We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Coiste (d'ath-thógaint—Airteagal a 20).

Contributions 136–276 of 276. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In my recollection, the Land Commission is covered by the decision in the Lynam-Butler case.

Comment on this

They do not seem to be too happy about it themselves.

Comment on this

They have, of course, acquired more power of late. As a lay man, it occurs to me that one word might possibly be added with useful effect: that is, where you speak of limited functions to say "limited specialised functions" so that there is no suggestion of anybody, except a judicial body, having a roving commission to decide all sorts of things.

Comment on this

I suggest it is a great pity that Deputy Lavery is not here for this debate, because I do not think he would be in agreement with his colleagues on this question.

Comment on this

I have not the slightest doubt that he would.

Comment on this

Deputy Lavery made a speech before the legal society of U.C.D. last winter very different in argument from the speech that Deputy Costello made here this evening. In that speech Deputy Lavery remarked that the courts were failing to meet the requirements of the public. He said that there ought to be power, and that it ought to be possible, for the ordinary citizen to go into the courts to get his rights either from his neighbour or from a public Department. He specially mentioned public Departments.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

There was evidence, he said, that the courts were failing to discharge their function, and because of the expense, and for other reasons, the ordinary citizen was prepared to suffer injustice rather than resort to the courts. Deputy Norton, a short time ago, pretty well supported that view when he said that to tell the people in Gloucester Street, or people with a great deal more means than the people in Gloucester Street, that the ordinary courts are open to them is like telling them that the Shelbourne Hotel is a very nice place to stop in when they have not got rooms of their own. It is all very well to talk about the encroachments of bureaucracy. Nobody wants bureaucracy entrenched at all.

But bureaucracy is better than nothing, and if the courts are not open to the ordinary citizen, as Deputy Lavery evidently thinks, and as most of us think, or open even for the middle classes—if the High Court and the Supreme Court only exist for people with very considerable means—then it is well to have at least a civil servant available that one can appeal to for certain rights. A civil servant, unless he is a very sinister person, will make an effort to do justice, and an effort to do some sort of justice is better than no effort at all.

Comment on this

Are we to understand from the President that the purpose of this Article is as Deputy Moore has outlined it?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I would like to point out that the remarks quoted from Deputy Lavery by Deputy Moore, and the other things the Deputy has said, have nothing whatever to do with the subject before the House at the moment. Deputy Lavery was quite obviously referring there to the fact that litigation is too expensive.

Comment on this

Is not that a very important question?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Deputy Moore made the point that it is only people of means who can afford to go to the High Court or to the Supreme Court. I would like to remind him that people of no means at all are often at a very great advantage in the Supreme Court or the High Court, because if they fail in the proceedings they bring no costs can be recovered from them.

Comment on this

What do the lawyers do then?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The President referred to what he called the present unsatisfactory position with regard to the matter dealt with in this Article. It is perhaps unsatisfactory, but that is owing to the extreme difficulty, if not the impossibility, of drawing the line between what are purely administrative functions and purely judicial functions. That is the reason why the position is not so satisfactory perhaps. The President made the further point that the decision of a Department should not be set aside on a purely technical plea. We all agree with that, and that position is protected by the present state of the law. The courts have on a number of occasions refused to set aside acts done by Departments on the ground that they were not an infringement of the exercise of judicial powers.

Deputy Costello has referred to a specific case where the Land Commission were exercising functions which, it could be argued, were largely judicial, but the Supreme Court held that they were entitled to exercise those functions in the circumstances.

Comment on this

In connection with this Article, has the President anything to say about Article 2A of the present Constitution?

Comment on this

I do not quite follow the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

Well, I suggest that, in reference to Article 38 of the Draft Constitution, something could be said with regard to the Military Tribunal. Does the President desire to continue the Military Tribunal? Does he think that it is desirable to continue the provisions of Article 2A of the present Constitution in this proposed Constitution?

Comment on this

Which particular section is the Deputy referring to?

Comment on this

I am referring to Sections 3 and 4 of Article 38, which deal with the setting up of special courts, military tribunals, and so on.

Comment on this

I have no hesitation whatever in saying that this is a power which, clearly, it is necessary to have in the Constitution. I have no hesitation whatever in saying that. I believe that it is necessary to make such a provision as this so that, in case there should be any need of passing a law to provide such special courts, it could be done.

Comment on this

The President evidently has found the angels necessary to administer it.

Comment on this

I do not follow the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

The President, on one occasion, said, referring to Article 2A of the Constitution, that it would take angels to administer it.

Comment on this

Fortunately, the angels came into office very quickly.

