We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Constitution (Consequential Provisions) Bill, 1937—Committee Stage.

Contributions 191–380 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Constitution (Consequential Provisions) Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 41 of 1937 ›

Is it also considered desirable to limit it to four people— two governmental and two official?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Is that in the section?

Comment on this

That is the intention.

Comment on this

Where is it in the section? The Taoiseach is one, the Tanaiste is another, the secretary is another, and then there is another officer.

Comment on this

Two or more officials.

Comment on this

No, two or more to start off with. Read the whole sub-section.

Comment on this

The intention is that normally the Secretary and the Assistant Secretary to the Executive Council would be the two officials authorised.

Comment on this

That is not here. Authorised to do what?

Comment on this

To affix the seal.

Comment on this

There is nothing about affixing the seal in this section. That is a new point. Who affixes the seal or who may affix it?

Comment on this

It is not a new point. That has always been the position.

Comment on this

What has always been the position?

Comment on this

Ministers have not to affix the seal themselves.

Comment on this

The section says: "The seal of the Government shall, when affixed to any instrument or document, be authenticated by the signature of the Taoiseach or of the Tanaiste or of a secretary or other officer of the Government authorised by the Taoiseach to act in that behalf." Affixed by whom?

Comment on this

By the officers appointed under this section.

Comment on this

Who are they?

Comment on this

I submit that there is nothing in the section authorising any Minister or officer, or even the Taoiseach, to affix a seal to anything, because it directs here that the affixing of the seal shall be authenticated by the signature of certain people, but there is not a word about who will affix the seal.

Comment on this

Who affixes the seal? Is there any provision about it yet at all?

Comment on this

The existing procedure is that the Government may order that the seal shall be affixed. It is affixed either by the Secretary or the Assistant Secretary of the Executive Council. It is the intention that the existing practice in all these cases shall be carried out as far as possible.

Comment on this

On that point, if it is the intention to carry on the existing practice, there must be some means of authenticating the seal. You have changed the method of authenticating the seal, but you have not changed the affixing of the seal. If it is necessary to change the means of authenticating the seal, it is also necessary to provide some means of affixing the seal.

Comment on this

The point is that the machinery provided now is as satisfactory as that which has been carried on for the past 15 years. The seal has been affixed constantly during that time. Yet the Deputy insists on raising these "footy" points.

Comment on this

Why put in the authentication section at all if there is no need for it?

Comment on this

Is the procedure for affixing the seal going to be supported by anything——

Comment on this

Not as far as I am aware.

Comment on this

It is merely hallowed by the usage of the last 15 years. I do not know where we are. The Minister tells us that it is the intention of the Government to confine the authentication of this peculiarly affixed seal to four categories of people. Is that the amendment the Minister promises to introduce at a later stage?

Comment on this

The Deputy is saying something that I have not said. I said that I would look into the point raised by Deputy Costello. I did not say that I would introduce an amendment. I do not intend to introduce any amendment if I can avoid it.

Comment on this

I wish you would say that of the Bill, that you did not intend to introduce it or to say anything about it.

Comment on this

The Deputy had plenty of time to bring in amendments if he wished. He has wasted two hours in bringing forward debating points.

Comment on this

I have not wasted much of the Minister's time. Until we are told about the number of persons who can authenticate this, we cannot go on. Is there a firm intention with regard to the number of people who will be allowed to authenticate the seal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

How many are there to be?

Comment on this

Four persons will be authorised. Presumably one person would be sufficient to authenticate.

Comment on this

Then it is the intention to have the authentication of the seal when affixed confined to four people at one time?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say where sub-section (2) bears that out? "The seal of the Government shall, when affixed to any instrument or document, be authenticated by the signature of the Taoiseach or of the Tanaiste or of a secretary or other officer of the Government." I suggest that under the Interpretation Act "other officer" means "other officers" in the next sub-section where we read: "More than one officer may, at any time, be authorised under the next preceding sub-section of this section to authenticate by his signature the seal of the Government, but such authorisation of two or more officers shall not render the signature of more than one such officer necessary for the authentication of the said seal." Surely the whole phraseology of the section is in regard to a big number of persons, a plurality of persons, much more than four?

