Committee on Finance. - Shop Assistants (Conditions of Employment (No. 2) Bill, 1937—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 193–396 of 396. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move amendment No. 22:—
To delete sub-section (1).
I mentioned on Second Reading that I would do so. Sub-section (1) provides: "Any offence under any section of this Act (other than Part VI) may be prosecuted by or at the suit of the Minister as prosecutor." I understand that that may be regarded as restrictive, that it may be regarded as having the effect of confining the prosecutions to the Minister and precluding anyone else from instituting proceedings. That is not what was intended, and I think it is not desirable. It is desirable that members of the staffs of shops, trade unions acting on their behalf, or any other person, should be in a position to institute proceedings for the purpose of the enforcement of the conditions of the Act. Therefore I propose to delete the sub-section, an amendment which will have that effect.
Comment on this
Certainly. I think it means that anyone can prosecute, the Minister or anybody else.
Comment on this
Where is that authority given because, as far as I know, unless there is a special enabling section nobody can prosecute except the Attorney-General? The Guards may, under the Attorney-General, but nobody can bring a criminal prosecution. Of course a person can proceed summarily if he is injured in his own person. I would very much question if a shop assistant who is kept after hours, and who wished to prosecute his employers, would be able to bring proceedings.
Comment on this
There is no question that he has the power to do so, but he has to do it in a capacity which, in this country, is not regarded as very pleasant. It is in the same capacity as that in which the Minister may proceed, namely, that of a common informer. On that basis anybody can proceed and it is on that basis the Minister will proceed when this sub-section is deleted.
Comment on this
It is quite a sound basis, although the name was associated with certain unpleasant things in our past history.
Comment on this
I do not think it is necessary. The theory, of course, is that any citizen who knows of an offence against the law proceeds to exercise his duty as a citizen and to invoke the law.
Comment on this
Is the Minister quite clear that a prosecution instituted by anybody would stand in law? Sub-section (2) says "shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly." I think that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is quite correct, that, on the wording of that section, nobody can prosecute but the Attorney-General. It is very doubtful if a prosecution instituted by, say, A.B. would stand in law without his being specially authorised to prosecute as a common informer. Is there any authority for such a thing?
Comment on this
I think so. I do not profess to have any legal knowledge. I am acting on advice but if any query is raised it will be examined and we can put in a line later to make clear who can institute proceedings.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy O'Brien would leave over Amendment No. 23 and in the meantime I shall look into the point raised.
Comment on this
The object is to enable a Union acting for workers to initiate proceedings where it is acting on behalf of the workers, in the same way as a worker would normally do it.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister should look into these various types of prosecutions. I think that in the Game Laws there is an express provision for prosecution by what you would call common informers.
Comment on this
I shall look into the matter. The difficulty, I understand, is that any provision of that kind is held to restrict the power to prosecute, even though the word "may" is used.
Comment on this
I would advise the Minister strongly to look into Section 6 very carefully, because he may find himself high and dry, with nobody having the power to prosecute except the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
Quite; I shall look into the matter.
Section 6, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 7.
(4) This section shall not apply in respect of the proprietor of a shop if the only members of the staff of such shop are relatives of such proprietor.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:—
In page 7, before sub-section (4) to insert the following new sub-section:—
"(4) If any person with intent to deceive makes, or causes or allows to be made, in any such record or notice as aforesaid, an entry which is, to his knowledge, false in any material part, or wilfully omits or causes or allows to be omitted from any such record or notice, an entry required to be made therein, such person shall be guilty of an offence under this Act."
Section 7 relates to the provision whereby the Minister may require the proprietor of a shop to keep certain records which, in his opinion, are necessary for the enforcement of certain portions of the Act. He may require a person to keep these records as often as he thinks fit. In sub-section (3) it is provided:—
If whenever a records order is in force the proprietor of a shop fails, neglects or refuses to comply with the requirements of such order, such proprietor shall be guilty of an offence under this section.
I think provision is clearly made there to deal with the case where a proprietor fails, neglects, or refuses to comply with the provisions of the order, but there does not appear to be any adequate provision, or, in fact, any provision at all, in regard to a case where a proprietor complies with the provisions of the order, but does so in a manner which results in information of a misleading character—either accidentally or wilfully misleading—being provided.
I think the Minister should take power in this section to deal with cases where a proprietor may find it necessary to comply with the Minister's order but does so in such a way as only to make available in respect of the order information of a misleading or inaccurate kind. It does not seem to me that the Minister has power to deal with cases where information of a misleading kind is provided under his requirement that certain records should be kept. I think the Minister should have power to deal with a situation of that kind and to enforce penalties.
Comment on this
I think it is hardly necessary to make the amendment sought by the Deputy, but I shall have inquiries made to see if the Parliamentary draftsman thinks that such a provision is necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
To delete sub-section 4.