Comment on this

I understood that it was the Military Tribunal, and not the Government, that administered the law in that case.

Comment on this

Is that what the Deputy thinks?

Comment on this

Well, I did not know. Was it the case that they were completely under the thumb of the Government?

Comment on this

No, but the Government has tremendous powers under that Article.

Comment on this

Yes, but I understood, from what the President said five years ago, that it would be necessary to have angels to administer it.

Comment on this

What has happened in the last five years to enable the President to change his mind? I remember that he described that piece of legislation as the greatest piece of coercion since Cromwell's time. Does the President hold the same view still?

Comment on this

I hold that that Act gave enormous powers to the Executive—powers which, at the time, I was very definitely of the view were going to be abused; and I still think that the existence of an Article such as Article 2A could only be justified under extreme circumstances. We have tried to create the circumstances under which Acts of that kind would be unnecessary. We have tried to bring about conditions that would render such an Act unnecessary any longer. Although the power is taken here to pass such legislation, I do still hope that the need for passing legislation to implement that power will not be necessary; but I think it would be a very grave mistake also for us, in view of the situation and the conditions that we have passed through, to do anything to prevent the passing of legislation of that nature.

In order to pass that other Act— which was so clearly and obviously against the Constitution—you had to introduce a constitutional measure. In fact, you had to make it the Constitution. That was the position. The position was that the rest of the Constitution had to be read subject to Article 2A. Now we have had a motion here from Deputy Norton regarding the rights and liberties possessed by the citizens, and saying that they should be continued. Well, I suggest that the Deputy should read Article 2A of the old Constitution. The position is that you are providing here that, if it should be necessary to set up special courts, you would not be prevented from doing so by the Constitution. One does not want to provide a constitutional barrier to the setting up of such special courts. After all, we are going here to have a Constitution which will not be changed easily. Under this Constitution it will not be possible to summon your Dáil or Seanad over-night, and in a day or two get a whole Act passed through. Under this Constitution you could never pass even a very, very modified Article 2A. This, however, gives you power, if the occasion demands it, to bring in such legislation, but this itself is not enacting anything. If the conditions demand it, you will have to have an Act to implement what you want. Perhaps I should not use the word "implement," as it is not the proper word to use; but under this Constitution you would have to have an Act brought in to set up such courts, and whatever Government would be here would have to bring it in. Accordingly I have no apology whatever to offer for that. I feel that it is a matter of ordinary common-sense and wisdom.

Comment on this

We do not ask the President to apologise for putting it into this Act, but we think he should apologise for some of the statements, in connection with this matter, that he made five years ago.

Comment on this

The conditions justify everything that I said. Conditions now are different.

Comment on this

I agree that the conditions then were quite different from what they are to-day. I agree that there was much more justification for it then than there is to-day, but I also say that there is much more justification to-day to talk about the greatest piece of coercion since Cromwell's time than there was when the President used the phrase in 1931.

Comment on this

I have no apologies to offer for it.

Comment on this

Of course, the President has no apologies to offer. We do not expect any from him. As usual, he claims that he is right. He claims that he is right five years after the event. The President talks about its being abused. Whatever abuse there was of that piece of the machinery of legislation, I suggest, was by the present Government. The first use made of that machinery of government by the present Government was against people who had not paid their rates.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not relevant to the matter under discussion. The merits or demerits of that particular Article are not relevant to this discussion. That particular Act has already been decided upon.

Comment on this

I know that, Sir, and I know that very many members of this House do not wish to be reminded of what happened under that Act. The President, however, talks about rushing it through, but the sole justification for the Article in the Constitution now is that it will not be necessary to amend the Constitution in order to bring in similar legislation, or even more drastic legislation. If the President considers that the occasion demands it—and the President has given us an idea of what the Government thinks necessitates trial by the Military Tribunal—people who are unable to pay their rates are to be hauled before the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Smith says "Hear, hear," but Deputy Smith was not prepared, under that Act, to have people, who had committed murder, brought before the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not relevant to the matter we are discussing.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey seems to have worked himself up into a little bit of a fury in regard to this.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Everybody who knows the circumstances can understand it. We can understand Deputy Morrissey's outlook. We all want ammunition for the week-end speeches, and Deputy Morrissey knows that all this will go down well in Tipperary next Sunday. The speeches made here will be trotted out next Sunday at some church gate, and there is no doubt that it will be a grand thing.

Comment on this

That is how you would do it.

