Committee on Finance. - Vote 10.—Office of Public Works (Resumed).
Contributions 1–156 of 518. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I should like to support what has been said by some previous speakers regarding Government buildings. The Department with which I am acquainted is the Department of Industry and Commerce, and it has been stated for a number of years that a building in Kildare Street would be constructed for that Department. I do not know whether or not there has been any reconsideration of that decision, or what may be the reason for the delay, but I do know that that Department in particular suffers very severely from want of proper accommodation. The staffs of the Department occupy at least 12 separate buildings in different portions of the city. I think, in fact, there may be more than 12. Most of the accommodation is very inadequate and unsuitable. The premises are in many cases converted private dwellinghouses, which obviously were never intended to give suitable office accommodation. There are many other Government Departments which are equally badly housed. I should like if the Parliamentary Secretary would tell us whether this problem is being considered as a whole. Has any consideration been given to what is going to be done over a considerable period regarding Government buildings? Obviously there will have to be a good deal of building some time or another, and I should like if the Parliamentary Secretary could tell us that that will be undertaken as part of a comprehensive plan.
The ideal thing, of course, would be if all the Government buildings could be grouped in one part of the city. That may not be possible; I do not know. The next best thing would be if the Departments could be in a number of groups, and I should like if we could have some information as to what consideration has been given to that matter. This Parliament building, for example, is obviously only a temporary one. Nobody would seriously state it is going to last for all time. Anyone who visits the capitals of continental countries, even the very small ones, must feel ashamed of the absence of a proper Parliament building here. Can the Parliamentary Secretary tell us if any consideration has been given to that? This question is very closely related to one which is the main concern of the Dublin Corporation and the Dublin County Council, namely, the replanning of the city—a very urgent matter, and one that requires very careful consideration. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary tell us that his Department, in so far as they have any authority or influence in the matter, will be sympathetic to a broad and comprehensive scheme which will take in not only all Government buildings, including a new Parliament building, but the cathedral that we hear about, the new city hall, and the various other public buildings, whether national or local. This subject, too, is very closely related to the problem of congestion, which will probably never be solved unless we have such a comprehensive plan. I should be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would give us an assurance that his Department is giving all the sympathy and support it can to the solution of that problem.
Comment on this
I hope the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government will pay more attention to the needs of the country before they think of moving out of a building such as this; it is quite good enough. I think the Parliamentary Secretary gave an indication to Deputy Dillon in regard to a drainage inquiry. I should like to knew at this stage what sort of terms of reference are to be put before this inquiry; and what are the powers that it is proposed to ask for? Is there any body of young men to get instruction with regard to surveying, especially with regard to drainage surveying for levels? We have a whole lot of bogland and low-lying land in this country. Although we have not the same type of bogland and low-lying land as they have in Holland, I think, in proportion to our size, we have more of that type of land than any other country in Europe. The position here was the same as it was in England—that before land purchase operated here there was a certain amount of authority; there was a certain amount of supervision. The owners of estates had men attached to each estate who made it their business to walk the waterways and see there was no obstruction. They made it their business to see that they were maintained at a certain level. That is still done in England, and you have not the problem there that you have here. In England they have not lost land that was of any use. We have lost thousands and thousands of acres here in one county alone. When purchase began, the supervision by the landlord owners ceased. In many cases it ceased long before they went out of the country altogether, with the result that our waterways have all got choked up.
Some drainage systems which had their outlet on those waterways, especially the minor ones, were effective when opened up after a period of perhaps 100 years. I want to know what is contemplated by the Department in regard to this matter, as it is a very important one. It ought to be recognised that there must be some State authority over waterways, even the minor ones. There ought to be State control over any waterways that are considered effective and necessary for drainage purposes. If put into proper condition in the first instance they could be supervised by the Guards in two visits a year, without any more expense to the State. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary is quite alive to the necessity for that. We see whole tracts of country destroyed because one part of the waterway has been allowed to become blocked up. In the course of time trees grow, and the whole place right back to the source is blocked and rendered useless. On his first Estimate in 1932 when the Minister for Agriculture referred to the number of cattle in the country, I made some of the suggestions which I am now making. The fact is that most of the land which is waste now was dairy land 60 or 80 years ago. Now, to maintain that standard of dairying, the arable land has to be encroached upon. Now, the arable land that could be used for tillage is dairy land, and the low-lying land has gone waste. One need only walk half a mile from one's own door in the part of the country that I come from to find whole tracts of waste land. A few years ago, when I had not as much practical experience of the matter as I have now, I followed up the idea that a certain place could be tremendously improved, and bought it for a few pounds. In order to do anything with the portion I had bought, I had to go half a mile into a neighbour's land. When I reached my own point I had gained a level of four feet. In that year, that was done in 13 days. It would be an education to anybody to see what has been done, and what are its effects. In the following year I devoted about three weeks to the work, and another fortnight in the year after, with the result that a large tract of country was drained, and about 500 acres of that are now arable land and have been tilled.
That is the position all over the country and that is the reason I say you must have some authority. A day for seeing that the waterways are kept clear would be more valuable to this country than an arbour day. I am prepared to go any distance to meet the man who wants to conserve water for cattle at certain seasons of the year, say, from May until October, because that can be done in a reasonable way. In these days of cement, when a man can put up piers on which he can have a temporary dam for the summer so as to conserve water, I can see the necessity for that and I am prepared to go any distance to meet that. But there ought to be a time varying with the different seasons, according to the rainfall, when all that ought to be cleared for the winter and give a free flow of water so as to make the drainage effective. The summer stoppage can do no damage. All this can be regulated and enforced but the time should come every year when all the waterways of the country should be cleared and kept clear. It should not be in the power of any individual anywhere to prevent that.
Comment on this
How would the Deputy deal with a farmer lower down the stream whose water was dammed off?
Comment on this
That could be arranged because it should be dammed before the water gets scarce so that it does not get the overflow. Some authority should decide that.
Comment on this
The Deputy will see that it can be a very difficult problem. I am not criticising the Deputy, because it is a good suggestion, if it could be carried out.
Comment on this
I think it could. Of course if one waits until the last moment and then dams the water, it will absorb all the supply. If it is done in good time, it still can overflow and go on and everybody can be provided for.
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent a man putting up a dam in the summer and preventing the water getting down.
Comment on this
That sort of thing will have to depend on circumstances, and the particular flow of water. It may be a little bit hard to work out. It may not, in every case, be possible to work it out in practice.
Comment on this
It is worth more than considering. I wonder have we a school of engineering of real experience with regard to this? If some of the things that have come to my notice are examples of it, I say decidedly— although it is the last thing I want to say—that we have not. There were some embankments broken down in my county at Ballyneale and down to the Suir side, and three or four attempts were made to deal with these, but they have not been successful. How were the banks put up in the old days when engineers had not the facilities they have to-day? How were the fen lands in England and in Holland shut off if we are not able to repair a few bridges and embankments here? The Land Commission took on the doing of these particular jobs in County Kilkenny, and they failed to do them. They allowed the money advanced on these particular holdings to go by the board.
On Saturday last I went to view the problem presented by the Lough Cullen drainage. I understand that officials of the Department were examining that place for months. The result was that they decided to do nothing. If I were there for a month or two, not alone would I have decided on what I should do, but I would have done it myself if I had a shovel and a bag. There are 1,000 acres of swamp there because that has not been dealt with. The first obstacle in the way is the accumulation of stones under the bridge controlled either by the county council or the Board of Works. There is a tongue of limestone coming from each side. The bridge is a very old one, and unable to take heavy traffic— an engine cannot get across it. The level has been raised at least one foot in that particular instance, and 200 yards further down you get another foot. About 150 yards below that, a two-foot high fence of sods and stones and trees is built across the river for support. This small river is only a mile or a mile and a half long. There is a mill on it which has not been worked, I suppose, for 30 years. From the head race supplying the mill to the tail race, you will get a depth of 17 or 18 feet, or perhaps more. There is no necessity to interfere with that in order to deal with this problem. If the weir is removed, and you work back from that to the bridge, a distance of less than one mile, this 1,000 acres of land will be brought back to its original fertility. When the mill was working, the people who had the water rights kept the place clean, with the result that the water was one and a half or two feet lower than it is now. I saw that area in my young days supporting more cattle than any similar area in any other part of the county. To-day, nothing can go into it.
Owing to the nature of the country, I consider that water obstruction is a more serious matter even than road obstruction. It is much more serious than having animals straying on the road for which prosecutions are instituted by the police. I am the last person in the world who wants any force used or annoyance caused to the people in occupation of the land, but there is a certain standard you must maintain if you are going to keep the land in arable condition and not have it wasted. It also has a bearing on the question of national health. You cannot maintain the health of the people and of animals properly in a water-logged country where there is an atmosphere of dampness.
With regard to this particular area at Lough Cullen, if I were sure of my rights and of the power of entry, I would have organised the people of the district and done the job in a fortnight. But, probably, if I removed the stones under the bridge I would be committing an offence for interfering with the foundations. I do not think, however, that that would be so, as it must be built on the rock. If I were living in the district and had the land rights that the people there have—and they have certain rights as well as the former owners of the mill—I would consult a solicitor with a view to prosecuting the county council for allowing the obstruction at the bridge and the further obstruction down the river.
I have nothing further to say except that I think the Parliamentary Secretary ought to take his courage in his hands and claim certain powers and authority, otherwise he will not get this very necessary work carried out. He should take whatever power he deems to be necessary to enable him to have the works carried out. There will be an odd individual here and there who will not co-operate, and who will endeavour to obstruct him in the attempt to exercise his right, but it is up to some central authority to take whatever steps are necessary to improve these lands. In the past the landlord had the right of supervision over these lands and now that he has passed away, the State should have that right. I think everybody in the country will agree that something in reason is necessary to improve the condition of such lands. As I have said already, I am the last in the world who would want anything drastic done, but I think in the cases I have mentioned some action should be taken to put the land of the country back into its former condition. Serious encroachment on the arable land of the country has occurred as the result of this particular neglect in low-lying lands, although these were among the most productive areas we formerly had.
Comment on this
I wish to raise just a few points on this Vote. Splendid work is being done by the Board of Works all over the country, through the medium of these minor relief schemes. These schemes are very much appreciated by the different sections of the community whom they serve and benefit. For instance, the repair of old boreens and the widening of by-roads leading into farms and farmers' houses, are, to my mind, very useful works and should be continued and, if possible, intensified. There is one matter in this connection that I should like to suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary, that is, the advisability of the Board of Works seeking compulsory powers for the acquisition of land from the owners wherever necessary. I know of a few cases in Waterford where owing to jealousy of neighbours, or for some other petty reason, the owners of certain land will not give the necessary permission for the work to proceed. I know of a number of desirable schemes in the constituency that have been held up for that reason. I believe myself that if compulsory powers were in the hands of the Board of Works, the knowledge that the Board of Works had such powers would in itself, without their being forced fully to exercise these powers, be sufficient to break down most of the opposition of the kind I mention. I think therefore, that either the Board of Works or the local authority should be given these powers.
