We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Standard of Living—Abolition of Duties on Foodstuffs—Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 338–511 of 511. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

£14,415 14s. 7d. I think the Minister must not have read my subsequent speech.

Comment on this

I did. I have said already that the Deputy corrected himself when he came here the following week. Deputy Gorey gave the impression to the House that these boards have done no good for the producer. The report goes on to say: "If we were to buy pigs at that price which we had to do before the board was formed, you would not be paying within 15/- to 20/- per cwt. of the present price, which would make it entirely uneconomic."

Comment on this

Who wrote that?

Comment on this

That is the annual report of the Waterford factory, praising up the system under which pigs were got.

Comment on this

That is not the annual report.

Comment on this

It is given here as the annual report. Then there is the chairman's reference to the recent strike. I have quoted from the documents that I got at the Castle, I have quoted from the Waterford Star newspaper, and from every official document that I could get, and yet Deputy Gorey denies everything.

Comment on this

They are all wrong?

Comment on this

Yes, according to the Deputy.

Comment on this

In connection with the £16,000, why did not the Minister quote the explanation that I gave at the next meeting of the Dáil? I gave the whole facts in connection with that. Why did not the Minister quote that and tell us about the 2,443 cattle that had to be fired into the river along with the tins in which they were packed? Why did the Minister not tell us about the cost of the strike?

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy why I did not do that. The Deputy knows himself that we are both negotiating on that very matter, whether they lost money on that item or not. I say that they did not lose money on it, and he says that they did.

Comment on this

Do not be trying to get out of it.

Comment on this

I know very well that I did not lose money.

Comment on this

We lost the money on your cattle that you paid £6 per head on and bribed the Kerry farmers—for fifty "bob."

Comment on this

Well, was not that a good price?

Comment on this

It was—at the expense of the people of this country. You bribed the Kerry farmers.

Comment on this

Well, I shall get back to that matter again. However, according to the motion, we are asked to take taxes off all foodstuffs coming into this country. Supposing we were to do so, what would happen? Do Deputies opposite realise what would happen in that case? I want Deputies to realise what would really happen if that were done. As I have said already, we have taxes, or, rather, import duties, on practically every agricultural commodity coming into this country, and the purpose of these taxes or duties is to protect our own producers. I want Deputies to realise that, if we take these duties off, our own producers would be put out of production. They would be unable to carry on. Yet, the Party opposite have put down this motion, and, evidently, want us to go ahead with the policy enshrined in this motion, as if it were a thing that could be done. Let us take one or two items. For instance, we put a duty on beef and mutton. Now, I got to-day's paper— to-day's Irish Times, as a matter of fact—a paper that, I am sure, Deputy Gorey will not dispute.

Comment on this

I never read it. I do not know that it exists. I have heard of it in my young days.

Comment on this

Well, I am glad that the Deputy will acknowledge even that much. At any rate, according to that paper, at the Manchester meat market yesterday chilled and frozen beef is as low as 4d. a lb.; and, of course, if we were to take the duty off beef or mutton, that frozen or chilled beef or mutton will come in here and be sold at that price, or, as a matter of fact, probably at a somewhat lower price, because the price there is regulated in the British market, and here it would probably be dumped in at a lower price. I do not know how our own people could compete with that price. Yet we are asked to take off such a tariff as that.

Comment on this

No. The only thing you were asked to take off is unconsidered or ill-considered tariffs.

Comment on this

Mention one of them.

Comment on this

The whole lot that you have put on.

Comment on this

Well, that is one.

Comment on this

You put a duty on bacon also.

Comment on this

Yes, in a proper way.

Comment on this

We put a duty on bacon.

Comment on this

Yes, but it was put on in what the Deputy calls an ill-considered way. We put it on in a proper way. We put a duty on the import of beef and mutton—incidentally, with the consent of the Party opposite—and now the Party opposite, according to this motion, wants it to be taken off. I have mentioned beef already, and here, I think, mutton is also mentioned, at 4½d. Are we to allow that to come in at that price and thereby wipe out our own producers? Of course I know that the Deputy does not want that done. All that the Deputy and other Deputies on the opposite side want is to talk about the motion, but if they were logical and meant what they say in the motion— that these duties should be removed and we should allow that beef and mutton in here—what would be the effect on prices?

Comment on this

Would it reduce the price to 4d.?

Comment on this

It would certainly bring it down, anyway.

Comment on this

Did the Minister ever hear of frozen beef coming into this country?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Where was it kept?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think the Deputy was interrupted once while he was speaking, and I think he should give the same hearing to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister speaks of frozen beef coming into this country. It is an extraordinary statement.

Comment on this

Of course, frozen beef came into this country.

Comment on this

Where was it held?

Comment on this

It came into this country.

Comment on this

It was here, all right.

Comment on this

It probably came from some country that did not go in for slaughtering calves.

Comment on this

Yes, I shall deal with that point later on. One Deputy— Deputy Brodrick, I think—said that the number of cattle was very little lower than in 1931, but I remember Deputy Bennett, in 1933, and other Deputies like him, suggesting that we had so many cattle in the country that they were beginning to eat one another and that we could not get sale for them. We brought in several measures to deal with that situation, and I think we dealt with it successfully, in spite of the Opposition. The fact is that we now have no trouble in selling our cattle and that we can sell all we can.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Because you killed the calves.

Comment on this

One of the things we tried to do, in an effort to deal with that situation, was to encourage the use of veal, and I said, at the time, that the only way to get the butchers to take the calves was to give a bounty.

Comment on this

It was all buried.

