Committee on Finance. - Vote 10.—Office of Public Works (Resumed).
Contributions 157–328 of 518. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Well, I think that it shows that if the leaders or spokesmen of these people had been prepared to come down to business, and discuss the matter in a proper manner, there would not have been a strike at Rhynana.
Comment on this
I am letting nobody down, but I suggest that the Labour members did let these people down. Allegations are also being made of particular discrimination in regard to the relief schemes. I think it was Deputy McGovern who stated that, within the last 12 months, he had submitted between 30 and 60 schemes for consideration, and nothing was done. Well, I am sure that I submitted at least 130 schemes for consideration, and I know that they received due consideration, but we do not expect all these things to be performed overnight. I think, as Deputy Larkin has pointed out, allegations of that sort should be either substantiated or withdrawn. The only other thing to which I should like to refer, before sitting down, is that, in view of the improved conditions, I think the Parliamentary Secretary should review this 24/- a week basis.
Comment on this
Before the Parliamentary Secretary replies to the discussion on this Estimate, there are one or two things that I should like to say. It seems to me, judging by the attitude of the Parliamentary Secretary on this Estimate, and also by the attitude of most of the members of his Party who have spoken, that Fianna Fáil have completed a circle. The kind of criticism which they now appear to resent from other sides of the House is precisely the kind of criticism in which they, when they were on these benches here, excelled. We have been asked to indicate a plan. When we look for full employment for those who are now employed, and when we look for the payment of those who are employed on a basis in keeping with the protestations of Fianna Fáil and with the principles laid down in the new Constitution, we are told that it is our responsibility to indicate where the money is to come from. Is not that a great come-down for the Party which hawked its plan around this country in the last election and in the previous election? Is it not a great come-down for the Party that told us a few years ago that, according to their ideals, when they had the responsibility of Government in this country, and when they had the affairs of State in their hands, they would provide for the people of this country conditions of decency and comfort on what they called a Christian standard? Now they tell us that they cannot do these things because they have not got the money. I suggest that, when Deputies from these benches here ask the Parliamentary Secretary to depart from the rotational system and provide schemes which will give full employment, and when they ask the Parliamentary Secretary to observe a decent wage standard in Rhynana and on relief schemes in the country generally where his Department has jurisdiction, it is not our business to find the money.
We had a Budget introduced in this House recently by the Minister for Finance, and, if sufficient money was not provided by the Government for the Department of the Minister for Finance or the Department of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, it is not the responsibility of members of the Opposition in this House to tell the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary how he should have dealt with it. If he is the Minister of a Government, which, professedly, has set out to solve the economic problems of this country, whether inside or outside the present political system, then it is the business of that Government to solve that problem, either inside or outside the present system, or else to give up entirely the pretence of being able to solve the problem.
Now, there has been criticism with regard to this miserable wage of 24/- a week. It comes as a surprise to me to find that any Deputy of this House —and particularly Deputies of a Party that came into power on promises of better wages, better conditions, and a progressive programme generally— should attempt to defend a wage of 24/- a week. Reference has been made to this business at Rhynana, and we have been told that, out of the goodness of his heart, the Parliamentary Secretary has raised the former miserable wage of 32/- a week to 35/- a week. Let it be remembered that that small increase, such as it was, only took place after a strike of some months. Are we seriously told now that the workers would have got that increase if they had not had a strike? Of course they would not have got an increase without that strike, and everybody in the House knows it. However, it is probably not reasonable to expect any better treatment for the workers in Rhynana when that was supported by Deputies who, I understand, on the Agricultural Wages Board, believed that 22/- a week was enough for an agricultural labourer. Of course, it is a great game to bring the level of wages for agricultural labourers down to 22/- a week, and then base other wage rates upon it, but I suppose it is what one must expect from a Government that sets such a standard, not alone in respect of their own direct employees, such as the civil servants, but of those employed on these various relief schemes—a standard that is a disgrace to the country.
One thing to which I should like to refer as a further instance of the complete lack of sympathy on the part of the Parliamentary Secretary with the lowest paid sections of the workers of this country, is that during the recent building strike, as has already been pointed out, the employees of local authorities in the Dublin area remained at work on the understanding that when the building strike was settled they would receive the terms of the settlement and not only that, but receive them retrospectively as from the commencement of the strike. In fact, the Dublin Corporation paid their workers retrospectively as from the commencement of the strike on the terms agreed on at the conclusion of the strike. But the people who were employed on relief work in Dublin, the relief workers of Dublin, and, of course, the worst paid workers in the city, were not paid retrospectively notwithstanding the fact that the corporation agreed to the principle of paying them. They were not paid, because the Office of Public Works and the Department of Finance would not agree to their being paid retrospectively. That is a further instance of the sympathy of the Parliamentary Secretary for the workers, and particularly for the lowest paid section of workers.
I think it is so obvious as to be hardly worth saying, that if we are going to establish a decent social system in this country and use whatever degree or control we have over our own affairs in this country, it is the duty of the State, and particularly of a large employing Department of the State like the Office of Public Works, to lay down standards in this matter of wages. There is no use in expecting private employers to pay decent wages; there is no use in the Department of Industry and Commerce intervening in trade disputes and trying to assist in whatever way it can to improve standards if you have a Government Department actually lowering standards and maintaining standards which are a disgrace to any country, and particularly a disgrace to a country which boasts of a Constitution such as ours, a Constitution which lays down general principles that are not carried out in practice.
I do not know that it is a matter of very great interest, but I understand that one member of the Fianna Fáil Party, I think Deputy Kennedy, recently suggested in a public speech that when Ministers of State visit centres in this country that the Tricolour—the national flag—should be flown over the buildings they visit. I do not know whether there is any particular reason for it or not, but the Parliamentary Secretary's Department is responsible, I understand, for the flying of flags on buildings over which it has control. I understand that, on the occasion of the Taoiseach's recent return from the London negotiations, the flag was not flown on Dun Laoghaire pier. Just as a matter of interest, perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would tell us whether or not that was merely an oversight, or whether it had any special significance, because it is rather interesting side by side with the fact that, I believe, for the first time in history the Tricolour was flown on that occasion over the Royal St. George Yacht Club in Dun Laoghaire.
Comment on this
I want to say in conclusion on this Estimate, with all due respect to the Parliamentary Secretary, that it is not the business of the Opposition to find the money to put the unemployed at work or to put them to work at decent rates of wages. When the Fianna Fáil Party were in opposition they never recognised it as their business to provide the money, the plan notwithstanding. We hope the Parliamentary Secretary will give some indication that he is prepared to follow on the lines belatedly adopted in connection with Rhynana, and effect some improvement in the wage standards that are obtaining generally in connection with schemes carried out under the Office of Public Works. Until he does that, I do not think there is much justification for any member of this House paying tributes and compliments to him.
