We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance.—Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 177–350 of 350. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The farmers at least got 50/- for them. I think, however, it is correct to say that the Minister for Agriculture got letters from every farmers' association in the Free State demanding that the old cows they had should be taken from them because, at the time, the position with regard to old and uneconomic cattle was a very bad one and demanded immediate attention. I would not agree to any extension of the Munster Institute. I suggest that visitors going to Cork, who wish to study up-to-date farming methods, will, if they pay a visit to the farm attached to Cork University, see them in operation there. I was amazed to hear Deputy Brasier urge an extension of these farms, in view of the fact that a short time ago he said that they were uneconomic.

Comment on this

I never said that, and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

The trouble with the Deputies opposite is that we cannot get two of them to agree on anything.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Cork Deputies should reserve this exchange of compliments for Cork. That would lead to more orderly debate here.

Comment on this

The debate on the Estimate has shown clearly that so far as the Deputies opposite are concerned they have no policy whatever. They come along and say that they are going to give a guaranteed price for milk, and at the same time get up and complain about the price of butter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must not repeat himself.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, no matter how often you state a thing for Deputies opposite, it does not sink in.

Comment on this

You have read our policy and that is enough.

Comment on this

I was rather surprised at the attitude taken up by Deputies opposite and I am glad to see that all sides of the House are now going to see that the farmer gets a decent price for his produce, even though it does drive up the price in the home market. I hope that we will hear fewer complaints about the cost of living and all the rest of it in the future from Deputies opposite, and that when Deputies are discussing the motion on the Order Paper on the cost of living, which now stands adjourned, we will hear less noise and talk about it, seeing that Deputies are agreed that the farmer is entitled to a fair price for his produce.

Comment on this

What about the taxes put on him?

Comment on this

This Estimate has been fairly exhaustively discussed already and I shall confine my remarks to three points with which I should like the Minister to deal when he is replying. In this Estimate there is an additional sum of £17,000 set aside for the purpose of reorganising the creamery industry, mainly in regard to the extinction of the redundant creameries. I realise well that, in the absence of legislation, it is rather a difficult matter for the Minister to deal with the wholesale reorganisation of the creamery industry in this country, and I am anxious to know from him whether this £17,000 is part of the expense at least connected with the general scheme for the reorganisation of the creamery industry, or whether this money is to be confined entirely to the creamery areas he mentioned when introducing the Estimate. I think the Minister some years ago, when discussing another agricultural estimate, gave us to understand that the experts in the Department of Agriculture were considering his scheme for the general reorganisation of the creamery industry in this country with the object of eliminating the redundant creameries and giving the other creameries an opportunity of bringing down their overhead expenses and putting them in a more economic position.

I think the Minister agrees with me that there are many counties where there are certainly redundant creameries to-day, and if these redundant creameries were closed down it would certainly assist in reducing the overhead expenses of the central creamery or the remaining creameries and in putting the creamery industry in a healthier economic position than it is at present. I also have the impression that, even before the Minister and his Party assumed the responsibility of Government, there was a scheme for the general reorganisation of the creamery industry in the course of preparation by the officials of the Department of Agriculture. I should like to know what has happened to that scheme, whether the Minister has pigeon-holed it or put it on one side to be examined in connection perhaps with legislation for the purpose of giving him wider powers to deal with the whole problem of creamery reorganisation.

Every Deputy, including Deputy Corry, is agreed and has admitted that the farmers are getting an uneconomic price for their milk. Sometime last year an agitation, which gained a great deal of prominence, was started in this country for the purpose of getting a better price for milk. I do not wish to say one word about the merits or otherwise of that agitation, but, in any event, the Minister apparently was forced to take cognisance of the effect which that agitation had on milk producers, because he himself sent around, and I think is still sending around, officials of another Department for the purpose of ascertaining the views of creamery managers and members of creamery committees on this question of an economic price for milk. I know that the Minister also has met more than one deputation in recent months for the purpose of discussing this rather vexed question of an economic price for milk, and I suggest to him that this would be a very suitable occasion for him to make a statement in connection with the matter.

The Minister himself stated on one occasion in the Dáil, when the cost of living was lower than it is to-day and feeding costs were much lower, that no farmer could produce milk at less than 5d. per gallon. I know that the Minister is satisfied that the price which the creameries are paying to-day for milk is not economic, and I also think that he has satisfied himself now that the price will have to be increased if milk production in this country is to be encouraged and the butter situation saved. I suggest to him, therefore, that he might avail of the discussion of this Estimate for the purpose of making some statement on that point and I hope his statement will be a favourable one.

There is a sum of £111,000 set aside here for the purpose of making provision for winter requirements of butter. The amount, I admit, is a very large one. Nevertheless, in existing circumstances, and by virtue of legislation which has already been passed regulating the butter industry, it is necessary to make provision for the storage of winter butter. But I sincerely hope that the Minister will take steps to ensure that such a situation as arose last winter will not arise again, when the Minister was forced to buy foreign butter, mainly Danish, and sell it to the unfortunate producers of this country at a profit of something like £50 per ton and, at the same time, we were forced to sell our own butter in the British market at a price far less than could have been obtained a few weeks earlier. There does appear to be a lack of organisation somewhere, either in the Department or in the organisation responsible for the marketing of our butter, and I suggest that the Minister should give the Dáil an assurance that such a situation as arose last winter is not likely to arise again, and that the unfortunate consumers of this country will not be forced to pay such a price for butter, and that the Minister, at the same time, will not allow his Department or any other Department to reap a profit on a transaction of that kind.

Comment on this

The greater part of this debate has dealt with the price of milk and butter. Deputy Roddy referred to the item of £111,000 for the provision of a winter supply. I should like to know how much of that sum will go towards the production of winter butter or the encouragement of winter dairying. Winter dairying was carried on very successfully in this country in years gone by and it was one of the greatest assets that the dairy farmer had, where it was carried out. From some of Deputy Davin's remarks it would appear that dairying is confined to the production of milk and butter. That is only one of the arms of the dairying industry. The dairying industry has several arms. One of the results of winter dairying is that you have early calves.

In my constituency years ago, before we had the unfortunate slaughter of calves and other economic disturbances, when we sold calves from 10 to 12 months old, the early calf fetched a price that was most economic. If the farmer did not get a price for his milk at the creamery, it could be utilised in other ways. He had, as I say, a very good price for his early calf. The same held with regard to pig production and fowl. As far as I know, the pig industry is steadily going down because the cost of feeding stuffs, as a result of the admixture scheme, has gone up so much that it is almost impossible to produce pigs at a profit. Very few beyond those who engage in mass production can now produce pigs at a profit. I should like to know from the Minister how much of this £111,000 goes for the encouragement of winter dairying. I would suggest that some of the money provided under sub-head O. O. (11), in connection with export licences, should be devoted to the encouragement of winter dairying, as it has been suggested that these licences might be done away with. That would be a step in the right direction.

In connection with sub-head G (1), improvement of milk production, I see here an item for grants to cow-testing associations. As far as I can remember the report of a meeting of the Shorthorn Breeders' Association, which the Minister attended, I gathered that while cow testing has been carried on in this country for a good many years, there has been a very slight improvement or increase in the quantity of the milk produced. It is nothing like what it should be. That speaks badly for cow testing, as it is carried on in this State. I think if you could increase the quantity of milk from 450 gallons, which I think is the average yield per cow, to 600 gallons, you would give assistance to the dairy farmer and when you are giving him assistance you are assisting everyone in this State. I think the only way to increase the yield is to have cow testing made compulsory and to have it carried out under State control, at the expense of the State. It is very hard to expect farmers to pay two or three shillings annually per cow to have cow testing carried out. I think it would be worth all the expense involved if cow testing were compulsorily carried out as a State business and if all the non-productive cows were removed to Roscrea. If such a compulsory system were adopted, I believe that in a short time the 600 gallon cow would be the rule rather than the exception in this country. If that were done there would be less need for subsidies.

