We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Standard of Living—Abolition of Duties on Foodstuffs—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 143–293 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Ah!

Comment on this

That is exactly the expression, that is exactly the tone, and that is exactly the answer that ought to be given to Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

They would not know what an evening dress is.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce in his remarks said:—

"I do not contest, and no one would be so foolish as to contest, that the cost of living has increased since 1934. It has definitely. In 1932-33 the cost of living fell. The fall was stopped in 1934, and since then there has been quite a substantial rise. The motion, however, contends that the rise in the cost of living is due to Government action."

Then he goes on to ask somebody to show the connection, and, again, nobody does. General statements are so much easier to make and so much more difficult to be tied down.

Deputy Dillon, at one point in his speech, trembled for a moment on a sense of responsibility. He was evidently thinking of a speech delivered in the British House of Commons early in the Abyssinian crisis, when the British Foreign Minister said that the position was so delicate that a word might precipitate a disaster, and, imagining himself for a moment in the position of a person of importance, a person whose saying or unsaying might possibly start an avalanche, he said that the word might precipitate trouble and for that reason, he hesitated to say anything which would disturb the financial position. He immediately went on to say: "The Minister, next year, will try to borrow money and he will not get sixpence." Now, there is the sense of responsibility of the man who tells you that a word may precipitate trouble. Then he goes on to say that the country is in a deep depression and, further on, he says: "Five years later, we will have a broken and destroyed land." That is the man with a sense of responsibility who does not want to say or do anything which would disturb the position. I think it was Deputy McGovern who told us that there was not a single industry in this country that could support itself.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary quote Deputy McGovern?

Comment on this

I am quoting. He said they were all leaning up against one another and that when one collapsed, they would all fall, and there again, you have the position where you must not do or say anything which will precipitate trouble. Deputy Dillon gets back on the subject and says: "There are signs of incipient bankruptcy." That you have signs of incipient bankruptcy in 1937 is an amazing improvement, an unbelievable improvement, on the conditions which, we were told, did in fact exist in 1932. In 1932, it was not incipient bankruptcy. It was not a question of five years after 1937 having a bankrupt and destroyed people; it was not that in 1937 no industry could support itself; that they were all leaning up against one another waiting to fall. What was the condition according to Fine Gael in 1932? We were bankrupt already.

Comment on this

What were the promises of Fianna Fáil before the 1932 election?

Comment on this

And what did Gladstone say in 1624?

Comment on this

Gladstone was not alive in 1624.

Comment on this

In 1932, we were told the country was bankrupt. Deputy Gorey in this House told us that, in September of 1932, there would be 400,000 cattle lying dead in the fields. 400,000 of them were going to die to make a holocaust for Deputy Gorey— a really gory holocaust.

Comment on this

You slaughtered them, too.

Comment on this

Evidently the Deputy has not been using a slide rule or logarithms; he has been using his imagination on his statistics. What I want to point out to the House is: Tell me the worst story your diseased imaginations could contrive of the conditions, hopes and prospects of this country and I will tell you that you are five years late compared with your colleagues who told us that those conditions had already existed five years ago. Five years ago, Fine Gael was telling our opponent in the economic war that he had already completely won; that we were on our knees; that we were crying out. They were saying: "Keep up the pressure and they will break," and when they did not break, "put on more pressure and they will break." The pressure went on and on and on, and the country did not break, and eventually we reached a condition in which the British Minister for Agriculture in the House of Commons said that he had failed completely, even for the interest of his own agricultural policy, in the efforts he had made. Let us quote Mr. Baldwin. Mr. Baldwin said:

"We have put on all the taxes we possibly could put upon beef and we have not been able to raise the price in the market."

What really happened was that the economic war started at a moment of acute agricultural depression, and, in spite of the piling up of British taxes, of the addition that would normally have been made to the cost of the commodities imported, and of the tariffs imposed, the price of beef fell and fell and could not be kept up until the British had, in addition to their tariffs, to put on—not for the purpose of the economic war and not for the purpose of recovery of any pretended debt, but purely and simply for the purposes of their own agriculture—quotas to buttress the failure of their efforts.

Comment on this

Who may we thank for the quotas but the policy of Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to know who may be thanked for that. The authority is the Minister for Agriculture in England, Mr. Elliott. He stated that quotas were not being imposed for the purposes of the economic war, but purely and simply as part of their agricultural policy. If the Deputy challenges that statement I will give the actual words later.

Comment on this

What about Canada?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like to introduce some other stars, Mercury, Neptune, or the Milky Way?

Comment on this

Where are the alternative markets you promised?

Comment on this

They will be in the appendices which I am going to put in at the end when I have availed of the opportunity to deal with the subject matter supposed to be discussed here. I am inclined to think that Deputies will be asking me—as Deputies on other occasions have asked—to deal with other matters, and when I did so they got up and asked to have me ruled out of order.

Comment on this

You cannot deal with them because you have not got them.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Dillon, who is not one to precipitate anything, went on to slither down the slope. Here is one of a series of extracts from Deputy Dillon:

Every country is booming in an unparalleled way, riding high, wide and handsome on a magnificent wave of prosperity, except this country.

