Finance Bill, 1937—Committee (Resumed.)
Contributions 133–265 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1937 ›
I thought Deputy Tom Kelly was asleep. I hope he is following the debate well, and will be able to answer the questions which he will be asked around the South City in a few weeks in regard to this particular tax. I should like to hear from the Minister why he chooses this five-fourths figure? What particular attraction has it got for him?
Comment on this
I think that if a debate were started in this House, on a private motion or otherwise, as to what is the proper basis of valuation in this country at the moment, the result of a fair-minded discussion — if no whips were put on — would be just as likely to be a decision on the figure of three-fourths as on the figure of five-fourths, which has been arrived at in some obscure way about which we have not yet heard.
Comment on this
I should like to say a word on this subject, about which I have spoken frequently before. I regard this tax as unworthy of the Minister — unworthy of that Minister for Finance who smiles on us, but still exacts his farthing. I regard this tax as a dishonest one. There is no personal implication in that. It did not take into account the fact that when a person purchased his house — as many of my friends have done, investing a certain sum of money which was hardly earned in many cases; it was got by careful saving and not by squandering — he expected a certain return for the money which he invested. The Minister, by this tax, has made what amounted to a capital levy on the assets of the tenant occupier. He destroyed their capital value by a certain sum. I do not know what the particular fraction is — I am not a mathematician — but it is a very considerable one. He reduced the value of their investments very considerably. It was somewhat like the procedure adopted when they cut down the debentures of the Great Southern Railways. That was also, in my opinion, a nonmoral transaction, inequitable, and unjustifiable on any grounds except those of dire emergency.
I do regard this tax as particularly aggravating. To some of us it is more than that. It is a hardship, and it is a tax hard to be met, because in every direction all the concessions that were given to the payers of income-tax have been cut down and whittled away. The general attitude of the Revenue Commissioners to the unfortunate income-tax payer, who does carry a fair share of the country on his back, is that he is something between a footpad and a sneak thief; that he has got an income which his neighbour ought to have. It is rather rough on people who have earned their income, and earned it hard, and who have been provident enough to invest their money in house property — their own house particularly. I do regard this tax as an encroachment on the capital of the unfortunate investor. It is on those grounds that I should like the Minister to consider it, shall I say, in a less financial mood; let him look at it fairly. I think he is doing considerable harm to the ordinary citizen, who ought to be encouraged to save his money and buy his own house. It is very desirable that a citizen should own his own house. Such citizens do not go in for revolutions or for blowing up things. I was aware that attempts were made to bring in this tax long before I ever heard of the Minister. Finally, those people who are organising it in the background succeeded. I do not think they did a good turn for the thrift of the country.
Comment on this
This section appears to enlarge the duty on a large number of articles. Something may have to be said on the Schedule in regard to these articles but we should like to have some explanation from the Minister as to what the policy at the back of this section is.
Comment on this
I do not know whether there is any special point the Deputy wants to raise, but I am prepared to deal with any point he may raise, either now or on the Schedule.
Comment on this
I think I have an amendment down to the Schedule, but here you have duties of 40 per cent. on shirts, 40 per cent. on collars, 60 per cent. on handkerchiefs and 40 per cent. on umbrellas. You have quite a series of 60 per cent. taxes, together with minimum charges of 3/- on a pullover, 1/3 on a shirt, 8d. on a glove, 15/- on a coat, suit or dress, 7/6 on a skirt and 10/- on an overcoat. I submit that on the section which proposes to treat with that Schedule, the Minister has a suitable opportunity for giving an explanation of policy behind all these rather exorbitant minimum tariffs.
Comment on this
The policy behind the tariffs is to secure the development of the production and manufacture of these articles here. I think that in respect of every article mentioned by the Deputy, there is a sufficient number of firms in this country equipped to supply all the requirements of our people in them. Their importation is no longer necessary, and these duties are imposed to restrict and to prevent the importation of these goods, in order to ensure that the products of Irish factories will be employed, and Irish people engaged in their manufacture. I doubt if it is possible to give a more detailed explanation of the policy than that. Of course, so far as the majority of the duties upon wearing apparel, to which the Deputy has referred, are concerned, they are not new duties. As I explained earlier, the duties upon wearing apparel have been simplified. Formerly, there was a very large number of separate items in the duty Schedule. These have been substantially reduced in number for the purpose of facilitating the administration of the duties, and, also, those who are engaged in the importation of those goods. The small number of separate duties and the wider definitions used will, I think, be found a convenience by everybody concerned, both the customs officers, on the one hand, and the importers on the other. In fact, the request that these duties upon wearing apparel should be simplified in that manner is one of long standing. It was not possible to meet it until now because of the detailed work involved, and the very close examination of the position with regard to a large number of articles which was necessary; but now that the request has been met, I think most people are glad of the change.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister is not making a detailed statement which, I suppose, he is reserving for the First Schedule. I take it that there are no revenue producing duties in the First Schedule. They are all protective?
Comment on this
The Minister has made a few general remarks with which we might all agree, but let us take this:
"Rates of minimum duty on suits, coats and dresses which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are made wholly or partly of woven tissue and are either suitable for wear by women or suitable for wear by girls, 15/- per suit, coat or dress, as the case may be."
Will the Minister give the House some explanation as to how that 15/- tax is arrived at? Is the position with regard to the production of women's clothing in the country that it requires a tax of 15/- an article to protect Irish manufacturers here?
Comment on this
It would require more than that, in my opinion, and in the opinion of anybody who knows anything about it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister seriously say that the women and the girls of this country would clothe themselves adequately, and to their own tastes, at a cost of 15/- per coat, 15/- per dress, and 15/- per suit, if there was not a 15/- tariff on here to make them use native manufacture?
Comment on this
No. The Deputy, of course, has been misled by Fine Gael propaganda. The fact that that duty is considered necessary for the purpose of protecting our own industries does not mean that the prices here are that much higher than they would be if imported goods were on sale. Particularly with regard to ladies' wear, there is necessity for having an effective rate of duty, because considerations of fashion and design enter so largely into the question of what makes an attractive article. I think most people will agree that design and fashion, much more than value, determine the price at which articles of ladies' apparel are sold. Furthermore, persons engaged in the sale of these goods have for many years established trade connections with foreign firms supplying them. For various reasons, they are not always willing to break these trade connections and to establish new connections with home suppliers, and, in relation to this class of goods in particular, it was found difficult to secure that the bulk of the orders for these goods would go to the home factories, although the home factories were quite capable of filling these orders. Hence a minimum rate of duty is necessary.
