Committee on Finance. - Industrial Alcohol Bill, 1938—Committee.
Contributions 147–289 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1938 ›
I do not know whether it is a matter of administrative practice or of constitutional requirement, but it is never done.
Comment on this
Now, this is interesting, because I question that. Suppose that you proceed to export some of this industrial alcohol. Under the subheads that have been already opened, it would certainly be possible to pay a subsidy.
Comment on this
Yes, but, clearly, Section 20 would not be required in the Bill in that case. If the Deputy is correct, Section 20 would not be required. Why do we have to put Section 20 in the Bill if we already have power to pay it?
Comment on this
You may or you may not have power to pay on the export of industrial alcohol, but suppose that you do come to pay out the money, will you then have to come back to Dáil Eireann to give that money or will you turn to some cover-all Vote and get, out of it, the requisite money referred to in sub-section (2)? I submit that that is possible, and I think it is a contingency which ought to be provided against, that, if the Minister proposes to pay subsidies to this company, a fresh proposal should be brought before Dáil Eireann. Where are our liabilities in connection with this enterprise going to end? We are going to subscribe, or have taken authority to subscribe, for £500,000 share capital and have taken authority to guarantee £500,000 debentures, and we are now asking authority to issue subsidies to this product. At the same time, we have fixed the community with notice that we are going to authorise this company to collect the equivalent of £175,000 per annum in subsidy, in the price which they are going to charge for the industrial alcohol, which they are going to sell to the public. Is not that so? The Minister told us that he is going to sell a certain quantity of industrial alcohol at 3/-, to take the place of the petrol which can be purchased at 4d. That represents a subsidy of 2/8 a gallon on industrial alcohol. Suppose we spend the £500,000 on shares and guarantee the debentures, it means that we are going to spend £1,000,000 for the purpose of purchasing a millstone of £175,000 per annum to hang around our necks. I contend that, along with the plain and unadorned mill-stone of £175,000 a year around our necks, the Minister wants us to give him authority to hang a whole lot of little mill-stones on to the big mill-stone, whenever he wants to do so. Surely, you have made a good enough bargain for that enterprise without adding this additional precaution? Surely you do not apprehend that, if you are going to collar 3/- a gallon, you will want any further financial assistance for this enterprise? If the Minister thinks that it is conceivable that any additional assistance should be required, he should tell us now, because it is nothing short of fraud to put this enterprise through Dáil Eireann on certain representations of maximum liability, and then, under cover of Section 20, to come back in 12 months' time and say "We are now deeply committed, and we shall have to shoulder further liabilities if the enterprise is to be carried on." Either Section 20 is unnecessary or else it conceals an intention of materially increasing the cost of this deplorable enterprise to the community.
Comment on this
No single penny can be paid by the Minister for Finance in subsidy to this company without the money being provided by the Oireachtas; that is to say, unless an Estimate is submitted here and passed. I do not expect that any subsidy will be paid, but I think it is a wise precaution, in enacting legislation of this kind, to make the statutory provision for it, because circumstances might arise at some future date which would make it good policy to do so. At present, however, in so far as we can foresee the future, no subsidy will be payable, nor will the circumstances which might justify a subsidy arise. The price we have fixed for industrial alcohol, as I have said, probably will be added to cover the entire cost of production and pay interest on capital invested in the enterprise. There is a certain amount of speculation about that, because we have not had the experience of a full year's working of the enterprise yet, nor do we quite know what the cost of manufacture will be in a full year. Of course, at any time there may be a variation in the price of materials, the costs of labour, or in the price of power which would have a bearing on prices. But at the present anticipated cost of potatoes, labour, coal, barley and the other commodities that are used by the company, we think that 3/- a gallon should prove quite capable of recovering the entire cost of production and still leave the margin which I have referred to. There is therefore, no intention of paying a subsidy.
The Deputy proposes that certain words should be deleted from the section. Whatever case he had for deleting the words in an earlier section, where the question of guaranteeing debentures is involved, there is no case here, because this section is inoperative until something has happened in the Dáil, namely, the introduction of a Supplementary Estimate authorising the Minister for Finance to make a payment for the purpose and providing him with the money wherewith to do it.
Comment on this
Because it is unnecessary here. Sub-section (2) is precisely the same as the Deputy's amendment. The section itself provides that—
The Minister for Finance may from time to time authorise the payment of subsidies to the company on such terms and conditions...
and the Deputy wants to insert after the word "conditions""as each House of the Oireachtas may from time to time approve." Sub-section (2) of the section provides that—
Any moneys required for the payment of subsidies under this section shall be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.
That, in effect, is the same thing.
Comment on this
Well, it is not, because there are two distinctions. One is that my amendment would require the Minister to get the sanction of this House for the terms upon which he proposes to pay a subsidy which, I think, is in itself desirable. The second thing is that my amendment would bring the Minister's technical justification for the subsidy before this House and the Upper House, whereas a financial resolution could be disposed of in this House alone. Now, you resurrected the Upper House yourselves as a vocational body which was to give some kind of expert advice to Ministers on certain matters. I think you were wise in doing that. You resurrected it on certain lines. Now, let us put it to work. If it has certain qualifications that this House has not got, let us avail of them. It is supposed to have certain technical qualifications that this House has not got. Here is a chance to avail of them. If you want to give a subsidy to the industrial alcohol business, bring your proposition to the Seanad and tell them what it is about. Let them declare that, having heard the Minister, they are quite satisfied with the proposal, and that a subsidy for the industry is defensible and good. Why should the Minister desire to cut the Seanad out?
