We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Standard of Living—Abolition of Duties on Foodstuffs—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 177–337 of 511. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

The Deputy is an optimist.

Comment on this

——but we will have to do it on merit. When we were asking for the responsibility of office we said: "We are prepared to deliver the goods," and I believe we have convinced the people that we are at least attempting to deliver the goods. Deputies over there had their innings. I am not suggesting that Labour will not get here some day, and may not get on better than we have done.

Comment on this

They are preventing you from delivering the goods, according to the Minister.

Comment on this

I want to say that I do not know what the future holds, but I say this: I am convinced that the public generally are not as half-witted as Deputy Morrissey would think them, judging by the introduction of such a motion. The public know what has happened. The big majority of the public know it better than Deputy Morrissey wants to give them credit for. They have better housing facilities and cheaper rents. Does Deputy Morrissey think that has no effect on them? Deputy Morrissey made some very important speeches in this House from those benches over there. If he will look up those speeches he will find that to-day we are living up to what he then said should be done. Yet to-day he is sitting over there and criticising us for what, years ago, he thought should be done. I say that this motion is attempting to include in it the whole policy of Fianna Fáil as compared with the whole policy for which our opponents over there stand. If the Deputies cannot make for this motion a better case than they have made up to the present, if they cannot give this House any concrete statement as to what they think should be done, if they cannot state what items should be removed from the sphere of danger as regards impositions and taxes, I think the best thing they can do is to withdraw the motion from the House and let us get on to more serious business.

Comment on this

There has been a marked reluctance, on the part of those who spoke for the Government on this motion, to deal with the facts of the case as they are presented in the motion. For a number of years here we have been told that we are in the era of an entirely new life for the agricultural community; that the Government's tillage policy and other aids to agriculture have been of such a nature that agriculturists are now in a position vastly superior to what they ever occupied in their lives before. In order to appreciate the value of whatever assistance they gave to the agricultural community, we must examine what sum of money agriculturists have got for their production within the last year or two, and compare it with what they got five or six years ago. I find, according to a Government publication, that the value of agricultural goods consumed or utilised by others in the Saorstát than those who are themselves engaged upon the land amounted to £11,785,000 in 1929-30. That was at a time when what was called the home market was not reserved exclusively for the agricultural community. To put it more shortly, it amounts to approximately £11,750,000. Now, after efforts have been made to conserve the entire home market to the agricultural community, let us see what the value of that has been to them. In 1934-5 the value, according to this Government publication, was £10,064,000. Therefore, it would appear that notwithstanding the fact that you had reserved exclusively to the agricultural community in this country the entire agricultural goods that are consumed in it, we are down £1,750,000. In the following year the figure amounted to £11,207,000.

Deputies opposite, of course, are utterly indifferent to this situation. We listened here for the best part of half an hour to a Deputy who did not give us facts, and who gave us few arguments. The attention we get for this motion is that certain members of the Government Party leave the House when they are hearing unpalatable facts. I am giving the House now no information other than is provided by the Government itself. It shows that this farce of preserving the home market, in so far as it has been worked during those last few years, has resulted in agriculturists getting a smaller sum of money from the nonagricultural community of this country than they got five or six years ago. What has been the cost to the nonagricultural and to the agricultural community of those benefits which we were told were going to rain down upon the entire land of this country as soon as this change over took place? In the last two or three years we have been paying for flour something like 10/- a sack more than the world price for it in Great Britain. We are told there is immense benefit to agriculture. It is not shown by these figures. We are told it has given employment. To how many people? If my recollection is correct, at the time when the Tariff Commission was hearing an application from the flour millers for a tariff on imported flour, the numbers that were going to be put into employment if they got it would not amount to more than 200 over and above the number then employed. Let us put it at a larger figure; we will say that 500 people have been employed. Could they not be employed at a cost to the State of less than £1,500,000 a year? Could you not improve agriculture to any greater extent than is indicated by its receipts from the nonagricultural community showing a reduction in one year of £1,750,000, and in another year of over £500,000.

Is it not the duty of Deputies on this side of the House to quote those facts and bring them before the House? Is it not their duty to criticise the policy of the Ministry that has been responsible for them? I think we would not be worthy of being representatives of the people at all if we did not bring up those matters. What other item is there in respect of which the Government claim to have conferred a benefit on the agricultural community? There is the production of sugar. At what cost to the whole country? The difference in price between the sugar that can be landed on the quays in Dublin or in Cork and the sugar that leaves the factories after manufacture is about £16 a ton. You have 66,000 tons manufactured in those factories. Deputies will find that that amounts to £1,000,000 a year, and that is a concession to the agricultural community. Notwithstanding that concession and whatever advantages are in it, they are getting less in respect of the goods that they sell than they got five years ago. Notwithstanding the fact that they are getting less, we are told that their standard of living has increased; that they are more prosperous; that the country is more prosperous and that it is nonsense to talk about the increased prices they have to pay for flour and sugar. Sugar is costing at least 1½d. a lb. more than what it would cost if it were not for this experiment. Similarly, with regard to bacon, which has cost the taxpayer very considerable sums of money during the last few years. We do not find any improvement in the bulk sum of money that has been got by the agriculturist from the non-agriculturist by reason of these taxes and impositions.

Let us examine another side of the picture. We are told the country is more prosperous, that widows have been paid pensions, that unemployment assistance has been given, that the shilling has been restored to the old age pension. You would expect to find from all these dispensations from the Exchequer that there would be an improvement in the consumption of flour, oatmeal or bacon. What are the facts? The facts, as taken from Government publications, are decidedly interesting. I will deal first of all with the consumption of bacon in the year 1931. That is the year in which complaint is made that old age pensioners were not paid in full; it is the year in which unemployment assistance was not given out and it is the year in which widows and orphans had not yet got pensions. Notwithstanding all this, there was consumed in this country in these bad times a total of 825,844 cwts. of bacon. What was consumed in 1935? The total consumption in that year was 613,014 cwts. The consumption is down by a quarter. Assuming there might be a mistake one year with another, let us see the figure for 1936. The consumption is still down 200,000 cwts. The figure is at 611,000 cwts. We have gone down in the consumption of bacon by 25 per cent. Where 4 lbs. of bacon were bought in 1931, only 3 lbs. were bought for consumption in 1935-1936.

Comment on this

But the food value of the bacon has gone up by 100 per cent. as compared with the imported joss. Does Deputy Cosgrave dispute that?

Comment on this

In that case we should have consumed only 400,000 cwts.

Comment on this

This Government sees that everyone gets his fill—enough to eat.

Comment on this

The fact is that they are getting ¾ lb. of bacon where they used to get 1 lb.

Comment on this

But it is better bacon.

Comment on this

It may be; I am not disputing that. I want now to distinguish between argument and fact. The Deputy introduces an argument. I want to know whether or not the citizen who wants to buy bacon and who has only 8d. with which to buy it, finds it is any advantage to him to know that the ½ lb. of bacon that he will get now for his 8d. would be better than 1 lb. of bacon he could get in other years for the same money. Let the Deputy go and tell that to the people who find it hard enough at the present time to buy a piece of bacon. After all, we should not be speaking here of the benefits of democracy or of the rights of the people to select what they are going to buy and consume if we have a gentleman—no matter how exalted his position or how mayoral his office—saying: "No, sir, you have to be regimented; you have to eat what we direct you to eat; you will be allowed to eat nothing else, and you have to pay the price because we will insist on you paying it." Perhaps they might be told, "If you have not got it, you will go without it."

Comment on this

We say that they do not get joss, anyhow, and it is not a matter of "It is good enough for the Irish."

Comment on this

Of course, the people were quite entitled to vote for the Deputy if they wished to do so. The Irish people have perfect freedom in matters of that sort, but it will probably be found in parts of the country where there is much more Irish blood than there is in the Deputy's veins——

Comment on this

The Deputy is just as Irish as Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

That does not matter. I want to tell the Deputy what the Irish people have a right to do.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite well aware of what the Irish people have done and what they will do.

Comment on this

As regards this 100 per cent. advantage that we are told of, let us examine it from another angle. Irish streaky bacon was sold in mid-August, 1931, at 1/3½ per lb. In mid-August, 1937, it was sold at 1/8¼ per lb., and we are told it is 100 per cent. better.

Comment on this

I disagree.

Comment on this

Well, if the Deputy disagrees he had better go to the Industry and Commerce Department and tell them that what they printed in the Trade Journal in September, 1931, and September, 1937, is wrong.

Comment on this

I handle bacon and I know what the price is.

