Private Deputies' Business. - Standard of Living—Abolition of Duties on Foodstuffs—Motion (Resumed).
Contributions 1–142 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When speaking to this motion a week ago, I gave certain figures. On last Monday I was questioned about those figures by an individual who may perhaps have also approached people on the Government Benches, and in order to anticipate any discussion I have armed myself with the balance sheets for the years 1935-6 and 1936-7. Those balance sheets disclose that in the year 1936-7 the net profit was £14,415 14s. 7d., and that for the year 1935-6 the net profit was £15,043 10s. 3d. Those are slightly less than the figures I mentioned last week.
Notice taken that a quorum was not present; House counted and 20 members being present,
Comment on this
The figures I mentioned last week were £16,000 and £17,000, while the actual figures are £14,000 and £15,000. It has to be remembered that this profit was made out of the bacon end of our business only. The business had to suffer a loss in other directions. It had to suffer the loss of the cost of the strike in 1936, and it had to suffer the loss of our first year's canning. The whole thing was a dead loss. The figure I mentioned a week ago would, therefore, be a very conservative figure indeed.
The Minister, in attacking this motion, based his attack under four different heads. I think we might disregard all the other speeches that were made against this motion. With all due respect to the Deputies, their speeches struck me as counting for nothing. The only case made was made by the Minister, and, as I have said, he concentrated his attack under four different heads: first, the increased number of motor cars in the country; secondly, the amount of beer and spirits consumed; thirdly, the bank clearances; and fourthly, the savings in the Post Office Savings Bank. Now, the Minister knows Dublin better than I do, and has better means of ascertaining the names of the owners of motor cars, but anybody coming into Dublin as I do, and seeing the number of motor cars parked on the streets, would come to the conclusion that the City of Dublin and its environs are responsible for 70 or 80 per cent. of the increase in the number of motor cars. You will have inspectors' cars; no inspector is worth two pins if he is not able to arm himself with a motor car, and, God knows, this Government has given us an army of inspectors. They have also given us an army of directors of a sort in all the new factories they have established. Every director has to arm himself with a car. The managers have to arm themselves with cars.
I think this largely explains the increase in the number of motor cars. There is also the same thing in the country towns and, if there is a suggestion by anybody here that motor cars have increased in numbers in the rural districts among the farming community, then let me examine the position. If a farmer or any man living in the country wants to go anywhere now, if he has any business in a town or at a fair, it is difficult to go except he has a motor car, because the road is impassable for his horse. If he has not a motor car and if the distance is not too great, he has to use his bicycle or walk. If any farmer owns a motor car, it is because it is an absolute necessity. There are less motor cars, from the luxury point of view, among the farmers than there used to be. Scarcely any farmer has a motor car from a luxury point of view. Any cars there are in the country are there by reason of absolute necessity, because the roads are impossible for horses. Nobody would think of bringing out a horse to do a journey on the roads. In an odd rural district, possibly on a by-road, a farmer might be able to use his horse to reach a town or a market. In most instances, if he has not a bicycle, he has to walk.
As regards the amount of beer and spirits consumed in the country, I was amazed at the statement that has been made. I am not going to question the Minister's figures, but from the point of view of the man who lives in the country like I do, the consumption of beer and spirits is remarkable for its absence, and I can only come to the conclusion that it is only in the cities, in Dublin in particular, that these luxuries are indulged in. Of course, that may be due to the higher wages that are being paid in industry here.
Comment on this
Not in the country. Smithwick's ale has a market all over the country, but it is not largely consumed in the rural districts. I have not seen a man drinking beer or spirits in the country for the last five or six years. Perhaps it is because I am not a frequenter of the bars. I never drank in my life, and perhaps that is the reason I know so little about it, but I had information that there is infinitely less drink consumed. It is almost reduced to disappearing point so far as the drink consumption by the farming community and the farm labourers is concerned. What could they consume it on? All their resources have been taken away from them and they cannot get anything, unless it is on tick.
If there is a grumble with regard to the cost of living—and there is a very serious, a universal, grumble—it cannot under any circumstances be half as acute among the workers in the towns and cities, who have got something in the way of an advance in their conditions. They have got a big advance with regard to wages, according to their own claim. Two or three times within the last 12 months ex-Senators Kennedy and Foran have claimed that wages have been advanced in the City of Dublin by £24,000 a week. If that is so, it proves that the industrial workers have got something to meet the increased cost of living.
What has the country worker, the farmer, to meet the increased cost of living? Let us take bacon as an example. There are infinitely less pigs in the country to-day than there were two years ago. As I pointed out last week, where we used to kill 1,500 to 1,700 a week, we now kill only 700 or 800. I made a mistake when I said that other factories were in like circumstances. I understand that that is not so. We have a shortage of 100,000 pigs. What is the cause of it? The farmer, the agricultural worker, is hit at both ends, as a producer and as a consumer. I am not going to deal with the other burden he has to bear, the burden of the economic war. That will more properly come up on another motion that is on the Order Paper. I will exclude that matter altogether, that is, if one is able to exclude that all-important aspect from one's mind, and I will deal with the farmer as a consumer and as a producer, the two things proper to this motion.
The farmer has gone out of pig production and he has gone out of fowl production. Every country dweller, every farmer's wife, used to have a certain number of hens and other fowl. How many have they to-day? The Minister for Agriculture was asked a supplementary question this afternoon. Did he answer it? He was too wise to do that. The fact is that there are no young fowl in the country. There are much less hens in the country; there are less pigs and less of everything that is dependent on the admixture scheme. There are two things responsible for that; either the admixture scheme is not suitable, is not giving a proper return, or it is too dear. Either nothing can thrive on it, can thrive sufficiently, or it is too dear, or both, and I think the answer is both.
The position of the farmer and the agricultural worker is infinitely worsened—that is, from the point of view of the producer. On top of that, they have to bear the cost of the economic war. As a consumer the farmer is asked to pay more for the necessaries of life. Is there any question about his position or that he has to pay more for the cost of living? Is there any question that his position as a producer is worsened? While there is a justifiable grumble among the people in the towns, the industrial workers, what is the position of the unfortunate man who has to carry the chief burdens of this country on his back? The industrial worker is not so badly hit.
I have here three circulars sent out to different traders inside the last fortnight. One circular says:—"In view of the continued advance of the cost of production, labour and materials, we are again compelled to advance the price of our spare parts. Kindly note, therefore, that there is an advance of 20 per cent. instead of the 10 per cent. of which we advised you a fortnight ago." Then they give the prices list. Here is a circular to another tradesman:—"We beg to advise that, due to the increased cost of production, we have been compelled to advance the price of all edged tools by 10 per cent."
Comment on this
Is it advisable that I should mention the names of the firms? If the Deputy wants to see the circulars, I will show them to him.
Comment on this
I do not think it is advisable that the names of traders or dealers should be mentioned.
Comment on this
I do not think it is advisable, because then the particular trader could be made a cockshot.
Comment on this
A convention has grown up here that the names of traders and dealers should not be mentioned, for obvious reasons.
Comment on this
I am not questioning that at all; I merely wanted to verify the allegation to which I refer.
Comment on this
I will hand these to Deputy Davin the moment I have finished with them. Will that suit the Deputy?