Another point which I should like to raise has reference to the withdrawal of minor relief schemes from areas where there is not a sufficient number of registered unemployed. This applies in particular to mountainy districts. With very few exceptions, the population of these districts consists of very small holders who are in very poor circumstances. For different reasons these people do not register as unemployed at the Exchange. For instance, they may live six or seven miles away from the nearest Guards barracks and, because of the small amount of unemployment assistance they could get, they do not bother to register. There is no doubt that those people, in a sense, are no better off financially than the ordinary labouring man and I would suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that those people should be considered in all future minor schemes. They should be considered as unemployed for the purpose of enabling these very necessary schemes to be carried out in the areas in which they live. If the Parliamentary Secretary would adopt that suggestion it would be a great benefit financially to those people and it would assist them considerably in tiding over the lean winter months when there is no income whatsoever coming into their household. As I have said before, they are in the unfortunate position that they are no better off than the ordinary labouring man whereas, at the same time, they have much greater overhead charges such as rent and rates. I think that that is a point that should be considered by the Parliamentary Secretary.
The only other matter to which I should like to refer is the desirability of employing men on minor relief schemes for at least six days of the week. This question has been raised by a number of Deputies. I am aware of a number of cases in Waterford where, last year, men were in receipt of, say, the maximum amount of unemployment assistance. They were then employed for two or three days on minor relief schemes and by reason of that fact they received less than they would have received if they were drawing unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
I know that a deputation came to me in Dungarvan last year in which there were five or six men who stated that that was a fact.
Comment on this
I shall go into that again. I was approached as I was leaving the town on that point. I am quite prepared to accept the Parliamentary Secretary's word, but I was given to understand by these men that they had that grievance. I think that is all I have to say on the matter. I should like if the minor relief schemes were continued on a greater scale and that the Parliamentary Secretary would take into consideration the case of people living in the mountainy districts that I have mentioned. I think it would be a great service to these people if they were allowed to register or were considered as unemployed for the purpose of having these schemes carried out in the mountainy areas.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey expressed a doubt as to whether we had the engineering capacity to deal with drainage works. I should say we have. Of that I have very little doubt and for the particular type of work, arterial drainage work, we have to do in this country, if we had not them I do not think we could get them from any other country.
Comment on this
Not that they have no drainage problems in other countries. They have, but their drainage problems are different from our drainage problems. In connection with our big drainage problems we tried to get and did get outside advice but it was extremely difficult to get such engineers outside, even as consultants. They have drainage problems in Switzerland completely different from ours. The same applies to Holland— essentially different from both. This is such a specialised type of work that you want more than general engineering capacity. We can get plenty of that type of men—and very good men, and you can train them up to be drainage experts. You want, however, not merely men of engineering capacity, men who are familiar with other types of drainage problems, but you want men trained in our particular problems. I think you have these in the Board of Works. The difficulty does not arise from lack of technical knowledge on the part of the engineering staff in the Board of Works. It comes from defective administrative machinery, and powers. That would be common ground. I think the Parliamentary Secretary will be the first to acknowledge that the actual administrative machinery at his disposal is not such as to enable him to deal with the different types of problem that come to him in connection with drainage. We have good material in the way of engineers throughout the country, and they could be taken and trained if necessary. I am sure the capacity is there to train others. If it is not there we shall not get it anywhere else. I am not quite sure when you come to the present drainage code in reference to the type of problem raised by Deputy Gorey, that you have the same technical skill elsewhere.
There is, for instance, the question of maintenance. Under the present law the duty of maintenance falls on county councils. Is there any guarantee that the county councils have the necessary staff to deal with that problem? They have engineers, but they are engaged in other work and it would not be fair to expect them to have the particular knowledge that is necessary, even for maintenance schemes. Therefore, what is really lacking is not technical capacity at the centre, but machinery—and that would require legislation. I cannot advocate that here, except in so far as it touches on the question of the setting up of the commission which may lead—and I presume will—to a new drainage code or a modification of the present one. Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary will forgive me if I am a bit sceptical about that commission.
Comment on this
Perhaps you may. At least, you can see the grounds of my scepticism. The Parliamentary Secretary intervened in this debate on Friday last, at column 1496 of the Parliamentary Debates. Replying to Deputy Dillon, he said:
"Mr. Flinn: I will answer the Deputy's question now if he wishes. The personnel is practically completed."
More than 12 months ago, on April 1st, 1937, speaking on this debate, Deputy O'Sullivan said——
Comment on this
The same Deputy as is now speaking. I was then indicating the extreme urgency of this matter, and said:
"My remarks are directed towards convincing the Parliamentary Secretary of the urgency of this matter and to help him administratively in connection with this particular subhead.
"Mr. Flinn: If I were to tell the Deputy that the commission is in process of being set up, would that save him any time?"
I was sceptical 12 months ago, and I replied that I did not think it would, that I had better put the matter forward, notwithstanding the fact that the commission was in process of being set up. I gather that it is still in the process of being set up. It advances at the same rate as the Awbeg river; and so shall we ever get that drainage commission? Twelve months ago we were told it was in process of being set up; things had advanced so far that at that time it was suggested by the Parliamentary Secretary that it was hardly worth while discussing the matter, as before the next 12 months we were led to understand there would be a new code of legislation before the House. To-day, more than 13 months later, should like to point out that we are in precisely the same position. I do not blame the Board of Works and I do not blame the Parliamentary Secretary. That is a matter of Government policy. But I want to point out that Government policy has been remarkably slow when the commission is in the same embryonic state, apparently, that it was in 12 months ago. If the incubation period is as slow as that, I should say that there will be very little of the existing drainage schemes left to investigate, because all will have gone into full disrepair. Not merely has the commission to be set up but, after that process, it has to consider evidence and that will, possibly, take a couple of years. The Parliamentary Secretary, whoever he will be, and the Board of Works will then have to consider the evidence, prepare heads of Bills and submit them to the Government. Twelve months after, the Government will wonder if it is necessary to deal with the matter, and perhaps ten or 15 years will elapse before the Parliamentary Secretary will be able to have drainage schemes considered. I suggest that much more speed than that is necessary, and much more speed than was evinced in the passage that I quoted from last Friday's debates and from the debate that took place over 12 months ago. There is just one excuse for the statement that was made 12 months ago. It was made on the 1st April and, possibly, we were more or less victims of playful efforts by the Parliamentary Secretary. It is possible that Deputies took it that the 1st of April statement was too seriously meant.
Comment on this
We generally receive information. The schemes that I mentioned on the last occasion illustrate the two big problems that the country has to face in connection with drainage. I am speaking, not of the minor schemes, but of the larger ones. One deals with maintenance such as Deputy Gorey mentioned. The Akeragh Lough scheme was planned out and completed by the Board of Works and handed over to the Kerry County Council; what was the result? The estimated annual benefit to farmers was in a very short time exceeded by the annual amount they had to pay. That was the position 12 months ago. I will find out the position at the present day later, as I will put a question to the Parliamentary Secretary about it. What does the position show? It shows the necessity for urgency. The county council says that it cannot help, that it has to exact these payments because it is the law. When the Parliamentary Secretary is approached the reply is that the Board of Works have washed their hands of the question. There is plenty of water, anyhow, in these places to do that. The Board of Works say that they handed over these schemes to the county councils, that they had no more to do with them and could not intervene. Undoubtedly here is a case in which more is being charged than it is professed the scheme was worth. Worse still, the scheme is actually falling into deterioration. This year may have been an exception. The problem is that schemes are being handed over that are imposing greater burdens on the farmers than the alleged benefits, and not only that, but that are quickly getting back to the original state, so that in a short time you find yourself in this position, that farmers are saddled with a heavy annuity without any benefit to show for it. But still the answer of the Board of Works is quite clear: "We cannot do anything in the matter. We cannot go in and inspect it. We cannot send an engineer down to see why the scheme is not working, to see whether it has fallen into disuse, to see whether the lands are returning to the state they were in ten years ago. We cannot do it. We have no power." I doubt if that is the only case in the country. I think there must be several other cases of the same kind. I see the Parliamentary Secretary agrees with me.
Comment on this
For the reason I have stated—because the calculated amount of the benefit was exceeded by maintenance plus annuity charge.
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary will find that what I say is correct. Anyhow he refused to intervene although the county council was bound to collect the annuities according to the law independent of whether the farmers were getting any benefit out of the scheme or not. That was their answer. The Parliamentary Secretary's answer was that by law he had no right to intervene. If there are any other cases of that kind—and I am sure there are a number of cases—where the benefits not merely do not come up to the estimation of the benefits but where they were actually overtopped by the maintenance expenses plus annuity charges, then all the more urgency for this commission being appointed.
There was another large case in the same constituency. I gave these as illustrations of different types. Here it is not a question of maintaining; here it is a question solely for the Board of Works. It is not a question of the local contribution. An arrangement was agreed to as regards that. So eager were the people, as I previously told the Parliamentary Secretary, that they were prepared to pay more than the Board of Works thought they would be liable for. Apparently agreement was come to between the then county council, who was the commissioner, the Board of Works, and the farmers whose lands were to be benefited. But once that agreement was reached—and up to this that was the principal difficulty, getting agreement on the percentages of the cost to be met by the different parties—but once that agreement was reached the scheme seems to have collapsed, to have stopped. Nothing else has been done and again I refer to the commission— to the commission that was in that advanced state of incubation 12 months ago and which has advanced just about a few minutes since then, and not much more.
This may be an exceptional year. Much damage may not have been done this spring to that "submarine estate" on the Brick and Cashen but, as the Parliamentary Secretary knows, that is a matter for which the farmers have to be thankful but for which the Board of Works can hardly claim the benefit. The Government will probably claim it but the Board of Works is much too modest to claim credit for that particular benefit. Every ordinary year that passes makes the amount of work to be done down there greater because there are embankments already in existence and they are yearly being destroyed. But the reply is that that is a scheme that is very difficult. I know it is. I admit it is. But, having to wait for a commission and new laws before any effective steps are taken even to keep the present embankments in the state they are in now is a mistake. It is a mistake to postpone everything to the commission. Some type of work might be done, some preliminary work that may lessen the work in the future, if you are ever going to undertake that work.