Comment on this

No; some of it was given to dogs.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister admits that, at least.

Comment on this

I said before, if Deputy Bennett would only recollect it, that that policy was not successful. As a matter of fact, we did not get the people of this country to turn to the use of veal. As a matter of fact, last year there were practically no calves slaughtered, and the only bounty to be paid would be in the case of a dead calf, and surely nobody can object to a farmer bringing in a dead calf and getting a bounty for the skin? Probably we will take the bounty off next year, and then, of course, we will have another complaint from the Party opposite put on a tariff. As a matter of fact, one would need to study a table of logarithms in order to find out what was meant by their sliding scale of tariffs at that time. There were two long tables, as a matter of fact; but then we came along and put on a decent tariff on bacon and did not allow it in at all.

Comment on this

We prohibited it altogether.

Comment on this

You did—for a month— and then you had this sliding-scale tariff, which did not mean anything, because the importers were against you. Then, however, we came along and put on a real tariff. Let us suppose, however, that that tariff were to be taken off.

Comment on this

We do not want the tariff off.

Comment on this

The object of the motion is to take it off.

Comment on this

The motion refers to ill-considered tariffs.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy knows what the motion is. He is not reading the motion at all.

Comment on this

The motion deals with ill-considered tariffs.

Comment on this

The phrase "ill-considered" is not in the motion. That phrase may apply to the motion, but it is not in the motion.

Comment on this

I cannot see it.

Comment on this

The Minister must be blind. Of course it is. In any case, do not we all know what it means?

Comment on this

At any rate, Deputies must know that, if we take off the tariff we have put on foreign bacon, it would mean that foreign bacon would be coming in here at a much lower price than can be got for our own bacon.

Comment on this

We never want to see it coming in again.

Comment on this

I quite agree, but some of the Deputy's colleagues, I am afraid, do not see that. One point made by Deputy Dillon, in regard to this question of a tariff on bacon, was that we were putting on the price on our own consumers. That is not true. We are paying subsidies on the exports of bacon to cover the tariff. There is one thing, however, which we must admit—that the English price for our bacon is not good enough for producers here. I do not want to find fault with the British market at all, but I want to say this, it is not good enough for us. We want to get a better price than they can give. We have to do that in the case of many commodities. We have to bolster up the British price for eggs, butter, bacon, and many other things, because the price we get for these on the British market would never keep our producers going. It may be what you might call a capacious market, it takes a lot of stuff; but it does not give a good price—not good enough for us. Therefore we must subsidise our producers on the British market.

Comment on this

I hope you will bolster up the price of cattle.

Comment on this

I will come to cattle. I am leaving cattle until the last. According to the Irish Times to-day the price of Irish bacon in Liverpool yesterday was from 85/- to 89/-. That is not good enough for our producers. I will tell you how it works out.

Comment on this

You work up to the hypothetical price.

Comment on this

I will just leave that out. We will add that on afterwards, if you like. The average price for pigs to the producer at present is 66/- per cwt. In 1931, when Deputy Gorey's Party was in power, it was 46/-. That is just en passant. Yet they talk about the farmers getting poor prices. He is getting £1 per cwt. for his bacon more than he did when they were in office. One cwt. of dead pig produces between 80 and 85 lbs. of bacon. If we put the value of the offals against the cost of producing the bacon—we are not going to give the factories any more than that—it means that the factory has got that cwt. of bacon at 89/-. What is the factory's list price now? From 90/- to 100/-. They have their bacon produced at a cost price of 89/- and they are selling it at from 90/- to 100/-. I do not want to say this definitely, but I am told that factories even sell bacon, in fact nearly always, under the list price. Their list price anyway runs from 90/- to 100/- and the bacon costs them 89/-.

Comment on this

The list price is from 90/- to 100/- at present? Whose list prices are you quoting?

Comment on this

The average. As a matter of fact, I thought the Deputy might dispute that, and, therefore, I will show him two invoices I got from a person in Dublin to show what he paid for bacon to-day. He paid 90/- for one lot, and 90/- for another lot; he was asked 100/- for another lot, but he did not buy. That is what he actually paid to-day for bacon—90/-. I say that on the present price of pigs our factories are paying 89/- for that bacon. Therefore, they must get at least 90/- on the home market; they cannot take less. But they will not get that on the British market; they will only get from 83/- to 87/-, I think. Therefore, we must bolster up the price in the British market. We must do something to give the factories a little more on the British market, otherwise they could not export.

Comment on this

Who is bolstering them up?

Comment on this

We have to give something more. In the first place, out of the export bounty fund they get a certain subsidy on exports—an export bounty.

Comment on this

How much do you deduct per cwt. from the curers to make up the hypothetical fund?

Comment on this

That is not an intelligent question. I do not know what the Deputy means by that. As well as what they get out of the export bounty fund, there is a stabilisation fund created by the board, and the board sometimes takes a levy off the curers who are selling on the home market and gives it to those who are exporting.

Comment on this

They are taking it off the curers who are supplying the home market and giving it to those who are exporting?

Comment on this

What else can they do when the export market is not good enough?

Comment on this

What do you do?

Comment on this

We do our duty. We give a subsidy against the duty. We cannot be expected to do any more. I want to tell Deputies opposite that if they want to bring down the price of bacon on the home market we must stop exports, because the export price is not good enough for our producers. If we stop exports we may bring it down by a fraction on the home market. But Deputies would not preach that to their constituents, because if they did they would have nothing left. "Give us back our markets" is the only cry they have left. If they are beaten that way, do you think they could go on? They would have no policy at all. I want them to realise that, at present prices, bacon could not be sold cheaper on the home market than from 90/- to 100/-, because, as I say, the curer is paying 89/- for the bacon. Surely he could not sell less than from 90/- to 100/-.

