We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Recommittal.

Contributions 439–668 of 668. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I confess that, as far as I am concerned, this amendment appears to me to be mere rubbish. I do not know what it means.

Comment on this

Why did the President leave out "control of processions"? Did he forget all about it?

Comment on this

The Deputy was very careful to have it in Article 2A.

Comment on this

And the President has it. Let him not forget that because, according to himself, he is the only person capable of using it.

Comment on this

To my mind, this is absolute sheer nonsense. It says that "provision may be made by law to prevent or control meetings which are determined in accordance with law to be calculated to cause a breach of the peace." Now, who is to determine in accordance with law, and what law are they to be determined in accordance with? All laws, of course, that are inconsistent with this are now swept away. All pre-existing laws which control the right of the citizen to assemble peaceably without arms are abolished, except so far as they are saved by this clause. Here you say that provision may be made in the future to prevent or control meetings which are determined in accordance with law to be calculated to cause a breach of the peace. As I say, all pre-existing laws are done away with, and you have no power to make any alteration, even if there were any existing laws, because you have no power except the particular law to prevent or to control meetings. You have got no power to define for the future what class of meetings shall be prevented. You must first get a determination—I do not know whether that means a determination by the courts or not—that a meeting is calculated to cause a breach of the peace, and when you have got that determination you may then by law prevent or control it. To my mind, the section is simply humbug.

Comment on this

I am sorry I do not agree with Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney that it is humbug. I think it is very dangerous. I think this is a limitation on the existing right of public meeting. We know what the right of public meeting was. Anybody who has been a student of Dicey's Constitutional Law remembers the appendix to the book where the right of public meeting is explained as being merely the right of one person to talk to another, multiplied in accordance with the number of people that are there in the exercise of that right. Here we have an entirely different matter. We are providing for a particular method of exercising that right which does not exist at the present moment. We are providing that the exercise of that right may be determined and controlled by law. In other words, a law may be passed by this House providing that any ordinary Civic Guard on point duty may think it his duty to prevent a public meeting in College Green if he likes. That is what it means, if it means anything at all.

Comment on this

We now have the lawyers differing on the opposite benches. That is rather interesting. I certainly cannot follow Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in his difficulty about the section. To me it seems clear enough that the Oireachtas can make laws to prevent or control meetings which are determined in accordance with law, which, I take it, will be made for that purpose, the determination to be set out as to the conditions under which meetings will be prevented or controlled.

Comment on this

I do not think anybody else would get that meaning out of the section.

Comment on this

The right to assemble peaceably and without arms is the general guaranteed constitutional right, but I do not think it would be possible for the State to continue without having some method in the public interest—we have exercised it in the past—of controlling or preventing meetings that might, in certain conditions, lead to a breach of the peace. That power must be safeguarded somehow, and the object of this section is to safeguard the power of the Legislature to pass laws which will be proper for the maintenance of public peace and to prevent the abuse or the misuse of the right of public meetings. Again, if there were a situation in which there was an obvious abuse of its power, I take it that the courts would interfere and say that it was an abuse.

Comment on this

Even if the meeting were prohibited and the matter was determined by the Legislature as being necessary?

Comment on this

Oh, I agree with the Deputy that, in this case, it is quite clear that the courts would be precluded by the law itself—that it is the law itself that would settle the conditions—but I hold that that does not apply to the previous case.

Comment on this

But it means that you have taken away their right, as a constitutional right, to assemble peaceably.

Comment on this

We cannot have it both ways. There is a general indication there of a right to be used properly: that is, without endangering the public safety. You must give to the Legislature the power of regulating the exercise of these rights in such a manner as to ensure that the exercise of these rights will not be contrary to the public good. That is absolutely necessary; you cannot avoid it, and you cannot tie yourself up by precluding the Legislature from doing it. The Deputy may say: Then what is the good of your phrase here at all—this phrase about the right of the citizens to assemble peaceably? He may ask, what is its value? I say that it is of value, and that it is a general headline to the Legislature.

Comment on this

Which they can neglect.

Comment on this

Yes, unfortunately, they can.

Comment on this

And the courts cannot interfere?

Comment on this

Unfortunately—and the Deputy knows it quite well—we cannot provide by any Constitution against the possible abuse of its powers by the Legislature in future. It is vain to attempt to do it. All we can do is to set headlines for the Legislature, as we are doing here—headlines with regard to the things the Legislature should aim at. If, however, you are going to guarantee this right, without its being subject to some control— and there is no way to control it properly except in this way—if you give that right and guarantee it, without giving any opportunity to the Legislature to exercise control over meetings, then it is quite clear that you would have a state of chaos. That is what it would amount to, and that right, as such, never was exercised.

