We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No.11-General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–200 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am glad to welcome the new atmosphere in which the House can discuss matters of this kind. The settlement of the dispute between this country and Britain has made it possible to discuss those matters without members of the Opposition or members on any side of the House being suspected of destructive criticism. I think at the present moment it is admitted on all sides that whatever criticism may be offered on this or other measures it is in order to serve the interests of the country as a whole. I think that all Parties have come to understand one another on that point.

This is that most disappointing Budget we have had for the last five or six years. It is only a couple o weeks since the country was rejoicing at the prospects of improved trade between this country and Great Britain as a result of the Agreement. The people were hoping, and they had good grounds for the hope, that there would be a reduction in taxation, and that other reliefs would be forthcoming in this Budget in onsequence of the settlement. I am sorry to say that the country has been sadly disappointed. The relief whih was expected has not come. The taxpayers are still bearing the abnormal burdens whih were imposed upon them during the last five or six years. During that period there was perhaps some reasonble excuse because of the dispute between this country and Britain, but certainly that is not so at a normal time, which those outstanding disputes have been settled and the neccessity for paying very large sums in bounties has passed away. We are told there are new items which are to taken the place of those bounties. One of them is defence. Like other Deputies in this House, I am not satisfied that the Minister and the Taoiseach are dealing fairly with this House or the country, because it is evident that something is being kept back in connection with this defence question. It is turn that hints have been dropped in regard to something very important to come in the immediate or distant future. We have been warned again and again that this is not such a boon as people expected, because defence is something very serious. The Taoiseach has given us some hints; so has the Minister. I think it is about time that the Minister should take the House into his confidence. Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, speaking last evening, used medical language and said that the Minister was giving it to the House in small doses. I think the people of this country are able to take a full dose. It may be advisable in some cases to break the news gradually. The Minister was afraid that the people had weak hearts and would not be able to stand the shock.

Comment on this

The Minister is not responsible under the Constitution for giving the defence policy to this House.

Comment on this

I think it is better that the House and the country should know the exact position, as far as the Minister can state it. I realise that it is difficult to arrive at the amount involved, but we are getting it pretty clearly from other sources. For instance, I think it was on 27th April last that I saw in the Daily Mail an article from the Dublin correspondent, in which it was stated that there was an understanding that at least the amount of money which was in dispute between the two countires would be spent on defence. The Minister should tell us whether that report was justified by the facts; he should tell us whether there is any such understanding. It would ease the anxiety of the people of this country to know whether there is any intention to spend so much money in the coming year. The people would like to have this information, and not to have it administered in small doses. Whatever the worst is, the people my as well know it. They would be prepared to face the facts. It would be more satisfactory at all events. With regard to this question of defence, maintaining that we are to defend 32 Counties, I do not see why a section of this country should take on a very serious responsibility the that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to question the sums allocated in the Budget or defence, but I would remind him that the policy of defence will be discussed when the Vote is introduced in the immediate future. The Minister for Defence is responsible for that policy, not Minister for Finance. Some of the questions now being put to the Minister for Finance should be reserved for the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

This Budget is providing £600,000 for defencce and other Deputies have referred to the matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not precluding the Deputy from referring to the amount et out in this Budget. The whole defence policy, however, should more properly be raised on the Vote for Defence.

Comment on this

I do not propose to dwell any longer on that subject. We will have opportunities for dealing with it again I hope. In the meantime, I still think that the sooner the people know more about it the better. It would allay their anxiety. There are complaints also down the country and keep disappointment amongst people who expected relief in this Budget. If we cast our minds bak to the time before the economic war, when the country was in a much better position and when the agricultural community was more prosperous than it is now, we will recall that at that time the Fianna Fáil Party strongly advocaed deating for farmers and it was hoped that out of the savings effected by the settlement, they would be able to implement that promise.

It is matter for regret that the Minister has not seen fit in this Budget to make this provision. He has tried to make people believe that all the saving which have been effected by the settlement, if there have been any savings, are being passed on to the farmers. In page 35 of the Minister's Budget statement he stated:—

"Deputies may wish at this stage to refer to Table 6. It sets out in a compact and convenient form that manner in which the moneys that in other circumstances might have been absorbed in payments to Great Britain have been utilised. It shows that after making the necessary adjustment for the old Local Loans capital, the total sum which the stoppage of the payments made available for disposal amounted to £4,240,273. Practically every penny of this, as may be seen, has been disposed of for the benefit of the farmers. They have secured the last remnant of gain arising out of the struggle to retain the annuities, and for them at any rate the campaign begun under the Land League has ended in indubitable victory."

I wonder was the Minister serious when the stated that practically every penny of this £4,240,273 has been disposed of for the benefit of the farmers? Dose anybody agree with the Minister? I very strongly disagree with him. He refers us to Table 6 to prove it. There is no proof of it in Table 3.

Deputy Cosgrave and other Deputies have stressed the case for derating for farmers as restitution for their losses during the last five or six years. I do not proposes to cover that ground again, because it has been already dealt with better than I can do it. But I do propose to question the Minister's statement, not upon the losses of the last five or six years, but on the farmers' position at present. Suppose we never had an economic war and the farmers had not been impoverished as they have been, I am prepared to question the Minister's statement and I think I will satisfy the Minister and the House that the Minister's contention is not correct, and that the farmers are entitled to dearating now more than they were in 1932, when Fiannan Fáil promised it and claimed that the farmers were entitled to it. In the first place, in Table 6 the Minister has given amounts that he claims have been passed on for the benefit of the farmers. Nothing of the sort has occurred.

The first of these is the halving of the annuities, £1,615,000 under the earlier Land Acts, and £612,000 under the 1923 Land Act. I do not question these figures which amount to £2,227,000. The farmers have got the benefit of that. The next item is "Increase over 1931-32 in provision in the Land Commission Vote for improvement of estates—£498,050." How did that benefit the average farmer? It may go to the benefit of some individuals, but how the Minister can claim that that is any benefit to the average farmer passes my comprehension Then there is No.4: "Net increase over 1931-32 in provision under other Land Commission subheads, excepting (2) and (3) above and the excess and bonus stock contribution—£186,000." I do not think that benefits the average farmer Then we have No.5: "Increase over 1931-32 in provision under other Votes for services in connection with Land Commission—£26,500." No.6 is: "Estimated loss on sugar revenuse as compared with 1931-3 consequent upon development of beet sugar industry (adhusted in respect of beet suger subsidy paid in 1931-32—£899,610)." Will the Minister tell us what benefit that is to the farers in County Cavan or in County Donegal, County Leitrim or County Sligo, where they are 200 miles from a sugar factor and where an acre of beet has never been grown? It may be a benefit of the districts where the beet is being grown, but the people who come from these districts question that.

This really is the penalty that we pay for uneconomic production, for produsing something which cannot be produced economically. If it is a benefit to anybody, it certainly dose not benefit the farmers, because the farmers are dissatified with the price they are being paid for beet. They say it is not an economic price. I do not propose to give an opinion on that, but people who come from these districts question whether there is a proper price being paid. Even one of the Minister's own Party, Deputy Corry, stated yesterday that it is not an economic price, so that the farmers get no benefit even in the districts where beet is grown. Certainly the farmers outside the beet growing districts, which are confined to very shall areas, derive no benefit from it.

The next item is No.7—increase over 1931-32 in the provision in the Vote for Agriculture, £189,342. What particular benefit has been conferred on the farmer by that? That is probably spent in the payment of inspectors for harassing and tormenting farmers, Every activity of the farmer, and everybody else, is being restricted by regulation and by order. The farmers do not regard it as any benefit to their industry to have it controlled and directed from Government Buildings. They prefer to be let live and to carry on their industry in their own way. They do not regard that provision as affording any benefit to the average farmer.

The next item relates to the provision for turf development, £123,952. What benefit is that to the farmers? None whatever. If there is any benefit accruing to the country as a whole from that provision, it certainly can not be referred to the farmers. Then there is another mall item, an increase of £83,515 in the Vote for afforestation. That brings no benefit to the farmer unless afforestation is carried out in the form of schemes taht would suit farmers, namely, shelter belts. That has not been done. I referred to that on the Vote for afforestation, and I expressed a desire that schemes of that kind should be carried out so that farmers might derive some benefit, if not immediately, certainly in the future. There is, therefore, only £2,227,000 of a benefit passed on to he farmer, according to the Minister, but I am not accepting that part of the statement.

As against that, what are the offsets? Taxation has been increased by £4,5000,000 for the last six years, since that time that Fianna Fáil promised that they would derate agricultural lane. It is admitted by statisticians that the farmers pay 59 per cent. of all taxation. If we roughly estimate their shar of this £4,500,000 they certainly pay more than this £2,227,000 of which they are supposed to get the benefit, so that, going no further, things are just as they were. But there are a number of other items which must be taken into consideration. How much has that cost of production increased? Take one item alone, the recent increase in wages given to agricultural labourers. I want to say with regard to agricultural wages, that that increase was long overdue. Agricultural labourers are the worst paid workers in this State, and 27/- per week is scarcely a living wage, having regard to the increase in the cost of living. I do not suppose that they are any better off now than when they were paid 24/- per week with a lower cost of living. I doubt if they are as well off. I believe that are not. I do not question that they are entitled to that wage, but at the same time the increase granted to them counts up in the cost of production.

The cost of production has been increased, for every man engaged by a farmer, at the rate of 3/- per week, that is, £7 16s. per year. The number of agricultural labouters in this country according to the 1926 census was 125,161. We are tole that the number has increased since Fianna Fáil came into office, but for the purpose of simplifying the calculation, we will take the figure provided by the 1926 census. Assuming the number to be 125,161, and multipling that by £7 16s., we get £976,255 as the increase in the cost of production, arising out of the payment of labour alone and as a result of the increase in wages that has recently been put into operation. That is as far as the agricultural labourer alone is concerned. There are 550,172 agricultural workers altogether in the State. If the cost of living has been so increased for the agricultural labourer, as nobody doubts it has, the cost of living has been increased to the same extent for the working farmer and the members of his family so that everyone of these 550,172 workers employed on the land are entilted to the same increased allowance to meet the increased cost of living. I think the Minister, or anybody in this country, will not deny that the working farmer, and the members of his family who are working on the land, are at least entitled to the same standard of living as the agricultural labourer who is the lowest paid labourer in the land. I think it is not too much to claim that the farmers and their families are entiled to the same allowance as the agricultural labourers. That would make the allowance for all these workers, arising out of the increased cost of living, £4,291,341. Therefor, instead of the farmers being in as good a position as they were in 1931, they are over £4,250,000 worse. If they were entitled to derating in 1931-32 as the Fianna Fáil Party said they were, they are £ 4,250,000 worse now. That is proven by figures that can hardly be questioned, and yet that is not the end of it.

The price of feeding stuffs has been increased and the cost of these feeding stuffs adds still further to the cost of production. The cost of machinery has also been increased. The price of implements and everything connected with production has been increased. The position of the farmers, therefore, if there never had been an economic war, is much worse now than it was in 1931-32. As other Deputies have pointed out, the economic war has robbed the people of their savings. It has left the average farmer who had not sufficient savings to carry him through the depression, swamped in banks or with shopkeepers, unable to pay his debts. It has left him with reduced stocks. With all those disadvabtages, we are now starting off with an additional disadvantage of £4,250,000 as compared with 1931-32. How, then, can the Minister hope to claim that the agricultural community are in a position to get any advantage out of the settlement? Everyone in the State should give careful consideration to that question. After all, the farming community are the backbone of the State, and unless they are in the position to live independently and to pay theur debts where is taxation to come from? Who is to pay salaries and to buy the products of factories? Agriculture is our basic industry, and those who claim that it is entitled to a fair deal are speaking in the best interests of the country. Everybody, whether he belongs to the cities or the rural parts, deplores the exodus of the people from the land. They are fleeing from it into the cities and the towns because they do not want to stay on the lane. Has not the policy of the present Government been responsible for the exodus? After a few years, if the people continue to leave the land, how are they to be replaced? Even if people later returned for the cities and towns would they be of any use on the land? If they once leave the land it is very difficult to get them to return to it.

Agriculture is our main industry, and the only one that could stand by itself if it got a chance. It has not got a chance, because burdens have been placed on it for the past few years, as high in some cases as 50 per cent., in order to encourage new industries. The agricultural people are most anxious to help these new insutries to the best of their ability, but there is a limt beyond which they cannot go. If they are expected to contribute towards the building up of these new industries their own industry is also entitled to some consideration, because we cannot continue taking form that industry without putting something back into it. I strongly urge the Minister to consider the claims of agriculture and to look at both sides of this question. The Minister can make up a very plausible story and juggle with figures in such a way as to give the impression that millions of money have been given to agriculture. He should look at the other side of the account. The figures then will shoe that farmers are now in a very show that farmers are now in a very much worse position than they were before the start of the economic war because of the sacrifices they made and of the debts they incurred.