The Deputy also should be aware that most countries in the world export goods for sale abroad at a much lower price than similar goods are sold in the country of production. Export trade is always carried on upon that basis. A factory engaged in the manufacture of goods for sale at home and abroad endeavours to secure that all its overhead charges will be met by the profit upon home sales, so that the exported goods can be sold at the lowest possible price. Consequently, goods of many classes can be imported here, apart from the protective duties in operation, cheaper than they can be purchased by the persons who actually make them in their own countries. The effective standard by which to judge prices prevailing here is not, therefore, the price at which goods can be imported from some other country, but the price at which similar goods can be purchased in other countries; and by that standard the prices prevailing here are, on the whole, very reasonable.
If we are to base our criticism of Irish industries upon a price consideration alone, and to regard their effectiveness and their efficiency solely by the prices they charge, I suggest it is utterly unfair to compare their prices with the lowest price at which similar goods can be purchased in other countries. That is the attitude that Deputy Mulcahy has consistently taken. I assume that anybody importing goods into this country will import them from England, or Japan, or China, or America, or wherever he can get them cheapest, irrespective of the conditions of labour or the export bounties paid, or the system of government in operation, or any factor which may operate to make these goods cheap. He will import the cheapest goods. It is against the price of these goods, the cheapest that can be imported from anywhere, that Deputy Mulcahy wants to put the price of Saorstát goods in comparison. I submit that that is not a fair standard by which to judge Irish industries. It is a fair standard to judge the prices prevailing here by the prices at which similar goods can be purchased in Great Britain or other countries where the general standard of living is not dissimilar to our own, and where the various factors which operate to increase or lower the cost of an article operate as they operate here. On that basis, the prices of our products are reasonable.
But, in framing protective duties, we have to have regard, not to the prices prevailing in Great Britain, not to the prices at which goods can be imported from these countries where the standard of living is similar to our own, but the prices at which goods can be purchased from any country, no matter what standards prevail. It is because goods can come in at an extraordinarily low price from certain countries that minimum rates of duties are necessary, because we can only compete with these prices on the basis of having a standard of living and rates of wages and conditions of employment and industry here similar to those in these particular countries. Nobody here would tolerate that for one moment. We have established a particular standard of living here which we are anxious to maintain, or rather to improve upon.
The Deputy's mentality is one which could be argued as being in favour of sweated wages and the very appalling conditions of employment which exist in certain countries which are developing an export trade of considerable dimensions at the present time upon the basis of the cheapness of their products. It is not in competition with these goods, exported from these countries, in the matter of price that we want to put the industries of this country. We want to assure that these industries will supply the requirements of our people at a reasonable cost, having regard to the cost of other commodities, and, at the same time, ensure reasonable wages and conditions of employment to their workers and, except on that basis, industries in this country are not worth having.
Comment on this
I move:—
Before Section 15, and in Part III, to insert a new section as follows:—
The Cement Act, 1933 (No. 17 of 1933) is hereby amended by the deletion of Section 36 and Section 37.
The effect of the amendment would be to delete that part of the Cement Act which enables the Minister for Finance to collect 5/- tax on every ton of cement imported into this country. When we take into consideration the amount by which the price of cement has increased recently and the increase in the cost of timber and every other article that goes into the building of a house, I think the time has come to stop the imposition of this tax on one of the most important of building materials. A lot of noise has been made about the amount of building that is going on in the country, but not so much noise is being made about the amount of debt that is being piled up on this State in respect of the houses that are being built. In respect of houses built by local authorities, for the loan charges on these houses I suppose about £3,500,000 or over has already been added to the State debt.
Comment on this
We can get it in a more satisfactory and clear way from the figures that are extracted from time to time from the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. At any rate the Minister for Finance will not question that in respect of the houses built up to the end of December last the amount of State debt due — moneys that have to be paid off from revenue in the coming years — was about £3,500,000. The Minister is giving grants, but he is to-day by this tax piling on more debt for housing. He is putting a tax of 5/- a ton on the cement used in the houses. That increase has to be raised by borrowed money, and I am given to understand that in the case of the ordinary house built by the local authority the increased cost, due to the rise in the price of cement alone, is something like £2 10s. to £3. That increased price of cement has come about chiefly in the last few months. In addition to that, the cost of timber has also risen, and so has the cost of every other article going into the houses. It is time that the cost of building houses should be relieved at all events of this particular tax. We had to-day a discussion in reference to one aspect of income-tax that causes a rise in the cost of homes. This tax of 5/- a ton on cement is another of the things that rise the cost of homes. With the other increases at the present time in the cost of building the Minister certainly should take off this cement tax and give relief at least by that amount to the building of homes for the people.
Comment on this
The Minister at the time this duty was put on cement claimed that the price of cement was so low that it could well bear the duty. That is what the Minister is now going on. Instead of, as Deputy Mulcahy said, the increased price of cement causing a difference of £2 10s. Od. or £3 in the building of a house, I am aware that the cost is more like £10 or £12 a house as compared with what it was, say in March, 1935. At that time, I know that in the western counties, cement was being sold at £2 2s. a ton. The duty brought it up to 47/- a ton. Some time afterwards there was a sharp rise to 52/- a ton, and to-day the price of cement delivered at the ports in the western countries is £3 a ton. That represents, roughly an increased price in the building of a labourer's cottage of from £10 to £12 per cottage. With the cost of building going up so much it is only fair that this duty should be taken off. The amount of cement imported in 1935 was 335,000 tons, and the tax on that was £83,750. The amount imported in 1936 was 336,687 tons, and the tax was £91,671. The Minister may say that is a small amount, but I am satisfied that it certainly is going to check or hold up building. At all events it will affect building, seeing that in every other respect there is an increase in cost in the last two years. In the last 12 months, leaving out entirely the increased costs caused by the Conditions of Employment Act, there has been an increase in building costs of 33? per cent. In February, 1935, lead was £20 a ton, and that has now gone up to £42. Steel and iron are up by 40 per cent.; ordinary concrete roof tiles are up by 10/- per 1,000. What will be the position in the case of houses to be erected in the coming year and afterwards? We find to-day in the West of Ireland that the tenants of the labourers' houses built at 33? per cent. less than they could be built to-day, plus 7 per cent. or 8 per cent. that might be added under the Conditions of Employment Act, say in all, 40 per cent., are complaining that they are unable to pay. The tenants are not able to pay those rents that are 40 per cent. less than future tenants will have to pay. What will be the position when the houses will have to be built at an increased cost of 40 per cent.? How will those tenants be able to pay the rents? I know that for houses that were built before there was a rise in the price of building material, and before this 5/-a ton tax on cement was put on, the tenants in rural towns in the West of Ireland are unable to pay something like 9/- a week. There is little employment in these towns. I know one town in which another scheme is being started. Already in that town houses are let at 9/-, but under the increase in cost the new houses will have to be let at least at 13/- a week. That is a matter I would ask the Minister to consider seriously. I know very well that the Government are not responsible for the increase in the price of materials, but they could at all events relieve people of building costs by removing this 5/- a ton tax. I am aware that at the time the duty was put on, the price of cement was low and it could bear that tax. Cement at that time was being sold at £2 a ton. Now it is being sold at £3. The Minister could give some relief to the building industry and relief to the poor man who wants a house by removing that tax. I understand that the revenue for one year, 1935-36, from this tax was £83,000, and the revenue for the following year was £91,000. The removal of that impost would, at all events, give some relief to the building trade and to the people who want houses.
