We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Bunreacht na hEireann (Dréacht)—Coiste (d'ath-thógaint).

Contributions 1–121 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I want to intimate that I do not propose to move amendment No. 126 or the remaining amendments now. I propose to move them on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Did you move amendment No. 126 last night?

Comment on this

No, I did not use the word "move" at all up to 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

The Deputy moved to report progress last night.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Mrs. Redmond I move amendment No. 127:

In Section 2, sub-section 1º, lines 1 and 2, to delete the words "by her life within the home".

I should like to know the President's attitude on this question.

Comment on this

I see no reason whatever for deleting these words.

Comment on this

Of course not.

Comment on this

It is perfectly obvious to anybody who takes the trouble of reading the section what its intention is. This is dealing with the family and states: "In particular, the State recognises that, by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved". I should like to know if anybody will controvert that. Then it goes on: "The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home." Surely that is a praiseworthy object for the State to set before itself—that mothers, whose work is essential for the common good, should not be compelled by economic necessity to abandon that fundamentally important work and be forced to undertake duties which would compel them to neglect their duties in the home.

I have not been able, from the start, to understand why there should be any antagonism of any kind to that section. I do not understand the attitude of any woman who objects to it. There is no suggestion in that that a woman should not be free to take up any avocation she chooses; no suggestion that a woman should not exercise her liberty of marrying or not marrying. What is stated here is, if women choose to marry and found a home, that they should not be compelled by modern conditions, which very often force mothers to engage in outside labour, to do that, and that it should be the duty of the State to endeavour to see that that shall not happen. How the State may endeavour to see that is quite another question. We leave the methods completely and absolutely open, as it is right that we should.

For example, to indicate my own mind in regard to the attitude the community should have towards men and women in that particular matter in regard to the home, I would say this, that if work and the means of livelihood are not available for the father of a family, the State should itself, if it cannot be found in ordinary industry, in ordinary commerce and in the economic life, endeavour to provide that work somehow. If the State is unable to do that, it is only then that the obligation of maintenance would fall upon the community as a whole. But, if I were able so to organise it, I certainly would try to get for the community as a whole some immediate return from a man who is getting assistance in that particular way. In other words, I should try so to organise it that work of public utility, something of value to the community as a whole, should result from the assistance which the community had to give in that particular matter. I think the man ought to render back to the community in the way of some work something for the assistance he is given.

But, if it were a woman, I take quite the other attitude. I say a woman, by her duties in the home, is, in fact, performing for the community as a whole a fundamental service. I would say that she, by doing that work, was rendering invaluable service to the State and I would not require of a mother, under these circumstances, any other form of return, such as I would be inclined to demand in the case of a man. That makes quite clear what our attitude is in regard to woman's position in the home. She is rendering in the home a fundamental and indispensable service to the State. The greatest service she can render is to perform her duties in the due manner and anything that would compel her to neglect these duties would be, in my opinion, a loss to the State as a whole.

Comment on this

I suggest that we should have a quorum to listen to this sermon.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

As I said, this seems to me to be a clause to which no reasonable person can object. There is nothing in the clause, so far as I can see, and nothing that can be deduced by way of supposed implication in the clause, which should cause any resentment on the part of any citizen in the State. Particularly, I cannot understand why there should appear to be resentment on the part of some women. Surely it cannot be that there is objection to this, because I mentioned the home, or because I mentioned one section of womankind. We are not supposed in this document to take every section and to deal with life as a whole. We are dealing with a very important matter in this section, namely that modern conditions are forcing women, through economic necessity, to neglect their duties in the home, not that they want to do it.

There is no suggestion in this Article of interfering with the free-will of any woman. The problem is to endeavour to provide some remedy for a great modern evil. I am at a loss to understand the Deputy's point of view. I should like to hear what anybody has to say on it, and to understand what is the basis of the criticism of this Article?

Comment on this

The President said that the purpose of this Article was to provide a remedy for a great modern evil. This section of Article 41 is his conception of providing a remedy for a great modern evil. It provides nothing. There was one part of a sentence in which I agreed with the President. He started a sentence in which he said "there is nothing in this Article..." If the President had stopped there the Opposition would agree with him. There is nothing in the Article. There is a great deal of pretence about the President and about everything he does, but this Article means nothing legislatively. The President himself says there is nothing in the Article, and with that part of his sentence I agree. That is what the Article means—nothing. It may, as a piece of guidance, have some effect. What the President aims at may be an excellent aim. There is nothing in this Article nor in this phrase "by her life within the home," which makes any more difference than if it were not there. The Article accomplishes nothing in the direction of achieving what the President tells us was the purpose of this Article. It compels the State to do nothing. It is exactly like Article 45. All one can gather from the President's speech is that it can do nothing and that it compels the State to do nothing.

How it is to be implemented is a matter for the future. That is one of those vague things about which we hear so much. One time we hear that the Article cannot bind us. The President says we cannot tie the House as to future legislation. But it is the business of a Constitution to bind the hands of future Legislatures. That is one of the purposes of a written Constitution. I was weary listening to the President last night saying "we cannot bind the hands of the future." Whether you can now bind them depends not on what is written down here, but on some vague things that are at the back of the President's mind. What he says about the great modern evil is excellent. Nobody denies that. But it does not help the House. It is a well-known principle of legislation that when you mention any particular thing you exclude other things. There is in this section the implication that "by her life within the home" the State is not to recognise other implications.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

The President does not and cannot understand the mentality of anybody else. That is why he is by nature so dictatorial. This Constitution is dictatorial——

Comment on this

Not dictatorial enough.

Comment on this

Oh, yes; this is like what we hear in Germany, "whatever the Leader says is right." I quite understand that that is Deputy Donnelly's point of view. We had a speech yesterday from another Minister as to what he wants in this Draft Constitution. Now undoubtedly woman's most important service is within the home. But to what does this commit you? How does it bind any future Legislature from refraining from doing or from doing certain things? This is the Draft Constitution. It is fundamental law, not the expression of the extremely vague desires of the President. The President tells us what he would like to do. I will give him an instance—does he intend to provide sufficient pensions for the subsistence of a widow with, say, seven or eight children so as to make it unnecessary for her to work at all except to look after the home; and will the pension be big enough to see that she will be able to bring up her children in comfort and with proper educational facilities? Suppose you take the case of a woman who has to work because her husband will not work? Is the President to compel such a man to work? What will be the position of the wife, or will the President deal with it? He does not like to deal with these things. He tells us that he is allowing the future Legislature to do it. That method is a method of washing his hands of the matter. That will not do. There is too much of this business of throwing the responsibility on someone else.

This section compels the State to do nothing and it prevents future Legislatures from doing nothing. But these Articles and the President's speeches do imply certain things—perhaps the word "imply" is too definite a word to use in the case of the President. At all events they seem, to a large number of women in this country, to imply certain things. The President has referred to these as women of advanced views. That is the phrase he used and that phrase shows the mentality of the President—these women are women of advanced views. That is what he says about the people who have given attention to this subject. We witnessed the President yesterday rejecting an amendment from Deputy Mrs. Redmond because, as he said, the word "class" was so hard to define. That was the objection to the amendment—the word was too difficult to define. Before we came to Article 41 at all I noticed that the second last word in the previous Article is "class," a word that is so hard to define. It is a word that is very difficult to define when Deputy Mrs. Redmond uses it, but not difficult to define when the President uses it.