This sub-section exempts the proprietor of a shop, who has only relatives employed, from keeping records. I am moving to delete that sub-section so as to make a person employing only relatives liable to keep records. It would certainly facilitate an inspector going to the shop if he were able to inspect records, to find out the number of employees there and the number of them who were relatives. I think that the least we should expect from people who employ only relatives is that they should keep records of those whom they employ, and thereby facilitate the inspector in his work of differentiating between ordinary employees and relatives.
Comment on this
That is quite sound in theory, but I want the Deputy to keep in mind Mrs. Mulligan's huckster shop in the Coombe. That is the type of shop that is going to be affected if this provision is cut out. Mrs. Mulligan will not keep the records, and in due course will have to be prosecuted. That will look a bit ridiculous, seeing that no really effective purpose is served by making her keep the records. Therefore, I would be disposed to resist the Deputy's amendment, because it is only in relation to Parts 2, 3 and 4 of the Bill that power to make those orders exists. They are: Restrictions on employment of juveniles; working hours and meal times, and the provision of holidays; and as none of the members of the family of an employer working in those shops is affected by those sections, the keeping of the records is only a formality. It would certainly be regarded as only a formality by the persons concerned, and they would not do it. That means that we would have made a provision here which was subsequently ignored, and it is bad to have any laws ignored, or else that in due course we would have to prosecute those people for a technicality. I do not think we should put ourselves in that position. It is better to leave it as it is, and I think the Deputy may be assured that the inspectors will have adequate powers under the next section to make whatever inquiries are necessary to enable them to enforce the provisions of the Act. It is better to deal with it in that way rather than put upon certain people a legal obligation, the carrying out of which is extremely improbable, and which, even if carried out, would be of very little benefit to anybody.
Comment on this
Let us take this lady friend of the Minister, Mrs. Mulligan, who keeps a huckster shop in the Coombe, and suppose Mrs. Mulligan has one employee in the shop, a young girl. Mrs. Mulligan is required to keep those records. Suppose a friend of Mrs. Mulligan, a few shops lower down, has in fact four relatives employed in the shop. Mrs. Mulligan's rival, with a staff of four relatives, would be exempt from keeping the records.
Comment on this
Quite. The Minister claims to know much more about this lady than I do, and I will acknowledge his superior judgment in this matter. But the Minister gives to Deputy McGowan a reason for resisting this amendment, which does not seem to me to carry any water. Let us get back to this immortal soul, Mrs. Mulligan, who has an establishment in the Coombe. If Mrs. Mulligan has one person employed in that shop, Mrs. Mulligan is obliged to keep records?
Comment on this
And those are the records that Deputy McGowan wants kept. Mrs. Mulligan's rival on the other side of the street, or a few shops further down, has two or three relatives employed in her shop and living with her. Mrs. Mulligan's rival is exempt from keeping records. Why should Mrs. Mulligan, with her establishment of one, be required to keep records when Mrs. Mulligan's rival, with an establishment of three, is exempt from keeping records?
Comment on this
Well, of course, those relatives are not employed. A number of relatives will come under the definition—sons or daughters, or brothers or sisters, living on the premises.
Comment on this
As Mrs. Mulligan's shop is on the floor of the street in the Coombe, am I to understand that she comes within the measure?
Comment on this
As far as I understand it, there is a good deal more in it than merely a small huckster shop. Suppose you take this fancy lady, Mrs. Mulligan, and suppose she has not a shop at all in the ordinary sense of the term. Suppose she has merely a street barrow. A street barrow is a shop within the meaning of this. Suppose she employs other relatives, and suppose an order were made, she would have to keep a record of the alleys in which any relative of hers was working with this barrow. That does seem rather farfetched.
Comment on this
I do not like this section at all. It undoubtedly does not go at all as far as the Hours of Employment Bill, but Section 8, in my judgment, even as it stands now, goes a good deal too far. I certainly should like the Minister to consider an amendment—although I have not put down an amendment myself—similar to that section which is in the Factory Acts. The Minister himself made reference to the Factory Acts in the discussion on the other measure as an authority for what he was doing. Under the Factory Acts there is a special provision that no statement made by a person under a particular section shall be used in evidence against him, and I certainly think that this Section 8 should have precisely the same safeguard for the liberty of the citizen. I would ask the Minister to consider that, and I hope he will do so. Otherwise I will put down an amendment myself on the Report Stage, but I hope that will not be necessary.
Comment on this
This section, in the manner in which it is drafted, raises a very much bigger question than the mere administration of this Bill, because, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney rightly points out, I think it goes very much further than the Factory Acts or the Shop Acts. As it is drafted, it is capable of introducing an entirely new feature into what might constitute an offence, and into the charge upon which a person might be tried, and possibly convicted. It has been recognised under the Shop Acts, and I think under the Factory Acts, that a statement made by a person cannot be used against him; in other words, that he cannot make a statement incriminating himself. I think if the Minister looks at those Acts he will see that. That has been the invariable practice in respect to prosecutions under the Acts. If we are going to depart from that principle, we ought to do it in a specific Act, definitely changing the existing legal position in that regard, but we ought not to drag in the principle through this Bill.
