Committee on Finance. - Shop Assistants (Conditions of Employment (No. 2) Bill, 1937—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–192 of 396. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
With regard to the next amendment, it would be better if amendment No. 13 were moved first, and amendments Nos. 12 and 13 discussed together. If amenedment No. 12 were carried, amendment No. 13 could not be moved.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, I formally move amendment No. 13:—
In sub-section (1), page 5, line 24, after the word "sister" to insert the words "nephew, niece".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:—
In sub-section (1), lines 23 to 25, to delete the words "or is a son, daughter, grandson, grand-daughter, stepson, step-daughter, brother, sister, half-brother or half-sister of such proprietor".
In the Bill as it stands there is a very wide definition of relatives who are excluded from the provisions of the Bill, and it seems to me that the relatives of small shopkeepers require the protection of this Bill just as much as other employed persons. In previous shops legislation, in the 1912 Shops Act, for instance, the only exclusion was the family of the shopkeeper, resident, I think, on the shopkeeper's premises, or something to that effect. In this case, relatives are exempted to a large extent, and I think there is a strong case for limiting the number of exemptions. The reason the amendment suggests cutting out the younger generation from the exemption is that while there might be a case for the old people hanging about the shop day and night, there is a case for limiting that in respect of the rising generation, or the younger relatives. I do not see why the relatives of the shopkeeper should not be put on the same footing, so far as this Bill is concerned, as shop assistants. Apart altogether from the merits of the case in respect of the shopkeeper's family, there is the other consideration that a shopkeeper who is getting his work done by his own relatives is in competition with another shopkeeper who has to employ persons from outside, and has possibly an advantage and, therefore, making all the conditions in the Bill more difficult of enforcement. I think there is a strong case for limiting the number of relatives exempted.
Comment on this
My amendment goes quite the other way. My suggestion is that it is a very ordinary thing for persons in business to get up relatives and train them in that business. They are really adopted children, and they become members of the family, and, according to the Bill, if they are living in the house with their relatives, they are really in the same position as children. I submit that if a nephew or niece comes up to live with an uncle or aunt in Dublin, he or she should be regarded in exactly the same way as the son, daughter and others whom the Minister has in his Bill.
Comment on this
It is very hard to say with any degree of certainty where we should draw the line in the exclusion of relatives of a shop proprietor from the scope of the measure. It is, I think, desirable on general grounds to exclude from the scope of legislation of this kind the immediate relatives of an employer, where those immediate relatives are maintained by the employer and reside with him in his premises. That is what we set out to do by this sub-section of Section 2. The particular definition of "relative" which we have embodied here is taken from the Workmen's Compensation Act. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney may remember that he raised the question of nephews and nieces when the Workmen's Compensation Act was before the Dáil as a Bill, and the arguments I shall have to make against his contention are similar to the arguments I made on that occasion. I do not think we should go so far as to carry the exemption of persons to that degree of kindred. It is, I think, not unusual for licensed premises' owners to go to quite considerable pains to hunt up relatives for the purpose of avoiding the obligations which would otherwise rest upon them in respect of the conditions of employment enforced by the trade union catering for the class of worker employed in licensed premises, and I fear that a somewhat similar state of affairs might develop if we were to extend the degrees of kindred set out there to any extent. It might well lead to shopkeepers in various parts of the country dispensing with the services of existing employees for the purpose of replacing them with nephews and nieces, and thus avoiding altogether the obligations imposed on them by this Bill in relation to the conditions of employment of those who work for them.
At the same time, I do not think we should go as far as Deputy Heron would have us go, and exempt from the definition in the Bill such persons as sons, daughters, grandsons, granddaughters, or brothers or sisters. We have any number of sons, daughters, brothers and sisters, half-brothers or grandsons, and where they are residing on the same premises as the employer, and are maintained by him, I think we can regard them as being so intimately associated with the ownership of the business that it is inappropriate to apply to them the various conditions which would otherwise be applied by placing on employers the obligation of giving these people certain annual holidays and other benefits, or to give them power to go to the Wages Board to have wages defined and so on. I appreciate that this is somewhat a difficult point, but I think we can take immediate relatives of an employer who reside with him and put them into a different category from the ordinary employees. We are really setting out to deal with conditions of the ordinary employee, the man who is selling his labour for wages, and who has no other intimate relationship with the employer than the contract of wages. It is for such persons the Bill is designed.
If there is any point to be made that abuses might arise, or that certain special advantages might be secured to particular employers by giving employment, to immediate relatives only, we could deal with that by amendment of the appropriate section. Wherever such questions as the employment of juveniles arise, or where orders are made limiting the number of juveniles in a shop in relation to adults, we take into account as adults persons who may be relatives of the proprietor working on the premises. In relation to this section, any appropriate suggestion of that kind can be considered. I doubt if it would be wise to adopt the course suggested by Deputy Heron, or the alternative suggested by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. We have a definition here of "relatives" which has, at least, the sanction of precedent, in so far as it appeared in other legislation and it emerged as a result of long discussion when that legislation was being enacted.
It is necessary to bear in mind that the mere fact of relationship between a proprietor and the persons concerned does not exempt the proprietor from the provisions of the Bill unless condition (b) also exists, that the relatives reside with the proprietor and are maintained by him. I think it is better to leave the definition as we have it. I know that it could be argued for a long time as to whether a half-brother, a granddaughter or a grandson should be in or out of the definition. In the last resource it seems to me, in the interests of common sense, that it would be unwise to do what is suggested by Deputy Heron or by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney.
Comment on this
In country districts, where small traders would not be able to employ a large number of assistants, their relatives would be employed. That is an advantage to them. It would be hard on them if restrictions were imposed.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just spoken has given the real justification for the amendment. It is precisely to ensure that a shopkeeper who is a good employer will be treated on the same basis, by law, as the shopkeeper who is a bad employer and who exploits assistants, whether they are his own relatives or not, that the change is suggested. I find it difficult to see why a difference should be made when one is, so to speak, protecting human life. If life is made tolerable for shop assistants, why should it not be made tolerable for relatives in shops?
Comment on this
If they cannot afford to pay them they should shut the shops, and let the trade be done by those who can pay.
Comment on this
If you allow relatives to be outside the provisions of the Bill, that may give the person who does not employ assistants a definite advantage over those who do employ assistants. Most of us who are familiar with shops know the system that prevails in the country of relatives being taken into the business. Relatives are installed to carry on the business on the assumption that when the shopkeeper passes out a niece or a nephew will succeed to the business. For the next ten years that niece or nephew may be a positive drudge, and may be treated worse than a paid assistant would ordinarily be treated. Then, owing to the adverse conditions, the niece or nephew might simply have to walk out. From the other angle, in order to protect the relatives, they should be included and protected by this Bill.
Comment on this
Deputies will appreciate the practical difficulty of enforcing a Bill in relation to intimate relatives of an employer who reside with him. It could not be done. You can make a law saying that these people must work for 48 hours only but, in fact, they could not refuse to work certain hours, nor could you prevent them doing so. There would be no point in putting that into legislation, because it could not be observed. Bear in mind that they are intimate relatives living with the employer in his house.
Comment on this
There are three points to which the Minister might give further attention. The first point is outstanding, that an undue advantage is given to an employer who is able to carry on his business with the aid of those in the family circle, and they are excluded from the provisions of this measure. That employer has an advantage over competitors, and having that advantage, this measure may destroy something that it is endeavoured to bring about freedom for shop assistants that they never had before. If you are going to destroy that freedom there is no advantage gained by the Bill. As regards protection for relatives in the family circle, we know that employers who employ relatives, instead of being generous to them, take advantages that they could not take with strangers. It may be said that those inside the family circle could join a trade union in which they could obtain protection, but they are reluctant to join a trade union because they know it will bring the wrath of the employer on their heads. If relatives in the family circle leave that type of employment, outside employers are reluctant to employ them, believing that there is something against them. The Minister should take these points into serious consideration. For these reasons, I feel that it would be a disaster to allow such people to escape their obligations.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy Lawlor and Deputy McGowan, one would think that the number of such nieces and nephews was inexhaustible.
