Shops (Conditions of Employment) Bill, 1937—Recommittal (Resumed).
Contributions 1–178 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
As Deputies will have noted, this amendment proposes to repeal the entire Section 18 and to substitute a number of new provisions therefor. In so far as the ordinary class of workers is concerned, the outstanding point of these new provisions is a slight reduction in the number of hours of overtime that may be worked in a period of four weeks, or in the course of a year. There is no variation in the hours of overtime which may be worked in each week. The principal change, however, to which no doubt Deputies have directed their attention, is the introduction of a new period of 56 hours which will apply in respect of workers employed in hotels. When the Bill was introduced, it applied only to a certain limited class of hotel workers, and I informed the House during the discussion in Committee that it seemed clear that we should either have to exclude hotel workers altogether, or include them all. I came to the decision to include them all, but I recognise that, in doing so, we are creating new difficulties and that the circumstances applying in hotels are in many respects dissimilar from those applying in ordinary shops and that different provision in respect of hotel workers will be necessary.
The Conditions of Employment Act, 1936, distinguished between industries, making different provisions for those industries which were worked by day and those which had to be worked by a continuous process. For the day industries, a 48-hour maximum week was prescribed, and for the continuous process industries, a 56-hour maximum. I think we can see some similarity between the type of work done in a hotel and in a continuous process industry in so far as the work proceeds ordinarily around the whole period of the day, and that there is, therefore, a justification for a differentiation between the maximum hours permitted in hotels and those permitted in shops. There are other considerations which apply also. In respect of a very large number of hotel workers, it is correct to say that they reside on the premises in which they work and, consequently, there is no time lost by them in going to or proceeding from their place of work to their homes. The provision of a longer normal working week for hotel workers involved, as a consequence, a variation in the maximum hours of overtime permitted. I think that it is necessary that some liberality in respect of overtime for hotel workers should be authorised.
Many Deputies referred to the circumstances existing in hotels which cater particularly for a holiday trade, where a very large rush of business occurs at particular seasons, and very often very limited seasons, while considerable slackness is experienced at other periods of the year. To enable the proprietors of such hotels to cater for abnormal business of that kind, occurring in very restricted seasons, some exceptional provision in respect of overtime is necessary. It is proposed to make that here for hotel workers. While Deputies may be perturbed by the institution in the Bill of a longer working week than that originally contemplated for all shop workers, I think it can be said with confidence that the inclusion of all hotel workers within the scope of the Bill will mean a very great improvement in their working conditions. Even the 56 hours authorised by the proposed new section will involve in many cases a substantial reduction in their working hours, whereas the operation of the holiday and the half-holiday provision will confer on these workers benefits which they did not previously enjoy.
I think the general scheme, the sum total of all the various provisions, will mean a substantial improvement in the working conditions of this class of workers. I do not say that we are fixing 56 hours as the normal working week for hotel workers in perpetuity. It is, of course, necessary again to remind Deputies that what the Bill proposes to do is to fix the maximum limits beyond which workers cannot be employed. It establishes the minimum standards of employment which must be observed, and there is, of course, nothing to prevent any hotel proprietor observing better standards, or any hotel worker seeking to obtain them. In any event, the experiment in the regulation of hotel work which this Bill will commence will enable data and experience to be obtained which will perhaps permit of fresh legislation governing that type of work at some future date. I am satisfied that we should not go further than it is proposed in this new section at present in the regulation of the hours of work in such shops.
Comment on this
There are seven amendments tabled to Section 18. The section, as recast in amendment No. 34, appears to contain concessions on the lines suggested by amendments Nos. 35 to 39. Amendment No. 40 would not fit in with the redrafted section. It would be possible, making certain alterations, to allow those amendments to be submitted to the proposed new section. That course, however, would be unsatisfactory in many ways. I suggest that Deputies might consider how far the concessions, or what appear to me to be concessions, meet the points raised, and then resubmit their amendments mutatis mutandis on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I think that suggestion was made and pretty generally approved last night, and it was agreed, subject to the approval of the Chair, that leave would be asked to recommit the Bill on Report Stage only in so far as amendments were concerned.
Comment on this
Before the discussion proceeds, I should also draw attention to other changes which the amendment effects in accordance with various suggestions made in Committee. We are prohibiting the employment of juveniles under 16 years of age on overtime at all. The overtime provisions, so far as they affect juveniles, relate only to juveniles over 16 years of age. Reference was also made to the difficulty in determining what would be the normal working week for a worker in a week in which he received a holiday, and in order to deal with that circumstance, we are providing that the worker shall be deemed to have done eight hours on a day on which he gets a whole holiday, so that if he gets a holiday in a week he will be entitled to overtime in respect of any period in excess of 40 hours' work within that week. We are also providing that where a shop assistant does industrial work for his employer, or where he works for another employer, the total work done by him is to be taken into account for the purpose of determining what his working hours were.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say what has become of sub-section (4) of the original Section 18?