Comment on this

He seems to have been making a great point out of the fact that the President has changed his mind in connection with the Military Tribunal. It is extraordinary how we all change our minds on occasions. I was looking over some records recently of an occasion on which Deputy Morrissey apparently changed his mind. I remember meeting Deputy Morrissey at a meeting in the Shelbourne Hotel when he was very anxious to hurl Deputy Cosgrave out of office because, as he said in this House, Deputy Cosgrave and his colleagues were the greatest political "omadhauns" that ever cursed this country.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy give the quotation for that?

Comment on this

It is on the Official Records.

Comment on this

I should like to get it.

Comment on this

If the Deputy comes down to the library, I will put his finger upon it. I, with a number of other people, met Deputy Morrissey in the Shelbourne Hotel, and his ambition then was to collect as many T.D.s as he could to hurl Deputy Cosgrave out of office. The Deputy has evidently changed his mind since that time.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Deputy if he would tell us the reason why the President refused to come into the Dáil on that occasion? The empty formula could not be taken then.

Comment on this

Might I make one suggestion in connection with clause 3 of Article 38? However much the President may not be disposed to accept my statement, the suggestion I make is one that I would recommend any Government with which I was associated to adopt, having regard to my experience both before and after the change of Government in connection with the Military Tribunal. That is, to allow the courts to determine, as a question of fact, whether the circumstances existing in the country were such as to justify the establishment of special courts and secondly, to provide in this Constitution that any law that would be passed establishing special courts, must provide for an appeal from the decision of these courts to the Court of Criminal Appeal. As I say, I make that suggestion in all seriousness to the President as a matter that I would advise any Government in their own interest to incorporate in a law establishing special courts. The President is probably aware that in connection with another clause in this Article ousting the jurisdiction of the courts during a time of war or armed rebellion, the decision as to whether a state of war or armed rebellion does or does not exist rests entirely with the courts. That was determined both prior and subsequent to the Treaty. A decision of our own courts, somewhere about 1923 or 1924, was that a state of armed rebellion did not exist although the courts had decided prior to that that such a state did exist. My submission to the President is, that if the suggestion I make were adopted, it would go far towards calming the very reasonable fears that special courts would be used for subverting the liberties of the subject and also for the purpose of enabling criminal trials to be carried through without advertence to the ordinary rules of evidence. The last remark I shall make on that subject is that some people think that the rules of evidence and laws of evidence are something in which lawyers revel, something which are highly technical. The rules of evidence, as a matter of fact, have been established over a course of years and as the result of experience. They are worked out as the result of experience, brought to bear on the interests of the ordinary litigant and on his interest alone. I make this suggestion for the President's consideration.

Comment on this

The President, of course, is now apparently anxious to justify the circumstances which necessitated the use by the Government of Article 2A, but I suggest to him that, in setting up a new Constitution, there is no case for the insertion of a provision to establish special courts in the manner provided in this Article, and that we have no evidence before us of the desirability of establishing such courts. There is no condition of affairs in the country to-day which justifies the continued use of the Military Tribunal. There is no situation in the country to-day which justifies the continued incarceration of people or, at any rate, of the overwhelming majority of the people detained, in accordance with sentences imposed by that nonlegal body. I suggest that it is anticipating trouble and anticipating a very abnormal situation to put a provision of this kind into the Constitution. If a situation developed here in which there was an abnormal set of circumstances existing, the country should have an opportunity to consider that situation without its being made so easy and convenient for an Executive Council to resort to the introduction of such special courts. I think, in a situation of this kind, we ought to aim at ensuring in the Constitution that our normal legal machinery would be adequate for the trial of any ordinary type of offence. It is not a very healthy situation when a country thinks it necessary to establish special courts for the purpose of dealing with offences. The ordinary run of civilised communities is that the ordinary courts are adequate to deal with offences known to the law of the country. That is the situation that should be aimed at in this and every other Constitution which is to govern a democratic country.

I do not want to see this Article here used for the enactment of legislation which creates an offence not known to the normal law of the country. This is intended to be a justification for perpetuating the Constitution (Amendment) Act, an Act which creates a whole category of new offences, offences not known to the ordinary law of this or any other country. I think it is regrettable to find a provision of this kind in the Constitution. The President, in other days, denounced the Constitution (Amendment) Act. I think he was right then and I think he is wrong now. I do not think any set of circumstances justifies the continuance of that Act on the Statute Book having regard to the conditions which exist in the country to-day. This Article appears to me to be incorporated for no other purpose than to justify the continuance of that Act. We may be told after the Constitution is passed, and the Constitution (Amendment) Act continued in operation, that the authority for keeping it in operation was the Constitution passed by this House and endorsed by the people. It is not possible, of course, to get a clear verdict from the people in a Constitution of this kind as to whether or not they desire the continuance of Article 2A and whether they are prepared to have that Article covered or continued in Article 38 of this Constitution.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy knows that this Constitution does not cover the continuance of Article 2A?

