Committee on Finance. - Resolution No.11-General (Resumed).
Contributions 201–409 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
This Budget has been a very disappointing one. In fact the keynote of the whole Budget has been disappointment for every class of the community. Naturally, taking into account the amount of money raised on taxation last year, an amount which approximated to the whole productivity of the country, those who had studied the position felt that with the new settlement the Minister should have at least some millions of money at his disposal to bring relief to certain classes of the community. Last year the whole productivity of the agricultural industry amounted to something like £43,000,000. Adding up the impositions on the people in the form of supply services, central fund services and Supplementary Estimates, and including local taxation, you will find that the aggregate of taxes and rates borne by the people approximated to that sum of £43,000,000, so we may well ask ourselves what did this country live upon. We have one basic industry—agriculture. The whole of it was absorbed in taxation, and what did the country live on? Somebody said we lived on the change out of the Civil Service salaries. That probably was only a joke. We produce nothing else in this country but agricultural goods. All the other industries are really a form of change from one kind into another, because we have no raw materials in this country. As I said, this Budget has been very disappointing. We felt that when the economic war was over there would be at least £4,000,000 at the Minister's disposal to bring relief to the taxpayer who had been paying this enormous sum of £43,000,000. What do we find? The Minister, instead of telling us that there is going to be any relief brought to us tells us that we are already enjoying reliefs, that the farmer is already enjoying half the annuity. But he has been enjoying that for the last four or five years. The Minister brings in no positive relief in this Budget. This Budget does not bring any relief to the farmer directly in any possible way.
In connection with this debate, one or two things have suck me very forcibly. ONe was, that the manner in which the Budget was approached from the Fianna Fáil Benches showed us how thorough, practical and effective has been the political education of Fianna Fáil during the last five years. Then, again, when I heard Deputy Norton capturing the whole Fine Gael policy with regard to helping the farmers, I thought we had at last reached the political Elysium in the splendid form of unity, that we had Labour, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael united in one splendid effort to help the farmers —a magnificent state of affairs.
I have heard so much about the farm ing community this evening, that I should like to part from the farming community for a moment and turn the Minister's attention to some other portions of the community where help would also be expected and where great disappointment arose because help was not forthcoming. The farmer, at all events, has been left with his capital. His chief asset in his land, and that is still left to him at all events. It is his chief capital and land cannot be burned up or destroyed; it remains there. But the person who, I think, has borne the greater brunt of the economic war, and who has come less into the limelight than the farmer, has been the unfortunate town dweller. When I say town dweller, I include every class of person in an urban community who pays rates, whether a trader, shopkeeper, professional man or worker. I think the people in these little urban towns, which I have particularly in mind, have been hit the hardest of any section of the community, and if any relief should be forthcoming it should be to those persons who have suffered in silence and whose capital is gone, whose business connections have gone, whose credit has gone, and whose whole fabric of commercial connection that they had built up has been absolutely frittered away while the war lasted. They went, first of all, when the fairs faded out, when the weekly markets came to an end, when the farmer's credit went down. The farmer then had no business coming to town to do anything. He had nothing else left but his monthly cheque at the creamery, and the whole commercial business of the farmer was thrown back on the co-operative trade concerns. In this way there has arisen, I am sorry to say, a sort of feeling that the co-operative concerns attached to creameries have run away with the whole business of the towns, while it has been by sheer force of economic pressure that the farmer has been thrown back on his monthly creamery cheque because he had no other asset to buy the necessary goods for his household and farm.
As to the question of derating, I am in favour of it for the farmer. It will give him a start, at all events, although, as I have said, his capital is unimpaired, as he is in the possession of his land. Less than £1,000,000 will derate the whole agricultural land in this country. That is not a very big sum when we can afford to raise £43,000,000 in national taxation and rateable charges. It was said this evening that the farmer pays 95 per cent. of the taxes. We all know that is not true. How many farmers, big or small, pay income tax of any kind? Does not everybody in this House realise that the greatest portion of the taxes come from the town dwellers in the consumption of exciseable goods and in every other way? They do not come out of the farms. I think it is wrong that the House should be misled by persons saying that the farmer pays 95 per cent. of the taxation. That is all wrong.
The amount collected in rates last year in this country amounted to nearly £6,000,000. When you take into account that less than £1,000,000 will derate the whole agricultural land of the country, you will see how much is contributed by the town dwellers of the £5,500,000 or nearly £6,000,000. Less than £1,000,000, as I say, will derate all the agricultural land, therefore, I conclude that the remainder of the burden falls on the town dwellers. In the towns, everybody, including the unemployed man drawing the dole, has to pay his proportion of the local rates. In any town to-day, no matter how small it is, or how big it is, the local rates are at least 25 per cent. more than the rates collected off the county. There is no such thing as relief for the town ratepayer in the form of an agricultural grant. There is no help given to the urban employer who pays labour. I employ about 34 men myself, and I get no help whatever in the form of relief from the local council for employing these men. But, because I employ one man on a bit of land, I get a certain amount of reduction in my agricultural rate. There is no help, no relief, for the urban ratepayer.
There was one form of taxation from which I thought the Minister this year, in the exercise of, I was going to say, his discretion, but, rather, I would say by a prick of his conscience, should have given relief, and that is the terrible taxation under Schedule A, where he raised the taxation by 25 per cent. He raised the valuation under Schedule A of the Income Tax to five-fourths. In fact, by one stroke of the pen, the Minister in one night raised the whole urban valuation of the country by 25 per cent.
Look how this works out compared with what previously prevailed. UP to the time the Minister did that very iniquitous thing by raising the urban valuation by 25 per cent., a person owning a house valued £12 did not pay income tax on £12 valuation. He got an allowance of one-sixth for repairs. That meant that he got £2 off the £12 and paid on a valuation of £10. Now what happens? Instead of paying on £12 valuation, there is 25 per cent. added, and he pays on £15 valuation, so that actually, in effect, he is paying on a 50 per cent. higher valuation than he would have before the Minister did this very iniquitous thing. I thought we would have got some relief on that point. I am driven to talk about the town dweller because I heard so much about the farmer. I do not want to put one against the other, but I believe the town dweller has been the worst sufferer in this war. He is the person who should get any little relief that is coming out of this Budget. As a matter of fact, there is no relief for him, but I emphasise these things as points on which he should get relief.
As Deputy Norton said this Budget is remarkable in the way it impinges on certain social problems and passes them by. He has dealt very effectively with the question of unemployment. The Minister ahs been boasting about how many unemployed we have and the steps the Government were taking to relieve that unemployment. I would point out that that unemployment problem is another town problem. There is not such a big unemployment problem in the country. In the country, especially in the poorer districts lke West Cork, with valuations round about £4, we have not got that big unemployment problem like that which we have to face in the towns. The unemployment problem is principally an urban question.
There is then this great increase in the cost of living to be considered. The cost of bread is one of the things that should be affected by our Budgetary considerations. The price of flour should not be, say 52/- in Cork and 38/- in Belfast, simply by force of economic conditions. Everybody knows that that discrepancy in the price of flour is due to a certain Government policy, to a certain fiscal policy propoundd and carried into practice by the Fianna Fáil Government. I maintain that the cost of living, particularly the cost of bread and of flour, is not due to any profiteering, but is due to a certain fiscal policy forced on the millers and the baking community by the Fianna Fáil Party. The same thing applies to bacon. Why should I have to pay 145/- per cwt. in Kinsale for bacon which is sold at 95/- to 98/- per cwt. in England? Why should I have to pay 1/5 per lb. for butter which I can buy in Birmingham or in Cardiff at 10d. or 11d. per lb? These are some of the things which call out for relief. These are the hidden taxes that do not appear in the Budget. I may not be in order in referring to them on the Budget, but they are a natural consequence of the fisal policy of the Government. They are matters which demand the serious attention of the Government and on which we have a right to demand relief.
The Minister has told us that according to British standards of public finance we have a surplus of £629,042. I do not think we should run our finance on British standards. At all events, we ought to have some regard for the actual state of affairs amongst ourselves here. It has been stated that derating could only be carried out by scrapping such schemes as wheat and beet growing. I do not think that that was ever advocated on this side of the House.
Comment on this
I am expressing my own views and I say for myself that I do not want any policy that ahs been carried into effect by Fianna Fáil and which has proved successful done away with all of a sudden. Certain vested interests have grown up out of these policies and people have got into certain habits. These habits cannot be done away with, especially if their abolition would mean the creation of unemployment or a diminution in the circulation of money.
Comment on this
I leave it to the Deputy's own intelligence to understand what it means. Another question was raised with regard to the farmers. There was a plea not to put into effect the tax of £20 on hawkers. If there is one thing more than another that has done harm in this country, both from the point of view of lessening the resources of the town and disemploying labour, it is the travelling shop. So far from having that tax abolished, I have heard the view expressed that instead of £20 it should be £200, if indeed there should not be a total prohibition of these travelling shops. The bringing of goods for distribution from larger centres into big regional areas has done away with the small regional areas in which goods were distributed formerly by the local merchants. In that way, our towns have suffered very severely by the practice of these travelling shops going to the farmers' houses and selling practically everything that the farmers need. They work by a system of barter, because they are prepared to exchange bread and tea for eggs and other agricultural produce which the farmer has to sell. This system of barter has practically wiped out the towns. It has wiped out not alone the trade of the local merchants but it has done away with the weekly market, because it prevents the farmer from coming into the town to dispose of his goods.
I have covered I think most of the ground so far as the economic war is concerned in so far as it affects the town dweller as distinct from the farmer. The farmer, of course, has our first claim as he is the only amn who produces anything. Al the wealth we have comes out of the soil. It is transmuted, of course, afterwards into other forms of activity, but I would suggest that the town dweller deserves some consideration as well as the farmer. We ought to help in some way to solve the social troubles that have arisen without leaving all these troubles to the bodies who administer local affairs. I see all around me in this House men who are connected with corporations and urban councils and wo are therefore fully aware of the problems existing in our towns. So far, we have got very little consideration from the Government with regard to these problems. The capacity of the people of the towns to pay these taxes is getting less every day while the taxes themselves are mounting up so that the problem so far as the towns are concerned is becoming very acute indeed. The population of the towns is declining. If you go into any small town to-morrow, you will see that shops are idle, that in every street there are houses closed up and houses to let. You will, of course, also see many new houses that have been built to replace some of the houses demolished under the Slum Clearance Orders but, generally speaking, there has been a decline in the population of these towns. For instance, in the town in which I myself was born the population has declined from 6,000 to 2,000 in the last 50 years and the 2,000 are left there simply because they have not the bus fares to get out of it.
This Budget has been praised in some quarters simply because it is so characterless and colourless. That is the most that can be said about it. It gives no relief in any positive way. We are thankful that it does not impose any new taxation, but I think the Minister instead of saying that he hoped to hear no more about the £2,000,000 should have availed of the great opportunity which this Budget gave him. I thought he would have availed not alone of the possibilities but of the actual facts of the situation to come along with his Budget and shout triumphantly: "At last, boys, I have been able to reduce taxation by £2,000,000." He has not done that. I am very disappointed that the Minister has not embraced this opportunity to introduce his Budget with that triumphant shout: "Boys, you will be glad to hear that at last I have been able to reduce taxation by £2,000,000."
