We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Constitution (Consequential Provisions) Bill, 1937—Committee Stage.

Contributions 381–564 of 564. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Constitution (Consequential Provisions) Bill, 1937
Enacted

No. 41 of 1937 ›

Surely the opinion was asked for before this section was drafted?

Comment on this

The opinion was asked.

Comment on this

What was the answer?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that in regard to drafting the general intentions are understood when a Minister is giving details of a Bill. That is the usual practice. The word "capital" was put in to deal with the possibility of cases occurring between now and the 29th December. It is simply a "carry-over," to continue the powers of remission in accordance with the general principles of the Constitution.

Comment on this

May I put this to the President before the question of capital cases arises? What is the meaning of giving power to defer punishment? This Act cannot come into operation as an Act until after the Constitution is in force. Therefore, at that time the Military Tribunal will have ceased legally to exist. I want to know how you can defer punishment given by a tribunal that has ceased.

Comment on this

It seems that cases have been tried but that punishment has been deferred.

Comment on this

Deferred?

Comment on this

Cases have been tried and punishment deferred, generally, I think, from the point of view of watching as to good conduct, to see if conduct was such that the punishment could be annulled altogether. This is continuing power of the same kind, power which is useful in the public interest.

Comment on this

I am afraid the President is not right in that. It is a very plausible explanation, but it is not a correct one.

Comment on this

That is the explanation which appears to me. This is a highly technical legal Bill on which one would have to get legal advice. Unfortunately, the Minister who was in charge of the Bill is ill.

Comment on this

It was introduced by yourself.

Comment on this

Yes, but it was the Minister for Justice who was really in charge of this Bill.

Comment on this

Article 36 of the Constitution provided that the right of pardon and the right to commute punishment inflicted by any courts exercising criminal jurisdiction was vested in the President. It refers to a court which, during the period of office of the President, is exercising criminal jurisdiction. In this particular case the tribunal will in fact not exist under the Constitution. It will have ceased on the 29th December if this Constitution comes into operation. We will have a President elected, let us say, six months hence, and he may then be confronted with a situation whereby a person is in custody, on a charge in respect of which he was convicted by a court not then existing. Has the President power in that case to commute the sentence?

Comment on this

I do not expect the case the Deputy is trying to imagine could arise. This is a "carrying-over" Bill to try to meet the existing situation, and to carry over parts essential for the future. The reason this clause is there, and is worded in this way, is to keep it in consonance with what will be done, and to give power to, the person who will have to act in capital cases. Supposing that there was a capital offence and that judgment was passed between this and the 29th December, when the 29th came along that ended the decision. If there was not "carrying-over" power such as this, there would be no power in anyone to remit the punishment inflicted. This is simply a safeguard, and is in consonance with the general spirit of the Constitution, which says that in capital cases it is reserved for the President, on the advice of the Executive Council, of course, to pardon.

Comment on this

There are three points raised here. One is to this exception about capital cases; the second, as to deferring punishment; and the third, to the general scope of Section 13. Taking the second one first, the President's explanation about deferring punishment is that the Government has already power to defer punishment, already deferred If it is not that, it has no meaning. As Deputy Costello pointed out, this Bill will not operate until after the 29th December, and by then we are told the body which imposed the punishment will have gone out of existence. It must operate punishments awarded prior to the 29th December, and the President says not merely convictions but those deferred. Why was there necessity to put in a special clause? Does not the Executive Council of Eire take the place of Saorstát Eireann? We have a variety of clauses described as "carrying on," and the whole purpose is to put the Executive Council of Ireland— with a note of interrogation after Ireland—into the same position as Saorstát Eireann. If the Executive Council of Saorstát Eireann have this power, the Executive Council of Eire will have the same power in previous clauses hereafter. Why pick this out?

Comment on this

The Department of Justice apparently consider that this safeguard should be inserted.

Comment on this

The President's colleague told us early in the evening that the Department demanded the bringing in of this, and when he was asked for the reasons that made the Minister accept the demand, he was not able to give one. The President is now drifting into the mood that his colleague has been in for the last hour and a half. It slumps down to this, that officials told him and he did not bother to question the officials whether their viewpoint was correct or not, or to get an example from them that he could put before the House. The Minister simply came here and told us that the officials demanded the bringing in of this, but we could not get any reason from him. It is no explanation for the President to come here now and say that the Department of Justice think it necessary to insert what he calls a safeguard. I presume that, when the Department did that, the President, or some of his colleagues, asked for the reason, and my submission is that this House ought to get the reasons and not simply the answer "the officials demand it." Bureaucrats always want all sorts of things. Surely we have not yet got to the point that the House is going to be asked to say: "The Department want this and we ought to pass it," and in that way resign ourselves into the control of a Department. If this is necessary, then let us pass it with some better argument than merely to be told that the Department want it.

