We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Standard of Living—Abolition of Duties on Foodstuffs—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 1–176 of 511. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

As I glanced through the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, and as I listened with no little care to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I began to wonder whether we were discussing, as the motion on the Order Paper says, the standard of living of this community, or whether we were dealing with some completely foreign community altogether; whether we were discussing the affairs of the Irish Free State and the standard of living of the citizens of this State, or whether we were dealing with Kamchatka or Greenland or some place equally remote.

This is not a debate in which we want extracts from statistical figures. It is not a debate in which we rely upon figures at all. It is a debate in which every Deputy can readily come to a definite conclusion. It is a debate in which every Deputy who does his work as a Deputy, who knows the conditions of the people who have sent him to this House, and who knows the affairs of his constituency, can form an opinion for himself and can arrive at a sounder, a truer and a better-based conclusion by reason of his knowledge of existing conditions than he can from any figures which may be quoted from statistical abstracts or any other like documents.

I am not interested in general flights into the theory of political economy. I am not going to delay the time of the House or the procedure of this debate by pointing out that the Parliamentary Secretary, in attending the Barrington lectures which, I understand, he attended at one time, managed to pick up a very small, a very scattered and an entirely inaccurate knowledge of the dismal science of political economy. I prefer to appeal in this debate very much more to the knowledge that every Deputy has got of conditions in this State. If the State is flourishing so wonderfully and if everyone is so rich as the Minister for Industry and Commerce would ask us to believe, why are those things not borne out by the reports we have day by day from all parts of the country?

Our experience tells us that this country is getting poorer and poorer and that the inhabitants are getting poorer and poorer, and yet the Minister for Industry and Commerce would like us to believe that everybody is flourishing and that it is quite easy to carry on in this State; that the cost of living is not rising to any appreciable degree. If that is so, I would like to have some answer from the Government as to why it is that from body after body in the State you get a cry for increased pay or increased salary on the ground that the cost of living is getting so high that people are unable to carry on. Is it a fact that there is the strongest agitation at the present moment, sufficiently vocal to be heard at almost every street corner and to be read in almost every paper, on the part of the national teachers, demanding that their salaries should be increased, that their cuts, as they say, should be restored, on the ground that they cannot make ends meet owing to the increased cost of living? Is that wrong? Is that faked or engineered, and, if so, by whom?

Does any Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches deny that such an agitation is going on? Were there not questions in the House about it? Are these people entirely mistaken and is the Minister for Industry and Commerce right? Are they all flourishing, and is living just as easy for them now as it was three or four years ago? If so, I should like to know what is the meaning of the intensity of their agitation. Surely, better than any figures that can be produced and any argument that can be drawn from any figures, is the practical knowledge that where these people were some time ago able to make ends meet, they cannot do so now? The answer to that is that it is due to the increased cost of living. But they are not the only persons. You find that, perhaps not so loudly or vigorously put, but at the same time just as deep and just as determined, there is an agitation going on by the Civic Guards to have their pay increased, their cuts restored, so that they will be put back to the pay they had at an earlier date. On what ground do they base that? Upon precisely the same ground that the national teachers base their claim— that their pay is not now sufficient for them to make ends meet owing to the increased cost of living. Is that a genuine cry on their part? Are they in earnest in it? I do not think that anybody can doubt that it is a very genuine cry, that they really are speaking because they feel the pinch and that they have become vocal simply because the pinch has made them vocal. Take these two classes. One can speak as loudly as it likes. The other class speaks more hesitatingly owing to its position. But does anybody believe that these two classes, making their demand upon the same ground—the high cost of living— are not perfectly genuine in their demands? Against the practical experience of these two classes—the teachers and the Guards—are you going to put the speeches of the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