Is that true? He went on to state that for 20 years he was prepared to guarantee peace in Europe. Is there anyone who will guarantee it for ten days? Deputy Brennan went on to say: "Let us work simply and solely on a peace policy." The Deputy was dealing with the question whether or not any of these agricultural impositions should be put on flour. He went on to ask: "Why do we want wheat? Why do we want flour?" Because of the fear of war. Deputy Brennan with that sense of responsibility which distinguishes the Rotary Club opposite, said that we must bank on a peace policy for 20 years. Is there any other senior statesman in Europe who is prepared in relation to any portion of the policy to his country to bank upon a peace policy for 20 years? We have the advice of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Brennan that this country has to ignore everything, and that in spite of the fact that a Deputy on the opposite benches to-day was asking the Minister for Defence to take precautions against gas attacks. Deputy Dillon has a very high respect for his country. He told us that 90 per cent. of the active, dignified, hard-working fellows had already gone out of the country.

I am not inventing that statement. These were his words. That is the sense of responsibility of the man who would not precipitate anything, who thinks, because this country has not fallen for flapdoodle, that 90 per cent. of the good men have gone away. Is Fine Gael defending that statement? Is it defending the statement that for 20 years we will have peace in Europe, and that no precautions of any kind are to be taken? Is that Party defending anything else in the motion? They are not prepared to name a single industry which they are prepared to have destroyed by the withdrawal of tariffs. They are not prepared to defend any portion of the motion.

Do they defend the statement of Deputy Dillon, that we have reached this level, that 90 per cent. of the active, dignified, hard-working fellows have gone? Nobody defends that. We will move to another statement of this statesman. The Deputy stated that they got a lot of political kudos out of this. Political kudos is capable of gradual accumulation, and a reserve of political kudos can be tested at odd times statistically. Where is the evidence that Fine Gael is collecting political kudos? I do not think that Deputy Dillon knows what the people of the country are thinking of his Party. His Party ought, by this time, to know what the country thinks of their leader, Deputy Dillon. I know that the biggest kudos they will get will be when he follows three or four of their previous leaders that we have seen go into the discard. Then Deputy Dillon came to the economic war. Here again we have one of these amazingly, almost unbelievably valuable contributions, one of these things for which the Dáil will live in history. I think one of its chief grounds for the possibility of immortality will be as a footnote to the life and speeches of Deputy Dillon. On column 738 he opened the Humber safe. He pronounces the magic words "Open Sesame," or gives the "high sign." I think it is "Abracadabra," one of Kipling's books that states the secret hid underneath the pyramid was that some contractor did Cheops out to save millions. Deputy Dillon possesses a secret. There is a very beautiful poem which I might be allowed to recite for the House, as it rather typifies my attitude of mind towards this great secret.

" As if within the sylvan centre of the land

There lay a nameless lake no sail had ever fanned;

As if within that lake a wooded islet grew;

As if within that isle a stream in silence flowed.

As if within a glen that stream, kept ever green,

A flower breathed forth;

As if within that flower a drop of dew reposed—

So many times removed, so secret, and so safe,

So lone and all improved."

That is the secret of how to end the economic war with advantage to Ireland.

Comment on this

This is good stuff for men working three days a week.

Comment on this

That secret was possessed and was kept up to the present, but to-day we had another exposition. On column 738 the Deputy said that the economic war must be abandoned, and that steps must be taken now to restore the national economy. That is what is called a loud, large phrase.

Comment on this

What did the Minister for Industry and Commerce say?

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that this is a difficult problem, but Deputy Dillon comes along and says that this can be done in one night—not, mind you, in three days. Deputy Cosgrave would have taken three days to do it. This is what Deputy Dillon says:

"There is a formula which can save faces on all sides and, overnight, restore the earning capacity of our people, and thus eliminate the rise in the cost of living and all the other evils that are complained of in this motion."

That is something. This is the formula:

"If the Minister and his colleagues will go to the British Government to-morrow, to the only market where we can raise money to bring down that cost of living, and say to the British Government, `We do not ask you to accept the truth of our contention in this dispute, nor must you ask us to accept the truth of your contention in this dispute.' "

That is the magic formula. What is that magic formula going to do?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Parliamentary Secretary please give the reference.

Comment on this

Column 738 of the 27th of October, 1937.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That was not said with reference to this motion?

Comment on this

It was. I can imagine your amazement. It is from the speech made on the motion by Deputy Dillon. I also am flabbergasted. But there is the formula which, according to Deputy Dillon, "can save faces on all sides and overnight restore the earning capacity of our people, and thus eliminate the rise in the cost of living and all the other evils that are complained of in this motion." His formula is: "We do not ask you to accept the truth of our contention in this dispute, nor must you ask us to accept the truth of your contention in this dispute, nor must you ask us to accept the truth of your contention in this dispute." That is the formula which is going to reduce the cost of living and remove "all the evils complained of in this motion." Deputy Dillon went on to say:

"Therefore, leaving both cases intact, neither side abandoning the attitude that they have taken up, let us acknowledge that there is money between us and that this has got to be settled sooner or later by the sensible method of compromise. On that basis a settlement can be arrived at, and hundreds of thousands of people in this country can be relieved from the unbearable burdens they are at present suffering."