Comment on this
I am supporting this amendment. I can very well remember the remarks made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when introducing this tax. At that time he said it was undoubtedly correct to say that cement was being sold, or dumped as he described it, in our markets below world prices. That was true. Now, there is an international cartel at work and I do not know whether everybody pays the same price. But certainly this market has got to stand a very substantial increase in the cost of cement. At the time it was stated that this tax on cement would be negligible. Possibly, that might have been thought then, but when you tot up all these negligible items they mount up to something and hence you have an increase all round. I understand that the amount collected by this 5/- per ton tax or the ad valorem tax came to £218,000. I suppose you could build close on 600 houses for that sum. If somebody suggested that this country was going to be made a present of 600 houses it would be considered a very substantial matter. Other Deputies have spoken about this tax and I wish merely to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that when it was first put on, it was represented that cement was really too cheap in our market and that it could very well stand an addition. I do not think anybody will deny that it has got to a very high price and it ought not to be asked to stand a revenue-producing tax, because I do not suppose the Minister is going to contend that the cement factory is going to put out any cement for a year, at any rate.
Having regard to the ad valorem tax which produces a revenue of £49,000, I would like to ask the Minister to do away with that. He will remember perfectly well that it was put on as a 10 per cent. emergency duty by way of reprisal when the English put a tax on the cattle. That was reduced under the Coal-Cattle Pact to 5 per cent., and it is an extraordinary anomaly that we are supposed to have got what we wanted under the Coal-Cattle Pact and yet we are holding on to the 5 per cent. on cement. I would like to suggest that it is not getting us anywhere in the annuities question. Either we are satisfied with the Coal-Cattle Pact or we are not. I think the tax could be taken off altogether and the cement should be left to find its own level. There is a flat rate of 5/- per ton on all cement coming into the country and I will ask, as I have previously asked, for the removal of that tax.
This ad valorem tax of 10 per cent., reduced to 5 per cent., is extraordinary and it works in a very peculiar fashion, because some people find that they have to get their supplies from England while others find that it does not suit them at all and, in that way, I think it is most unjust to discriminate against one article which was supposed to have formed the basis for a settlement with the cattle. I suggest to the Minister that he should take the duty off the cement and ask the English for a corresponding quid pro quo. Other speakers have suggested that the increase, due to world conditions, has raised the cost of building. Nobody could look upon a cost to building of £218,000 as a trifle, and I suggest it is a serious condemnation in view of the shortage there is of houses and the way we are practically borrowing money to build most of the houses. I would like to support this amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Dockrell rightly described the origin of this licence fee. At the time the Cement Act was passed and power was taken to charge this fee on the issue of a licence to import cement, this was practically the only free market for cement in Europe. For some reason the international cartel had made no arrangement concerning this market, with the result that the surplus production of all cement-producing countries came in here at extraordinarily low prices, prices in some cases so low that they hardly seemed to repay the cost of transporting the cement here. We had determined to engage in the manufacture of cement ourselves. We foresaw the end of this arrangement which was temporarily advantageous to us and the consequent increase in cement prices when this market was brought within the ambit of the cartel's arrangements. This licence fee device was decided upon for the purpose of stepping up the price of cement to an economic level until such time as Saorstát-made cement would be available. In the meantime, however, the cartel came to an agreement concerning this market and the price of cement went up very considerably. In the circumstances now existing, the amount of this fee is obviously open for reconsideration at any time. But that is not what Deputy Mulcahy is proposing. He is not proposing that we should reconsider the amount of the fee; he is proposing that we should abolish the power to charge a fee at all, and that is something we could not agree to.
Comment on this
Will the Minister make provision for limiting the size of the fee? It is absurd to be charging 5/-.
Comment on this
The economic price of cement is the price at which we can manufacture it here with up-to-date equipment. The aim is to ensure that cement will be got at the price at which it will be available from these plants when they are in operation here. If there is any benefit to be secured for the Exchequer, well and good. The Exchequer is open to receive any contribution of that kind. With the rise in the price of cement, the amount of the fee is open for reconsideration at any time. Whether circumstances justify its reconsideration now, I am not in a position to express an opinion.
Comment on this
I think we could not abolish the power to charge a fee because the two cement factories which are being constructed will be capable between them of producing 250,000 tons of cement per year. At the time we decided upon the construction of these factories, that appeared to be about the amount of cement required annually in this country; but, as Deputies have remarked, the consumption of cement here has increased considerably and, in fact, on the basis of last year's figures and the figures of the year before, there is now room for a third factory of an economic size. Until that third factory is constructed there will be a period during which a proportion of cur requirements of cement will be supplied from the factories at Drogheda and Limerick and the remainder will be imported. This fee arrangement is designed to ensure that the price of the home-produced cement and the imported cement will be uniform and that no one part of the country will have a special advantage, or disadvantage, as against another. I think the power to charge this fee should be retained, although the fee itself may vary from time to time. In fact, the Act gives power to vary the fee not merely from time to time but in relation to various ports of importation and it is desirable to keep that power, particularly now when we are coming to the point at which home-produced cement will be available to meet some part of the requirements of the country, but not all. I cannot say now that this fee is going to be changed, but I can assure the House that the position in respect of cement prices is under examination and that the power to vary the fee will be exercised when the circumstances appear to justify it.
