Constitution (Consequential Provisions) Bill, 1937—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–190 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 41 of 1937 ›
This section contains a phrase with these words "the Constitution of Ireland lately enacted by the People." Will the Minister tell us, first of all, in what enactment or series of enactments, were the people given power to legislate in this country and, secondly, whether what has been discussed as the Constitution is not an amendment of the Constitution that was in being here, and if not, why not?
Comment on this
The Constitution has been enacted by the votes of the people recently. I understand that Deputies opposite have already raised the question as to the power of the people to enact this Constitution. All I have to say is that the Constitution has been enacted by the votes of the people and the present measure is brought in connection with that enactment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister mind addressing himself to the exact question that was asked: under what Act was such power conferred on the people? That was the question that was asked. Perhaps he might enlighten the House, or does the Minister think that, as we have already had so many absurd pretences in connection with the Constitution, so many real falsehoods, an additional one like this does not matter? Will the Minister not answer the precise question asked?
Comment on this
We are asked to accept in this Bill a statement which is not yet proved to be accurate. There was a Constitution in this country from 1922. In that Constitution legislative power was given to a body called the Oireachtas. That body could have, if it so wished, given back power to the people to enact legislation but it failed to do so. As long as that Constitution ran, the only legislative authority in this country was in the Oireachtas. The Oireachtas did not give away that power to anybody else. They did not re-put it into the hands of the people. How does it come then that the people enact anything?
Comment on this
I question the power of the people to do this: If the law of the country is that the Oireachtas enacts legislation, and if that is not changed, as it could have been changed by legislation, and if something happens which is declared to be legislation by the people, then I ask where is the power of the people to legislate? It is nowhere in the old Constitution. It could have been derived from the old Constitution, but it was not derived from it.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly, but in the old Constitution all legislative power was vested in the Oireachtas so that the Oireachtas was the only body with power to legislate. The Oireachtas could have changed that but it did not. How do the people enact?
Comment on this
Is it the Minister's contention that the people can legislate on the very same lines as the Oireachtas can legislate? If the people can enact a Constitution by virtue of some inherent power and bring that legislation into force, surely the people can enact ordinary legislation by the same inherent power?
Comment on this
We shall have a division on this if we cannot get an answer to the questions put. Deputy Linehan makes the point wider. If the people can enact a Constitution, they can enact ordinary legislation.
Comment on this
When the Opposition Deputies formed the Government of the country they told us a lot about the will of the people. Now when they get it they are objecting to it.
Comment on this
That last answer shows the sheer ignorance of the Deputy on the matter expressed. The people can be given power to enact law but they were not given it. If the Deputy thinks that that power was passed on to them then the Deputy must agree that the people could to-morrow pass a law about transport or about cattle. Can they do it?
Comment on this
I think you will have to get over the elementary stages before you could understand that.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
The general object of the Bill, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, is as explained by the Minister for Justice on the Second Reading. It is to ensure that there will be continuity in legislation, and that the changes which have come about in connection with the operation of the new Constitution, which will come into effect on 29th December, will not have the effect of causing any dislocation. The object of this measure is to ensure that the legislative machinery will continue, and that there will be no dislocation. The method under which that result is sought to be arrived at is to give the Executive Council— which will be the Government under the new Constitution—power to make orders on the same lines as were made in 1922 under the Adaptation of Enactments Act when a somewhat similar change was being made on the coming into operation of the Constitution of Saorstát Eireann. It is entirely a legal matter.
Comment on this
Will the Minister refer me to the sub-section of Section 2 which gives the power to make an order?
Comment on this
I am only explaining the general terms of the Bill. I did not say it was included in Section 2. Section 2 deals with the general adaptation of the expressions "Saorstát Eireann" and "Irish Free State" and makes provision with reference to matters that have come into operation. They shall be construed and have effect in like manner as they were construed and had effect immediately prior to the date of the coming into operation of the Constitution in relation to anything done or to be done or an event occurring or a period or series of periods beginning after the coming into operation of the Constitution. The expressions "Saorstát Eireann" and "Irish Free State" are to be construed and have effect as meaning Ireland. There is this further provision in paragraph (c): "in relation to anything done or to be done or an event occurring partly before and partly after the coming into operation of the Constitution"; that is, which will be partly completed afterwards, and it makes arrangements so that there will be no break in the continuity with reference to the appropriate legislation in that regard. The object of the section is to modify the expressions "Saorstát Eireann" and "Irish Free State" so that such statutory instruments as refer to these shall be carried on and shall have the same force when the new Constitution comes into operation.
