We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance.—Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 1–176 of 350. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move:-

Go ndeontar suim Bhreise ná raghaidh thar £139,704 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá dé Mhárta, 1938, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Talmhaíochta agus Seirbhísí áirithe atá fé riaradh na hOifige sin, maraon le hIldeontaisí-i-gCabhair.

That a Supplementary sum not exceeding £139,704 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1938, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture and of certain Services administered by that Office, including sundry Grants-in-Aid.

There are some items on this Estimate which may require explanation. The first item, £631, includes subscriptions to the International Institute of Agriculture, the headquarters of which are in Rome. What really happened was that the subscription for 1936-37 was not paid until the present financial year, and the subscription for 1937-38 will be also paid during the present financial year. It was therefore necessary to have a Supplementary Estimate. The amount payable up to the present year to the International Dairying Federation was very small. The amount has been raised, and as a result we have to pay £20 more than we paid previously. The International Beef Conference includes countries which export beef or cattle for the British market and the different countries that participate contribute in proportion to the exports. Our share amounts to £109.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say what countries are members of the Beef Conference?

Comment on this

All countries which export beef, principally Australia, Argentine and Uruguay.

Comment on this

Great Britain does not belong to it.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In addition to those that are exporters?

Comment on this

Yes. Sub-head F (1) deals with agricultural schools and farms. There are three farms concerned—Athenry, Chantilly and the Munster Institute, Cork. In the case of Athenry and the Munster Institute the expenses of keeping students and keeping live stock increased. In the case of Chantilly the position was different owing to the fact that we purchased more stallions than was anticipated when the original Estimate was introduced. Sub-head G (1) refers to the improvement of milk production. Here we had a somewhat larger number of cows under test and the travelling expenses of supervisors were heavier than anticipated. Expenditure on the purchase of dairy bulls for leasing or resale at reduced prices was £350 more than the original Estimate. With regard to land reclamation, £2,000 additional was required for the employment of gangers. These schemes were in congested districts and in other specified areas and deal with the reclamation of land belonging to small farmers which up to the present was not productive. Small grants were given for the reclamation of that land and it entails a certain amount of supervision. More work was done than was anticipated. Sub-head M (5)—dealing with the improvement of the creamery industry—is a large item. There was the purchase of two creameries, one co-operative and the other proprietary. There were also two creameries at Leitra. One was handed over to a co-operative society and Ballymacelligott was offered to the Dairy Disposals Board. We also commenced the organisation of schemes for districts in West and South Kerry from Cahirciveen to Kenmare and from Kenmare to Castletownbere. The organisation of these districts will it is expected entail an expenditure of £40,000 but not more than £8,000 will be spent during the present financial year. There will be a central creamery at Kenmare, a collecting centre at Castletownbere, and nine travelling creameries operating to bring the cream to the large centres. All churning will be done at Kenmare. It is very difficult to say with certainty at the present juncture if it is going to be a complete economic success, but it is thought that more can be done by spending a certain amount of money organising creameries in the area that will be for the good of the people, than by spending an equal amount on unemployment relief or that type of work. I have hopes that the project will succeed. At any rate, Deputies who know the area will not I think find any great fault at the expenditure of a comparatively small amount of money if there is a hope that some good can be done there. Sub-head M (8) refers to expenditure in connection with the provision of butter for winter requirements. When the Budget was brought in early in the financial year a change was made in the price of butter to the consumer and the creameries received for April 139/- per cwt. but paid a levy of 27/-a cwt. making the net amount 112/-. As they had gone through a difficult winter it was felt that we should try to continue winter prices for the month of April and that meant paying back 17/- a cwt. to the creameries for April production In addition, a certain amount of butter was left unsold at the end of April which they had to sell at 118/-, the price from May to November. We had to give an additional 11/- per cwt. on that costing £5,200 on a total production for April of 28,700 cwts. For the last four or five years we had a scheme of storing butter for winter consumption. Up to the present year the scheme was to remit a certain amount of the levy on butter in cold storage, usually I think 9/-. As the levy was only 1/- this year we had to pay up, instead of remitting the levy on 56,500 cwts. stored to the middle of September at 9/6, and after that on 16,000 cwts. at 6/- a cwt. as well as on 4,000 cwts. of non-creamery butter, making a total of 76,500 cwts. stored for winter use. In addition to that for the last four or five years we remitted the levy during the winter months in order to give a better price for winter production than for summer production. As we had no levy to remit we had instead to give a subsidy during the winter months and that amounted to 12/- a cwt. The amount spent on that was £49,000. The three items, April production, storage for winter, and production during the winter, make a total of £111,000.

Comment on this

There is no compensating saving anywhere in the accounts for that expenditure?

Comment on this

It would come out of the export bounty Vote but it was held that it was not dated on the face of the Estimate and therefore might be regarded as not included because it was not exported.

Comment on this

You will save out of the export bounty practically the amount of money that you are disbursing here.

Comment on this

In connection with the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Acts, the amount of compensation set out is £15,000 but there are savings against that which amount to almost £15,000. There are two items in connection with that sum of £15,000. The first is that the co-operative meat factory in Waterford entered into an agreement with me about three years ago to take cattle from the Kerry cattle area for conversion into corned beef and meat essences. Under that agreement they were paid a certain amount per head for the cattle—not a fixed amount per head. They bought the cattle at a fixed price from me. I had to purchase the cattle in the Kerry cattle area at a somewhat higher price; and, therefore, there was a certain loss, but it did a considerable amount to relieve the position in the Kerry cattle area in improving prices there. Fortunately, if you like, prices improved considerably during the present year, with the result that it became altogether uneconomic to purchase those cattle and resell to Waterford. We had a provision in the agreement that up to the 31st July, 1937, I had the option of paying them £10,000 compensation and dropping the agreement, or paying them the amount that they had spent on the factory if that was a lesser sum. As a matter of fact it was higher, and, therefore, we paid them the £10,000. As far as the Kerry cattle area is concerned the scheme is finished. They are carrying on this business now on their own. They are purchasing a rougher type of cattle and of young cows which they claim to be more suitable for the making of corned beef and of meat essences. That is as regards the £10,000. The other £5,000 was paid to the factory in Roscrea under somewhat similar circumstances. The factory in Roscrea commenced production about three years ago, I think. The original agreement there provided that the promoters would build the factory, having got a certain amount of money on loan on which they were paying 4 per cent. There was, however, an agreement that we should supply them with a certain number of cows.

Comment on this

They got all the money they required for the factory.

Comment on this

They thought at the time that they would get it. They got £16,000 on debentures, and claim that they have spent much more than that. One part of the agreement was that we would have to supply them with a certain number of cows.

Comment on this

For nothing?

Comment on this

Yes. They paid the freight on them. There was a compensation clause in case we failed to supply the number of cows. We gave them cows for a while. As a matter of fact, we were being offered many more cows than we could take, and we had to enter into a second agreement with Roscrea to enlarge the factory, and that we would send them more cows. We found, after some time, that it was impossible to get cows at the price which we were paying, namely, 50/- each. We were advised by people in the country that unless we paid considerably more we would not get the number of cows that we wanted for the factory. We would become liable, therefore, for the penalty for not supplying the cows. Instead of paying the penalty, we considered that we would be making a better bargain by compensating them for the cost of the additions to the original factory. It has not yet been decided what that amount is. We paid £5,000 on account. It would be very unwise on my part if I were to say now what I think they should get, but the position is that we have paid £5,000 on account. I should say that under the Cattle and Sheep Act everything in connection with these agreements—what has been paid out and all the rest—must be laid before the Dáil at the end of the financial year, so that all those things will come up for consideration in more detail at a later stage.