Then suppose the duty was removed off butter, how would we be? For the last five years, for instance, we sometimes had butter coming in at about 83/-; it was as low as 70/- at times. Even to-day, in spite of the threats made by Deputy Bennett and some of his colleagues in Limerick and other counties about looking for the world price for butter, Australian and New Zealand butter could come in here and cut our prices. Anyone who knows anything about the question of butter could see that the rise during the last month was only a temporary thing—it just went up and it is down again. Again coming back to the Irish Times, in the Liverpool market yesterday New Zealand butter was sold at from 117/- to 121/-, and Australian at from 116/- to 119/-. Australian butter could be landed here as easily as in Liverpool, I suppose, at 116/- if we took off the tariff. What would become of the butter which we are producing, and not only that, but the butter we cold-store for the winter and for which we expect to get a better price than has been got up to this? This whole motion is absolute nonsense, and everybody on the other side knows it is. They do not want the duty taken off foodstuffs. They know very well that if they took the duties off foodstuffs no farmer here could live at all. Still they are going to vote for this motion—why, I do not know. I never heard a single reason why they should vote for it. Take poultry and eggs.

Comment on this

What about cattle?

Comment on this

I want to come to them gradually.

Comment on this

Wait until you get the 140/-.

Comment on this

On the Dublin market yesterday, Irish eggs were worth from 22/6 to 23/-. If there were no tariff on eggs, Australian best-grade eggs could come in at 15/-, in other words, 1/- per dozen less, and put our farmers completely out of production. That is what the Opposition Party are going to vote for—to take the tariff off eggs as well as everything else. The same thing applies to every one of our farm products. No matter what we are producing here, we are getting a much better price for it on the home market than the imported article can be got for. The imported article could come in in every single instance and cut the prices here and put our own farmers out of production.

Comment on this

Could you give an idea as to when these Australian eggs were laid?

Comment on this

I quote from the Irish Times.

Comment on this

What are Irish eggs in Britain at the moment?

Comment on this

They are not quoted at the moment, I am afraid.

Comment on this

They are more than 15/- anyhow.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, they are much better. They are probably about 21/-.

Comment on this

Therefore, your argument about the Australian eggs does not apply.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us what is the export value of our eggs for 1936-37 as compared with 1931?

Comment on this

I have not got that here but I gave it in the last speech I made. I already talked about barley and the same remarks apply to barley and to fruit. Deputy Gorey knows that we are not getting a very good price for our apples, and I hope to have something to say in that connection later, but what would it be if there were no protection? The same remark applies to tomatoes and vegetables. Here the other day Deputy O'Neill talked about imports of fish and asked what were we going to do about them. I suppose he meant that we should try to keep out fish. Is Deputy O'Neill actually advocating that we should, by some imposition, prevent fish coming in here and, if so, will he still vote for this motion? I may be coming before the House shortly with a proposal to protect fish and to keep out certain classes of fish. I can say that now, because there can be no forestalling in fish. If I bring forward such a proposal, will Deputies support me, if they support this motion? It would be absolutely illogical for them to do so.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Neill could.

Comment on this

Perhaps so; he is a man of great resource.

Comment on this

You have no fish here to start with.

Comment on this

We have.

Comment on this
A Deputy

We have a lot of cod.

Comment on this

I have read many statements by Deputies that the farmers are badly off, statements which show that they are altogether illogical in putting forward this motion. I have here the prices obtained by farmers for the week ending October 23, in 1931, with the prices for the corresponding week this year. I shall leave cattle to the last, because I want to say something special about cattle. In 1931 store sheep were fetching £1 19s. 6d. per head. Strange to say, in the same week in 1937 the price was exactly the same, £1 19s. 6d. Store pigs, 12 weeks to four months old, in 1931 were £1 4s. 3d. each and in 1937 were £1 11s. 9d. each. The price there is well up. Pigs over four months old in 1931 were £1 17s. 6d. and this year were £2 5s. 9d.

Comment on this

Did you kill any of the sheep?

Comment on this

We do kill sheep.

Comment on this

You did not kill them like you killed the calves.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not eat chops? In 1931 porkers were quoted at 57/3 per cwt., and in this year at 65/- per cwt. In 1931 bacon pigs were 46/6 per cwt., and this year were 65/- per cwt. Farmer's butter was 10¼d. in 1931 and this year it is 10½d. Eggs were 1/4, and this year were 1/5. Fat sheep were 33/3 per cwt. in 1931, and this year were 42/3. Do Deputies think that we should bring these prices down to the 1931 level, because that is what the motion means? Is any Deputy prepared, or has he the courage to get up and say: "Take the tariff off sheep and let mutton comedown to the poor people," or "take the tariff off pigs and butter and let bacon and butter come down to the poor people"? Not a single Deputy would have the courage to say that, although they put it forward in a vague motion like this and vote for it. We know they have not the courage to do that, but yet they come in here with this vague sort of motion talking about taxes, levies and impositions, talking about the economic war, and telling us about how badly off the farmers are. When I quote present prices and compare them with the prices obtained in the corresponding week in 1931, I find that the farmers are getting more for everything except cattle than in 1931. They are getting more for sheep, pigs, butter and eggs, and of course we all know that they are getting a lot more for their green vegetables and fruit. There is no use in quoting figures to Deputies opposite. They will go out now, and it will just fall off them like water off a duck. They will still talk about the farmer being worse off than in 1931. We all know that the farmers were worse off in 1931. They got such a bad time that they put out Cumann na nGaedheal and they swore that they would never put them back again.