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister. I think there is considerable difference between the workers in hotels and the workers in ordinary shops, owing to the fact that the shop assistant is there the whole time working, and in the case of the hotel worker. there is a very considerable interval in the day during which he is not working, but just sitting down. That makes a substantial difference. What puzzles me in this section is sub-section (4), which refers to the question of leave (sub-section quoted). The whole holiday there is part of the assistant's annual leave, and that whole holiday is to count as eight hours of shop work. I think I understand what the Minister means. If one day of the 14 is taken casually, the Minister intends, I think, that that should count as eight hours of work. Suppose this state of affairs comes about: the holidays are taken not on a Monday, but in the middle of the week. Let us assume that the 14 days run from Wednesday until the following Wednesday week. Then, it appears to me that every one of these 14 days will count as eight-hour working days so far as part of the first week is concerned. If the holidays run from Tuesday, the assistant will have free Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday of that week, and these will count as eight-hour working days. I do not think that that is the Minister's intention. In the following week, they would not count in that way because he would be getting the whole of that week, but the days in the following week on which he would still be on holiday would count as eight hours because he would not be getting the whole of that week. I do not think that it was the Minister's intention that, if 14 days were taken consecutively, they should count as eight-hour working days for the week in which they occur.
Comment on this
I am not sure that I understand the Deputy properly. The difficulty we had to contend with was that the Bill prescribed, as a normal working week, a week of 48 hours. The question would then arise: What would happen in the week in which a shop assistant gets the whole period or gets two or three days of annual leave? Could the 48 hours be crowded into the remainder of the week — into three or four days or into five days. In order to deal with that situation, we had to fix, in relation to the day on which he gets leave, a number of hours in respect of which he could be said to have worked for the purpose of determining what the working week would be. A shop assistant who gets one day as a whole holiday, if he is working the normal working week, will work 40 hours in the other five days. If he works more he is entitled to overtime pay.
Comment on this
If an employee has a holiday, on that holiday, for purposes of calculation, he is assumed to have worked eight hours.
Comment on this
Take the case I put. He is working one day in the week and, for the other five days, he has holidays because he is taking his annual leave. As the section stands, that would count as 40 hours. The Minister says that the number of hours he works in the week will be taken as 48, and that 48 hours will have to be taken off the 216 hours in any period of four consecutive weeks. The period of hours is not confined to one week. It will come off the 216 hours in any period of four consecutive weeks and it will come off the 2,600 hours in a year. I do not think that that is the Minister's intention. I do not know whether the Minister appreciates the point I am endeavouring to explain. It is very difficult to explain it.
Comment on this
It is correct to say that the assistant will be deemed to have worked eight hours both for the purpose of sub-section (2), which deals with the ordinary working week, and for the purpose of sub-section (3), which deals with overtime. Otherwise, it would be possible to contemplate the possibility of a man getting five days' holidays in the week and being required to work 60 hours in one day.
Comment on this
I am not thinking of that. The time comes off the long period. If a man is allowed 14 consecutive days' holidays, commencing on a Monday, no trouble arises. Nothing is taken off the 216 hours for the 14 days' annual holiday and nothing is taken off the 2,000 hours. On the other hand, if the holiday begins on Tuesday then this section operates and the five days' holidays are to be counted as 40 hours, which will be taken off the 2,600 hours, so that there will be a considerable difference between the annual holiday beginning on a Monday and the annual holiday beginning on a Tuesday. That is what puzzles me.
Comment on this
I think that it is necessary to maintain that. It is necessary that eight hours in respect of every day's leave should be taken from the total number of hours he might work in four weeks because otherwise you would have a position where the whole of the four weeks of permitted overtime might be concentrated into two weeks. As a matter of fact, it could not be worked in that time, having regard to the overriding maximum of an 11-hour day.
Comment on this
In one case, the annual holiday will have to be taken off the 2,600 hours and in the other case it will not. Whether it will or not, will depend on what day of the week it commences.
Comment on this
May I direct the attention of the House to this aspect of the question: This Bill is intended to be a code which will rigidly bind every shop proprietor in the country and every breach of which will make him liable to the law. You have the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has been consulting his permanent officials, probably, for the last six months about this Bill; you have Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, a lawyer of wide experience; you have members of the Labour Party, who have probably consulted over this measure with their trade union officials, and it is abundantly clear that all of them find considerable difficulty in arriving at certainty, even after discussion, as to what the exact meaning of these provisions is.
Comment on this
I have listened to what took place between Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenny and the Minister. What are the feelings of the small shopkeeper in Collooney going to be when trying to keep within the law? He has three separate schedules to consider and a weekly modicum of hours of about six different periods in respect of each.
Comment on this
He would want to. Let me urge this on the House, that all the active participants in this legislation are men whose minds are principally bent on conditions obtaining in Dublin, Cork and the larger cities. Not a single one of them has turned his mind to conditions obtaining in rural Ireland, with the exception of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I do not deny that the other Deputies taking part in the debate are experts, probably, on shop conditions in cities but there is no analogy between conditions in city shops and in the rural areas.
Comment on this
That is why the Bill is necessary. The conditions being laid down in the Bill already obtain in the cities.
Comment on this
Then this Bill has been promoted fraudulently and falsely, because, as I understood, it was to remedy abuses where juvenile shop assistants were kept working endless hours in small shops in Dublin and neighbourhood.