Comment on this

When all the money is spent, I suppose.

Comment on this

When the cows come home.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say who owns this factory in Roscrea?

Comment on this

The present company own it, but it falls back into the hands of the Minister for Agriculture after four years' operation at the original cost.

Comment on this

After borrowing £16,000 on debentures, are the boys going to sell it back to you again?

Comment on this

They must pay us the £16,000.

Comment on this

You are going to pay them at the end of four years the cost of building the factory, and they are going to hand you over a dud factory?

Comment on this

We have the alternative of taking our money back, and leaving it with them. If we get our £16,000 back we can leave it with them. We have the option of either taking the factory at the original cost or leaving it with them.

Comment on this

It would be contrary to all the principles of commercial enterprise for anyone to take back a failure.

Comment on this

With regard to the distribution of cattle export licences, when the scheme was brought in of giving a bounty on stall-fed cattle, it necessitated the allocation of a certain number of inspectors for that purpose. That involved an expenditure of £1,144, plus £150 for travelling expenses. In the case of the Flax Act, there was a slight excess of expenditure in connection with travelling expenses of £200. Under Appropriations-in-Aid, there was an estimated deficiency in the items set out—receipts from students' fees, sale of live stock and farm produce, etc. Most of that is due to the fact that one of the farms owned by the Department of Agriculture had to get rid completely of its stock of pigs because they had a breed that was not doing well. The result was that for some few months there were no pigs, and, therefore, no sales, a thing which was not anticipated.

Comment on this

They would take the land off a farmer if he told them that.

Comment on this

They have their pigs back again now.

Comment on this

The unfortunate farmer would not get time. The Minister for Lands would take the land off him and give it to his neighbour.

Comment on this

Were they York pigs they were getting rid of?

Comment on this

They are getting them back again.

Comment on this

They found they were not suitable?

Comment on this

Not at all. They are getting them back. The next item is: "Receipts from service fees of stallions, sale of colts, sale and leasing of bulls, etc.". We did not succeed in purchasing the number of stallions we had hoped to get and therefore there was a smaller receipt from the sale of stallions. The next item is: "Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act: Receipts from fees, etc.—£1,000". That was due to a reduction in the export of eggs. Then there is: "Dairy Products Acts and Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Acts—£7,240". That is due to the fact that we had a rather large staff the previous year for the collection of the levy on farmers' butter and these officials were not necessary during the present year because we dropped the levy. If we had employed these people the amount would be recouped to the Department out of the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Fund. As the officials were not wanted they were not paid and therefore there was no recoupment and no Appropriation-in-Aid under that head because the officials were not employed.

Comment on this

You paid them?

Comment on this

No, we did not pay them. If we had paid them we would have been recouped that amount from the Price Stabilisation Fund.

Comment on this

You have a compensating item?

Comment on this

They were not paid at all.

Comment on this

There would have been £7,000 going out under another sub-head?

Comment on this

There is that much less, on the salaries.

Comment on this

If these people had been continued in their employment would they have been able to collect what would pay their own salaries?

Comment on this

They did more than that. They did not collect enough and that is why we did away with that. The next item is: "Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Acts". The same thing applies there. At the time that we ceased paying subsidies to the wheat growers a certain amount was outstanding from certain growers to a merchant under guarantees from the Department that the merchant would be able to collect his bill for seed from these people. At the time the Bill was going through it was provided that the Department would undertake the responsibility of collecting these amounts and would pay them over to the merchants. Of course the amount is not paid out to the merchant. We did not get in as much as we expected and therefore the Appropriations-in-Aid are down by £360.

Comment on this

Are you taking steps to recover the amount?

Comment on this

Yes. The next item is "Agricultural Products (Regulation of Export) Acts (sub-head 0.9)." That deals with the export of butter to Belgium and Germany. There was less butter exported to Belgium than we anticipated, and also somewhat less to Germany, and therefore less receipts amounting to £90,000. The same thing applies to the next item, "Receipts in connection with the administration of the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Acts, etc."

Comment on this

You have a corresponding saving on each sub-head?

Comment on this

Yes, on the purchase. Fewer cattle were exported to Belgium. There were more cattle exported to Germany than in the previous year, but the number was fewer than anticipated probably due to shipping strikes lasting a couple of weeks, when no cattle went out. That item has been made up in that way. The number of cattle that went out in the year 1937 was 16,775, as compared with 14,382 the previous year, so that the number was actually up, but not as high as was anticipated when preparing the original Estimate.

Comment on this

What is the value of the cattle that went out in 1937-38, because you expected £515,000 worth to go out?

Comment on this

£175,000 of that sum is for the reduction on the Estimate for cattle receipts. If you take £175,000 from the original Estimate you have it.

Comment on this

£340,000 worth of cattle went out. You dropped £195,000 in Appropriations-in-Aid.

Comment on this

Yes, but I should like to assure the Deputy that there was a profit on the cattle during the year.

Comment on this

Was there much profit on the cattle sent to Germany?

Comment on this

A fair amount. I would not like to say any more now, because we are negotiating with Germany for a better price.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us what the profit was? Of course it represents a levy on the farmers who sell the cattle.

Comment on this

I do not want to keep that information from the Deputy, but I should like to say that this has to be produced at the end of each financial year's trading. We are negotiating about the price at present.

Comment on this

Perhaps it is as well to leave it over then.

Comment on this

The sum total that we want under the Estimate is £139,704.

Comment on this

In so far as this Estimate applies to the internal agricultural policy of this country, it seems to me to reveal a most astonishing situation of confusion and, in certain respects, of folly. Anyone listening to the Minister attempting to explain the Supplementary Estimate under M (8)—"Expenses in connection with the provision of butter for winter requirements" and certain of the items under the Appropriations-in-Aid deficiency relating to butter, must realise that it is now entirely impossible for any normal human being to follow the activities of the Minister in his relation with the butter industry of the country. Levies are changed every fortnight, payments are altered continually, and the Minister has constituted himself a kind of price dictator of the industry, and he manages the price by levying tolls on the consumer, and by doling out handfuls of money where he, in his absolute discretion, considers it a desirable thing to pass over £30,000 or £40,000 to the people. It would be very much better to take over the entire creamery industry and run it on the basis of the Electricity Supply Board. I would contemplate such procedure with horror because I detest Socialism. I detest concentration of every activity of the community under the control of bureaucrats or civil servants, but if I have to choose between some kind of order, be it a bureaucratic order, and chaos such as is at present going on under the Minister's activities, I would choose a bureaucratic order. Far better that the industry should be provided with an opportunity of getting on to normal lines. I do not propose to go into that aspect of the question now.

Comment on this

Tell us what you would do.

Comment on this

I have not the slightest intention of discussing that aspect of the question. If the Deputy has not heard me say that I trust he will be a little more attentive in future.

Comment on this

I suspected that.