Comment on this

I am not so sure at all.

Comment on this

Does it not definitely repeal the whole of the old Constitution?

Comment on this

This does?

Comment on this

This Constitution, when it is passed, will repeal the whole of the old Constitution, including that famous Article 2A.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

How then can it be used as a basis for continuing it?

Comment on this

Is the President suggesting, therefore, that automatically with the repeal of the old Constitution we are going to have no attempt made to continue the provisions of the present Constitution (Amendment) Act?

Comment on this

That is not the question.

Comment on this

But that is a very important aspect of the question. Are we to understand—because it would alter my viewpoint a good deal on this Article—that when this Constitution is passed Article 2A will be dropped, and dropped definitely, and that no effort will be made to revive the Article in another form and as a basis of the abnormal legislation that is provided for here? Whether that is going to happen or not—and my fear is that it is going to happen—we ought not to embody legislation of this kind in a normal Constitution. If there is need to meet any special situation, it ought to be an obligation on the Executive Council of the day, firstly, to enact its legislation through the Legislature, and, if that legislation invades the ordinary rights of the citizens as enshrined in the Constitution, there ought to be an obligation on the Executive Council to get the authority of the people by referendum to pass that ordinary legislation.

I dislike giving any Executive the power to pass that abnormal, extraordinary legislation in the simple, easy way that would be possible if this Article passed in its present form. All that is necessary to do then is to get a majority of one in this House and special legislation of the type foreshadowed here could be passed. It will then be possible to invade the ordinary liberties of the citizen in the manner provided for in this Constitution and in precisely the same way as the Constitution (Amendment) Act was passed. If a set of circumstances of that kind arises, the Government should be put under an obligation to get its legislation through the House, and should be compelled to get a referendum from the people before it is entitled to tear up the ordinary protective provisions of the Constitution. I think, therefore, that this type of legislation which is foreshadowed here is the type of legislation for which the Government should be required to get a special mandate from the people by means of a referendum, and that it should not be slipped in in this way in order to enable the Government to utilise it when a particular set of circumstances may make it possible for the Government to use the provision in the Constitution in a manner that will enable them to make political capital out of their powers and to inflict considerable political damage on their political opponents.

Comment on this

I do not suppose that anybody is entirely satisfied with what is known as the Public Safety Act, or Article 2A as it stands, and if legislation is brought in under the power given by this new Article 38 of the present Constitution, I think it is more than likely that such legislation would differ in some important respects from the actual provisions of Article 2A of the old Constitution. As for this new Article itself, Article 38, which Deputy Norton considers to be unsuitable to a civilised or democratic country, I must say outright that I warmly support it. It is unfortunate that such an Article should be necessary, but there is no use in shutting our eyes to facts. Owing to the unfortunate circumstances of our history there is an old tradition of secret terrorism in this country, a tradition that is liable from time to time to be revived. We have not got it out of our blood yet in this country. I am sure that, as a result of the exercise of self-government, the time will come when we will have got it out of our blood, but it is not out of our blood yet, and while Deputy Norton speaks as if the state of the country were wholly satisfactory, our memories are not so very short as he seems to imagine. After all, there were three very terrible murders committed not at all so long ago, the More O'Ferral murder, the Egan murder and the Somerville murder. It is for cases like that—where the ordinary courts cannot be expected to function successfully, and have in fact been proved by experience not to function successfully —that it is necessary to provide by such an Article as is now under consideration. Therefore I warmly support the Article, and I would consider myself undemocratic if I opposed it, because nothing could be more undemocratic than to expose the humble citizens of the country to crime and intimidation and violence.

Comment on this

As Deputy Norton continued to speak he began to get a little bit clear about what the actual position is. The position is that this Constitution, by its enactment, will repeal Article 2A. You will then have the ordinary courts, trial by jury, and so on. I am perfectly certain that there is no Deputy here in this House who will hold that trial by jury is possible if there is an organised, armed body that can intimidate and terrorise. Is it not quite evident that, under modern conditions, if you have an organised, armed body throughout the country they can prevent trial by jury? If you are to preserve trial by jury as an institution, you need protection of this sort.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

What we are doing here, then, is that when this Constitution is passed we are thrown back upon the ordinary law. I hope that that will be sufficient—that we will be able to work under that. I sincerely hope so, but we have to remember that it is only a hope. If that hope should not be realised, and if there should be circumstances such as we have passed through, in which you will have murders committed and in which you will have intimidation and terrorism, surely the community as a whole must be empowered to protect itself. Consequently, in such circumstances, you do need to have a system under which you will be able to protect the community in general by means of these courts, which will not be intimidated. That is the purpose. It would certainly be very wrong for us, in passing a Constitution of this sort, which unlike the old Constitution cannot be changed by a simple Act, if we did not make provision for a possibility which is there. All that is done here is that it will be possible, if it is necessary, to bring in a law to arrange for special courts of a character that will not be open to intimidation, and I think we would not be doing our duty at all if we did not have an Article of this sort.

