Shops (Conditions of Employment) Bill, 1937—Recommittal (Resumed).
Contributions 179–352 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I think a further improvement could be made in that. I think the words "after such commencement" should come after the word "amount" in line 51. At the moment I think it is an involved sentence and that that change would improve it considerably.
Comment on this
I think the same consideration does not arise in respect of a railway bookstall in relation to Part IV of the Bill as in relation to Part III.
Comment on this
I do not think it can be regarded as a special trading establishment. They get different kinds of holidays and different protection in respect of the half-holiday and the rest of it. The simplest arrangement would be to regard those railway bookstalls in the same way as refreshment houses. I will consider the point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:—
In page 13, line 55, Section 25, to delete the words "any form of" and substitute the word "doing."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55: —
In page 14, at the end of Section 27, to insert two new sub-sections as follows: —
(3) The Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order under this sub-section amend in respect of any specified area, sub-section (1) of this section in any one or more of the following ways, that is to say:—
(a) by substituting, for the day which is a public holiday by virtue of paragraph (b) of the said sub-section (1), the 1st day of January, or the 6th day of January.
(b) by substituting for Easter Monday, Ascension Thursday,
(c) by substituting for Whit Monday, the Feast of Corpus Christi or the 29th day of June,
(d) by substituting for the first Monday in August, the 15th day of August,
and whenever any such order is made in respect of any specified area, then, so long as such order remains in force, sub-section (1) of this section shall have effect in relation to any shops in such area subject to such amendment.
(4) The Minister may by order under this sub-section amend or revoke any order made by him under this section (including this sub-section).
This is a question of the substitution of public holidays by Church holidays. I would be strongly opposed to making it optional on the employer to substitute Church holidays for public holidays. It is a fact that in certain parts of the country the ordinary practice is to observe Church holidays and not public holidays; all shops and businesses close down on Church holidays and keep open on public holidays. This amendment is taking power by order to alter the practice in such areas. If we are to have an alternative day to the public holiday it will be an alternative day for everybody. It seems to me that if there is to be enforcement at all, and also in order to secure reasonable opportunity of having an enjoyable holiday, that we must have a uniform practice in every part of the country and not allow any individual discretion in the matter. In some parts of the country the Church holiday is probably the best business day of the year and it would be a considerable hardship upon employers if their shops were to be closed. In the diocese of Ferns the very reverse to what happens elsewhere is the case. Even if we were to compel the shops to close on public holidays in that area the people would still close on Church holidays and no business would be done on these days. This amendment gives us power to bring the law into conformity with the practice in an area like that.
Comment on this
In the West of Ireland the country people all flock into the towns on Church holidays and the ordinary country churches are empty while the churches in the town are full. That happens all over the West of Ireland.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56: —
In page 14, at the end of Section 27, to add the following new sub-section: —
(3) Save as is otherwise provided by this Act, it shall not be lawful for the proprietor of a shop to permit any member of the staff of that shop to do shop work on any day which is a public holiday for the purpose of this section.
The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that it is unlawful to work on a public holiday. I do not think that it is clearly stated in any part of the Bill that it is unlawful to work on a public holiday. The amendment safeguards the exceptions.
Comment on this
The Bill is not designed to make it illegal to work on public holidays. What the Bill does is to provide that those who are employed during a public holiday must get another day in substitution for the public holiday. It does not propose to prohibit employment on public holidays. We must protect the interests of the individual and provide that if he works on a public holiday he must get another holiday instead. No uniform regulation is possible that would apply equitably in all parts of the country.
Comment on this
It would be very unpleasant for the employee if he were to go on a holiday himself and find himself in a town where, because of some provision in the Bill, he would be allowed to have no food. I am not aware that refreshment houses are excluded.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:—
In page 14, at the end of Section 28, to insert the following new sub-section:—
(3) In this section the expression "salary or wages" shall in relation to the member of the staff of a shop be construed as excluding overtime pay and any payment made for commencing work earlier or finishing work later than other members of the staff of such shop employed in similar work.
This amendment provides that in calculating the payment for such holidays, previous earnings should not be taken into account, that is earnings for, say, overtime or anything of an abnormal kind. It is the ordinary normal week's pay that must be taken as the basis.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:—
In page 14, at the end of Section 28, to add the following new sub-section: —
(3) For the purpose of this section the expression "salary or wages" shall include in the case of a member of the staff of a shop to whom annual leave is allowed who, immediately before the commencement of such annual leave was entitled to receive as part of his remuneration either board or lodgings or both board and lodgings such allowance in respect thereof as is determined by the Shop Wages Board in respect to the district in which the shop is situated to be the cash value of such board or lodgings or board and lodgings as the case may be.
This amendment is designed to ensure that board and lodgings shall be taken into consideration when paying for holidays. The Minister is aware that in trade agreements this has been done. It is necessary that board and lodgings should be taken into account in calculating salary or wages.
Comment on this
The proposal in the amendment seems equitable but I do not see how we are going to enforce it. I do not think it would be possible for the Shop Wages Board to deal with that question, district by district, having regard to the circumstances prevailing in different districts. If we could take a purely arbitrary figure and say that that shall be regarded as an allowance in respect of board and lodging, it would be the nearest we could get to it.
Comment on this
If we were to try to insert a figure in the Bill it would have to be a figure which would be equitable in all cases, even though it might be less than what would be the practice in certain trades in some areas.
Comment on this
The Minister recognises that, as the Bill stands, a shop assistant, part of whose remuneration consists of board and lodging, would actually lose that and it would not go into his holiday pay.
Comment on this
Will the Minister meet the point by putting down an amendment himself at a later stage?
Comment on this
This appears to be an equitable amendment and I will support it. I quite see that in every case the value of the support of a man could hardly come before the Shop Wages Board. There is a difficulty in that, but it seems to me that in most cases you would probably get an agreed figure between the employer and employee. I think if the principle were embodied in the Bill it could be worked out. What I suggest now is rather tentative, but what occurs to me is that we might indicate such a figure as the employer and employee would agree upon as the value of his support and, in default of agreement, I would suggest, not the Shop Wages Board, but the ordinary district court.