Comment on this

Nobody has suggested at any time that there should be an unlimited right of public meeting. Nobody has suggested at any time that disorderly assembly should be carried on, or anything of that kind. However, we have got a very interesting admission now from the President as to what is the meaning of a constitutional guarantee, and the definition we have got from the President of a constitutional guarantee is that the constitutional guarantee is to be nothing more than a headline to the Oireachtas as to what it is to do; but as a guarantee to the subject, which it is supposed to be, against the Oireachtas—as a guarantee to the citizens of the State of certain rights that the Oireachtas shall not have power to interfere with—we now discover that it is not that guarantee at all but that it is just a headline for the Oireachtas. So much for this new Constitution.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows full well that we have here, in general, as I pointed out long ago, to try to get a balance as between the common good, or the good of the public welfare, and the good of the individual as expressed by the exercise of his rights; and one of the chief functions of the Legislature is to preserve that balance; and by any constitutional Articles of that sort, you cannot, in my opinion, properly deprive the Legislature of that power. If it is to be a question between the general good of the community and the good of the individual, the determination of that, in any particular case, will have to be left to the Legislature which, after all, is composed of the representatives of the people, who are interested in preserving the individual rights, and many of us who are arguing here for leaving the door open so that the Legislature may be in a position to deal with any circumstances that might arise, would probably find ourselves, in a particular case, arguing not on the side that a law should be enacted, but against the enactment of that law. For instance, if this question came up that we had a moment ago—the question of the liberty of expression—I would probably find myself against any use of that power which would create another evil which might be more dangerous than the evil we are trying to deal with.

Comment on this

And I can well imagine all that the President would talk on that.

Comment on this

Yes, it is quite possible that I would talk on that.

Comment on this

Not alone "that," but I can well imagine "all" that the President would talk.

Comment on this

Well, the Deputy has a good deal of "all" to his record also. The point is that we have had to get a balance here between preserving the greatest possible liberty for the individual and seeing that that liberty is not used to the detriment of the common good.

Comment on this

There is one question I should like to ask. If everything is to be left to the Oireachtas, what is the use of going through the farce of enacting a Constitution at all?

Comment on this

That is carrying it to the other extreme again.

Comment on this

That is what the President said.

Comment on this

It is a bit of a farce.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that, pretty well, the middle of the road is the right thing in these cases, and that going to either extreme is wrong.

Comment on this

The President talks about the balance. Now, let us look at this balance. On the one hand, we have a public right given, subject to public order and morality and subject to the determination of the courts, and immediately we find that provision may be made by law to prevent or control meetings, and once a law is passed here the courts cannot touch it. Provision may be made to prevent or control meetings which are determined by law to be calculated to be a danger. The ordinary way that it is determined that they are calculated to be a danger is that it is left to a member of the Government or a member of the Civic Guards to say that such a meeting is calculated to do certain things. Accordingly, the law comes along and says that a Civic Guard can say that a meeting is calculated to be a danger or a nuisance to the general public, and out goes the right to peaceable assembly.

Comment on this

If the Legislature would pass such a law.

Comment on this

It can pass such a law under this. This phrase not merely invites them to pass such a law, but gives them the power to do it, shows them the way to do it, and tells them how easy it is to do it. It says that all you have to do is to get some law passed here, and it will rule when meetings are declared to be calculated to be a danger or a nuisance. First of all, you have the liberty for the exercise of the right guaranteed, subject to public order and morality, and public order and morality is analysed and determined by the independent judiciary. What do we put instead of it? We find that the Dáil in its wisdom may pass some piece of legislation giving over, say, to a Minister—probably the Minister for Justice—or to a Civic Guard, the question of the determination of this matter, and once either of them pronounces, then the courts are ousted. That is the balance the President talks about. Did the President ever read, or did he ever see, the play, "Thompson in Tír-na-nÓg"? The Thompson in the play was a man who wanted all his rights and who went around parading with his "ould gun" until one day it went off and he was "blew up," to use his own phrase? Well, I think there is a great deal of that in this parading of rights in this Constitution and that they may be "blew up" too.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy take responsibility for precluding the Legislature from having such power?

Comment on this

I would leave it to the courts. That is the difference.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:—

In page 86, lines 33 and 34, Article 41, Section 2, to delete the words "life within the home" and substitute therefor the words "work for the home".

I want to direct attention to the phrase in the Draft "in particular the State recognises that by her life within the home". I was not present when the speeches were made on a similar amendment on the previous stage, but as I read the debates, the attitude of the President was that he was insisting on woman's value in life and what women did in the way of adding value to life. He happens to have enclosed all that by the phrase "life within the home". I do not think these words, "within the home", should have been used at all, but seeing that an amendment to delete the word "within" was deleted I am now moving to delete the words "life within the home" and to substitute the words "work for the home". That will mean that whenever we do look at whatever women do, in order to ascertain what value is to be associated with it, we shall look at the work done, not merely within the home but what has to be done for, and towards, the upkeep of the home.

Comment on this

I do not think any point would be gained by discussing this matter further. On the last day I clearly indicated the intention of this paragraph. We had an amendment of practically the same type before, and there seems to be no reason for going over the same ground again.

Comment on this

I made a suggestion when we were last discussing this which I understood the President was going to consider. I do not know whether he is prepared to consider it still or whether he has decided against it. My suggestion was to substitute the word "function" for "life", the idea being that "life" might be read to imply the whole of woman's active life in the home, whereas if you use the word "function" we might cover woman's function in the home and other activities outside.

Comment on this

I remember now that the Deputy used the word "function." I do not agree that the word "function" would suggest the same connection with the home. I do not see that it would necessarily add anything to the section.

Comment on this

That is a gem.

Comment on this

I should not like to start discussing it with the Deputy again.

Comment on this

That is the brightest crown in the Constitution.

Comment on this

The fact is that I have considered this question. I am prepared if there is anybody in favour of it to substitute the phrase "by the performance of her duties within the home," but I did not think that that would improve matters. Consequently I did not put it forward. I think what is intended is quite clear.