Comment on this
The third circular refers to scythes and hay knives and it says: "We are reluctantly compelled to inform you that, owing to the increase in the cost of raw materials and labour rates, we have no option but to advance the price of scythe blades and hay knives." The position is that the demand is made. The people come together. The two industries involved come together. They agree and without any trouble the cost of the article is increased. That is a very happy state of affairs for them. It is something we have all envied and something that we are envying and regretting that we cannot participate in. You demand, we agree and we pass on the additional cost to the poor devil in the country who is not able to defend himself. That is the position. But I tell the House that this vicious circle must stop because the people of this country, as a whole, cannot put up with it. I want the Dáil and the people outside to realise that half of this community are not going to act as cart horses for the other half. They are not going to carry this heavy load for the benefit of the other half of the community. One citizen of this State has as much right under the Constitution as another. Hungry men will not live in this country, and they would be damn fools if they did.
Comment on this
The system that permits or enforces that cannot continue. The people of this country should be left to work out their own salvation in their own way instead of being penalised by a power that we cannot fight. We cannot fight that power except by a slow fight at the polls. As I have already said, this is a vicious circle and it must stop. Many people in this country to-day have made up or they are beginning to make up their minds that any 'ism that will put all the people of this country fairly pulling their load would be preferable to the present system. Any 'ism that does that, whether it be Fascism or Christian Communism or anything else, is preferable to what we have to put up with. Anything by way of redress that will ensure that the people of this country will all be compelled to pull their load, and to pull evenly, will be acceptable by all the people.
We had enough of the privileged classes in this country. Twenty or 30 years ago we got rid of some of that privileged class, and we got rid of the rest of them 15 years ago. We are not going to set up a new privileged class. We have no room for that class. We have no room for the new class of inspectors, directors and the rest of them. This morning a man handed me a quotation for 36-inch ranges manufactured in the Free State. The price is £4 15s. 0d. The same class of range, but a more suitable range and one that is more in demand by the people and which they buy in preference to this range at £4 15s. 0d., is a Glasgow range. The price is £4 5s. 6d. That is 9/6 cheaper than the home range. That £4 5s. 6d. range has to bear a tariff of 40 per cent. In other words, the Glasgow range would be only 51/- without the tariff. On the one hand you have a home-manufactured range costing £4 15s. Od., and on the other side there is a range costing £2 11s. 0d. and the Glasgow range is a better range. It is no wonder that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has been attending dinners and banquets. It is no wonder he and others are able to dine and wine and enjoy banquets when this sort of thing is going on. It is the people who have to buy these ranges who are paying for the banquets and the wining and the dining.
If a farmer wants a load of any material to do anything about his house, he is forced to go to the railway company and find out when he can get their lorry. Else he can go without it. What he is generally doing is going without. If the farmer wanted a load of gravel, sand or lime, he has to go to the railway company for their lorry and employ them. If he employs a local lorry, and if that lorry has not the proper plate, the farmer is prosecuted. There was such a prosecution in Callan in Kilkenny last Friday. That was the prosecution of a man for bringing a lorry-load of chips. In any event the case was dismissed. I will not go into the matter of the evidence that was produced in order to effect that dismissal. There is the position. The whole country has been handed over to Deputy Davin and his friends.
Comment on this
The Transport Acts and the Traffic Acts were passed by the Oireachtas. The administration of those Acts is not relevant to this debate.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Gorey aware that there are 6,000 private lorries operating in the country?
Comment on this
The cost of living has been so much increased by the operation of these things that they affect the people very seriously. I admit that this particular thing is not in these Acts. What I refer to is that the railway lorry has to arrive with the driver and two loaders. By the time the farmer has his lorry-load of material home he will have spent a load of gold, or at all events a load of copper, on it. The result is that the farmer is going without these things. The grant of £40 to farmers whose valuation is under £25 for building is not being availed of. All the farmer would get for that £40 would be 40 loads of sand. The farmer has either to pay this money or to go without these things, because he cannot bring his horse on to the roads at all. The roads are made impossible for horse traffic. That is the position in which we are now.
During this debate we heard a great wail about our attacking the programme of the Government on the one hand and on the other hand adopting it. Of course we have to adopt the programme of the Government. If the Government commit the people of this country to a certain type of economy, the people for the time being are helpless. We have heard a good deal about the wheat scheme. That is like other schemes introduced by the Government, and people have to carry it out, but I tell the House that it only requires 12 months more for the whole wheat scheme to die a natural death. Last year the area under wheat was reduced by 30,000 acres, and all indications point to the certainty that there will be a still further reduction next year.
Comment on this
Because the land that has been growing wheat is only producing two, three or four barrels per acre now. In addition, the growing of wheat has left a legacy in weeds that will do the farmer, and more than be enough for him, during the rest of his natural life. If Deputy Davin were only to go down to Kilismesta or Durrow in his own constituency he would only have to open his eyes and see what the position is. He could there see the state to which the country has been reduced by the wheat scheme. The only further liability this State will have with regard to wheat-growing in the future is the provision of a decent funeral for wheat-growing, for that wheat scheme is going to die a natural death. While every died a natural death. While every other form of agriculture has been penalised by this Government, wheat has been subsidised.
Every other form of agriculture has been penalised by the economic war. If wheat growing could be a success at all it should be a success under these conditions. If the penalty were taken off the other forms of agriculture, if the cattle embargo of £4 5s. per head, or, as it used to be, £6 per head, were taken off, will any Deputy tell me what chance would wheat growing have? Wheat growing has no chance unless it is subsidised. If the penalties imposed on other industries were removed, will any Deputy tell me how long would wheat growing as an economic proposition last in this country? Take away the bounty on wheat production and how long would it last? It is already dying, under the most favourable conditions, and it will be dead in 12 months more. Whenever the economic war is settled, good-bye wheat.
Take the case of the Post Office Savings Bank. The Minister tells us that he has exact figures, and he says:—
"I propose to give the exact figure representing the weekly average amount deposited in the Post Office Savings Bank, less withdrawals, plus the amount paid for savings certificates, less payments.... There is no evidence of a reduction in the standard of living there. Indeed, the evidence is to the contrary. There is evidence that our people are saving more. That increase in savings was recorded in each month of this year up to June."
Deputy Davin asked at this stage "What about the bank overdrafts?" The Minister went on:—
"In July there was no increase recorded, but that was to be expected, having regard to the prolonged building strike which necessitated some depositors realising on their savings in order to maintain themselves."
In other words, the whole increase in deposits in the Post Office Savings Bank is attributable to the City of Dublin and a few towns. The Minister is in a better position than I am to give details. He can tell us in what part of the country these savings were effected—whether they were effected in Kilkenny, Cork, Leitrim, Kerry, or in Dublin. Again, his argument proves conclusively that while one section of the community—the people engaged in industry—have favoured treatment, the other section is infinitely worse off. Only one section of the community can attempt to meet this increased cost of living. The other section cannot do so. I need not go further than the Minister's words to show that. I should like to have the knowledge which he has at his disposal. It would prove our case.
From people all over the country there are complaints of the pests which are overrunning the country. There is a plague of rabbits, foxes, rats and winged pests. Still, the price of cartridges has been increasing steadily for the last three or four years. There is another increase going on now on the only cartridge which, in my opinion—and I am fairly experienced— will shoot anything. When using the home manufactured cartridge which we were getting six months ago, you would think that your gun had tuberculosis. It was getting a tubercular cough and depositing the wads and charge at the mouth of the gun. It would not kill anything, and everybody was handing back these cartridges and demanding Remingtons. There was an advertisement in the Kilkenny and Waterford papers recently announcing "The last of the Remingtons". This home-produced cartridge may be somewhat improved now. The Government should give the country a good, cheap cartridge to deal with these pests. Why would not the country be over-run with rabbits, rats and other pests when we have cartridges of that kind? If it costs 2d. to kill a rat or a rabbit, is anybody going to fire at it? These pests got a footing during the civil war. They were thinned down considerably because of the fur prices. To-day they are worse than ever. There are complaints from every county. The only way to deal with the situation would be for the Government to supply cheap cartridges to the people and try to reduce their cost of living.