Comment on this
Exactly. I want to make my amendment effective by requiring the Minister for Finance to justify to the Oireachtas the conditions upon which he is going to give a subsidy. It is quite true that the Seanad has no authority over Money Bills, and, therefore, sub-section (2), which brings this matter before the Oireachtas only by way of a Financial Resolution, leaves the Seanad completely out of the business.
Comment on this
I know, but I want the conditions of any subsidy which you propose to give to the company to go before the Seanad. Why not?
Comment on this
I would not agree with the Deputy there. If the Dáil decides to vote money for a particular purpose, that should end the matter. The Dáil is the final authority on financial matters.
Comment on this
Suppose the Dáil decides to subsidise a thing, does the Minister not think that the conditions on which they decide to give a subsidy should be subject to review?
Comment on this
One of the functions of the Seanad is to advise and counsel this House. If the Dáil proposes to give a subsidy on terms to an enterprise, surely it is quite within the competence of the Seanad to say: "It is none of our business how much you give, but we advise you that if you are going to give this firm a subsidy, you ought to require certain conditions to be fulfilled, and we think that they ought to give you a certain undertaking." Otherwise, what function has the Seanad if you are going to withhold from them every expert matter upon which they might reasonably be expected intelligently to pass judgment? Why should you dig them up at all? Why not let them repose in silence?
Comment on this
To tell the truth, I do not quite follow what the Minister is up to. I do not ask the Minister to understand, because I do not believe he wishes to understand. I believe in Parliamentary institutions and in supreme authority of Parliament. I apologise to the Minister for pressing that view upon him, as I know how distasteful it is to him, and how difficult it is for him to remain patient when he has no argument to present in face of that thesis.
Comment on this
Five minutes ago the Deputy was claiming that he was entirely responsible for my education. Now he is talking about my ignorance. I cannot follow him at all.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 5:—
In sub-section (1), line 19, before the word "may" to insert the words "and by the Minister".
This amendment is one of considerable importance, because Section 21 purports to give to this company power to authorise an inspector to enter upon anybody's land and there conduct inquiries, make examinations and do a variety of other acts which constitute a substantial infringement of an owner's title to his land. It is recognised that for certain public purposes it may be necessary to give inspectors that right, but it is a right which should be carefully circumscribed and should not be vested in any person who does not carry with him the authority of a Minister of State. My amendment is, therefore, designed to secure that any authority issued by the company to this end will be countersigned by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and unless so countersigned will not give an inspector any authority to trespass on a citizen's property.
Comment on this
I do not like the countersigning arrangement, but if the Deputy would prefer to have the authorisation issued by the Minister to having it issued by the company I should be prepared to do that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
In sub-section (2), line 24, after the word "person" to insert the words "having been shown the written authority of the authorised officer".
I think this amendment will commend itself to the Minister. It is in most of the Acts.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the amendment, but I should like the Deputy to leave it over so that the parliamentary draftsman may look at it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
In sub-section (2), line 35, before the word, "Minister" to insert the words "the local authority and the".
This is the section which gives the company power to lay down certain pipe-lines and carry out certain works which may interfere with public roads and passages for which a local authority is ordinarily responsible. Sub-section 2 requires the company to get the previous consent of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health before they interfere with a public road in the laying down of a pipe line. I feel that it would assist the Minister and make for good feeling all round if the local authority were brought in here and the sub-section were made to read: "The company shall not, without the previous consent of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health and the local authority, lay down any pipe line under any public road".
Comment on this
I have read it back to front, but it does not make much difference. The net result, if matters were pushed to a crisis, would be the same, because the Minister for Local Government, I think, by sealed order could compel the local authority to give the necessary permission so that if the Minister were satisfied in his mind that the permission was reasonably sought and was being unreasonably withheld by the local authority, he could issue his sealed order and command the assent of the local authority. The introduction of my amendment would require the local authority to be consulted in each case. I am convinced that if it is not done quarrels will arise in every case where a public road is to be interfered with. I am satisfied that in nine cases out of ten if this amendment is inserted no difficulty will arise with a local authority.
Comment on this
I am not disposed to accept the amendment. I think the section as it stands provides sufficient protection for the local authority in that the consent of the Minister must be secured. I may say in relation to the whole of Part III that it is scarcely necessary at all. In so far as the industrial alcohol factories are concerned, it is not intended that there should be any substantial extension of the enterprise beyond its present size, and, therefore, it can be said that all the construction work intended has already been done. Part III of the Bill is taken in its entirety from other legislation of a similar kind. The most recent legislation of that kind was the Air Navigation Act. The whole of the corresponding part of that Act was dumped in here because it was considered desirable that all these provisions should be inserted. In fact, however, no construction works of major importance are contemplated or likely to arise for a long time to come. So far as the particular point raised is concerned, I think the consent of the Minister for Local Government alone is sufficient protection for the local authority, and I may point out that the section is precisely the same as that in all the other Acts that have passed the Oireachtas authorising Government Departments or bodies set up by the Government like the Electricity Supply Board, the Sugar Company and the Air Navigation Company to undertake works of construction. No difficulty, to my knowledge, has arisen in consequence of the operation of similar sections in these Acts.