Comment on this

If it is not, you can ask elsewhere and at a later time say what it does mean.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:—

In page 88, line 4, Article 41, Section 2, at the end of sub-section 2º, to add a new sub-section as follows:—

Nothing in this section, however, shall be invoked to prohibit, control, or interfere with any citizen proposing to engage or being engaged in any legitimate occupation for remuneration.

I am moving this amendment to remove an anxiety that is said to have been induced by the phrasing of sub-section 2º. We were told that this Article was framed in the interests of women, and that we were going to prevent women being driven out to do work to the neglect of their duties in the home. I want at any rate to ensure that, if women want to work at certain things, they will be allowed to operate their free choice in the matter and that there will be no sex disqualification or discrimination in regard to that matter.

Comment on this

There is nothing about sex disqualification here, but the full implications of the Deputy's amendment I do not know. I do not know whether you could limit the hours of work under this amendment.

Comment on this

"Nothing in this section."

Comment on this

I do not know whether, if there were a general law for the purpose of limiting the hours of labour in a factory, this would not possibly be caught up. In any case, I do not see that there is any need whatever for interfering with the clause as it stands. The State having acknowledged the work that is done in the home by women performing their duties to the family, the clause states:—

The State shall endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home.

I cannot conceive that being misused. The purpose is to see that economic necessity does not force women, who want to do their duty in the home, out to work.

Comment on this

What about the addition?

Comment on this

I cannot accept that.

Comment on this

Because I do not see any purpose in it.

Comment on this

Had you read it until to-night?

Comment on this

I had.

Comment on this

It did not seem so.

Comment on this

I had read it.

Comment on this

You did not advert to the opening phrase until your attention was directed to it.

Comment on this

After all, something is to be gained by allaying fears. I am sorry the President has decided not to accept this amendment of Deputy McGilligan, because I cannot see any possible danger lurking in it. It seems to lay down a very reasonable principle.

Comment on this

I do not know the implications of it.

Comment on this

Give us some of the fears you imagine.

Comment on this

I have indicated them already.

Comment on this

That was before you read it.

Comment on this

Oh, no. I still hold that it is possible to use that section to say, for instance, if there was a limitation on hours of labour in a particular factory or something of that sort, that it would be interfering with the citizen "proposing to engage or being engaged in any legitimate occupation."

Comment on this

You mean that.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

"Nothing in this section, however, shall be invoked to prohibit, control or interfere with any citizen proposing to engage or being engaged in any legitimate occupation for remuneration." The section to which it is proposed to add that states: "The State shall therefore endeavour to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labour to the neglect of their duties in the home." The President says that he thinks the amendment might be used in some way to prevent the shortening of hours of work in a factory.

Comment on this

Yes, where mothers were concerned. Its implications are too broad. I do not want to go into the matter now.

Comment on this

You do not know anything about it. You have not an example to give.

Comment on this

I have. Since this morning I have looked into the Deputy's amendment and I came to the conclusion that it would not be well to accept it.

Comment on this

Certainly the House should be swayed by such eloquence on this point! It is the most pitiable example of attempted argument that any deliberative assembly has ever listened to.

Comment on this

We have had a great deal of argument from the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is nothing but mulish stubbornness.

Amendment put and declared defeated.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:—

In page 88, line 11, Article 41, Section 3, sub-section 3º, after the word "State" to insert the words "but is a subsisting valid marriage under the law for the time being in force within the jurisdiction of the Government and Parliament established by this Constitution", and to delete in line 12 the words "in Éire" and insert in the same line after the word "marriage" the words "within that jurisdiction."

The purpose of this amendment is to see that the mere fact that a marriage was dissolved in another State would not of itself, by itself, prevent a person from being married in this country. I think everybody will agree that if the marriage is, according to the laws of this country, a subsisting valid marriage, one of the partners to that marriage—even if it were dissolved by the civil law of another State—should not come here and get married.

Notice taken that a quorum was not present. House counted and 20 members being present—

Comment on this

Has the President considered or got considered the whole question of the effect of this clause in the Constitution dealing with divorce? We have laid down here in this country long ago the principle that we have no legislation with reference to divorce. Now we are putting into the Constitution a certain clause. The President has been careful, when proposals were put up from this side, to say that he would not accept them because he did not understand the implications of them. Does the President understand the implications of this clause dealing with divorce, from the point of view of international law in the first place and from the point of view of the canons of the Catholic Church in the second place?

Comment on this

Both these points of view have been discussed with me, and I am satisfied that this is satisfactory.

Comment on this

And, I suppose, because the President is satisfied, it is satisfactory?

Comment on this

Is that ex-cathedra?

Comment on this

The Deputy raised a point and gave me an example on the last day. The only point raised was whether the phrase as it stood would mean that the mere dissolution of a marriage—whether, according to our law, it was a valid marriage or not; whether it was invalid ab initio, or was a valid marriage according to our law—would, of itself, prevent one of the persons involved from marrying here. That was pointed out by the Deputy, and I think it has been met by this amendment. No other point of that sort has been raised. Naturally, a matter of this importance was one which did receive very careful consideration, and if Deputies raise any particular points about it we will be able to meet them.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:—

In page 90, Article 42, Section 4, line 1, after the word "education" to insert the words "including school books, requisites and a free meal during school hours for each child attending school."