Comment on this
I think this is the most disappointing Budget that has been yet introduced by Fianna Fáil. It is the seventh Budget brought in by the Fianna Fáil Government and it is the most disappointing of the seven. It is all the more disappointing because this year the economic war was ended. We were all delighted with the Agreement that the Government made with Great Britain and hope that its good effects will soon be seen in the country. The Taoiseach has stated that we cannot expect the good results of the Agreement to be made manifest in the near future. I agree with that. I believe that it will take a few years before the good effects of the Agreement will be seen. But in the meantime I would say that the good effects of this Agreement will never be seen unless the Government is prepared immediately to put the farmers in a position to produce agricultural products for the British market and to produce them even more extensively than they did before the economic war.
Every Deputy knows what the farmers have gone through in the past six years. During the economic war a great many of their homes were wrecked, and their sons and daughters were forced to seek a living in the land across the water taht this Government and its supporters stated was our only enemy. In fact, conditions were so bad with some of the farmers that the money to send young men and women away had to be borrowed. We are glad that that state of affairs has ended, and we all hope for prosperity, not only for the farmers but for all the people. However, we cannot expect that prosperity if we are not going to help the farmers immediately. I believe good prices were secured for cattle in the Dublin market to-day. I hope that the increase will be greater in the future, but meantime the farmers must be helped financially immediately. A plea has been made from this side of the House for derating. The Government does not agree with that now, although at one time they approved of it. I believe it is possible to derate agricultural land, and that it is possible for the Government to float a loan at a low rate of interest, so as to enable farmers to restock their land and carry on their business as they carried on before the economic war started. Under the Agreement the Government here has been relieved of payments to the British Exchequer totalling over £4,250,000. One of these payments concerns the land annuities. When the economic war started the Government, after some time, brought in a measure reducing the annuities by 50 per cent. With the settlement of the economic war this country has been relieved of payment of the full annuities, but the farmers are still paying half the annuities to the Irish Government. I believe that the Government here was only an agent for the collection of money that was paid by the British Government to the stockholders. Now that the agency has ceased, I cannot see that there is any moral obligation on the people to pay the annuities any longer. The only amount for which the farmers are liable is their share of the £10,000,000 payment to be made.
Comment on this
The £10,000,000 payment can be met by the £1,750,000 yearly that was paid to the Government up to the present as half the annuities, and the balance can be given to the farmers in the form of relief from paying half annuities. If that is done, and if a loan is raised at a very low rate of interest, I believe that within the space of two years we will have a prosperous agricultural community, and when we have a prosperous agricultural community we will have a prosperous country. Deputy O'Neill remarked that we had heard a lot about the farmers recently. A great deal more will be heard about them, because they are the most important section of the community. They are the producers of wealth. Another section, the business people, has got no relief whatever under this Budget. These people have been very hard hit. I am very anxious about a statement the Minister made when speaking about the low rateable valuation of the country. He seemed to suggest that something should be done about that in the immediate future. I hope he is not going to raise valuations on business people in the towns who were so hard hit by the economic war. The only money the people had to fall back upon, as Deputy O'Neill mentioned, was the monthly cheque for milk, and that was eaten up by the co-operative stores. It will be no pleasure to farmers if, owing to the operations of the co-operative stores, the grass grows at the doors of shopkeepers. I believe in co-operation for farmers to a certain extent, but I do not believe it is good business on the part of any Government in this or in any other country to help co-operation for the agricultural community to such an extent as to drive out the ordinary business people and to have grass growing at their doors.
Another item in the Budget statement to which I wish to refer concerns a payment made to Great Britain for Local Loans. Reference to that payment of £600,000 caused some confusion. I hold that the local authorities combined to make that payment of £600,000 for Local Loans each year. That item has been wiped off under this Agreement. The biggest part of the amount was raised for the building of labourers' cottages during the past 40 or 45 years. Some years ago, in 1933 and 1934, the present Government claimed that they were the Government of the poor man. If they are really the Government of the poor man they have now an opportunity of relieving the workers of a certain amount of their payments. There is an opportunity to relieve the cottiers of a certain amount of rent and also to relieve local authorities now that that payment of £600,000 yearly for Local Loans has been wiped out. Deputy Corry asked me yesterday for my views concerning Deputy Dillon's suggestion to do away with the four beet factories. My answer is that I agree with the growing of beet. I spoke in favour of it, and I believe the growing of beet will continue. I hope it will continue, and I will do everything in my power to see that the four factories that have been erected at public expense will not, as Mr. Corry and some of his friends said some years ago about the Carlow Beet Factory, become white elephants. If public moneys have been expended on industries during the past five or six years I think it is the rightful duty of the Government and of the people of the country to protect them and to see that they will not go out of production.
I do not know that there is anything more I have to say on this, Sir, except that this is the most disappointing Budget for the past seven years. This year more than any other year the people of the country, owing to the Agreement arrived at between this Government and the Government of Great Britain, were expecting great reliefs from this Budget. They have got none. Instead of that, after seven years, the people of this country to-day find themselves taxed to the extent of over £4,000,000 extra taxation since 1931. They are paying over £4,000,000 annually more than they did prior to the advent of Fianna Fáil. I want to know, Sir, how are the people of the country going to keep paying? If we are going to keep us the present standard of social services in the country, the only way it can be done is by increased agricultural production. We must increase our agricultural production a thousand-fold. The only way you can do that is for the Government now, after six long years of the economic war, to go to the assistance of the farmers of the country and put them in the position that they will be able to produce agricultural produce for the market that we have across the water, next door to the borders of our country.
Comment on this
It is true, I think, to say that a great many people in this country were this year expecting a reduction in taxation in consequence of the close of the economic war, but those of us who were listening to the Taoiseach when he was introducing the Bill which implemented those Articles of Agreement did not expect any relief so soon.
I think it is time, as Deputy O'Neill pointed out, that something should be said on behalf of the town dwellers. We all know that the farmers have suffered and have suffered considerably during the economic war. Deputy O'Neill expressed himself as being surprised that Deputy Norton, on behalf of the Labour Party, had advocated in the course of his statement to-day that something should be done immediately to re-establish the farmers and to help them to re-stock their lands. There is nothing new about that, in so far as the Labour Party is concerned. That can be found in the printed policy as outlined by the Party to which I belong. In so far as the town dwellers are concerned, Deputy O'Neill has rightly indicated that no relief whatever has been given to town dwellers. Business people in towns suffered considerably during the period of the economic war because the farmers were not in a position to pay their debts in a great many cases; they had to receive extensive credit and, of course, the shopkeepers did not refuse them that credit. Now the economic war is settled and the farmer will be able to re-establish himself on the British market and we all hope, and hope sincerely, that he will be in a better position than ever he has been before. It is time that something should be done to help the town dweller. Not along has the town dweller suffered during the economic war by reason of the fact that the business person, above all, could not get in certain moneys that were due to him, but his rates and the rates of town dwellers generally have been raised considerably in a great many case in order to help to implement the policy of the present Government. I have only to refer to the position in so far as the relief of the unemployed is concerned. Members of the Dáil are aware that certain urban areas over a certain population have, since 1933, been paying 1/6 and 9d. in the £ respectively. In the Cities of Dublin, Cork and Waterford and places of that kind they pay 1/6 in the £. That has been increased recently, as a matter of fact. In urban centres like Wexford, Sligo and Clonmel they have to levy themselves to the extent of 9d. in the £. That really is an impost of 10d. in the £ because the Minister insists on getting the gross amount which that rate would bring forth. The rural population have not been called upon to pay that levy, although the people in the rural area get advantage of it. I do not want to set one section of the community against another, but I do suggest seriously that the Minister should divert his attention to the urban centres now in order to do something to help. Together with the fact that 1/6 and 9d. in the £, respectively, have been levied on certain urban and county borough areas, urban authorities have been called upon to levy a rate in order to supplement the grants given by the Government for the relief of unemployment. This Government, when it went into power, stated very definitely that it had a plan to deal with the unemployment problem, and nobody ever dreamt when they set about to relieve unemployment that both urban and county areas would be called upon to levy the rates that they have been asked to levy within recent years. In the town which I come from we are at the moment levied to the extent of about 2/9 in the £ in order to supplement grants for the relief of unemployment. We do not begrudge doing that, but, at the same time, it is a big impost upon the urban ratepayer, and not alone on the business man, but the ordinary man, even the man who is unemployed, because we all know that the moment the rate is increased the landlord will immediately adjust the rent in order to secure that the increase in retes is paid through the medium of the rent.
Deputy Daly has referred to the question of local loans. As he indicated, up to 1933 there was an amount of £600,000 paid to the British Government as repayment of loans which had been given for the building of houses and the laying of sewers and watermains and things of that kind. That has entirely disappeared in so far as the payment to England is concerned, and I would suggest that some relief should be given to urban areas in consequence of the fact that those payments have now ceased.
Immediately prior to the War certain urban authorities had committed themselves to certain housing schemes. Those schemes did not materialise until the years 1915 and 1916. During those two years we all know how the value of money decreased and how much more had to be paid in order to secure loans at the outbreak of the War. Not alone was the War responsible for making money dearer, but it was also responsible for making houses dearer. In consequence, houses cost a great deal more than they had been costing two years previously. The result was that the local authorities were faced with the problem of not being able to charge an economic rent for the houses they built in those years. The local ratepayers were asked to pay a goodly sum in order to enable working-class people to occupy those houses. I suggest to the Minister that in cases of that kind relief should be given, especially in view of the fact that the Government has been relieved of £600,000 a year which up to now they had to pay under the head of local loans. In that connection also I suggest that a good deal of that £600,000 was money on foot of which labourers' cottages were built. I suggest that here again some relief should be given to the county boards of health to enable them to adjust the rents of the labourers' cottages.
Again we come back to the farmer and to the farmer's burden. That burden has been lightened by reason of the fact that the land annuities have been decreased by 50 per cent. I suggest to the Government that it is not too much at all to ask that instead of the 25 per cent. reduction set forth in the Act to enable the labourers to become owners of their own cottages, there should be at least a reduction of 50 per cent. now that this sum of £600,000 has been struck out and that we have not got to pay it to England. After all, it will be agreed that while the farmers were fighting the economic war the agricultural labourers were also fighting and that the interest of the agricultural labourers suffered considerably during the period. I submit that it would be a very wise gesture on the part of the Government to amend that Act and to fix the reduction at 50 per cent. instead of the 25 per cent. As was indicated by this Party during the progress of that Bill through this House, 25 per cent. reduction means very little. The position created by the passage of the Act would impose a very serious burden on agricultural labourers because of the fact that they would have to accept liability for the repair of the cottages.