Comment on this
The Deputy suggested that there would be an end to all employment for other people if nephews and nieces were allowed to work as members of a family when they were, for all practical purposes, adopted into the family by living in the place.
Comment on this
Then we had the other argument, that a person who has relatives is very much better off than a person who has not. Let us take the case of the farmer who has half-a-dozen sons. He is very much better off than his neighbour who has no sons. I wonder if the argument will be put forward from the Labour Benches that, in those circumstances, this farmer's sons should not be allowed to work on their father's farm, because in doing so it will mean giving the father an unfair advantage over his trade rivals.
Comment on this
Nobody suggested that a shopkeeper's son should not be allowed to work for his father. The only suggestion made was that his conditions should be reasonable, just as if somebody else was working for the father.
Comment on this
The condition can be left entirely to what the father considers for the good of the family.
Comment on this
According to the Labour amendments the whole country is being spoiled because he is getting it. I would remind the Labour Party that there is such a thing as the family. It is the natural unit and should be regarded as such.
Comment on this
I have a great deal of sympathy with the Minister's outlook on these amendments. I think you could argue up and down as to the degrees of relationship that ought to be included or excluded. It seems to me that not enough has been made of one point, and that is: why should not relatives get the same conditions as regards hours as shop assistants? Is somebody going to make the case that, under this Bill, the hours are absurdly short, and, therefore, that a man's relatives may quite easily work a while longer? It seems to me that shopkeepers who have relatives living with them and working for them are of two kinds. They may be generous people and treat their relatives in exactly the same way as ordinary employees; they pay them the same wages and give them the same hours of work. If that is done, I do not suppose that this Bill is intended to apply to those people.
In the case where people are possibly inclined to take their relatives at something less than their market value, it is entirely in a proprietor's hands to say what he will pay them, and, apparently, it is also left to him to say what hours he will work them. In my opinion a relative ought to be in no better and in no worse position than any other human being. The Minister has made the point that he cannot check that up in the case of relatives. I quite agree that that may be so in some cases, but if flagrant cases occur, and I suppose there are such where relatives are consistently worked longer hours than ordinary assistants, I imagine that in such cases some one will be found to come forward and give information. I do not think that this legislative body should take up the position that relatives are in any different position from that of ordinary employees. As to the number of hours worked, the treatment of both should be the same. The question of wages is a different one. I am not going to try to draw the line as to what relatives ought to be in or what relatives ought to be out, but, personally, I would like to see them on the same footing as other employees.
Comment on this
There must be some exclusion. When Deputy Lawlor was speaking of a shopkeeper employing his relatives, and in that way getting an advantage over his competitors, he drew a picture which might possibly appear occasionally in some area at some time, but it is not the typical picture that Deputies should consider. What Deputies should keep in mind when considering the amendment is the typical picture of Mrs. Mulligan, who runs a huckster's shop and who is assisted by her daughter, Miss Mulligan. If the House were to adopt the amendment to exclude sons and daughters from the definition section, then Mrs. Mulligan would have to put up an abstract of the Act for the benefit of her daughter, Miss Mulligan, and keep all records prescribed under the Act, and in all other respects would have to treat the daughter who assisted her as a salaried employee.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the relations between the average mother and daughter are human or inhuman.
Comment on this
I think the same lady reappears in almost every constituency. That is the type of shop that I ask Deputies to keep in mind, and in relation to such establishments it is obviously unwise, if not foolish, to adopt any amendment which means that a son or a daughter in that relationship is to be put in exactly the same position as a salaried employee. Undoubtedly, you may come across the case of a shopkeeper with four or five sons who will exploit their labour and get some competitive advantage on that account. That case is not typical, however, and applies no more to the retail trade than it does to farming or any other occupation. I think, however, it would become more general if we were to extend the definition to the extent that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggests. The relationship between cousins is obviously less intimate than between father and son, or brother and brother. In cases where you have a father and a son, or a brother and brother carrying on business in the same premises, it is impossible for the law to step in and try to regulate their relationship with any degree of exactness. It cannot be done, and I do not think that we should attempt to do it.
The possibility that a shopkeeper may be placed at some disadvantage by reason of the fact that he has to employ others under the terms of this measure does not warrant, in my opinion, any alteration in the definition. The position might become serious in some areas if we were to extend the definition. I am not prepared to extend it, and, on the other hand, I do not think that we should restrict it. We find this definition in previous legislation passed by the Dáil. I refer to that fact merely to indicate that this question has already been before the Dáil when it was the subject of considerable debate; and this definition of what is a "relative" has been put in merely on account of the fact that it represents the best effort which the last Dáil could achieve in that connection, and which, I am sure, the present Dáil would find it difficult to improve upon.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
In sub-section (1), page 5, line 27, after the word "proprietor" to insert the words "provided there is available in such house sufficient accommodation for such relative or relatives".
This amendment of mine concerns relatives who are not actually physically living in the same premises of the proprietor of the establishment, in a case where there is not room in the house of the proprietor to accommodate them. Of course, we all know that, in a great number of houses, there is a shortage of accommodation, and I submit that, if the accommodation in such a house is not sufficient to enable the employed relative to reside in that house, it is reasonable that, if he resides out, he should receive the same treatment as the ordinary assistant.
Comment on this
Well, I am afraid that we would be going very far if we were to adopt this amendment. I think there is a case, as I have said, for exempting a relative who resides with the employer in the employer's house, but to try to deal with the case where there is not sufficient accommodation in the employer's house, and where the employed relative lives elsewhere, would create great difficulties, because, of course, it would mean imposing on the inspector, or upon whomever was thinking of taking proceedings under the Act, the obligation of being satisfied as to the adequacy of the accommodation in the house of the proprietor, and if the inspector could not satisfy himself on that point, then, in fact, the amendment would operate to exempt the relatives concerned, no matter where they resided, from the conditions of the Act. I do not think that we could go that far. I am certainly in sympathy with the idea the Deputy has in mind, but I think that his amendment—or at least the interpretation of it—would go much farther than is intended and that it would be interpreted as extending the provisions of the Act to a much greater extent than the Deputy himself has suggested in his remarks. In view of that, I think we should hesitate about accepting this amendment.
Comment on this
I should like to oppose the amendment, Sir. It seems to me that, in the minds of a good many members of this House, there is the idea that any degree of exploitation of shop workers or shop assistants is justified provided that the employed person happens to be a relative of the shopkeeper. At an earlier stage and in view of the Minister's attitude, I advocated a further delimitation with regard to the exemption of relatives of employers who come within the scope of this Bill. For the same reasons, I now urge the rejection of this amendment. This idea of bringing in relatives of employers who do not live on the premises of their employers is simply an endeavour to take away from the Bill the value that it has as a protection for certain persons in the community against unfair exploitation. I think that, possibly, the best case that can be made for the Minister's attitude in regard to the limitation to persons living on the premises of the employer is the difficulty of the enforcement of the provisions of the Bill. I admit that it would be very difficult for an inspector to deal with a situation where the persons actually lived on the shop premises, but I do not see any justification whatever for enabling a shopkeeper to engage in a special degree of exploitation of his employees simply because he can claim that these employees happen to be relatives of his. Therefore, I hope that this amendment will not be accepted by the House.
Comment on this
Judging from his remarks, there seems to be running through Deputy Heron's mind an absolute conviction that anybody in this country who has a relative employed in his premises is anxious to browbeat and bully that employee.
Comment on this
No such thing. I did not suggest that such people are anxious to browbeat and bully their employees.