Comment on this

Irish shoulder bacon, as so recorded, sold at 10½d. per lb. in 1931 and at 1/2¼ in 1937—mid-August. Pigs' heads were sold at 5d. in 1931 and 6d. in 1937. So much for bacon and for the incredulousness of the interrupting Deputy. Our pig trade is such that during the last 12 months something happened in this country that never happened here before. We had to import pigs into a country in which benefits were supposed to be raining down on the farmers, and apparently they could not see them.

With regard to the consumption of flour, in the year 1931 it was 7,196,871 cwts. For 1935 the figure is 7,080,224 cwts. That shows a reduction in consumption of 116,647 cwts. Remember that this is a period in which people are more prosperous, their standard of living has gone up and they are able to buy more. It must be a great source of satisfaction to those who have been unable to buy either flour or bacon to know that there are people in Dublin or in other parts of the country able to buy motor cars who never bought them before.

Comment on this

And perhaps hunting horses.

Comment on this

It should be obvious to the Deputy that there are farmers who have benefited considerably through the Government's policy. They grew their own wheat and beet and gained by so doing.

Comment on this

Let me tell the Deputy who talks about hunting horses that if we have hunting horses we can ride them as well as pay for them. Let me come now to oatmeal. The total production in 1931 was 325,816 cwts. as against 290,751 cwts. in 1935. There is a reduction there of 35,000 cwts. I have dealt now with the price of flour, which has been increased by Government action; I have dealt with the price of sugar, which has been increased by Government action, and I have dealt with the price of bacon, which has been increased by Government action. If Deputies wish they will find in this year's Estimates a sum of £13,000 which is to be expended during the year on machinery which has been set up by an Act passed a few years ago dealing with pigs and bacon, and so on. The receipts in connection with that particular service will amount to something like £16,000. Even in the setting up of machinery, steps are taken to ensure that whoever has got to pay the Government will have a profit out of it. So far as one section of the community is concerned —the agricultural section—it is obvious from the figures I have given that they have less bulk money in respect of the goods they sell in this country than they had five years ago.

Let us examine for a moment how they stand with regard to the expenses of their production. Deputies who were in this House in 1931-32 will remember the agitation that took place for the derating of agricultural land. So much was the Opposition, which is now the Government, impressed with the necessity for relieving the costs of agriculture that they proposed a motion in this House that an agricultural grant, to the amount of £1,000,000, should be made available by the Government for the relief of rates. A sum of £750,000 was provided in the Budget of that year, 1932-33, for that purpose. That amount was denounced as insufficient. In addition to denouncing it, the Party opposite also criticised the taxation imposed to raise it, so that they had the best of both worlds. They said the amount was not enough and, in the second place, that we should not have taxed anybody for what we were giving. In their first year of office, they provided an extra £250,000. That was in 1932-33, but they never did it since. This year, the sum made available in relief of rates on agricultural land is £1,870,000, or £300,000 less than was provided in 1932-33. Whatever may be said in criticism of the policy pursued in 1931-32, in so far as agriculture was concerned, nobody is so foolish as to deny that agriculture was then in a prosperous condition as compared with the condition in which it is now. If Deputies want to test that, they can look up the publications which are issued by the Currency Commission, with which they will be supplied free on application. They will find that the index price for agriculture has gone down during the last few years by about 30 points. After the years pre-1931-32, and in that year, there was an average price of approximately £110 for agricultural goods priced at about £100 in the pre-war years, 1911-13. That price has gone down during the past few years as low as 83.4 and 83.5. The average for last year was about 90.6, so that if there was a case for relieving the rates on agricultural land in 1931-32, there is a far stronger case now. A different view is, however, held on the opposite side. Consequently, farmers are expected to pay more in rates during these bad years than they did five years ago. Of course, five years ago they were being promised that every possible trouble in this country would be settled. Farmers were to get £16 more for every person engaged on the land; taxation was to be reduced; thousands were to be put into employment and so forth. Recently, we were told in this House that farmers had to pay more for their forks, spades, shovels and agricultural machinery and that they had to pay more even for some phosphates. Occasionally, during the course of this debate Deputies on the opposite benches have made miserable contributions and, in trying to combat what has been put down in this motion, have sought to gain a political advantage by saying: "Are you going to close this factory or that factory?" In this Party, we are not making our living out of politics. We have come in here to represent the people and we are going to represent them, no matter what the political disadvantage be. We could still be on the opposite side if we had adopted the same course as Deputies on the opposite side have adopted in this debate or if we used the methods they used to get there. As soon as they got there, they found that a great many things were different from what they had thought.

Is it unreasonable on the part of a farmer to examine the returns of taxes collected, let us say, on forks, shovels and spades during the past few years? If he finds that the Government has collected practically the same amount of taxes on the goods coming in, has he not the right to say that that particular industrial activity has not yet made good? It is one thing to look at the returns and find that £3,000 or £4,000 has been collected on forks or shovels or spades. It is another thing to ascertain the price the farmer has to pay, over and above what he paid five years ago, for goods made in this country. I am quite agreeable to taxing farmers in respect of industrial expansion, properly planned, efficiently conducted and devised towards providing employment for the people, with fair but not exorbitant remuneration for those engaged in the management of these concerns—the boards of directors and others. But the farmers have good cause to complain if they see, year after year, sums of money being collected by the State ostensibly for the purpose of protecting industries but really as a means of raising revenue or for the purpose of subsidising some particular industry at a price which the agricultural industry cannot afford to pay. We were asked if we were going to close up places that were making bolts and nuts. I took out the figures regarding bolts, nuts and iron goods generally for the past few years. There is no improvement. The Government collected last year the same amount as they collected the year before. Has any attention been paid to that aspect of our great industrial expansion. Is it not viewed with a certain amount of indifference, if we were to take the case made by the last speaker, for instance. He practically said: "We must get money." He says that we had to tax tea. I have looked up the returns for tea and there is not a year in which the gentlemen opposite have occupied these benches that they have not collected money on tea. Even up to April of this year they were collecting money on tea.

I should perhaps apologise for not having the figures with regard to bolts and nuts, but, roughly, the position is that we collected something like £60,000 in the year 1935-36 on iron goods and something like the same amount in the following year. Having said so much, I will leave the matter at that, except to say that if Deputies think I have exaggerated in respect of the collection of customs duties on forks, spades, shovels, bolts, nuts, screws, and iron goods, I refer them to the finance accounts, published annually, for the last two or three years. There they can see for themselves whether or not I have exaggerated in that respect.

To come back to the purpose which animated the Government in devising those means of improving the position of farmers and of the farming industry here, Deputy Flinn, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, in the course of the discussion on this motion last week, said, at columns 1086 and 1087 of the Official Debates, 17th November, Volume 69:

"The pressure went on and on and the country did not break, and eventually we reached a condition in which the British Minister for Agriculture in the House of Commons said that he had failed completely, even for the interest of his own agricultural policy, in the efforts he had made. Let us quote Mr. Baldwin. Mr. Baldwin said:

‘We have put on all the taxes we possibly could put upon beef and we have not been able to raise the price in the market'."

We get occasionally comparisons between the price of fat cattle in this country and in Great Britain. The agricultural community in Great Britain had a complaint in respect of the price they were obtaining for fat beef. What position were the farmers in this country in considering that, at that time, something like £5 or £6 a head of a tariff was deducted from the price the farmer got in going into the British market? And that price very largely ruled the price he was getting here. It was said in the course of this debate that a quota had to be put on to help the British beef producers. Once before in this House I gave this information. I am quoting now from what is called Hansard, the Parliamentary Debates (Commons), Volume 292 of July 9th, 1931, page 803. The person speaking was Mr. Elliott, who was Minister for Agriculture. On the Cattle Industry (Emergency Provisions) Bill, he said:

"I will quote merely the case of New Zealand in regard to beef and the United States in regard to pork. New Zealand in the Ottawa year sent 377,000 cwts. of frozen beef. The estimates of the Dominion were that there would be an increase thereafter of 10 per cent. The shipments in 1933 on the basis of the Ottawa year plus 10/- per cent. would have been 414,000 cwts. But the actual shipments in 1933 were 700,000 cwts. In the first half of this year they have been over 500,000 cwts. and there is another 500,000 cwts. still to come."