Comment on this
There are difficulties in determining what constitutes board and lodging and in making provision for a person who has board or part board, or board and lodging or part board and lodging. I think the best way to deal with it would be upon some percentage basis of the cash earnings, so that there will be no room for disagreement. The possibility of a large number of cases going to the district court or to the Shop Wages Board does not appeal to me. I would prefer to have an arbitrary arrangement so that where he has board and lodging he will get his cash earnings plus a percentage.
Comment on this
Yes, on board and lodgings and perquisites. The same thing could be done here, whether by the Minister or the wages board would be a matter for future consideration. We are mainly concerned to ensure that there will be some value given to board and lodgings and that the employee on holiday will get compensation in his wages for the loss of that.
Comment on this
If the Deputy agrees to leave the matter over, I will see what I can produce on the next stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 14, before Section 29, to insert the following new section: —
So much of this Part of this Act as relates to annual leave of members of staffs of shops and pay in respect of annual leave shall apply in respect of railway refreshment-car attendants, and for the purposes of such application —
(a) a railway refreshment-car attendant shall be deemed to be a member of the staff of a special — trade shop, and
(b) the railway company by which a railway refreshment-car attendant is employed shall be deemed to be the proprietor of a special-trade shop.
This amendment is designed to secure that railway refreshment-car attendants will be entitled to an annual holiday under this part of the Bill.
Comment on this
All the railway refreshment-car attendants get is an annual holiday; there is no provision for a half-holiday?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I believe they get it and there will probably be no trouble, but there is no actual provision for a half-holiday.
Comment on this
We are bringing them into the Bill to this extent, that we are giving them 14 days' annual leave.
Comment on this
I went into the matter carefully and I am sure the Deputy will appreciate some of the difficulties. We may have to deal with them separately. I ascertained that if we were to give them a half-holiday, we might be doing the attendants a considerable injustice, because they could not get the half-holiday except at the other end of the line. For instance, a man starting out in the morning for Cork would have to have his half-holiday in Cork, and possibly he might have to stay in Cork overnight.
Comment on this
Quite so, but that would be a very poor kind of half-holiday. Their conditions of work are such that they cannot be brought into the Shops Bill, whatever other Bill they may be brought into.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:—
In page 15, before Section 29 (3), to insert the following four new sub-sections: —
(3) Where the period of annual leave allowed to a member of the staff of a non-special-trade shop falls wholly within one week neither sub-section (1) nor sub-section (2) of this section shall apply in respect of that week.
(4) Where the period of annual leave allowed to a member of the staff of a Sunday-trading shop falls wholly within two weeks, neither sub-section (1) nor sub-section (2) of this section shall apply in respect of those weeks.
(5) Where the period of annual leave allowed to a member of the staff of a non-special-trade shop falls within two weeks, sub-sections (1) and (2) of this section shall apply only in respect of such one of those weeks as the proprietor of such shop may select, and the day specified in a notice under the said sub-section (2) in the week so selected shall not be a day which falls within such period of annual leave.
(6) Where the period of annual leave allowed to a member of the staff of a Sunday-trading shop falls within three weeks, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say: —
(a) neither sub-section (1) nor sub-section (2) of this section shall apply in respect of the second of those weeks,
(b) sub-sections (1) and (2) of this section shall apply only in respect of such one of the first or third of those weeks as the proprietor of such shop may select and the day specified in a notice under the said sub-section (2) in the week so selected shall not be a day falling within such period of annual leave.
Section 29 provides for a half-holiday each week to the staffs of a non-special-trade shop or a Sunday-trading shop. This amendment seeks to ensure that a worker will not be entitled to an extra half-day in respect of any week during which he had leave and, if such leave covers part of two consecutive weeks, the employer may not appoint one half-holiday in such a way that it falls on a day during which the assistant is on leave. A similar provision is made in cases where the workers are entitled to 14 days' consecutive leave and the leave might be spread over three weeks. It is a fairly cumbersome amendment, but that is the effect of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:—
In page 15, at the end of Section 29, to insert the following new sub-section: —
In this Part of this Act the expression "statutory half-holiday" means a day on which a half-holiday is allowed in pursuance of this section.
The definition is supposed to be inserted here for the purpose of amendment No. 63.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62: —
In page 16, Section 31 (1), to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following paragraph: —
(b) in case such member does shop work for more than two hours but not more than four hours, a half-holiday.
The Bill as it stands provides that where an assistant works four hours on Sunday he is entitled to a half-day, and if he works more than four hours he is entitled to a whole day. Deputies will recollect the case made on behalf of the chemists. I have been considering the representations made by them, and I think it is not unreasonable to provide that where a member of the staff works for not more than two hours on Sunday the obligation to provide a holiday or half-holiday in lieu should not apply. That is the effect of the amendment. Where the assistant works not more than two hours, no consequences arise. Where he works more than two hours and not more than four hours he becomes entitled to a half-day in lieu of the Sunday work. If he works more than four hours he becomes entitled to a whole day. That meets the representations made on behalf of the chemists, and I think it is not an unreasonable provision.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63: —
In page 16, before Section 31 (2), to insert the following new sub-section: —
(2) Where —
(a) a member of the staff of a shop is entitled in any week to a half-holiday under this section. and
(b) the proprietor of such shop allows such member a whole holiday on the day in such week which is in respect of such member a statutory half-holiday,
such proprietor shall be deemed to have allowed such member a half-holiday under this section on that day.
Shop assistants generally are entitled to a half-day a week, and in certain cases they will be entitled to another half-day as compensation for Sunday work. The amendment provides that the granting of one whole day in the relevant week will discharge the responsibility for giving two half-days. The amendment provides that this shall be given on the statutory half-holiday. That is why the statutory half-holiday was defined in amendment No. 61.
Comment on this
I thought that was in the Bill already. I thought you could have two half-holidays on the same day.
Comment on this
That could not have been done because the half-holiday defined in the Bill was for the second part of the day.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64, on behalf of Deputy Norton:—
In page 16, line 50, Section 33 (1), to delete the word "six" and substitute the word "twelve".