When milk was selling at 3d. per gallon in this country, the farmer at least had the advantage of having a market for the other arms of the agricultural industry—butter, cattle, calves, pigs and poultry. He has lost his market for those items, owing to the unfortunate economic dispute. Those items have become a dead letter as far as he is concerned, hence all the cry for the subsidising of milk and butter. Now that we hope that all these difficulties will disappear in the near future, we think we can look forward to a better time in the dairying industry and we need not have this pessimistic note that has been struck by some speakers here to-night. Coming back to the question of winter dairying, I would stress the point that the Minister should give that branch of the industry all encouragement. We lack continuity of supply in our markets. If we could get that continuity of supply, so that we would have an equal supply all the year round, I think it would be worth spending money to achieve it.

I should like to refer briefly to the small item of £200 provided under the Flax Act for travelling expenses. I was able to get a concession from the Minister, for which I am very grateful, for Cork under the Flax Act, but the growing of flax has not got the encouragement that it should get in County Cork, where the farmers have a flax tradition. I would ask the Minister now that some of this £200 provided for travelling expenses should be devoted to sending an instructor down there. Now is the time to assist the farmers in Cork who cannot grow beet or wheat. They can grow flax and handle it well. The price of flax has been profitable for the last few years. The Government has not lost anything by giving a guaranteed price. I would ask the Minister again to spend some of this money by sending an instructor down to encourage the people in the flax-growing areas in County Cork. I do not know if I might refer for a moment to stallions. Every year that this Estimate is brought forward I have asked that registered Clydesdale stallions should be provided. There is a demand in West Cork for them and the Minister might consider meeting that demand.

Comment on this

I should like to have from the Minister an explanation of what is meant by the term "creameries and associated businesses" mentioned in the detail of sub-head N (5) — Improvement of the Creamery Industry. The reason I ask for the explanation is that many people are concerned at the moment about the activities of some of the creamery undertakings of the country. They were established at first to deal with milk and milk products, and later on they added poultry and other sidelines. Now they have in many cases extended their business still further and blossomed out as retailers of goods other than these milk products. A number of the smaller shopkeepers in the country are complaining of this practice. They have some justification for that complaint because it is well known that many of these creameries escape income tax, and they are provided for in various ways out of Government funds. I think it is a matter into which the Minister should look in the near future. It is a system that has grown up and possibly it may be difficult to check it now, but certainly something should be done in the direction of at least confining these creameries to their original functions, namely, that of dealing with milk and manufacturing milk products.

Denmark was mentioned a few moments ago by Deputy Davin. Whilst it might be useful to emulate Denmark in the matter of the marketing of their products, I feel that there are not many people who would care to emulate Denmark in other ways. The Danes usually export most of their butter and eat margarine. I do not want to see the Irish people reduced to that position. I am supporting this Vote because I have always advocated, and will continue to advocate, that agriculture should have the first claim on our Government. Some time ago it was brought home to the Minister himself that most of the farmers, particularly the dairy farmers, are existing under extraordinary conditions in this country. At a dairy conference held in Cork recently, at which the Minister for Agriculture was present, a veterinary surgeon who occupies a high position in Cork City in the administration of those Acts, read a very fine paper. I was struck by four instances which he gave of the impoverished conditions of some of our farmers. Let me say that he advocated that the cow-testing associations should have a much greater membership. I am glad to know that Deputy O'Donovan touched on that matter, because I believe that many farmers at the present moment are unable to afford the expense of joining those cow-testing associations at the rate of 2/- per cow, some farmers having 20 or 30 cows. I want to read an extract from that paper, and it will be an eyeopener to many persons who do not live so close to the agricultural areas as some of us do. He speaks of his intimate association with farmers throughout the Counties of Cork, Kerry and Limerick, and cites three cases which he says would represent the position of many farmers in those areas. Here is what he says:—

"Farmer A resides in County Limerick on a farm of 85 Irish acres, P.L.V. £77 10s., rent and rates £68, milks 27 cows, and employs two boys and a girl. His total income from all sources on the farm, including calves, pigs, and poultry was £465 16s. last year. His expenditure in rent and rates, food for livestock, manures and seeds, labour, maintenance, and repairs and other such essentials to production totalled £481 10s., leaving him at a loss of more than £15 without having provided for himself, his wife and five children. Farmer B lives in County Cork on a farm of 50 statute acres, P.L.V. £21, milks 15 cows, labour is provided by himself and his two sons. His total income from all sources, which in this case included nine tons of potatoes, was £223 last year, and his outgoings in respect of his household and his farm amounted to £205, so he is left with but £18 to provide for the future of his two sons and three young daughters, not to speak of making provision for his own and his wife's old age."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy inform the Chair to what particular item in the Estimate he relates his quotations?

Comment on this

Item M (5) — Improvement of the Creamery Industry.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understood the Deputy to refer to potatoes among other commodities.

Comment on this

Anyhow, those are cases which are brought to the notice of this House only on very rare occasions, nor is the general public always conversant with the facts. I am quite sure that reforms of any character mean an increase in Government expenditure which, in turn, means an increase in taxation. We cannot have it both ways, and because of that I am supporting this Estimate.

Comment on this

Limited as is the review which this Supplementary Estimate affords us to-night, it makes one feel I do not know whether it is sympathy for the Minister, or whether we ought to extend him our pity. Some may think he is entitled to sympathy for having had to bring this particular Estimate before the House to-night in the form in which it had to be brought before it. It does seem an extraordinary thing that Deputies speaking on this Estimate — particularly Deputy Davin, who spoke about the British market so often — did not get down to bedrock. One would imagine we were speaking about a normal period and were trading in normal times. Of course we are not. Mind you, I have a certain amount of sympathy for the Minister, who is endeavouring to put up some kind of scheme to tide himself and his Party and this country over their own blundering. What has happened? If any person wants to know what has happened during the Fianna Fáil régime, I would recommend him, as far as agriculture is concerned, and particularly those items before us to-night, to take the advice given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and look at the figures which his Department has produced. We have gone down in everything. When Deputy Davin spoke about co-operative marketing in London on an equal basis with Denmark, one would imagine that we could get in on an equal basis with Denmark. Of course, at one time we were on the British market with a preferential rate of 10 per cent. Now we are there with 40 per cent. against us, while Denmark is there with 50 per cent., and yet Deputy Davin thinks we can compete with those people. In view of the negotiations which are proceeding at the moment, it was really a pity that the Minister brought in this Estimate this evening if he could have avoided it.

Deputy Davin seemed to think that the Minister did not have any clear-cut policy with regard to the Roscrea factory. Personally, I do not think he ever had such a clear-cut policy on anything. He told us here to-night what appeared to be the most extraordinary thing I ever heard in my life, that he entered into a contract with a certain private company to give them the money—on certain debentures which they were supposed to pay back—to build a factory in Roscrea; to supply them free with the raw material; and afterwards, if he was not able to supply them with the raw material, to compensate them for the fact that he was not able to supply them. The Minister told us there is danger now of the factory closing down; that we can get our debentures back, amounting to, I think, £18,000; or that we have the alternative of taking the factory. I wonder what we are going to do with it? If the factory in Roscrea, which was established for the manufacture of meat meal from old and diseased cattle, goes on the market, I wonder how much the taxpayers will be able to realise on the sale of it? Would it not be much more economical for the Minister — except, of course, that it would not hide the blundering of Fianna Fáil well — if he did with the old cows what he did with the calves, that is, give every man 50/- for the skin of the old cow? Then he would not have the factory; he would not have this white elephant on his hands, and he would not have to give any compensation. Of course, he could not have faced that at the time. It would not do. Really the most extraordinary disclossure I ever heard in my life was this one in regard to the position in which this State has been put in order to get over the blunders of the present Government. Some effort really had to be made to deal with the old cows. The Minister knew perfectly well why the old cows were on the people's hands. There was a time when any farmer could fatten his old cow and get rid of her, but after the Minister came in, the farmer could not do it. The Minister knows that. Instead of facing the country and saying: "We will give you 50/- for every old cow," the Minister entered into a contract with some company to build a factory and accept all the consequences.