The next point is with regard to capital cases. Is there any change being made? I gather not. The situation, as I understand it, is that the Executive Council had control in this matter under Article 2A. By this Bill the new Executive Council, with the Taoiseach and the Tanaiste at the head of it, is going to have the same powers as the present Executive Council. What, therefore, is the need for all this? The Executive Council has those powers by law. The President's colleague told us on an earlier section that the whole scheme of this was to ensure that there would be no dislocation; that there would be smoothness in the running over from one period to the next.

I do not know what the point about the capital cases is. We are told that there is a constitutional provision that the remission in capital cases cannot be conferred upon anybody except the President. If that is so, then the Constitution would rule it simply. The last point is with regard to the scope of the section. Before the President came in, his colleague, briefed, I suppose, by the Department responsible for the Bill, told us that this was intended to operate in the future. When I questioned the whole thing coming to an end on the 29th of this month the Minister was quite precise about that.

Comment on this

I referred to the relieving power. The Deputy is trying to give the House the impression that I said—I may unwittingly have given the impression—that the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal would continue in operation. What I meant to say, and what I believe I did say, was that the relieving powers which the Executive Council have at present would continue after the 29th December, and that that was the object of this section.

Comment on this

It was idle to have such an aim as that, because that aim was already achieved if, by nothing else, then by a preceding section which puts the new Executive Council into the same position as the Executive Council that preceded it. The other point, I believe, is the correct one, that the phrase has no limitation with regard to time. That phrase, if it comes hereafter to be construed, will certainly mean that any punishment imposed from time to time will be imposed by the new Special Powers Tribunal.

Comment on this

Nonsense! because this is obviously a Bill of another character.

Comment on this

What other character?

Comment on this

I will speak when the Deputy has finished.

Comment on this

This is a Bill "to make divers provisions consequential on or incidental to the coming into operation of the Constitution." One of the Articles of the Constitution is Article 38, which says that "special courts may be established by law for the trial of offences in cases where it may be determined in accordance with such law that the ordinary courts are inadequate." It is contemplated, therefore, in the Constitution that courts corresponding to the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal will be set up. Suppose one is set up next year, and that it bears the name of the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal, surely this clause meets the case.

Comment on this

It does not, because it would clearly be interpreted in connection with the particular Act named.

Comment on this

Suppose there is a new body to be called the Special Powers Tribunal, does the President say that this could not apply to it?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

Suppose there is a new body not called the Special Powers Tribunal, the Taoiseach has power by himself under sub-section (2) of Section 4 of this Bill to determine that the new body is equivalent to the new Special Powers Tribunal and his decision is final. That sub-section has a definitely ominous meaning, because if any question arises as to the new body the Taoiseach determines it. It is possible, therefore, under the new Constitution for a new body to be set up and called the Military Tribunal. The Taoiseach can, by his determination which is final, say that that body represents the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal, and thereafter we have the relieving effect of this section carried forward. The Minister tried to retrace his steps. He did say that that clause looked to the future. He did not make any limitation with regard to the other relieving powers. He was first of all thinking of the court which would be established.

Comment on this

I was not thinking of it.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly the Minister was.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be very clever, but clever as he is he cannot read my thoughts.

Comment on this

They were not disclosed to-night, so that I could hardly read any. The Minister put himself on record as saying that this looked to the future.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

And that the clause was carried into the future. The Minister now seeks to limit that by saying that it has only a relieving effect. I do not think that is a suitable explanation.

Comment on this

The Deputy ought to know that Article 2A goes out of existence with the disappearance of the old Constitution. Therefore the Executive Council will have no powers that are not given to it by some Act of Parliament. If the Constitutional provision which gives those powers to the Executive Council disappears, then the Executive Council have got none, and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

I can give the President a reference to the contrary— the Interpretation Act.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows perfectly well that the Executive Council will have no powers when the foundation of their powers disappears. With regard to this Bill, I am sorry that the Minister for Justice, who had charge of it, is unable, through illness, to attend in the House. It is a Bill of a technical and legal character, and the Minister in charge has to make up the details to meet all the points likely to be raised. Again I say that when the present Constitution disappears, Article 2A, which gives the Executive Council the powers they have at present, also disappears. Therefore the Executive Council have no powers that could be continued over, so that this is necessary.

Comment on this

That answer is unsatisfactory, first of all, because under the Interpretation Act of 1923 a peculiar position was created. When a Bill is repealed, there is a gap that is still left, and I suggest that the President has been misinformed if he suggests that his answer is the correct one. I suggest that he has not got that answer, and that this interpretation of his can be disregarded for that reason. The second point is that under Article 2A there is a general prerogative of mercy, and general prerogatives of mercy are carried forward by the Constitution. Therefore there is no necessity for this.