Comment on this
Does it not seem essential that there should be some consultation with the local authority? Take a public road under which you want to put down some drain pipes and with which you interfere in doing so. There must be some agreement that the road will be left in its proper condition, and only by consultation with the local authority can that be done. It may be a kind of gentleman's agreement, if you like, but it ought to be there. There ought to be some consultation with the local authority. Of course, the Minister, I presume, would have overriding authority, but for the sake of peace and of getting the thing done as it ought to be done, there ought to be some consultation with the local authority. It is not good enough for the Minister to say that it will probably never arise.
Comment on this
Is not consultation with and getting the agreement of the Minister in itself a sufficient safeguard? The Minister for Local Government exists to ensure that the interests of local authorities will be protected.
Comment on this
The Minister has no experience of local authorities' work. If he had he would not adopt that attitude. If there is personal contact with the local authority, in the person of the county surveyor, for instance, the whole thing will be settled immediately. If the Minister put in some such words as "consultation with the local authority" it would get the county surveyor into the matter, and arrangements would be made to ensure that the work would be left in a proper condition. I have seen various difficulties arise with contractors——
Comment on this
No difficulty did arise. All the factories are, in fact, built and all the pipes we contemplate will be required are laid. All that work has been done, and no difficulty has arisen, although the relevant section of the original Act was precisely the same. This part of the Bill is really there because the 1934 Act is being repealed and the corresponding sections have been carried over here; but unless it is decided at some later stage to build a sixth factory in some new part of the country this part of the Bill will not have to operate at all because all the factories are already built and in production.
Comment on this
As a matter of purely academic interest, would the Minister satisfy my curiosity as to how Section 22 relates to and is consistent with his own amendment later on to Section 23? Section 22 says that the company can lay down pipes under the roadway, but the Minister's own amendment says that they are not to do it. It says that they are not to acquire any land or any right in any land used or owned by a local authority for the purpose of gas or water undertakings or anything of that description. Are there not gas pipes, water pipes and sewers under public roads, and therefore that part of that road is owned by the local authority for the purpose of a gas or water undertaking?
Comment on this
The Minister's amendment does not allow the company to acquire a right in that part of the road where the gas pipes or sewers go. Reading the two sections, they struck me as being rather inconsistent.
Comment on this
I doubt very much whether a gas pipe under a public road makes the public road part of the gas undertaking of a local authority.
Comment on this
Look at the wording of the proposed amendment. It says: "The company shall not acquire any land or any right over any land held or occupied by a local authority for the purposes of any railway, tramway, dock, canal, water, gas, electricity or other public undertaking." In order to put down a sewer pipe, the local authority must have the bit of land through which it goes and it is then owned or occupied by the local authority for the purpose of a sewer pipe.
Comment on this
I am speaking of that as merely comprised of water. Take a big water main. That would come within the word "water."
Comment on this
But you cannot acquire any interest in the land through which that goes. Therefore, you may have a main water pipe going through a public road. This company hypothetically wants to go through that public road, and it may not be able to do it without going through this pipe.
Comment on this
If the Deputy's interpretation of the amendment is correct I shall have to get the amendment changed.
Comment on this
We certainly say we should not take the waterworks or gas undertaking of a local authority, or something of that kind, but a public road is a different matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
In sub-section (1), lines 41/42 and lines 43/44, in sub-section (2), lines 50/51 and lines 1/2, page 8, to delete the words and brackets "(either permanently or temporarily)."
This is a very important amendment. The proposal here is to give the company a power of compulsory acquisition which I have never seen given. We are all familiar with the power conferred upon public authorities or bodies like the E.S.B. compulsorily to acquire lands which are required for the normal development of their responsibilities, but I have never yet seen a power conferred on such a body to acquire land permanently or temporarily as they may see fit. They can compulsorily acquire any land, permanently or temporarily, under paragraph (a) and under paragraph (b) they can compulsorily acquire permanently or temporarily any easement, way-leave, water-right, fishing right, or other right whatsoever existing over or in respect of any land or water. Suppose this company came along and temporarily acquired my fishing right over a stretch of water, wrecked it, and then handed it back to me at the end of a long period, where am I? During the entire period of their tenancy I am in doubt as to what their ultimate intention is. I do not know how long they are going to remain tenants of this piece of property which they have temporarily acquired, and I am not in a position to make any alternative arrangements for the employment of my time or energies. Normally if a man wants to come and take your land, he takes your land; you get your compensation, and you can buy another farm and start up somewhere else. If he subsequently discovers that he does not want the land any longer, he puts it on the market, sells it for what he can get for it and writes off his loss—the difference between the price he realises and the compensation he paid—or takes to credit the difference if he gets more for it than in fact he gave.