Another matter on which I think the Minister was not well advised was in increasing the duty on hawkers' licences. The amount of the duty has been doubled. I do not think any Minister should double taxation in an off-hand way without inquiry. O know that there has been a clamour by some merchants who were afraid of competition and who were afraid that these hawkers would take away their trade. These traders would not stir from behind their counters to improve their trade and that gave the hawkers, as they are called, their chance. Hawkers are not a lazy class of people, and were serving the people in he country districts. The Minister should consider the position of persons living five or six mils from a town who wanted to sell eggs a couple of times in the week. In the past the women had to take baskets of eggs to the towns. In the past they sometimes had an ass and car or a horse and car, but the roads are made in such a way now that these people are in danger of being run down by other traffic. In addition, the roads are so slippery they ar afraid to being animals on them. If they cannot dispose of their eggs people in the country will not be able to get the household necessaries that these hawkers supplied when they called. If hawkers are comelled to pay the extra licence duty it is the people in the country will eventually have to pay it by getting less for their eggs and other produce. In the last resort it is another tax on the land and another incentive to people to et away from the lane.

This was a necessary service that sprang up naturally to meet the changed condidtions that have been brought about. The hawkers are as necessary to the country people to-day as the towns were ten years age. The country does not exist for the benefit of the towns—I always understood that the towns existed for the benefit of the country. If people can do their business with hawkers why should they not continue to do so? If traders find that hawkers are geetings inside their business let them send out supplies to the country. If a man can sent out a lorry and serve 40 people, is not that better than having 40 people quitting work and shutting up their houses in order to go into the towns for supplies? Only that the people found it was a benefit they would not have encouraged the hawkers to come around. I think the Minister might reconsider the position, or if he cannot fo so this year, he might restore the duty in the next Budget to what it was. The Minister should mot listen to any story without having both side concerned heard.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

An economist said that the magic of properly trurned sand into gold, but I think Deputies who are farmers do not ponder sufficently on that wise saying. All our Irish tenant farmers are looking forward to the time when they shall become owners of the farms they hold, and any work they do, or that they are going to do on them, will be for the benefit of themselves and their families who, let us hope, will be eternally in possession of the land. During the remainder of the period until their annuities have run out, the Irish tenant purchasers will enjoy a direct reduction of half the amount of annuties which they would have had to pay had the state of affairs which existed when we came into office still continued. The Minster for Finanace pointed out in his Budget speech that parctically the whole of the £2,900,000, which would be collectible as annuities, had there been no econoimc war, and no settlement, was going back to Irish tenant farmers, and about £2,227,000, according to the figures given are going back to them directly this year in the form of a reduction of the annuties by 50 per cent.

I think that that is a very substantial relief to agriculture which is not sufficiently stressed, and I, for one, am glad that the Minister for Finance took the opportunity to put these reliefs which had been given to agriculture, Government gave in other directions to that industry, in their proper perspective in his Budget statement. One would imagine also, if one were to look back on what we have heard in this House for that past five years with regard to the dire effect of the economic war, the uselessness of protecting the home market for our farmers, the extravagance and wrthlessness of any system of boundties or subsiodides for the development of agreiculture, and the increasing of agricultural production, that, in fact, all these various measures counted nothing so long as the economic dispute continued. One would have expected from the critics of the Budget the admission that now that this economic dispute is settled, and,, as far as we can see, they are highly pleased with the settlement, to that extent at any rate, those arguments that they had been using against they Goverment measures which had been adopted and which were found necessary, no longer applied, One would imagine that they would go back to the statement of the former Minister for Agriculture, the late Mr. Hogan, to which Deputy Dillon Briefly referred in his speech. Unfortunately, Deputy Dillon did not dwell upon the poicy expounded by the late Mr. Hogan in the way that one would expect. He seemed to the rather anxious to get away from that policy which, I think, could be fairly expressed as being to help the farmer to help him self.

Comment on this

And denounced by you for ten yours!

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon did not dwell upon that. Deputy dillon Stareted off by telling us that the immediate neccessity was to reduce the overhead chrges on the agricultural producer. As I have said, it is rather extraordinary that Deputy Dillon and his collegues have no taken the opportunity, if they still believe in the policy which the late Mr. Hogan preached, to inform their supporters in the country and to drive home to the Irish agriculturist, in particular, that no matter what reliefs he may get from the Government, of no matter what economic settlements he may reap the advantage of, he will still have to do a hard day's work to get a decent days's wage, and to get a decent return; that in that market he will still have to face that competition of practically every nation on the surface of the glove which is engaged in the agricultural industry, and that now is certainly the time for the Irish farmer to look into the question whether he has been availing himself of the opportunities that he has had and that he is now presented with to reap the fullest economic advantage out of them.

The Deputy who has just sat down informed us that the farmers had suffered greatly during the past few years We all admit that, but one would like to get some figures to show that deposits held by farmers in the Irish banks have, in fact, decreased during the past five or six years to the extent that is supposed It has been stated on very reliable authority that the deposits held by the banks from Irish agricultural depositors have increased in proportion to the amounts held by other section of the community that, in fact, the perecentage of deposits held by Irish agriculturists has increased whicle the precentage held by other sections of the community has decreased.

Comment on this

The very reverse of that is the case.

Comment on this

The deputy should preduce the figures.

Comment on this

You should produce the figures.

Comment on this

The Deputy will hear the figures in due course. Deputy Dillon says that in order to rap the beast profits out of this market which head charges in has now been made available, and the opening of which to the Irish farmer has made the Deputy almost delirious with joy, the great thing for the Government now to do is to reduce overhead charges. One of the ways in which industrialists—and I suppose that in connection with the securing of efficiency in agriculture one ought to advert to the process by which efficiency us secured in industry —one of the ways in which industry secures an efficent return and a reduction of overhead charges is by increasing its total production. Increasing its total volume of production is the one way, the surest and easiest way, in which ineustrialists generally endeavour to secure a reduction a sug-overhead charges. But through this whole debate has been running a suggestion not that we would increase our total national production, but that in certain very important respects we should reduce that production. I would like to know on what grounds it is suggested that very important aspects of our national production should now be departed from, that we should actually close up our beet factories, that we ought even close up some of our industries, that we ought, in fact—becouse unmistakably the suggestion is at the back of these criticusms—go back to the policy of the old Farmers' Union, which I thought was dead and buried long since; that we should continue to but the foreign article no matter what that we should continue to buy the foreign article no matter what the circumstances might be under which it was produced or what the effect upon our own economy might be so long s it was the cheapest. I hope that that policy is dead and buried and that anybody who attempts to resurrect it will receive short shrift in this country. I think that no matter how much we may be intereasted in the welfare of the small farmer, of the worker, or of the consumer, we ought to realise that we have to secure employment for our people in this country, and that it is only by encouraging private enterprise, and ecouraging enterprise where necessary, either by direct intervention of the State or by Government subvention, that we shall, n fact, be able to ensure that substantial numbers of our people will find employment here. If we are going back to the policy of the ranch, if we are going to sacrifice our tillage policy and our industiral policy in order that the policy preached by the least patriotic and least worthy section of the Irish community should be carried into effect, then I say it is a misfortune that we ever got freedom in this country or every got control of our own affairs, To return however to Deputy Dillon's Statement with regard to derating, I think that no doubt the question of local finance in general demand examination—

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has indicated that certain steps have been taken in that regard. Perhaps it would be premature for the Government at this stage to undertake any substantial change until they satisfy themselves that that is the best way to encourage the agricultural industry.

Comment on this

We will convert you yet. You are coming on.

Comment on this

I also belive that the policy of total and full derating would no be the best way to help agriculture. We had this question discussed in the House on a great many occasions years ago. I do not think Deputy Dillon was here at that time. The Party of which I am a member had a motion down in support or substantial support of drating. There was an amendment brought in by Deputy O'Connell, the then leader of the Labour Party. Deputy O'Connel made a good case to show that derating, in fact, would no benefit the small farmers, who were the vast majority of the holders of agricultrual land in this country Donegal, about example, in the County Donegal, about three-fourths of the farmers are under a £10 valuation. At the present time they are paying rates. We will say that a man there with a £5 valuation—— which would be the valuation of the average 20 acre holding in that country —would be paying about £3 12s. 5d. That is the amount of the current rate demanded in a demand note I have before me. Now that man gets £1 5s. 1., or roughly 35 per cent. of rates reduction in respect of agricultural land. That is the special allowance in respect of the abatement on agricultural lane. There is, therefore, at the present time an actual reduction so far as the small farmer is concerned —a direct reduction—of 35 per cent. He is still paying 65 per cent. Having regard to the fact that a very large percentage of our farmers are comparatively smallholders, what we have to ask curselves is whether in these conditions and having regard to their circumstance, that best way of assisting them —if assistance on a substantial scale is necessary—would be to wipe out their rates completely. I think it was proved on that occasion that that was not the best way so far as the small farmer is concerned. We have to bear in mind that the money from which derating is to be provided, if derating is to be put into operation, can only be secured by indirect taxation. We know because we have calculated in the past that in order to relieve the small farmers of £2, £3 or £4 in rates, you would have to put on some taxes which would offset that relief to a considerable extent if not perhaps wipe it out altogether; you would have to impose increased taxation on such commodities as tea, sugar and so on.

Comment on this

What is the small farmer in Donegal getting out of sugar beet?

Comment on this

The small farmer in Donegal at any rate can be held up to the rest of the country as the farmer who per excellence has kept up the standard of tillage in this country. No other county but Donegal in this portion of Ireland sill has that percentage of lane under tillage which could be compared in any favourable manner with the amount of land under tillage 50 or 60 years ago. I have heard from those who know the people of Donegal—and I have discussed the matter with people who know Donegal intimately —that it is not by one particular scheme but by a number of schemes that the small farmers can be helped fully. I think anybody acquainted with them will realise that neither by halving the annuities nor by any single scheme like derating can this be accomplished. These things at any rate would only mean a few pounds per head to these people and that is not going to mean anything very great in their economic circumstances. So that as far as the small farmer is concerned derating should not be considered as being the most suitable way to assist] him.

We have to bear in mind that at the present time very substantial aid is being given to farmers under a £20 valuation. Deputy Cosgrave pointed out that the agricultural grant was somewhat higher in the last year the agricultural grant without talking other circumstance also all the other services that the State has either extended or introduced during the term of office of the present Government? What about the great increase in social services? Is it claimed that the rural community are not getting a fair share of these social services? in my opinion they are getting a fair share I venture to say, if the question were now examined as it was examined by the Derating Commission, and if the position of the agriculturists in reference to national revenue were examined, it might in fact be shown that the agriculturist is contributing less proportionately toward the national revenue now than he was at that time. At any rate there was no suggestion then that he was bearing the brunt of the taxation in this country.

In addition to the £3,000,000 which is going to the tenant purchasers in one way or another, the Minister for Finance was able to point out in his Budget statement that in getting the sugar beet industry going, the State sacrificed a revenue of £900,000. Naturally the loss of so much revenue must be a serious consideration for the Minister for Finance. But the Government decided that it was necessary to provided a crop so as to afford facilities for farmers who were prepared to undertake tillage. In order to give them a reasonable price for their beet crop, three other factories were set up. All I have to say in connection with these new factories is that if there was the same appreciation of the usefulness of the factories to the agricultural community, and the same appreciation of their benefits in other areas, as there is in Carlow and around the Carlow factory, there would be no doubt whatever about the continued success and the continued operation of these factories. Time after time the farmers in that area have state: "We are not going to grow beet at the price fixed," but I have been told by those who are in a position to know Carlow intimately that it has never yet happened when the time came to sow bees that there were not scores, and probably hundreds, of farmers anxious and willing to grow beet in excess of the amount required.

Comment on this

Go down to Tuam and make a few inquiries there.

Comment on this

Well, I am hopeful that in the other areas the same readiness and anxiety to grow beet will prevail when the farmers in those other areas understand the crop better; when they are more familiarised with the conditions, and when they have as good a scientific knowledge of farming as a great many farmers in the Carlow district seem to have.

Deputy Cosgrave, of course, stated, with regard to derating, that his Party were not wedded to derating, and I think that is a very useful and a vary proper statement No fault whatever should be found with Deputies for suggesting means by which agriculture, or any other industry for that matter, can be made more efficient, can be helped along; but I think what we have a right to object to is a suggestion, which was delivered in a certain pontifical manner, that a certain proposal, which was turned down in the most solemm way by a commission for which a former Government was responsible, should now be sought to be dragged back again into the public view without being closely and seriously examined. I welcome, therefore, Deputy Cosgarave's statement that his Party are not wedded by any means to the proposal that there should be total derating and I would be greatly surprised if that Party which, like this one, represents the small farmers and not the big ranchers, who are confined to certain counties in this country——

Comment on this

Where are the big ranchers?

Comment on this

——that that Party, representing as we do the Western counties would, any more than this Party, be anxious to see in operation a policy which would, in effect, mean that the small farmer would have to pay, through increased taxation on the necessities of life, for the relief of socalled farmers, some of them with a great number of farms of land which are certainly not giving a fair return to this country either in the amount of food they produce or the employment they give.

Deputy Davin referred to a great many matters. Had the Deputy looked at the Order Paper he would have seen that a great many of the Estimates in which he seems to be interested are on that Paper for early discussion in the Dáil, and I have no great sympathy with Deputy Davin in his haste to cover such a lot of ground, such a great many points which would more properly have come up during the coming weeks on the appropriate Votes. The Deputy has the knack of taking out certain points which he thinks will be useful to him politically, and he completely forgets, as great many other critics of the Budget forget, that in order that we shall have a fair picture of our economic and financial conditions as a State, we should being everything into the picture which is relevant. We should not, for instance, seize on one or two isolated figures or other matters which have come under our observation and endeavour to suggest that because these points appeal to us personally they, in fact, represent the whole of the picture, because they do not.