Now, I want the House to analyse that sacred and holy formula, that "open sesame," that blessed word Mesopotamia—that anything you like—that Abracadabra, that magic of Deputy Dillon's, which is going to remove all difficulty. "We do not ask you to accept the truth of our contention in this dispute, nor must you ask us to accept the truth of your contention in this dispute." Does any reasonable person believe that there is anything in that statement which would have any effect whatever? What is the meaning of it? Does it mean that we are to say that there really never was anything in dispute between us? Are we to say that there is no purpose, meaning or reality in the fight which both sides have made, and, if we are not going to say that, what is going to happen after Deputy Dillon has got rid of his formula? The dispute will come up for consideration, and you will be in exactly the same position that you were in before Deputy Dillon invented his formula. We have had this before. We had it from ex-Deputy MacDermot—the same old story that if only we would use some magic words of this character all would be well.

Comment on this

You have abandoned the Republic.

Comment on this

That has got nothing to do with this at all. You might say, let us abandon the Republic, or let us have a monarchy, or Dominion Home Rule, or anything you like——

Comment on this

That is the sore point.

Comment on this

What is the secret underneath this? On what terms are you prepared to negotiate a settlement? Let us have some formula from you. Remember, if we are to treat the Opposition as responsible people—and if we could conceive the possibility that, by any chance, they should be put in the position of being negotiators they would have to be treated as responsible people—then what they had previously said would have to be taken into account. Their great leader, General O'Duffy, said that no Government in this country would ever pay the annuities.

Comment on this

Are they not being paid four times over?

Comment on this

General O'Duffy cannot be right even on that. He said that no Government in this country would ever pay the annuities. If Deputy Dillon goes over with his formula what happens? He says in effect: we do not ask you to accept the truth of our contention in this dispute, namely, that we do not owe you the money; but we will not pay you the money, and on that basis you can settle it overnight. Does anybody believe that? Is it not very extraordinary that we cannot get any answer from the Deputies opposite but irrelevant interruptions? We can get no answer to specific questions. I ask them now: what single tax which is to-day imposed are you prepared to remove? What single imposition are you prepared to have removed, what single industry are you prepared to destroy? What particular industry is increasing the cost of living? Will they say how the Government is responsible, and in what proportion and degree, for the rise in the cost of living? There is not a single answer to these questions. When I go back to the heaven-sent leader, Deputy Dillon, he says that he has got a magic formula. I ask the House to give me any meaning that will attach to it. Again, I get nothing but inarticulate interruptions from the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

Is the Government responsible for the economic war?

Comment on this

According to us, no.

Comment on this

According to the President, yes. He said that his Government fired the first shot.

Comment on this

We still get back to this, that we are in the position that there is only one man in the House who knows the secret as to how all this can be attained without any loss, damage or hurt to any man in the country, and he will not tell us. He simply says that we are to go to the British Government and say that there never has been any dispute between us—that "when you say that we owe you the money we are not going to pay any attention to that; when we say that we do not owe you the money, you are not going to pay any attention to that; when you say that we are going to exact and collect the money to the last penny, we are not going to pay any attention to that; when we say that no Government in this country will ever pay the annuities again, they are not going to pay any attention." And that is going to settle the economic war! That is the statement up to the present. In other words, these Deputies have not got a solution and do not dare to admit that they have not got it, except a solution overnight. What is the solution? I will give way to any Deputy who can tell me what is the solution.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Is the Coal-Cattle Pact a solution of it?

Comment on this

I would not regard it as a solution.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What would you regard it as?

Comment on this

I would regard it as a Coal-Cattle Pact.

Comment on this

A surrender! Give all or give nothing.

Comment on this

It is like all the rest— everybody knows that the cost of living has risen, and that the standard of living has fallen, and, of course, everybody knows how to solve the economic war!

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Except Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Except Fianna Fáil! We do not know how to solve the economic war at the present moment on terms that would be honourable and acceptable to this country, and until we know how that problem can be settled on terms honourable and acceptable to this country, it will not be settled.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Is it honourable with regard to the agricultural policy?

Comment on this

I think that, when the record of this debate is published, it will be very interesting to see the physical record of it, and see what proportion of the time I have been on my feet and what proportion of the time the Deputy has been on his feet.

Comment on this

Loud cheers and lobsters !

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Get on to the subject.

Comment on this

Yes. We will get on to the subject, but, again, what the Deputy means by that is to get on to nothing but the alleged responsibility of this Government for a rise in the cost of living—that the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in connection with this motion, was false—anything but the motion!

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The Deputy says "Hear, hear." At least, we seem to be in agreement.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

The Deputy has been a long way from it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is interrupting all the time. He has been interrupting the whole time: I suppose you did not get "a fair do" over there at all? Well you know that you did.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, Deputy Kelly has helped me very much now, because he gave an interval—not that I object to the interruptions. I hope Deputies will not be astonished if I say that Deputy Brennan then started to discuss the tragedy of executive versus legislative imposition of tariffs. Deputy Brennan discussed that for a considerable period of time, and during the time that he was going on to emphasise that difference I was hoping that, at some time before he finished his speech, he would use that illuminating speech in some such way as would make a coherent whole and that he would use some phrase that would drag the speech within the ambit of a conclusion. Having complained bitterly of the executive imposition of tariffs, he got off that— apparently agreeing with it. I thought, at first, that he was going to take that line again—all the time hoping and praying that something like a consecutive idea would come from what he was saying in connection with this motion. I hoped to hear what the policy of the Fine Gael Party would be, and whether it would be to remove the tariffs which had been imposed by administrative rather than by executive action. However, as every tax imposed by administrative action has been covered by executive action, there does not seem to be very much difference. At any rate, the Deputy evidently found that he could not do very much with regard to that. He then went on to criticise the policy of self-sufficiency, and he pointed out that the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that we must have exports as well. Of course, in his speech, he misrepresented the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That, however, is merely an unconscious habit, I am sure. I do not think it is even deliberate on the other side, in one sense. It has become a custom or a habit, and is almost unconscious. I mean that it has become part of the warp and woof of the political life of their demeanour here—part of the custom and colour of their speaking habit and of the texture of their minds and souls. I want to acquit them of the deliberate action of having anything whatever arising from an intelligent conception of the fact that they are misrepresenting the facts. I am merely pointing out that it has become a habit with them to do it. Deputy Brennan went on to say, in the course of his speech, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that there must be exports in order to raise the standard of living. The Minister said nothing of the kind. He made a perfectly simple, bald and incontrovertible statement: that an increase in exports could raise the standard of living.

