer, and that he had to add that to the price of the bacon. If that is not a true explanation, what is the justification for the price of bacon in relation to the price of pork? That makes the questions raised by Deputy Goulding and Deputy Haslett much more pertinent. Who is getting the difference or where is it going? If the Minister knew that, and apparently he did— if he did not know it in the past he knows it now—what is the justification for the price of bacon in relation to the price of pork? Deputy Goulding has told the House that the resources of civilisation are not yet exhausted. That is merely a piece of Balfourian philosophy and it is not wise to apply Mr. Balfour's subtleties to everything that arises. I think Deputy Goulding will agree that they do not apply to this case. Has Deputy Goulding any suggestion to offer in regard to the people who are now going out of pig production, the people to whom Deputy Haslett referred? I can confirm what Deputy Haslett says, that when the census showing the number of pigs is taken this month people will be surprised and so will the Minister. That is a very regrettable thing.

Everybody in the country is complaining about this matter. The producers certainly are complaining about it, especially in parts of my constituency where pig production is, in the main, the backbone of the people's livelihood. You get a small farm there on which there is a limited amount of arable land, and on which there is no outlet in the way of a large production of cattle. The occupiers balance that by pig production. Those who had not the benefit of technical advice could not understand what was happening in the fairs and markets with regard to prices. The only thing they could say was that they were not getting enough for their pigs. They merely said: "Look at what we are getting for our pork and what is being charged to the public for bacon. We must be robbed." Whether they were robbed or not, we are here legislating for that problem. These people are going out of production because they feel that they cannot produce pigs at the price they are getting. I went to some trouble in my constituency to get some information in regard to this matter, because it is a fundamental matter so far as my constituency is concerned. I have taken an approximate census of the position there, and I went to some trouble to do that. I went into one small area, a small valley, and I took a census of the pigs that would be marketed there in the month of April this year as compared with the number marketed in April, 1936, and what did I find? That only 12 pigs could be marketed last April, whereas 150 pigs were marketed in the same area during April, 1936. I ascertained further that in the 12 months 18 sows in this one area—a parish area, if you like—had been slaughtered. The worst feature about that was that both the county committee of agriculture and the Pigs Marketing Board last year, in order, firstly, to increase production, and, secondly, to put the right type of pig into Donegal—the White York—put 300 or 400 sows into the county. That was a very excellent thing. They were given a nominal price—at a sum much less than what they actually cost. What happened? A large number of those sows were slaughtered. Of course that can be met to some extent. The pigs were marked, and the Pigs Marketing Board have given instructions to the curers not to buy any sows with those marks. On the other hand, they can be sold and fattened locally to be consumed at home. That will be done when the producer finds that the production of pigs does not pay him. The fact of the curers not taking the sows into the factory does not solve the problem. They can be fattened and used at home. Is this Bill going to cure that?

Deputy Dillon made a violent attack on the proposal to eliminate the minor curer. It is a fundamental business axiom that competition is the life of trade. I do not think anybody will dispute that. A case may be made out for the elimination of small people out of business. I do not care for that case. I think it is bad. I think it is necessarily bad.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Why did you not say that when the main Bill came before the House two years ago?

Comment on this

I have been in business. I know something about particular branches of business, but I never had the audacity to interfere in branches of business which I knew nothing about. I know that much about business.

Comment on this

It is a pity you made this mistake.

Comment on this

I made no mistake. The reason why I did not make a mistake was that I did not know anything about it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

And you do now?

Comment on this

I do not now. I am asking for information. I told the Minister that I am absolutely with him, and will do anything that is humanly possible for me to do to perfect a machine here that will serve the public. In regard to monopoly of this kind, there was a crisis in the American meat industry somewhere around 1910 and 1911. That is a long time ago. I was in business then, and I was interested in this thing to some extent. Of course, the House now forgets all about that. Look what happened. It took a national crisis in America to smash that—a crisis so great that it killed the meat-curing business in America for the time being. They could not sell one pound of their products for about two years. Let us not forget that. I remember it well. There were thousands and thousands of cases—shiploads of cases—lying rotting. You could not give them away. But the crisis cured the monopolists in America; it brought them to their senses. It took a national crisis in America to bring that about. Deputy Dillon referred to conditions in America. I expect he does not remember anything about this. I remember it well. It took a national crisis in America to cure the monopolists. Shiploads of their stuff lay rotting, and had to be thrown out. They had to knuckle down and do two things. They had to serve the producer and they had to serve the consumer. They got a lesson, and it was a very drastic one. We do not want any of those drastic things here. That monopoly in America brought about a crisis which came to a head, I think, in the year 1911. We are not going to have that crisis.

Deputy Dillon talks about one of two things happening. The first is what actually did take place in America in that year. I do not think that is going to happen in this country. What is going to happen, and is already happening, is that the farmers are going out of pig production. I think, as Deputy Haslett has said, that that is a national disaster, and everything possible should be done to prevent it. From my experience of business I think restriction in trade is wrong in principle. The common law in England, in its wisdom of centuries, has refused generally to lay down the principle of any restriction in trade. That is the result of the joint wisdom of centuries in the common law of England. Why did they do that? Now take the statute law. As a result of the wisdom derived from centuries of experience the English law lays down as an axiom that any attempt to restrict the freedom of trade or business is illegal.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think Deputy McMenamin is discussing a principle that was decided by the first Bill. Is that in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not in order to discuss now anything that was decided by the first Bill.

