We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Industrial Alcohol Bill, 1938—Committee.

Contributions 1–146 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Industrial Alcohol Bill 1938
Lapsed

No. 14 of 1938 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

In line 30, to delete the word "forty" and substitute the word "fifty-five."

In the original Bill the expression "industrial alcohol" was defined as meaning ethyl alcohol, whether denatured or not, which has been distilled or rectified to a strength of not less than 55 degrees overproof. That strength has been reduced to 40 degrees in the Bill before us now, and, though this matter was raised on the Second Stage, we could not get from the Minister what appeared to be a fully satisfactory explanation of the change. We, therefore, afford him by this amendment an opportunity of giving us a somewhat more detailed explanation of why it was deemed expedient to lower the proof in the definition of "industrial alcohol."

Comment on this

I was under the impression—apparently, a wrong impression— that I had given an adequate and most lucid explanation. The strength was fixed at 55 degrees above proof in the original Bill in order to exclude the possibility of whiskey distillers requiring a licence under it. We were informed by the Revenue Commissioners that whiskey distillers occasionally distil whiskey slightly above 50 degrees overproof. By fixing the figure at 55, we placed ourselves in a position whereby only one firm, other than the industrial alcohol factories, would require a licence—the Cork Yeast Company. Now, however, we think we can exclude the whiskey distillers by inserting the words "other than the pot-still process" in the definition of "agricultural alcohol." By bringing the strength down to 40 degrees overproof, we secure to the industrial alcohol factories the manufacture of industrial alcohol used in certain commercial process by manufacturing chemists in the production of perfumes. The manufacture of that spirit in our factories would, in our opinion, be a profitable sideline to the main activities of the company. That is the main reason why the change is being made. The effect of the change is to secure that the degree of control for which the Bill provides over the manufacture and use of industrial alcohol will apply to all forms of industrial alcohol. We have retained the position by which a distiller will not require a licence and the only other firm which is likely to require a licence would, in any event, under the earlier definition, with a higher definition, require it. The idea is to secure that industrial alcohol used for commercial purposes will be brought within the definition so that the possibility of selling that alcohol will be secured to this company.

Comment on this

I do not know what relation industrial alcohol bears to that type of alcohol normally consumed as whiskey, gin or brandy, but the Minister might tell us now what proof the stuff will be which it is proposed to sell to the people who will actually mix it through the petrol. Is there any ideal proof at which that should be done? So far as I am aware, if you distil alcohol, you can reduce the proof by adding water to it. If I want to reduce whiskey which is delivered at 40 degrees overproof to the statutory level at which it is normally sold for consumption—24 degrees under-proof—I add a certain calculated amount of distilled water to the whiskey. I cannot see how it can make much difference to the alcohol factories at what proof they produce the alcohol. What is relevant is the proof at which they will sell the alcohol at the fixed price. The Minister has told us that he expects the Industrial Alcohol Company to sell industrial alcohol at 3/- a gallon. When he says that, does he mean that that will be industrial alcohol of 43 degrees overproof?

Comment on this

Absolute alcohol—pure alcohol.

Comment on this

Of what proof?

Comment on this

I cannot say.

Comment on this

I do not want to raise any difficulties. I differ profoundly from the Minister as to this industrial alcohol project, but let us get down to the technicalities of the question. We are to have industrial alcohol of 40 degrees over-proof. It has been represented to the Minister that that will be sold to the petrol companies at 3/- and he has given his approval to that proposal. We do not know at what proof it is going to be sold. If industrial alcohol is identical with whiskey, gin or rum, you would reduce that industrial alcohol to proof by adding spring water to it. Does the Minister understand from the Industrial Alcohol Company that they are going to sell industrial alcohol to the petrol-mixers at proof, or at what degree over-proof, because, until he knows that, he does not know what proportion of the commodity they are going to get 3/- a gallon for will consist of spring water.

Comment on this

The maximum amount of water which can be in the alcohol is .2 of 1 per cent. 99.8 per cent. of what is supplied must be pure alcohol.

Comment on this

I am in this difficulty that if I were reducing whiskey 15 degrees, it would take far more than .8 per cent. of volume to reduce it. You have by definition reduced industrial alcohol from 55 degrees overproof to 40 degrees overproof. If it is possible to produce industrial alcohol at 55 degrees over-proof, industrial alcohol at 40 degrees overproof has prima facie a large percentage of distilled water. Does the Minister propose to raise the proof of that distilled alcohol before it is sold to the mixers and, if so, to what proof is it going to be raised?

