We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1937—Committee (Resumed.)

Contributions 1–132 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 8 of 1937 ›

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

Oh, yes. The Minister has not replied to it yet as far as I know. Is the Minister going to make any reply to the arguments advanced?

Comment on this

It is very hard to deal with the Opposition——

Comment on this

This may be very interesting but we cannot hear a word the Minister says.

Comment on this

——when they put down vexatious amendments in this House and then, when the amendments are being discussed, walk out of the House. Deputy Costello was not here when I replied last night. I replied after Deputy Mulcahy had spoken.

Comment on this

I was not here and did not know that.

Comment on this

I had intended to say something on this amendment with reference to a statement which was made last night by Deputy Dillon, to which I think it is essential I should take the earliest opportunity of calling the attention of the Dáil. In the course of my reply to a speech which was made by Deputy Costello and Deputy Mulcahy on this amendment last night I said:

"I said then"

—that was with reference to an amendment which Deputy Costello had down last year—

"and I say now, that I know of no case of hardship occasioned by Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1935 and I challenge any Deputy opposite, if he does not want to give me the name of an individual here, to give it to me in confidence and I shall ask the Revenue Commissioners to investigate the case."

I think it is necessary to direct your attention to the fact that I only undertook that, if a case of alleged hardship were submitted to me, I should ask the Revenue Commissioners to investigate it. When Deputy Dillon rose after I sat down he said:

"The Minister in the course of his observations has said that if he was given a case of a named person in confidence he would refer it to the Revenue Commissioners for investigation and report."

The Deputy then went on to say:

"To me that raises a very interesting question. Are the Revenue Commissioners free to report to the Minister personally on private income affairs which they learn in confidence."

I drew the attention of the Deputy— I do not propose to repeat what I said—to the fact that he was grossly misrepresenting me and Deputy Dillon went on to say this:

"There is a statutory obligation on the Revenue Commissioners to preserve the confidences they receive in the case of individual citizen's income returns. There is no such statutory obligation on me and I think it would be a very unfortunate thing if even on the obiter dictum of so irresponsible a man as the Minister for Finance, any doubt were cast upon the integrity of the Revenue Commissioners.”

I think Deputy Dillon's observations last night were scandalous in the extreme and were in the extreme unfair. First of all, he attributes to me a statement which I did not make and then on foot of that statement— which I repeat I did not make—he charges me with having made an irresponsible statement which, in fact, would cast a doubt upon the integrity of the Revenue Commissioners. If Deputy Dillon were in his place I should expect him to have the grace to withdraw the allegation which he made last night. I said then, and I say again, that if a case of alleged hardship were submitted to me, I should ask the Revenue Commissioners to investigate it. I would not ask that they should make any report to me as to the particular circumstances of any individual.

But the whole case for this amendment has been based on one thing, and one thing only—that cases of alleged hardship have been brought to the notice of Deputy Costello. I said to Deputy Costello here last night and I say to him here to-day that if there is any case of alleged hardship brought to my notice, I shall have it investigated. It is not the purpose of this section to cause hardship. The purpose of this section is to deal fairly with all taxpayers.

I see Deputy Dillon in the House now and I would draw his attention to the typescript of the report of my speech last night. I tell the Deputy that he grossly misrepresented what I said last night. When I ask the Revenue Commissioners to investigate for me, I do not, no matter how irresponsible he considers me, undertake that I shall put any strain on the integrity of the Revenue Commissioners. I have been very careful always in regard to that matter. I never once approached them to report to me on any individual case unless I had the permission of the income-tax payer who alleged that he had a grievance. In such a case I would ask the Revenue Commissioners to examine the case and, if necessary, to make a report as to the circumstances. I, however, am the person who is responsible to this House for the fairness and the equity of the revenue laws and accordingly, because I take the responsibility seriously, I am prepared to refer a case of alleged hardship, if it is submitted to me, to the Revenue Commissioners and ask them to investigate it. I am not going to ask them to report as to the particular circumstances unless I have the permission of the individual concerned. I am not going to ask them to violate the confidence which should naturally enshroud the private affairs of an individual when he is dealing with such an important body as the Revenue Commissioners.

I again say that I did not say last night, and I have never said, anything in this House which would justify the accusation which Deputy Dillon levelled against me. I do not think that is going to worry Deputy Dillon. We have heard him here time after time in this Dáil make statements as wild and as unfounded as the allegation which he levelled against me last night. He has charged Ministers with corruption. He has charged private individuals with corruption. On Friday last, as I say, he alleged an attempt had been made to blackmail and coerce him into taking certain action in regard to a board established under one of the statutes of this House. The public who read the report of what I said last night and of what Deputy Dillon said, will now have a touchstone by which to gauge the trustworthiness of any statements that may emanate from Deputy Dillon in future.

Comment on this

Listening to the Minister's arguments it seems to me that he is answering a case that was never made.

Comment on this

A not infrequent occurrence.

Comment on this

Last night he said that Deputy Dillon was out to produce a privileged class of the community. The Minister has also offered that if any case of hardship is brought to the notice of the Revenue Commissioners it will be investigated and presumably remedied. I am not in Deputy Costello's confidence, but I should be greatly surprised if he could point out anybody who, having received a demand for the five-fourths Schedule A, income-tax, is now in receipt of home assistance. I think it is most unlikely that any such case as that has been brought forward. That is not the case which was made from this side of the House. What we said was that after people had been induced to invest their money in a class of property from which they were led to believe, by making certain calculations, that they would receive a certain return, the dice was then loaded against them by Government action. That is the charge we are making, and the Minister has carefully refrained from answering it. Perhaps it has not been put with sufficient force from this side of the House, and lest the Minister has not fully understood the case we are making I should like again to urge upon him that that is our complaint.

What would be thought of a commercial concern which had put out a prospectus for a certain return on an investment if it were subsequently found that it had altered the terms of the yield for the investor? I suppose it would be said that they were obtaining money under false pretences. I do not suggest that the Government are exactly obtaining money under false pretences, but people were induced to invest money in buying their own houses, and remember that the Government ought to be anxious for as many of the community as possible to own their own houses and feel a sense of responsibility. Are the Government and the municipalities to be the only landlords in this State? Considerations of thrift and everything else enter into it. To sum up the charge which has been made from this side, it is that the conditions on which the investor was induced to purchase his house have been altered, by Government action, to his detriment. The investors who purchased their own houses would not have made that investment if they had known what was coming in the legislation. That is the charge we are making on this side. I listened very carefully to the Minister, but to my mind he made no reply to that case.

Comment on this

The Minister has referred to the amendment down in my name and the name of Deputy General Mulcahy as a vexatious amendment. His constituents will be interested to hear that. He also went on to say that I left this House before he replied. I left this House, and I am back in this House, but he has not yet replied to the arguments that were put up. He did not reply last night. He spoke, but he did not reply to the arguments put forward in support of the amendment, as Deputy Dockrell has pointed out.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello does not know whether I did or not.