Comment on this

Well, the opinion I have given the Deputy is the legal opinion I have been given, and, in a case of that sort, I am going to depend on the advice of those who have the responsibility for giving a real legal opinion, and not on the advice of those who have not any responsibility and who are only concerned with what political points they can make out of the matter. The reasons that I have given to the House for this are the reasons that have been given to me by people competent to advise, and I think that these reasons are good reasons. If anybody else thinks differently, then the matter can be decided in a different way.

Comment on this

I am sorry to hear that the Minister for Justice is ill, but I was in the House yesterday, or at least on the day when the President mentioned four Bills—or perhaps it was the Minister for Local Government—but I doubt if this was one of the four Bills mentioned on that occasion.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Well, if a Minister brings a Bill before the House—and the President may realise this yet—he ought at least to try to convince the House about what the Bill relates to, and not say, in effect: "Well, I asked the boys, and they said it was all right." In bringing the Seanad Bill through the House, one of the chief arguments used was that this Bill would clarify certain sections of the Seanad Bill, but our experience of the last few weeks makes that a rather difficult pill to swallow.

Comment on this

The position with regard to the Seanad Bill was very different from that of this Bill. In the case of the Seanad Bill, there were three or four alternative schemes in regard to the Seanad, and there was no use in trying to work out all the details corresponding to the various schemes proposed. Accordingly, the Seanad Bill was entirely different in character from this Bill. This is a Bill which was very carefully considered, and it is well known what is the usual practice in regard to such Bills. I am talking now to people who know perfectly well what is the usual procedure in regard to such Bills. If some of the criticism that has been levelled in this connection came from people who did not know how this sort of work is done it would be quite a different matter, but the Deputies opposite know perfectly well what is the usual procedure—what is necessary in order to get Government business done, and how it is necessary, once the general principles of a Bill have been established, sent to the draftsmen, considered by the draftsmen and returned, that the final carrying of the Bill through the House and the explanation of the Bill to the House is entrusted to one Minister so as to prevent unnecessary details being brought into discussion. What happened in this case is that, unfortunately, the Minister concerned got ill at the last moment and another Minister had to substitute for him. I have not myself been in charge of the Bill, but it seems to me to be quite obvious that, when you know what happens in regard to deferred sentences and so on, you can see the interpretation at once that should be put on this, and I say that the answer I have given to Deputy McGilligan is correct, and that is that the Executive Council, once Article 2A of the Constitution is removed, will have no powers except such as are given by Act of Parliament. Therefore the question of continuing powers is not affected.

Comment on this

A legal opinion is only worth the argument by which it is sustained.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

The President's legal opinions have not been sustained by argument.

Comment on this

They have been sustained in the sense that I have given to the House.

Comment on this

And the sense is that we ought to know what these Departmental officials know about it.

Comment on this

That is not so. I have given the reasons.

Comment on this

The only reason that I can see is that, after the Minister for Education had given one interpretation, a completely different interpretation is given on this matter.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

The President's anger on this matter is quite clearly understandable, because he does not want to admit that this Constitution allows certain courts, such as we are discussing, to be set up.

Comment on this

No, that is not so.

Comment on this

The President need not be hectoring the House in this manner. He must admit that this makes allowance for the continuance of these tribunals.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy's opinion would not be worth very much.

Comment on this

I have never asked that my opinion should be accepted by the President, because I do not think he is too good a judge of anything. As far as I can make out, the President goes by whatever a lot of "yes" men, sitting like sparrows on a telegraph pole, say to him.

Comment on this

We are not a collection of jaw-bones, anyway.

Comment on this

Well, I am not sure that, if your jaw-bones were exercised more against certain matters, they might have a certain value. However, what we are told in connection with this is that it is necessary because, once Article 2A is gone, the power of the Executive Council with regard to pardon is gone. I say that it is not. First of all I ask the President to look at the Interpretation Act and, after that, to look at the clause that he himself put in the Constitution carrying forward the prerogative with regard to mercy—whether retained in law or not—and to find out what happened in regard to that.

Comment on this

I hope when your turn comes there will be no prerogative.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will not again call Deputy Corry to order in to-day's session.

Comment on this

The President makes the pretence that the object of this is to fit into the constitutional scheme. I put it to the President again that, in connection with the question of these prerogatives being overridden, there was no necessity to bring in this particular phrase unless you consider one thing, and one thing only: and that is, the possibility of these special tribunals being brought into being hereafter; and evidently the President thought it well to safeguard the position, because although it might be considered that the tribunals were not carried forward, still it was necessary to have some provision whereby they could be set up. I think it is as plain as daylight.

Comment on this

It is as plain as daylight that what the Deputy is saying has no reference to this Bill.

Comment on this

It is as plain as daylight that between what the Minister for Education said and what the President says there is nothing to clarify the matter. The Minister said that it would carry on into the future.

Comment on this

I explained——

Comment on this

Possibly, the phrase came out because Ministers had been giving the matter consideration.

Comment on this

I deny that.