Comment on this
The compliments that I get at any time are not very many, and any bouquet that is thrown to me generally has a pot attached to it. A man starts off by saying that the Parliamentary Secretary is very nice, very courteous and kindly, that he is a human, soft-hearted man of amazing and unbelievable efficiency, but, and then the "but"—
Comment on this
I think it was the Parliamentary Secretary's officials who were described as being efficient and not the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
On occasion the Parliamentary Secretary has been so described. Certainly, the softness of his heart has almost been treated as a matter of poetry, but there is always a "but." The fact of the matter is that the Parliamentary Secretary has a certain job or work to do; he does it as well and as conscientiously as he can do it, and he proposes to continue to do that without any regard to compliments or the opposite.
Comment on this
I am sure the House will recognise that there is a huge variety of stuff here to be dealt with and that to co-ordinate it—to deal with it in a consecutive or comprehensive order— would be beyond the Parliamentary Secretary even when he is being most complimented. One typical statement was made by Deputy Hurley. He said that the Parliamentary Secretary has no regard whatever for the health of little children. Apparently the Parliamentary Secretary is a sort of ogre who has one of them for breakfast. That is about the standard which the Parliamentary Secretary is supposed to have when he comes to deal with schools. In order to prove that, Deputy Hurley went on to say that less and less money is being spent each year on the maintenance of schools. Now, Deputy Hurley said that twice. He said it after he had read figures proving the contrary. That is an amazing attitude of mind for a man to take who has been given the actual figures—who has made out the figures himself, and having done that twice, to misrepresent, and then add that scandalous addendum. The actual facts are that the Office of Public Works has been spending more and more money on schools during the last three years. The sum spent in 1935-36 was £126,000; in 1936-37, £132,000, and in 1937-38, £159,000—the year of the building strike. I think that any fair-minded man will say that whether or not £159,000 is the right amount to spend, there is evidence here that the Department is trying to do what it can to bring about improvement. I do not think there is a Deputy in this House who, talking to another Deputy down in the smoke-room, has any doubt that we are trying to do our best and that we intend to do our best. Not even Deputy Hurley will say to himself outside a platform where he is trying to get some little very despicable political kudos, that the figures for the building of schools represent that callous disregard for the health and welfare of children which he suggests. I suggest that is going altogether below the belt, and the sooner that sort of thing is cut out the better.
It might be said: "After all, what is £159,000?" In the three years before we came in the figures were £89,000, £65,000 and £100,000. I can tell the House that there has been a complete reorganisation on the staff and on the administration side in the Office of Public Works for the purpose of improving the school position. That could not produce its complete result last year, due to the strike. We hope it will produce it next year and increasingly as the years go on. One thing I will say is that we, as a Department, accept it as a conscientious responsibility, to the limit of our powers, in relation to any funds which we have at our disposal for the purpose of schools, to spend them as rapidly, as efficiently and as fairly as we possibly can, and I do not think that any person in the House doubts that.
Deputy Hurley raised the question of the wage of 24/- a week on relief schemes, now that it is 27/- a week for other work. As the House is aware, we have a motion before us here to refer this Vote back. Deputy Norton, who put down the motion, was courteous enough to inform me of the basis on which he moved to refer it back. He did so on the basis of 24/- a week and on the basis of rotation. I was very anxious that the House should have a full opportunity to deliver its attack on that basis uninterfered with by any announcement on the subject. The wages on minor relief schemes are now 27/-. They came up at once.
Comment on this
From the 23rd, from the same date as the other. Deputy Hurley also wanted preference given to married as distinct from single men. I do not want to touch on the original process at all, because I think the less we say about what used to happen, the better. In our original system, we did give employment to married men first. They got it practically exclusively, but that was found, in practice, to be unfair, and especially unfair in the rural districts, where we found that single men had a good many dependents. It has changed to the extent that 25 per cent. of the total employment was given to single men, but that was where we were working on a rule of thumb method of recruiting labour. At that time there was no employment exchange, unemployment assistance register, and we had no statutory means, as to some extent, we have now, of ascertaining the different levels of distress of individuals. As soon as there was set up under the law a system of ascertaining in a mathematical form the relative distress of people who were suffering from unemployment, we changed over to using that register. The unemployment assistance register at the moment is a direct measure of the difference between the minimum amount of money which the State regards as necessary during a person's period of unemployment and the amount of income which he has been ascertained to possess, independent of his wages; in other words, it is as near as we can get it a comparative, if not an absolute, measure of the distress due to unemployment as between individual men.
That was a standard which we were all very glad to get. It was something which every honest man who had anything to do with or any responsibility for employment schemes was very anxious to get, and as soon as we got it we said: "All right; we will use that basis." Now, the unemployment assistance basis takes into account the whole of a man's commitments relative to other men. It takes into account all his income, apart from wages, relative to other men; of his title to receive from the State a share of any artificial funds of that kind. For that reason, and that reason only, we decided that preference should be given in employment schemes to men in proportion to the amount of unemployment assistance they receive, whether they are married or single men. I, personally, know of no fairer method of dealing with it. If any fairer method can be offered to me, I shall be in the debt of those who will give it to me.
One of the difficulties we had in previous years in taking men off the top end of the panel, with an inadequate amount of the total funds, for the purpose of fully employing them was that that meant that only those men got employment, and the single men, and men relatively less in necessity further down, might find themselves getting no advantage at all. It meant that the married man being taken on might be kept on for the duration of the scheme and, as a result, the money did not go around. I am speaking of a system which has been in the process of evolution. We have come out of chaos now into some degree of reasonable order and what I am speaking of now is the process in which that came. This year, we decided that that defect, at any rate, would be remedied and that the mere fact that a man automatically came on the register because he was at the top end would not mean that he would remain in employment for the whole period of the scheme. In addition to that, there was the difficulty that a man who remained in employment for more than five weeks could not, when his period was over, go back directly on the unemployment assistance register. He had to wait a week. Those two factors taken together induced us to say that we would limit the period, where there were more men available for work than the scheme could absorb, to four weeks. At the end of that time (1) the man would automatically go back on the unemployment assistance register without losing the week, and (2) the next set of men, more necessitous, judging by that standard, on the register would be brought in. We calculated that we were able this year to deal with something approximating to two-thirds of the register in that way. Exactly how far it has worked out I cannot say yet. It is a matter of a considerable amount of accountancy and calculation, but as soon as they are available, I will let the House have the actual figures of the degree of success or failure which has been attained in the matter. At any rate, I think the present system, under which we employ men not because they are married and not because they are single, but in proportion to their necessity judged by the unemployment assistance standards, and under which we change them at intervals of four weeks, is the best way that I know of using the amount of money which I have at my disposal. The question of the efficiency of schemes of this kind was raised. Quite a number of people conscientiously believed that efficiency could not possibly be achieved under a system of this kind. As I said in my opening brief, neither I nor any other sane man is going to pretend that you are going to get out of any relief scheme —where you have to take men purely and simply on the ground of their necessity and employ them for the purpose of their benefit—the same efficiency that a contractor could get by employing people purely and simply on their merits as workmen.