Just at that particular time, this country was placed upon a quota in respect of supplies of beef and the one country more than any other responsible for the reduction in the exports from this country to Great Britain was New Zealand. New Zealand had made, or had got, a bargain at Ottawa. We had not, and it is to meet situations such as that that the farmers of this country have been plundered during the last five years, that the moneys they have got for what they have had to sell have been enormously reduced and that, in consequence, their purchasing power has been reduced; and it is no satisfaction to them to know that there are 200 or 300 more motor cars being sold in this country each month of this year than there were five years ago.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in speaking on this motion, cited the number of barrels of beer sold and gave the average for this year over and above that of five years ago. I have taken the trouble to reduce these barrels of beer to pints of beer and they would allow 40,000 persons to take an extra pint compared with what they took five years ago. Similarly with regard to spirits. Something like 2,000 persons have been consuming a glass of whiskey which they did not consume five years ago. That is not dealing with this motion. That is simply pointing to the fact that a certain limited number of persons are perhaps better off than they were; but, if you contrast those figures with the fact that our bacon consumption has gone down by a quarter, that we are not even consuming as much bread as we did five years ago and that the cost of bread, bacon, butter and all those other items, by reason of Government impositions, quotas, licences and so on, has increased to the people, there is unquestionably a case for this motion.

During the course of the election, a businessman told me about one article of diet in respect of which a quota had been fixed. He showed me what the price was. It was 2/6 for a certain quantity which, with duties and transit costs, amounting to 1/8, came to 4/2. A quota was imposed and it became the duty of businessmen to buy from the person who had the licence and the price went from 4/- to 7/6, 10/-, 14/-, and the last man had to pay even £1 for that article— onions or something of the kind, I think. What did the farmer get out of that particular cost? I am practically certain he did not get 5/- out of the £1. So it is with every single one of these Government impositions. It has ever been the case where the Government puts on impositions that the ordinary consumers had ultimately to bear the cost of them.

If we are to take the figures given, as to the great improvement in employment, what is being done with the money? They are not putting it into the banks. I have taken out the banking returns, and I find that only at one period during the last ten years have the deposits in the banks been so low as in September, 1937. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us that the average deposits in the Post Office Savings Bank are higher than they were three, four or five years ago, let us examine what is inferred from that. Normally one would say that it means greater prosperity. The average lodgments of money in banks are no indication whatever of the prosperity either of the individual or of the country as a whole. If you want to get a real figure as regards savings, you have to get the account at the end of the year and compare it with another year. One gentleman has drawn my attention to the fact that though his income is £600 a year, his bank lodgments total something like £6,000 a year. I can quite understand that. Business transactions of one sort or another take place, and there are lodgments and withdrawals, and so on.

Twelve months ago, or on the Budget for 1936-37, the Minister for Finance gave figures representing three different institutions, the Post Office, the Savings Banks, and Savings Certificates, and compared them with what they were five years ago. I have taken the trouble to take out these figures. There was something like £13,000,000 in the Post Office in Savings Certificates or Trustee Savings, in 1931-32. That amount had grown to £18,000,000 in the year ending 31st March, 1936. One would say that it appeared as if they had done better in the last five years than in the first ten. The fact is that the last five years had the advantage of the accumulated interest of the £13,000,000, whereas we had to start from scratch, and we did not start on the 31st March, 1922. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance made very light of our adverse trade balance, which now amounts to over £20,000,000. It cannot be dismissed so lightly. He said in the course of the discussion that a country might be very prosperous, might be importing considerable quantities of goods, might have an adverse balance of £100,000,000, and still be rich. In the course of the discussion we have been occasionally reminded— I think it was by the Minister for Industry and Commerce—that he had no use for any book on economics. These are not the exact words he used, but something like that. He said that if Deputies consulted well-known books on economics they would find out this, that and the other. I noticed that when Deputy Norton was speaking down the country during the week-end he referred slightingly to a gentleman called Micawber. Micawber laid down a rule in economics that I think neither Stuart Mill, Locke, or any of the other authorities can dispute. It was a very simple rule. I am not giving the exact words. It was: "Income £1, expenditure 19/11, peace and happiness. Income £1, expenditure £1 and one penny, misery—ultimate misery."

We have been living during the last five years on a very big expenditure of public money. If the income of the people was equal to the taxation imposed, very well; if not, very bad. Obviously, no documents can refute the returns we got concerning the income of the agricultural community during that time. It has catastrophically declined. Have we got compensations on the other side? We have not. I venture to say, as I said during the general election, that, comparing 1931-32 with 1936-37, on our export of eggs alone we lost more money than is paid in wages in all the industries started over the entire country. It is our desire to see any industrial activity started in this country succeed. We are particularly anxious that it should succeed, because we were long enough on the opposite benches to realise that any loss sustained by the country, particularly any big loss, will ultimately react on every section of the community. Unfortunately, it always strikes most severely those least able to bear it. The poorest always suffer. In all the examples that have taken place of inflation of currency, those most affected and hardest hit were the poorest of the people, so that we have a particular interest in seeing that there will be no national loss.

We cannot look on, year after year, with the adverse trade balance going to practically £20,000,000, without reflecting that that cannot continue indefinitely. When we examine our sterling balances to-day, we find a reduction, so that it is obvious we have been trading on our reserves. While our dead weight of debt has increased, our deposits are diminishing. Our reserves have diminished. That is a situation, apart altogether from the terms of the motion, that the Government would be very well advised to consider, having regard to the fact that five years ago they considered the agricultural community required much more relief, in respect of rates, than was given them at that time. Matters have not improved during the last five years. The principal cause is the trouble we are in with regard to the export of agricultural produce, and the sooner the Government realises that the better it will be for them and for the country. The expedients of growing sugar beet, wheat, of subsidising tobacco, and all the other items are merely shillings instead of pounds. We are losing pounds in connection with this question, and until they take the advice that was given them from these benches more than once—to settle the economic war—so long will prices continue what they are, so long will consumption be reduced, the standard of living lowered, and the people taxed beyond their resources.

Comment on this

In reading over the motion before the House I had a good deal of difficulty in understanding what was the motive underlying the proposal contained in it. Until I listened this evening to Deputy Fitzgerald Kenney and Deputy Cosgrave, I must say that not only had I difficulty in understanding what the proposal meant, but I felt that if I were to interpret it, as I find it printed before me, I should say that it was one that would give rise to serious misgiving amongst the community generally. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney stated that until we got free entry into the British market, by means of sensible negotiation, serious conditions would continue to prevail here. That, probably, gave me some insight to the real motive underlying this proposal, which reads:

That the Dáil deplores the lowering of the standard of living of the community by Government action through the operation of taxes, levies, duties and like impositions on foodstuffs and other necessaries of life, and is of opinion that all such impositions should be forthwith abolished.

If Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's real purpose is to get back to the British market by sensible negotiation, it is quite obvious that what he considers sensible negotiation is a reduction of, or the destruction of, every tariff and protection that makes it possible for industry to exist here, thereby handing back, as a bargaining asset, to the British a market here for their industrial products. That is to be the return, according to him, for the free entry which he assumes we will get for our farm products in the British market. If that is the real purpose behind this motion, then I say it is a matter of serious consequence for everybody in this country. We have to understand that, while our people had for generations been looking forward to, and working for, the freedom of their country that they had in mind not merely national freedom, not merely freedom in name, but that all sensible people always understood that to maintain national freedom it was necessary also to endeavour to secure economic freedom. What we find proposed here is a departure from all the theory and philosophy of what freedom really meant. In effect, it amounts to this: "Give back to an outside country the economic control of our affairs." What sort of freedom would we have left under these conditions?

Remember that all the magnificent benefits which the Opposition Party seem to think will accrue the moment that we get the right of free entry into the British market were ours for generations. The Act of Union, passed over 100 years ago, was heralded by its advocates as calculated to bring wonderful possibilities to the whole community in Ireland at that time— union with England, with all the advantages of that great progressive nation and empire and all its possibilities. In actual practice it was found that the benefits which were promised did not reach our people. What happened was that decay persisted during the whole period of the Union. Members of the House who had anything to do with the farming industry will remember that prior to 1921, except during the boom periods of the war, free entry into the British market did not bring prosperity and opulence to the farming community. It did not give the farmer opportunities to provide for himself or his family. The only advantage that the right of free entry to the British market gave to our people was to continue in a state of mere existence. In most cases the members of the farming community were unable to provide for their families. If it were not for the fact that America offered the possibility of favourable opportunities for the members of our surplus population who might go there and, as a result of their industry, send home fairly large sums of money to their people, the latter would not have been able to get an economic existence even though they had a free entry for their products to the British market.

If the main purpose of the Opposition is to do all the things that they set out in the motion for the purpose of reducing the cost of living, then I can see very serious consequences arising from it. If we are to sell our whole economic freedom merely for the purpose, at the moment, of reducing the cost of living, then surely it is quite consistent that we should go further in this motion and say: "Stop all industrial undertakings; stop all building concerns in this country, because every bounty given for the building of houses is a lien on the cost of living; stop paying the unemployed because that is an imposition that increases the cost of living; cut away the widows' and orphans' pensions because that is a lien on the cost of living; reduce, at least, the old age pensions because that is an increase on the cost of living: destroy all these things and do away with every social service that we are providing for the people. Do all these things for the one purpose of reducing the cost of living, because, in the opinion of the Deputies opposite, the cost of living is of much more importance than economic national freedom or the provision of social services for the people of this State. Having attained all that, we get a free entry into the great British market.