Comment on this

I am only referring to the abolition of those minor curers. It might in many ways be a good thing for the industry, but, taking the long view of it, I think it is wrong; I think it is bad business. I think it is a bad thing to put out of business any man who has gone into that business and applied himself to it, even though he has not, if you like, got away on a big scale. It does not follow at all that a man who does not make a huge fortune out of business has not carried on that business successfully. The men who went into business and carried it on in a small way have been the salt of business, and the salt of the country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This Bill does not put anybody out of business.

Comment on this

Oh, that is the snag about it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Will the Deputy point out where it does?

Comment on this

I am not saying that it does. I agree with the Minister. I am not alleging that at all. Do not let the Minister think I am trying to cross him. Quite the contrary is the case, but this is an occasion on which we should speak frankly.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That would be a good idea.

Comment on this

How can I operate that machine? Surely the Minister does not suggest he has sufficient experience of business to say that I cannot do it in another way.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

How?

Comment on this

One hundred and one ways.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

One will do me.

Comment on this

If you give a lever to Deputy Moore whereby he can crush me out of business, it can be done.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What is it?

Comment on this

There are one hundred and one ways.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I want only one.

Comment on this

The combines have crushed everybody out. Let us take one example. Take the Imperial Tobacco Company.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not want generalities. Tell me how it is done in this case.

Comment on this

This has not been put in operation yet. The Minister has been "rattled" since early morning. I assure him I am not trying to "rattle" him.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This is merely a lot of futile talk. You do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

I do not want to "rattle" the Minister.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The worst of it is that you do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

The people with the money can buy out the small man. That is what has happened in the case of all monopolies. That is how all monopolies have been created. That is sticking out in this case.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

How does this Bill help them to do that to any greater extent?

Comment on this

Let me take a case as example. I have a small curing station with a capital of £10,000. I am making only one per cent. on that or, if the matter were strictly worked out, I might be making nothing. Deputy Keyes has a reserve of £200,000 and he says to me: "McMenamin, I will give you £50,000 for your place." Is not that what has happened all over the world?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That cannot be done under this Bill.

Comment on this

We have been hearing stories like that all our lives.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is talking through his hat.

Comment on this

Under the old Act 3/1 was provided for the carriage of pork. What has happened——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Will the Deputy quote any clause to support his contention?

Comment on this

They went to the Great Southern Railways and got a flat rate of 1/2 per pig from any part of the Free State to their curing stations. From Sligo to Cork or Cork to Sligo, they had a flat rate of 1/2 while we gave them 3/1.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is wrong.

Comment on this

I am finished. There is no use in talking to that man.

Comment on this

I should like to voice my protest in the strongest possible terms against this Bill. I can see no justification for it and it seems to me that people do not realise the significance of it or the dangers enshrined in it. I do not think that it is feasible for the farmer who has a few pigs to sell to arrange, as Deputy Dillon pointed out, for their transport. Up to the present, the onus as to transport was thrown on the pig dealer. The farmer who brought in his pig to the fair had not to think of the transport of the pig to whatever place it was destined for. In future, it will be quite a different matter. He will have to make the necessary arrangements and it may not be feasible to get the pig away on a particular day to the factory to which it is to go. That is one item which should be looked into. It is, perhaps, a small item and it may be possible to get over it.

There is a far greater evil in the Bill and, to my mind, it is one that ought to receive attention. The Bill does away with competition. The pig dealer, no matter what anybody may say in this House, has always been regarded as a decent and honourable man. The pig dealers in the South of Ireland have a good tradition. These men have devoted their lives to the business. It has been handed down from father to son and I think legislation of this type to do away with the calling of these men comes very badly from an Irish Parliament. I ask the Minister to look into the matter and inquire as to the benefit which he thinks will be conferred by this proposal. These men are Irishmen. Why should we hand over their business to people who will have a complete monopoly of the bacon trade? It has been said here that these men have cut prices and that they have not, as it were, given the producers a fair run for their money. I absolutely contradict that statement. These men have an honourable past and are regarded as a decent body.

The pig producers, so far as I know, are much more anxious to sell to the pig dealer than they are to sell direct to the agents of the factory. The pig dealers at the fairs during the past month have given as much as 5/- per cwt. over and above the price offered by the Bacon Board. That is a fact, and I cannot for the life of me see how it can be made out that the pig dealer has tried to do damage to the producer of the pig. It is for the Minister to look into that. I have it on the best authority and I can stand over it.