Comment on this

The definition has nothing to do with the strength of the alcohol to be produced in the factories and sold to petrol consumers. The only form in which industrial alcohol could be used for motor purposes is as absolute alcohol. It is desirable there should be no water whatever, and, in fact, the only margin allowed is the very small one I have indicated; but if the Deputy will study the Bill, he will see that certain restrictions are placed upon the purchase of industrial alcohol by anybody in the country. The reason this definition of industrial alcohol is inserted is in connection with these provisions in the Bill, and it is designed to secure that industrial alcohol used for commercial purposes and which may, and does, contain a high percentage of water will nevertheless come subject to these provisions so that a market will be secured for these factories.

Comment on this

So these factories are intended to produce two separate articles. One is alcohol unadulterated with any water, so far as it is humanly possible, and the other industrial alcohol for chemical purposes which will be sold at a certain ascertained proof.

Comment on this

At whatever proof the users will require.

Comment on this

I understand that they have given the Minister no particular undertaking in regard to the price which will be charged for the industrial alcohol which is to be used by the chemists?

Comment on this

It will have to be sold at the commercial price, whatever it is.

Comment on this

Imports of that will be permitted?

Comment on this

It is subject to control, but the Deputy can take it that industrial alcohol used for commercial purposes of that kind is generally sold at a higher price than we will be charging the petrol distributors. The average price, if my memory is correct, is well over 3/-.

Comment on this

This is going to be a most extraordinary position. If you are going to require these people to sell absolute alcohol at 3/- a gallon and then permit them to add, by volume, 20 per cent. of pure water and authorise them to charge substantially more for that water and alcohol than is charged for the pure alcohol, a most extraordinary situation arises, which, I think, requires careful consideration. I have at least directed the Minister's attention to that aspect of the position.

The second question that arises on this definition is this: Let us assume that this company is going to deliver to the petrol mixers industrial alcohol, or, as defined by the Minister, pure alcohol. Can the Minister tell us now if it is true that while it is possible to construct a highly efficient petrol engine, and while it is possible to construct a highly efficient alcohol engine, it is not possible to construct a highly efficient engine that will burn both fuels? If you insist on the consumer in this country burning pure alcohol——

Comment on this

We have no intention of doing so. I do not know that it is practicable.

Comment on this

If you insist on forcing the consumer here to use petrol which contains a considerable percentage of industrial alcohol in an engine which was constructed for the combustion of petrol, the resultant wear and tear on that engine will be substantially increased. That is a matter of fact.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

The Deputy might wait a moment. All I am asking the Minister is whether he has put that issue before his technical advisers, and if he has, what is the advice tendered to him by those technical advisers.

Comment on this

What will be sold is a blend which is quite capable of being utilised in an ordinary petrol engine and is, in fact, a much superior fuel to unblended petrol.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister never put this question to his advisers?

Comment on this

Nobody ever suggested that we should burn 100 per cent. pure alcohol in any engine.

Comment on this

Is it true that while it it possible to make a highly efficient petrol engine and a highly efficient alcohol engine, it is not possible to make a highly efficient engine which will burn a blend of these two fuels? Has the Minister any technical advice on that subject?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I should be glad to hear it.

Comment on this

A very slight adjustment in the ordinary petrol engine will permit of its burning a blend, and burning a blend that will give a much more efficient performance than as a petrol engine. As Deputy Moore mentioned on the previous day, the highest grade of motor fuel known involves a blend of petrol and industrial alcohol.

Comment on this

Does the superior efficiency depend on the ethyl lead which it is proposed to add to this mixture or on the alcohol?

Comment on this

It is very hard to say to what it is attributable. The blend itself happens to have that efficiency.

Comment on this

Does the blend referred to, ethyl alcohol, involve the introduction of ethyl lead?

Comment on this

What is this ethyl?

Comment on this

It is a definition of industrial alcohol. I do not know why it is so called.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that there is such a thing as ethyl petrol. It is produced by the addition of a substance, the name of which perhaps Deputy Moore can tell us. Perhaps the Deputy would tell us what is the substance one adds to petrol to produce ethyl petrol?

Comment on this

Menthanol.

Comment on this

Ethyl alcohol is alcohol produced from vegetables.

Comment on this

And has no relation to the ethyl contained in the ethyl petrol?

Comment on this

Might I suggest that Deputy Dillon has the experience of several of the most important countries in the world on which to base a conclusion with regard to this matter? It was pointed out in the debate on the British Budget, for instance, that the consumption of industrial alcohol in England by motorists has risen from less than 200,000 gallons in 1931 to 8,000,000 in the current year. In Italy there is a 15 per cent. mixture. The Deputy knows that the French engineers are not altogether contemptible in the world of engineering and since it was discovered French motorists have been using industrial alcohol as a blend. Of course, he knows that that is the case in Germany, too, to the extent of 10 or 12 per cent., so that why our Minister should go to all this suggested trouble I do not know. As the Minister has remarked, it is admitted that for aeroplane engines it has a high octane quality—do not ask me what octane means—and for ordinary motors it is supposed to be a strong anti-knock spirit. Altogether so far from there being any disadvantage, there is an advantage to motorists.