Comment on this

They were misled by you, but they are wiser now.

Comment on this

They are sticking to us all the same.

Comment on this

They will be finished with both of you in a short time.

Comment on this

I now come to deal with cattle. Cattle from one to two years in 1931 fetched £11 17s. 6d. per head, and this year during the same week they fetched £8 16s. 6d. per head. That is £3 per head less. Cattle two to three years were quoted at £15 in 1931 and this year £12 4s. 6d. Milch cows in 1931 fetched £19 14s. 0d., and this year £15 8s. 3d. In the case of fat cattle, the price was 35/6 per cwt. at that market in 1931, while at the corresponding market this year the price was 26/3.

Comment on this

That is nearly £5 on the week.

Comment on this

It is not £5; it is about £4 5s. on the average. If you take the number of store cattle exported from this country this year, the number of fat cattle exported, and the number of milch cows exported, it works out at about something under £4 a head. Take it at £4, and multiply that by 800,000, which I believe is roughly the output of cattle, and it is over £3,000,000. Against that we have halved the annuities for the farmers, and we have put £2,000,000 into the farmers' pockets for wheat, so in that alone we have done more for them than the loss on the cattle, and they have all the other things for themselves. However, that has not much to do with this motion. The question for Fine Gael to answer is this: Where those prices have gone up, do they want them to come down, because that is what the motion means if those impositions and taxes on foodstuffs are to come off beef and mutton and so on, in order to bring the prices down to what they were in 1931? Naturally, according to this motion, they would not like beef and mutton to increase in price, and if they want to vote for the motion they should be anxious for those to come down. I already dealt with the point about the price which the factories are paying for pigs. I tried to defend the factories because there is an investigation going on. The Prices Commission will be allowed to investigate this matter. In regard to the price of butter, before we took up office a system had been introduced here of putting a tariff on butter. Butter was stored here during the summer and sold in the winter. The price of butter went up in the winter to the consumer, but it all went into the pockets of speculators. Under our system it is quite different. We have a system under which the producer and consumer get the best possible value. There is a very small margin between the price which the producer gets for his butter and what the consumer pays for it. As I say, the consumer did not get as good value before this Government came into office.

With regard to the price of bread, again this is a matter which has been investigated, and perhaps rightly so, but Deputy Corry quoted figures from an official publication showing that in 1926 wheat was coming into this country at 30/- a barrel, and at that time there was no control of flour mills. The flour was imported at 52/6; it was produced at 52/6 by our own mills, and the loaf was 1/-. There was no investigation by the people opposite. Things were allowed to go on, and 1/- was paid for the loaf, but there is the greatest possible row now. I think that covers many of the points which have been raised about the price of food. I should like some speaker on the opposite side to tell us why we should accept this motion. It is all right getting up and saying: "Accept the motion," but I should like some speaker to tell us even this: Suppose it is carried, what are we going to do? They have suggested nothing we can do. They have suggested not one single tax that we should remit or reduce. They talk about levies. I do not know of any levies. They talk about those duties on foodstuffs. In regard to every single duty which I mentioned, Deputy Gorey and others said they did not want it taken off. They do not want any duties taken off; they do not want any taxes taken off, and there is no levy to take off. Yet they want us to vote for this motion. There is nothing whatever in the motion. I know it was ill-considered. There was a hurry about putting it down for fear the Labour Party would put it down before them. Even so, they might have withdrawn it, redrafted it on consideration, and given us something intelligent at least. I should have liked to hear what the Labour Party think about this motion, but they have not spoken. They are not shy, but they are cute.

Comment on this

When the Minister sits down he will hear it all.

Comment on this

Good.

Comment on this

We are keeping the good wine until last.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear that they are going to speak at last. It was well they made up their minds to do so. Do the Labour Party want those tariffed industries? Even if they put up the prices of certain goods, do they still want them? They want social services. They speak about better wages. We must get certain taxation to pay for social services and so on, because our income from the tariffs is going down, and, therefore, we must have taxation to finance the social services. It may be awkward for the Labour Party to support this motion on that account, and I suppose it will be still more awkward for them to vote against it after all the row they made in the country about the cost of living. However, I am sure Deputy Norton will make all that clear if he is going to speak.

Comment on this

Another challenge.

Comment on this

If Deputy Norton gets up I also want him to say what he really wanted done about Japanese pottery. Does he want it kept out, as he seemed to imply in to-day's question, and does he want the poor man to pay more for his plate and jug?

Comment on this

He is paying at the present time.

Comment on this

I am not saying he is wrong in advocating that, but I should like to know whether he is advocating it or not.

Comment on this

Are you not taxing it at present? What are you talking about?

Comment on this

Do not get out of it that way. I simply want a straight answer to a straight question.

Comment on this

I never heard a straight question from the Minister yet.

Comment on this

I want to know whether the Labour Party wants it kept out, and wants the poor man to pay more for his jug and plate. I said here that our yield from customs was going down. On this same sheet of the Irish Times I see the revenue returns up-to-date, and the strange thing is that we have collected £1,000 more than we did up to this time last year, but customs have gone down and excise has gone down, which I suppose is a good sign, because if we are to believe what is being said by certain Deputies opposite—and I think they are right—if our industries are being built up, naturally our receipts from customs will be reduced, and therefore that is a sign, I take it, that our industries are being built up. We got an increase from motor duties. Deputy Gorey did not think very much of that, but, however, we got an increase. Deputy Dillon did not believe that, but we got it. I remember when Deputy Cosgrave used to sit here on this side he said many a wise thing. Of course, he said many a foolish thing, too, but there was one thing he said and I think there was a lot of wisdom in it. He said the best guide of all to the progress of the country was estates duty. Mind you, our estates duties are going up. They went up by £100,000 this year as compared with last year.