I referred to the spring weather, to the weather we have had for the last two months. I admit the Board of Works could not have foreseen that but at least, they could have had schemes of this kind ready so as to take advantage of it when it did come. I know no better chance of dealing with difficult river schemes than the type of weather we have had for the last two months. But here, as I say, there is no scheme ready. These two cases, the Akeragh Lough and Brick and Cashen schemes, I bring forward as typical of how this matter is being dealt with, the slowness, I was going to say, of the advance, but, candidly, with the examples before me, I cannot register any advance. I should be a person to whom faith comes very easy if I saw any evidence of an advance between now and 13 months ago. I am not, as I say, blaming the Parliamentary Secretary; he may have difficulties with his Government and with his Minister for Finance, but he should let us know why it is that, 12 months after that statement was made by the Parliamentary Secretary, namely, that the commission is in the process of being set up, we are still in the same position.
Now, there are one or two other matters to which I may refer. A matter has come up here for discussion, for consideration perhaps. That is the question of rotational employment. The Deputy from Waterford, Deputy Morrissey, was speaking and he made the statement that they receive less than the dole. That was promptly denied by the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
I am not going into that, but shall I put it this way —a number of people do not receive very much more. One of the statements made by the Parliamentary Secretary is this, and I am not at all throwing any doubt on this:
"...until recent years a traditional laxity and inefficiency has grown up in this and in other countries in respect of relief works, and this was due, in part at least, to the hasty manner in which it was always found necessary to organise and to carry on..."
and so on. But then I think the Parliamentary Secretary will admit there is another reason why that should be so. He goes on:
"In these circumstances it is not surprising that relief works came to acquire a poor reputation in the past for efficiency, and there is no doubt that this bad tradition still persists in one degree or another."
If you give men a few shillings per week more than they get for doing nothing, that is practically dole. The work would be counted as dole, looked upon as dole, and you will not get efficient work. That would be the tendency. You may, in certain instances, get it, but, on the whole, there is the danger that if you give men only a few shillings a week more than they get for doing nothing, they look upon the relief work as dole, and you will not get the full return. That is natural, human nature being what it is. You may give me instances in which you may get a good return, but, I say, the temptation will be in the direction I suggest. Therefore, from the point of view of getting a return for money, and of efficiency, I think you are embarking on a wrong line by simply giving men for doing hard work a few shillings a week more than they would get for doing nothing. I remember when I was in the Board of Works we gave people pay for drainage work; it was not a high rate, indeed, but they did excellent work because it was constant work. I saw the returns in some of these drainage districts, and there was nothing to complain of. That was, at least, my experience for the short period, the very happy period, that I happened to be there.
Comment on this
I did not hear complaints then. I cannot speak now of whether the work was permanent or not but certainly we got the information at that time from our engineers on the spot and from our experts, that there was excellent return given in the way of work. But with this doling out of work you cannot expect men to give you their full work. They look upon this merely as dole and the temptation will be to do as little as they can. That is human nature and that is one of the worst results that I see flowing from this particular system. The Parliamentary Secretary says: "Very good; it will require £10,000,000 a year to deal with unemployment if you deal with it fully." That is a very interesting figure. The Parliamentary Secretary will remember that on more than one occasion he stood up in this House and pointed out what use we could not make of the unemployment figures. I never got from him what use we could make of them, but he was very clear and very eloquent that any use anybody ever made of them was wrong. In fact I never knew, if he were correct in his views, why these figures were published. Nobody apparently could see how they were to be interpreted. I think that is not a misinterpretation of the Parliamentary Secretary's attitude here with regard to the question of unemployment returns. A sum of £10,000,000 a year at the rate of wages paid puts at a very high figure the number of unemployed in this country. I should say it would work out at something like 110,000 unemployed. That is the figure most critics of the Government pretend it is. There were one or two other matters which I think I put to the Parliamentary Secretary on a previous occasion——
Comment on this
I am dealing with it. If the Parliamentary Secretary vacates that position he holds, I am quite ready to deal with that matter.
Comment on this
It might be better to do that than to continue what the Parliamentary Secretary is doing. We are getting into the position from which it is harder to get salvation. It is worse to continue doing what he is doing.
Comment on this
I would like to get from the Deputy whether his suggestion includes £10,000,000 or reducing that amount, or is he coming down to any competent plan?
Comment on this
From the statement of the Minister for Finance —last year, was it? —we have to take it that we shall always have the unemployed with us, and from the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary we are to take it that we shall always have the rotational system with us. We are no longer going to solve unemployment by the plan! That is now the confession from the Government Benches.
Comment on this
It was the Government who undertook to do this thing. They undertook it then, and they had no doubt they could do it. What I am protesting against is a different thing. The Parliamentary Secretary is doing much more serious damage to the country than any mere wastage of money. He is interfering with the morale of the country. Take his own statement. The system which is there can only do something which will lead to inefficiency in the work. The Parliamentary Secretary complains of inefficiency in this type of work. What else can he expect from the modified dole system?
I now put to the Parliamentary Secretary one or two questions connected with another matter. Is what is being done in the way of school buildings anything more than keeping level with the deterioration that is taking place? I even doubt if we are doing so much. I remember there was an inquiry several years ago. The Board of Works and the Education Department were both dealing with the matter. They made a census of unsuitable and bad schools, and it was calculated that, at the rate school-building was then progressing, it would require something like what you have on this Estimate to keep up with the deterioration alone, to say nothing of making good the huge arrears of one kind or another. On one occasion I asked the Parliamentary Secretary whether it was not possible to get a cheaper type of school. I know the Board of Works is very keen on building very substantial schools. I doubt the wisdom of that. In this as well as in other matters ideas change every 50 years. Building a school that will last 100 years is, to my mind, a mistake. One of the difficulties about unsuitable schools at present is that the buildings are really so solid that there is a reluctance to scrap them. I think a cheaper kind of school, such as the Vocational Department is setting up, would be much cheaper and would be quite suitable for the next 30 or 40 years. At that time a future generation could solve the difficulty about the type of school it needed, and in solving that difficulty they would not be up against the difficulties that we have to face now.
Another matter to which I should like to direct attention is this: The Parliamentary Secretary became almost poetic when dealing with the work he is doing in the opening of vistas of scenery. I agree that nothing is more irritating to a tourist than to find when he is going through the country that there is excellent scenery on the other side of a belt of trees and that he is not able to see it through the obstruction. There is another problem not merely having such occasional vistas, but making it comfortable for tourists to get through the country at all to get to it. We have tourist difficulties owing to the weather and a short season and why add to these by bad roads? Some of our most beautiful scenery is approached by roads that are very bad. The beautiful scenery at Sleigh Head is unsurpassed, but is approached by a road that is almost impassable. But the Parliamentary Secretary need not go down as far as Kerry to look for first quality scenery being approached by bad roads. I have no doubt the Minister would like to go down there. Everybody should. But if he takes some of the best and finest scenery within 20 miles of us he will find the position is the same. I do not think there is any other country in Europe that lays itself out to make something out of the tourist traffic where such a thing could occur as you have here. Now the road from here to Sally Gap is bad. But if you want to know what is a really bad road, go from Sally Gap to Togher or Roundwood and then all your worst fears will be fulfilled. Here are two cases that illustrate the point to which I was referring—one here near Dublin, the other the roads in Kerry, approaches to one of the most beautiful pieces of coast scenery I know. These are Government problems. The county council cannot solve them. These are matters that I want to raise on this Vote. The Parliamentary Secretary asks am I in favour of spending £10,000,000. I will answer that question when the Parliamentary Secretary spends a much smaller amount voted and gets better results.
Comment on this
The matter I want to raise on this Vote is of some importance to the City of Dublin. I refer to the position of the Royal Hospital at Kilmainham. That is a question that is very much interesting the Dublin Corporation at present. Some time ago a very important report was received from the Medical Officer of Health of Dublin and we had statements from the people of the Cork Street Hospital. The position is that if an epidemic of scarlatina or measles were to break out there is no room for children in the Dublin hospitals. In a city like Dublin where so many thousand families have to live with five, six, seven, eight or sometimes ten children in one little room, if one of these little ones gets the measles or scarlatina, one can just imagine the position that would arise. I am sure Deputy Larkin could give very graphic examples from the people whom he meets each day to bear out my fears. The Corporation were asked was it possible to get temporary accommodation under such circumstances. They tried and failed. I have some knowledge of the interior of this building and the very old buildings that are attached to it. It maintained 400 pensioners more or less during its career. There are no pensioners in it now. It was built as an hospital and has still most of the equipment that an hospital needs but certainly it is not up to date. However, it could be easily turned into use as a temporary makeshift to meet the difficulties I have mentioned should an epidemic break out. Application was made by the Corporation to be allowed to go in to see the place. Some of the members did not exactly believe me that this place could be made suitable. The reply that the City Manager got was to this effect, that whoever wrote the letter did not think any good result would come of an inspection. I submit to the Parliamentary Secretary, and he is a man of good heart, that this building might be made adaptable for the accommodation of people during an epidemic that might occur in the city in the late autumn, the winter, or the spring. It could be utilised just as a makeshift; we do not want the permanent use of it at all. The position here is very bad during these portions of the year that I have alluded to and I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will see his way to allow an inspection of the building by members of the Corporation and their officers.
I desire to refer to one or two other matters; they are only minor matters. One is with reference to the Chapel Royal in the precincts of Dublin Castle. Interiorly, it is one of the most beautiful buildings in Dublin and it has this attraction for craftsmen—and Dublin is a city of craftsmen—that the carvings there are absolutely the finest in the country. The building is closed; no one can get into it for the purpose of seeing the beautiful interior. If a visitor wants to get in there he has to go in a roundabout way to get admission. It is not used now for religious purposes. I have not been inside it for a long time and all I know about it now is what people tell me. I think this place should be left open to the people.
Comment on this
I see that there is a sum of £680 for the purpose of improving the lighting of this Chamber. I am one who sits a great deal here and, on occasions, I have been glad of some distraction rather than have to listen to the spate of oratory that we have here. As a matter of fact, I have counted the chairs in this establishment possibly a thousand times; indeed, I have counted them so often that I quite forget the number now. If you look at the seats you will observe that some of them are becoming rusty, so rusty indeed that if you bring a stranger here at a time when the lights are not on, the interior of the Chamber is quite shabby. I think you could get the skins off and have them dyed a different colour. Now that we are all brothers, we might have them all the one colour. Deputies need not laugh. I would want to have a marble in my mouth pronouncing the word "brothers" in order to give it a proper roll. I think a different colour scheme would be advisable for the chairs. When the lights are not on, the place presents a very poor appearance. These lights are just for the good of our complexions—I do not see any other use for them. I suggest that the seating of the chairs should be coloured differently so as to give a better appearance to the Chamber.