Comment on this

If it is necessary for the conduct of business that there should be four, or even more, then they can be appointed.

Comment on this

But the Minister told me that there was an intention to confine the authentication to four.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Minister said that, but it may have been wrong.

Comment on this

It is not confined absolutely to four. Though it is thought that four will be sufficient, circumstances may arise when four, five or six might be required. I cannot foresee these circumstances. I am not responsible for the phraseology of the draftsman.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if there are persons authorised by the Taoiseach other than the Tanaiste or the secretary, how that authorisation can be proved? Supposing there was some minor officer authorised to authenticate the seal, some person who is not so well known as the Secretary of the Department, and the point is raised, "What authority have you to put that authentication on the document?" how will that authorisation be proved?

Comment on this

If it is sealed with the seal of the Government, every order or other instrument "shall be received in evidence without further proof." If the Government seal is affixed, that is sufficient.

Comment on this

If it purports to be authenticated as provided by the section, that is to say, if it is signed by the Taoiseach or the Tanaiste, then it is quite clear; but if it is signed by an individual of whom nobody ever heard, purporting to act under authorisation, I suggest that will have to be proved, and I want to know how it will be proved.

Comment on this

He will presumably have the same authorisation as any other officer appointed.

Comment on this

In other words, there will not be any necessity to prove authority?

Comment on this

I do not see that there is any provision here for proving authority.

Comment on this

Is there anything which makes the proving of it unnecessary.

Comment on this

That is one of the Deputy's points.

Comment on this

It is not one of the Minister's bright points.

Comment on this

How many seals are there under sub-section (2) at the moment?

Comment on this

The Deputy can put down a Parliamentary question.

Comment on this

If I get a parliamentary reply from the Minister. How many are there? Are there many more than the official seals?

Comment on this

I suppose the courts have seals in addition to the Government. I have no knowledge of what seals there are outside the Departments of State.

Comment on this

Amongst other people—say, executive authorities? I thought we would get some enlightenment on the little seals.

Comment on this

How does Section 10 bring the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act into the county councils? We were told it did.

Comment on this

Yes, it does.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

Because it was one of the measures which were repealed under the Seanad Eireann (Consequential Provisions) Act, 1936, which is now being revived under the section.

Comment on this

It applies to the new electoral colleges—the seven county councillors?

Comment on this

We are not discussing the electoral colleges at present.

Comment on this

We were told on the Seanad Bill that this matter was mended by the Consequential Provisions Bill, and we were referred to the Minister in charge of the Bill for an explanation.

Comment on this

No explanation is required. The Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act operates in this case.

Comment on this

Where seven people are elected by a county council to become members of the electoral college for the new Seanad, is there anything in this Act or in the Act that is being brought back into force here to show that it applies to those people? I suggest there is nothing in this Act to show that.

Comment on this

There is enough in it.

Comment on this

This point was raised on the Seanad Bill and has not been explained yet.

Comment on this

I have answered the Deputy's point by saying that the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act is being revived in connection with the election for the Seanad.

Comment on this

With all due respect, to say that does not answer the point. The Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act never applied to the people who will become electors under the new Seanad Act. At any period in its existence it never applied to the seven people who will be selected by Deputy Corry's friends on the Cork County Council as electors under the new Seanad Act.

Comment on this

It was you selected them. You selected the committees anyway.

Comment on this

The Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act never applied. Its application to those people was never contemplated. It is certainly no answer to the point for the Minister to get up and say that this Bill he is introducing is bringing the Act back into force, and that it is now going to apply to the people who will be put on the electoral colleges, because there is nothing in this Bill or in the original Act to say it does apply to them.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks that the Electoral Abuses Act is not sufficient, he ought to try and have it amended.