Just listen to what it says: "Special courts may be established by law"—they must be set up by law; this does not set them up—"for the trial of offences in cases where it may be determined in accordance with such law"—the law will determine the cases or, rather, it will determine the general conditions—"that the ordinary courts are inadequate to secure the effective administration of justice, and the preservation of public peace and order."

If the ordinary courts are not able to secure the effective administration of justice, and the preservation of public peace and order, does Deputy Norton suggest that they should not be supplemented by courts which could do the necessary work for the community? What Deputy Norton wants is, that we should omit this provision, and we would then find, before we could take any action to supplement the ordinary courts, to make the administration of justice effective and to preserve the peace, possibly that we should have to go through the process of amending the Constitution by means of a plebiscite. I am perfectly certain that if Deputy Norton was here, and had the same responsibility for seeing that order is preserved in the community, he would take very good care that the possibility of establishing such courts would be provided for in the Constitution.

Comment on this

That is what Deputy Cosgrave said and you challenged him.

Comment on this

And I challenge you now.

Comment on this

You challenged Deputy Cosgrave then, but you are wandering away from it now.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Norton will be in agreement with me when I congratulate the President on the thoroughness of his conversion. He refused to give an apology to Deputy Morrissey, who, I am sorry, was not then in the House. Luckily he came in at the end to hear that thorough justification of his action. I never heard a more thorough justification than the President gave, and I congratulate him on it. Deputy Norton must not think that the President will forego this Article. When they have dealt with it he will find that the Constitution consists largely of Article 2A. A hurried glance at it gives that impression.

Comment on this

This finishes Article 2A.

Comment on this

It does not. The President knows it does not. I am not quarrelling with the President. I am only congratulating him on the thoroughness with which he repudiated and so succinctly everything that he condemned when he was sitting on these benches. As he said to Deputy Norton, truth is one thing over there and another thing here. When Deputy Norton gets on to these benches he will have a different conception of truth. The President had that different conception of truth. We now have it that he does not think Deputy Norton will ever get on these benches and that he does not expect to change him. I want to apologise for one slight dereliction on my part towards the present Government. I refer to a quotation I gave in which there was a reference to a government of angels. I find that the reference was made by the then Deputy Lemass and that he said: "We believe these powers are such that they should not be conferred even on a Government of archangels."

Comment on this

A higher one.

Comment on this

A supreme court. The conversion is thorough.

Comment on this

The President became heated and bothered over this Article and, as he was speaking, while I recognised the figure present as that of Deputy de Valera I found considerable difficulty in recognising the philosophy and the mentality that was Deputy de Valera's that I used to know when he was on the Opposition Benches. It was the very antithesis. While the hand was the hand of Esau the voice was the voice of Jacob. The President delivered a speech which was an absolute repentance for everything he said when on the Opposition Benches. He said that if a jury cannot be got to function in abnormal circumstances someone must be got to convict. Will the President treat himself to a little exhilarating amusement this evening by looking up a speech he delivered on a Bill to abolish the practice of having juries named in open court? When the President discourses in a rather heated way about the necessity for something of the type of a military tribunal, will he look up the speech he made on the Constitution (Amendment) Act? If he does not think that sufficiently fiery, let him look at the speeches made by those who are now sitting on the Front Benches. When finished with that process, let him then say to himself: "Well, all we said about that then I now justify as something that is necessary, even in circumstances which to-day are in no way comparable with those which existed when the Constitution (Amendment) Act was introduced."

Comment on this

You have a Constitution now. The people will have a Constitution about which there will be no excuse of any kind.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave said the very same thing.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave said at that time precisely what the President said now. I venture to say that if a committee of inquiry was established to compare the Second Reading speeches on the Constitution (Amendment) Act and the speech the President delivered five minutes ago, there would not be much trouble in discovering that there was no difference whatever in the mentality in both instances as to the necessity for that particular type of abnormal legislation. I prefer to believe what the President said in 1931. I think what he said then about the Constitution (Amendment) Bill and the abnormal powers in it was right. I think the President is wrong in 1937. If the President gets rather annoyed and heated because I think he was right in 1931 and wrong in 1937, that is equivalent to a declaration by the President, though not conveyed in so many words, that he believes in 1937 that he was wrong in opposing the Constitution (Amendment) Act in 1931.