Comment on this
Following the Minister's explanation, I take that as being the full content of Section 2. We have passed two measures called the Control of Manufactures Acts. In one of those the definition of national does not correspond with the definition of national in the old Constitution, nor does it correspond with the definition of national in the present Constitution. Am I to take it that that word in relation to anything done prior to the coming into operation of the Constitution of Saorstát Eireann and in relation to anything that happened afterwards means Ireland? The Minister will see that it was a definition by which it was attempted to ensure certain things for nationals of this country with regard to manufactures in the country. I think the word "national" was not defined in such a way as to include Ireland. I am bound to take it from the Minister's explanation that hereafter the word "national" means anybody who is Irish. If that is so there is a big change effected. I would like to know if that is so.
Comment on this
It is not sought to make any change, but simply to carry on the existing position. As far as I know, the general object of the measure is to carry on the existing position. The Deputy says a change is being effected. I may not be competent to say whether or not a change is being effected, but the advice I have received is that the object of this measure and of this section is simply to carry on the existing situation.
Comment on this
So this does not affect the present situation; it is only a question of a change of name? I would like to have that made clear before the bonfires are lit, merely over the changing of a name.
Comment on this
I would like to have that on record, that the Minister is aware of what he is saying when he declares that this carrying into operation of the Constitution effects no material change and it is only a question of a name.
Comment on this
The Deputy can misinterpret what I am saying very skilfully. I did not say it makes no material change. I said the general object of the measure is to ensure that there will be no dislocation and that the existing situation with regard to legislation will be carried on after the new Constitution comes into operation.
Comment on this
I am going to interpret the Minister's words by reading portion of sub-section (2):—
No adaptation of the expression "Saorstát Eireann" or the expression "Irish Free State" by virtue of the foregoing sub-section of this section shall operate so as to extend the meaning of such expression as to include therein any area which is, for the time being, not within the area and extent of application of the laws enacted by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
No change whatever. There is a bit of a label stuck on and we are to have bonfires lit for that. Remember that this does not change the position. If the Minister is afraid to say it, I will say it for him. I think we can agree to the section on the basis that it means nothing.
Comment on this
On Section 4, I would like some explanation of the necessity for those sub-sections which oust the courts in favour of the Taoiseach. What is the meaning of sub-section (2)?
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) leaves it to the Taoiseach to determine questions as to the most appropriate particular official person or body or governmental authority under the new Constitution. It follows on the lines of the Adaptation of Enactments Act, 1922, from which it is taken almost word for word.
Comment on this
I presume we take that with sub-section (3) of the next section. I want to get that clear.
Comment on this
The Minister says this is giving power to the Taoiseach to determine certain things. It is quite clear it does and it adds that the decision of the Taoiseach shall be final. It does not say when that decision shall be made. There is a corresponding sub-section in the next section which relates to government orders. It says:
Every order made by the Government under this section shall, unless such order otherwise provides, have and be deemed always to have had effect as from the commencement of this Act.
If I take the analogy of that, then the situation would appear to be that at any time, say, ten years hence, the Taoiseach may come to a conclusion with regard to some correspondence between an official in the new State and an official in the old State and that that will operate as having a retrospective effect going back ten years. That would be a pretty serious situation and I would like to ask what is this supposed to have reference to and what is the importance of it and how may the legal situation hereafter be changed by any decision made by the Taoiseach?
Comment on this
The Deputy asks me how will the legal position be altered. I think he should be in a position to answer his own question and to know what way it is going to alter it. This provision is not going to make any change in the existing situation, which is that the President of the Executive Council, under the Adaptation of Enactments Act of 1922, has power to decide these matters where a dispute arises. I do not know whether, in fact, a dispute has arisen. If a dispute had arisen and it became necessary for the President to determine the point, I have no doubt that the legal advisers to the Government, if they felt that further provision was necessary to cover the circumstances, would have made such provision in the present Bill.
Comment on this
Is there any danger that the Taoiseach might, deliberately or otherwise, delay in adjudicating a matter like that or is it possible that a question might not be put up to the Taoiseach for a number of years and that he would then give a decision which would have retrospective effect? Will no period be fixed during which that sub-section might have the effect of operating retrospectively to the detriment of some official or somebody else.
Comment on this
In that case, the matter would probably be dealt with under the next section, where the Government has power to make certain adaptations and modifications. If it were found necessary that the adaptation should have retrospective effect, the Government would make an order under Section 5.