Comment on this

According to the statement of one of your Ministers at one time, it could not. That was some years ago.

Comment on this

I think that that statement is almost too indefinite, even for a Fine Gael interrupter.

Comment on this

Well, we could give it to you.

Comment on this

The present time is the present time.

Comment on this

The suggestion is that this country is suffering because the total of its international trade has been reduced. A lot of people think that the only wealth of a country is its international trade. That is not true. International trade can be part of the wealth of a country, but it can quite easily be part merely of the poverty of a country.

Comment on this

I am glad you are realising that now.

Comment on this

You have the ordinary case of imports and exports, and we are now gradually getting back to a portion of Deputy Dillon's speech— which lasted for some columns—in which we analysed the causes, and so on, of the adverse trade balance. The exports of a country, apparently, are what everybody wants to keep up, and you speak of an adverse balance of trade when your imports are greater than your exports. Why that is so, I have never been able to understand. At no time, either as a member of the Government or when I was in opposition, have I accepted that doctrine of the adverse trade balance. The exports of a country are the payments they make. They are their expenses. The imports of a country are its income, and a country that has permanently a favourable trade balance, as the saying is, would be a country which, undoubtedly, would be bankrupt, because it would mean that it was every year sending out more goods than it received payment for. The export and import of goods are not in themselves in any way an absolute indication. It depends altogether on the nature of the goods.

Comment on this

What about the export of boys and girls?

Comment on this

250,000 of them went to see their friends in America under the Fine Gael régime.

Comment on this

They were coming home.

Comment on this

They are all coming home, are they?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Deputy need not worry. We will not have any re-exports.

Comment on this

That is subtle. Sometime the Deputy will put it in the form of a resolution as obscure as this resolution.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

It is not too subtle for Deputy Flinn. Do not worry about that.

Comment on this

We will return to the export and the import trade. Say, for instance, a country imported £100,000,000 worth of goods which are saturated with labour; £100,000,000 worth of goods, every pound of which goods had contributed the maximum possible amount to the maintenance of the lives of working people in another country; and that country were to export in return £100,000,000 worth of purely raw materials practically untouched by labour. How are you going to balance those two accounts? It is quite obvious that in adding these two things together, or in making any calculation from them, you are adding together things of an entirely different nature. Therefore, the first and primal proposition which I think everybody in the House will accept is that, unless and until you analyse the nature, the labour content, and the other qualities of imported and exported goods, no calculation can be made on the basis of imports and exports.

Take another case. Say, for instance, you have 100,000 people in a country creating an export of, say, £10,000,000 worth of goods to another country, and obtaining from that country £10,000,000 worth of goods created by the labour of 100,000 people of the other country; I want you to add those two things together. Those are things of the same nature, but of opposite sign. In both cases the imports of one country are maintaining a population in another country. Say, for instance, that you destroy that whole £20,000,000 worth of international trade in a night. I want to ask yourself if that necessarily means that, by one penny piece, either country has lost. Let us take, for instance, that we were exporting £10,000,000 worth of labour-saturated material to another country to maintain there 100,000 people, who might have been maintained in our country making the £10,000,000 worth of stuff that we imported. Assume for a moment that I have destroyed that import and that export; that instead of maintaining 100,000 people in a foreign country, to send me £10,000,000 worth of imports, I maintain those 100,000 people in my country to manufacture those materials in my country, I will have destroyed £20,000,000 worth of international trade, but I will have added 100,000 livelihoods to the possession of my own country.

Those facts taken together will make wild generalisations on the subject of trade balances feel very awkward. Let me take another case. Say you take the case of a country which had no exports whatever and yet had continuously a large import. In practice, that country might be very wealthy. That occurs in small communities at present all over the world. I do not think it does, in fact, occur in any country in the world as a whole. There is no country in the world whose life is so specialised that it is possible for that sort of thing to occur. But it will be within the recollection of this House that, hundreds of years ago, there were in the University of Armagh alone at least twice as many students as there are in all the Universities in Ireland at present. There was a time when we were, to a very large extent, in so far as our cultural life was concerned, teachers as well as apostles. You might, for a moment, imagine that that position would be exaggerated and that we became the teachers of the world; that all the fundamental and beautiful economics that I have heard from the opposite benches had attracted the attention of the statesmen of the world; that all the knowledge of agriculture which I have heard preached on the other side, had that appreciation in the world which it had in the minds of those who uttered it from the other benches; that an appreciation of all the knowledge in relation to industry, culture and everything else, which they are so satisfied they possess, had spread to all corners of the world, so that the seas would be black with argosies carrying tribute to this country to pay for the education of the children of all the world. Under those conditions there need be no return cargoes for these argosies; there need be no export from this country; there need be no material production of any kind within the borders of this country. There could be an adverse trade balance of 100 per cent. lasting for 100 centuries, and the country would be running with milk and honey subscribed to it in the form of visible imports in return for the invisible exports of learning, knowledge and intelligence.