Comment on this

That is the essence of the President's declaration this evening. To complete his conversion, he should make a declaration that having got on the Government Benches— which apparently justifies a great deal —it was not right to oppose this, because then there will be responsibility.

Comment on this

No, I said you would have to make provision of this sort.

Comment on this

Why did the President object to the Government in 1931 making a provision of this sort?

Comment on this

Because I would not bring in a Bill of that character.

Comment on this

You would not bring it in; you would only operate it.

Comment on this

Article 2A has had a pretty good run since 1931.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not done much to stop the run of it.

Comment on this

I did more than you did to oppose it every time I got the opportunity. You voted for it.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Norton can bear out that statement.

Comment on this

I can. I will be glad to hear, in the course of the debate, if it is permissible in what connection the statement can be disproved.

Comment on this

You voted against a vote of censure on the Government for using Article 2A against the Blue-shirts and the farmers.

Comment on this

I will demolish that statement completely.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not now; the Deputy can take another opportunity.

Comment on this

Everyone knows that the reference of Deputy MacDermot was to a particular political proposal submitted by the Deputy when he was a member of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy come back to the Constitution?

Comment on this

I say that there should be no necessity for putting this abnormal provision into a Constitution of this kind. If there are circumstances which necessitate abnormal measures, the Government should be forced to go to the country to get authority from the people. They should not have exceptional facilities or abnormal powers enshrined in this Constitution. I say in conclusion that if the President were still over on these benches, instead of being in the particularly delicate position he is in now, when he is standing on thin ice, the President would be saying the very same things about this provision as he said in 1931 and as I am saying now, namely, he would be advocating that a Government should not be entitled to arrogate to itself these special powers for use with any speed or facility the Government cares to exercise in the utilisation of these powers. I believe he would be saying, if he were on the Opposition Benches, that, if there is an abnormal situation, the people ought to be given an opportunity of saying whether the situation is so abnormal as to justify giving to an Executive Council the powers which the President proposes to arrogate to an Executive Council under this Constitution.

Comment on this

That is an absurd statement about the Government arrogating to itself powers under this Constitution. It is arrogating nothing. It is equally absurd to say that this is unusual. As a matter of fact, there is hardly a Constitution of a written character in which you have not sweeping provisions to enable the Government to suspend the whole Constitution in the circumstances in which we are only taking power to set up a special court to deal with cases where the ordinary courts cannot function. So that it is nonsense to make statements of that sort about the Government arrogating power to itself. What is here is a very mild form of an Article which is found in partically every written Constitution, an Article providing for the complete suspension of constitutional guarantees in order to be able to deal with cases where the ordinary machinery of Government is not capable of coping with the situation it has to deal with. Consequently, if we did not have this here, we could have it in another form. We could have—and it might have passed without any criticism such as has been levelled at this—an Article which would be in the usual form, that in certain circumstances all constitutional guarantees are suspended.

I think we are doing very much less than suspending all the constitutional guarantees. We came in here with no desire to use anything but the ordinary courts. We suspended Article 2A the moment we came into office; we put it out of operation, so far as we were concerned. Then we had to resort to it, because it was the only thing available at our hands, to enable us to act in the public interest at the time. It was the only means available to us and, as it was available to us, we used it. But we had confidence in ourselves that we were not going to abuse these powers. If I were in opposition, I would again oppose the Government being allowed to continue with these powers. It is one thing having confidence in yourself and in the Government. There is no nonsense about it. It is a fact that every man is able to judge for himself whether he is going to abuse an instrument. If the same instrument is put into other people's hands, naturally he will be suspicious and say that they might very well abuse it. If I were on the other Benches, I would be opposing any extraordinary powers such as are in Article 2A. I would not be opposing this, because this is in a rigid Constitution and gives to the Legislature power to pass laws to meet emergencies which are provided for in other Constitutions by another method, and a much more drastic method.

I have nothing further to say in regard to this than that, in my opinion, and in the opinion of my colleagues, an Article such as this is necessary so long as it is possible to have an armed organisation in the country. There may be quite a different set of circumstances in ten years' time. It may be another type of armed organisation that you will have to deal with—a different type. As long as you have modern weapons and modern powers of organising, then the community needs to have some method at its disposal for dealing with such situations, and all that is done here is to provide that a law can be passed to deal with such a situation.