Here, this entirely new arrangement is introduced. I could multiply instances in which the inconvenience of having a compulsory tenant thrust upon you is demonstrated, but I do not think it is necessary. For instance, a man might acquire an easement or a way-leave over your land and become an intolerable nuisance, and then throw the whole thing up after having made your land uninhabitable for the purposes for which you normally used it. It is true to say that no matter what kind of injury you inflict upon your neighbour there must be some measure of the loss which can be ascertained. In theory that is true, but in practice it is not, and I submit to the Minister that we ought not to introduce this new principle of temporary compulsory acquisition. If we are to have compulsory acquisition by a public body or the State, then let it be acquisition for fair compensation, and give the person whose property is temporarily acquired an opportunity of starting up elsewhere. Do not let us leave people suspended like Mohamet's coffin, not knowing the day or the hour when the tenant who has thrust himself compulsorily upon him may pull up his stakes and move off, throwing back on his hands the property which was compulsorily let under this Section. We have, therefore, moved to delete the words "either permanently or temporarily" wherever they appear in this Section. That leaves the Section fully effective for the purpose of compulsorily acquiring such lands as may become necessary for the proper conduct of this industrial alcohol business.
Comment on this
I am sorry I cannot agree that this Amendment is of any importance. It seems to me it does not make much difference one way or the other whether these words are included in the Section or are left out. As I understand it, if the words are left out, and the word "acquire" left without qualification, it means to acquire permanently. But the company can of course dispose of any property which it acquires. The position is, therefore, that there is some property the cost of permanent acquisition of which may be regarded by the company as prohibitive. They can, as the Bill stands, take a lease of that property for whatever period they need it, but if the words are left out it means they have to acquire it and dispose of it when their use for it is finished.
Comment on this
The owner of the property will have the same right to compensation as he would have if the property were permanently acquired. The compensation will be determined, in default of agreement, under the provisions of the Land Clauses Acts. I do not see how the point made by the Deputy arises in that regard. If the user of the property by the company is such as to destroy its subsequent utility to the owner, then presumably that will be taken into account in determining the compensation to be paid or in fixing the agreed rent to be charged. Either way, it does not seem to me that the owner is any better off by leaving the words out.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister see the difference between my arriving at his house to-morrow and announcing that he must move out his lares et penates as I am going to become his tenant for an indefinite term, and my arriving and saying he must move out his lares et penates as I am going to buy his house and he must make up his mind to take a new residence?
Comment on this
There is, of course, a difference, but is the owner any better off? Is it not much better to enable the company to take a temporary lease of the premises, if a temporary lease is all that they require? What the Deputy is trying to do is to put the company in the position that they must acquire it.
Comment on this
Then the owner has no choice in the matter. All those powers of compulsory acquisition are put in here because the Government is the owner of this company. The Deputy knows quite well that when the Government goes out to buy or lease property the price charged for it goes up at once by 100, or 200, or 300 per cent. The Government cannot get property at the market value. Consequently, unless there is power of compulsory acquisition it will not get property at all except at fabulous and ridiculous prices. I said the other day that quite recent experience showed that the mere knowledge that the Government was supporting an enterprise undertaken by a private company had precisely the same effect upon the value of the land which that private company decided to acquire.
Comment on this
There is an analogous case which will support the Minister's contention. It is the case of the fuel company in County Kildare. For months that particular company was held up because they could not get an easement or a right of way over a canal. The Minister will remember the case himself?
Comment on this
In that case tremendous difficulties were thrown in the way of a semi-government concern by the stupidity of those people. Eventually they had to be permitted to put a bridge over the canal. That project was held up for months. In this case, I think, the power in the Bill is a proper one and should be exercised.
Comment on this
If that is so in a case where the Government has only a sort of external interest it is much more true in the case of a company of this kind where the Government is the sole owner.
Comment on this
Therefore, we have to give powers of compulsory acquisition. If the company requires merely a temporary lease of property it should have power to take a temporary lease. The power of compulsory acquisition is there mainly to ensure that a temporary lease will be given at a reasonable amount. In fact, as the Deputy knows, it is very rarely that the power of compulsory acquisition has to be exercised. I cannot remember a single case during my period as Minister apart from such matters as the acquisition of the Shannon fisheries or a few cases of the kind where this power of compulsory acquisition of land had to be exercised. But the knowledge that the power was there ensured that we were able to get the land at its market value, or something above its market value. The same applies in the case of a temporary lease. The knowledge that we can get it compulsorily will make the owner of the property reasonable to deal with. The deletion of the words merely creates this situation, that the owner is no better off except that the company will have to acquire it completely with a view to disposing of it when the use of it has expired.