To come now to general matters, Deputy O'Neill referred to the increase which is supposed to be imposed on hawkers for their licences. I agree that if it is at all possible hawkers should be prohibited altogether, and certainly travelling shops should be prohibited altogether. These create a very serious menace to shopkeepers in urban areas. Week after week and month after month we have people squatting in the market-places of our towns and setting up stalls in competition with the ordinary shopkeepers who have to pay rent, rates and taxes. The shopkeepers are handicapped very much by the fact that they have to pay heavy rates to keep up the town, while these people can squat down there, sometimes leaving the place in a state of litter after them. The people who are in competition with them have to pay rates in order to have the streets cleaned up after the travelling shops. Something should be done to prohibit this class of trading which is unfavourable to the business people of those urban areas.
While Deputy Séamus Bourke was speaking he suggested that one way of helping the farmers would be to remove the tariff on agricultural machinery. As a Wexford man, I cannot sit here and listen to that proposal. I hope the Minister will turn a deaf ear to it. The town which I represent is practically entirely dependent upon the production of agricultural machinery. There are 400 to 500 men employed in the foundries there, and if that tariff were removed it would be very serious for their industry. As far as competition is concerned, the Wexford firms do not fear it; but prior to the imposition of the tariff there was a good deal of dumping by agricultural machinery manufacturers from the other side of the water. I do hope the Minister will not take any serious notice of the suggestion made by Deputy Bourke. If any tariff were proposed to be taken off an industry in his district he would very much resent it. That is all I have to say on the Budget. I earnestly invite the Minister's attention to the suggestions I have made. If these suggestions were adopted they would be very helpful to large numbers of people.
Comment on this
I do not intend to delay the House very long for the discussion on this Motion has been already long enough; quite a number of the Opposition have spoken at length and I do not include the Labour Party in that.
Comment on this
In case there is any doubt a Deputy indicated quite clearly that it was a very featureless Budget, that there was nothing alarming but that there was nothing in it it encourage the people in general. I am quite sure if this economic war had ended at another period and if the Minister for Finance had been given a little time to judge what was going to be the result, he would possibly have been more generous. I hold that, unquestionably, it is a wise and sensible Budget and I think, notwithstanding what has been said here, that the business community have accepted it as such.
Comment on this
Many members of the Fine Gael Party advocated what was just and right and what I would agree with. They advocated some form of compensation to the farmers who have suffered quite a considerable amount. Their capital has been diminished. Many of those Deputies advocated that farmers should be derated. Some Deputy stated that the land annuities should be entirely forgiven. He followed that up with a demand for a very cheap system of loan in order that production could be increased. Deputy Dillon, who is supposed to be a fairly sensible men——
Comment on this
In any case, Deputy Dillon was quite satisfied and had no doubts about it that not alone could all the ordinary fields of this country be brought into rapid production but that every hole and corner in those fields would be made available to go into production. I take it that the first thing the Minister for Finance discovered was that notwithstanding all that talk he had to turn about to provide a subsidy to the tune of £600,000 so as to enable farmers' crops to be sold in the British market. We have no experience of what will be the result. Cattle and sheep are the only thing we are able to sell in the British market without a bounty.
I am not so sure along what lines credit at the moment could be given. It might become a very serious business to encourage the production of eggs, poultry and other things and have to provide continuous subsidies in order to sell them. I think the Minister was perfectly wise to hold his hand until he and the country could see what was going to be the result of the settlement of the economic war. There is no doubt that some people, apparently innocent people, did foolishly believe the Opposition when they said that the moment the war was settled, by this very day, they were going to get back all the wealth of the past, the fabulous wealth of the war period. Anyone who saw the excitement that prevailed yesterday and this morning in shipping consignments of cattle to Great Britain would have come to the conclusion that these people actually did believe all that sort of thing was going to happen; that during the period from 1929 to 1931 nothing had happened, that there was no world depression, that Great Britain had no problems of her own, that out of sheer generosity she gave subsidies to her cattle, that she had pig and bacon schemes the same as we had, that she encouraged poultry and subsidised farming, that she provided cheap sent from here are sold on the easy-payment system, such as is advertised in the English papers.
But the indications are that the weather is not so calm as some people believe it to be outside and, consequently, the Minister for Finance very wisely decided that a certain precaution or care was necessary in formulating this Budget. It is possible if this settlement had occurred six months ago that he would have had a very reasonable idea how things were going to run and, as he gets his money from the public, through the medium of taxes, he would have been able to decide what he has just taken then normal method adopted for the last six or seven years.
Comment on this
It may be questionable to some, but to my mind that is what he has done. His policy, so far as the Budget is concerned, has not changed one iota.
Comment on this
There is one line of consistency through the whole Budget, and that is that the Minister has made every effort to continue the social services. The item of £600,000 for these forts that are to be taken over was very severely criticised. It was criticised by some because they had no knowledge of how we were going to set them up or what we were going to do with them. I take it that the £600,000 will not do much more than put a few soldiers there to keep the places from falling to pieces, to keep them in order. I take it that the setting up of a complete armament, as is the modern method and as all outside countries are doing would cost undoubtedly a great deal more. There is hardly a doubt about that. There may be some reason behind the people who have suspicion that enormous sums might be spent, or that we were going to start out to conquer other countries, whether it would be the Isle of Man or some other place
Comment on this
The real facts of the situation are that these are ports which will be handed over to us on a certain date. We may occupy them or we may leave them unoccupied. If they are unoccupied, any of these great fellows from Europe, these swashbucklers, may come along and occupy the forts, and perhaps it is just as well that there is someone there to tell us that they are about to be occupied or are actually occupied. I submit it is essential that some provision should be made for the taking over of these forts and their occupation. Personally, I believe they should be occupied properly and fully equipped. There were lamentations for generations over the loss of these forts, the great loss they meant to the country and the control held over us by a foreign country. Now that we have complete control, surely we are not afraid to shoulder responsibility, because there is a responsibility, and everyone of us knows that perfectly well. Freedom gives responsibility; it imposes responsibility on the people of this country. I am satisfied that the members of this Party, and, I am sure, the members of the Party opposite, are satisfied to shoulder that responsibility. It cost us a great deal to get that responsibility. It cost a great deal in blood to get that responsibility, and I am quite satisfied that almost everyone on the opposite side is prepared to shoulder that responsibility.
Comment on this
After all the enthusiasm of the past few weeks in connection with the Agreement, I think this Budget comes as a great damper and tends to lessen very considerably that feeling of enthusiasm. I know that the people at the present time are more or less disgusted because they were told by responsible Ministers here that they had won the war. If they have won the war, they certainly, and quite naturally, expect to see some of the fruits of their victory. I am sorry that they have not been offered very much in this Budget. We all know the people who bore the brunt of the economic war on their shoulders. The people who form the agricultural community were the soldiers of the economic war. Every decent country after a war tries to compensate its victorious soldiers in some manner, and I wonder the Minister for Finance did not come to the aid of the wounded and disabled soldiers of the economic war. I think it is very callous and unnatural that he should be so indifferent.
If we want to gain the fruits of victory from the Agreement we must put the agricultural community on their feet. When I say the agricultural community, I mean the workers and the farmers. This is unquestionably an agricultural country and our only hope is to get agriculture properly on its feet and then let the farmers work out their own salvation. We must first of all get a prosperous agricultural community, get people on the land who will be able to give employment, who will be able to buy and sell and become quite independent. I am sorry to say that at present our agricultural community are in a bad plight. They are in the position that, Agreement or no Agreement, they are not worrying one way or the other. The fact is that in most cases they do not own their land at all. The bank or somebody else has a big interest in it and the farmers are in the position of being little better than herds on the land.
The Minister for Finance having got this Agreement—and it is a fair Agreement—should at least arrange to devote a few millions for the purpose of assisting the agricultural community. One of the most serious problems in the country at the moment is the amount outstanding in arrears of annuities. Some small farmers owe annuities over a period of three to five years. They are quite willing to pay, but they are unable to do so. They do not want to have the arrears wiped out. All they want is that the Government should give them some idea how they are going to start paying on a proper and ordinary basis. I think there should be some indication, with regard to the men who owe arrears over three to five years, that there will be some way of funding that, or at least telling the farmers that they will have a space of 12 months or so before they are asked to pay up the arrears. The Government could indicate to them that if they paid the current annuities they would be given a year or two in which to pay the arrears. If that were done, I think the agricultural community would be satisfied and it would be a great help to them.
We hear a great deal about derating. I quite agree that it is a great front plank in the platform of any Party, and it is needed, because derating will mean immediate benefits, not to the farmer alone, but to the unfortunate unemployed. The Government should be able to initiate a plan whereby the money saved to the farmers when they would not have to pay rates would be spent in giving employment. The Government could see to it that the money was spent in that way, and that would mean perhaps 30,000 to 50,000 unemployed men getting work on the land and producing the necessaries of life for themselves and the people generally.
For the last 20 years almost we have had an Irish Government. I am one of those who sacrificed a fair amount to bring an Irish Government into being, but I am not satisfied that we should be for 16 or 20 years trying to get to the position of running this country in a business-like way. The present Government have almost brought the country to the edge of despair, when they should have it at the peak of prosperity and on the high road to become a proper Irish nation. At the moment this country is poor and impoverished and all through our own doing. There is no use in attributing it to John Bull; it was all done by our own hands.
It is time the State realised the need for something like an emergency call. I think there is an emergency in the present year, and that the nation should be called together to see how we are going to get out of our difficulties. I certainly think that a Council of State is needed, and that the resources and the brains of the State should be put together in order to see how we are going to make this a proper and a prosperous nation. I think that it can be done, because up to the present moment our economy plans were not plans at all. We were just blundering along from day to day, hoping to see if anything would turn up to help us out of our difficulties. A little did turn up, of course, such as the Agreement with England, but that will not help to procure employment for the 100,000 unemployed men who are at present on the dole. If we are to provide employment for most of these people, we must concentrate on one thing, and that is to get back the people from the towns and cities, to which they fled because they could not get work on the farms— to get them back and working on the land—and to do that the only hope for us is to try to ease the burdens on the people who own the land by taking off some of the overhead charges that are on the land at the moment. I think that if that is not done, we will not get the fruits of this Agreement.
Some of the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches did not either praise the Budget or anything else, except to talk about all that had been done during the last so many years for social services. I quite agree that they did a fair amount for social services, but when they talk of such services they ought to bear in mind what has been done for social services in other countries, in Europe and so on. I think it will be found, on examination, that other countries have increased their provision for social services by about 100 per cent. more than we did in Ireland. We have only been tinkering with the matter here, giving widows and orphans pensions and so on, but we have been really doing nothing to get our country on its feet properly, and we should not talk at all about what we did for social services, because actually we did nothing; we did not even scratch the surface yet.
Now, one of the burning problems of the day—with men of my type at least—is concerned with what I call the old soldier in the republican army, and in that connection I should like to know where we stand in the matter of defence. We have certain sentimental ideas with regard to the independence of our country, such as that we fought for, and are prepared, if necessary, to fight for, the full independence of Ireland, as we did in the past, and we only accepted the Treaty as a stepping-stone to the full independence of our country, just as we accepted the Agreement of 1926 as a stepping-stone, and just as we are now agreeing to the Agreement of 1938 as a stepping-stone to our ultimate freedom, but I am afraid that, the country being so low in itself up to the present moment, and the Government being so glad to get some agreement or another with England, there is a danger that they think this is the final settlement. Well, I am satisfied that further generations will arise to proclaim and to fight, if necessary, for the principle that Ireland must be free from shore to shore, that it should be no Crown colony of England, that it should be absolutely independent and free to make agreements with any country that it likes to make an agreement with, and I say that until that day comes we will not be free or cannot regard ourselves as being free.