The purpose of the amendment is to provide a minimum of 12 days' holidays instead of six, as the Bill provides. It has been a well-established practice in shops in the cities and in the larger towns, at any rate, as long as I remember, to allow shop assistants a fortnight's holidays or 12 working days' holidays in the year, apart from bank holidays. I think that the Minister will recognise that that is the practice at present in Dublin City and most of the larger towns. I happen to know that, even in the smaller centres, there are existing agreements in a great many cases between shop assistants' organisations and local shopkeepers or shopkeepers' organisations providing, amongst other things, for a continuous holiday of 12 days during the summer leave period. As the purpose of this Bill is to protect the unorganised shop workers, I think that what is a well-established practice should be accepted as the standard for minimum conditions in this Bill. I, therefore, appeal to the Minister to accept 12 days instead of six days as the leave period.
Comment on this
I intimated on Committee Stage that this was one of the provisions of the Bill upon which the Government had made up its mind and by which it must stand. We are only providing for a statutory minimum. In so far as trade unions have secured agreements providing for longer holidays, these agreements will stand. There is nothing in this Bill to invalidate or upset these agreements in any way. We merely fixed the statutory period as one week. When we shall have that one week generally recognised and accepted as a normal feature of employment, then we can consider moving forward. At that time, I think we should try to move forward in a uniform way in respect of all employments. So long as there is a minimum statutory period provided in the case of industrial employment, the same minimum should apply here and in all employments and the possibility of increasing that period can be considered later. For many employers, this is a not inconsiderable expense and a new expense. They have not become accustomed to it and it will be some time before people will come to regard this annual holiday arrangement as a normal and natural provision. When that occurs, we can consider lengthening the period but, at the moment, we have done as much as we should do in fixing a statutory period of one week.
Comment on this
If this amendment provided for a 12-day period for all employees, I might not be in entire agreement with it, but when we are dealing with shop assistants specifically, we are dealing with people who are a race apart. They generally live away from home, either in "digs" or on their employers' premises. They have to work on Saturday night until the shop closes. Their six-day holiday would, therefore, start on Sunday morning or late on Saturday night. As travelling facilities are not as good on Sundays as on week-days, the assistant has to stay in his place of employment or in the town on Sunday, with the result that his holidays are reduced to four or five days out of the six. In order to resume work on the following Monday morning, he has to travel on Saturday, owing to lack of facilities on Sunday, so that he has really only Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday as a holiday.
When I moved this amendment on Committee Stage, I intimated that it was only giving legislative sanction to what was already the general practice. I think the Minister was inclined to disagree with that and say that he had not heard of it. Since then, I have made a great many inquiries and I have ascertained that this practice is nearly universal in the country and, particularly, in the larger towns. Numerous agreements have been made providing for 12 days' holidays. The City of Dublin is chock full of these agreements and, even in Mullingar and elsewhere throughout Southern Ireland, it is the practice. In view of the fact that the shop assistant generally lives away from home, there is a strong case to be made for special treatment in his case.
Comment on this
We could argue this problem for a month, but it is a matter on which argument is not much use.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister recognise that it is the established custom of the trade to give a fortnight's holidays and that that was so before there was much trade union organisation or legislation?
Comment on this
Outside certain trades in certain areas, I do not think it is an established custom. In so far as it is the custom, we are not interfering with it.
Comment on this
So far as I am aware, it is the established custom in all shops, even in rural Ireland, to provide 14 days' holidays for assistants where more than one assistant is employed.
Comment on this
I am anxious to get the statutory provisions relating to all classes of workers on a uniform basis. Otherwise, there will be a certain amount of uneasiness and unrest which will make it more difficult to secure uniform development.
Comment on this
Up to the present, the law provided for no holidays and yet you had the universal practice, as we are told, of giving 14 days' leave. On that basis we should go to three weeks.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65: —
In page 16, before Section 33 (2), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Where in any employment year the proprietor of a special-trade shop has allowed or purposes to allow any member of the staff of such shop a whole holiday on one or more of the public holidays enumerated in Section 27 of this Act such proprietor may deduct a corresponding number of whole holidays from the 14 consecutive whole holidays specified in paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) of this section and such proprietor shall be deemed to have complied with the provisions of this section in such employment year when he allows such member of the staff of such shop the reduced number of consecutive whole holidays.
While there are plenty of special-trade shops which keep busy on bank holidays, there is a smaller class of special-trade shops which cater for the business community to which that does not apply. The Minister is probably aware that a certain number of shops in Dublin serve meals for a number of the business community. When a bank holiday comes along, these shops shut up. If they kept open, none of their customers would put in an appearance. I am sure that there are similar places in other centres. My amendment proposes that on days on which these shops would do no business, they can close up, allow their assistants a holiday, same as the business community, and deduct these holidays so given from the 14 days leave.
Comment on this
I admit the force of the Deputy's argument but, having examined the matter, I am satisfied that the amendment would introduce such a complication of the Bill as not to be worth while. It is probably true of all shops that there are days in the year when they could shut up because there is no business to be done. If we were to allow these shopkeepers to spread the annual leave of their assistants over these individual days, we would destroy the whole principle of annual leave. These shops are permitted to keep open on public holidays and to employ their assistants. Because there is no business to be done, they do not avail of that permission. I suppose there is hardly a shop in the country which would not find itself precisely in that position on some one day in the year. This proposal is all very well from the point of view of the proprietors but, from the point of view of the assistants, it is obviously undesirable that the proprietor should have the right to give the assistant his annual leave not in a consecutive number of days but in individual days throughout the year. I do not think I could agree to the amendment, even though, when argued from the Deputy's point of view, there appears to be something to be said for it.
Comment on this
Possibly the Minister has overlooked the point. I am suggesting this only in respect of bank holidays.
Comment on this
I thought the Minister was arguing in respect of ordinary days, and with that I should entirely agree. There are certain days when the proprietor would find himself doing no business, and it would be obviously unfair that he should be allowed to say: "We will shut up to-day and take one day off your leave." Why should the Minister arbitrarily put these people into a class to which they do not belong? That is the point I am making. They take their business from the business community and they serve the business community. On a public holiday the majority of the refreshment houses are serving holiday-makers and that is what makes them busy and that is why you want them to keep open. It would be obviously absurd to insist on a refreshment house keeping open on a public holiday when it can do no business. I can understand the Minister's point of view. He does not want a special-trade shop to be allowed to dodge from one class to the other, but I think that with certain safeguards which the Minister could very easily draw up they might be allowed to do that.