I should like to make a special appeal for the pig dealer, because he has not only his own livelihood and the livelihood of his children to think about, but in the past his business has gone down —particularly within the last four years owing to the economic war. Anybody who dares to say that the pig dealer was not a benefit to more people than himself does not know what he is talking about. I know that all the smaller towns have benefited greatly by the pig dealers coming to the fairs and staying there for a night or two. What have these small towns to look forward to if the pig fairs are to be abolished, as they must be, under this Bill, because competition is being done away with and we all know that the life of trade lies in competition. I ask the Minister, in the interests of the pig dealer in whom I am particularly interested, and in the interests of the smaller towns, to see that this does not happen and that some amendment will be made to the Bill to ensure that it will not happen. It would be a serious thing for country towns which have been going down for several years, and particularly for the past four years. I ask the Minister to give special attention to this matter and to make sure that the pig dealer will not be driven out of business, as at present appears to be the intention. The pig dealers are in a very uneasy state. Their livelihood is threatened and there is no talk of compensation. They are simply being thrown out by the wilful act of the Government, for no reason. They have served their country well. They have advanced the interests of their country and they had built up a big business in England. Without rhyme or reason, their calling is being taken from them by act of the Government. In the interests of the towns and the pig dealers, I ask the Minister to have this matter attended to.

Comment on this

So far as I understand it, this Bill is designed to amend an Act passed by this House about two years ago with the approval and co-operation of all Parties. Listening to the speech made by Deputy Dillon and to the speeches of some of the Deputies who followed him on that side of the House, one would get the impression that the members of this Party were entirely composed of bacon curers or the representatives of bacon curers. Deputy Dillon and Deputy McMenamin would have us and the country forget that they were equally responsible with us for the legislation we are now proposing to amend.

Comment on this

Were you equally responsible with us for the Constitution Amendment Act?

Comment on this

I want to say that in so far as this Bill proposes to amend any of the grievances or complaints of pig producers which have come to my notice as a result of its operation for the last two years, I think this measure is entitled to our support. Having listened to the opening statement of Deputy Dillon, I sat here in the belief that he would, during the course of a rather long speech, proceed to prove some of the charges he made, and before I deal with that portion of this amending Bill in which I am particularly interested, I want to refer to one statement made by him. Deputy Dillon speaks here as a businessman and I am sure that if anybody made a charge of sharp practice, so far as the public is concerned, against him, or any members of his trade, profession, or whatever you like to call it, such a charge would be resented very vehemently by Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon, however, stands up here and proceeds to tell us the story of the small farmer, the producer of the two pigs, and to show us that when that man takes his two pigs to the bacon factory, that innocent man who is not aware of his legal rights and who hands over his two pigs to the bacon factory in whatever town he goes to, let it be Monaghan, Cavan or any town in which there is a bacon curing concern, he never knows what kind of deal he is going to get from that bacon curer, so far as the weighing, the grading and all the matters that are of such vital interest to the producer are concerned. He never knows what sort of deal he is going to get from the bacon curer, he says, because he is not permitted to go inside that concern.

I am surprised at a man who always makes it a point, and especially in the speech to which we have just listened, to tell us of his business connections, getting up here to tell us that businessmen of any class could make themselves responsible for a campaign designed to deprive the producer of his rights. I might as well charge Deputy Dillon here with endeavouring to deceive the customers whom, I am sure, he has in Mayo, Roscommon, and all over the West, and say that every businessman would take advantage of the fact that in every farmer's house there is not a weigh-bridge, and that businessmen of that type might endeavour to sell to the public a lb. of tea, which was not in fact a lb. of tea, a stone of sugar, which was not, in fact, a stone of sugar, and a cwt. of meal when, in fact, the bag contained no such weight. I have no connection with business, but I think I have some little knowledge of that type of small farmer producer who might go to Cavan town with his two or three pigs, and while I am prepared to concede that the bacon curers would perhaps adopt the ordinary sharp practices followed in business, I have more confidence in the bacon curers than to believe that any bacon curer would stoop so low, would degrade himself to such an extent, as to deceive that small producer who might stand outside his gate and not know how his pig was graded and weighed.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know that the Minister has himself been endeavouring for the last two months to devise a plan to circumvent just such practices as the Deputy is now describing?

Comment on this

I do not know anything of the kind.

Comment on this

And that the Bacon Marketing Board invited me, the Deputy, and all the Deputies of County Donegal to consult with them as to how best to circumvent the actual practices the Deputy is now describing, because they were being carried on by certain people despite the Bacon Marketing Board?

Comment on this

I am prepared to agree that, so far as the grading of pigs is concerned, it is possible that in the best regulated concern a mistake may be made, just as in the case of the weighing of pigs when we in our county and in County Monaghan had the dead-pork markets, and when the farmer was permitted to take his cart on to the market square and see his pigs being weighed, because if the man in charge of the weigh-bridge did not give it sufficient time to function, he might record a weight for the man's pigs that was too much or too little. I can see the possibility of an injustice being done to a producer in a bacon concern, but, even after Deputy Dillon's intervention, I am still not prepared to believe that the owner of a bacon concern can go to his 50, 60 or 100 employees, because, after all, it must be his employees who will cheat the public for him in this way—he cannot grade and weigh the pigs and do all the other things that are necessary when a pig is taken in for curing —and get them into a little room and say to them: "Gentlemen, I want to be a rogue and I cannot be a rogue unless you help me," and then tell those employees how they are going to help him to be a rogue. Even assuming that the type of individual engaged in this business was as mean as Deputy Dillon alleges, I say that it is quite impossible for him to succeed in that effort. I do not believe that is the kind of statement, or the type of impression, that should be conveyed to the public, because mind you, the public have a sort of tendency to mistrust, and while the public has to be on its guard, it is not right that we should set a further hare going in that respect, because I believe it would be better if the public had a little more confidence, and if all of us had a little more confidence in one another, as to the honesty of our motives and our attempts to do what we think is right.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon gave you credit for being simple. He could not be fairer to you.