Comment on this
I will take even that. I am quite satisfied that in a great many State activities at the present moment, local and otherwise, a contractor could go in and pay better wages and get better results, because he would insist——
Comment on this
No, he is not, but he would jolly well see to it. When I first came across this particular scheme— which I may say originated with a letter from a young Mayo priest, asking for some use of the unemployed men in his district of more benefit to them and more benefit to the State than paying them what is called dole—I certainly did not realise that it had the possibilities which I now believe it has. I certainly assumed that under it we could do a great deal of fairly elementary work, but I could see the limitations and I could see many of the reactions which are now pleaded against it. Experience has shown that our fears in that respect were certainly not well-founded. What happened was that an experiment was made in four or five counties in one year, costing somewhere about £20,000, on a strictly mathematical rotation, that is to say, a rotation in which a man got in the form of wages exactly 40 per cent.—or as near to it as possible—more than his unemployment assistance, plus beef. The success of those schemes was so surprisingly greater than we had expected, and the difficulties which we had anticipated were so completely absent, that we revised our ideas of the possibilities.
I was speaking to a county surveyor who had been using the system successfully for us, and I asked him what work he could efficiently do under it. Very much to my surprise, he said he could do efficiently any work which he was then doing as county surveyor. Rather for the purpose of carrying it to an absurd point, I asked him if he could do a public health work of a technical character, and he said he was prepared to undertake it. I said: "How many key-men working full time and selected by yourself will you require in order to do it?" He said: "Practically none." I asked: "What amount will you add to the ordinary contract price in order to do the job?" He replied: "I will do it at the contract price." I think we will all take off our hats to the courage of that engineer, having regard to the obvious difficulties and limitations of a scheme of that kind. A scheme of some £6,000 or £7,000 was found for this purpose. It was most strictly and critically estimated by two Departments and the local authority which had to deal with it. It abolished the unemployment register in a certain district for practically 11 months. I have here a certificate of the high technical efficiency of that job. It was a difficult job in a hilly district with cascade manholes and deep cuts which had to be strussed and supported. It had all the difficulties which I, as a devil's advocate, would have chosen for the purpose of trying out a scheme of that kind to destruction. The estimated cost was £6,788. The actual cost was £5,529. The saving on that scheme, by doing it in this particular method, as compared with the price at which it would have been done by contract, was £1,259. This is the sort of thing which makes one think. We have had a series of cases in which we have had costed accounts. The conditions under which they have been done have been various, but in every case in which a costed account has been produced the result has been better than we expected.
The reason I have raised this particular point in this particular way was because Deputy Hurley raised the question of a particular job which was done in Cork by the Cork Harbour Commissioners. They applied for a grant for doing certain works in concreting quays and the like. During the discussions which took place after that grant had been applied for by the local authority very strong expressions of opinion were made as to the utter impossibility of doing work of that kind efficiently with rotational labour taken from the unemployment assistance register. I replied that I was satisfied, from the experience which I had previously had, that under proper supervision as good results could be got—I am speaking now of technical and economic results —under a rotational system of labour as under any other method of employing that labour. I stated that the work would be inspected before, during and after construction, that costing accounts would be required and that on that it would be tested.
There were two works done in the City of Cork under this scheme. They were estimated on the basis of the ordinary production of the full-time workmen of that local authority. The estimates were made by their own engineer, the supervision was under their own engineer, and the certificate of completion, of cost, and of efficiency is by their own engineer, backed by the separate, independent inspection of the technical officers of the Office of Works. What is the result? One of these works was carried out under the conditions which are specified, that is to say, uninterrupted work. The engineer certifies to the harbour board that more work was done for the money than by his own workmen acting under permanent employment. In relation to the other, it was very greatly interrupted by traffic conditions. It was on a quay, subject to vessels coming alongside, and so on, and he certifies that no part of the discrepancy is due to any other cause but that and specifically that no part of it is due to rotation or the quality of the workmen got under rotation. Yet, in spite of that certificate, we have Deputy Hurley, a member of that board, saying it cannot be done. The man who went to the zoo and said: "There ain't no such animal" is in exactly the same position. Nothing that we can do will prove it to those who have made up their minds that it cannot be done.
Do those two cases represent the average? I do not think so—I wish they did. It is my intention, so far as in me lies, to see that that system is set up under which they will represent the average. I have county surveyors employing 6,000, 7,000, 8,000 and 9,000 men at the same time. Those men certify that they are getting 90 to 100 per cent. efficiency. I have county councils which are employing 400 men, and they tell me that they are getting 60 per cent. efficiency. I think the whole case is a case (1) of the efficiency of supervision, and (2) the quality of the men. If you take the Western seaboard—take Mayo, Kerry, Donegal and places of that kind—the great proportion of the men on the register are fairly typical of the districts in which they are.
Comment on this
Yes, small farmers. I would ask those who do conscientiously look at this thing as a matter of conscience, not as a matter of polemics, to go down and really carefully examine the two maps which are lying near the Library. They will tell you the story of the distribution. They will tell you where these 100,000 men that we are speaking of are unemployed. They will show you the incidence of the problem. If you compare the other one with the distribution of the works and see the meticulous accuracy—it has gone too far if anything—with which that map of need is translated into a map of service in the form of works, I do not think that any of you will have the face to accuse the Department that is responsible for it of any other attitude of mind than that of a deep sense of responsibility in relation to this problem and every part of it. The leopard does not change its spots. We do not make a scheme of the kind which will stand any criticism in relation to the mass and then mess it about by doing something wrong or something careless, or something even inconsiderate in the matter of how we employ men in those rural districts where 90 per cent. of the men over a period are employed.
You may take it, as Deputy Davin stated, that you are dealing with the small farming class, and they are all pretty well efficient. I will say this, that when they turn out on a job of this kind they do give their best. I have seen men working on rotation schemes in a blizzard, and I have seen them honestly and deliberately giving all that was in them in return for their wages. I personally have the highest and deepest possible respect for the men whom I have seen working, and all I can say is that there is no evidence of failure of discharge of duty on an average of those people which would fit in with the a priori, synthetic reasoning on which we have been going that this thing must be inefficient.
You turn away from that and you come to a gang which I was shown by a public official some time ago working in a city. They also were working on rotation. It was perfectly obvious that a considerable proportion of those men were definitely sub-standard. You could not expect to get from those men the output that we were getting in other districts, or that you would expect to get from good men in the cities. To that extent, no matter what we do, whether we employ them whole-time, week about, or otherwise, you are not going to get from those sub-standard men the performance of standard men. But what we are doing is, we are trying to some extent to recondition them into standard men. With the inadequacy of the inadequate resources which we have—
Comment on this
We will take this quietly, if you do not mind. Rotation itself is not responsible for a small payment to men, nor in the Office of Public Works are we responsible for deciding how much assistance will be brought to unemployment. That is the duty of this House as a whole. How much money would the State provide for the purpose? Once that has been decided, then the question of the efficiency of its spending and its distribution enters. What we are attempting to do is, with whatever resources we have to meet the problem as broadly and as fairly as we can. Rotation is a very flexible instrument.