I think the Minister will realise that in the working of Acts such as this there should be a certain amount of flexibility. I do not want that flexibility to be used for the purpose of evasion, but I submit that it is merely bringing the Act into ridicule to ask a person to keep open on a day on which he can do no business at all. It is not a question of his getting up in the morning and discovering that he cannot do business on that particular day, which was what I rather thought the Minister was suggesting. I should like the Minister to look into this matter and to see whether, with proper safeguards, this question could not be further dealt with. The Minister will appreciate my point when I say that there are special-trade shops which come into a different category. Although they are special-trade shops, they come into the category of ordinary business houses. They open and close with them. That is the point I wanted to make.
Comment on this
In admitting the force of that argument, I have, nevertheless, to plead the extraordinary complication which it would introduce into the Bill if we were to attempt to distinguish between shops, not merely by reference to the nature of the trade they do, but to the character of their clients. That, I think, is what Deputy Dockrell is suggesting. We take these restaurants and refreshment houses, and put them in a special category, and recognising what the ordinary circumstances under which they carry on their business are, we give them certain special provisions different from those applying to ordinary shops. The Deputy wants us to go further. He asks us to divide these restaurants and refreshment houses into two classes according to the general character of their clients. I do not think we could do that without introducing very great complications into the Bill and creating the risk of weakening its enforcement and permitting the evasion to which the Deputy has referred. The inspector, or whoever might be charged with its enforcement, cannot easily distinguish between one type of refreshment house and another. The net result of the position in which these shops find themselves because of the provisions of the Bill is that they are obliged to give 14 days' consecutive leave instead of seven. I think we have to leave it at that as the easiest way of adapting the Bill to the circumstances of the trade.
Comment on this
We seem to be at cross purposes. The amendment says: —
Where in any employment year the proprietor of a special-trade shop has allowed or purposes to allow any member of the staff of such shop a whole holiday on one or more of the public holidays enumerated in Section 27 of this Act such proprietor may deduct a corresponding number of whole holidays from the 14 consecutive whole holidays....
I am not asking that their assistants should be allowed less than 14 days, because I quite agree with the Minister that they are refreshment houses, and that is the law for them. What I am suggesting is that the Minister, with all due respect to him, is doing something really absurd in asking people to keep open on a day when they do no business, or to shut up and pay their assistants on a day on which they earn no money. I do not want to put them in any better or worse position than other refreshment houses. I merely want a certain amount of flexibility and I suggest that, with proper safeguards, it could be worked. I do not know whether a notice in the shop or the special advising of somebody would satisfy the Minister. I am not seeking to assist evasion, but the Minister will see that there is undoubted hardship in relation to this limited class which does a special trade and which is tied up with the business community.
Comment on this
I am sure it is the experience of every shop proprietor that there are days when he has to open his shop and pay his assistants while he does no business. I do not think it is possible to deal with these cases in the manner the Deputy suggests. I think it would be impossible to keep cheek on them. We can distinguish between shops according to the class of business they do—a restaurant from a drapery shop and a drapery shop from a railway bookstall —but to distinguish between shops and to make different provisions because of the general character of their clients would be an impossible task, and that is what the Deputy is suggesting. The net result of the position is that the proprietors of these shops are entitled to keep their shops open on bank holidays. If they do not do so because they are not likely to do any business, that is their concern, but it does not exempt them from the obligation of giving annual leave to an employee.
Comment on this
Will the Minister keep an open mind in case an amendment that would satisfy him is suggested between this and the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66: —
In page 18, to delete Section 33 (7).
This has to be taken in connection with amendment No. 67. Section 33 (7) made it illegal for a shop assistant on leave to work in another shop, and amendment No. 67 provides that a shop assistant may not assist in or do any industrial work on any day on which he is allowed a whole holiday or on any half-day he is allowed a half-holiday. Amendment No. 67 also provides that any shop assistant acting in contravention of the section will be guilty of an offence. That amendment was suggested during the course of the Committee Stage discussions.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67: —
In page 20, before Section 36, but in part IV, to insert the following new section: —
(1) It shall not be lawful for a member of the staff of a shop to do for any other person for reward any shop work or industrial work—
(a) at any time on any day on which he is allowed under this Act a whole holiday, or
(b) on any day on which he is allowed under this Act a half-holiday, after the time at which such half-holiday commences.
(2) If a member of the staff of a shop acts in contravention of this section, such member shall be guilty of an offence under this section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:—
In page 22, at the end of Section 41, to insert the following new sub-section: —
(2) Where an agreement has been signed (whether before or after the passing of this Act) by or on behalf of a body or bodies substantially representative, in the opinion of the Minister, of proprietors of shops of a particular class in a particular area and by or on behalf of a body or bodies substantially representative, in the opinion of the Minister, of a particular class of members of the staffs of such shops whereby rates of salary, wages or other reward payable to such members are regulated or restricted, and such agreement is sent to the Minister by one or more of the parties thereto, with a request that it may be referred to the board under this sub-section, the Minister may, in his discretion, either refer or refuse to refer such agreement to the beard, and, if the Minister so refers such agreement to the board, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say —
(a) the board shall hold an investigation into the subject matter of such agreement, but shall before commencing such investigation publish in some newspaper circulating in such area, a notice specifying their intention to hold such investigation and inviting interested parties to submit evidence, and shall consider any evidence so submitted;
(b) on the conclusion of such investigation, the board shall do one of the following things, that is to say: —
(i) make, subject to the provisions of this Act, rules fixing minimum rates of wages (which shall be the same as the rates of wages specified in such agreement) for such class, as the board thinks proper and specifies in such rules, of members of staffs of shops of such class, as the board thinks proper and specifies in such rules, situate in such area as the board thinks proper and specifies or delimits in or by such rules, or
(ii) report to the Minister that in their opinion it is not expedient to make such rules.
