We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 10.—Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 329–518 of 518. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

"An international transatlantic transoceanic"—trans what? We had weeks of it.

Comment on this

Give us the quotation now.

Comment on this

The men were left under that impression——

Comment on this

What about the quotation?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy O'Grady to give you the quotation.

Comment on this

They were also left under the impression that a very short strike would be effective.

Comment on this

Who told them that also?

Comment on this

Go down and tell the men in Rhynana that they were not told this and that they did not believe this.

Comment on this

Who told them?

Comment on this

I know what they were told. They tell me what they were told.

Comment on this

Who told them?

Comment on this

Their leaders.

Comment on this

Who are they? The Parliamentary Secretary is hedging again.

Comment on this

I am not hedging at all.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

They were also under the impression that they were in a highly good tactical position for a strike, that this Government was under commitments in the matter of time, and all the rest of it, and that striking at that particular time would be very effective. None of those things was true.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has made an allegation against Deputy Hogan. I submit that he should either substantiate it or withdraw it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I did not hear any allegation.

Comment on this

He accused Deputy Hogan of having said certain things to the workers.

Comment on this

Which Deputy Hogan stated was untrue.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to withdraw his statement?

Comment on this

No, I am not withdrawing anything.

Comment on this

I call your attention, Sir, to the fact that the procedure in this House prescribes that when a statement of the kind is made and when a Deputy denies it, the statement is withdrawn. May I say, with very great respect, that I have heard you rule time and again that a Deputy's declaration that a certain statement was untrue meant that the statement should be withdrawn?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A Deputy's word as to what he actually did say is always accepted in this House.

Comment on this

If the Deputy says he did not say it, I will accept it. All I can say is that it was said at meetings at which the Deputy was present.

Comment on this

Even if that were true, it is different.

Comment on this

I am taking it that there was a responsible organisation running these things and that they were not going to run away from things said publicly on platforms.

Comment on this

Something very like it was said in the Dáil.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Parliamentary Secretary, but I wish to say that I do not want a withdrawal of any statement which the Parliamentary Secretary makes in respect of me. If withdrawals are made, they are made in deference to the House rather than to me. I did not say what the Parliamentary Secretary alleges I did say and I did not at any time tell the men that the position was of tactical advantage to them.

Comment on this

I did not say the Deputy did.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to be fair in debate, he ought to substantiate his statement by quotations from my remarks, either in the local press or anywhere else.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look up his own speech when he was opening he will find that he went as far as he could to suggest that this was an international piece of property.

Comment on this

I quoted the Acting Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Education.

Comment on this

None of those statements, by whomsoever made, was true. This aerodrome is the property of this State; every single penny that is spent on it is spent by this State, and by no one else.

Comment on this

And wages should be paid.

Comment on this

We are dealing with the mere question of whether or not it belonged to this State.

Comment on this

Is that bogey gone?

Comment on this

That bogey is gone and that bogey was at the root of the strike. It was also alleged that men were being paid four or five times as much on the building of other aerodromes which were part of this business, and that was not true. It was also alleged that this Government was going to be recouped, that the money which was being spent on this was actually going to be refunded.

Comment on this

Again I ask for quota tions.

Comment on this

I will give you quotations.

Comment on this

Give them now when making the charges.

Comment on this

The statement was made, and made by a leader of the strikers ——

Comment on this

Give quotations when making the charge.

Comment on this

I am making the charge, and the mere fact that I give the quotation will not alter it.

Comment on this

No, but it will prove it.

Comment on this

There is no question at all about it. It is made in writing. The suggestion also is that those people were driven by economic pressure. The thing which causes economic pressure is when men are thrown out of an existing and established trade, men who have large elements of dependency, and who have no alternative economic background. How does that apply to Rhynana? This was not an old-established business out of which they had been thrown.

Comment on this

They were starving.

Comment on this

It was a sporadic enterprise brought in artificially. It could have been interrupted without explanation or complaint at any time. It could have been put anywhere else without explanation or complaint.

Comment on this

Rob the poor because they are poor!

Comment on this

We are dealing simply with the question of whether economic pressure caused the strike. Let us get the economic background. This is a farming area in which the valuation per head of the agricultural population is £7 15s. With the exception of the richest part of County Dublin there is no higher agricultural valuation in the country. What was the economic position of the men themselves? The total number of men on the unemployment register previous to the time at which we started was 11. At the time the strike took place, when somewhere between 450 and 500 men came out, the largest number of men in our employment who had ever been on the unemployment register was 58. About 10 per cent. of the total number of employed people had ever been heard of on the unemployment register.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

Bosh!