Take the universities of Oxford and Cambridge; take particular sections of Dublin, like Trinity College and the National University; take any school or college in the country and that is exactly what is going on there—a continuous visible import, and nothing but an invisible export. That being so, we find ourselves on even more uncertain ground, on ground on which certainly no one but people with a reckless mind like that of Deputy Dillon would venture in the spirit in which he entered on it. If you want to know whether a country has improved or disimproved, you have got to take into account, not merely the whole of its visible imports and exports, not merely the whole of its invisible imports and exports, but you have got to take into account, and intimately analyse, the labour and other social value content of every single item of its imports and exports.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Including the loaf.

Comment on this

Proof of the recklessness of the statements which were made on this matter, and how far Deputies are prepared to go, is represented by the attempt of Deputy Dillon to come down to figures. He said that in a period of five years, I think it was, the totality of our adverse trade balance was £76,000,000. That £76,000,000 of an adverse trade balance must have come from somewhere. He starts in to show that it has come out of the sterling holdings in the banks. Under the Cumann na nGaedheal régime, in three or four years the sterling holdings dropped by nearly £11,000,000, of which even Deputy Dillon knows £8,000,000 was what was called "hot money" or money that had come in here either for temporary refuge or to escape the economic blizzards that swept other countries. What is clear is that unless Deputy Dillon knew from outside sources that there was £8,000,000 of "hot money" in that £11,000,000, these figures would be completely misleading and would entirely misrepresent the policy and the accomplishments of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. We do happen to know that under this régime these holdings have dropped about £4,500,000 and the "unfavourable" trade balance is £76,000,000. Where is the other £72,000,000, even assuming that this £4,500,000 is a correct figure?

When you come to analyse the factories that have been built, the import of machinery, when you come to take into account the amount of money which has been withdrawn from outside securities no longer held by the banks and put into Irish industries, when you analyse the expenses which have been created in building up Irish industries of one kind or another, nobody but a person who had the most exact opportunities of laborious and painstaking examination over a long period, would be able to analyse the exact significance of any such figures. But what is quite obvious is that anyone who says that an adverse trade balance of £76,000,000 in five years, represents anything approaching a loss of that amount, is simply talking through his hat. In England, during 15 of its most prosperous years, its adverse trade balance —I think the figures were given by Deputy Dowdall—was £5,000,000,000. There again unless Deputies are prepared to come down to something more than a general statement that the adverse trade balance has increased or decreased, you are not in a position to make any deduction from it.

Deputy Dillon went on to tell us some sad story about the Treasury balance. To-day he found himself asking an inaccurate supplementary question when it was made quite clear to him that the Treasury balance, instead of decreasing, as he believed and as he hoped, had increased. It is a pity that a great Party, which has behind it a record of 11 years of government, should now be reduced to the carrion crow position of looking for something dead to live on—looking for a bad harvest, looking for a bad trade return, looking for an increase in the unemployment register, looking for a fall in the Treasury balance, looking forward to the failure of the Minister for Finance who, according to them, will go to borrow money next year and will not get sixpence. Surely something better than that can be expected from them—Jeremiads like "industries leaning on one another and waiting to fall"; "incipient bankruptcy"; "a country broken in spirit and in finance." Surely they can find some ground upon which to build the possibilities and the hopes of the future of their Party other than the destruction and the weakness of their own country. My difficulty is that which we have had here on this debate —and as far as I know, we are going to have it again—Deputies getting up and making speeches in the air, making speeches which deliberately avoid the essence, the purpose and the principle of the motion.

These debates could be enormously useful. I am not going to pretend for one moment that all the wisdom, all the knowledge, all the patriotism, all the love of country, or all the specialised knowledge in relation to the industries and activities of this country, are on this bench, that bench, or any particular bench. Members of this House should, upon this motion, have been able to take any particular industry or industries and tell us in relation to them those things which they believe are being supported by tariffs and impositions which should not be so supported. No one in his senses is going to suggest that every one of the hundreds of industries and activities which a high tariff policy has brought into being, and has maintained, is equally valuable. No one is going to pretend that abuses of one kind or another cannot have crept in, in particular instances. It is, therefore, possible that there may be industries, the cost of maintenance of which by the State in the form of tariffs is altogether greater than the benefit which the State receives in the way of extra employment. Those are things which should be within the particular knowledge and competence of individual members opposite. If so, they can, by their valuable services, bring a lot nearer the day when there would be strict examination and investigation into these matters. They could provide the machinery; they could provide the atmosphere; they could provide the public opinion that would render abuses—which, in my opinion, to some extent are inseparable from every large change of policy—nonexistent. If there are particular industries which are causing an undue increase in the cost of living; if there are industries which are, on net balance, reducing the capacity of the State to maintain them—and such a thing is perfectly conceivable—one single instance brought to the issue of proof by a man who knew what he was talking about in this House would do far more to clarify the system, to sanatise it, to make it strong and clean than a thousand general debates.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not know whether it is intended that the House should adjourn to-night at 10.30, but if that is the intention, I want to protest against that arrangement, and I should like to ask whether I will have an opportunity of raising that point?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have an opportunity. The House will have an opportunity of coming to a decision on that matter considerably before 10.30.