One of the most amazing things about Deputy Davin is that he never, so far as I know, has admitted in this House, except when he was able to try to claim some credit for it himself or try to get credit for his Party through it, the very substantial improvement there has been in the conditions under which the workers of this country have been living, not alone during the period this Government has been in office, but since the war period, or since the pre-war period. I wonder do those people who, like Deputy Davin, never seem to see anything except the problems which, unfortunately, have still to be solved, ever look back and ask themselves what an amount of ground has been covered and what an amount of progress has been achieved? If the Deputy, and those who think with him, would only look at the conditions of the Irish worker in the pre-war period and in the period immediately after the war and look at the conditions at the present time I think they should be prepared to clap this Government or any other Government which is in office in this country on the back, because I am quite convinced that the conditions, taking all the circumstances into account in this country, so far as labour conditions hold, compare very favourably with the conditions existing in the powerful and wealthy State across the water. I am quite satisfied that the conditions of labour here are better than they are in a great many countries in Europe and possibly elsewhere.

Comment on this

Who made them better?

Comment on this

Then we have Deputy Davin coming along telling us that there were 18,000,000 loaves of bread less eaten in this country last year or the year before than five or six years ago. If the Deputy had known anything about the principles which go to the consideration of the question whether the standard of living in a country the standard of living in a country is a fair one or not, he would know that as the standard of living goes up in a country the consumption of bread goes down. If he were examining the standard of living in the United States, Great Britain or any other country, would he measure it by the amount of bread consumed? He certainly would not. He would measure it by the amount of eggs, butter and meat consumes, by the number of motor cars, by the amount of money collected in taxation.

In this country, as was pointed out not so long ago, when this ramp which had been carried on here for the preceding 12 months was brought up in the form of a motion, and when it was sought to be proved that the cost of living had gone sky wards, it was shown conclusively that in respect of beer, spirits and tobacco there had been a steady increase in the yield of taxation. There could not have been an increase in the yield from these commodities if the people had not more in their pockets to buy these commodities. When newspapers talk of the enormous increase which admittedly there has been in the figures in modern Budgets, they conveniently forget, like Deputy Davin, to put on the other side of the picture the enormous, the staggering increase in the standard of living which has taken place in this as in great many other countries. They forget that completely. If they look back for a generation and examine the conditions a generation ago in this or any other country, they will find ample corroboration of that. We have corroboration of it in these figures dealing with the revenue returns, in the figures dealing with the number of motor car registrations, in the figures dealing with the Post Office Savings Bank and the Saving Certificates returns.

All of those things go to show there is a good deal of money in circulation.

Everybody may not have benefited, but the figures certainly go the show that in the community as a whole there has been a steady and a satisfactory improvement, a raising of the standard of living, and that is proved conclusively, as I have said, by the fact that on our taxable commodities more revenue is being collected and more of these commodities are being consumed; the people have more money and there are more of them buying these commodities. That fact should be kept in mind when the figures dealing with taxation are being stressed.

What also should be borne in mind and pointed out by the wise gentlemen in the newspapers is that this money which is being collected in taxation is going back in services to the people, and that services have contributed more than any other thing to raise the standard of living in this as in other countries. That is a fact which, of course, is completely left out of consideration by Deputy Davin and others like him, who will give no credit for what has been done and will omit entirely—I suppose it has not occurred to them—to dwell on the fact that enormous progress has been made. What we should say to ourselves is that at any rate we are progressing. If everything is not in as satisfactory a condition as we would wish, at any rate, as honest men and men who profess to have a knowledge of what we are speaking of, we should bring into the picture these very important factors.

Deputy Davin also, having already referred, on the last occasion he was here, to the fact that he anticipated certain things from the Budget, has come forward on this occasion and told us that the cost of living must not be increased; that bacon, bread, and butter must be sold here at the same price as in Great Britain. On the other hand, Sir, the Deputy asked me a question as to whether I still believe that a guaranteed price should be paid for beet. With regard to beet, bacon, butter, or any other agricultural product, if, by reserving the home market for the Irish producer, we can guarantee to the producer a reasonable and a fair price without imposing an altogether undue, burden on the community, I certainly am strongly in favour of that policy. I cannot understand, however, the attitude of one like Deputy Davin, who takes the farmers so much to heart that he even seemed to cast a languishing smile towards Deputy Gorey yesterday evening when he suggested that he was sorry that the farmers of this country had not placed their destinies in his (Deputy Davin's) hands. Deputy Davin takes a very keen interest, according to himself, in agricultural conditions. Of course, he represents an agricultural constituency, but unfortunately the same speech, or the same set of arguments, which will appeal to the workers in Portlaoighise will not appeal to the small farmers in Arles, because if you tell the people in Portlaoighise that they are paying too much for their butter and bacon, and then tell the farmers in Arles, or some place down here where they are working in bog areas and on badland, that they will have to sell their produce here at the price that holds in the British market, no matter how low that price is, you cannot expect them to be pleased, nor can you expect the ordinary observe to think that there is much sincerity or much principal behind them when you gave those two opposing arguments coming from the same source. If the Deputy is consistent in his anxiety to help the farmers, and if he believes in the policy of protecting the home market -if he his interested in the question of guaranteed prices—then, in all conscience he cannot come along and demand that the farmers should sell their produce here at low prices—particularly, as was pointed out to him by Deputy Allen, if they are actually below the cost of production—just because, according to Deputy Davin, the international price on the English market should rule here.

The Deputy also should realise, I think that it is only fair to point out to the agricultural community—apart from the question of the economic war altogether—the advantages which the dispute brought to the community for which he speaks. One of the advantages being that during the period when, according to Deputy Cosgrave —and Deputy Davin has respected his argument—there was a considerable reduction in the home consumption of bacon in this country—another argument that the standard of living in the country had seriously deteriorated and that we were in a very serious position—there were compensating factors. Neither Deputy Cosgrave nor Deputy Davin, who talked a good deal when the scheme was being introduced, and who could not so easily have forgotten it, thought fit to mention the compensating factor of the free beef and free meat schemes under which scores of million of pounds of free ment and fee beef were given to thousands and thousands of poor people in this country who never had meat before.

Comment on this

Scores of millions! Take a note of that.

Comment on this

They forgot to take a note of that, and I think they should note that, so far as the demand for Irish beef in this country is concerned, it has been improved as a result. Deputy Davin also forgot to point out when he was dealing with the question of food prices that between the years 1929 and 1934 there was a very serious fall indeed in agricultural prices here as elsewhere. Agricultural prices all over the would reached rock-bottom during those years. Deputy Davin conveniently forgets to point out to his followers, if they are his followers, that during those years thy reaped the advantages of cheap food. That got food at a price at which it was never got before. Then, when in the succeeding years, 1936 and 1937 there began to be an increase in food prices, we had a general ramp to the effect that the Government was in some way responsible, and that whenever there was an increase in the prices of bacon, butter, or, in fact, any commodity, whether for the purpose of eating or otherwise, the Government was responsible for that increase. Deputy Davin forgets that. He forgets also that about £6,000,000 of extra expenditure have gone each year into social and allied services; and when he tells us here and when the weeps tears for the numbers of unemployed here, or for the migration to Great Britain surely he ought to consider the fact that £6,000,000 a years of additional expenditure on social and similar services is an extraordinary amount for a Government in this country and shows extraordinary generosity, and, if I may say so, certainly proves that we are in advance of the times in our concern to see that the poorer sections of the community are looked after.

There has also been improvement in labour conditions and so on, and these improvements have mounted up to very substantial sums of money. These sums of money, paid either in increased wages or through improved working conditions, although they go into circulation here and benefit certain classes of the community—the working classed and so on—at the same time have to be provided by somebody. These sums of money have to be provided by the consumer of by the taxpayer in the long run. It would be well that Deputy Davin and his colleagues should remember that, if we are trying to secure better conditions for labour, if we are trying to secure higher wages and so on the provision or the wherewithal for these improved conditions and higher wages has to be got from the community; in other words, presumably, it has to be got from the consumer.

Comment on this

Would the Minister permit me to ask in connection with what he has just said whether he is contend ing that higher wages are being paid to some sections of the community out of State revenue?

Comment on this

I do not see the relevance of the question, Sir.

Comment on this

Surely Sir, it is relevant. If the Minister is talking about higher wages having to be got from the community, is he suggesting that the State itself is paying the higher wages to somebody, or is he suggesting that the State has to find the money for the higher wages paid by private employers?

Comment on this

I would say that the community has to pay in the long run, in some way, for all the increases in wages, or for anything which goes to increase the price of commodities. For example, in the case of house-building, there has been an increase in the price of materials and in labour costs, and the consumer of houses is, in this country in order to produce bread we have a system which apparently produces less units of bread per man than across the water and at a much higher price per unit which the community has to pay, people are put in a position to say that the Government is responsible there again. It has been suggested over and over again that the Government is responsible, either through the wheat scheme or through not having proper control of the flour mills, because the people have to pay more for bread, but what is entirely for-= gotten is the question of labour costs and the method of producing bread, which was only brought under public notice, after the Government had been denounced for a long time in all the moods and tenses, when the statement of comparative labour costs was made up by those responsible for the industry. It was only then it was made quite clear that there was a very heavy burden indeed placed upon the consumer.

Comment on this

The burden arises from the 12/- a sack that the Government has put on flour. That is where the burden is at the present moment.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy's Party take off some part of that 12/-?

Comment on this

Every penny of it.

Comment on this

And shut down the flour mills?

Comment on this

Not a single one.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin made the pint that the money saved by the settlement should be made available for those who suffered. I have shown, and the Minister for Finance has already shown, that the tenant purchasers have reaped, and will continue to reap, as large share of the advantage, and I think the Deputy is not unaware of the fact, no matter how plausible or simple he may seem, that many million pounds have gone into circulation here during the course of the economic war for the improvement of social services. The people who he says suffered most, certainly reaped advantages from those services.

Reference has been made to the question of defence. An agreement was accepted by this house under which we have taken over, unconditionally, as was explained by the Taoiseach, certain ports. It was stated also by the Taoiseach, in the clearest manner possible, that the Government proposes to undertake certain responsibilities in connection with we were facing these new responsibilities, and that we intended at an early and opportune moment to place our policy with regard to defence before the House and the country and would ask the House and the country to accept that policy wholeheartedly. I have only to say on this occasion that, as the Minister for Finance has already pointed out, we intend to provide for our own defence out of our own resources, If that fundamental consideration is kept in mind, if that is regarded as the principle on which we are going to work, it will save a great deal of misunderstanding. Whatever others may have in view with regard to defence, that is the principle on which we are working: that we are going to undertake responsibility ourselves for the defence of our country, and that we are going to provided, ion so far as we can, for that defence effectively from our own resources.

Deputy O'Higgins referred to the amounts of money which is being provided in connection with defence. I have no wish to anticipate in any way the discussion, and I am sure there will be more than one discussion, in the House in the near future with regard to this very important mater; but I think I may say that the £6,000,000 need not necessarily or will not necessarily be all spent on the ports. Votes for the provision of that sum of money will come before the House in due course, and, presumably the House will discuss the question fully. As has frequently been pointed out by the Minister for Finance, in the course of speeches made in the house by deputy Davin and other Deputies, the Minster for Defence is the appropriate Minister under whose Vote this whole question can be properly discussed. If we were to start a discussion of defence on the Budget statement there is no reason why we should not start discussion on the question of education or on any other question.

I am rather surprised that those who vote gladly for the Agreement, having heard the Taoiseach's statement at the beginning and the end of that debate in which regard to defence, now seem to suggest either that something is being withheld or that the Government has no taken the House and the country fully into its confidence. As was explained by the Taoiseach, and as I now repeat, the whole defence policy or the Government will be put before the House in due course. At any rate, it is obvious that the elimination of Articles 6 and 7 which held such dangerous potentialities for us in the event of the international situation becoming serious—in the event of any danger of war—is a matter of the greatest moment to this country, a matter I think upon which, no matter what our views may be, we can all rejoice—that these Articles have been swept away. I think we can all recognise that the final abrogation of these Articles creates an entirely new position. We are now quit free. We always were, I suppose, so far as the Dáil is concerned. It was always made clear under the old Constitution as well as under the new Constitution, that the Dáil—the Parliament of the People—was, of course, the final body to determine what our attitude should be in connection with war. In the same way the Dáil the People's legislature, is the supreme body to deal with all questions of national defence. These never has been, and never can be, any question but that that is the case.

I do hope that when the question comes up the atmosphere will be somewhat different from what it has been whenever defence has been dragged into this debate. It is, undoubtedly, a most serious matter, one to which we would all be well advised to address ourselves in a very serious fashion, a matter to which we should give the utmost consideration. I hope, then, that when it is discussed by us as Irishmen whose only anxiety is to do that best we can for our country, to take such steps as will ensure that we shall be united, and shall be in a position to defend ourselves if the necessity for so doing arises. I hope that the good spirit which has existed for some time past in the House and the promises of co-operation which the Government has received in connection with the implementation of the new Agreement. will be followed in connection with the question of national defence, that it will be discussed as a national question of the greatest importance to each one of us and of the greatest importance to the future of our country, a question upon which it is the duty of each one of us to see that a right decision is come to.