Comment on this

I have got the list.

Comment on this

They struck for fun!

Comment on this

71 per cent. of them were single men, and the rate at which they were being paid was higher than any rate they had ever earned at that kind of occupation in that area.

Comment on this

They never built an aerodrome in that area before.

Comment on this

Why did you pay them 35/- at all?

Comment on this

We are dealing with the point that Deputy Anthony was told that those people were miserable wretches, driven by economic pressure. I am pointing out that the area was rich and comfortable, and when the strike started 70 men in one village went straight back into employment on their own land or on the land of their relatives. In a fortnight I traced 120 men into paid employment.

Comment on this

That must have been disappointing.

Comment on this

Oh, no. The Deputy will see the effect in a moment. I traced over 120 men into paid employment— sometimes higher paid employment.

Comment on this

What happened the other 380?

Comment on this

Over half the men went straight into employment. The number of men on that scheme—and this is my complaint about it—who could have been subjected to economic pressure was so small that with the slightest possible pre-vision, with the slightest possible organisation on the part of those who were responsible for the strike, with the slightest possible assistance from the Labour Party who pledged their support to them, no economic pressure of any kind could ever have been exercised upon them.

Comment on this

Why did you give them 3/- extra?

Comment on this

We are getting off the question very rapidly. I am perfectly satisfied that however long that strike lasted, within any reason, there was no necessity for any man to act under economic pressure. It could have been properly looked after, but it was not.

Comment on this

We did not conduct it rightly?

Comment on this

You did not conduct it rightly, I quite agree. You let them down every single time.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan is a bad boy. The Parliamentary Secretary should have been running the strike.

Comment on this

If I had been running it, no man would have had to fall on the ground of economic pressure.

Comment on this

We will get him the next time there is a strike at Rhynana.

Comment on this

It was not run properly.

Comment on this

They got 3/-. anyway.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan said:—

"This is a great national service, we are told. It is not alone a State service but a national service. It is not alone a national service, it is an international service; and we have acting together, as I mentioned a moment ago, a mighty Empire, a powerful Republic, and a powerful Dominion."

Comment on this

Is it not right?

Comment on this

That confirms your charge?

Comment on this

Then we move on——

Comment on this

No wonder you would.

Comment on this

Are you sorry you read it?

Comment on this

We were told there was no negotiation; that we treated the men with contempt.

Comment on this

The Minister is getting very restive.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

About a week or ten days after the strike started the whole of the men were collected together in Rhynana for the purpose of having their wages paid to them. All the men were there; all their leaders were there. The properly appointed and accredited officer of the Board of Works, the engineer in charge, sent for the chairman of the Union and said: "Have you anything to say to me?" The answer was: "I have nothing to say to you."

Comment on this

Did deputations ask to be received? Were they refused?

Comment on this

The answer was "I have nothing to say to you". Were the men told that? Publicity is objected to. It is suggested there was something wrong in the publication—I think it was over the radio—which is specially in the Deputy's mind, of a letter of mine in answer to the chairman of the committee.

Comment on this

The chairman of the Union.

Comment on this
Mr. Flynn

Yes, the Union, though it was in the name of a committee, not of the Union, that the strike was started. It was a committee gave us notice, not a union.

Comment on this

They were all there.

Comment on this

We are dealing now with the question of publicity. Something very wrong was done in publishing that letter. Why was it published? Because it was only written incidentally to the chairman of that Union. It was written to the men on strike, and they did not get to know about it until it was published.

Comment on this

Bosh. Your friends across the water got it.

Comment on this

Yes, our friends across the water got it after that same committee had telegraphed to Lindberg.

Comment on this

He is a director of it.

Comment on this

Our friends across the water had got it then.

Comment on this

That riled you.

Comment on this

Not a bit. I am only asking why you complain of publicity after they had declared through Lindberg to the world that there would not be any aerodrome built unless we gave way to that committee. Then Deputy Hogan invented a menu for the men in the huts. He discovered that it would cost 17/6 for food, and he alleged that he got it from the horse's mouth.

Comment on this

So I did.

Comment on this

I think that was the expression. The horse might have told him, but no one else did.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

I took your 15/3 and dealt with it.

Comment on this

We will take these things gradually. We are dealing with the credibility of a witness. The Deputy got it from the horse's mouth. No officer of the Board of Works communicated directly or indirectly that information to the Deputy. No officer of the Board of Works contributed that information to anybody, and the particular menu which he read out was a figment of his own imagination.