As regards motor cars, I saw one of these new aristocrats, in addition to the aristocracy established here a few years ago, in the country last Friday. He called on the local horticultural instructor and offered 3/6 per cwt. for apples. That is a great encouragement to farmers to grow apples, which would be about 4d. per lb. in Dublin. He said he would give more if they were properly sprayed. Judging by all the Bills we have going through this House—judging even by the Bills we had before us to-day—I am afraid that legislators, perhaps in both Parties, think only in terms of the City of Dublin.
They think only of the conditions of employment in the cities and they are only interested at times of election in the country. "Out of sight, out of mind." Even Deputies from the country seem to take the situation very easily. They do not care two pins about the conditions of the farmers and farm labourers so long as certain favoured treatment is meted out to this superior order of humanity which resides in the cities. Is it any wonder that all our young men and young women want to get out of the country? What has been done to try to keep them at home and make their lot attractive? Is it any wonder that they have gone to England and that they have gone into the cities at home? Nobody seems to have any regard for the country. Some of the speeches I have heard here from country Deputies would lead me to believe that they have either no power of observation or that they are criminal fools.
There is no doubt at all that the cost of living in every direction has gone up. I remember the Minister for Industry and Commerce proposing a tariff on phosphates in 1932. He would listen to nobody's advice, and he forced the tariff through. At that time people were using hundreds of tons of phosphates as grass manure. How many hundreds of tons of phosphates were used during the last few years? Where people were selling large quantities of phosphates some years ago, they are not selling a ton to-day. In regard to beet and wheat, there may be some used; but whoever thought of that tariff on phosphates did not know anything about his job or did not care. At all events, the Minister did the worst turn that could be done to agriculture, and, in my opinion, he did a very bad turn to the manufacturers of phosphates. I can conceive nothing worse than that tariff.
A Deputy speaks of the improvement in the quality of boots. I see no increase in the quality, and I wear Irish boots. The uppers and quarters may be good enough, but the sole leather is utterly inferior. The good old sole leather which we used to have and which we used to need is not there now. To say that the percentage in England has gone up as high as the percentage here is not giving any idea of the actual figures. There was room for an increase in the English price of boots because of the low level at which they stood. There is a big gap indeed between the two prices. I have not been over in England for two or three years, so I am not able to give exact figures as I was a few years ago, but I remember the gap then, and it is not a fair comparison to talk of the rise there and the rise here. Deputy Kelly, or some other Deputy, described conditions in England as unhealthy. He suggested that that was not an indication of prosperity, and that the prosperity that was there was founded on armaments expenditure. Whatever the foundation, prosperity was brought to England, and that prosperity has been reflected here, and were it not for that we should all be in the workhouse to-day. The 1933, 1934 and 1935 position has been saved and revolutionised because of that prosperity, whether it is right or wrong. It has prolonged our agony and saved us from the work house. We will not get there for another year or two.
Comment on this
I rise, as a newcomer to oppose this motion. I attribute my presence in this House to the very important fact that there is a very considerable increase in the standard of living in this country to-day, a standard which has been steadily improving from 1932 to 1937. I claim the honour of having replaced in this House one who stood for a policy which the people of this country on the last three occasions have rejected. When Deputy Dillon was speaking on this motion he availed of the opportunity to throw what I would describe as a financial smoke screen around the position as it presents itself to us. I leave Deputy Dillon's smoke screen to be dealt with by those in financial responsibility to the Government; but in passing I wonder if the late Government had collected its share of the indemnities which Britain claimed from Germany for the loss of the 35,000 brave Irishmen who died fighting her battles on the fields of France, Flanders, Gallipoli, Mesopotamia, and all the other theatres of war, what would be the position? We are told that if we had that money it would very considerably assist the standard of living here to-day. It is on record that Britain's claim against Germany for the loss of those 35,000 Irishmen was based on the figure of £800 per head. We hear a great deal about the emigration that is taking place from this country in our day and of the exodus of the young men and women from this miserable land of ours; but I would remind the House—and these are recorded facts, recorded not by the Fianna Fáil Government but recorded facts of the late Government—that we lost no less than 250,000 of the cream of Ireland's young manhood and young womanhood from 1922 to 1932, and, if my mathematical calculations be correct—based on a calculation of £800 per head—those 250,000 young men and women who had to flee from this land during those years, when this land was, as we were so often told, flowing with milk and honey, represented £200,000,000 worth of rich red Irish blood and strong white Irish bone. But what does that matter? They are the common Irish.
We hear lamentations from all sides of the Opposition about the dreadful losses which this country is suffering through the economic war, and we are told that our standard of living is gradually declining. I contend that the standard of living in this country has not been equalled in its history. Deputy Dillon laments the dreadful amount of money required by this Government to conduct the affairs of this country. This Government could very easily run the affairs of this country at a figure similar to that at which the late Government ran them, if it were to condemn our Irish people to continue to live in the dreadful hovels of misery and disease from which the late Government did nothing to relieve them.
Comment on this
We could also save millions if we were to deny the widows and the orphans the pensions they were justly entitled to as children of this country, because I contend that the land of Ireland is to the people of Ireland what the earth is to the whole human race. It is the heritage and the patrimony given to them by its Creator as a free gift whereby they could, by the application of their continuous toil and labour, produce the necessaries of life so as to enable them to live in decency and comfort. We are asked about the £35,000,000. That was a one-sided game, we are told. I think that Deputies attending this House should have the common intelligence, at least, to understand that it takes two to make a quarrel. During the discussion on this motion Deputy Brennan also took grave exception to the fact that this Government has taken steps to ensure that, so far as possible, all the farming implements required in the farming life of this country shall be produced here. We had an intimation to the effect that even the material produced here is not what it should be, and is not comparable to what is imported. I should like to ask this question: How did the people of Ireland till the land with Irish implements when this country maintained almost 8,000,000 of people in the 32 counties? These tools were made at blacksmiths' forges, where they turned out not only forks and shovels, but ploughs and harrows, and no fault was found with them in those far-off days.
Comment on this
Of course, any cudgel is good enough with which to try to belittle the efforts of Fianna Fáil, in trying to establish here a policy of self-sufficiency. Is not that the objective, where it is possible to achieve it, not only in this country but practically all over the world to-day? During the debate we had a wail of woe from Deputy McGovern. His wail of woe regarding the cost of living seemed to be that his friends around Cavan are not able to secure a sufficiency of second-hand clothing. Personally, I say "wails of woe to them," because I trust it will be many years before there is a sufficiency of these second-hand clothing bargains— that spread disease as well as other things throughout the country. Some time ago Deputy Dillon applauded the fact that we could have emigration and could send our exiles throughout the world. In the olden days the cry was, "To hell or to Connaught with the Irish." The modern cry throughout the world is for a population that can be kept at an economic level. Very extensive use has been made of the Statistical Abstract, a copy of which has been presented to every Deputy. I ask Deputies on the opposite benches to give a little consideration to page 6, to see if they could not learn a lesson in Irish history from it. I draw the attention of Deputy Gorey, who has just left the House, to the position of Kilkenny. In 1851 Kilkenny had a population of 19,975 souls. What was the population in 1936? It was 10,222, so that 9,753 people were driven from that city during a period of 50 years. I direct the attention of Deputies for Kilkenny to the position of the town of Callan. In 1851 the population there was 4,650 and in 1936, 1,508. Did Fianna Fáil or its policy drive the people from Kilkenny or from Callan? Was it that policy drove the people from Drogheda, Ballinasloe, or from Thurles which in 1851 had a population of 8,800, and to-day has 5,000?