At the present moment men are employed at a minimum of three, and a maximum of five, days per week. Though a very considerable number of employment schemes are carried out on a full time basis, public health schemes and things of that kind, broadly speaking, rural road relief and minor relief schemes, are carried out on the three, four, and five day basis. Even then, last year, when we employed at the maximum 50,000 men, I had still 90,000 men on the register. Now unless somebody is going to say to me that I must employ less of the 50,000 and increase the 90,000; unless someone is going to say that I shall give more to the few and take it from the many, then some form of rotation, some form of division, is absolutely necessary. It does not matter whether it is bi-weekly, bi-fortnightly, three days or otherwise. It is the machinery of distribution. If we have more money for the purpose, we can either employ more men on the present standard or we can give more days to every man who is now getting a limited number. At the present moment what is happening is that all the money we get, we distribute in every county, every village and every electoral area in proportion to the necessity of that area relative to all other areas. We try to distribute it between every man in these electoral areas in proportion to his necessity relative to all other people. If anyone can suggest a higher standard of distribution, I am at his disposal.
Comment on this
On the point of the amount of money to be expended, is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that it is only a Minister who can move for increased expenditure in this House?
Comment on this
I am not dealing with any question of polemics in this matter at all. I have never talked polemics or politics in connection with these schemes.
Comment on this
But the Parliamentary Secretary said that the House could increase the expenditure on these schemes. The House cannot increase expenditure beyond a certain point.
Comment on this
What the House can do is to avoid going into the lobby to vote against an unpopular tax. That is exactly the problem. The whole issue is this: if we bring in a series of budgets which mean raising money, which can only be raised by an unpopular tax, is the Labour Party going into the "No" lobby against them?
Comment on this
I will not deal with that at this moment. The Deputy has raised a point which I think ought to be met, up to a point. If the Deputy can get a majority in this House in favour of an increase in income-tax let him come to the Minister for Finance and ask him to increase that tax, but the Deputy will not. He would rather have the popularity of saying: "I will vote for a tax that I know there is not going to be a majority in this House for." The only time that the Minister did attempt to raise income-tax, because it affected some people who might vote for the Deputy he and his colleagues went into the lobby and voted against an increase in income-tax. I should like to drop that atmosphere. I want to put it to the House again that if there is to be a larger number of days given to any man, or if there is to be a larger number of men employed, then it means that the taxation of this country will have to be raised. There are no popular taxes left which the Minister for Finance can introduce. The whole question at issue is whether the House is prepared to vote for additional unpopular taxation for the purpose of getting that money. I have stressed that point because there has been no attack on rotation here in this debate. No attack on rotation has been made in this debate. Somebody has said that it is scandalous and somebody else has said that it is one thing or another, but when they were asked to come down to brass tacks, no one had any attack to make on the system except that there was not enough money. I am emphasising that. There is no attack upon rotation. No one is saying at the moment: "We want more money spent on unemployment schemes; we want more money given in each week to each individual person."
Comment on this
That is not correct. I definitely challenge that your system is not rotation. I do not want to make any political or polemical statement either but I say it is not rotation.
Comment on this
The Deputy says that the scheme we are following is not rotation. I think that may pass without my saying anything. I should be very glad if anyone in this House would deliver a considered attack on rotation and I would be specially and particularly grateful if they would give that to me in writing. I promise anyone who can find for me a method which will, in any detail whatever, improve the existing method of the distribution of the money, I shall adopt that method without any hesitation whatever, wherever it comes from. I think the House knows that.
Deputy Tubridy raised the question of small farmers and others not in receipt of unemployment assistance, and who, therefore, were debarred. That again boils down to the fact that I have a particular fund to deal with. If I use any portion of that fund for people who are not now regarded as people in need, then I must give less to those who are in need. I think there is something—I want to be quite frank —to be said for the point of view which is advocated there, but I do not think that I am entitled to spend one penny of this money for that purpose unless I am in a position to treat adequately all those who are entitled to it. My line of conduct is that I am not entitled to be generous to anybody until I have been just to all. Here is what is happening. I can see the urge which it is producing. We have carried out somewhere about 9,000 minor relief schemes alone since this Government came into office. Those consisted mainly, as the House knows, of bog roads, accommodation roads, and works of that character, works which are largely amenities to farmers and people of that kind. I am quite satisfied that a good many of them have meant the difference between mere existence and living in the country for many thousands of people. Those have all taken place in poor areas, and farmers in other areas, who are not poor, find that their poorer neighbours are getting these amenities while they are not. The problem boils down to that. I have never heard the claim seriously put forward that farmers in those areas should get the money required for such works. Everyone says: "Bring in your unemployed men, and do what you like, but do not have us travelling to our houses with our knees in mud while all our poorer neighbours have fine roads to theirs." There is a lot to be said for that, but there is nothing to be said for taking money out of this fund for it.
Look at the map, and ask yourself whether you would abandon any scheme in any area, or take it out and put it somewhere where we have not put it. Until you are prepared to do that, and say that it would be the proper way to use the money, you are not entitled to ask that such work should be done under this scheme. A certain number of schemes of that kind may eventually be done as an experiment, in order to find out its reactions. That would be right and legitimate, even under a Vote of this kind, in so far as all information relating to the unemployment problem would be of legitimate use for the money, but any large scheme would be outside the ambit, and would be held up by our friends, the Committee of Public Accounts. Deputy McGowan said that the rotation scheme was a matter for local authorities. All I say is that apparently they understand it. I should like to give the Deputy an example, and an opportunity to work out the rotation system for, say 20 men, who had to work anything from 16 to five days a month. I mean strict mathematical rotation, and to keep a regular gauge while doing it. That was the problem we offered local authorities during the experimental period and we gave them no help. We wanted them to work in their own way, and to our amazement everyone of them solved that difficult mathematical problem.
Comment on this
It was well done. They got to the bottom of it. It may be taken that that element is gone. Every one of them has been through troubles and trials, but they know how to do it now, so that there is no difficulty. I think the Deputy raised a question about certain people being afraid to take employment on "off" days while on rotation work. A man employed on rotation work is perfectly entitled to take any casual employment. What happened was that men on unemployment assistance were afraid to take casual employment or, if they did, it was sub rosa. Now a man can take extra days' work over and above the three days.
Comment on this
I was comparing the system of a week on and a week out with the system of working three days and being off two days. I suggested as an alternative that a man should work an on and an off week, because after working three days he might secure casual employment, but might say to himself: "I will not take it as I would miss my chance of getting the rotation." The alternative of a week on and a week off would be better.