There is one particular matter to which I should like to refer. Deputy Dillon referred here to-night to the provision of special-term bulls — the purchase of dairy bulls for leasing or resale at reduced prices. I maintain that, to a certain extent at least, Deputy Dillon was correct in what he stated. When he stated that the Minister made profits on the resale of those bulls, I do not know whether or not he had information to bear it out, but I do know that the Department has made a profit, in this way: That they have ceased buying the first-class bulls, which were premium bulls, and distributing them through the country, but have got in those other special-term bulls, which are not premium bulls. In that way, the Department is making money on the transaction in comparison with what happened before. I should like the Minister in some way to make a survey of what is happening in the country to-day with regard to these particular bulls, and he should try to find out whether his efforts in relation to the provision of short-term bulls has met with any success. Personally, I think his efforts have not met with success and that the scheme has worked the other way around. The whole fabric of agriculture, however, has been broken up, and the Minister must find some kind of expedient of this type to get over the period. Now, we cannot have any progress in this country — and the Minister knows it perfectly well — until agriculture is put on a paying basis, and I do not see any reason whatever why it could not be done if this country were trading under normal conditions and if the people running the Government in this country would recognise that it must be run in that way. I do not see any reason why, under normal conditions, agriculture could not be put on a paying basis, but it is not fair to take the present time as a normal period. This is an abnormal period of trading, and when people are making suggestions they should realise that we are not trading in a normal period. If, as Deputy Davin says, we are going into the British market to compete with the Dane and are not able to sell him down, the reason is that where we had a 10 per cent. preference, it is now 40 per cent. against us.

Comment on this

That is not the reason at all. It is made good to the farmer.

Comment on this

What makes it good? It is the levy on the farmers.

Comment on this

But the return to the farmers is more than they give.

Comment on this

Suppose we did not have to jump the 40 per cent., would we be any better?

Comment on this

Suppose you had to pay the price on the British market, where would you be?

Comment on this

If we were able to get into the British market with a 40 per cent. advantage on our present prices, would we not be better off? Yes, we would.

Comment on this

You have no guarantee.

Comment on this

With all our non-guaranteeing, we are dying to get into it. Every one of us is dying to get into it, and the Deputy knows it. Now, we have the whole list of agricultural production — so much of it as calls for it—under review to-night. It sets out clearly the road we are travelling, and the sooner the Minister for Agriculture makes up his mind that it is really a disgraceful thing to have to bring in an Estimate like that into this House — and it is a disgraceful thing where the State is made responsible for something like the case of Roscrea — and the sooner that sort of thing is wiped out, the better. Agriculture is, and will be at all times, the mainstay of this country. Everybody realises that now, and the Government realises it now, when we are practically too late, but even if the lesson taught is an expensive one, the fact that the Minister had to bring this before the House may have done good.

Comment on this

The discussion on this Estimate may be helpful to the Minister with a view to improving the agricultural policy and possibly raising the standard of living of the people in the rural districts. That is really what is at the bottom of most of our troubles — that the standard of living of the people on the land is too low, and they cannot make a living in their own country. That is the root of the problem of emigration and of migration into the towns from the country as well. All this trouble has arisen out of the low standard of living and the difficulty the people on the land experience in trying to make ends meet. Now, I say that the Minister is making great efforts, according to his own views, to help agriculture. A great deal of public money is being spent on agriculture, but the question is whether or not it is being spent in the proper way. It is with a view to helping out the Minister in these directions that we are here to criticise constructively and, if possible, to help the Minister out. I dare say, however, that the Minister, just as in the case of everything else that is spoken about on this side of the House, will get up and say that this is all Fine Gael propaganda and there is nothing constructive in it. That is generally what is said, no matter what is proposed or what suggestions are made from this side of the House. The Minister must see, however, that although we are spending more on agriculture now than ever before, the position is that we have less milch cows, less cattle, less pigs, less sheep —less of everything—and less people working on the land because they are flying out of it.

The minimum wage of 24/- that has been fixed is the lowest for any industry in the State, and yet the people on the land cannot pay it. That is a well-known fact. It is an unfortunate position and one that must be faced up to, that agricultural people who require agricultural labourers are not able to pay them the minimum wage. How, then, are these farmers themselves and their own families to work at the smaller wage which they can get? That is the position in which the country is, unfortunately. Now, with all the money that is being spent on agriculture at the present time, I think that something could be done to improve agriculture by means of some scheme that would be self-supporting. I proposed a self-supporting scheme to the Minister before, but he turned it down. The scheme I proposed was for the setting up of demonstration farms. I think everybody in this House will agree, no matter on what side they are, that where we are spending over £1,000,000 upon an industry in order to help the people in that industry and to instruct them in research work and so on, it would be well worth while to bring home to the people in that industry how the best use could be made of their land, and how to get the best advantage of the Department's information and of the experiments that the Department's officials have carried out. I am still convinced that the best way that can be done is by means of these demonstration farms, where practical proof could be given and where it could be shown how these things should be reduced to practice. It is all very well to experiment and to spend plenty of money upon experimenting and upon research work, but, unless you can get the people to believe in it, they will not profit by it. I know that the Department is doing very useful work and has always done very useful work, but the trouble is that the people have not confidence in it, and that is why I would recommend the Minister, if he does not wish to go in for a scheme like this in a large way, to begin it in a small way. I recommend that, at least, he should run a demonstration farm in each county. That would not be a big thing.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must know that this is a Supplementary Estimate and does not amount to £1,000,000. No money is provided in it for setting up demonstration farms in each parish or county.

Comment on this

I quite see that, but I notice that the very second item on this Estimate is £1,000 for agricultural schools and farms. Upon these agricultural schools and farms there has been £36,000 spent under the original Estimate, and now a further £1,000 is required. I therefore think that it should not be very much out of order if I suggest——

Comment on this

A little out of order is not much harm, Sir.

Comment on this

I am not questioning the Ceann Comhairle's ruling, to which I bow. But to my mind it would be well to try some scheme that would be self-supporting. The scheme I am proposing would be self-supporting, otherwise it would not be worth trying. I leave the matter at that. I hope the Minister will consider this suggestion. Now, on the question of the improvement of milk production, I do know that milk is not being economically produced at the present time. It should be remembered that milk is only the source of half the profits of the dairy farm. The rearing of calves and so on would be the other half, and anything that can be done to improve the price of young cattle is helping the dairy farmer. Anything that can be done to improve store cattle will help the dairy farmer while it will be no burden on the taxpayer. That is a point of which the Minister should never lose sight. When speaking of agriculture we do not want to confine ourselves to milk alone. Milk may be very important in one district, while in another district wheat-growing or beet-growing may be the important item. But when we speak of agriculture we should consider agriculture as a whole, and in this country, taking the thing in general, it is the mixed system of agriculture which pays. Any branch of agriculture that is self-supporting or nearly self-supporting should be encouraged in preference to branches that require large subsidies.

That is a principle it would be well the Minister should keep in mind, for, in the long run, it would save the taxpayer and increase and encourage production of agricultural products in the country. I said branches of agriculture that are nearly economic, because I do not think any branch of agriculture just now is economic. What I say is that milk production and the production of store cattle, sheep and pigs and all these things should be taken as a whole. Then each item that is likely to be economic should be encouraged, rather than go to the extraordinary expense that is connected with the growing of beet and wheat. These two crops are confined to certain portions of the country. They are no benefit to other sections——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They are also outside this Supplementary Estimate.