The question of existing wages agreements was raised for discussion on the Committee Stage and I intimated my intention of making some provision in relation to them in this part of the Bill. We are setting up a shop wages board for the purpose of fixing minimum wages, subject to confirmation by the Minister. This amendment provides that where an agreement, whether made before or after the passing of the Act, has been made between representative bodies, and such agreement is sent to the Minister by one or other of the parties, the Minister may refer that agreement to the board, and the board may make rules fixing the minimum rates of wages for the classes of shops in the area specified by the board, or may report to the Minister that in their opinion it is not expedient to make such rules. The amendment is put in that way, as generally speaking it may be inadvisable to apply it to all shops in an area selling a certain class of goods the terms of such agreement. Furthermore, as Deputies are aware, the Agreement Wages Register adopted under the Conditions of Employment Act of 1936 has not proved operative. It is not easy to discover why it has not operated, the only explanation being that there are reasons which are not apparent on the surface while, on the other hand, minor changes in the agreement cannot be made to make registration possible. As some Deputies are aware, some agreements were presented for registration but could not be accepted because of minor defects, such as the defect of having no definite provision for its duration. The Act provided that agreements must be expressed to operate for not less than one year. Some of the agreements sent for registration could not be registered merely because they had not that provision, and yet no change was made in the terms of the agreement to make registration possible. Some agreements had to be rejected as they covered matters other than rates of wages. I am having that section of the Conditions of Employment Act considered in consultation with parties likely to be interested in the amendment. If possible I prefer to work along that line, that is, to secure uniformity of wages in various occupations by means of registered agreements, rather than by rules made by the board but enforceable by law. Because of the fact that we had run into such difficulties along that line, I thought it desirable to experiment along another line. I think the special circumstances that prevail in the retail trade necessitate another line. What we propose here is that the agreement may be presented. Effect will not be given to the wages rates prescribed in the agreement by any firm on registration but, instead, the Wages Board will examine the agreement and make rules prescribing the wages, but this determines what shall be the limit of their operations. In other words, we get over all the difficulties that occurred on the question of the registration of an agreement by giving the board power to say how long it shall operate, to what class of shops it will apply, and over what area. This way will be found more effective, even if from another point of view, it is less attractive than the other one.
Comment on this
Bodies that, in the opinion of the Minister, are representative of the workers and the employees concerned.
Comment on this
No. That was one of the difficulties we encountered about the other Act. In some particular trades there was a limited number of employers, and although every employer signed the agreement, we could not register them because they signed individually and not as a body.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will find that that is more the practice in shops than in factories; where employers have no representative body and the agreement has to be made individually.
Comment on this
I do not think we can get over that. The difficulty in the case of the individual is insurmountable. I have been examining legislation of this kind enacted in Czechoslovakia and Austria, and in every case they found it necessary to prescribe that an agreement made with an individual or an individual employer could not be accepted for registration. Agreements have to be made by some body that is representative. The abnormal situation where every employer signs, but did not sign as-a body, can be got over by arrangement between themselves.
Comment on this
It has not, and we want a different method. We get over the immediate difficulty in this particular way. We take the agreement but we do not try to register it, as it may have been drawn up in vague words which may relate to a lot of other things besides wages, and it may contain other features which make registration difficult. We take the agreement and extract from it the rates of wages, embodying these in an order to the board, authorising the board to define the area, the type of shop or other circumstance which will determine the operation of the rates. That will get over the essential difficulty of wages agreement rates, which is this, that agreements are not phrased in legal language at all but are phrased in language for the purpose of making them understood, which, of course, is totally unsuitable for a document made a legal document, in effect, by the process of registration. This system will prove better, although I would prefer the other if it could be made to work.
Comment on this
The Minister gave one account of registration. I was wondering if foolish workers or foolish employers prevented registration from coming about. I think the Minister would want to go a little further in this matter. He told us about things that should not be in the agreements. I am afraid he will have to get on or get off with regard to agreements that he wants to have registered. I suggested when discussing the Conditions of Employment Act that he should draw up a skeleton agreement. Enterprising bodies think they could send in an agreement and ask the Minister to use the blue pencil on it, so as to make it perfect. The Minister surely will see that if there is to be a registered agreement he must start himself by providing some sort of a skeleton on which to work. I suggest to him that in this Bill he should have a skeleton schedule which could be filled in when agreements are come to. That would do away with the difficulty facing bodies of employers and employees who want to draw up an agreement for registration and find that it is impossible to do so. That, I suggest, is absurd. After all, if an agreement is going to be enforced the provisions that ought to prevail are those agreed to between employers and workers. Under this scheme are we going to have a board which will say to the workers, "Well, you should not have put down so and so," and to the employers, "you should have put down so and so." If the Minister provided the skeleton schedule that I have spoken of — one that would simply need to be filled in — it would, I suggest, go a long way towards making agreement possible, because there is no doubt that there were bodies of employers and workers who were ready to draw up agreements for registration and found that it was not possible to do so.
Comment on this
I would not say that they found it was impossible, but what I do say is that we found employers and organisations very reluctant to accept the excellent advice offered to them by officers of my Department. The fact is that, although we have had some 50 documents presented to us, we have not got one agreement that we could have registered, and that is why we are providing a different way here.
Comment on this
Under this Bill it does not matter what the form of the agreement is, provided it clearly sets out the rates of wages. The board will extract these and put them into its own document, which presumably it will take care to see will be in the proper form.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:—
In page 25, Section 50, to delete sub-sections (6) and (7).
Section 50 is the section which makes provision for sanitary and other arrangements in shops. It sets out the conditions and requirements to be fulfilled, particularly with reference to sanitary conditions, means of lighting, ventilation and washing facilities for shop assistants and other employees, and lays down that certain standards must be maintained. Sub-sections (6) and (7), which I am proposing to delete, give the power of exemption to provide suitable sanitary convenience and to maintain suitable washing facilities. The power of exemption is to be exercised by the local sanitary authority. This Bill and relevant legislation is, I suggest, doing one good thing for this country, and that is: it is taking away from local bodies, from local jugglers, certain power that they have hitherto exercised.
Comment on this
What has Deputy Corish to say to that very disrespectful observation in regard to local bodies?
Comment on this
I submit to the House that if these two sub-sections are allowed to remain in the Bill, vesting in the local sanitary authority the power of exemption, that the whole scheme is going to fail absolutely. We all know that more political juggling goes on at these local boards than in Barnum's circus.