Comment on this

Do I take it, Sir, that an opportunity to come to a decision on the matter will be accompanied by an opportunity to give reasons to the House as to why it should sit for more than one day per week?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Seán T. O'Kelly The Vice-President Fianna Fáil

I should like now to give the House notice that there is a proposition to adjourn the House at 10.30 to-night until Wednesday next.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take it that there is opposition to that motion?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To put matters in order, I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary formally to move the adjournment of the debate until Friday next.

Comment on this

I move the adjournment of the debate until Friday next.

Comment on this

Is the Vice-President now asking that the House adjourn?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair requires a formal motion from the Vice-President that the House do now adjourn until 3 p.m. on Wednesday next.

Comment on this
Seán T. O'Kelly The Vice-President Fianna Fáil

I formally move that the House do now adjourn until 3 p.m. on Wednesday next.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In order to give the House an opportunity of coming to a decision, I am taking the motion now.

Comment on this

I take it that the Parliamentary Secretary has not finished?

Comment on this

Whatever is most convenient for the House.

Comment on this

What I want to find out is at what stage this particular matter is to be taken up.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary will be in possession when the debate is resumed.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

On a point of order, is it in order, without any previous notice whatever, to curtail private Members' time by half-an-hour?

Comment on this

Deputy Norton asked for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am entitled to ask information from the Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Private Deputies have got more than the hour and a half to which they are entitled on Wednesday. However, that is perhaps going into the merits of the case. It is quite in order for the Chair to afford the Dáil an opportunity of deciding whether or not the House will adjourn until Wednesday next. The Chair is now affording the House that opportunity.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I grant that through the operation of the Government timetable we have had a little more than the hour and a half, but might I point out that a member on the Government Front Bench has occupied more than an hour and a half on one speech?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Duration of speeches cannot be regulated by the Chair.

Comment on this

I want to protest against this arrangement whereby the House is convened for a single day, and then, after Deputies have been put to the trouble of coming here and the State to the expense of bringing them here for the purpose of discussing Parliamentary business, the House calmly proceeds to adjourn for a week or a fortnight, as the case may be. We have been asked now by the Vice-President to consent to an arrangement by which the House, having met to-day at 3 o'clock, will adjourn to-night at 10.30 and meet a week hence.

If that were an isolated instance one could understand that the exigencies of Parliamentary business probably necessitated it, but this apparently has been a studied arrangement for a long time past. In order that the House may have an opportunity of judging where it is drifting, I have calculated the amount of Parliamentary time which has been occupied since the general election of July last. The House met on 21st July for one day—in fact not even for a complete day—and then adjourned for 11 weeks until 6th October. It met on 6th and 7th October and adjourned for a fortnight. It met on 20th October for one day, and adjourned for a week. It met again on 27th October for one day, and adjourned for a fortnight. It met on 10th November for one day, and adjourned for a week. It met on 17th November, and now proposes to adjourn for another week. When you calculate the total amount of Parliamentary time, you find that the Dáil has met on seven days out of 17 weeks, and apparently the Government cannot order their business in any better way than that.

If there were nothing to discuss one might understand an adjournment of that kind, but there are 11 motions on the Paper, all dealing with matters which are as important as many of the measures which have been introduced by the Government, and I submit, Sir, that, when the Government brings Deputies to the city for the purpose of discussing legislation, the House should be required to sit on its normal sitting days while there is business either of a public or a private character to be transacted. Hundreds of thousands of citizens are affected by the private Members' motions which are on the Order Paper, and yet we are not to be allowed to have an opportunity to debate those motions even though there is another day and a-half available for Parliamentary discussion this week, as there was a day and a half available for Parliamentary discussion in other weeks. Then again there is the matter of questions submitted by Members. We have had experience of questions held up here for three weeks, because the Dáil was not sitting and time was not available for answering those questions, so that while we have an abundance of Parliamentary time available on the one hand, we cannot get time to discuss Parliamentary business on the other hand.

I suggest to the Vice-President that that state of affairs is no credit to the Government. It ought to be possible, with so many motions on the Agenda, for the Dáil to sit for the remainder of this week—and the remainder of every other week in which public business takes only one day—for the consideration of private Members' motions which are on the Order Paper. The continuance of Parliamentary business on to-morrow and Friday would occasion no expense to the State. No case whatever can be made for this wasteful procedure whereby the State brings Deputies together for the purpose of transacting business on only one day, when, in fact, three days are available for the purpose of transacting that business. I submit that the present procedure is a burlesque on Parliamentary institutions. I think the present arrangement is gross extravagance in the expenditure of public money, and I think some steps ought to be taken to arrange the business of the House in a much better and much more satisfactory manner than has been possible so far.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy anything to suggest?

Comment on this

Sit to-morrow and Friday.

Comment on this

Could you not curtail the speeches?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Flinn that. He has taken two hours this evening.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I should like to support the protest by Deputy Norton, and might I take this opportunity of reminding the Vice-President in particular, and the Minister for Education and some of the members who sit behind him, of the attitude they took up in regard to Parliamentary time when they were in opposition in this House? If, five years ago, it was suggested to the present Vice-President that this House should sit for only seven days in 17 weeks, as Deputy Norton has pointed out, he would have pulled down the roof on us. On one occasion he gave a very fine exhibition of what he could do when it was suggested that the House should adjourn for a fortnight. There is, as Deputy Norton has pointed out, a considerable number of motions on this Order Paper. I want to suggest to the House that it is because those motions are there that the Government does not want Parliament to sit. The Government are afraid, frankly, of an exposure in this House of their policy and the effects of their policy. The Government are a minority Government, and they are afraid of being tested on vital motions here in a division. Statements and pronouncements which should be made by Ministers in this House to the representatives of the people are made in halls under police guard in this city.