Comment on this
That has been brought up in the case of Cork, where a grant of £26,000 was actually refused by a combination of Labour and Fine Gael rather than take rotation. That is the only case on record in all the millions of money. I had the pleasure of administering in this particular way. The only money ever refused and lost by local authorities was in Cork Borough by a combined vote of the two Opposition Parties rather than have rotation in spite of the fact that they had a petition from the men engaged on rotation work saying that they wanted it; in spite also of the fact that they had a petition saying that they wanted the three days rotation instead of the weekly rotation, and declaring from their experience of working under it that there had been a great social improvement. That is amazing, almost unbelievable. There was £26,000 belonging to their own constituents thrown away rather than face the facts. The question came on again this year on another £20,000 which they were very likely to lose on account of the same prejudice. Alderman Ailen then got up and said: "I do not like rotation, but I have got here the signatures of 300 men asking for it, and that is good enough for me." I think that will be good enough for the Deputy. The only complaint I got from the workers in relation to it is one I am trying to deal with, by giving successive panels, as enough men were not getting access to them. I heard complaints about unemployed workers from Waterford, and they said they had no complaints in any way; that it was very good, but that only a very small percentage got the benefit of it.
Deputy Dillon, having thrown a bouquet at me, followed it up with a very large pot, of the character that makes the bouquet very unacceptable. I do not value a tribute to the efficiency of my Department which impeaches its good faith. Some years ago, before this Government came into office, our predecessors had found money for an unemployment scheme by voting £250,000 to a Department which was already overworked, and that had to choose between failing to spend its own money or failing to spend that sum. They had not, as a matter of fact, to raise the money by taxation. The British owed it to them. Undoubtedly, they said, the British would pay, so they decided to spend it for the purpose of unemployment relief. They sent the money to a Department that could not spend it. In other words, they fooled the unemployed. Deputy Dillon, having paid a compliment to the efficiency of the Department, then turned round and said we were doing the same thing. The justification he pleads for that is the fact that there was a re-Vote in a particular year of £167,000. From the very first day we handled unemployment we had a re-Vote of one kind or another. On the first occasion I accounted for that in this House I said that it was utterly impossible to carry on a system of Unemployment Vote from year to year unless there was a re-Vote. Each year successively we explained the machinery by which that was done. Because that re-Vote appears we are now told we remain in the same category as the people who had the £250,000 Vote. It is an outrageous accusation, an accusation that fits in with nothing in our records. You might as well accuse us of doing the other things that were done. Why not tell us that our gangers are publicans who pay their men in their own publichouses; that the men have got to give testimonials to their gangers; that gangers could take home their men to work on their own farms instead of doing their work? Why not tell us that we also allow our gangers to be political gangsters? Why not say that every ganger in a particular district was the personating agent of the Party that was administering the fund? Why not say that every man who got employment had to get it because he was somebody's political henchman and only held his job as long as he remained that political henchman? Why not say that our schemes are administered and distributed on the same system as they once were when Deputies got them scullions who got tips to carry round on to political platforms and to change into cash?
Comment on this
‘Would you permit me to ask the Parliamentary Secretary does he mean what he has said?
Comment on this
By all means question that. Prove it. Show that any single scheme of ours has been informed by that corruption.
Comment on this
When in doubt, believe the worst. Our schemes have been clean. Every single scheme that has been done is there for everybody to read it. When did any other administration of relief schemes put up visibly the evidence which we put up, upon which we can be criticised? Again, I did not mean to diverge into this matter, but I do regard it as a gross insult to mention in the same breath our administration of the schemes and the administration of our predecessors.
Comment on this
I say, Sir, it is brazenness on your part, from what I know of your schemes for four or five years.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary admit that it can be done without their knowledge?
Comment on this
There is not a man in this House, there is not a man outside this House, who does not know that our schemes to-day are honest and clean.
Comment on this
Where is the Deputy's evidence? If the Deputy has any evidence to the contrary he is bound in honour to table it and I am bound in honour to investigate it and lay it before the House. The Deputy has no evidence. It is only cod. But, at any rate, I am not prepared in future to receive any compliments tied up with the pots of the character which Deputy Dillon handed out in that particular case.
Deputy Dillon referred to swimming pools. He said that we had been very good to him in the matter of swimming pools and he wanted that developed. We would be very glad indeed to do anything of that kind if a plan is put forward. His suggestion that we should draw up a series of typical plans, in my opinion, will not be feasible. I will try it but it will not be feasible. Our experience of all swimming pool projects is that they are special to the district. I mean, anything you do depends simply and solely on an exact topographical knowledge. At any rate, all I can tell you is that we will help in any way we can.
Deputy Anthony attacked rotation. Being asked for his objections he said he objected to the system of so many days on and off, and he suggested week on and week off. That is not an objection to rotation. That is a different form of rotation. At any rate, this is a form of rotation which the unemployed people who have had experience of it have asked should be left as it is.
Deputy Kelly asked whether there had been at any time a reduction in the number of days' employment given per week to married men. The answer is no. What happened is that, at one time, single men used to get two days' employment. That was raised to three days' employment, but there was not necessarily a corresponding rise in other rates and, very curiously, it may appeal to the sense of humour of this House, it was not the men who were getting two days a week who were responsible for the agitation to get an increase; it was the men who worked three days who wanted the two-day men to have to work for their third day instead of drawing it in the form of unemployment assistance.
Deputy Kelly raised the question that where minor drainage schemes had been started in one year they should be completed in the next. That is the intention. Last year, some 450 schemes of summer drainage were done, involving amounts of £150, and that kind of thing, but to any extent to which these had been left incomplete—I do not think there were many —the intention would be to complete them.
Deputy Brodrick raised, I think, the same question as the previous Deputy, and said that he did not agree with the selection of schemes in accordance with the number of unemployed on the register. Within the ambit of the Vote, it is quite clear that any departure from that would be wrong, but I think that his idea was to get work of social amenity done in non-poverty areas, a thing which can be argued on its own basis but which cannot be financed out of the employment Vote.
Deputy Beegan said he did not like to see men breaking stones about Christmas, that they were not used to breaking stones, and some other method ought to be adopted. I will tell the House quite frankly that in relation to the small towns, I think the first time that unemployment works were ever done in the small towns it was about two years ago under this scheme and the number of schemes which are available seem to be very limited. I want the House to take my point of view in the matter. My point of view is to see that as much as possible of every £100 I spend goes into the pocket of some poor man. The schemes which are available in the little towns which have a large proportion of unskilled labour in them apparently are very limited; they seem to boil down to footpaths. All I can say is that I have used all the brains I have and all the brains that I can borrow to find schemes that are suitable for those areas which will have a considerable labour content. Can anyone tell me something that we have forgotten? You all know the story of the man who forgot Goschen—we may have in this matter forgotten Goschen—but at the moment we are finding it extremely difficult and over a period of years, I think, we are going to find it impossible to keep up the supply of schemes which have a large unskilled labour content in the small towns. I am passing schemes now that I do not like. I am passing schemes with 50 per cent. of labour content and I tell you quite frankly that that is on my conscience.