Comment on this
I repeat that and emphasise it. If the local boards are largely composed, as in many cases they are, of the proprietors of shops, then, naturally, they will grant the exemptions.
Comment on this
Why should this power of exemption be left with local boards? The idea behind the amendment is that the obligation shall be placed on the proprietors of shops to provide suitable sanitary conveniences and maintain washing facilities. In Section 49 "the expression ‘suitable and sufficient' means, in relation to any shop or part of a shop, suitable and sufficient having regard to the circumstances and conditions affecting that shop or part." I suggest that gives adequate protection to shop proprietors, and therefore I ask the Minister to accept the amendment and to take away the power he proposes to give to those local sanitary authorities.
Comment on this
The Bill provides that in every shop there shall be provided suitable and sufficient sanitary accommodation and suitable and sufficient washing accommodation. I think it will be accepted as reasonable that where there are special circumstances which make it impossible to provide suitable or sufficient conveniences, and where such suitable and sufficient accommodation is otherwise conveniently available, that there should be this power of exemption. We come to the point, then, which is the most suitable body to determine whether that exemption should be given. I cannot for the life of me see any more suitable body than the sanitary authority of the district concerned. That, in my opinion, is the appropriate authority to exercise the very limited discretion permitted in sub-sections (6) and (7). As Deputies know, Part VI of this Bill is only in here for reasons of convenience. Ordinarily, these provisions would appear in a Public Health Bill promoted by the Department of Local Government and Public Health because they deal with public health matters. If that part of the Bill appeared under the auspices of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, I do not think that anyone would question the selection of the sanitary authority as the most suitable authority to exercise the power of discretion conferred in these two sub-sections. I certainly could not suggest any more suitable authority than the local sanitary authority for that purpose. The discretion should be there where there are special circumstances and where adequate and suitable accommodation is otherwise available, and if it should be there, it can be carried out by the sanitary authority and not by anybody else.
Comment on this
What is the Minister's opinion as to what is suitable and sufficient sanitary accommodation in a village where there is no sewerage scheme and no water supply?
Comment on this
The Minister evidently had them in mind when he put into it the provision regarding the conditions and circumstances.
Comment on this
If the Minister found himself in such a village, the consequences would be perfectly disastrous to his health.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:—
In page 25, before Section 50 (8), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
Where the sanitary authority refuse to make all exemption order under either or both of the preceding sub-sections the proprietor may appeal to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health against such refusal.
The Minister, I think, has admitted to a certain extent the necessity for this, seeing that in sub-section (9) (b) he provides for an appeal against the desire of the sanitary authority to cancel an exemption order. It seems to me only equitable that if you may appeal against the desire to cancel an order, you should also be able to appeal against the refusal to make the order originally. It is possible that the circumstances might all fulfil the requirements of the Bill and yet, for some purely local reason, the sanitary authority might refuse to grant an exemption, and I think the proprietor should have the right to appeal against that.
Comment on this
I have been asked by the Department of Local Government to resist the amendment vigorously and, therefore, I must do it. It is their view that an amendment of this kind would be an invitation to lodge an appeal in all cases in which exemption orders were refused. Furthermore, they hold that such an amendment would be contrary to the spirit of all the public health Acts which puts the final power in the hands of the local sanitary authority, and they are anxious to preserve that position and not have power to appeal from the sanitary authority to the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:—
In page 27, at the end of Section 50, to insert the following new sub-section:—
Where a document is required by this section to be served on the proprietor of a shop, such document shall be addressed to such proprietor and shall be served on such proprietor in some one of the following ways, that is to say:—
(a) by delivering it to such proprietor;
(b) by leaving it at the address at which such proprietor ordinarily resides;
(c) by sending it by post in a prepaid registered letter addressed to such proprietor at the address at which he ordinarily resides.
For the purposes of this sub-section a company registered under the Companies Acts, 1908 to 1924, shall be deemed to be ordinarily resident at its registered office, and every body corporate and every unincorporated body shall be deemed to be ordinarily resident at its principal office or place of business within the State.
This provides rules for the service of documents. I do not think any further explanation is required.
Comment on this
"By leaving it at the address at which such proprietor ordinarily resides." What happens in the case of a lock-up shop?
Comment on this
"By delivering it to such proprietor," or "by leaving it at the address at which such proprietor ordinarily resides."
Comment on this
Would it not be better to have it addressed to the shop? Suppose the proprietor was on holidays, and it was addressed to his residence, it would never reach his shop.
Comment on this
Surely the point is, if a single proprietor is an unincorporated body. If he is, then he resides in his shop. If he is not an unincorporated body, he is not dealt with at all.
Comment on this
The term covers all such companies and every body corporate and every unincorporated body. I refer the Deputy to the relevant part of the Interpretation Act about which he waxed most eloquently when it was going through the House.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:—
In page 27, at the end of Section 50, to insert the following new sub-section:—
An order made by a sanitary authority under this section shall be under their seal and shall be authenticated by the signature of their chief executive officer or his lawful deputy, and every notice proceeding from a sanitary authority under this section shall be signed by their chief executive officer or his lawful deputy.
This is another amendment which the Department of Local Government propose. It seems desirable to them for their own reasons. It is not of great importance from the point of view of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 27, at the end of Section 50, to insert the following new sub-section:—
Any document made or proceeding from a sanitary authority under this section may be proved by the production of a copy thereof certified to be a true copy by the person purporting to be the chief executive officer of such sanitary authority.
This is another amendment which the Department of Local Government and Public Health suggest. They have since suggested that they want to modify it in a slight respect and I may have to introduce an amendment to this amendment at the next stage to meet the wishes of the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
From our point of view it is more convenient to get it enacted now. I will consider that point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 27, before Section 51. to insert the following new section:—
It shall be competent for a trade union representative of persons to whom this Act applies in the event of the failure of a sanitary authority to enforce the provisions of this Part of this Act to require such sanitary authority to secure compliance with the provisions aforesaid and for that purpose may, in default of such compliance, apply to a judge of the Circuit Court for the district in which such sanitary authority has its chief office and the court may, upon the hearing of such application, make such order as appears to the court to be just and equitable.