Comment on this
We cannot see the parts without reference to the existing position, namely, the Factory Acts and the Shop Acts.
Comment on this
I do not know what they have got to do with it. Here is a section which sets out the powers of the inspectors. To what part of it does the Deputy object?
Comment on this
He must, under penalty, answer every question which is put to him, and his answers can then be used in evidence against him.
Comment on this
Oh, no. He is under penalty if he furnishes any information knowing the same to be false.
Comment on this
Under sub-section (1) (c), he is required to give such information in regard to any particular member of the staff as may reasonably be required. If he refuses to do it, such person shall be guilty of an offence under this section.
Comment on this
But the whole position up to date has been that he cannot be required to do anything which would incriminate himself. Will the Minister say why there has been such a departure from the existing position? Has that been specifically considered? Has it been thought desirable to depart from it? If it has, it ought to be done in a piece of general legislation, and not in particular legislation of this kind. There ought to be the onus on the State of prosecuting the person and producing evidence to convict the person; but the person should not be put in the position whereby a statement of his can incriminate him. The reverse has been the position up to now.
Comment on this
Has the Minister seen the relevant provisions of the Shops Act and the Factory Acts?
Comment on this
I want Deputy Norton to tell me how it is possible to enforce the provisions of this Act unless the inspector has power to enter at all reasonable times any shop and require the proprietor to produce to him any records which such proprietor is required to keep and to inspect and take copies of entries and records and require such information with regard to any particular member of the staff as he may reasonably require. If the Deputy can tell me any way by which an inspector——
Comment on this
That sets out the penalty that applies in certain circumstances. I am dealing with the powers given to the inspector. If there is, for instance, an order which says that not more than two juveniles can be employed for every five adults, should not an inspector be empowered to go in and ask the proprietor questions in that connection, and should it not be an offence for the proprietor to refuse to give information?
Comment on this
The general practice has been that a person should not be required to make a statement incriminating himself.
Comment on this
If the Minister looks into the Factory Acts he will see there that the answers which are made by the proprietor of the factory to the inspector, or any person who is interrogated by the factory inspector, shall not be used in evidence against him. That is precisely the amendment which I wish to have brought in here. For the first time in our laws—it was under Article 2A of the Constitution—powers were taken to compel a person to answer questions put to him. Now, Article 2A was dealing with a very dangerous conspiracy. You are putting perhaps not quite as bad a power in this measure, but here you have the thin end of the wedge. Under the legislation dealing with the hours of employment, you have gone the whole hog, but here you have not gone quite so far. I suggest the Minister should bring in an amendment on the Report Stage which will make it clear that an answer given by a man shall not be used in evidence against that man if he is prosecuted. That is in the Factory Acts and I do not see why it should not be in these Acts. It goes down to the very basis of the administration of criminal law in this land, that nobody shall be convicted upon his own statements unless those statements are made by him freely and voluntarily.
The Minister must be aware that, in the ordinary course of their business investigating serious crimes, the Guards have to give a caution to the individual if they intend to arrest him, that he need not say anything, and that if he says anything it will be taken down in evidence and may be used against him. Here you have got a completely new departure, that a person must submit to interrogation and examination and that his answers may be used in court against him. It is an entirely new departure. I venture to think that if the Attorney-General, who is a man of standing in the Irish Bar, were to see this section, and especially if he were to see the section in the Shop Hours Act, he would very nearly get a stroke of apoplexy. I do not think the Minister quite understands the gravity of the change he is bringing in. I am sure he does not.
The Minister accused me the other day of trying to pull the leg of the House—I think that is what he said. I am not; I am talking very seriously, and I inform him that he is bringing in an alarming innovation into the administration of criminal law in this country. He is upsetting the whole basis upon which the criminal law rests, that is, that no man is bound to incriminate himself. Here you have a section in which a man is bound to incriminate himself, and his answers can be used in evidence against him. I wish the Minister would talk to the Attorney-General. If he does, I am satisfied this section will not stand. I would like to know if the Minister will bring in an amendment such as I have suggested, bringing this into line with the Factory Acts. If he says he will not, I will bring in such an amendment on the Report Stage and I will fight this section as hard as I can.
Comment on this
I have some sympathy with the point of view of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in this matter, but I do not think he correctly quoted the Factory Acts. As I understand it, he said that the Factory Acts have a provision to the effect that a statement made to an inspector using the powers given him under the Act may not be used in evidence against the person making the statement. That is not the position. The position is that there is a provision which says that the person under inspection may not be required to make a statement which can be used to incriminate him. It is not just the same thing. I do think there is a case for something like that in this section. I think it is desirable that the inspectors or Gárdaí or anybody having the responsibility of enforcing legislation of this kind should have the widest possible powers. I have no sympathy with any attempt to limit reasonable powers of inspection, but I think there is a case for the introduction of a proviso here such as exists in the Factory Acts.