Comment on this

Had I been here I would have called attention to that word myself.

Comment on this

And the President would have defined it. The word is incapable of definition where Deputy Mrs. Redmond is concerned and because it was moved from these benches. There we have the gospel; the Leader is always right. His word is always law. He does not understand what the Opposition want or what women want. He does not understand what anybody who suggests a modification of this Constitution puts forward. The continual burden of his speeches is: "I cannot understand." The word is impossible of being defined when it comes from these benches. It is impossible to define the word "class." But the word "class" is the second last word in Article 40 of the sacred text itself. There is no doubt that the President's whole attitude is a bias against women seeking work.

Comment on this

Not true; absolutely false.

Comment on this

Oh, well, that is my view, and that is the President's difficulty. He means certain things. I am taking the Articles as they stand; I do not care what the President means by them or what is in his mind. We are not yet legislating about what is in the President's mind. We are legislating about what is in these Articles. That is our difficulty. We have to know what the words will mean legally, not what the President thinks they will mean or what he thinks is their purport. That is why women object to these words. Is the President aware that these women, many of his own followers amongst them, are perturbed because of these words "by her life within the home" in Article 41?

Is it not because they recognised the implication? Who is responsible for that? If there is such lack of clarity that it obscures their vision, the vision of even some of his supporters, it is not due to Party bias. Why is that so? Why cannot they understand what the President is driving at? It is obvious the Articles themselves do not convey what the President intends, if he intends anything definite.

So far as every word that the President said is concerned, he indicated excellent things for the State to aim at, but we must remember that this is legislation. How is it to be administered? If the State fails to do these things, if a future Legislature fails to do these things, is there any remedy? This is a fundamental Constitution that must be honoured by a legislative body. If that body fails, is there any remedy? Surely nobody could appeal to that Article— I am referring to Article 2—to compel the Legislature to do anything? Taking them all together, there is one purpose in them, one drift in them.

Comment on this

I would regard these clauses as entirely harmless if there had never been any movement in this and other countries to shut out women from competition with men. But there have been such movements. Even during the last few years I have seen fairly numerous letters to newspapers advocating that certain restrictions should be imposed to prevent women competing, shall we say, with fathers of families, for jobs. And it is because there has been a certain amount of that sort of agitation that women have been rendered nervous by these Articles in the Constitution. I think it is reasonable to expect that they would be rendered nervous about them.

Personally, I am convinced of the President's good faith in this matter. I do not think he or his Party have any policy in their minds of shutting out women from gainful occupations. But I do know that what Deputy O'Sullivan said is quite true—that great uneasiness has been excited in the minds of women, not merely women who have some political interest in opposing the Fianna Fáil Party—because I have met women myself with no political bias whatever who have been exceedingly alarmed by the insertion of these Articles—for the reason that there has been a certain agitation which crops up from time to time and which these Articles tend to foster.

Comment on this

How? Could the Deputy point that out?

Comment on this

I do not say that it logically follows from these Articles that that agitation is right, not for a moment. If you take these Articles, analyse them, parse them and treat them in a perfectly abstract spirit, there is nothing in them to object to; there is not a single word in them that I consider wrong; I think every word is right as they stand. But you have to think of possible effects as well, and if there has been an undesirable kind of agitation against women you have to consider whether some colour may not be given to that agitation and whether the Articles cannot be thus interpreted by nervous women.

Comment on this

Read the Article and see how you can interpret it.

Comment on this

I merely say there has been an impression created that these Articles favour the view that a woman's proper place is in the home and that where she is not in the home there is an anomaly that legislation ought to strive to correct. That is the notion that has spread abroad, that these Articles can be so read as to favour that view. I am not imagining these movements and agitations. I remember a speech made two years ago by one of the leaders of the Opposition, Deputy Dillon, in County Louth or County Meath, where he advocated that pensions should be given to all women—10/- a week, I think it was—and that, simultaneously, gainful occupations should be closed to them. I am sure he would not advocate that now, but he did throw that out in a moment of expansiveness, and in doing so he was not doing something that was entirely disconnected with certain feelings and agitations that did exist in the country. I have had, and I dare say other Deputies have had, letters from constituents urging that something should be done to prevent women from competing with heads of families.

Comment on this

Was that the object of Deputy Dillon's suggestion about pensions?

Comment on this

I do not remember the particulars. I remember that, in general, pensions were suggested so as to provide more employment for men, as I understood it at the time. But there is nothing singular in that. Lots of people from time to time have suggested that women should not be allowed to compete freely with fathers of families. The danger of these Articles in the minds of women is that they seem to give support to a theory of that kind.

Comment on this

But how?

Comment on this

The President keeps saying to me, "How?" but I am merely telling him the fact that that has been the impression created in the women's minds This Constitution has in many parts of it been so drawn as to expose the largest possible surface to attack. You cannot behave as if every human being were strictly logical. Human beings are not strictly logical, and when they read something that seems to them to give a sort of indirect support to an attack on their bread and butter they get exceedingly alarmed, and I would suggest that it ought not to be beyond the powers of the President to add something making it quite explicit that the State will not discriminate against women in the matter of opportunities for earning their livelihood. If he would put in something of that type he would allay the fears which I know to exist very widely among people who honestly have no political bias against the Party in power.

Comment on this

I would like to direct the attention of the President and the House to the fact that we are dealing with a particular amendment the effect of which is to delete the words "by her life within the home." The President's entire observations were addressed to sub-clause (2) of Section 2 of the Article, whereas these words occur in the preceding sub-clause. Speaking relevantly to the amendment before the House, and leaving aside other matters until we come to the next amendment, I would like to point out that the objection to the words we propose to delete, "by her life within the home," is that the insertion of those words has led, and reasonably led, to the belief that into that particular clause may be read some sort of slight, if I may put it that way, on either married women who do work not merely inside their homes but outside their homes, or unmarried women, whether they work inside or outside their homes. The amendment seeks to delete these words because they are capable of that meaning.

What is the objection to the deletion of those words? Many women, both married and unmarried, give very valuable work to the community in the way of social services and otherwise, outside the home. Many women who work for their daily bread give valuable service to the State although they do not work within the home, and perhaps, in addition to doing that, they do carry out their ordinary work within the home. It is because of the fact that for some reason that is not quite apparent, the kind of service given by women in the home is picked out here to the exclusion of everything else that objection has been taken and fears aroused. That is the amendment we are dealing with at the moment. I want to know what is the objection to leaving out the words "by her life within the home." Deputy O'Sullivan has referred to the maxim to which I drew the President's attention last evening. I gave the Latin version—expressio unius—and I do not want to go over it again, but if you set down certain matters, impliedly you leave out other matters.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The President may say that it is nonsense and he may believe that it is nonsense.