Comment on this

I, like other Deputies on these benches, regret that the report of the Banking Commission was not produced before we came to discuss the Budget, The Minister has stated that the report is in the printers' hands and that he has not read it yet, Of course, we in this House must accept the Minister;/s statement and admit that he is correct. WE do not for a moment insinuate that he is saying anything that is not true. Nevertheless, there has been a rumour through the country—what it is worth I am not in a position to say—that this report was presented to the Prime Minister in England as an argument why we could not——

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The report of the Banking Commission is not before the House, much less are rumours in connection with it.

Comment on this

We regret that is not before the House. As this is the first time. I have spoken since he recent Agreement was made, I desire to congratulate the Government upon it. As a Deputy from one of the Border counties, I feel, with the people there, that we have got a certain amount of relief. Generally speaking, I think that the Agreement is an indication that the Government have come to realise that small nations cannot exist if themselves. The Government have evidently learned that from what has happened in other parts of the world during the past couple of years. As regards the Budget, I do not think that the farmers have any reason to congratulate the Minister. The only people I know who have any right to congratulate the Minister are the directors of a lot of these new factories who are making a fine thing by way of salary and making a fine thing by way of salary and income out of these undertakings. As a rule, the farmer has no interest in income-tax. His anxiety is to make ends meet. He has never any money with which to pay income-tax. I do not think that the Department of Finance would waste an envelope in sending a demand for income-tax to the ordinary farmer. They would get nothing out of it. As the Government have been assisting almost every industry established in the country during the last few years, it is time they tried to do something for the farming community. The only feasible way of doing that is by way of derating.

We shall probably be told that now that the tariffs are off the cattle and we are able to send our cattle free into Great Britain, it should be quite sufficient for us. I so not think that the Minister can argue that because we have heard form Ministers and from Deputies on the Government Benches repeatedly during the last four or five years that we have been at no disadvantage regarding the price we have been receiving for our cattle—that the price we were receiving here was quite as good as was being received in Northern Ireland. If that was true four or five years ago, it is equally true to-day and we are not going to get sufficient to make up for what we lost during the past few years. There is no doubt about the poverty existing at present amongst the farming community. The Minister for Education has told us that farmers' deposits in the banks and post offices have increased during the last few years. If the Minister was certain of that, he should have produced figures to substantiate his statement. He did not give us any figures. Instead, he asked us to produce fugures. He knows it is utterly impossible for any Deputy it is go to a bank and ask what deposit they have belonging to farmers. The Government can easily find out what deposits there are belonging farmers and what deposits have been withdrawn during the last four or five years. I can say that, but for the deposits in the banks and post offices, the farmers could not have existed form 1933 to the present time. They had to withdraw any money they had in the banks. As proof of that, I ask the Minister to consider making a request to a farmere to go a bank and ask for a loan of £50 or even of a loan of a £ note. He would be refused. If there were deposits belonging to the farmers in the banks and if farming were in a prosperous condition, there is no doubt that the banks would be very glad to advance money to the farmers. At present, no farmer would get advance of even a £10 note without collateral security.

Some of the back benchers want to know where the money for derating is to come from. But for the recent Agreement, we would have had to pay £104,000,000 to the British Government. We have got out of that for £10,000,000. We are, therefore, better off to the extent of £94,000,000. Surely that benefit should go to the farmers in some form. Of course, the Government could get money in other ways. They could use some economy which they are no using at the present time. There is quite a lot of money—not thousands but millions— being squandered in various ways. One of these ways has to do with the Pigs Marketing Board. Probably, the Ceann Comhairle will rule me out of order again and say that this is a matter for the Minister for Agriculture. It is, however, an item that could be saved and it is a thing that should never have been introduced into this country because the farmers do not want it and never wanted it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now irrelevent.

Comment on this

I thought I would be ruled out but, with your permission, I have told the Minister what I wanted to tell him. As regards the Land Commission I suppose I shall be ruled out also——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Certainly.

Comment on this

The Minister must acknowledge that the farmers of the Twenty-six Counties, and particularly those of Caven, Monaghan, and Donegal, have to compete with the farmers of Northern Ireland. They cannot do so unless they get some rating concession. The farmers of Northern Ireland are derated. They also get a subsidy on their cattle. Every fat animal sold in Northern Ireland carries a subsidy of 7/6 or 5/- per cwt. We are not getting that concession. Until we get something to equal it, we are not in a position to compete with the farmers of Northern Ireland have also agreed to do what the Government here are not willing cession to the farmers to try to get their lands cleaned up, to get bushes cut, drains cleared and work of that kind which used years ago to be carried out in winter time, done. Owing to the loss of interest in their land because of the uncertainly of their position, farmers ceased to do that work. The Government of Northern Ireland are contributing, I think, 80 per cent. —I am not sure of the exact figure—of the wages paid in respect of extra work, such as I have referred to, on the reclamation of land. If the Minister wants to use up some of his unemployed men in the country, instead of bringing them up to the factories here and trying to create employment for them at the expense of the farmers—it is the farmers who have to pay eventually— why should he not give the farmers a certain amount towards the employment of these men? Would it not be the easiest way of getting rid of them, of assisting the country and increasing its tillage?

Comment on this

I hold that this is a good Budget, so far as the ordinary taxpayer is concerned, and that is the opinion I found expressed all over the country by the people who have to pay pay the taxes; but in order to justify their political existence, both Fine Gael and Labour Deputies are trying to bolster up a case against the Budget. In this respect they are more to be pitied than blamed, as the case put up by them will not bear the test of public opinion. They are relying on the agricultural community as the only straw which they can hope to grasp and save themselves from drowning in the sea of politics. The principal baits used to capture the farmers' votes are derating, the retention by the farmers of their land annuities, and cheap loans for farmers.

Comment on this

Could we have a copy of the Deputy's paper?

Comment on this

You will get it afterwards in the Official Report.

Comment on this

The Deputy is relevant which Deputy Gorey was not.

Comment on this

As a farmer, I am anxious to express my views on these matters to the House.

Comment on this

Do not forget to look at the paper all the same.

Comment on this

Yes, and it is not bad that I can do without the aid of galesses.

Comment on this

I think he is doing remarkably well.

Comment on this

Some Deputies opposite put up the suggestion that in order to finance derating, the beet industry finance derating, the beet industry should be scrapped. If that suggestion were put into practice, it would mean depriving 30,000 farmers of the advantages they derive form the growing of beet. It would mean putting out of employment the permanent staffs empolyed in the four sugar factories, as well as those employed in these factories during the campaign periods. It would mean mpre unemployment also for the transport whrkers—those engaged in the transport of the beet to the factories and of sugar from the factories—and would also mean a huge financial loss to those who have their money invested in the sugar companies, as well as those who have their moneys invested in the various transport undertakings in the country. I think it would be disastrous for the country generally if the beet industru were scrapped. We remember a time during the last war when beet growing and the sugar industry were unknown in this country and when we were dependent on foreign lands for our sugar supplies. Sugar was scarce and the price was exorbitant—far higher than the price to-day. We have no guarantee that a similar situation may not ariose again and unfortunately, there is every indication that in the furture there may be another world upheaval. I do not think the people, muck less the Government of this country, are foolish enough to scrap an industry that safeguards one of it important food supplies.

If derating comes by way of taxation, I am anxious to know how that will affect the small and the medium-sized farmers. I am but human, and if sonebody paid my rates and my annuities for me to-morrow morning, I should much appreciate to gift, bur if that somebody, after paying these things for me, were to take an amount of money 50 per cent. greater than what he has paid in order to finance the scheme, I should feel that I would much prefer to keep paying as I had been. To my mind, derating would only tend to make the rich richer and keep the grazier still a grazier, at the expense of other members of the community, including those farmers I speak of, and including even the farm labourer.

With regard to the suggestion of cheap loans for farmers, I want to point out that it is not fair to the farming community to say that a large percentage of them are badly off. Despite the economic struggle against Britain, the vast majority of our farmers came out of that struggle with their heads well above water. There are, of course, certain farmers, and there always were, who were not and are not now in a good position financially, but if you examine these people you will find that 50 per cent. of them are unable to meet their commitments to-day for the simple reason that they got a loan or went surety for somebody for a loan in the past. He who goes a-borrowing goes a-sorrowing, and I think you could not do a worse turn to the ordinary farmer than to encourage him to take loans.

Comment on this

Where were we going to get our £10,000,000?

Comment on this

I am speaking of the farming community. The Minister for Finance can arrange about the £10,000,000.

Comment on this

He will go a-sorrowing then.

Comment on this

There is an element of truth in it, even for the State.

Comment on this

Those are my views with regard to derating and cheap loans. With regard to the other point, according to the 1933 Land Act, the full repayment of the annuities will expire in the same number of years as it would if the annuities were not revised by 50 per cent.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree with that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would the Minister make a statement to that effect?

Comment on this

I advise the Deputy, who is a lawyer, to read up the 1933 Land Act. I am not a lawyer, but I have common sense.

Comment on this

If the Deputy read it he would see that there is no such thing in the 1933 Land Act, and I defy the Minster or anybody else to say that there is.

Comment on this

As regards the annuities, I know and I am satisfied with the use which is being made of the annuities that are being collected at the moment. As a farmer, it is no good to be too selfish. We have to consider the other members of the community. We have to consider the small farmers who are being provived——

Comment on this

Who have the votes!

Comment on this

—— With holdings through the land Commission. If the land annuties were forgiven the farmers to-morrow morning, the mony would have to be raised again by way of taxation, and I would prefer to keep paying the balance of may annuities than to start paying a land point that the sugar industry was not of any use to certain countries. I think that is a very narrow view. After all, there is a subsidy on butter and on eggs in order to make them an economic proposition for our farmers at the present day, despite the fact that we now have free access to the English market. I think it is rather short-sighted that one set of farmers should think it unfair to subsidise another set while they are being subsidised themselves. I should also like to point out to those Deputy that sugar beet pulp, which is a cheap and valuable food, is available for the feeding of live stock in those districts, and would be a far better bragain than the imported Indian meal.

Several Deputies objected to the exopenditure of £6,00,000 on defence Deputy Davin waxed eloquent on the matter last evening. As a matter of fact I think Deputy Davin is the most generous Deputy who has spoken so far in the House, because according to him we should get higher prices for our farm products, higher wages for our farm products, higher wages for everyone engeaged in industry, and a lower cost of living. Well I hope he can perform the miracle. In objecting to this £6,000,000 for defence he insinuated that there must be a secret agreement, despite the fact that the Taoiseach has pledged his word to the House and the country to the contaray. It is a peculiar fact that the Deputies who are not in agreement with this expenditure of £6,000,000 on defence never took an active part in bringing this country to the position it occupies to-day; they never took and active part in the military sense. I hold that as far as the people of this country are concerned they are anxions that any advance we have made and any advantage we have gained in this country should be strengthened, and that what is our own we should hold against all comers. It is well to remember that it took us over 700 years of suffering and sacrifice to achieve the position we have now arrived at.

Comment on this

The Deputy is looking brave and healthy after it.

Comment on this

It is as a result of that suffering and sacrifice that we are now in the happy position that every god of the Twenty-six Counties belongs to the people of Ireland, and to the people of Ireland alone, without any outside ingterference. As men were found willing to make these sacrifies down the centuries, and particularly within the past 20 years, to accomplish this fact, so the manhood of our country is still willing to defend the right of the Irish people. and the tax-payers of the country are still willing to defray the cost. That is as it should be. Looking back on our history, we find one very sad period. If we go back to the days of what was called the Grattan Parliament, the last Irish Parliament before Dáil Eireann was establised——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It seems a bit too far back to be relevant.

Comment on this

It is no harm to ramind some people that there is a past.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Unfortunatly, I am interested only in the present.

Comment on this

Very well. I am coming to the present. I do no want to see a repetition of what happened then. I do not want to have our shores exoposed to whatever power likes to come along here; I do not care whether it is King or Kaiser. I do not want to have the Irish people doing what the members of Grattan's Parliament did, when they sold their country and thanked God they had a country to sell.

Comment on this

The speech of the Minister for Eduction was rather remarkable. There were a few statemants made by him to show how prosperous this country has been for the past five or six years under the Fianna Fáil Government. He tried to prove to this House that the standard of living had not gone yup in the last five or six years. In order to prove that he instanced the case of the number of motor cars that had been purchased in this country. He did not tell us bout the number of motor cars that had been purchased on the instalment system under the Fianna Fáil Government or the number that possibly would never be paid for. He also instanced the number of picture housed erected in Dublin and the attendance at these picture housed during the last five or six years. Fancy the Minister for Education derawing his conclusions as to the prosperity of the country from the fact that there were so many thousand motor cars unpaid for and so many new picture houses in Dublin! I should like to ask the Minister has he ever gone outside the City of Dublin since he assumed office except to open some school or some new housing scheme. The Minister also told us that the Government had some to the relief of the unemployed by the provision of unemployment assistance and even went so far as to mention the giving of free beef to the people. Who paid for that? Was it not the people of the country? They were giving free beef because the Government deprived the people of employment. You would imagine that no one was paying for that.