Comment on this

One thing certain is that the chaos at present obtaining in this industry should be stopped, both from the point of view of public funds and the point of view of the industry itself. The further one delves into it, the more abundantly clear it is that, not only is it impossible for the ordinary observer to follow what the Minister is doing, but that the Minister himself, I do not believe, knows from day to day what he is doing. He simply lives from hand to mouth, doling out money one day and frantically drawing it back another day, storing too much butter this month and frantically scrambling to get butter out of the country the next month and then eventually finding that he has to import it from Denmark. I think it is true to say that not long ago when butter was saleable at a fancy price in London the Minister for Agriculture issued instructions to store in Dublin. Then when prices slumped on the British market, the Minister began to export Irish butter to the markets of the world. He then discovered when winter came that in that period of depressed prices he had sold more butter abroad than should have been sold if a balance were to be left in this country adequate to meet winter demands, and he had eventually to buy back butter from Denmark at winter prices. So we held, in Ireland, Irish butter while the price was at its highest in Great Britain and we sold in Great Britain and on the Continent when the price was at the very bottom. We bought back from Denmark winter butter at winter prices because we discovered we had not retained enough of our own production in this country to meet the home demand. That is characteristic of the chaos surrounding the administration of the butter industry at the present time. It is deplorable that it should be allowed to continue.

I think sub-head O (11) really gives rise to something closely approximating to a grave scandal. Here you have a small group of private capitalists who come to the Minister and express their readiness to embark on a speculation and the terms of their speculation are as follows: If the Minister will lend them £16,000 they will build a factory on condition that they get all the raw material for the industry from the Minister for nothing, and the Minister will buy that raw material out of public funds; furthermore, that the Minister must tell them the exact amount of that raw material which he will deliver to them for nothing every month and if he should fail to deliver the last cow to the number he undertakes to deliver, he has to pay them a penalty in respect of his failure to do so. They are to sell the product of the factory and put the entire proceeds of the sale into their own pockets and, at the conclusion of four years, they can sell the factory back to the Minister by declining to pay the debentures and handing back the factory to the Minister if, as has transpired, the business for which the factory was originally built has come to an end. The Minister is to be made a present by this group of speculators at the end of four years of a factory which is useless, and the boys are to go off with four years' plunder in their pocket. Well, now, really such a transaction as this is scandalous beyond description.

Then we are told that these gentlemen have actually had the effrontery to make a claim on the Government for compensation and that the Minister has paid them £5,000 on account and does not dare to say here what is his estimate of the ultimate liability. Was there ever such a revelation of the misuse of public funds? Did anyone in this House, either on the Fianna Fáil Benches or on the Opposition Benches, know at any time when the Minister's Estimates were before the House of the nature of this transaction? I should like to know if there is a single Deputy in this House who realised the nature of this transaction. I do not believe that there was a single one except those directly interested in the transaction. We are now informed of the true nature of the transaction, when the time comes for paying the penalties and when nothing can be done about it.

Realise what has happened. The Minister, under cover of our authority, has entered into agreements binding the State to pay penalties of an unascertained character and laying the absolute obligation on the public funds of this country to pay moneys out to these warriors who are engaged in this speculation, if speculation it can be called. Were the accounts of this private company — that is to say, a private company, as opposed to a State-controlled company — audited by a Government auditor? Does the Minister know whether profits have been made during these four years, and, if so, how great were these profits? Perhaps the Minister would tell us now is this a private company or a public company? Does the Minister happen to know?

Comment on this

I think it is a private company.

Comment on this

A private company! I have no doubt that if these gentlemen were a body of independent persons of whom the Minister had no knowledge except that they came along in the ordinary course of business, and he understood that they would carry on, that they were in no way connected with the Minister or his Government——

Comment on this

I shall answer all this.

Comment on this

Were they members of the Dáil?

Comment on this

Who is in the group? Would the Minister be good enough to tell us?

Comment on this

I shall answer all these questions afterwards.

Comment on this

I infer from what the Minister said now that some of the members of the private company were, in fact, connected with the Government, and he rests on the fact that this was a private company, obliged to publish no balance sheet, obliged to reveal not one figure as to what its profits were or were not. Was there ever such transaction entered into by any Government, dictatorial, democratic or otherwise? How can the Minister come to this House and ask for money to maintain conduct of that kind? It is a howling public scandal.

Comment on this

He is getting money back here!

Comment on this

He is paying out £4,000 on account of damages for failure to deliver a sufficient quantity of raw material for nothing to this private company.

Comment on this

There are Appropriations-in-Aid.

Comment on this

Appropriations-in-Aid have nothing to do with it. The Minister has fixed this House with warning that this is only the first instalment of what he proposes to do, and that he does not venture to estimate what their ultimate claim is going to be. Remember, the injury which they suffered is that the Minister did not deliver to them for nothing a sufficient quantity of the raw material on which they were operating. Such a transaction I never heard of, nor anybody else either. I listened with interest to the promise that the Minister is going to explain it all to us. I hope he will, and I will be particularly anxious to hear from the Minister has he taken, or will he now take, urgent steps to put in Government auditors to this company and report to this House what profits have been made, and what claim in equity this company can have to large damages, in view of the fact that at the conclusion of their four years' operations they could pass back to the State the worthless factory for the entire sum it cost them to build it.

The Minister directs our attention to the fact that the Appropriations-in-Aid fall short by £1,000 in respect of fees on the export of eggs. That has got nothing or very little to do with the situation operating abroad. The fall in the output of eggs is almost entirely due to the maize-meal mixture scheme set on foot by the Minister himself as part of the internal policy, without reference to external relations or external policy of any kind whatever, but just as a useful normal departure in the normal agricultural life of the country. What actually happened? This fraudulent, reckless, and irresponsible scheme was thrust down the throats of the people of this country. The object of it was, if you please, to increase tillage — to consume a greater quantity of barley and oats in this country than had been consumed heretofore. What actually happened? We are now consuming less barley and oats than we consumed before the scheme was put into operation. It emerged, after the damage was done, that the price of Indian meal had been raised so high over so long a period by the maize-meal mixture scheme that the number of fowl in the country had dropped by about 4,000,000. It then emerged that, quite unknown to or unrealised by the experts, the fowl of the country were consuming a very considerable quantity of oats; that they were keeping a very considerable quantity of land under oats in the country, which would cease to be under oats if the fowl were not there to eat them. All this land was kept under oats, which were consumed by the fowl and exported profitably in the shape of eggs—an export worth £2,250,000 per annum. Five years of the maize-meal mixture scheme brought our export of eggs down to £700,000 per annum; it reduced our export of eggs by nearly two-thirds, and so destroyed the consuming power of the egg-production industry in regard to oats and grain that the loss of oat acreage resulting from the destruction of the egg industry far exceeds the increased quantity of oats and barley consumed as a result of the maize-meal mixture scheme.

In that way we have burdened our people for five years with an immense charge, and mark you, we have burdened the poorest parts of the country with that immense charge, because if you take the hen population and the pig population of this country — and remember, the maize-meal mixture largely affects pigs as well as hens — you will find them concentrated everywhere in the congested areas, while the grain-growing areas are concentrated in the richest parts of the country. We were subsidising the richest parts at the expense of the poorest parts. For five years we laid that burden on the backs of the poorest section of the community. We destroyed the pig trade; we destroyed the egg trade; we reduced the acreage of grain; and we derived no benefit, direct or indirect from the whole experiment. Nevertheless it is being carried on to the present time, and I venture to say that Deputy Allen is thumping a tub about it down in Wexford. I should not even be surprised if Deputy Allen still believed in it. He is an innocent, good-natured kind of man. He was misled into this business, and he still probably nurtures some sort of illusion that it was sound, but that something went wrong; he does not know what. But these are the facts. These are the inescapable facts published in the Minister's own statistics, and so to-day we are face to face with the fact that the fees payable in respect of export of eggs are down by £1,000.