Comment on this

Of course, it is.

Comment on this

The mere fact that the President says "of course, it is" does not make it nonsense. That has been the attitude of the President throughout this entire debate on every suggestion we put up. Because he thinks the suggestions we make are either without ground or nonsense, they are, therefore, in fact, groundless or nonsense. We have directed attention in the course of the debate on this and on other sections to certain very fundamental objections to this Constitution. We have not been met in one single instance. We have ensured this at all events, that nobody can say that we did not carry out our duty in directing attention to it. We are doing it now on this clause and we are speaking solely on this clause now. That expression "by her life within the home" has given cause for uneasiness, if not cause for offence, to a number of women, both married and single, who do good work in the State. Married women are giving very great social service in child welfare work and unmarried women are doing the same. Married and unmarried women help in the ladies' association of charity attached to the St. Vincent de Paul Society. They are left out here and one thing is picked out for special reference. The fact that that is picked out is capable of being interpreted as being inserted for some particular reason and, consequently, has reasonably, as I say, given cause for uneasiness. If that particular expression is left out, I cannot see what objection there can be to the clause as it will then stand.

I propose to repeat very shortly what I said yesterday afternoon about the assertion of general principles and the following of that assertion by some particular instance, the effect of which is to cut away from the statement of general principles. When we find in Article 41 of clauses 1 and 2 the State guaranteeing to protect a family, does that not cover everything? If the State undertakes to do its duty in protecting the family and in seeing that it is the natural, primary and fundamental unit group of society, does that not cover the next sub-clause of clause 2, that the State shall endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home? In order to cut down the discussion to the smallest amount of time, compatible with the asserting of principle, may I say again that the President, by putting in that sub-clause (2) of clause 2, again offends against the rule of construction to which I have referred. The State is to endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to work.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will wait I will tell him. If the State is to endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to work, is it not an indication from that that the State is to take no notice of anything else that may cause mothers to have to work? Economic necessity is the only thing they are to deal with. If the father is drunken, if he is lazy and will not go to the trouble of getting work, that is not economic necessity.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

The State is not to take any notice of that. It is not economic necessity of the class which the State is to look after, and if a man is lazy, drunken, will not work or will not keep his work when he gets it, the State is to take no notice of it. You cannot, by merely inserting a principle which everybody agrees with and putting it down on paper, pretend that you have carried out in practice some laudable purpose which we all would wish to see achieved. Merely writing down high principles in this Constitution is not going to see that these things are, in fact, achieved in practice. There is a lot of theory in this Constitution. I deal in practice and I want to see how in practice this is going to be achieved and I direct attention, merely on technical grounds to the fact, as illustrating the point I am making, that by referring merely to economic necessity, a whole field of other matters is, by implication, left out. There is nothing here about the duty of a father to protect the family; there is nothing here about the duty of the State to see that he carries out his duty. We hear a lot about the rights of this, that and the other, but there should be more insistence on the duty of the people rather than on their rights. Here we have the family looked after, but there is nothing in this Article, if I may again give an example, to impose duties on people who are responsible for keeping the family, for maintaining the family institution, to do their duty.

Comment on this

I think it would be well if some clear exposition were given by the President as to what line he has pursued in drafting this document. He said parenthetically yesterday that this document was not intended to be entombed in dusty law reports.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this

Let me correct that. He created the impression on reasonable men listening to him that he intended to convey that he did not want this Constitution entombed in dusty law reports. Doubtless he did not say that, but that was the impression he conveyed to some people who heard him— that it was intended to inform the plain people of the country of what the meaning of the Constitution was. That, I believe, is the dilemma into which the President has fallen. As I understand it, this Constitution should really be addressed to those who will be called on to interpret it on behalf of the people whose rights it is designed to defend, and when I desire to defend my constitutional rights as guaranteed by this document, it is not to the people on the hustings I will go, but to the courts of law. The courts of law will interpret that document, and unless the President is prepared to take cognisance of the well-established principles of judicial interpretation of such documents, the result of what he writes or of what this House puts into the Constitution, in the country may be entirely different from what he intends.

I twice yesterday directed the President's attention in respect of another Article to the danger of qualifications, because sometimes a qualification, when it comes to be judicially interpreted, assumes much more importance than the positive assertion of the fundamental right. Sometimes, as Deputy Costello has pointed out, if you put in one particular qualification, the assumption is that you mean no other; alternatively, if you put in a qualification desiring to convey nothing more than that particular qualification, it may, in the process of interpretation, carry a far more pregnant meaning when read in conjunction with the assertion of the fundamental principle. I urge on the President, without losing patience, calmly to tell us whether he has borne in mind, or intends to bear in mind, the well-established rules of judicial interpretation when dealing with this document, or whether he is resolved to address this document to the lay people who know nothing of judicial interpretation and care very little about it until such time as the vindication of their constitutional rights may arise.

Deputy MacDermot has referred to the fact that I was heard to advocate on one occasion the giving of 10/- a week to all women to abstain from gainful employment. I cannot remember whether I ever advocated that in public or not. I feel sure that I have often discussed it with the Deputy and I may very possibly have mentioned it in public in his hearing, but let me make my position clear in regard to it. I have always regarded it as the fundamental groundwork of our social outlook that our ideal should be to ensure that every human creature had enough before anybody was allowed to enjoy a surplus.

That has always been my idea of it, and my only difficulty has been to find anywhere any scheme which would achieve that ideal and which would work. There are thousands of schemes —economic nostrums—which, we are told, would achieve that but, when they are put into operation, they calamitously fail and bring in their train far greater evils than existed before they were attempted at all. I have discussed a hundred proposals for redistribution of wealth and I have always had in my mind the difficulty that, if you try to give everybody enough before anybody enjoys a surplus, one of the results may be to destroy the initiative and energy which make the capitalist system, founded on individual liberty, function. If you make life too easy for every able-bodied person, you may damp down the initiative which makes the system work and which draws from the natural resources with which God Almighty provided us the maximum return.