Comment on this
Cannot you industrialise the country and produce your crops industrially and absorb all the men and thousands more? You don't want schemes.
Comment on this
That is another point. The question of an airport at Midleton has been raised by three or four Deputies. The original intention was to build that airport as an unemployment scheme. We had two big pools of unemployment—the Borough of Cork, where there would be about 3,000 on the register of unemployed; in Cobh we might have 400, and we had a very small number in the Midleton area itself. It is a peculiarity, and a very uncomfortable peculiarity, that these acrodromes are falling in the very rich areas. If only they would fall in Donegal, West Kerry or somewhere like that it would help us more in solving the unemployment problem. But in every single case they are falling in the very richest areas. In the three we have dealt with now they are falling in the three richest areas in the whole country. For instance, Collinstown, Rhynana and Midleton. The problem of getting people who are entitled to work on the unemployment fund is very difficult. We found it was not practicable to transport them from the Borough of Cork to Midleton. The arrangement was to transport them from Cobh. In Cobh most of the unemployment has now been dealt with by another means. A considerable portion of those who will remain on the register will not be suitable for work on the aerodrome. Therefore, financing it by an unemployment scheme, however willing we might be, is going to be very difficult. In addition, the whole scheme seems to be altered by those who are interested in it. At the present moment there is an element of indefiniteness as to what is required. All I can say in relation to the Midleton aerodrome is that when we get a definite programme we will go into it as rapidly as we can. I could not bring it any further than that.
Deputy Dillon raised a very difficult question when he raised the matter of a man who had been in the employment of the Board of Works, but who, due to reconstruction, became superfluous. He was perfectly fair. I am not complaining in any way of what he said, but he raised a very difficult problem; he did it in a manner which was, in my opinion, perfectly right. He took the line that in those cases the Board of Works should not disemploy that man. Well, if this were one case, one would say, "yes, one can stretch a point." But this is occurring to a considerable extent in a good many departments. Sometimes, where you go to reconstruct a place, you will find on proper reorganisation of the work that you will have ten people unemployed. That happened in half a dozen cases; we have dealt with them in every case as sympathetically as we could. In some cases we have been able to absorb them into other portions of the works. Sometimes we have been able to get them into other departments, and in some cases we have kept them on for a considerable time as supernumeries. This is one of those very unpleasant problems you have to face. In no case is a man dismissed, or anything of that kind, without my taking personal responsibility for doing it. I am not at all willing to have a man dismissed if it is at all possible to keep him on.
Comment on this
It is this way: For instance, there is a carpenter in charge. A carpenter in charge is practically the same as the clerk of works or the foreman. His clerk is the man who deals with the requisitions for supplies, deals with the time sheets and things of that kind. That is the type of person he is. All I can say is that we deal with this matter where a man is superfluous as sympathetically as we can.
The question of the Dun Laighaire Pier was raised. To me the pier calls for the consideration of the railway and the navigation problem. It is agreed that improvements are desirable, particularly to deal with the rush periods. The exact form the improvements can take is not so easy a problem. The Great Southern and the L.M.S. are mainly concerned with the traffic and it is up to them to say what facilities they consider desirable. The companies know that we are prepared to consider any proposals put forward. Their interests may clash and it may be that the extension of the Carlisle Pier would render navigation more difficult. We refused to attend a conference at Dun Laoghaire because no useful purpose could be served by the conference. That was because no actual proposals had been put forward for technical examination. Until we have proposals to work on there is not the faintest use of going into a room and saying: "Now, we will look at so and so." If people want to put forward something let them give us an idea of what they do want and then we will be prepared to consider it.
Comment on this
We asked everybody concerned to put forward any proposal they like and we would be glad to consider it.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking us to put on more taxes? Then when the taxes are produced it would be another story. On one occasion a Labour Deputy asked me to take my courage in both hands and do this, that and the other thing. I asked him and his colleagues to take their courage in both feet, go into the unpopular lobby and vote for these taxes.
Comment on this
I suggest it is not necessary for Dun Laoghaire Pier, while there is money available there.
Comment on this
You may take it definitely that if that problem has to be faced in anything like the spirit in which it was talked of that is not the way in which it should be done.
Comment on this
Is it not possible for the Parliamentary Secretary to call in technical experts and others concerned, including the Dun Laoghaire Corporation?
Comment on this
All I can tell you is that if the technical experts write down just what they want, it will be considered— and they do not even need a stamp.
Comment on this
No, it is not. What is the use of the Department building a pier of the type that they may not want. If they write down just what they want, then the position will be clearer.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary quite sure that this money is not available for carrying out various works?
Comment on this
The Deputy is dreaming. As it is, there is a whole lot of maintenance work being done for the benefit of Dun Laoghaire. All these things are being kept in order free by the State and if they do not take the trouble to write down what they want, then what can I do?
Comment on this
There is one thing that I should like to mention to the Parliamentary Secretary. The L.M.S. case, I understand, is: "Our contract is running out for the carrying of the mails and what is the use of discussing a new pier or new boats when we have a contract which is just going to expire."
Comment on this
Does that prevent them indicating what they would like in a pier? If what the Deputy says represents the intelligence of the company, then they ought to sue him for libel. Deputy Hogan referred to half a dozen schemes in County Clare and he said that the county council would not allow the county surveyor to take them over because they were not completed. So far as I know, there are seven in all and two have been taken over by the county council. The final award is not complete in the case of the other schemes. Deputy Ryan mentioned the case of the Ballybeg drainage scheme and he also called attention to the drainage scheme carried out on the Black River. He said a large amount of the good work done by the drainage of the Black River was nullified by the amount of damage done from the point where the drainage was stopped to the mouth of the Suir. That is an example of the shortcomings of the present drainage code and it is one of the matters that gave rise to the idea of a drainage commission.
He also raised the question of the very marked discrepancy between the estimates of the Board of Works for doing a particular job, and the estimates of the officer acting on behalf of the local body. His own surveyor apparently provides merely for cleaning up shoals and bushes and so on, while we were calculating on the expensive work of redraining the river. There is an idea that you can go into a river, take away a few bushes and a weir, and everything is all right. In practice it is no good unless you go back over the whole thing and make the whole channel the same size as the new place which you have cleared.