Comment on this

That is a direct charge that I misinformed the House on a matter. I ask if that is in order. He says that what I told the House was a figment of my own imagination.

Comment on this

I propose to prove it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be very difficult for the Chair to decide whether a particular menu which was presented to this House as being given to the men in Rhynana contained correct figures. The Parliamentary Secretary and the Deputy may differ radically as to the purchasing power of money.

Comment on this

He said that I invented the menu, that it was a figment of my own imagination.

Comment on this

We will amend that and say he got it from the horse's mouth.

Comment on this

It is not the horse's mouth we are getting it from now.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will stay quiet it will come out.

Comment on this

It is not the Board of Works, but the contractors, the suppliers.

Comment on this

No contractor or anyone else gave that information.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

He had not got it. There was no such menu in existence at any time. Let us come down to the precise and special portion of that menu of which the Deputy is the father, mother, and elder brother.

Comment on this

There was no sausage in it.

Comment on this

We will deal with the sausage. The Deputy has discovered now that there was no sausage. There was one finger of sausage which has been held up in the face of this country for the last three months.

Comment on this

There was not—that is the worst of it.

Comment on this

Last week it was divided in four.

Comment on this

There was not.

Comment on this

There was no sausage. That sausage is the invention of the Deputy. Let me get down to facts. Nobody, neither the contractor nor any officer of the Board of Works, ever gave the Deputy that information, wherever he got it.

Comment on this

If there was no menu in existence, why did you tell me in the Dáil that 15/3 was the cost?

Comment on this

There is a menu in existence; that menu came out of the horse's mouth. Now we will deal with the 15/3. The 17/6 menu did not exist —there was no such charge as 17/6. There was a series of three standard meals over seven days——

Comment on this

There was a menu?

Comment on this

——which cost 12/3, plus 3/- for lodging. Now the 17/6 disappears and there comes the actual authentic 12/3—quite a big difference. I took the trouble—it was a very great deal of trouble—actually to find out the value of the Deputy's menu, the one that came out of the horse's mouth. It is not 17/6, it is not 15/3, it is not 12/3, but, as near as I can make out, it is 10/6.

Comment on this

That is the Mountjoy. menu.

Comment on this

What we are concerned with is that it was the Deputy's menu. He said it cost 17/6. In other words, the Deputy was only 70 per cent. out, which, of course, was a very mild allowance to make for any statement of the Deputy's.

Comment on this

Why did they get 3/- per week of a rise?

Comment on this

We are getting back to that—anything but the subject we are discussing.

Comment on this

Was the Parliamentary Secretary's menu 15/3?

Comment on this

No, 12/3?

Comment on this

Did you not make that statement in the House?

Comment on this

No, I did not. I said 12/3, plus 3/- for lodging.

Comment on this

Is not that 15/3?

Comment on this

That is not a menu.

Comment on this

Out of the magnificent sum of 30/-, and that in a Christian country!

Comment on this

We are told that this union gave us adequate and proper notice and that it was a regular and proper union. They came along to us on the 7th February and told us that unless every man working on the ground became a member of the union all workmen would be withdrawn at ten o'clock the next day— 24 hours' notice for shutting down the whole scheme! When the men themselves, through their representatives, had arranged to return, these leaders came along and said they must not return and that they would not return and that there was no necessity for us to open the works because the men would not come unless and until it was made clear that no man would be allowed to work except a member of that union.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary ought to be fair and tell the story right.

Comment on this

That is the whole story.

Comment on this

It is not the whole story; it is not the story at all.

Comment on this

In other words, when the men were willing to return they tried to prevent them.

Comment on this

How could they?

Comment on this

They could not—that was it. By the way, we have been accused of strike-breaking.

Comment on this

Who are the mysterious leaders anyway?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has spoken about giving notice. Will he say if an application for an improvement in wages was received by the Department and refused, and that the strike notice was formally served?

Comment on this

Yes, by a union which never took a ballot of its men and gave us twenty-four hours' notice to create a strike.

Comment on this

And it lasted 11 weeks.

Comment on this

A union which has only one rule—that no ballot vote will be taken. No ballot vote was taken. If a ballot vote had been taken during the strike, the strike would have come to an end. The men were accused of being traitors, of treachery to their class and everything else, merely because they wanted a ballot vote to decide whether or not they would continue to strike.

Comment on this

Majority rule is a good thing sometimes.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, but not when it applies to a ballot vote.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

We have got the philosophy exactly. I am told that I am trying to break up unions and to prevent the right to strike. Here Deputy O'Brien tells us that the one standard rule is that no majority rule, by ballot vote, will be allowed in the unions which he controls.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

That is exactly the philosophy.