Comment on this
Now, the Deputy is young—I mean that he is young to the House—and I suggest that a little restraint is very good for youth. At any rate, the Deputy seems to be impressed by the idea that everybody in this country is inhuman and that the one idea in life of everybody in this country who has got a relative employed, who is a young person, is to bully and browbeat them and give the worst possible life to that person. That is not the case at all, and I should imagine that, in 999 cases out of 1,000, the relative is very much better treated by the proprietor than is the paid assistant of the establishment. That, certainly, is the thing that one would expect, and I believe it is the thing that one would find in most cases. My amendment is not to the effect that such a person should be worse treated than the shop assistant, but that the regulations, which the law may find it necessary to bring in to regulate the relations between master and employee, ought not to apply as between the members of a family and the head of that family. Probably the relative is much better treated than the ordinary assistant, and probably, in a great number of instances, he works very much shorter hours and gets holidays off and days off that a paid assistant may not get. At the same time, however, he may work for a much longer period on one particular day. There might be a race meeting on one afternoon, to which one might want to go, and the relative might be let off for that occasion, but the paid assistant might not be allowed off.
Comment on this
At least I am very fortunate, I think, that I have met a very different point from all those covered by the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I resent, Sir, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's suggestion that I held that all employers of relatives in this country were inhuman and that they wanted to exploit their relatives and so on. If these employers are prepared to have their relatives working under decent conditions, they have nothing to fear from the provisions of this Bill, which is merely laying down a certain minimum with regard to the conditions which are regarded as being tolerable for people working under the conditions concerned; and I take it, therefore, that the people employing relatives, in such circumstances, will be only too glad to avail of the provisions of this Bill. I only want to protect, for instance, juveniles, from coming up against a certain kind of person who might, possibly, exploit them, and whom, evidently, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney wants exempted from the scope of this Bill.
Comment on this
I would suggest to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney that, as he is concerned for the good relations between people and their relatives, he should not propose a thing that would lead to an argument in court as to whether or not there is sufficient accommodation in a house for persons employed in the establishment or not. I think it would be very unseemly for people to have to answer questions as to how the accommodation in their houses is provided, and I think it is not the sort of thing that should be invited. However the Deputy may feel on the matter, I suggest that it would not be seemly to invite such a procedure.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:—
In sub-section (1), line 29, to delete the word "fourteen" and substitute the word "fifteen".
I think this deals with the same point as is raised in amendment No. 33 later on. The purpose of this amendment is to endeavour to bring into conformity with this measure what has been a popular opinion in many circles, concerned with the raising of the school age and the raising of the age for absorbing youth into industry. While the general trend of opinion, as annunciated at Trades Union Congresses and at the meetings of other representative bodies, is that the age ought to be 16, I take it, therefore, that the amendment is modest and that there is every reason why it should be acceptable to the Minister.
I should also like to state that at many conferences which have taken place between representatives of employers and trade unions the question of employment of juveniles was under consideration and there was, practically speaking, no hostility on the part of employers in certain industries, or in almost all the industries in reference to which that particular matter was raised. But they certainly did maintain that, in order to make it effective, it ought to be universal. This measure gives an opportunity of reaching the half-way house, if I may put it that way. Instead of pressing for the age of 16, as has been done by other bodies up to now, the amendment says 15 years. Employers have stated, on the other hand, that they will be satisfied to meet the trades unions in connection with the matter of absorbing juvenile labour, but that it should be universal.
I submit to the Minister that this is an opportunity which will not occur again for a very considerable time, and I should like very much that he should accept the amendment. I see no reason why it should not be adopted. We all know, with the changes which have taken place, the difficulty that confronts young lads or girls who are absorbed into industry at 14 years when not properly educated and the fight they have in after life. At the present time that fight is more intense than it was some few years ago. If the Minister accepted this amendment, he would certainly meet many points that are worthy of consideration. He would make this universal and it would be a benefit to the children as well as to the people who are going to be absorbed into employment later. I would appeal to the Minister to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I presume that Deputy Lawlor appreciates that the adoption of the amendment will not raise the school-leaving age.
Comment on this
I made that remark for the purpose of emphasising that the general problems associated with juvenile employment cannot be tackled piecemeal; in fact, if they are to be tackled at all in any systematic way, a beginning must be made at some other point than restriction on the employment of juveniles. This question of raising the school-leaving age hardly arises on this Bill, but I would remind the Deputy that it has been the subject of very careful examination and the report of a commission, which has been set up to consider it, has been published. The general feeling, I think, is in favour of raising the school-leaving age and, consequently, the age of entering into industrial employment. There may be a difference of opinion in rural areas upon certain aspects of the problem, but, so far as urban areas and industrial and commercial employment are concerned, the general view is undoubtedly in favour of raising the school-leaving age and the age of entry into employment. But there are practical difficulties, and these difficulties are not removed merely by prohibiting young people from being employed in certain occupations until they are 15 or 16 years of age.
The immediate difficulty, of course, is the provision, not merely of school accommodation, but of an adequate system of instruction in schools, if and when the accommodation is provided. If the school-leaving age were raised to 15 to-morrow, there would be a complete inadequacy of school accommodation and of everything associated with school accommodation for a very considerable time. Not merely would that scarcity of accommodation, lack of suitable teachers, and other difficulties arise, but I gather that educationists are of opinion that the benefit to young persons would be negligible. In other words, that it is impossible to work out an addition to the existing primary school programme covering one year only which would be of any real benefit to students; that if we raised the school-leaving age to 15, the last year would be practically a repetition of the previous year; and that if any educational purpose is to be served by the raising of the school-leaving age, it must be to some point beyond 15; that the added period must be more than a year, if any useful system of instruction is to be devised which will be of permanent benefit to the students.
The problems associated with that aspect of the matter are, of course, being examined by the Department of Education. In fact, the Department of Education, as the Deputy may be aware, are proceeding along the lines recommended by the commission— which was to deal with this problem of raising the school-leaving age, not by the general application of a new rule, but by what I may call an experimental development in particular localities. That was the recommendation of the commission, that instead of enacting legislation raising the school-leaving age to 15 or 16 for the whole of the country, in particular districts the age should be raised when the accommodation had been provided, when the programme of instruction had been worked out, and teachers trained in the provision of that instruction. When the Department of Education has made progress in its particular sphere of activity, then I think we can, at some stage, consider this question of limiting the age of entry into industrial or commercial employment. I do not think that we should do it before then. If we were to insert the amendment in this Bill, the only effect would be to prevent persons between 14 and 15 years of age getting employment in shops. We would not prevent them from getting employment; we would merely prevent them from getting employment in shops. I am not sure that that is desirable.
There are, of course, other problems which arise, problems with which no doubt the Labour Party are familiar, or should be familiar. In other countries where they have raised the school-leaving age they had to take into account the circumstances of working-class families where the income, small as it might be, which juveniles over 14 years of age could bring into the household was of importance, and, consequently, they provided, by various methods, for substituting for that income some other means of support for the family while the children were attending school over the age of 14 years. That particular aspect of the whole problem has been also dealt with in the commission's report to which I have referred.
With the general proposition that the school-leaving age should be raised, at any rate in the towns, and that, as a consequence, the age of entry into industrial and commercial employment should be further restricted, I am in complete agreement. I think, however, that it would be wrong to start by restricting the age of entry into employment; that the start must obviously be made by raising the age up to which children must attend school. Before that can be done, a great deal of preliminary work has to be undertaken and a great deal of preliminary expense to be met, because, of course, the provision of new school accommodation, additional teaching staff, and all the rest, cannot be done without considerable cost. If we are to contemplate a general extension to the higher age to cover all children in towns and cities, some provision may also have to be made in the other direction to which I have referred; that is, in the matter of making good to poorer families the income which these children might have earned if the change had not been effected.