I notice that what has been said in this debate has had a considerable effect upon the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because the speech which he delivered in this House is very different in tone from that of his two speeches which he delivered the other night—one in Dublin and the other in Cork. When he was speaking in this House, everything was rosy, everything was for the best in this best of all possible countries. Outside, his tone was entirely different. Inside the House, the country was progressing in a wonderful way; more motor cars were being bought and because of that the country was extremely rich, there could be no poverty and the cost of living could not be hitting people at all. I wonder if anybody would walk in to a bank manager and say: "I am a very rich man; I own a motor car; you are entirely mistaken when you think I have an overdraft. Everybody who owns a motor car, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is rich and, therefore, nobody who owns a motor car could possibly have an overdraft. Your book-keeping must, therefore, be wrong." Would that have very much effect on the bank manager? I wonder if the bank manager would be inclined to wipe out the overdraft simply on the theory that a man who owns a motor car must be very rich. That is the sort of argument which the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when inside this House, draws from statistics. Outside the House, his argument is completely different. Outside the House, he admits that the country is going very badly. He says, in effect, that a favourable answer cannot be given to the cry of the teachers and the Guards. He says that no money is now available without extra taxation and that extra taxation can be imposed only to relieve the unemployed, that no other case is so urgent. If this country is so rich as we were told it was and if the revenue is so buoyant as it was represented to be, why should it be necessary to put on extra taxation to raise a sum of £250,000, which was the figure given, roughly, by the Minister. Outside the House, the Minister changes the attitude which was taken up by himself and his whole Party. He goes back upon speech after speech made from the Fianna Fáil benches. At long last, he is a convert, though a somewhat belated one. He preaches the doctrine which. again and again, has been preached from these benches. What was denounced on our part as unsound and unnational is now preached by the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself. We have stated, again and again, that this country can only prosper if its main industry—the agricultural industry—is put and kept in a flourishing condition. We have, again and again, stated that, if this country be deprived of its main market, it is impossible for it to carry on successfully. In season and out of season, we have preached that doctrine. We have never tired of preaching it. On the other hand, the opposite doctrine has been preached, time and again, from the Fianna Fáil Benches. To begin with, we were told that the loss of our principal market was a blessing in disguise. We were told that it would hurry up the great transition which the Government wanted to effect. We combated these views and said they were entirely false. Now, we find that the Minister is a belated convert. I wonder if he has converted the Deputies on his benches. We have the statement that it is necessary for this country to increase its export to the British market. The Minister combined that with a statement which was very false. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has got a very faithless servant in his memory. It is unfortunate that he should have such a terribly bad recollection. The Minister stated in his speech in Dublin that, at the instance of the members on this side of the House, the British Government put taxes on stuff going from this country into the British market. That statement is entirely false. There is not the slightest shred of foundation for it. It is a figment of the Minister's imagination, as I think members of the Fianna Fáil Party and everybody else knows. The memory of the Minister played him false. In this House the leader of his Party proudly declared that he fired the first shot in the economic war.

Comment on this

He never said that.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

President de Valera said he fired the first shot in the economic war.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Deputy Briscoe forgets that statement, too. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is not the only person in the House with a faithless memory. I wonder if the memories of the other members of Fianna Fáil are equally faithless.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

They are.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

The Deputies opposite are a great lot—always forgetting what it is inconvenient to remember. That is a very fortunate state of mind. We had in this House, however, the proud boast of the President of the Executive Council that— and I am using his own words—he fired the first shot in the economic war. What has been the result? He was told then, as we tell him now, that this country cannot prosper until the agricultural industry is put properly upon its feet, and the agricultural industry cannot be put properly on its feet until we have an unrestricted entry into the British market. We can get that, as we are satisfied, by sensible negotiation with the British.

So long as the economic war was going on this country had, as I say, no chance. When the economic war was terminated, when peace was made between this country and Great Britain, even when, by the terms of the Coal-Cattle Pact, which ended the economic war, it was agreed that the sum of £5,000,000 should be levied off our cattle and produce going into the British market, our position was, to a certain extent, improved. I admit that we are not now as badly off as we were while the economic war was going on, but the economic peace which was negotiated by this Government, or by civil servants on their behalf, and which was ratified by this House, is an absolutely, hopelessly bad peace, and until those peace terms are completely revised and until we get, as we ought to get by sensible common-sense negotiations with Great Britain, free entry into the British market, this country cannot be put in the position financially in which it ought to be put. In consequence, the cost of living which is going up and up every day is pressing more and more heavily upon the people who are impoverished, first, by the war, and then by the peace made by the Government opposite.

I know the Government did not like that peace, and I am quite sure they would have liked to have got better peace terms than they did get; but they were the best peace terms they were able to negotiate. The world knows that Germany did not like the peace terms negotiated at Versailles, but she had to endure them. She is kicking against them and trying to have them altered, and until we kick against the peace terms negotiated between this Government and Great Britain, until we get terms of peace, final and lasting, giving us free entry into the British market for our agricultural produce, this country cannot prosper and this cost of living must press more and more heavily upon the people who are suffering from the effect of the Government's action.

One argument which has been put again and again from the Fianna Fáil Benches is: Look at the cost of living figure; they do not show any very tremendous rise. I wish to impress upon the House that so far as my constituency is concerned, so far as the people for whom and on whose behalf I am now addressing the House are concerned, the small farmers of County Mayo and the labourers and workers in County Mayo, because it is a constituency in which there are no large farmers, the cost of living index is not of the slightest importance. The cost of living index depends entirely on how it is weighted. Weighting is a technical term, but it means that in compiling the cost of living index, greater weight must be given to the prices of certain articles than to the prices of other articles. Greater weight, for instance, must be given to the price of bread than would be given to the price of some luxury article.