Comment on this

I think it should not go on the Records of this House that this particular Article is far less drastic than the ordinary provision found in written Constitutions providing for the suspension of constitutional guarantees in certain cases. In its effect this particular Article is capable of being used in every bit as drastic a manner as any of the provisions in any of the written Constitutions providing for the suspension of the constitutional guarantees. The chief guarantees in written Constitutions are: the guarantee of habeas corpus, the guarantee of the free expression of opinion, and the guarantee of public meeting. This article allows any law to be passed, in the circumstances covered by it, suspending the right of habeas corpus, suspending the right of free speech, suspending the right of free expression of opinion, and suspending the right of public meeting. It is right, irrespective of the merits or demerits of this Article, that it should not appear on the Records of this House that this Article is not as drastic or as capable of being utilised in a drastic fashion as any of the provisions of the Continental Constitutions providing for the suspension of constitutional guarantees.

Comment on this

It might be no harm to reinforce what I have said. This is one of the Constitutions in this book which has been handed to me. I could give quite a number of them.

Comment on this

They are all the same.

Comment on this

There are quite a number of them. Let us see one of them. This is Article 124 of the Constitution of the Polish Republic:—

"The rights of the individual— liberty of the person (Article 97), inviolability of the dwelling (Article 100), liberty of the Press (Article 105), secrecy of correspondence (Article 106), right of combination and association and of forming unions (Article 108)—may be temporarily suspended in the whole territory of the State, or in any parts thereof, if rendered necessary for reasons of public safety."

All these individual rights are swept away through the whole State if rendered necessary by reasons of public safety. The Article goes on to state:—

"The Council of Ministers has the exclusive right to decree such suspension..."

—there is no question of law now—

"...with the authorisation of the President of the Republic in case of war or danger of war, of internal disorder, or of grave conspiracies of a treasonable character threatening the Constitution or the public safety."

That is pretty drastic. As the Deputy pointed out, it is almost a common feature of these written Constitutions that there is power for a most sweeping suspension of all the guarantees to the individual, and so on, that are given in the Constitution.

Comment on this

All I can say is that the President's conversion is complete. I am not arguing against this Article. I am only pointing that out. There is no good in his telling the House that he is repealing Article 2A, when any Government with a majority can carry it in 48 hours. Secondly, he said that he would not have brought in Article 2A. But he administered it. Why did he never amend it? Was it because he was squeamish about amending the Constitution? He brought in several amendments to the Constitution. If there was anything in that Article which was too drastic, why did he not amend it? The explanation is quite clear. The President has no confidence in any Government that is not himself. Is not that what he said? No powers are to be given to anyone except himself, and any powers proposed to be given to anybody except himself he will criticise and obstruct and refuse powers against even murder if necessary.

Comment on this

Nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

He will prevent any other Government getting the powers necessary to deal with these emergency cases. He pointed out that the circumstances were different in 1931. They will be quite different at the end of 1937. The circumstances are different now because he is responsible for the Government. He was not responsible in 1931, and he will not be responsible at the end of 1937. That is the difference.

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Sullivan say that he said that also?

Comment on this

The President said that if he were again on these benches he would oppose something of that kind, and he said he would do so because some other body would be administering it and because it would not be administered by himself.

Comment on this

Oh, now, be fair.

Comment on this

Well, we were all listening to him. I have no objection to the Deputy allowing me to emphasise that the President's objection to this Article 2A of the Constitution was that he was not administering it himself. As long as he was administering Article 2A it was a perfect Article, but the very minute any other Government came to administer it, it became a bad Article. He told us that in such circumstances, if he were over here on the Opposition side, he would oppose it as he did in 1931.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not get Deputy Costello to agree with him in what he is saying.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, he will.

Comment on this

I am just saying what the President told the whole House. There is no other explanation of his words.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows there is.

Comment on this

That is an unfair interpretation.

Comment on this

The President has too many assessors.

Comment on this

We are dealing with the President's speech. If the President can give another explanation than the explanation I have given, I will listen to it; but I understood that the main cause of his objection to this Article 2A was not the Article itself but the people who were administering it.

Comment on this

We on this side did not understand that from what the President said.

Comment on this

To be sure the Deputy did not. It is very difficult for the President himself to understand it, but for back-benchers on the Government side it is impossible. If Deputy Briscoe will explain what was in the mind of the President I will be quite satisfied, but the President said quite distinctly that he had confidence in himself to do the right thing.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

He admits it. He shakes his head. He is prepared to deny what I am going to say before I have said it. That shows you the whole Fianna Fáil tactics; only one person can govern this country. As long as he is governing this country let him have full powers to do what he likes, but let no one else or any other Government have any powers. That is the President's suggestion.