We are told that £400 in respect of deficiency in appropriations-in-aid results from the complete deterioration of the entire pig stock on one of the Minister's own farms. Was there ever such a confession made by a Minister responsible for a Department of Agriculture? Just imagine one of our farmers discovering that he had to take his entire stock of pigs and dispose of them on the grounds that they were so bad that he could not keep them on the place any longer. Everyone would say "Well, the sooner that fellow gets out of farming, and becomes a tram conductor or something else, the better for everyone concerned." The Minister would have qualified to become a tram conductor if that were one of the tests. On one of his own farms there has been such a deterioration in the grade of pigs that he has had to clear out the whole lot, and buy in a new stock, probably from some farmer whom his colleague, the Minister for Lands, will shortly certify as not being able to keep his lands in accordance with proper methods of husbandry, so that his lands will be taken from him and handed to some fellow who believes in farming a la Deputy Allen, and who will start producing in north Wexford a Manitoba No. 1 wheat superior to that which can be produced in Canada.

Comment on this

To choke the Deputy!

Comment on this

There is a very odd item here under sub-head I (4). The Minister explains that the expenditure of £2,000 — I direct the special attention of the Labour Party to this — on land reclamation schemes will be recouped to him out of the Unemployment Grant. We always had land reclamation schemes. We always had appropriations under the Land Commission Vote for those land reclamation schemes, but under the new dispensation you make a great hub-bub about all the money you are providing for the relief of the unemployed, and then you proceed to go around from one Vote to the other and pay for the normal expenditure that ought to be undertaken on those Votes out of the unemployment relief grant. That means either of two things; either you dislodge the normal worker who would get employment under those Votes at the ordinary rate of wages, by employing relief workers at 24/- a week to do the same work, or else you simply take from the Relief Vote the money that was ordinarily voted in the ordinary way for the maintenance of the public services. Would I be right in saying that this £2,000 is recouped from the Unemployment Relief Fund, and that in regard to the persons employed on those reclamation schemes, their work is valued on the basis of a 24/- a week wage? I should be glad if the Minister would tell us that.

Now, in regard to G (1), I want to direct the attention of the Minister to sub-head D. That, I understand, has to deal with the special-term bull, and I want to ask the Minister this question: Is it true that the Minister is making a profit out of these special-term bull transactions? My reason for asking that is that I suspect the Minister is going around the country with an air of benevolence bestowing special-term bulls on selected farmers as a bounty from the Government, when, in fact, what is happening is that the Minister's inspectors go to a show and, after all the good bulls, the expensive bulls, have been bought either by private persons or the Department for the purpose of distributing under the premium bull schemes, the Minister then buys all the left-over bulls which are adjudged by his inspectors to be fit for service at all at knock-down prices, and, having bought them at knock-down prices, he then proceeds to distribute them to farmers throughout the country as special-term bulls, and gets from the farmer who buys the special-term bull £6 or £10 more than he, the Minister, paid for the bull when he bought it. If that is true, I think it is an indefensible operation and highly undesirable, and I seriously doubt the prudence of this special-term bull system at all. We all know the difficulties that lay in the way of raising the standard of live stock in this country. The average small farmer was inclined to say: "Ah, the ould bulls were the best ones, and these Department bulls are not much good." Now, the only way to overcome that natural prejudice, the existence of which it is only common prudence to recognise, was to allow no bull to go out to the country as a Department bull, except a really tip-top animal, so that gradually all would come to realise that, if a bull was a Department bull, it was as good an animal as could be got. It is a mistake, in my judgment, to send out as a Department bull what is only a medium-class animal, and we have got to remember that when you call an animal a special-term bull, or a premium bull, or whatever else you call it, the country people lump them all together as Department bulls. I think that, on the whole, the Minister would be well advised to reconsider that business and to withdraw from the system of sending out special-term bulls altogether, and confine himself to sending out to the country nothing but the really choice bulls which have been associated with the premium standard over a long time.

Now, the Minister has described to us an item of expenditure here, which he undertook, under M (5), for the development of the creamery business in the County of Kerry. He says that it may prove to be uneconomic, but that no one will grudge the £1,000 or so that the scheme will cost, even if it is uneconomic, owing to the special circumstances obtaining in Kerry. I think the time has come when we ought to ask ourselves a question here, and that is, how much would it cost to supply milk; free of charge, generally, to the necessitous population of the cities of this country? I wonder if you paid the farmers of this country five pence a gallon for milk and, instead of trying to convert that milk into butter, brought it into the large centres of population and distributed it free, or at a nominal sum — and I would prefer to distribute it free — what would it involve the public purse? I think many people would be astonished at how little it would cost. It is pretty generally admitted that the most perfect foodstuff you can possibly get for young people is milk. I am convinced that, if you proposed to distribute it generally, it would have to be on the basis of pasteurising it all. Some people would say "How would you bring the milk all the way from Kerry to Dublin?" Well, that is nonsense, because all the milk that goes into London comes from greater distances than from Kerry to Dublin, and in many parts of America the milk is carried hundreds of miles to the centre of population where it is consumed, and the question of distance presents no difficulty. I suppose that, 100 years ago, if a man got up and suggested that you ought to bring water into every house in Dublin, and not only into every house, but into every tenement and every room in which people live, prudent financiers would have laughed at such a suggestion and said that the cost of pipes would be ruinous and that the cost of the maintenance of such a system of water supply would be prohibitive. We have now changed our minds in that regard, and I say that the idea of bringing milk into the centres of population in the same way is no more ludicrous than the idea of bringing water into the cities was 100 or so years ago. Can any individual walk through the streets of Dublin and see children literally starving—because an under-nourished child is a starved child—and say to themselves, quite blandly, that it is unthinkable to provide that child with the food requisite to give it enough? I feel the exact opposite. I feel that, so long as you have children living in an urban or indeed in any other centre, about whom you are bound to admit that they are not getting enough food, far from saying that it is grotesque to insist, without counting the cost, that they must get it, it is insane not to say that the thing is to give them food and count the cost afterwards.

Comment on this

The Deputy is preaching Socialism now.

Comment on this

Not at all. I am not preaching Socialism, but the soundest of economics.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It would require legislation.

Comment on this

No, Sir, because the Minister under this section says deliberately that he is going to lose some money, the primary object of which is to maintain the milk production in County Kerry, and I say that, instead of converting it into butter, the milk should be brought to Limerick or Dublin and given out to the people. I press on the House — of course I do not expect the House to rise up now and to say that this thing should be done to-morrow or the day after to-morrow — but I do press on the House that some effort should be made to find a remedy for a great social evil. The disposal of milk at the present time is extremely difficult. It does not seem to be possible for us to produce milk economically for conversion into butter, because the position in New Zealand and the Antipodes generally seems to be that they can produce butter more cheaply. Denmark seems to be able to do it because of their particular methods, but it is not necessary to go into the question of winter production and so on. Whatever the reason, the disposal of milk in a manufactured condition is extremely difficult. In England, they have tackled the problem by setting up milk boards and actually raising the price of milk. Here in Dublin we have actually entered into a conspiracy with the milk producers to raise the price of milk by a ½d. a quart. If any person who walks every day through Gloucester Street, Marlborough Street and Lower Gardiner Street could imagine that the Minister, or the Government, would still raise the price of milk to these people, it would seem to be incredibly outside betting. Could we not approach this problem, where there is redundant milk in the country, by recognising that milk production is a vital element in the live-stock industry of this country and that we have got to have milk production if we are to maintain the immensely valuable live-stock industry and, instead of manufacturing milk into butter to be sold at an uneconomic price in Germany, Great Britain and elsewhere, we should organise transport, if necessary in glass-lined vehicles, bring the milk to Dublin, pasteurise it and, if needs be, distribute it free? I seriously throw out that suggestion to the House for consideration, and I venture to make this prophecy: that if we have not the courage to bring into existence and operate some scheme of that kind in our day, our children certainly will. It is incredible to think that a foodstuff like milk should be wasted by converting it into butter that nobody wants and for which nobody will pay, when you could consume it in its ordinary condition, pasteurised or else produced in such a hygienic way as to render pasteurisation unnecessary—and I think that that is impracticable. It astonishes me that there should be any choice between the two methods.