I have often seen an agricultural labourer contemplating marriage, and the difficulty was that he had 30/- a week and that he hesitated to accept family responsibility on that slender income. If he knew that, far from putting additional burdens on himself by the marrying of a wife, he would bring a small additional income into his home and that, even though earning 30/- a week himself, he would, as a married man, have £2 a week, it might give him courage to face family responsibility and facilitate marriage for poorer people. Furthermore, many women who at present go out and take work to help out the family budget would, if they had 10/- per week, be able to give that help within the family without going out to work at all. That particular matter has been partially recognised in this House. We have given—and rightly given—pensions to widows, but an elderly spinster can very often be a much more pitiable figure than a widow——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is within his right in replying to points made against him in debate, but I suggest that he has had sufficient scope in which to explain his position.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, but the debate on this amendment has strayed into the entire Article. If you take the express words of the amendment, I agree that I have travelled beyond it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I took it that the Deputy was replying to some remarks attributed to him by Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

I shall not delay, but I want to make, clear that proposals of that kind, which have been in my mind, are similar to many others the ultimate end of which has always been to attain the ideal that every human creature would have enough before any human creature would be allowed to enjoy a surplus. Subject to this overriding principle, which is strictly relevant to the matter we are considering, in this day and age, the liberty of a woman to earn her living, if she desires to do so, should not be restricted. You have got to protect her against exploitation, and I freely confess that it would be easy for us, if we wanted to do so, to trip the President up by suggesting that any kind of restriction on the exploitation of women was an interference with the fundamental liberties of women. I do not think that there is any desire on our side to attempt that subterfuge. Liberty for women to earn their living does not mean that the State should stand idly by while poor women were induced to go down half-naked in a coal mine and drag up coal tubs, as they did at one time in the North of England. But, subject to the social restrictions that are necessary to prevent the exploitation of men, women and children, we feel that, in this day and age, the right of a woman to earn her living, if she wants to earn it, should be held sacrosanct. I, personally, hold that anything we here could do to spare a mother the necessity of having to work to live ought to be done. I, perhaps, would go further and say that, if we wanted effectively to redistribute wealth, having provided for the aged and infirm, I should like to consider with experts the question of whether the redistribution of wealth might not, in part in any case, be achieved by easing the lives of women. If it were proposed that a lump sum to ease the lives of all should be provided—if that were practicable, I should like first to make adequate provision to spare women the necessity for servile work of any kind before I would relieve any able-bodied man of the necessity of servile work in order to live. I do not want to elaborate that fully, but one is so liable to misrepresentation that one is tempted to guard against every possible attempt to misrepresent one's views hereafter.

I think I have made my position pretty clear, and I now turn with a specific question to the President: Does he intend to recognise the well-known principles of judicial interpretation to which Deputy Costello has referred, or is he addressing this document to lay people who have no knowledge whatever of judicial interpretation, and leaving to chance the results that may accrue from its judicial interpretation.

Comment on this

Is there any understanding as to whether the next amendment is to be taken in conjunction with this amendment?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy desires to have a separate decision on the next amendment, I shall so put the question on this amendment as to permit of that.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to know whether the next amendment was being discussed in conjunction with this amendment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think the next amendment has been discussed in conjunction with this amendment.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I was not in the House during the discussion, and I thought these two amendments were being discussed together. The Deputy may discuss the next amendment when this amendment is disposed of.

Comment on this

I am indifferent in the matter.

Comment on this

One can sympathise with Deputy O'Sullivan and the other members of that Party on the difficulty in which they have found themselves when face to face with words, and when they had to defend a certain attitude. Of course, one would expect, in these circumstances, that all we could have would be trifling with the matter. Anybody who fairly reads the remarks of Deputy O'Sullivan in the papers to-morrow or who will read them in the Official Report, will agree that he was merely trifling, and nothing else. He did not address himself at all to the words here, or attempt to show us in what way the words of this Article could give rise to the apprehensions which he said were rife, that an attack was being made somehow on women's liberties and rights.

He says with one breath that this means nothing: that it cannot bind. It does mean something. It means that, when the people have adopted this Constitution, they will have agreed with a common mind and purpose to try to see that the State, which will represent them, should ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home. This is a directive, a strong directive, to the Legislature with the backing of the people as a whole that this is a purpose which ought to be given effect to and ought to be pursued. It does mean something, and well the Deputy knows it.

Then we had Deputy Costello falling back again on his old friend the canon of interpretation which has, of course, a limited application always, and is not a thing to be applied everywhere. If we are dealing with any particular subject, the fact that we are not dealing with other subjects is not to suggest that these things are not matters of importance, so that when a person takes special canons of interpretation for legal documents in a certain way, and tries to apply them in a way in which no lawyer would attempt to apply them in court, I can only call that trifling also. The Deputy must too clearly understand what is the meaning and purpose of this section. The attempt to suggest that, because other women are not mentioned in this section, there is a definite intention to put them in a lower status or anything of that kind, has no foundation whatever. This is a section dealing with the family. The words immediately preceding it are to the effect that the family is the basis of social order and is indispensable to the welfare of the nation. If the family's welfare is to be preserved, who is going to deny that it is necessary for the woman to be free to perform her motherly duties in the home? It is a bad system of society in which the mother is forced to go out and labour to the neglect of her duties in the home. I can conceive of no higher purpose that we could have here in this community of ours than to see to it that economic necessity will not force mothers to abandon their duties in the home.

What, then, is the justification for the attack that is made here? We are dealing with the home, with mothers in the home, and with the duties of mothers in the home, and if we are not dealing with women who are in other occupations outside the home, who is going to suggest that that is a reflection upon them? This is a just recognition of the important part that mothers play in society as a whole in their homes. That does not mean to say that women are not playing important parts elsewhere. Does it mean that men, the fathers of families, are not playing important parts both in the home and out of it? It does not, because that particular aspect did not demand attention from us. Here we are dealing with mothers. We are trying to deal with a great modern evil, as I have already said. All that is done here is to try to get people to agree, as part of their fundamental law, that it should be the purpose of the State to try to secure that mothers will not be forced to neglect their duties in the home by economic necessity compelling them to labour outside. Personally, I can have no patience with the attacks which have been made on this Article. I think they are altogether unjustified.

Deputy MacDermot tells me that I would have been wiser if I had proceeded in another way. Of course I could. I need not have put in the word "home" there, but because the word "home" is mentioned, it brings back to the minds of certain people the fact that there was a very cheap gibe at women who were not able to be in the home either through inclination or the economic necessity which compelled them to work elsewhere—the cheap gibe that their place was in the home. I am not responsible for that gibe, and I am not going to leave the word "home" out of its proper context because there is a gibe associated in some people's minds with it. It is a strange position that the sacred word "home" should be omitted. Well, I am not going to omit it anyhow. As far as I can get any support, it is going to remain, but there is no implication and no suggestion of inferiority as regards other women. There is a just recognition here of the special part that is played by mothers in the home, and there is, further, the indicated intention of the community, through its Legislature, to endeavour to secure that that work, which is so vital to the State, shall not be hindered by economic conditions which force women to work outside.

I have only to say, then, to Deputy MacDermot that this was not drawn from a propagandist point of view. It is true that every Constitution gives a very broad surface for attack. It must, because it covers the whole of our political life. It covers our political life in the broad sense, and covers all our social and economic life, and everybody would like to see future Legislatures tied down here so that any particular privileges which they may have will be preserved. We had from Deputy Norton last night an extraordinary exhibition. He wanted us tied in one direction and loose in another. The position of a Legislature, as I said last night, for the future as in the present must be that it will be free to co-ordinate the public good, the individual good and the individual right. That is its prime, main duty. I repeat that here there is no suggestion of any kind that women who are not in the home are not playing an important part. There is no suggestion of any kind in this that there should be any discrimination against women in regard to earning a livelihood.