This question has arisen on other Bills, of course. It is a simple matter for me to speak against Deputy Lawlor's amendment on the ground that no purpose would be served by preventing the employment of such juveniles in shops when they could get employment in factories or other less healthy occupations, but I do not want to defeat the amendment on that ground. I am urging that it should not be adopted because it is a long way from setting about solving this problem, a problem which we all want to see tackled and a problem on which I feel action will ultimately be taken. The beginning must be made at the education end, and until some progress has been made at that end we can hardly consider legislation of this kind. Remember, the school-leaving age was raised to 14 and the Compulsory Attendance Act was passed when there was no restriction on the age at which children could be absorbed in industrial occupations, so it need not be considered that the amendment is an inevitable consequence of the raising of the school age. The raising of the school age would be in itself effective to achieve the end which the Deputy has in mind, when the necessary preliminary steps have been taken, the necessary finances provided, and the machinery brought into existence which will enable that to be done.
Comment on this
Would not the increased facilities now in existence for vocational education be one of the problems?
Comment on this
I do not claim to be an educational expert, but undoubtedly it is, in my opinion, desirable that any increase in the school-leaving age should be associated with the adoption of a system of education which would have a definitely vocational bent. I think that is desirable, but what the educationists tell me is that it is not possible to do that on the basis of a one-year programme only, that one year would be too short a period to afford any instructional value to the pupils; that if the school-leaving age is to be raised at all in a way that is to have any educational value for the students, it has got to be a two-year period which will be added. Whether that is so or not, I do not know. I do not claim to be an expert on this subject, but the problem has been considered by experts whose views are available in the published report.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy Lawlor's amendment would defeat its own purpose, because if juveniles were not, as the Minister suggested, absorbed in some form of employment, it would mean that they would have to spend one year free of any control, because, presumably, the male parent at least would be working. They would be out of school at 14, and they would be for one year completely out of control. They would not, in many cases, be useful members of an establishment after that year of absolute freedom. I quite agree that something should be done, and if by means of vocational tests such as have been instituted by the Institute of Industrial Psychology, tests could be carried out during the last year at school, and could be followed up by one or two years' vocational education, the result would be to make these juveniles very much more useful to a factory, shop, or whatever other form of employment in which they might be absorbed. As the amendment stands at the moment, I think it would defeat its own object.
Comment on this
I think we are all glad to hear the Minister express his sympathy with the object in view. He maintains, of course, that it is practically impossible to have it included in a Bill of this kind. He has referred to the report of the departmental committee which inquired into the question of the school-leaving age. I am glad to know that he has not, expressly at any rate, approved of the statement in that report that children of fourteen are not too immature to enter into industry. I hope I am right in assuming that he does not endorse that view.
Comment on this
Not if I could help it, but this is a different question. The question is whether it is better for children to remain at school, or to get into an occupation where they will be able to learn a certain type of skill that will be of benefit to them in after-life. That is an open question. For certain classes of occupation, the actual transposition from the school to the factory can be done at that age. It does not mean that the education of the juvenile has come to a stop, but that his education will take a different form, and very few means of vocational instruction are available unless provided in a factory associated with a particular work. Of course we are not dealing with factories now, and that is a theory which does not apply to most forms of shop work. While I should like to see a general system which would permit of young people remaining at school for a longer period than they are now required by law, at the same time I do not think it does all the harm, which has occasionally been stated, to have them going to work at 14 or 15 years, provided the work is work of a healthy kind and likely to help them to something better in after life—in other words, that it is not blind-alley work, which is merely a source of a few shillings a week for the parents and of no benefit to the juvenile.
Comment on this
The Minister said he started to work early himself, but that he would not start his children to work early. I take it that the higher grade civil servants who framed this report would not permit their own children to start work at 14 in a factory. They would prefer to send them on to the university, provided out of public funds and maintained out of the rates that all of us pay. The Minister said he considered this a right age to bring them into a factory. The Minister is, no doubt, aware of the fact that manufacturers in Great Britain a few generations ago maintained it was absolutely essential for the welfare of British industry that children of seven or eight years should be brought into cotton factories. They needed workers with pliable fingers to handle the cotton, and these would not be available unless they brought in children of immature years. Well, now, we should have moved away from all that. If there is a lot of people idle in the country, it is better to have fully-grown men and women absorbed in industry than to force in immature children. The Minister raises a point in regard to the question of adding an extra year after 14 and says that certain preliminaries would have to be introduced. I offer him an alternative, to take off a year at the other end, so that the minimum age at which children would be admitted to school would be seven instead of six. Instead of forcing very young children to go to school to get them out of the way, it would be much better to have school attendance enforced between the ages of seven and 15 rather than between six and 14.
Comment on this
I should like to hear from the Minister, after his endorsement of the employment of juveniles even at the age of 14, what type of employment there is in this country at present where the conditions are sufficiently healthy to permit of the employment of children of that age.
Comment on this
Before I withdraw the amendment, I should like to make a few remarks. A point has been made by the Minister in reference to the child's help to the family by going out to work at an early age. I think the Minister will admit that in the overwhelming majority of cases a child helps only for a short time. That help brings about the sacrifice of that child for the balance of its life, and certainly does not tend to make it a good and decent citizen. The Minister may have worked before he was 14, but he is one of the few, and he was not working in a blind alley occupation. The overwhelming mass of the juveniles of this country who go into industry under 14 years of age are going into blind alley industries. The result is that to-day you will find nearly every street corner in Dublin offering its quota of young men and young women who have worked only for a couple of years, starting at 14 and getting left off at 16. I am pleased that the Minister can see there is good reason for the amendment, and I am satisfied that the contention he is making as regards its general application cannot be found in my amendment. It would undoubtedly have to come from the other end, where the school leaving age would be compulsorily increased. Therefore, I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In sub-section (1), line 30, after the word "work" where it secondly occurs, to insert the words "including the work of an accountant, clerk or other person employed in an office."
Section 2 defines what shop work means. It declares that the expression "shop-work" means "work (whether within or outside a shop) which is connected with or ancillary to the business carried on at a shop, but does not include work in connection with a wholesale shop", and so on. The object of this amendment is to ensure that the expression "shopwork" will also include "the work of an accountant, clerk or other person employed in an office"—then the section goes on to operate again—"which is connected with or ancillary to the business carried on at a shop". The object of the amendment is to ensure that when we come to find what shop work is we will not exclude from the provisions of this Bill and from such benefits as are provided in the Bill a person who is employed as an accountant, clerk, or in any other capacity in an office which is connected with or ancillary to the business carried on.
I am leaving those words in the section, and consequently the ancillary character of the work of an accountant, clerk or other person has to be established in order to bring the person within the scope of the Act. Frankly, the object is to extend the scope of the Act, and bring into it persons who are employed on work of an ancillary kind, such as an accountant, clerk or person employed in any other capacity which is not covered by the title of accountant or clerk, but who will, nevertheless, perform certain tasks in connection with the business which is carried on in the shop.
Comment on this
On that occasion I expressed the view that it would be undesirable to extend this Bill to cover persons who are engaged in purely clerical work only, that is, clerical work, in relation to shops, of a similar character to clerical work done in relation to any other form of commercial activity. In so far as clerical workers are engaged in shop work in conjunction with the serving of customers, or the receipt and despatch of goods, they come within the scope of this measure, but the type of person who is engaged in other forms of clerical work which have no direct relation, to the actual form of activity carried on is not covered, nor do I think he should be covered.
Comment on this
Let us take the case of a shop carried on in a particular premises in town—an ordinary shop for the purpose of dealing with customers; it might be for the purchase of drapery goods, for instance. Let us assume that upstairs there is a person working as a book-keeper, keeping the accounts of that shop, and another person whose job is the sending out of invoices or the posting of ledgers in respect of the purchases which are made downstairs. Do I understand from the Minister that in his opinion those people are excluded from the scope of the Bill?