Comment on this

Motor cars.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

They would hardly come in at all. If you weight, as the cost-of-living figure in this country is weighted, for the Civil Service, it is no index at all as to the rise or fall of the cost of living for the ordinary working man. If you want to discover the cost of living for the ordinary working man and the ordinary small farmer, you have to weight your figure in the cost-of-living index in a completely different way from the way in which you weight it when ascertaining the cost of living of the civil servant. That is not a mere argument on my part. It has been found so by practical experience. In Australia, where the courts were called upon to fix a minimum wage, the courts refused to act upon the cost-of-living index figure which was compiled for the Civil Service. They insisted on having brought before them a certain number of ordinary housekeepers who gave to the courts, on oath, the various items of their expenditure showing what it cost them to live. Later on, I believe, in Australia another index figure was arrived at. They have worked out a cost of living figure for the artisan and for the labourer, but in the beginning, when their cost-of-living index figure was compiled for civil servants, the courts refused to act upon it. The reason for that is perfectly plain and ought to be perfectly plain to any Deputy opposite.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest that the present cost-of-living figure here was compiled for civil servants?

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entirely wrong, of course.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Will the Deputy tell me for whom it was compiled?

Comment on this

Not for civil servants.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I beg the Deputy's pardon. It was compiled in order that the bonus for civil servants should be ascertained.

Comment on this

It was not. It purports to be based on a labourer's budget pre-war, and has no application whatever to civil servants, except that it is applied to their salaries.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

That is simply a matter of fact on which I differ from the Deputy. I say that the figures here, and the cost of living here, are not weighted to the working man. The Deputy may say that they are. I say they are not.

Comment on this

They are probably not weighted for anyone. They do not purport to be weighted for civil servants.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I differ with the Deputy. That can be ascertained.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

I assert one fact and the Deputy asserts another. There is no use in asserting, one against the other.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

A statement has been made from the opposite benches that the entire rise—sometimes they admit it, and sometimes they do not—in the cost of living is due to external matters; that there has been a cost-of-living rise all over the world. That is complete dust. I appeal to Deputies to take facts and practical experience that cannot be denied. We had figures quoted, and Deputies with practical experience, who live in the Border counties, made it perfectly plain that in the expenditure of money, and for the same amount of stuff, we had to pay £1 in this State for what could be got for something like 14/- in the Six Counties, and for something less in Great Britain. That is not due to any external causes; it is due to Government action. Apart from Government action, there is no reason why commodities should be cheaper in Belfast than they are here. No explanation can be given of the undoubted fact that the purchasing power of money in this State is far lower than the purchasing power of money in even the Six Counties. That is due to Government action. That is what the motion states. I should like to know if it is not due to Government action. In the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary, which lasted for nearly two hours, no attempt was made to explain that fact. If any other Deputies on the opposite benches or the Minister for Education intend to take part in the debate, perhaps some of them will explain what are the causes which make the cost of living so much higher here than in the Six Counties. Are any of them natural causes or are they due to Government action? If they are natural causes, I should like to know what they are. If they are not natural causes it must be owing to Government action. Take the price of one of the necessities of life. Bacon was regarded as one of the main foods of the people, indeed, it was the only meat which small farmers in the West and in other parts of Ireland took. Bacon has now gone to a price that is prohibitive. I should like if Fianna Fáil Deputies who come from country districts went into the houses of the ordinary £7 or £8 holders and asked them how often in the week they had bacon for dinner five or six years ago and on how many days they have it for dinner now. I venture to think the answer would be that five or six years ago there was bacon for dinner six days in the week, and that if there is bacon for dinner at all now, it is once a week.

Comment on this

It was Russian bacon.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Assuming it was, is it better to eat Russian bacon or starve? Deputy Munnelly does not wish to answer that question. One might even eat Russian bacon without becoming a Bolshie.

Comment on this

You might not live after eating it.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Possibly. I never tried it. It is quite obvious the Deputy has not tried it either. I do not wish to detain the House, but I think this is a debate in which every Deputy is in a position to use his own mind, his own judgment and experience. It is his experience and knowledge, what he hears from friends and acquaintances, and what he sees, that ought to influence his vote. Though he may have to enter the Lobby which his Party Whip directs, he will enter it with the clear knowledge and with the sure conviction that he is entering a Lobby where he is voting against his own beliefs.

Comment on this

If I had not the motion before me, but had been listening to the Deputy who has just concluded, I would not have known what the subject matter of the debate was. A short time ago a Bill was passed through this House, the title of which one of the Deputy's colleagues suggested should be changed. I think the title of this motion should be changed to what the Deputy's colleague suggested: "Don't cry little fish." The Deputy began by saying that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had wasted the time of the House by referring to the cost of living in different parts of the world—Timbuctoo and elsewhere. The Deputy suggested that the proper way to treat this motion was to discuss facts as they confronted us in this State; yet he had to go to Germany and to Australia to try to illustrate some of the points he wished to make. That is an example of the difficulty in which the Deputy and his Party find themselves in attempting to make a case for this motion. The Deputy asked what was the cause of the increase in the cost of living, and who was most concerned by the increased cost. He referred to the position as it confronted us some five years ago. I think he should have gone back much longer, back to 1912, when the wages paid to certain workers in this State were as low as 13/- for a full week's work. At that time the cost of living from the point of view of the index figures was at the very lowest. I challenge Deputies opposite to tell us if the lot of the majority was better when the cost of living was at the very lowest. I think that when the workers organised themselves and brought about an increase in wages, they at the same time brought about an increase in the cost of living. Nevertheless, they bettered their conditions. If we are to face facts, is not this a fact of importance: that, if a person has the money with which to buy the necessaries of life at a certain price, he is thereby in a better position than if he had no money to buy goods at a cheaper price. That is one fact that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney lost sight of completely.