I would like to ask the Deputies opposite if they have examined the possibilities of that market. Have they gone to the people who are in a position to negotiate that free entry, and made arrangements to ensure that the things that they conceive as probable will become a reality? Having destroyed the industries that are here, and made available to the full the market that is here for British manufacturers, have they made arrangements by which the British Government will undertake, over a period of years, to give to our farmers a guaranteed price for the products they will have to sell? Have they got such an assurance from the British Government?

If it is their intention to destroy all that has been done and is being done under the economic policy of the present Government, surely it is reasonable to ask them to tell us what substitute they have ready to put in its place. According to the motion, we are now going to put everything on this altar of a low cost of living. We have reached the stage when we are going to produce nothing only agricultural products, because, under this proposal, every form of bounty on agricultural production must be set aside. We must stop the growing of wheat, barley and oats because the bounties paid on their production increases the cost of living. We must stop the growing of beet and the production of milk. We must stop the export of everything upon which a bounty is paid because the bounties increase the cost of living. There must be a drop in the prices paid for pigs and butter. In a word, we must go out of production of all these essentials. Instead of that, we are going to buy in the cheapest possible markets. Where are they to be found? England will not sell us wheat: she does not grow it. We will have to get it from Canada or elsewhere, and say to these countries, in effect: "We have come to make a deal with you; we are not going to be in competition with you; we are going to buy from you, and we will make a bargain with you." How can you make that bargain, and for what period of time; and what guarantee have you that, once our farmers have gone out of production, the price may not be very much higher than at the present time? That is the case with regard to wheat, and it is a similar case with regard to other items. Can you go to the producers of other commodities in, let us say, England—which country, I assume, would be the principal people you would be dealing with, from the nature of things—and say to them: "Now that we have stopped production in the Free State, will you make a bargain with us, and for what period of years will you continue the bargain?" Of course, it will have to be a cheap price; and, of course, you will say to them that, no matter what the cost of their production is —with this N.C., or this N.O.C., or whatever is this new tax that the British have put on—you are not prepared to pay a war tax, apart from the tax that the British need for protective purposes for their own commodities. Are you going to buy all these things from the British producers and to pay for these things to British industrialists? If you do not buy them there, I presume you will buy them from Japan and other countries that will be able to produce these goods at a fraction of the cost that the British industrialists can produce them at. If you do that, it is probable that England will not make the bargain with you that you want to make.

In proposing this motion, I suggest that you are making a proposal of far-reaching consequences. Where is your bargain or your plan? Surely we are entitled to ask: What do you propose as against this scheme of ours? One would imagine that it was only here that prices had increased. Only recently, the United States of America agreed to set up a commission of inquiry into prices there, and they were alarmed to find that retail prices had increased, since 1933, by 42 per cent. With regard to England, I cannot give you the exact percentage, but nobody will deny that the prices of commodities have gone up there: and is not this motion here just one more item in that ramp that you people, over there, have been trying to carry on for political purposes? Is there one little bit of sincerity underneath the motion—any of it? Is it not all a piece of political propaganda? I do not believe that the motion itself has been considered for one moment. Has it not been considered only from the point of view of whether or not it was feasible to get some political propaganda out of it?

I thought, when Deputy Cosgrave rose to speak here, that, at least, we would have some responsible statement made on this motion. Instead of that, Deputy Cosgrave started off by endeavouring to quote for us the amount of money that farmers received for their produce last year as compared with what they received in the years 1928 and 1929. Is not that a piece of cheap buffoonery?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair objects to the word "buffoonery" being used in reference to a Deputy.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir, I withdraw the expression. However, Deputy Cosgrave knows the position very well with regard to the prices paid for the produce of the farmers in these years; but he then goes on to show that the amount of food-stuffs purchased in the Free State in the last five years has been reduced considerably. Amongst the items he mentioned were flour and bacon, but he must know perfectly well that the reduction, or the apparent reduction, in those commodities, is not due to the fact that the people are consuming less of these commodities, but that the farmer is now, so to speak, less of a shopkeeper than he was, and that the farmer is producing more wheat and grinding more of it and so on. The Deputy must know that the same applies to bacon. That was not a very good case for the Deputy to make. I suggest that it was just a cheap point, but that it is consistent with the purpose of this whole motion, which is for nothing else but political propaganda.

Now, when we go in for the production of this cheap food supply, and when we have put out of production all the people who are now engaged in tillage and the people who are engaged at the moment in industrial production—when we put all these people out of production as a result of this cheap food policy and put them on the dole —when we stop housing activities and so on—all in the interest of cheap living—what will be our position? Do we assume that these people can live by going around watching farmers getting fat on cattle production? I think we will have to go further. I think that cattle will have to be produced here more cheaply, and that will mean that we will have to acquire large ranches where the cost of producing cattle can be reduced to the minimum. That, of course, means that the small farmers must go, and then what is to become of them? When we have driven our people into that situation, as a result of this cheap food and low prices campaign, I suppose the Opposition will say, if people protest against it, that that is the voice of Communism, and I suppose they will send their secret emissaries around the country to the various churches, as they have done before, trying to have crushed out every outspoken voice on behalf of the people. That is what this scheme would lead to if the country were foolish enough to put it into operation or if you were seriously to put it into operation.

This motion calls for the removal of every tax, levy, and imposition on everything relating to foodstuffs. When Deputies are casting their vote on the motion or seriously considering it, I suggest to those Deputies, who are clear-minded and are in a position clearly to interpret the national mind and the national wants of the people, to consider this: that the best service they could give to the people of the country would be to remove the greatest imposition with which the people are afflicted—a group of politicians who are unscrupulous enough to put up a propaganda scheme like this to waste the time of the Dáil in discussing it with the full knowledge that, if it were adopted, it would mean the destruction of the whole economic life and independence of this country. I hope those who are capable of clear thinking and who know the wants of the people of the country will consider it from the angle from which I have put it to you, and I am perfectly sure the public want you to do that, and are tired of impositions.

Comment on this

We have heard something from Deputy Maguire with regard to the fight for national and economic freedom. I ask Deputy Maguire, or any other Fianna Fáil Deputy, does he seriously think that he has more national freedom under the Fianna Fáil policy than he had under the previous policy? Are we not every year compromising with that great enemy, as I suppose Deputy Maguire thinks, the British Empire? Since Fianna Fáil came into office have we each year compromised with them in order that they will take our live stock and live-stock products? Did we not compromise with them even with regard to coal, although the Fianna Fáil Government had a turf scheme and we were previously asked to burn more turf, and the cry was: "Burn everything British but coal"? What is the policy of Fianna Fáil to-day: "Burn no other coal but British coal: you need not burn turf; burn coal."

Deputy Maguire must have a very short memory if he has forgotten the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce about a week ago. What did the Minister say at that locked-up meeting? The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that only agricultural exports can save this country. Deputy Maguire asks what price are we going to pay for our exports to Great Britain. Until the economic war started no price had to be paid. When Fianna Fáil tried to get alternative markets, how far did they get? That is clear proof that there is only one market. I will just give Deputy Maguire a few figures. Our total exports in 1931 amounted to £36,340,000 and of these £34,985,000 worth went to Great Britain and Northern Ireland. In 1936 our exports were reduced to £22,504,000 and of these £20,000,000 worth went to Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Is that the market upon which Deputy Maguire does not agree with the Minister for Industry and Commerce? If we go over the live stock and other exports from this country it is plain to be seen that we have only one market for them. Even without that statistical abstract, it has been proved years ago by the present Government that there is only one market for our exports.

Dealing with the country itself, we have heard from Fianna Fáil Deputies that the cost of living is not going up. We have heard from Deputy Maguire that we are out to close up factories in this country. He believes that it is necessary for economic freedom to have those factories going. If he looks it up he will find that most of the raw material that we import from a so-called enemy country goes to keep those factories going. How much of the steel-work used by our farmers and used in the building of houses do we produce here? Do we produce any?