This amendment proposes to give the trade union representative of the employees power to take action in the Circuit Court in a case of failure of the sanitary authority to make an order. Deputy McGowan has given instances where there may be reason for members of the local sanitary authority to fail in their duty in this matter and we think the trade union ought to have the right to take action.
Comment on this
This is an entirely different case from the other section in respect to which we discussed giving certain powers to a trade union. I think it would be very undesirable to give a trade union the right to prosecute a sanitary authority. I think the obvious course for a trade union to take in a case of that kind would be to report the matter to the Minister for Local Government or approach the Minister through the parliamentary representatives. It is the Minister for Local Government who should proceed against the sanitary authority if it is clear that it is not carrying out its duties.
Comment on this
This turns on a recent decision given against the Distributive Workers' Union, which was discussed yesterday at length, which was that to succeed in an action for mandamus the person must be a good relator and have an interest. In other words, a shop assistant would be able to maintain an action for a mandamus against one of these local bodies, but the position would be rather peculiar. What employee is going to institute proceedings against his employer when he knows that in a very short time, for some reason or other, his services will be dispensed with? Is it not much better to give the power to his trade union and let them institute the proceedings and perhaps succeed? I consider that it would prevent vexatious litigation. In the case of, say, a malcontent employee, who has some grievance against his employer who may perhaps contemplate discharging him, what will happen? He may start an action for a mandamus and maintain it, whereas if the trade union were given power to do it and he went to his trade union, they, being sensible men, will not move if they see that they are going to be mulcted in costs, which in fact did occur in this particular case.
Comment on this
I suggest to Deputy McGowan that this is perfectly unworkable and hopeless. I do not know what it means. A Circuit Court judge has no power to give an order for a mandamus.
Comment on this
There is no Bill here. The amendment says that they may —
"apply to a judge of the Circuit Court... and the court may, upon the hearing of such application, make such order as appears to the court to be just and equitable."
I take it that that order must be within its existing jurisdiction. You cannot give jurisdiction in this way to a Circuit Court which it has not got. Therefore it would have no power to give a mandamus against the sanitary authority. Besides, this amendment does not even say that the order is to be made against the sanitary authority. It is so vague that the court may make an order against the individual without hearing him, because there is nothing about the individual being served.
Comment on this
This is making a present of an idea to the Minister. We ask him to accept the principle of the thing and then the rest is another day's work.
Comment on this
I think that on the last occasion, although the Minister did not say that he would accept the amendment, he said that he would favourably consider giving trade unions power to prosecute. I suggest that this is practically consequential on the previous amendment put down. I cannot see any great difference.
Comment on this
On the last occasion on which we discussed the powers of trade unions it was in relation to prosecutions for offences of an individual employer. Here we are talking about a sanitary authority, and I suggest that the way to deal with a sanitary authority that is neglecting its duty is through the Department of Local Government and Public Health. A trade union is not debarred from moving in the most effective way to compel such a sanitary authority to carry out its duty, namely, directly through the Department of Local Government or through their Parliamentary representatives. That is the way to do it, and that is why I would be disposed to oppose the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 27, before Section 51, to insert the following new section:—
If any person being either the owner or the occupier of a shop, who has incurred or is about to incur any expenses for the purpose of securing that the requirements of this Part of this Act are complied with in respect to such shop, alleges that the whole, or any part of the expense ought to be borne by any other person having an interest in the premises, he may apply to the district court for the district in which the shop is situated, and that court may, upon the hearing of such application, make such order concerning the expenses or their apportionment as appears to the court, having regard to all the circumstances of the case, including the terms of any contract between the parties, to be just and equitable, and any order made under this section may direct that any such contract as aforesaid shall cease to have effect in so far as it is inconsistent with the terms of the order.
Believe it or not, this is an amendment which I think would be of considerable help to a shopkeeper. Under this part of the Bill, a sanitary authority can compel a shopkeeper to carry out certain improvements and if he does not do so, certain penalties are provided. These improvements will involve the shopkeeper in certain expense. In some cases it may involve him in considerable expense. The idea underlying the amendment is that where that particular shopkeeper happens to be a tenant, paying rent to a landlord, he shall have the right to apply to the local district court, in default of agreement, to have the expenses which he has incurred apportioned between himself and the landlord. I think it is a very reasonable provision. There is a provision absolutely similar to it in the 1934 Act passed by the British House of Commons. I think it is only reasonable that a shopkeeper tenant should be compensated in some small way by his landlord for such expense. I think it is a very reasonable amendment.
Comment on this
I am advised that it is not necessary. I am advised that the formidable provisions of sub-section (2), Section 50, meet the position. I cannot say that of my own knowledge because the sub-section has reference to various public health Acts and sub-sections of Acts and what they exactly provide I do not know.
Comment on this
Pardon me, I should have said sub-section (11) of Section 50. No Deputy can understand that from a casual reading of it, but I am told that is the position.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77: —
In page 27, before Section 52, to insert the following new section: —
(1) A sanitary authority shall for the purposes of this Part of this Act appoint such inspectors as the Minister for Local Government and Public Health may direct, and every inspector so appointed shall be deemed to be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878, and the provisions of that section shall apply accordingly.
(2) The Minister for Local Government and Public Health may, in lieu of, or in addition to directing the appointment by a sanitary authority of inspectors under the immediately preceding sub-section, assign to any of the sanitary officers of such sanitary authority under Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878, such duties in relation to the carrying out of this Part of this Act as he may think proper, and any such officer to whom such duties shall have been so assigned shall perform such duties and shall, if so declared by the said Minister, be deemed to be an inspector appointed by such sanitary authority for the purposes of this Part of this Act.
(3) References in the next following section of this Act to an inspector of a sanitary authority shall be construed as references to a person appointed or deemed to have been appointed under this section an inspector by such sanitary authority for the purposes of this Part of this Act.
This is another amendment which is suggested by the Department of Local Government and Public Health and deals with procedure. Again, there will be some drafting changes in this amendment to be made on the next stage.
Comment on this
This amendment means that sanitary authorities will be obliged by this Act to appoint extra inspectors.