I do not know how the Deputy brought in the economic war and then the economic peace. I could not quite follow him on that. It seemed to me that he wished us to be back again to the period of the economic war, because, according to himself, he finds fault with the economic peace. I confess I do not know how that comes in, but that is what we had from the Deputy. What I am concerned with is the position as I see it. The Deputy appealed to the members of the House to see things with their own eyes and to listen to the things that they hear going on around them in their own neighbourhoods. I am quite satisfied that this motion was rushed in without thought and without consideration, and without any relation to the facts of the situation. I feel certain that if the Deputies opposite got the chance of reconsidering their position they would not introduce such a motion, and I think they would be well advised now to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Can Deputy Briscoe see this fact: that while the 4-lb. loaf is costing 1/- in Dublin, it is being sold outside of this State for eight pence.

Comment on this

I will deal with the facts. Deputy Morrissey wants support for his motion on this ground: that we should go back to the period of five years ago when the Party that he now belongs to set about improving the standard of living of the people here by taking 1/- off the old age pensioners.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Party that the Deputy belongs to has taken a great deal more off them.

Comment on this

Another step that the Party opposite took to improve the standard of living was to make a cut in the pay of the Guards when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was Minister for Justice. This is the Deputy who is now crying about the pay of the Guards and wants us to go back to the period of five years ago because, he says, in the interval the cost of living has increased.

Comment on this

Tell us about the 4-lb. loaf.

Comment on this

The man who has a 1/- to buy the 4-lb. loaf at a 1/-is surely better off than the man who had nothing when the Party to which the Deputy belongs was in power to buy a loaf even if he could get it for eight pence. That is not the position now. The facts are these: that when this Government came into office it decided that, as far as the resources of the State would permit, provision would be made for everybody, and, under that policy, the people whom our predecessors neglected have been taken care of by us. When our predecessors were in office there were no pensions for widows and orphans, and what did it matter to people whether the 4-lb. loaf was 6d., or 8d. or 1/- if they had no money to buy it. This Government changed that, and decided that everyone should have a bit to eat. Deputy Morrissey is not satisfied. He wants us to go back to the glorious days of the past when the country was faced almost with a revolution because of the hopeless state into which it had been allowed to get by our predecessors. There is no fear of that now. The gentlemen opposite grumble because the cost of living is increased.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney referred to the civil servants and to the Guards in particular, but, as Deputy Heron pointed out to him, the cost-of-living figures are not based in relation to the salaries and wages paid to civil servants except in so far as the bonus is concerned. They are weighted down in a way altogether different from that which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney attempted to show. Arising out of an interjection made by Deputy Heron, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's argument was an attempt to prove that there were two facts in existence, one at complete variance with the other. The fact is this, that the majority of the people of this country are better off to-day. Last week we had a speech on this motion from Deputy Gorey in which he said that the business community was never better off than it is to-day, and that the members of it should be on their knees day and night thanking this Government for all it had done for them.

Comment on this

The profiteers.

Comment on this

That was Deputy Gorey's statement, so that whatever the reason be, whether it be profiteering or otherwise, and I am not saying it is, the business community must be satisfied with this Government.

Comment on this

They are in the minority.

Comment on this

At any rate, they are a considerable section of the people.

Comment on this

The Deputy is the poor man's friend.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Do not put him off the line that he is on.

Comment on this

The Deputy's interruptions do not worry me in the least. Deputy Gorey suggested, at any rate, that the business community had no grievance, and yet other members of his Party, when they get up to speak, say that the business community is being taxed out of existence. That is the kind of statement we get from them when new duties are introduced by the Government—that the business community is being taxed out of existence, that there is no security for investments, and that the country is going to rack and ruin. It seems to me that the Deputies opposite have to frame a special set of arguments for each matter that comes forward. Judging by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's speech to-day, I do not think that he could have been properly briefed. If he had been, I do not think he would have made the statements that he did make. His speech was a hopeless one. For instance, the Deputy suggested that the question of who fired the first shot in the economic war had something to do with the matter we are discussing. He said that the President had admitted firing the first shot. I think that if the Deputy took the care to quote the President's statement from the Official Debates he would feel bound to withdraw that statement. If there has been an increase in the cost of certain things which has affected the cost of living, I maintain that there has been a reduction in the cost of other things, and if for the purposes of this debate it is agreed that there has been an increase in the cost of living, I hold that it has not had the effect of reducing the standard of living amongst our people. That is what those who are behind this motion are attempting to prove, that the standard of living has been lowered by the policy of this Government. I say that the standard of living in this country has definitely increased in the last few years. This is a point that was dealt with by Deputy O'Reilly in his speech on the motion. He asked what was the first essential needed to bring about an improvement in the standard of living of our people, and he answered the question himself by saying that it was the provision of good housing accommodation for them.