Comment on this

At any rate, it was one of the few points about which the Minister was clear. About everything else, he was in a fog. Does not everybody know that if there were going to be an attempt, even a tricky attempt, to carry such things through, it would be a matter for discussion by the Executive Council and ought to be impressed on the Minister's mind, and not——

Comment on this

Very clever!

Comment on this

It may be very clever. Of course, the President's Government is so much of a one-man business that he would not even discuss such a matter with his colleagues and advisers! He knows that he would. If he would discuss these other comparatively harmless and minor matters, surely he would discuss the more important ones; and is it not amazing that a Minister, who made such a woeful exhibition of himself with regard to other clauses of this Bill, should suddenly have become aroused to the extent of having some definite idea with regard to this particular clause. The one thing that starts out from the whole thing is that this clause was considered as an Executive Council matter and the rest were not. The only reason it was considered is because it is an important matter to make some provision for the future re-establishment of these special tribunals.

Comment on this

The Deputy is extremely clever and very unconvincing. If he looks at the clause he will see that this is the power of remission. If we are even to take the Deputy's view that it was carried over, is it not clearly only the power of remission and the prerogative of mercy? What do we want it for? For the reasons we have given. That is all that can be alleged, even under his own suggestion, which is, of course, absurd on the face of it. The Deputy need not be afraid, if he thinks it is going to be of any political value, to say that special courts may be necessary. They may be necessary. If they are necessary, this Government, in carrying out its duty, will come to Parliament to set them up. Do not think that we are running away from the possibility of anything of that sort. If it is necessary, it will be done, and then the Deputy can talk as much as he likes about it. I say in answer to the Deputy that if he thinks there is any political advantage in talking in that manner, I will give him all he wants of it, and he can take all the advantage he wishes out of the statement which I make here deliberately—that if public order here demands that there should be, under the new Constitution, special courts set up, it will be done; and if this Executive Council is in office, it will face its responsibility and bring in a measure to deal with it. Is the Deputy satisfied?

Comment on this

I am waiting for the cheers from the background.

Comment on this

So far as this is concerned, it is carrying over the powers of deferment of sentences, of commutation and relief of sentences, which is already given by Article 2A but which will disappear when Article 2A disappears, because the foundation of the power of commutation and remission of sentence, which the Executive Council has at present in regard to prisoners convicted by the tribunal, is given to them by Article 2A. We want to see, if there are any prisoners in prison at the time the new Constitution comes in and the old one goes out, that the powers of remission are continued over.

The Deputy says that is not an answer. I say that people, in whose opinion I have much more faith than I have in any legal opinion which he would give, consider that it is advisable and necessary. Even if it were not necessary, what harm can be done by giving these extra powers so as to make, if you like, assurance doubly sure? It is ridiculous to say that these are powers in relation to some future tribunal which is supposed to be set up.

Comment on this

There is one phrase in this section: "The Government may, in their absolute discretion, at any time remit in whole or in part or modify (by way of mitigation only) or defer (conditionally or unconditionally) any punishment imposed by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal." I take it that any person who is now in custody, under sentence imposed by the Military Tribunal, is actually undergoing sentence, and that that provision about deferment cannot refer to a person who is actually undergoing sentence at present. We have to deal with remission or modification there. Is not that so?

Comment on this

I do not know whether you can defer portion of a sentence. It is the same thing as remission.

Comment on this

Let us leave out deferment. There are certain categories of powers which the Executive Council may exercise under that section. They may remit in whole or in part, or modify by way of mitigation only. I take it, therefore, that where a person is serving a term of imprisonment, the only function they can really exercise in that respect would be remission in whole or in part. Then that is clearly not dealing with a case where you want to defer punishment. Deferment is a different thing. The only circumstance in which deferment might arise is in the case of any person who is brought before the tribunal between now and the 29th of this month.

Comment on this

There are some deferred cases already—deferred cases, for instance, for a period, some under conditions and some not under conditions.

Comment on this

What type of cases are these?

Comment on this

Cases where there has been deferment.

Comment on this

Of the sentence imposed.

Comment on this

Yes, the punishment being deferred.

Comment on this

A suspended sentence.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Let us deal with that side of it. Persons have been before the tribunal and sentences have been imposed. I take it that in certain cases these sentences have been deferred subject, presumably, to something happening in the meantime on the part of the person sentenced.

Comment on this

Usually good conduct or something like that.

Comment on this

Under the existing Constitution (Amendment) Act there is power to exercise that deferment, so that that Act really gives you the power of deferment while the Military Tribunal lasts. Is not that so?

Comment on this

I would not say that.

Comment on this

There is power for deferment under the Act?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There is that power of deferment up to the 29th December when the tribunal ceases to function?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the purpose, therefore, of carrying over the power to defer? Presumably, a person, if he is not called upon before the 29th of this month to serve his sentence, will not certainly be afterwards asked to serve it.

Comment on this

What about the prisoners in jail at present? May not their sentences be deferred?