Comment on this

I was in the House.

Comment on this

I will deal with Deputy Dockrell in due course——

Comment on this

The Minister can deal with me afterwards, when I sit down.

Comment on this

——but I am dealing now with the assertion, made by a gentleman who was not present, that I did not reply.

Comment on this

Again I repeat that, whether I was present or whether I was not present, the Minister did not reply to the case made for this amendment here in this House last night. The fact that the Minister, for want of an argument, is reduced to the position where he can say nothing else than that the amendment is a vexatious amendment, is a condemnation of the Minister's attitude in reference to this matter, and a complete justification of our attitude in putting down this amendment. I am speaking from actual cases. The Minister says grandiloquently that he will ask the Revenue Commissioners to investigate and report on any case of alleged hardship. I am not interested in whether or not any aspersions have been cast on the tender feelings of the Revenue Commissioners. The Revenue Commissioners' feelings are extraordinarily tender. We have the tenderness of their feelings demonstrated in practically every Act we pass. I am not interested in their feelings. I am interested in the taxpayer, for whose very tender feelings the Revenue Commissioners have no feelings whatever, whether he is suffering any hardship or not.

I should like if the Minister would think it worth while to answer this point: What authority have the Revenue Commissioners to investigate any case of alleged hardship? The Revenue Commissioners are a body whose duty it is to administer the law, not to say whether the application of the law or the administration of the law causes any hardships. That is not their function as I understand it, and I should certainly be interested if the Minister would give me any reference to show where the Revenue Commissioners are authorised by law to investigate hardships caused by the existing statutory law which they are bound by law to administer and carry out. I want to know, if I furnish the Minister with information in cases of hardship, whether the Revenue Commissioners are to be the judges as to whether or not hardship has been caused in the administration of an Act? Where is the statutory authority for that? The Revenue Commissioners' duty is to assess in accordance with the law as laid down in this section which we desire to amend. Their duty is to collect the 25 per cent. additional, and not to consider what consequences flow from the imposition of that additional tax.

I want the Minister to say if he can give any justification whatever for this additional 25 per cent. tax. I stated last night that this was a tax on a limited class. Taxation on a limited class is quite unjustifiable. As Deputy Dockrell pointed out last night, when introduced there was an endeavour to justify it on the grounds that there was going to be a revaluation of property. Even on that ground it could not be justified. Taking it even on that ground of valuation, this is a flat rate of 25 per cent. Revaluation can only be justified on the basis that existing valuations are not in accordance with proper principles—that some houses are valued too high and that some are valued too low. Whether some houses are valued too high and some houses are valued too low, this tax has been imposed on everybody, irrespective of whether the poor law valuation of their premises has been assessed on a proper basis or not. The case I made was on behalf of small property owners and people who purchased their own houses on the assumption that the poor law valuation was a certain thing. Anybody who has any experience of the purchase and sale of houses knows that one of the matters which are considered in connection with the purchase price of a house is the poor law valuation. Money passed, houses were bought and sold, on the assumption that the poor law valuation was not going to be disturbed except in accordance with law, and that income-tax was going to be assessed only in the ordinary way in which it has been assessed, levied and collected for years past.

Suddenly the Minister comes along —having, as I said last night, taken away the one-sixth allowance for repairs which was allowed for years until the Minister took charge of the Department of Finance—and imposes this entirely artificial burden. I ask the Minister for Finance is he prepared to give complete relief in respect of this to those people of small valuations who have purchased their own holdings— small property owners who are living out of the income that they derive from letting those houses which are subject to the restrictions imposed by the Rent Restrictions Act. Those owners of property cannot, under the Rent Restrictions Act, increase the rent charged to their tenants, but the Minister comes in to increase the burdens which they have to bear and the outgoings which they have to pay. They have no method of recouping themselves for that. There is no method that I know of by which that hardship can be got over.

It is no use for the Minister to come here with these grandiloquent phrases. We have got enough of these in other directions. There is no use in saying that the Revenue Commissioners will investigate alleged cases of hardship. That is not their function or duty, nor have they any right to investigate alleged cases of hardship. I do not intend to let the Minister get away with that. Is the Minister prepared to give relief in the three cases I mentioned—cases of low valuation, cases where persons have purchased their own houses with the intention of living in them before this tax was imposed and the case of people who have purchased property on the strength of the existing valuation, with no idea that the valuation of the premises would be artificially increased for one purpose and one purpose only, the imposition of a special tax on a limited class of people? Can the Minister advance any argument for his action other than the use of this grandiloquent phrase that the Revenue Commissioners will investigate cases of alleged hardship? It is no answer to my case to say that this is a vexatious amendment or that it has been put down for property owners. It is put down for property owners and it is no justification for injustice or hardship for the Minister to sneer at property owners. Can he make any case for the continued imposition of this tax other than the mere collection of taxation by artificial means from a limited class?

Comment on this

Deputy Costello is evidently a believer in the confusing effect of loud noise. We have heard a speech from him full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. The reason Deputy Costello delivered that speech was in order to evade the obligation which rests upon him of submitting to me for investigation instances of alleged hardship upon which, in his speech last night as in his speech a year ago, he rested the case for this amendment. Twelve months ago, the Deputy ran away from that challenge.

Comment on this

Then it was a challenge?

Comment on this

To-day, he has continued his strategic retreat. I say that, according to the Revenue Commissioners, this section of the 1935 Act has wrought no hardship and has not worked inequitably. Deputy Dockrell took it upon himself to deliver a homily to the Minister because he had not answered his case and he said that he stayed in the House as I was speaking on the matter. I have here the Official Report of what I said:

"We have been told in this debate that Deputy Costello——"

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Official Report of last night's proceedings yet available? If it is, I have not received a copy.

Comment on this

The Deputy can get a typescript copy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Official Report is not yet available and the typescript is not, of course, conclusive evidence.

Comment on this

I am quite certain that any Deputy sufficiently interested would be able to get a typed copy.

Comment on this

I understand that it is a rule of order that a typescript, secured by courtesy of the reporting staff, may not be used in the House for the purpose of quotation. It may be used as a note to help a Deputy to frame his observations, but not for quotation. If the typescript of the Report is to be used in this way, it is going to give rise to very serious difficulty.

Comment on this

I shall use this typescript to refresh my memory. I am not submitting it as the Official Report, but I do not suppose that any fair-minded Deputy will allege that my memory, as refreshed by this note, is not reliable. This is what I said:

"That was the purport of Deputy Mulcahy's speech. That was the end to which Deputy Costello's effort was directed. We have been told in this debate that Deputy Costello was moved to put down this amendment because of the hardships which Section 3 of the Finance Act, 1935, had inflicted upon certain individuals. Now, the Revenue Commissioners deal with all classes of income-tax payers. The case of every income-tax payer comes under the notice of the Revenue Commissioners' staff and of their inspectors, and the Revenue Commissioners tell me that not a single case has come under their notice in which the section has worked inequitably—that is to say, not one case in which the actual net income taking one year with another, derived from house property, or which, if the property were let, would be derived, fell short of the Schedule A assessment, calculated in the manner required by Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1935, the section which it is proposed to repeal."