Comment on this

Then will the Minister give facilities for the introduction of a Private Members' Bill to make it quite clear that those nominees of county councils who are to form portion of the electorate for the election of members of the Seanad will be prevented from accepting bribes for their votes? I raised this point on the last stage of the Seanad Bill, and I raised it in all seriousness, because I regard it as a matter of paramount importance that any dealings in votes by those people who are nominees of county councils, or by members of the Dáil, if you like to put them all on the one plane, should be clearly and specifically provided against by law. It is a matter of very vital importance in connection with an election of this kind. If any abuses once creep in, in connection with the election of Senators, then not merely will we get a bad type of Senator but we will get the new Seanad brought into very considerable disrepute, which is a thing that we on this side of the House, at all events, want to avoid. I raised this point in all seriousness. I am not yet satisfied, because of the fact that a new type of electorate is being created ad hoc for the purpose of the Seanad election, a type of electorate which never existed before, that the provisions of the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act will apply to that new type of body which is to be selected by the county councils.

Deputy Corry rose.

Comment on this

Now we are going to get some legal advice.

Comment on this

I wonder by what process does the Deputy consider that county councillors are always open to bribes?

Comment on this

I never said anything of the sort.

Comment on this

Was that his experience?

Comment on this

I never said anything of the sort.

Comment on this

It has been quite evident here for the past two hours that there is deliberate obstruction going on on the part of three legal gentlemen who apparently have no place to practice except in this House. I would suggest, A Chinn Chomhairle, that they should not practise here.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair would remind the Deputy that the Chair is to judge whether there is obstruction or not, and that the matter before the House is whether the Corrupt Practices Act applies to certain electors.

Comment on this

That is in Section 9.

Comment on this

It is not in Section 9. That is the very point.

Comment on this

With all respect to the legal luminary who supported the Minister, there is this very definite point raised by Deputy Costello—that there is a new type of electorate coming into being under the Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill. The point has been put, and can be met in an easy way, as to whether or not that electoral body is subject to the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act, and if so, what is the linking up of the different sections? All the Minister has told us is that something was prohibited by the Act of 1936, and that now the whole thing is revived. There immediately, of course, jumps to one's mind that there was not this particular type of electorate when the Act of 1936 was passed, and there was not, of course, this type of electorate when the Act of 1933 was passed. It may be the situation that the words are so general in those Acts that they meet the new body, but it may also be that the old Acts are so tied up with references to Seanad elections and Dáil Eireann elections that they do not meet the new electoral bodies of seven. If the situation is that those Acts do apply, that is capable of explanation, and is capable of very simple explanation. Would the Minister give it to us?

Comment on this

Certainly. If the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act has been found satisfactory for both Dáil and Seanad elections, where the electors were the ordinary people of the country, since 1923, why should that Act not be sufficient to deal with the new electorate?

Comment on this

Is that the answer?

Comment on this

Yes. If the Deputy has any fault to find with the Act, let him say in what respect it is deficient and not capable of carrying out this work satisfactorily.

Comment on this

The Minister is answering one question by asking another?

Comment on this

I am taking a leaf out of the Deputy's book.

Comment on this

But not the same questions. Here is a point which can be traced through Acts, and the Minister should be able to do it. We have not got that information from him.

Comment on this

The point is that the matter has been raised by the Deputy on another measure which is going through the House.

Comment on this

And when it was raised I was referred to this Bill.

Comment on this

Exactly the same provisions will apply to the election of the new Seanad as applied to the old Seanad.

Comment on this

The point was raised on the Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill, and when it was raised there we were told it was a matter which fell for discussion on this Bill. Now we are raising it here, this being the place where we were told it could most appropriately be discussed.

Comment on this

I submit that the Deputy is not raising any point whatever.

Comment on this

I am raising what I am entitled to raise. I am asking the Minister to satisfy the House before this passes that a promise given to us is being carried out. The promise was that what we may familiarly call the Corrupt Practices Act applied to the new group of seven nominees put up by each county council. A suggestion has been made that it does not, and the suggestion has been backed up by those references to the novel situation that the new body never was in existence before and the new body never could have been contemplated by the old Act. It is possible that the old Act does not apply to the new body. If it does, it is easy to see how it does, and we want that information.