Comment on this
We cannot have it both ways. If Deputy Heron says that conditions in Dublin are ideal, then we ought to know that the Bill was drafted to remedy abuses existing in the country, but not a single word has been said about that in the debate. If certain types of abuse exist in the country—and I am sure there might be abuses existing there—then this Bill has not been handled with an eye to conditions in the country. There are strict regulations as to the maximum number of hours that may be worked in a given week. My recollection is that either in this Bill or in the Shops (Hours of Trading) Bill there was some proviso that at certain seasons of the year there would be greater laxity in the matter of overtime. It appears from Section 18 that there is no differentiation between the Christmas season and any other season as to the maximum number of hours overtime that can be worked in a week. Nobody wants to have overtime unless it is necessary, and the employer has to pay his employees more for working overtime. But, suppose that Christmas falls on a Saturday, and that Monday and Tuesday are normal working days, when the assistants work eight hours, the country people would have only Wednesday, Thursday and Friday of that week for their Christmas shopping. All the work would be concentrated into three days. How are you going to get the work done if there is not sufficient overtime to keep the shelves filled? The thing cannot be done. Once you fix this no shopkeeper is going to make an assistant work overtime when it is not necessary. It seems to me to be an extremely imprudent thing to have the overtime hours as rigid as that in a country town. It simply will not work, and people will have to be sent home without their Christmas goods. There are those who say that that kind of objection can be offered to every reform of legislation. If I were making this objection in respect of the whole year round, or if I said that if shopkeepers in country towns were not allowed to remain open until 9 o'clock the people would not get what they wanted, I would agree with Deputy Heron that that is the kind of obstructive demurrer that might be offered to every piece of legislation. That is not the case I make. I am making the case that at Christmas these people have to wait for money to come from America, or from the Christmas fair, because they will not do their shopping until they have something to pay on account They get the money either from their children or from what they sell at the Christmas fair. It may be said that that is a bad system but you would have to abolish the whole credit system in rural Ireland if you want to do away with it. If you cannot meet the convenience of the people in respect of Christmas requirements real hardship will result. I do not blame the Minister for Industry and Commerce for feeling that that is not a valid objection, because he does not know anything about it. He was born in the City of Dublin and has lived all his life in it.
Comment on this
All I want the Minister to do, in the event of the section being passed, is that he would, in respect of rural Ireland, waive the overtime provision for Christmas week. I would not ask for more because I think Deputy Heron's objection then validly applies. If you try to go beyond that you will merely pander to stock objections of all sorts.
Comment on this
I am not making any case that would be absurd, and I am not suggesting that a shop should be open for 15 hours. No sane man would do so.
Comment on this
If the shelves of a shop are depleted of goods they have to be restocked for the Christmas fair. Otherwise the shopkeeper might have to tell customers on the day of the fair that he would supply them but had to stay in late the night before to get the goods. An employer could then tell his assistants to go home and take a good rest after the Christmas rush. It is a time that puts a very great strain on everyone concerned with the work. It is an emergency that arises once a year and seeing that shopkeepers and their assistants live out of the farmer for the 12 months, the least they can do is to convenience them after their exceptionally arduous work. That would not be too much to ask for the agricultural community.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy indicate the hours that he thinks reasonable for shop assistants to work on Christmas Eve? Would it be 13 hours, 14 hours, or 24 hours?
Comment on this
I think shop assistants and proprietors of shops in country towns during the Christmas season should be prepared to work as long as is necessary to provide customers with what they require.
Comment on this
Bear in mind that there is a provision in the Bill that after eight hours assistants must get overtime. What sane shopkeeper, whose profits depend upon the difference between his takings and his overhead expenses is going to permit his shop assistants to work one second longer than is vitally necessary to get stuff ready for sale the following day?
Comment on this
What shopkeeper is going maliciously to make assistants work longer than is vitally necessary to meet the profitable trade to be done the following day?
Comment on this
The Deputy said that shop assistants will not be asked to work longer than is necessary.
Comment on this
Casuistry can condemn or justify any case. There is no use taking a particular case. In my judgment if the convenience of the country demands that the requirements of the people be met before Christmas, then I think shop assistants and employers in rural Ireland ought to meet them. I am prepared to say that further than that the Legislature should not be prepared to make a concession. I do not believe that if you were to go round those benches and ask any single Deputy who knows rural conditions in Ireland to stand up that he will contradict what I say—not one, if they have the moral courage to say so. The next thing that I want to point out is that you prohibit all overtime for juveniles in this new section.
Comment on this
Very well, open your eyes to what you are doing, and do it in the knowledge of what you are doing.
Comment on this
The Minister stated five minutes ago that he was prohibiting all overtime for juveniles.
Comment on this
There is no use arguing about it now. I am not going to wrangle with the Deputy, who can read what was said in the Official Report. Whatever the Minister said, this Bill operates to prevent overtime for persons under 16 years of age. That may be right or it may be wrong, but at least open your eyes to what you are doing. That means that any boy who is serving his apprenticeship in a country shop must be sent off the premises at the end of his 48 hours in any given week. Either we believe in the apprenticeship system or we do not. There is a good deal to be said against the apprenticeship system; there is a good deal to be said for it. I believe it is a system which is capable of great abuse just as the boarding school system is capable of great abuse, or as most other human institutions are capable of abuse. On balance, I think that the system is a good system, and that it is a good method of getting a training for juveniles who will have to earn their living later in the ordinary way. But, if you categorically prohibit all work over 48 hours a week for the apprentice under 16 learning his trade, it means that in Christmas week — and mind you that is the week that is going to give rise to all the difficulty: the rest of the year may require adjustment, but it can be met—a certain proportion of your staff must be put off the premises and the remainder left there to get the work done.