Comment on this
I would like to put one point to the Minister. I wonder, under a section like this, does he realise the position of the ordinary individual? Has he compared the position of an individual who will be prosecuted for a breach of an Act of this nature with that of the person charged with being suspected of a grave criminal offence? Such a person cannot be compelled to make any statement except under due caution. A person suspected of committing a breach of a highly technical Act of this nature is put in this position by the inspector "Heads I win, tails you lose." If a person does not give him the information he will be prosecuted, and if he does give the information he may be convicted out of his own mouth. I do not think that is a reasonable principle of law to establish.
Again, where an inspector gets a statement from an individual under these circumstances, that statement is given verbally. It may or may not be entered by the inspector in a notebook. I suggest to the Minister that prosecutions under this Act might develop into a terrible farce in court and prosecutions may be rendered farcical if you are going to have this type of thing with an inspector: "On such a day I interrogated So-and-so and he told me..." Then the defendant states that the inspector's recollection is entirely wrong and he told him no such thing. There you will have a verbal statement to the inspector. The inspector declares that the defendant told him a certain thing and the defendant denies it, and it will be a question whether the inspector's version of what happened will be accepted in preference to the defendant's. I think that type of legislation is entirely wrong. You should not compel people to convict themselves.
Comment on this
Yes. I hope Deputies have also studied the legislation enacted here, legislation of this character, over the last 15 years, providing for the appointment of inspectors. I thought I was considerably restrained in the powers I sought under this Bill for inspectors, at least compared with other measures passed here.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us of any Bill which was passed here that contained a provision of this kind? I do not recollect a single one.
Comment on this
I want to know which one the Minister refers to. In Article 2A of the Constitution there is a similar provision, but I did not introduce Article 2A.
Comment on this
If the Minister will point to a single Bill passed by this House, even under the ægis of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, in which a provision of this kind was inserted, I shall certainly take a new view, but I venture to say that what the Minister has urged in that respect is evidence of the fact that he does not really appreciate the radical departure from the existing criminal law which is effected in this section. My complaint as regards the section is that it has a Constitution Amendment Act mentality. Under that Act, it was an offence to refuse to answer a question. That is not an offence in any other democratic country. Under the Constitution Amendment Act we made that an artificial offence for the purpose of squeezing people for certain information. If they refused to give the information, we arraigned them on that charge. That was what the Constitution Amendment Act provided and we all know the mentality in which that Act was conceived. Here we have the same mentality. If any person refuses to produce any record or refuses to give any information which an inspector may lawfully require him to produce or give——
Comment on this
——then that person is guilty of an offence. If you refuse to give information, you are guilty of an offence. That has not been the position up to now under our criminal law and I challenge the Minister to produce an Act, other than the Constitution Amendment Act, in which a person becomes guilty of an offence by refusing to give information.
Comment on this
All that the section says is that an inspector may lawfully require the proprietor of a shop to give him such information, with regard to a particular member of the staff, as he may reasonably need for the fulfilment of his duties. This section provides that, if the proprietor refuses to give information, he is guilty of an offence. There is nothing in the section about the information being used to convict him.
Comment on this
If the Deputy consults his legal adviser, he will find that the matter is governed by the rules of evidence.
Comment on this
Quite clearly, the meaning of this section is that if one refuses to give information to an inspector, he will convict himself.
Comment on this
What the section on its face says is that if the proprietor of a shop refuses to give information which an inspector may lawfully require, it is an offence. There is nothing in the section which says that the information thus given may be adduced in evidence against the proprietor of the shop in any proceedings under any other part of the Bill.
Comment on this
I suggest that the section has a much wider significance than that, and that it is upsetting a well-defined criminal principle.
Comment on this
The Minister put in another section—6 (1)—empowering him to act as prosecutor. He probably got advice that that was limiting the prosecution to the Minister. If he consults the same authority as he consulted in connection with that provision, and if he looks up the Shops Act of 1912, and the Factory Acts, he will find that in both there has been recognition of the principle that a person should not be required to make a statement which will convict himself. Under this section a person can be required to make a statement to convict himself. As a layman, that is the meaning which I attach to these words.
Comment on this
That is obviously not the meaning which a layman would take from the words. There is nothing in the section about that.
Comment on this
The Minister should consult the Attorney-General and submit to him the relevant provisions of the other Acts. If he does that, he will find that we are enthroning here an entirely new principle not recognised, so far, in our criminal law. When he is doing that research work, he might also ascertain for us in what previous Bill a provision of this kind was inserted. He made the statement that it was inserted in many Bills.
Comment on this
The Minister says there is nothing in the section which provides that the information got from the proprietor of a shop will be used in evidence against him. Let us take a case in point. The inspector goes in. He tells the shopkeeper he wants to interrogate him and that, under the section, he must answer the questions. He gets answers in which the person concerned admits the offence. Will these answers be used in the court or will they not?