Comment on this
On the last occasion when this Vote was before the House I referred to certain matters of administration in County Cavan that seemed to me, at any rate, to be more or less irregular. The Parliamentary Secretary feigned indignation, or perhaps he felt it, at the suggestion that there was anything out of the ordinary. I want to assure the Parliamentary Secretary that I had no desire then, and I have no desire now, to misrepresent, or indeed to blacken, him in any way. It would ill become either the Parliamentary Secretary or myself to attempt to blacken one another. What I propose to do now is to submit facts to the House. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will take notice of them and he can then judge for himself. He can admit them, deny them, ignore them, or explain them away. I know the Parliamentary Secretary's eloquence, and his ability. I believe that no matter what hole you put him into, he will get out of it. I know that if I happened to be in the same hole, there is not a man in Eire who would get me out of it.
For the last 12 months I have made recommendations to the Department over which the Parliamentary Secretary presides. I recommended anything from 30 to 60 works, and I do not know that one of them has been carried out. There are some hundreds of works going on in the county, but there is not one of those I recommended included. After all, the supporters of Fine Gael pay taxation as well as other people, and if schemes are submitted they should be considered just as carefully as other schemes, and the Fine Gael people are entitled to their share of the schemes. Of course, I am open to correction in regard to schemes that are being, or have been, carried out. If the Parliamentary Secretary can correct me and point out that any of the schemes I recommended have been done, I shall be very glad.
I am merely indicating the position as I see it, and it is really a position which the average individual cannot understand. It is especially difficult to understand the situation when it is known that these things are discussed in the Fianna Fáil club, and that Deputy Smith asked people in Killkonny Hall how many supporters of ours are living along a proposed work. You cannot blame the people if they form conclusions of their own. I do not know if the Parliamentary Secretary is aware of this, but it is as well to let him know now. I hope when this Vote is under consideration again that there will be no need to refer to this matter.
Comment on this
I will send the name of the person who is my informant to the Parliamentary Secretary. I am not going to give names publicly here.
Comment on this
I did not catch what the Deputy said. If the Parliamentary Secretary wants the name of my informant, I will give it to him and he can communicate with him directly. I am not inventing anything. I would much rather be complimenting the Parliamentary Secretary as I heard others compliment him. I hope, when all this is thrashed out, that the Parliamentary Secretary is not responsible for these things. I always regard him as a man whose heart is better than his tongue—like my own.
Comment on this
I know of one work that was started and it was in Deputy Smith's neighbourhood. It was one of the works I recommended and £15 was laid out for it. It passed the Board of Works engineer, or it would not have been started. It concerned the drainage of a bog, a small affair. For some reason or another, however, that work was stopped. My information is that it was stopped because the ganger first raised objection. It went from that to the county surveyor and the county surveyor discontinued the work. Now, that did not look so well for the engineer to the Board of Works or the county engineer who was directed by the ganger. In fact, it looked rather as if the tail were wagging the dog. Anyway, that, added to the other facts, makes something like two and two, which ought to make four—of course, anybody who wishes to try to explain it otherwise can make two and two make five or six, or only one, but I shall believe that two and two make four, until the contrary is proven.
Now, there is another matter to which I referred last year. It is connected with a certain work, and the Parliamentary Secretary asked me to give him the names in the particular case in question. Well, I have an objection to giving the names of individuals in public, no matter what Party they may belong to.
Comment on this
No matter what side we may happen to belong to, I suppose none of us wishes to expose the other.
Comment on this
How can I remedy the matter, if the Deputy will not give me the names or the particulars?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary knows the particulars. I gave the particulars and names in the Board of Works Office.
Comment on this
I furnished the particulars to the Board of Works, since, and I gave the particulars of a principal Fianna Fáil leader in the district concerned—it is in my own district. The man concerned was a ganger, who had practically £200 a year coming into his house and owned a large farm; he was in charge of a road as ganger, and he began at one end of the road, which led to another road, and when he came to the mearing of a Fine Gael supporter, he stopped and began the road at the other end and stopped again when he reached the mearing on the other side of that man's land and left the road unfinished. If the Parliamentary Secretary will come down to that part of the country, I promise him that I will point out the place, actually from my own door, and I think I can prove to him that it is there as a standing monument to the impartiality of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I invite the Parliamentary Secretary to come down, and I will point out the place to him. As a matter of fact, I am sure that the fresh air of Cavan will do the Parliamentary Secretary good, and, at least, if he should come there he can see for himself what is going on and I hope that if he should come, he will take a note of these things so as to prevent such happenings in the future. Now, I am quite prepared to draw a sponge over the whole slate of the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
I know, of course, that facts will melt like snow before the eloquence of the Parliamentary Secretary when he gets up to reply, but, all the same, I have doubts if he will be able to get over the facts so handily. I have always found that facts are stubborn things to remove, and when there are too many facts supporting one another, that is something which simply cannot be disproved. However, no matter what may have been done in the past, we have hope for better in the future. I would ask him anyhow to consider a scheme lately brought to my notice, and that is a scheme in Sallaghan Bog, near Cavan. I understand that there are about 400 farmers getting good turf from that bog, and I think that a scheme in connection with that bog would be very desirable. I hope that when the board send down their engineer, the engineer will be able to report favourably and that the Parliamentary Secretary will endeavour to carry out whatever scheme may be proposed.
At the present moment, there is another urgent scheme on foot, which I shall try to explain briefly to the Parliamentary Secretary in order that he may take special action in connection with it, since there are some 30 small farmers involved. There is a lawsuit pending in connection with the case. The scheme to which I refer is Brackley Lake. There is an obstruction there because of certain water rights, and a number of small farmers have lost as a result of the lowlands, in which their farms are situated, being flooded. As a matter of fact, the obstruction was so bad that two lives were lost as a result of the flooding there some time ago. Therefore, it is very important, from every point of view, that something should be done by some public body or other to remedy this matter. So many people were involved and suffered losses, their hay and crops being ruined by flooding, in the year before last, that I was asked to communicate with the Board of Works to see whether or not something could be done to relieve this matter of flooding. I did communicate with the Board of Works, and I got a reply to the effect that they had sent an inspector there in 1933, but that the mill-owner concerned objected to the drainage being carried out. When the farmers concerned in the matter heard that, they called a meeting in order to see what action could be taken, and there was a proposal to buy out the rights of the mill-owner concerned. The mill itself had been lying idle, as it happened, for nine or ten years, and the mill-owner did consent to sell out her rights, but the price was prohibitive. The farmers then decided to sue her for the loss sustained by them as a result of the flooding. The matter came before the courts in November last, and Judge Sheehy drew attention to the expense that had already been incurred and to the further expense that would certainly be incurred in continuing the action. He advised both parties to go home and consider the matter between themselves, and suggested that the engineer representing the farmers—Mr. McCarthy, here in Dublin—should propose a scheme that would lower the lake in question sufficiently to relieve the flooding and that would also still leave sufficient water for the mill. Mr. McCarthy has submitted his scheme to the mill-owner and her engineer, and both the mill-owner and her engineer have agreed to the scheme. In other words, both parties to the dispute are agreed on the solution, but the difficulty is the question of who is to do the work. If the Board of Works take over this scheme, then the difficulty will be removed and the case will be settled up and there will be no more law about it; but if the Board of Works, or some other public body, do not take up this matter, then the law will have to go on. The case will come up in June— the next quarter session—so I hope that the Parliamentary Secretary will consider this question with the least possible delay.
In conclusion, I want to say that every time I have ever called to the Board of Works I have received nothing but courtesy. Indeed, it is literally true to say that I got nothing else but courtesy from them, but in any case I always did receive courtesy from the officials of the Department, and I hope that I shall get something more than courtesy in the future.
Comment on this
It was not my intention to take part in this debate, but my colleague, Deputy McGovern, from the County Cavan, has again made a charge of incompetence—I may say of unfair treatment to the political opponents of the Government—against, not members of this Party, but against the county surveyor of Cavan and his assistants. Now, that charge was made here last year by Deputy McGovern, and I think, when this House and the people generally understand the circumstances that exist in the case of the Cavan County Council, they will appreciate how much foundation there can be for the allegation made last year by the Deputy, and repeated here this evening.
Comment on this
The Cavan County Council is presided over by a member of the Party to which Deputy McGovern belongs. I also am a member of that council. Deputy McGovern's Party have not a majority on the council, but by a combination of Unionist and Fine Gael members they have succeeded in controlling the council since the coming into office of this Government, and, indeed, prior to that. How does it come, then, if there is the victimisation to which Deputy McGovern has referred on two occasions in this House—if there is any foundation or substance in the allegation that he has made—that not on one occasion has any allegation whatever been made against the council's officials by any member of the Deputy's Party in the local council chamber?
Deputy McGovern has complained that the Board of Works have failed to carry out some schemes that were recommended by him. To what extent that is true or false, is a thing that I am not able to say, but if those of us who do not know the nature of the schemes submitted to him are to judge them by the type of speech or suggestion to which we have just listened from the Deputy, then I think we can easily understand why no responsible Department, having examined any scheme or proposal put forward by a Deputy having a mind such as his, would approve of any such scheme or proposal. He has made the charge on two occasions that members of this organisation have been employed by the Cavan County Council, and by the engineering staff of that council, and put in charge of work. I ask Deputy McGovern, or any other member of the House, or people outside of it, is there any reason in the world why a man, because he has Fianna Fáil tendencies or Fianna Fáil sympathies, or because he works for and votes for this Party, should not be competent for, or given responsibility for, ganging men, just the same as a man from the ranks of some other Party who possesses the same degree of competence.
Comment on this
I do not think that such men would produce anything as hooked or as warped as the Deputy.
Comment on this
In connection with this rotational system of employment we have heard criticisms from the members of the Labour Party on more than one occasion. The mover of the motion to refer back the Vote, and some members of the Labour Party who followed him, took exception to this rotational system. I said here on the last occasion that the members of this Party would be delighted if the Labour Party would indicate to us to what extent it was feasible, or possible, to give continuous and constant employment to all those who are in receipt of unemployment assistance on this rotational system.
Comment on this
We have asked repeatedly for some such indication from the members of the Labour Party: as to how we were to give that constant employment that we all want to see those people getting.
Comment on this
——not my point. I say that the members on this side, when they hear from Labour members a proposition or suggestion as to how, instead of this system of rotational employment, we can offer to those people constant employment, it will then have to be shown whether that proposition is feasible or not.
Comment on this
No suggestion, good, bad or indifferent, has come from either the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party as to how that is to be done. I think it has been indicated on more than one occasion from these benches that the sum of money that would be required to give effect to such a proposal, and to give these men constant employment, would be very great: that while it might be possible to do that for one year and while you might get suitable work to absorb the amount of money available for one, two or three years, that it would be impossible to keep that up.
Comment on this
The members of the Labour Party should be able to say, in so far as money is made available for dealing with this problem, whether they want more money given to a smaller number of people or whether they want the system as it stands at present to continue. I think that the people of the country will accept it that we are just as anxious as the members of the Labour Party not only to provide those people with work on three, four or five days a week, but with a full week's work if that were feasible or possible. Surely, it is not any harm for those of us who have been listening to the critics of this scheme to ask them to suggest ways by which that can be done.