Comment on this

The offences which are laid down in the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act presumably are offences of a general nature and do not require to be attached specifically to particular types of election. They are abuses that arise in connection with elections generally, and, therefore, bringing in the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act here should be quite sufficient to cover any abuses that may arise in the forthcoming Seanad election.

Comment on this

Did the abuses referred to in the Corrupt Practices Act apply to local government elections?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

They did not. There is the extent of the Minister's knowledge.

Comment on this

At any rate, they applied to the Dáil and Seanad elections.

Comment on this

There is a way of testing it. Will it apply to the type of person who is going to be on the electorate for the Seanad?

Comment on this

I just wish to raise one other point. I hesitate to do so. The fact is I am terrified of being accused by Deputy Corry of obstruction and of endeavouring to improve or sharpen my legal practice at the expense of Deputy Corry's patience. Section 4 of the Act of 1923 provides a definition of treating. I base this issue that I am putting forward here by reference to that section, which I take at random. Sub-section (2) sets out that "every elector who corruptly accepts or takes any such meat, drink, entertainment or provision as is mentioned in the preceding sub-section shall be guilty of treating." I have searched through the Act of 1923 to see if the definition of elector there has the smallest application to the elector who will be represented as the nominee of the county councils.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

If Deputy Corry had been listening he would have heard me. I am quoting from Section 4 (2) of the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act, 1923. Is that clear enough?

Comment on this

An Act which the Deputy well knows. He has it at his finger tips.

Comment on this

According to Section 56 of the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act the expression "Seanad election" means an election of Senators to serve in Seanad Eireann, and the expression "Seanad elector" means a person entitled to vote at a Seanad election.

Comment on this

But that has no application to the elector who is referred to in Section 4 (2). A Seanad elector is defined and a Dáil elector is defined in that Act, but the word "elector" as used in this section that I took at random is in a different category, and I want to know how that can be applied to the new elector who is to be selected as the nominee of the county council. I cannot find it, and it does not come within the definitions of Section 56.

Comment on this

It is suggested that the word "elector" is used because it previously applies to either type of elector.

Comment on this

Possibly. Does the Minister admit that there is a point to be considered in what I have said?

Comment on this

Surely.

Comment on this

On Section 12, will the Minister explain what is meant by "impressed stamps" in sub-section (3)?

Comment on this

It is to make it clear that it is an impressed stamp.

Comment on this

I thought it meant it was a document, but possibly I was wrong. What is the meaning of the sub-section? Is it that an impressed stamp is an impressed stamp? It has taken four lines to say that.

Comment on this

It says here that it shall be deemed to be a document.

Comment on this

Will the Minister read the first line with the new light shed on it and explain what the whole thing means? What is peculiar about an impressed stamp that it requires a whole sub-section?

Comment on this

It is thought necessary to bring them within the section.

Comment on this

Bring what within the section?

Comment on this

Why do you single them out? What is the difficulty about impressed stamps?

Comment on this

The only reason seems to be to make it a document for the purpose of the Bill.

Comment on this

And not an impressed stamps?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

So the Minister has gone completely round now?

Comment on this

The Minister is surely aware there are other stamps in existence under Government authority besides impressed stamps, and what is going to happen them?

Comment on this

Are stamps documents?

Comment on this

Impressed stamps are.

Comment on this

And apparently stamps are not. Is a stamp a document?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Why is it necessary to deem an impressed stamp to be a document?

Comment on this

Lawyers.

Comment on this

Is that the answer —lawyers?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

On Section 13, what precisely is the meaning of giving power to the Government to defer punishment? It is certainly a novel form of authority to give a Government. I can conceive of a Government being entitled to remit punishment or to give free pardons, but why they should be entitled to get a sort of cat-and-mouse power—that appears to be what it is—in respect of persons convicted by the Military Tribunal I do not know. Apparently, they can say to a person who has been convicted by that tribunal and sentenced to six years: "We shall let you out for a couple of years but, at the end of that time, you will have to serve the rest of your sentence." Is that what is intended?

Comment on this

This is a general relieving power under Article 2A. It has been utilised and may be utilised in the future. Since it is a relieving power, I do not see why there should be any objection to it.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to it. I merely want to know what is the reason for giving power to defer punishment.