Comment on this

Very well, I will get away from that. I was only making a passing reference. I am just recommending to the Minister that he should encourage those lines that are economic and that are capable of being pursued in almost every part of the country. The next item on the Vote is "Land reclamation, etc. Schemes in congested districts and other special areas." That is a very useful item and one that should be encouraged. I think there could be an extension of that scheme. The extension that I suggest is that the employment of agricultural labourers at certain periods of the year should be subsidised to a certain extent. For instance, anyone who employs extra men for draining and cleaning or improving the land should get a subsidy for this work. This would refer to people who would not be qualified at present to get grants. Part of the wages should be paid to farmers so as to encourage them to do work of this kind that in itself is not economic. In some districts the land is of inferior quality. I refer specially to congested areas; this is work that would be scarcely economic. At the same time, when we bear in mind that there is so much money paid in doles to people for doing nothing or doing work that is of very doubtful value— such as making roads where they are not wanted—it would be worth while to subsidise people for doing reproductive work of this kind on the land to the extent, say, of one-half or one-third of the wages paid. This might be tried in congested areas. It would result in reducing the number of people in receipt of unemployment assistance and at the same time the lands of these areas would be drained, the district made more healthy, and production increased. It would be a benefit in another way, because it would improve the morale of the young people who are now being demoralised by getting money for doing nothing. This is a matter to which I would urge the Minister to give consideration. Perhaps he would make an experiment in a small way and then see whether the experiment could be extended. I am putting these few suggestions to the Minister because I believe he is wishful to help agriculture, and we should encourage these branches of farming that require the least assistance. That is a thing the Minister has not been doing up to now. If he were to do this, he would find that it would be more profitable to everybody than encouraging the production of crops that can never be economic. I hope the Minister will bear these things in mind and that he will set up a number of these demonstration plots on which he will experiment in a small way.

Comment on this

In reference to grants for reclamations to farmers, I would like to point out to the Minister that many of the schemes in question have not been completed within the period set forth in the scheme. I understood the Department stipulated that the schemes should be completed before the 31st March. However, in view of weather conditions and other difficulties, a number of small householders in these congested areas found it impossible time and again to have the schemes completed within the scheduled time. I would ask that, in such cases, some arrangement might be made with a view to having the time limit extended. I should also like some consideration to be given to the difficulties existing in these areas, and that the system should be adjusted with a view to facilitating those small holders and enabling them to qualify for the grant in April or at any later period that would be required.

The other item to which I would like to make reference is the question of cheap seeds, such as seed oats and seed potatoes for the small holders in congested districts. I understand that the Department have restricted the output and that the quantity to be allowed this year will be, roughly, one-third of last year's allocation. I appeal strongly to the Minister to continue the same allocation as last year. I understand that the experts in the Department make the case that the results were so favourable last year, and the statistics went to show that everything was so satisfactory, that they felt there was no further need to give subsidies or assistance of any sort; that the point had been reached when these areas were able to maintain themselves so far as the special seed was concerned. As against that I would like to point out that the conditions were so bad in the poorer districts that the people had to use all their seed potatoes and the other seeds that were available and there was nothing left with which to get them through the next season.

The Department's point of view may be all right from the theoretical end, but from the practical aspect the story is quite different, and I would like the Department to maintain the position of last year and so help to carry on the good work that they have already conducted on behalf of these poor people. I make that case, knowing the conditions. I am aware that the inspectors find it difficult to satisfy all the requirements of the people. I know it would be absolutely impossible to meet all the requirements if the Department insist on their restricted issue of seeds.

Comment on this

Does the Minister intend to intervene before concluding on the Estimate? There have been a lot of points raised on which there is further information requested. Does the Minister not propose to give that information, so as to enable the debate to be conducted in a more detailed fashion?

Comment on this

When I am concluding, I am prepared to answer any questions that may be asked.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not going to give the information that has been asked for?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The usual practice has been for the Minister to conclude on a Supplementary Estimate.

Comment on this

Yes, when the Minister has given the details to enable the debate to be carried on, and which he has not given this time.

Comment on this

I have already given very full details.

Comment on this

As regards the Roscrea factory, does the Minister pretend he has given details about that?

Comment on this

I gave certain details.

Comment on this

Then I am afraid I shall have to ask him some further questions in order to secure certain details and necessary information in relation to other points. There are several matters to which I should like to direct the Minister's attention. One has reference to the general policy with regard to agriculture in the main, and that aspect of it which is known as the dairying end. There appears now to be agreement amongst everybody that the dairying industry has got to be subsidised. But when that is said, the matter is by no means finished. Once subsidies are brought into any scheme in relation to economics in this country, we find ourselves back again in the old circle. Subsidies are not got out of a sort of bottomless pit, into which the Government may dig at any moment. Subsidies can only be got from the ordinary taxpayer. If there were any question of trying to subsidise the production of milk and to charge up the necessary amount on the consumers of milk, there would be even a greater howl than has arisen. The same practice has been tried in regard to butter, and is being observed in regard to bacon.

There are some people in the country who imagine that they have said all that is required of them when they tell us there is guaranteed such a price as will enable the farmer to be given a certain amount per gallon for the milk. They wash their hands out of it when it comes to the question of who is to be responsible for the money. It is impossible to give a guaranteed price now except by placing an intolerable burden on the people at a period when production generally is down. Those people who have with glee chortled over the situation that has been brought about in which agricultural production is down by some £10,000,000 to £20,000,000, look rather wry when they are asked where, out of that diminishing production, they are going to find the extra money required in order to give the farmer what is thought to be a proper price for his milk. It is not playing fair with the electors for people to come here and, in a light-hearted fashion, speak of a subsidy, leaving it to others to find where, out of the mess which has resulted in a decreased production, or in a production for which a price cannot be got, the money is to be obtained.

There is a welcome change in this House. On a previous occasion, when I spoke to the motion on the cost of living, I gave a quotation from the President where he said that the British market had gone for ever, as far as he could see. What is the position to-day? His followers are now waiting hungrily for the moment when he will declare the British market open to us. Some years ago there would have been cheers at the statement that the British market had gone for ever. There was a period when many people were deluded into false hopes about other foreign markets and about the home market. Now those people are hoping against hope that the British market will again be opened to us. For five years it was regarded as good politics, and it was lauded as sound patriotism, to talk about the closing of the British market, about turning our backs on it and pretending that we had no use for it. The people who carried on that sort of thing find themselves in a difficult position to-day. They are looking hungrily to the time when the declaration will be made that the British market will be open to something like the old extent.

You cannot continue indefinitely this policy of subsidising an industry that has been partially killed through Government action. There seems to be agreement now that whatever subsidies have to be got for any purpose, they ought not to be raised off the foodstuffs of the people. Subsidies, like the moneys that are required for any social service, are found out of taxation of luxuries or semi-luxuries, and the Government have been forced to confess that they were obliged to tax the necessities of life, not because they liked it, but because there was nothing else left to tax. How the Government's policy of endeavouring to dart in two directions is to be reconciled, I do not know. If the Minister brings forward a definite proposal to get the farmers properly remunerated for the milk that is produced, he, no doubt, will have the support of the House; but let him take heed and see whether the other policies he has been engaged in fathering for some years have not been in some way responsible for bringing the price that can be got for milk in the country to the present point. There is definitely a clamour for the British market at the moment.

We embarked here on a policy of self-sufficiency, an unattainable idea, and we applauded any other country going in for a policy of self-sufficiency. As long as that policy was operating with enthusiasm, so long was there a lowering of the standard of living and an increase in the cost of living in every country. Only in the last two or three years, when that policy has been found to be the complete fraud it is and people have veered from it, has there been any lift in the cloud of depression. We think that we can make our little effort to damage British trade, and we want the people upon whom we rely to give us a decent price for the foodstuffs we have to export to be put into a position to pay this bigger price while patriots down the country will applaud everything we think will bring them to their knees. There is to be a reconciliation of the impossible. We are to be patriots, patting ourselves on the backs for all we do to bring the British down, and then cringing in our endeavour to get Britain to pay us a better price for the goods we must export to her because no other place will take them.

A very nauseating scandal is obviously concealed under this item O.O. 11 in which £15,000 is being provided for payment to two separate factories. They are being paid, so far as I understand from what has been recounted to me of the Minister's speech, on foot of penalty clauses in two contracts. The Minister fears that they may be enforced against him because he contracted to supply Waterford factory with old cattle at 11/- per cwt. and call no longer keep his contract and that he contracted — most marvellous of all — to supply Roscrea factory with cattle for nothing——

Comment on this

I should like to set Deputy McGilligan right. We want to protect our products down in Waterford.