Comment on this

You quote badly.

Comment on this

No ballot vote in eleven weeks. Time after time the men asking for it, and no ballot vote.

Comment on this

You misquoted Deputy O'Brien, deliberately misquoted him.

Comment on this

Then we were told that we introduced blacklegs. The accusation can be easily made that no attempt was made by the Office of Public Works to bring that strike to an end. No attempt was made to break that strike. Does anybody suggest there was.

Comment on this

You tried every exchange round about.

Comment on this

We did not. We did not try to take on a single man, nor did we take on a single man.

Comment on this

Did the Minister for Industry and Commerce not refuse to do his duty? Did he not refuse to call a conference to settle it?

Comment on this

That does not constitute strike-breaking. It is alleged that we did everything to break the strike and brought in blacklegs.

Comment on this

You tried Limerick and Kilrush at all events.

Comment on this

I give the House a definite assurance that no attempt was made to recruit a single man during that period.

Comment on this

And I say that there was.

Comment on this

I say that is not true, and the Deputy, having made the allegation, can withdraw it now.

Comment on this

If these men had had the Labour support that was promised to them, they could have gone on indefinitely. I do not believe that this strike would ever have been broken by economic pressure. Look at the position. Quite a number of them farmers in the district who went straight away from the works to do their ordinary tillage operations which were interfered with.

Comment on this

Why would they need Labour support?

Comment on this

They did not need it.

Comment on this

I thought you said that they wanted it.

Comment on this

The whole point is this: were they broken by economic pressure? Any support given to them would have prevented their being broken by economic pressure.

Comment on this

That was your hope.

Comment on this

No, it was not. I was quite satisfied that they could not be broken by economic pressure. They were not broken by economic pressure. They were broken by common sense.

Comment on this

You will never be broken so.

Comment on this

No. I do not think that that can ever be used against me. What happened was this: the men recognised the position. They recognised that they had been led out on a strike at the very worst possible moment to start a strike, I mean from the point of view of winning.

Comment on this

Are you an expert on this?

Comment on this

Yes, I am. The technique of a strike is quite simple. It is a fight, in some sense. You should go out on strike at a time when your opponent does not want you to go out.

Comment on this

Strike while the iron is hot!

Comment on this

Oh, no, strike when the iron is cold. Then you should go out on strike on conditions under which the longer you stay out the more your opponent wants you to come back. Is that not so? Now, what happened?

Comment on this

That is how you carried on the economic war.

Comment on this

They went out at a time when they should have stayed to negotiate. They were two or three weeks there during which there was some pressure to keep them on but once they were out, every day and every week that passed made it less necessary or less useful to bring them back in a hurry. In other words, they were led out by leaders who did not know what they were doing and when they were led out they were deserted by those leaders and left in the lunch.

Comment on this

Was there any mistake that they did not make?

Comment on this

I do not think there was any mistake that these leaders did not make.

Comment on this

Why did they get 3/-a week of a rise?

Comment on this

I shall tell you that in a moment. We are gradually coming to it. They were not driven out by economic pressure. Were they driven back by economic pressure? As far as a considerable number of them were concerned, they were men who had done their harvesting operations.

Comment on this

600 of them!

Comment on this

Not 600 of them but a very considerable proportion of them.

Comment on this

600 farmers?

Comment on this

I shall tell the House the truth exactly. When I speak of harvesting, I should, perhaps, say husbandry. It is rather curious that their critical necessity in relation to husbandry coincided exactly with our critical necessity. It was when we wanted to plough and sow that they wanted to plough and sow. They went and did their own ploughing and sowing and left us to do our ploughing and sowing. There has never been a strike in history which I think caused less distress in relation to the number engaged and the period for which it lasted.

Comment on this

And you will stand over that?

Comment on this

I wish to have it on record. I know of no strike which caused less distress,and any distress which was caused was due to the culpable mismanagement of those who led them out and deserted them. In the end the men decided that the longer they stayed out, the longer they would stay out; that there was no reason, in reason, why the strike should not last for ever. Remember this was work brought into that area. If the Government had abandoned it altogether, no one would have a grievance. If the Government had not put it there, no one would have a grievance. A big mass of artificial work had been created. They came into it from all sorts of places and they were very eager to get back to it, and eventually they decided to come back. Instead of staying out until they were—what-ever few of them were so concerned— in a state of economic pressure, they came back before that condition had arrived. It takes a good deal of wisdom to recognise that a position to which you have advanced is not tenable, and it takes a good deal of courage to abandon an untenable position before you are called upon to make any attempt to defend it.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

These men did. They went back unbroken. They did not go back as miserable wretches. They went back as a solid body—140 of them the first day, 160 of them the second day, 510 in three days.