In connection with the ports, I am afraid the people are in dismay because it seems to me that we are now binding ourselves openly and avowedly to Imperial England, saddling ourselves with responsibilities in connection with Imperial England, and making ourselves part and parcel of the next European war whenever it may come. Before the matter goes too far, I think it should be made clear——
Comment on this
Now, the matter in discussion at present would seem to be the sum of £600,000 for defence.
Comment on this
Yes, but the whole question of defence can be raised on the Estimate for Defence, which will come up for discussion in the immediate future, and the Minister for Finance is not the Minister responsible for defence or for the policy of defence.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir, but I suggest that this £600,000 that is to be spent on modernising these ports should be knocked out of the Budget this year. I do not think we should start modernising these ports yet, but that that question should be left over until the people are able to bear the cost of modernising them. In that way we could save that money in the coming year and devote it to the purpose of getting work on the land for the people who are at present unemployed. Getting back the ports is all right, but in any case I do not think that they are any great concern of ours, because if we have to spend money on defence I do not suppose it will be spent on these ports, but on aeroplanes, certain types of armament, and so on. As far as I understand, these ports are derelict, and I think it would be a good thing to let them go derelict. How ever, I would ask the Minister to drop this £600,000 out of the Budget this year, if it were only as a gesture that he is doing his best to relieve the unemployed men in this country who have had to flock out of the country into the cities and towns and across the water.
I suggest that it would be a far better thing to give the country a chance to settle down, because the real problem of the day is to get work, and more work, at decent wages for our people, and to enable our farmers to pay those wages. If we do that, I can assure the Minister that the farming community and the workers will respond at any time they are needed in a national emergency, and that they will come to the aid of any Government that will help them to live in decent circumstances and will help them to get out of the beggarly, hand-to-mouth, miserable existence that they have had to put up with for the last six years. If you leave people living in the miserable conditions in which they have had to live for some years past, then you cannot expect much from them in an emergency, and if you want to get back your lost province, your lost Six Counties, from the North, you must provide your farmers in this part of the country with better circumstances and better living conditions than they have in the North. As a matter of fact, if you can do that, instead of having to prevent the Six-County farmers from coming in, they will fall in on top of you, but if you are to have the uncertainty and misery that has been here for the last five or six years, they will not come in with you.
Again, I suggest that the Minister should leave out things that are not needed, such as this £600,000 for defence, and, in fact, if I were Minister for Finance in an Irish Government, I would go further than that and would sack all those hordes of officials that have been brought in as a result of the economic war. We are spending hundreds of thousands of pounds on these.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir. It seems that I cannot speak on that, but I should like to say that I cannot understand how it is that, with our population growing less in this country, it is taking more money to run the country. That is something that is very curious. I cannot understand how it is that with a smaller population, we should have higher taxation. It would seem that the lesser the population, the higher the taxation goes up. That is something that needs some economist to find out. At any rate, it is something more than I can solve. However, as the Minister claims that he did win the war, I would ask him at least to give the soldiers of that war some compensation for the losses they have sustained. That is all I have to say.
Comment on this
I do not wish to take up the time of the House, but, like Deputy Davin and other Deputies, I should like to say that there is a good deal of disappointment down the country at this Budget. Undoubtedly, people did expect that, as a result of the settlement of this economic war, there would be a relief of taxation. Deputy O'Reilly talked about this Budget having been described by other Deputies as a featureless Budget and as a Budget that had nothing in it to encourage the people. Well, there is really nothing in it to encourage the people and, mind you, since 1933, I have been looking forward to the fulfilment by the Minister for Finance of the promise he then made, namely, to reduce taxation by £2,000,000. That was at a time when taxation was under £22,000,000. I do not wish to take up the time of the House, as I said, and indeed I could talk for the next week, quoting the different Ministers on what they said at that time, but I am sure that the Minister for Finance will not deny that he said at that time that the country could not stand the burden of taxation. I should like to ask him how he feels to-day that the country can be prosperous when taxation, taking it all around, is about £10,000,000 more than it was then. There is no doubt about it that those who have referred to the position of the agricultural community and the people of the towns are simply telling what is the truth. You could go into any town in the country at the present moment and play a score of bowls without endangering the life of anybody. The farmers have been in the front line trenches during the past six years, and I have always held that until there was a settlement of the economic war there could be no hope for the people in the towns and cities. It is natural to expect that the more the farmers get for their produce the more they will have to spend.
When the Agreement was under discussion two weeks ago, Deputy McGilligan, during his criticism of it, was asked by the Minister for Finance if he would vote for it. The Deputy replied that he would, and added that if it was a much worse Agreement he would vote for it if the effect was going to be to improve the conditions of the agricultural community. Deputy Moore interrupted to say that the farmers were not of that opinion in 1932. Deputy McGilligan replied that he believed that were it not for the results of the general election last July, the Taoiseach would not have gone across to make this settlement with the British. We were all glad to see that the Agreement was made. I have my own views with regard to the settlement and would much prefer to discuss the merits of it at the crossroads or at a private session of the Dáil rather than in the presence of the Press.
There has been a good deal of talk about the amount of money that is being spent on social services. Deputy Corry said that the last Government, during its ten years of office, did nothing. I do not like to be ripping up old sores, but everyone in the country knows that the last Government, when in office, had to establish constitutional government in this country. Even the Minister for Finance complimented the Leader of our Party on that, and said that he had to admit that the last Government established constitutionalism, and that the present Government were there to maintain it. Everyone knows what it cost to repair the damage done by those associated with the Party now on the Government Benches. I am not saying that out of any spirit of vindictiveness, but I think that, when we on this side are attacked, we have the right to reply.
There has been a good deal of talk about the reduction of the annuities. I think it was Deputy Allen who said yesterday that the farmers would reap an immediate benefit of £1,700,000. In the Budget statement we find two items. Under the first it is proposed to expend £600,000 on defence. The second is the sum of £500,000 to meet interest charges on the £10,000,000 loan. These are two big items. The Minister for Agriculture, when he sat on these benches, said that the farmers produced 80 per cent. of the wealth of the country and, therefore, paid 80 per cent. of the taxation. I am not one of those who believe in subsidies or bounties. I think they are complicating the financial system we have here. To a great extent I fear that the provision of them is probably a political game.
The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance, when in opposition, advocated the giving of £1,000,000 for derating, but they maintain now that derating would be of no advantage to the farmers. I believe Deputy Meaney said—I was not in the House—that derating would bring no benefit to the farmers. There has been a good deal of talk about the ranches and of the benefits that would go to the big ranchers from derating.
I propose to give to the House particulars of the case of a small farmer who lives at the back of my own place in the County Cork. His valuation is £9 10s. In 1932 his annuity was £5 11s. 2d., and his rates £2 6s. 6d., the total outgoings being £7 17s. 8d. In 1931 his annuity was £5 11s. 2d., and his rates £2 8s. 6d., making a total of £7 19s. 8d. In 1937 his new annuity was £3 1s. 4d. and his rates £3 12s. 6d., making a total of £6 13s. 10d., or a difference, as compared with 1932, of £1 3s. 10d. Is there any Deputy who will contend that it would not benefit such a man to get relief under a derating scheme to the extent of £3 12s. 6d., the amount of rates that he paid on this land in 1937. Is there any Deputy from the constituency that I represent who will not admit that there has been a vast increase in the cost of feeding stuffs, and in the agricultural implements that we have to buy, as well as on every commodity that is consumed in farmers' homes? Deputy Corry spoke the other night about the admixture scheme, but I have to watch the Ceann Comhairle, because I fear he may not allow me to discuss that.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry argued that the farmers were getting 16/- a barrel for their barley. I asked him at whose expense, but he would not reply. Of course, I know it does not make any difference to Deputy Corry, or those associated with him, where that 16/- comes from. I put it to Deputies on the Government Benches— a great many of them come from the poorer parts of the country—do they think it just to subsidise people, who are able to grow barley and wheat, and other produce, at the expense of the people in the poorer parts?
Comment on this
I am not in favour of subsidies on anything. I would much prefer to see the Administration carried out as it was in the past, so that the people might have a better opportunity of realising the burden of taxation that they are carrying. Deputy Meaney talks about the subsidy on butter and eggs. I want to ask him, will the Government allow us to purchase our feeding stuffs at the world price as we were able to do in 1932? If they do, I am prepared to take the responsibility for saying that we will not ask for any subsidy on butter and eggs.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not depending on it, and neither am I. We are getting 1/4 for our milk.
Comment on this
I was not sent here to speak for myself. I am here to speak for the majority of the people in West Cork who elected me. If I believe in a certain thing I will express my views on it, and am prepared to take responsibility for doing so. I did not go into politics for the sake of getting anything out of it. Deputy Corry says that I am not dependent on this subsidy. I want to tell him that I am no millionaire, but I have not benefited as much as he has by the change of Government! If he wants to hear any more about that I will tell him.
Comment on this
Probably it is just as well. I ask the Minister to take responsibility now and say that the Government are prepared to go into the question of the cost of feeding stuffs—to do something that will help to bring relief to the people in the poorer parts of the country who are so urgently in need of it. The markets are now open, and why should not the people who can grow feeding stuffs do so, and feed them on their own land? Why do they expect the people down the country to pay £2 or more to subsidise them? I was opposed to that when my Party was in power. I am opposed to it to-day and I am going to continue my opposition to it as long as I am in the House.
I want to say a few words with regard to the position of the small farmers as a result of the having of their annuities. I want to compare the position of a farmer as regards both rates and annuities in 1932 and in 1937. The valuation of the man I have in mind is £9 10s.—£2 for the house and £7 10s. for the land. Nobody will say that the valuation of the house is too high. His annuity in 1932 was £5 11s. 2d. and his rates £2 6s. 6d.—total, £7 17s. 8d. In 1937 his annuity was £3 1s. 4d. and his rates £3 12s. 6d.—total, £6 13s. 10d. As a result of the halving of the annuities, he benefited by £1 3s. 10d. That does not take account of his contribution towards the £10,000,000 extra taxation imposed on this country. Taking the population at 3,000,000, that would work out at £3 per head, including every member of his family. Reference has been made to the position of the farmers and to the lightening of their burden by 50 per cent., I say that their position has not been lightened to the extent of 50 per cent., taking rates and annuities into account, which, in justice to them, you must take into account.
Deputy Corry spoke about the subsidy on eggs and butter. I ask Deputy Corry, or any Deputy on the Government Benches, to explain why people went out of egg production. Is it not the truth that the price of feeding stuffs drove them out of egg production? Deputy Corry said that the cow population had gone up by 100,000 since 1931. I do not know what the figures are, but I am not sorry to see the number of cows increasing. As long as you have cows there will be more employment. There was a time when a great many people went into milk production as a result of the position created by the economic war. People who were engaged in rearing calves and producing cattle went out of that business and into milk production. Will Deputy Corry deny that?