I should be glad if the Minister would tell me netly what exactly does the beef conference refer to under one sub-head? What I mean is, do they meet ever so often, or do they recommend to the British Government what the import quotas will be, or what functions have they got? I say straightly to the Minister that, in my judgment, a very grave obligation indeed devolves upon him to explain in full detail the nature of the transaction that has taken place between his Department and the Roscrea Meat Factory, and I feel bound to say that, on the facts disclosed, the prima facie evidence is that a very grave and undesirable scandal is at present proceeding in regard to that matter.

Comment on this

I would vote for this Supplementary Estimate with a good deal more enthusiasm if I were sure it was going to pull this staggering industry out of the mess of economic chaos in which it certainly is to-day. Listening to the Minister's speech one certainly finds no grounds for enthusiasm as to the future of the dairying industry. Apparently the Minister himself does not know in what direction he is going or in what direction he is driving the dairying industry. I had thought that Deputy Dillon would have indicated a line of policy on the part of the Opposition which might improve the dairying industry or drag it out of the staggering position in which it is at present. I believe that, under present circumstances, the dairying industry cannot be saved, and that under the circumstances of the past four or five years it could not be saved, without providing a subsidy at the expense of the taxpayers.

Comment on this

Why should these circumstances continue?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon knows the reason, or, if he does not know the reason, Deputy Bennett or Deputy Fagan or the other Deputies near him will be able to tell him. From the evidence given it is clear that during certain periods within the last two or three years the dairy farmer without a subsidy would be only in a position to get 2½d. per gallon for his milk.

Comment on this

Only 1¼d.

Comment on this

I want to know from Deputy Bennett whether the dairy farmers could continue to supply milk if they were guaranteed a price of only 2½d. a gallon?

Comment on this

Why does Deputy Davin say that?

Comment on this

The figures are available, but Deputy McGilligan has not made a study of them nor has he made as much study of this question as he might.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell me why he puts the figure at 2½d. only?

Comment on this

The price of butter in the world market in which we have to sell it is such that creameries could pay only 2½d. a gallon for it if they were given no subsidy. I ask the Minister to say whether that is roughly correct or not?

Comment on this

At one time it was.

Comment on this

Then with the large amount we voted this year and last year for subsidising butter, the price has not exceeded 4½d. per gallon. Now that price of 4½d. a gallon is not an economic price to the dairy farmer and if we are going to support this industry by a system of subsidies — if a subsidy is justified at all it is only for the purpose of providing a proper price for the dairy farmers — and if we are to vote for this subsidy let us have a figure which would give the farmer something like 6d. per gallon. I would like to be checked up on these figures by Deputy Bennett. Notwithstanding the large amount which has been voted by way of subsidies in the last year or two and making allowance for what we are now asked to vote on the Supplementary Estimate, the extraordinary position in my part of the country is that the milk supplied to the Midland creameries has dropped by 30 or 40 per cent. I would like to ask the Minister now to give the House an explanation for that state of things.

Comment on this

Has any reason been suggested to Deputy Davin?

Comment on this

I would like to hear what the Minister has to say on the matter.

Comment on this

Has not Deputy Davin taken the opinion of men in the dairying industry down the country?

Comment on this

I do not think there are many creameries in the constituency that Deputy Brennan represents, but the Deputy probably knows something about the industry, and perhaps he would contribute in this debate something in the way of information.

Comment on this

Not less than yours.

Comment on this

I am entitled to ask the Minister, in spite of Deputy McGilligan's interruptions, for his explanation as to why the supply of milk to the Midland creameries has dropped by over 30 per cent.?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin did not understand the compliment I pay him. I would rather have his opinion.

Comment on this

I am an enthusiastic supporter of the establishment and the extension of the dairying industry on co-operative lines. I have listened with pleasure to the Minister paying lip service to that policy. He has gone much further than giving lip service to it, for he has come to this House, and the majority of the Deputies here, in spite of the Opposition, have voted millions of money for the purpose of maintaining that industry. But notwithstanding that the Minister has not gone far enough. If we are going to maintain or extend the dairying industry on co-operative lines we will have to go further than the Minister has gone. There is no use in establishing creameries under the co-operative system, getting the farmers to supply milk to them, giving them a proper price for the milk and giving them a guaranteed market for it either at home or in Great Britain, unless the Minister is prepared to go one step further, a step which will enable us not only to maintain the market we have got but will enable us to get a better market in Great Britain for our butter. If we are to build up a market in Great Britain or wherever the market may be in the future, we will have to copy the methods of competing countries. What are the methods of competing countries? Denmark is crushing us out of the English market because the Danes are organised on co-operative lines for production and for sale. They have organised themselves for the purpose of supplying big purchasers in Great Britain.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy did not want the British market.

Comment on this

I have a limited knowledge of the methods of marketing butter, eggs and bacon in this country. From that limited knowledge I say that not only will we not maintain the position we hold in the English market to-day but we will lose that position unless the Minister wakes up and sets up, in addition to a marketing scheme, an efficient selling organisation which will get us a better price and a better market in Britain for our butter. We are all glad to know that the Minister was engaged recently in negotiations with the British Government. The negotiations are going on for the purpose of securing a wider trade agreement, an agreement which will probably get us a guaranteed market for more eggs, butter and bacon, if we can produce them and be in a position to place them on the British market.

Comment on this

You opposed the sale of them there.

Comment on this

We supported this policy when the Deputy went into the Division Lobby against it. Deputy Fagan generally makes a contribution in this House by way of interruption. I hope I have provoked him into making a speech, making some intelligent contribution. If he does, I would like him to quote a speech in which any Labour Deputy since 1922 opposed the sale of our surplus produce in the British market.

Comment on this

That is a good one.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not laugh. Will he tell us where it is?

Comment on this

Does Deputy McGilligan or any Deputy there seriously suggest that I am a convert to this policy?

Comment on this

Yes, of supporting the British market.

Comment on this

At all times I have advocated, both by speech and vote, the extension of the dairying and allied industries, and the selling by efficient marketing methods of our surplus butter, eggs and bacon in whatever may be our principal market, Britain or elsewhere.

Comment on this

The Deputy must be one of the apostles at the moment.

Comment on this

I do not think so; I am quite certain I am not. Let me say that speeches of this kind were made from these benches before many of the present Fine Gael Deputies came into this House. The majority of those who came into this House with me in 1922 have since been kicked out. They may still be supporters of this policy, for all I know. I have travelled a fair share in many countries, and I think travelling is the best education anyone could get. Deputy McGilligan may say that the graduate of the university is the best educated, that that is the beginning and end of education. I think the man who has a fair amount of commonsense, and who keeps his eyes open and his ears to the ground when he travels around the world, will learn more than any man who takes out a degree in a university and who goes no further than a university.