Comment on this
May I remind Deputy O'Leary that the late Government was responsible for at least five of the years included in the last census. I invite the Deputy to contradict that statement.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that emigration had stopped when the late Government went out of office?
Comment on this
I have stated that between 1922 and 1932 we lost 250,000 of our population.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me a question, and I asked him if emigration had not stopped when the late Government went out of office. Will the Deputy answer that question from the Statistical Abstract?
Comment on this
Was that not due to the fact that no more were ready to go?
Comment on this
The population has been reduced since. There were more people in the country at that period than now.
Comment on this
The population of Youghal in 1851 was 10,260. To-day the population is 5,237. Is Fianna Fáil responsible for a reduction to half of the population during that period? I want to draw the attention of Deputies from Meath to some statistics which are not included in the Statistical Abstract issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce. I wish to remind Deputy Giles, who was interrupting some time ago, that it is lamentable that we have in the Parliament of the Irish nation a native of Royal Meath who does not know the history of this country. That is a regrettable thing to have to say, but it is none the less true. In 1841 the human population of County Meath was 183,828, and the cattle population 83,471. How did the Irish people manage to survive when there was twice the population here, and less than half the present number of cattle?
Comment on this
The human population of Meath in 1866 was 62,969, so that there was a loss of 120,859. Yet we are told that the standard of living is rapidly declining and that the people are fleeing from the land. What is the inference to be drawn from that? Deputies on the opposite side have one policy and one policy only, and that is to surrender to our ancient enemy.
Comment on this
That is their policy. We have it from the leader of the Opposition. He says: "Settle the economic war and we will have an increased standard of living."
Comment on this
In that period there was an increase in the cattle population of from 83,000 to 323,116, an increase in the animal population of 178 per cent., while we lost 50.7 per cent. of our human population, and yet the Party opposite say that their policy is the right policy for the country.
Comment on this
That is the effect of their policy, but I would remind the Deputies opposite of the cause. In 1841, when the clearances in Royal Meath started, we had no less than 2,428 evictions of families comprising 11,658 people. The number employed in agricultural pursuits and in industry in the County Meath was 51,000.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I had to leave the House last week because I was told I was not in order.
Comment on this
The motion before the House states:—
That the Dáil deplores the lowering of the standard of living of the community by Government action through the operation of taxes, levies, duties and the like impositions on foodstuffs and other necessaries of life, and is of opinion that all such impositions should be forthwith abolished.
I would like to point out that what the Deputy is saying has nothing whatever to do with the motion before the House.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy O'Leary that the evictions in Royal Meath in 1841 bear no relation to the motion before the House, but I do not for a moment accept the Deputy's statement that he was asked to leave the House for being irrelevant. He was asked to leave the House for flouting the authority of the Chair.
Comment on this
I have been asked by Deputy Giles when did I come into politics?
Comment on this
May I, with your permission, say that I came into politics in the year 1911.
Comment on this
To get back to the point that I was dealing with when the interruptions took place, I submit that the analogy which I am drawing here has a very grave bearing on the question that we are discussing. I would remind Deputies that in the year 1831 the population of all Ireland was 7,767,401, and that in that year we exported to England 211,189 barrels of wheat, 805,670 barrels of oats, 176,561 cwts. of flour and barley. In 1930, and this is the ticklish point to which I would direct the attention of the Opposition, the population of this country was roughly 4,000,000. It had gone down by almost half, and, while that is so, what do we find? That we imported wheat, barley, oats, maize, flour and oat products to the value of £9,114,288. These figures are not figures compiled by the Fianna Fáil Government. They are the figures of the late Government. In addition, we imported here something like £1,500,000 worth of Chinese bacon and punk stuff from Yokahama, not to speak of the salt bacon which Deputy Dillon is anxious to get on the market here again in order that he can make his 100 per cent. profit on it instead of handling Irish bacon.
Comment on this
The Deputy must leave the business concerns of his fellow-Deputies out of debate in this House.
Comment on this
We could then have a reduced cost of living. We could have Russian bacon at 3½d. a lb. Admit tedly, we could not sell our own bacon for that to-day, but we would have a better opportunity of getting the 100 per cent. profit on the imported bacon. As one interested in the trade, I am heartily glad that the foreign stuff is shut out, and I hope that we will never see the day when it will be readmitted to this country. It certainly gave us a reduced cost of living, but undoubtedly it also gave disease to the children of this country who happened to be fed on it for some years past. From 1922 to 1932 we lost that dreadful amount through emigration. I am one of those who hold that the solution of this problem is to settle the people of this country on the land of Ireland, which is their rightful inheritance. As a Catholic Irishman I make no apology to the House for quoting from the legislation of Pope Clement VII in 1523. His Holiness decreed:
"Long ago our predecessor, Sixtus IV, of happy memory, remarked that for many years before his time the whole region around the City of Rome often afforded but scanty harvest of grain, to the serious loss and suffering of the people dwelling therein. He took into account that, allowing for the natural qualities of the climate and weather, this scarcity was due most of all to the lack of tillage of the land. The fields were by preference kept untilled for their owners, to serve as grazing ranches for brute beasts, on account of what was perhaps a greater return from the land while in that condition. This was done rather than till the soil or permit it to be tilled for the nourishment and support of human beings."
Have we not here an exact replica of the policy which was condemned by the Popes?
Comment on this
From the Catholic Bulletin for November, 1933. The quotation continues:
"Hence Sixtus IV had decreed and ordained that for all time henceforth anyone whosoever wished to plough and till in the region around our City...should be at liberty to break up, plough and till at the proper and usual seasons a third part which he shall himself think fit to select of every single holding or tenure..."
Clement VII acted on the same lines as his predecessor by his decree of March, 1523:
"The third part of all land in the hands of leaseholders, the third part of every estate, the third of all the demesnes situated in Roman territory, in the patrimony of St. Peter, and on the coastal territory of the Campagna and twenty miles around it, whether belonging to Churches or to monasteries or to hospitals or to the Apostolic Chamber or to barons, nobles, Roman citizens, persons of all conditions and of all dignities, even eminent Cardinals...must without any hindrance or obstacle be every year worked, sown and kept in condition for the harvesting of corn,"
when it was a question of providing food for the people. Further, we have the legislation of Pope Pius VI in 1783. In January, 1783, His Holiness required "that farm buildings be opened to the landless tillers free of charge, and went even further in exempting the tiller from all payment of rent to the ranch-lord."
Now, we are told that it is an unholy thing in this country if the Government takes steps to divide land. Of course, we do not have open opposition to this sort of thing. We have what is known as the subterfuge, the wirepulling, and the red-tape, that was so strongly in evidence at one period, of a native Government in this country. We have evidence of that. We have evidence of it in abundance, if we wish to show it.
Comment on this
Is not that article that the Deputy has read an article for the justification of the forcible seizure of land, and was not that article written with a certain purpose? Is the Deputy accepting all the tenets of that article?
Comment on this
I am sorry, Sir. I withdraw the expression, but I will say we have so many men interested in the importation of so many commodities of all kinds——
Comment on this
Exactly — Russian bacon and so on. We know that it does not suit certain traders, and in particular the graziers and import grafters, to stand for the importation of what is necessary to be imported and the exportation of what we have to sell. Their only interest is in the profits they can make out of the export of their live stock and the other commodities they have to export, and what profits they can make out of their import trade, such as it is; but I say that it is the duty of this Government to keep both exports and imports on a healthy level and to make them the servant rather than the master of this State; and I say further that when the Government has done that they will have done a good day's work for Ireland.