Comment on this
The discussion has become entirely irrelevant for the purpose proposed as I understand by the amendment. If I might be, perhaps, not quite so irrelevant as the Minister was, I should like to direct his attention to a case that is at hearing to-day in reference to one of the operations of certain people connected with industrial alcohol. Perhaps the facts of the case when he learns them, if he does not know them already, might, perhaps, give him a different view of the way in which these powers have been, in fact, operated. We do not object to the power of compulsory acquisition. In fact, the amendment gives a wider power than the Minister was seeking. Everybody knows that for the purpose of allowing a Government or any public authority to acquire land there must be power of compulsory acquisition, coupled with the right of the owner of the property to get a fair arbitration. That procedure is supplied in Section 24 which follows. Both the Minister and the owner have an opportunity of presenting their case on the question of the amount in accordance with the principles laid down by the Act of 1919. We are not objecting to that. What we are objecting to is the power of temporary acquisition of certain rights or of a piece of land. If the Minister requires the power of temporary acquisition I suggest that there ought to be some provision put in providing that the company should only be entitled to acquire temporarily on certain conditions.
Take the case Deputy Dillon referred to. If a house is taken over, say, for five years by temporary acquisition, there is nothing in the Bill to say that at the end of the five years the company is to hand it over in good order, repair and condition. If a lease is given to a tenant by a landlord of a house the ordinary covenant is to keep it in good repair and to deliver it up in good repair. Under this section, the company can acquire premises for five years and then go to the arbitrator and say they were only taking a lease for five years, give evidence of the letting value of the house, say, £20 or £25 per year, and say that five times £25 is £125 and that should be the compensation. There is no power that I can see in this section or in the arbitrator to say: "You cannot acquire this land or this house unless you undertake to deliver it up in the same condition as you got it when you compulsorily acquired it." If it is a house it is an obvious example. If it is a right-of-way lorries and other heavy traffic can go over it and destroy the ground for years after the expiration of the temporary user by the company, and there is no power to impose upon the company the condition that they will deliver up that roadway or the right-of-way that they took in good condition, in the condition they acquired it originally.
These are the kind of notions which are at the back of this amendment. If there were something in the section saying, if it is merely temporary acquisition, that there should be certain conditions imposed on the lines I suggest, the matter might be fairly equitable and not likely to work hardship. But under the provisions of the section you must get compensation once and for all. You have only one arbitration and one award of compensation. So that if a house is taken over for a period of five years the arbitrator fixes the compensation on the basis of a five years' period and when that is paid, and it is determined once and for all, then at the end of the five years the house may be in a shockingly dilapidated condition as the result of user, neglect, or any other cause which may occur to any one. There is no provision providing for a contingency of that kind. It is matters of that kind that really require consideration and that motivated the putting down of this amendment. It is not any suggestion that there should not be the power of compulsory acquisition. It is only the idea that if it is desired there should be this power of acquisition for a temporary period then there should be some conditions in relation to the compensation attached to it.
Comment on this
I cannot agree that this is without precedent because, in fact, the section is taken word for word from the 1934 Act. I do not think it is important, because in practice it makes no difference, I believe, whether the words are in or not. I realise that that argument is as much against myself as the Deputies, because if I strongly resist the amendment I am doing so without due cause, in the same way as they propose it without due cause. If the Deputies are very strong about it, I am prepared to take these words out. In practice, I do not think it will make any difference.
Comment on this
If the Minister takes them out, and if he wants to insert them in some other Bill, we can reexamine them on their merits.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert the following new sub-section:—
(3) The company shall not acquire under this section any land or any right over or in respect of any land held or occupied by a local authority or any body corporate for the purposes of any railway, tramway, dock, canal, water, gas, electricity, or other public undertaking.
It has been put down at the request of some of the statutory authorities concerned, and should perhaps have appeared in the original Bill, as it is in the corresponding part of the Air Navigation and similar Acts. The purport of it is to debar the company from acquiring land which is in use for any public undertaking of the kind mentioned.
Comment on this
In sub-section 4 (b) (c) are not the periods of one month and three months rather short notice?
Comment on this
It is the usual time. In fact, I think there never was a case where these powers were exercised without longer notice; but that is the standard form in which that section appears in other legislation for compulsory acquisition. There is nothing new in this.
Comment on this
Take a case where they go in under what we call a caretaker's agreement. There have been such delays in a good many instances, that the tenant does not get his money for a long time, but eventually gets interest, although he has to leave his house or land and is seriously inconvenienced.
Comment on this
That is not avoided by giving longer notice. I agree that, as soon as the acquisition has been completed, the terms of the compensation should be fixed expeditiously. But that is a different point from the period of notice to be given.
Comment on this
On the question of going in more or less under a caretaker's agreement, that is generally an invitation to whoever is concerned to delay as long as possible. That is under sub-section (3). In many instances hardship is inflicted.
Comment on this
That matter of temporary acquisition is now ended, because I have agreed that, if compulsory acquisition is resorted to, it will be permanent acquisition.
Comment on this
Suppose, for instance, under (b) you decide to acquire land. There is no reason why we should not make a new law, because this is in another Act.
Comment on this
In a case where a family is occupying a house and you walk in under a caretaker's agreement, I think three months is very short notice. You should give the man time to get another house and to move into it.