Comment on this

I raised this point on the Second Reading, and I am sure the Minister has a very satisfactory explanation, but to me it does look strange that moneys which arise from an enterprise of this kind, an enterprise which is altogether apart from the ordinary work of the Government, should be paid into the general Exchequer and used as ordinary revenue. The same question arises under Section 13, sub-section (2). I would imagine that it would give a false idea of revenue, for instance, if in the receipts issued by the Minister for Finance from time to time, there is included any substantial sum from such a source as that, seeing that those moneys are not really general Government moneys at all, but are altogether exceptional, and are not intended to have anything to do with the ordinary activities of the Government.

Comment on this

I do not know that the matter arises on this section, whatever about any other. This section provides that the Minister for Finance may lend a sum not exceeding £1,500 to the company to defray its formation expenses, and that whatever money is repaid to the Minister for Finance will be put into the Exchequer. I do not know what else we should do with it. The money is going from revenue, and going back into the Central Fund of the State in the ordinary way. There is no question here of realising an asset.

Comment on this

No, but it is repayment of moneys advanced for a capital purpose, for a purpose altogether outside the ordinary activities of the Government. Such a repayment is to appear in the accounts of the Government as an ordinary receipt.

Comment on this

I congratulate Deputy Moore. He is becoming a financial purist at last.

Comment on this

I think most financial purists strongly support the idea upon which this State works—the idea of having one Central Fund into which and out of which all Government receipts and expenses are paid.

Comment on this

I do not think it ever yet dawned on the poor Minister for Industry and Commerce what financial integrity means, particularly in the matter of national finance. The Minister for Industry and Commerce simply does not know what Deputy Moore is talking about.

Comment on this

I think that is the Deputy's dilemma.

Comment on this

He does not realise the difference between capital and current expenditure. This does not strike him as incongruous at all. His solution of those problems is that you mix them all up together; you borrow and you tax, and whenever you have a deficit you call the deficit capital expenditure, and borrow for it. At the end of the year, when you find you have borrowed too much, you call it a revenue surplus, and have three cheers at a public meeting at College Green. Of course, Deputy Moore is perfectly right. This money is issuing forth from the Treasury for a capital purpose——

Comment on this

From the Central Fund, yes.

Comment on this

——and as capital expenditure, expenditure in regard to which the Minister for Finance would put his hand upon his heart and say "No one will challenge my right to borrow for this item of expenditure in as much as it is clearly a capital sum." But suppose he borrowed this, as he might legitimately do on the representation that it was a capital expenditure, Deputy Moore points out that under the terms of this Bill that will come trickling back into the Treasury as a casual receipt, and appear as revenue, to be used as revenue—a thoroughly unsound practice. But as it amounts only to £1,500, and as the Minister for Finance has been doing this in respect of millions for the last six years, why Deputy Moore should start tossing on his peaceful pillow now I cannot imagine. He has slept sweetly through this performance for six Budgets. Why the industrial alcohol Bill should start him off I cannot imagine, and I sympathise with the Minister's display of embarrassment and dismay at this assault upon his flank. But Deputy Moore is right.

Comment on this

As Deputy Dillon knows so much more than all the rest of us I am astonished that he wastes his time coming in here at all. It must be a terrible effort on his part to come down to our level.

Comment on this

It is; I agree.

Comment on this

Does it ever occur to the Deputy that he might be wrong? Did that prospect ever dawn on him? Did he ever in his wildest moments look forward to the day when he might make a mistake, when he might say something which was not correct or jump to a conclusion that was a wrong conclusion? There is a very rude awakening waiting for him.

Comment on this

Not so long as the Minister is in disagreement with me.

Comment on this

But he is not quite so clever as he thinks he is. Perhaps if he takes the trouble to study in the Official Reports the remarks he has just made he will realise that this long anticipated error of judgment, this one mistake against which he has been training himself all his life, has happened at last. He is wrong. We have in this country the practice of maintaining a Central Fund into which all revenue from all sources is paid and out of which all expenses for all purposes are met. In other countries they have a Capital Fund. They keep a separate fund into which and out of which purely revenue receipts and revenue expenses are paid, and a Capital Fund for the purposes of which the Minister for Finance borrows, and which is used for the purpose of defraying capital expenditure as authorised by law. That does not happen to be the practice here. But in this particular case it would not matter. The transaction under this section will be completed well within the financial year. The advancing of £1,500 to defray the formation expenses of this company, and the repayment of that amount, will all occur within a very short period. Consequently it is not necessary to go into deep financial theories, however entertaining they may be to Deputy Dillon, in order to understand precisely what this section means. Deputy Moore's point would probably arise in another connection. I think if he studies the financial statement made by the Minister for Finance this year he will find that a very large part of it dealt with that precise matter, and justified my preference for the practice of this State as compared with others.