Comment on this
The Deputy included a number of people in his definition. In the ordinary course, a person whom I would describe as an invoice clerk is covered by the Bill. I put that person in a different category to the person who is employed purely in the accountant's office, keeping the books of the concern. It is very hard to get a definition. The actual definition which appears in the Bill here has been the subject of legal interpretation in the past, and possibly will again in the future. The type of person whom it is not intended to cover by this Bill is a clerk who is doing in relation to a shop precisely the same type of clerical work that he would be doing if his employers were operating a factory or an insurance company or a betting office or any other type of commercial activity. If the person is employed in any way in relation to the actual business of retail trade, then that person is covered by the Bill.
I mentioned here before, in relation to those clerical workers, that, while there may be a case for general regulation, it was not as easy to effect it as in the case of shop assistants or industrial workers. We could, of course, provide certain safeguards in respect of wages, and in so far as I am familiar with the circumstances under which a number of clerical workers are employed, I think that is the safeguard which is most urgently required, but I do not think it would be possible to regulate, with the same degree of precision as is possible in the case of other classes of workers, the hours of work or other conditions of employment. We are providing them with a statutory right to holidays, but I should not like to have to undertake the task of regulating the other conditions of employment, because it is not unusual—in fact I would say that, on the contrary, it is quite usual—that the relations between those clerical workers and the employers are on a different basis to those of other workers. They are more confidential. They involve a greater degree of personal trust, and so forth, in the ordinary case. There may, of course, be establishments where a huge number of clerical workers are employed, and the thing is run as a machine, but that is the exception, and in relation to those establishments the abuses to which I have referred do not as a rule exist, because their very size ensures against them in the ordinary case. I do not think we should attempt to extend this Bill beyond those who may be regarded as shop assistants, that is, those who are engaged in any way in connection with the serving of customers. I do not mean to confine it to those brought into actual physical contact with the customers; it applies to those whose work has any connection with the serving of customers or similar activities carried on in shops.
Comment on this
The Bill says "connected with or ancillary to the business carried on at a shop"; that is not the actual serving of customers.
Comment on this
That is what I have said; it is not intended to confine the Bill to persons who are actually concerned with the serving of customers, but to include also person who do work connected with or ancillary to the serving of customers, such as the despatch of goods or the receipt of orders. Those persons will, in fact, be found to include, in respect of the great majority of retail trades, every person employed. In fact, it is only in the case of multiple shops, where the accountancy and office work are separated altogether from the actual business of individual establishments, that the distinction will arise.
Comment on this
The object of this amendment is not to bring clerical workers generally within the scope of the Bill. I recognise there must be a limit to its scope. But here we are purporting to frame a code for persons engaged in shop work, and we proceed to say that this Bill will apply to the assistant. I take it that it will apply without question to the cashier—will that be so?
Comment on this
But the person who actually deals with the accounts of the customer who makes a purchase, presumably, will not be included, and the person who keeps the books in relation to that purchaser's credit facilities or payments will not be included. That seems to me to be an indefensible restriction. If we are going to permit the cashier and the dispatch clerk to be included, why should we not permit the book-keeper and the person who does the general work of keeping the accounts of customers who shop on the lower floor of the building? It might be argued that they are in because they are doing work ancillary to the business carried on at the shop, and I think a court might well rule that the person who keeps the accounts created by the customer making purchases downstairs in the shop is, in fact, performing work ancillary to the business carried on in the shop. I think the way in which that could be arranged is that this type of work includes the work of an accountant, a clerk, or other person employed in the office, all the time bearing in mind the governing phrase "work which is connected with or ancillary to the business carried on." That ensures that an ordinary accountant, any private accountant, could not come along and say that he is within the scope of this Bill. The person who would be included would be the person who would be doing work connected with or ancillary to the business of the shop. That would not let in the general clerk.
Take the case of an ordinary establishment in the city. The clerical workers go to work the same time as the shop assistants; they go to lunch at the same time and they are off in the evening at the same time as the assistants. Why should we apply this measure solely to the assistants and leave out the ordinary clerks who are dealing with the accounts of the customers, and why should we leave out the accountant or the book-keeper who keeps the accounts? I suggest there is a very much stronger case for extending the scope of this Bill to the persons I have mentioned rather than for limiting the scope of the Bill and prohibiting the inclusion of these people. I think that if you include these people it will be found that the Bill will be much easier and simpler to work. I would like the Minister to consider the matter with a view to covering that type of employment, all the time reserving the governing provision that the work must be connected with or ancillary to the business carried on at the shop.
Comment on this
I am afraid I could not agree to that. I gave my views on the subject on an earlier amendment before Deputy Norton arrived. Without desiring to repeat myself too often, I would like to say again that in my opinion, in so far as clerical workers require protection in regard to their conditions of employment, they should be dealt with as a class. I do not think we should deal with a certain group of clerical workers in this Bill, merely because they are clerical workers employed in connection with shops, any more than we should deal with clerical workers employed in factories in legislation governing employment in factories, or any more than we should deal with clerical workers in insurance offices in legislation affecting insurance. We might consider it desirable to introduce general legislation covering clerical workers, no matter where they are employed. I use the term "might" because I see considerable difficulty in devising a suitable type of legislation and enforcing it after we had enacted it.
There is one, and possibly there are two, matters in respect of which provision for clerical workers could be said to be needed. The first matter has relation to holidays. They should be given the same statutory right to public holidays and annual holidays as shop assistants are getting under this Bill. We may propose to do that for them by embodying them in a general measure covering all workers not already covered by legislation. The second matter is in respect of their earnings. Quite a large number of clerical workers are employed—not usually in connection with shops, but in connection with other occupations —at wages which are unduly low, and some means of enabling such persons to protect themselves and ensure reasonable remuneration for their labours may have to be devised by law. To that extent I am quite prepared to go, but I could not see my way clearly to go beyond that in the regulation of the conditions of employment of clerical workers, because there are difficulties that I do not think Deputy Norton has quite considered. He merely sees these clerical workers as members of the staff of the shop, and his point is that, if we are dealing with the shops, let us include these. I see them as a class, the same as I see transport workers, and a line of demarcation must be drawn somewhere.
Comment on this
It is not desirable, I think, in the case of transport workers —I dealt with that before—and yet there are transport workers employed in shops, just as they are employed in factories and elsewhere. In so far as it is desirable to deal with clerical workers, I think we should deal with them as a class.
Comment on this
In this instance you are bringing in some clerical workers and leaving out other clerical workers. Why not make the shop the line of demarcation?
Comment on this
I do not think it is the practical way to do it. I have been considering this matter, because I got representations on the subject. As regards clerical workers, I am going to give them, by legislation, the benefit of the holiday provision of this Bill. If circumstances should arise to facilitate it, and if it were clearly necessary, I would be prepared to introduce legislation in relation to clerical workers somewhat similar to the wages part of this measure. But I have not got in my head any clear idea as to how you could go beyond that satisfactorily in the regulation of conditions of employment of clerical workers. In some types of establishment it could be done; in others it could not; but that is a question to which I would like to give further consideration before giving any opinion. I would prefer to deal with the clerical workers as a class, the same as we propose to deal with transport workers as a separate category of workers and the same as we are dealing with shop assistants as a separate category.
Comment on this
I am anxious to find out what portion of the clerical workers the Minister is proposing to cover, and I should like to have that clearly stated. I am afraid the consolation that I received in the debate on an earlier amendment has been shattered by the discussion on amendment No. 16. The Minister referred me to work which is wholly or mainly performed within the shop and is wholly or mainly in connection with the serving of customers. Deputy Norton starts in to try and analyse where the Minister cuts the cord in connection with serving a customer. It is quite clear that the assistant who takes the order or displays the goods is a shop assistant. I raised a point about somebody who might be in a department standing there, possibly taking down that order for the salesman or assistant. The Minister extended the scope still further, I thought, when he spoke about a clerk who is making out invoices, that he is included. Deputy Norton mentioned the book-keeper who puts those invoices into the ledger. Apparently those clerks are also connected with serving a customer. Now, if you come down the other end of the line and follow the goods as they travel out, you find the dispatch clerk in the delivery department and the person who keeps a book recording the deliveries.