Comment on this

I agree with you, but I wish you travelled farther.

Comment on this

The far-away cows have long horns.

Comment on this

Amongst the places I had the privilege of visiting were Paris and London.

Comment on this

There is plenty of agriculture there.

Comment on this

Some of my colleagues went further.

Comment on this

I am sure on such occasions the Deputy was universally admired.

Comment on this

One cannot fail to notice the fact that in London particularly, the centre of our principal export market——

Comment on this

You are certainly emphasising that.

Comment on this

One cannot fail to notice that there you have two or three catering firms, feeding a moving population of 2,000,000 or 3,000,000 people. Imagine Lyons and Co. of London being compelled, as they would be under certain circumstances, to come over here and visit 20 or 30 creameries for the purpose of finding out whether they could get all the butter they require daily, in a guaranteed quantity. These big London catering firms will come to the people of a country who can supply them with the butter, eggs and bacon they must get daily for the purpose of feeding their customers. We cannot supply here because we have no selling organisation capable of providing the eggs, butter and bacon in the quantities which large firms like Lyons would require.

Comment on this

What about beef? We killed all the calves.

Comment on this

I am encouraging the Minister to take a further step in the case of the dairying industry which will ensure success to it and which will ensure of the dairy farmer being provided with a profitable price for his milk and a guaranteed market at a reasonable price for his butter, bacon and eggs. The type of criticism which Deputy Dillon put up here to-night is not going to bring us to that stage. I challenged Deputy Dillon quite deliberately, when he was criticising the policy of the Minister — although it is not a clear-cut policy — to say what he stood for. I challenge Deputy Dillon to deny that his policy is to do away with the subsidy and let the dairy farmers rest on their own individual efforts. The Deputy says that that is the only way the dairying industry can be saved. That is the surest way of destroying it. If we want to ensure its success we must continue to subsidise the industry by providing a profitable price for the dairy farmer and setting up, although it may mean legislation, a marketing organisation which will be capable of helping our dairy farmers to compete with the Danish in our principal market.

Comment on this

What is a profitable price for milk?

Comment on this

I am not an expert, but I am sure if the dairy farmers of the midlands were guaranteed a price of 6d. or 6½d. a gallon they would regard it as a profitable price. If I am wrong I would like to be corrected, but I would prefer the views of a man like Deputy Bennett to those of Deputy McGilligan or Deputy Dillon. I hope that Deputy Bennett, who must feel very keenly the position of the Limerick dairy farmers, will make some contribution to this debate and will say in emphatic terms whether he is a supporter of the subsidy policy under present circumstances, or whether he is supporting Deputy Dillon in abolishing the subsidy and letting the dairy farmers get the best price they can.

I would like the Minister to say what the future policy in regard to dairying is to be. Has he any clear-cut policy which will hold out greater hope for a better price and a better market for the surplus butter which we have to sell? Deputy Dillon referred at length and in rather humorous terms to the peculiar position of the Roscrea meat factory. Roscrea borders on my constituency and, following up what the Minister said to the House this evening, I think it is desirable that he and those advising him on matters of this kind should have some clear-cut policy as to the future position of the factory before the four-year period expires. More than that I am not going to say. I am not going to associate myself with some of the rather personal criticism which Deputy Dillon directed against the conduct of that particular place.

Comment on this

Such as?

Comment on this

When Deputy Dillon reads some of the remarks he made in reference to the present conduct of the Roscrea factory, he can judge for himself whether he was using this debate for the purpose of scoring points off the Minister at the expense of some Government supporters associated with this factory.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy suggest I said?

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to indicate his plans for the extension and development of the dairying industry.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not answer my question. He is hunting with the hounds and running with the hare.

Comment on this

I am voting for this subsidy, anyway.

Comment on this

I would like to refer to a few items, and, following Deputy Davin, I will deal with a few matters concerning the dairying industry. We have here, as we have in all Estimates connected with agriculture, provision for numerous sums for the dairying industry. As Deputy Dillon says, the ordinary Deputy who gets hold of an Estimate in connection with the dairying industry or the industries allied to dairying, is somewhat confused. He ends by giving it up and saying he does not know where he is. The position of the dairying industry is that many farmers are reducing their herds, and some of them are getting altogether out of dairy stock. That, in some way, explains the deficiency in the milk supply in Deputy Davin's constituency. That is operating in many districts. There would, of course, be other reasons for the deficiency in the milk supply. There are, as is shown by another Estimate, other influences operating against the dairy farmer. When the Minister was referring to item 4, which deals with agricultural schools and farms, he explained that the additional sum was required because the feedingstuffs for stock were more expensive. That is one of the things that operate in connection with the dairying industry. The cost of feedingstuffs in dairying has gone up. There is, then, the factor of the recent legislation regarding agricultural wages. Everybody was glad that that measure was passed, and would be glad if its provisions could be operated.

The Minister knows the difficulties in the way of doing that and I do not want to enter into them. The Minister has had deputations from farmers in this connection. Deputy Davin knows as well as anybody else that the farmers are in difficulties in this regard. The fact that Deputy Davin is so strong an advocate of increased prices in the dairying industry is proof that Deputy Davin knows the difficulties which the farmers are experiencing in complying with that Act. He knows that it is impossible for the farmers to comply with the Agricultural Wages Act in existing conditions. Every other Deputy knows the same. I come from practically the biggest dairying county in the State. Deputy Davin was good enough to say that I know something about dairying. He challenges us to say what we would do. Anybody who reads the programme of our Party knows of one thing which we would do. We were the first Party to take up the principle of a guaranteed price for milk.

Comment on this

How will you get it?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin advocated 6½d. a gallon but he did not say where he would get it. He said that the Minister could get it. I agree with him that it must be got if the dairying industry is to be maintained. If dairying is not maintained, bang goes the agricultural industry altogether. If dairying goes, everything else will go, with results not altogether confined to the dairy farmers. It is, perhaps, belated recognition of the serious plight of the dairy farmers that has brought us such outspoken advocacy of the improvement of the conditions of these farmers from the Labour Party. In recent years we had not that outspoken sympathy and support. We have it now because a belated measure to improve the conditions of the agricultural labourer was passed by this House. I am in agreement with that measure, as every other Deputy must be in agreement with it, but every Deputy, from the Minister down, knows that that is a measure which cannot be operated for any considerable time. It may be satisfactorily operated for a short time in the dairying industry, but it cannot be continued in operation for long unless something additional to the small Votes before us to-day is offered to the dairying industry. There is no way out of the present plight of the dairying industry except something in the way of a guaranteed price for milk. I hope the Minister is considering that point. That would cure the other things of which I spoke. There will be no serious opposition to the Agricultural Wages Act or any other similar measure provided the farmer is put in a position to meet his overhead charges and given some prospect of a living.

Comment on this

How will you get the guaranteed price—by subsidy?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin thought that he suggested a means by which the Minister would get the 6½d. I am making a suggestion to the Minister on similar lines. When I asked the Minister to do this, I was assured that Deputy Davin was behind me. I thought he was prepared to go further than I was. Now Deputy Davin retorts upon me by asking me where I am to get the money to do this. In making the request I was expecting Deputy Davin to back me.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear Deputy Bennett repudiating the policy advocated by Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin knows as well as I do that Deputy Dillon is one of the leaders of the Party which was the first to urge the principle of a guaranteed price for milk. It is futile for Deputy Davin to be engaging in the type of interruption in which he is now engaging. Let him read our programme.