We were told about the social services that were provided. One would imagine that the money for the upkeep of those social services came from some other country. The Minister did not tell us about the increased ates necessary for the upkeep of these services. He did not tell is that the rates had gone up by at least one-thrid within the last five or six years. What value are we getting for that? As against that, Deputy Corry told us last night that there should be some relief afforded in regard to rates. He said that a man paying £10 in rates a few years ago was now paying £20. The Minister for Education practically told us that that is not a fact, that the conditions in the country are much better to-day than five or six years ago. He also said that we are a free country now—— Deputy Meaney tried to follow him in that—and added that we were always a free country. If we were a free country five or sic years ago what was the need for the economic war? What was the need for making paupers practically of every section of the community? Not alone the farmers, but the business people, the labourers and the tradesmen have been brought to that position, bur particularly the farming community. If we were a free country five or sic years ago why was it necessary to put the country to the loss of £25,000,000 inside the last six years?

Comment on this

£5,000,000 per year.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party told us that this fight had to be made in order to regain our freedom, although the Minister for Education told us that we had our freedom. It had to be made in order to get back the ports on which money will have to be expended. I do not believe that that will be to the country's benefit. Even so far back as ten years ago we heard from the Taoiseach that there was only one country we should be afraid of—that he did not believe Germany or any other country would ever attack us. Now we have to spend £600,000 in order to protect that country that we were afraid of ten years ago.

Comment on this

Rubbish.

Comment on this

It is not rubbish.

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the £600,000 which is provided for in the Budget. That is the position into which you have put the country. After telling the people that you were going to win the fight and that then you would give relief to the people, and to the farmers particularly, what does the Budget tell them? That they will have to suffer on. Apparently the war is not over. That is the policy which Fianna Fáil wants the country to swallow. From my experience of the country during the last five or six years, I believe that that policy is not going to be swallowed by the people in future.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like another general election to test that?

Comment on this

Another portion of the Government's policy is that they are going to make the farmers prosperous by giving them £2 per ton for potatoes. The Minister for Education complimented the people on the organisation of the Carlow factory, but said that he was not satisfied with the working of the other three factories. The fact is that the Caarlow factory was organised long before this Government came into power. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us that the best paying industry at present was beet. Fianna Fáil members, including Deputy Corry, are practically telling the farmers that they should not grow beet at 37/6 per ton.

Comment on this

If we had not so many renagers in your country we would get more.

Comment on this

You are so intelligent now that you have sown it, that you do not know what you are going to get for it.

Comment on this

I know well what I will get for it.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry told us that night what they were giving for the upkeep of the roads and, at the same time, he said that he had not seen a horse and cart passing his house for some years. What does he see passing his house? Does he not see the moors and the lorries and are they not paying for the upkeep of the roads? Dose he think the money is coming from the Minister for Fiannce? The Government should give up bluffing as they have been bluffing long enough, and the people have found them out. The people were expecting some relief from this Budget for the losses they had suffered during a number of years. For what did they suffer these losses? In order that we should protect the ports for the country we condemned ten years ago.

Comment on this

An one who welcomed the recent Agreement and who understands its implications in a variety of ways, I did not expect as a cordollary to that Agreement any relief in any conceivable way to the tax-payers. Therefore, I will confine may remarks to one or two aspects of the Budget. I followed very closely the statement made by Deputy Meaney. I followed him up to the time when he went off the deep end and conjured up all these figures in ancient history. I was rather wondering if he was going to go back to the mythological figures which have impressed so many of our youthful people in the recent past. However, I do not want to follow Deputy Meaney into the past. I am sure we all appreciated that colourful peroration of his, and I am rather sorry that we do not hear more of that kind of stuff occasionally, because it helps, in some respect ay any rate, to colour the atmosphere of this rather drab Dáil. Earlier in the debate Deputy Davin, speaking on behalf of the Labour Party, asked a couple o very pertinent questions. I do not want to repeat those questions. I feel, however, that I can subscribe to much of what he said in the course of his speech but I certainly could not follow him in some of his attacks an the Ministers. For once ion a way, the Minister for Fianace had my sympathy. I believe in fair play, even for a Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Not too much.

Comment on this

I could not subscribe to Deputy Davin's statement that he and the Labour Party represented the majority of persons in this State who suffered more severely than any other section of the community. I do feel the working class of this country undoubtedly did bear a very great share of the suffering—I suggest a share equally as great as that of the working farmer of this country. I feel that the working classes undoubtedly have suffered as much as, if not more, in fact, than many of the working farmers of the country. In that I am at one with Deputy Davin, but I am not at one with him when he says that he and his Party represent the majority of the people of this country. The Deputies who represent the majority of the people of this country, whether you like it or not, or whether you believe it or not, are the Deputies who occupy the Government Benches. The second largest Party, of course, is the Fine Gael Party and the third largest Party is the Labour Party. It can never be said, therefore, that Deputy Davin's Party of 13 represents the majority of the people of this country .

Deputy Davin asked one very pertinent question, one to which the Irish people, as a whole, deman a clear and lucid answer, with regard to the £600,000 expenditure necessitated by the handing over of the forts. That and the question of Partition have caused a good deal of discussion, not alone here, but outside the House. I hold certain views in regard to that item in the Budget statement of the Minister and also in relation to the question of Partition, which possibly are not commonly felt. If they are felt by people inside and outside this House these persons do not make themselves vocal. I firmly believe that there is a tremendous lack of moral courage in the country. It is a challenging thing to say, I know, but there is, I feel, in this country a whole lot of make-believe. People say on public platforms things that they do not mean. I believe that kind of conduct is reponsible for many persons being elected to this House.

On the question of the expenditure of £6,00,000 on the forts, the Minister for Education, speaking a short time ago, indicated that all that £600,000 would not be spent on the forts. I do know that on the Estimate for Defence all these matters pertaining to the Vote may be, and undoubtedly will be, gone into, but when the Minister made that statement that not all the £600,000 would be spent on the forts, I was wondering if the Minister for Education had given any thought or study at all to the question of defence. He must know, and I as a layman do know, that £600,000 spent on the equipment of modern forts which, of course, connotes in addition, big guns and a certain number of aircraft——

Comment on this

Ad timber ones.

Comment on this

If you are a "cabogue" you should not be in this House. You caused more trouble in this country by your statement about blowing poison gas up to the North than all the most pugnacious speakers we had in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

In fact, you would not be tolerated in any House of Parliament that I know of and I have had many contacts, contacts sometimes soiled by people like you. On this question of forts, I have just indicated that the Minister for Education cannot have given the necessary thought to that question, otherwise he would not have said, as he did say, that not all of the £6,00,000 would be spent on the forts. It must be known certainly to the minister for Defence, as I am sure it is known to the Minister for Finance, that £6,00,000 is only an infinitesimal part of the amount that would be required properly to equip defences of this country. I subscribe to what my friend Deputy Meaney said a while ago, and what I think the Taoiseach has also said on another occasion, that we should be responsible for our own defence. Again, I want to point out that if we equip these forts and make sure that our defences will be as nearly foolproof as human agencies can make them, it will mean a tremendous amount of expense on the tax-paying community. I think that should be borne in mind when dealing with this matter of £6,00,000 in relation to those forts.

I have felt in that conection—it may be appropriate to say so now—that a more businesslike method would be to lay off some of that responsibility. I think there are many person, some members of the Fianna Fáil party, who are directors of insurance companies and they must know that they lay off a lot of their liabilities from time to time, just as stockborkers and bookmakers do, with firms in England. They often consider it a wise thing to do so long as they know that the firms to which they pass over this responsiblity are firms of standing. In that connection, I cannot see why we should not make the fullest possible use out of this Agreement and exploit it to the fullest. After all, why should the British not help in this direction? Let them accept at least the greater part of the responsibility of manning and equipping these forts. That may no seems a patriotic thing to say. I agree that sentiment may enter leargely into this question of the forts.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy is going into administration now.

Comment on this

I am referring to the expenses necessary for the maintenance of these forts. The Minister for Finance may suggest that the manning of these forts will absorb a lot of young men into the defence forces, possibly a couple of thousand, and that that, in turn, may relieve unemployment to that extent but it will be relieved to that extent only. No deep impression will be made in that way on the large volume of employment in the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is clearly adminstration.

Comment on this

As Deputy Davin was allowed to mention these matters——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davin was not allowed to go into administration.

Comment on this

At any rate, the question of floting the loan of £10,000,000 was touched on by some speakers, Althought I was not present then, I understand that that flotation will cost something like £425,000. I believe that Minister for Finaces is doing his best under rather difficult circumstances, and I feel, in view of the suggestions made by the Taoiseach and others that nothing should be done that would in any way damage the credit of the country. I fell that the credit of this country stands very high. We all wish success to the loan. I believe there will be a good deal of team work towards the floating of the loan, and that the Minister will get support from all sides of the House. Even where he dose not get support people will not make themselves vocal against it. That is an assurance that should be an encouragement to the Minister, and I am sure he appreciates it. I was wondering if the Minister had in mind the exploring of an avenue which I suggested in a question a few weeks ago, to try some other method of raising the money. The cost of the flotation, something like £425,000, seems like a lot of money.

Comment on this

As this is important perhaps I might interrupt the Deputy to say that the £425,000 includes the full service of interest and sinking fund accrued during the year.

Comment on this

I suppose that we can deduct something like 15 per cent, or 20 per cent. so?

Comment on this

Much more, I hope.

Comment on this

My calculation was a rough one. When the Minister for Education spoke he appeared to think that the improvement in the standard of living of the working people was due to the beneficence of this Government or the one that preceded it. I do not suggest that he said so in so many words, but that was the impression gathered on this side of the House. This Government and the one that preceded it had nothing at all to do with improving the position of the workers in relation to their standard of living. That was brought about by the Great War. There is no use in either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael telling any intelligent person that it was they brought about the improvement in the standard of living of the working—class people. However, I want to say, as the Government has been charged with doing nothing for the working classes, that at least two things stand to their credit. The only regret I have is that these things were done through political action instead of industrial action. the Government passed two measures, the Conditions of Employment Act and the Shops Act. I want to give credit where credit is due, and this Government has to be thanked for these two Acts. It is regrettable,however, that the Budget dose not give us any indication, either by way of relief of taxation or in other ways, that Budgets generally give. We have no indication whatever that relief will be given, whether by taxation or otherwise, to certain of our people who are unemployed. Emigration continues on a vary large scal. I am afraid it will continue on a still larger scale, because quite recently the Taoiseach tole us quite plainly that we cannot expect any immediate relief as a result of the Agreement.

Undobutedly, immediate relief has been given to a number of people in the cattle trade who were enabled yesterday to get their stock off to the English markets. I do not think that even these people have made any great profits out of the transaction, because it must be remembered that most of their stock was held up for 13 or 14 weeks. With hay costing £5 a ton, I do not think feeders could have made a lot of profit. It would not surprise me to hear that farmers and dealers had lost hundreds of thousand of pounds over this transaction. One thing that has emerged from the Budget is this, that we have no extra taxation worth talking about, while there are hopes of womething to come. I should like if the Minister, when replying, could throw some light on the question raised by Deputy Davin and by other speakers regarding the Banking Commission's report. I unreservedly accept the Minister's statement that he had not time to read the report because, as he explained, the evidence was so voluminous. One could quite understand that. After all, a Minister has certain responsibilites, and I could understand that he would be unable to find time to read through such a document. Bur I wish he could indicate if we are to have tat report at an early date so that any uneasiness that may exist may be removed. A good deal of uneasiness does exist in the minds of many people, and in order to remove it, perhaps the Minister could indicate the salient features of the report. If they are healthy so much the better and if unhealthy so much the worse for the Minister and for the country .

Comment on this

The introduction of a Budget gives the opportunity to the Oppostion to make a many points as they can possibly conceive against it and naturally against the government. The discussion of this year's Budget has been unique, inasmuch as the Opposition has failed to being forward any critisism of a practical kind or to shoe that the Budget contained anything that is contrary to the interests of the community when it is compared with Budgets introduced in other countries about the same time. The only suggestions against the Budget that were stressed by practically all speakers were the old and hackneyed ones that are normally used at election periods. These were concerned mainly with the derating of agricultural land, and doing away with some other forms of taxation. These suggestions are hackneyed and originated many years back at election times, but they offered no useful contribuation to the Budget debate and were of no practical use. One item mentioned in the Budget attracted a good deal of attention from the critics, and that concerned a sum of £600,000. Deputy Davin waxed very wrath about that item and opposed its existence. He seemed to see no useful purpose being served by the expenditute for which that sum was earmarked, and indicated that much better service could be obtained by using it for the derating of land. Deputy Davin must know that the amount of £600,000 would not do the whole if derating, but would only do part of it. He further indicated as means by which he would go further, that he would ask the State to take control of our main roads. I think he mentioned our mental hospitals, finding employment for out unemployed and increasing the amount of unemployment assistance paid to our unemployed. i do not know how he would get this with the sum if £600,000, seeing that that sum would hardly reduce by half the first claim he made on it, derating, and that it could not do more than increase by 50 per cent. the present allowance made of the unemployed in the country, and I do not know how he would achieve the remaining purpose, to find employment for our unemployed and the mainteanance of the main roads. How he is to get all those serviced out of that sum of money would be very enlightening indeed if he explained it to the Minister for Finance.