Comment on this

It was done last night.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

We were threatened, and the country is threatened, by the Minister with a general election, and the Government are afraid so to arrange their business as to enable it to be discussed in the House by the people elected three months ago to discuss these matters. Frankly, the position is that the Government are afraid of this Dáil; they are afraid to have decisions taken; they are afraid to have the position tested. I take it that it is not going to be suggested, even by the Vice-President, that in the last three months the Government had not a sufficient opportunity so to arrange their business as to keep the House in session up to the Christmas adjournment. Will the Vice-President now say that the Government have been unable so to arrange that business as to keep the House going? Will he say if there is any good reason why this Parliament should not meet to discuss and take decisions upon the various motions on the Order Paper? It is the old trick of the present Government not to give time for discussion and decision upon motions put down in the names of private members.

When the last Dáil was dissolved there were motions on the paper for nearly two years. Private members, under the Standing Orders and by practice and procedure, are supposed to be given an opportunity to have motions brought before the House discussed and a decision taken upon them. They are now being denied that right and the Government use various means to deprive private members of that time. Sometimes, if it does not suit the convenience of the Government to have a division on a particular motion on a certain night, we are treated to long-distance speakers like Deputy Flinn, who is put up to talk nonsense for an hour and three-quarters. On other occasions we have a different procedure, or perhaps we have both—Deputy Flinn and the one-day sitting at the same time. I think Deputy Norton's protest is very necessary, and I think the Vice-President will find it difficult to satisfy the House and the country that the Government are taking parliamentary business seriously.

Comment on this

I want to express the country Deputy's point of view on this matter. We have been summoned here for one day each week. To-day the Government business occupied only three hours. Why can we not be summoned for three days in the one week and then be let home for a fortnight, and not be coming here once a week for a three-hour job? It is all very well for Deputies living in and around Dublin, but most Deputies have to travel 80, 100 or 150 miles from the country districts and it is a farce to have to travel that distance to consider business that occupies only two or three hours and then go back again. Deputy Norton has made reference to the extravagance of summoning the Dáil for only one day in the week. I support that statement. It is extravagance, gross extravagance, and it looks as if the Government were trying to throw dust in the eyes of the Dáil and of the people of the country. From the point of view of economy, there is no justification for being summoned for a three hour job. Why can we not be given business to consider here on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday—there is enough business on the Order Paper in that respect—and then let us go home for two or three weeks? We have something to attend to at home instead of fooling about Dublin and listening to a man like Deputy Flinn, the funny man of the Party. We do not want to listen to the stage Irishman at all. There is not a man in this country but objects to the stage Irishman.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is scarcely parliamentary to refer to the Deputy as a stage Irishman.

Comment on this

I do not know what it is, but it seems to me——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a parliamentary term.

Comment on this

Call him a stage Englishman so.

Comment on this

If it is considered by the Chair a term of offence, I am sorry for having used it.

Comment on this

I would like to support the remarks made by Deputy Norton. There was a time in this House when this Party occupied the Government Benches and the Deputies who are now on the Government Benches used to protest strongly, even against the adjournment for Christmas. That was the time when there were supposed to be 60,000 unemployed. To-day the number of unemployed is infinitely greater, and thousands are leaving this country every year and the people on the Government Benches are doing very little to help them. We were accused at one time of being dictators. What is this but dictatorship? To make things worse, these people are setting out to increase their own allowances and put a further burden on the people.

Comment on this

It is not correct for Deputy Gorey to say that the Dáil has been summoned for one day. The Dáil was not summoned for one day; the Dáil was summoned to do parliamentary business, such business as was put on the Order Paper. To-day, to my mind, at any rate, there was a considerable amount of public business on the Order Paper that the Government asked the Dáil to deal with. I would not have been a bit surprised if to-day's business went over well into to-morrow. What applies to the business on the Order Paper for to-day applied, I think, with equal truth to the business put before the Dáil last Wednesday. But the business was got through expeditiously, to my mind unusually so. I would have thought a great deal more time would have been taken by the House to debate some of the important issues before the House to-day and last Wednesday. It is not the Government's fault that the House dealt as expeditiously as it did with the important Government business that was down for consideration.

Comment on this

There was nothing of importance put before the House.

Comment on this

I suggest there was one item that may not appear very important to Deputy Gorey, but I am sure it appears to others to be of great importance. I refer to the legislation dealing with shops.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister for Industry and Commerce decided that that was a Committee Bill.

Comment on this

It is an important measure.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Minister for Industry and Commerce declared that it was really a Committee Bill.