Comment on this

That is your policy only since the last election.

Comment on this

I may have thought that it did not go far enough, but that was the line of our policy in relation to dairying. If the dairying conditions are worse now than they were at the time the heads of our policy were adopted, it follows that more drastic remedies will be required. That, however, is a question for another day.

Comment on this

When did you adopt that policy?

Comment on this

I did not wait until the year 1938. I have been arguing for that policy for many years, and I had not Deputy Davin's support until 1938.

Comment on this

You did not do it in 1932.

Comment on this

Nobody minds Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin's advocacy is of considerable use to me, and I am delighted that he realises now, owing to the complaints of his constituents, that something must be done for the dairying industry if it is not to be extinguished. He knows full well that the Agricultural Wages Act cannot be continued in operation for more than three months unless the Minister steps in and gives the farmers a quid pro quo in respect of the increased wages.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Davin says "Hear, hear," and Deputy Heron has almost a fit at the other end of the bench.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that it is necessary to provide the farmer with a better price for milk if he is to continue in the industry. The Minister has had his attention also drawn to the fact that the farmers are not, under present conditions, able to comply with recent wages legislation. I agree with Deputy Dillon, as regards the two factories in Waterford and Roscrea, that the principle adopted was altogether wrong and undesirable. The old contract system provided that when a man made a reasonable contract he should be held to it. When the ordinary contractors enter into a contract they generally do so in the light of what they think the future market will be. The Minister contracted to supply cattle to Waterford at 10/- a cwt., and he contracted to supply other cattle to Roscrea at nothing per cwt. In the one case he is going to compensate them because he can no longer supply cattle at anything like 10/- a cwt., and in the second case it is altogether impossible, even with the finances behind him, to supply cattle for nothing any further. He entered into what one must call a foolish and disastrous contract, and unfortunately put a provision in the original contract that he would compensate them if he could not fulfil it, and apparently he is now about to pay the compensation. I wish the people who are getting it luck, and I hope we will never have a repetition of such a performance.

There is another matter to which nobody has so far alluded — the distribution of export licences. We are at the moment in the position that we cannot produce enough cattle for export, and I thought that we would have arrived at a period when cattle licences would be no longer necessary, and when free trade amongst the farmers themselves would be allowed. There may be some reason for the continued operation of the licensing system, but I know that there is grave dissatisfaction with that system. I know that some people have licences to throw away while other people who want them cannot get them, and, as a matter of fact, although the licences are not worth much now— there were days when they were worth £3 each and there was traffic in them at £3 — there is traffic in them even at 5/-. The time has definitely come when this system of licences in respect of agricultural produce should cease, particularly when we are in the position that we cannot produce enough cattle for export. I hope the Minister will pay some attention to the suggestions made, particularly by Deputy Davin and myself, and that he will endeavour to provide such conditions for the creamery industry generally that there will be some prospect of its continuance, because the Minister, if he gets the same reports as I, and if he reads the auctioneers' lists in the various dairying industries, must be aware, as I am aware, that many farmers are reducing their herds and a good number of them getting out of the dairying industry altogether.

Comment on this

I was glad to hear Deputy Davin advocating the establishment of selling organisations in the British market. I would back him up in that, and I suggest that the Minister should look into it because the Danish farmers are surely beating us in the British market, and it is up to our Government to start something on the lines suggested in order that we may beat the Danes. I am very proud that the day has come when Deputy Davin agrees that the British market is the only market for our surplus produce here, and I am proud that commonsense has at last come to the people in this House. They told us a few years ago that the British market was dead and gone for ever and that we would get alternative markets. That is all gone now, and I am glad that it has gone. I hope Deputy Davin's suggestion will be acted on by the Minister, and if he had made that suggestion two or three years ago, there would not be so much poverty amongst the farmers to-day.

Comment on this

What about the truce?

Comment on this

With regard to the Waterford and Roscrea factories, the Minister has found them very bad propositions. There is a certain amount of money lost and all I can say is that any man with commonsense who would make a contract to supply anybody with cattle at 10/- a cwt. for two or three years ahead must have thought that cattle were going to be worth nothing.

Comment on this

Roscrea got them for nothing.

Comment on this

Roscrea must be a charity affair — that is the way I look at it. So far as supplying cattle at 10/- a cwt. for two or three years is concerned, all one can say is that the man who agreed to do that must have thought that cattle were going to be dirt in the country. Both the Waterford and Roscrea factories are subsidised, and if every factory in this country is subsidised as these two are subsidised, God help the taxpayers of the country.

With regard to licences, I know quite a lot about them, and I know the trafficking that has gone on for the last four or five years. I handle them practically every day in the week. The Minister may laugh, but I see it going on, and I suggest to the Minister that there should be some other arrangement made for giving out those licences. In our Committee of Agriculture, if I want a licence for March or April, I have to put in the list now, but how could I know what cattle I will have fat in May? I could go out to the market in March, buy 10 or 12 cattle and put them in the stall for a fortnight or three weeks to fatten, but if I had not applied for licences in February, I can get none. That situation should be remedied, because it means that men are not encouraged to buy beasts to eat the food which they have around their houses and to fatten for a month or six weeks. I suggest that the whole system should be done away with. I cannot see that the system is necessary because we did not half fill our fat cattle quota for the last two years. I suggest that the licences should be left at the ports — I suggested that before, but there must be some difficulty about it — so that when men are shipping cattle, they could get as many as they wanted.

It is questionable whether the Minister is entitled by law to charge farmers ? each for these licences. They are given to him by the British Government for nothing, and I question whether he has the right to charge ? each to the farmer. Everybody in the cattle trade is bothered and annoyed with the licensing system, and I ask the Minister to change it. You go to the Dublin market and buy cattle and you find that people have not got licences because they did not apply for them. Many of them come down to the County Committee and they have to go back because they are not applied for. If they were at the ports, people could get them easily when shipping cattle. Another matter on which I want information is whether the Minister is going to adopt the Horse Breeding Commission's report or not. I am not saying I am in favour of it, but I should like to know if he proposes to adopt it. At the last meeting of the Horse Breeders' Association I was requested to ask the Minister about it, and I take this opportunity of doing so.

With regard to the German cattle trade, before this year I did not think much of that trade, but I admit that it was a help in the market this year. I give the Minister credit for that, because there is, in my opinion, a kind of ring at present among dealers, and the German buying tends to check that ring. If the German or the Government buyers were not present, prices each week might not be so good. Many farmers in the country would like to know soon whether the German cattle buying is going to continue, because you can buy a certain sort of cattle for that market. I should like the Minister to say whether it is going to be continued or not. If the Minister made a profit I think that is not fair to the farmers. If the Government find that a profit has been made they should give a little higher price, only asking for a margin which would not show a loss. That would help to increase the price of cattle in the Dublin market and elsewhere. If there is a big profit it is not a good thing that the Government should carry on in that way. They should work in such a way that the profit could be passed on week in week out, so that it would react in prices being higher, by making shippers to the English market increase their prices.