To the best of my recollection, as refreshed by this note, that is the statement I made last night. Yet, Deputy Dockrell has charged me to-day with misrepresenting the reply I made last night. Deputy Costello says I did not reply at all. Deputy Dillon went further and, as I have already told the House, put words in my mouth which I did not use at all. Is there any sense of fairness or fair play in the Opposition? Have they any regard for the virtue of truth since they are reduced to resorting to the tactics which I have detailed to the House? How can we be expected to deal seriously with them? I shall try to deal with some of the arguments used by Deputy Dockrell and I shall try to show him where they lead.

The Deputy's case for this amendment, and against the section, is based on this ground: that when people bought certain property, they expected the charges upon that property would be a certain amount and assumed, in their wisdom, that they would never be more. Then, he went on to ask what would be thought of a company which issued a prospectus and subsequently departed from the terms of that prospectus. Surely, the Deputy, as an intelligent business man, must realise that there is no true analogy between the two cases. What position would the Government, or even the Corporation of Dublin be placed in, if they were to accept Deputy Dockrell's principle? We could not revalue these houses because, if they were revalued, it is quite likely there would be an increase in the tax charges upon them. If we are to assume, according to Deputy Dockrell's argument, that the charges borne by property at the date of purchase should remain fixed for all time, we could not come in and increase the rate of income-tax. The Corporation of Dublin could not vary its rates one year with another. Is not that the case Deputy Dockrell has made for this amendment?

Comment on this

Is not the whole case he has made that, when certain property was purchased, it had to bear a certain amount in respect of income-tax and that, when that amount was increased, the Government was breaking a bargain with the purchaser of the property. The Deputy knows that there is no such thing as a contract between the Government and the purchaser or vendor of property. Does not that show the shallow basis on which this amendment is put forward?

What is the basic principle underlying the income-tax code? It is that a person will be taxed according to his true income, whether he derives that income out of the profits of a business, the practice of a profession or as remuneration for services rendered as an employee. Deputy Costello has tried to becloud the whole issue by dragging in a lot of extraneous factors, but there is one thing clear, and there is one thing generally admitted, and that is that of all tax systems, provided that due allowance is made for the circumstances of the individual taxpayer, and the tax code is so designed as to give a fair grading —the income-tax is possibly the fairest and most equitable because people are taxed upon their true incomes, upon their real capacity to pay.

Comment on this

But not upon the five-fourths of their true income.

Comment on this

That just betrays the lack of knowledge and the absence of logic which is characteristic of the whole attitude of the Opposition. May I take the Deputy over the ground again? The basic principle of the income-tax code is that the tax will be levied on the true income of the person. I have cited cases time after time in this House to show that, in fact, the true income derived from and enjoyed by the owner of house property, in the generality of cases and, I would say, universally, so far as our country is concerned, exceeds the valuation which, for poor law purposes, was placed upon the property. Now, the question at issue here is whether you will tax a person upon the real and true income he derives from the property, or whether you will tax him upon a much lesser amount, upon the notional value placed on the property many years ago, or upon the bulk of property many years ago, to which the valuations made upon new properties to-day are related? If you are going to be consistent and to give effect to what is the true principle of the income-tax code, that is, that the taxpayer should be taxed according to his real income, you have no justification whatever for taxing him according to the notional income which is represented by the poor law valuation of the property. In the case of the notional income, based on the poor law valuation, the amount of tax he will pay will be too low and if one taxpayer pays less than he would be called upon to pay if he were taxed upon his true income, then you are giving that taxpayer a privilege and a concession at the expense of the general body of taxpayers and you are treating the general body of taxpayers unfairly as compared with him. You are treating him inequitably. You are letting him off with a much lighter burden of tax that he ought to pay.

The whole plea that has been made in favour of this amendment from the opposite benches is that, just as in the case of the stallion owners, we ought to make them a privileged class in the community, so, too, in the case of the property owners, we ought to constitute them a privileged class. We can only do that, and I make this statement with special reference to the speech of Deputy Mulcahy last night, at the expense, not merely of the remainder of the body of direct taxpayers who are not fortunate enough to own property, but also at the expense of the general body of indirect taxpayers, of the poor man about whom Deputy Mulcahy talks so glibly here, and who, according to him, has to pay a tax on his table, on his boots, on his clothes, on his sugar and on his tea.

Comment on this

And his windows, and his wallpaper, and his oilcloth.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy's purpose in this amendment is to increase the tax upon that poor man in order to relieve that small section of the taxpayers who are fortunate enough to own property and to derive an income from it.

Comment on this

I wonder that the Minister for Industry and Commerce did not spring from his slumbers when he heard the Minister for Finance describe his protective tariffs as taxes. This debate has dragged out a great deal of useful information. I welcome the earnest disclaimer by the Minister for Finance of any desire to pry into confidential matters——

Comment on this

That statement is characteristic of Deputy Dillon. First, he concocts a lie——

Comment on this

The Minister has not allowed me to proceed.

Comment on this

——and then he gives currency to it.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to say that the Deputy concocted a lie?

Comment on this

We will not quarrel about it.

Comment on this

The records of the House would convict the Deputy.

Comment on this

I rejoice to hear that the Minister and I are in entire agreement as to what are the obligations devolving on the Revenue Commissioners in regard to secrecy and confidence, and I rejoice that the Minister has given to his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the well-deserved rebuke of pointing out to him that many of the sky-high tariffs he has imposed operate as a cruel tax burden upon the people. The Minister for Finance feels that he must put 25 per cent. extra on the property owner, lest the savage rapacity of his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce would be further inflamed to scourge the backs of the very poor to a greater extent than he already has.

The Minister first says that to ask exemption from this 25 per cent. impost is to ask for the creation of a privileged class. Far from it. It is a request that there should not be a victimised class in the community. Would the Minister think it a justinable application of the income-tax code to provide to-morrow that income derived from preference shares or fixed interest bearing securities would be deemed to be five-fourths of their true value for the purpose of income-tax, while income derived from ordinary shares or equities would be taxed on their actual value, because surely that is the position?

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks that is the position, there is no use arguing with him.