Comment on this

The Deputy should know, because he was responsible for drafting Article 2A.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is wrong in saying that I was responsible for the drafting of Article 2A. The Parliamentary Secretary, who used to be a solicitor, and who is now Parliamentary Secretary to the President should know, because of that position, if not of his own knowledge, that the Attorney-General is not the draftsman and has nothing to do with the drafting of Bills.(Interruption by Deputy Corry.) If I could hear Deputy Corry, I might have some chance of understanding him. When he is bawling, it is hard enough to understand him, but when he whispers, it is impossible. Even assuming that this is a copy of a corresponding provision in Article 2A, it is conceivable that, in the circumstances giving rise to the putting into force of the provisions of Article 2A, the Government might usefully have a power of deferring punishment, but Article 2A and the powers of the Military Tribunal automatically come to an end on the 29th of this month. Are the Government going to let some of these men who are now in jail out under the power given to defer their punishment? Are we to understand that the men in jail may be released with the warning, “Remember that at any time we take it into our heads, back you go to serve the rest of your sentence.” The Minister should realise that there is a complete difference in the operation of the section embodied in Article 2A and the operation of the power now proposed to be conferred on the Government. I want to know what is the meaning of that power.

Comment on this

You did not wait for the power.

Comment on this

The Government would like to have the power. The circumstances under which it might be exercised would be a matter for careful consideration.

Comment on this

What is the power? At the moment, there are a few people incarcerated under orders of the Military Tribunal. Perhaps the Minister is having a sitting of the Military Tribunal as a sort of farewell party whereat they will appoint punishment to some former friends of the Government, as a farewell gesture, before they pass out of existence under the Constitution. The Government would then have power to say: "We have caught you now. We may let you out for the next few years but, if we should happen to be Government at the end of that time, back you will go if you do not behave yourselves." I cannot conceive of any other circumstances in which this power would operate. The punishment of people already sentenced by the Military Tribunal cannot be deferred even under the power proposed to be given here. I want to know if it is intended that people will be rushed hurriedly to a farewell sitting of the Military Tribunal and that the Government want to be vested with this peculiar cat-and-mouse power in respect of these persons.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy getting nervous?

Comment on this

I have been wondering why the Deputy has been sitting here through a debate of this kind.

Comment on this

The power has been exercised frequently by the Government. The Deputy may never have heard of its being exercised. We do not see why the Government should not have power to exercise it in the future if it thinks fit.

Comment on this

There will not be any power to exercise it after the 29th, because Article 2A goes on the 29th.

Comment on this

I am not contesting the Deputy's contention that the power may not be there in any event, but we are making sure that we will have it here.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to accept my contention that the Constitution provides that Article 2A goes on the 29th. If you want to have the powers under Article 2A, or corresponding powers, you will have to reenact Article 2A or some similar measure. This provision will not operate on the re-enactment of Article 2A. It can only operate in connection with the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal which comes to an end on the 29th. The Government may think fit to bring in a measure giving powers corresponding to those in Article 2A, but this section will not operate on them.

Comment on this

Even if the present section is passed into law, the Government cannot, in fact, defer sentence?

Comment on this

These powers can operate only between now and the 29th in reference to anybody sentenced by the Military Tribunal. That is a matter of 17 or 18 days.

Comment on this

Supposing that is so, what is the objection to giving the power?

Comment on this

I have made quite clear that I have no objection. I merely want to know what the power is there for, and what it is intended to operate upon. I cannot find anything on which it can operate except the sentences of the Military Tribunal between now and the 29th. I want to know if the Government intend to have a farewell celebration for the Military Tribunal, to sentence a number of people for Christmas so that they may release them for celebration purposes on Constitution Day and defer the sentences under this section.