Comment on this

I have dealt with the statement made by Deputy Dillon and the one part of this amending legislation in which I am substantially interested is the part to which I had hoped Deputy Dillon would have referred at greater length. He gave the impression that he had a solution different from the one provided in this Bill for dealing with a difficulty that this proposal purports to deal with. I had hoped that his solution would be better than this one. But, I must say from what I know, and from what I have seen tried out, that it is not as good as this one. I would not say this one is entirely perfect. I have seen an effort made to put the one which Deputy Dillon recommended into operation, and I would not have it as against the one suggested here. There is the problem of a particular curer refusing to take pigs from a certain producer in his area for one reason or another. That is a problem with which I think all Deputies have been confronted, especially Deputies from Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan—perhaps in some other counties—but these are the areas with which I am most intimately connected. That is certainly a problem which has agitated our minds, especially at a period when we had a surplus of pigs. Deputy Dillon said he had a solution for that other than the solution provided in this Bill. I had hoped he really had one, but the only one he had to put forward was the establishment of fairs and the introduction into these fairs of pig buyers, and so on. I do not agree that that will be effective. While this is not as complete as those of us who have experience of that problem would like it to be, I still think that this is far ahead of what the Deputy suggests.

Here is one suggestion I want to make and I cannot see how this cannot be done. When a bacon curer gets his quota for a period of one month, or whatever the extent of it is, I think the Bacon Board, or the chairman of the board, should be in a position to tell that curer that he was to take all pigs suitable for production of bacon, and, when that quota had been exhausted, that curer should get permission from the board to take and cure whatever surplus there is, if not for meeting the requirements of his own trade, for the Bacon Board itself, and then the accumulated surplus all over the State should be dealt with in whatever way the Bacon Board may decide. Surely what is possible for a bacon curer to do under the previous Act must be remedied. I certainly would like to hear a more reasoned criticism of this provision and more suitable alternatives suggested than that of Deputy Dillon. For some time past this problem did not arise and at the present time it does not arise. But, at certain periods of the year, we are always likely to have over-production. When potatoes and other feeding stuffs are dear at this time of the year you have not a very heavy production. How do we know that next year, say, the position may not be different? How do we know that potato prices and other things will be as they are this year? My point is that a surplus such as we have experienced in those areas may arise at any time and I am in some doubt whether the provision made here is ample to deal with that. But, as I said, no suggestion has been made that seems more feasible. I have seen the other suggestion tried and it has not been a success and, therefore, I cannot give it any further consideration.

Comment on this

Do you know why it was not a success?

Comment on this

It was not a success.

Comment on this

Because the Minister would not give licences to pig dealers to export live pigs.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did. The Deputy is entirely wrong. I met them twice and gave them licences for that purpose.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The dealers who go to Donegal, and it was not a success.

Comment on this

That is all very well, but I know it has not been a success.

Comment on this

It has to be tried for a protracted period or it will not work. There is no use doing it for a month and then giving it up.

Comment on this

It is very hard to introduce a new system. The argument that the Deputy advanced against this provision here is, to my mind, not a really effective argument when you come to examine it closely. The Deputy asked in his criticism of this provision what was a man in Ballybofey or some other place in Donegal to do who was ordered to take his two pigs to some place 40 miles away. Everybody knows that that man was not going to take these pigs 40 miles away. But, in the event of a surplus such as we have experienced in the past arising, you may take it that not alone will you have the two pigs belonging to that man in Ballybofey, but you will have, as all of us experienced at the time we have in mind, many farmers who had pigs on their hands and could not dispose of them. If there were only two pigs left in the area there would be no surplus, and therefore the point that the Deputy made is really not an effective point. I do not know whether this can be done or not. I believe that this provision is ample, provided the Monaghan bacon curers or the bacon establishment in Cavan, when they have exhausted their quota, will get permission to take and cure for the board all the surplus pigs and let the board dispose of that surplus some other time. I do not see any other effective means of doing that. They have been accustomed to sending their pigs there. I think that is the best thing, and I believe it will provide a solution for our difficulties in so far as that matter is concerned. That is really the problem that affects me most acutely. I am sure that that is a problem that affects most of us who are Deputies. Deputy Dillon proceeded to deal with the matter of minor curers and the possibility of minor curers being gobbled up by what he described as a ring. There is no provision in this amending legislation to compel minor curers to sell. I do not see where the anxiety could possibly exist on the part of the 30 licensed curers to buy up the 19 minor curers when the Minister has power to license further concerns for that purpose.

Comment on this

Where is that power?

Comment on this

If this were definitely made close and complete, if the Minister had no power, I might, if I were in business, be tempted to buy up six or seven smaller concerns so as to have the whole field to myself. But if there were six or seven smaller concerns of, say, the same type that might start, I would not be tempted to the same extent to buy up the existing ones. On listening to Deputy Dillon one would have thought that he was really going to say something constructive. I must honestly confess that I listened to him and he did not attempt to establish to my satisfaction any of the charges that he made at the outset of his speech.