Comment on this
There is nothing in the section which deals with that. I should imagine that that would be determined by the rules of evidence.
Comment on this
Under the Factory Act, 1921, inspectors are given even wider powers than are given to the inspectors who will act under this Bill. But, after setting out those powers, that Act provides that no person shall be required to make a statement to be used in evidence against him. Is there any objection to inserting a clause of that kind in this Bill?
Comment on this
An interjection by the Minister suggested that the rules of evidence would govern this matter. The Supreme Court held that statements made to a Gárda officer were admissible in evidence.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney could provide for that, he had to amend the Constitution.
Comment on this
It is as specifically provided for here as it was in the Constitution (Amendment) Act.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 26:—
In sub-section (1), page 7, line 39, to insert after the word "shall" the words "in both the Irish and English languages".
The effect of the amendment is to provide that the abstract of the Act to be published shall be published bilingually.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:—
In page 7, before sub-section (2) to insert the following new sub-section:—
"The provisions of the next preceding sub-section shall not apply as regards any place, not being a shop, in which retail trade or business is carried on."
These abstracts are of large dimensions, about 48 inches by 38 inches. The Minister will understand the impossibility of displaying such large abstracts on, say, a barrow, a pedlar's pack, or again, on Mrs. Mulligan's wheelbarrow in the street. It would be impossible for these people to carry these large abstracts around. On my reading of the section the ordinary coalman going through the streets retailing coal would have to have them displayed, when the Bill becomes law.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the amendment in principle, but it is clear that the case Deputy McGowan makes for it does not hold water. The obligation of displaying the abstract applies only where a staff is employed.
Comment on this
It would not apply to a person selling goods from a barrow on the street, or to anything of that kind, unless someone was employed for wages.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the amendment. If persons are sent out from an establishment where they are employed in any numbers, I think the provision was intended to ensure that the employees would be aware of their rights. The sole idea of the abstract is to ensure that means will be provided by which employees could be made familiar with their rights. I am not so sure whether a person selling coal from a barrow in the street is a proprietor or an employee. In the great majority of cases I think they are proprietors. They are not in any sense employees of the merchants from whom they get the coal, and, consequently, they would not be affected by the section, unless they were assisted by a person employed for wages, which, I gather, is not the practice.
Comment on this
The Minister is not right in making that statement. It is the practice in Dublin for coal hawkers to employ a man, and, in the capacity of employers, they would come under the provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:—
Before Section 10 to insert the following new section:—
(1) In determining for the purpose of this Act the number of hours during which a person has, in any week, or other period, been employed about the business of any shop, he shall be deemed to have been so employed during any time during which he was in that week or other period as aforesaid employed about the business of any other shop or in any employment to which the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936, applies.
(2) A person who has been previously employed on any day in an employment to which the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936, applies shall not be employed on that day about the business of a shop for a longer period than will, together with the time during which he has been previously employed on that day in such other employment, complete the number of hours which under this Act he may lawfully be employed to do shop work.
The object of the amendment is to prevent a person being employed on the same day, first in a factory, and later in a shop, for more than the number of hours he could lawfully be employed, if employed in the shop the whole day. There is a similar provision in the Conditions of Employment Act, which provides that a person's hours of work can be determined by finding out what he was engaged at before he undertook a particular type of industrial work. Once he was employed in industrial work that day, it is part of his employment at industrial work. Under the Conditions of Employment Act all his hours in any kind of work can be aggregated and if they bring him to the maximum hours provided under that Act, that maximum operates in respect of that person. This is an attempt to bring in a similar provision which, I think, is a useful one, under this Bill in respect of shop workers, to have something comparable to what the Conditions of Employment Act does in respect to industrial workers.
Comment on this
I was not quite clear from the amendment what the Deputy had in mind. In view of what the Deputy has said I am prepared to consider in principle the insertion of an amendment which will have the effect he desires. I do not think his amendment as worded would have that effect. However, that is another matter. Perhaps the Deputy would withdraw his amendment now?
Comment on this
The idea is to extend it to persons employed at any occupations which come under this Bill, or occupations covered by the Conditions of Employment Act, so that they would be limited to the maximum hours that may be worked in a day or in a week to the maximum permitted by this Bill, even though a person had been at both kinds of employment during that period.
Comment on this
Yes. You might have a situation where a shop is run in connection with a factory, and a worker might be employed in the factory for three hours in the morning, and then work for nine or ten hours, as the case may be, in a shop for the remainder of the day. In respect of that work I want the factory and shop attendance aggregated so that the total attendance must be regarded as attendance which must be viewed in the light of this Bill.
Comment on this
I am prepared to draft an amendment to that effect, but I hope the Deputy will appreciate the difficulty of enforcing it.
Comment on this
I appreciate the difficulty, but there is a certain deterrent possible which can be used, as far as it can be used.