Comment on this

But first of all you would want to have a fire in the house.

Comment on this

Is it not admitted that the first thing you need is the house. I presume it will not be disputed that, during the few years this Government has been in office, it has done more to improve the housing conditions of the people than our predecessors did during the ten years they were in office. Is that denied?

Comment on this

We had to build up what you knocked down.

Comment on this

Deputy Giles need not tell me about what was knocked down or what was built up. I am talking about what this Government has done to provide housing accommodation for the poorer sections of the community.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

And the people are so well off that they are unable to pay their rents.

Comment on this

I do not think that the Deputy could prove that.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Ask some of the members of your Party.

Comment on this

I say that does not apply to the City of Dublin, where a great number of houses have been built in the last few years, nor do I think it applies to the Deputy's own constituency.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

It does.

Comment on this

I do not think it does.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am sure of it.

Comment on this

Could he give us the figures of it?

Comment on this

We suspended four rent collectors in Cork because they could not get in any arrears.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that we should suspend interruptions, and give Deputy Briscoe a chance of speaking.

Comment on this

The Deputy over there, of course, was one of those who advised people not to pay their annuities.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

The Deputy was one of those who went around the country advising people not to pay their annuities.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They are collected, anyway.

Comment on this

Yes, they are collected, but it was despite the Deputy's advice.

Comment on this

Our advice was that the policy of your Government was such that it prevented the farmers from being able to pay.

Comment on this

What was your advice?

Comment on this

The farmers were not able to pay. We asked you to put them in a position to pay by settling the economic war.

Comment on this

The Deputy must remember that there is a difference between now and three or four or five years ago.

Comment on this

At any rate, I am sure that Deputies will not dispute the fact that one of the fundamental conditions of good living for the people is to give them good houses in which to live.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

And enough to eat?

Comment on this

Yes, enough to eat; but let us take one thing at a time.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

A man can be hungry even though he is living in a good house.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Well, the Deputy looks well fed enough himself.

Comment on this

At least, I think that we have done a good deal to provide food and work, where it was available, and where it was possible to provide them, so far as our own resources would permit. I admit, and I have always said, that a lot more could be done, but, within the limits of our resources, I hold that we have done our best and that a considerable improvement has been made; and I say that when we compare the conditions to-day with those that obtained when we took over office, it will be found that the standard of living, generally, has improved in the whole Twenty-Six Counties. I am satisfied that it has improved. The gentlemen opposite make a comparison between the cost of essentials here and the cost of essentials across the Border. Will they go further and compare the conditions of unemployment across the Border and the conditions of unemployment here?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Yes.

Comment on this

I am not at all afraid of Deputy Morrissey, and I do not think that he should look so fierce.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am only looking at the Deputy with amusement.

Comment on this

Perhaps, but the Deputy does not care to answer the question I put to him.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Yes.

Comment on this

The whole purpose behind this motion is to try to confuse the people by comparing the conditions of to-day with the conditions of ten years ago. There is no use in the people opposite trying to deceive themselves. They will not deceive anybody else, but at least they should give up trying to deceive themselves. I have not heard any serious suggestions from anybody over there to remedy the situation they have described to us. Not one of them has put forward any concrete suggestion. If I were a party to a motion of this kind, at least I should take the trouble to arm myself with some facts or some illustrations in support of the motion. I would come prepared with some facts as to what I would do. For instance, Deputy Corry got up here the other day and asked some of the people over there what taxes they wanted removed in order to have agreement on this matter. He asked, in effect, did they say that the flour-milling industry should not be interfered with, but nobody has answered him. Do Deputies over there agree that we should go back to the old system of importing foreign wheat, or does Deputy Morrissey agree that we should close down the beet factories? Does Deputy Morrissey agree that we should close down the beet factory at Thurles, in his own constituency? I do not believe that Deputy Morrissey would vote for the closing down of the Thurles beet factory.

Comment on this

Is the farmer getting the cost of production?

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey has not answered the question as to whether the factory should be closed down. A Deputy speaks about the cost of production and so on, but, if so, will we not have to get a bigger price for sugar?

Comment on this

What about the profits of the company?