Comment on this

It is highly significant that the members of the Labour Party have realised the necessity that exists to assist an industry that is absolutely down and out. Evidently the Deputy who has just laughed has not suffered in the depression which has hit the agricultural community. The Labour Party in the past had to cut out any connection with the agricultural labourers, but now, after a terrible fight, they have realised that it is only by helping the farmer to pay wages that they can get anything like reasonable conditions for the agricultural labourers. Deputy Davin spoke in favour of helping the dairy farmers. He knows that a larger amount of labour is employed on dairy farms than on any other form of agriculture. There was an allusion during the discussion to the purchase of bad bulls. I do not think any of the activities of the Department has been more inimical to the welfare of cattle breeding or stock raising than the setting loose of an inferior class of bulls through the country. Independent farmers who in the past purchased high-priced bulls realised from experience that it was essential to do so if they were to carry on on the right lines. Deputy Fagan referred to the cattle licences. What is the necessity for these licences now when we are not able to fill the British quota? What is the necessity for employing 16 temporary certifying officers when the quota cannot be filled? That situation has been brought about by the policy of the Government in slaughtering calves. The position we find ourselves in now is that many farmers are understocked and are not able to supply the cattle when there is a market and a demand for them in the English market. I think such a provision now is absolute waste of money, and that it should be devoted to some other purpose.

Reference has been made to the Munster Institute in Cork. That is an excellent institution, and I should like if the Minister could extend the amount of land as well as the operations of the institute so that demonstrations would be available for farmers who visit Cork. It would be a very good thing if young farmers visited the institute and saw the different experiments carried out there. There is an urgent demand for stallions in the constituency I represent. Appeals have been repeatedly made to the Department to supply stallions, but the reply is that they are unable to do so. Having regard to the importance of horse breeding and the bloodstock industry the Minister should make a special effort to provide stallions of the necessary high standard for an industry that is especially valuable in Ireland. Deputy Bennett dealt with the position with regard to the milk industry. Assistance has been given to dairy farmers near cities in order that they might supply milk at specially fixed prices not only to public bodies but to the poor generally. The Minister might give special attention to the remarks of Deputy Dillon with regard to the provision of free milk for the necessitous poor. There is no better form of food for building up a healthy and virile population. The Minister might take that question into account, in order to secure a distribution of milk that can be sold at something like a reasonable price.

The castigation which has been given to the Department over the scandalous position in regard to the Roscrea factory need not, I think, be further touched upon, but I must say that the sooner things of that kind are brought to an end the better. I am afraid we have to discountenance some of the acts of the Department, however good, and to regard them as unbusinesslike, and as exceedingly bad as financiers, when such an example is set by the State.

We were asked what means we would take to improve the position of the agricultural community. My answer would be to remove many of the taxes and heavy imposts that are on almost every item connected with agricultural production. If there was less interference with agriculture, Irish farmers, with their tradition and experience, as shrewd business men, would then be better able to make a fist of an industry which they have brought to a very high state of efficiency. I might also mention the de-rating of agricultural land and buildings. I see the Minister laughing. If the agriculturists of this country are poor remember it is all due to the present policy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The general policy of agriculture is not under discussion.

Comment on this

We were asked to say how we would relieve agriculture, and I gave an indication of how it could be done in connection with taxation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Irrelevant questions do not justify irrelevant answers.

Comment on this

The question should not have been asked.

Comment on this

If I may make a submission, the sub-heads covered by this Vote are so wide that it would be hard to say what is general policy, and what is not general policy.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

While I agree with the Deputy's submission, I have ruled that the subject matter referred to by Deputy Brasier is out of order.

Comment on this

As you did not rule the question out of order, I answered it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

We had a round-up by Deputy Dillon to-night, and I must sympathise with Deputy Brasier in finding himself out of order. Deputy Dillon discussed old cows, dairies, old type bulls, Manitoba wheat, milk prices, the feeding of children and a special sucking pipe from Kerry. As all these things were discussed on the Vote, I sympathise with the Deputy. There are a few matters on which, apparently, Deputy Dillon is condemned as a heretic even by his own Party. Deputy Dillon condemns root and branch special types of bulls which Deputy Brasier says, and I agree with him, are of great benefit to our district. The price of milk and the dairying industry have been discussed. We had the announcement made by the Party opposite that they were the first to adopt a guaranteed price for milk, but I would like to take their minds back to the period, a few years ago, when the dairying industry was faced with bankruptcy: when the price of butter on the English market was between 68/-and 73/-, and when the price of milk at the creameries was between 1¾d. and 2d. per gallon.

Comment on this

The price was never as low as that.

Comment on this

Indeed it was, and, when the Minister for Agriculture came to the Dáil with a Prices Stabilisation Bill, the Deputies opposite voted against it. I congratulate Deputy Bennett, because he was the only member of the Party opposite who joined with the Labour Party and ourselves at that time in seeing that the farmers would get a price for their milk. We cannot have Deputies at one moment agitating for a better price for milk and at the same time coming in here week after week raising an outcry about the price of butter. If the price of milk goes up it follows that the price of butter must go up. If a guaranteed price is to be given to farmers for their milk, then there will have to be a higher price for butter. I am glad to see that Deputy Davin is supporting that policy. I am sure that no member of the Labour Party would wish to see the farmers getting an uneconomic price.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that the members of the Labour Party advocated guaranteed prices for the farmers before the Fianna Fáil Party came into the Dáil in 1927?

Comment on this

I am not concerned with what kind of a show you ran before we came in in 1927.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's language in reference to the Dáil is not parliamentary.

Comment on this

I regret it. Deputy Bennett referred rather belatedly to the plight of the dairy farmers. Their plight, and the prices they were getting for their milk and butter, was recognised by this Party in 1933, when the Prices Stabilisation Bill was introduced by the Minister for Agriculture, a Bill that the Deputies opposite very strongly opposed and voted against. If it were not for the introduction of that measure the price that farmers would have been paid for their milk for two years would not have been 3d. per gallon. We could have settled the whole cattle trouble on the line of giving the farmers whatever price butter was on the English market and paying the full tariff for them, but I would like to see how many farmers could produce milk at 2d. per gallon. That was the position we were up against and that we had to deal with.

Deputy Dillon also attacked the admixture scheme, but I did not hear Deputy Brasier agree with him on that. I am anxious to know how much of the agricultural policy of the Party opposite is put forward by Deputy Dillon, and to what extent the Party agree with that policy as put forward by him. Are we going to have a different agricultural policy from each member of the Party opposite?

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

Was Deputy Dillon then expressing the views of Deputy Brasier when speaking to-night——?

Comment on this

I advise the Deputy to mind his own business.

Comment on this

——when he definitely opposed the admixture scheme? I am very anxious to know that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is waiting to hear Deputy Corry's opinions on this Estimate.

Comment on this

And I am giving them.

Comment on this

What about the price of beet?

Comment on this

We are not discussing that now, but should we unfortunately have another day on it, I hope the Labour Party will advise their people not to handle tainted goods.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a rebel against his own Party on that.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is for ever attacking the admixture scheme under which our farmers have succeeded in getting a price for their barley and oats. Until this Party came into office and introduced that scheme, oats and barley were practically unsaleable. Deputy Brasier knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

I found a market for my barley, and the Deputy followed on my coat-tails.

Comment on this

The Deputy never found a market for anything except for old clothes. In connection with the Roscrea factory, it is right to point out that about 94,000 old cows, which were a burden on the farming community, were got rid of following the establishment of that factory.

Comment on this

The factory got them for nothing.

Comment on this