Comment on this
The Minister has given us a sample of the kind of two-headed monster that is attacking our people. I could understand the Minister for Finance claiming that he wanted money and that if necessary he was going to get it off the importation of building material. But I cannot understand the Minister for Industry and Commerce, with the prices of building materials what they are at the present time, saying that the Minister for Finance was entitled to any money that he was able to get. The only suggestion that can be gleaned from the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is that either he has been shutting his eyes completely to the cost of building materials or that he is prepared to allow a revenue tax to go on building materials coming into the country. It shows the danger of giving the Minister for Industry and Commerce power to operate a sliding scale of taxation like this. No discrimination is made in the amount of the licence fee that has to be paid in respect of different ports in the country. The 5/- per ton is charged on all cement coming in.
Comment on this
In spite of the repeated rise in cost, the Minister has not shown any indication of sliding down the charge of 5/-at any particular port. The 5/- is simply left on and is being taken in as revenue.
Comment on this
When speaking I had intended making some reference to the remarks of Deputy Brodrick and others concerning the price of building materials. The price of all building materials has gone up quite considerably during the course of the past year, due to causes, operating in all countries, which are, in the main, outside of our control altogether. We are not in a position to control the price of timber, of steel or of lead or of quite a number of other materials used in the construction of a house. That increase in the cost of materials has its reaction upon the cost of the completed dwelling-house or other building. In so far as a large part of the cost of building represents the wages paid to labour, the increase in cost is less obvious than a mere comparison of the present prices with the prices prevailing 12 months ago would suggest. Because there has been this increase in the cost of building materials, and because buildings of the kind that it is desired to provide for members of the working classes in cities and for agricultural labourers in the country, if constructed and let at a minimum rent, would be altogether too dear for the members of these classes to occupy, the State provides a subsidy.
The only way you can off-set the high cost of building and at the same time ensure that houses will be available to those for whom they are intended at rents they can afford is by giving a subsidy: by providing from the Exchequer in one form or another a direct contribution towards the cost, although from Deputy Mulcahy's remarks it appears that he objects to that. All this talk we have had about the debt on local authorities and the contribution which the State is paying towards the fulfilment of the Government's housing problem are at least an indication that they object to the subsidy available. But there is no alternative to it. The subsidy may be varied as costs rise or fall, but apart from that subsidy arrangement there is no other way of ensuring that houses can be constructed and let at rents which the members of the working classes and agricultural classes can pay.
Comment on this
It is rather strange that while we have the admission from the Minister that he has the power under the Act to revise the duty on cement, and that there has been an increase in the cost of building, yet he will not exercise his power to reduce the duty. He says that the Government are subsidising the cost of building. Will the Minister deny, in connection with development schemes down through the country and the building of labourers' cottages, that unless the local authority keeps within a certain figure the Government will refuse to pay the subsidy? A case came under my notice where plans and specifications were prepared for development work in connection with a particular scheme of cottages. The estimate exceeded the figure approved by the Government, and, accordingly, the Government refused to sanction the scheme. They refused to pay the subsidy unless the estimate for building was brought down to a certain figure.
Will the Minister not again consider the increase in the cost of housing? I do not blame the Government for the increase in the price of timber, steel and lead. Where the Minister has the opportunity of reducing the cost of houses for the poor people of the country, I think he should do it. In the two years since the duty was put on, the Government have taken in a sum of £171,000. Why not utilise some of that to bring down the cost of houses for the poor people of the country? Labourers' cottages, which could be erected for £250 in March, 1936, are at present prices going to cost £320. In view of that, I think the Minister should make a proportionate increase in the amount of the subsidy. It should be increased to meet the difference in cost as between the prices in March of last year and present-day prices. If the Minister did that, houses could be built and let at an economic rent. If he refuses, houses cannot be let at an economic rent. I am familiar with schemes where, making allowance for all charges, the rents of the houses are 9/- per week. With building costs as they are to-day, houses of the same type cannot be let in future at less than 13/- or 14/- per week if the Minister does not do something in the way of meeting the increased cost of building by increasing the subsidy.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that this amendment was designed to take away the power to levy the 5/- tax. I think the House would be prepared to concede to the Minister that when the time arrived to give protection to the cement factory here it would be ready to confer on him the power to levy a duty on cement coming in. Apparently the Minister is sympathetic. He thinks the time has arrived when there ought to be some reduction in this 5/- duty on cement. It seemed to me that he destroyed his own case when he admitted that the duty of 5/- was put on at a time when cement was 30/-, and that it is being continued now when cement is 50/-. At what point does the Minister consider that this duty ought to be reduced? Surely the Minister must have some idea as to what price the new factories here are going to charge for cement. I imagine the Minister has an approximate figure in his mind as to what their price will be. I think that at the time this cement duty, or licence fee, was introduced Deputy Good suggested that, probably, the cement manufactured in this country would cost £1 a ton more. I think that the Minister expressed horror at that idea at the time, but it looks as if it has now become part of the settled idea that the price of cement is not going to be reduced by the home production when it does arrive. However, I should certainly like the Minister to give us some indication as to at what point he considers that some relief ought to be given to the cost of cement by a reduction in this 5/- tax.
The Minister has been absolutely silent about the other question that I asked, namely, about the ad valorem duty on the price of English cement. I suggested to the Minister that he might consider the abolition of that altogether and put all cement importers into this country on the one footing. Perhaps the Minister could see his way to give us some enlightenment on that point.
Comment on this
As regards the point at which a variation in the licence fee would be considered justified, I can say no more than that the matter is under careful consideration. I can hold out no immediate prospect, however, of the 5 per cent. emergency duty being removed.
Comment on this
I must say that the Minister has been very unconvincing in this matter, and it does not appear that he has given any thought to it. However, I do not want to take the power from the Minister that is in the Act, but I do think that that power ought to be taken if the cost is going to be left at the present price owing to the 5/- tax, but I have no desire to press the removal of this now if the Minister says that the matter is really under consideration.
Comment on this
It is definitely under consideration, but I cannot commit myself as to what is going to be the outcome of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:—
In page 13, reference No. 13, to insert in column 2, outside and after the brackets in sub-section (a), the words "excluding cotton quilts and cotton blankets."