Comment on this

The Minister contracted to supply Waterford with something at 10/- a cwt. and—most marvellous of all—he was to supply Roscrea with cattle for nothing. Apparently, he entered into a binding contract, with a penalty clause, that if he did not continue to supply Roscrea with cattle for nothing, Roscrea would have an action against him. We are told that he is making an advance of £5,000 in respect of some unascertained liability in respect of that penalty clause. That is an interesting contract. Is it going to be published? Shall we get full particulars of it? Shall we be told what the Government was going to get out of it at any time? I cannot understand the Government guaranteeing to supply raw material for nothing if it has to pay something for it and is not going to get something out of it in the end. These cattle which wended their way to Roscrea found themselves coming out in the form of some sort of tinned stuff. That was to be sold. At what price? Were the Government to get any part of the price or was that handed over to the promoters? If it was, it was a completely one-sided contract. Did the Minister ever hear of a contract in which one party bound itself to supply raw material for nothing to a factory and the factory people were allowed to get away with that item of profit or with whatever profit was made or to be made out of it? If the Government were to be made a present of these cattle, one could understand their benevolence but one would inquire who were the parties to whom they were so benevolent.

The Government had to purchase these cattle. We paid for them. The Government had contracted that, for four or five years, they would buy cattle, making the taxpayer pay for them, and hand them over free to the Roscrea factory. They would not ask the Roscrea factory whether they made profits or losses, because the Government had no share in the profits and, I hope, had no share in the losses. The Government bound themselves to continue to supply these cattle to Roscrea for a number of years: If that is the contract, will the Minister take a piece of gratuitous advice? The contract is so bad that it could not be enforced and he need not hesitate to go into court to get it set aside. The only plea that could be set up against the Minister would be that he knew what he was doing. The Minister might have to enter the sad plea that he was slightly deranged at the time the contract was made. Would any man in commercial life present himself as a sane man before the public and say he bound himself in a penalty clause, which could be enforced against him in court, to supply goods free for which he had to pay and out of the product of which he was to have no share?

There are other items in connection with Roscrea which will need further examination. A road was made to that factory. I understand it was made free by local labour on the ground that the people making it were to be given employment for a number of years in the factory. I hope the Minister has not guaranteed to pay them something if they are thrown out of the factory. Who are the directors of this company——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On that point, I understand that this company is a private company. It is the established practice of this House not to discuss the affairs of private companies or private individuals.

Comment on this

We are being asked to pay money to a private company. I suggest that it is a matter that goes to the root of parliamentary institutions that we should be allowed to find out whether there are, or are not, Deputies of this House making money in that company. I suggest that there are.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The company in question is, I understand, a private company. The action of Deputies, as members of such companies, is not a matter for discussion in this House. I presume that the Comptroller and Auditor-General will have to decide whether the money is properly spent or not, and thus Deputies may question this or any other transaction — that is, in connection with the Public Accounts.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if any company enters into relation with the State by virtue of which it exacts heavy penalties from the State and puts large sums of money into its pocket, does that not abrogate the protection afforded by this House to the affairs of private individuals? If private individuals enter into personal relations with the State, on foot of which they claim the right to collect large sums of public money, does not that constitute an abrogation of the rule?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is on record that there have been Deputies who had an interest in companies that had Government contracts. That fact would not justify the introduction of their business concerns or of their companies into debate in the Dáil. Neither is it permissible to discuss the affairs of this private company, the constitution of its directorate, or whether or not Deputies are connected with it. If it is desired to arraign the Government or a Minister on such a matter, it should be done by formal motion and not casually on a Supplementary Estimate.

Comment on this

I suggest that this matter goes to the root of parliamentary institutions. Most governments have arrangements whereby all members of Parliament who become interested in a contract have to reveal and declare it. Most governments and most parliamentary institutions have provisions whereby publicity is given to the fact that members of parties are entering into contractual relations with the Government. It is sought now by the Minister to conceal that, and the rules of the House to which you have given expression — and which I have not yet understood — aids and abets that nefarious practice. It is a thing that certainly strikes at the root of parliamentary institutions if there is to be secrecy about such a matter as this. Whether it is a private company or not does not matter. I am not revealing for the first time that it is notoriously manned by Deputies. Should a private company, exhibited in that way, which never can lose, be kept alive so far as votes from this House can keep it alive, while the Minister can never win? The Minister was to supply goods free to this factory. How the profits were to be made the Minister was not, apparently, concerned because he was going to get no part of the profits. Yet, the Minister ties himself by a penalty clause to the company, which contains a couple of members of his own Party. I assert that as a fact.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I trust I was not misunderstood when I referred to companies, in which Deputies were interested, having Government contracts. I named no company. The Deputy seems to be making a charge against members of the House. Such a charge cannot be made in that informal manner. The Deputy, if he so desires, may raise the matter, by motion, but neither the concerns of a private company nor its composition may be discussed in a casual way.

Comment on this

Apparently there has been some misunderstanding of my remarks. I am not charging any Deputy; I am charging the Minister, and he is the man who is answering for this Vote, that he entered into a completely indefensible contract, and I say that, as an aggravation of that, the parties who can only be gainers—who certainly cannot be losers so far as votes of public money can put them in the right position — happen to be Deputies, or companies partly composed of Deputies. The Minister, however, must bear the blame for this, and he does not get away from the blame by attempting to be secretive about the matter. I presume this contract will have to be discussed by the Public Accounts Committee. I hope it will be published, and I think the Minister should publish it now, and if he had no shame about it, he would publish it and every detail would be thrown open for every Deputy who is interested to read. Instead of our getting in a piecemeal way, by question and by more or less putting things to the Minister which he cannot deny, a hold of this nauseating affair, the Minister should have stood up and told us exactly what happened. If no more is said than what I am saying very briefly, surely there is something for the Minister to reveal.

The Minister binds himself that he will disburse public money under a penalty clause. The penalty is to be inflicted on him — and he appears to think it is a penalty that can be enforced legally — because he cannot carry out a promise. What was the promise? That he should supply cattle free to Roscrea for five years. As a bad bargain phrased that way, there might be some of the edge taken off it if the Minister could say: "I was to have got this, that or the other thing," but the Minister does not tell us that. It is not there. The Minister never was to gain; the State never could gain; and the people never could gain. All that was to happen was that public money could be devoted by the Minister to this concern when this concern threatened the Minister with an action —an action that could not be stood over on any grounds of equity, but an action which the Minister would hate to defend. It is an action which, I believe, if fought out, will not be fought out in open court, but some hugger-mugger class of arbitration board will be set up in such a way that the public will get no notice, and all that they will be told is the amount of the bill which they have to foot. We have a foreshadowing of that to-night. This £5,000 is an instalment.

Of courses it was a scandalous transaction. No brains could ever have been associated with it. The only thing associated with it was camouflage and secrecy. It has been put here already to the Minister that it would have been a better performance for him to say to the people, as he did with regard to the calves: "We will give you so much for every old cow you slaughter and of which you send us the hide." If that had been done, whatever money has now been lost could have been divided up amongst the farmers, and we would have had the knowledge that it went into the hands of the people who had the old cows and killed them. Instead of that, we find that these animals were gathered into Roscrea; subsidies paid to Roscrea for the erection of a factory; a lot of machinery gathered together, inside walls, with a Government pledge to take it over on a certain date; the factory now rendered unusable; and the Minister bound to make good on a penalty clause some sum of money, of which £5,000 is the first instalment, because the cattle, under his mismanagement, are no longer so bad that they can be supplied for nothing to Roscrea.

The Minister, of course, did not dare to attempt the business of having the slaughter of old cows as well as the slaughter of calves running at the same time. That would have been too great an exposure of the policy he stands over; but that, although scandalous enough from the angle of economics, would not have been bad from the angle of business. This is the same result. It gets the cattle killed in a way that brings no benefit to the community. The only benefit there is arising out of the whole transaction is to those people who are concerned in the factory. What is going to happen to the building eventually? There was a building put up. Who stood for the cost of the building? I am told that there was something said here to-day about debentures for £16,000. Is it that the factory cost £16,000? Who supplied the money? What about the machinery? Where did it come from? Is there much machinery? What did it cost? What is the scrap value of it, if it is going to be scrapped? Is it machinery that can be changed for anything else, and, if so, what is it likely to be used for? Can we run it on industrial alcohol from potatoes for some other absurd purpose? What will happen eventually if we find that the factory cannot be used? What is the end of our losses in this connection?