Comment on this
They need not make an order under Section 5. Suppose the Government of the day find themselves in difficulties and they can see a way out if they can give to some new official the powers possessed by, say, the Revenue Commissioners in relation to matters that should arise in court. The Taoiseach by saying, "I find that he is the corresponding official to the officials who at one time had certain powers"—by this simple decision as to correspondence between two people he could carry over and give into the possession of a new official powers previously possessed by another body. Is that what is intended?
Comment on this
I am not talking about retrospection at the moment. There is no prohibition of retrospection in Section 4.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach does something that he is not entitled to do under the code governing adaptations, I presume the courts will be there to deal with the position.
Comment on this
I am asking as to the intentions before we get to a court interpretation. What is the intention as regards this provision?
Comment on this
Are we not putting the Taoiseach into a position in which the courts might be helpless so far as retrospection is concerned?
Comment on this
We are making the law. Are we putting the Taoiseach into a position in which the courts cannot question what he has done? The courts cannot override the law.
Comment on this
I have already informed the Deputy that, if it is necessary to have an adaptation, it will probably be done under Section 5. A specific Order will be made and the House will have an opportunity of discussing it.
Comment on this
We shall deal with that afterwards. That is not in this section. The House need not necessarily have an opportunity of discussing the matter.
Comment on this
There is one man who does not like to hear himself talking and I admire his discretion.
Comment on this
If we do not get a satisfactory reply, we shall give Deputy Fogarty some exercise. If he cannot talk, he will walk.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told that the intention is that the power should not be made use of retrospectively, and that it is only intended to apply in cases of dispute arising between Governmental authorities. In those cases, the Taoiseach would have the determination of the question. The provision is exactly the same as was in the 1922 Act. I cannot see how the Deputy thinks that a question will arise now when no such question has arisen in the past 15 years.
Comment on this
I did not know what was intended. The Minister might have brought in an amendment to make clear that it was not to be retrospective. Will the Minister get the advice of some of his officials as to whether it is clear that it is not retrospective? We could adjourn for a few minutes until he receives that advice. I submit that it can be retrospective.
Comment on this
Not if we pass it now. I am asking the Minister to take advice as to whether, as drafted, this provision can have retrospective effect.
Comment on this
I have told the Deputy that, if I think there is any point in the matters he is raising, I shall ask the advisers of the Government to consider whether or not amendments are necessary. I am told that, in this case, an amendment is not considered necessary.
Comment on this
The Minister has at last been told that such a determination could not be retrospective.
Comment on this
I should like to have some reason for that advice. If the Taoiseach determines a question with retrospective effect, is not his decision final?
Comment on this
Where do the courts come in to prevent his decision being retrospective? Surely that is a simple point to determine.
Comment on this
The courts cannot decide against a law passed by this House which states that the matter is to be finally determined by the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
What does the Minister mean by saying "the courts are there"? Where? Are they not ousted by this provision?
Comment on this
How can they be ousted? They have jurisdiction in connection with determining questions that may arise under Section 5, for example, and the Deputy thinks that the Government would adopt an ingenious method of using the Taoiseach to get over the courts. I do not think they would be likely to get away with that, but one cannot see the decision the Deputy has in mind which would not be properly made as a specific adaptation by the Government under an Order, and if it is made under an Order, it will come automatically under the jurisdiction of the courts.
Comment on this
I should like to be very clear on this. The question is to be determined by the Taoiseach, whose decision, according to this Bill, is to be final. It is either final or it is not final. The Minister says it is not— that the courts are there—but he does not say that the courts have any overriding power in respect of an Act of the Oireachtas. I should like to know if the Minister is saying that the courts definitely have the power to override the decision of the Taoiseach, which is stated in this Bill to be final, or is it merely a problematical matter the deciding of which in the Supreme Court at some future date may cost the State a lot of money?
Comment on this
The powers of the Taoiseach are confined to determining an issue as between two disputing persons, bodies or Governmental authorities, as to which is the appropriate authority.
Comment on this
Apart from that, what do the terms used mean? I cannot see any phrase which refers to a question between two official persons, or bodies, or Governmental authorities as to which should be the authority. It does not say that.
Comment on this
Maybe, but that is no answer. Maybe there were different intentions. I am talking about how closely you have wedded your intentions and the language in which they are incorporated.
Comment on this
If the Deputy assumes that a future Government would try to devise means of getting around legislation, I think there are several ways of dealing with such a situation. The Deputy does not seem to have much confidence in the future Taoiseach, or in his sense of responsibility to the people.
Comment on this
All this is highly irrelevant to the question here—what does sub-section (2) mean, and whether a determination by the Taoiseach, with retrospective effect, is not carried by the section. I suggest it is.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move the amendment on the Order Paper:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) Every order made by the Government under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as conveniently may be after it is made, and if either such House shall, within twenty-one days on which such House has sat after such order is laid before it, pass a resolution annulling such order, such order shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.