Comment on this

I cannot say. I am not a shareholder, but at least I will say that Deputy Brodrick should not make an interjection unless he knows about the matter himself. Deputy Brodrick should know that himself, or else he should not make an interjection of that kind. I will not make an interjection unless I am satisfied about my facts. However, apart from that, Deputy Morrissey will not answer my question as to whether or not the Thurles beet factory should be closed down, and that is what the motion implies. Is he standing for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I am standing over the whole motion and what it implies.

Comment on this

At any rate, we have this: that we are at liberty to go down the country—howling down the country, as Deputy Dillon says—and stand for the closing down of the beet factories.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

You would be howling, whether you were at liberty or not.

Comment on this

The Deputy will say that, anyhow. The motion is in line with the Deputy's attitude. The motion says something, and it means nothing. Not one of the Deputies opposite has got up and said that they want any particular tax removed. Do the Limerick Deputies want the butter levy removed?

Comment on this

We want the world market price.

Comment on this

The world market price for the last five years?

Comment on this

Why did you not skin the calves?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe should not be inviting interruptions.

Comment on this

I am not inviting interruptions, Sir, but I am trying to deal with the arguments put up by the opposite side in connection with this motion, because I take them as being seriously meant. I am really trying to deal with the motion which, I will say, I considered as being seriously ment, and I am trying to deal with it in a serious way. I have not heard any of the Deputies on the opposite side speaking in a united way—if it is possible for them to be united on any matter—in connection with this motion. They have spoken vaguely about the whole thing but not one has told us what tax should be removed, except Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to-day, who, I suppose, conscience-stricken, told us that it was in his period of office that the 1/6 boot allowance was taken off the Gárda, and he is using this motion as an excuse to argue that point. But he also forgets that it was in his period of office that a substantial cut was made in the teachers' salaries, and he is trying now to bring in that under this motion. He forgets, or neglects to say, that the cut was taken off during his period of office, and that the only reason it has been continued is to make a pension scheme sound.

Comment on this

The cuts are retained by your Party.

Comment on this

Yes, but I will not say for how long that will be so. I am asking you to choose between letting things stay as they are and getting back to the things that obtained that Deputy Morrissey, evidently, would like us to get back to, when there was a cut of 1/- on old-age pensions and all the other cuts. If it comes to that, and that one must stand between one and the other, I will stand for a little bit less for some gentlemen and a little bit more for those for whom no provision was made at all. As to this Utopia that Deputy Morrissey wants for certain people, I say advisedly and with consideration that, if this motion were by any misfortune to be carried by this House, it would be disastrous for the community and you would find Deputy Morrissey running at the head of a long line of people to get the position brought back to what it is to-day or would be if this were not to upset it. I want to hear some Deputies on the opposite side tell us what they want us to do. There was a tax on tea in the period of office of our predecessors.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

When you came into office?

Comment on this

No, but there was a tax on tea during their period of office. We know you took it off, but during the greater portion of the period of office of our predecessors there was a tax upon tea. Is that denied?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There was never a tax on tea during that period?

Comment on this

It is denied that there was a tax on tea during the greater part of our period of office.

Comment on this

The greater part—but at any time?

Comment on this

You said during the greater part.

Comment on this

I withdraw that. There was a tax on tea at some time during his period of office.

Comment on this

Not as much as was imposed by the Deputy's Party.

Comment on this

The question of degree does not enter into it—the principle is there. The Party opposite took 1/- off the old-age pensioners and 1/6 off the policemen's boot allowance and, to make things better and to increase the standard of living, it put a small tax on tea for a short time. The fact is that the tax was there at one period. Now they come along and say: "It is unheard of, shocking, to be taxing anything in the nature of foodstuffs for the poor people." Does Deputy Morrissey really feel happy?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

What has this to do with the tax on tea?

Comment on this

The Deputy wants the taxes removed, and I want to know why he wants them removed. I ask him was there ever a tax on tea imposed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Administration?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

They took it off and you put it on again.

Comment on this

I should like to see it taken off, but it cannot be done at the moment. The Minister would be glad to take it off.

Comment on this

He took it off for the election.

Comment on this

The Minister has to provide funds for people for whom no provision was made previously. He has to provide funds by various ways and the tax-payers have to provide funds to build houses to improve the standard of living of the people which Deputy Cosgrave neglected when he was President.

Comment on this

To build Jewmen's factories.

Comment on this

Whether the factories are controlled or owned or associated with people of my persuasion or not, I do not think Deputy Giles need worry. There is nothing to prevent Deputy Giles from opening factories if he desires to give much-needed employment to people who have no work. I am quite prepared to be examined on my record in that regard, and I should like the Deputy to be in the same position. If the Deputy wants to sink to that level, the cross-roads is the place for him, not this House.

Comment on this

Where you should be.

Comment on this

I have always been at the cross-roads when occasion arose, and I have never been afraid or ashamed to go there. The Deputy will have an opportunity to go there. This is not the place to deal with that kind of talk. The standard of living has been improved also by the employment given in the new industries. I suppose the Deputy will not dispute that. Will Deputy Morrissey dispute that the standard of living of a great number of his constituents has been improved by the establishment of factories in his constituency? I do not think he will deny that; I do not think any Deputy will deny it.