The Minister says—I hope he will correct me if I am wrong—that all these classes are "in connection with the serving of customers." He used the analogy of the betting shop, and said that the people employed on that class of business in a retail establishment did not come within the scope of this Bill. I am only anxious to get a definition of who is and who is not covered by the Bill. As regards the analogy of the betting shop, letters would be received in the morning. In a retail establishment, letters would also be received. Evidently, the clerical workers operating in connection with these letters would not be covered. The Minister also spoke about a factory. In a factory, they make purchases. So does a retail establishment. Evidently, a book-keeper who kept a creditors' ledger would be outside the scope of the Bill, while one who kept a debtors' ledger would be inside the scope of the Bill. A person who prepared invoices would be inside the terms of the Bill, and a person who dealt with out voices would be outside the scope of the Bill. I should like to know if that is the position, because we are all anxious to know where we stand. The Minister will have to get down to some more precise definition than that in line 14. I should like to hear the Minister on that point so that we should have a clear-cut idea as to the clerical people who are within the terms of the Bill and those who are outside the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy Dockrell has made clear that, with the definition in the Bill, it is difficult for anybody, including the Minister, to say who are covered as people engaged on shop work.
Comment on this
I think that the Minister has failed to get the force of the argument for a change in the definition. Deputy Dockrell is concerned only with having the definition clear and knowing who is included and who is excluded. We, of this Party, are concerned with something more than that. We are concerned with having a clear definition, but we are also concerned with having a definition that will include all shop workers.
The Minister has seen the inside of a shop and he knows that it usually contains an office. In that office, in the case of the larger shops, there is a cashier, who would be actually in contact with customers and who would clearly come within the definition in the Bill. Besides that cashier, there might be a ledger clerk who would be entering up customers' accounts. Is it suggested that the cashier will be within the terms of the Bill but that the ledger clerk will not because he is not in direct contact with customers?
When the Minister talks about the need for legislation on somewhat different lines for clerical workers outside shops, we all agree. That is a different problem. The problem with which we are dealing is that of clerical workers employed inside shops. If there is to be a line of demarcation drawn, you could hardly have a better one than that which would be drawn around the shops. It is illogical to include certain clerks, and anybody who happens to be in contact with customers, and to exclude those clerks sitting beside them because they are not in contact with customers, notwithstanding that they are working in the same shop and under the same conditions and for the same hours as those included. I suggest that the Minister should make the definition clear and should include everybody employed in a shop. The introduction of clerical workers in insurance offices, banks and other establishments did not seem to me to have anything to do with this question. The present position seems to me to be ridiculous. If you have inspectors enforcing this legislation, one of them may go into a shop and see that the provisions of the Act are being complied with in respect of everybody but the ledger clerk. He will pass him by and say: "I shall come next week, or some other inspector will come, and look after you." Surely it would simplify the matter, from the Minister's point of view, to include all people employed within the four walls of a shop.
Comment on this
I should like to put another point to the Minister. With the development of the telephone, the practice of ordering goods by telephone is growing. Deputy Dockrell will probably confirm that. A person may ring up a shop, ask the prices of certain commodities, order certain commodities, ask when they will be delivered, and direct the bill to be sent to him. The employee is there dealing with a customer. He may be a clerk employed in the office, because you cannot have a telephone at the counter where particular goods are stocked. Why should not that employee be brought within the scope of the Bill in the same way as an ordinary assistant dealing with a customer? If the Minister said that all employees other than those standing behind the counter would be outside the scope of the Bill, I could understand his contention, but here we have a section which says that the Bill applies to persons engaged in shopwork, that work being defined as "any type of work connected with or ancillary to the business." You do not mean by that the actual serving of a customer. It means something over and above that. It means work extending into another domain such as that of cashier, dispatch clerk, or a person who would answer the telephone and take an order of the kind I have mentioned.
When the Minister brings these workers within the scope of the Bill, he is clearly driven to including certain clerical workers employed in the shop. Why not go further and say that, in these circumstances, the shop is the proper line of demarcation and that all clerical workers employed in the shop are, in fact, covered by the Bill? If, at a later stage, legislation is introduced to deal with clerical workers generally, it would be possible, by repealing certain portions of this Bill, to transfer the clerical workers affected to the new Bill. At this stage the most convenient course is to bring in all clerical workers whose business is ancillary to the business of the shop. I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter in the light of the difficulties to which attention has been drawn.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dockrell wants to suggest any alteration in it, I am prepared to consider it, but, in my opinion, if you attempt to become more precise in relation to the class of persons covered by it, you will become more restrictive, and it is not necessary to do so. There are in relation to the terms used here a number of legal decisions which make it considerably easier to draft this legislation knowing precisely the consequences it is going to have. So far as Deputy Norton's point is concerned, I can say only this to him, that if he says that clerical workers require the protection of legislation of this kind as shop assistants require it, that transport workers require this protection, or that any other class of worker not covered by the existing Act require it, I am inclined to agree with him, but this is a Bill to deal with shop assistants, and I want to confine it to shop assistants.
Comment on this
Well, persons who are engaged wholly or mainly in connection with the serving of customers, receipt of orders and dispatch of goods in a shop.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not see the force of this, that it is entirely illogical to include in the scope of the Bill the invoice clerk and exclude the ledger clerk? Does it not really mean that, as interpreted by the Minister?
Comment on this
I would not say that, nor do I think it wise that we should use terms of that kind. I draw the line around the shop, and I say that anyone who works in that shop is covered by the Bill. Deputy Norton wants to go further and take in the whole building in which the shop is located, and to include the office of the firm operating the shop, although that office may be on the opposite side of the city.
Comment on this
No, not necessarily. I am leaving in the words, "connected with or ancillary to the business carried on in the shop."
Comment on this
The office where the accounts of the firm are made up and the profit and loss determined is distinct, in my opinion, from the shop. In the average medium-sized shop this question will not arise at all, because the people who are doing that type of clerical work are either proprietors or persons otherwise engaged in connection with the shop, but in the larger establishments there is a clear distinction between the shop and the office. We are dealing with the shop, and everyone who works in the shop, even though the work he does is clerical work, is covered by the Bill. We are dealing with the type of people who work in the shops as members of the staffs of shops, and I propose to resist any movement to get beyond that. I think it was a mistake to have gone beyond that in relation to hotels, but we have gone there now and we will stay there. I think it might have been better to have kept hotels out of this legislation, as not being shops and as offering different problems from those which arise in shops, but to the extent to which they are in we will have to keep them in if we can get over the purely drafting difficulties involved. I want to confine this legislation to the members of staffs of shops, leaving out the purely clerical workers whose association with shops arises from their employers operating shops, as would be the case if those employers operated factories, and leaving out the purely transport workers and certain other people who might be employed, such as electricians and plumbers.
Comment on this
You will get overlapping cases. When the Conditions of Employment Act was before us, I mentioned that Woolworth's had been held to be a factory because there was a girl behind the counter printing visiting cards. These cases will arise where some difficulty of interpretation or application develops, but I am setting forth here the general idea behind this Bill, and, while I am prepared to consider any proposal designed to ensure that that general idea will be carried out, I am, at the same time, prepared to resist any proposal to extend that general idea.
I am at one with Deputy Norton, or any other Deputy who urges that similar legislation is required for other classes of workers. I agree fully with that, but I say that it should be done by separate measures, and not by extension of this Bill. We should confine this to persons who work as members of the staffs of shops— anybody doing work which is defined here as work proper to be done by the members of staffs of shops.