Comment on this

I should like to know what it is intended to do in the case of persons convicted on capital charges. Are there any persons detained under sentences imposed by this Special Tribunal on capital charges? What will be the position of any such person in future? I observe that the Government are not taking power to defer punishment in that case. What is it intended to do in the case of a person serving a sentence by the Military Tribunal on a capital charge? If such a person is serving a commuted sentence on a capital charge, is it intended that he should remain in prison for the next 40 years, if he lives so long, or is the ordinary practice to be followed? If the ordinary practice is to be followed, where is the power to release that person in view of the limited provisions in the section?

Comment on this

We can release at present the person the Deputy has presumably in mind. The Government have the power to do so. Whether they exercise that power or not is a matter for them. The President of the Executive Council deals with matters of general policy, and the Deputy has put down Parliamentary questions on the subject to him. I am not in a position to add anything to what the President has said.

Comment on this

I did not put down a Parliamentary question at any time seeking elucidation of Section 13. If the Executive Council have power to release a person sentenced to a term of imprisonment on a capital charge, have they the same power in respect of the mitigation of sentences imposed by that tribunal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the purpose then of enacting this section if they already have power in that regard?

Comment on this

I find it exceedingly difficult to reconcile what I was told last week with what the Minister in charge of the Bill now has just told Deputy Norton. I was distinctly told last week that this was to preserve the prerogatives of the Uachtarán, that it was he had power to remit capital punishment, that the reason this exception was made was that the Government had not power but that, under the Constitution, it was the Uachtarán who had the power. We get an entirely different answer now, so far as I can understand the answers, and I will admit the limitation. There is, I understand, one person under sentence, and here I should like to put this question: on what is this supposed to operate? There has been a man sentenced to death by this Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal, and that sentence has been commuted to penal servitude. Therefore, the commutation has already taken place. What, then, is the point of the section? On what is it supposed to operate?

Comment on this

To carry on after the Constitution comes into effect.

Comment on this

If this were not there, you mean that you would have to execute him?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

The position, according to the Minister, but not, I am sure, according to the lawyers, is that if this section were not there they would have to execute the man.

Comment on this

The intention is that the powers which the Government have at present for mitigation of sentences, and the relieving powers they have, will lapse when the new Constitution comes into effect, and the purpose of this section is to enable the Government to exercise these relieving powers in respect of prisoners after the Constitution comes into effect on 29th December.

Comment on this

Why are capital cases excluded?

Comment on this

Because the President of the State, under the Constitution, has the power of pardon.

Comment on this

What Article is that?

Comment on this

I understand that the Minister takes up the line that the President has the power. Of what? Of commuting or pardoning?

Comment on this

Pardoning.

Comment on this

Therefore, the Government has not the power, for instance, to let this man out. It is the President has it. Am I to understand that that is the position?

Comment on this

Surely the prerogatives of the Crown are still in existence?

Comment on this

Will the Minister address himself to the question put? On what is this intended to operate? There is only one man sentenced to death by the tribunal and his sentence has already been commuted. What is the purpose of continuing the power of commuting that sentence? There is nothing on which to operate it; or does the Minister expect to have a death sentence imposed by the Military Tribunal between now and 29th December? If that is so, now that that man is serving a sentence of penal servitude, is it only the Uachtarán has power to lessen his sentence, or to let him out at any particular time? Is that the contention of the Minister?

Comment on this

I am not clear as to the point the Minister is trying to make. It has been mentioned that one person has been sentenced to death after trial by the Military Tribunal. That sentence was subsequently commuted by the Executive Council to penal servitude for life. I take it, therefore, that a sentence of life imprisonment in such circumstances is in a category somewhat similar to a sentence of three years' imprisonment. If I am right in assuming that, I take it that, under this section, the Executive Council would have power to modify either a life sentence or a penal servitude sentence.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If they have, with what type of case then do the capital cases referred to in this section deal? Does the section refer to the case of a man tried on a capital charge, or is it anticipated that somebody may be brought before the tribunal between now and 29th December on a capital charge? Does this section refer to a capital charge on which a man has already been arraigned, or does it refer to a possible capital charge between now and 29th December?

Comment on this

The President has heard the Deputy's question and he will deal with it, but I understand the capital cases referred to here are capital cases which arise after the Constitution has come into operation on 29th December.