Comment on this
I understood from the assistant county surveyor that there could be a good job done on this river for £1,000.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied it could not be done. We have had dozens of cases where we had estimates and where we were going to spend as much as £20,000, and when we examined them we found they had been only opening the door for us to come in and do the work. Deputy Nally raised questions about the drainage of the Gweston, Pollock and Yellow Rivers and he referred to drainage on the Claredalgan River. These have been all subject to critical examination and it was found they would be extremely uneconomic. The same applies to the Brick and Cashin to which Deputy O'Sullivan referred. He also raised the question of another river in which he stated the maintenance cost which the people were being asked to pay was altogether out of proportion to the improvement. In that particular case there were four years of unpaid maintenance charges included in the figure. What happens is that a scheme is handed over to the county council and they are then responsible for the maintenance of the river. They do not do it, or, if they do, they find they cannot collect the instalments from the people who have been benefited. Once we have handed it over, our responsibility finishes.
Deputy Brasier referred to the Maglin river. This was brought to an award in 1900. There is a drainage board still functioning in the district, and any question of maintenance will have to be referred to it; we have nothing to do with it. Deputy Linehan asked if we proposed to build a President's residence. It is proposed to do so, but for the present we have decided to use the former Viceregal Lodge, while the whole question is being gone into. Deputy Dockrell and Deputy Benson referred to the question of parking. That only concerns us in so far as it is alleged that some particular area which is under our control is kept out of that use. There is no area at the present moment under our control, which, in my opinion, could be more properly used for parking than it is now being used. I think the Deputy suggested taking down the pillars around Stephen's Green. I am quite sure it would produce a storm of protest if we were to touch them. At any rate, we have no legal power to do so. We have that in trust, and it would require legislation to enable us to do what the Deputy wants. However, he ventilated that particular question, and that is all he requires.
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary does me an injustice. I want to contribute something to the solution. I think the Parliamentary Secretary had been confounding the pillars and the railings.
Comment on this
At any rate, we cannot touch it without legislation. I think that is sufficient answer for the Deputy. If we could give him any help in reason, we would, but we are stopped by law.
Comment on this
No, none whatever, except money. It is all a question of money. You would be amazed the number of things one can do if one had unlimited money, and one had not to raise that money by taxation.
Comment on this
You kept the secret well for a time. You should have passed it on to other Deputies.
Comment on this
If it can be pointed out to me that at any time I said I did not know that the people had to pay for all they got, I would be glad to have that quotation.
Comment on this
Deputy Hurley asked for particulars with regard to the leases of Haulbowline. These have been laid on the Table in accordance with the State Land Acts. They are in the Library if the Deputy wants to see them. I think it was Deputy Larkin who raised the question of the financing of the memorial park. The Government put £40,000 in the Unemployment Vote into it—that was voted by a previous Administration—against £56,000 put in by the trustees of the memorial fund. The work is practically complete. The Government moneys were used to develop the park, and the trustees' money built the memorial. Of that sum of £40,000, £10,000 have been kept for the purpose of maintenance, and, of course, it will eventually go into the same thing.
Deputy Larkin raised the question, much to my surprise, that there had been political interference in the employment in Collinstown. I can assure the Deputy that I am not aware of it, and I should be very glad if he would give me any particulars of any such political interference.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary investigate the matter if particulars are furnished to him?
Comment on this
Certainly. I am absolutely going to discourage anything of the kind. I want to make that quite clear. After all, we have got to do our jobs, and to do them properly. Deputy Larkin also raised the question of the periodical contractor as distinct from employing direct. Well, that again is a matter on which two opinions can be held, and on which two opinions are held. On balance, at any rate, we have decided that the present arrangement is the best arrangement. We do not regard as exorbitant the actual cost of 10 per cent., of which the Deputy speaks—of course, I want to be gentle in the matter—but we do not regard it as exorbitant, and it covers quite a good deal, and is in many ways a convenient and proper method. It gets over some of the difficulties which the Deputy himself is raising in connection with a question which he has put down to me, and which he knows I am investigating. Of course, nobody can speak ex cathedra on the subject, but we have looked at it from both angles, and, of course, the contracts also go before the committee.
Comment on this
But what about the possibility of a contract going each year to the same contractor?
Comment on this
That may be, but it is perfectly straight. After all, if there is anything straight in the country, it is the method of contract.
Comment on this
Oh, yes. He does his work very well, but it must be remembered that we are only dealing now with the question of integrity of contracts. At any rate, the Deputy can have absolute assurance on that point. Deputy Davin raised what, I think, is a hardy annual of his when he asked that any scheme that is started should be completed in the year in which it is started. As against that, however, I have had the strongest representations, both from the Deputy's own Party and from other Parties, in the other direction. The problem is this: You have an area which is entitled to a certain amount of money, and let us say that there are five small schemes and one big scheme. Let us assume that the big scheme is outstandingly better than the small schemes. Well, then, you can do either of two things. You can either abandon the big scheme altogether, because it is too big for the amount of money which belongs to the area concerned, or you arrange to do it in three successive years, or you can take money from some other area and give it to that area. In practice, what we do is this: If the big scheme is obviously better, we do it over a series of years. That has been our practice, and we shall continue to follow that practice.
Comment on this
It would depend on the area concerned. Deputies do not realise the differences that exist in different areas. For instance, within seven miles of Rhynana, when we first started there, there were 11 men on the unemployment register, whereas within a similar area in Mayo, there were 1,740 on the unemployment register. In other words, what would be all right for Rhynana, or the district around it to which I have referred, would be only a flea-bite to a similar district in Mayo.
Comment on this
Well, I do not intend to take from one area its money in order to give it to another area, and, if I possibly can, I do not propose to do a poor scheme in priority to another which is a good scheme, even if it takes three years to do it.
Comment on this
Whatever the job may be. Now, Deputy Beegan referred to the number of men in receipt of unemployment assistance, and he took a different attitude in that regard to most Deputies. He said that a lot of men were in receipt of unemployment assistance, or were on the unemployment register, who should not be on the unemployment register. That, definitely, is not the function of this Department, but, to some extent, I must say that we have contributed to it. There is no question at all about it, that the fact that unemployment relief schemes are being run does induce people to go on the unemployed register who otherwise would not go on that register, and I think that, to some extent, the unemployment register has been swelled by that activity of ours, and I should be very glad to know of any means by which it would not be so swelled. Deputy O'Sullivan raised the question of the Drainage Commission. All I can say in that connection is that we are very anxious to move it on as rapidly as we can. The Deputy was perfectly correct in pointing out that the drainage problem in Ireland is peculiarly our own. The drainage problem in Ireland is sui generis, and I do not know any case where the same problem exists or where the specialised experience of specialised drainage engineers would be so useful. We are going to get any outside knowledge of that kind that we can get, naturally, but I do believe that the problem here is a problem of our own. Deputy Gorey raised certain points which I shall look into, with a view to seeing what can be done in the matter.
Comment on this
I am sorry that I have not got them, but the Deputy may take it that, broadly, they will include the whole question of drainage. We are really up against both a financial problem and an administrative problem. There is the question: Who is going to take over the jobs when they are done, and who is going to be responsible for the collection of the moneys required to maintain them?