Comment on this

I think in fact you are borrowing some of this industrial alcohol money.

Comment on this

The whole of it is being borrowed.

Comment on this

That gives added weight to Deputy Moore's point.

Comment on this

There is no question of the repayment of that money. There is a question of the payment of interest on it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

In sub-section (3), line 1, page 5, to delete the word "five" and substitute the word "three".

This amendment is designed to reduce the limit beyond which the Minister may not go without coming back to Parliament for further authority. Under Section 10, sub-section (2), the total amount which may be expended by the Minister for Finance in the acquisition of shares of the company shall not exceed £500,000, less the nominal value of the shares to be issued to him under the next following section. It appears to us from the figures afforded by the Minister for Industry and Commerce so far in the course of the debate that a sufficient sum for the present would be £300,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy is merely £56,000 out, but that is not unnatural in his case.

Comment on this

Well, we would be prepared to meet the Minister in that matter if an additional £56,000 would meet his point of view, but we object to leaving in his hands—or indeed in the hands of any Minister—the right to commit the State to an expenditure of a further £150,000 without coming back to this House with some kind of a report on the progress of the enterprise.

I would remind the Minister that these amendments were drawn before the Money Resolution was discussed and that we had to arrive at as good an approximation of the figures as we could get. The Minister says that this leaves him £56,000 short. Is he sure of that? Because the amount provided for in sub-section (3) of Section 10 is governed by Section 11, and the Minister is to receive shares in respect of the money that he has paid to the company for "the acquisition of any land, easement, profit á prendre, or other right, the construction of distilleries, rectifying plants and other necessary works and the purchase of machinery, plant and equipment.” Those purposes having been financed by the Minister, the Minister is entitled to transfer the assets to the company and, on his certificate, to get shares issued to him. That represents £266,000 of the sum of £356,000 to which the Minister referred. Therefore the Minister will have allotted to him £266,000 in shares at once. Section 10 operates to give him the right to subscribe for £234,000 in addition to that. Our amendment would restrict him to subscribing for only £44,000 in excess of that allocation of shares. He told us that the amount required for working capital was £30,000. That would leave him a surplus of £14,000 over the actual requirements of working capital for such other incidentals as he mentioned. Will that not meet the Minister's requirements?

Comment on this

I think it is much wiser to fix the nominal capital of the company, that is the total amount the Minister for Finance may invest in the shares of the company, at a figure reasonably in excess of the known requirements. It is known that the Minister will have to get under Section 11 shares to the value of the capital expenditure already incurred. Furthermore, the company will be in immediate need of additional capital, the total amount of the expenditure to date, and the immediate capital needs for working capital required being, as I said, £356,000. It is not likely that any substantial additional capital expenditure beyond that will be undertaken immediately. Some minor capital expenditure may be required, but if a substantial expansion in the capital expenditure of the company should be contemplated, then it will be necessary to come to the Minister for Finance, and the Minister will have to come to the Dáil. There is no taking away of the powers of the Dáil here, because the Minister for Finance has no money for the purpose unless the Dáil makes that money available and, consequently, the Dáil will have an opportunity of expressing its opinion on the matter at any time. But, even if the money were voted by the Dáil, the amount invested in the shares of the company could not exceed £500,000 without an amendment of the Act.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Dillon's point, that so far as this particular Act is concerned, it gives the Minister power to expend £500,000. The case he puts up against that is that we should limit our expenditure now to £300,000. If further money is required it is reasonable to come to the Dáil for the other £200,000 if and when it is required.

Comment on this

We would have to come with amending legislation.

Comment on this

Yes, for the extra money. At the moment the Minister's case is that he is committed to an expenditure of £266,000.

Comment on this

£356,000.

Comment on this

There are some items which I would be disposed to ignore.

Comment on this

Has he not the power to borrow under Section 15 to buy shares?

Comment on this

I do not see why, for example, we should make provision in this Bill for payment of interest on the money. Assuming the Minister puts £500,000 into it, portion of the provision which the Minister announced to us this evening was to pay interest. There is an ample sum allowed in the £300,000, with the £30,000 for working capital, and £4,000 for such expenditure as the Minister indicated. If further money is required what is the objection to coming to the Dáil for it instead of getting a blank cheque for the whole sum?