Comment on this

How much of it is provided by estates duty which was not on until last year?

Comment on this

Stamps have gone up too. Income-tax has gone up. Corporation profits tax has gone up.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if that is correct about the estates duty?

Comment on this

I do not think so. There has been no change in the rate.

Comment on this

Last year a section was put into the Finance Act which made joint accounts—on which it was not usually collected before—liable for estates duty. Does that represent the increased estates duty now?

Comment on this

The cat is out of the bag now!

Comment on this

It was only estimated to bring in a small amount. Excise profits are gone down. That is another good sign. The Post Office is the same. The collection of land annuities has increased. Another good sign!

Comment on this

Thanks to the sheriff.

Comment on this

Every tax there that should go down, like customs, excise and so on, has gone down, and every tax that should go up, like estates duty, has gone up. I think it is a splendid certificate of efficiency for this Government—that return of revenue. I want to put some questions to the next speaker from the Opposition Benches. Can he produce evidence to rebut any of the statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to show that the standard of living has not gone down— has, in fact, gone up? No evidence has been produced so far against the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

It has gone up in Dublin —there is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

Will any Deputy opposite tell me where there is a levy on foodstuffs and, if there is, will he advise us to remove it? I do not think there is any levy. Will any Deputy there mention what particular import duty he would like to see removed on foodstuffs? I mentioned every one I could think of, and Deputy Gorey and other Deputies opposite said: "Not that one." What one are we to remove? What tax should we remove? Deputies did not indicate a single tax that we should remove. So far as I can make out, no one wants any tax removed; no one wants any duty removed, or any levy taken off, if there is any levy. In such circumstances why should we, or anybody else for that matter, vote for this motion? If the motion were carried, what could we do? I think we should have more agreements in this House, and we should often agree with motions put in by the Opposition, if we reasonably could do so. If we were told in definite language what we could do, then perhaps we might accept a motion.

Comment on this

You promised to reduce taxation by £2,000,000 and you did not do it.

Comment on this

That is not the motion. We heard all about the economic war and extra taxation in Newfoundland and bankruptcy, but nothing at all about the subject matter of the motion. No one has made a case for it and, in such circumstances, I think no one should vote for it.

Comment on this

This motion by the Fine Gael Party was, I understand, submitted almost immediately after the recent general election. I cannot help imagining that, in the desire to submit the motion speedily, the Party did not give adequate consideration to its ramifications, to the implications which the motion carried, or to the consequences to the nation generally following the adoption of a motion of this kind. Let us assume, for argument's sake, that all these aspects of the question were considered and that the motion was submitted only after very careful and mature consideration by the Party. If we are to assume the latter, then I think we must make up our minds that the motion, and the mentality underlying it, are the clearest possible evidence that the Fine Gael Party have now become definitely a free trade party, because, underlying the motion and the speeches made in favour of it, has been a downright advocacy of free trade. I should like to know from the Party opposite whether they have now definitely run up the free trade flag and whether they realise all the implications to the nation by the adoption of a policy of that kind.

This motion, in my opinion, is part and parcel of the mentality which has been displayed by the Fine Gael Party in vigorously opposing the imposition of tariffs. This motion is just another effort by the Party to attack the policy of tariffs which are extensively supported in this country, not by one Party or group, but by a number of Parties and many groups, because it is realised, in the circumstances, in this country that we can adequately protect our industries only by preventing the dumping here of goods made in countries which have a long industrial tradition, made in countries where mechanisation has been carried to the acme of perfection, or made in countries where the wage standards of the workers are very much lower than those which obtain here. If we are prepared to permit this country to be used as a dumping ground for the produce of every other country in the world it will, of course, be possible for our people to live here and to purchase commodities more cheaply than they can purchase them to-day.

I gather that the mentality of the Fine Gael Party in this motion is that we should let in all commodities that can be imported cheaper than they are produced here; in other words, that every type of commodity which can be imported cheaply here should be allowed to be imported simply because it is cheaper. I would like to ask the Fine Gael Party where does that policy lead us to? What is the natural end of the adoption of a policy of that kind? In my view, it will mean that no native industry can survive if we are satisfied to allow this country to be made the dumping ground for goods produced elsewhere. It is true, of course, that by permitting that condition of affairs to continue we can buy commodities cheaply here; but then we will have circumstances where our people will be idle, where our unemployed problem will be serious, where those at present working will be disemployed and, notwithstanding the cheapness of the commodities available from other countries, our people will not be able to purchase them because there are no means by which they can obtain employment in a productive capacity in their own country.

But even if it were possible, on the pure arithmetic of the case upon which free trade is and always has been based, to argue that it had certain advantages in certain circumstances, I think we must take stock of the fact that we are living in an era when practically every country in the world has been compelled to adopt a policy of protection to one degree or another for its own home production. The outstanding characteristic of the economic nationalism that has developed during the past 15 years has been a determination on the part of almost every country to protect its own home market for its own produce and, at the same time, to use the surplus goods produced in order to dump these goods at bankrupt prices on other countries, with all the chaos that a dumping policy of that kind can cause in industries in other countries which are not protected by substantial tariff walls.