He also advocated in that direction, and I think it is only fair that it should be known, that not merely should the main roads of this country be taken over and made a STate service, but that the State should also take over the transport services in this country, which, he stated, are at present in a state of chaos. Deputy Davin is an official of that service himself, and I do not think a higher compliment could be paid to he Government than that he should indicate that they are capable of taking countol of a service that is in a chaotic condition and put it on a right footing. I am rather surprised that Deputy Davin, having regard to the position he holds in that service, would not have brought forward the suggestion that he ha in mind to make that service a success.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin would ask us to clear up the chaos which he has created.

Comment on this

That is a really good joke.

Comment on this

I think, instead of asking that State to take over this chaotic service, of which Deputy Davin is an official, that he should being forward his suggestions to his present board of directors and show them how they should do it.

Comment on this

Would you bring forward to the insurance companies similar proposals?

Comment on this

If the insurance service required my advice can I had it available I would be very glad to give it.

Comment on this

The policy-holders would like it in any case.

Comment on this

When I am dealing with my policy-holders they are satisfied with the position they are in and they do not ask for further improvement. That is the contribution that I listened to last night here from Deputy Davin and it was not a very illuminating criticism of the Budget. It certainly showed that if that was the amount of criticism that Deputy Davin was capable of offering on the Budget then the Budget must have been largely in a practical and sound position, that he was incapable of forming any charge against it, because he undoubtedly sought with great energy to make charges without consideration and to make a point against the standing of the budget.

Deputy Cole this evening again spoke with a good deal of, not consideration, but lack of consideration and the holding back of information that I am sure he himself was in possession of. He, too, of course, advocated derating, and he complained that the Minister for Education did not submit figures to show that what he said about the increase of deposits in the bank, in the Post office, was an indication of prosperity in this country. He found fault with the Minister for Education that he did not produce statistics to prove that, thereby conveying the impression that he did not believe the statement because of the absence of proof, but he himself has no doubt that this House should believe his statement, which is a sweeping one, unsupported by any evidence or statistics, that the country has become much poorer. Where is the logic in that sort of criticism?

Deputy Davin also stated that the farmers here are in a worse position than the farmers of the Sic Counties That is not true. So far as payments on the land are concerned, our farmers are in a better position, because, while we have not derating in its entirety, we have substantial assistance given to agriculturists in the form of reduction of the rates. We have also a reduction by half of the annuties. These facts are known perfectly well to Deputy Cole, and why is the time of this House wasted by misrepresenting or holding back facts that are essential and necessary to the statement, if it is to be a true repersentation of the case? Why time is wasted in that form is difficult to understand. Again I suggest it is a tribute to the Budget that is before us and that should be discussed in a practical way. It has not been discussed because the Oppfosition do not feel that they are entitled to come out and applaud it as it should be applauaded. They are incapable of finding a practical hold to point at, and they are unable to discuss it in a critical form with any degree of success for their own Party.

I think that this Budget is one which is entitled to recieve favourable mention from all parties in this country. It does contain all the essentials that go to make for better prospects and a better outlook for every section in this country. It embodies in its own way the general plan, Government plan, which covers practically every industry in this country. In so far as it opines better prospects for the farming community in this country if officers a very substantial and enconuraging thing to that very important section of our people. The improvement of agrciulture is guaranteed there. The improvement of our workers and industrialists is guaranteed. The continuation of bounties for our farm products, guaranteed prices for our farm products in the way of beet and wheat particularly, bounties for certain other export products, eggs, bacon, butter—— all these are guarantees for the farmer that he is going to receive, in the promise of that Budget, a better price for his stuff than this country could normally receive selling their stuff in the freest and best market in the world. Over and beyond the market which is offered to them, they are receiving in bounties a price that will leave them an advantage over any competitor. That is something that we should talk about and something our people should know. Our industrialists, in the same way; are guaranteed a continuation of industry. Another important fact in this community: the income tax people can satisfy themselves that if there is no reduction of their payments they are at least better off than those in the other end of our country, the Sic Counties, or in England. All these are very important and outstanding matters which we cannot emphasise sufficiently and we cannot, as some Deputies tried to do, in the one breath hold out that this country is in a sound financial position and thereby think that they are supporting the new flotation of the loan, and, in the next breath and in all their breaths, denounce the policy of the Government as the policy that has robbed and ruined and brought to the end of their resources all the people living in the country. You cannot blow hot and cold on these things. We must face realities. Until the Opposition in this country come to realise that and face up to realties, and call a spade a spade, call a good Budget a good Budget and convince the public that they are sincerely thinking of things in a practical way the Opposition in this country will continue to dwindle in its improtance, the loss of which will be a serious matter in this country, the loss of a serious attempt at opposition. This question of the spending of £600,000 seems o lend the Opposition an opportunity of suggesting that there is a motive there and a driving force for the spending of that money on these defences other than the will and the wants of he people of this country.

Comment on this

What is the hurry about it?

Comment on this

There is no hurry.

Comment on this

Mr. Chamberlain is in it.

Comment on this

There is no Chamberlain whatever in it. There is this hury about it that it is the first time we had the opportunity of deliberately planning the defence of our country from attack.

Comment on this

Where is the plan?

Comment on this

The plans should be in existence when the present occupiers give up possession of those ports.

Comment on this

Will you tell us what value are the plans?

Comment on this

I will tell you in this way what they are and what the reasons for these provisions are. If a farmer started farming in this country with grand ideas of farming, let us say theoretically; that he was to raise every form of produce that could be raised on that farm and that he was equipping his farm with machinery and every sort of implement that was needed, with the men necessary to work that farm and the experts that he needed, and after all that installation it was found he refused to put fences round that farm, would any man of common sense, however sound the theories that farmer had in his mind, say that such a man was going to make a success of his farm or that he was going to retain possession of it?

Comment on this

I cannot see the analogy.

Comment on this

Ha the Deputy the intelligence to see it? I am only trying to illustrate the position for him.

Comment on this

If Deputy Maguire has any intelligence he is displaying it very poorly.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with the Deputy who says that these ports are being fortified at the instigation of people outside the country, Mr. Chamberlain or anybody else. I cannot deal with that sort of argument. I am dealing with the practical reasons for putting up these deences. I am trying to show that if this country refused to take cognisance of its responsibilities and maintain its boundaries, then the people of this country cannot hope to maintain their territory in the event of future contingences.

Comment on this

How many battleships is the Deputy going to build with £600,00?

Comment on this

That is another thing. We hope to do as much with £600,000 as the Deputy told us last evening he was going to do with it.

Comment on this

One would think from the speech of Deputy Maguire that we were living 200 years back.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had lived 200 years back he would have the experience of 200 years, but he dose not appear to have benefited by any experience.

Comment on this

It is not our fault if the Deputy is unable to give a sound illustration.

Comment on this

I agree that the Deputy is not responsible for his appearance. None of us is.

Comment on this

It is want of intelli gence on Deputy Maguire's part.

Comment on this

Or lack of enthusiasm on the part of the Dublin voters.

Comment on this

Yes, or lack of inteelligence in the part of the Dublin voters.

Comment on this

I hope they are as intelligent as the Northern Ireland voters. They would not have the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will have no interruptions while the Deputy is speaking.

Comment on this

That is all right, but the House will know that a number of interruption took place before I spoke.

Comment on this

Allow the Deputy to speak.

Comment on this

Allow the Labour Party to run the House.

Comment on this

This is the new battleship.

Comment on this

The necessity for developing those defences is merely a matter of ordinary common-sense. No one would assume that there is any such thing as leaving open the ordinary form of defence even of farm fences. But that is an indication of the limitation of somebody's lip freedom. It is also an indication of the boundary over which somebody has a right to say the moment the fences are laid down that the fences should not be there; that somebody should say: "I should have the right to put my foot across it; I should have the right to control some part of that property." But will the fact that no fence is put up, that the place is left derelict discourage that tendency on the part of anyone who is inclined to trespass? Will it not rather be an incentive and an inducement to those who feel half inclined to do so to come in and trespass on that property.

Did anyone ever know of a house vacated, left derelict and wihout any supervision that in a very short time in come mysterious way, such a house was not prowled, plundered and carried away bit by bit? Is it not the same with our defences? If we leave these forts unprotected we may rest assured that as soon as war breaks out between any two big countries that one or both are going to say: "There are these waste forts over there; their possession by my enemy will be injurious to me; it is a question now which of us should get there first." If there is an indication given that the people who own these forts are to defend them no matter how small that defence may be, it is a direct repulse to any such approach. That is at least an indication if the sincerity of the people of this country to proctec t the freedom they have won. Failure to defend these forts; failure to build war defences would be leaving ourselves open to certain attack and certain particupation in any major war in future. Maintaining the defences of these forts is the only guarantee we can have of remaining in a neutral position when a war takes place. I suggest that the people who oppose the spending of this £600,000 have not considered this question at all from the national point of view.

Comment on this

There is one feature about this budget and that is that it has apparently impressed Deputy Maguire. I think most people will regard this a s a dull, unimaginative Budget introduced at a time when there are many problems confronting the country. The Budget deals with these problem sin a very perfunctory manner, leaving them completely untouched in many cases. Not only dose this Budget not solve but it does not attempt a solution of any of the problems which need solution. Besides this, it actually presents some new problems which, so far, have not troubled the country. Of the three main aspects of the Budget, it might be said that they contain noting to deal with the very grave prbolem of unemployment which exists in this country notwithstanding the mythical El Dorado of which Deputy Maguire has been telling us. It does nothing in a substantial way to assist the farmer and the agricultural community. On the contrary, it creates new problems, imposing upon this country what may turn out to be the crushing burdens of armaments.

Deputy Maguire tells us that we should be proud of and pleased with this Budget. He says we ought to be pleased and satisfied that all our problems have now been brought to an end, and he tells us that there was now opening up to the country a vista of prosperity which the country had never before seen.

What are the facts of the situation? Notwithstanding the glowing picture painted by Deputy Maguire, the Department of Industry and Commerce tells us that there are still 100,000 people registered at the employment exchanges in the country. There is the fact that 100,000 persons have satisfied the rigorous test that they are unable to get work and that their pitiable plight calls for relief through the medium of the Unemploy-ment Assistance Act. If we pass from that situation to the national health section of the Department of Industry and Commerce we find that taking the past three years the numbers drawing benefit under the national health insurance have increased in some cases by 25 per cent. Now that is the situation which to-day confronts us in this country, notwithstanding Deputy Maguire's belief that everything in the garden is lovely. There is in this Budget no proposal for facing up to a situation of that kind. There is no proposal in this Budget whereby the State may tackle in an effective manner a serious problem of that kind, a problem which brings misery and destitution in its train and which constitutes the most serious menace that was ever known to the progress and prosperity of this country.

We used to be told away back in the light-hearted days of 1931 and 1932 that the Government had a plan for the solution of the unemployment problem. We used to be told then that Fianna Fáil would cure unemployment, that it was merely yearning for an opportunity of introducing its proposals and these would result in the complete solution of that problem. After six years we find 100,000 persons registered as unemployed at the employment exchanges and there are no proposals whatever in this Budget for dealing with a problem of that kind. In my opinion the unemploy-ment problem is likely to get worse and not better owing to the developments within recent weeks. The London Agreement which has been signed in my opinion opens up new difficulties of an economic kind. Clause 8 of that Agreement provides that our existing tariffs, quotas and restrictions must be reviewed by the Prices Commission in such a manner as to give the United Kingdom producers full opportunities for selling their goods here. There can be only one meaning in that Clause and that is that United Kingdom producers——

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The subject-matters of the London Agreement, the merits or demerits of that Agreement, do not fall for discussion on these Financial Motions.

Comment on this

May I submit that I am quite entitled to refer to it and it has always been the practice on a Budget discussion to deal with such proposals, if any, as may be made for the relief of unemployment? I am entitled, therefore, in accordance with the practice in the House, to refer to the problem of unemployment and, if I so desire, to show that it is a problem for which no provision has been made and that it is a problem which is tending to grow more serious and to merit much more the attention of the Government. I do not propose to discuss the London Agreement except to point out, with your permission, that in certain respects it is calculated to aggravate the problem with which I want to deal, namely, unemployment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

What I want to guard against is that in discussing the question of unemployment the Deputy does not discuss the London Agreement.

Comment on this

I do not propose to discuss the London Agreement. I merely propose to say that, in my opinion, the problem of unemployment is calculated to get worse and the events of the past few weeks are calculated to aggravate it, because we may now be giving a portion of this market to producers in another country to supply and I submit that the fact that they are going to supply it on certain terms now envisaged for them is calculated to add to the number of unemployed in this country. During the past week I have seen the representatives of many trade unions in this country. They came to me and told me they had good reason to believe, from their own experience and from the information conveyed to them by employers, that the effect of the Agreement was calculated to slow down production in the future and that they did not think they could continue to hold their present share of the home market.

I think anybody who has taken the trouble to inquire during the past couple to months into industrial productivity and employment in the country will find that a substantial number of hands have been laid off in various factories through want of orders. He will also find that there is now a feeling of instability and unsteadiness in many industries and, in respect of some of them, they have great fears as to their capacity to carry on in view of the picture opened up to them. I think that is the experience of anybody who has any contact with industry and who has had any contact with the trade unions catering for the workers in many of the industries affected by the Agreement. If that fact were not obvious through contacts of that kind, the fact that the Department of Industry and Commerce has been stormed by deputation after deputation asking where they stand and what is the effect on certain tariffs, quotas and restrictions, would indicate a certain feeling of instability and, in turn, it must inevitably add to the problem of unemployment.

