We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 57—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 1–124 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Last evening there was some remark made from this side of the House about the quality of the handles in hay-forks and the quality of shovels. There seemed to be such doubt cast upon those statements from the other side of the House that I thought I would just let the House know what was my experience of an Irish spade. Some months ago I bought an Irish spade and used it for the purpose for which it was designed. It was not very long before I noticed the laminations in the spake parting company and presently a bit came off. A little bit later on the handle broke. I brought the handle in with me. Here is the handle [produced].

Comment on this

A dangerous weapon.

Comment on this

It is, but it would be more dangerous if it were a better quality. What I would like to point out to the Minister are some of the consequences that flow from matters such as that. I think I paid 5/6 for the shovel and I inquired what a new one would cost and what an English one would cost. I was informed that an English one would cost considerably more and, accordingly, I purchased another Irish spade. At the time I asked did any people purchase English spades at the considerably higher price and I was told yes, that a certain percentage definitely paid a much higher price on quality.

I do not bring this matter to the notice of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to ask him to inquire personally into the spade that I had such an unfortunate experience with, but I would like to point out to him some of the things that flow from that. Apparently that particular handle is what they call hedge-grown; the grain is not as straight as it should be. I understand that Irish spades are hand-forged and that the English spades are machine-forged. I am not going to say, for one moment, that the manufacturers of the Irish spades are not doing their very best, but the ultimate test as to whether Irish spades or English spades are going to be used in this country rests with the consumer. The consumer can pay a greatly increased price, and will do so if he thinks he is getting value for it.

A lot of praise was given to the Minister's Department for the way they are conducting affairs at the present time. If I could not go quite so far as some of the speakers, I certainly am not prepared to throw any stones at the Minister's Department. I think they are endeavouring to discharge a very difficult task to the limit of their ability, but there must come a stage at which the Department must say: "Now, we cannot continue to give this preference," or "This preference is not worth while owing to the cost to the consumer." I think, not at all considering the spade in question any further than as an illustration of what I mean, that it behoves the Minister and the Department to give some idea to the consuming public at what point they would abandon protecting an Irish industry which, although they might be doing the best according to their lights, were really not giving value, considered in the light of the fact that the people who work with the spades have also to get a return for their labour. That brings one to another point.

Comment on this

On a point of information, could we find out from the Deputy what factory he is referring to?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be much wiser not to name the factory.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Deputy Dockrell is talking generally.

Comment on this

I entirely agree with the ruling, or the advice, of the Chair, whichever it is.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

They are all in the same boat.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy in possession agrees to give way, Deputy Tubridy may intervene, but not otherwise.

Comment on this

I do not object to the Deputy asking questions.

Comment on this

We have a factory.

Comment on this

What do you mean by "we"?

Comment on this

In my constituency in Galway.

Comment on this

Where is the factory?

Comment on this

We would like to know is it a fact that a complaint has been made that the produce of that factory is not satisfactory?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is quite a different question. Deputy Dockrell has not mentioned any factory.

Comment on this

The Deputy might answer that.

Comment on this

I do not propose to answer it. I have said that I do not wish the Minister, in replying to me, to take my remarks as a personal attack on spades in general or on factories in particular. I merely wished him to state for the benefit of the consuming public where the borderline was crossed in which he thought that the consuming public were not getting a square deal. When I say a square deal, I do not mean by that that the factory is defrauding them, or anything like that. All the circumstances taken into account, the people over here may have to work by hand when their competitors are working by machinery, and I merely wanted to know how far the game was worth the candle. That is one phase.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to shovel them out of existence.

Comment on this

It is a spade I am talking about, not a shovel.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

If they are not giving value it would be a very good job to shovel them out.

Comment on this

I do not want them to dig themselves in on the good nature of the Minister and his Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Well said.

Comment on this

You want to go four spades on a two spade hand.

Comment on this

I think I have the ace of spades.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dockrell must be allowed to handle his speech in his own way.

Comment on this

There is another matter I would like to bring to the notice of the Minister, and it is merely a type also. The Minister's Department, when asked for a licence or permit or something like that, usually says: "Apply to the people who manufacture those goods." In some cases, of course, it is absolutely in their line. They reply and the goods are imported duty free. But there is a borderline case where a manufacturer considers that the goods which he offers ought to be used. The person who wants to use them may find some difficulty in using those goods. He points out to the officials of the Department the diference that exists. I have heard it said that one harassed official replied to a person: "Well, I know one of you is lying, but I do not know which." He did not know whether it was the applicant or the manufacturer. Be that as it may, I am afraid that sometimes shelter is taken behind the point: "Well, goods are manufactured in this country and these on the face of it appear somewhat similar." You have not got a letter from the people who purport to manufacture those goods, and you must pay the duty. I am afraid in a lot of cases the duty is paid and that is only raising the cost of living on a number of people here.