In this Constitution we are setting out to declare that the State shall provide free primary education, presumably for children of school-going age. As we are making a constitutional provision for education of a primary character, I think we ought to go further in that respect, and recognise that the mere provision of primary education, in existing circumstances, is not adequate provision, having regard to the moral responsibility which ought to devolve upon the State to ensure that education is imparted in the best possible circumstances and under conditions which will enable the children to absorb the maximum amount of education. The object of this amendment, therefore, is to provide that the State shall supply free primary education, including school books, requisites and a free meal during school hours for each child attending school.

I think it is well within the knowledge of members of the House that, in the case of thousands of children who are at present required to go to school, their parents are not in an economic position to purchase school books for them. The result is that we have schools provided, we have teachers provided, but through economic necessity the children are forced to go to school without school books, and have to try to absorb education by looking over the shoulder of another child to see what subject is being taught. Similarly, we have children going to school whose parents are in such an economic plight that it is not possible for them to provide the children with sufficient food in order that their frail bodies may be equipped for the task of absorbing education. Again, economic necessity is the root cause of that kind of evil and that kind of hardship which is inflicted upon school-going children. The object, therefore, of this amendment is to ensure that if the State is providing free primary education it should also provide school books, requisites and a free meal during school-going hours, so that every child attending school may have an opportunity of absorbing education free from those disabilities which go hand in hand with economic depression in the child's family. I think if the State wants to endow education in this way they ought to recognise that education does not merely consist in providing a school building and a teacher, but should also include the provision of books, requisites and a meal at school. In asking that that should be done here, I am not making any unusual or revolutionary demand, because in many other countries school meals and school books are provided for school-going children. Under a Constitution which says that the family has inalienable and imprescriptible rights, I think the best way in which that could be recognised would be by ensuring that the children in the family would be provided with education under circumstances which would enable them to derive the maximum benefit from such educational facilities as are provided.

Comment on this

I do not propose to accept the amendment. I think matters of that sort can very well be left to be dealt with by law. Where there are questions of public controversy we cannot decide them in the Constitution. If I were to argue that question, or enter into a discussion of the merits of it, apart from the Constitution, there are many things I would have to say about it. I agree that it seems to be waste to provide teachers if proper education cannot be given, and if an essential necessity is not being provided. There is another side to the picture. The question is: how can we best, so that there will be least abuse and most value, meet that situation? I have for a long time held the view that there is a great deal of waste about books in schools. I think the present position about text books in schools, and text books generally is a deplorable one, but it is not an easy one to rectify. I hope to see that situation met in some way in a relatively short time. I think there should be at least cheap books. I am afraid of completely free books, but cheap books ought to be available. If we had suitable text books, I think the old system, by which a book in a family was passed from one child to another, by which the elder children were able to become private tutors, so to speak, to the younger ones, and parents who had used the same text books were also able to be tutors, was very much better than the present system. Every household in which there are children is full of books that, in some cases, are worthless, and that seem to me to be almost rubbish. However, that is another day's work. I am not going into the merits of the question now. It is not a matter we could deal with in the Constitution.

Comment on this

This will not mean another Bill being introduced for Second Reading before the election?

Comment on this

No. I am not dealing with it.

Comment on this

This is a concrete example of the sham in the Constitution.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:—

In page 92, Article 44, Section 2, to delete sub-section 2º, and substitute the following two sub-sections:—

2º. The State guarantees not to endow any religion.

3º. The State shall not impose any disabilities or make any discrimination on the ground of religious profession, belief, or status.

That is simply to carry out the promise which I gave to separate the question of endowment from the general question of imposing disability on the ground of religious profession, belief or status.

Comment on this

Did the President consult Deputy Keely about this amendment?

Comment on this

I want to ask him that seriously. Deputy Keely told me on an amendment I was moving earlier that, if some words of mine were accepted, and if there was a conscription law passed, there could not be an exception made in favour of the clergy. Let me read what the President has: "The State shall not impose any disabilities or make any discrimination on the ground of religious profession, belief or status". So that if there is conscription, the clergy are in with the rest. Is not that so?

Comment on this

I say discrimination as between those who profess different religions.

Comment on this

That is not here.

Comment on this

That is clearly the intention.

Comment on this

That is not here.

Comment on this

It was in the old Constitution.

Comment on this

That is what the President means, but it is not what is here.

Comment on this

Deputy Keely thought my words were an insidious attack on the Church. I said it was a matter for derision. The President does not say so. I was proposing a rough and ready amendment, and, naturally, my words were not very definitely considered. Consider this, if the Constitution is to carry, in the religious section, this phrase: "2º. The State guarantees not to endow any religion: 3º. The State shall not impose any disabilities or make any discrimination on the ground of religious profession, belief or status." If there is going to be conscription, can you exempt the clergy under that?

Comment on this

I say, yes.

Comment on this

I want to know is it possible to exempt them?

Comment on this

I would say, unhesitatingly, yes.

Comment on this

It is possible?

Comment on this

Yes, provided you do not discriminate between clergymen of one religious profession and those of another.

Comment on this

You can discriminate?

Comment on this

Are they all in, in the event of conscription?

Comment on this

I will not say what will happen, but I say that this would not prevent the Legislature from doing it.

Comment on this

I see Deputy Keely has arrived. The President's view now is that there could be an exemption made in favour of the clergy generally, but not in favour of one body as against another. Is that what is meant?

Comment on this

I would say the meaning is, as it was in the old Constitution, that you were not to discriminate unjustly as between persons of one religious belief and another. I think that is clearly the meaning of it there. I do not think that that would prevent the Legislature from discriminating and relieving clergymen if it thought wise from the application of a conscription law. What you could not do is, you could not do it for one religious belief and not give the same concession to others.