Now, the ordinary well-organised establishment divides its work into certain routine duties for each section of the staff. The junior apprentices will be doing the simplest routine jobs. As they rise up and gain experience their responsibilities extend until the junior paid assistant is doing reasonably responsible work. If you have to put your apprentices out in the evening, and have to call upon your paid assistants to do the routine jobs that the apprentice normally does, it means that your whole organisation becomes chaotic. You are immensely hindered and involved in all kinds of difficulties that it is hard for the person who has not got practical experience of running a shop to understand. Here, again, I believe that this difficulty is going to arise almost exclusively during the Christmas season. I apprehend that if this difficulty is going to be left in its present form that, taken together with the other restrictions provided in the Bill, it will sooner or later abolish the apprenticeship system in every decent shop. Nobody who does not want to trade on his apprentices and abuse them will retain apprentices. I agree that the man who is deliberately misusing his apprentices — trying to make them do the work of salaried men — may find it worth his while to wind his way in and out of the provisions of this Bill, but the decent man who really wants to give his apprentices an honest, decent training will simply say that they are trouble enough as it is — that if on top of being responsible for the youngsters' moral and general upbringing and for teaching them their business, he has to comply with a pyramid of regulations he will say that it is not worth his while, and will clear out his apprentices altogether. It may be that the Legislature has made up its mind that it wants to do that. Very well, if you have made up your minds to do that, then, in the name of God, abolish the apprenticeship system altogether. This kind of thing will mean that the bad master will continue to take apprentices, and that the good master will chuck them. That is the worst thing that could happen. Abolish the system altogether if you want to do so now, but do not allow a situation to arise in which you will have to come back and abolish it in two or three years' time because you yourselves have created such abuses in connection with it that it is no longer possible to tolerate its continuance.
The new section also provides for time and a quarter, and this must be read in conjunction with Section 22, which is virtually unamended. Under Section 22, you provide that existing rates of wages must continue to be paid even though the terms and conditions have been improved and the hours shortened, and under this new section, you further provide that time and a quarter must be paid for any period over 48 hours which an employee works. That means that the employer who has pushed wages up to the last penny that he was able to afford to pay in existing conditions is now required to pay 25 per cent. on that high wage which he had fixed for his employees out of his own sense of duty before this Bill was ever heard of, whereas the sweater, who kept his men down to the lowest penny that he could persuade them to take, is only going to be required to pay 25 per cent. extra in consideration of the improved conditions provided for in this Bill. There are individuals whom I know who have honestly tried to squeeze out of their business the last penny that they could economically give their employees who, perhaps, are working 54 hours a week now as well as substantial overtime around the Christmas season. But making full allowance for all the profit that the shopkeeper was able to get on the basis of a 54-hour week and free overtime at Christmas, he was giving to his employees the last penny that he could afford. Let us assume that that is not only subjectively true for the shopkeeper but objectively true; in fact, that he was giving them the last penny his business could afford to pay. He is now called upon to shorten their hours and to raise these inflated wages by 25 per cent. in respect of every hour's overtime work.
But what is the position of the sweater next door who is paying the lowest rate of wages that he can persuade his employees to take? There is a nominal provision in the Bill that the Minister can fix rates of wages if called upon to do so, but the position of the sweater at present is that he need only pay time and a quarter extra on a sweated rate. That is simply not rational. It is penalising those who have tried to do their duty and is setting a premium on bad conduct in the past. The Minister may ask me, what do you propose to do? My answer is perfectly simple. It is that you cannot fix overtime rates if you do not fix wages. If you are going to provide by law that overtime must be paid for at time and a quarter, you must go on and fix minimum rates of wages for industry.
Comment on this
Yes, if done by an informed body: if done prudently and after careful inquiry with due regard to the circumstances surrounding the different trades involved. If you are going to have regulation on that scale, I will say "yes."
Comment on this
There is no need to remind me. I am not in the habit of making one speech in Athy and another in Dáil Eireann. What I am saying now will probably be published. My answer to that question, in the light of this body of regulations, is yes, provided it is done by an informed body who will really look into the difficulties and complications surrounding the situation. If you are going to fix overtime rates, you must fix a minimum wage, otherwise you set a premium on the bad employer and gravely penalise the man who is trying to do his duty.
Let me put this last point to the House. This is the kind of situation that is going to arise. You have provided that overtime must be paid on this time and a quarter rate. Take a merchant who has honestly been paying the maximum he can afford to pay on the basis of the present hours of work, and who has also provided his assistants with three weeks' holidays with full pay, instead of the fortnight provided for in the Bill. Is it contrary to the spirit of this Bill for that employer to say to his employees hereafter: "I am going to lay you off for a week in the summer, give you two weeks' holidays and a week off without pay, and when Christmas comes round, out of the pool created by laying off all the assistants for one week in summer, I will pay you the overtime you will earn by working overtime at Christmas"? If you are to take Section 22 literally, that is certainly contrary to the spirit of the Bill, but would it be all unreasonable thing to do? I do not think it would. I should like the Minister to speak honestly and tell us what he thinks.
Comment on this
The Minister need not be insolent and rude. If he finds that I have misunderstood the Bill, I think he will find that a lot of shopkeepers will not understand it better than I do.
Comment on this
They may suffer in silence. The Minister will surely recognise that there is some value in having somebody to talk to instead of civil servants. The Minister spends all his time talking to officials who have nothing else to do only to riddle the puzzles which he provides for the public, and the public have something else to do than trying to find out the puzzles put to them by the Minister. I speak largely as a citizen who knows a great deal about the conditions which are going to be affected by the Bill. I want information, and I think this is the time to put before the Minister and the House the difficulties that some of these regulations are going to create. I think it is a perfectly legitimate question to ask whether, in the light of Section 22 with its reactions on Section 18, it would be in the spirit of the legislation to gather a pool of money in the summer by giving a week's holiday without pay, laying off the assistants for a week without pay, and giving back that money to the assistants at Christmas in exchange for such overtime as they may work? I put three or four deliberate questions to the Minister and every Deputy interested, and I think they ought to be answered before you leave the amendment.