Comment on this
In view of the extent to which purchasing on the instalment plan has developed, will the Minister say whether collectors and canvassers connected with a shop come within the Bill?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether the clerical worker who answers the telephone, deals with a customer's order and transacts a good portion of the business in connection with it, comes within the scope of the Bill?
Comment on this
The definition says that shop work means "work connected with or ancillary to the business".
Comment on this
The Deputy will see that the term used in the earlier definition of a member of a staff is "wholly or mainly".
Comment on this
The Minister has told us, and I think quite rightly, that he proposes to introduce a Bill to deal with the question of transport, but the latter portion of the definition says:—
...does not include work in connection with the wholesale shop other than... (b) work in the collection or delivery of goods, or in attendance upon customers, or in carrying messages or running errands.
Is there any reason why this should not have been left over for that Transport Bill?
Comment on this
I have just been reading that myself, and I have been puzzling over it. I am not clear as to whether or not there has been a typing error there, and I should like to reconsider it before dealing with it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (1), before line 39, to insert the words:—"without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing the expression `shop work' shall include the work done within a shop in connection with the cleaning of such shop".
The amendment proposes to bring in cleaners. That class of workers in factories is covered by the Conditions of Employment Act. I would hope that the Minister would bring them into the Bill.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear as to what class of worker the Deputy has in mind. A person who is ordinarily a shop assistant remains one even though occasionally he has to clean the shop or portion of the shop. If the Deputy has in mind charwomen and people of that character, I do not think they would fit in under this Bill. Their hours of work must obviously be different from those of the ordinary shop assistant. I do not think that the same conditions would apply in respect of them as would apply in respect of shop assistants.
Comment on this
From the legislative point of view, what does the Minister propose to do in respect of that class?
Comment on this
That is another question. I cannot quite visualise the type of person that Deputy O'Brien seems to have in mind. I think that most of the persons engaged in the larger shops in connection with the cleaning of them are also engaged as packers or as persons who would come within the definition of "a member of the staff," as set out in the section. I do not know that there would be any person employed solely as a cleaner except perhaps in a part-time capacity.
Comment on this
They would not work for more than a few hours in a day in those establishments, and could not, therefore, be regarded as in need of legislation of this kind. What those people would probably require is not a restriction of hours of work but more work.
Comment on this
I have already mentioned that it is intended to introduce legislation—a general Bill applying to people under contract of service, with certain obvious exemptions.
Comment on this
Subject to all sorts of contingencies, early next year, so that it will operate next year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (1), before line 39, to insert the following words:—"the expression `catering trades' means the business carried on in a refreshment house".
There is no definition of "catering" in the Bill, and I think the Minister will agree that this is a trade that requires a definition. The Minister is probably aware that when the British Ministry of Labour proposed to establish a trade board for the catering trade there was an action brought in the High Court. The decision of the court was that the word "catering" was not sufficiently precise to be defined. I think the Minister will agree that a definition is required here.
Comment on this
I will have the matter examined, and if a definition is required I will have one inserted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
In sub-section (1), before line 45, to insert the following words—"the expression `contravention' in relation to any provision includes any failure to comply with that provision or with any rule, regulation, bye-law or order construed in reference thereto".
This is a purely technical amendment. It is a definition of the word "contravention".
Comment on this
The word is used with regard to an Act of Parliament itself, but when you use it with reference to orders made by the Minister, I think it would definitely mean something in the nature of an interpretation. I think if the Minister looks into the matter he will see that a definition of the word is required.
Comment on this
It is purely a drafting matter. If the Deputy leaves it over I will consult the draftsman.
Comment on this
On the section, I wish to call attention to the wording of sub-section (3), which says:—
Save as is otherwise expressly provided in this Act, the provisions of this Act shall extend to any place where any retail trade or business is carried on as if that place were a shop and as if in relation to any such place the person by whom the retail trade or business is carried on there were the proprietor of that shop.
What happens where different classes of trade are being carried on in the same part of a shop? Take the ordinary country shop, where over the same counter alcohol, cutlery, boots and a lot of other things are being sold. There is only the one counter, and you have a mixed general business being carried on over it. This seems to contemplate that a person is selling boots, alcohol, etc., over different counters. That is not done in the ordinary country shop.
Comment on this
That point does not arise here. If a person is selling one class of goods in one part of the premises and another class of goods in another part of the premises then the whole of the premises is regarded as a shop. There is no difficulty in determining that fact. The case that we are attempting to meet here is where the business carried on in part of the premises is not a retail business. Where a retail business is carried on in some part of the premises then, for the purposes of the Act, the whole of the premises is deemed to be a shop.
Comment on this
I simply put this forward as a matter that the Minister might consider. Suppose you have one of these Sunday trading businesses, plus a retail trade in boots carried on over the same counter, a difficulty may arise.
Comment on this
That is a problem that would arise in connection with the Hours of Trading Bill but not on this Bill.
Comment on this
I desire to draw the Minister's attention to the definition of the expressions "member of the staff" and "shop work". To my mind "shop work" is given a much wider definition than "member of the staff." The expression "member of the staff" is said to mean any person who does any work which is wholly or mainly performed within the shop and is wholly or mainly in connection with the serving of customers or the receipt of orders or the despatch of goods or the unpacking or packing of goods and is not industrial work under the Conditions of Employment Act. The expression "shop work" is said to mean work which is connected with or ancillary to the business carried on at a shop, and so on. On Deputy Norton's amendment I think that certain clerical workers would be out as members of the staff and in as doing shop work, so that it seems to me that these two definitions are in conflict.
Comment on this
In connection with the definition of "shop work" I have already mentioned that I want the phraseology there used reconsidered, because I think it might be clarified, or amended in some respects.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
Before Section 3 to insert the following new section:—
For the purpose of this Act a person shall be deemed to continue to do shop work during the time which the person so employed is at the disposal of the employer exclusive of any intervals allowed for rest or meals.
The amendment seeks to ensure that an employee, so long as he is available for work on the premises, will be regarded as being in continuous employment. It might happen that an employer would have a shop worker available at certain periods and say to him that his services were not required at that particular moment, and that in consequence of that the hours so spent on the premises would not count in his favour. This amendment proposes to make that position impossible: that, so long as a worker is on the premises and available for work, his hours there will count.
Comment on this
I am prepared to accept the amendment in principle, although I think it will be necessary to provide that the worker is on the premises on the strict instructions of his employer. If the Deputy is prepared to leave the matter over I will see what we can do.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, line 5, after the word "gain" to insert the words "except a club in respect of which there is granted or renewed a certificate of registration pursuant to the provisions of the Registration of Clubs (Ireland) Act, 1904."
The object of this amendment is that a club should be put on the same basis as ordinary licensed premises. I will admit immediately to the Minister that, as I drafted this amendment, it is really much wider and covers much more than what I have in mind in connection with this matter. The class of clubs that I wish to deal with are not social clubs, such as golf clubs, and clubs of that nature, but the type of club which is really, in all but name, a publichouse. I am sure the Minister knows the type of club to which I refer. It is rather difficult to get a word that would cover that type of club and yet not include the other type of club, but what I am driving at really is that, as I am sure the Minister knows, there are various clubs around the city here which, in effect, are simply publichouses under another name, and I do not see why the employees in such places should not be treated in the same way as in other cases.
Comment on this
Yes, but I am afraid that I have drafted it in such a way as to cover more than I meant it to cover. I think it is a little too wide in its application as I have drafted it.