Comment on this

Would you blame us for the increased cost you are paying for it?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the Deputy's statement that our policy was to close these factories. That is not so. But we have no economic freedom in these factories, because we are importing the raw materials from a foreign country and all we do in most of these factories is to assemble that material. You have only to go down the country to see the conditions under which the farmers are living and the expense they are under. If you go to the small towns in which they deal you will find the differences to-day in the price of a sack of flour as compared with Northern Ireland. The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated here some years ago that his idea was to decentralise industry here. What is he doing at present? Is he not centralising industry in this country? Has he not mentioned in the Dáil that when the small millers down the country do over-milling of the farmers' wheat he is prepared to extract penalties from them? I know a small farmers' mill which was recently fined £83 for over-milling the wheat of the farmers who were the owners of that mill. Although they applied for an increased quota they were fined that sum in the court. That was done in order to stop that mill from milling the farmers' wheat and in order to stop the farmers from getting their flour at 14/- per sack less than they could get it from a Limerick mill. Does that not show that the cost of living has gone up? Is it not shown by the increase in the cost of flour amounting to from 10/- to 12/-. a sack? I know another mill run by private enterprise which was fined £70 for over-milling farmers' wheat, which was known to be millable wheat. That is the position we have in the milling industry.

Then let us take the farm implements which are used in this country. We are not producing them in this country and we know what the cost of them is. Everyone knows that the cost has increased very much within the last few years. Everyone knows that last year copper sulphate for the spraying of potatoes went up by 100 per cent. Yet we are told that the cost of living has not gone up. I mentioned in the Dáil some months ago that a clergyman in the West of Ireland had to appeal for help to a children's society in order to provide the children there with clothes. Is it not a fact that in that same district in the West of Ireland the only daily meal that the children got for a number of months was the school meal given to them? Then we are told that the standard of living has not gone down. Take the egg industry which is, at the present time, practically the biggest industry in this country. The bounty on eggs at present practically amounts to ½d. per egg. What is the reason for that? Has not the farmer and the taxpayer to pay that ½d. per egg? Why is it that, in order to export our eggs, we have to pay practically a ½d. per egg? I think it is time to cry halt. We are told here that the Government has done quite a lot for the working man. I admit that working men have good houses and that in rural districts these houses are let at a reasonable rent, but what is the use of a good house, even at a reasonable rent in winter time, if there is no fire in that house? What use are houses if the occupiers are not in a position to pay even for fuel for these houses? I may be reminded by some other speakers that we have a good industry in the West of Ireland in the beet industry. I know that the beet industry gives a fair amount of employment but does the production of beet pay the producer at the price he is at present getting? Does it pay the producer when the average yield per acre is eight tons and when the price is 37/6 per ton at the factory? In some cases I know that the freight on beet ranges from 10/4 to 11/3 per ton. Does that pay the producer, a net yield of £1 7s. per ton or something like £11 per acre? I ask any of those farmers on the Fianna Fáil benches, does that pay the producer?

Comment on this

Would it pay them better if you removed protection from the sugar industry?

Comment on this

I am speaking for the producer and I am trying to prove to you that his cost of living has increased. He has to pay more for his bag of flour and more for machinery and then for an acre of beet all he receives at the present time in some parts of County Galway is £11.

Comment on this

You are making the case that he is not getting enough of money out of his acre of beet?

Comment on this

I am making the case that he is only getting £11 per acre out of beet.

Comment on this

Would he be better off if the factory were closed down?

Comment on this

If he had only to pay the wage which the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance thinks sufficient for labourers, namely, £1 4s. per week, that acre of beet would cost him £13 to produce.

Comment on this

You are making the case for giving him a better price?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And still you ask that we should remove the tariff.

Comment on this

You could give him some of the increased profits of the sugar company, who are profiteering at a rate by which they hope to get back their capital in seven years.

Comment on this

Is your argument not in favour of reducing the tax on sugar and still you say the farmers are not getting enough for their beet? You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

A halfpenny per lb. on sugar may mean a lot, but the farmer is certainly entitled to be paid for his time.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I believe that he could be paid a better price by taking some of the profits away from the sugar company instead of enabling them to recover their capital in seven years, as some of the other factories have done.

Comment on this

But the Deputy is trying——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have to put his remarks in connected form. He will have ample opportunity of contributing to the debate if he so desires.

Comment on this

We have another industry in the West of Ireland, a bagmaking industry. For the information of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I may say that in connection with the potato industry, both for certified seed and for the main crop, we use from 700,000 to 800,000 bags per annum. We have factories in Dublin and in the West of Ireland for the making of these bags, but, strange to say, the majority of the bags which are marked Irish Free State and exported with potatoes from Galway port, come from Dundee.

Comment on this

They are assembled in Galway.

Comment on this

They are not even assembled there. They are going with Irish Free State seed from Galway port to the Canary Islands and other places.

Comment on this

That is a very serious statement you are making.

Comment on this

I make it, and I will stand over it.

Comment on this

I hope you will—it will be examined.

Comment on this

It has been examined already.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

It will be examined again.

Comment on this

The Minister knows it, and his Department knows it. The Fianna Fáil Party have learned many things during the last four or five years, but they have still to learn a good deal more. One of their first aims was to decentralise industry. Now, you have to import flour for biscuits while the smaller millers are having more penalties extracted from them for over-milling. As regards the bag industry, the firm is being controlled by another big firm, and Fianna Fáil Deputies know that as well as I do. A good deal of capital has been made out of the increase in tillage since Fianna Fáil came into office. Deputy Maguire told us about the great number put into employment as a result of the increase in tillage, but he did not mention anything about the 60,000 or 70,000 who have gone to England.

Comment on this

Or the 250,000 who emigrated during your term of office.

Comment on this

In 1928 the total acreage under corn and root crops was 1,529,932, while in 1936 the acreage was 1,621,235, showing an increase of only 132,303 acres. In 1928 the area under wheat was 31,350 acres, while in 1936 the area was 254,521, showing an increase in the acreage of 223,171 acres. Although in all root and grain crops you had only an increase of 132,303 acres, in the case of wheat you had an increase of 223,171 between 1928 and 1936.

Comment on this

Why not take the acreage in 1931?

Comment on this

I am taking 1928 and 1936.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because I got them here.

Comment on this

Take 1931.

Comment on this

I think I had enough trouble in getting 1928 and 1936. If we take 1928, you had 16,624 acres of beet and in 1936 you had 61,491, that is an increase of 44,863 acres. In all, taking the subsidised crops, wheat and beet, you had an increase of 268,038 acres. All over the whole Free State, in the other crops that are not subsidised you had an increase of only 132,000 acres, so that you have practically no increased tillage in this country under the Fianna Fáil policy. I say you have no increased tillage, because the growing of beet and wheat has been substituted for other crops which we think were just as valuable for the farmer. In regard to beet, I mentioned a figure of eight tons to the acre, and although some people may say it was the beet fly or the mangold fly that ruined the crop, I think the real fact was that there was not sufficient nutrition for the soil. I think it is the opinion of farmers in the West of Ireland that in order to have continued cropping of their land they must have farmyard manure.

We now come to the question of live stock. I think that no matter what Government action is taken in the stopping of the production of live stock, it will continue in spite of it, as some figures here show. In spite of the slaughter of calves throughout the country under the present régime, in 1931 you had 4,029,000 cattle in the country, and in 1936 you had 4,014,000. Even with all the cattle that were slaughtered, there was a decrease in the five years of only 15,000 head of cattle in the country. Now we will go back to pig production in this country. We all know that pig production has been a great industry. It has brought a good deal of money to the country. It gave a good deal of employment. In 1931 you had 1,227,000 pigs in the country, and in 1936 you had 1,016,512 pigs, that is a reduction of 210,491 pigs in that period. In 1931 you had 3,575,379 sheep, and in 1936 you had 3,061,512, a decrease of 513,867. If you take horses, even with the greatly increased tillage we hear of from the Fianna Fáil Benches time after time, in 1931 you had 449,697 horses in the country, while in 1936 you had only 423,529, that is a reduction of 26,168 horses inside five years. If we take 1931 as compared with 1935, there were 30,000 less horses in 1935, with your so-called increased tillage, than in 1931. When you had 30,000 less horses in this country, you must certainly have had a big number less employed in agriculture in the country. Taking poultry, in 1931 you had 22,782,229, and in 1936 you had 20,311,749.

Comment on this

What is it in 1937, I wonder?

Comment on this

There was, therefore, a decrease in poultry in this country of 2,470,480—practically 2,500,000—inside five years. I do not think it necessary for me to go any further. Taking the cost of living, it will be found that the rates in practically every county are increasing each year. Why are they increasing? They are increasing because there are more charges from the different institutions. I have been reading over an estimate for an institution in the West of Ireland. Last year the estimate was £7,000; this year it is £9,000 —an increase of £2,000.

The answer which the secretary gave to his members regarding the increase was that it was due to the increased cost of living and the cost of materials for the inmates of that particular institution. I believe that the number put into employment in industries in this country does not compensate for the increased cost of living. I firmly believe that some change should be brought about. The one change that I believe is necessary for this country is that there should be an end of that foolish—I say it is nothing else —economic war which was certainly started by the present Government. I say it is foolish because there is no need for it. If that was once cleared off from this country we would have a chance of free exports.