Comment on this

Is there any advantage in leaving in the words "or status"; if it merely read "The State shall not impose any disabilities or make any discrimination on the ground of religious profession or belief"?

Comment on this

If "belief" were the only word in it the argument is sound, but once you put in "profession or status" it extends it.

Comment on this

The Deputy may think that that is the interpretation, but I have given mine. The meaning in the context is clear. I have no doubt that the meaning in the context is that there shall not be unfair discrimination in favour of those of one religious belief, and unjust discrimination against those of another. I think it is quite clear that that is the meaning. If we have to bring Deputy Keely's point into this connection, I would say that, if you wanted authority for making an exemption, you could do it on the ground of having due regard for social function.

Comment on this

Discrimination on the ground of religious profession means that you can discriminate between all clergy and the laity, but you cannot discriminate between the clergy inter se. That is not in the Article. I do not care what is meant. We will not have this Article with the glosses on it here— we will have the Article alone.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It is seriously suggested that that allows discrimination as between the clergy as a body and the laity as a body, while it does not allow discrimination between groups of clergy?

Comment on this

I would hold, yes.

Comment on this

You may hold that in a very sincere way, but it is not there.

Comment on this

On the whole context.

Comment on this

On the ground of different religious belief or status. Clearly that would carry what is said, but that is not there. It is on the ground of religious profession. Supposing there is a conscription law passed and a general exemption of the clergy in it, surely it is a law making a discrimination on the ground of religious profession. What else is it? I do not care whether it should be there or not, but we must argue on the merits.

Comment on this

I will look into the matter from the point of view of the whole context. That is a repetition of the clause that was in the old Constitution. I told the House why I thought it wise to take advantage of these Articles. We lived under them for a number of years. There had been no criticism of them. They were found satisfactory. We adopted these and the word "discrimination," too. I think that in the whole of that context the intention is clear that it is discrimination in favour of one denomination against another; an unfair discrimination is the meaning there. I would deny, straight off, Deputy McGilligan's contention. I do not see anything wrong with the clause. If this were a single clause and we were asked to determine what was its meaning, I could only say that discrimination would be only differentiation; although unjust discrimination is in some contexts unfair discrimination. But in this context I would have to admit that discrimination here would be on the grounds of religious profession, belief or status, and would seem to imply that you could not make an exemption if you are depending on that alone. But my point is we are not depending on that alone. There is a clear indication that "social function" would cover it. However, on further examination, if there is anything to be covered by that, I am prepared to look into it; but unless there is very good reason for changing it, I prefer to leave it as it was for a number of years. I do not want to introduce any new element.

Comment on this

"The State guarantees not to endow any religion." The distinction there is endowment of religion. Then there are three other conditions—religious profession, belief or status. Religious belief means what the President is arguing about. Religious profession means something. What do they mean? What do they add to the phrase "religious belief"? Article 8 of the old Constitution did speak of making "any discrimination as respects State aid between schools under the management of different religious denominations——"

Comment on this

Drop out this thing about "profession" and "status," and leave "belief." That is all that is necessary.

Comment on this

I will have to look into it again. I did satisfy myself that the word "status" did cover this and that it had a meaning in the old Constitution and was intended to cover a very definite matter. At the moment it had escaped my memory. I will look into it again and see how the matter stands in the light of criticism.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:—

In page 94, line 5, Article 45, to delete the word "exclusive" and in the same line after the word "Oireachtas" to insert the word "exclusively".

This is simply a verbal alteration—to delete the word "exclusive" and after the word "Oireachtas" to insert the word "exclusively".

Comment on this

Not even the courts are going to take cognisance of this.

Comment on this

It is right to have it properly expressed.

Comment on this

It does not matter a row of pins.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:—

In page 96, Article 45, Section 3, sub-section 2º, line 5, before the word "against" to insert the words "and the workers".

This sub-section opens with: "The State shall endeavour to secure that private enterprise shall so be conducted as to ensure reasonable efficiency in the production and distribution of goods and as to protect the public against unjust exploitation." We have a declaration here that it is desirable to protect the public against unjust exploitation. I would imagine in providing an Article of that kind the President would have thought of those who are actually engaged in that kind of enterprise.

Comment on this

Who are "the public"?

Comment on this

I suggest the consumers of the goods produced by the enterprise. If the enterprise happened to be a bacon factory, a worker in it who did not like bacon would not be a consumer. We have an Article here saying that private enterprise shall be conducted so as to ensure reasonable efficiency in the production and distribution of goods. The Article refers to the public in that context. Surely that is meant to protect the public against exploitation in the production and distribution charges or to protect the public from being held up to ransom in order to obtain unreasonably high prices for goods produced. In this Article it is apparently only those who are likely to be exploited as consumers who are protected. There is no protection given to those who are immediately employed in the enterprise. Such protection given is for those who were consumers.

I do not think anybody would hold that the term "public" used here would include those who are actually workers engaged in the industry. Therefore, if this Constitution is to have an Article protecting anybody against unjust exploitation from private enterprise, surely the protection ought to be for those who were actually engaged in the enterprise and who may be exploited and who are a greater subject for exploitation by the enterprise in the form of asking them to work for low wages or for long hours and under such conditions as would constitute a very severe hardship upon them. If the President thinks that "the public" includes "workers" I do not think he is correct in his contention. If it is to include the workers this section ought to be given a better definition.