The object of this is to prevent the possibility of cotton quilts and cotton blankets coming under a duty of 40 per cent. Cotton blankets are things that nobody in this country wants to manufacture. I understand that they are made from very rough cotton waste, that they principally came from the Continent, and that they come in at such a price that Lancashire itself could not make them. The price of a pair of cotton blankets at the present time — say 50 inches by 70 inches — is 2/11 retail. If you get a mixture of wool and cotton, then you go into the realm of 13/11 per pair, and for all wool 15/11. What is proposed under reference No. 13 is that, as well as putting 40 per cent. on certain other articles, a 40 per cent. duty is going to be put on cotton blankets, a type of blanket mainly used in poor families. It is not every year that the ordinary working-class household is able to pay 13/11 or 15/11 for a pair of these articles, and the Minister is imposing a tariff of 40 per cent. on an article which no one proposes to manufacture here and which is used only in the houses of the poor classes, the working classes.
Then there is the case of cotton quilts. Nobody at all proposes to manufacture them here. The cotton quilt is the honeycombed article that you see in nearly every rural bedroom or in the bedrooms of working-class homes. The Minister may say that bed-spreads may be made here or that they are going to be made here, but there is no comparison between the articles used in certain homes and in working-class homes. Here you have a tariff being imposed, under reference No. 13, on two articles that are not going to be made here and that are used only in the houses of workers.
Comment on this
So far as cotton blankets are concerned, the duty is being imposed upon these for the first time by this Resolution. I understand that there are at least two firms about to engage in the manufacture of cotton blankets from imported material.
Comment on this
Our industrial programme also includes the manufacture of the material at a later stage; but I intend that, in the interval, cotton blankets will be imported, free of duty, under licence, to a reasonable extent.
Comment on this
By persons previously engaged in the business of importing cotton blankets. However, I want the Deputy to mark the words I used. I think it would not be in the national interests to allow free import, unrestricted as to quantity, particularly now that it is known that these blankets are about to be manufactured here.
Comment on this
I can get the information for the Deputy if he will put down a Parliamentary question. I cannot tell him from memory at the moment. That is the only difficulty I have in that regard. However, a reasonable quantity will come in under licence for a certain time. There will be no difficulty in having the full amount manufactured here. The process of manufacturing these articles from imported materials offers no very great difficulties. At a later stage, however, I hope we shall be manufacturing the material as well, but that is something for the future. The same applies in regard to cotton quilts. I am aware of at least one firm that proposes to engage in the manufacture of these cotton quilts from imported material, and at a later stage we hope to be able to manufacture the material. In the meantime, reasonable quantities will be imported, free of duty, under the licence provision.
Comment on this
Yes, the biscuit. He proposes to put a tariff of 40 per cent. on the manufacture of cotton quilts and cotton blankets, and he says that both of these articles are going to be manufactured in this country, when persons who are closely in touch with that line of business express themselves as being of opinion that it is impossible to get these articles manufactured here, that there is no likelihood of their being manufactured, and that, at the prices at which they are available from the Continent, they could not be manufactured even in Lancashire. An important industrial development of that kind, which the Minister said is going to surprise so many people in this country, is going to take place, and he does not know where it will take place.
Comment on this
The Minister has just found out that it is going to take place in Dublin. Well, the Minister ought to know somewhat more about it and he ought to have his information a little bit more digested in his mind than merely, say, after a scratch of the head and a casual inquiry, that it is going to be made in Dublin. All the preparations for putting this tariff on these articles were made some months ago, and the Minister never went to the trouble before to find out that it was in Dublin this factory was going to be established. The Minister is only humbugging the House. The Minister proposes to put on a tariff that is going to squeeze revenue out of the unfortunate people who have to rear families in this country. Again we are dealing with a tax that is going to raise the cost of living for every family in the country.
Comment on this
It is impossible for me to stock my mind with all the information which Deputy Mulcahy might possibly require on a schedule of this kind. I think nobody could attempt to do that. So far as I am aware, there is no difficulty in the manufacture of these goods here. One of the firms that are about to engage in their production can be described as one of the largest hosiery manufacturers in the country. They are confident of their ability to produce these goods here. In any event, I would advise Deputy Mulcahy not to commit himself again to the statement, in relation to any article, that it cannot be manufactured here. He said that about so many articles that are now being successfully produced in this country that his stock as a prophet is at a considerable discount. These articles will be manufactured here. I agree that, in relation to these and other articles, there may be some countries which would be able to export them at a price with which we could not compete, but there is no reason why the prices of these articles should be any higher here than they are in other countries where similar wages are paid and similar machinery used.
Comment on this
If I felt that any good could be done by dealing with a larger number of articles than I am dealing with at the present moment, I assure the House I would deal with them. The Minister has been aware for nearly a fortnight — for ten days at any rate — that he would be asked to deal, in response to an amendment put down by me, with five articles. Cement was one. Cotton quilts and cotton blankets were the next. He had ten days' notice that he was going to be asked to agree to the removal of these articles from the Schedule and yet, he found it impossible to prepare an answer to all the questions that he might be asked. Again the Minister is simply trifling with the House.
Comment on this
I want to make a few remarks on Nos. 6 and 28. In regard to the duty which it is proposed to impose under No. 6, I am afraid the wording does not make clear what it is intended to catch. Veneer, I suppose, is usually understood to be a hard wood and very thin, but where a veneer stops and a plywood begins I should like the Minister to make clear. I take it he is not going to put a duty on plywood. The next thing which seems, to my mind, a little bit obscure is this phrase: "Wood which is imported in the piece." Is that intended only to catch raw wood on which a veneer has been put? That would be perfectly plain and everybody would understand it. But is it intended to go further? Is it intended, say, to catch the case of a piano, or something like that, which has veen veneered? I have referred to the question of plywood. I do not know if the Minister can put in the hard woods which he intended to catch as veneers. Plywood may be, say, birch or elderwood, which are really laminations, if you like to put it that way, but at the moment it seems to me that plywood is really veneer-wood. I do not think the Minister intends to catch that at all, and I suppose there would be some latitude under the licensing provision. At the same time it would be desirable if the position could be still further clarified as between wood in the piece — whether that is intended to catch articles which are partly or wholly manufactured and which are veneered — and plywood. I will not say anything about No. 28, on which I was going to make a few remarks, until the Minister tells us what the position is in regard to No. 6.