We have, therefore, apart from large-scale migration, a problem of 100,000 unemployed, notwithstanding the fact that we had assurances from the present Government that it had a plan for the solution of unemployment and only awaited the votes of the people to put the plan into operation and solve a very serious problem. In this Budget there is no proposal whatever calculated to absorb the unemployed into productive employment. There is no proposal even for increasing the low rates of unemploy-ment assistance benefit paid to them during periods of unemployment. The Government have now cultivated the mentality that unemployment is an insoluble problem so far as they are concerned. They are willing to continue to treat the unemployed by means of giving them miserable pittances each week, but they have apparently abandoned all effort to deal with the unemployment problem in the big and comprehensive way of which they talked so glibly in 1931 and 1932. Unemployment, according to the Government actions, is now an insoluble problem and the Minister for Finance does not spend much time propounding solutions for the problem or making financial provision for its solution in the Budget.

There have been discussions on this Budget as to the position of the farmers. Mention has been made of the fact that the farmers' savings have been relatively intact, notwithstanding the conditions through which they have passed for the past six years. Anybody who is in contact with the rural constituencies, with the farming community; any Deputy who has to deal with the problem of the agriculturist, knows perfectly well that the problem of the farmer to-day is a problem of having no money form any source. Anybody who makes a contrary statement knows nothing whatever about the conditions of the agricultural community. If you go through the country and take any trouble to make inquiries into the matter, you will find the farmer is suffering from the problem of having no money, and his lands are not nearly stocked to capacity. He has no means of getting new stock, having borne heavy losses through the events of the last few years.

This Budget does nothing to deal with that situation or to make available credit facilities for the farmers. It does nothing whatever to realise the enormous wealth which resides within a properly developed agricultural economy. This country has been said to be mainly an agricultural community. In recent years efforts have been made to establish an industrial arm, but the main source of wealth here has been, and for a long time must continue to be, agriculture. It is the height of economic insanity not to avail ourselves of the opportunity to develop to the full our agricultural possibilities and sell our agricultural produce in a market which is capable of absorbing a substantially greater proportion of agricultural produce than we are capable of providing for it to-day.

Everybody knows that during the past six years there have been considerable difficulties confronting the agriculturists of this country. Everybody knows that, due to the economic war, farmers were put in a very difficult position: that the market which would normally be available to them was restricted and that they were only permitted to trade in that market on terms which imposed heavy losses upon them. That period has now come to an end, and, realising the possibilities of that market and realising the wealth which is contained within the agricultural economy of this country, we ought now to take steps to exploit our agricultural possibilities to the full; but how can you exploit our agricultural possibilities, having a farming community, on the one hand short of money, an don the other hand, unable to obtain credit facilities on terms which will not impose a very heavy burden upon them? There is not a bank in the country to-day that would lend a farmer money on land—and the bigger the holding of land is, the harder it is for the farmer to get money. There is not a bank in the country to-day that would lend a farmer money on a small-holding. It may be said that the Agricultural Credit Corporation is there for the purpose of advancing money to farmers for agricultural purposes, but if one takes the trouble to inquire into the inquisitions that are held by the Agricultural Credit Corporation as a condition of granting a loan to a farmer, one will find that a very negligible proportion of farmers in this country could possibly avail of any facilities offered by that corporation. Before you have any chance of getting a loan of money from the Agricultural Credit Corporation, you must owe no rents, you must owe no rates, you must owe no traders' bills, you must have no shop debts, you must have your annuities paid up to date, and, in fact, in order to have any chance of getting money there, you must really be in such a position that almost anybody would lend you money. The very fact that such a small amount of money is lent annually, and the small sums lent to small farmers, is an indication that that corporation never can adequately finance the rehabilitation of the agricultural community in this country, and agriculture, obviously, must be rehabilitated if we have any commonsense left so far as the economy of this country is concerned.

It is obvious that the farming community must be assisted to get over the losses they have sustained during the last few years, and good sense suggests that the farmers ought to be financially assisted in order to enable them to take advantage of the opportunities which are now available to them in the matter of supplying another market. I would suggest, therefore, that the Minister for Finance might have availed of this Budget as an opportunity to indicate that the Government realises the losses which the agricultural community have suffered during the past six years and that, so far as the resources of the State permit, agriculture would be assisted in every possible way to rehabilitate itself and to equip itself for the task ahead. One of the ways in which that could be done would be by the raising of a very substantial sum in the form of an agricultural loan, in order to make available to farmers credit facilities at extremely low rates of interest. Even if the general community were to bear the service of the debt in the form of providing for the payment of the interest I think the expenditure of a large sum of money, by means of an advance to farmers throughout the country, would help to absorb a very large number of unemployed persons in the rural areas: would help to take them of the unemployment assistance rates and would given them some hope that the next six years would not be as bleak and as miserable for them as the last six years have been.

It has got to be realised that, while you may open a new factory in a town or in a city, or while you may start an occasional new factory in a rural area, you cannot put a factory, in a small country like this, into every rural area in the country or into every small town throughout the country. What hope, therefore, have we of absorbing the adolescent boys and girls in these areas except through the medium of agriculture? What hope have we of absorbing into productive employment the large number of growing young men in rural areas who are unable at present to get employment in agriculture and who have to seek, in the emigrant ship, relief from the misery of long-continued unemployment, except through the medium of agriculture? We could make every big and every small farm in the country, however, a kind of agricultural workshop if you could only stimulate the farmer into industrial productivity by making available to him credit facilities on terms that would be acceptable to him. If we have any faith in the development of agriculture; if we have any belief that the opening again of the British market is going to be of assistance to agriculture, then, obviously, we ought to take steps to assist agriculture to benefit by the change which has now taken place and to recover some of the heavy losses of recent years.

In this debate the provision of a sum of £600,000 for armaments has been referred to, and we must bear in mind that that sum of £600,000 is for armaments for a portion of this year. The size of that sum, and hte fact that provision had to be made at short notice, is an indication, of course, of what we are likely to experience in future years in respect of the new armaments policy upon which we are about to embark. Everybody, I think, will praise the fact that the ports are now to be restored to the jurisdiction of this country. They ought never to have been out of the jurisdiction of this country, because Britain never had any moral right whatever to occupy ports in this country, and the restoration of these ports was just a recognition by Britain that she never had a right to occupy these ports rather than a gesture of any generosity on her part towards the country. Having taken them over, not merely have we reintegrated the ports with the rest of the country as Irish territory, but apparently we are now to embark on a policy of defending the ports. Now, I want to raise the question here as to the wisdom of embarking on a policy of that kind, which is eminently suitable to Britain, and which meets Britain's imperial needs and her shipping needs. Does it, however, meet Irish needs, and is it not calculated to have our association with Britain for defence purposes seriously misunderstood throughout Europe and the world? The original scheme of defending Cobh, Berehaven and Lough Swilly was for the purpose of enabling Britain to have ports of defence for her trade routes. Britain defended the southern coast of this country because, from a shipping point of view, it is the busiest portion of the ocean.

Comment on this

Is not this a matter, Sir, more appropriate to the Estimate for Defence?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This question has been discussed already.

Comment on this

Yes, because you, Sir, permitted it to be discussed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Minister wants to make any reflection on the ruling of the Chair, there is a method of doing it, if the Minister so desires, but the Chair will not take from the Minister that statement regarding the Chair's ruling. The Chair ruled in accordance with Standing Orders to the effect that matters of expenditure, taxation, revenue and financial policy could be discussed.

Comment on this

My view, Sir, for what it is worth, is that this matter ought properly to be discussed on the Estimate. However, I am at the mercy of the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister may not make a reflection on the Chair in that fashion, any more than any other Deputy may do so. The Minister has to obey the ruling of the Chair just the same as any other Deputy.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir; I bow to your ruling, because I must.

Comment on this

I was pointing out, Sir, before the disorderly interruption of the Minister for Finance, that it was very questionable whether a scheme of defending the ports, situated as they are, was one that suited Irish interests. I was saying that these ports were originally defended by Britain in order to protect her trade routes. Britain wants to protect the shipping off the south coast of Ireland going into British ports, and she wants to protect the shipping off the north coast of Ireland going into Scottish ports. These are the chief British shipping highways, and it is for that reason only that these ports were defended. Now, we are to take over these ports and to protect them and defend them, even though they are not on our shipping lines. We are going to defend these ports now, and they are the nearest defence ports to British shipping routes. I question whether that is good policy from an Irish point of view.

Comment on this

The Deputy had his chance to speak and vote against the Agreement when he was told that the ports were going to be modernised.

Comment on this

That is only another way of saying that I am not entitled to raise that matter here, although the Chair has ruled to the contrary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has interrupted; that is all.

Comment on this

Can the Minister not wait until he gets a chance of replying? Could he not just keep quiet until he comes to reply?

Comment on this

I can understand a British Prime Minister interrupting me on this, but why he should manage to get a Deputy in the Parliament of Éire to do his work is another matter.

Comment on this

Is that, Sir, in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will hear the Minister if he will point out to me the disorder in it.

Comment on this

The Deputy has suggested that the Prime Minister of England has retained my services. Is that in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Norton has suggested that a British Prime Minister has got a Deputy in this House to make a certain statement. That is all.

Comment on this

Yes. Mark what you have said: that another gentleman outside this House has got a person in this House to make a certain statement.

Comment on this

May I put the Minister's fears at rest and say that the question only reveals his own vanity?

Comment on this

Is that in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no precedent to guide me, but I have heard it suggested in this House, if my memory serves me right, that members of another Parliament found Deputies of this House to make statements for them also on other occasions.

Comment on this

Traitors and Imperialists.

Comment on this

Is that in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no precedent with me as to how they were dealt with.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the defences of these forts, situated where they are, are going to be of much more use to Britain than they are to this country. I ask the question here on this Budget discussion: what are we going to defend these particular forts for? Why should we defend only the forts that are protecting British shipping routes?

Comment on this

Where is the suggestion in this Budget statement that only these forts will be defended?

Comment on this

May I ask that the Taoiseach be sent for to try and keep his Minister for Finance in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Norton.

Comment on this

It is quite clear to everyone that the main immediate armament policy is to defend the forts which have been taken over, and the point that I am raising is: why should we proceed at once, and with this indecent haste, to protect, defend and modernise forts which are to protect British shipping routes? One might argue in another sense that you could have a defence policy related to Irish needs, and I am prepared to admit that that is something with which one could say with ease "that is the right road or the wrong road"; but for the moment I want the House and the country to realise that we are now embarking on a policy of equipping and modernising forts to protect British shipping routes. I want to know, is it worth our while as Irish people to defend these forts, having regard to Irish interests. What purpose is achieved in defending these Irish forts? What purpose is gained by starting off immediately to take over and defend these forts—we were told by the Taoiseach that they would be defended—with this speed, without first giving consideration to the whole question as to what is the best method of defence to employ, what are the best centres to defend, and against whom are we going to defend the forts?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is now going on to administration.

Comment on this

I do not propose to deal with administration at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The policy of defence would be indicated by the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

I am raising the question as to why we should immediately embark upon spending money in taking over, equipping and modernising these forts with such haste without having a thought-out policy, because clearly we have not thought out any defence policy for the nation. I am not talking about routine or purely administrative methods of defence. Defence has long since ceased to be a matter of defence. It is really to-day a political matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I can only hear the Deputy on expenditure with reference to defence, and not on defence policy. Obviously that would be a matter for the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

I am doing my best to indicate to you that I am not discussing the details of this foolish expenditure of £600,000 on an incompletely thought-out defence policy, leaving aside altogether the routine administration of defence. I want to know why we are spending this £600,000, and for what purpose, and whom are we defending the forts against. These are the two main questions that I am concerned with. I want to know: who are we to assume is the enemy?

Comment on this

Am I entitled to raise a point of order on this?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this

Surely there is one matter that is clearly a question of defence policy and not financial policy. It is: whom are we going to defend ourselves against? Deputy Norton says he wants to know on this debate which concerns itself with financial policy: whom are we going to defend ourselves against?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have already indicated to Deputy Norton that I will not allow him to discuss matters which appertain to the Ministry of Defence, and so far I have followed Deputy Norton closely. As far as I understand the matter, he has confined himself to the advisability of the financial policy of the Government in expending £600,000 on the equipment, etc., of the ports.

Comment on this

I submit that the question as to whether the £600,000 is well or ill-spent depends upon whether it is good defence policy or not to modernise these forts. My submission is that you cannot discuss that. You can only say that the country cannot discuss whether it is good policy or bad policy to modernise the forts, and Deputy Norton's speech has been devoted to that one particular question whether it is good defence policy or not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think Deputy Norton's speech has been devoted to the question as to whether it is good or bad policy to spend £600,000 on the forts. That seems to me to imping on expenditure and on financial policy.

Comment on this

I submit it is entirely a question of defence.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the reluctance of the Minister for Finance to tell us what he is going to do with the £600,000. We are going to expend £600,000. Whom are we going to protect ourselves against? Is the enemy to come from the East or the West?

Comment on this

The Deputy was told that.