Comment on this
With regard to a great deal of what Deputy Dillon has said, I think that he answered himself when he said that this kind of objection is made to every measure the object of which is to give protection to any section of the community. In the main, I think that Deputy Dillon's case has been special pleading. In reference to this question of overtime during the Christmas rush period, I suggest to Deputy Dillon that, as the Bill stands, the shop assistants on Christmas Eve, or the day before Christmas Eve, could be kept at work for 13 hours, making an allowance of two hours for meals. I presume the Deputy would permit the assistants to eat during that period of 13 hours. They will be at work for 11 hours, but if you add on the two hours for meals, they will be actually on duty for 13 hours in one day. I suggest that it is long enough to be on duty from 9 in the morning until midnight. I suggest that that is long enough for any shop assistant to work on any day during the Christmas rush or any other day.
Comment on this
Well, from 9 in the morning until 10 at night or from 10 in the morning until 11 at night. Will the Deputy agree that that is long enough for any person to work on any day?
Comment on this
It is wrong, I think, for the Deputy to suggest that the Bill, as it now stands, is unreasonable in relation to Christmas trade conditions in country shops. That is my view. On the other question, the question of penalising the fair employer in the interests of the unfair employer, Deputy Dillon suggests that, having regard to the overtime provision in the Bill, the sweating employer will get his labour cheap and the good employer will be compelled to pay overtime rates. This portion of this section of the Bill purports to regulate hours and, in regulating hours, it is impossible to go into the question of what every individual employer is paying in wages at present. But I suggest to Deputy Dillon that the bad employer and the good employer will be relatively in the same position as before so far as the hour-fixing section of the Bill is concerned.
Comment on this
Suppose the bad employer is paying an assistant £2 a week for an eight-hour day and his good neighbour is paying £3 a week for an eight-hour day. One is a sweater and the other is a fair employer. The sweater's man works an hour's overtime and he gets time-and-a-quarter at the rate of 40/- a week. The good man's employee works an hour's overtime and he gets time-and-a-quarter at the rate of 60/- a week.
Comment on this
What is the alternative? Deputy Dillon, when asked for an alternative, suggested that wage-fixing machinery should accompany any hour-fixing machinery — that there should be a legal minimum wage. I, personally, am glad, and I am sure every member of the Labour Party is glad to hear Deputy Dillon say that. We believe that there ought to be a national minimum wage for all workers, including shop workers. But Deputy Dillon overlooked the fact that in the Bill there is provision for adjusting wages and the elimination of the bad employer. There is a section in the Bill which provides for the establishment of a wages board which will be given authority to fix wages. Surely that meets the objection made by Deputy Dillon. If it is the view of the Minister that, in a particular district, there are sweating employers taking the kind of advantage of this legislation which Deputy Dillon refers to, then a wages board can be established. The good employers and the shop assistants in a particular area can make representations to the Minister to have a wages board established to deal with the sweating employers.
Comment on this
Let us take an arbitrary figure, not binding ourselves to saying whether it is the right figure or not. Suppose the wages board meets and says that the minimum wage shall be 50/- in this area. Supposing the good employer says: "I have been able to afford £3." Why should he be required to pay overtime on the basis of £3 per week if the wages board fixes the wages at 50/-? He should not be. The Bill does not provide that, if you fix a minimum wage by the wages board, all the employers in the area will be entitled to pay overtime on the basis of that wage. They must go on paying on the basis of the wage they were paying when the Bill came into operation. That is what I say is wrong. I know many cases of agricultural employers who had not to change the wages at all, because the wages we were paying not only paid the agricultural labourer's wages, but we had a substantial sum in addition towards overtime if he worked 12 hours.
Comment on this
That is gratuitous. I know cases in which, even if the agricultural labourer worked 12 hours per day, he would not have earned enough overtime on the minimum wage to increase the wage he was entitled to.
Comment on this
Yes, if this House will fix minimum wages and let everybody pay on the same basis. If you are going to have this system of regulation, that is the best way, but you have no right to penalise a man who is trying to do his best as compared with the man who got away with it in the past.
Comment on this
I say that you should fix minimum standards if you are going to have a provision for overtime rates, and unless you do, you are going to penalise people who tried to pay a fair rate before there was any attempt to enforce it by law.
Comment on this
If I understand the Deputy's argument correctly, it is that unless there is a uniform wage fixed by law, there should be no payment for overtime.
Comment on this
I shall pass from that. Does Deputy Dillon seriously believe that a 48-hour week for juveniles without overtime is going to lead to the abolition of the apprenticeship system? Does any other Deputy believe that? I do not think so. As regards the Christmas week, there is a provision in the Bill for the exemption of special trades from the hours provisions in any special period. In the ordinary course remember Christmas does not fall on Monday. It only falls on Monday in one year in seven. Where it falls on a day in the middle of the week no difficulty will arise——
Comment on this
— because there will be adequate scope for overtime within the existing hours, subject to the overriding maximum of eleven hours per day which the Bill lays down. It may be necessary to make some additional provision in relation to that matter when Christmas day falls on a Monday.