Comment on this
I will grant Deputy O'Leary this—that a lot of them who were keeping their land for dry stock did go into milk production, and it was a good job, because it gave more employment.
Comment on this
Take County Limerick and County Wexford. One is a tillage county and the other is a grass county. If the Deputy refers to the statistics, he will find that more employment is given in County Limerick than is given in County Wexford, which is a tillage county.
Comment on this
Reference has been made to employment on the land. I had a worker with me from Athy within the last week. He worked with me in 1931 for 16 or 18 weeks. He came up looking for a job on the Liffey scheme. I asked him how it was he could not get employment at home, and he said that he could not get employment because everybody had a tractor. I have had some experience myself in connection with this matter of employment. We in the country are supposed to be allowed a certain amount for permanent employees. I kept four permanent hands, but, as a result of the demoralisation brought about by the Government during the past six years, the tendency is for workers to go off the land. I was allowed only for two men. It was not my fault that the men came and went as they pleased. I could not keep them. One man left me on the 26th, and the secretary of the county council refused to allow me in respect of him—
Comment on this
Beidh lá eile againn, is docha. Deputy Corry spoke about a tillage policy. We were always in favour of a tillage policy but we were never in favour of a policy of subsidising one farmer at the expense of another. It will be admitted now that Mr. Hogan, the late Minister for Agriculture was probably the best Minister for Agriculture in the world. He did not advocate the growing of corn as a cash crop. He advocated the keeping of another cow and another sow and the growing of another acre of corn.
Comment on this
There is no overproduction in this country with regard to cereals, because we are importing more than we consume. Will the Deputy deny that? I should like to hear an intelligent remark from the Deputy.
Comment on this
Was not overproduction responsible for the low price of grain before this Government came into office?
Comment on this
I shall quote Deputy Corry in reply to that. Deputy Corry stated that, from 1924 to 1929, in the British market, the price of what we exported came down by £13,000,000. Why did it come down? Was it not because the world market price came down? Have the Government fixed a standard price for our agricultural products for the next six years? I shall hear the Deputy on that.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry criticised the last Government. We never stood for anything but the acceptance of the world market price. Even the present Minister for Agriculture maintains that the export price to Britain rules agricultural prices in this country. We maintain that and stand for it. Deputy Corry used to sneer at us and say that we would never get into the Government Benches. We never worried about getting into the Government Benches. We were more worried about the position of the people. I often told Deputy Corry that it would be a pity if he and his Party should go out of office before the people realised the full effect of their policy.
Comment on this
I have been telling it. Government policy has been discussed and I have a right to reply. I could stay talking for the next week or fortnight, and I could bring up about 100 Official Reports and keep reading from them, but I do not want to detain the House any further. I want to say, however, that Deputy Corry objected to the principle of derating. He did not like the word "derating", but did he not advocate derating in another sense when he said that the Government should give some allowance towards the maintenance of main roads and mental hospitals in this country?
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, that matter was raised here last night by Deputy O'Higgins and I should like to make it clear that I did not advocate derating. What I advocated was that the unjust and unfair burden placed on the agricultural community, namely, the up-keep of main roads, should be taken off. That was not advocating derating.
Comment on this
I am not an expert on English—in fact, I know the Irish language better than the English—but I do not think there is any difference between one and the other. I should like to quote Deputy Davin before I conclude. He said that the agricultural community were in the front line crenches, and he said that he was speaking for men he knew. I am also speaking for men I know, and I know that some of the most industrious people in this country have been brought to the verge of ruin, and I challenge any Deputy to contradict me in that. Deputy Davin asked if the Government would, even now, set up a commission to investigate the conditions of these people and find out what hardships have been imposed on them in the last six years. I think that is a reasonable demand. Commissions have been appointed for other purposes, but I think I had better keep off that subject for the present. I shall have another day for that, too, and I will have some quotations from the past. I hope to spend some time showing the views of these people at that time as compared with their views now.
I appeal to the Government to set up some kind of commission to investigate the position of the agricultural community and to try to find some means of helping them out. I have always maintained, and I maintained it before we got the Treaty, that agriculture was and would be the main industry of this country, that on agriculture depended the prosperity of the whole people, and that, instead of destroying production, as was encouraged by the Government in the past six years, production should be encouraged and an effort made to secure a market. We have the market, although we were told at one time that that market was gone, and gone for ever. Now, however, we have had the experience of seeing the people who held that view going across to England and negotiating. At last they have come to their senses and have found out the real position in the country. I agree with Deputy McGilligan that were it not for that realisation the Taoiseach would never have crossed the Channel to negotiate with the British people.
Comment on this
The discussion on this Budget has ranged around two matters—the question of derating and the question of national defence. I do not intend to indicate how far I think a discussion in regard to questions of defence policy was strictly relevant to the debate but, in any event, a large part of certain Deputies' speeches concerned itself with that issue. I do not think that the question properly arises for detailed discussion on this Resolution. An opportunity to discuss this question of national defence arose when the Agreements with the United Kingdom were under discussion a few days ago, and the House was then told, in no equivocal terms that, in the Government's view, large sums of money would thenceforward have to be provided for the purpose of national defence. Deputies were informed that this was the considered view of the Government, and that after the Agreements were ratified by the House, the Dáil, in due course, would be asked to vote large sums of money for that purpose. Deputy Norton, Deputy Davin, Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Bennett, Deputy Giles—in fact practically every Fine Gael Deputy and every Deputy from the Labour Benches who has spoken—who referred to this matter were well aware of the fact which I have mentioned when those Agreements were before the House. If they differed from our view in regard to this question, they could have taken the opportunity to make that clear by voting against the Agreement.
They were told in the debate by the Taoiseach that it was the Government's intention, first of all, to take over these ports at the earliest possible moment, at the moment at which we had the skilled and trained personnel to take them over, and that when they were taken over, they would be modernised. If Deputies and, in particular, those who have responsibility for leading Parties or for sitting on the Front Benches as representing the guiding and leading lights of Parties, felt that that was an unwise policy, they could have expressed their dissent from that policy in the way in which it is open to every member in this House; in the way, for instance, of which Deputy Larkin availed himself, by not voting for the Agreement. When these Deputies who have been so vocal to-day, so full of protest against money being raised for the purpose of Imperial defence, as they term it, who to-day are questioning the wisdom of modernising the ports and equipping this nation to defend itself against whomsover may attack it—for that is the sole purpose for which the country is being asked to provide this money—had an opportunity to give practical expression to those views by voting against the Agreement, which proposed to take over these ports, and by voting against the policy which was announced when that Agreement was put before the House; that is to say, that it was our intention to modernise those ports, and not merely that but to strengthen and extend every provision which hitherto with our limited resources we had been able to make for the purposes of national defence, they should have had the courage, they should have had the honesty, they should have had the honour, to get up here and do so then. They had not the hardihood, Sir, to do that. Therefore I suggest that if they want a full statement of our policy with regard to national defence they should have to wait, and I respectfully suggest that the Chair should have compelled them to wait until that policy was unfolded either by the Taoiseach——
Comment on this
The Chair does not require from Ministers nor from Deputies suggestions or directions as how to direct the business of this House.
Comment on this
——until that policy, as I was saying, is unfolded either by An Taoiseach, who is responsible for the general policy of the Government, or by the Minister for Defence, who has been charged by this House with responsibility in the first place for national defence. I, Sir, am not in that position; the responsibilities of my office, my particular duties, do not call upon me to state on an occasion such as this what the policy of the Government is in regard to that matter. Therefore I do not intend to deal with it further.
Deputy O'Higgins informed us yesterday that the Budget had been received in some quarters with rather acute disappointment, and in other quarters with a certain amount of relief. The Deputy said the relief was felt in places in which a big increase in taxation had been expected, and that the disappointment had been felt elsewhere. I must differ from the Deputy when he suggests that the country has been accustomed to expect a big increase in taxation every year for the past six years. I am quite sure that the Deputy, in making that statement must quite accidentally have overlooked the facts of the matter. They are quite simple, and I think they are within the recollection of most of us. In any event, if the recollection of any element in the House is at variance with what I say, they can substantiate the truth of my statements by looking up the records of the past six years. When we took office in 1932 we had not only to make up the heavy deficit on the Budget of the coming year which then confronted us, but we had also to begin to provide the people with certain social services which had been withheld from them during the preceding ten years. This involved for that year in our first Budget a heavy increase in taxation, but in 1933 there was no change in the rate of taxation, and in 1934 there was a reduction. In 1935, again on account of the increased provision which had to be made for certain services, particularly for that of unemployment assistance, some rates of taxation were increased. In 1936 and in 1937, however, there were heavy reductions in those rates, so that, so far from its being true that in every year for the past six years there have been increases in the rates of taxation here, such increases in fact took place only in 1932, when we had to make good the deficit which we inherited from our predecessors, and when we had to provide for the people the social services which had been so much in demand but which they had withheld from them during the preceding ten years.
In that year 1932, and again in 1935, when we had to provide the heavy sums required for unemployment assistance, there were increases in taxation, but in most of the other years— notably in 1934, 1936 and 1937, there were heavy reductions in taxation.
But, of course, the members of the Opposition have hypnotised themselves into believing that there have been heavy increases in the rates of taxation over the past six years. Naturally, they have now come to judge a Budget not from the point of view of the benefits or advantages which the country can be expected to reap from the services for which the Budget is to provide, but merely on the narrow issue as to whether or not it is proposed to increase the rates of taxation. There we have rather a paradoxical situation. Most people would hold that a Budget which did not increase the rates of taxation, or even did not change the rates of taxation, should be regarded as a good Budget, but that is not the view of the Opposition. If it does increase the rates of taxation, then from the point of view of the Opposition, as it is customarily expressed here in this House, it is a good Budget because it affords them an opportunity of making the utmost Party capital out of that fact. If on the other hand it does not increase the rates of taxation, then it is—as this Budget has been described —a bad Budget, or at best a disappointing one. But though, as Deputy O'Higgins had to admit yesterday, the ordinary citizen is relieved at this Budget and thinks it a good one, we need not be surprised if the members of the Opposition, certain members of the Labour Party, and every other Deputy in this House who had hoped to make capital out of the fact that some one other than himself has had to take the odium of collecting taxes in order to meet the costs of the services which they, in common with every other member of the community, demand, should find this a bad and disappointing Budget. It is a bad and disappointing Budget indeed from the point of view of its effect upon their political fortunes, but I think, and I believe the country will agree with me, that this is a good Budget and a sound Budget, and one which in present circumstances will be extremely advantageous to the country and the community as a whole.