Comment on this

I deny it, because there is no factory in my constituency.

Comment on this

That is your complaint. Another Deputy wants all the factories closed because they are increasing the cost of living, notwithstanding the fact that they are improving the standard of living. Deputy Fagan wants one opened in his area, because it will do the same thing which it has done in other constituencies.

Comment on this

There is one in Mullingar. Is not that in the Deputy's constituency?

Comment on this

You cannot have it every way. If the industries we are starting are contributing, to a certain extent, as they are, to increase the cost of living by the increased cost of commodities, and by that method have improved the standard of living of a great number of people—if that is the objection some Deputies have, and they want those factories to close down and want us to go back again to a free market and free trade, I say that Deputy Fagan should not ask for a factory in his constituency.

Comment on this

Is not the motion to lower the cost of foodstuffs, not the factories making nuts and bolts and pencils?

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy read the motion. The Deputy could not have read the motion introduced by his own Party under the signature of Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Morrissey I will read it for him. (Motion read). One of these impositions was the imposition put on flour coming into the country. By keeping out flour and bringing in a certain amount of wheat, and growing our own wheat, as Deputy Corry illustrated in great detail when he spoke, we were enabled to open flour mills which had been absolutely out of operation and to improve others which had been only working part-time. What Deputy Fagan wants us to do now is to close those down.

Comment on this

Why is flour 10/- a sack dearer here than in Northern Ireland and Great Britain? Let us be practical.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Leary and Deputy Fagan will speak one at a time or agree as to which interruption I shall answer first, I will do so. It is hard to answer two or three at the same time.

Comment on this

You do not understand me when I speak in Irish.

Comment on this

I understand your English and sometimes I understand your Irish. I am dealing with Deputy Fagan now.

Comment on this

Deal with the 10/- on the sack of flour.

Comment on this

When I finish with Deputy Fagan I will come to the 10/- on flour. Deputy Fagan has a grievance that no new industries have been opened up in his constituency. Deputy Morrissey has a grievance that too many factories have been opened up all over the country and that the community is paying too dearly for them, and that therefore the cost of living has gone up and the standard of living has gone down.

Mr. O'Leary interrupted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Leary should give Deputy Briscoe a chance to make his statement.

Comment on this

I am sorry, but it is very hard to be patient.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I am so provoking to some Deputies. I am trying to deal with this matter in the only way in which I think it can be dealt with. It is hard enough to hear three Deputies speaking at the one time, but it is harder to hear somebody speaking when you are speaking yourself.

Comment on this

It is hard to hear what you do not want to hear.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy repeat it now?

Comment on this

I will. Fianna Fáil promised that by milling all our flour they would give the producer of live stock very cheap mill offals. Has that happened?

Comment on this

I have not the exact figures as to mill offals, but I know that when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was dealing with that matter a few weeks ago, he went to the trouble of getting the prices of corresponding items in a neighbouring country and comparing them with the prices here, and he was satisfied that the farmer was not paying any more for these offals than he would if he had to import them. Deputy Cosgrave's complaint was that the prices did not matter, although cheaper, because you could not get them at all. I found out afterwards that delivery could be got of these offals at the prices stated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, which were in fact cheaper than the prices for similar items across-Channel.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that the bag of flour is costing 2/8 more in the Free State than in England?

Comment on this

That is not an offal.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Keating has not yet spoken on this motion.

Comment on this

I will speak and I will talk common sense when I do speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am asking the Deputy to restrain himself until he gets an opportunity to speak and then he can say all he wants to say. Deputy Briscoe is entitled to speak without interruption and so is every other Deputy.

Comment on this

Is he not asking for them?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not going to be cross-examined by any Deputy. Deputy Keating had better realise that.

Comment on this

He does.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to conduct himself.

Comment on this

He always did conduct himself where respect is due.

Comment on this

I am trying to make the point that the standard of living in this country has been increased. I admit, for the purpose of this debate, that the cost of living has gone up somewhat and is dearer, if you like, than the cost of living in other places with which comparison can be made. I say that the fact that the cost of living has increased does not necessarily mean that there has been a lowering of the standard of living. I say emphatically that the standard of living has been considerably improved since the policy of this Government has been brought into operation. I am trying to argue that and to illustrate it by the line I have taken. The interruptions prove that I might be right. It is quite true that flour is dearer here than elsewhere and that, if we went back again to the free importation of flour, you would have flour at a cheaper price, possibly, at periods. You might also have to pay a dearer price when the world price fluctuated against us but, for the sake of this debate, let us assume that the price of flour in other parts of the world is 10/- or 7/6 per sack cheaper than it is here. For the purposes of this debate I will concede that point, but the price we would have to pay for getting that flour cheaper is this: Firstly, we would not be able to grow our own wheat because we would have no means of milling it, as our flour mills would not be open; and secondly, the flour mills now in operation, giving much-needed employment at fairly reasonable wages, would all have to be closed down. That is the price we would have to pay. The actual fact is that the price of flour in the rest of the world is going up. There are periods, and have been periods, when flour outside the Free State has been almost as dear as in the Free State.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Yes. The price of foreign wheat in 1926 was 30/- and the price of flour then imported was 52/6. The price of foreign wheat in 1937 is 30/-, while the price of home-manufactured flour is 51/6. How much worse off are we?