Comment on this

Although they are in jail?

Comment on this

I asked the President, where a person is at present undergoing sentence and it is desired to release him, what power the Executive Council exercise, and the President answered "the power of remission." The power of remission is the only power which can be exercised then.

Comment on this

I think he expressed doubt.

Comment on this

I think the President was clear on the matter. Now the Minister for Education asks: "What about the people who are at present serving"? The President, who knows more about the Bill, says they will have to deal with these people by way of remission of sentence. The difference between the President, who says: "You must deal with them by way of remission," and the Minister for Education, who says: "You must deal with them by way of deferment——"

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

The Minister implied that he meant deferment as applied to existing prisoners.

Comment on this

I have been trying to explain to the Deputy, as the President has just explained to him, that the Executive Council have exercised the power of deferment in the past. I can see no reason why they should not exercise that in the future, if they think fit.

Comment on this

What future?

Comment on this

After the 29th of this month in respect of the existing prisoners.

Comment on this

It is an explanation of that kind that causes all the difficulty.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

I will do my best to explain. This section enables the Government to exercise certain functions.

Comment on this

This section is taken straight out of the Constitution (Amendment) (2A) Act. The relieving powers are taken out of it and are being carried on.

Comment on this

The section says: "The Government may in their absolute discretion at any time remit in whole or in part or modify (by way of mitigation only) or defer, conditionally or unconditionally, any punishment imposed by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal." We are dealing with persons undergoing sentence by the tribunal. They are in custody at If it is desired to release any of these, I take it that the Government must exercise the power of remission. It is not a case of deferment, because you cannot defer a sentence already being served. What must operate in that case is the power of remission.

Comment on this

You can defer the portion of the sentence which has not been served.

Comment on this

If the Minister will read the section he will see clearly that the function to be exercised in these circumstances is the remission. You say that you remit either in whole or in part. You cannot remit the whole sentence; you can remit only the unserved portion of it. Clearly, this provision to defer conditionally or unconditionally any punishment is entirely a different type of power. There is, at present, under the Constitution (Amendment) Act, power to defer any punishment which may be imposed by the Tribunal. Seeing that we have that power and can exercise it, up to the 29th of this month, when the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal disappears, what is the purpose of carrying this power into this Bill unless it is thought that that power can be exercised here after the 29th December? Why are we carrying over that power seeing that we can only exercise it up to the 29th December? Surely we do not need it after the 29th December unless we were thinking of having a deferred sentence, and that we might revoke the deferment and reimpose the sentence?

Comment on this

First of all, some point has been made about the Minister saying that you defer. From a layman's point of view in this matter, we might say you defer or you remit; as long as the remission is achieved it does not matter very much. Technically, both can be used so that when the Minister speaks about deferring portion of a sentence remitted he strictly would not be inaccurate. That may prevent misunderstanding. The next question is: what is deferment? The power of deferring has often been exercised in this particular way. We defer sentence for a certain period on the understanding that it will come up to be reviewed at a certain time. In other words, you say that if you get satisfactory reports as to the conduct of the person whose sentence has been deferred, the sentence may be remitted completely. If, however, the report is not completely satisfactory you may say: "Very well; it is in the public interest that this particular person should have a further period of probation in which we shall see what his conduct will be like and we can get a further report upon him." There you defer the matter for review at a certain period. That is a power undoubtedly that under this section will be continued.

Let us say that the sentence was to be reviewed on the 1st January and that on the 1st January you found that the conduct, generally, of the person involved had been of such a character that, if this transition had not taken place, the Government would not have been prepared completely to remit the sentence. In that case we might say: "We have reviewed this and we consider it proper to put it back for a further review at the end of March." That power is given in the Bill and that is the sense in which deferment is used. The power to defer is being used in that connection to give a period during which reports would be got as to the conduct of the individual concerned so that these reports could be considered when the matter would come up for review. It is deferred for review. If on that date it was found that his conduct had been satisfactory, and that it would be consistent with the general public interest that the sentence should be remitted completely, then it would be remitted. If, on the other hand, it was considered that the public interest demanded that a further period should be given and that the matter should be reviewed again after the lapse of some months, then it would be deferred for that period.

Comment on this

Is there any deferment in a case where a person actually served some portion of his punishment?

Comment on this

I understand there has not been.

Comment on this

The position as I understood it was this: There are two powers that were very distinctly stated for those who want consideration of this section. Deputy Norton has definitely stated one case. There is a power of remission where a man had been sentenced and where he began to serve his sentence. The rest of the sentence is remitted. That is one power. He contrasted with that, very clearly, the power of deferring punishment. That has been explained by the President. Whilst Deputy Norton was discussing the matter, on two occasions the Minister for Education said: "What about the prisoners who are now in prison?" In reference to the power of deferment that can only mean one thing. I want to know does it mean this, and the President has not yet stated that it does. Say a person was sentenced to 18 months and served six months. The only interpretation that can be put on the Minister's interruption is this, and it can bear no other explanation, because Deputy Norton stated the alternatives clearly: "He has served six months; we are now letting him out and deferring the other 12 months." Is that possible?