Comment on this
Like the last speaker, Sir, I am also a newcomer to this House and I am not as familiar with the rules of procedure as I hope to be after I have been here for some time, and therefore I shall endeavour, in the few minutes of the time of the House which I intend to take up, to keep a little more to the point than the last Deputy has done. Perhaps the only relevant remark he made —or perhaps the only relevant portion of his speech—was when he quoted from the figures of the population of this country around about the year 1850 or so, and then compared the figures of that period with the figures of the population to-day. Perhaps he was relevant, and I think that he was in this respect at least: because he must have introduced into the minds of all here that word that stands out as a nightmare to all of us in this country, namely, the word "famine." In that respect I think he was relevant, because it is on the subject of famine in this country that this motion is being debated here to-day.
Another remark which I should like to make is, that this motion has been received by the Minister, who has already spoken, and by the members of his Party who supported him, in a way which, I think, does great discredit to men who come here to represent the people of this country. Leave this House and go down to any part of the country, and do not we all know and realise as sensible men that the only thing that matters and the only thing that is spoken about in this country at the present time is the cost of living? I say that we owe it as a duty to our constituents—to the people who sent us here—to treat such a motion with the respect it is entitled to get. After this debate had been very eloquently opened by the proposer and seconder of the motion a few weeks ago, I sat here and listened to the speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in reply. May I say, without offence to this House or to anybody in this House, that I have watched the Minister for Industry and Commerce operating there on the Government Benches from time to time, and may I pay tribute to him as being, undoubtedly, a hard-working man—a man who comes into this House full of figures and facts—but I say that the question of the standard of living in this country is not going to be decided on the end of a slide-rule or on figures made with logarithms. I was informed by one of the Deputies sitting in this House that anything to which the Minister for Industry and Commerce referred could be established by some book published in his Department. The other day I received a copy of the book to which the last Deputy referred, namely, the Statistical Abstract. That is a book issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce. I spent—I will not say an enjoyable evening—but an enlightening evening reading that book from cover to cover, and as a result of my reading of that book, I would invite Deputies to peruse it and see what is contained in it. It covers a period, roughly speaking, of the last four or five years, and no matter what you look at, whether it be fisheries or any other department of our trade, it will be seen that there has been a steady decline in the years between 1932 and 1936. I looked through that book in an effort to find some figure that would give me a glimmer of a hope to show that this country is not going down the banks, and I could not find anything to justify that hope. Every single figure was reduced during that period. Now, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when he was going to refer to certain figures the other day, said that they were incontrovertible. He did not refer to a great number of other figures in that book, and he did not tell us that he was going to pass them by—as he was entitled to pass them. He got up and quoted the first sentence of the motion, to the effect that the Dáil deplores the lowering of the standard of living of the community, and then he stopped there, and asked us not to pass the motion; but he should have continued reading to the end of the sentence. What he said, first of all, was that we on this side of the House, or on any side of the House, who are going to support this motion, would have to show that the standard of living of the people in this country, in fact, had been lowered; and he went on to prove that, instead of being lowered, the standard of living, in fact, had been raised. In support of his argument he instanced, first of all, that there was more drink sold in this country to-day than was sold some years ago.
Does anyone think for one moment that, because the consumption of alcohol has increased in this country the standard of living has been increased? I think it is hardly necessary for me to dwell on that. However, the Minister referred to another matter, to which Deputy Gorey has referred, and that is the sale of motor cars. Does the Minister realise that, in the last few years, there has been put on the market here a new and cheap type of motor car, and does he also realise the great spread of the hire purchase system? That is what is responsible for the increase in the use of motor cars— motor cars not yet paid for, but which are being paid for in monthly instalments. I hope I am not offending anybody here in saying that, because I admit that I am the owner of a motor car myself for which I pay by monthly instalments. My point is that these two cases were given of the increase in the consumption of drink and the use of motor cars, and that the Minister went on to show by that that the standard of living had increased. It has been said that you can prove anything by figures. I see that the Deputy opposite nods his head, and I am sure he does that because he hopes that he will prove the same thing to me later on. However, I suggest to the Minister and to other members on the Fianna Fáil Benches and to Deputy Hugo Flinn that they should go down to their constituencies with all this mass of figures—all of which can be verified in documents produced—that they should go down as ordinary Deputies representing their constituencies, and go up the lanes of this country and to the places where the farmers and agricultural labourers live—far away from the main road—to the places where the bulk of the population of this country lives, and where they work and toil—and put it to them whether or not the standard of living has risen. I suggest that they go there with these figures and say to them: "The standard of living has risen; look how much drink is sold in Dublin and how many clerks and inspectors have motor cars." That is where the real pulse of this country is to be felt, and that is the place where the people do not base their decisions on figures, but on the real facts that count. Furthermore, I suggest that the whole Fianna Fáil Party should get themselves on to the deck of the Liverpool, the Glasgow, or the Rosslare boat and tell the unfortunate boys and girls, sons of decent people in this country, people who want to work, and who are leaving for England—the arch-enemy, as our friend opposite has told us—"Do not go away; not only will we give you a good job, but we will put you back in your homes with an increased standard of living."
That is the real test of what this motion means. We are not going to be blinded by figures produced in this House. This motion means that the standard of living has been lowered by the actions and activities of the Government in their policy during the past few years. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and many Deputies are so obsessed with the idea of proving that the standard of living had not been reduced that they entirely neglected to deal with the latter part of the motion as to the cause. They might, at least, for the purpose of debate have admitted that the standard of living had in some sense decreased. I must say that there was one, if I may say so, glorious exception in this debate to the attitude adopted towards this matter by the members of the Government, and that was the speech, which I listened to with real pleasure, of Deputy O'Reilly on the last day on which this debate took place. The Deputy very candidly admitted, not perhaps that the standard of living had in fact decreased, but that the cost of living had gone up. In so far as there was any real contribution to this debate and any real desire on the part of any member of the Government Party to produce something that would, at all events, send a message of hope to the people at the present time, I think that did very fairly come from the lips of Deputy O'Reilly.
Other Deputies who spoke were led away by figures. There was Deputy Moore, who addressed us on the subject of the plight of Canada. He quoted from a very well-known geographical writer and he got into difficulties over the question of the failure of the crop, I think it was in the State of Manitoba, in Canada. He was naturally in very great difficulties because that same gentleman who wrote that article is a very well-known authority, and he also wrote an article in a paper known as the National Geographical Magazine. I regret to say that I was unable to find that magazine, but I will put anyone who likes on the track of it afterwards. The tenour of the remarks of this gentleman, who was quoted at length by Deputy Moore, in this article in the Geographical Magazine was that the failure of the crops in the Middle West of North America was due to the fact that, year after year crops had been taken out of the soil without the necessary manure to go back into it in order to create a state of affairs when crops may be taken off the soil at different periods, letting it rest from time to time, and getting the benefit of the application of manure.