Comment on this

Why is this provision put into the Bill at all? What is it there for? Will the Deputy please tell us?

Comment on this

I am only saying what I said when Deputy Dillon was not in the House. I said before he came in here that one listening to him, and to other Deputies, would have thought that we were, in fact, the representatives of the curing concerns. One would have thought that Deputy Dillon and the others had no responsibility for the Act which we are proposing to amend now. I think the Deputy could have treated this subject in a very different way. We certainly are not wedded to the curers and we have no interest in them. As far as I am concerned, I certainly have not any kind of interest in the curers. I would be prepared to deal in a reasonable way with any suggestion made in any quarter for helping us to get out of this difficulty. Deputy Dillon has made no contribution to this debate that is in any way more attractive or that offers more security in any shape or form, than the provision in the Bill. In this matter we ought all, on whichever side of the House we sit, keep in mind the fact that we are endeavouring to amend a piece of legislation for which we all have the same responsibility. Surely in a matter like this which concerns the country we should be reasonable with one another and not endeavour to give the impression that we can come in here, say what we like, and wipe our hands of the responsibility which belongs, to the same extent, to all of us.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Smith sits down, I would like to have his guidance on this matter—whether he approves of the proposal that the bacon curers should be permitted to buy up the minor curers with the money of the Bacon Board?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has said nothing to satisfy me that that is wrong.

Comment on this

Perhaps, Sir, from the spirit in which Deputy Smith approaches this, you would permit me to put another question so as to clear our minds on this matter?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Certainly.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Smith approve of the principle under which the major curers can buy out the minor curers and that the major curers can do that by using the funds of the Bacon Marketing Board, not their own money?

Comment on this

So long as there is no compulsion under this legislation, why should not I, as a minor curer, have the right to offer my business for sale, and if I were going to get any compensation, hand it over? Why should not I have the right to do that?

Comment on this

Admitted, but why should it be paid for with the money of the Bacon Marketing Board?

Comment on this

That is a small matter. But Deputy Dillon has not shown any better method of meeting that.

Comment on this

But why not buy them out with their own money? Why should they be allowed to use the money of the Bacon Marketing Board?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon thinks it is right that there should be provision made for me that I should have the right to offer my business for sale. Has he not admitted that?

Comment on this

Anyone can offer his business for sale to another but why should the bacon curers not buy the business with their own money and not with the money of the Bacon Marketing Board?

Comment on this

That is a matter we would like Deputy Dillon to make clear. That is where we would like him to make some suggestion.

Comment on this

Legislation by reference is always difficult to follow and there are many sections in this Bill which cannot be understood without reference to the parent Act and even after reading the sections in the parent Act it is difficult to understand them without the references in the Dáil debates to these sections. Deputy Haslett said that pig production in every county in Ireland varies. That statement is perfectly true. There are local conditions in different areas pertaining to pig production. I think the Minister understands that perfectly well. In the counties of Cavan and Monaghan the circumstances are somewhat peculiarly affected by the fact that when the original Bill was introduced there had to be a change-over from one breed of pig to another. That change-over naturally dislocated pig production in these counties. The same thing happened in Donegal and in other counties where the people were accustomed to one breed of pig for many years. That had a particular effect on the problem in those areas.

Pig production has always been the main source of the farmer's income. Whether the Minister likes it or not, there is no question that one of the effects of this legislation regulating pig production has been to drive a certain number of people out of pig production. I admit that all those who have gone out of pig production have not done so because of this legislation. This has happened through other causes such as the cost of feeding-stuffs. In any event I hold that the legislation that the Minister had introduced for the purpose of pig production is not suited to the requirements of farmers. That legislation has been modelled on British lines. But the Minister must realise that pig production in Great Britain is carried out on completely different lines to those in which it is carried on in this country. Pig production in Great Britain at the present time is worked on scientific, mass-production principles. The farmer there is engaged exclusively in pig production and some producers turn out probably a couple of hundred thousand pigs a year. Some of them are on a smaller scale and produce considerably less pigs. But the Minister in his original legislation did not envisage the conditions in the small farmer's home who, after all, is the main pig producer in this country. His legislation was not designed to cater for the particular type of pig production in the small farmer's home. Consequently, a number of the small farmers have gone out of production.

Under the original Act pigs were graded. You had four different grades and different prices were fixed for these different grades. The discrepancy between the "A" grade and the lower grades was very substantial. I admit that difficulty has been overcome since by approximating the prices in the different grades much more closely. When the original Act came into operation there were many farmers who undoubtedly tried, in so far as they could in rough guess-work fashion, to comply with the regulations and produce the type of pig which they thought would be graded as grade 1 or grade 2. When they went to the factory to sell they found that, according to the standards laid down in order to qualify for a particular grade, their pig qualified only for the grade 4 price, and so on. In that way, right at the very outset, many of the farmers were discouraged because they thought it would not be an economic proposition.

There is no doubt that there is a big decline in the number of pigs shown at our fairs and markets. I can speak with authority for my own county, and the decline there is very noticeable, especially at the principal fairs and markets. Usually in the big towns in Sligo there is a two-day fair, one day being for pigs and the other for sheep, horses and cattle. Recently there was a fair in one town, and the number of pigs for sale was from 50 to 60 per cent. less than at the corresponding fair the previous year. Many of the farmers engaged breeding pigs are ceasing to do so because of the fact that the price for young pigs, until recently, was so small that it would scarcely cover the cost of production. The Minister has rushed this legislation too much. He has rushed all sorts of regulations with the object of regulating pig production. The net result of the regulations under the parent Act has been to drive a number of people who were anxious to remain in pig production, out of that industry.