Comment on this
They shall appoint such inspectors as the Minister shall direct. Suppose they have enough inspectors at the present moment who are able to carry out the ordinary sanitary work and do what will not be the very heavy work imposed under this Bill?
Comment on this
If they have enough inspectors, the appointment of additional inspectors will not be required.
Comment on this
It gives the Minister considerable power over sanitary authorities which he had not before.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78: —
In page 27, line 27, Section 52 (1), to delete the words "appointed by" and substitute the word "of."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79: —
In page 27, before Section 54, to insert the following new section:—
(1) Whenever power is conferred on the Minister for Local Government and Public Health by this Part of this Act to make any order or take any other action, the said Minister may, before exercising such power, hold a public inquiry into the matter which is the subject of the exercise of such power.
(2) Article 32 of the Schedule to the Local Government (Application of Enactments) Order, 1898, shall apply in respect of every public inquiry held under this section in like manner as the said Article applies in respect of the local inquiries mentioned therein.
The provisions of this amendment are obvious. I shall move at the next stage to have the term "public inquiry" replaced by "local inquiry," which, I think, would be better.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a question with reference to Schedules because I rather understood from what the Minister said that he was going to amend paragraph 3 of the Second Schedule, with regard to the tea interval. I suggested to the Minister that that should not apply where work finished at 7 o'clock, and I understood that he was going to bring in an amendment. I therefore did not put down an amendment.
Comment on this
I said I would look into it, and when I looked into it I found that the best thing I could do was to leave it alone. I am opposed strongly to an amendment of the Second Schedule. I think that, if the Deputy examines it further, he will find that whatever alteration might be made is not worth while. From many points of view, it is better to leave it as it stands.
Comment on this
If a man goes off work at 7 o'clock, it is unnecessary that he should be compelled to go off at 6 to take his tea and come back at 6.30.
Comment on this
That is not what is involved. It says that where the hours of work include the period from 4 p.m. to 7 p.m., a half an hour's interval shall be allowed for tea. If we were to change that, we would have to extend it to 7.30——
Comment on this
——before an assistant would be entitled to a half an hour for tea. I do not think that is desirable. If he does work until 7, he should get this break for a tea interval.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise what the position is? In a country town the assistants generally live at the other end of the town or of the village. Ordinarily, in the country, as in the United States, the people do not take afternoon tea. The meal in the evening is supper, and they frequently take no other meal before they retire. If you send them home for half an hour, you are going to extend their work by half an hour longer than would be otherwise necessary, and they will not take their tea at that time, because it is not suitable. After their work they ordinarily go home, change their working clothes, and then sit down to what they call tea, but which nobody in Dublin would call tea. In Dublin it would be called supper. They take that at their leisure, then dress, and go out for the evening to pictures or to some other entertainment. This, instead of being a benefit to the country employee, is going to be an intolerable nuisance. You will have them breaking off work for half an hour and lounging round the town, and then they will have to remain in an hour longer than they otherwise would.
Comment on this
If you extend the period, what is going to happen is that the existing arrangement will continue, whatever it may be. In many cases you will find that merchants in the country close their shops at 7 o'clock and send their assistants home. They cannot do that now, because if they remain open until 7 they are obliged to give the assistants half an hour for tea.
Comment on this
If 7.30 would be better, I would be prepared to amend it. I thought it was not worth making the change.
Comment on this
It is. You will find that an immense number of shops in the country close for the day at 7 o'clock and allow their assistants to go away. If you leave this as it is, it will mean that those shops will have to go through the form of putting their assistants out for half an hour. They will accordingly keep their shops open for an extra half-hour, instead of allowing their assistants to go away at 7 o'clock.
Comment on this
There must be some motion at this juncture, and there are a few submissions which I should like to make on that motion. What is the motion before the House?
Comment on this
With reference to that, I should like to ask the Minister a few questions, and I want to direct the Labour Party's attention to this. What would be left undone if, instead of passing this immense and complicated measure, we passed a simple measure providing that all shops must close after having had their doors open for eight hours, and secondly that every shop must pay their assistants the minimum wage as fixed, or a greater wage? Is there anything in this elaborate and extremely difficult Bill to understand which would be left undone if you had a simple Bill providing those two things? I ask the Labour Party to digest that question.
Comment on this
I submit to the Minister that, having in my opinion reasonably and effectively resisted an amendment from the Labour Party designed to prohibit the employment of persons under 15 in shops, on the ground that he would not enact such a provision until the school-leaving age was raised to 15, his general prohibition of overtime for persons under 16 years of age will operate exactly in the same way, making it impossible for any youth between the ages of 14 and 16 to get employment in a shop. I assert most positively that it will do so, because I know the first question always asked is: "Will you be 16 years before Christmas?" If not, the boy would only be a nuisance. He would be creating heart burnings and worry for the remainder of the employees, because when a rush time came it would be a case of: "Now, John, you go home, but everybody else must stay." You do not want a boy like that. This would operate to prevent employment as an apprentice of any youth who will not have attained the age of 16 years on 1st December following his employment. I think that is a great mistake. I think you are doing a very foolish thing. With the general provisions of the Bill, there is no danger of a general abuse arising in the way of slave driving of juveniles in the retail distribution trade. This distinction in respect of juveniles under 16 is simply going to upset the apprenticeship system in a way in which you do not want it upset. It is much better to abolish the whole system altogether, or else accept it with its admitted dangers, and not try half measures of this kind which will create nothing but confusion. I ask the Minister to bear that in mind. If he would only ask some people who know the trade he would discover that this prohibition of juvenile overtime will operate exactly the same as if he had prohibited altogether the admission to employment of juveniles under 16.
Comment on this
I know the Deputy is wrong, and I will give him two reasons. Precisely the same argument was advanced when the previous Conditions of Employment Bill was before the House, and that Bill prescribed a 40-hour week for juveniles under 18. That was the ordinary working week prescribed, and it has not operated to reduce the number of such persons employed in industry. The second argument is that this provision prohibiting overtime for persons under 16 has been the law in Great Britain for some time and has not had that effect
Comment on this
In this Bill there is provision for the taking of an oath. When the Presidential Elections Bill was before this House there was in Section 30 a definite provision for oath and affirmation. As it was necessary there, is it or is it not necessary here?