I should like to ask Fine Gael what country in the world to-day could stand on an undiluted free trade policy? What industries could stand in this or any other country if the respective countries in which these industries exist were not determined that their industries should be protected by the erection of substantial tariff walls? Whether we like it or not, free trade as an economic policy is dead to-day. It is impossible to revive it, and no ardent advocacy of free trade is possible in a world situation where every country is adopting protection to a greater and greater extent and where there is a world-wide determination on the part of countries to protect their own home market against dumping by other countries. And yet this motion and the speeches made in favour of it would appear to indicate that a Party here, which not so long ago was the Government Party, now believe that it is possible for us to maintain a free trade policy in a highly-protected world.

Comment on this

Nobody is arguing that.

Comment on this

I cannot imagine any sensible person arguing that, but that is the mentality behind this motion, and those are the lines upon which this motion has been supported.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey has now been converted against this motion. This motion has no sanity and no sane economics, and it is part and parcel of the mentality which, during Deputy Gorey's absence from this House, the Fine Gael Party have displayed in opposition to the protection of industries from foreign competition and foreign dumping.

Comment on this

There is more than protection here; there is plunder.

Comment on this

We can deal with the plunder side of it later.

Comment on this

Look at the dividends they are paying.

Comment on this

Let us realise that it is quite impossible for this country to rely on a policy of free trade in a highly-protected world.

Comment on this

Why waste your time arguing that?

Comment on this

We all know that.

Comment on this

That is my complaint. I imagine you all know that, but why produce a motion of this kind and permit speeches such as have been made from the Fine Gael Benches in support of this motion?

Comment on this

Why denounce the Government because of the high cost of living?

Comment on this

Perhaps I should have consulted you as to what I should say.

Comment on this

I can speak for myself and anything I say here or in the country I am prepared to stand over.

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey would, apparently, want to have his views recorded much more clearly in connection with this question of tariffs, because, in moving the motion, he said that the Labour Party here was the only Labour Party in the world to stand for tariffs, as if it were something objectionable to stand for a policy of protecting your own industries by the imposition of tariffs. What was the purpose of a remark of that kind by Deputy Morrissey except tariffs were objectionable to him or to the Fine Gael Party? It is remarks of that kind and speeches of that kind which, I say, justify us in interpreting this motion as advocating undiluted free trade. Deputy Morrissey could not have made any research into the policies of Labour Parties in other countries or he would scarcely have made a speech so obviously incorrect as that which he made. Labour Governments function in New Zealand, Sweden and Denmark, and, if Deputy Morrissey will take the trouble to go to the Library in this House, he will find a long list of tariffs that are in operation in each of these countries— tariffs which were imposed and increased by Labour Governments.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Without any safeguard for the consumer?

Comment on this

We shall deal with safeguards for the consumer later. If Deputy Morrissey is so much concerned about the consumer, why did he omit him when making his speech in favour of this motion?

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Read the motion itself.

Comment on this

I have read the Deputy's speech. The Deputy said that the Labour Party here was the only Labour Party in the world which stood for a policy of tariffs. Even if that were true, I should still be proud to stand for a policy of protecting our own industries, but it is not true because, as I have explained, Labour Governments in New Zealand, Sweden and Denmark have already found it necessary to impose tariffs to protect their own industries, while in countries like Australia, America, Canada, France and Belgium, Labour Parties have, from time to time, when in office and even when out of office, either imposed tariffs or advocated the imposition of tariffs in order to stimulate their national industries. I hope that before he makes another statement in that connection, Deputy Morrissey will show a much greater knowledge of the policies of Labour Parties throughout the world than he could claim when he was introducing this motion.

The Labour Party, personally and collectively, take the view that free trade is not a policy which is feasible to-day for any country. It is particularly impossible in a small country such as this, with relatively undeveloped resources, with its industrial possibilities little more than scratched, and which is striving to produce many commodities for which it previously relied on other countries. Free trade, in my opinion, means a continuance of the policy adopted by the Fine Gael Party of allowing this country to be used as a dumping ground for the produce of every other country. Free trade will mean the closing down of our own industries and making it impossible for them to survive as against external competition. Free trade will mean more unemployment for our people. While it may mean cheap food for our people, we shall be-living in such conditions that our people will not be able to buy the commodities, cheaper though they may be than those produced in our own industries.

Comment on this

What about the sweat shops of which you spoke at one time?

Comment on this

The Deputy seems to know so much about them that he ought to make a speech.

Comment on this

I am quoting the Deputy.

Comment on this

You are wise in that. If you continue to do that, you will not go far wrong.

Comment on this

It was you described them as "sweat shops."

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey thought that this motion provided an ideal opportunity for attacking the Labour Party. I do not know whether Deputy Morrissey's association with Deputy McGilligan on this motion is just an effort by Deputy Morrissey to prove that he has now swallowed the whole philosophy and policy of the Fine Gael Party. There was a time when Deputy Morrissey did not think so highly of Fine Gael or of the Deputy whose name is associated with his in connection with this motion. According to the Official Report of Debates, volume 20, column 40, Deputy Morrissey opposed the nomination of Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Industry and Commerce. He explained his opposition by saying that "the Cosgrave Government had failed in their fundamental duty to a large body of citizens." On that occasion, Deputy Anthony told us that there were 200,000 unemployed people during the middle of that summer. On a later occasion, Deputy Morrissey, speaking on the same subject—the nomination of Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Industry and Commerce —said:—

"I do contend that he (Deputy McGilligan) has never shown the least grasp of the position in this country from the point of view of a Minister for Industry and Commerce."