Comment on this
As I said at the outset, I had no intention of intervening in the debate. I have covered the few points that I wanted to deal with, and that is all I have to say.
Comment on this
I am sure that the members on this side of the House, and those who want to face the facts properly, will be very grateful to Deputy Smith for the very blunt and straightforward speech that he has just delivered, and for his admission, in the concluding portion of his speech, that the plan which was published previous to the 1932 election has either been lost or forgotten. The details of that published plan have been read so often in this House by other members from these benches that I do not propose to trouble Deputy Smith by again reading it for him and reminding him of what it contains.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has forgotten all about that plan I would advise him to go into the offices of the Fianna Fáil Party in Mount Street, or into the offices of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to read it.
Comment on this
I have always given credit to Deputy Smith for being a democratically-minded member of the Fianna Fáil Party. The Deputy claims to be a member of a Christian Government, to be one of the chief whips of a Party that calls itself a Christian Government. I remember the Taoiseach on one occasion saying that, if he could not solve the problem of unemployment within the existing system, he would go outside the system in order to do so.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith comes along now and says that the sum of money that would be required to be raised for the purpose of giving continuous work to the workless would place an impossible burden on the State. I always understood that it was the duty of a Christian Government to pledge the whole resources of the State to provide work and a decent livelihood for all its citizens—to provide food, clothing and shelter for every citizen of this State. Now, we have this admission from Deputy Smith— the Deputy must have been talking to some bank managers—that it would be an impossible burden to bear if they were to face the problem of finding all the money that would be necessary in order to provide continuous work for the workless. The Deputy's statement is not going to be lost sight of in the immediate future. I daresay that Deputy Smith, being one of the principal spokesmen for the Fianna Fáil Party in this House, was saying bluntly what he believes to be the present attitude and policy of the Government of which he is such a strong supporter.
I am supporting the motion for the reference back of this Estimate in order to give the Parliamentary Secretary plenty of time to reconsider the question of maintaining this objectionable method of employing men on public works under the rotational relief scheme. The Parliamentary Secretary was candid enough also to say that the rotational relief scheme has come to stay. If that means anything, surely it means that unemployment has come to stay and that there is no intention of putting into operation this plan which was supposed to be lying in the pigeon holes of the Board of Works and the office of the Fianna Fáil Party, previous to the 1932 General Election.
Comment on this
Yes, and we still have over 100,000 people waiting for the work promised over six years ago.
Comment on this
We are also asking that this Vote be referred back because the Parliamentary Secretary still persists in paying relief workers at the blackleg rate of 24/- a week. The position to-day in that respect is different from what it was last year, because, as a result of an order issued by the Agricultural Wages Board, the wages of the agricultural workers of this country, I am glad to say, have been fixed, as from yesterday, at the rate of 27/- per week. I understand that if a Deputy wants to speak a second time, he will be given the opportunity, and I should be very glad to hear Deputy Meaney, if he can be induced to make one of his usual eloquent speeches, saying, as the spokesman to the farmers of the South of Ireland, as he claims to be, that the farmers of this State should be compelled——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am not the paid Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, and I suggest that it is not fair for Deputy Davin to ask questions of me which should be addressed to the Parliamentary Secretary, although I do not mind answering him, if I am allowed to do so.
Comment on this
The reason I am inviting Deputy Meaney to give us the benefit of his advice is that, when speaking here, he emphasised that he was speaking on behalf of the farmers of Cork and the South of Ireland generally. I invite him to say whether he is in favour of compelling the farmers of the South of Ireland to pay their agricultural labourers at the rate of 27/- per week and whether, at the same time, he thinks it right that the Government, which is supposed to be the best employer in the State, should continue to pay workers on relief schemes at the blackleg rate of 24/- a week. That is a fair question which I hope the Deputy, or somebody else who speaks with some authority, will answer before the debate concludes.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary gets more abuse inside and outside this House than he is really liable for in respect of matters of this kind. He is merely the useful and willing tool of the Cabinet responsible for this low wage policy.
Comment on this
It is the Government and not so much the Parliamentary Secretary who should be criticised and censured for this portion of their policy. The Parliamentary Secretary gloats in taking on a job of this kind and that is why he is looking a good deal better this year in defending his Estimate than when he was defending it last year. It is true that his salary was increased since the Estimate was last before the House and for the same reason, as well as for other reasons, the workers employed by his Department should also get an increase in their low rate of pay. It is also true that a commission was set up to inquire into the question of salary and expenses of Parliamentary Secretaries and others. That commission gave a very hurried decision and, as I suggested here before, if the Parliamentary Secretary and members of the Cabinet, who apparently stood behind him in this matter, want to get this sympathetically and hurriedly considered, I advise them to refer the issue to the same body.
I am glad to know that since this debate commenced, the workers at the Rhynana airport who were agitating for an increase in their pay have been given an increase. I dare say the Parliamentary Secretary will say that that increase is due to the generosity of himself and of members of the Cabinet. I would challenge any such assertion. If he and members of the Party standing behind him had a generous and Christian outlook on such matters, why did they not fix a rate of 35/- per week when the work was commenced, rather than strike a rate of 27/- and then raise it to 32/-? Now, as a result of the agitation and a strike, which I am glad to see had the support apparently of the priests and people of County Clare, the rate has been fixed at 35/-. The workers employed on the Rhynana airport scheme are as intelligent in matters of this kind as the Parliamentary Secretary, and they know perfectly well that were it not for the fact that they came together in an organisation, and stood together, they would have had no hope of getting the wage of 35/- a week which they are getting to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Meaney would be well advised to have a private talk with the Parliamentary Secretary and to read the file in connection with the wages dispute on the Rhynana scheme. I am afraid he will be letting the Parliamentary Secretary down if he interrupts too often on this matter. I desire to congratulate the workers of Rhynana for the way in which they conducted their agitation and for the loyalty and solidarity which forced— and I use the word deliberately—the Parliamentary Secretary and the Cabinet to raise their wages to a rate of 35/- per week. It is true, as I think Deputy Larkin and other Deputies know, that the workers in Rhynana had no powerful trade union, but they had—and I am very glad to recognise it—the sympathy and support of the people of County Clare, and that is what drove the Parliamentary Secretary into the position he is in to-day. I hope that other workers employed on public work schemes provided by taxpayers' money will learn a lesson from what has happened in Rhynana, if the Parliamentary Secretary does not see his way to meet the reasonable demand put forward by the mover of this motion.
Deputy Smith invited members of this Party to put forward suggestions which would enable the State, if it had the necessary money or the courage to raise it, to provide continuous work for some of the workless citizens of the country. I think if Deputy Smith makes inquiries he will find that suggestions of that kind have been put forward from these benches both on behalf of the Party and by individual members of the Party, in connection with works of a national character as well as works which would provide useful employment at decent rates of wages in the different constituencies represented by the Labour Deputies. The files of the Board of Works, as I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary will not deny, do contain many suggestions and recommendations put forward by members on these benches. I am not going to make any allegation that because they were submitted by Labour Deputies they have not got proper consideration, because I know that the reason why many of those recommendations have not received consideration is the limited amount of money which the Cabinet have set aside for carrying out relief works of this kind.
I do complain, however, about the attitude of the Parliamentary Secretary and the Board of Works in not allocating, at the one time, the necessary amount of money for the purpose of completing whatever schemes are undertaken. During previous discussions on this Estimate I have already drawn attention to the fact that those schemes are being carried out in a patchwork way. My attention was recently drawn to a case close to the village of Kilcormack—I do not want to go into local schemes, but this is a glaring case—where three small grants have already been allocated for the repair of one bog road used by a very large number of families in the district. Those three grants have been provided in three different years and it will require a further small grant to enable that work to be completed. Why in the name of goodness does not the Parliamentary Secretary, if he is, as he claims to be, a good businessman, set aside a sum of money which will enable the work to be started and completed in a satisfactory way, instead of carrying it out in the patchwork manner in which that scheme and others of the same kind have been carried out during the past three or four years? At any rate, I invite him as a good businessman to set aside all the money required for the carrying out of whatever work is undertaken, so that that work can be completed, giving employment to men who are waiting for work on schemes of that kind. I should like to draw attention to the fact that there is a large number of unemployed in that area at the present time, while that work is awaiting completion until the Parliamentary Secretary allocates the small sum required. I could quote many other cases, but I have furnished full particulars of cases of this kind to the Parliamentary Secretary.
I should like to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary whether he has any access to the suggestions coming from other Departments of Government; whether, for instance, he has any knowledge of a bog reclamation scheme of a national character which was submitted and which was, I believe, considered some time ago. If he has, will he tell us whether the scheme has been approved of, and if so what is the cause of the delay on the part of the Departments concerned to proceed with work of that national character which would provide valuable and continuous employment in almost every county in the State until that scheme is completed? I should like to hear from him whether he is prepared to give the House his views on the scheme, if he he has any knowledge of the particular one to which I am referring. For his information, I should like to remind him that the Minister for Lands is apparently fully acquainted with the details of that scheme, because he referred to it when discussing his Estimate here in the House. I am aware, and have been aware for some considerable time past, that that scheme has been shelved in some of the Government Departments. By carrying out a scheme of that kind you could avoid the necessity for migrating people to the midland counties, and causing—as a scheme of migration has caused—considerable annoyance to the local people in many places. I understand it is possible under that scheme to make a very large tract of land arable. I should like to hear what the Parliamentary Secretary has to say about the scheme. If it has been approved of, I should like to hear whether it has been held up as a result of the failure of the Government to provide the necessary money to carry it out.
I should also like to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary whether any proposals have been put up by anybody at any time for the construction of coastal roads, which would enable tourists and our own citizens who desire to see the beauty spots of this country, to see them to better advantage than is possible at the present time. I believe a good deal of continuous work could be provided on a scheme of that kind. If the Government have any desire to improve the natural coastal scenery which we undoubtedly have in this country, they could do so by setting aside some money which would provide a good deal of continuous work in the construction of coastal roads, which in my opinion could be constructed in counties like Clare, Kerry, Galway, and so on. I also heard a suggestion put forward some time ago at a meeting of members of this Party that if the Government could see their way to provide money from some source, it could be usefully spent on widening and straightening our main and trunk roads. Work would be provided in every county in the State on a scheme of that kind. I have travelled on some of what are known as the trunk roads in England and some Continental countries, and one cannot fail to admire the way in which those roads are constructed and maintained. Many of our main and trunk roads could be considerably improved by being widened by a yard, or two yards if possible. I should like to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary, for the information of Deputy Smith particularly, whether any such scheme is in the files of the Board of Works, whether a scheme of that kind has been given any consideration, or whether, if he had the money at his disposal, he would sympathetically consider carrying out a scheme of that kind.