Comment on this

I am informed that it has been possible.

Comment on this

Is it desired to keep that power?

Comment on this

It is desired to keep that power with any with other power of deferment. In so far as the power of deferment in the other sense is kept on, the power of deferment in that sense is kept on.

Comment on this

And it is desired to keep it on?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Now that we have finished with sub-section (1), I desire to call the attention of the President to a matter arising out of sub-section (2). This sub-section states that whenever a free pardon has been granted by the President to a person convicted by the Constitution (Special Powers) Tribunal, the forfeiture or disqualification occasioned by such conviction shall, as from the date of such pardon, be annulled. I presume that one of the disqualifications there would be, for instance, the right to receive an Army pension. Any doubts I had on that matter were removed when the scheme was going through this House quite recently. It was stated that anybody who was convicted by a court of competent jurisdiction and received a sentence of six months would automatically lose his pension. I asked the Minister for Defence would he include in that category convictions by the Military Tribunal, and he said "yes." He said that the tribunal would be considered a court of competent jurisdiction. Now, under this Bill, when a man so sentenced is pardoned, it automatically follows that he gets back his pension. He may be sentenced to death and his sentence is commuted. He serves ten years, the President pardons him, and then he gets his pension back. Then take the case of a man caught with a gun, for instance, who gets 12 months' imprisonment. He serves that 12 months, does his time, but he cannot get the pension back.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He will get the gun back.

Comment on this

Does the President say that is so?

Comment on this

He serves 12 months for a minor offence and he does not get his pension back, whereas a man who has, perhaps, committed murder does get his pension—in fact, must get it. It is mandatory. I suggest that is the interpretation of the sub-section.

Comment on this

The Deputy is arguing something that is not here. The fact that a free pardon will carry certain things does not mean that something contrary to this would be done in other cases. It would be quite possible to deal with that case in an independent manner. The clause set out here makes it quite clear that a free pardon, when it is given, means wiping out the offence as if it had not existed, and in so far as any disqualification or forfeiture is concerned, when the President gives a free pardon, as from the date on which it is given the disqualification and the forfeiture disappear.

Now, to say that because you do that in that particular case you are implying that something else will happen in some other case, I do not think is accurate at all. It does not flow from this. If what the Deputy says is true, it may be a question of saying: "That is a peculiar situation in law", but that does not arise as far as this section is concerned. This section is of narrow import. It simply gives legal and statutory assurance to this fact, that a free pardon when it is given is to mean that all those things are wiped out.

Comment on this

The President's use of what I may call the parable of the eleventh hour will hardly fit here, namely, because he is giving a big concession in one case no obligation is there to give it in smaller cases. There is such a thing as even-handed justice which the Government is bound to mete out. Deputy McGilligan's point is that if you are giving this big concession in this particular case you certainly ought to give it in minor cases. There is a moral obligation on you to do so.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I am just explaining what I think was the point which was made.

Comment on this

I understand the point.

Comment on this

I think that is the point.

Comment on this

I understand it perfectly. But the point is what does the Deputy want?

Comment on this

I want you to undertake to do the same in regard to minor sentences.

Comment on this

In other words, the Deputy wants to insert it in this?

Comment on this

No—not here. I said "undertake to do it". The President admits there should be even-handed justice?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

It is not even-handed justice that a person guilty of a major offence will, because it is a major offence, probably get a pardon, whereas the person guilty of a minor offence who gets a minor sentence will probably serve it out and not get a pardon. For that reason he is put in a disadvantageous position as compared with the other person, and that is not even-handed justice.

Comment on this

The Deputy has gone to the moon away from all this. I appreciate the point about even-handed justice, but that has no immediate relation to this, unless he wishes that we should insert something in this Bill in regard to the other case. If that is the contention, I understand it. What is the position? A free pardon —as I have understood it at any rate, whether I am right or wrong—has been as if the offence had not been committed; a complete wiping clean of the slate. Where are free pardons given? A free pardon will not be given to everybody. A free pardon is given when there are some special reasons for it, and that free pardon, in so far as the wiping out of those particular consequences is concerned, can be given, I understand, to a person who has served his sentence.

This is important from the Deputy's point of view. A free pardon may be given to a person who has served his sentence. If it is considered by the Executive Council that a case for a free pardon arises, whether the sentence has been served or whether it has not, that free pardon can be given. When it is given, all this ensures is that that is a method by which you wipe out all the consequences. In so far as they cannot make it retrospective—if a man has suffered certain punishment in the past, you cannot make it retrospective—that wipes it out. I hope the Deputy understands.

Comment on this

At the same time I consider it is doing it unjustly; that the justice is not even-handed. Either this should be deleted altogether or the President should bring in something else to try to balance the scale.