The policy of the Government at the present time is to take away from this country all the benefits which it should have, by disregarding the real prominence and importance of that industry in the economic life of the country. I do not blame the Government a bit for having introduced this policy. I do not blame them as a Government or as a Party for having introduced it, because the history of their association with this House is such that when, having been in opposition, they came to form a Government, they realised that they owed a duty to this country and to the people who live in this country to govern the country. They realised in their hearts, with all the importance of government thrown on their shoulders, and all the responsibility that that entails, that the only sensible and sane thing to do was to follow the policy that until then had been carried on by the Government which they displaced. The suggestion I make, and I think it is true, is that they said to themselves: "If we carry on this same policy what will the people of the country say—`There is no difference; we were wrong'." Then they sat down and said: "What are we going to do? We will have to invent something different, something, at all events, that has proved useful and good so far as this country is concerned," and they invented the new economic policy which we have all heard of and which is known as the new industrial policy. When members opposite say that this debate was got up for the sole purpose of having a tilt at Irish industry, they should look at the members on these benches here, the great majority of whom are in some way or another engaged in the greatest industry that this country ever had, that this country has to-day, and that this country will ever have, namely, the agricultural industry.
The last Deputy spoke with force and vehemence on the subject of land for the people, etc. What does land for the people mean except the cultivation of the land and the continuation of this great industry of agriculture? If Deputies go to any encyclopædia, whether English or foreign, and look up there some description of the Irish Free State—I do not care whether it was issued in 1870, 1890, 1915 or 1923— they will always see, "Industry—agriculture" under the heading of this country. They will see that also under the heading of other countries in an English encyclopædia, but if they go to a foreign encyclopaedia they will see exactly the same thing in reference to this country. It is no good trying to disguise the fact that this country can suffer perhaps for five years or six years under this industrial plan, but sooner or later—and I think the later has arrived now—the Government policy will have been proved to be wrong.
I do not want to suggest that any Deputy has supported any policy, or that the Government has put forward any policy for the purpose of deliberately injuring the livelihood of the people or the future economic wealth of the country. But I do suggest that, as amateurs, they were wrong, and I suggest to them now, in 1937, that they should acknowledge that they were wrong and, like honest men and patriotic citizens, come forward now, even at the last hour, and admit the error of their ways. The writing is on the wall in many different counties in this country. It is only necessary to read the daily Press to see that a revolt is taking place amongst the members of the farming community. That revolt is not brought about by the activities of any political Party or any group of politicians. It has occurred in such widely different counties as Wicklow, Limerick, Tipperary and Clare. It is not a revolt that was brought about by any political activity on anybody's part. It is a revolt that has occurred of itself, like a volcano bubbling up, as a result of the crushing burdens imposed on the people of this country and as a result of the lowering of the standard of living. I said that I was not going to take up much of the time of the House, and I do not intend to do so. May I impress upon Deputies that I come into this House with an open mind on all subjects, believing that everyone has come here to do the best he can to represent his constituents and to achieve what this country desires and what Deputies know this country needs. I know that it is difficult for a Party such as the Fianna Fáil Party to realise, as they must when they open their papers, that they no longer enjoy the confidence of the people of this country. I know it is difficult, but there is a greater and a wiser thing, if I may say so, that they might do, and that is to accept the motion and meet it in the spirit in which it has been offered.
Comment on this
I have listened for the last few weeks to a debate which I had been previously listening to for many months. I have listened to speeches delivered upon this motion which, word for word, have been delivered on half a dozen other motions in this House. I have listened to speeches every one of which will be re-delivered on half a dozen motions which still are on the Order Paper. Private members' motions apparently have sunk to the level in which they are so framed, and so spoken to, that any person, without special preparation of any kind, without even a knowledge of the wording of the motion before the House, can come in here and deliver a speech. Everybody here practically has read the motion to the House and has complained bitterly that no one else has touched on the motion. At any rate, that charge cannot be levelled with any fairness against the Minister for Industry and Commerce. If there has been one speech which attempted to be relevant, which attempted to come up to the issue, which attempted to induce and help members of the House to come to the issue, it has been the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I have the report of the speech here before me, and frankly I do not know of any better speech or any better or more relevant way to speak upon this subject, than the actual lines laid down there.
I would like some Deputy who follows to get out of this area of generality and tell us where the Minister for Industry and Commerce failed to attempt to be relevant. Now, I am only taking that as an example, because I am not going to suggest for one single moment that everybody who followed on this side has been equally relevant. It would have been impossible for them to be so and to pay any respect whatever to the speeches which had previously been delivered. It is one of the reasonable courtesies of debate that, in following a speaker, one shall pay some attention to what he said, shall attempt to meet his arguments, shall attempt to follow somewhat in his footsteps; and I, frankly, have failed—and I have sat here and listened with a considerable amount of interest and some attention—to see any Deputy on the other side even making an attempt to accept the invitation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister for Industry and Commerce pointed out to the House that this motion consisted of three parts—(1) a declaration that the standard of living had been lowered; (2) that it had been lowered by the imposition of Government taxes, levies and duties; and (3) a demand that all such impositions should be forthwith abolished. These were the three relevant portions of the motion, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce asked anyone to prove that the standard of living had been lowered.
Comment on this
When the Deputy becomes a little older he will refuse to help me by interrupting. It was not for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, it was for those who were responsible for this motion, to prove that the standard of living had been lowered.
Comment on this
I most certainly am not going to read the Deputy's speech. I heard the whole of the Deputies' speeches, and they made no attempt whatever to prove anything of the kind. What they all said was: "Everybody knows; Everybody says," but no one came down to the point of showing that the standard of living was in fact reduced. The standard of living is not, in fact, reduced, and no member of this House has yet been able to contest the actual facts, statements and figures, and the references to these facts, given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I was very hopeful that the Deputy who spoke a few moments ago was going to attempt to put his feet in the footprints of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and show that the Minister was wrong. He started out on drink and then went on to motor cars. Then he dropped the question like a hot potato.
Now, I have had the experience of attempting to check up on statistics. Some years ago I was anxious to get, if possible, a moving picture of the progress of the effects of the economic war and other changes on local conditions in this country. I was anxious, if it was possible, to trace through, say, the Western counties and the Eastern counties, through the counties of the mountainy men, through the meads and grazing districts, through the milk-producing and other counties, to see if I could get year by year the effect of a certain movement. For that reason I got together a series of statistics of various kinds which in our opinion would indicate a change in the economic condition. I do not need at the moment to go into those particular facts. Some day I hope to be able to give that picture to the House. It included, for instance, the monthly turnovers of the banks in each of the counties. It included a whole lot of statistics of one kind or another that were intended to show the effect, and eventually we got from them some sort of a picture. But what I am getting at for the moment is this, that we went back afterwards to see if we could find one statistic in the whole of the indices which were used that would closely approximate to the average result given by all the indices. In other words, was there any common statistic which could be regarded as an indication?
Now, to my amazement and somewhat to my discontent, I found that the indication which was ridiculed by Deputy Esmonde, the indication of the increase or the relativity of decrease in the consumption of alcohol, was, on the whole, the most representative index. Now, taking the last few years, as the House knows, that was a period in which there has been no large variation, no very significant or strong variation upward, in the consumption of drink. On the whole, over a period of ten years or fifteen years, the record of this country in the reduced consumption of drink is amazingly satisfactory to everyone except those who have to collect revenue from it for the purpose of running the country, but I give it to you now purely and simply as the result of a student's examination of the facts, that, other things being equal, the increase or decrease in the consumption of alcohol in the form in which it is commonly used—I am not now speaking of high-priced wines or anything of that kind—is, in fact, a very fair and accurate index to the variations in conditions in different periods and in different areas. It is not, in my opinion, right—no student would regard it as right—to treat as ridiculous the variation in the consumption of alcohol in the popular form as an indication of variation in the condition of prosperity.