The object of the amendment is to make provision for bringing orders made by the Government under the section before each House of the Oireachtas. It was intended that this provision would be in the Bill but it was omitted. It was also omitted from the 1922 Act.
Comment on this
If it is on the lines of the 1922 Act there is a strange omission in the Bill. It was so left that the Government's retrospective adaptation might have been carried through by them and not published. This amendment carries us some length. During the discussion on the last section the Minister used the phrase that there was an amendment on the Order Paper which would give the Dáil an opportunity to discuss any of these orders. This amendment does not do anything of the sort. It simply means that the order is to be brought in "and if either such House shall, within twenty-one days on which such House has sat after such order is laid before it, pass a resolution annulling such order, such order shall be annulled accordingly..." That is the ordinary form of order that comes in but it is not the type of order that gives the Dáil a chance to discuss it. The order that necessitates that the Dáil must discuss is one that says it shall not be valid until it is affirmed. This order can lie on the Table for 21 days, and unless the Government is so disposed the 21 days may have passed without the Dáil getting an opportunity to discuss the matter at all. The order is then useless. If the 21 days have passed there is no value in raising a discussion, even though it is going to lead to a vote against the order. If Ministers deliberately use this order, and the Dáil does not get a chance of discussing it, then why have they brought in an order requiring an affirmative vote before it becomes affirmative? We have had experience of that before in the use of this order. In fact, motions were put down but, because of the impossibility of fitting in discussion of such motions with the disposal of Government time, there was no question of discussing them and matters became law by lapse of time. The Minister may defend this kind of order as one that is commonly made. It is, but it is not an order that gives the House any rights. It only gives rights if the Government so wishes.
Comment on this
The intention is that there should be consistent interpretation from the coming into force of the new Constitution, and that there should not be any variations from time to time. The intention is to try to secure the same interpretation right through, after the Constitution comes into force.
Comment on this
So that if an order is made some years after the Constitution comes into effect, it will be consistent. There might be some inconsistencies if this retrospective power were not there.
Comment on this
There are two things at issue. Something may occur requiring decision five years after the Constitution comes into operation. It may be necessary not to have any breach of continuity, but that can be done without making this legislation operate retrospectively, to make legal anything illegal that may have been done in the meantime. This goes the whole way and gives power to make it retrospective and to have retroactive effect. There is a difference. Generally when there is this patchwork arrangement contemplated, it is necessary to see that there is no breach of continuity, but that may be done without prejudice to any matters affected and without invalidating things that happened. This allows, and the contemplation is, that these matters shall be validated; that there shall be a new decision which shall have retrospective effect from the commencement of the Act. Why is that necessary? I can see the necessity of having no breach of continuity. Why have such breach of continuity voided by invalidating all that happened in the meantime?
Comment on this
In the particular case that the Deputy has in mind, it is hardly likely that the Government would seek to apply an order with retrospective effect. The necessity for this retrospective clause is to preserve consistency. If there is a definite upsetting of something that has gone before. I do not think that the Government would approach it by making an adaptation order. Presumably they would deal with it by legislation.
Comment on this
The whole tenour of this is to make it retrospective with invalidating effect. The phraseology used is such as if it were contemplated that every order should be retrospective. Why should that power be taken?
Comment on this
The opinion of the legal advisers of the Government, after their experience of the past 15 years, is that the Government should be given more power of elasticity. In accordance with that, they have made a specific adaptation superior to the general adaptation in the preceding section. Under this section they are seeking power to enable them to have more elasticity. As I have said, from their experience they feel that special circumstances may arise, and that it is necessary to have this power. They are simply going on their general experience as to the operation of these adaptation orders in past years.
Comment on this
Then we might get declared here what is this experience in the concrete which leads to this. I do not know of anything that leads to it.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy had any experience with regard to these orders being contested, or of the state of affairs that he envisages having arisen?
Comment on this
I have no concrete example of such an order being made, That is the first point. The Minister says that the experience of the Government's legal advisers is such as to make them demand more elasticity. What is that experience? Is there one concrete case that can be given to support that, one single example?
Comment on this
The legal advisers of the Government are of the opinion that there should not be this hiatus: that it is bad, and they simply want to prevent a dislocation in the future as far as they can. It may not be necessary, but they are going on their past experience.