The suggestion which I resent very strongly is that I have some reactionary views about women. It is not true. I have never shown it either in public or in private. I believe that the culture and the progress of a community can very well be estimated by the status and the position which women occupy in it. I have always held that. I do not compare men and women at all in the sense in which some people want to compare them. I do not think that the words "equality and inequality" can properly be applied to them. Each has its own particular and important part to play, just like a back or a forward in a football team. Men and women are complementary of each other in society, working out in their own particular spheres the parts for which they are best fitted. Individuals with special aptitudes may go outside that sphere to the good of society as a whole. I am not accepting the amendment to delete, and I am not going to accept the suggestion "for," because I am dealing with mothers and the work which they do within the home in regard to the upbringing of children.

Comment on this

Women, not mothers.

Comment on this

I am talking about mothers here. I am talking, in general here, about mothers.

Comment on this

Where is the reference?

Comment on this

We are talking here about this sub-section, which says: "The State recognises that, by her life within the home, woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved."

Comment on this

But that is not "mothers." Put in the word "mothers" and there is no objection to the paragraph at all.

Comment on this

There are mothers and wives too, and not all wives happen to be mothers. I am not going to say anything that is not here now. I have made up my mind that this is accurate and I am not going to put in anything else. I am not going to put in what is not here now.

Comment on this

But that is ridiculous. The President has been arguing here for a quarter of an hour about this, and now, when it is pointed out to him, he looks at the document and he finds that the word "mothers" is not there. Put in "mothers" and it will be all right.

Comment on this

As I have said, there are wives who are not mothers, and wives also, by their lives within the home, give to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved. I think that that is quite all right, and, as I said, I am not going to accept either the amendment to delete these words or to accept the phrase "for the home."

Comment on this

I just want to make this point, Sir. The President says that he gets impatient because people make arguments that do not appeal to him. But the President himself argues for a quarter of an hour here, very trenchantly, for the insertion of the words "mothers and wives," and he then looks at the document and discovers the word "woman."

Comment on this

I did not discover it.

Comment on this

Put in the words "mothers and wives" and our objections fall to the ground.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read the next sub-clause?

Comment on this

Just wait a minute. The President argued very trenchantly for the inclusion of the words "mothers and wives." Very well, put in these words and you get rid of a great deal of the objection that has been raised. The President, however, looked down at the document and discovered that neither is there, and that the word there is "woman" It is because of that, that we have demurred, lest there be any misunderstanding.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy read Clause 2, or shall I read it for him?

Comment on this

I ask the President to keep his seat. The amendment here is perfectly clear. If there is any very heated feeling about it, I do not give a fiddle-dee-dee what is in the Bunreacht—I do not think it matters two straws what is in it—but the President asked us to come in here and give him our assistance and discuss the matter with him. We had the President getting up here and talking for a quarter of an hour and, by implication, he admitted our objection, then he looked down at the document and discovered that there is no reference to mothers and wives in the paragraph we are referring to. We object to the word "woman" in that part because, to put in the word "mothers" there would make the Article more clear to the President, to the House and to the country. As I say, I do not give a fiddle-dee-dee if you do not want it, but there is no need for impatience on the President's part. If he does not agree to it, well, that is well and good.

Comment on this

You did not move an amendment to that.

Comment on this

Of course we did.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not read it, and the President did not read it— well, pardon me, probably the President did read it, but he spoke under a complete misapprehension of it, because I think our argument had carried some force to his mind, and he saw that the Article would read more cogently, and that the meaning of it would be much more obvious if he spoke of mothers and wives, and that to use the word "woman" in that case left it open to misapprehension. That is our case. If you do not agree with it, then let us agree to differ, but let there be no suggestion from the President that representations from these benches were made from a purely obstructive and hypercritical attitude. At any rate, they were sufficient to make him speak for a quarter of an hour. We spoke because we believed there was an amendment of substance to be made.

Comment on this

That is mere trifling. That would be quite all right if there was not clearly set out—that is, in the first part—a recognition, and then the conclusion: "The State shall, therefore, endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home." I was talking about economic necessity, practically the whole time, as forcing mothers to get out and work outside. The first part is more general.

Comment on this

Let me repeat, Sir, that I object to the word "trifling." There has been no trifling going on here. I do not give a fiddle-dee-dee what is going into this Constitution, but the President asked for our assistance, and anything that we have put in has been suggested with a view to giving that assistance.

Comment on this

I am afraid, Sir, that we strayed into a discussion of sub-section 2º as well as of sub-section 1º I must confess that the remarks I, personally, have made about 20 minutes ago, were rather directed to sub-section 2º than to sub-section 1º. To get back, however, to this particular amendment in the name of Deputy Mrs. Redmond, I must say that it seems to me to make no sense, because, if we are to make a statement here at all about woman, it must be in connection with the family, and it would be entirely out of place to have that sub-section stand with the words, "by her life within the home," left out.

Comment on this

Read it, leaving out these words, and see if you would have any objection to it then.

Comment on this

It would then read: "In particular, the State recognises that woman gives to the State a support without which the common good cannot be achieved."

Comment on this

Anything wrong with that?

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with it, but it is wholly irrelevant to the subject of the family.

Comment on this

What about the Deputy's own new canon of interpretation of documents?

Comment on this

Not my canon.

Comment on this

Certainly, I regard it as irrelevant to the subject of the family. It did occur to me, during the last few minutes, that perhaps it might be an improvement in that sub-section to put the word "married" before the word "woman," but on second thoughts I did not even feel that that would do, because a woman who is sometimes performing the duties of a mother and a wife may be a sister, or something of that sort. Accordingly, I confess that this first sub-section seems to me to be wholly unobjectionable. I think that any alarm created would arise more naturally from the second sub-section, about which I shall speak in a moment.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words, Sir, on this. I will not reach the heights of oratory which the President has reached, and I will just speak from the point of view of the plain man in the street—the point of view of a person who always thought well of the home and who thought that the responsibility always rested on the members of the family to support the parents. It seems to me that the President has never read that old proverb, "Man shall earn his bread by the sweat of his brow." It also seems to me that the President is setting out, in this Constitution, to make a paradise of this world. He seems to forget that, after all, this is only a vale of tears. He seems also to give the impression that he, above all men, is the only man that ever thought about the home and had any respect for the heads of the home.

Let me state here and now that there is hardly any man in this House or in the members of his Party who has done more to disrupt the homes of this country than he and the members of his Party have done in the last few years. Of course, the members of the Party opposite do not like plain facts. They go down the country with very nice platitudes about preventing the people from starving and preventing the women from having to go out to earn their living.

Comment on this

We did well for Dundalk, at any rate.

Comment on this

The fact is that, with my knowledge of a lot of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, I think that if you went through the books of the St. Vincent de Paul Society you would not get the names of one of them on the books for a "bob."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might come to the matter before the House.