Comment on this

The Article reads: "shall be so conducted... as to protect the public against unjust exploitation." The question is "the public," I take it, as opposed to the private owner. If the word citizen were used the Deputy would not object. The view that the Deputy takes is that in his particular context what you want to prevent is the exploitation of the consumer. That would be narrower than the word "public" used here. However, I will put in the word "citizen" instead of "public." It will then read "to protect the citizen against unjust exploitation."

Comment on this

Including resident aliens?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is after now.

Comment on this

Does "citizen" include "resident aliens"?

Comment on this

As we use it, no.

Comment on this

As we use it, yes.

Comment on this

I take it that when we want to do that, we will have to use the word "person," not "citizen."

Comment on this

So all these rights granted to citizens are to nationals?

Comment on this

I take it when we use the word "citizen" here that we mean citizen. I know we have been, in some cases, anxious about that, and where there was a question of doubt we put in the word "person."

Comment on this

Where the dwelling of every citizen is declared to be inviolable, does that mean that an alien's house can be broken into?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows quite well that when you guarantee the rights of a certain class, you are not going to abuse the rights of another class.

Comment on this

But you are not giving them definite constitutional protection.

Comment on this

We are giving constitutional protection to citizens.

Comment on this

But the house of a resident alien is not constitutionally guaranteed.

Comment on this

That might be the strict reading, but in practice it would be different.

Comment on this

That is contrary to all constitutional practice.

Comment on this

Are we not now discussing an entirely different matter?

Comment on this

Not quite. The point seems to be what we would mean if we substituted the word "public" instead of "citizen".

Comment on this

Would the President consider putting in something to safeguard employees from exploitation?

Comment on this

The question might equally arise as to whether there might not be exploitation of the owners, too. You could so manage matters that even the owners might need to be safeguarded.

Comment on this

Let us take the killing of calves, for example.

Comment on this

They did not have to kill them. There was no compulsion.

Comment on this

There was a price offered.

Comment on this

There was no compulsion, because the market was destroyed?

Comment on this

May I call attention to a ruling given by the Chair on a much narrower matter than this? I was not allowed to talk on the section, not to speak at all of calves.

Comment on this

If the words "all concerned" were substituted for the word "public," would it improve matters?

Comment on this

The President says that he believes the words "the public" would include the workers.

Comment on this

I believe it would cover all who might be concerned with the conduct of this enterprise.

Comment on this

The section opens with the declaration that private enterprise shall be so conducted as to ensure reasonable efficiency as regards production and distribution, and as to protect the public against unjust exploitation. Clearly, the protection talked of here is protection against the manner in which a private enterprise is being conducted, and obviously, in the sense in which the matter is referred to here, the protection is against unfair or unscrupulous management.

Comment on this

Put in all the words you desire; it does not matter a fiddlededee what you put in this section. I suggest we all put in a word.

Comment on this

Why can we not put into this section the phrase "so as to protect the worker and the public generally," or "citizens generally"? Obviously, when you talk about exploitation in this sense, I think it is essential to give protection to the workers.

Comment on this

My difficulty about singling out classes is this — that I feel if you put in the workers you must of necessity put in other classes. The intention was to cover everybody by such a word as "public," and not confine it, say, to the consumers.

Comment on this

The word "public" might not include the owners; they might be a corporate body.

Comment on this

But they would also be included in "the public."

Comment on this

And they might be aliens and would not come in under "citizens."

Comment on this

Will Deputy Norton say what benefit he thinks this will confer on workers?

Comment on this

Well, this particular protection is being given to the public and not to the employees.

Comment on this

What protection?

Comment on this

The protection of the mentality behind this particular section.

Comment on this

Now I am as wise as I was before. The fact is that this Article confers protection on nobody, and it is specifically declared that it is not to be taken as conferring anything on anybody at any time or for any reason. It is just put in here to give the President an opportunity of taking a literary whirl and that is all.

Comment on this

I want to test who is being protected here in this Article.

Comment on this

Nobody. Someone may be protected in somebody's mentality, but it is nowhere else.

Comment on this

How will this Article be promulgated? Will it be by means of post cards? What is supposed to be done with this Article?

Comment on this

It is going to be a general headline approved of by the people as a whole — by the majority of the people, I hope.

Comment on this

And kept out of the law?

Comment on this

It will be approved as a headline for the Legislature. The difference between Deputy Norton and myself is this: I would rather have a comprehensive term to cover, as Deputy MacDermot suggested, all concerned, both the workers and the owners. I could imagine conditions in which the owners were being exploited, too. I do not want to indicate that it is only for a certain section or certain sections of the people. The word "public" was the widest word to cover all that. The Deputy is reading it as if "the public" meant those not actually engaged in the enterprise — what I might call the outside public. I am afraid the criticism of Deputy McGilligan would be more or less against the use of the word "citizen" if we were consistently going to use "citizen" in the sense in which it is defined as being a person of Irish nationality, belonging to the nation.

Comment on this

Why not put in "the world" instead of "the public"?

Comment on this

The Deputy was helpful up to the present, but now he is beginning to be unhelpful.