Comment on this

All farmers!

Comment on this

No, a considerable portion of them farmers or farmers' relatives. Five hundred and ten of them went back in three days and then they started to negotiate. They offered good value in return. They were in a position to negotiate. They were not broken men. They were not a broken army, and they were not miserable wretches. They were men with self-respect. I respect the courage that was shown; and because they went back in that spirit, capable of negotiating, we were not merely willing but glad and anxious to help them in the matter. They have given something which is well worth the money going to be given them. They have given us a promise of good value for their wages, and we are satisfied. I commend the courage of the men who, abandoned by their leaders, betrayed by their advisers, in an abandoned and untenable position, went back, and fought forward to gain the position they have deserved.

Now we will take Collinstown. As everyone knows, the question at issue there is, whether or not a particular work was agricultural work or building work. We hold that it is agricultural work. I think £78,000 roughly has been spent at Collinstown up to the present. We found a field which was fairly well drained, and fairly level, but not as well drained and not as level as it required to be. When that £78,000 was spent we had still a field, and nothing but a field, and no one going over that field will be able to tell that anything has been spent there, apart from the road we put in during the last two or three weeks. The whole of the £78,000 was spent in reconditioning that field, and trying to grow grass on it. We recognise that during that particular period a wage which would be based on the agricultural wage would be the wage which would be paid. In so far as we recognise that there would be certain other activities, which might be controversial to a limited extent, and, in order to have complete freedom to transfer men from one job to another; and having regard to the fact that if we wanted a great many more men than are normally available in the district, we set the wage, not at the agricultural wage of 30/-, which was then the wage, but at the very much higher rate of 42/-. It has been alleged that we have been employing certain men who were better off than people who were not employed. What happened in Collinstown was this. We first took every man who was on the unemployment register, three, five or seven miles distant, and when it came to a further extension, before we absorbed any other man who was not on the register, we arranged that the option of coming to Collinstown should be given to every man within a radius of 15 miles. In other words, if ever an effort was made so that work went to necessitous people, it was in Collinstown. A strike took place and, in the end, we took back to work every single striker who applied, without any exception whatever, as far as I know. How there could be any cause of complaint on that ground I do not know.

It is alleged that there was an agreement in relation to Collinstown which we broke. There was no such agreement. There was never an agreement at any time to regard the agricultural work which was being done at Collinstown as building work. It was always recognised that there would be two stages in Collinstown, one in which the vast majority of the men working would be employed on agricultural work, and, therefore, could be paid upon the basis relating to agriculture; and that there would be another period, probably much more extensive, in which work done there in the form of building work and hangars would be obviously building, and of a non-agricultural character.

It was recognised that there would be a period in between, where predominantly agricultural work was turning over to predominantly building work. It was decided from the beginning that the wage paid when it was predominantly agricultural and unskilled labour should be 42/-. It was decided when the work was predominantly of a non-agricultural character that it would be done at ordinary contract rates, under the ordinary fair wage building clauses, and, at the period which would be between the two, when the number of agricultural labourers had fallen to a level which might be relatively unimportant compared to the total, that we would not have two rates of wages. What has happened to Collinstown? A total of something about 1,000 men has sunk to somewhere about 80, of whom I should say three-quarters are engaged on purely agricultural work still, and a certain number on road work. I think the building contracts are let, and I should imagine that building will start there in a few weeks. At that time, it is obvious the number of agricultural workers will have fallen so small that it will not be reasonable or convenient to pay them a different rate to the others, and, at that time, the two rates can be assimilated. I see no difficulty and no cause of controversy or trouble in the change over.

The plan we are working on is the plan worked on from the beginning, first, agricultural rates, and eventually building rates. During this little interregnum of the change over, there will be a gradual assimilation of the two rates. There will be a measure of increase in the rate, not on the ground that the work is not agricultural, not on the ground that anything has been done that should not be done, but purely and simply for the purpose of merging these two periods quietly into one another. I am very proud and very glad to have seen the action taken by the men at Rhynana. I think the State is going to receive full value for the increases which have been given, and I hope the same spirit of reasonableness, common sense and courage, which was shown in the negotiations which came successfully to an end there will continue in Collinstown, as the best basis for the mutual cooperation of the State and its workmen in producing a thoroughly national asset in property at Rhynana and Collinstown.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration."

Tá 31
·
Níl 53
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?