A strong case has been made by many speakers for the pig dealer. It so happens that at all the fairs for the last three or four months the dealers paid, on an average, 5/- more than the top price paid by the Pigs Marketing Board. All during last year the pig dealers were on the average 3/- or 4/- higher than the board's top price. The tendency of all the legislation is to drive that type of man out of the pig business.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We could not drive them out if they are paying more.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that the pig dealers paid on an average from 4/- to 5/- more than the board?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am surprised to hear it, because I am sure they would get all the pigs if they did.

Comment on this

Well, they did. I venture to say that the majority of the farmers engaged in pig production would much prefer to deal with the pig dealers than with the factory.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Well, we will not prevent them.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will agree, from his knowledge of the psychology of the farmer, that it is in the interests of the scheme that is embodied in the legislation that the pig buyer should be encouraged, because it is only in that way that you will be able to keep up pig production.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know whether you should encourage the buyer or not, but there is nothing to prevent him buying all the pigs if he wishes.

Comment on this

The tendency of the legislation has been to discourage the pig buyers.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

How does the Deputy make that out?

Comment on this

There are sections in this Bill calculated still further to discourage the pig buyers.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would like to have them pointed out.

Comment on this

A great deal of the discussion centred round Section 36, which provides for compensation to the minor curers. The Minister asserted that it is not his intention to drive the minor curer out of business. If it is not his intention, will the Minister amend this section in such a fashion as to ensure that the minor curer will be allowed to continue in business?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

He has that right.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If the Deputy can point out that he has not that right, I certainly would amend it.

Comment on this

The argument has been made that the section is included in order to favour the big bacon curer.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not agree with that argument.

Comment on this

The bacon curer has to pay the compensation. As a matter of fact, the compensation will be paid by the Bacon Board, and that is composed of bacon curers, and it is quite natural that a board controlled by curers will be operated in the interests of the curers. The impression prevails very generally—I hope the Minister will be in a position to dispel it—amongst the people engaged in the trade in a very big way, that it is the object of the major curers to drive the smaller curers completely out of business. That is the impression that also exists in the minds of the minor curers.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps I would be permitted to intervene, as I may not have an opportunity of concluding to-day. I asked that that clause relating to compensation be put in. I was not asked by any official or by any minor curer or major curer to insert it. I myself came along and suggested this compensation clause, and I am awfully sorry if I have offended the minor curers, because I thought I was doing them a good turn. Some of the arguments we have heard are most ridiculous.

Comment on this

The Minister is going away from the point.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There seems to be a suggestion that the major curers wanted this provision—the bigger curers. They never asked for it.

Comment on this

In any event, our case is this, that this section is going to be operated by the big curers in their own interests. We know very well that the whole bacon trade, in so far as they control it, is operated in their interests and they do not care two hoots about the minor curers or the producers. The Minister proposes in this section to give them an opportunity of operating the trade to a much greater extent in their own interests at the producers' expense. That is really what the section does mean. If the Minister is sincere, and I accept his word that he is sincerely desirous to keep the minor curers in business, he should amend this section to ensure that the big curers will have no right to interfere with the interests of the minor curers.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is the law, and if the Deputy will point out where that is not the law, then I will amend it.

Comment on this

The Minister has introduced the principle of compensation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

And I am very sorry I did—I can tell you that.

Comment on this

That principle will be operated by the Bacon Board, which is controlled by the big curers, for the purpose of driving their competitors, the minor curers, out of business and getting a complete grasp of the trade.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If there is any danger of that in the clause I am prepared to amend it.

Comment on this

The Minister knows enough to realise that where an opportunity presents itself to a big group of men engaged in the pig business to wipe out competitors, they will naturally and inevitably avail of it, as they have been doing since the original Act was introduced.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Can they do anything more against those men with compensation than they could have done without compensation? Does compensation make any difference?

Comment on this

The Minister can amend the Bill. If a minor curer wants voluntarily to go out of the business——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is exactly what the section refers to.

Comment on this

——and offers to do so, why should he be paid?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If the Deputy wants to offer that amendment, we will discuss it.

Comment on this

There is no question about it: the interpretation placed by Deputy Dillon and other Deputies on this section is perfectly legitimate, and that is that the section can be, and in fact will be, operated in the interests of the big curers. The Minister himself has admitted that the Bacon Board is comprised entirely of the big bacon curers, and he can rest assured that they will operate this section in their own interest. They have operated the whole Bill in their own interest.

Comment on this

There is just one question I should like to ask the Minister. Of course, if a man goes out of business, he can sell to anybody?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If I agree, yes.

Comment on this

Well, anyhow, the money will be paid by the person buying the business?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

Is there not this danger, as the thing is going to be operated in future, that the money that will be paid to benefit the curer will ultimately come out of the money of the producer?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That does not follow.

Comment on this

Does it not follow in practice?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No. It is intended that the levy shall be got back from the curers.