Comment on this
Is the Minister so bullied by the legal advisers that he cannot ask them, "why do you want this," before he comes in here, and so have some example before his mind? Can we have one example given to warrant us in passing this? I would like to hear if there is one. Is there one example in the past 15 years that can be adduced to the House to warrant this power being given?
Comment on this
There may not be a specific example available, but the legal advisers of the Government, acting on their general experience, think that it is necessary.
Comment on this
Surely it is their duty to give reasons, unless the Minister just takes what they say. I want to find out if any reason has been given—any example in the last 15 years, which the Minister can recollect, that could be regarded as a sufficient reason for the House to pass this. I do not know of any.
Comment on this
The coming into effect of a new Constitution is an important matter, and I think the Deputy will concede that it is necessary that the legal advisers should see that every precaution is taken to ensure that there will be no dislocation: that everything will run smoothly, and that matters of interpretation will be consistent as far as possible.
Comment on this
Can a concrete example be given of one matter that looms as an important matter in the eyes of the legal advisers on which they have demanded this clause, and in respect of which the Minister is disposed to give it to them?
Comment on this
One case put up is in connection with the old Public Health Act. Different Ministers are referred to in different parts of that measure. The experience of the law advisers has shown that one part may have reference to the Minister for Local Government and another to the Minister for Justice. The Adaptation Order will have to take cognisance of that.
Comment on this
I think it is the duty of our legal advisers to see that all precautions are taken to ensure that there will not be any dislocation: that no serious constitutional crisis will arise through failure to take the necessary precautions beforehand.
Comment on this
These advisers must have been speaking very crossly to the Minister recently. Did the Ministry, as a whole, do anything to annoy them?
Comment on this
I am against this retrospective clause. Would the Minister say if this is contained in the old Adaptation of Enactments Act?
Comment on this
The only one that the Minister could give in 15 minutes' wriggling. This is a deplorable exhibition. The whole thing is a farce.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
It is simply to carry on certain provisions with regard to the Central Fund. As the first sub-section shows, the Central Fund, as contemplated in Article 11 of the Constitution, is described as the Central Fund of Ireland, and the rights and liabilities attaching to the Central Fund hitherto will attach to the Central Fund of Ireland after the Constitution comes into operation.
Comment on this
The Minister used the phrase "carrying on". Is that a general description of the Bill?
Comment on this
Is there any other phrase the Minister could give us except "carrying on"? A lot of phrases suggest themselves.
Comment on this
What is the meaning of sub-section (5): "If no such seal as is provided for in the foregoing provisions of this section is available at the commencement of this Act..."? Is there such a seal available before the commencement of the Act?
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain, in connection with the affixing of the seal, why it may be done by the Taoiseach or the Tanaiste, or a secretary, or other officer of the government authorised by the Taoiseach? Has the Minister reflected that in a neighbouring country the seal of a local authority was secured by a financier and that in consequence huge sums of money were lost by the municipality? In this case, if you are going to hand the seal from one person to another, it is obvious that there will not be respect for the seal and there is a danger of its being abused.
Comment on this
Where does the Minister get power to provide the seal? There is power to use the seal, but, so far as I can see, there is no power for the buying of one or the making of one.
Comment on this
Is there anything in mind about the type of seal or about the design or anything like that?
Comment on this
I was under the impression that the President explained to the House what the design of the new seal would be.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal with the other point, as to why more than a single person is to be held responsible for the use of the seal?
Comment on this
The obvious answer, I think, is that a single person may be ill or unable to act at a particular time. My experience as a Minister is that there have always been two persons for that reason.
Comment on this
Yes, one, or an alternative Minister appointed by the Executive Council; but officials are now brought in under this Bill.
Comment on this
The reason is to give the greatest possible latitude consistent with safeguarding the position that Deputy Cosgrave has in mind. What is going to happen if there is nobody available to affix the seal?
Comment on this
There is, first of all, the Taoiseach, then there is the Tanaiste, and, in the event of one being out of office, the other immediately operates. Presumably, the Executive Council will, in the event of the illness of the second person, appoint a third Minister. But why bring in officials? After all, the seal must have some importance. It is apparently given a position of some significance. We want to make sure that a person with ministerial responsibility alone will have the use of it. I was asking the Minister if he can tell us why officials are brought in.
Comment on this
The position is that the Government direct, at an Executive Council meeting, that the seal be affixed, and this applies to the actual affixing of the seal. I do not know whether Deputy Cosgrave has in mind that the seal must be affixed in the actual presence of the Minister or by the Minister.
Comment on this
It is not an operation which occurs very often. It is an operation of some importance, because once it is affixed it stands for something. What I want to make sure of is that a Minister will be present when the seal is being affixed.