Comment on this

I want to know where the enemy is to come from. In the past we used to be told that Britain was the only enemy. I want to know is she the only enemy still, and is the £600,000 going to the spend defending the country against Britain. If it is I could see my way to a new view of the thing and could understand an expenditure of £600,000, or even more, but is that the policy? Is it on that assumption that the £600,000 is being asked for? Is the assumption now that we need to defend the country against Britain who, in the past, was the only enemy, the traditional enemy, or are we now going to run the risk of taking on a new enemy elsewhere and a worse enemy, and from what source may we except attack? I think I am entitled to ask from whoever is in charge of Government business here what are we spending this £600,000 for. Is it for the purpose of preventing Britain from again putting her foot into the portion of this country over which this Parliament has jurisdiction, or is it for the purpose of lining up with Britain to resist a possible attack on British shipping interests in this region by a Continental air power? Surely we ought to have some light and guidance as to what we are being committed to, and what this £600,000 is going to be spend on, because it will be contributed, in the main, by people who have their own economic needs still unsatisfied. I should like the Minister for Finance to tell us on exactly what principle this new armament policy is being based and exactly on what fear this £600,000 is being spent. What are we trying to avert? Do we still fear Britain, or do we fear a Continental air power?

Comment on this

Is this financial policy?

Comment on this

I think the whole policy of defence needs to be——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The policy of defence does not arise on this Resolution.

Comment on this

I am going to suggest that the policy of defence in the future needs to be carefully studied, particularly in relation to this new armaments race. If it is not possible to tell the nation as a whole what it is committed to in respect of armaments, at least some machinery ought to be evolved for supplying Parties in this House, who have responsibility to the country, with particulars of the kind of defence machinery we are being committed to, how much we shall have to raise to finance it, when it is going to start and when it is going to end, and what will be the burden over the entire period. We should be told now what load the country is being asked to bear and the objective, from the Irish point of view, for which it is being asked to bear that load. Everybody knows that £600,000 would not provide anything like adequate protection for this country. An expenditure of £600,000 would not keep out an invasion of bees. It is only the wedge, and, when we get to the end of the wedge, we may discover that the expenditure is to be substantially higher than £600,000. I do not want to see this country committed to a colossal armaments policy which may be unnecessary, on the one hand, and useless on the other hand. I do not want to have the people of this country told, as the people of other European countries have been told, that they should be glad to sacrifies their standard of living and their food to finance an armaments policy. I realise that it may be necessary, in certain circumstances, to take certain measure. We ought to know what measures we are expected to take. We ought to see the road clearly. We ought not to be asked to expend money on the incomplete statement of national defence which we have had from the Government. This is a small country, and, while it has substantial resources, they are relatively limited when it comes to buying armaments. Al these armaments will have to be bought outside the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is now dealing with administration.

Comment on this

I have not spent a second on that and, on my way to make an argument, I shall inevitably have to use some words which may be common to administration and to policy. That is due to the limitations of the language rather than to any inherent weakness on my part or any desire to be out of order. I should prefer to have the money to be spend or armaments devoted to raising the standard of living of the people. In any event, I do not want to see money used in such a way that its expenditure will be capable of having our aspirations and our outlook misinterpreted. We have no imperial designs on Britain or on any other country. We have no desire for territorial expansion. All we desire is the reintegration in the motherland of the portion Britain has wrung from us and keeps from us by hte use of her armed forces. I do not want to see this country linked up with Britain in an imperial defence policy while she is occupying the North, and I do not want to see our people linked with an imperial defence policy which is capable of having our position misunderstood in Europe.

Comment on this

Is this defence policy or merely finance?

Comment on this

I fear that the expenditure of this £600,000 is going to create a complete misconception of our policy in Europe. I think that there is hope and moral strength to be get by this country by constantly proclaiming our neutrality, by making it clear to the peoples of Europe that we have no imperial designs, and that we desire only to live in peace, our last political objective being to get Britain out of portion of this country in which she has no right. A policy of that kind would give us a straightforward position incapable of misunderstanding. I am afraid that the expenditure of this large sum as an instalment on a hastily-thought-out armaments policy, taking no notice whatever of the source from which an attack may be expected, is capable of doing us considerable mischief in Europe.

Comment on this

At the outset, the Minister is to be congratulated on having introduced a Budget which reflects very accurately a Budget which reflects every accurately the subdued atmosphere which we have in the country since the new Agreement was entered into with Great Britain. I am glad to say that that atmosphere is reflected in the Dáil. At least, it has been reflected up to this evening. There have been a few ripples on the surface this evening but I am sure they will blow over and leave no trace behind. Even Deputy Corry spoke in this debate in every chastened mood. It looks as if, at long last, this Dáil is about to become what it was originally intended to be—a deliberative assembly. I hope that that spirit will inspire those who, in the future, will be responsible for our legislative programme, that the subdued tempo which we have in the country at present will have a retarding influence on our Bill-making machinery. Deputies, during the hectic years of the economic war, have been faced with the necessity of digesting and assimilating a regular plethora of incongruous and oftentimes contradietory legislation. The effect has been serious enough to Deputies but it was still worse int he case of the lawyers in the Four Courts who had to interpret this extraordinary accumulation of legislation. What the effect has been on the business community I cannot say but I do know that the farmers, as a result of this hurly-burly for many years, have been almost at their wits' ends. And is it any wonder? If the Ministers, instead of adopting the ordinary procedure, had brought into the House big drums of the Hospitals Trust, threw the various legislative measures into it holus-bolus, and then picked them out in the same haphazard way in which the sweep prizes are drawn, the result could scarcely be more bewildering or more problematical.

Nobody was driven further by this economic war that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and we all watched, with the greatest sympathy, the extraordinary eforts he made by legislation to save the baby of economic self-sufficiency. I am sure that the Minister is pleased that this ordeal is now over and we are pleased to be in the position of watching him coming back, slowly but surely, to the policy of his predecessors—the policy of selective protection. We all hope— and it is very difficult to find out how this Budget is going to affect them— that the great majority of the industries founded by the Minister will be put on a permanently healthy basis; but we must realise that the success of those industries will depend, to a very much greater extent, on the spirit animating the employers and employees in those industries than on any artificial stimuli applied by the Minister. The people of this country in the past have heartily supported native industry and they will continue to support it in the future, but that does not mean that there is no limit to the amount of money which the people are prepared to expend in order to give a preference to native industries, or no limit to the length of time during which they are prepared to continue giving that preference. If the Irish people have been sufficiently patriotic to make genuine sacrifies to ensure the success of Irish industries without any prospect of gain or advantage to themselves the least they may expect is that those employers and employees whose profits and jobs depend on the patriotic feelings of the general public will at least reciprocate.

I agree with Deputy Dillon in the proposal he made here the other evening, that in the same way as the Minister has seen fit to take the tariffs off certain articles used by the blind, and particularly the blind in institutions, he should also be prepared to remove the tariffs from certain commodities, free entry of which into this country would greatly relieve the burdens on the very poor. Deputy Dillon gave the instance of cotton underclothing manufactured in Japan which could be purchased here for 1/- apiece. Those articles were a very great help to the poorer type of manual worker, and there are various other commodities of the same type which, if they were allowed into this country, without tax, would give great relief to the poor. Such an arrangement would not cost the Exchequer very much and would not interfere with the progress or prosperity of our native industry, and I think the Minister should give consideration to that subject. I am not, int he ordinary way, in favour of purchasing very many commodities from Japan, and not for the reason which seemed to be at the back of Deputy Dillon's mind, but because Japan purchases very little from us. I think that in the ordinary way we should make most of our purchases in those countries which purchase most from us, purely as a business arrangement. I do not agree with the view held by certain Deputies, that comodities which come into this country from Japan are produced by sweated labour. Modern factories in Japan are extremely efficient, and, in their own way, the Japanese workers in those factories are as well housed, as well clothed, and as well fed as our workers in similar factories here. I merely say that because I think it would be a bad idea to allow abroad that the reason we are not able to compete with Japan or any other country is that our conditions are better here than in those countries.

On page 23 of the Minister's statement, there is a passage which puzzles me and somewhat alarms me. So far as I can gather, it simply means that the Minister intends at an early date to increase valuations in this country. Already something tantamount to that has been done for income-tax purposes. The Minister has, and in fact, all Ministers have, a decided tendency to place on the rates the cost of schemes and services which rightly should be borne by the central Exchequer, and this expedient of increasing valuations, and, as a consequence, the amount of the rate collectible will enable the Minister to carry on in a still more flagrant manner this very reprehensible practice. The Minister in his speech went out of his way to plume himself on his generosity in increasing taxation for the purpose of extending our elemosynary services. Already it has been pointed out by many speakers, and I do not intend to follow them, that a great deal of this expenditure is not confined to social services, but is spread over such services as the Army, the Gárda Síochaána, and the Civil Service. Even if it were a fact that all this increased taxation was being expended on such excellent services as old age pensions, unemploy-ment assistance and insurance and so forth, I do not think the Minister has any reason to plume himself in that respect. It is no indication of progress or prosperity in a country. In fact, the opposite would be the case. If he were in a position to reduce the amount expended on those services, the country would be in a much sounder position.

When this Dáil was first established, I remember that one of its earliest activities was to set about devising a scheme for getting rid of the workhouses which advertised the poverty of the Irish people to the world, but the Minister does not scruple to boradeast from this House the social disabilities of our people in a much more effective way than was ever done by the old workhouses. Ministers are becoming very sensitive about the £2,000,000 reduction in taxation that they promised us when they were out of office. When the Ministers were out of office there was not a weapon in the armoury of political warfare which they did not use, and use unscrupulously, against their predecessors in office. They did not care whether they hit above the belt or below the belt, or what the effect was on the nation, so long as they could have a crack at the Government. Now, when the shoe is on the other foot, they expect that no weapon should be used against them. Possibly, the Ministers may find that we on this side of the House are not ready to pay them back in the same coin. They may find that we are not going to continue taunting them with their reckless promises in the past, and their still more reckless incitements to a credulous public, but they will probably find that there are people outside this Dáil, in the country, with long memories, people who will continue to ask awkward questions and who will not forget as readily as we do.

This Budget will prove a very serious disappointment to the farmers, who have borne the brunt of the economic war. Many fo the most progressive and industrious of those farmers have gone with the wind of that war, and it is up to the Minister to see that so far as possible the survivors are put on their feet. Money put into the land, particularly in an agricultural country like Ireland, is never lost. The farmers of this country have submitted to something which I might compare to a transfusion of blood operation in order to save the rest of the community during this ordeal. It would be only common justice, as well as very good business, to see that the strength of this industry is restored. Of course, there will always be a difference of opinion as to how you can best assist the farmers. It is generally held by economists that the soundest way in which you cab help them is by reducing their overhead charges. That naturally leads s to derating. Derating has been criticised on the grounds that it helps the larger farmer to a greater extent than the smaller farmer. I think that is a very unsound and very mean sort of criticism. I have always regarded the agricultural industry in this country as a unit. I think it is right that it should be so regarded. If you help the farmer in Dublin and Koldare. In the same way, in helping the bigger farmers in Kildare and Dublin you are helping the smaller farmers in Donegal and throughout other parts of Ireland. I believe the Minister should give derating, and along with that I believe the tariffs should be taken off agricultural implements and artificial manures unless, of course, in exceptional cases where some of those implements are manufactured here at approximately the same cost as the imported article, and where you turn out just as good an article. But in the present state of affairs in the country. I do not think that is sufficient. A great number of farmers here are just hanging on to their holdings by the skin of their teeth. At the present moment, as a result of the depression not only during the economic war but some time before that—because world depression had hit this country even before the present Government got into office, but certainly it was greatly intensified during the economic war—a great many farmers are in a very serious position. Their capital has gone. Not merely that, but their land has run down; they have taken successive crops of hay off their land, and they have not been puting manure into it. A great many of the farms in this country are under-stocked or not stocked at all. Something drastic will have to be done in order to remedy that situation, and I think the Minister would be wise if he granted a moratorium to annuitants for two years until the farmers get on their feet.

The Minister for Education has reminded us that the proper way to help agriculture and the proper way to reduce the overhead charges in the agricultural industry is to increase production. There is no good in preaching about an increase of production if there is no capital or no other means of increasing production. If a moratorium were granted, the credit of those farmers would immediately go up. They would be able to purchase the stock required for their land. They would be able to purchase manures, and in all respects bring their land into heart. They would then be in a position to avail to the full of the new conditions which result from the re-opening of the market in England. I think it should be the Government's policy to see that every acre of land which has been divided in this country, at a considerable cost to the taxpayers, is utilised to its fullest capacity. That is the only way in which the people can be reimbursed for their very heavy expenditure on the acquiring and division of estates in this country. I do not intend to say any more on that matter. The important item in the Budget, the £600,000, has been very well debated. Deputy Norton in particular has dwelt on it with great and pungent effect. It is really a very important item. I think everybody in the country anxious to know whether this £600,000 is to be a recurring charge; whether it is going to remain as it is or be increased; whether, as Deputy Norton said, it is merely the thin end of the wedge, and whether we may expect something much bigger to follow. Most important of all, everybody would like to know thether this expenditure on defence or imperial defence. The answers to those questions will, to a very large extent, decide how good was the settlement with Great Britain. I am not criticising that settlement, because we all realised that anything which would bring the economic war to an end of a reasonable basis would be a good settlement, but we should like to have answers to those questions so that we may know exactly where we stand.

Comment on this