Comment on this

My chief objection to all the President's speech here to-day is that, as an Irishman who is always fond of a home and who always worked to keep up the home, I say: "Hands off the home." The President's whole policy here means nothing more or less than nationalisation. His policy, in effect, means a policy symbolic of that which at the moment obtains in Soviet Russia. Take charge of the families, take charge of the mothers, and with that done, of course, to use the words of the President, this little country of ours is going to be a paradise. I totally object to any section of this sort being put into the Constitution. Personally, I have the utmost contempt for Constitutions.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

My constitution is that little book we used to call at school "The Penny Catechism." Perhaps some of the Deputies opposite have not read that. The President says that mothers should not be allowed to go out and work.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

What has the President said? That the State shall, as far as possible, take steps to ensure that through economic necessity mothers— although the word does not appear in the section at all—shall not be obliged to go out to work.

Comment on this

It does appear in the section.

Comment on this

What is the whole trend of the President's remarks? After all, the best tribute to me is to hear Deputy Donnelly laugh. Of course, he laughed the other day, too, on his own amendment to the Constitution in regard to the North of Ireland, and afterwards he voted for this Constitution. That is the consistency that is so characteristic of the Fianna Fáil Party. In the same way, in regard to this section, the President will go down to private meetings of his supporters, where men only are present, and will say to them: "In this section we are protecting you against women. We are seeing that no woman will go out and take a man's job." Later he will go to a meeting at which women only are present, a meeting at which the attendance will probably include Deputy Mrs. Concannon and Deputy Miss Pearse, and say: "Oh, we do not mean that at all. Women can still earn their living." At the back of all that, he has these qualifications to every section in the Constitution. He legislates first and qualifies afterwards. There is no use in the President trying to get away with this whole business of pretending that he, of all men, is the only one who is anxious for the welfare of the home. Let me tell him again, and let me emphasise the fact—I want no help from his Party nor do thousands of the women of Ireland either. They are able to earn an honest living in this country. There are fathers and mothers in this country who have reared families of 14 and more, and they were never known to go out and look for any help from anybody. The Fianna Fáil Party and the President are out to degrade the men and the women of this country who suffered hardships and who reared their families—and they were not small families either. That is my chief objection to the policy enunciated by the President.

Let Deputy Donnelly or any member of his Party come down to Louth at the next election and I shall say there what I am saying here, because I know the men and women of that county. You want to degrade and pauperise the fathers and mothers of this country while you pretend that, were it not for Fianna Fáil, the mothers of this country would have to go out and make their living and that you are out to make a paradise of this country. I ask the President again what steps is he going to take to put this section in operation or to make it effective? Let him leave out the platitudes. I could argue that the steps taken by the President might be the means of putting far more mothers out of work as they might mean jeopardising the position of these women's husbands in industry—probably as a result of higher taxation—if I wanted to go deeply into the whole subject. You know as well as I do that steps may be taken to cure evils in certain directions and that these steps may create evils in other directions. This, of course, is a source of laughter to Deputy Donnelly and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party. We, on this side of the House, have no sympathy whatever for the mothers of this country! Let me tell the President and the members of his Party that we had sympathy with mothers and advised children to obey their parents when the Party opposite were telling them to disregard parental control. Now we have the sneers of the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to this section. I am speaking the honest sentiments of my mind.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to hear the Deputy on the amendment.

Comment on this

I say we should not interfere with the position of the home. Let the mothers and women of Ireland have the same opportunity they always had of earning their living and we can do with less qualifications and platitudes expressed by the President on this occasion.

Amendment put and declared defeated.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 128:

In Section 2, sub-section 1º, to delete the word "within" and substitute the word "for".

I am a little embarrassed in moving this amendment by the fact that before hearing anything that is to be said for it the President has declared his opposition to it. I had hoped that there was not much in this amendment which would be in opposition to the President's views. There is nothing in it that is in opposition to any of the views which he has expressed to-day on this matter, so I feel somewhat embarrassed by his declared opposition before he has heard any of the arguments bearing on the matter. I do not object to the expressed words——

Comment on this

As the family is so important perhaps we should have a House to listen to the discussion.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I was about to say that I have no objection to the express statement laid down in this sub-section, but I think that, standing by itself, it is too limited and that it is likely to lead to misunderstanding and probably to misapplication in future. It is true, and I think we all agree, that by her life within the home woman gives to the State a support without which the common good could not be achieved. We all realise the immense importance of "the woman of the house" to the home and the nation. We have no difference, I think, on what the President has said on that topic, but I suggest to him that woman—even the mother of the family, "the woman of the house" to use the common expression here—has duties to the home, for the home, which are not exclusively exercised within the home, and it is with the hope of obtaining the assent of the President and his Party to that view that I put down this amendment.

As the sub-section stands, it suggests that the entire life of the woman is within the home, that her whole activity, her whole influence on society, is exercised and should be exercised within the home. I am not questioning that the influence of the mother in the home, as mistress of the house, as instructress of her children, is the most important influence she can exercise on society. But I do suggest that she has wider influence, and that the phrasing of this sub-section seems to suggest that her entire influence is within the home, instead of, as I should like to put it "for the home". It is not good for the mother of the house to be exclusively occupied with the domestic concerns of her own house, within the home. A certain degree of such occupation is necessary, but her work within the home will be all the better for her having interests outside the home, and I would suggest that this sub-section tends to limit the tendency towards her having such outside interests.

Again, the President declared—and I entirely accept his declaration—that this clause was not drawn from a propagandist point of view. I do not at all question the sincerity of that statement, but what seems to create a certain danger in regard to this section, as in regard to other parts of the Constitution, is that the President is optimistic enough to assume that future generations will interpret the Constitution in exactly the same spirit as he has framed it. Being confident of his own good intentions he assumes that the intentions will be the same in the minds of his successors. But that is an assumption which is not justified by our knowledge of the world. I think that, in consequence of that optimistic point of view, he has taken risks in this sub-section, and in other subsections of the Constitution, in regard to the direction in which he intends to travel. He used the word "directive" himself to-day in regard to this clause. He said it was intended to be directive. If so, the direction is hardly precise enough. It may very easily lead in the wrong direction; it may lead to a limitation of the influence of the mistress of the house, instead of increased emphasis being laid on that influence.

During the President's speech I ventured to interject the remark that "woman" and "mother" were different terms. Up to that point his speech had been entirely about the mother. I do not bring this point up again simply to emphasise what appeared to me a lack of clarity for the moment in the President's mind as to what we were concerned with, but in order to point out that where this word "woman" is used here in sub-section 1º it has a much wider meaning than the word "mother" as used in the next sub-section, and I do not think the President will suggest that the main sub-section 1º is to be controlled or interpreted by the word in sub-section 2º. One takes it in the ordinary way that the first general statement laid down is the ruling statement, and that the other is an application of it, if not a clarification of it —in this case an application of it to a particular instance. Again, I think we are all with the President in regard to the actual terms of sub-section 2º, although not perhaps agreeing that it will always be interpreted wisely in future. Woman in the house is something more than mother in the house in numbers, and she is something more than wife in the house. There are many women in many houses in addition to the wife and mother, and this clause seems to me to stand in the way or may be applied in the future to stand in the way of these women exercising their activity outside the four walls of the home.