Later in the same speech, he said:—

"The Minister has never approached the question of unemployment from a humane point of view."

In the same speech, Deputy Morrissey said:—

"I say that this House will be doing a great wrong to a large number of citizens of this country if they put back into this position as Minister for Industry and Commerce a Deputy who has said and reiterated that it is not the duty of the Department or of the Government with which he is connected to find work for many who are on the verge of starvation."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Morrissey's opinion of Deputy McGilligan at any time does not seem to me to be relevant to this motion.

Comment on this

It is very nice for us to hear.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not my concern.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

I thought 32/- a week was very bad until you fixed 21/-. If I said that about a man who was paying 32/- a week, what should I say about a Government that pays 21/-?

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy Morrissey that he ought not to devote so much time to endeavouring to discover inconsistencies in the Labour Party's policy, or Labour Party utterances, while inconsistencies of the kind I have referred to exist in the official records of this House. It may be that Deputy Morrissey has converted Deputy McGilligan to his point of view. That may have happened, and if Deputy Morrissey has achieved that result, it is certainly an achievement of which he is entitled to feel proud; on the other hand, I imagine that Deputy McGilligan would stoutly resist any suggestion that he had been converted from the policy which Deputy Morrissey denounced in such unmeasured terms. I submit that I am entitled to suggest to Deputy Morrissey, when he goes looking for inconsistencies, that there is quite a tidy monument of inconsistencies available in the records of this House which show that Deputy Morrissey advocates one thing one day, and on another day can be induced to swallow his own words when the political wheel shifts.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Will the Deputy show where I am swallowing my own words?

Comment on this

I thought I had shown it already by proving to the Deputy that he is now associated, arm in arm, with a Deputy who, he said, was a Minister in the Government which had reiterated that it was not the duty of the Government with which he was connected to find work for many who were on the verge of starvation. If the Deputy cannot see the inconsistency there, I give up all efforts at trying to show it to him.

This motion has been availed of for the purpose of a general examination of the whole question of the standard of living of the people. Some speakers have taken the view that the standard of living has increased, while others have taken the view that the standard of living has decreased. That kind of argument has perhaps an academic interest for some people, but the point of view which concerns me most is that, whether the standard of living has increased or decreased, the fact remains that it is appallingly low to-day for tens of thousands of people who live in this country. Deputy Moore intervened on this motion and took us on an international review of the position in other countries. He quoted some of the Scandinavian countries and told us that Scandinavia to-day was reeking with depression, whereas if Deputy Moore had consulted any authority on the matter, had even gone to the trouble of looking up official statistics available in the Library here, he would have realised that the Scandinavian countries are the outstanding examples in Europe to-day of their capacity to manage their business constructively and to deal as democratic Governments with the social evils which affect these countries. Everybody who has attempted to write on the economic position in Scandinavia has paid tribute to the manner in which the democratic Scandinavian countries have been able to surmount their difficulties without resort to the evil of dictatorship which has afflicted other lands.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Does that apply to Denmark?

Comment on this

It applies to Norway, Sweden and Denmark, where, I suggest, the standard of living is substantially higher than it is here to-day, and Sweden is the outstanding example among that group of Scandinavian nations. Deputy Moore was not satisfied with an excursion to Scandinavia. He thought he would go to New Zealand as well and he painted a picture of coming bankruptey for that country, when, as a matter of fact, everybody who has any knowledge of the position, or who has taken any trouble to inquire into it, knows that New Zealand to-day is passing through a period of prosperity which it has never before experienced.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

The Ottawa Pact.

Comment on this

No, the Labour Government. The population of New Zealand is approximately half the population of this country. Deputy Moore tells us that there is depression there and prosperity here, but a comparison of the depression there and the prosperity here might well make a number of our people wish they were afflicted with New Zealand depression instead of Free State prosperity. The rate of unemployment benefit in New Zealand was increased recently to £1 for a single man and 35/- for a married man, plus 4/- a week for each dependent child. When you compare 35/- a week for a married man, plus 4/- for each dependent child, with the 12/6 maximum unemployment assistance paid here, a substantial difference reveals itself. The unemployed father of a family of seven children receives three guineas a week in New Zealand and in Saorstát Eireann he receives 12/6 a week.

Comment on this

What does he receive for work?

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy that if he will be a little patient. The New Zealand Government pays old-age pensions to women at 60 and to men at 65 at a rate of 22/6 a week and the pension payable to a husband and wife, when both are eligible for a pension, is £2 5s. per week. The widows' pension was recently increased in the case of a widow with dependent children from 10/- to £1 per week when the Labour Government took office, and in addition, a widow receives 10/- per week for each dependent child under 15 years of age. Invalidity pensions are payable in New Zealand, but, of course, they are not payable here. The rate is £1 per week to the man permanently incapacitated for work and in addition, there is an allowance of 10/- a week for the wife and 10/- a week for each child under 16 years of age. Some Fine Gael Deputy has asked what the rate of wages is. Under legislation passed in New Zealand establishing an arbitration board to fix basic rates of wages at a level sufficient to enable an adult male worker to maintain a wife and three children in a fair and reasonable standard of comfort, the basic rate fixed for the lowest grade of worker is £3 16s. per week.

Comment on this

Would they take any Irishmen over there?

Comment on this

It is a pity it is not nearer. I imagine they would have a good deal of trouble keeping them out.

Comment on this

Five members of the Cabinet are Irishmen, as a matter of fact.

Comment on this

The standard of living and the wages paid to agricultural workers will provide some food for thought for the Minister for Agriculture, and if it were possible for the Cabinet to do it, he ought to be sent there on an extended holiday.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy say the population of New Zealand was?