Comment on this
If Deputy Norton intends to provide for the position where the employer is the same there is a good deal to be said for the amendment. I do not think that an employer should be allowed to combine the two employments and work an employee in a manner other than would be allowed under one employment. If it is intended to extend the scope to different employments I do not see how there is going to be any check-up.
Comment on this
The same provision in respect of different employments is in the Conditions of Employment Act.
Comment on this
In the Conditions of Employment Act we made it a penalty for the worker to do so. In fact, that is the only way you can do it at all.
Comment on this
I want Deputy Norton to put the saddle on the right horse. In the case of one employer the worker should not be employed as is suggested here. If they are different employments I do not see how the employer can be held responsible. If Deputy Norton wants to make the worker liable to a penalty that is a matter for him.
Comment on this
When the Minister is considering this matter, will he consider applying it to relatives, so as to prevent persons working all day in a factory then going into the shop of a relative and working there in the evening?
Comment on this
If the Deputy is referring to persons who are relatives within the scope of the Bill I do not see how you could make that apply very well without altering the scheme of the measure, as a whole. You could certainly make it apply to persons following two occupations, working in a factory during the day and taking employment for wages in a shop in the evening, by making that an offence if it involved working hours exceeding those permitted in the Bill. I cannot see how you could prevent relatives of a proprietor, persons who come within the definition of "relatives," and living with him on his premises, giving a hand in a shop after the day's work. It would be a difficult thing to do that without altering that part of the Bill which exempts these relatives from coming within its scope at all.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
In line 49, after the word "may" to insert the words "by order".
Comment on this
I think this amendment is unnecessary. The making of these regulations is done in the ordinary way. There are certain provisions for doing things by order, but the making of regulations in relation to matters to be prescribed is a mere formality. You have regulations in regard to forms and one thing or another. It is not usual to have a formal statutory order with regard to such things as the form of application, the form in which records are to be kept and such matters. All that is done by ordinary regulation, and it is a much simpler procedure than having it done by a formal statutory order.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Deputy that there is no need to move these amendments. All legislation has to be drafted in the form in which it appears in this Bill at the moment, but I presume that when the Seanad is constituted again there will be some omnibus provision to deal with matters of this kind just as there was when the Seanad was abolished.
Comment on this
It strikes me that, under the section as worded, there is the possibility, assuming that you have the two Houses, than an Order need only be laid on the Table of one House. I think that is conceivable. There is nothing in the section which shows that there is any intention of having an Order laid on the Table of the Seanad when there is a Seanad. I suggest to the Minister that he should accept these amendments, because long before this Bill becomes law the Constitution will be in operation.
Comment on this
But the Second House will not be there, and our hope is that this Bill will become law before the end of January. I do not think that the Seanad will be constituted before the end of March.
Comment on this
I think provision should be made now to have the Order laid on the Table of the Seanad also, and ensure that, during the period before the Seanad is constituted, Orders will be laid on the Table of the Dáil. It is only a matter of drafting, and it could be easily arranged.
Comment on this
It is hardly necessary, I think, to do that. There will have to be some provision dealing with the new circumstances resulting from the reappearance of the Seanad. It is, of course possible to provide that Orders of this kind can only be annulled by a resolution of the Dáil with a provision in the Order to enable the matter to be discussed. This is a matter on which some difference may exist between members of the House as to what exactly the powers of the Seanad in that regard should be. In the ordinary course, I assume that in the future the practice which prevailed in the past will continue to operate, and that is when documents of this kind are laid on the Tables of the Houses they may be annulled by a resolution of either House. I would prefer that matters of this kind should be dealt with by general legislation, consequential on the constitutional changes, rather than by a specific amendment to this Bill.
Comment on this
I quite understand that there may be a section in a general Interpretation Act later which says that wherever the words "Dáil Eireann" appear in any statute passed after the abolition of the last Seanad that they shall be deemed to include "the Seanad". I think that is quite possible.
Comment on this
But there may be certain occasions in which the words "Dáil Eireann" cannot mean "the Seanad". I do not think that you can use such universal words. I think the Minister would be well advised to put the Seanad into this Bill.
Comment on this
It would be taking a chance when the Seanad is not there. The Seanad will be there before the end of March unless there is a general election before the end of March.
Comment on this
Why not say, "until such time as the Seanad is constituted Orders shall be laid on the Table of the Dáil only"?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if his prophecy about the general election is likely to be fulfilled?
Comment on this
I am not making any prophecies. I say that I hope the Seanad will be held before the end of March.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what types of expenses are visualised by him under this section?
Comment on this
For example, the expenses of the Wages Board and the ordinary administrative expenses of the Department.
Comment on this
What about inspectors? Does the Minister contemplate employing an additional number of inspectors, or is it the intention to utilise the existing staff?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say how many inspectors he has got at the moment who would be available to do this work?