I suppose the Minister cannot be asked to give some guess even as to the figure he will likely lose over this penalty clause because he might be giving himself away too openly, but would the Minister tell us how is this matter going to be fought out? Will it be in public? Will it be tried by a judge, or is he going to scuttle into a corner before some arbitrator? Is there going to be a secret bargain about this? What is going to happen to the building? Has the Minister any idea as to a new use for it? Is he going to be saddled with it? What about the machinery and, in the end, will the Minister promise — he cannot do it now, but some day — to tell the House the sorry story of the Roscrea factory and what it has cost the country? I have often heard the phrase about chickens coming home to roost and I have often wondered what would happen when the white elephants came home to roost, but we are beginning to realise now some part of it.

Comment on this

A number of matters have been raised on this Estimate which, I suppose, I might take in order. Deputy Dillon spoke of an incident about 12 months ago and said that we had sold butter on the British market at a low price and had imported butter afterwards from Denmark at a high price. I do not happen to have the figures of that particular incident at hand, but I do know that, during the last five years, it happened only once that our calculations as to the amount of butter required for the winter and our calculations as to the production for the winter were wrong. That was in the winter of 1936-37. A certain amount of Danish butter did come in, but not at an exorbitant price. This year, to date, the amount of production on which we calculated is about right, and it would look as if the amount of butter which we kept in cold store for the supply here at home will work out at the proper amount. The Deputy made an accusation against me on a former occasion that in that year, 1936, when this miscalculation was made, we stored butter in July and August, when prices were high, and sold it in September and October, when prices were low, and said that anybody with any common sense would have done the other thing —that is, sell the butter in summer and keep it in September and October for winter use. We followed exactly the same practice in 1937 as in 1936, and it happened that we were absolutely right. We stored our butter in July and August, when prices were low, and sold it in September and October, when prices were very high. We happen to be right, so that the person of common sense is not always the person who can make the best forecast of these things. There is a great deal of chance and we must make the best forecast we can, and take the best possible view you can of the prospects on the foreign market.

The next point that was raised by Deputy Dillon was in relation to the Roscrea factory. Deputy McGilligan has made a speech which I would say he would be glad to get the opportunity of making. He seldom appears on an agricultural Estimate, but when this matter of Roscrea was mentioned, I saw him coming into the House. I wondered if he had been sent for, but I knew what he was going to do and what he was going to say. He is always glad of an opportunity to accuse his opponents of all sorts of wrong-doings and to throw out his usual accusations, semi-accusations, insinuations and so on.

Comment on this

He repeated verbatim what I had already said.

Comment on this

I would not give Deputy Dillon that credit. I do not believe he is half as clever as Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Possibly that is true, but the substance was the same.

Comment on this

He may be trying. He is, perhaps, a good pupil of Deputy McGilligan, but he will never have the bitterness. He may try, but he will not have it.

Comment on this

So I should be happy.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be happy because it is not his nature. Deputy McGilligan started by saying that it was a scandal and by making insinuations. He asked questions and I have no objection to answering them. The Ceann Comhairle has overruled the question of mentioning names. I will have the question answered publicly. Deputy McGilligan knows, Deputy Dillon knows, and everyone knows who is connected with the Roscrea factory. It is only a matter of having the names published which, I am sure, we can have done. Let us try to get back to the position of the Roscrea factory when started early in 1935. There were numbers of old and uneconomic cows here which would not be allowed into the British market. We did not want to kill them for human consumption. I will not say that they were all diseased but, under the regulations, a number of them were. As we did not want to kill them for human consumption, it was a problem at that time to know what to do with these old uneconomic cows.

Comment on this

Bury them.

Comment on this

That is what would have happened. At the same time, as there was a deficiency in meat meal in this country we thought we could make use of them for that purpose. At that time there were factories in this country making meat meal. In order to give Deputy Dillon and Deputy McGilligan, if they are willing to learn, some idea of the economics of that particular business, I think the documents can be produced. I had a certain firm approached to know on what terms they would take old cows. It was an existing concern and would not take them if it got them free. First of all, the firm would need to enlarge their premises. They would not take money on loan. They would take a grant and would take the cows free if delivered. That, roughly, is what the offer made to us meant. The position was then put up to me that we should do this business on our own as a State concern. When these things are put up by officials as well as by people outside, they differ. Some officials rather favour State concerns, while some officials wish to avoid it, if possible, so that one gets a difference of opinion, with such advice. This group came along. I honestly cannot remember now, but I may have discussed it with some of the group. I certainly did not ask them to put up a proposition. They came along and put it up. I would say that it was a much better proposition than one put up by an existing firm. Documents can be produced to prove that.

Comment on this

They will?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants another inquiry they will be.

Comment on this

Had this firm been compensated to get out of business?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Were not some people in Dublin compensated over Roscrea?

Comment on this

No. That is a different matter, and has nothing to do with Roscrea. They came along undertaking to do the business, roughly on the lines indicated. They would undertake the building of the factory with a capacity to deal with something like from 900 to 1,300 cows a week. They had not enough money. They had some money. I do not know how much. Roughly, they had £7,000 or £8,000 of their own. This private company asked for a loan and we advanced £16,000 on debentures. There was an agreement that they were to put some money into it. Unless we made an agreement and delivered the cows, they would not do so. We made an agreement to deliver the cows free at the rail and they paid freight, which was more than the other firms would do.

Comment on this

Did they pay the freight?

Comment on this

Yes. They took them in at that time. I am assuming that Deputies opposite are honest in inquiring into this matter. I think if I was on the Opposition Benches I might ask for a lot of information. If we are honest about inquiring into this matter let us go back to see the price of fats at that time, which was one of the big items. The price of hides was another big item. Then there was the position in the meat meal market. They were turning out a certain quantity of meat meal. There was only a market three or four years ago for about half the quantity of meat meal turned out, and there was no prospect of getting any export market elsewhere. They had to take a chance. They said they probably could not get an export market. As it happened, they did not want it, because they sold meat meal roughly at £4 a ton less than any other firm, and in that way got bigger consumption. The price has remained down by £4 or £5 a ton less than it was before that. I say, therefore, that at that time it was not altogether so rosy a prospect.

Comment on this

Did I understand the Minister to say that with State assistance these gentlemen sold meat meal for about half the price and wiped out all the existing firms?

Comment on this

No, I did not say anything about a State subsidy.

Comment on this

They were getting the raw material for nothing?

Comment on this

I did not say that there was a subsidy on meat meal. I do not think Deputy McGilligan wants to get at the truth of this. We will assume that he does, and we will go ahead. It did not look such a rosy prospect then, because the price of hides is much higher and fats are much higher.

Comment on this

Are hides higher now?

Comment on this

They are not, perhaps, as high now as they were last year. They are higher than they were at the beginning of 1935. All these points were there, so that it did not look such a rosy proposition as it looks to those on the opposite benches now. It did not look to be a rosy proposition to the existing factory. We would be glad to give these terms to the existing factory if they accepted them.

Comment on this

How many of the existing factories were consulted about it?

Comment on this

I could not say, but I will look it up. I am sure more than one was consulted. Deputies want to know something about the agreement. As I stated, they had some money, but I do not know how much. I should say that under the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act the heads of the agreement, at least, should be placed on the Table of the Dáil. Probably they have been placed on the Table. I am not sure. The agreement set out that we should deliver so many cattle, and if we fell down on the delivery of that number, we could pay a certain amount of compensation each year.

Comment on this

When was the agreement placed on the Table?

Comment on this

I am not sure, but under the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act the heads of any agreement made were to be placed on the Table. I do not know if the time to do so was limited, and I do not know if they appeared on the Table.

The agreement, at any rate, was that at the end of four years they were to pay back what they owed to us — that is, the £16,000 — or we had the option, on the other hand, of buying from them on an agreed basis which, I think, was the original cost. We had both options, of either taking our money back within the four years — the money that we had lent them — or of taking over the factory on an agreed cost, I cannot say what it was.