It is, of course, common knowledge that not all the daughters, in the modern society of this country as in every other country, will be content to remain in the home where there is not ample work for them, where there is nothing to do but assist the mother in the management of a small house. Not only in this country but in other countries these girls have independence, and look for work useful to themselves, useful to society, and useful to the home. They are bringing their earnings in to maintain the home. They are getting a wider outlook on the world. They are getting greater opportunities for a suitable choice in marriage, and in every way their services for the home are useful not only to the home but to society. I suggest that if the President were to reconsider his rather anticipatory condemnation of this amendment he might see that he is not weakening the doctrine he is laying down by accepting the term "for the home" instead of "within the home", but that in using the words "within the home" he is indirectly casting a certain slur on the many women, the majority of women, who have to undertake some occupation other than that which they may actually practise inside the four walls of the home, although that occupation is for the home. Girls who go out as governesses, nurses, shop assistants, and so on, are working for the home, and their work is just as important or more important than if they remained at home tied to the mother's apron strings, where they would be unnecessary and would be almost completely idle.

The principle of this amendment is, of course, quite different from that of the amendment which was disposed of a few moments ago. It illuminates what seems to me the underlying groundwork of the President's theory, which I accept, as to the importance of woman in the home, but I think it applies to the principle in a broader way, in a way that is more useful and more applicable both to the state of society as it is at the moment and to the state of society which we are bound to have in the future. We here cannot hope to follow Herr Hitler's example in sending girls back to the home, confining their activities there, and doing nothing else but knit and sew in the home. That will not be adopted in this country nor, I am sure, will it be adopted for long in Herr Hitler's country either.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy does not suggest that there is anything in this section which says that women should be sent back, as he said Herr Hitler had sent them—I do not know to what extent he has—to remain in the home. This is closely-knit reasoning. We are putting upon the State an obligation in future to endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in work outside to the neglect of their duties at home.

Comment on this

Would the President mind dealing with the section to which the amendment applies?

Comment on this

I say it is closely-knit reasoning. Because of the fact that there is an obligation, we want to give a reason for it, and the reason we have given in this connection is that the work that is done by woman in the home—as the home-maker, in the care of her children, in the rearing of her children, in the care of the home—is indispensable to the welfare of the nation as a whole, and because it is indispensable we say, further indicating the extent, that we recognise that she gives to the State a support without which the common good could not be achieved. That is repeating in another form the words of a previous phrase.

The object in putting in the first clause is not merely to recognise what part woman plays but as a groundwork for the conclusion. Fathers of families who earn the wherewithal to maintain the family are doing work for the home. This is not intended to be a catalogue of all the people who serve the home or who serve the State. It is intended as a preliminary, to point to a conclusion, and the conclusion is that work in the home is such that mothers ought not to be forced by economic necessity to leave these duties. The first part is closely knit up with the second part.

That is why I dealt with the second part. I cannot see in any suggestion that they do otherwise than serve the home. This is a particular kind of service, and of such importance, that the State should make it its special purpose to see that it should not be interfered with. I am dealing with that particular part of woman's life within the home. If you take this away completely from the context here and try to make it mean something other than what was intended, or if you put in "for the home," it would not lead up to the second part. The difficulty is that mothers are forced to leave their proper duties, and I want to see it accepted as the purpose of the nation as a whole that we should endeavour to see that that necessity would no longer exist.

Take the case of a daughter who is forced to emigrate and who sends the wherewithal to maintain the home. She is working for the home. I am not thinking of that case, or of women who go out to work at all. I am thinking of the particular aspect of woman's life connected with her duties in the home, as woman of the house, to use the Deputy's phrase, which covers exactly what I am dealing with. I tried to deal with that as best I could. I must say that the criticism made it hard to keep an open mind. I am trying to interpret this as an ordinary person would interpret it. I know that there are certain people anxious to drag it away from the clear and obvious meaning. I am very anxious that no person could misinterpret the context, or read into it the idea that there is some reflection on woman whose work is not of this character or even that part of woman's work which is not of this character. As the Deputy stated, very often you have women, who not only perform their duties in the home but are able to do a great deal of good work outside as well. I am not against that. I think the very definite answer of the State is that every citizen should contribute to the common good in whatever way that citizen is best fitted.

Where I feel the Deputy's amendment fails is that it would change the whole context and take away the closeness of the reasoning in the clause. It would also raise many other matters. My mind was running rather upon whether there was some possible suggestion that "by her life within the home" it should necessarily be spent within the home. There is no suggestion of that in the clause as it stands. If I were disposed to amend it at all, it would be to try to make it certain that nobody was going reasonably to read into it by the words "by her life within the home" that there was some suggestion that woman's life was to be confined absolutely within the home. I am only dealing with one aspect of woman's life. I am forced to reject the amendment, because I think it would change the whole meaning of the clause. I am prepared to consider whether in the words "by her life within the home" there is not a suggestion that people would condemn her, so to speak, to live entirely in the home. I think that would be absurd in our state of society.

Comment on this

Possibly if the word "function" was substituted for "life" it would meet the case.

Comment on this

I tried reasonably to read into it the meaning I stated.

Comment on this

The President said he would consider the matter again, though not in the direction I suggested. As things stand the argument is weak owing to the fact that there is no common term between the two phrases. The President would really strengthen his argument in support of the next sub-section if he adopted a suggestion which was made earlier, that he should put the term "mother" in sub-section 1º as well as in sub-section 2º. Then his argument would be perfectly clear, and, as Deputy Dillon stated, no one would object to a recognition of the mother in the home, whereas "woman" includes too much. I hope the President will think the matter over before dealing with the section again.

Comment on this

I would point out that it is the particular aspect of woman's life within the home that leads up to the term "mother". It is clear that "by her life within the home" qualifies the term "woman". I will have the matter looked into again to see if there is anything reasonable in the objections.

Comment on this

As this discussion has practically ranged over the topic dealt with in the next amendment, I am not moving it.

Comment on this

At the risk of being told that it is foolish and trifling, I wish to draw attention to a difficulty arising out of the clauses dealing with the dissolution of marriage. Clause 2 provides:—

No law shall be enacted providing for the grant of a dissolution of marriage.

I think that clause is too wide. Clause 3 provides:—

No person whose marriage has been dissolved under the civil law of any other State shall be capable of contracting in Eire a valid marriage during the lifetime of the other party to the marriage so dissolved.

In my view, that is also entirely too wide. It is well known that the Catholic Church does not recognise marriage in a registry office or other than through the method and form laid down by the Catholic Church. A case came under my personal experience where an Irish girl, a Catholic, married a Scotchman of a different religion in a registry office. Of course, that marriage was not in accordance with the views of the Catholic Church, was invalid and no marriage at all. It was a marriage merely under the civil law of Great Britain. In fact, the marriage was never consummated, because the parties separated at the door of the registry office and never saw each other again. The girl came back to Ireland and desired to marry. According to the view of the Catholic Church she was entitled to marry. The case was submitted to me when I was Attorney-General with a view to prosecution for bigamy. I need hardly say that I did not prosecute.