Comment on this
At the moment I am not able to give the number that would be available. The existing inspectorate, those who deal with factory inspections and so forth, may, presumably, be appointed inspectors for the purposes of this Act as well.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what is going to be the position of the full-time inspectors at present in the service of the Dublin Corporation and of some other local authorities? Is it his intention to take them over?
Comment on this
They go. There is no provision in the Bill to take them over. Most of the persons employed as shop inspectors by local authorities are also engaged on a number of other jobs.
Comment on this
The shop inspectors in the employment of the Dublin Corporation are exclusively engaged on that work.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:—
In sub-section (1) page 8, lines 15 and 16, to delete the words "as a member of the staff of such shop" and substitute the words "to do shop work."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister says that this is a drafting amendment, but is that in view of finding that the phrase "to do shop work" is more all-embracing than the phrase "as a member of the staff of such shop," because that is what we were on earlier?
Comment on this
It will have to relate to the circumstances in which each phrase is used. It is because the definition of shop work is wider than the duties of members of the staff of a shop that it is necessary to make this change.
Comment on this
Surely the definition of a member of the staff ought to be wide enough. In any case, however, I take it that the Minister is going to try and bring them parallel?
Comment on this
I am not saying that. What I am saying is that it is an endeavour to see that there are no anomalies.
Comment on this
With regard to this matter, I suppose it means that a relative under 14 years of age cannot be qualified; that is to say that a father cannot employ his child, who is under 14, to work in his shop. Is that correct? I take it that it is the intention, but I should like to know.
Comment on this
He cannot be employed, but there may be some qualification necessary. I presume that a father could work his son in the shop under 14 years of age, but he could not employ him under a contract of service.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:—
In sub-section (1), page 8, line 22, to delete the words "as a member of the staff of such shop" and substitute the words "to do shop work."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:—
In sub-section (2), page 8, lines 27 and 28, to delete the words "the prescribed form and containing the prescribed particulars "and substitute the words "such form and containing such particulars as the Minister for Local Government and Public Health may direct."
The object of this amendment is to make clear that it should be in such form and containing such particulars as the Minister for Local Government and Public Health may direct, and not the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It is the Minister for Local Government who deals with these matters, such as the provision of birth certificates. He is responsible in that regard and it is he who will deal with that matter and prescribe the circumstances under which the certificate at this cheap rate should be given.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:—
To delete sub-section (1) and substitute the following two subsections:—
(1) Subject to the provisions of this section, the Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order do the following things, that is to say:—
(a) apply such order to shops of a particular class (defined in such manner and by reference to such things as the Minister thinks proper) situate in any area specified or delimited in such order, and
(b) prohibit the employment, as members of the staff of any shop of that class in that area, of juveniles.
(2) Subject to the provisions of this section, the Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order do the following things, that is to say:—
(a) apply such order to shops of a particular class (defined in such manner and by reference to such things as the Minister thinks proper) situate in an area specified or delimited in such order, and
(b) divide, by reference to the number of adults employed as members of the staff of each of such shops, such shops into such and so many grades as the Minister thinks proper;
(c) prohibit the employment, as members of the staff of any shop which falls within any grade, of any juveniles in excess of the number appointed by such order in respect of that grade.
On examination, it was believed in practice that the provision that the proprietor of a shop who was an adult should be deemed to be a member of the staff of such shop would render inoperative the provisions of paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 16, which empowers the Minister to prohibit the employment of juveniles in his shop in which no adult is employed. Consequently, we have provided for the recasting of this section, and the purpose of this amendment is to delete the existing sub-section and to substitute the recasted sub-section for it, which deals with that point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:—
To delete sub-section (3) and substitute the following two subsections:—
(3) Any order under this section may, if the Minister thinks proper, provide that the proprietor of a shop who is an adult shall, for all or any (as may be specified in such order) of the purposes of such order, be deemed to be a member of the staff of such shop.
(4) In calculating for the purposes of an order under this section, the number of adult members of the staff of a shop, account shall be taken of any adults who are relatives of the proprietor of such shop and who are members of the staff of such shop.
That is consequential upon amendment No. 37.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:—
At the end of sub-section (3) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
(c) in calculating the number of juvenile members of the staff of a shop, account shall be taken of any juveniles who are relatives of the proprietor of such shop and are members of the staff of such shop.
This section confers on the Minister the power to make orders for the purpose of restricting or limiting the number of juveniles who may be employed in a shop in relation to the number of adults so employed, and the object of the amendment is to ensure that in calculating the number of juvenile members of the staff of the shop, account shall be taken of any juveniles who are relatives of the proprietor and are members of the staff of such shop. In sub-section (3) of the section provision is made that when calculating the number of adults employed in a shop the proprietor and his relatives will be taken into consideration if they are adults. Why then should not the juvenile relatives be taken into consideration in determining the number of juveniles employed there? If the Minister would consider making the whole of this part of the Act applicable to relatives, it would meet the point here, but if not I think we ought to calculate the number of junior relatives for the purpose of calculating the number of juvenile employees so as to ensure that, in fixing the proportions, an employer employing a number of juvenile employees would not have an unfair advantage.