Comment on this
If it falls on Friday or Saturday, there are five days during that week during which the overriding maximum of eleven hours per day can be worked. The maximum hours which can be worked are 55 in that week, and an assistant can work up to the limit provided by the Bill, on every day, without any alteration in the overtime provision. The only circumstances in which some alteration in the overtime provision might be necessary would be when Christmas Day falls on a Monday, and then only in relation to specific types of trades that might be affected, or perhaps only in special areas. I know that in Dublin it used to be the custom to remain open until one or two o'clock on the morning of Christmas day. That custom has now disappeared, except in relation to certain provision shops. I think most business establishments are closed down at 10 o'clock or 10.30. There may be special circumstances in rural areas, and power to deal with these special circumstances are taken in the Bill. When an Order is made under sub-section (7) or (8), which deals with the general exemption from the powers of the Bill, provision is made for consultation, but an Order can be made at any time to deal with a special problem arising in a special trade or in a special area. That can be used to deal with any special circumstances that may arise. It was mainly designed to meet with such special circumstances as might arise on some occasion such as the Eucharistic Congress when crowds might flock into one particular area and an unusual leniency in regard to hours might be called for.
Comment on this
The Minister began by being rude, and he then went on to show that the representations which I had made had some substance.
Comment on this
However, the reason that I suggest that you should suspend the provision for overtime in the Christmas week is this: It is no use in saying that during Christmas week you can work 11 hours per day. I do not want to work 11 hours on every day before Christmas. I only want to work eight hours on the day on which there is no particular reason to work more. Supposing I work a normal day on Monday, that my customers come in in crowds on Tuesday, and that the shelves are cleared. I then have got to fill the shelves for Wednesday's trade. How am I going to do it under the conditions laid down here? There is no use in telling me that if I had foresight to do it on Monday I would not be required to work late on Tuesday. I could not pile the stuff up on the floor. I would simply have got to wait until the shelves were cleared. Supposing you had a big reserve stock of sugar, and that after your shelves were cleared on Tuesday, you found that what the people had bought was currants, and you had plenty of sugar but no currants, what were you going to do?
Comment on this
I could not tell you. Let me say this as an employer. I can assure Deputy Heron of this, if I have to pay time and a quarter for overtime the assistants will not be allowed to work one second longer than is absolutely vitally necessary to get my shop ready for the following day's trade. There is no inducement to me at any time to detain them or keep them there.
Comment on this
I was waiting for that. I have been trying to get one of you to say that for the last ten minutes. Of course, in a place like Dublin you can get extra hands, but where am I to get extra hands in a country town?
Comment on this
Here is a Deputy who comes tumbling down from Skerries to talk about what is happening in County Mayo! If a shop assistant becomes unemployed in Ballaghaderreen, he does not go out and march up and down the street waiting for someone to call him in to a job. He goes home to his mother, and his mother may live away at Tourlestrane, or out on the side of a country road, perhaps 30 or 35 miles away. He, perhaps, tells some of his companions: "If you hear of a job will you send for me." During Christmas week, when I am called upon to deal with a sudden rush of customers, I cannot send a message to tell Paddy MacNulty, 30 miles away, that there is a job waiting for him, and even if I did succeed in sending him that message, it would cost him more to come in a car than he would get for that day's work. That is what I am trying to emphasise. The conditions in rural Ireland are quite different from those in Dublin and other large centres of population. In Dublin, in London and in other big centres in which I have worked myself there is a floating population of temporary labour always on tap, and they turn up every morning at the employment exchange. If you want ten, or even 50, or 100 hands, there are means of getting in touch with them overnight. That does not apply in rural Ireland. I agree with Deputy Heron that if we had recourse to a pool of that description all my case would fall to the ground. If it were possible to get extra help immediately I do not think I could argue for getting exemption for rural areas, but that difficulty is there, and we cannot surmount the difficulty by any other means. That is why I want the overtime provision to be waived for Christmas week. If the Minister evolves some plan, or can explain how a country shopkeeper could get a staff on the lines suggested by Deputy Heron, then the bulk of my objection falls to the ground. Of course, it is not possible to get such a staff. For that reason, I think the proper course here would be to waive the overtime provisions for Christmas week. If the representatives of the Labour Party or decent employers come to the conclusion that that gives rise to abuse, Parliament will still be sitting, and we can always come back to it and remedy that situation. The Labour Party have no reason to think that in this matter they are struggling against a hard-shelled, conservative and reactionary opposition. They are not. Every side of this House, the Government, the Opposition and all others, are anxious to provide a decent standard of living for the workingman in this country, and they have given ample evidence of that in the last two or three years. Let us not adopt tactics as if we were pushing against a conservative, reactionary majority, from whom we had to wring every concession. Everyone is anxious to lend a hand, and we should approach those problems in the knowledge that that is so.
Comment on this
I am interested in the case of business men who run hotels, refreshment houses and places of amusement in seaside and pleasure resorts, and I would ask the Minister what concession he can make with regard to employment in those areas — places which the workers themselves visit when they have ceased work. This employment is of a very seasonal character, and in all probability the workers would have to go elsewhere if they did not get this particular form of employment. It is a very serious matter for those people. Their profits are not very large, and I think this is a case where the Minister could perhaps see his way to make some concession.
Comment on this
Exemption in the matter of hours. The Minister might see his way to settle that particular difficulty. It has been represented to me that it is a very big one, and that those people cannot afford to pay for extra hours, or for a double staff which is probably what it would mean as the employment is very seasonal. This is a matter of some seriousness to those people, and I should like the Minister to try and find some method of dealing with this situation. I think, having regard to the fact that the workers themselves come down and visit those resorts after their work is done, something will have to be done to meet the situation, unless they are to be charged a very much higher figure for their entertainment. I am simply bringing this matter to the Minister's notice to see if he can do anything to remedy it.