Comment on this

Here is what generally happens: A person has been convieted by the tribunal of an offence of a certain type. He may have been punished, or perhaps before the punishment a petition comes to the Executive Council that for such and such reasons a free pardon should be granted. The Executive Council may say: "Very well. We are prepared to consider that favourably if we get some assurance that the same sort of offence which resulted in this particular punishment being inflicted will not occur again." In such a case the Executive Council has always tried to take as lenient a view as possible under the circumstances. There is this petition. It may be after the sentence has been served. It is considered on its merits. If the Executive Council is satisfied that they are exercising their functions for the interests of the community as a whole by giving a free pardon, then they can give it. All that is here is that if it is given it will carry the consequence of complete wiping out, so that it is really even-handed if the Deputy regards it in that sense.

Comment on this

The President, I think, understands, that even if a free pardon is granted ordinarily, it does not wipe out the conviction. The person will still be under a disability.

Comment on this

I think a free pardon always took that with it. This is, if you like, making assurance doubly sure.

Comment on this

The President is discussing free pardon in different terms. What does a free pardon mean? Is it a remission of sentence in the whole?

Comment on this

It is as if the offence had not been committed. It is wiping the slate clean.

Comment on this

If a person gets the whole of a sentence remitted, is that a free pardon?

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. They are different things. Surely there is a big distinction. When was a free pardon ordinarily granted?

Comment on this

I am not going to go into the question.

Comment on this

I suggest that a free pardon always is granted when there is considered to have been a miscarriage of justice, and not otherwise.

Comment on this

That is not always so.

Comment on this

If it is supposed to be in some other terms, and the President certainly discussed it as if it were, then there is an enlargement of the general use of the phrase "free pardon." As long as we know that there is an enlargement of the phrase, we can get some idea of the more extensive territory it is going to cover. The more it does cover away from a miscarriage of justice case, the more point there is in Deputy McGowan's objection. He makes the objection that a man is brought before the tribunal, is considered to have committed some minor offence, and is sentenced to a year's imprisonment; he serves the year and his disqualification continues. He does something else which gets him a sentence for life. After he has done five years, there is what the President now describes as a free pardon. He then gets his whole rights restored to him.

Comment on this

And given under Article 2A, as the Deputy knows.

Comment on this

I am talking about free pardon. Does the phrase "free pardon" come into Article 2A?

Comment on this

I am sure it does.

Comment on this

I want an assurance that it does. "Free pardon" as used in ordinary law has no reference to a remission of sentence. In fact, it is what it says; it is a pardon so as to put a man back into his civic rights because it is believed that the sentence never should have been imposed on him. That is what it generally means. I am going back to Section I, notwithstanding what Deputy McGowan says. We are told this is continuing relieving powers, and we have had examination of what the relieving powers come to. One thing emerged. A man is brought before the tribunal and given two years, not to be imposed if he is of good behaviour. Deputy Norton gave the example, and the President accepted it, that you may call that man up next January and say: "We are not satisfied that you are of good behaviour; we will have another look at you next March." He comes up next March and you say to him: "You will go to jail for two years now." I do not call that a relieving power.

Comment on this

It might be a justice power.

Comment on this

Of course it might. I am glad to hear somebody on the Back Benches approving of justice from the President. There was the dullest and deadliest silence over there when the President tried to enthuse his followers about this tribunal.

Comment on this

We are the jury.

Comment on this

We understand the President. You do not.

Comment on this

Quite right!

Comment on this

Special courts may be established. The President has told us they are going to be established if required, and there is not a spark of enthusiasm for them on the Back Benches.

Comment on this

In the event of a man being detained on a capital charge, in what way can the President exercise his prerogative of mercy? How can he get out?

Comment on this

He is given the power here, on the advice of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

Which Article contains that?

Comment on this

The Government may do it in their absolute discretion.

Comment on this

But capital offences are exempted from that; it exempts capital offences. I am suggesting that the only way would be a free pardon by exercising sub-section (2).

Comment on this

There is the right of free pardon here in Article 13 (6): "The right of pardon and the power to commute or remit punishment imposed by any court exercising criminal jurisdiction are hereby vested in the President, but such power of commutation or remission may, except in capital cases, also be conferred by law on other authorities." You have here the conferring by law on another authority.

Comment on this

In the event of a person being sentenced to penal servitude and after the completion of five or seven years it is found that that person is completely innocent, he will get a free pardon and possibly that will satisfy him. But in other places they grant a sum of money to that type of person by way of compensation. Does this Bill include that, or have you a fund in another place for that purpose?

Comment on this

That is a case of clear miscarriage of justice and you will have to consider it in its own setting.

Comment on this

I am not at all clear that a free pardon in the ordinary meaning removes the conviction. The stain of the conviction is still there.

Comment on this

It does. Free pardon is mentioned in a certain context in a certain sense.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy does not anticipate anything.