Comment on this

It might have been substantially in excess of the debentures outstanding?

Comment on this

Possibly. That was the agreement. If I were to come here to-day and tell Deputies that I could, within four years, take back my debentures, I think they would say that I should also have an agreement to take over the factory if it was a going paying concern. It was hard to imagine how it could be a going paying concern if all supplies stopped. But suppose we stopped the scheme of supplying the old cows, it is quite possible that they could collect those cows at a very small cost themselves. Some of those old cows were not worth anything to any other person except the Roscrea factory and, naturally, they could get them very cheap. I am not sure whether they could make it a going paying concern, but possibly they could. As I say, we had the option to purchase. If it proved that, after four years' experience, it was a factory that could be put on a paying basis, we could then take it and run it ourselves, or take it and let it to another company. I was asked the question whether any Deputy was connected with this company. Yes, there was a Deputy of this Party connected with the company. The Ceann Comhairle has ruled that we must not mention names. The name will be made public, and there is no desire to conceal it. Take the Waterford factory, for instance. We made the same type of agreement with the Waterford factory. We agreed to give cattle at 10/- a cwt. to the Waterford factory — as Deputy Gorey said, the best of cattle — because we had to clear a certain area in Kerry, suitable healthy cattle, good for canning and the making of meat extract.

We made that agreement with Waterford. It also contained a penalty clause under which we had to pay up if we did not go on with our contract. We paid up £10,000. It was a much smaller transaction than with the Roscrea factory. In the case of Waterford we were dealing with between 4,000 and 10,000 cattle a year, while in the case of Roscrea the number was 50,000. Therefore, anyone can see that the amount of capital required in Roscrea would be higher than in the case of the Waterford factory. Hence the compensation clause was higher. A Deputy opposite was connected with the Waterford factory and no one will find any fault with that.

Comment on this

He was not a Deputy.

Comment on this

He is a Deputy now.

Comment on this

That is another story.

Comment on this

I am wrong. There was a Deputy connected with it.

Comment on this

There is the difference that the Waterford factory was not started for that special purpose.

Comment on this

But still it stood to gain that £10,000.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what was the basis of calculation in respect of the £10,000?

Comment on this

In the case of Waterford it was that we were to pay them either £10,000 or their capital outlay, whichever we thought the lower.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Am I to understand from the Minister that ever £100,000 worth of free cattle were given to this Roscrea factory?

Comment on this

Very much more. Almost 100,000 cattle were delivered in three years.

Comment on this

At £2 10s. each?

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

So that the factory got a subsidy of £250,000?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy admit that he allowed the estimates for the last three years to go through — the Dáil voting £180,000 for cows for Roscrea — and never noticed it?

Comment on this

We did not realise the imbecility of the bargain.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that Roscrea canned some of this stuff and thought to sell it both here and on the continent?

Comment on this

There was none of it sold here.

Comment on this

Well, on the continent?

Comment on this

They may have.

Comment on this

What about the compensation paid to people here in connection with the Roscrea factory?

Comment on this

I was asked whether we had compensated certain firms here in Dublin as a result of setting up these factories. Under the agreement we made with the Waterford factory, we did ask firms that were doing a very small business here in Dublin to go out of business on the basis of compensation, which they did.

Comment on this

And those firms were compensated?

Comment on this

They were, because they were in the business. We wanted a firm that would take the Kerry cattle. We wanted a firm that would take over the entire business, and we made that agreement with Waterford.

Comment on this

And you were to get certain profits.

Comment on this

What was the cost of the compensation?

Comment on this

About £3,000, I think.

Comment on this

It is a mercy it is so low.

Comment on this

I may be wrong in that. It may be £3,000 or £4,000. Deputy McGilligan can go now, because I think I have finished with Roscrea.

Comment on this

Let us make everything quite clear. Is it true that the Roscrea factory, having received free £250,000 worth of old cows on the representation that they were going to convert them into meat meal, did, in fact, slaughter and can some of those old cows for human food and seek to sell that on the Continent as an Irish packed meat product?

Comment on this

I honestly cannot answer whether they tried to sell it on the Continent.

Comment on this

Did they try to sell it outside the Saorstát?

Comment on this

They did make a certain amount of tinned meat.

Comment on this

And tried to sell that as an Irish packed meat product that they got for nothing.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that they tried to sell some of this as sides of Irish beef in Belgium?

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the giving of a subsidy for some old humans and send them to Roscrea?

Comment on this

Agreement on every side of the House.

Comment on this

Why Deputy Walsh should insist on insulting himself I cannot imagine.

Comment on this

If we want to have the truth of the matter, there was no food left Roscrea factory except in tins — at any rate not, as Deputy Fagan says, in sides for Belgium.

Comment on this

I heard a person trying to make a price for sides from Roscrea factory for Belgium. I was listening to the conversation.

Comment on this

That is not true. I do not want to move on if there are any other questions to be put.

Comment on this

We want the contract and documents referred to.

Comment on this

Under the Act I must put certain information before the Dáil. It may have been put before the Dáil, but if not it will be.

Comment on this

There are two other documents you said you would give the House.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy will ask me to bring before the House a letter from a private firm in reply to a communication from me.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister refer to it?

Comment on this

I am prepared to show it to any Deputy privately.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not publish it, taking out the name of the firm? We do not want the name.

Comment on this

I will see if that can be done.

Comment on this

We want to see how far there was a finger poked in anyone's eye.

Comment on this

My finger?

Comment on this

No; yours would be more the eye than the finger.

Comment on this

The Deputy did say that I could put up a plea in court of being mentally deranged at the time. It is just the Deputy's style.

Comment on this

It is the Minister's affliction.

Comment on this

If the Deputy went out we could have a more pleasant debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will hear the Minister without any interruption.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Deputy Dillon that because the export of eggs is down there is a corresponding decrease in production. As a matter of fact, I think if he will look up the figures — I am not sure if they are published yet, but I have seen the figures from the Department of Industry and Commerce, which, if not published yet, will be soon — he will find that there is a very big increase in the consumption of eggs in this country — in fact, almost sufficient, so far as I can read the figures, to make up the gap between the exports six or seven years ago and now.

Comment on this

You do not believe that.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon, or some other Deputy, said to-night that we ought to look at the figures supplied by the Department of Industry and Commerce and learn for ourselves.

Comment on this

You do not do that.

Comment on this

I did that all right.

Comment on this

Someone has been telling you things again.

Comment on this

With regard to land reclamation schemes, it is true that seven or eight years ago we had schemes for the reclamation of about 3,000 acres of land. It has now gone up to 50,000 acres. The agricultural overseers and the assistant overseers who were there in 1929 and 1930 are still on the Vote for agriculture. It is only the men who are taken on temporarily during the winter for land reclamation work who are put on the employment scheme Vote. So that it is not true, as Deputy Dillon says, that we are shifting over the expenditure under some heads to the employment Vote and in that way relieving the Vote for agriculture. As to special-term bulls, it is not true that we are making any profit on them. These bulls are never sold for more than they are bought at, and sometimes they are sold for less. It is not true either to say that the good bulls are gone before we purchase these bulls. We try to get the best bulls possible.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will find that some of his own officers have stated in public that the procedure whereunder the special-term bulls are purchased is that the premium bulls are bought first.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Then any bull which has not been sold is picked up by the Department and distributed as a special-term bull.

Comment on this

I think you will find that the best buyers are there and that they do get the best possible bulls after the premium bulls. Deputy Dillon suggested taking this milk from the Kerry area where we propose to put up creameries. He thought it might be done in an economic way. It is perhaps a very good scheme from a social point of view to give milk to people who cannot afford to purchase it, but as an economic proposition it would be altogether hopeless. It only costs about ¾d. per lb. to convert milk into butter in a creamery. If you take the average cost of distribution of milk in Dublin at the moment I think it must be about 8d. or 9d. per gallon. If you compare that with the ¾d., which is the cost of converting the milk into butter, surely if we are to give the farmer the same price for milk, it is cheaper under a semi-State scheme at least to convert it into butter and sell the butter, rather than try to distribute it free in Dublin or elsewhere. That may have its merits from a social point of view, but not from an economic point of view.