Comment on this

It was important and it was put through expeditiously. There was just a little over an hour taken in the House to discuss a matter of that kind. That is not the Government's fault. The Government had a very considerable amount of business before the general election and the House was kept very fully occupied. Then there were constitutional measures that have had to be put through the various Government Departments and made law. They had to be prepared before they were brought to the House. These items alone are of the first importance and many of them have been before the House and have been dealt with expeditiously. There is no fault to be laid at the Government's door. I am not making any complaint on that score, not at all, but the House has dealt with these matters expeditiously, and it is all to the credit of the House. Deputy Morrissey has suggested that the Government is afraid of being tested. I think that statement bears its own contradiction on its face. On every measure that has been brought before the House here the Government is being tested. That is the case in every Bill of every kind that is brought in here. On every Bill it is open to the House here to challenge a division. Every time the Dáil meets a division can be challenged and the policy of the Government can be challenged. That is being done and can be done on every motion before the House. Consequently I fail to see any foundation for the statement that the Government is afraid of being tested. The position is quite the contrary. The Deputy referred to the remarks made by Deputy Lemass, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, last night. I do not see what the Deputy has to object to in that. He said that the Government is afraid of being tested.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What I said in reference to the remarks of the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night was that the statement made at that meeting should have been made here in this House in reply to questions asked the Minister since the last meeting of the Dáil. That statement should have been made here by the Minister and not at a meeting held down in the city——

Comment on this

"Under police protection." That is what the Deputy said. We deny that, that the meeting was under police protection.

Comment on this

But it was. The Guards were there.

Comment on this

The Deputy said we were afraid of being tested. We were tested not so long ago and we are satisfied with the result.

Comment on this

Only for the gerrymandering we know where the Minister and his Party would be. The result would be different.

Comment on this

There has been no closure whatsoever on Government business. The Dáil has been free to take any time it pleases in discussing business. A considerable amount of business has been put before the House on the various occasions on which this House has met since the general election. It is to the credit of the Dáil and to everybody that that business has been got through expeditiously. I fail to see that there is any merit in calling the Dáil together when there is no business for the Dáil. Why should the Dáil continue sitting here when there is no business before it? It is without precedent that the Dáil should be called to sit upon days when there is no Government business.

Comment on this

Seeing that there is business on the Order Paper awaiting the attention of the House, is there any valid reason why the Dáil should not meet to-morrow to do this business?

Comment on this

That raises the question of private Deputy's time. Now the fact is that last week and this week the private Deputies have got their full amount of time, the amount of time they would get in any ordinary week with the Dáil sitting three days. They have got as much time on those two days on which the Dáil sat this week and last week as they would have got had the Dáil met three days each week. They got practically the full amount of time that would be given in a full week. It is without precedent for the Dáil to meet on a day when there is no Government business.

Comment on this

Do not the Standing Orders contemplate that private Deputies are entitled to three and a half hours' time each week? That would be 24½ hours private Deputies' time for the period during which we have been sitting since the Dáil reassembled here. Private Deputies have not been given half that amount of time during the period.

Comment on this

That is quite true.

Comment on this

The Vice-President has not given any reason why Deputies who have been summoned here for three hours' business, such as has happened here to-day, should be sent back again to the country when especially, as the Vice-President knows perfectly well, there is plenty of business on the Order Paper awaiting attention. Last night in an address delivered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in a hall which, despite what Deputy Tom Kelly says, was guarded by Gárda——

Comment on this

It was not, and the less Deputy Davin says about that the better.

Comment on this

I saw that at that meeting we, the non-Government Deputies, were told that if we did not give the necessary co-operation to carry out Government business there would be an appeal to the country. We are not a bit afraid of an appeal to the country.

Comment on this

Oh, you would not like that.

Comment on this

We are not one bit afraid of an appeal to the country. The Government can have an appeal to the country if they like. I protest against the Government bringing us here for one day.

Comment on this

You do not want an appeal to the country.

Comment on this

Then try it.

Comment on this

Let us have here in this House arguments in favour of the statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night that the non-Government Parties were not giving the necessary co-operation to carry out Government business.

Comment on this

They are not, and you know it. This motion is not a sensible one, and the Deputy knows it is not.

Comment on this

It is very seldom Deputy Tom Kelly gets excited and I am prepared to make all allowances for him.

Comment on this

Once a man, twice a child.

Comment on this

If Government Deputies would only exercise their brains they would see the House would be given a reasonable time——

Comment on this

The men over there on the Opposition are not exercising their brains.

Comment on this

It is time Deputy T. Kelly got up and made a speech.

Comment on this

There was a time when one of the Government Party called us dumb-driven cattle. The Government Deputies are now the dumb-driven cattle.

Comment on this

I think it is quite wrong to go to a private hall in the city and take advantage of a meeting held there for the purpose of making a case against item 22 on the Order Paper before that case was made here in this House and before the Minister had heard the case in favour of it. That is a sort of proceeding that never happened in the history of the Dáil since it was first established.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the motion is not a reasonable one.

Comment on this

The Minister would be treating this House in a proper spirit and with due respect if he waited to make that statement after he had given Deputy Norton, Deputy Lawlor and myself an opportunity to make a case in favour of our motion. We want the House to meet here to-morrow and get this motion cleared off the Order Paper. The Government claims to be a democratic Government. If it has any right to that claim let us have a discussion here on this motion and take the will of the people on it. That is what the Minister for Industry and Commerce should have done and not skidaddle away to a big hall in the city to make a statement that he should have made here.

Comment on this

I would ask Deputy Davin to read now the motion he is talking about.

Comment on this

I move that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am accepting the motion that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the question be now put."

Tá 58
·
Níl 48
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am now putting the question that the Dáil do adjourn to 3 p.m. on Wednesday, 24th inst.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 58
·
Níl 49
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?