Comment on this
I am prepared to agree that in ordinary cases longer notice should be given and I think in every case much longer notice is given. Where, however, a public enterprise is being pushed ahead, different considerations arise. This section appears in the same form in all Bills of this nature, whether dealing with railways, canals or harbours. We cannot allow this enterprise to be held up indefinitely merely for the purpose of giving longer notice to people whose tenancies are likely to be disturbed. I have not, however, known any case where a very long notice was not given. In the case of the Poulaphouca scheme, for instance, more than 12 months' notice was given although the provisions regarding the giving of notice were precisely the same as in this Bill.
Section 23, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Sections 24 to 29 inclusive ordered to stand Part of the Bill.
SECTION 30.
(2) The following provisions shall have effect in relation to every transport works order, that is to say:—
(b) without prejudice to the generality of paragraph (a) of this sub-section.
(iv) such order may incorporate all or any of the provisions of the Lands Clauses Consolidation Acts, with such modifications and adaptations as the Minister thinks proper.
(4) Every order made under this section shall have the force of law.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:—
In sub-section (2) (b) (iv), page 11, line 6, to delete the word "Consolidation."
This is just a drafting amendment. The word "Consolidation" should not appear there.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:—
To delete sub-section (4).
Sub-section (4) provides that the orders that are referred to in the section, which may contain practically anything that comes into the Minister's head, shall have the force of law. In other words, it gives very wide power to the Minister to legislate and to usurp the functions of Parliament. It is on that question of principle that the amendment is put down. We do not wish to hamper the Minister in the exercise of any power which it is desirable he should have in the making of these orders but it does come rather as a shock that the order which the Minister is empowered to make, after inquiry, "shall contain such provisions as the Minister thinks necessary or expedient for the purposes of such order." Anything that he thinks proper can be put in the order and it is to have the force of law, just the same as if it were passed in the Dáil. I think that is going beyond the legitimate purpose of a statutory order and should not be insisted upon.
Here we have a general power in the widest possible terms given to the Minister to say that anything he thinks necessary goes into the order, and once he puts it into the order it is the same as if it had gone through both Houses of the Oireachtas. That is going beyond anything that has been done in the way of delegated legislation in this Oireachtas since it was established. I doubt if there is any precedent for it but, if so, it must have slipped through unnoticed in this House. I think it is quite sufficient that the Minister should have power to make these orders without adding this extraordinary provision that they are to have the force of law, just the same as if they went through the ordinary process of legislation here. The widest possible power is given to the Minister to put into the order anything which he thinks necessary or proper, but I think it will come as a shock to the public conscience that it is to have the force of law. Even if that were not enough, the sub-section proceeds to say that without prejudice to the generality of the overriding paragraph, the order may contain certain provisions. That involves the company, at all events—a matter in which I am not very much interested—in a criminal proceeding, but it may also involve private individuals in criminal proceedings, because the Minister might put in something creating an offence if he thinks it proper to do so. He may think it necessary or proper to create an offence and, at the same time, provide that it should not be heard by the ordinary courts but by the managing director of the company. I do not suggest that any responsible Minister would do that. I am merely producing a reductio ad absurdum for the purpose of giving point to my argument.
Comment on this
What is involved here is a legal point. As I understand it, the insertion of that section is necessary because of the provisions of paragraph 9 of sub-section (2) relating to the penalties which are involved in a breach of the order. I consulted the parliamentary draftsman on this matter—I was not clear myself as to why the clause must appear in that precise form—and he has advised that because of the penalties provided in paragraph 9, sub-section (2), sub-section (4) must go in. The only observation I have to make in that connection is that we are not establishing a precedent as a precisely similar sub-section appeared in the Cement Act, in the Air Navigation Act, and in a number of other Acts as well. This section relates to transport works orders. It gives the Minister power to authorise by order the construction of certain works. The only difference between the powers given in these orders made by the Minister and those ordinarily given in the case of a private company, is that the private company would have to seek these powers by way of a private Bill. In this section we give the Minister power to make orders authorising the construction of such works.
Comment on this
This amendment was put down by me on a matter of principle and not because of the particular character of this Bill. If there is any precedent in the Acts mentioned by the Minister I regret that these provisions were overlooked when the Bills were passing through. Certainly it was a shock to my legal conscience, shall we say, or to my constitutional ideas, when I saw that these orders were to have the force of law. I have no recollection of seeing anything like that in previous measures. It is merely for the purpose of preventing such a precedent from growing up that I have put down this amendment. Delegated powers are the subject matter of very considerable controversy in this country, and very much more so in Great Britain. The Minister stated that he had got certain advice. I would not presume to disagree with an opinion which I have not seen or the reasons for which it is worth, but I am entitled to say that as far as my opinion goes, for what it is worth, there is no necessity for sub-section (4) in order to give effect to paragraph 9. Frequently we find statutory orders and rules being made under statutory orders which create offences.