Sub-clause 3º of clause 3 provides that no person whose marriage has been dissolved in another State shall be capable of contracting marriage here. If a Catholic is married in a registry office in England to a Protestant, or even to a Catholic, that is an invalid marriage according to the law of the Catholic Church, and according to the civil law here and the civil law in England it is valid. That marriage is dissolved. Then it is no marriage in Great Britain and it is not a marriage according to the Catholic Church. But, according to this clause, either of these persons cannot be married here afterwards. Will the President say if that is a foolish interjection or is it of some assistance to him?

Comment on this

The Deputy can always be sure that when he addresses himself to matters in the way he has now, nobody is going to accuse him of anything foolish. It is quite a different matter, and I think it is obvious to everybody, when there is a case being argued that is really only being argued because the person happens to feel that he has to say something on the Opposition Benches. I think this is something quite different. Anyone can see that there are genuine difficulties to be dealt with there. I am not a lawyer, but I think there is a difference between dissolution and a declaration of nullity.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the case of a marriage which has been dissolved by the English law—the case of divorce in the accepted sense in England.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said it was declared invalid.

Comment on this

I am only a layman, but I understood there was a difference——

Comment on this

There is a difference between nullity of a marriage, which is no marriage, which never was a marriage, and a marriage which was a marriage in law and which is dissolved. The case I am putting is the concrete instance where a marriage is perfectly valid in accordance with the English law, and possibly consummated, a marriage celebrated, if you can use that expression, in a registry office. Subsequently, by the law of divorce in England, it is dissolved, and one of the parties comes over here and wants to get married. It is no marriage, according to the Catholic Church. It is not a marriage, according to the law, because it has been dissolved in England, and this Article prevents either of the parties getting married here.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said it would be declared invalid and that it had been no marriage at all. If it is dissolved, of course it is clearly coming under this, and there is a difficulty which will have to be met. I can only promise to look into that matter. The matter has been raised already, and I do not see that there is any definite solution for it. The main thing we want to see is that there shall not be granted a dissolution of a valid marriage in our own State. We have the old difficulty, that if you try to make room for all the possible exceptions that may occur, then you may get away altogether from the fundamental purpose.

Comment on this

Could not sub-section 3º be left out altogether?

Comment on this

I do not think it could; not if we want to have that in its general terms. We do not want to permit a person who has been validly married in another country and whose marriage has been dissolved by the civil law of another country to come here and get married here. I promise to have the matter examined to see if we can possibly deal with it. But, as I said, the matter has come up and I have come to the conclusion that it would be almost impossible to deal with it without opening the door in such a way as to cause undesirable results in another direction.

Comment on this

There is, I think, a harder case than that mentioned by Deputy Costello. There may be a case where a seeming marriage has been annulled by the authorities of the Catholic Church, but the parties might not be able to get an annulment in civil law in another country, and in order to make the separation effective they might have to proceed through the ordinary law of divorce. It might happen that the marriage was annulled at Rome on grounds which would not carry under the law in England and, in order to make the separation effective, these parties might have to proceed by the ordinary law of divorce in England. Having had the marriage dissolved, let us say, in England, if they came over here they could not contract a valid marriage, although in the opinion of the majority of the people in this country there never had been a marriage. I think that is a case which is worthy of consideration, and that it can occur.

I should like to make one or two observations on this Article in general. I have been told—I am not sure whether it is so or not—that when the President was speaking on the Second Reading he stated that this section was not put in as based on any theological convictions held by the majority of the people of this country, but that it was put in purely from social considerations. That would leave the matter, of course, much easier to discuss. It would be impertinent in both senses of the word for me to discuss the discipline of the Church to which the majority of the people of this country willingly submit themselves, or to suggest that they shall not consider themselves bound by the discipline of that Church. But it is another matter if they think it their duty to enforce the discipline of one Church on the consciences of people who do not submit themselves to such discipline. Therefore, I think that, if the section were based on such a ground, there would be reasonable ground for complaint on the part of, admittedly, a small number of people in this country.

However, I am assuming that the President did make the statement which I am told he made—that he was not affected by the theological opinions of himself or others in bringing in the section, or some phrase to that effect. The question then comes back to the pure question of social considerations, as to the advantage or disadvantage of permitting divorce in any circumstances in the country, and providing against it in the Constitution. It seems to me that it might be discussed here at a considerable length without readily arriving at a conclusion. I am not going to discuss it at any length. But I should like to say this, that while I do not think anybody in the country wishes to have divorce made easy, or that marriage and the dissolution of marriage should be made such light things that they could be undertaken without responsibility, undoubtedly anyone of experience in the world knows that there are many cases in which marriages have been quite definitely a failure, in which through faults of one sort or another, there is no hope that the continuance of such a marriage will be of use to society, and that giving freedom to these people, restoring them to the status they had before marriage, would conceivably give an opportunity for establishing a happy home which would be useful to society.

I am not going to proceed further along that line. I think it is a matter which could be discussed at great length, and discussed either usefully or uselessly, according to the manner of it. But one meets these cases. Anyone with experience of the world, any clergyman, any doctor, will meet many such cases in which he cannot but believe that a divorce would have led to a happier life and a more moral life on the part of those concerned. I will make no further observations on the Article, but I wish to draw the President's attention to the particular case I mentioned when I got up.

Comment on this

I will have to look into it. My feeling is that if you try to meet certain very specialised cases you will have to go into quite another field altogether. However, as the Deputy thinks it is an important matter, I will have it further examined. With regard to the question of divorce in general, there is no doubt that sometimes there are unhappy marriages, but from the social point of view, without considering any other point of view, the obvious evil would be so great, and it has been proved to be so great in other countries, that I do not think any person would have any difficulty—at least I would not—in making a choice on this matter. I do not think any useful purpose could be served by such a discussion as the Deputy has indicated. If we were to open out into a broad discussion on the matter it would, as I understand it, only lead to one result and it would not be useful to enter into it. With regard to the cases mentioned by Deputy Costello and Deputy Rowlette, I will have them examined to see if we could modify this Article to meet these cases.

Comment on this

There is one question I would like to put to the President: what is the meaning of sub-section 2º of Section 1: "The State, therefore, guarantees to protect the family in its constitution and authority..." What does "authority" mean? Does it mean the authority of the head of the family over the family? If it does not mean that, what alternative meaning is there?

Comment on this

It is the authority of the heads of the family over their children, their right to look after their education and not to be interfered with by another authority in the State except for reasons that would be mentioned; that is to say where there was failure or neglect on their part to provide for the children, or, from the social point of view, failure to see that the children received a proper education. The family have rights antecedent to and superior to all positive law, and any interference with the authority of the head of the family will have to be justified on certain grounds. That is the authority that is referred to there.

Comment on this

The President has indicated not merely that the family does possess certain inalienable and imprescriptible rights in addition to education——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want me to enter into a full discussion on the inalienable and imprescriptible rights of the family? We have been talking about the rights of individuals; where we specified the rights of individuals we dealt with them. Is the Deputy going to take me over the whole field of individual rights?

Comment on this