But when an Opposition bases all its hopes in regard to a Budget upon the expectation and desire that it will provide for increased taxation, it is hard for them to adopt an attitude consistent with their own pasts. We have had that difficulty fully exhibited in this debate. Prior to this day week, the clamour of the Opposition, heightened by the thin, piping note of Deputy Davin, was for a reduction of taxation. But to-day they are demanding that taxation should be increased, mind you, not by £100,000 or £200,000, but by £2,000,000, for that is what this demand for the derating of agricultural land involves—an increase in general taxation of not less than £2,000,000 per annum. And the Party which up to a week ago was clamouring that taxation should be reduced, is now equally clamorous that it should be increased by no less than £2,000,000. For, as I said, that is what the derating of agricultural land would cost, except in one eventuality, which is that, if those who are crying out for the derating of agricultural land are prepared to surrender the concession which was afforded to them in the Land Act of 1933 and to agree that the Land Acts shall be so amended that henceforward every person who is buying out, or who from this time onwards buys out his land, will agree to pay for it, not even at its full market price, but at something less, and at the same time, something very much more than he is paying for it now. That is to say that those who are clamouring for derating should agree that the purchase of their land should be completed not upon the terms of the 1933 Act but on the terms of the 1923 Act. In that way we can have derating without extra taxation. Indeed, I might say that if those who want derating can see their way to concede that condition, not merely would we be able to give derating without increased taxation, but we would be able to give derating with a reduction in taxation as well.
Now let us look at the figures. Derating, as I have said, would cost £2,000,000 in round figures. The reductions granted in the pre-1923 annuities cost the State approximately £1,615,000 a year. In respect of the post-1923 annuities, the reductions already granted are expected to cost this year £612,000. But that is not the whole story. There still remains land to be bought out and divided. It is expected that in order to complete the redistribution of the land of the country in economic holdings, further issues of land bonds to the amount of £7,750,000 must be made. Of this capital sum, no less than £3,750,000 is expected to fall as a direct responsibility on the Exchequer, and in respect of that an annual charge of £184,000 will have to be met, and met, of course, out of taxation. So that when land purchase is completed within a comparatively few years from now, the total benefit which agriculturists will derive from the reduction of the land annuities, which was granted under the 1933 Act alone, will amount to £2,411,000 per year, or almost £400,000 more than would be required to derate agricultural land.
Now here is a chance for Deputies who want derating and who, as I said, used to want at the same time a reduction in taxation. Deputy Gorey, Deputy Bennett, who is not here, and Deputy O'Leary, who has gone out— let them combine and let them go to the Land Commission and pay into it the full amount of the annuities which they would have paid, which they were paying, I think prior to 1933, and let them say to the collector there: "We should like this money to be handed over to the Minister for Finance to enable him to derate agricultural land." I can promise that, when Deputy Gorey, Deputy Bennett and the other members of the Opposition generally, can persuade their friends to pay over to the Land Commission the full amount of the annuities on the pre-1933 basis, derating from the point of view of the Exchequer will become a practical proposition. But, until then, I am afraid that it will not be possible for this or any other Government to deal with that proposal upon any equitable basis or in any practical way. I should like to know now from the Opposition whether a proposal of that sort would be considered.
Comment on this
It is an easy one, it is a simple one, it is one the merits of which every farmer can weigh up and decide for himself.
Comment on this
Would he surrender the concessions which have been granted to him in regard to his purchase annuity and take derating instead? It is only on the basis of such a proposition that derating can be considered. That would make it, as I have said, a practical proposition for the Exchequer and, I suggest, an equitable one for the community. I feel, of course, that the proposal would not commend itself to Deputy Bennett or to Deputy Davin. It might do so, when he thinks over it, to Deputy Gorey, because, notwithstanding the terms in which he sometimes expresses himself. Deputy Gorey is a Deputy who is inclined to look at things in a responsible and realistic way. Some of the other Deputies who spoke in this debate have not the same direct, acute mind that Deputy Gorey has. They will try to have it both ways. They will not agree to give up the concession in regard to the annuities and they will continue to clamour for derating, and, accordingly, they will want it, of course, to be financed out of taxation.
It is extraordinary what lax views certain Deputies of the Opposition, and some, but not all, Deputies of the Labour Party, have in regard to this matter of taxation. I have referred to the fact that in 1932 we had to impose increased taxation, and we had again to do it in 1935—an unpleasant task, an invidious task, an odious one, and one which leaves one open to a great deal of personal attack of a very acrimonious kind, and naturally so, because taxation, in essence, means that a group of men entrusted with certain temporary power proceed to take what, in the first instance, belongs to another in order to devote this property of a private individual or individuals to a public purpose.
We used to hear from Fine Gael Deputies a great deal about the Communistic tendency of the Fianna Fáil Party. When we were in opposition it was freely alleged by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, as they were called then, that we were in league with the Reds. When we came into power, we were described and we were held up by the Opposition, during that brief but inglorious period when they were trying to establish a Fascist movement here, as men who were paving the way for the dark revolutionary forces which were hidden in the background. It was said that we would bow to the forces of disorder and that, by the stand we had taken against Great Britain in regard to the land annuities, we had created in the minds of the people loose conceptions about private property and private right, so that eventually we should be swept aside and replaced by those who did not believe in private property and private right, and who would establish an irreligious, Godless and sanguinary Communistic dictatorship here. That was what used to be said about us here. That was the least thing said about us here when we increased the income-tax by 9d. in the £ in 1932. Any interference by the Government with the property of a private individual, any imposition by way of taxation upon the back of that individual was, as I have said, regarded and held up by those who were opposing us in initiating and expanding social services as being Communistic in its tendency. A number of them, filled with holy zeal, donned a blue shirt in order to prevent us going Red. Not one of these dire prophecies has come to pass.
Comment on this
I am not going to dilate on the fact that after six years of our administration there is comparative peace and order, that we are still in office and that no one feels himself insecure either in his property or in his person. These things are there and the fact that they are there speaks for itself. I must say that I am surprised, as I have said, to find that those who in 1932 regarded our action in taking 9d. more in the £ off a man's income than was taken in 1931 as an act of unjustifiable confiscation, who condemned us because when a person went into a cinema we insisted that some part of the money paid out for the purposes of amusement should be taken for public purposes, who condemned us, as I say, in terms that could be applicable only to highway robbers—I am surprised to find now that they regard so lightly the right of the individual to retain and to enjoy what he earns and what he owns, that they have no compunction whatever, no scruple, in demanding that an additional £2,000,000 should be raised for the purposes of derating.
How do those who have advocated derating, who have advocated that we should raise that £2,000,000 think it can be secured? We could get it by increasing income tax by 2/6 or 3/- in the £, making it 7/- or 7/6. Do the Opposition advocate that? Or we could get it by putting about 6/- per lb. on tobacco or putting, perhaps, 2/- per lb. on tea, or 2½d per lb. on sugar. Does Deputy Davin, who told us that he wants derating also, want to put 2½d per lb on sugar, 2/- per lb. on tea, 6/- per lb. on tobacco or 2/6 or 3/- in the £ on income-tax? Or does he want a combination of these, say 1d per lb. on sugar, 4d per lb. on tea, 8d per lb. on tobacco and 1/- in the £ on income-tax?
Comment on this
I shall read to the House what Deputy Davin did say: "I also desire to support with certain qualifications——"
Comment on this
——"the repeated demands from all parts of the House for many years that the farmer should get some assistance by way of the derating of agricultural land".
Comment on this
Of course Deputy Davin has qualifications. Deputy Davin has qualifications even about his own existence.
Comment on this
Of course the Deputy always leaves some way out, always some corner out of which he can wriggle. There is always some loophole which Deputy Davin can get through but the part that will be quoted, the part that will be headlined when he sends the report down to his constituency is this: "I also desire to support with certain qualifications the repeated demands from all parts of the House for many years that the farmer should get some assistance by way of derating of agricultural land."
Comment on this
What I have been saying has particular relation to Deputy Davin or any other Deputy who has been advocating derating in this House. Does he want a combination of these taxes? Let me repeat them—1d per lb. on sugar, 4d per lb. on tea, 8d per lb. on tobacco and 1/- in the £ increase in income-tax.
Comment on this
Of course, I know the Deputy would be bearing a heavy burden if a tax were imposed on ginger beer, because he would be paying an excise duty on a lot of his froth. When Deputy Davin has got that 1d. per lb. on sugar, 4d. per lb. on tea, ½d. per ounce on tobacco, and 1/- in the £ increase on income tax, will Deputy Davin come along then crying out about the crushing burden of taxation and the high cost of living? Why should I ask such a question? Everyone knows that Deputy Davin has taken to himself the injunction of Polonius. Whatever else happens, Deputy Davin always carries this admonition in his mind: "To thine own self be true." Unfortunately the remainder of the quotation does not apply. His colleagues in the representation of the constituency, in the Labour Party, and Ministers in the Government—and not merely in this Government but in its predecessor's—will understand that Deputy Davin is always true to himself. Never once has that prevented Deputy Davin from being false to others if it suited Deputy Davin's turn. Therefore, I say, why should I ask if Deputy Davin, having succeeded in imposing this additional £2,000,000 of taxation, will come out and complain about the high rates of taxation and the high cost of living? Of course in these circumstances Deputy Davin will complain about the high taxation and the high cost of living, because it is Deputy Davin's nature and character to do so.
I have said that unless the concession in regard to the land annuities is withdrawn with, of course, the consent of the overwhelming majority of the farmers, it is not possible to derate agricultural land without increasing taxation. I have asked the House to recall how in former years the Opposition used to condemn, as unwarranted, the imposition of taxation which was necessary to provide for improved and new social services. Of course, we did not heed that cry then, and the public conscience endorsed our attitude in that regard.
The fact that the people decided that taxation for public purposes was fully justifiable, because it was for social services, should not induce us, however, to forget that taxation, to be endurable, must have its basis either in social justice or national necessity. Taxes may be imposed and the yield of these taxes may justly be taken for the public exchequer, if it is taken for the common good of the whole community; if it be taken, for instance, in order to provide for the preservation of public health, for the education of the citizens, for the maintenance of public peace, the administration of justice, or the defence of national territory. These are all works and services of national necessity to which, so far as it can be secured by the methods of the ordinary work-a-day world, each citizen should contribute according to his means.
Comment on this
Again, the Government would be justified in taking, by way of taxation, some part of their possessions from those who have a superfluity in order to help those who have nothing, or only a sufficiency wherewith to maintain themselves and their families.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Minister that he might take that taxation, for instance, from Dublin bakers, who receive 102/- a week, and take it off the farmers when they keep accounts and show losses?
Comment on this
I say that we should be justified in taking from those who have much for those who have little or nothing, but such taxation would be based on the principle of social justice, a principle that teaches us to feed the hungry and clothe the naked. Now is this demand for derating founded either upon the basis of national necessity or social justice? Where is justification to be found for imposing that additional £2,000,000 of taxation which the Opposition in the last two days have been demanding? There are approximately 1,300,000 people occupied in gainful pursuits in the Twenty-Six Counties. Out of every 130, 53 on the average may be classified as farmers or assisting on farms. The House must bear in mind that most of these are property owners, relatives of property owners, or prospective property owners, and the remaining 77 out of the 130 are members of the community who do not own or occupy land. In fact, most of them own nothing, except perhaps the clothes on their backs, and sometimes, but only sometimes, the furniture in their houses, often only the room in which, as the fruit of centuries of neglect, they are condemned to live. The proposal of the Opposition, and, of course, of Deputy Davin, with qualifications——
Comment on this
——looked at broadly, without any qualification, is to impose an enormous burden, in the first place, upon a non-land-owning class, and, in the second place, upon the poorer land-owning class, in order to help those who own the best lands in this country, and own them in large holdings.