Comment on this

It is a blank cheque up to £500,000, of which £356,000 is to meet capital expenditure. The margin is the difference between them. That is not an unreasonable margin to allow in the case of a commercial enterprise of this kind. We cannot have a commercial enterprise of this kind in the position that it cannot undertake any capital expenditure whatever without having further legislation promoted. That would be involved if we were to limit the provision in Section 10 to the amount known to be necessary, the amount already expended or involved in the immediate operations of the company. Some margin beyond that is required, and the margin suggested is, I think, not unreasonable if this enterprise is to be run with the same freedom of action that a commercial enterprise would require. It seems to me that we would be better under this system than to work as we are working at present with everything being done by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and in his name, even though in practice he delegates his function to an advisory board. That system has not proved satisfactory, and it is never likely to prove satisfactory, as the whole machinery of a Government Department is not suitable to running a commercial enterprise. That is why we are going away from that system to another system which will set up a company which will be as independent of the Government as any other company, apart from the fact that the Minister for Finance will be its only shareholder. We think that that company should be given precisely the same liberty which an ordinary commercial undertaking would have if it is to work successfully as we hope a commercial company would.

Comment on this

The most the Minister can make a case for is £356,000, assuming there is to be no more capital development than at present. The Act under which he has been operating up to date is the 1934 Act, I think, and his estimate of expenditure from that period amounts to £356,000. That is the amount——

Comment on this

That has been spent.

Comment on this

That has been expended, including £30,000 for working capital, plus £4,000 for some other purpose, plus interest that has to be earned, plus royalties, and making no allowance whatever for any profits which may be anticipated from this particular development. In these circumstances, we put it that this new company should not have, or any nominee of the Minister should not have £144,000 to play with or experiment with. In fact, we consider that he would be supplied fairly well with £266,000, £30,000 as working capital and £4,000 in addition, and that when any further development is required we ought to hear about it. We ought to know what the company is doing and if they get this £500,000, then they can go on spending it either on the factories they have got or buying or constructing other factories.

Comment on this

The company will not have £500,000.

Comment on this

I know, but the Minister has power to give it, the Minister is a trustee in that respect. The Dáil is asked to give too much money away even to the Minister's nominees in this case—to give £144,000, plus interest and royalties and everything else and to assume that the company will make no money. If my recollection is correct, the Minister stated that we are in a position to make money from this industrial alcohol, selling it at 3/- per gallon. I do not know whether they have charged that price up to this to petrol consumers but whatever price they have charged, I suppose they have made provision for a profit. I do think that the Dáil ought not to give the Minister, or whatever officers he may have, more than this £356,000.

Comment on this

The Minister changes his feet briskly. When caught on one foot he slips lightly over to the other. He said that there was no necessity for alarm, no necessity for the amendment, because, while there was power to issue additional capital if this section passed in its present form, the Minister would have to come back to the Dáil before he could buy further shares, but Section 15 exonerates him from any such necessity. Under Section 15 he can borrow money without further reference to the Dáil of any kind. Say that we authorise the company to issue capital up to £500,000. We authorise the Minister to borrow for investment in industrial alcohol. Having subscribed that £500,000, the company can then proceed to borrow on debentures without limit. There is no limit to its borrowing power under debenture, and the Minister has an unlimited power of guarantee. They can borrow £1,000,000 under Section 14, and the Minister can guarantee it. Is that not so? Under Section 14:

whenever the company proposes to issue any debentures the Minister for Finance may, if he thinks fit, guarantee in such manner and form as he may think proper the due payment by the company in accordance with the terms of such debentures of the principal moneys and interest secured by such debentures.

I see no limitation there at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy will see it in the Schedule to the Bill—the conditions to which the company has to conform.

Comment on this

What is the limit of the debentures the company may issue?

Comment on this

They may not exceed the paid-up capital of the company.

Comment on this

If we pass this section in its present form we not only authorise the Minister for Finance to subscribe £500,000 to the shares of the company, but we also authorise him to borrow or pledge the State's credit on debentures to the tune of another £500,000. Our modest proposal is that he should be restricted to subscribing £300,000 or that he should not pledge the State's credit for more than £300,000. I think that is a very reasonable proposal. We do not stickle over £50,000, if the Minister states that the arrangements and commitments already entered into make that addition absolutely vital. Personally, to give up a penny to this enterprise greatly depresses me. There is no use discussing that now, but if the Minister says that he has entered into commitments which makes the provision of £350,000 essential now, we would be prepared to assent to that. I think the Minister could limit himself to that amount, especially in view of the fact that under Section 15 everything we do now can be added to at a later stage.