Comment on this

There are certain classes of people in this country, and in every other country, who prefer a small yield for perfect security. They measure what they expect their expenses to be in their later years, and they invest their savings in debentures, in preference stocks and in house property. They measure very carefully to get the last penny they can out of whatever slender assets they have. Is it right that you should go to those people and say, "Despite your careful reckoning in respect of these fixed interest securities which yield you a certain income, we are going to upset the reckoning. Although we know that you could have got a bigger income by putting your money into ordinary securities, which are subject to wide fluctuations, and that you deliberately sacrificed that greater income for the security to be derived from preference shares and house property, we propose to take that security from you by introducing a new peril into investment, that is, the particular whim of an individual Minister for Finance who will not hesitate to segregate one restricted class in the community and tax them on a fictitious valuation of their incomes." The Minister says this is not a fictitious valuation of income; on the contrary, the valuation is itself a fictitious representation of income, and the five-fourths valuation much more closely approximates to the true income than does the valuation itself. The Minister, however, has forgotten that most house property of the kind affected by this legislation changes hands, particularly amongst people who hold houses and desire to derive an income from the rents. The person who invested his money, say, four years ago, was told by the house agent, "This is a house with a valuation of £15, but the rent is £25." Of course, if the rent were only £15, the house for your purpose would be worth very much less than it is.

Here is a house, the rent of which is substantially in excess of the valuation, and it is, therefore, worth more money. The investor who had a couple of thousand pounds to put into house property turned that proposition over in his mind, and, estimating the valuation and the rent that should be derived from the property, paid an extra sum four years ago for that house, because, as the Minister has very properly said, the fundamental rule of the income-tax code is that it should be applied to all equally, in accordance with their real incomes. That person's real income from that house was £25 a year, and the rule of the income-tax law had been, and presumably was going to go on being, based on the valuation; whereupon the purchaser paid more for the house than he otherwise would. Now, he is quite calmly told that his valuation for the purpose of income-tax is going to be increased in the Minister's mind—I emphasise these words, in the Minister's mind. He then goes to his tenant and says, "I want you either to accept this burden or at least to share it with me." He is informed by the statute law of this country that he cannot ask the tenant to do that. If he induces the tenant voluntarily to do it, at the end of ten, 15 or 20 years the tenant, by a process under the Rent Restrictions Act, can recover every penny of his contribution to that new burden. What equity is there in that?

The Minister's argument up to this has been an argument for revaluation. There may be an argument for revaluation. There may be an argument that the Commissioner of Valuation ought to be given a general warrant to revise valuations all over the country, or at least the valuation of house property. If such a revaluation did take place no reasonable tenant could object. It is right that houses should be correctly valued, because if they are not, from the point of view of municipal taxes, national taxes, and every other kind of levy based on valuation, one person is paying more than he ought to pay, and another person less than he ought to pay. But, to put 25 per cent. on house property necessarily means that you must do injustice, because we cannot accept the proposition that there is not a single house in the Free State which has been properly valued. If there is a single house which has been properly valued, must not this tax be inequitable?

Comment on this

I challenge the Deputy to produce that case.

Comment on this

The Minister admits that if there is a single house correctly valued, injustice accrues in that case. I take him on that. If there is one house which is correctly valued the Minister admits there is injustice here.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by correctly valued?

Comment on this

What did the Minister desire to do when he evolved this method of arriving at a true valuation of properties which are taxed under Schedule A?

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean when he says, "if there was one house correctly valued?" What is the standard?

Comment on this

We must help the Minister, because he stands in need of help. I can understand that under the leash of the Revenue Commissioners he is inclined to wince and, naturally, he will take the easiest way. Without intimidating or frightening him, we must encourage him to walk straight. What had the Minister in mind when he devised this plan of the five-fourths valuation? His plan was to bring the valuation of a house into line with some preconceived standard of valuation which, in his mind, and in the mind of the commissioner, was an equitable standard. The proper way to go about that was not to put on a flat increase, but to ask the Commissioner of Valuation to revalue the property. When this change in the revenue law was made doubtless houses in this country fell into three classes—those which were too highly valued, those which were correctly valued, and those which were valued too low. The Minister says his object was to get at the houses that were valued too low. What he did was to get at all three classes. If the three classes are equal, he has done two injustices for every justice. If the vast majority of houses were undervalued, he has done as much injustice as he has done justice. But, whatever way you approach his plan, unless you approach it on the assumption that every house in incorrectly valued, substantial injustice has been done.

It must be borne in mind that a great many houses were valued comparatively recently. This House has no reason to imagine that the Commissioners of Valuation fell down on their job. Obviously the method employed by the Minister was an easy method, an expeditious method, but it is not a just method. On the Minister's admission, if one single house was correctly valued before this provision was brought in then injustice exists. The Minister has indicated that if he is satisfied that injustices have arisen out of the operation of this provision he will consider a proposal to revise it. On his own argument, must there not be cases of injustice? If that is so, is he prepared to accept the amendment standing in the name of Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

There are two points to which I wish to direct attention, not that I wish to waste either my time or Deputies' time in replying to alleged arguments of the Minister, because they are not worth replying to. He, presumably, thought it would hurt my feelings if he would not answer my arguments, but I have a very strong hide, and I am capable of putting up with much more hard insults than the Minister, even with his vituperative tongue, can produce. But I wish to put on record two points in reply to the statements made by the Minister in answer to Deputy Dockrell. The Minister said that the Revenue Commissioners had not heard of any single case of hardship. I would be amazed to think that the Revenue Commissioners had heard of any case of hardship arising out of this, because it is not their business. They would be wasting their time for which they are paid if they were looking after cases of hardship. It is no argument to say that Revenue Commissioners have heard of no case of hardship. I will go to this extent and say, that in every single instance where a taxpayer had to pay this additional unjustifiable burden there is hardship—Revenue Commissioners or no Revenue Commissioners. Except the Revenue Commissioners were wasting their time, for which they are paid, doing that, instead of collecting the taxes which it is their duty to collect, they could not investigate this matter. Suppose the taxpayer whose letter I have here wrote to the Revenue Commissioners and said: "There is a hardship caused to me in this case," the Revenue Commissioners would be bound to file it away and say, "That is not our business. We are here to carry out the law; the law is such; and until it is changed we have nothing to do with hardships—pay up."

I want to put this specific case of a man who has a house from which he received an income which is within the limits laid down by the Rent Restrictions Acts and who is dependent upon that income for his livelihood, partly or wholly. This additional tax is put on an artificial increase of the valuation of the property, thereby increasing, in fact, his outgoings, and thereby reducing his income. I want to ask the Minister (1) does he consider that a hardship; and (2)—to come to the second alleged point—does he consider that that man has been charged income-tax on his true rate of income? Does he believe in his own argument, that the income-tax code is based on taxing a person on his true income? Because, if he does, he must take this tax off. The true income of the man whose case I have put here is what he gets from the tenant. Under the Rent Restrictions Acts he is only allowed a certain income from that property. He is allowed to vary that with the increase in rates, if they go up; but he is not allowed to increase it by the amount of the increased artificial income-tax put on by this provision. Where is the principle of taxation on true income? He is taxed an additional 25 per cent. artificially on the same income that he is getting out of the property. Where is the principle of true income? If you test the argument of the Minister on the great principle upon which he says he is acting, that income-tax is a tax on true income, the argument falls to the ground and shows to what straits the Minister is reduced to answer any argument in this matter.