It is true that the taxation to be imposed would not be confined only to those who have no property in land. Of necessity, those who own land would have to bear a share of that taxation, but the burden would not be equitably distributed even amongst those who own land. The small landowner would have to be taxed in order to relieve the big man, and to relieve most the landowner who, while he may in present circumstances produce the greatest amount of wealth for himself, at the same time employs comparatively few persons on the land.
Let us see how derating would operate in the case of small farmers. If the £2,000,000 which we should have to find were to be found, say, by increasing the sugar duty, an increase of 2¼d. per lb. would not suffice for the purpose, because if we increased the price of sugar to as much even as 5d. per lb., there would be a serious decline in consumption. Accordingly, if we were to get £2,000,000 out of sugar, we should not be safe in putting the increase in the excise and customs duties at less than 2½d. in the lb., and that would make the price of sugar 5¾d. or 6d., whichever Deputies choose to take. Allowing for the decrease in consumption, which would arise from the increased price, we may assume that the average quantity of sugar consumed per head of the population would fall to about 70 lbs. per year, so that the consumption in the average household of five persons would amount to 350 lbs. per year. An increase, therefore, of 2½d. per lb. in the sugar duty, would mean in each household that the outlay on sugar would be £3 13s. per annum. Let us ask ourselves who would pay that £3 13s. per annum. Large farmers, of course, might possibly pay a little more, because their houses are larger, and they are able to employ more servants than the small or medium farmers. Small farmers would pay, possibly, more than the average amount, because, as a rule, the size of their households and the numbers of children in them are above the average. Agricultural labourers and landless men would pay that £3 13s. Every poverty-stricken person in the community would pay it and, of course, Deputy Davin, who wants derating, and is not merely the light but sometimes the delight of the Labour Party, wants that.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin wants the small man, the landless man, the agricultural labourer, the unemployed, the poor and the needy, to pay taxes so that the large landowner and the rancher, as I have heard the Deputy describe them, should be derated. Let us see the extent of the injustice, because it must be plain to the House that the proposal which the Deputy made, when examined in that form, is an unjust proposal. Let us see the extent of that injustice even as between the farmers themselves. Of the holdings in this country 74 per cent. are of £20 valuation or under, and the average rates payable upon farms which are in that category, a category which comprises 74 per cent. of the total holdings in this country, may be taken in round figures as £1 10s.; in some counties the figure may be larger than that, but on an average throughout the country the rates payable on holdings within the category of £20 valuation and under amount to £1 10s. per holding, and that applies to 74 per cent. of the farmers in this country. Those farmers are not the most vocal. They were not very vocal during the economic war. They were those who helped us to win it. If we agreed to derating they would get, in relief from rates, £1 10s., but they would have to pay in increased taxation no less than £3 13s., and they would lose, on the balance, 43/- per annum. Forty-three shillings would be paid by the small farmer in order that the big man might be relieved of bearing his fair share of the cost of the public services, which benefit him just as much as they benefit the poor man, and, possibly, in some cases, benefit him a great deal more.
The position of the small farmer is bad enough, but what about the position of the agricultural labourer? He owns no land. He would make no saving on the rates, but, out of his "poor and narrow pittance of 27/- a week", when he is working, and out of his unemployment assistance when he is not working, he would be called upon to find, in round figures, 1/5 per week in order that his employer, whether his constant employer or part-time employer, his much-better-off employer, should be relieved of some share of the burden of the public services. That is the proposal that has been put up to us, and it will apply not merely to 74 per cent. of the farmers of this country and to all agricultural labourers, but to the dwellers in the small towns.
Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan was the first person to raise this issue of derating in this debate. In the same speech he was very plaintive indeed about the hard plight of the small towns. He talked about them looking like continental plages in the off-season, with their shutters up and the houses looking decrepit and derelict, and yet the Deputy who was pleading for the small towns, in the same speech advocated a proposal which would impose an additional burden of £3 13s. per annum on every householder in those towns, not only on such prosperous shopkeepers as there might be in those towns, but on every family in the back lanes and slums of those towns. And Deputy Davin! Deputy Davin, as a member of the Labour Party who wants social justice, gets up and stands shoulder to shoulder with Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan in making that iniquitous demand.
Comment on this
Did you know all this when you were advocating derating from the Opposition Benches?
Comment on this
The Deputy apparently has got wisdom within the last 40 minutes. I do not suppose that, even with qualifications, he is advocating derating now.
Comment on this
Now, what justice or equity could there be in such a transaction as has been proposed to us now?
Comment on this
It would be well if the Deputy sometimes prepared his speeches; they might be more relevant.
Comment on this
The Deputy and I can have it out on the Estimate for my Department. I am asking, what justice or equity could there be in a proposal such as I have outlined? It is quite clear that derating could only be granted in our present circumstances upon such conditions as would be disadvantageous, not merely to the poor in the urban areas, to the landless men and the agricultural labourer, but to 74 per cent. of the farmers as well, and it was on this ground that the Derating Commission rejected the proposal in 1931. Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Brennan, of course, do not admit that. They have gone back upon their policy in 1931. The commission which investigated this matter very carefully, with a great deal of pains and, I am sure, with a cool, impartial judgment, spending a long time upon it, turned down this proposal in 1931.
Comment on this
Did I hear the Deputy correctly? Did I hear the Deputy say that it was decided before the commission sat?
Comment on this
It reflects certainly —I do not believe creditably—upon the Government which appointed that commission, upon the late Minister for Agriculture, upon the other members of the Government, upon the Deputy's own leader, upon the Deputy's own colleagues, and it reflects also upon those who sat on the commission. I do not believe, at any rate, that the Government had decided that they would not grant derating, and that they were setting up this commission as a blind, merely to impose upon the credulous farmers who were supporting them at that time. Whatever the attitude of the then Government may have been in regard to derating. I certainly do not think that those who took the pains and the care to investigate that problem as fully as they did investigate it, as is shown by that report and by every line of that report, had prejudged it
Comment on this
At any rate they turned it down because the proposal could not in the circumstances be an equitable one. Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Brennan say that it was not because the proposal was inequitable. But mark you the grounds upon which they allege the proposal was rejected. It was because, as they say, in 1931 the farmers were prosperous. What an ungrateful lot the farmers of Ireland must have been in 1932! In 1931 the farmers under the Cosgrave régime were prosperous and in 1932 they discarded the men who had brought them prosperity.
Comment on this
What about those promises you made them? Was it not because they swallowed your pill?
Comment on this
At any rate this report was signed in 1931 and it was on the merits or demerits on that date that it was rejected. Deputy Cosgrave trying to make the case for the volte face which has taken place, for the political somersault in which the Opposition is now engaged, said that the commission could not report in favour of derating in 1931 because the farmers at that time were prosperous. The Deputy referred to certain figures. For instance he said that in 1926 the farmers owned 27 per cent. of the moneys on deposit in our banks and that in 1929 they owned 29 per cent. of those moneys. That is to say in 1926 the bank deposits belonging to the farmers amounted to 27 per cent. and the remaining 73 per cent. of these deposits belonged to the rest of the community. In 1929, according to the report of the commission, about 29 per cent of these deposits belonged to the farmers and 71 to the rest of the community. That is what Deputy Cosgrave said. I read just a few weeks ago a statement from a very authoritative source——
Comment on this
I do not know what source but I know that the person who wrote the article would have been in a position to know. I do not know where he got his figures.
Comment on this
I do not know where he would have got his figures. At any rate, this person, whose credibility I do not doubt, and whose ability to speak with authority I accept, said that the amount of the Irish farmers' share of the bank deposits which had been 27 per cent. in 1929 had risen in 1936 to 39 per cent. That is to say that, while in 1929 when the wave of prosperity must have been at its height, the Irish farmers owned 27 per cent. of the deposits in Irish banks and the rest of the community 73 per cent., according to this authority, which I am prepared to accept, the farmers' share of the deposits in 1936 had risen to 39 per cent.
Comment on this
In 1936 the Irish farmers owned 39 per cent. of the money on deposit in the banks and 61 per cent. of it belonged to the rest of the community.
Comment on this
Now I have the clue to the Deputy's very intelligent speech on this Budget. Mind you, it was a bit of a shock—the Deputy will not misunderstand me. I do not mean to suggest that Deputy Gorey does not usually speak intelligently. He does, but the Deputy's intelligence in this debate was a bit of a shock to the members of his own Front Bench and to his colleagues behind him. The Deputy stood up and said it could not be contended that all the farmers had lost through the economic war. He said himself that 50 per cent. had got through it scathlessly and might have made money through the economic war.
Comment on this
I would not like Deputy Gorey to believe that I am trying to controvert that statement. I expect the Deputy is in a position in this matter to speak about what he knows.
Comment on this
I see the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands grinning behind the Minister.
Comment on this
Many speeches have been made on this Resolution. Many Deputies have asked what the Government's intentions are. The Minister for Finance should be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
We have asked him to set up a commission to report on the position of the farmers. The Minister would get information direct from that commission.
Comment on this
All in good time. Surely the Deputy does not expect to get everything at the first time he asks for it, even from the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I want to make this clear. I have had no verbal communication from anybody in regard to this matter but I do read the papers.
Comment on this
I know it appeared, as the Deputy says, in a journal of great standing, written by a man of standing in this country. Deputy Gorey read it, and he has confirmed what I say. That is why Deputy Gorey began to think this out for himself and that is why he had the candour and honesty, which I appreciate, to come into this House saying that 50 per cent. of the farmers—I will say had not been broken and sunk by the economic war, because I do not want to put more on his words than they would bear—but that was what the Deputy said, and there is an explanation of that. So the farmers have in certain circumstances been able to save money.
Comment on this
And Deputy Corry ought not to be on strike for beet or wheat, and ought not be asking more money in that case.
Comment on this
I would be very sorry if the great efforts the Government made to help the farmers in the past six years had gone for nothing. I say this not from any Party point of view, but from a desire to be of assistance here in examining this proposal. I am wholeheartedly glad, from a national point of view, that our farmers who stood up with us against these economic sanctions have come triumphantly through.
Comment on this
The farmers have stood up to the fight, but the Minister was not in the trenches; he was never asked to go into the trenches. The position is that he flung one regiment into the trenches and left them there all the time.
Comment on this
Well, then, he will appreciate the words of the old song, "Johnny, I hardly knew you."
Comment on this
The devil a bit were you in the trenches, any kind of a trench, except in a rat-hole, where you belong.
Comment on this
That is an expression that should not be used towards any Deputy in this House. Deputy Gorey will withdraw that expression.
Comment on this
I am sorry that Deputy Gorey has forgotten the good character I gave him. I should be surprised, very seriously surprised, if there had not been some increase in the farmers' savings, taking them broadly. I do not mean to say that every farmer saved money. I am perfectly certain a lot of farmers lost, a lot of them, but if any reliance can be placed on the figures given, in the first instance, in the report of the Derating Commission and the figures which were published a couple of months ago in a newspaper, broadly it would seem that the general mass of the farmers have managed to come through the economic war fairly successfully. I do not want to talk in superlatives, but I would be surprised if that were not a fact, because figures which are in our possession and which we have got from year to year—the returns for the Post Office Savings Bank deposits and for Savings Certificates—show that, whereas in 1931-32 the figures for savings held in those ways amounted to £13,119,000, for 1937-38 they had gone up to £21,369,000. Of course, the Savings Banks are found all over the country, and Savings Certificates are sold all over the country, and these deposits must belong in some part to members of the rural community and the remainder similarly belong to those who live in urban areas.