Comment on this
Yes, provided they do not go outside the powers provided by the Act. It is perhaps objectionable that statutory orders should create offences and prescribe penalties but it is still more objectionable that, when that power is given, it should have the force of law because if the provision in the statute does not provide that it is to have the force of law, then it is possible to attack these provisions as being ultra vires and there is a check on the arbitrary use of these powers in that way. There is no check, however, under this legislation by Departmental order. This is legislation of the worst description. It applies not merely to paragraph (ix) but to the whole of anything that the Minister likes to put into the order. In effect, he may create an offence that is not mentioned specifically in the section, which will then have the force of law. I press upon the Minister as forcibly as I can, and not with any desire to obstruct, that this is a bad precedent to follow. It is on the point of principle that I press it, and for no other reason.
Comment on this
I am not inclined to agree to that. In relation to transport undertakings a number of regulations must be made. The bye-laws prescribe specific offences and things of that kind. I agree that it is usually done by law. The Dublin Tramways Company and the Great Southern Railways have to get statutes enacted by legislation.
Comment on this
No, with respect. They get power from the Legislature to make bye-laws. Bye-laws have not the force of law, but are derived from the law giving the power to make them.
Comment on this
If this was a private company it would come and promote a Private Bill to construct and operate a transport undertaking, but because it is not a private company, but a public one, we propose to have it in this way and I think it is much better to have it after public inquiry, and to have orders, penalties and offences specified.
Comment on this
I repeat that I am not arguing against giving the Minister power to make orders or to provide for the things he wants to provide for, as specified in the section. What I say is that if he leaves out sub-section (4) he will be in a position to do what is required in the public interest. To add sub-section (4) in my submission goes beyond the power given under any Act of our Parliament, because it gives the Minister power to legislate without reference to the Oireachtas. I do not think that is necessary. The Minister has led himself into a false analogy. If a private company was applying for these powers it would have to have a Bill. Perhaps it would get the powers contained in Section 30, but it would not get sub-section (4).
Comment on this
No. Take the Dublin Tramways, which is a public company operating transport services. A statute is passed giving them power to operate transport services, and that contains general power to make bye-laws in reference to A, B, C, D and E, matters specifically enumerated and set out seriatum in the Bill. In a general way the details are all filled in by the bye-laws. The company then has power to make bye-laws which have authority but not the force of law. They have statutory authority derivable from the statute. Here I want to leave power to the Minister to do all things. In Section 30 he has full statutory authority to do everything, but to put in sub-section (4) is wholly unnecessary and is going beyond what is reasonably required. Certainly, in my view, it is putting in something that is a matter of grave dereliction of principle.
Comment on this
I am not competent to argue that. I am advised that sub-section (4) is required because of paragraph 9.
Comment on this
The Minister says he is advised that sub-section (4) is merely required because of paragraph 9. I offer to accept the application of sub-section (4) to paragraph 9 only. Is that the only one he was advised on?
Comment on this
This gives power to make a lot of different orders. What the section does is to give power to make an order which may contain any provisions.
Comment on this
All you have to do is to take out the paragraph and to add the words "such provisions shall have the force of law".
Comment on this
I prefer to deal with the Parliamentary draftsman. It is too much of a legal point for me.
Comment on this
I suggest that paragraph (b) of this section gives the Minister power to overrule the courts. It says that the Minister may make regulations, and under them a company that had not been convicted of an offence might be required to do so and so. Say that a company was charged with doing a certain thing, and that it was found not guilty, the Minister might say: "The court says the company was not guilty, but I say it was, and, therefore, it must do so and so."
Comment on this
I do not think that could be argued. The only thing I can say about the sections is that they are in standard form, and are taken en bloc from other enactments, virtually the only changes being those necessary to adapt them.
Comment on this
I suppose paragraph (c) of this section dealing with the protection of public roads and bridges as against the company is founded on previous legislation?
Comment on this
It is a bit of a surprise to have the Dáil expressing such profound contempt for local authorities. These local authorities or their engineers are not consulted, and the Custom House authorities merely inform them that the liability for their share of the work was so much. I think the Dáil never intended to do that.
Comment on this
The Deputy has put me "on the spot". I remember arguing in a similar way when a similar section appeared in a Bill before the Seanad.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that in line 41 there is a difference between the meaning of the words "light" and "lights."
Comment on this
Yes; there is a printer's error there. The "s" on the end of "light" should not be there.
Comment on this
Yes; it is a printer's mistake. There is a similar error in the very first line of the page. "Any sums or sums" should be "any sum or sums".
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Dillon I move amendment No. 13:—
In sub-section (1) (a), line 49, after the word "quantity", to insert the words "not exceeding one gallon of industrial alcohol to forty gallons of mineral hydrocarbon light oil".
I confess to the Minister that I am not at all clear what the purpose of it is. I did know it some time ago, but I think the general purport of it is this: that a certain amount of industrial alcohol will be made by the various factories that will bear a certain proportion to the amount of petrol, shall we say, that is consumed in the country. The object of this is to prevent, say, the whole of the output of the factories being, so to speak, unloaded on to the petrol suppliers at one time.