The Minister spoke about valuation in answer to Deputy Dockrell. Is the Oireachtas to be prevented from ever having a revaluation, or is the local authority ever to be prevented from getting rates? Certainly not. The Minister knows perfectly well that that is not at all analogous to the present case. What happened in this case is that the income is supposed to be taxed, whether it is the true income or otherwise. When the Minister first brought in this section in the Act of 1935, the income-tax on house property was based on the valuation. That was the rule of thumb method, but at all events it was the statutory method by which the income was measured. How was the valuation of premises supposed to be arrived at? By the letting value, the sum at which houses will let from year to year, taking one year with another. That is roughly the principle of the Valuation Acts. The valuation is on the income which is supposed to be got from the property. That is the principle upon which houses, whether new houses or old houses, were supposed to be valued. That was the principle upon which income-tax was extracted from property owners. The true income was represented by the valuation, and then an addition of 25 per cent. was artificially imposed and the Minister justifies that by saying, "We are only taxing the man's true income." That is demonstratively false. Then he tells us that we are making a case for the rich man. In 1935 his own Parliamentary Secretary asked: "Why should not the poor man be taxed?" He was taxed in 1935 before this five-fourths section was added, and he was taxed additionally by this new section in the Act of 1935.

Comment on this

I want to take up from the debris that has fallen down on him in this debate, the head of the family who is living in the home that he bought to shelter his family. At the time when this income-tax——

Comment on this

What was his income?

Comment on this

——on his home should be taken entirely off him— when we consider the great increase in the income-tax rate and the increase in other taxes that have fallen down on that unfortunate man —at the time when he should be relieved entirely of tax on his home, he finds the income-tax on his home increased artificially in this particular way. We heard a great lot of talk in this debate about the property owner, the property owner with a capital "P" and a capital "O." And this is the time when we are supposed to be discussing the family preservation, the family exaltation and the family as a unit of our social organisation and the special attention that should be given to it. We have been hearing about property rents. Now if there is any property which ought to be safeguarded from indiscriminate attacks it is the home, the house in which the man is rearing his family, the man of humble circumstances.

Comment on this

The man of humble circumstances?

Comment on this

The working class or middle class man who has bought his own home and who has been caught under the increased tax the Minister has imposed through the increased cost of living, finds himself now with his income-tax on his home increased by 25 per cent. The Minister has attempted in the course of his contribution to this debate to label the man who owns his home as "a property owner."

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me what he is?

Comment on this

I have told the Minister what he is. The Minister has complained of misrepresentation by Deputy Dillon and Deputy Costello. I want to be in on that misrepresentation too. I want to underline the fact that in speaking of a home owner like that, the Minister has intervened to obscure his case by labelling him as a property owner. That shows how much credit we can attach to the protestations of the Minister about his regard for the family and their property rights.

Comment on this

I am afraid I must again charge the Minister with having failed to answer the case that was made. I also think he was a little bit inconsistent because he reproached Deputy Costello with leaving the House and at the same time reproached me for remaining in the House. That is what I get for listening carefully to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not listen carefully to me.

Comment on this

The Minister refreshed his memory with some notes of last night's debates on the particular point on which I wished rather to refresh my memory. Fortunately, the Minister repeated what he said last night. He mentioned last night that it was Deputy Dillon who wished to create a privileged class. The Minister mentioned stallion owners and that we were out to create a privileged class amongst property owners. I want again to repeat that that quotation shows that the Minister has not yet grasped that we are making a case for property owners who have been deprived of something. The Minister makes a great case that these people are property owners and are very wealthy people. I suppose they range from people who are bordering on the wealthy down to the very humble people who have in a number of cases borrowed money from the bank or money from a building society or from some other source and invested that money in the purchase of the house in which they are living.

In my opinion the Minister has loaded the dice against these people. I instanced the case of an investor who invested money in a commercial concern, and then found that there had been some alterations in the conditions. The Minister made great play with that. He said: "What about income-tax rates, are we never to alter them?" He asked: "What about the local rates?" I would like to say that I never suggested that the terms upon which a person purchased a house meant that they did not have to take a risk of the rise or fall of certain of those items which went to make the whole cost of the house. The local rates may go up. As a matter of fact they have gone up. The Government may alter the income-tax but, as Deputy McGuire interjected, what the Minister had not a right to do was to make the fraction five-fourths and charge the man income-tax on that.

The case that was made for this class being attacked when the Minister altered the conditions in 1935 was that a revaluation was imminent. Now, apparently, the Minister has forgotten that and he says he has a perfect right to alter the fraction to five-fourths. Is there any reason why he should not alter it to six-fourths or seven-fourths or eight-fourths? That is a point that the Minister has not replied to. I would like to suggest to the Minister that he is altering the terms on which people invested in house property. If investors thought that this five-fourths was going to be followed by six-fourths and further increases, there would be a landslide in house property. At the present time, with houses so scarce, the Minister surely is most anxious that all the investors who can be brought in, small or large, to carry the burden of building houses and owning them, ought to be encouraged. That is the reason for the proposal in this amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister's main case for this imposition is that the house property in this country is undervalued. Now, in the case of the City of Dublin a general revaluation took place some 20 years ago and the increase in the valuation amounted to somewhere about 10 or 12 per cent. Examining what the Minister has done with regard to income-tax on house property, we find that he removed the one-sixth which was a concession the people had until he commenced to interfere with it. With the one-sixth the house valued for £12 was assessed at £10. By reason of the five-fourths the house formerly assessed for £10 on a valuation of £12 is being assessed for income-tax at £15, so that the Minister has put up the income-tax assessment by 50 per cent. Let me repeat that in the case of the revaluation of Dublin, to which I have referred, the actual increase all over was somewhere between 10 and 12 per cent.

It might be well, not alone for Deputies here, but for people outside to watch with very great care the possibility of a revaluation of property. The whole idea is to get as much income-tax as possible out of the property of this country. Within the last 15 or 20 years very large rebuilding took place in the two principal cities in this country, Cork and Dublin. In the case of Cork the valuations were increased enormously. Houses that were formerly valued at £80, say, were increased to £200, £300 or £400. Is there a hardship in those cases? In this particular clause which it is now proposed to repeal, exception was made in the case of one borough, the Borough of Waterford. The extra valuation of the property which was destroyed in Dublin or Cork would probably have exceeded the whole value of the City of Waterford.

The question really at issue is whether or not it is fair in all the circumstances to assess certain people at 6/9 in the £ instead of the 4/6 that other people are being charged. That is the essence of this particular imposition. If there are small property owners, who, by reason of this tax which was imposed in 1935, are paying 6/9, I think the Minister ought in justice to them make some case as to why he is charging them 6/9 in the £ while other people, who are either earning £1,000 a year or drawing incomes at £1,490 a year, are charged only 4/6 in the £. There was at one time—I do not know whether it prevails now or not—a general view that if the rent of a house exceeded the valuation by 50 per cent., it was supposed to be a rack-rent. I presume it is on some such lines that the Minister is justifying this particular imposition.