Comment on this

I am sure that Deputy O'Sullivan is only fooling. He is not serious about this at all.

Comment on this

Oh, indeed I am. That is just the President's mind.

Comment on this

I am asked now why we did not amend Article 2A of the Constitution. If we had to deal with the situation we would have to bring in a Bill to give certain powers. Now the greater includes the lesser, and in Article 2A there were those powers which I would certainly oppose being given to any Government if I were in Opposition. I certainly would oppose the giving of such powers because I had a right to think they would be abused. I would not be surprised at all to find, if there was an Act brought in under this, that the Government and the Opposition would be taking different views about it. That would be no surprise whatever to me. We have got here an Act which gives us lots of things we would not bring in at all if we were bringing in the measure ourselves. But included in that Act are powers which we ourselves would seek. Why should we, while in office, change that Act? That Act gave us certain powers. We were not going to abuse these powers, powers that we believed could be abused. Why should we, as long as we were in office, bring in and pass another Act? When we were dealing with these matters we did not think the Seanad was going to deal with the measures we would bring in, in the same way as the Seanad dealt with the measures brought in by the Opposition when they were in office. The circumstances in which we used that Act were circumstances in which it was necessary to use it in order to protect order and public safety. We had to have some measure, and we used this and we continued to use it. Now this Draft Constitution is completely repealing the Constitution. A situation will be created, once the Constitution is enacted, in which you will have only the ordinary law on which to depend. You will have to depend on conditions at the time. Whether the Government of that time will immediately come to Parliament with a measure providing for the powers which may be necessary to maintain order is a situation that will have to be faced. That is the situation, and that is why this Article is here.

Comment on this

The President talks about the ordinary law. Perhaps it is no harm to remind him again of his own views some time ago.

Comment on this

I would like to hear some quotations.

Comment on this

The President charged that the previous Government could not rule without coercion. The President will remember what he said about the previous Government—that they could not rule by the ordinary law. He now gives his reasons why he did not amend Article 2A of the Constitution——

Comment on this

I would like to hear the quotations the Deputy has promised.

Comment on this

If the President will allow me he will hear them. The President tries to give reasons for not amending Article 2A of the Constitution. Will he tell us what powers were enshrined in Article 2A of the Constitution that he has not used during the last five years? That is one of the things I would like to know. Will any Deputy on the Government side who spoke so strongly on this matter five years ago, tell us what has arisen in the last five years which justifies them in changing their minds? I want to say quite clearly and candidly, that I am glad that Deputies on the opposite side including the President have come around to our point of view. The difference between the President and Deputy Norton is this: the President knows he was wrong in 1931 and he now admits it; Deputy Norton and the Labour Party know they were wrong in 1931, but they are not prepared to admit it even now. That is the difference between the Labour Party and the Government Party. The President has made that very clear in every speech he has made upon this Article.

Comment on this

So much has been said about 1931 and the President changing his point of view that I think it would be illuminating to refer to what was said in 1921 about the President——

Comment on this

Is it in order?

Comment on this

There has been a great deal of talk about 1931, and if references to 1931 are to be admitted, I think I should be permitted to speak for a few moments about something that happened in 1921.

Comment on this

Article 2A of the Constitution was not there in 1921.

Comment on this

What I am about to say applies very closely to the matter we have been discussing here to-day. This is an extract from the meeting of Dáil Eireann on Friday, 26th August, 1921, on the occasion of the election of President. After Deputy Seán MacEoin had spoken in Irish, he said in English:—

"The honour has fallen on me to put before the Dáil the name of Eamon de Valera as President of the Irish Republic"——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy relate that quotation to the provisions in this Constitution giving power to set up special courts? I am not preventing the Deputy from reading this quotation if he will relate it to the matter under discussion. I am not preventing him from referring to the meeting of Dáil Eireann in 1921 if he relates it to this debate.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, in this way— that the President has been charged with changing his mind, and we want to prove that other people, too, have changed their minds.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must take another occasion to do that. The Deputy will please sit down.

Comment on this

I think the President must be going out of his mind when he invites quotations from his former speeches.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

If the President wants a large sheaf of quotations from the speeches of himself and his colleagues, he has only to refer to the debate on the motion of censure by me in 1933——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

At this point perhaps the Deputy would report progress.

Comment on this

Very well. I beg to report progress.

Comment on this