Comment on this

The key to the Deputy's whole attitude is contained in the sentence in which he said that he would not give a penny towards this enterprise. That is the difference between us. The Deputy wants to see the enterprise destroyed. We think it is a good and reasonable enterprise, and we think that the Minister for Finance should be authorised to advance £500,000 for this purpose. We propose to ask the Dáil to do that. It is obvious that we cannot possibly reconcile our points of view. The Deputy wants the whole thing washed out. We think it is not unreasonable to ask the Minister for Finance to provide up to £500,000 for the purposes of this enterprise. We are telling the Dáil that the immediate capital requirements do not amount to that figure. They amount to £356,000, which includes £30,000 for working capital. In fact, the total capital expenditure is less, but we are proposing to capitalise the items which I mentioned—the royalties paid to Messrs. Noury and van der Lande, the interest on capital for the first working year, and the excess in the working costs for the first working year. Perhaps the items may be grouped together, because they represent in a sense the same thing. The price of the product was fixed at 3/- per gallon. That price is sufficient to cover the whole of the cost of production, and includes provision for the payment of interest on the capital advanced by the Minister for Finance in respect of shares in the case of the new company. The working costs, however, were in excess of 3/- per gallon for the first year. The year was not complete. Some of the factories were only working for a very small part of the season; consequently the expenses were much higher than in a normal working year, but we believe that it would be possible to sell profitably at that figure in a full working year. By selling at that figure for the first year, a loss was incurred, and that is being capitalised. The capitalisation of that loss, plus the capitalisation of the efficiency and interest payments on the amount advanced for the first year, amount, as I have said, to £26,000 or two sums of £13,000. In addition, we are capitalising the royalty payments. We think it is unreasonable to charge against the price of the product the bulk sum we have to pay for technical knowledge we had not got. We think that it is more reasonable to capitalise that sum and charge it against the whole enterprise. These two items of £13,000, plus the £30,000 royalty payment, plus the sum of £4,000, which represents capital expenditure not already incurred, plus the £30,000 required for working capital, plus capital expenditure, brings the total sum required to date up to £365,000. Their requirements may, however, increase, and we think it is not unreasonable to propose that the Minister should be authorised to advance beyond that £300,000 up to a limit of £500,000 without having to come for new legislation.

Comment on this

Up to £1,000,000.

Comment on this

Up to £500,000, the amount he can invest in the ordinary shares of the company. We do that because we want to see it given a chance, and because we do not want to see it unduly handicapped by any unnecessary restrictions of the kind the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

It often astonishes me the way Deputies of this House act. Is there any sane Deputy of the House to-day who would invest £1,000,000 of his own money in the manufacture of industrial alcohol?

Comment on this

On the terms of this Bill?

Comment on this

Is there any sane Deputy who, acting as the trustee of any fund, would elect to invest money in industrial alcohol?

Comment on this

Is there any sane man who would refuse to invest in such an enterprise if he had a guaranteed market?

Comment on this

I do not believe there is any sane man who would invest in such an industry. We are just handing over to the Minister for Finance authority to put £1,000,000 into this enterprise, £1,000,000 which would establish the greatest seat of learning in Europe in this country and endow it for all time. We are just going to squander that amount on "codology." Where is the use of talking?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

Indeed, I am.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 56
·
Níl 35
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I expected to see Deputy Moore springing to his feet, because, if the practice to which he directed attention under Section 8 is to be decried, the activities under this section are beyond the beyond.

Comment on this

I referred to Section 13 before.

Comment on this

I invite the Deputy to rise in righteous wrath again and point out to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that by whatever quibble he scrambled out of the difficulty under Section 8 he cannot escape it here, because here the Minister can borrow money to buy shares and, having borrowed money to buy shares, he can then sell the shares to any purchaser and bring the money into revenue and use it as ordinary revenue. The Minister may acquire £500,000 worth of shares, partly under Section 11 and partly under Section 10. He may arrive close to the end of his financial year with one of his customary deficits, and it may suit his political hand to emerge triumphantly with a surplus, whereupon he can resort to one of the many large funds under his command and sell the shares in the Industrial Alcohol Company to one of those funds and arrive triumphantly at the end of the year with a surplus of receipts of £500,000, and devote all that money to defraying what would normally be a substantial deficit on his Budget. What has Deputy Moore to say to that? Come, now, Deputy Moore. Deputy Moore is a gallant campaigner in the cause of righteous finance. I cannot imagine that he has been so completely cowed by the Minister's observations a few moments ago that there is not a yap in him now.

Comment on this

The Deputy clearly misunderstands what it is all about. What the Minister does with the money he may get out of the sale of shares is, of course, a matter which might be a subject of criticism. If he were to use money he received in the sale of an asset of this kind as ordinary revenue, there would be some point in the Deputy's remarks, but it does not say that here.

Comment on this

It gives him the right to do so.

Comment on this

It says the money may be used in such manner as he may direct.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

He may direct it to be used in the cancellation of debt.

Comment on this

Put that in there.

Comment on this

Or in such manner as would avoid the creation of a new debt.

Comment on this

Put that in there.

Comment on this

And that is quite legitimate and quite sound finance.