Comment on this

And free imports.

Comment on this

Imports of what?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Bread, bacon, and so on.

Comment on this

The bacon trade was on before he was born.

Comment on this

Free imports of steel? Have we steel in this country? Are we not making penknives from Sheffield steel in this country?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Unfortunately.

Comment on this

Are we not making razor blades from it? When the Deputy and the Fianna Fáil Party have left——

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Wait and see.

Comment on this

I do not think it would harm the industrial policy of the Government in any way whatever if the economic war finished, for this reason, that I firmly believe the present Government has not given sufficient attention to the natural resources of this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

That speaks badly for the Deputy's Party.

Comment on this

There is a number of slate quarries in this country. Why are they not worked? If you put up a building to-day you cannot get an Irish slate for it. What is the idea of importing cement from Belgium to roof the houses of this country?

Comment on this

What were the Deputy's Party doing for ten years?

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Congratulations! The Deputy is being converted.

Comment on this

Why not develop the slate quarries which are here? For the roofing of the houses that you pride yourselves so much on, the cement for those tiles is imported from Belgium, the dye is imported from Germany, and the steel work in which they are cased is imported from Britain, while you have slate quarries idle throughout the country. I hope that this motion in the name of Deputy Morrissey will be accepted by the Government. If it is accepted by the Government, I believe you will have what Deputy Maguire calls greater economic freedom. If accepted, it will be a step in the right direction.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

You will certainly have greater free trade freedom.

Comment on this

I spent some time reading the debates on this motion and I have had the pleasure of listening to Deputy Brodrick, who made a speech which was rather typical of the speeches on the Opposition side. His speech was partly in favour of the motion and partly against, but I would be inclined to think it was mostly against. Many of the points Deputy Brodrick made were ones that could be made from this side, in opposition to the motion. Indeed, similar points were made by some of the speakers on this side. Deputy Brodrick wound up his speech with a plea for the development of our slate quarries. He pointed out that the tiles used as a substitute to roof houses were composed of foreign materials such as cement and dyes. He made a plea for self-sufficiency, which we often hear condemned on other occasions by Deputies on the opposite benches. The Deputy talked of the low prices the farmers are getting for beet, and he said that even if sugar were to be increased by ½d. a lb. what about it; was not the farmer entitled to it?

Comment on this

Why not reduce the profits and let the farmers benefit?

Comment on this

The Deputy selected the one foodstuff, so far as I can recollect, that there is a duty on coming into this country. There is an excise duty on sugar imported, and it is the only foodstuff imported on which there is a duty. Deputy Brodrick said that duty was not high enough and we should put another ½d. a lb. on it, so that the farmers could derive some benefit. All the time he was speaking in favour of the motion and, no doubt, will vote for it. He made one of the most telling points against the motion, and he went further than any Deputy on this side would be prepared to go.

Comment on this

My main point was that the farmer should get more for his beet out of the profits.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would examine the balance sheets of the beet company and take all the profits made for the last couple of years and add them to the price of beet, it would mean a very small increase for the farmers. When Deputy Brodrick makes a point like that, it indicates that he is in a difficulty. He wants the farmers to get more for their beet. We all do. He wants to support the motion that there should be no increase in taxation, but the only suggestion he can offer to satisfy the farmers, and make the best case he can for this ridiculous motion, is that the farmers should get more out of the profits. If the Deputy takes all the profits and distributes them amongest the Galway farmers and tells them he has succeeded in getting this increased price for beet, they will not be very thankful, because there will not be much money to distribute.

The Deputy goes on to tell us that we are paying a bounty of ½d. on every egg that goes out of the country. When Deputies of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are in a difficulty, they do not make any suggestions; they merely make statements. Deputy Brodrick made the usual statement that one would expect from a Cumann na nGaedheal speaker. He said: "It is time to cry a halt." That is the sort of expression we always get from Cumann na nGaedheal. They never suggest that we stop paying bounties, because that might not suit certain voters in, for example, Deputy Brodrick's constituency. You never hear Deputies over there saying the farmers are getting too much for their eggs or for anything else. We always hear the cry that the farmers are not getting sufficient and they should get more, and we are told that it is time to cry a halt.

Comment on this

Let the farmer do just as he wishes and he will not need any bounty.

Comment on this

That is the sort of solution we get from Deputies opposite—"It is time to cry a halt." The Deputy talked about sacks coming in from Dundee. I do not know if that is true, but I will not doubt the Deputy's word. I do not believe that he would say it if he did not consider it was true. His suggestion is that all the sacks required could easily be made in Athenry or some such town, and they would be used by the Irish farmers, and there could be good wages paid to the workers in Athenry.

Comment on this

I believe if the industry were encouraged there that the sacks could be manufactured and sold at practically the same price.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy would like to see good wages paid. So far as having sacks made at Athenry is concerned, we may presume that if this Athenry firm were to make all the sacks they would have to charge a little more, the farmer would pay a little more, and that would be the solution. I merely take those points as examples of the types of speeches we get from the Opposition side. To my mind they are speeches largely against the motion. I really have come to the conclusion that Deputies on the opposite benches do not know what the motion is about. Whoever drafted the motion does not seem to know what it is about. It is really very vague and nobody seems to know what it means. The fact is that most Deputies who have spoken did not confine themselves to the motion at all. They usually ended with a flourish like Deputy Brodrick, telling us to stop the economic war, as if that had anything to do with taxes and levies and impositions.

Another point that Deputy Brodrick mentioned was in reference to subsidised crops. How does he distinguish between the subsidised and the nonsubsidised crops? What is the difference between wheat and barley? Wheat is allowed in free, but barley is not, and, therefore, wheat is not as subsidised as barley. The Deputy could truthfully say that barley is a subsidised crop. We do not allow barley or oats in free of duty. For that matter, turnips is a subsidised crop because you cannot import turnips into this country unless you pay 8d. a lb. by way of duty.

Comment on this

Who wants to import turnips?

Comment on this

I know we do not want turnips; that is why we put a high duty on them. All this gives one an idea of the sort of loose talk that Deputies over there go on with. This is a motion that deals with taxes, and levies and duties and then, for fear they might miss anything, they mention impositions. What is an imposition? This motion is an imposition, if you like, but what an imposition is in that connection as set out in the motion, I do not know. I should like to know what the Deputies opposite regard as an imposition. They deplore the lowering of the standard of living. Deputy Brodrick referred to the standard of living, but almost every other speaker on his side spoke about the increased cost of living, which is not mentioned here at all. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, early in the debate, talked about the standard of living and quoted plenty of figures giving the source every time. With all the speakers we have since heard, we have not had a single thing contradicted that the Minister mentioned in the course of his statement. I heard Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney say that, whatever the figures might show, they all knew that the standard of living is going down. There is no use in trying to convince those people. It evidently does not suit their policy to be convinced on this point. Whatever the figures may show, it suits Fine Gael to believe that the standard of living is going down and they must maintain that. They bring in a motion assuming straight away that the standard of living has gone down. They have no proof of that but they say that everybody believes that it is gone down. What is the meaning of this expression "by Government action"? That is a thing about which I complained already to-day. In most cases, these things were done by the Dáil. I have here a list of tariffs imposed on agricultural imports. Everyone of these as put on in this House, all Parties agreeing. I do not remember that they were ever put to a vote. After all Parties have agreed to the imposition of a tariff, Deputies opposite come along and say that Government action is lowering the standard of living.

The motion refers to "taxes, levies, duties and like impositions." What is the difference between these? There is a difference between a levy and a tax and between a levy and a duty, but "tax" and "duty" are used very often in the same sense. What are the levies on foodstuffs at present? I do not know of any. I have not heard any mentioned by any member of the Opposition who spoke on this motion. But, as I pointed out, they did not speak to the motion. They did not talk of "taxes, levies, duties and like impositions"; they talked about the economic war and Newfoundland. There are no levies, so far as I know. I may be forgetting something but I should be very glad if any member of the Opposition would remind me. I do not know of any levy on any foodstuff at present. Therefore, there is no necessity to bring in a motion to have it removed. There are import duties on practically all the foods we produce here, such as beef, mutton, bacon, eggs, vegetables and fruit. But not a single member of the Opposition who spoke would suggest, that any one of these duties should be removed. If I were to put it to Deputies opposite that we should remove a particular tax, they, knowing that it does not make any difference what they say, might reply: "Remove it." But if they were asked to give their opinion conscientiously as to whether that duty should be removed or not, I am certain they would say: "Do not remove that duty because it should be maintained for the protection of the agriculturist." They have not suggested a single duty for removal, but they have introduced a general motion, and they go on talking, not about the motion, but about things that have nothing to do with it. When the question comes to be decided, they will gaily walk into the lobby and vote for a motion that they know would, if passed, be ruinous to this country. That does not worry them. It gives them an opportunity to make a speech about something else, and that is all they want.