The Parliamentary Secretary, in introducing this Estimate, stated that the maximum number of men employed at a particular period on those minor relief works was 36,924. That reference can be found in Volume 7, column 999 of the Official Debates. I should like to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary for how long on an average were the 36,924 men employed, and how much in the shape of wages did they receive from the great, almighty, and generous Parliamentary Secretary through the operation of those minor relief schemes. I am sure the figures would be very interesting, and I am sure the very efficient officials whom the Parliamentary Secretary has at his disposal will enable him to provide those figures for the information of Deputies, and for the information of the workless throughout the country as well as the taxpayers as a whole. It is only by having figures of that kind at our disposal that we can really judge the effect of the operation of those minor relief schemes. I should also like to ascertain from the Parliamentary Secretary—I hope he will not overlook the matter when replying— whether it is the intention of his Department to honour the court decision given recently in the High Court by Judge Johnston. For many years past Deputies of this House, including Fianna Fáil Deputies when in opposition and possibly since the Government came into office, have been criticising the Board of Works and other Government Departments for their failure to stamp the unemployment insurance cards of men employed on major and minor relief schemes and arterial drainage schemes. A number of cases were brought to the High Court, and a decision was given quite recently by Judge Johnston indicating clearly that in his opinion——
Comment on this
That question was asked and answered on Friday. The Deputy will find it in the records.
Comment on this
Is it the intention of the Parliamentary Secretary—I do not think he answered this part of it—to apply that decision retrospectively?
Comment on this
There is one other matter to which I should like to refer, and that is a question which was addressed to the Parliamentary Secretary by Deputy McGowan on 13th January last, as to whether it was the intention of the Board of Works to make any improvements for the purpose of enabling the Great Southern Railways to deal with the passenger traffic at Dun Laoghaire pier in a more efficient way. I was listening the other day to some Deputies speaking in the House, and apparently they are under the impression that I am an official of the Great Southern Railways. I want to disabuse their minds of that, because that is not so, and therefore I have not any personal interest in this matter. But I am interested, and for many years, long before I became a Deputy, had been interested in the development of the tourist traffic. I have, of course, some access to information, and have some experience in connection with the working of the tourist traffic, as the Parliamentary Secretary knows. The Parliamentary Secretary, in reply, said:
"The pier is large enough to accommodate the normal number utilising this service."
I should like to inform him that the pier is not large enough, and was never large enough, to accommodate at one time the number of mail trains required to handle the traffic even in the winter period. I should, therefore, like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to go back to his advisers and get them to look into the matter from that point of view. If there is a desire, as I believe there is, on the part of the Ministry, and particularly on the part of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to provide reasonable facilities for the development of the tourist traffic, something will have to be done, in my opinion, to provide better facilities for the conveyance of the passengers landed at Dun Laoghaire who have to be carried to Dublin and all parts of the country in the winter as well as in the summer period.
Comment on this
I should like to inform the Deputy that something like 600,000 people were handled last year there and it is a miracle that they were able to be dealt with, particularly at one busy period. As I say, I speak with some knowledge, and I also know that the Parliamentary Secretary has been personally investigating this matter. I was looking at his pleasant face there one evening when he was touring the surroundings and I am sure that he has some knowledge of the requirements there. I want to say quite sincerely and seriously to him that the statement that the pier is large enough to accommodate the normal number utilising that service is not correct.
Comment on this
I can tell the Parliamentary Secretary, and it can be confirmed by any working railway man who has knowledge of the place, that not alone is it impossible to put the three trains required in the winter period on the pier at present, but it is not possible to put two of the three full main trains on the pier for the purpose of dealing with the traffic. The fact is that the pier is out of date. I should also like to disabuse the minds of some people that that pier is the property of the railway company. The pier is the property of the Board of Works and it is the responsibility of that board to make such improvements as are necessary for the efficient working of the traffic to be dealt with both in the summer and in the winter. I do not speak as an expert, because I believe that it requires technical experts to deal with a matter of this kind. If the Parliamentary Secretary called into conference technical experts who have a knowledge of the requirements of the place, from the point of view of the railway and shipping companies, the Board of Works, and the Dun Laoghaire Borough Corporation, he could get some very valuable information which would help him to move in the right direction. I raise this matter because I understand that the Board of Works refused to attend a conference some time ago which was convened by the Dun Laoghaire Corporation for the purpose of dealing with this matter. However, I should like him to look into the matter again. This reply also contained the statement that no suggestions were put forward by the railway or shipping companies or the Dun Laoghaire Corporation. I do not think it is the duty of the Dun Laoghaire Corporation or of the railway or shipping companies to put forward suggestions.
Comment on this
I think it is the duty of the Board of Works that owns the pier and gets a very high revenue from it to take that responsibility on its shoulders and if necessary call into consultation the people who are in a position to give some valuable information, although their suggestions might not be coming from an infallible source. It is a big problem and one which the Parliamentary Secretary is, I am sure, prepared to face up to. If so, instead of refusing to attend a conference convened by an interested local authority, I suggest to him that he should use his good offices for the purpose of calling the technical experts of the parties concerned into consultation with himself.
Comment on this
The Estimates are considered in Committee. Nevertheless, it is unusual, if not unprecedented, for a Deputy to intervene twice in the discussion of an Estimate. When the House rose on Friday last, Deputy Larkin moved to report progress and intimated his desire to continue his remarks to-day. The discussion was resumed to-day at the abnormally early hour of ten minutes past three. Deputy Larkin was not in his place then. In the circumstances the Chair is prepared to call on Deputy Larkin later. Deputy Bartley.
Comment on this
There are one or two points to which I should like to call the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary in connection with marine proposals. I am interested in a number of proposals in connection with the Galway coast, particularly some of those on the islands. I know that the proposals must be carried out by some Department other than the Board of Works—at least that certain aspects must be referred to another Department. But, so far as that work has been done by the Department of Fisheries, I am not satisfied with the results obtained in certain cases. As an example, I should like to refer to the case of a place known as Dog's Harbour. The job there is really a small one, costing £15 or £20, but the case made for it was that it was necessary for the lobster fishermen in order to enable them to get back on returning from fishing expeditions and that if it were not attended to the consequences might be very serious. As a matter of fact, three or four years ago two lobster fishermen were drowned in the vicinity. I cannot understand why the Department of Fisheries could not give the necessary approval that the Board of Works asked for in a case of that kind. There are other considerations in dealing with these marine proposals that do not come within the province of the Department of Fisheries at all. Very often these places are used for fishery purposes, but they are also used for getting in seaweed and turf. Very often that is what they are principally used for and I do not think the Department of Fisheries are competent to deal with any proposal from either of these two points of view.
While on the marine proposals, I should also like to draw attention to the necessity for the carrying out of works on the two small Aran Islands and also on Innisboffin. The county council are responsible for the road adjoining the sea wall in the latter place, but the sea wall has been eaten away and the erosion continues. Some houses have been already evacuated, and more will have to be evacuated, including the post office. I do not think responsibility in the matter is entirely that of the Board of Works, but I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will bring whatever pressure he can to bear on the other Departments who have an interest in the matter.
In the case of the two other islands mentioned, the extension of the existing pier and the construction of a quay or a slip for the landing of turf are works that are urgently required. The purpose which the pier would serve, that is, the landing of turf, could be achieved by the extension of the existing protection wall, or what is known locally as a "slash" wall. That is a very necessary work. The Parliamentary Secretary may have seen, or could have seen, these men bringing turf ashore. The turf has to be loaded out of the hookers into currachs and then brought into the slips, and the people have to work feverishly to get the turf away before the tide comes in. I would direct his special attention to these three places, Innisbofin, Innisheer and Innishmaan.
Another point in reference to employment schemes in general is that the work sometimes is started too late. I do not know that it is a widespread complaint, but it has happened in a number of cases to my own knowledge. What I mean by late is that no works have been commenced in certain areas before Christmas. I would suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that in all those districts where works have been listed a start should be made before Christmas, so that some income would be provided for the homes of people who are registered as unemployed before the Christmas season sets in. As regards the rotational aspect of these schemes, about which there has been a good deal of talk, I think I can say, speaking for the majority of the people who find employment on these works in Connemara, that the scheme suits the requirements of the majority of the people who benefit by them, that is, people who have some land which does not occupy their full time. I had the extraordinary request made to me in the case of one scheme in my area that, owing to the lateness of the season, the work should be suspended. I was asked to try to get the work suspended for a fortnight or three weeks so that potatoes might be planted. I did not convey that request to the Parliamentary Secretary, because I thought that once you get works going it is not a proper or a desirable thing to have them suspended, and if you do succeed in having them suspended, the Parliamentary Secretary will probably take you at your word the following year and will not start works at all.
I would say that the rotational system does serve the man who has some land to attend to, and in the rural areas practically 90 per cent. of those who benefit by the schemes either own land themselves or are immediately interested in land and have work to do on it. I do not think that, from the point of view of serving the people who have some work to do on their own land, a better system than the rotational system could be devised. I have nothing more to say on this Vote except that my experience has been that the Board of Works has done its work perfectly in every area of which I have experience, and that it is, in my opinion, a marvel of efficiency. There may be grievances on other scores, but I think, at all events, the system whereby money is allocated to the various electoral divisions has raised the whole administration of the scheme above any reasonable complaint. It does not make a bit of difference whether or not a Deputy recommends any area specially. Under the system as it has been worked out, each area gets its due share on the basis of the amount of unemployment prevailing in the area.
Comment on this
I want to thank the House and the Chair for permitting me to continue the discussion on the shortcomings of the Parliamentary Secretary. I do not believe that if the motion to refer this Vote back goes to a vote, it will be carried. I think the object of moving it was to provide us with an opportunity of commenting on the activities of the Parliamentary Secretary and his office, his lack of capacity and his lack of vision. It is for that purpose that I avail of it. To continue my, I hope, helpful criticism of this episode in Collinstown, I want to assure the Parliamentary Secretary again that those who are interested in this new form of transport are particularly anxious that no hitch should occur either in the opening up of the work or in the continuity of it. But you cannot, in existing circumstances, get established the relations that should exist between Government Departments and those who speak in a representative capacity for the workers employed in carrying out this work. You cannot get it because of the mentality of the Department, which is peculiarly affecting Deputies in this House, particularly the Deputy who last spoke and who said that, of course, this rotational system was almost perfect. When I referred on Friday to this lack of perfection on the part of the Parliamentary Secretary, he laughingly agreed to it. The system of employing labour in the Board of Works is unsatisfactory, uneconomic and, if I might adopt the phrase of my friend in the front bench, Deputy Davin, unChristian. At least we ought to give to the humblest amongst us, the same treatment that we would expect to be given to ourselves and if the men in office abuse their privileges and powers then I think they fail to come up to the standard set up by the eminent Deputy, Deputy Davin.