A man is assessed in the normal course upon his income and one takes some time to appraise the value of the Minister's statement that the income-tax code is on a fair basis. Where did he get it? This income-tax code came from Great Britain. They left it here. The Minister is not one of those who would charge the British with either justice, mercy or consideration for the people of this country, or fair dealing. But that is what they left. They left an income-tax code that allowed one-sixth off. In fact, so far as they are concerned, comparing them with the Minister, the Minister is charging on house property 50 per cent. more than they did. They had a basis upon which they based their whole income-tax code.

It was held apparently with such conviction by those people whom we used to charge with injustice, and whom the Minister delights in referring to as unjust administrators—they were so convinced with the difference in conditions as between this country and Great Britain that they allowed this particular exemption. That is what the Minister inherited, but he has changed it, and his only case for changing it is that this is a privileged class. It is no such thing. A house may be assessed at the present moment for £12, let us say. The Minister will collect that tax in the year in which the house falls. A normal income-tax payer only pays upon the income he receives, but the Minister will charge it in that particular case. I must say I never heard such an explanation as that the Revenue Commissioners or the Minister will consider cases of hardship. The Minister does not hear them and it is not the business of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

I am a better judge of what the Revenue Commissioners' business is than the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have had a longer experience of that than the Minister, and the Minister will scarcely have as long an experience as I have had.

Comment on this

The Deputy, when he had the opportunity of gaining experience, did not take his duties very seriously.

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion, and it is one in which I would weigh the Minister's opinion very lightly.

Comment on this

It is a matter of more than opinion with some people.

Comment on this

This is a proposal that came up before in a previous Parliament. I was the single member of the Executive Council who was opposed to it. I was left in the extraordinary position of having to defend it here when the Seanad refused to accept it. There was a Parliament here at that time which supported me with a very considerable majority.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say which particular proposal he is referring to?

Comment on this

The proposal to take off the one-sixth.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking upon another motion.

Comment on this

I am not going to let the Minister away with the two loads. This refers to the five-fourths. The Minister previously took off the one-sixth. The Parliament here then was not a tied Parliament. The people in it were not afraid to express their opinions, and even though there was a Party vote that day Parliament rejected the proposal.

Comment on this

We are not discussing that proposal now.

Comment on this

That was in the year 1924. This is the year 1937. The reason for this particular imposition, pure and simple, is this: that the Minister was short £60,000 to balance his Budget He asked the Revenue Commissioners what is the easiest method of getting it, and they told him. This is his proposal, and that is the whole justice of it from beginning to end.

Comment on this

I am sorry to have to rise again, but I must after the speech to which we have just listened. We were supposed to be discussing an amendment to annul Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1935. That is an amendment which provides that Schedule A assessment on house property will be based on five-fourths of the valuation. Deputy Cosgrave has devoted most of his speech to quite a different aspect of the income-tax code governing Schedule A assessments. However, it is not my business to do more than draw the attention of the House to that fact. I would, however, like again to draw attention to the tactics which have been pursued by the Opposition in the course of this debate. At the beginning of the proceedings to-day I had occasion to put on record the fact that last night Deputy Dillon deliberately invented and put into my mouth words which I did not use in order that he might be able, by misrepresenting me, to bolster up a bad case. I had occasion also last night to call attention to the fact that the Opposition was seriously divided in the views which it expressed as to what was in order and also in relation to matters of greater public concern than that.

Deputy Dillon, who preceded Deputy Cosgrave, when speaking to the amendment, urged that the right way to deal with this anomaly was by having a revaluation of house property. Deputy Dillon, I think, is the deputy Leader of the Opposition. The titular Leader of the Opposition comes in now and warns the public to watch the idea of a revaluation of property. Deputy Dillon wants a revaluation of property. Deputy Cosgrave, apparently, is opposed to a revaluation of property. Not for the first time has the Opposition been divided against itself, but there is one thing upon which the Opposition is agreed, and that is, when they are short of facts to substantiate a case "then let us invent them to suit our case."

I said, in the course of my reply to Deputy Dockrell, that income-tax was a fair and equitable tax provided it were levied on the true income of the taxpayer. Deputy Cosgrave gets up and alleges that I said that the income-tax code was a fair one. There is a world of difference between the two statements. One of the reasons why we deprived the property owner of the allowance which he was getting twice over when he was getting that additional allowance of one-sixth for repairs, is that we were trying to make the property owner pay upon a basis of assessment which will be more nearly approximate to the true income which he derives from his property, and to make the income-tax code which we have inherited from the British a fairer code in this country. Now, income-tax is a fair tax, but if the code, to the extent to which it governs the assessment and collection of the tax is anomalous and inequitable as between individual taxpayers, to that extent the tax tends to become an unfair one. We are trying to remove the inequities and to make the income-tax code in this country a fairer one than that which we inherited from the British.

I do not know whether I should deal first with Deputy Dillon or with Deputy Mulcahy, but as Deputy Dillon is absent from the House possibly I may deal with Deputy Mulcahy first. Deputy Mulcahy got up here and said that he wanted to speak for this forgotten man: for this lowly individual hidden under the debris which had accumulated in this debate—I presume that when he referred to the debris he meant to refer to the broken arguments of the Opposition. He said that he was going to speak for the man in the humble circumstances. I asked him would he be good enough to particularise the circumstances which, in his view, might be truly described as humble. Just as Deputy Costello refused to cite one instance of the alleged hardships which had been brought under his notice, Deputy Mulcahy ran away from the obligation of defining what in his view were humble circumstances.

But, let us take the case of a man who might be described as being in humble circumstances, and consider how he is, in fact, affected by this Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1935 I notice that Deputy Mulcahy is not worried about, and does not want to listen to, this example, because if Deputy Mulcahy were to have a specific case put before him it might embarrass him, but I do not think it would prevent him from getting up here and treating the House to the same sort of hypocritical misrepresentation of the true position as we had to listen to from him last night and to-day. However, whether he listens or not——

Comment on this

I am listening.

Comment on this

We shall take the case of a married man with a salary of £360 per annum. He is a father with two children. I do not know whether that person would be described as being in humble circumstances or not by Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

He would have his difficulties, I can tell the Minister.

Comment on this

I am sure he would if Deputy Mulcahy was sitting here on these benches and I was sitting as I used to over there.

Comment on this

The Minister will be over here soon enough.