Comment on this

How will it? How will you get it back?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy Dillon asks superciliously how will it be got back, but his point when he was speaking was that, if we took the money from Henry Denny, it would be all right, but not when we took it from the others. Now, when we say that we will take it from Denny, Deputy Dillon gets up, in his superior way, and wants to know how we will get it.

Comment on this

What provision is there for that?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We can levy on the curers to get it back.

Comment on this

And they can levy on the producer?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

If, as I say, the Minister is sincere in his desire to secure the interests of the minor curers, then I say that he has an opportunity to amend this in such a fashion as to ensure that the minor curers can continue in business without molestation from the big curers. As I have said, this is entirely operated by the big curers. However, as it is a Bill that can be considered in detail on the Committee Stage and which will lend itself to exhaustive and useful discussion on that Stage, I do not propose to say anything more at the moment.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Before Deputy Gibbons speaks, Sir, I should like to know whether any other Deputy wants to speak from the opposite side?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is all I wanted to know.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words arising from the conflict of opinion that has taken place between Deputy Roddy and the Minister. I should like to suggest that, in the event of the ownership of any of the minor bacon curing establishments changing hands, the location of the industry should remain the same—that there should be no change in the locality of the establishment with the change of ownership, and that it should be carried on just the same as if there had been no change in ownership.

That is a very important consideration, and I can assure the Minister that if the people knew there was not going to be any change in that respect, it would allay a good deal of the anxiety in the country that has been created by the scare headings in certain sections of the public Press regarding the abolition of the minor curers. We have some minor curers in Kilkenny. There are two curing establishments there, one in the city and one in the county, and they serve a very important purpose there. They are a convenient market for the local pig producers who can market their pigs there very conveniently and very satisfactorily, and who would prefer to do business with the local bacon curers rather than send their pigs further afield. I am making the suggestion seriously to the Minister that, in the event of those who run local bacon-curing establishments being induced, by considerations of money or for other reasons, to part with their business, the business should remain in the same locality. In other words, the Minister should decentralise the industry in that regard. These establishments give good employment, and it is also 100 per cent. native employment. Anybody who is interested in the industry, or in the welfare of the country generally, would not wish to see any of those establishments closed up. I make that suggestion in all seriousness.

Regarding the measure itself, it was an agreed measure which was introduced as an amendment to legislation which was passed here, with the approval of all Parties in the House, two years ago. In some respects, the amendment will be a decided improvement, particularly where it deals with periods in which there is a surplus of pigs and where it purports to ensure that the curers will take these pigs off the hands of the producers and give the fixed price for them. The Minister told us to-day—it was information for some of us—that some curers had been getting their supplies of surplus pigs through dealers.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that, and that is very unsatisfactory. Evidently the people who were operating that were the pig dealers, in whom Deputy Dillon seems to be so interested.

Comment on this

That, certainly, is untrue.

Comment on this

Well, the Minister must have data, or he would not have said that.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that. He said that it was not the dealers, but dummy dealers, that had been appointed to do this work.

Comment on this

Every business section contains its fair quota of sharks.

Comment on this

There are very few of them here.

Comment on this

Well, in that connection, we all remember the conditions that prevailed some years ago—about a quarter of a century ago—when the pig dealers had sole control of that industry. We know what the feelings of the farmers were in respect of the treatment they received from the pig dealers. They were completely at the mercy of the pig dealers, and we know of the conflict that took place—the miniature war that took place, in Deputy Goulding's words—in Waterford, on several occasions. If the pig dealers were giving the pig producers as good a price as Denny's factory was giving and the other factories were giving, the producers would continue to give the pigs to the dealers, but the dealers gave any price they liked. When Deputy Desmond refers in such glowing terms to the pig dealers and their altruism in the good prices they were giving to the farmers and the service they gave to the farmers, I certainly say that his description would not be recognised by the pig producers of Kilkenny anyhow, in respect of the pig dealers of Waterford and the South of Ireland.

We know the price that obtained for pigs in 1931. We know the position in which the Minister found the industry when he came into office, and we know the steps that were necessary.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know the price of Indian meal in 1931?

Comment on this

Well, my only object in getting up was to make some sensible suggestions if I could. If Deputy Dillon, or any other Deputy, is in a position to make suggestions to the Minister which will benefit the industry, the Minister will gladly accept them. I know that some of us have gone to the Minister and to the Minister's Department over and over again, both personally and in a public capacity, and our representations have always been very carefully considered, and it is up to Deputy Dillon and other Deputies, if they have suggestions to make, to make them to the Minister and his Department. After all, this is a national matter, which concerns all of us. It should be a non-Party matter, and we should all endeavour to make any suggestions we can with a view to improving this important industry, which affects a very important section of the community. In rising to speak, however, my principal object was to make the suggestion that, in the event of any bacon-curing establishment, either in the provincial towns or in rural areas, being acquired, the location of these establishments should not be interfered with.