Comment on this

May I put it this way to Deputy Mrs. Concannon, that if I admonish her to-morrow that her great-grandfather's great-grandaunt did not think a certain type of legislation was good legislation, and she ought not to approve of it, she would probably reply that the aunt died somewhere in 1692 and the views that obtained then do not obtain now. This Article simply puts on record the current opinion of the great great grand-uncles of our great great grand-nephews. This is supposed to direct Oireachtas Eireann for all time, and it is addressed to posterity, if you please. What on earth would our great-grandchildren care about what we think is a desirable form of law? It is quite a different thing if we lay down a fundamental law and give people constitutional rights, because if you want to change that law you first have to convince the people that it should be changed. But you need never change anything to depart from Article 45. Therefore, two courses are open, one, to pay no heed to it, and the other is to let everybody put in a word. It does not matter what you put in or what you do not put in; it has no effect on anybody at any time or anywhere.

Comment on this

I do not quite agree with that. I think this raises important points in connection with legislation that may be introduced into this House.

Comment on this

I admit that at first sight it did not appear that the owners would be capable of exploitation under this section. I do not think that the workers need safeguarding, that they need special protection, because we have the whole system of social legislation which will be dealing with that aspect. The intention was that the words "the public" would protect all concerned, but "all concerned" seems by itself a rather indefinite phrase.

Comment on this

What about "safeguarding the workers against unjust exploitation"?

Comment on this

That is getting nearer to it, I admit——

Comment on this

Could you throw lots for it and let us get on?

Comment on this

——except that Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Costello would be getting rules of interpretation.

Comment on this

It does not matter. You can put anything in here.

Comment on this

There is nobody ever going to interpret this. It is only a general guidance.

Comment on this

The Legislature will interpret it.

Comment on this

As it pleases, and that will be mainly by not bothering their heads about it.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will never be there to interpret anything.

Comment on this

What does Von Blomberg say?

Comment on this

Is the President accepting these three words?

Comment on this

As the thing is so general, there seems to be no objection to the use of such general words as "all concerned".

Comment on this

"All concerned" gives it the atmosphere of "all and sundry".

Comment on this

There is a good phrase now—"all and sundry".

Comment on this

We may possibly be able to omit the words altogether and get some general phrase to guard against unjust exploitation.

Comment on this

To prevent unjust exploitation.

Comment on this

I should be prepared to accept a phrase like "to prevent unjust exploitation".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 60:—

In page 96, Article 45, Section 4, to delete sub-section 2º, and substitute the following new sub-section:—

2º. The State shall endeavour to ensure that the strength and health of workers, men and women, and the tender age of children shall not be abused and that citizens shall not be forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their sex, age or strength.

I already indicated that I would accept the first part of the amendment which Deputy Rowlette moved on Committee Stage, the amendment of which this is part. He suggested that there, with an earlier part, were two propositions, and I feel that that would be out of the context. That particular part introduced propositions which, if they were to be put in at all, would be more appropriate elsewhere. We say in part of the Constitution that the citizens may through their occupations find the means of making reasonable provision for their domestic needs, and the first part of the proposition is not really ad rem.

Comment on this

I agree with the President that the two sections of the proposition I put before the House last week were more or less independent of each other, but I do not mind where the President puts it in. I should be glad, however, to learn whether he is considering putting in some statement which would represent the sense of the first part of the amendment.

Comment on this

I have considered it, but it is very hard to take a document like the Constitution to bits and to put in bricks here and there. You throw out the whole structure, so to speak. I have considered it, but I do not see where I can put it in appropriately.

Comment on this

The President has not quarrelled, I understand, with the meaning or the sentiment of it. He has said that it would be irrelevant to this section, and I am not quarrelling with the view; but if he does not quarrel with the sentiment, it seems to me a very fundamental thing that it should be got in somewhere. So far as I can see, there is no statement anywhere in the Constitution that women have an economic equality with men. The President has stated, and I agree with him, that they are given political equality in the Constitution, but I do not see anywhere that they are given economic equality or economic freedom and I would ask him again to consider it to see where he could best fit it in.

Comment on this

Deputy Rowlette ought to remember — I hope he will pardon my reminding him — that an amendment of mine, amendment No. 54, was refused to-night. In the section dealing with the family and in the particular section dealing with mothers, I moved to insert: "Nothing in this section"—the matter dealing with mothers—"shall operate to prevent, prohibit or interfere with any citizen proposing to engage or engaging in any legitimate occupation for remuneration." That was refused. The dagger is still unsheathed. It is there for use and women may be discriminated against definitely and entirely on the ground of sex in respect of employment. I have amendment No. 61 down but I do not care much about discussing it or any amendment to Article 45, it having the status it has in the Constitution, but let us consider what happens. We opened that Article with a section in which we mark out for distinction the inadequate strength of women and the tender age of children, and we went on solemnly to declare, for the general guidance of the Oireachtas, that women or children should not be forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their sex, age or strength. I wanted to remove from that the reference to women so that the section would read:—

The State shall endeavour to secure that the tender age of children shall not be abused and that they should not be forced to enter avocations unsuited to their age or strength.

The President does a double twist and where we previously pointed to the inadequate strength of women and children, we now, if it pleases you, point to the inadequate strength of the whole lot of us, men, women and children. We now solemnly give, for the guidance of the Oireachtas, this admonition:

The State shall endeavour to ensure that the strength and health of workers, men and women, and the tender age of children...

the children still get special mention of their age

.... shall not be abused ....

the sting is still in the tail

.... and that citizens shall not be forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited...

to what? Their sex, age or strength. Cut out the word "sex". Why leave it in?