Comment on this
I do not know if I can explain this matter any further. The Bill provides for a normal working week of 48 hours. It also permits of an employee being employed, subject to the payment of overtime, for 11 hours a day, up to 60 hours. It further makes provision for an order being made to deal with certain circumstances by regulations. I do not think it is possible to go further than the section proposes to go.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41: —
In page 11, line 29, Section 19 (1), to insert after the word "shop" the words "(other than a refreshment house)."
It was urged that this section which deals with employment in spells would not be applicable to the case of refreshment houses, and therefore this amendment proposes to remove refreshment houses from the scope of the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42: —
In page 11, before Section 19 (2), to insert the following two sub-sections: —
(2) The Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order under this sub-section amend in respect of shops (other than refreshment houses) of a specified class (defined in such manner and by reference to such things as the Minister thinks proper) in a specified area the provisions of sub-section (1) of this section relating to the number of spells into which the hours of employment of a member of the staff of a shop may be divided on any day, and the provisions of the said sub-section relating to the duration of the period between spells or both such provisions, and in that case so long as such order remains in force the said sub-section shall have effect in respect of such shops subject to such amendment.
(3) The Minister may by order under this sub-section amend or revoke any order made under this section (including this sub-section). Apart from the alteration of the section by the exclusion of refreshment houses, it is, I think, necessary to have a further safety valve, and this amendment is designed to make it possible for the Minister to make an order amending the sub-section in respect of any type of employment where it may be urged that such an amendment is required. From various representations made to me both by employers and labour organisations, there is a possibility that circumstances will arise in which strict application of the section would be undesirable, and consequently this power of amendment by order is, I think, a necessary provision.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44: —
In page 11, at the end of Section 19, to add a new sub-section as follows: —
(3) Nothing in this section shall apply to the business carried on at a railway bookstall on or adjoining a railway platform.
I think the Minister is admitting the principle of this amendment.
Comment on this
The provisions of Section 42 would make it possible to deal with the special circumstances of bookstalls by order if it were considered necessary to do so. There is something to be said for this amendment. I am not quite sure how much, and perhaps it might be more desirable to deal with the matter after inquiry than in the way suggested. It is believed that the hours of work in a railway bookstall, that is a bookstall on or adjacent to a railway platform, must depend fairly largely on the hours of arrival and departure of trains. Although in the case of some railways, the bookstalls remain open in the ordinary way of shops, in others they do not. I think on the whole — I do not know what the view of other Deputies would be — it might be as well to insert the amendment. I do not think it makes a lot of difference one way or another, but perhaps it would be safer to have it in.
Comment on this
It is obvious that is would be quite impossible to have a four-hour break, because the attendant will go away for an hour and then come back when a train comes in. We all know that railway bookstalls are shut up to a very few minutes before a train is due to arrive.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will leave the amendment over I should like the Parliamentary draftsman to have a look at the wording of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45: —
In page 11, line 35, Section 20 (1), to delete the words "subject to the provisions of this section."
This is merely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47: —
In page 11, to delete Section 21 (1) and substitute the following two new sub-sections:—
(1) The proprietor of a shop who employs any persons as members of the staff of that shop shall specify in a notice (in this Part of this Act referred to as an hours of work notice), which shall be in the prescribed form and be constantly kept posted in a prominent place in such shop where it may be conveniently read by such persons, the daily hours to be worked for the time being by such persons and the intervals for rest and meals to be allowed for the time being to such persons.
(2) The proprietor of a shop may from time to time substitute a new hours of work notice for an existing hours of work notice, but shall not do so unless, not less than forty-eight hours before such new hours of work notice comes into operation, he has informed each of the members of the staff of that shop, whose hours of work will be changed by such new hours of work notice, of his intention to so substitute a new hours of work notice and of the terms of such new hours of work notice.
This amendment deals with the notices of working hours. There was considerable criticism of the provisions of the section, and I admitted that the criticisms were justified. This amendment empowers the proprietor of a shop to substitute a new hours of work notice on 48 hours' notice. Some such provision is necessary, and I think that is the most reasonable provision.
Comment on this
Before we pass away from this amendment, Sir, there is a point which I should like to raise.
Comment on this
Let us suppose that, in amendment No. 49, provision is made for a certain emergency; might not a sudden emergency arise also in connection with amendment No. 47? Suppose somebody gets sick, it might be necessary to change that matter of the 48 hours' notice in connection with the conditions of another employee.
Comment on this
I do not think it does deal with it. Amendment No. 47 deals with the putting up of the notice. The person's hours must be put up and those hours cannot be changed without 48 hours' notice.
Comment on this
As far as I can see, there is no provision dealing with a certain emergency in amendment No. 47. Amendment No. 49 deals with the hours during which the person concerned actually works, but it does not deal with the putting up of the notice.
Comment on this
I think it would be necessary for the Minister to put in some words such as "certain emergency" to qualify that 48 hours' notice, so that if something happens suddenly, the hours can be changed without 48 hours' notice.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy is right. In amendment No. 49 it is provided that, where a proprietor of a shop is charged with an offence in connection with amendment No. 47, which will now be a section of the Bill, it shall be a good defence for him to prove that the alleged contravention was rendered necessary by reason of illness amongst the members of the staff or other unforeseen causes.
Comment on this
May I point out to the Minister that, where the proprietor is charged with an offence under this section there is a safeguard, but that that is a new section. I am quite sure it is the Minister's intention to provide a safeguard, and I am only pointing out what I think is an oversight.
Comment on this
Is it the Deputy's point that, if the proprietor is charged with failure to exhibit the notice, there is no safeguard?