Comment on this
That was a different point. Deputy Benson's point was whether it would be lawful for an employer to utilise the services of his son or his daughter if that person were under 14 years of age.
Comment on this
In any event, I am prepared to consider his point. The Deputy wants to ensure that if there is any Order made limiting the number of juveniles, juveniles who are relatives of the employer will be taken into account.
Comment on this
There is one thing that strikes me as being, possibly, rather a difficulty in this connection. There may be a juvenile relative who does not work whole-time but only for an hour or two. Whether you will count that juvenile in or not I do not know. For instance, I can quite visualise the case of a boy who comes home from school and works for an hour or two in a shop, and whether he is to be counted in as a working relative or not would be a very difficult thing to deal with. I think you will have to make it a juvenile relative working whole-time.
Comment on this
As to amendment 41, has the Deputy confused Section 17 with Section 19? The general question of employment in spells will arise on Section 19 whereas this new section is proposed to be inserted before Section 17. I presume it is a mistake.
Comment on this
It may be dealt with then, if it is applicable. The amendment is stated to refer to Part 2 of the Act, which would mean its insertion before Section 17.
Comment on this
Yes, the Chair was perturbed lest there might be a duplication of debate on it on Section 19.
Comment on this
If you desire, Sir, I shall leave the amendment over until we dispose of Section 19.
Comment on this
That is the prohibition of the employment of juveniles, who are relatives, at hours at which it would be illegal to employ a juvenile who is not a relative. That seems reasonable and I will consider that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:—
In sub-section (1), line 35, to delete the word "eleven" and substitute the word "nine."
Under this section, it is provided:
"It shall not be lawful for a proprietor of a shop to permit any member of the staff of that shop to continue to do shop work after the time in any day when such member has completed 11 hours' shop work on such day."
When we were dealing with the fixing of a maximum working day under the Conditions of Employment Bill the maximum working day was fixed at nine hours. But in respect of shop workers, we are apparently contemplating a position whereby a shop worker may work for a maximum of 11 hours on any one day. That seems to be a particularly unfair and arduous provision. For instance, it may be possible for an employer to organise his business in such a way that, on two days of the week, he may require his workers to work, with certain intervals for meals, for 11 hours each day. Of course a worker who is required to work 11 hours each day has practically no social existence on these days, because the 11 hours is spent in the service of his employer. The actual attendance of that worker in the service of his employer would be 11 hours, plus one hour for dinner and half an hour for tea. So that you can contemplate a situation developing where a worker would start work at nine o'clock in the morning and would not be out of the service of the employer until 12½ hours afterwards, including an hour for dinner and a half hour for tea, when his task would be to get to his home, have a meal, and get back again. He would, therefore, be in the service of his employer from nine in the morning until 9.30 in the evening. That is an unduly high maximum.
I think the nine hours' maximum provided for in the Conditions of Employment Act is adequate. I do not think we should contemplate extending the working day in shops to 11 hours. One could understand the necessity during an emergency at certain times of the year, but there is no reason why we should contemplate, as part of a normal day's work, that an employer should have the right to employ a worker for as much as 11 hours. The effect of the provision will be to enable employers to take advantage, in many cases, of the provisions of this Bill, which it is not possible for them to take advantage of to-day, because they are held down to-day in many cases by better conditions under trade union agreements. Employers can now point to the fact that, under this Bill, the Minister considers it desirable, in certain circumstances, that employees should be allowed to work 11 hours. Trade unions, presented with a situation of that kind, will really find, through the medium of this Bill, the Minister's name being used to justify the viewpoint that there is nothing improper in an employee being required to work a maximum of 11 hours in one day. I think nine hours as a maximum is reasonable, considering that there is a provision also enabling a worker to be employed on overtime within certain limits. Even after the worker has worked for 11 hours, as provided for in this section, an employer can also require him to work on overtime.
Comment on this
That is not so. The Deputy is wrong there. There is no provision for overtime. In the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936, a nine-hour day was provided for, with two hours per day overtime permitted. There is no provision for overtime in this section. It is an 11 hour maximum.
Comment on this
The overtime cannot be grafted on to the 11 hours, but it can be grafted on to the week in which the 11 hours are worked. It is possible, for instance, under the Bill for a worker to be employed in any one week up to 60 hours, 48 of which would be normal and the additional 12 would be overtime. So that in any one week you can contemplate a situation developing whereby a worker would be employed under the Bill for 11 hours on two days, making a total of 22 hours, and the remainder of the 60 hours, including overtime to a maximum of 12 hours, could be spread over the other four days. If you permit an employer to employ a worker for 48 hours per week and up to 60 hours with overtime is resorted to, you ought not to allow that employer to fix a maximum of 11 hours.
I move to report progress.