In the same way, you can take the consumption of such a thing as tobacco. There are individual people to whom tobacco is a necessity. There are people to whose family the consumption of tobacco is of very great interest. I know one case in which a man, for Lenten purposes, gave up the consumption of tobacco, and his whole family went into petition in the interests of the comfort of their homes that he should abandon that particular form of abstinence. While there are certain cases in which it is a necessity, in the vast majority of cases it is a luxury. The consumption of tobacco, widely spread as it is over all the community, is an indication that there is some reserve in the possession of common people for the purpose of enjoyment. I could go through, in the same way, the number of indications given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I do not propose to do so. It is not my business. It is the business of someone in the Opposition to follow him step by step, and show, one by one, that the indications which he gave to rebut the statement that the standard of living has fallen do not carry that significance. No member of the Opposition—in view of the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has, in that precise and detailed manner, faced up to the first issue which was raised—is entitled to say that the Government have ignored or have disregarded the essence of this discussion, or have failed to meet the issues which were raised.
The second issue is that whatever falling off there has been, real or imaginary, in the standard of living, has been caused by taxes, levies, duties and impositions on foodstuffs and other necessities of life imposed by this Government. It has been said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce denied that the cost of living had risen. He did not deny anything of the kind. If Deputies will look at column 231 of the Official Debates of 6th October, they will find that statements of that kind are nonsense. "There is a tide in the affairs of men," and there is a tide in the affairs of the prices of commodities. That tide reached a peak in 1929. It fell again, and it has been rising now for about a year. It has been rising very steeply in this year. It has, apparently, in the last few months, again reached a peak and begun to fall. Now, in so far as there is that universal and international tendency to variation in prices, no Government can be attacked—can properly and reasonably be attacked— because that trend in world prices is evidenced in the actual prices internal to that country. I think everyone will concede that proposition without hesitation. At least, no reasonable man could deny it. The only question which does arise—and here is a matter on which you can begin to get at a Government—is that, if it can be shown in any country that the prices of the necessities and essentials of life have in that country risen more than they have risen in the international market, then the onus of proof may be put upon the Government to show, first, that they are not directly responsible for that variation; and secondly, that there is no countervailing advantage which would meet that difference.
Now, that is one way in which the Opposition could tackle the proposition. I am deliberately inviting the Opposition to tackle the proposition in that way. If they can do that, then they are putting the onus of proof upon this Government. But, unless and until they do, unless and until they come down to hard, clean, provable facts of that kind, all sorts of vague statements will carry them nowhere. All sorts of vague statements, eloquent or vehement as the last Deputy who spoke of said, all sorts of statements that everybody knows, will carry them nowhere. It is like the man who gets up and says, "I am not going to make a political speech." We all know what kind of a speech he will make. Or it is like the man who says, "I am not going to detain you long." We all know how long he is going to detain us. Or it may be the man who starts off reading the subject-matter of the discussion. We all know how far away from the subject-matter of the discussion he is going to keep.
Comment on this
That is one of the reasons why I carefully avoided reading the subject-matter of the discussion.
Comment on this
Shakespeare? We have a greater poet in this House than Shakespeare; one certainly whose works I have read with very great pleasure and profit.
Comment on this
I would have to sing them, I am afraid. Coming back now to one of the actual speeches which were delivered here, I will take the speech of Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon started off with that nice courtesy, that meticulous courtesy, which distinguishes him in matters of this kind, by speaking of the contribution of the Minister for Industry and Commerce as a brazen-faced performance.
Comment on this
Deputy Flinn would never be guilty of saying anything like that.
Comment on this
No. The extraordinary part about this Deputy is the amazing and almost unbelievable restraint which he exercises over his language. If I were to allow myself to use the kind of language which is used by some Deputies opposite, it would be regarded as amazing.
Comment on this
Let us hope that the Deputy never takes off the brakes. We had a couple of peculiar samples.
Comment on this
I defy any Deputy to quote any speech of mine in which there was strong language of any kind. A lot of people have tried to do so and they came back and said: "You meant a lot more than you said."
Comment on this
Righto. A brazen-faced performance—that is the description by Deputy Dillon of the contribution of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who meticulously followed this resolution. Fraudulent misrepresentation—that was the nice, courteous, meticulously courteous, expression by Deputy Dillon in relation to a speech in which the Minister not merely gave facts, out gave the references and authorities of those facts and asked that anyone should check up against fraudulent misrepresentation. Those who listened to him were the Minister's gulls. I believe the man who did not like strong language has left that Party. But then the Deputy proceeded and, with that delightful humour, expressed again with the meticulous courtesy which makes his contributions to this debate so valuable to those who want to learn what to avoid in speech, he went on to say that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had started a glorious factory in Naas which, while it lasted, smelled beautifully.
That is really an example of the sense of responsibility and the sense of courtesy and dignity of debate that Deputy Dillon thought should introduce a motion of this kind, which deplores the lowering of the standard of living, which charges the Government with responsibility for it, and then goes on to demand that every tariff, levy, duty and like imposition on foodstuffs and other necessities of life in this country shall forthwith be abolished. What of the brazen-faced performance of those who have refused to tell us one single one of all the levies, taxes, impositions and the like on foodstuffs which they want taken off? We had an example here the other night from Deputy Martin Corry, who attempted to deal with a few of them. He mentioned a couple of tariffed industries which exist, in virtue of levies, taxes and impositions, in the constituencies of Deputies opposite. But none of those taxes, levies or impositions was to be removed. As far as I can gather the position, it is that everybody wants every levy, tax and like imposition which is put upon anything, the putting on of which does not benefit himself or his own constituents, to be abolished. But no one has yet come down except Deputy Brennan, who hesitated for a moment on the fact that £8,000 had been raised upon shovels and other instruments of agriculture. Does Deputy Esmonde want the tax taken off shovels and agricultural implements?
Is there any particular proposal the removal of which any Deputy on the other side of the House is prepared to advocate which some other Deputy on his own benches will not get up and say must not be taken off on any account whatsoever? I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is entitled to take the dictionary meaning of this term, that every tax, every imposition and every tariff is to be removed. And he is entitled to demand that those who formulated that resolution shall define its terms and shall give us a list of the industries which are now tariffed which are to disappear, or the particular commodities which to-day are buttressed, and the particular impositions of one kind or another that have to go. It is not fair of those who accused the Minister for Industry and Commerce of ignoring this motion that they themselves shall ignore it to the extent of failing to put it in a form in which it can be reasonably debated.
For instance, if we had a list setting out that the tax should come off tobacco, should come off silk stockings, should come off boots, should come off flour or should come off imports of bolts and nails, then the House would be in a position, with a statistical abstract before them and such other figures as the Minister may have, with returns of unemployment, returns of home assistance, the geographical distribution of the industries which are concerned, with a knowledge of the number of people employed and the wages paid to them, to come down to brass tacks and say: "Yes, that particular tariff is not producing the results which the House and the country hoped for, and it should go," or "This particular tax, this particular imposition, is producing results such as we hoped for, and it is to be retained." But when we get the universal motion that every single one of them should go, what are we to do? It seems to me that the first thing we would have to do would be to find other means of raising the particular revenue which they produce. I personally agree that in a period of what one might call high tariff taxation there should be a review of all the taxes which have been imposed and the results of them traced. I remember when the previous Government was introducing what they called experimental tariffs. It took them, I think, three and a half years to decide that there would be a tariff on rosary beads. That industry employed, I think, about ten people. It took them another couple of years to decide whether or not there would be a tariff on woollens, and that just synchronised with a Budget which required the money. There were various other small tariffs of that kind, for instance, the tariff on boots. The one thing in which I did agree with the previous Government in relation to those tariffs was the idea of treating them as experimental. I mean by that quite apart from the question of whether a high or low tariff policy was good, there was something definitely to be said for regarding the tariff before it was imposed as something to be carefully studied, and after it was imposed as something to be carefully watched. After these tariffs had been in operation for a bit I made inquiries. I went to the Department of Industry and Commerce. It was a somewhat moribund, cobwebbed, fly-covered Department at that time. It was the Department in which some very good men struggled with an atmosphere which would have been sufficient to break the hearts of any group of men. I asked them for the results over a period of years of those experimental tariffs. I asked what they had found out of those tariffs, and how they had traced the effect upon the community, and whether the cost of those particular goods had risen over and above what would be normally allowable, due to the variation of the cycle of trade and the price of raw material. I went there in an atmosphere of faith and hope.