Comment on this

Of course, I anticipate that one day I shall be over there, but I hope that when I am in Opposition I shall have learnt more than the present Opposition appear to have learned when they were in office, and I shall, when we come to discuss these matters, discuss them with some modicum of knowledge to back my arguments. I was dealing with the case of a married man, with two children, in receipt of a salary of £360 per annum. He owns a house, and since he is in humble circumstances, I suppose that even Deputy Mulcahy would admit the house could not possibly be a very large one. But, at any rate, it is a house with a poor law valuation of £20. It is not too uncomfortable a habitation for a man in humble circumstances. Under the existing income-tax code, after applying this fraction of five-fourths, the total income of that man would be £360, plus £20, the poor law valuation of his house, and plus £5 the additional one-fourth added for income-tax purposes under Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1935. Therefore, his total income would be £385. Now, against that total income in the year 1937-38—the present year—there would be earned income relief, marriage allowance, and children's allowances, totalling £405.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners send him £20 to make it right.

Comment on this

It is quite possible that Deputy Cosgrave may have that notion in his head, because, judging by some of the statements he has made here, I would not put it beyond the bounds of possibility that he should know so little about the income-tax code as to believe that, in that event, the Revenue Commissioners would hand this gentleman out an additional £20. In any event, however, the position is that his total income, for income-tax purposes, amounts to £385, and the amount of allowances to which he is entitled under the income-tax code, as amended since 1932, comes to £405. Therefore, in the year 1937-38, that man, in humble circumstances, that poor, honest John Citizen, would pay nothing. He would pay no income-tax.

Comment on this

Would the Minister allow me to ask him a question?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is going to ask me what that man would have paid in 1931-32, I am quite willing to tell him. I am quite willing to tell the Deputy that the man who owns a house with a poor law valuation of £20, who has an income of £360, and who is a married man with two children, would have paid, under Deputy Cosgrave's administration, £4 18s. 0d. in 1931-32, whereas now he would pay nothing. Deputy Mulcahy is full of concern to-day for the man in humble circumstances—the man from whom the then Minister for Finance, in the Cabinet of which Deputy Mulcahy was a member, extracted £4 18s. 0d. However, Sir, supposing we consider the case of another man—let us say the case of a married man with three children——

Comment on this

Why not discuss Donal Buckley's pension?

Comment on this

——or Deputy Mulcahy, if we are talking about pensions.

Comment on this

Discuss Mr. Donal Buckley's case.

Comment on this

Other pensions could be discussed also.

Comment on this

It might be desirable to discuss some of them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The point is that none of them is in order at present.

Comment on this

As I was saying, Sir, let us take the case of a married man with three children, who has an income of £420, and who, again, owns a house of a poor law valuation of £20. His circumstances are not so humble as those of the previous case I mentioned, if we are to appraise them by the income he earns. Under the existing income-tax code, his assessable income would be £445, but against that, again on account of the increases that we have granted in respect of the earned income relief and children's allowances, he would be entitled to allowances amounting to £475, and he will pay no income-tax in 1937-38; but in 1931-32, this man, in circumstances not so humble as the other man, would have paid £7 5s. 3d. to Deputy Cosgrave's administration. Now, I think I have disposed adequately of all this cant that the Opposition are putting forward to the effect that, in this amendment, they are fighting the battle of the man in humble circumstances. The fact of the matter is that they are fighting the battle of the big property owner, and they know it. They are fighting to confer upon the big property owners an exemption from income-tax at the expense of the general body of the ratepayers.

Let me pursue this matter a little further. It is extraordinary how much of the Opposition case is based, even in the case of Deputy Costello, upon ignorance of the income-tax code. Deputy Dillon made the point that, if one house were valued correctly, then the tax was unjust. Again, in trying to get the Opposition to talk in precise terms and to put in clear language what they are trying to say, I asked Deputy Dillon to tell me when he would regard a house as being correctly valued. The Deputy dodged around that point and did not give me a straight answer. Of course, the house might be assumed to be correctly valued when the valuation placed upon it was equal to what the house was worth to be let from year to year, and if the valuation of the house is equal to the nett rent at which it was worth to be let from year to year, then the tax is a fair one. If the fraction of five-fourths represents that, then the tax is a fair one. In so far as the valuation, plus the additional 25 per cent., would fall short of what the house is worth to be let from year to year, then the tax is unfair, but not unfair to the taxpayer—unfair to the Revenue. On the other hand, it might be said that, if the valuation, plus the additional 25 per cent., were in excess of the nett rent derived from the property from year to year, it might be unfair to the taxpayer; and it would be unfair if the income-tax code did not make provision to relieve the income-tax payer in such circumstances.

That brings me to the statement which I made a few minutes ago, that a great part of the case which is being made against the section by the Opposition is founded upon an ignorance of the income-tax code, because, Sir, that position—the position in which a taxpayer might be called upon to pay an amount based upon a notional income, due to the application of the five-fourths fraction, greater than that which he actually derives from the property—is covered by sub-section (4) of Section 187 of the Income Tax Act of 1918—the Consolidated Act. What do we find there, and it is well-known to taxpayers who derive their incomes from property? We find there that:

"If it is proved to the satisfaction of the special commissioners by whom the appeal is heard, or the Recorder or County Court judge by whom the appeal is reheard, as the case may be, that the annual value on which the assessment is based exceeds the annual rent at which the property in respect of which the assessment is made is worth to be let from year to year, relief shall be given by reducing the assessment and charging the tax on the amount on which it would have been charged if that rent had been adopted as the basis of the assessment instead of such annual value."

Accordingly, what is the position under the law? The position is that if, in fact, an income-tax payer is assessed for tax on a greater income than he actually derives from his property, he has his remedy by going before the special commissioners. In fact in most cases, it is not necessary to go before the special commissioners. The matter may be settled by the inspector, but, at all events, by going before the special commissioners he can have the tax levied on his true income. Therefore, there is no case made for the amendment. That is the reason that I have so often and so emphatically challenged the Opposition to cite one single case in which an income-tax payer has been charged on a greater sum than he would be charged on the income which, in fact, he would derive from the property if he let it. I have not been able to get as much as a single example of that occurrence.

Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Costello had occasion in this House to tell me what the duties of the Revenue Commissioners were. They said it was not their duty and it was not their function to investigate complaints of hardship if hardships occur. I, Sir, am the Minister responsible to this House for the Revenue Commissioners and I say the Revenue Commissioners, who are my advisers in regard to these taxes, to whose representations as to the effect of taxes I am bound to listen if I want to fulfil my responsibility in the matter to the full, the people who administer these laws,— they and I both agree, notwithstanding what Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Costello have said, that it is clearly the duty of the Revenue Commissioners to inform the Minister, if a section is working hardship in cases which the Minister brings to their notice. I take my responsibility very seriously and so do the Revenue Commissioners. They are not there as mere machines, to steamroll taxpayers. They are not there as ruthless tax gatherers. They are there to gather taxes, it is true, but also to advise me as to any anomalies, hardships or inequities which their experience brings to their notice during the course of the year. Therefore, they would be bound if real hardship occurred in any case to draw my attention to it. If there was a case in which this particular tax operated inequitably, that is to say if there was a case in which it was levied, by reason of some phraseology in the statute, upon persons in such a way that they would be taxed upon a greater income than they in fact enjoy, it would be the duty of the Revenue Commissioners, and I regard it as their duty notwithstanding what Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Costello have said, to call my attention to that fact, whatever may have been the position before 1932. If the instructions of the former Minister for Finance and the then Administration to the Revenue Commissioners were to be ruthless in dealing with the taxpayer, that is not the position now. The Revenue Commissioners are, as I have said, my principal advisers in these matters and they, as well as I, regard it as their duty to bring to my notice any cases of hardship that may arise in the administration of the income-tax code or any other code of taxes.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has thought fit to refer to me as a pensioner.