The Beef Conference meets in London and all countries exporting beef into the British market are members. They deal, first of all, with the global quota for the quarter. They make recommendations to the British Government as to what the global quota should be for all countries and then make recommendations on the division of that global quota amongst the countries participating.

Comment on this

Is this country regarded simply as on an equal footing with, say, the Argentine or elsewhere, or does our membership of that Beef Conference permit us, subsequent to the discussions, to make individual representations to the British Board of Trade for special advantages for ourselves?

Comment on this

Yes, we have made these individual representations outside the Beef Conference in regard to, say, the fat cattle quota and so on, and so far that has not been objected to by the Beef Conference.

Deputy Davin said I held out no great hope as to the dairying industry. It is very difficult to make any forecast of what is there for the dairying industry in the years to come. The present price is undoubtedly unremunerative to our farmers; that is, I suppose, even if we had a free market, about 110/- or 112/- per cwt. That would mean at the present time, if we had no subsidies or bounties and so on, that the farmer would only get about 4d. per gallon for the milk. I think no Deputy would claim that that would be sufficient, even if he were getting a better price for his young cattle as well. I am sure there would be an agitation that we should try to do something better for the dairying industry — that they could not possibly carry on at 4d. per gallon. It is true that if we had no stabilisation scheme and bounties and so on, in the year 1935 the price payable to the farmer would be about 2½d. per gallon when butter was 69/- per cwt. on the world market.

I do not know if I can give Deputy Davin any very convincing reasons why the supply of milk in the midland creameries has gone down. I had graphs made out on one occasion showing the price of milk and the supply of milk, the price of cattle and the number of cows. So far as I could learn any lesson from these graphs, they would go to show that if the price of cattle is rising usually the number of cows goes down and it has far more influence on the number of cows than the price of milk. However, that was only over a comparatively short period, which perhaps was not sufficient to be a reliable guide on these matters. It may be due to both causes — that the farmer considered the price of milk unsatisfactory and at the same time saw an improvement in the price of cattle. Probably it is due to both.

Comment on this

Would it be due to the fact that they cannot get anyone to milk them?

Comment on this

The question which Deputy Davin put to me as to the future dairying policy is a big one. I think, as I said before on several occasions, that we should try as far as we can to maintain the number of cows in the country, because a great deal depends on the number of cows we have—in the first place, the number of calves and the output of milk, not only for human consumption but also for the feeding of calves, pigs, poultry, etc. It is therefore a very important basic industry. We should try, as far as we possibly can, to keep the dairying industry going. There are, of course, two factors in the situation which we must always keep in mind. The world price is an important consideration, and if we have to subsidise our dairy farmers so as to bring the price up to the level at which they can continue to produce, to find the difference between that price and the world price may mean a very heavy burden at times on the taxpayer. As far as our forecasts for the coming year go, it would appear as if the world price of butter is not going to be any better than it was last year, even if it is as good, so that it will take a considerable amount of money to keep our dairying industry going as it is, and it will take considerably more to improve matters.

A question was raised about the distribution of cattle licences. When the distribution of cattle licences was in the hands of the Department, I think there was a great deal of dissatisfaction, and Deputies opposite were kind enough on some occasions even to suggest that the friends of the Fianna Fáil Party got more licences than friends of the other Parties. It was an extremely difficult thing to distribute those licences — in fact, impossible to distribute them and give satisfaction. Eventually they were divided amongst the county committees on the assumption that the county committees would know more of local needs and would try to distribute them fairly. I think we shall have to continue that system. Deputy Fagan said that in order to get licences for April he would have to apply now. I do not think that can be so.

Comment on this

You would have to apply for them now in order to get them two months hence.

Comment on this

I applied for 20 licences recently, and I was told that I could not get them until April.

Comment on this

I must make inquiries into that matter. It should be possible by applying now to get them in March. If they are applied for early in February, they should be available in March, but the county secretary must have sufficient time to make up his mind as to how many he can give. In regard to the charge for licences, I think it is a good thing to charge something because, before we commenced to charge, people who did not want them applied for them, and when they got them threw them aside and did not use them. Imposing a small charge means that they will be available for those who really want them.

Comment on this

The question is, are you entitled to charge?

Comment on this

We can go on charging, at any rate, until somebody challenges it. With regard to giving out licences at the ports on the demand of exporters, a great complaint was made before when a system such as that was in operation that the exporters were not passing back the benefits of the full prices to the producer.

Comment on this

At that time there was a scarcity of licences.

Comment on this

I am afraid we would have the same complaint again if we did that.

Comment on this

Is it not true that we are not filling the quota or anything like it?

Comment on this

It is true, but I am afraid that if only the exporters would have access to these licences we would have that complaint from the farmers, whether there would be any foundation for it or not.

Comment on this

I do not see how you could get that complaint when you have not enough fat cattle for all the licences available.

Comment on this

I am afraid the present system will have to continue, for this season, at any rate. With regard to the report of the Horse Breeding Commission, most of the recommendations were adopted. There are some that have not been adopted up to now.

Comment on this

Are these all the Government are going to adopt?

Comment on this

Practically, that is all they are going to do. Deputy Fagan said that we were making big profits out of the German trade.

Comment on this

I did not say big profits.

Comment on this

I would not say we made big profits but it has paid us this year. Even if we did make big profits, I do not see how we could do what the Deputy suggests. If we send our buyers into the cattle market and they give a good price, they cannot give a great deal more than anybody else, as if they did we would have sellers immediately coming along, saying: "We want to sell our cattle for the German market because we can get more by selling them in that way than by selling them to anybody else."

Comment on this

If the Minister had a little profit, could he not afford to give 1/- or 6d. per cwt. more this week than other buyers? That would tend to raise the prices next week.

Comment on this

We have tried to do that on many occasions. We tried in the past to raise the market price by giving 1/- or so per cwt. more than anybody else.

Comment on this

If the £4 5s. tariff were taken off they would not be going to Germany.

Comment on this

They might.

Comment on this

They would go to Johnny Lord and Mosey Lee.

Comment on this

They might not, but we shall see.

Comment on this

That is rather hopeful —"we shall see."

Comment on this

Deputy Brasier talked about sending out inferior bulls. We have been trying to get the best possible bulls. Of course, there are only a certain number of bulls in the country. Deputy Roddy asked if it was proposed to have a general reorganisation of the dairying industry under this Estimate. In this Estimate no provision is made for such reorganisation but we are continually having that matter under review and trying to reorganise the dairying industry in general. Where there are creameries that can be amalgamated, or where creameries can swop auxiliaries, we do our best to bring them to an agreement. We cannot use any compulsion on them. All we can do is to suggest that it would be a good step to take.

Sometimes they do what is suggested to them, but in most cases they do not. It is true that we have had a number of meetings and consultations with dairying interests about what the price might be for the coming year. I have not yet been able to make any announcement because, although we might make a forecast for the coming year, we have not yet reached agreement as to what the taxpayer would be able to give us to tide us over our difficulties.

Deputy O'Donovan asked how much was being devoted to the winter production of butter. I mentioned the sum already — £49,000. Deputy Anthony raised a question with regard to the type of trading carried on by co-operative societies. That question does not arise under this Vote, but I can assure the Deputy that the money voted for new societies will not be used to encourage their activities in mixed trading. Deputy J. Flynn raised two points. One had reference to the reclamation schemes and he thought it would be well to continue them beyond the 31st March. I shall take a note of that point, but I am afraid it is rather difficult to carry out what the Deputy suggests. It may be easier to do it now than formerly because we are working under somewhat different conditions. I shall take a note of the suggestion to see if it is possible to give effect to it. In regard to his suggestion about seed potatoes and seed oats, I shall try to ascertain if we can give out the same amount of seed as we gave out last year. The only other speaker, I think, was Deputy McGilligan, who devoted his attention principally to the Roscrea factory. I have, I think, covered all the points raised.

Comment on this