Comment on this
It is not intended that plywood should be subject to this duty. The definition has been framed with some care in order that the duty will apply only to veneer and not to plywood. I think the Deputy need have no fears on that score. It will be possible to administer the duty so as to catch only the class of goods to which it is intended that it should apply — that is, veneer-wood as distinct from plywood. Similarly, the duty will apply only to veneer-wood imported in the piece. A manufactured article composed of veneer-wood, such as a piano case, to use the Deputy's illustration, will not be subject to this duty. It will apply only to veneer-wood imported in the piece.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say anything with reference to No. 5, elastic stockings, socks and bands? I think a question in regard to it was asked at an earlier stage, but the Deputy who asked it is not here. That is a matter of general interest, because it affects the sick.
Comment on this
These articles are being manufactured here. In fact, there is little difficulty in manufacturing them. I expect that practically every hosiery firm in the country will, in due course, instal a machine for the manufacture of these goods. But they are being manufactured now. If there is any immediate difficulty in getting supplies, following the imposition of the duty, the licensing provision will be operated. In a short time, however, there should be no reason to import these articles. There is no difficulty about their production, apart from getting the necessary machinery, and the machinery which is being installed is sufficient to supply all the requirements of the country.
Comment on this
With regard to reference No. 13, I do not know whether any comment has been made on the general nature of that provision. It refers to "articles ... which are made wholly or mainly of woven material and are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, suitable for personal, domestic or household use." Some articles come under that reference, which, I think, it was not contemplated by the person who drafted the provision would come under it. I take it that the Minister will agree that it is an extraordinarily general provision. One article I have in mind — it is only one of a large number — is what is called a fabric handbag. Undoubtedly, there are handbags produced here at the moment, but they are mainly of leather. Handbags of the fabric type are largely purchased by women in the early and late summer. If they cannot get that particular type of handbag they will not buy any. I understand that no such article is produced in this country. I wonder if I am correct in that. The Minister may have information at his disposal to show whether I am or not. I understood from what he said when I was here about half an hour ago that these tariffs are intended to be protective of industries which he has established or is establishing. These types of fabric handbag are not made in the country, and, if imported, they could not possibly be sold with that tariff of 40 per cent. added to the cost.
Comment on this
Handbags made of woven material are subject to this duty. These handbags are being made, or are about to be made, here. Leather handbags and handbags of other materials are being manufactured here at present and that production is being extended to cover these handbags of woven material. They will be subject to this duty and will be manufactured here.
Comment on this
Shops do a fairly good trade in this type of fabric handbag and it would be a great loss to them if they were not able to do that business during the present summer. If they cannot get these handbags at home, they will not be able to sell the imported handbags if a 40 per cent. tariff is imposed. The people will not pay that price.
Comment on this
These articles are about to be made here, but that should cause no difficulty this summer, because the licensing provision will be used to ensure that supplies will be available until the home production shall have sufficiently grown to meet requirements.
Comment on this
Reference No. 28 refers to adhesive pastes and powders for the preparation of adhesive pastes. I do not know what the deciding factor is to be as to an adhesive paste or a powder for the preparation of an adhesive paste. Will wheaten flour or maize flour be dutiable as a preparation for pastes? Pastes could, undoubtedly, be made out of these flours. I should like the Minister to give us some idea as to what will be caught by this section.
Comment on this
The powders described in the reference are powders prepared for, and sold as, adhesive paste when water is added. Certain firms engage in the production of these goods. Instead of selling paste in a jar, they sell powder which becomes paste when water is poured on it. It is intended to catch these adhesive pastes for office use.
Comment on this
Only powders for the preparation of adhesive pastes — not powders for the preparation of powders for the preparation of adhesive pastes.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that a tariff was put on starch and that it still remains on corn-flour, as a result.
Comment on this
Is the Minister inclined to be generous in operating the licensing provision dealing with Linguaphone and linguistic records generally as affected by reference No. 21?
Comment on this
I assured the Deputy on a previous occasion that if there is any difficulty in procuring records giving lessons in a particular language, the licensing provision will be operated to allow them in. It is the intention of the company manufacturing these records to produce here any of them for which there is a demand. For some of them, there may not be sufficient demand to justify production here, in which case the licensing provision will be used.
I should like to mention that, in connection with the duty on wrapping paper, I propose on the next stage to move an amendment to remove from the scope of that duty paper which is called cloth-faced paper and cloth-centred paper. These classes of paper will not be manufactured here, and it is not intended that the duty should apply to them. If I did not give notice of that amendment now, I understand that it would not be permissible to move it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In page 22, Part I, to delete reference No. 14 and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
Reference No. 14 imposes a duty of 60 per cent. on "articles of personal clothing or wearing apparel not chargable under any other reference number in this part of this Schedule." This is a blind swipe — and a heavy one — at every other type of article imported for wear. I suggest that it is a duty which will impose a great hardship on those who have to clothe children. It is going to hit a variety of articles used in small numbers and not manufactured here. These articles are not manufacturable here because the market is not big enough. This tax is going to hit particularly people who have to clothe young families.
Comment on this
All the articles which are made subject to this duty under this reference were dutiable previously, although not all at the 60 per cent. rate. A large number of them and, in fact, from the point of view of value of sales, probably the bulk of them, were chargeable at the 60 per cent. rate and there has been no change in relation to them. It is true that in relation to boys' clothing the rate has been raised. The primary consideration in effecting this change is to simplify the duty, to get all the articles of similar description into one category and to make them subject to one duty, so as to facilitate administration and also the business of importation, to whatever extent importation must take place. So far as boys' clothing is concerned, the home firms are quite capable of supplying all the articles of that kind required. So far as girls' clothing is concerned, I will admit that the task of getting home firms to the point of supplying the entire market here has been somewhat more difficult, and an increase in the duty there is necessitated. But again, these firms are quite capable of producing much larger quantities of these goods than they have been selling heretofore, and under the stimulus of an increased duty there is no reason why any garments of these descriptions should be imported.
In relation to the bulk of the garments covered by this duty, there is quite considerable competition between the home firms, which, between them, are capable of producing much more than the market can absorb, and that competition has, I think, operated to effect considerable keenness in the fixing of prices. I feel that in relation to these classes of goods, there is no reason why we should have any imports at all. These are goods which require no very heavy capital equipment and no very high degree of technical skill to manufacture. Our people are familar with all the processes of manufacture, and, if organised properly, can produce these goods as well as they can be produced anywhere, and I think that duty at the rate suggested is desirable in order to stop imports, because we can do all this work for ourselves.