Comment on this
Clubs, of course, are not exempted from the provisions of the Bill. The sub-section does exempt certain institutions, such as libraries and so on, which are not carried on for purposes of gain other than that of making profits for some philanthropic object. I think that what the Deputy has in mind is certain so-called clubs which purport not to be carried on for the purposes of gain but which are, in fact, so carried on and which, as the Deputy says, are practically publichouses, except in name. It is very difficult, however, to see how one could deal with that point, because what you are up against in a case like that is the question of an evasion of the law. The law cannot touch a case like that because these clubs, to which the Deputy has referred, manage to keep within the letter of the law, even though they might be outside the spirit of it, and I do not see how we could quite get at such institutions without, at the same time, bringing within the scope of the Bill quite a number of bona fide charitable institutions which should not be affected by legislation of this kind.
Of course we might exempt clubs from this sub-section altogether and make them all subject to the provisions of the Bill, and say that their employees should be entitled to the benefits of the Bill whether these clubs or other such institutions are carried on for purposes of gain or not. I think that that would be the only way to meet the Deputy's point, but that would have the effect of bringing in golf clubs and other such clubs and making these bodies subject to the provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
Well, perhaps the Minister would consult with the parliamentary draftsman with a view to seeing whether or not some scheme might be devised, or some formula devised, which would take in the particular class of club I have in mind, and of which I am sure the Minister is aware, and at the same time exempt the other class of club. Of course, if the parliamentary draftsman says that it cannot be done, well, I suppose it cannot be done.
Comment on this
If these clubs, to which the Deputy refers, have employees, why should they not be entitled to the same benefits as those which the employees of other institutions are entitled to under the Bill? The object of the Bill is to provide certain benefits for the employees of clubs carried on for gain. Why, therefore, should we have a sub-division of these clubs in order to ascertain whether or not certain people are entitled to benefits? Is it the object to take from outside the scope of the Bill certain employees and to prevent them from getting the benefits that would be got by employees engaged in similar work in a private establishment?
Comment on this
Well, of course, the distinction I drew was that in certain clubs the servants are in the same position as the servants in ordinary houses. However, I do not want to deal with that point. What I want to deal with is this other type of club, to which I have referred and which, I am sure, both the Deputy and the Minister know about.
Comment on this
On Section 4, Sir, I should like to know from the Minister what kind of person exactly is sub-section (2) (b) intended to refer to.
Comment on this
I think that the definition in the sub-section is fairly clear. One of the questions that arose when this Bill was being prepared was the question of the extent to which it should apply to post offices, and there was considerable discussion between my Department and the Department of Posts and Telegraphs before agreement was reached. The agreement was to the effect that where a member of a staff of a shop in which post-office business is carried on is a person who has been appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, then that person is outside the scope of the Bill, but that where he was appointed by somebody else, such as, let us say, by the person who was appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, then he comes within the provisions of the Bill and gets whatever benefits may accrue under the provisions of this Bill. The one thing we wanted to avoid—and I am sure the Deputy will realise its necessity—was to have one Department of State making regulations governing the conditions of employment of persons in the service of another Department of State.
Comment on this
Well, I wonder why this exclusion has been put in, because it seems to me that the person who is appointed in the circumstances would be a person who had been appointed sub-postmaster or sub-postmistress as the case might be. That person would be the owner of the shop, and I never heard of a case of an appointment made in any other way.
Comment on this
Well, I am not very familiar with the affairs of the Post Office Department, but I understand that there are certain types of intermediary establishments or shops of that nature.
Comment on this
I mean that, as I understand it, there are certain types of shops where certain people, other than the proprietors of the shops, are appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, as distinct from the case where the sub-postmaster or sub-postmistress is appointed by the Department and might employ other persons as members of the staff who are not within the Minister's control. The point is that the persons appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will not come under the provisions of the Act, and, of course, if they are proprietors, they will not be under its provisions.
Comment on this
I think that this provision is redundant, because I think you cannot find a case where the sub-postmaster or the sub-postmistress is a member of the staff of a shop. What happens in normal circumstances, and, in fact, in all circumstances one might say, is that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs appoints a person as sub-postmaster or sub-postmistress, and that person functions in that capacity for the Minister; but, in addition, that person may also run a shop and, in respect of that shop, that person is the owner of the shop and the employer in regard to any staff he may have. I should like to know under what circumstances that person is within the scope of the Bill at all to make it necessary for the Minister to provide for this exemption.
Comment on this
Then why not say that no proprietor is within the scope of the Bill, instead of making this kind of special provision? It seems to be unnecessary in the circumstances and, because of its obviously unnecessary character, my suspicions were aroused. Why not say every proprietor is out? Why take this particular line?
Comment on this
A sub-postmaster or a sub-postmistress might have a shop as well as the post office running for private gain. Why should it not apply then?
Comment on this
The proprietor of the shop might be an employee of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. I am anxious to get the Deputy's point.
Comment on this
The Minister asks us to pass a Bill and I am asking him to explain what he is asking us to pass. He cannot explain. I will tell you what I understand. In this Bill the proprietor is not intended. Is not that clear?
Comment on this
Where the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs appoints a sub-postmaster—I presume that is what they are called—and that sub-postmaster employs a staff, that staff is in precisely the same position as the staff employed by any other shop proprietor. But, then, there are post offices where the staffs are not appointed by the sub-postmaster; they are appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. They, presumably, would be civil servants. In any event, it is intended that they should be excluded by the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy means by an ordinary post office. In the G.P.O. the selling of postal orders might be held to be within the scope of the Bill if the sub-section were not there.
Comment on this
I take it that this sub-section would cover a case like the following. Suppose there is a postmaster or a postmistress and there is appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, let me say, a girl to do the telegraph business in that particular office. In addition, because that would not take up her whole time, she might work at selling drapery or something of that kind for the postmistress, receiving pay. She would not then be covered by this Bill.
Comment on this
There are obviously persons employed in post offices who are appointed by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.
Comment on this
We all know that. What I want to know is, would an ordinary post office, let us say the General Post Office, or the College Green post office, be within the scope of the Bill were it not for sub-section (2) (b), and is a post office ordinarily within the Bill under the definition?
Comment on this
The object is to exclude from the scope of the Bill civil serwants employed in a post office.
Comment on this
Is that the purpose of sub-section (2) (b)? Would they be in were it not for sub-section (2) (b)?
Comment on this
That is clear, because they are not employed by the Minister. In the case of an ordinary post office official who works behind the counter of the shop, would that person be in were it not for sub-section (2) (b)?
Comment on this
There is a point I raised with the Minister on Second Reading and that is as regards sub-section (2) (a), "A member of the staff of a shop who is a relative of the proprietor of such shop," and the Minister pointed out that it would be absurd to expect a husband to allow his wife a week's holiday. I do not know that he put it quite like that.
Comment on this
That it would be absurd to compel him to do it. I think there are other sections in the Bill where the power of compulsion on the relatives might be enforced. As a matter of fact, this matter has already been covered fairly extensively on the definition section and, possibly, the Minister might hold that it would be better to raise the others on the different sections. There is, for instance, the question of the employment of juveniles, the working hours for juveniles, and the working hours for adults, which might be better brought up under the sections.
Comment on this
It says here, "save where otherwise expressly provided." So far as I read the Bill, it is not expressly provided anywhere.
Comment on this
It is expressly provided in Part II, for example, which relates to the restriction on the employment of juveniles. If an Order were made fixing the maximum number of juveniles who may be employed in a shop in relation to the number of adults, then, in calculating the number of adult members of the staff, account will be taken of any adult members who are relatives of the proprietor of the shop and members of the staff of such shop. I cannot remember for a moment if it arises on any other Part of the Bill but it certainly does arise in Part II, that members of the staff of shops who are relatives of the proprietor, and therefore excluded from the benefits of the Bill, have nevertheless to be taken into account in relation to certain provisions.
Comment on this
In sub-sections (a) and (b) there seems to be a big difference between the penalties which can be imposed. Is there any particular reason for that?
Comment on this
In sub-section (a) we are defining the penalties which may be imposed on members of the staff of shops and, in the other, the penalties which may be inflicted on proprietors.