Comment on this

That is right. I knew that. The Military Tribunal is to exist in the future.

Comment on this

How can they arise after the Constitution comes into effect?

Comment on this

Because, under the Constitution, the President has power of pardon in capital cases.

Comment on this

What Article is that?

Comment on this

How can anybody be tried on a capital charge by the Special Powers Tribunal, if that means the Military Tribunal, after 29th December?

Comment on this

The point is that, as things stand, the remaining prisoners will presumably be in jail after 29th December, and this section simply seeks to give the Government the same relieving powers which they will continue to have up to 29th December and to continue those powers after 29th December.

Comment on this

Will the Minister address himself, not to the powers being given to the Government, but to the powers being specifically withheld from the Government? There is an "except" in the section. It is no good saying that certain powers are conferred on the Government. The argument is about the powers that are excepted and not conferred on the Government. To get up and tell us that certain powers are conferred on the Government is not answering the point in discussion at all. The point in discussion is: why is there an exception? What are the capital charges contemplated on which this exception is to operate?

Comment on this

May I make a submission to the President, because I suppose this is the President's child and he probably knows something about it? What is the purpose of saying in this section that "except in capital cases the Government may remit, in whole or in part, any punishment imposed by the Constitution (Special Powers) Bill"? I understand there is one person at present serving a term of imprisonment who was tried by the Military Tribunal, sentenced to death, and which sentence was commuted to penal servitude for life. I am speaking subject to correction. I take it that a sentence of that kind is in somewhat the same category as a sentence of three, five or ten years' penal servitude, but in any event, it is not now a capital case, because it is an ordinary definable term of imprisonment for life or for five or ten years. I take it, therefore, that that is the kind of case in which the Government may, in their discretion, exercise certain clemency by way of modification or deferment of the punishment.

If that is so, what is the purpose in this section of this phrase: "Except in capital cases"? I do not think there are any other capital cases. The Minister for Education told us it was necessary to have these powers after the Constitution comes into operation. I cannot understand that reason at all. I take it that the Constitution (Special Tribunal) Act lapses and that probably the only type of capital case to be dealt with by the Military Tribunal would be a case that would arise between now and the 29th of this month. What is the precise explanation of the words "Except in capital cases"?

Comment on this

I had not the advantage of hearing the whole of the arguments, but it seems to me the purpose is to bring this into accord with the Constitution. The power of remission in capital cases is the prerogative of the President.

Comment on this

What is the Article? I was told it was Article 8. That is about the national language.

Comment on this

Article 13.

Comment on this

We were told that it was an Article which deals with the national language. That is hardly a capital charge.

Comment on this

When running through documents it is not easy to give the right one. Article 13 (6) says:

"The right of pardon and the power to commute or remit punishment imposed by any court exercising criminal jurisdiction are hereby vested in the President, but such power of commutation or remission may, except in capital cases, also be conferred by law on other authorities."

There are certain powers conferred on the Executive Council, and these are being carried on. This is to bring them into accord with that clause, so that the power in capital cases may still be reserved to the President, on the advice of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

The President has made a general statement about the power of remitting capital punishment.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The actual section has a definite reference to one particular type of sentence, and that is a sentence imposed by the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this

Yes. The point is this: suppose that before the 29th December, there may be or may have been, capital cases in which the power of remission would probably belong to the President, on the advice of the Executive Council, the general intention, as I understand it, is to continue the powers which the Executive Council has at the moment for remitting punishment in certain cases. The desire is, in the case of any prisoners that might be in prison after the new Constitution has come into operation, that these powers of remission should still continue. Otherwise, there would be a difficulty, in case it was thought advisable by people interested that remission should be given. My view is that the introduction of this, except in capital cases, is for no other purpose but to bring this clause into agreement with the general principle of the Constitution which gives to the President power to deal with capital cases, on the advice of the Government. In other cases the Government is going to replace the Executive Council in this respect. Are there any capital cases? I do not know whether, in fact, there are capital cases that would continue to be referred to as "capital cases."

Comment on this

Would they?

Comment on this

That is a matter on which I would have to get legal opinion.

Comment on this