Comment on this
——to prepare the large range of various classes of clothing that are required for infants, for children, say, up to the age of four years. The Minister emphasises the position we are in with regard to boys' clothing. We would be alright in that respect if we could get decent thread for the manufacturers to make the clothing with, but we cannot. That is another matter, however, but the fact is that, in spite of the Minister's pious explanations, this putting of a round 60 per cent. duty, a duty at the highest rate in Part I of the Schedule, on all other articles of clothing not caught by that Schedule is going to put a serious tax on people who have to clothe families, and young families particularly.
Comment on this
There are a very large number of factories engaged in the production of these goods.
Comment on this
In my view, it is impossible for the Minister to make such a sweeping statement as is made in this reference. It refers to "Articles of personal clothing and wearing apparel not chargeable under any other reference number in this Part of this Schedule." I submit that it would be difficult for the Minister, on the spur of the moment, to satisfy himself as to what would be included in a sweeping statement of that character, or for his officials even after considerable thought, because when you make a general statement of this type, it is impossible, even after days or weeks of consideration, to be sure that you have contemplated everything that possibly can be brought under it. Relate that to the Minister's statement that he wishes to put a tariff only on things which he regards this country as being capable of producing, and it seems to me that the bona fides of that statement are slightly staggered. In my view, the common-sense way of going about tariffing goods which we are capable of producing here would be to get reports from people who contemplate producing these things, get accurate details of what they intend to produce and then tariff those particular goods seriatim. Here we have put in a general statement of this kind covering perhaps 20 per cent. of the things generally used in this community in that particular line, covering merely what is produced or is capable of production in this country, and then covering the other 80 per cent. of the same line which cannot be produced here and which must be bought by the purchasing public. There is that danger. I do not say that it exists here. There may be only a 5 per cent. margin of error here, but I think that, when introducing duties of this type, my method of approach is far preferable to that used by the Minister, and he shows that he uses that method by employing a general statement of this type.
Comment on this
I should say that this Schedule is really the result of ten years' experience. I think it is ten years, or more than ten years, since the first duty was imposed upon wearing apparel of all descriptions. It is quite true that the original duty was collected upon all sorts of extraordinary things, such as divers' suits, cricket bats, wigs, paper carnival hats, and a number of other things of that sort, but throughout the whole of that period, benefiting by experience, changes have been made. These articles are being brought into other categories and the flat rate duty upon all wearing apparel which originally existed has been broken up into a number of separate rates. The rates have been raised in a number of cases, it is true, but we reached the point last year at which we felt we could take the whole of the Schedule of duties upon wearing apparel of all descriptions, which, as I mentioned here, ran to well over 200 items, and simplify it. There were frequent consultations between the officers of the different Departments concerned, who had ten years' experience of the administration of these duties, and there were consultations with traders and other people likely to be able to give advice on the matter. As a result, this Schedule was produced. It effects changes in duty only incidentally, as it were, in order to achieve the simplification at which we were aiming. We have got that simplification and we are satisfied that this duty in its present form will be much more workable than the long scale of duties which was in existence heretofore.
All the other articles which might at one stage have been deemed to have been caught in a general definition of this kind are now being taken out of it and put into other categories, so that they will not be subject to this duty at all. I may say that it has been my experience that a general duty of this kind is always somewhat doubtful. It is much better to specify exactly the articles you intend to catch rather than have a general description of this kind, but in relation to these duties, after the ten years' experience of their operation, it is possible to have this definition without any apprehension that we are, in fact, catching more than we intend to catch.
Comment on this
I am still somewhat in agreement with Deputy McGuire as to this section. It seems to be, as Deputy McGuire puts it, an attempt to make it impossible for any article of any kind of clothing to evade duty. It seems to be a case, putting it in betting parlance, of so much against the field. The Minister is putting a 60 per cent. tariff against the field, and the field includes everything. I notice that Deputy Allen smiles. I do not know whether he understands the term, but perhaps the Minister knows that, in racing terms, the field includes everything, even a non-runner. Under this section, we have caught anything in the line of clothing that may have evaded the ingenuity of the Revenue Commissioners for ten years. Having assessed all the items of clothing for men, women and children that could be thought of, we are now putting a duty on any article not chargeable under any other reference number. There ought to be no necessity for that. If there was a 60 to one or a 40 to one chance of the taxpayer escaping the Revenue Commissioners and the various manufacturers he should get it.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
In Part I, to delete reference No. 15 and all references thereto in columns 2 and 3.
The amendment is to delete the words —
"Articles which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, accessories of personal clothing or wearing apparel."
It is bad enough to come up against a 60 per cent. duty on every article of clothing that the Minister and his officials could not think of, but when we come up against a 60 per cent. duty on anything that could be an accessory to an article of clothing, it is hard to dissociate the proposals in these Schedules from taxes that affect the home we have been discussing; and it is very hard to credit what the Minister says—that the proposals made in these Schedules are to safeguard and round-off the position in this country so as to stabilise and completely develop the clothing industry here. It seems to be, to a large extent, an imposition of taxation for revenue purposes. The Minister is aware that a very considerable amount of clothing of types not made in this country is going to come into the country and the Minister for Finance is going to get his taxation on that. Here we are putting a 60 per cent. duty on anything that is an accessory, and I should like to ask what is going to come under this heading?
Comment on this
Braces, belts, sock suspenders, garters and all that class of goods, as well as trimmings and other decorations.
Comment on this
These are dutiable under other Schedules. All these accessories have been dutiable heretofore, but not at this rate. They are being kept dutiable, and I think we could not contemplate removing the duty on these goods, all of which are made here. If wearing apparel can be made here, these accessories of wearing apparel can be made here also.
Comment on this
One article occurs to my mind which I have heard discussed. It is what is called a cravat and is part of women's wear. I do not know whether the Minister knows about it, but I believe it is made in 100 or 200 different varieties and is not produced in the Free State.
Comment on this
I do not know whether that would come under the definition of an accessory. I think it would be part of the wearing apparel.
Comment on this
That is something which is not produced here at all. This will be a pure revenue tax, because I believe there is no one producing these cravats here. A cravat is not an ancient sort of article. If Deputy Mrs. Concannon and Deputy Miss Pearse were here, they would be very worried to imagine that a tax was being put on this type of article, because there is nothing very ancient about it. It is something which is sought after every day of the week by women shoppers. Am I accurate in saying that this article is not being produced in this country or that it is not contemplated producing it here?