Comment on this
Also charity, as it turned out, because I was told that nothing had been done to attempt to follow out and trace the result of the extremely limited number of tariffs, some of which had taken two or three years to put on.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary state in what year he was told that?
Comment on this
I could not say now. I will look it up later on, but I think it was somewhere about 1929.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary was told there was no information available?
Comment on this
No. I was told that no information showing the effect of these tariffs was available.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary would probably get that information in the library downstairs.
Comment on this
No; there was one person who made an attempt to help them. That person was myself when I brought them commodities and got them to analyse those commodities. All those commodities were torn down to their ultimate primal components in order that the cost of them could be traced. Now, if that proved above the capacity of the Department of Industry and Commerce when they were dealing with only two or three tariffs for four or five years, surely it is a much more difficult task where there are, as has been said in this debate, hundreds of these tariffs. But the mere fact that there are hundreds of these tariffs will not, in my opinion, relieve the Government of this country of the responsibility some time, and at some early date, of attempting to investigate, in relation to a considerable number of them, what exactly has been the effect of the tariffs.
Comment on this
Oh, no; there are no cobwebs in that Department now. That is the most active and vital Department of the State now. There is no question that the staff in the Department of Industry and Commerce are working to-day and that they have something to work at. I am putting this to the House as reasonably-minded men, as a jury sitting on the actual economic and social conditions engendered and produced by a series of industries which are to-day employing somewhere about 60,000 men—at any rate, 60,000 people. What knowledge have Deputies opposite which enables them to pass a sentence of death now and by this motion on all those industries? What knowledge have Deputies opposite of the bootmaking industry, the flour industry, the silk industry, the ready-made clothing industry, the woollen industry, the nuts and bolts industry, and all these other industries which enables them to say now that in a single individual one of the industries there should be a withdrawal of the protection under which they have grown up, that they should be condemned to death, and that the people who are employed in them shall be put out? I am putting that question in relation to any single one industry. Is there any man in this House who knows a particular industry and knows from his own knowledge of that industry that it is an industry that should be destroyed? Can any Deputy say that the extra people now employed in that particular industry should, for the benefit of the State, be put out of employment? Will any Deputy opposite say of any particular industry that it should for the benefit of the State be destroyed? No. That would be coming down to the particular. It is far easier to say in this motion that all duties, levies and other impositions on foodstuffs and other necessaries of life should forthwith be abolished. It is far easier to say that all these things should go.
But there is not a single Deputy here who is prepared to say that the flour industry should be abolished or that the boot trade should be abolished; that the nut and bolt industry should be abolished; that the manufacture of motor cars, motor tyres and lubricating oil should be abolished—not a man is prepared to say that any one of these industries should be abolished, but the whole body—every single one of them—are prepared to say that they should all be abolished. We shall go a bit further. If they are not prepared to condemn any one of these industries to death, which one of them will they reprieve except one in their own constituency? Am I wrong in saying that that means the removal of all the taxes and all the levies and all the impositions and all the protections of all the industries engaged in food production or the production of other necessaries of life? If I am wrong, in what particular am I wrong? Name me one industry you intend to leave here, any one of you, outside an industry in your own constituency. And we are ignoring the motion! It does seem rather difficult——
Comment on this
You want that abolished? Out of 60,000 men employed, the whole Fine Gael Party is prepared to take responsibility for disemploying two who are not in the Deputy's constituency.
Comment on this
Are we to take it that we have come down to facts, that the Fine Gael Party are standing over the fact that there shall be no impositions, no tariffs, no protections for anything in relation to agriculture—that everything in that connection is to come in free?
Comment on this
Anything but the motion. I shall come to that later, not because it is in the motion, but because the speakers who have been amusing themselves in relation to this motion were driven to dealing with the economic war. What I am concerned with is to find out the meaning, in the mind of the Opposition, of this motion—that all tariffs, levies, duties and like impositions on foodstuffs shall be removed. Are Fine Gael in favour of taking them all off? Are they in favour of retaining some of them? What are they in favour of retaining? What are they prepared to remove? Whose sins shall you forgive and whose sins shall you retain?
Comment on this
I am going to start in and make a note of all the things apart from this motion I am asked to talk about, and afterwards I shall try to deal with them.
Comment on this
You are talking about things that are not in the motion. People do not eat nuts and bolts.
Comment on this
"Necessaries of life." I should like to see Deputy Esmonde coming along in that monthly-instalment motor car of his without any nuts or bolts.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not a motor car. He is not like a Minister or Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not even allow a Deputy of his own Party to tell us that he possesses a motor car. Deputy Esmonde told us that he was coming into the possession of a motor car on the instalment plan and the Deputy says that, for the purpose of that motor car, nuts and bolts are not necessary.
Comment on this
Since the nuts and bolts have come in and since they are not necessaries of life, we shall go back to Deputy Esmonde for a moment. Deputy Esmonde made the remarkable statement that people could not live on slide rules and logarithms. The real meaning he had behind that was that all statistics that did not suit him were lies. In other words, it was no use for the Minister for Industry and Commerce to attempt to prove that the standard of living had not fallen, because if the Minister for Industry and Commerce used figures to prove that, then the proof was no good. You cannot prove things by slide rules or logarithms. In other words, you cannot prove by statistics, you cannot prove by observed and attested facts. The only way that you can prove anything is by somebody coming along and saying: "Everybody knows." If that be so, what sort of impudence did Deputy Brennan show in actually taking a book of statistics and quoting from it? So far as I know, the Minister for Industry and Commerce did nothing but quote statistics and give the reference to them. According to Deputy Esmonde, he must not do anything of the kind. Are we, or are we not, to use statistics? Are we, or are we not, to use facts; or are we simply to deal with the wild imaginings of people? Are we going to rule statistics and calculations out of our discussion?
Now, we shall take Deputy Brennan. Deputy Brennan speaks of "the Minister's bluff." Is it bluff that in the 23 industries 31,000 more men are employed? Is it bluff for the Minister to state that 60,000 or 70,000 of a total are employed in these industries? Is it bluff that the capacity of this State to maintain a population is increased by the fact that 31,000 additional persons are statistically proved and shown to be engaged in these industries?
Comment on this
At present there are 15,000 fewer persons applying for unemployment assistance than there were at this time last year.
Comment on this
I shall deal with that also. That is one of the matters I shall refer to the appendix.
Comment on this
Somebody has told us that something like 250,000 went out under another régime, but then, they did not go because of poverty. Deputy Cosgrave will tell you why they went—they went to see their friends. The Deputy was not here. He has not listened to his great leader. They are not going now for poverty.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy mind listening to me for a couple of minutes? He can then give me some more subject-matter on which to speak. They are not leaving for poverty now, according to the authority of the Deputy's front bench.
Comment on this
That is not the explanation either—try another. The explanation given by Deputy Dillon was that they could not get the really nice cloths they wanted to make their evening dresses. I am not saying that is true; I am saying that Deputy Dillon is talking through his hat, as usual.