Comment on this

I have already indicated that this is practically the amendment that was proposed by Deputy Rowlette last week.

Comment on this

There is still the sex discrimination in it.

Comment on this

It was proposed to replace the original text and I agreed to accept it. The second part of Deputy Rowlette's amendment was:—

The State shall endeavour to ensure that the strength and health of workers and the tender age of children shall not be abused, and no citizen or child shall be forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their sex, age, or strength.

I have practically reproduced that here.

Comment on this

And the President thinks that a return for that part of Deputy Rowlette's amendment which he has cited? That amendment opened with this preamble:

"The State recognises the right of all citizens to work and obtain work, and that in this respect the rights of men and women are equal."

What follows is overridden by that preamble. That is one statement of fact. What we have here is an entirely different one.

Comment on this

This is one in this context.

Comment on this

It still contains the element of sex discrimination and there is no positive statement that men and women are to be recognised as having equal rights in regard to the obtaining of work.

Comment on this

Having equal rights to gain a livelihood.

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

It is not there.

Comment on this

Where is it at all?

Comment on this

It is not in that context.

Comment on this

Where is it at all?

Comment on this

It is probably in their occupations, where we say: "The citizens may through their occupations find the means of making reasonable provision for their domestic needs."

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

In Article 45 (2) (1).

Comment on this

That is no statement with regard to the absence of discrimination. It does not prohibit discrimination.

Comment on this

I have said to the Deputy that we cannot, with our eyes open, close every possible door from the point of view of social legislation which will be to the benefit of the community as a whole. The point is that you are leaving these questions as a matter for the future to determine. We are looking for rights that were not guaranteed hitherto, and what I am prepared to stand on definitely is that men and women are entitled to and have an equal right to a livelihood, being members of the community. A further right than that I cannot see. I doubt very much whether two men have an equal right to a particular occupation. I do not think they have. Differences of capacity might make one of them quite unfitted, and if we are going to read "an equal right to work" as meaning that if there is a particular position vacant, two of us have the same right to it, I think it would be absurd. We would not have the same right to it. It would depend on our ability to perform the work. You cannot say off-hand that citizens shall have a right to work if by that you mean other than the right to earn a livelihood. You cannot restrict it and be honest. Whether they be men or women, well-equipped or ill-equipped, they have a right to a means of livelihood. That is a fundamental right.

Comment on this

It is not in the Constitution.

Comment on this

There are a large number of matters which are not in the Constitution. Nobody suggested that this Constitution should be a catalogue of individual and family rights.

Comment on this

No Article says men and women shall have an equal right to a livelihood.

Comment on this

Except in so far as it is implied in Article 45 (2) (1). If the proposal to amend in one place is of no use, it is of no use in the other place.

Comment on this

These are fundamental rights not guaranteed by law.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not have gone as far as I have gone in guaranteeing those rights. I was one of the first to make the statement which the Deputy quotes at me in which I used the word "enmeshed." I hold that if persons are prevented, because of being members of organised society, from doing things to get a livelihood that they would not otherwise be prevented from doing, it is the duty of the community to see that they get that livelihood. I am quite prepared to put that in Article 45 or elsewhere if I can get a place for it.

Comment on this

You have not done it.

Comment on this

Because there is a host of other things not mentioned. There is no pretence that this Constitution is a complete catalogue of individual and family rights. We are trying to provide certain foundations for a State organisation and, on the social side, we are providing certain directives. An equal right to work is not a thing that can be predicated of men or women. I do not think it is a true proposition. Whether they be men or women, well endowed or ill-endowed by nature for the competition which exists, they are entitled to an adequate means of livelihood. From that point of view, there is equality of right. I am quite prepared to put that into an appropriate section of the Constitution.

Comment on this

The President has admitted the principle for which I am contending. He admits there is a fundamental human right. Will he consider the insertion of a suitable provision?

Comment on this

I would not put it in in this connection at all.

Comment on this

I believe there is a special reason for doing this. It would allay the anxiety of a large section of the community if the President could find a suitable place in which to insert a provision such as I have suggested.

Comment on this

I shall try again. This is something apart, and it is hard to get a suitable place in which to insert it. The right that should be guaranteed by the community is, I think, the right to an adequate means of livelihood. What is "adequate" would be difficult to define, and we do not want to have vexatious cases brought before the courts. If we put it in the courts section we would have such cases.

Comment on this

Is it to be a cognisable right?

Comment on this

The best we could do would be to indicate somewhere in Article 45 that we recognise it as a fundamental right that citizens should have access to an adequate means of livelihood through their occupation, or, if that fails, through community action. An equal right to work might mean an equal right to a particular post, which would be absurd. I shall try to get in what I have said somewhere.

Comment on this

The President has talked profoundly and sincerely about the value of these fundamental human rights. When it comes to translating sentiment into action, he is merely prepared to embody this phrase in Article 45, which opens with the delightfully innocuous declaration that the application of the principle contained in it shall not be cognisable under any of the provisions of the Constitution. The President could put almost anything into Article 45 because there is no means of enforcing the right. The President agrees with Deputy Rowlette that this provision should be made, and then proceeds — I do not think he intends to do so — to sell him a pup in the kennel labelled "Article 45." The President could not only give Deputy Rowlette the right he asked for in this Article, but he could give him a sack of rights. What is wanted is a right enforceable by law. Why not put the right into an Article other than 45?

Comment on this

Because he is trying to choke the cat with something other than a pound of butter.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this