In Collinstown we have a peculiar set of circumstances. Reflections on the political honesty of certain Parties have been cast backwards and forward during this discussion. Malversation of funds has not been referred to but actually there must have been malversation of funds if moneys were given in the country because of political opinions and political affiliations. That charge has been made and it should be substantiated or withdrawn. That is a crude form of criticism, but when it is made and stated, it should be probed to the bottom and, if there is one iota of proof for it, then the person responsible should be removed from public life. In North County Dublin I definitely make the charge of political interference in the employment of these men. I stated here, in correcting the speaker who was discussing it in the first place, Deputy McGowan, that the men had been employed three weeks before Christmas, 1936. I want to repeat that. The wages paid to them were 30/- per week for work which the Parliamentary Secretary and his officers had agreed to pay the recognised rate of wages—recognised and adjusted as between the employers in that particular area and the representatives of the workers.
What was the rate of wages agreed to? There can be no argument about it. The rate was agreed to and was reaffirmed. Since Christmas, 1936, there has been a prolonged struggle for a readjustment of the relations between employers and workers in the City and County of Dublin. The rate was 30/-, but after representations being made to the Board of Works, and after two meetings with the commissioners—the chairman of which is a personal friend of mine—at which everything was gone into, sympathetically on our side, because those representing the workers, skilled and unskilled, were enthusiastic about this work, the matter was discussed and settled. I want it to go on the records of the House that the Corporation of Dublin agreed to associate itself with the work, and to charge itself with an expenditure of £150,000—not £250,000 —towards completing the scheme. Why did the commissioners, the three groups and the Corporation of Dublin accept the statement of myself and those who represented the organised workers in the corporation? Men like Deputy Kelly, who has given the service of a lifetime to Dublin, his fellow loyal political fanatic, Deputy Doyle, the Whip of the Fine Gael Party, and the Lord Mayor of Dublin, who is not here with his chain, agreed unanimously to co-operate in every way in demanding a measure of justice, because of the breaking of a gentleman's agreement. The 30/- was made £2 2s.
The Board of Works told me on two occasions that they were paying the rate of wages agreed to and recognised in County Dublin by the county council. I told the Secretary of the Department that he was wrong. I say now that he is wrong, that the board have never paid that rate, but have simply taken advantage of conditions for which their Party was responsible. I take it that they believed they were morally right then, and that they were prepared to face the issue of exacting these terms from persons outside this territory. Whatever the aftermath, we have all to share it. The whole burden was not cast on the farmers, who were not hungry, but on the hungry men on the roads of County Dublin. They were to get £2 2s 0d. if they worked the whole week, but labourers in Dublin County Council employment get £2 7s. 0d. a week, a fortnight's holidays, and they get regular work, and boots and clothing in some cases. These other men have to come ten or 20 miles, and have to walk if they do not get a "lift," and, without any break to make tea, or place to boil it, and then walk home again. If that is the treatment you are going to give ordinary people, it is about time you woke up. I hold in my hand the minutes of an agreement that was entered into after a dispute. It was made with the Parliamentary Secretary and with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who gave it his unwearying attention night and day over a period of five months. I want to give him that credit. In that document the Board of Works agreed to accept the agreement as the governing issue in the relations of the workers with his Department. What do we find? Since 1896 there has been a gentleman's agreement—it is not in writing—under which, whatever wages were arrived at, or whatever adjustments were made in wages between employers and workers in the City of Dublin, the Board of Works would also recognise. That was reaffirmed in the 1907 dispute. In 1913 it was again reaffirmed, by which Board of Works employees were not to be called out, and that, whatever wages were arrived at, at the end of a dispute the board would pay, and pay retrospectively. In 1937, we were waited on and met the commissioners to provide them with information concerning employment in the Civil Service, about which there were complaints at that period. A contract was drawn up, and we were asked if we could get any more men. We told them that we could not until the question of wages was adjusted. Discussions took place, and the strike was brought to an end. Rates of wages were set down for these areas.
In our judgment, we did something that had never been done before. We made three zones for the city and county. Dublin and Dun Laoghaire was one, and there was also zone B and zone C. Collinstown being in B area, the rate of wages is 1/5 an hour. In Dun Laoghaire they pay skilled men 1/5 without any hesitation. Public bodies agreed to that rate in the city, including Grangegorman Mental Home, the corporation, the gas company, and the Electricity Supply Board. All others pay according to the terms made in the agreement. But the Board of Works is above and beyond all such equity. They pay the rate to the City of Dublin labourers, but in Dun Laoghaire the labourers appear to be considered a different type of manhood. In Swords and Collinstown the labourers are still considered as being on the agricultural rate. I submitted months ago that any fair employer or any architectural or constructional engineer would agree that the work there is engineering constructional work. The Government Department charged with the carrying out of it would not agree. The Parliamentary Secretary's Department says that it is only agricultural work. Fancy getting ready such a site for great buildings to meet the needs of a big form of transportation and to have the type of mind that calls that ordinary agricultural work. A man who is a good agriculturist should be able to do anything. A good farmer ought to be the best educated man in the community, not only ought he know everything about life, he ought to have vision and he ought to be able to lift his mind out of the drains and look up to the light. But he is far from that. We are not perfect in the city. Let us take the city man. I do submit to you that no man would dare go and intrude upon that site at Collinstown and dare to suggest that he had the knowledge to lay down the levels or get that site ready for the construction of the building it was necessary to put upon the site. I made a point and, I think, the Parliamentary Secretary is going to give me this information, or I am going to get it—who is responsible for putting up the building that was put up—a steel erection—and then taken down almost immediately and put on another site? Why did they have to bring foreign experts over when we have got engineers, graduates of our own universities? Why is the work not done in a right and workmanlike manner?
Deputy McGowan made a threat that this particular job is going to meet with difficulty. The job is black to all skilled workers in this country, national unions or international unions. To all organised workers this job is black, and no decent union man can go and work on it. That blackness will not be wiped out until there is an adjustment. The gentlemen who are working there at the present time have been drawn from all parts. Some are small farmers who are generally the backbone of this country, and I hope they will always remain the backbone of this country. They have been induced by some influence, whether political or otherwise I do not know, to go in there. They are working there under those conditions, taking two guineas a week for a job that ought to be paid £2 7s. Our wages in that area are not £2 7s., and no man who has got any character in the City of Dublin or county will work for those wages. For the county man the rate ought to be at least 54/-. As long as I have any breath, the Corporation of Dublin are not going to put any money into it and are not going to take any share in it. But to-morrow the Corporation, unanimously, I think, will agree, if the job is only made a decent and a clean job, to take their proportion and take a pride in that particular aerodrome. Of course, people will ask how are these things going to be adjusted. They have been adjusted with private employers even after a long struggle. But with the Board of Works there is no approach. They will not listen to any representation. You will get courteous treatment. You will get an official to take you upstairs; you see the secretary and the commissioners. Deputy McGovern over there said they always get courtesy. We also get courtesy, but we were able to compel them to recognise our claim in regard to skilled workers. Under his own name, the Parliamentary Secretary has agreed to try and divide the sheep from the goats, that he is going to recognise the skilled workers at Collinstown Aerodrome site, but the labourers are still going to be the step-children of this nation. But the labourers are going to see that they are not going to be the step-children of this nation any longer. When we were discussing these things a rather peculiar thing arose. The Parliamentary Secretary's secretary, one of the ablest men I have met in the Civil Service, suggested that we were wrong, for this reason, that our own organisation had accepted a lower rate of wages in the county than even offered by the Board of Works. It is true. I do not know whether I influenced the Parliamentary Secretary, but he went on the stool of repentance between Friday night and Sunday morning and, to everybody's surprise, this most ridiculed organ of publicity, a good deal of which is deserved, our national radio—Radio Eireann— blazoned all over this country, Great Britain and all the Dominions across the seas that the Parliamentary Secretary had gone on the stool of repentance and had given those working on the Rhynana Aerodrome an increase of 3/- a week. That was to his credit. I hope that he is still in the repentant mood and that he is going to treat these people in a more generous manner. But I do not see how you can get fairness in the laws that govern relations of men in this country when you have an official of the Labour Party who objects to these cruel wages being paid to these unfortunate men, creatures of circumstance, and rightly brings the attention of the public to this unrighteous act of the Parliamentary Secretary. There is an ordinary phrase: "Physician, heal thyself." The man who was discussing the matter in debate himself as an employer was paying less in the North County, but the Leader of the Labour Party and his union belongs to an organisation that officially accepted 9d. an hour.
Comment on this
We cannot discuss the attitude of any particular organisation in reference to any wages matter. Deputies may only discuss what the Parliamentary Secretary is responsible for. The Parliamentary Secretary is not responsible for that.
Comment on this
I submit to your ruling, Sir. I was pointing out that a conversation took place in the Office of the Parliamentary Secretary in which one of the reasons why we should accept these wages as offered and paid by the Parliamentary Secretary's Office staff was because our own individuals accepted a lower wage in the county area even closer to Dublin, as some people think, than what is paid by the Parliamentary Secretary and his officials. What is our position? How can we logically and equitably get up and condemn a public board when such a condition of things exists? Is that true or not? The wages for 45 hours in Poolaphouca were 33/- a week. The Parliamentary Secretary has been called to account because they are paying 24/- a week to farm labourers. That comes under his Department. Who fixed the 24/- a week? So-called representatives who were asked to go and sit upon a wages board, certain alleged farm labourers. There never was a public meeting called and yet they decided the wages for a farm labourer was 24/-.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt Deputy Larkin too much but the Parliamentary Secretary is not responsible for agricultural rates of wages.
Comment on this
He was paying that rate. He never took occasion to correct Deputy Davin when he was quoted as paying that rate in connection with minor improvement schemes carried out under the direction of the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
But it was quoted here that this was the rate of wages paid by the Parliamentary Secretary on minor improvement schemes—24/- a week. However, the Parliamentary Secretary has corrected that mistake to some extent and there has been a measure of improvement in wages for the labourers in County Clare. Why not carry that a stage further, as I suggested? Some years ago I was called in to help in the adjustment of differences between employers and workers. Why cannot we get a small committee of the members of this House to sit along with the Parliamentary Secretary and representatives of the workers to go into this immediate question, and get this position clarified, and get an adjustment in regard to the workers at Collinstown Aerodrome in which all of us are so deeply interested; make it a success and carry it into fruition? It is not a very happy thing for the people who are charged with a knowledge of the needs of workers to stand in the way of progress. It is not. We do not want this trouble. We want to get it removed. A question was put at an intellectual contest, and again I have got to refer to that organ of publicity, Radio Eireann. The question was "How far a rabbit can get into a wood?" There was no one who could answer that question. The answer was "He can only get half way in," as he would then be running out. The Parliamentary Secretary is half way in a hole. I think he ought to pull himself though and get this thing adjusted. I am not going to labour this matter of Collinstown further. It is for us who represent the minds of the people of this country, if we do represent them, at least we kept them together as an army——
Comment on this
I have not made any innuendoes. I have spoken about facts. As to my purpose in America, I have had occasion in this House to prove that it was official and in connection with labour. I have not lived in the ghostly mantle of a man who is now dead in the flesh.