Comment on this

But the object of this Bill is to abolish them.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the Second Reading debate on this measure has been availed of chiefly for the purpose of either glorifying or vilifying the people who contributed to the building up of the bacon industry in the past. We have had speeches by some glorifying the pig dealers, and by other Deputies vilifying them, and we have had similar speeches about the curers, and so on. I certainly think that Deputies in this House, who only two years ago enacted the 1935 Act, had sufficient and ample time then to measure the merits or demerits of the people who were contributing to the bacon trade, and their speeches should not be utilised, as they are being utilised to-day, to level charges, in most cases unsupported by any facts, against either one side or the other. I come from a county in which a very large number of pig buyers reside, and whatever may be said about Deputy Gibbons's references to 25 years ago, I should heartily resent, from my personal knowledge of the pig buyers of Limerick, any suggestion that they were wilfully dishonest in their dealings with their clients during all the years that I have known them.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. They supported the old Irish Party. They supported everything national when Deputy Gibbons was pulling down the country.

Comment on this

Why this unseemly interruption? The bacon curers, on the other hand, it has been alleged, have been stooping to all kinds of sharp practices behind the backs of the producers, by giving false and fictitious weights for the pigs, by giving them a false grading and reducing the prices paid to producers in that way. All this discussion, in my opinion, is the very greatest deterrent that could be utilised against increased pig production. The original Act was intended to improve our pig population. Under the old method which existed, we have had it on the authority of the pig curers and pig buyers, there was not sufficient enthusiasm amongst producers and there was no continuity of steady prices to induce them to maintain production. When there was a slump in prices, there was a falling off in pig production. Sows were killed off and the bonhams were not reared, with the result that when prices increased you had no pigs to meet the demand. I think it was to meet a situation of that kind that the Act of 1935 was introduced. Since then some deficiencies or defects have evidently been discovered in that Act which necessitated this amending Bill. I am not quite conversant with these defects, as I had not the advantage of hearing the Minister's opening statement, but these defects must have been of a rather grave character when they rendered this Bill so speedily necessary. One of these defects apparently affects minor curers.

Deputy Gibbons has dealt with the point that if any of these curers go out of operation the factory should be reopened in the same locality where they had been operating. As I understand the matter, if a curer is capable of dealing with a production of 2,000 cwts. in the year, there is no reason why he should be driven out of production by any of the provisions of this Bill. I do not know that there is anything, either in the parent Act or in this Bill, which would result in his being driven out of business if he is capable of dealing with minimum requirements in that way. If for some reason a curer has to go out of business and is compensated, if he has failed or has proved himself incapable of fulfilling minimum requirements in a particular locality, and if it seems desirable in the interests of pig production generally that his factory should be closed, I see grave difficulties in the way of adopting the suggestion which Deputy Gibbons has put forward. I do not know that you could get somebody in that locality to carry on the factory if it is incapable of coming up to the minimum requirements and the producers' pigs must be sold somewhere. I, as I say, have not had the advantage of hearing the Minister's opening statement, but I hope to hear the provisions of the Bill explained in more detail on the Committee Stage. Meanwhile I would appeal to members of the House on both sides that they should try to get away from vilifying anybody concerned in this trade. I do not want to glorify them either, but I think it is bad for the trade generally and it is not likely to inspire confidence amongst producers if Deputies here spend the best part of their time in stating that pig buyers and bacon curers have been dishonest in their dealings with producers.

Comment on this

There are a few points that as an outsider, and at the same time as a Deputy representing a county interested in pig production, I should like to put before the Minister, covering some of the views I have heard expressed in the course of the last 12 or 18 months. As regards the suggestion made by Deputy Gibbons, I gathered from the opening statement of the Minister that one of the attractions, from the strictly economic point of view, is that the larger the firm is and the more pigs it handles, the more economically the work can be done. If that is one of the purposes—and I take it it is; otherwise I cannot understand the Minister's referring to the matter in his opening statement—I do not see how Deputy Gibbons' suggestion fits in with the purpose of the Minister. I think, undoubtedly, although there is no provision in this particular Bill for driving certain people, namely, the minor curers out of the trade, one of the things envisaged in the Bill will have that result.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am asking everybody why?

Comment on this

That is exactly like some of the arguments we heard last night from the President, that he was not doing certain things, but that he made certain things possible.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Would the Deputy like me to argue it?

Comment on this

The Minister had many questions put to him and he answered some of them. There were some questions, however, very deliberately put, in regard to which the Minister preserved an extraordinarily stony silence.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What were they?

Comment on this

There was first of all a refusal on his part to guarantee a quota.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is guaranteed.

Comment on this

Then the Minister said that the licence is guaranteed.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

So it is.

Comment on this

The next point was whether the Minister had any information about the profits made by the curers in this particular instance.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Nothing but the ordinary information.

Comment on this

Do I understand that the Minister knows nothing about their profits?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is being inquired into by another body.

Comment on this

And the Minister refuses to answer the question?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I have answered it. I have only the ordinary information.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us any particulars——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would have to go back on the papers to get it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us some indication of the profits made at the present moment? A number of people are interested.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

And I told the Deputy that I have no such information.

Comment on this

And you have not tried to get it?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, because the Prices Tribunal are inquiring into it.

Comment on this

You can give no indication as to the profits that are being made?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

That was a point the Minister deliberately refrained from answering. I say "deliberately" because of the attitude he adopted, looking up at the pictures on the wall, the best possible imitation of a sphinx that has ever been given in this House. Now I understand that he has not the information. I move to report progress.

Comment on this