Comment on this
No. It is the matter of substitution. I am referring to sub-section 2, in connection with amendment No. 47, where it says that the proprietor of a shop may from time to time substitute a new hours of work notice for an existing hours of work notice, but shall not do so unless, not less than 48 hours before such new hours of work notice comes into operation, he has informed each of the members of the staff, and so on, of his intention to so substitute a new hours of work notice. Let us suppose that there is this case of sudden illness, or some such cause, and the employer has got to get workman "A" to do the work which workman "B" would do ordinarily. He cannot do that because he has workman "A" working during times which are different from the times of his notice, and he cannot change that without 48 hours' notice. I suggest that, in the case of a sudden emergency, the employer should be allowed to change the notice immediately and the employee could work his new hours during that particular day and then return to the other conditions under which he is covered.
Comment on this
I do not think the change of notice is of very great importance if, in fact, the man is allowed to work in other times than those specified in the notice.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 48 deals with the contravention of the requirements, and amendment No. 49 deals with the obligation on proprietors of shops to observe the hours of work specified in the notice. Amendment No. 49 also says that where the proprietor of a shop is charged with an offence under this section, it shall be a good defence for him to urge that the doing so was rendered necessary by reason of illness among the members of the staff or other unforeseen cause; so that, in fact, in the case of illness or other unforeseen cause, it is possible for him, without being subject to penalty, to work assistants at hours without the notice specified.
Comment on this
The Minister may be correct, but I understood that amendment No. 48 dealt with the commission of an offence.
Comment on this
The only offence that would arise under amendment No. 47 is that of failing to exhibit the notice.
Comment on this
But surely a false notice would be an offence, and it becomes a false notice if you have a man working at a time in which he should not be working?
Comment on this
I am not pressing the point, but I want to draw the Minister's attention to what appears to be an oversight, and I am sure the Minister will try to deal with the point.
Comment on this
I think it is an offence to show a false notice. That is dealt with under an earlier section — one that the Minister amended yesterday.
Comment on this
Oh, no. I think it would be under amendment No. 23, which deals with the exhibiting of a false notice. The exhibiting of a false notice, I think, would be an offence, and it becomes a false notice if the man concerned is working at a wrong time.
Comment on this
Well, is not that a record? I take it that a record is anything that is written down. However, it certainly appears to me that there should be some proviso here to meet the case I have in mind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:—
In page 11, lines 53 and 54, Section 21 (2), to delete the words "fails to comply with the requirements" and substitute the words "acts in contravention (whether by commission or omission)".
This is really consequential. The point about the other amendment is that a proprietor can commit an offence by way of omission as well as by way of commission in the manner in which the section is now framed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49: —
In page 12, before Section 22, to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) It shall not be lawful for the proprietor of a shop to require any member of the staff of that shop to do shop work for him during any hours on any day other than the hours of work specified for that day in respect of such member in the hours of work notice for the time being in force relating to that shop.
(2) If the proprietor of a shop acts in contravention of this section, such proprietor shall be guilty of an offence under this section.
(3) Where the proprietor of a shop is charged with an offence under this section it shall be a good defence to such charge for such proprietor to prove to the satisfaction of the court before which such offence is tried that the alleged contravention of this section was rendered necessary by reason of illness amongst the members of the staff of that shop or other unforeseen cause.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will have to agree that there is a difficulty with regard to that word "require". That means practically the same thing as "compel", and it might be said by a proprietor as a defence, "I did not require the man to work, but he came to me and offered to work." I think that is a matter for examination.
Comment on this
There is one point to which I should like to refer—I am not sure whether it arises on amendment No. 49 or amendment No. 47 — and that is the question of overtime. Is it held that, in amendment No. 47 the daily hours to be worked are the ordinary hours, exclusive of overtime?
Comment on this
Well, is there any-anything that says so, or is it just the opinion of the Minister? It appears to me that, if the daily hours are the ordinary hours, exclusive of overtime, there would be an offence under amendment No. 49 during that overtime. I do not think it is specified anywhere in the Bill that the daily hours of work are those exclusive of overtime.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any possibility of that misunderstanding arising. However, I shall have the point examined. I think the fact that the requirement specified that the daily hours should be worked indicates the normal hours to be worked, outside of overtime. However, I shall look into the matter.
Comment on this
This is not quite so easy as in the Conditions of Employment Act, where the daily time is not laid down because there they can put down any hours at all really, provided they do not tot up to more than 48.
Comment on this
And then there is the balance of 12 hours. However, I do not know that it is going to be of much help to the Minister, having those records, because the matter is so variable, and there are powers to vary it.
Comment on this
They were in Section 18, which has now gone — dealing with the number of hours per day.
Comment on this
That is so. I think that the term "hours of work" will be regarded as relating only to the hours exclusive of the hours worked at overtime. That is what the Deputy has in mind. I will look into the section on that point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50: —
In page 12, line 9, Section 22 (1), to insert after the word "reward" the words "(excluding overtime pay and any payments made for commencing work earlier or finishing work later than other members of the staff of such shop employed in similar work)".
The section is designed to preserve, as far as possible, the existing wages despite any reduction effected by the Bill. The Bill is intended to ensure that any abnormal wages such as for overtime will not be taken into consideration for the purpose of this section. The amendment is intended to make it clear that we are preserving only the normal earnings apart from any additional payment for the time referred to.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:—
In page 12, line 24, Section 22 (1), to insert after the word "earnings" the words "(excluding overtime pay and any payments made for commencing work earlier or finishing work later than other members of the staff of such shop employed in similar work)".