Comment on this

I should like to take the Report Stage now. It is rather urgent that this measure should become law. I think the points that have been raised by the Opposition have been examined fairly carefully. There were only two important points and they were related to the Prevention of Electoral Abuses Act. We are satisfied that they are covered. Our advisers have informed me that they have gone into that matter and they are quite satisfied that position is fully met. Therefore, there would be no advantage in postponing further discussion of the measure and I would ask the House to facilitate us by giving us the remaining Stages.

Comment on this

This is an amazing request. During the course of this Bill, when the Minister was mainly in a fog, he said he would look into at least three matters. He now tells us that the only point of importance was in connection with electoral abuses. He says that his advisers are satisfied. If he could convey that satisfaction to us and the reasons for it, we might allow him to get this measure through; but it is surely treating the House with contempt to come here and say, after a conversation across the gangway, that his advisers are satisfied that something has been met?

Comment on this

Does not Deputy McGilligan know by this that when the Minister says he will consider a point, that is the last we will hear of it? It has become merely a polite method of telling the House that Ministers do not care what the House thinks. Frequently, when we raise important points here we are told: "This matter will be considered and, by the next stage, we will have an opportunity of getting the matter explained or else an amendment will be introduced to meet the situation." When the next stage is reached there is no opportunity afforded of discussing the point because no amendment has been introduced by the Government and, therefore, it cannot be raised any further. It has become a practice with the Government when they are up against any difficulty in this House to say: "We will consider that point and by the next stage we will be able to clarify the position in regard to this particular matter." That is merely the common practice. It is the Government's method of deceiving the House. Indeed, it has become almost a sacrosanct procedure.

Comment on this

I suggest that it has become the practice simply because the Opposition have not gone to the trouble of putting down amendments to meet their own point of view. As a rule, when there is a Second Stage there is ample time given between that and the next stage for putting down amendments. I am not applying that to recent measures, because I admit that in the case of this Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill we have been rushing things a bit because of the pressure of time. But, ordinarily, when a Minister says: "I will consider that and possibly put down an amendment," the moment the amendment sheet appears and Deputies opposite see their point is not covered, then it is up to them to go to the trouble of trying to put down an amendment to meet their point of view and get the sense of the House upon it.

Very often it happens—it has happened in my own case quite often— that a point is made from the opposite benches and it appears at first sight to have some substance to it, but when related to other parts of the Bill it will become evident that the point has been met, or there is a reference in some other paragraph which covers the whole thing. In those circumstances it is not necessary to put down an amendment. When you have a long, complicated Bill it is very easy, when you are attending to one section, to lose sight of the effect or the force of another section. You require to sit down carefully and consider the Bill. Certain things may be lost sight of when we are on our feet meeting a point raised for the first time. If Deputies want a point properly debated, the way to do that is to put down an amendment so that Ministers will have an opportunity of considering it calmly and quietly and getting any advice, if there is a legal point raised, on the particular merits of it. Lawyers differ as doctors differ, and very often the construction of a particular paragraph or section of a Bill may give rise to a difference of view. You may have a difference of opinion, and even amongst your advisers you may have a difference of view, and, finally, the person in charge has to make up his mind what he is going to do in the circumstances.

My attitude is that wherever there is a doubt I try to make assurance doubly sure, even if I were told that already the point was sufficiently sound. When Deputies raise points and we say we will consider them, they are actually considered. The judgment may be that the point has been met in some other section, or that the point is not sound. Deputies ought not to take it that there is not proper attention paid to their points because Ministers do not come along with an amendment, for the reason that we are convinced and amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

I was dealing with my experience of the last couple of weeks. It is absurd, for instance, in the particular case the President refers to, to expect that we could put down amendments. How could we be expected to put down amendments when we only got the President's amendments to-day? Further, I explained to-day quite seriously that I thought it would be detrimental to a bad Bill if we made any suggestions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

May I take it the objection is not pressed?

Comment on this

The proposal is that this Bill should get the Fourth Stage now. The President has given us a lecture on the duty of the Opposition to put down amendments and, in order to allow us to put down amendments, we are asked to take the Fourth Stage now. It all seems very logical.

Comment on this

One reason why we might give the President this Bill is that we will not have a repetition of the Ministerial conduct that we had here for the last three or four hours.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The question is: "That the Bill, as amended, be received for final consideration."

Comment on this

I am going to object unless every stage is taken now, because there are some flaws in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy has threatened us in that respect many a time.

Comment on this

You found them out afterwards.

Comment on this

The threats never materialised. We were threatened about the Bill dealing with the abolition of the Seanad even by an ex-Attorney-General, but the threats did not amount to a row of pins.

Comment on this

They amounted to a whole heap. You had to bring in amending legislation. Is it proposed to take all the stages now?

Comment on this

Yes.

Bill received for final consideration, and passed.

Comment on this