Comment on this

Yes, but put it in there.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy suggest what should go in there? What would have to go in there would be something which would involve the creation of some separate fund other than the Central Fund, and I do not know that the Deputy will find that many experts in public finance would agree that that is sound policy. I think that the deputy, if he examines the record of the administration of the public finances of this State for the past six years, will find that the rules of orthodoxy have not been departed from very often. The Deputy spoke about our "customary deficit." I think if the Party opposite were alive to their business they would find much more effective ground for criticising the Government in the fact that the surplus each year has been too large. If I were in the Opposition that is the line I would take.

Comment on this

We know. We have had experience of that before.

Comment on this

You would reduce taxation by £2,000,000 and cut down nobody's salary.

Comment on this

A surplus of £1,000,000 a year would make that very easy.

Comment on this

You may get that surplus in the next world. You will not get it here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In line 41, to delete the words "if he thinks fit" and substitute the words "with the prior consent of each House of the Oireachtas".

This amendment is designed to restrict the Minister from multiplying the rights of subscription to the share capital of this company by two without coming back to the House, and requires the Minister if he is going to guarantee the debentures for this company to come back to the House for authority to do so. I think that is a reasonable proposal. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has founded his case all along during this discussion on the contention that £500,000 provides an ample margin for every contingency that can be foreseen at the present time and that he does not at the moment foresee any contingency which will require the use of all that money, but he likes to have the knowledge that it is there if a contingency should arise.

Section 14, as at present drafted, provides not only the margin included in £500,000, but £500,000 on top of that again without any further reference to the Oireachtas. My amendment does no more than require, in the event of his having to spend a full £500,000 in subscribing for capital, that he will have to go back to Dáil Eireann and inform them of his intention to guarantee debentures of this kind.

Comment on this

I could not agree to that nor would any provision of this kind have any precedent. This is not the first Bill; this is only one of many designed to set up companies under the auspices of this State or to authorise the Minister for Finance to invest in the shares of companies. Consequently this Bill is in standard form. I do not think we have ever had it suggested in relation to any of the many Bills which preceded this for the establishment of companies for one purpose or another that a provision of this kind should be inserted, nor do I think it desirable, on the face of it, that we should have the affairs of a commercial enterprise subject to public discussion upon every occasion upon which additional capital expenditure has to be undertaken by it. I cannot agree to the amendment. I think we have got to give this company a fair chance. I do not think we should allow Deputy Dillon's hostility to it to induce us to so cripple it that it is desirable that an enterprise in which the State is interested should be run not by a Government Department, but by a company established upon the lines of an ordinary commercial undertaking, then they have got to facilitate that line of development by ensuring that these commercial companies will have the liberty of action and the possibility of success which a privately-owned company would have. If the Deputies want to get rigid control by the Legislature over all the commercial activities and undertakings of this kind the way to do it is to maintain the present position under which the Minister for Industry and Commerce runs the show and not a company set up in the manner contemplated by this Bill. I do not think they want to do that. If they do, in relation to this particular enterprise, it is a departure from their usual policy in such matters. They have always expressed the view, which I hold, that a State Department organised as the Department of Industry and Commerce is organised is not capable of running a purely commercial enterprise. I know that the red tape and regulations necessary in a Government Department where public funds are being administered and every penny accounted for in a particular manner to the Comptroller and Auditor-General——

Comment on this

That is what is wrong, is it?

Comment on this

——is not fit to run a commercial enterprise successfully. It may run it successfully, but it will run it in a much more costly manner than an ordinary commercial company. It is because of that we are proposing to transfer this enterprise from the Minister for Industry and Commerce to a commercial company, but, if we do that, we must give that commercial company a reasonable prospect of success and not ring it round with restrictions and limitations such as the Deputy now proposes.

Comment on this

With great respect to the Minister, these observations are largely flapdoodle.

Comment on this

I do not know what that means. The Deputy as an expert might tell me.

Comment on this

"Flapdoodle" means nonsense. The Minister says that we must not impose restrictions upon this company other than those we would impose upon an ordinary commercial enterprise. What ordinary commercial enterprise in this country has a right to get its debentures guaranteed by the Minister for Finance? What ordinary commercial enterprise here would claim to have an issue of debentures guaranteed by the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

The Agricultural Credit Corporation, for instance.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Moore call that an ordinary commercial enterprise?

Comment on this

Under the Trades Loan (Guarantee) Act any company that trades gets these debentures guaranteed.