Comment on this
I could not answer straight away. I should imagine they are being manufactured here by the firms engaged in the production of clothing apparel.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In Part III, reference No. 28, in column 2, after the word "gauntlets" to insert the words "other than gloves and gauntlets suitable for wear by children."
Reference No. 28 proposes to put a duty of 8d. per article on "Gloves and gauntlets made wholly or mainly of leather or of skin or of leather and skin and not backed with fur, and also component parts (made of leather or skin or of leather and skin) of any such gloves." That means a tax of 1/4 on a pair of gloves. Again, this is a tax that will hit persons with young families particularly. Gloves are not made in this country in the various sizes and descriptions suitable for children, and the greater part of the gloves of that particular kind used by children here will have to be imported. The Minister must be aware of that. It is an absurd tax to put on children's gloves. That is why I ask to have this amendment inserted.
Comment on this
I am prepared to bring in an amendment on the next stage to exclude children's gloves from the scope of this duty, if the Deputy will let the matter stand over until then
Comment on this
As to reference No. 30, one is tempted to say that, while under our draft Constitution we are anxious to see that the skirt is kept on women, we seem, on the other hand, to have the opposite desire so far as this reference is concerned, in which it is proposed that "skirts which do not form part of a suit or costume at importation and are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, made wholly or partly of woven tissue" are to have a duty imposed on them of 7/6 per article. The Minister is probably aware that this particular duty will affect the very poorest type of purchaser of this particular type of article, because so far as they are produced in this country at present, they are not of anything like the quality of those which have been imported up to this.
There are shops all over the City of Dublin, in Grafton Street and Henry Street, and they have been able to buy their skirts in England at a price which enables them to sell them at something like 3/11. I do not know what the actual cost would be. It will now be impossible to get in any article of this sort at a price like that. An article bought in England at 3/11 would be sold somewhere in the region of 5/11. That is a modest estimate as to what the retail trade would expect on an article of that kind. I suggest that the Minister's Department should, before imposing a duty of 7/6 on an article of that kind which is of universal use amongst women, be satisfied that the local manufacturer would be able to produce an article which would ensure that no hardship would be inflicted on the people who require these goods. I am sure the Minister would agree that this is the sort of article that women cannot get on without.
Comment on this
I do not like to introduce any humorous element on this tariff. The matter works out in this way — that the more prosperous buyer of this class of goods is not going to be affected at all. The imposition of this 7/6 tariff will bring the selling price of a 3/11 article up to 13/-, and possibly the retail price will be considerably over that figure. That price would not affect the richer customers. They can buy no matter what the tariff is. The type of person I have in mind are the poor, who will not be able to get the article at all.
The tax is a prohibitive one and that, taken in conjunction with the other point, which is equally important, that no similarly cheap article is being produced here at all, will work out as a hardship on the very poor. It amounts to this: I understand that 4/11 is the basic price of skirts in this country. The selling price would be about 5/11. That would compare very unfavourably with the present price. I am sure the Minister would be able to correlate my remarks on this particular schedule with the general remarks made in the House already to-day about the rise in the cost of living. These things do not come into the calculation of the cost-of-living index figure at all but they are things that a Minister should take into account.
Comment on this
The particular duty mentioned here can be regarded as prohibitive. These goods can be made here and we believe that the firms engaged in the manufacture of them will be able to cut down their costs and compete in price with the imported goods when they get down to business. These firms are in a position to supply all the articles required and will do so.
Comment on this
I can understand from the Minister that this is a prohibitive tariff. That is evident on the face of it. But this tariff would possibly have another effect on the cost of living in this country. This tariff under reference No. 30 would mean a 200 per cent. protection. That is to say, that gives protection to the people engaged in this business in this country up to a margin of 200 per cent. That will make the cost of articles used here very high. I know the Minister is interested in protecting industry. At the same time he must be interested in protecting the consumers, and a 200 per cent. tariff is certainly going to hit the consumers of these articles.
Comment on this
In most classes of readymade clothing, indeed I might say in all classes, the competition between the existing firms here is quite keen. That will check any tendency to put up prices.
Comment on this
I just want to refer to Part II. of this Schedule to which no reference has been made. That is reference No. 16 dealing with second-hand garments brought in for resale. Some persons might consider that the tariff of 25 per cent there was not high enough.
Comment on this
That is what I remember. If the Minister is satisfied there is sufficient competition amongst the producers of cheap clothing, this tariff is high enough. I know the idea originally was to protect the home market and to keep out these second-hand goods of which much were imported but what I want to refer to just now is that a great deal of these second-hand goods are brought in by charitable societies and people like that.
Comment on this
The position has not been changed by this Bill. In the earlier years second-hand clothing came in and the Revenue Commissioners had discretion. I do not want to be taken as speaking authoritatively now, but my recollection is that the discretion worked all right.
Comment on this
Are they allowed in free? The Minister should allow them in free of duty, because they are of great advantage to the poor. The distribution of these goods coming into the country has been a great boon to poor people.
Comment on this
There is no change made under this Bill.
Third Schedule put and agreed to.
FOURTH SCHEDULE.
Comment on this
I oppose this Fourth Schedule. In reference No. 1 you have a tariff on wireless cabinets which is increased from the present 25 per cent. to 50 per cent. You have in reference No. 7 an increase in unglazed clay manufactures from 50 to 75 per cent. or on the preferential side from 33? per cent. to 50 per cent. The duty on dry batteries is increased from 33? to 50 per cent., and parcel tape and holders are increased from 50 per cent. to 100 per cent. One of the features of the information that was given in the preface to the trade returns in 1935 was the substantial rise in the cost of boots and shoes from 1932 to 1935. The rise in the cost of boots and shoes was accompanied by complaints on the part of the general public as to the quality of the boots and shoes.
In reference No. 16 there is a change in the rate of duty on certain component parts of boots and shoes. Component parts of boots and shoes, after bearing a tariff of 30 per cent., are now increased to 60 per cent., and another section of these is increased from 20 per cent. to 40 per cent. These are only a few samples out of Schedule IV, showing how the tariff wall grows, and with it the cost of living of the people is going up.
Fourth Schedule put and agreed to.
Fifth Schedule and Title put and agreed to.