All these duties and levies are, according to the motion, to be "forthwith abolished." I shall give the House a list of what we are to abolish forthwith if this motion is passed, but I shall deal with the motion more generally in the first instance. Nobody could expect this motion to be in any way intelligible or well thought-out. Before the Dáil had met at all after the general election, we had five motions circulated by Fine Gael. Why were they in such a hurry? I suppose they were afraid that the Labour Party would get in before them. They had motions put down dealing with the standard of living, rates, Civil Service arbitration and some other subjects which they wanted to talk about, and yet they did not know at that time what Government was going to be elected. They did not know that they were going to be in opposition. All they knew was that, if they were not quick, Labour might get in before them with these motions. They did not take time to draft the motions properly. They did not know what they were asking and, not knowing what they were asking, they talked about something else when this motion came to be discussed. Yet, when the motion is put, they will vote for it.

I read this debate right through. I started with Deputy Morrissey's speech, and the only thing I could mark as worthy of comment was this statement:—

"The Government fixes a guaranteed price for wheat, irrespective of what the world price is, and the miller is given full power here to get that increase, whatever it may be, out of the consumer of the flour or bread."

That is the sort of statement one would expect from Deputy Morrissey, who would make a statement regardless of the real facts—a good statement for his purpose, a statement to go down with his own followers throughout the country, who do not examine the facts and who are inclined to swallow that sort of propaganda. The fact is that our Irish wheat this year did not put any additional expense on the miller because it was bought, to the extent of 25 per cent., roughly at the world price of wheat and made good bread, although Deputy Gorey would hardly agree with that. I am judging from Deputy Gorey's speech.

Comment on this

You have only to look at me to know whether I am eating it or not.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey's speech suggested that everything of Irish manufacture was inferior.

Comment on this

I do not say any such thing.

Comment on this

I shall quote from the Deputy's speech later. He is not the only one on that side who has an inferiority complex and who believes that anything that comes from England is better than that which can be produced at home. Deputy Morrissey says that the cash prices of boots and shoes are being kept down but the quality is not being kept up. When we produce figures to prove, so far as it can be proven by figures, that Deputies on the other side are wrong, that the prices of boots and shoes here are not higher than they were before the tariffs were imposed and not higher than they are in England or Northern Ireland, they turn round and say the quality is inferior. Deputy Gorey said that the uppers were all right but that the soles were soft. That is a damning form of praise, because a boot is not worth much without a sole.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

That is the sort of statement we get from Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Gorey. When it is proven that they are wrong, they say that the quality is inferior.

Comment on this

The prices are not the same, and you know it.

Comment on this

No matter what one says, they will find a way out.

Comment on this

The uppers were right before you were heard of.

Comment on this

There were good boots before I was born and will be after I am gone, but that has nothing to do with this motion. I do not think that Deputy Morrissey made any other statement worthy of comment. He was the mover of the motion, and we were anxious to ascertain what lead he would give and what he would suggest should be done. He talked about the price of coal, bad boots and so on, but he gave no suggestion whatever as to what should be done. He gave the general impression in his speech that he believed tariffs were bad for this country, but he did not go further than that. He merely gave that impression, but he made sure not to name any particular tariff that should be taken off, and no Deputy has so far done so. When he was asked to name an article which had definitely gone up in price and in respect of which he could show profiteering, the only article he could give was castor oil.

Deputy Linehan seconded the motion and, in his case, I again looked for some inspiration, some indication of what Fine Gael would like us to do. Again, I was disappointed. Deputy Linehan did, however, make one point. He said:

"If any of these taxes, levies or impositions are putting an extra shilling on a poor person which he cannot afford to pay, then I say such taxes, levies and impositions should be removed."

He said "if," but he does not say that they are. That is Fine Gael tactics. Do not offend any particular employer; do not offend any particular manufacturer, or the workers working for that manufacturer, but make that sort of vague, general statement. He did not say that these taxes and levies were putting an extra shilling on the poor person; he made the sort of speech that gave the impression that the cost of living is going up, with no definite statement, and so he got through with that "if" statement in the end. He winds up with this:

"If we are going to have any honesty here, if we are going to have any consideration for the poor people, if we are going to live up to these Christian democratic principles about which we hear so much, we should carry this motion."

I wonder how can anybody talk of carrying this motion which nobody on the other side has spoken to and of the meaning of which nobody has given any suggestion or indication. We have not been told what should be done under the motion, if carried. They have not given a single thing that should be done in that event. Then, having put up this motion and having debated it in a general way, without giving any indication of what it is about, he says that if we have any honesty, if we have any Christian democratic principles, we should carry it. Why should we? We have not been told why we should do so. No indication whatever has been given as to why we should, and yet we are told that if we have any honesty we should carry it.

The next speaker was the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and, as I have said already, he made an unanswerable case. He quoted figures, and Deputies afterwards referred to his statement in regard to motor cars. That, however, was only one instance of many. He gave what the people were consuming in many ways, what people had saved during the last three or four years, and many other figures which went to show that the ordinary person in this country had not a lower standard of living than they in 1931, and that, in fact, he had a higher standard. Opposition speakers grasped his statement about motor cars, and said that the Minister thought that the country was better off because there are more motor cars being sold; but he gave that instance as one of many. He gave the source for every figure he quoted, and Deputies have not come forward to contradict these figures.

Deputy Dillon, so far as I could find out from reading through his speech, never referred to the motion. He talked a good lot about Newfoundland and the conditions there, and about the economic war, as other Deputies did. He also talked on the old subject of bankruptcy. When Deputy Gorey was here before in 1932, he will remember that bankruptcy was staring us in the face. It was only three months ahead. In June, we were told it was to come in September, and, in September, it was to come shortly after Christmas. It was always three months ahead, and gradually it began to get further away, and now Deputy Dillon says in five years we are going to meet with bankruptcy. He is getting a little more sensible about it now. That was his speech—Newfoundland, the economic war and bankruptcy, but nothing about the motion.

Deputy Moore took Deputy Dillon up on that matter of world prosperity, and he again made a speech in which he gave the sources of his information and quoted from international documents. Not a single person on the other side has contradicted anything he said. There was one matter in Deputy Brennan's speech to which I wish to draw attention. The only thing I could regard as in any way referring to the motion was his statement:

"That kind of control which the Government has at the present time by way of levies to certain departments of the agricultural industry is leading the country into a rut."

To what did the Deputy refer? "Levies that the agricultural Department have are leading the country into a rut." As I have already said, I do not know of any such levies and none was mentioned in this debate. They are mentioned in the motion, and because they are mentioned in the motion Deputy Brennan concluded that Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Morrissey must have known of some levy and, therefore, he talks about a levy and makes the statement that it is leading the country into a rut. There is no levy at all. That was his only reference to the motion and the House can see what it is worth.

Deputy Gorey was the next speaker, and I think that for departure from the truth I have never seen some of the statements he made beaten in this House. He was talking about the Pigs and Bacon Boards and he said:

"The facts are that before these boards came into existence we were killing anything from 1,500 to 1,700 pigs a week. What are we killing for the last 12 or 18 months?"

He asks the question and nobody replies. He answers himself and says:

"From 700 to 800. We are killing half the pigs we used to kill before, and the same applies, I think, to nearly all the factories."

He corrected the last statement afterwards. It does not apply to all the factories, but does it apply to Deputy Gorey's factory? Not at all. Deputy Gorey may be drawing on his imagination, but he did not make any attempt whatever to find out what the facts were from the factory of which he is chairman and with the workers in which he is evidently not at all familiar. He made the statement, a statement like that which has no truth whatever in it, and thought that everybody would believe it because he was chairman. In 1934, before control came in, the Waterford factory, of which Deputy Gorey is chairman, killed on an average 1,039 pigs a week.

Comment on this

On an average?

Comment on this

The whole year through.

Comment on this

May I ask where you got the figures?

Comment on this

I got them in my own Department from returns made by your company when looking for a quota from the Bacon Board. Naturally they put the figures as high as they could for 1934. The average number was 1,039 pigs a week. What did they kill in 1937? They killed 1,074, so that they killed more pigs since control came in. Deputy Gorey stated that before the boards came into existence they were killing anything from 1,500 to 1,700 pigs per week, and that since then they were killing from 700 to 800. Was not that a good one coming from the chairman who should know all about the company?

Comment on this

Can the Minister not go back a little further?