Comment on this
As long as you and ex-Senator Foran were there to take my place everything was safe in this country. I left my gun in good hands. I was dealing with a portion, Sir, of my criticism in reference to Collinstown. I want to go on to other matters which, I feel, concern the Parliamentary Secretary deeply. During the course of the dispute in Dublin we came to the conclusion that we should ask the Parliamentary Secretary would he not see his way to engage men directly in the Department. The House is aware that for years there has been a system of contract. The majority of the work carried on in the Department is not carried on by the advisers of the Department, skilled or semi-skilled. What happens is that the work is marked out, estimated and given to contract. The contractor gets paid for the wages he expends, plus 10 per cent. for paying the wages and for keeping time. Why that is necessary I do not know. I do not know any businessman who would carry out his work in that way. The contractor is getting 10 per cent. for paying the wages.
Comment on this
I agree but the insurance would be no more than one per cent. or one and a half per cent. and in some cases it is only one half per cent. As against that he gets ten per cent. Not only that but the same contractors seem to be there generation after generation. Now in every contract we have some competition, perhaps not always, but the peculiar state of things is that one set of contractors have always been the contractors to the Board of Works. When the firm did pass out as a firm and became re-organised, the same firm still got the bulk of the contracts given by the Board of Works That is a very peculiar condition of things. I do not say that it is wrong. But if the work is to be done by tender, then that tender ought to be published. I know what tenders are, having been engaged for years in opening tenders. I know there is a great disparity between the highest and the lowest tender. To my mind it would be better to have the work done direct by the Board of Works and save the ten per cent.; at least six per cent. of it could be saved. A set number of men could be passed by the Employment Exchange for continuous employment.
I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to direct his attention to the case of the Widow Byrne and to ascertain the cause of the delay in her case. I know it is not due to the Parliamentary Secretary at all. This woman's husband was killed in Dun Laoghaire Harbour. It was held it was an accident. Nine months have passed. A claim for compensation was submitted at the time. If such a claim were submitted to a private employer such a long period would not intervene between the entering of the claim and its adjustment. Another thing, the son of the widow might have been given employment. As it is the widow and the family of five or six were left to the ordinary mercies of the Poor Law though the eldest boy is fit in every way to be employed by the Board of Works. Deputy Dillon made the point of a man being dismissed on a few minutes notice after having served the board for several years. That is a matter that should be inquired into. There is another matter in which I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary for an answer and that is as to the wages paid to the men employed by his Department in Dun Laoghaire.
On the question of the schools, I know the Parliamentary Secretary cannot answer for the policy of the Department of Education, but I want to know from him if it is true that a site for a new school for Crumlin has been agreed upon, and that plans, specifications and quantities have been drawn up. Why the delay in the building of the school? When it was agreed that there was to be a school there, why is the Board of Works not going on with the work? Why is it that thousands of young children have to be carried daily to and from Crumlin to the city schools at a cost of over £3,000 a year? Why are these children sometimes suffering from diseases brought into juxtaposition with the children attending city schools? When the plans have been passed, why not get on with the building of the schools quickly? Is it not possible for two Departments of State to get together and have this work carried out? In a few months from now we will have 1,000 additional families in that area. I think there should be the ordinary courtesy between two public Departments in expediting the erection of this school. Deputy Tom Kelly will tell the House that we are harassed every day by the parents of these children because of the delay in the building of this school. The children are suffering very much inconvenience. Thirty, 40 or 50 of them, after standing for a while under the rain at a corner, are packed into one bus. After waiting there in the cold air of the morning, they are packed into this heated bus. That sort of thing could be obviated, and in obviating it, employment could be provided for people who need it. This, too, would save a good deal of the self-respect of the people.
Might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to consider the point made by Deputy Dockrell? It is part of his functions. In Dublin the transport problem is becoming most difficult to handle. In Stephen's Green we have a fine parking place and Deputy Dockrell suggests that we ought to use it in a different manner from that in which it has been used. There is the problem of parking cars. Deputy Smith might suggest to the Executive Council that a considerable amount of work might be given in Stephen's Green in having it turned into a parking place. Why not take these unemployed men who, according to the Parliamentary Secretary, are now working uneconomically and put them on an economic job? Why not make a parking place there and let those who use it pay for it? I could put 10,000 men at work to-morrow in Dublin on something useful. In one sense every Government Department is non-productive and I say this, that the work should be done either by contract or by direct labour. It is the duty of the Government to control Stephen's Green Park and not allow anybody to interfere with it. I endorse the submission made by Deputy T. Kelly that you give us a right to go in there and to make an underground garage. You may have to go down there to garage your cars as I did in America. This is a matter that the Parliamentary Secretary ought to discuss with Deputy Dockrell. It is a practical proposal and would give useful employment.
I challenge any Deputy to give the differential between a man usefully employed and a man on the dole. Men were employed at Chapelizod at three days a week and they were given 30/- for the three days. They had to pay 4d. a day for a bus or a tram and sometimes 6d. I had on many occasions to go to the manager of the tramway company to get them to reduce the rate. But if they were not employed there at all they would have saved themselves getting up in the morning, saved themselves the exhaustive agonies of body and mind, working under exceptionally difficult circumstances in trenches 12 to 14 feet deep, up to their waists in water, badly clothed and wet most of the time. Yet they were only getting a few shillings more than if they were not working. It took us four months of hard preaching and propaganda to get the Board of Works to agree to extend it to four days a week.
I can produce figures for you, together with names of the people, the numbers of their families and the jobs they were on, and I will prove that it was not only uneconomic and unscientific, but it was unhuman. Many of the men broke down and they had to enter a hospital, all because of that policy. It is true that in a small farming area, where a man has a few acres, he may think it great value to have three days rotational work, but there is no analogy between a seaboard town or even a midland town dweller, and the man with an acre or two. There is no comparison between the small landholder and the man with no property who has to pay possibly 12/- a week for a room in Dublin and in that room there may be dwelling, as Deputy Kelly pointed out, five, ten or 11 persons.
I must thank Deputies for listening to me so attentively. I feel sure the Parliamentary Secretary will answer in a sympathetic way all the points that have been raised. He generally answers all questions in a sympathetic manner and we all realise that behind that facade there is a gentlemanly demeanour and a kindly respect. Some people say he has a heart of stone, but I know it has been melted for the last week. We know we have a sympathetic listener when we refer to matters that require rectification and adjustment.
I do not think that anyone would dare suggest that the entrance gate to this country is a fit and proper entrance gate. Any person who would suggest that must surely be irresponsible and cannot have a true sense of balance. There is no country in the world that has a port like Dun Laoghaire, if it were properly looked after and improved. Unfortunately, at the moment there is no blacker spot in any part of the world than the dark hole we come into when we arrive at Dun Laoghaire. It makes a very bad impression on visitors to our country. Anyone arriving on a winter's morning finds it absolutely desolate, scarcely a place open or a light to be seen. Anyone who talks about the marshalling of traffic does not know the realities of the position.
Again, we should like to know why was the appointment given to the person who now holds the position of harbour master. Was it because he was in the Royal Naval Reserve? One wonders why he was selected, while men who forfeited their jobs as captains and who lost other distinguished posts had not their applications entertained. Some of these men forfeited their liberties in other countries, risked their lives for this country, and we should like to know why they were ignored, and not given an opportunity of becoming the harbour master at Dún Laoghaire or some other of our ports.
How much has it cost this Government to build the memorial park in South County Dublin to the memory of the men who died for the Empire? Will the Parliamentary Secretary tell us if the work is completed, if the funds are exhausted, and if we have to make another supplementary grant? I should like to know when that park will be opened, and I hope the opportunity may be given to this House later on to give as much, if not double, the amount to a memorial in North County Dublin to the men who gave us an opportunity of sitting in this House.
Comment on this
I wish to call the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to the letting of lands under the jurisdiction of the Board of Works. The lands I allude to are those formerly held by the British defence forces, and they are now under the jurisdiction of the Parliamentary Secretary's Department. I suggest that in letting these lands in the future they should be let in small lots. The present system, I understand, is that tenders are taken for small lots, and a tender will also be taken for a certain number of lots, and even tenders will be received for a whole collection of lots. That is not fair competition and it does not give an opportunity to the small farmers and labourers to get little plots. I know it is open to everybody to tender, but why not do away with the system of having one tender for a whole group? Why not let it field by field, as was done in former years? I would like the Parliamentary Secretary's Department to get into touch with the Department of Defence and find out how much, if any, of these lands will not be required in the future for defence purposes. If there are any such lands they should be handed over to the Land Commission for distribution, the same as is done with ordinary estates through the country.
Deputy Davin invited me a while ago to say something with regard to agricultural wages. I believe he asked me something about 22/- a week for agricultural wages.
Comment on this
I know that, but this arose in the course of the debate. If I am out of order I submit to your ruling.
Comment on this
I am not looking for a way out. Whenever I wanted I got my way out, and I got my way in when I needed it. At any rate, a suggestion was put up by Deputy Davin as regards the rate of 24/- a week. The agricultural rate is at present fixed at 27/-. I suggest that our agriculturists should be put in as sound a position as it possible to put them, within the wers of the Government, and the Government should pay as high a rate as possible to their employees. I believe the discrepancy between what the agriculturist gets out of his industry and what those in industry get is too great. It is not Government policy that is responsible for that; it is world conditions and it is a system. I trust the Government will help to lessen that discrepancy.
I believe that in rural areas the agricultural rate should be higher. The Parliamentary Secretary was attacked during this debate as regards the rotational system. It would be an ideal thing if we were in the position to give every man permanent employment at a decent wage. I hold that, so far as the Government are concerned, they are making an honest attempt, but they are not given the co-operation from other Parties to which they are entitled. Last week certain Deputies on the Labour Benches made a vehement attack on the Parliamentary Secretary in regard to the Rhynana airport.
Comment on this
Certain allegations were hurled against the Parliamentary Secretary, which, to my mind, were entirely unjustified. He was blamed for causing suffering to these men who were employed at Rhynana, and for prolonging the agony, but we find, since then, that these men were only back a week at work when they got an increase of 3/- a week. I think that that is to the credit of the Parliamentary Secretary.