Comment on this

Exactly, but they have got to go and make a case on the merits of their enterprise. The Minister does not give them a general benediction, and indicate that there is a guarantee available for them without any question. The Minister does not give them an undertaking that the Government will always have their issues guaranteed. At this stage there is no question of the merits or the demerits of this enterprise. Rotten as it is, our job is to make it as efficient as it can be made, in the knowledge that it is floated by this Parliament. But in that set of circumstances we have got to adhere to the reasonable rules of prudence. It does not seem to me to be in accordance with the reasonable rules of prudence to authorise the Minister to provide a sum quite as much as that which the Minister for Industry and Commerce says represents the maximum that he can say is necessary, looking as far ahead as he is able to look. I am not asking the Minister to put into this Bill a prohibition against issuing any further moneys to this company at all. All I am asking is that if the Minister wants to put on the State a further liability of £500,000, that he would come back here and ask for it; that he would come and ask the consent of each House of the Oireachtas. The Minister represents that attitude as striking a death blow at the whole enterprise. His attitude is that it would be a death blow at the enterprise if Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, were to stand up here and say: "I am about guaranteeing debentures for the industrial alcohol factories——"

Comment on this

And Deputy Dillon would have an opportunity then of saying that the enterprise was rotten; that the loan was an extremely bad one. That would be the position then before the country.

Comment on this

I am exercising what is the common, democratic right of discussing in this Parliament the affairs of the State. I know that the exercise of that right grates severely on the tender feelings of the Minister for Industry and Commerce——

Comment on this

On everybody's feelings.

Comment on this

I quite understand Deputy Smith's position. His spiritual home is Berlin. But we have educated Deputy Smith in the past five years and we have also educated the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Smith has got some education in the last five years, and there is a hope that in the next 15 or 20 years we will almost civilise him. Having educated the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the last five years, I do not despair that within the next ten years we will make him a good democrat. At the same time, I do not expect the Minister to take kindly to the proposition that he will answer to the House for what he has to do. I do not expect that he will welcome the position in which, instead of guaranteeing these debentures on his own authority without any reference to the Oireachtas, he will stand up here and tell the most insignificant Deputy of this House what he proposes to do. My amendment that the Minister is to get the prior consent of each House of the Oireachtas before guaranteeing any further debentures for this company is construed by the Minister as a dastardly attack on this industrial alcohol enterprise. That is how the amendment looks to people with the Hitler mind. To the ordinary man, to the ordinary mind, the proposition is one that is perfectly right and proper.

Comment on this

It should occur to the democratic mind of Deputy Dillon that the Minister is responsible to Parliament for all his actions, and Deputies here are entitled to question him at all times.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 53
·
Níl 38
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

May I assume the Deputy will take that decision as governing amendments Nos. 4 and 12?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 4 relates to Section 20. I do not know that that raises quite the same point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

All right.

SECTION 15.

Comment on this

Under Section 15, may the Minister borrow money for the subscription of these debentures?

Comment on this

I do not think he can, because he cannot buy the debentures; he can only guarantee the debentures.

Comment on this

Quite right. I thought the Deputy was referring to the shares.

Comment on this

Is the requirement contained in sub-section (1) of Section 18, to furnish an annual profit-and-loss account in addition to an annual balance sheet, a new introduction into this kind of legislation?

Comment on this

No, it is the same in them all.

Comment on this

Why are you taking these out from under the Control of Manufactures Act?

Comment on this

We always do that when there is special legislation affecting the industry. The Control of Manufactures Act does not affect any industry in regard to which there is special legislation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In sub-section (1), line 9, to delete the words "as he thinks fit" and substitute the words "as each House of the Oireachtas may from time to time approve."

I think this amendment is very much wider than the amendment that went before.

Comment on this

In fact, there is no case for this at all, because here the money must be voted by the Dáil.

Comment on this

Sometimes I am tempted to charge the Minister with bad faith but, on reflection——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy ever do that?

Comment on this

——I always prefer to assume that he is peculiarly prone to falling into error. As the Minister is aware, Votes are introduced here for general subsidies, giving the Minister a wide discretion as to how those moneys shall be allocated, and I see no reason why, under Section 20, he could not pay the subsidy out of moneys which had been voted by the Oireachtas under the general head of subsidies.

Comment on this

There is no money voted under the general head.

Comment on this

Well, that I cannot remember for the moment, but I seem to remember that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has a general authority to pay subsidies on industrial exports, for instance, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself determines which of those exports he shall pay a subsidy upon. There is a special Vote taken in this House every year, called "Export Bounties and Subsidies." It is No. 70 in the Book of Estimates. The heading of that Estimate is "An Estimate of the amount required in the year ending 31st March, 1939, for export bounties and subsidies." There appears to me to be, in this heading, no restriction on the ambit of that Vote. I cannot say what amount of that Vote was surrendered at the end of last year, but the sum appropriated was £2,242,010. Whether there was any surrender at the end of the year or not I do not know, but I am quite satisfied that under sub-head F, which provides for bounties and subsidies on exports of potatoes and other agricultural products, and expenditure on trial consignments to external markets, or under a new sub-head, a provision might be made within the ambit of that Vote for a subsidy on industrial alcohol.

Comment on this

Not without a Supple mentary Estimate.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

It could not be done.

Comment on this