Comment on this

The year 1934 was the year before control came in. I will get particulars for 1932, and some speakers next week can use them when the Deputy will be still further on.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

I sincerely hope that this motion will be finished before next Wednesday.

Comment on this

Then there will be an opportunity of dealing with the matter on some other debate. Deputy Gorey made the statement and the Irish Independent wrote a sub-leader about the villainy of the Government and the way in which-poor Deputy Gorey's factory was treated. I know that they do not want much of an opportunity to write a sub-leader in the Irish Independent against the Government, but I want Deputy Gorey and others like him in responsible positions to know that the statement that he made as chairman is without foundation. In 1934, they dealt with 1,039 pigs a week, and in 1936, 1,074 pigs. There was another point I was going to refer to but I will not.

Comment on this

I was going to talk about the strike. They dealt with 1,037 and one week with 1,038. They went back later, but not to 900.

Comment on this

The reason I asked the source of the information is that I want to know the authority for the figures the Minister is quoting. I also want the figures for 1936 and 1937.

Comment on this

They are supplied.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

Supplied partly by my Department and partly by the Bacon Board, which allocates a certain amount of an export quota to each factory, including Waterford. The Bacon Board also allocates home sales and the total killings. The Bacou Board knows exactly, not only the number allocated to each factory, but the numbers killed. These are the figures I am giving.

Comment on this

Would the Minister point to the portion of Deputy Gorey's speech in which he referred to the number of pigs killed in 1934?

Comment on this

He said before control.

Comment on this

I said a lot more.

Comment on this

I will deal with that, too. I know that you said a lot more, and a lot more foolish things, too.

Comment on this

It suits the Minister to say so. I know the source of the information.

Comment on this

No. I would not say it if it was not true. The Deputy continued: "The facts are that before these boards came into existence we were killing anything from 1,500 to 1,700 pigs a week." That was before 1934.

Comment on this

What is the particular application to the year 1934?

Comment on this

It was the last complete year before control came into operation.

Comment on this

Give the figures for other years.

Comment on this

I have not got them, but I will get them.

Comment on this

They might not suit.

Comment on this

The Deputy went on: "What are we killing for the last 12 or 18 months? From 700 to 800." All through 1934 there were 1,074 pigs and for 1937, to date, 1,038 pigs. These numbers are very different from the 700 or 800 that the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is making a mistake. I know what I am talking about, and I know where the Minister got his information.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You could have checked the figures.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

The Deputy went on to ask, "Why have the number of pigs fallen?" They have fallen for two reasons, according to the Deputy—"because of the price of the feeding stuff, and the fact that the animals fed on it did not give a return for the food they got at the price that had to be paid for it." Deputy Gorey and others in the same position have, by their statements that pigs are not paying, done a great deal to bring down the number of pigs in the country. Deputy Gorey does not know whether pigs are paying or not. How could the Deputy know whether they are paying or not? I keep pigs and I know that they are paying. I do not think Deputy Gorey keeps pigs. I do not believe he does.

Comment on this

Good.

Comment on this

If he does, he does not keep any accounts. The Deputy made the statement for political reasons and for no other reason. If he had any interest in the factory, and any interest in the shareholders or producers, he would try to encourage them, instead of putting them out of that business. The Deputy is more of a politician than chairman of a bacon company, and there are others like him who have done a lot to bring down the number of pigs being kept.

Comment on this

On a point of order, does the Minister contend that what I said a week ago had anything to do with the reduction of the pig population during the last two years?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a query, not a point of order.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer that question?

Comment on this

The Deputy did not make the statement I refer to for the first time last week. He has been making that statement in public for the last couple of years as well as making it here. I say that that sort of statement, that the Deputy and others in a similar position made, has had a great deal to do with the reduction in the number of pigs. Anyone who keeps pigs and keeps accounts knows that pigs are paying, despite the wild statements that Deputy Gorey and men like him make for political reasons. The Deputy went on to talk of the profits of the factory. He said that they were making a profit of £1,500 to £2,000 a year on 1,500 or 1,600 pigs a week. They never had 1,600 pigs a week, but I will forgive him for saying that. The Deputy meant the period before control came in. I will tell him where I got my figures. I sent a man to Dublin Castle and I paid 1/- to see the balance sheet of the Waterford company with which Deputy Gorey is connected. In 1932-33, when there was no control, the Waterford factory made a profit of £11,058 or nearly £12,000. It was not £2,000 profit but £12,000. According to the balance sheet lodged in the Castle that was not an exaggeration, because when people lodge documents in the Castle they bring the figures as low as they can. I am sure Deputy Gorey is no more of a patriot than the rest of us in that respect. The amount was £12,000 and not £2,000. Yet Deputy Gorey made one of these wild statements which do a lot of harm and that no one will question. The Irish Independent wrote a sub-leader about that statement, that the factory was making a profit of £2,000 when it was £12,000. In the next year, again before control, the company made a net profit of £10,194, and the next year, again before control, they made £11,827, so that during three years in succession before control, the average profit was over £11,000. Deputy Gorey's statement was £2,000 before control and £16,000 since, or 8 to 1. Now what did they make since control? Not £16,000 but £13,156, so that the profits went up since control from £11,827 to £13,156, a difference of £1,500 and not £15,000, as Deputy Gorey said. These are the sort of statements that we get from Deputy Gorey, the chairman of the company. I can tell the House when the company lost. It lost when Deputy Gorey was looking after it and before Mr. Landy came there to manage it. The company lost £981 in one year, £768 in another, and £1,395 in another year. When the new manager came along it began to pay. Their profits increased each year from the time that the new manager came in 1930-31. In that year it made a profit of £4,107. The new manager cleaned up completely the mess that was there, and converted an annual loss, that was going on when Deputy Gorey was in charge, into a profit of £4,107. The new manager did that in his first year, and went on increasing the profits each year until 1936-37, when they reached the figure of £14,415.

Comment on this

On a point of order, would the Minister again read out the figures in the balance sheet for the year 1933-34?

Comment on this

The net profit in that year was £10,194.

Comment on this

I am just wondering what the Minister is reading from.

Comment on this

These are the returns that have been made to the Registrar of Friendly Societies, and I warn the Deputy to say nothing more on them.

Comment on this

According to the balance sheet, the profit for 1933-34 was £5,817 18s. 11d. If the Minister wants the figures I can refer to the balance sheets for 1931-32 and 1932-33.

Comment on this

As I have already told the House, I got these figures from the returns at the Castle. It cost me 1/- to get this certified document.

Comment on this

In 1931-32, according to the balance sheet, the profit was £4,374 19s. 5d.; in 1932-3 it was £5,657 3s. 8d., and in 1933-4 £5,817 18s. 11d. I think the Minister spent his 1/- very badly.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Deputy was not more particular when he was giving those figures on the first occasion. The figure that he gave then was £2,000.

Comment on this

Will the Minister justify the figures that he has given? He has talked about figures procured from Dublin Castle, and Deputy Gorey is quoting from the balance sheet of the company.

Comment on this

I think that we must depend on the returns made and lodged in the Department of Industry and Commerce, and must accept them as true.

Comment on this

Did the Minister speak of the balance sheet?

Comment on this

I am quoting from the column which gives the net profit on trade. I have given the figures for each year.

Comment on this

But the balance sheet is here.

Comment on this

I have here the audited balance sheets.

Comment on this

I think that the Deputy ought to get these things corrected if he can. If the Deputy is right, there will be money coming to me. Deputy Gorey left us under the impression that things were not too good as a result of control in the case of the Waterford factory: that they were not getting very many pigs compared with what they were getting before, and yet that they were making a huge profit, while they were not making a good profit at all before. In the annual statement of the company——

Comment on this

The Minister took a chance.

Comment on this

I did not. I want again to tell the Deputy that what I am quoting from is a certified document from the Castle. Anyway, I think I may go on. Prima facie any fairminded person will believe me rather than the Deputy because he admits that the statements he made here, on the figures which he quotes now, were a series of misstatements. On the last occasion he talked here of a profit of £2,000, but he admits now that the profit was £5,000 or £6,000.

Comment on this

These are the highest of the high ones.

Comment on this

I admit that if you go back to 1929-30 there were losses in the factory due to bad management.

Comment on this

There was no bad management in 1929-30.

Comment on this

We all know that there was bad management. Here is the statement made at the annual meeting of the company. The Deputy said that the net profit since control came in was £16,000. But here is the statement which appeared in the Waterford Star, a statement which was submitted at the annual meeting of the company. The net profit given for the year in that report is £14,415 14s. 7d. The Deputy says £16,000.

Comment on this

I will prove the £16,000, if not a lot more.

Comment on this

Then why do you publish these things in the papers? Why not tell the truth in the papers?

Comment on this