Comment on this

No, but the Deputy said——

Comment on this

I should like to remind the Minister that I spent 13 years in the Civil Service of this country, apart from any military service which I rendered entitling me to a pension. I do hope that I am rendering services to the country here that are altogether out of proportion to the amount of money which I get as a military service pension and I want to say that I could not render these services if I had not that pension.

Comment on this

Are we going to discuss this?

Comment on this

I am prepared to discuss it. The Minister introduced it.

Comment on this

No, the Deputy introduced it.

Comment on this

The Minister introduced it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter was introduced by an irrelevant interruption.

Comment on this

From the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not from the Minister, but from the Opposition Benches.

Comment on this

I am replying to the Minister and I am entitled to do so.

Comment on this

The interruption was an interruption made by Deputy Mulcahy in relation to a Bill before the House the other day.

Comment on this

If the interruption was made by me, at any rate I am not conscious of it but I shall reply to the Minister's interruption. I just want now to deal with the matter under discussion. The Minister's attitude simply amounts to this. There is a figure staring in the face the heads of families in every part of the country. That is not the official cost-of-living figure. It is a very much bigger and darker figure which arises from every aspect of the cost of keeping up a home. That figure has to be supported and put in proper perspective. The Minister is simply in this matter erecting a pedestal sufficiently large to ensure that the cost of the maintenance and upkeep of that home will not look out of proportion. That is the explanation for the Minister's sticking so fast to this particular proposal. He wants to make the cost of the home sufficiently large so that the cost of maintenance of that home will not look too much out of perspective.

Comment on this

Before the debate proceeds, Sir, when I was speaking I heard an interruption which, I understood, came from Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The interruption was not made by Deputy Mulcahy. It came from the Opposition Benches.

Comment on this

I wish to apologise to Deputy Mulcahy for the remarks I used and which I made under the misapprehension that the interruption came from Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

If it was not in the Minister's mind it would not come out.

Comment on this

It is in the Deputy too.

Comment on this

It was I made the interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy McGuire should keep out of these matters.

Comment on this

The Minister I am afraid did not reply, and I suppose is not going to reply, to the arguments that were raised. He has given another set of figures which require some contradiction from this side. He has taken the case of a married man with two children, who had, I think he said, £400 a year.

Comment on this

£360.

Comment on this

In 1932 he paid £8.

Comment on this

£4 18s. 0d.

Comment on this

I make the Minister a present of that statement. I am sure it is perfectly correct but one story is very good until you hear another. If the head of a household does not pay income-tax it will not loom very much in his calculations, but he would be entitled to assume that he had to face an all-in cost-of-living figure. If you compare the all-in cost-of-living figures at the present day with those of 1932, 5 per cent. would be a moderate increase.

Comment on this

1931-32?

Comment on this

It would apply equally well. There is a rise on 1931 of at least 5 per cent.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not correct.

Comment on this

We will just take what the figures are.

Comment on this

Over the whole year?

Comment on this

Take May, 1931, and November, 1936. It is 11 points up.

Comment on this

But they are not comparable figures. Take May, 1931, and May of this year.

Comment on this

There are points higher. The Minister has taken two favourable dates, and we hear from time to time from the Labour Benches about the cost-of-living figures not really representing the increase. However, I will make the Minister a present of that. The saving which he has made in the income-tax is more than swallowed up if you take the percentage increase in the cost-of-living figures.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter before us is the question of income-tax, and the cost-of-living figures in comparison with those of 1931 do not arise.

Comment on this

Well, a Chinn Comhairle, I accept your ruling, and having allowed me to make the point I will hand it to the Minister.

Comment on this

No case whatever for the retention of this section of the 1935 Act has been made by the Minister. I have often heard the Minister speak in this House, but seldom have I heard him let off such an amount of hot air as he has let off here during the last hour or so since I came into the House. The points made by Deputy Dillon — I think he spoke twice on this amendment — do not seem to have been grasped by the Minister. He made the point — quite clearly I thought, although the Minister does not seem to have grasped it — that, if there is even one case of hardship created by this section, that is something which should receive the consideration of the Minister, and the Minister in argument should try to reply on that particular point. We have heard a great deal from the Minister about consultations which took place between him and the Revenue Commissioners, but all that seems to me to be beside the point. What can the revenue collectors tell the Minister except that they failed to collect or that they have collected. I take it that, in the vast majority of cases, their story to the Minister in connection with this five-fourths valuation is that they have successfully collected. The Minister assumes from that statement that this particular tax is working no hardship. That is exactly the point which the Minister made. If some other communication was made to him or to his officials I should like to hear what the nature of it was, but I take it that the sort of communication which did come was that this tax is not working any hardships or inequalities for the simple reason that it is collected.

Comment on this

That is not so. I did not say that. I repeated twice in the House what I did say in that regard.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell the House how he could know whether a particular taxpayer has or has not experienced the necessity of going to a moneylender for the purpose of getting money to pay this tax?

Comment on this

That is a different matter. He might have to go to a moneylender because he squanders his income in other ways.

Comment on this

Would not the tax be working a hardship if the taxpayer had to go to a moneylender?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

How could such a case come to the Minister's notice? This tax should be taken on its own merits. The suggestion by the Minister is that instead of taking the valuation figure another quarter should be added on — that he should take five-fourths instead of four-fourths. I should like to know from the Minister why he takes that particular figure of five-fourths? Why should it not be three-fourths? Could not just as much be said for the figure of three-fourths as for the figure of five-fourths? Has there been a report on the valuations throughout the country? Had the Minister anything to go on except informal conversations between himself and the other members of the Executive Council? Was there anything except, as Deputy Cosgrave said, a request from the Minister to his revenue officials: "What is the easiest way to get £60,000?" The Minister, as we all know, was looking for this £60,000. He asked his officials: "What is the easiest way to get this £60,000," and they said: "Put another quarter on to the valuations, and you will get it very quickly." That is the sum total of it. The Minister comes in here now and raises a lot of hares which he expects the Deputies in this House to follow — the Deputies on this side of the House, because the attendance on his side when this rather important matter is being discussed is conspicuous by its absence, except for three Deputies, one of whom is fast asleep.

Comment on this