Comment on this
Yes, to maintain them. That is a very important matter. The whole 1925 Act was delayed owing to neglected maintenance. Every scheme that was covered under it was delayed in neglected maintenance.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary confusing two things? Is he confusing the restoration of a scheme with the maintenance of it after it has been restored?
Comment on this
No. There is the making of a scheme. Then there is the failure to maintain it; there is the restoring of it, and then there is the maintenance of it after it has been restored. These four stages are, I think, clear in my mind and in the Deputy's. As the House knows, there is a real problem that we have to deal with, and that is that Ireland is a flat plain, practically a cup. The gradients over which you have to drain from that central plain are very poor. There is the question of getting the water away. Up to the present, there has not been that amount of money spent on the outlets which will enable the upper drainage to be affected. None of that outlet drainage is going to have a direct value in the sense of improving land. Deputies may take it that a large portion of the money spent would not directly benefit any measurable amount of land. One of the jobs that a drainage commission will have to face will be, how to extend outfall drainage of that character.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary consider the question of getting a number of qualified advisers who would be available in each county to give technical assistance to individuals, or bodies of individuals prepared to undertake the job themselves. At the moment these individuals have not the experience required because the work I have in mind has not been done for the last 60 or 100 years.
Comment on this
We will consider it. What I suggest to the Deputy is that he should place all that information before the Commission. If he can find some better way of doing the work we are quite ready to hear him. We do not think the present machinery is adequate to deal with that problem. The Commission will consider the whole of this problem from the outlet to the source. If there is anyone who can contribute any light or wisdom as to a better way of doing the work, or suggest a better method of financing it and maintaining it, we will be very glad to hear of it. What I would suggest to the Deputy is that he should write down what he has to say on this. It is amazing the number of people who are ready to make speeches in comparison to the number who are ready to subject themselves to the more exacting test of putting their considered recommendations on paper. It has been said that "writing maketh an exact man." I should say that talking maketh a voluble man.
Comment on this
Would I be expecting too much if I were to ask the Parliamentary Secretary to allow me to see the files in his Department with regard to some of the schemes that have been put in, the estimates for them and all the rest?
Comment on this
The Deputy would be expecting too much in view of the fact that at the moment he is alleging that some people outside the Department have knowledge and information which they can give to us.
Comment on this
Then I misunderstood the Deputy. Deputy Kelly raised a question about Kilmainham Hospital. It is required for a definite Government purpose and is not available. The question of the lighting of this Chamber was also raised. I would ask Deputies to observe the effect of the two new lamps which have been installed, and I think they will agree that there is a marked improvement. They are certainly an improvement compared to the others.
Comment on this
The two that have been put up are not the same, and I was hoping that the whole lot were not going to be different.
Comment on this
On two or three occasions Deputy McGovern has got loose with various accusations. I have given him every possible opportunity to come to the test with proof, but he has failed to do so. What I want to say is that any man who knows of anything wrong in connection with the administration of a relief scheme and does not tell about it is no friend of this House. Any man who does know of anything wrong and says it in such a way as to make it effective is no enemy of this Government. We want all the criticism that we can get
Comment on this
I am sure the House absolutely believes what I have said. Deputy Davin referred to some contract schemes put forward for labour. If the Deputy was alluding to mere incidental schemes put forward in the ordinary way for contract works, I want to say that they got exactly the terms as anybody else.
Comment on this
That is why I could not quite understand the Deputy. Everyone speaks of afforestation, of roads, tourist roads, and all that kind of thing. What I want to say is that when you come down to the labour content of those schemes——
Comment on this
What about the Blue Lagoon? The potentialities of that scheme are greater than these of any of your schemes.
Comment on this
We went into that scheme with great care, and found that it would cost £500,000 of money at least, and that if it was given as a gift to the Corporation they were not prepared to maintain it.
Comment on this
I have put a moderate figure on it, but if a scheme which was going to cost all that money is not even worth maintaining by the people you give it to, what can you do? There is another technical difficulty that the Deputy knows of. The harbour authority objected definitely to anything of that kind.
Comment on this
That is another matter. Deputy Davin raised the question of a large scheme of bog reclamation. The whole question with regard to bogs is a matter for the Department of Industry and Commerce. All requisitions that we have received for bog development have been met.
Comment on this
All that I can tell the Deputy is that any scheme of that kind that we have had has already been met. So far as I know there is nothing outstanding.
Comment on this
So far as this Vote is concerned, and so far as the Office of Public Works is concerned, I can tell the Deputy that everything we have been asked to do in relation to bogs has been done. The Deputy raised the wildly original matter of coastal roads.
Comment on this
We are spending £400,000 on roads this year, and are giving a preference to tourist roads in every possible case. You could spend £10,000,000 on them, but would the Deputy be prepared to vote the cost for them?
Comment on this
You would not get £10,000,000 out of income-tax by increasing it. With regard to the questions raised by Deputy Bartlett in relation to the Aran Islands, the Deputy knows that in that matter our hearts are very soft. Anything we can do with reason for those people, because they are all practically in black areas, is done automatically; but whenever I am asked for a pier it is always in the one place in which fishing is required, and I actually have gone to places where I found all the currachs from hundreds of miles around collected to prove the goodness of the case. They do not appear at any time except when I am there. All I can say is that we do all that kind of marine work that is possible very willingly.
There are two other questions with which I shall deal briefly. The House will have noticed that in the introduction I did not say anything on the subject of Rhynana. I deliberately avoided that subject, except to the extent of giving that financial information which enabled everybody to raise the whole question if they willed. It was because, in my opinion, no useful purpose was going to be served——
Comment on this
Oh, no. Because I deliberately exercised all the restraint which I thought was right and proper in the matter. Deputy Anthony last night spoke of the men in Rhynana as miserable wretches, driven back like dogs. He would not treat a dog like that, he said. That is the atmosphere which has been injected into this matter. I am perfectly sure that there is no man in Rhynana who recognises himself as a miserable wretch or as driven back to anything.
Comment on this
That is the information, at any rate. Let the Parliamentary Secretary read my speech.
Comment on this
I have the Deputy's speech. The Deputy said he was acting on certain information and he told us that it was limited. He then went on to say, broadly speaking, that if that was true, then, these were miserable wretches treated like dogs. It is because that propaganda has got loose that the Deputy believes all that.
Comment on this
Yes, more than on the spot. It is said that this strike was started by gross underpayment and that the men were forced into the strike by economic pressure and forced back by economic pressure. There never was a strike in history with the starting, the maintaining, or the stopping of which economic pressure had less to do. That strike was a tactical strike, organised from outside —by a section of men who were working there, but principally from outside —and run under the impression that this was a rich international corporation which was exploiting them. That is what the men were told.
Comment on this
That is not true. I challenge the Parliamentary Secretary to quote me as saying it at any time in any place.