Comment on this

We are 14/- a sack worse off.

Comment on this

We are 1/- better off although we are milling our own flour. Those are figures that Deputy Keating or any other Deputy can verify very easily. If they are not accurate, I shall withdraw them, and I shall make amends by having them withdrawn from the records of the House. These are the actual facts. In 1926, when we had not got the number of people in employment milling flour that we have to-day and when we had not got the acreage under wheat that we have now, we were paying 52/6 for imported flour. To-day, when we have flour mills working, which are giving this much-needed employment, and when we allow, as Deputy Corry and Deputy Gorey say, a handsome profit for the millers, the price of the home-manufactured flour is 51/6. I do not know whether it can be argued that that is one of the items that should be interfered with by this motion. As I said before when I referred to the sugar industry, Deputy Morrissey by his motion implies that the beet factories should be closed down.

Comment on this

We have too much of that.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey has not been here for the last half hour.

Comment on this

That was a good job for himself.

Comment on this

If he had been here, he would understand and he would not interrupt me. Deputy Morrissey will not say that he wants them closed down but he implies it by his motion. When he was forced to give some answer he said: "Give the farmers more money for their beet."

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Who.

Comment on this

You.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

I am sorry. It was Deputy Keating said that.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

"Give the producer more money for the beet." What is that going to mean? Either we close down the factories and oblige Deputy Morrissey, or we keep them open and make sugar dearer for the public, to oblige Deputy Keating.

Comment on this

When you were in opposition, you wanted to close down the only one we had.

Comment on this

When we were in opposition, we criticised the beet factory then in existence and we proved that we were right by doing what we did when we took it over.

Comment on this

You changed your mind.

Comment on this

We changed the ownership of the factory when we got there.

Comment on this

It is no longer in the hands of the foreigner.

Comment on this

We made it a State-owned concern instead of having it as a privately-owned concern.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

And you substantially reduced the price of wheat.

Comment on this

We got a better price for our beet then, although the factory was supposed to be a white elephant.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I have made my argument clear to the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

You could not make it clear. That is impossible.

Comment on this

Deputy Finlay has only just arrived. He is rather a large man and it would take him a long time to absorb some of my arguments, but I do not think that, as he has only just arrived, he should say that he does not understand it.

Comment on this

I am here long enough, considering your experience of beet and wheat. Your experience of beet or wheat would not get us very far.

Comment on this

A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, is Deputy Briscoe going to be allowed to make his speech? Is it the attitude of Opposition Deputies that nobody on this side of the House is to be allowed to speak without interruption? If they are going to take up the attitude that they will not listen to speeches from this side, then they ought to leave the House.

Comment on this

I was trying to deal with the motion in a manner which I thought would be understood by any person who wanted to understand what our attitude is. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney spoke this afternoon and begged some of us to contribute to the debate, so that we could satisfy him that we were giving the matter consideration in accordance with what we saw, what we heard, and what we felt. I am attempting to do that. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is not here now, because his appeal was made with the same sincerity as that with which this motion was handed in. It was not sincere at all.

Comment on this

What about bacon?

Comment on this

I think I shall leave somebody else to deal with bacon. Deputy Gorey dealt with the bacon situation, and other Deputies also have spoken about it. I am not au fait with the bacon situation, as the Deputy well knows. What I want to find out is, what do the Deputies want? Do they want to take taxes off particular items or off all items? If they want them off particular items, why not say what these items are and be prepared to stand by the consequences with public opinion? Say what you want done, and then take the consequences with public opinion. We are taking the consequences with public opinion by opposing this motion. We are prepared to take the decision, in the face of public opinion, of voting against this motion. The Deputies over there do not want to do that at all. They want to have their cake and eat it. It cannot be done. You must either eat it and be done with it, or you must not eat it and have it.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Some people in this country are eating it and having it at the same time.

Comment on this

I do not know who the "some people" are. If the Deputy will be a little more explicit, perhaps I can deal with his remarks. I can deal only with interjections which have specific relation to specific cases.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy would deal with the motion and not with interjections.

Comment on this

I am sorry, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle. I am not going to take up very much more of the time of the House. I want to say this: I realise my position as a Deputy of the Government Party. I realise that I— if I am selected ever again—or my Party will have to face the electors and ask them for a vote of confidence. I believe we will be returned to office——

Comment on this