Comment on this
Yes, or on one company. I think that is the idea. At the present time it may be said that the proportion that the total production of industrial alcohol of which the factories are capable will bear in relation to the total consumption of petrol in the year will be one to 40 and, if that continues as the ordinary practice, alcohol will be distributed to the distributors in that proportion. They will get one-fortieth of their imports of petrol, but clearly it would be unwise to fix that percentage in the Bill because the percentage of the consumption of petrol may go up or down. It would cause difficulty, and if it prevented the distilleries getting rid of their alcohol it would make it impossible to operate. There is, in fact, not the slightest danger of all the alcohol being unloaded on the distributors at the one time. Quite the reverse. The storage at each of the distilleries is only sufficient to hold a fortnight's output, so that there must be a continuous outflow of alcohol from the distilleries to the distributors, or else the distilleries will have to stop working. There is not the slightest danger of holding up supplies until a large stock of spirit is ready, and then passing it out in a short while to distributors. That could not happen. They have not the storage. In fact, the arrangements are such that unless there is a steady and continuous outflow from the distilleries to the distributors the factories cannot work at all. While therefore, I say that it is intended to do that to maintain a steady distribution of the spirit, to distribute it evenly amongst the distributors in proportion to their withdrawal from bond of imported petrol, at the same time we cannot fix the percentage in the Bill, because to do so would tie us down to a system of working based upon this year's experience, which might be altogether impracticable in the case of next year.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give any indication as to what proportion he intends to be the standard one?
Comment on this
The industrial alcohol will be only about one fortieth of the total consumption of motor spirit in the country, but I am informed that it is not practicable to mix petrol and industrial alcohol in the proportion of one to 40 and, in fact, a much higher percentage of industrial alcohol must be used to get a proper blend, the correct mixture, and, in fact, what is intended is to put a new spirit on the market which will contain petrol and alcohol in the best proportions to constitute a good motor spirit and endeavour to sell that spirit as an adjunct to the existing lines.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister has looked into all these things? I gather from some conversation I had that if industrial alcohol is mixed with petrol in a certain way you are liable to be left on the road with your cylinders burnt out.
Comment on this
That again is a matter for the distributors. They get the alcohol and can dispose of it the way they think best. Some may prefer one mixture; others another.
Comment on this
Speaking as one who buys petrol occasionally, I think it is also a matter for the purchaser of petrol to see that his interests are safeguarded.
Comment on this
The distributors will be anxious to sell it and that is what I am worried about. As a person who goes in to buy petrol, I want to see that I am not going to get something that somebody is trying on the dog or on the motor car.
Comment on this
You will have the alternative of purchasing pure petrol. If they sell the mixture they will sell it because of its superior quality or because of its cheaper price.
Comment on this
A point arising out of the Minister's remarks. He says that the factories have only a limited storage. I understand they are also seasonal. They only operate for six months of the year. Who is going to do the storage for the other six months?
Comment on this
The distributors will be anxious to dispose of it. They have to pay for the alcohol and they will be anxious to realise on it as quickly as possible. Is there any possibility that the mixture will vary considerably in each case?
Comment on this
I understand an organisation called Industrial Alcohol Distributors Limited has been created and they are arranging for the distribution. In fact, we have produced 315,000 gallons of industrial alcohol already and none has been distributed, as far as I know. It is being held in storage by the distributors. They will not start until they have enough to ensure that they can maintain a supply of standard spirit throughout the year.
Comment on this
In regard to the Schedule, these are points that I should have raised on the Second Reading, but I was not here. I notice the Schedule consists practically of the memorandum and articles of association of the company. I think that is practically what the Schedule is. I wonder is it possible to include more powers or reserve more powers for the Minister in the memorandum and articles of association, particularly in regard to the control of the company and the appointment of all the directors. I think only a majority of the directors may be appointed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce as long as certain conditions obtain.
Comment on this
That is only in theory. In practice what it provides for is that certain directors will be appointed by the Minister for Finance after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the balance will be appointed by the shareholders, but, of course, in this particular case, the only shareholder is the Minister for Finance, so in practice he appoints them all.
Comment on this
I have a bee in my bonnet for a long time as regards control. There have been certain undertakings in this country like this, semi-Government, in which there are a lot of what I might call foreign experts in control. Generally, when there are a lot of foreign or some we will call "non-nationals" on the board, there has been certain manipulation carried out to the detriment of the country and to the other individual shareholders. It has been alleged and, in fact, it can be proved, that in some of these connections where there is raw material being delivered from the foreign country to a factory here in this country and a director of the company in Ireland is also a director of the company in England or whatever country it may be, the raw materials are sold by him to the company in Ireland and he collects commission on that as a buyer and as a seller. Furthermore, it has been shown and can be proved that, in addition to that, that particular company sells raw material to another company in Ireland, that some of these people happen to be directors of the third company, and that they have, in fact, collected a commission on two or three occasions. That has actually taken place in semi-Government controlled companies, and the bee I have in my bonnet is this, that the Minister should get more control whereby he can go in and ask for the entire books of these companies and see who is not. I know it is rather late in the day to raise these points now, but I can give the Minister definite proof of where commission has been collected on three occasions on the same matter.
Comment on this
These companies are privately-owned companies and I would advise the Deputy to believe half what he sees and none of what he hears.
Comment on this
But I have seen it myself. My point is that if you have to give them a monopoly they should be properly controlled.