Comment on this

1,600,000. The minimum rate of wages for farm workers ranges from 17/6 for those under 17, to £2 2s. for those aged 21 and over. When you want to get a picture of what even capitalist newspapers think of this condition of affairs, you have only to refer to the Financial Times, which has admitted that the New Zealand Government is paying its way, and that the Labour Government there has been an outstanding success. The Irish Monthly, an organ edited by an eminent Irish Jesuit, has selected New Zealand as one of the countries which has set an example to all the Governments of the world in the handling of economic problems.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

It certainly can afford protection.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore selected that country as one of the countries that was staggering on the precipice of bankruptcy, and he told us, in the face of these conditions, that we ought to be glad we were living in Saorstát Eireann to-day. I should like him to offer that suggestion to New Zealand workers, and to suggest that they might take our code, and our impoverished standard of living, and to let us have theirs. I imagine Deputy Moore would not have a cordial reception if he went to New Zealand on a mission of that kind. That shows you the foolish kind of economics that percolate into the minds of people who imagine that everything in this country is lovely. Deputy Moore is probably a reflex in some ways of some people on the Front Benches. Probably they imagine there is depression in New Zealand and prosperity here. There are many Irish workers who would prefer the New Zealand form of depression to the Free State form of prosperity. The Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke for a long time on this motion, and he seemed to me to work himself up to a high degree of enthusiasm at the fact that more motor cars had been purchased, more tobacco and more spirits consumed, as if these were a reliable test of prosperity so far as the working-class people are concerned. The motor cars which, apparently, are being used in increasing numbers, are being purchased by those tariff exploiters to whom the Minister referred at Cork a few days ago. Up to that time it was a kind of high treason amounting almost to sabotage, for anyone to suggest that anyone was exploiting tariffs here. Yet the Minister, having hotly denied that anyone was exploiting the tariffs, a few days ago went and announced that the Government would ruthlessly put down all this tariff exploitation by a few people who wanted to get rich quick. Probably these are the people who have been buying all the motor cars, consuming the tobacco, and treating themselves generally to spirits, apparently by exploiting the community's desire to protect home industries.

The serious portion of the Minister's speech was where he, in that kind of flamboyant cavalier way of his, declared that we were on the high road to prosperity; that our economic and social difficulties were at an end, and that, in fact, there was really nothing to worry about, so far as the standard of the prosperity of the people was concerned. The fact that more motor cars were purchased, more spirits and tobacco consumed indicated the manner in which the economic barometer moved. I suggest to the Minister that there are other tests which could be applied, and that they are better tests, tests which will give more reliable, though perhaps more heart-rending, results. What are the facts of the economic position in this country to-day? After all the after-dinner speeches about prosperity have been made, and when the platform orations about returned prosperity are over, the fact remains that there is a very serious economic problem here to-day. There is a very hard core of unemployment and a substantial amount of economic discontent here. According to the Department's latest figures there are now over 90,000 registered unemployed at the unemployment exchanges. These 90,000 people satisfied the Department that they are unemployed. Everyone knows the inquisition that is held on people before they can get even the miserable stipend that is given under the Unemployment Assistance Act. Most of the 90,000 are in receipt of unemployment assistance benefit, and very substantial numbers are compelled to support a wife and five children on the maximum benefit of 12/6 a week.

In a country that, according to the Minister, is teeming with prosperity, in a country which is using more motor cars, and consuming more tobacco and more spirits, the most that can be offered to an unemployed man, to keep himself, his wife, and five children is the miserable pittance of 12/6 a week. We are offering that to such a man, at a time when the price of the 2-lb. loaf is 6d.; when the unemployed man at the exchanges can get in cash or kind the equivalent of 25 loaves to sustain a family of seven for a week. How does that condition of affairs square with the prosperity that we hear so much about? Is not that condition of affairs a much more reliable test, as to the serious economic position which exists, than warped reports that could be got from the increased use of motor cars or a larger consumption of spirits and tobacco? To-day the unemployed man is compelled to provide for himself, his wife and five children on a pittance which will buy ten loaves of bread and 5 lbs. of butter. The State does not care where the money is to come for rent, fuel, light, clothes, footwear, school-books and the other commodities which should be found in a civilised homestead. The Minister tells us that 12/6 a week is all that the resources of the State could afford. Is that the kind of prosperity that exists in this State? Is that the kind of economic fabric he can give us after five years of Fianna Fáil government?

We do not need merely to take the figures in respect of unemployment to test the serious economic position that exists. Other tests can be imposed. The best test is emigration. Every day in the week, and every week in the year the position at the ports tells its own tale. Thousands and thousands of the virile manhood and womanhood are leaving to find employment in Great Britain. It is sought to justify that on the grounds that Great Britain is passing through a boom period and that what is attracting the manhood and womanhood of this country are the standards of wages that cannot be got here. Everyone knows perfectly well that if work was available here, at reasonable rates of wages, Irishmen and women would remain here, rather than be attracted elsewhere by higher rates of wages. There is no prosperity in the rural areas, and the unemployed are compelled to exist on the miserable pittance of 12/6 a week. It is the fact that they are condemned to try to eke out a livelihood on rotational schemes, for which they get, in many cases, not more than 12/- a week, and they are forced to select the emigrant ship as the lesser of two evils. I move the adjournment of the debate, as I understand there is to be some discussion about the Dáil sitting to-morrow.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There was an arrangement that the adjournment would be moved at 10 o'clock.

Comment on this