In any event, there has not been anything like the serious deterioration in the economic position of any section of the community that Deputies who have been clamouring for derating and making a poor wail about the farmers' conditions would have us believe. I think they are doing small credit to the farmers. I would not like to think that the farmers of Ireland would care to see their representatives standing up here like a lot of banshees wailing for the coming demise of the Irish farmers. The farmers of Ireland are men who stood up during the economic war, and they put this Government in power during that economic war, and while I think they would like us to do as much as we possibly could——
Comment on this
We did it in Wexford. I was saying that I know that the farmers, like every other section of the community, would like us to do the best we could for them, but they would not like us to do anything for them that would be unjust to the remainder of the community. They have a great sense of civic spirit, a great public spirit, the farmers of Ireland, and all they want is a fair crack of the whip, and every election since 1932 has proven that, at any rate, the farmers believe they have got a fair crack of the whip from this Government.
Comment on this
Let us, however, again consider the position. In 1931 the farmers could not get derating, because in 1929 they owned 29 per cent. of the deposits in the Irish banks. That is what Deputy Cosgrave said. How is Deputy Cosgrave now going to justify his advocacy of derating, which he refused when the farmers had only 29 per cent. of the deposits—how is he going to justify his advocacy now when the farmers hold 39 per cent. of the deposits? In 1931 the farmers were paying the full 20/- in the £ of the agreed land purchase annuities. To-day they are paying only 10/- in the £.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would ask himself how much they paid to Great Britain during the ten years up to 1932?
Comment on this
Even Deputy Keating cannot deny this, that the farmers are paying only the half annuity to-day, no matter what they may have paid in other years.
Comment on this
Now, the Deputy cannot turn back the clock; he cannot project himself back into 1932. Even Deputy Keating will have to forget the past and realise that he is living in 1938. In 1931 the Irish farmers had the British market and they were paying 20/- in the £ in respect of land purchase annuities. To-day the Irish farmers have the British market again for as much as it is worth, and they are paying only 10/- in the £ by way of annuities.
Comment on this
You claimed you fired the first shot, and you fired the last shot, too. Not alone did you go with your hat in your hand, but you went in your bare feet over to England.
Comment on this
Deputy Keating must restrain himself, and he should allow the Minister to proceed with his speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Keating will restrain himself and permit the Minister to make his statement. That is the last warning I am giving to Deputy Keating.
Comment on this
As I was saying, in 1931 the Irish farmer had not the full benefit of a developed beet-sugar industry, and if Deputies want proof of that——
Comment on this
If Deputies want proof of that, they can turn to the Appropriation Accounts for that year and they will find that in 1931 the beet sugar industry produced 5,306 tons of beet sugar and cost the Exchequer £57,000. Last year the sugar factories produced over 80,000 tons of beet sugar and the cost of that production to the Exchequer was £900,000, all of it going to the farmers.
Comment on this
In 1931 the farmers had no guaranteed price of wheat; there was nothing to assist those engaged in tillage.
Comment on this
Similarly, in 1931 they had no guaranteed price for butter and nothing, as everybody must recall, was being done for the dairying industry in that year. Our ports were open to the agricultural products of the world. Danish butter. Siberian butter, Chinese bacon, Chinese eggs— all these things were coming in in 1931, and all that is ended now. Whatever is consumed in this country in the way of dairy products, as well as a large part of our wheat consumption, all our eggs, all our poultry, all our beef and all our mutton—all these are Irish produce, produced by the Irish farmer.
Let me go back over this again, because I think it will be seen that what is really responsible for the condition of deep melancholia which seems to afflict the Opposition, and particularly the farmer members of it, is that they still think that, not merely are they living in the last six years, but that they are back again in 1931. Let us remember, however, that the plight of the Irish farmers in 1931 was not an enviable one, and I want to bring home to the members of the Opposition the difference between 1937-38 and 1931. First of all, they pay only one half of the annuities they were paying in 1931. The beet growing which then cost the Exchequer £57,000 has now been so developed that it is costing £900,000. In 1931, farmers were being driven out of tillage; to-day, tillage has been made profitable. Deputy Gorey himself had admitted that, because he told us that, in his view, 50 per cent. of the farming community which had done well out of the economic war were those who were engaged in growing wheat and beet and, in general, those who had adopted and followed the tillage policy of the Government.
Comment on this
I admit that, possibly, we might be something worse off in that regard than we were in 1931, but I think that, on a calm examination, when he reads his statements in regard to that phenomenon the Deputy will agree that his arguments are not tenable. However, let me go on. I said that in 1931 the farmers were being driven out of tillage, and that now tillage was profitable. In 1931 the dairying industry was in a state of collapse; to-day it is thriving. In 1931 foreign farmers were competing with the Irish farmer for his own market in practically every commodity which the Irish farmer produced. To-day, that cutthroat competition no longer exists, and the Irish market belongs to the Irish farmer, and he has as good a place in the British market, as I said before, as he ever had. In short, in every way the position of the Irish farmer to-day is much better than it was in 1931. I do not say that it is as good as it should be or as it will be, but, at any rate, it is very much better than it was in 1931. Every impartial individual whom you meet in the country to-day will admit the truth of that statement. There has been talk of derating, as I have said, and yet in 1931 the Derating Commission reported that it could not find any justification for derating. How much less justification is there for it to-day. I had intended to go more into this subject, but I have been talking longer that I had meant to.
Comment on this
Well, I shall talk only a little longer. I was going to say that I wished to discuss one proposal which was made by a Deputy which, I think, was even more outrageous than that proposed by the leader of the Opposition, and that was a proposal to derate urban property. I understand that that proposal was made by a Deputy in this debate, and I think it could only have been made because those who advocate derating in one form or another do not realise the fact that, however we may look upon the question of derating, one thing that must be kept in mind is that rates are borne, in the main, by the owners of property, and that a demand for general derating simply means that you lift the burden off the backs of those who are fortunate enough to have property, whether in the form of land or houses, and transfer it, or a very large part of that burden, to the backs of those who have no property.
However, as I said, it is later than I had anticipated, and I do not intend to examine at length this problem of urban derating, but there is one proposal that I think I should not sit down without touching upon, and that was the proposal that credit should be provided in some way for farmers at low rates of interest. I wonder has anybody ever considered what that would entail, and whether it could possibly be administered. I would like to have a practical scheme discussed here in the House as to what its effect might be. I heard a farmer say to-day, and I agree, that the great majority of hard-pressed farmers—the farmers who are virtually down-and-out—are in that condition by reason of unwise liabilities which they contracted, either on their own behalf or on behalf of other people, in regard to loans.
Comment on this
I said "unwise", and the Deputy can call it "bosh" if he likes to do so, but everybody knows what a millstone it is for a farmer to have raised money on loan in times of comparative prosperity, as the great majority of Irish farmers did in the years 1919 and 1920, and then to have to carry that liability through the depression. The only ones who came through that depression were those who were wise enough in their generation not to over-borrow on a boom. However, in this connection, are Deputies aware how much money was advanced on loan to the Irish farmers? I had some calculations made in that regard before the last election, as a matter of fact, so that I might be in a position to examine some of the proposals in the Fine Gael programme. The amount cannot be much less than £15,000,000—that is, the amount which the banks have advanced to Irish farmers. Now, that is money advanced to credit-worthy farmers. Of course, some farmers are not so credit-worthy now as they were at the time when advances were made and, as a result, some of these advances might be regarded as frozen loans. There might be about 70,000 farmers who were able to get loans but there might be another 15,000 who have not been able to get loans. Then again, there are many other farmers who have not wanted loans, because they have been in a prosperous financial position and have been able to finance their farming all the time—farmers who, if they could get their money out of their farming and invest it, or take a turn on the stock exchange, could make money and get even. With the way markets are going at present, one might make money even when there is a fall, as well as a rise. At any rate, you would have the 70,000 to consider in the first place, and then you would have an additional few thousand—I do not know how many it might be—of people who have not been able to get money from the banks. Then there are others who, if they thought they were able to get money, at, say, 3 per cent. or 3½ per cent. from the Government—and what a temptation that is, for we all know how difficult it may be on occasions for the Government to enforce its rights in regard to loans as, for instance, our experience in regard to the fishery loans—might come along and say: "Why should I sink my money in my farm, when I can get money at 3 per cent. from the Government, and can put my own money into an industrial investment, and even though I might be getting 5 or 6 or 10 per cent. on it in the farm, in any event, if I can get money to replace it at 3 per cent. from the Government I can make a 3 per cent. profit on my own money by investing it in this way."
This, then, would be the problem: that every man who had been able to get money from the bank, and every man who had not been able to get money from a bank, and every man who did not want money from a bank would come along and want a Government loan. And how could anybody be refused? Are we to have a whole corps of investigators? We have heard, on some of the Estimates here, the complaint made that too many officials are poking their noses into the farmers' business. If we are to avoid that, we cannot make fish of one and flesh of another in regard to this matter of Government loans. Every man who came for a loan would have to get one. He would have to get as much as he demanded, and we could not make too many bones about an investigation. What would be the financial problem which the Government would have to face, and what would be the financial problem which the banks would have to face when this money was thrown back into them? What was going to be the problem of the bank depositors when this money was thrown back on the banks, and when no use could be found for it? First of all, you would be in this position, that the Government would have to find an enormous sum and suffer a very heavy continuous loss for a considerable number of years—a loss that I could not put a price on, but it might be £1,000,000 or more. And, remember, you could not refuse any person a loan under these circumstances. Deputy Gorey, who would not want a loan in normal circumstances, would have to get it if he demanded it, and even the person whom I have heard Deputy Gorey describe as a wastrel—the person who, he says, neither works nor wants work —he would have to get his loan. How are you going to discriminate? You could not discriminate between sections of farmers. And, further, who is going to administer it? We hear a lot of talk about the number of officials. We have heard it said that the cost of the Civil Service has gone up by nearly £1,000,000. How many officials, do you think, would you require to administer a scheme of that sort if the Government was going to stand up as the milch cow for every man, who owned a bit of land in the country, to come and have his draw out of it?
The fact of the matter is that the first people to clamour for a cessation of that state of affairs would be the honest working farmers of the country, because they would very quickly realise that where there was easy money to be got, once people got it, they were not going to use it properly. That conclusion is based upon the experience of every person who ever had to deal with money. If money can be got easily it will be wasted and misused, so that when we talk about loans for farmers we might as well say gifts for farmers. That means taking the money out of the farmer's right-hand pocket and putting it into his left-hand pocket, because, as we are so often told, the farmers bear a very large share of the cost of government. I have kept the House at great length, but I am grateful for the patient hearing which I have had, even from Deputy Keating, under great provocation.