Another matter that I wish to bring to the Minister's notice is this — and it is something on all-fours with the other two points — what is a reasonable time during the busy season for an Irish manufacturer to be behind in his delivery of stock? Would, for instance, the Minister consider that three months was a reasonable time in the case of an article or a pattern that was in general request? What would be the procedure or remedy for a thing such as that?

There is one other point that I wish to raise because I am sure the Minister's Department must be plagued with it and it is this: There are a number of articles which are not manufactured in this country. It would take time and money to set about engaging in the manufacture of these articles. Yet permits have to be got for every single consignment of those goods. I would like to read out to the Minister the procedure for one single transaction such as I have mentioned. In order to get a licence an invoice must be obtained from the manufacturer. That takes two or three days. This invoice has to be submitted to the local manufacturer who will give a letter stating that he cannot supply. This means another couple of days' delay. This letter and invoice have then to be sent to the Department of Industry and Commerce. After three or four days we get a letter stating that they have instructed the Revenue Commissioners to send us a licence. We get this licence after a further three or four days. We then have to submit the licence to the shipping company who will hand it to the customs officers, who will release the goods after three or four days. At least 14 days' delay occurs in all these transactions, and, if there is the slightest hitch or anything like that, double that time may elapse. I would like to ask the Minister what is the sense of having these items which are not made in this country subjected to this procedure? The cost of the Minister's Department has risen. He does not answer these letters for nothing. They have to be looked into by responsible officials. The same applies to the members of the mercantile community. They have to employ clerks and typists to deal with and send out these letters and carefully file the replies.

I have mentioned four types of cases that I would like to bring to the Minister's notice. In the last case we can do nothing; in the other cases I would like if he would say how far he realises what is happening? In the old days when goods came in here without duty the public either took the goods of Irish manufacture or of English manufacture according to their individual ideas. Now that the Minister has stepped in and there is only the Minister's Department between the general public and the question whether those goods are to be allowed in or what goods are to be used, I would like to urge on the Minister that in the last resort the final decision rests with the public.

The French have a proverb that you have to be cruel to be kind. I would like to suggest to the Minister that in some cases if he were cruel, nominally, he might save it in the goodwill towards Irish manufactured goods. I say that because in the last resort the goodwill and purchasing power for Irish industries rests on the services and the prices and delivery that is obtained from the manufacturer. I do not want to increase the Minister's difficulties because this is a very complicated and difficult subject, but at the same time no service would be done to Irish industries by concealing the fact that there is a very difficult situation which requires to be very carefully and delicately handled.

Comment on this

I wish to intervene in this debate for the purpose of trying to elicit some information in regard to certain industries in the area which I represent — Cork. I have already spoken with regard to the closing down of a mill at Sallybrook, Glanmire, County Cork. This mill has been in operation for generations — close on 100 years. In March, 1937, the proprietors gave notice that the mill was to be closed down. The local people intervened and tried to persuade the directors to carry on that mill. It had competed successfully for generations and there were between 70 and 80 people employed in it. It was the second last remaining little rural industry in that locality. There had been at one time as many as 10 or 12 of these little rural industries in this particular area and at present there is only one.

This mill, however, was threatened to be closed down in March, 1937.

The local people summoned the representatives of the constituency without distinction of Party and a deputation was appointed to interview the proprietor, Mr. O'Shaughnessy, and find out what exactly was the cause of closing down the mill. Mr. O'Shaughnessy refused to meet this deputation on which were representatives of the constituency. The mill struggled on until just after the General Election of 1937. The attention of the Minister was called to the fact that the mill was about to be closed down. Even the Taoiseach was made acquainted with the facts by myself. But despite everything that could be done, the mill has definitely closed down and these people have been thrown out of employment. My opinion is — and I think it is correct— that a number of them have gone across to England to find work there; I think about six have been employed in another mill at Dripsey which Mr. O'Shaughnessy also runs. Now that building at Glanmire is idle at the moment. It probably will be pulled down, as another building which housed the starch factory in the neighbourhood was pulled down and dismantled. It is a very fine structure. The reason why I refer to this matter is that while it is the policy of the Department of Industry and Commerce to help to get industries going in each locality, I think there is a greater necessity for trying to keep going industries that already exist in localities, especially in rural districts.

I referred to the Sallybrook mill. I do not know if there is any possibility of that being utilised in the very near future for carrying on that industry, but it is a fact that it made a profit over a number of years, even without the help of tariffs. It manufactured a type of blanket which found a ready sale, not alone in this country, but across in Great Britain. We have in Douglas, near the City of Cork, a woollen industry, and I should like to know from the Minister what exactly is the position with regard to that industry. Rumour has it, just as in the case of Sallybrook, that there is a danger of that industry also going, and various reasons have been put forward why that rumour is correct. I should like the Minister to inquire into the position there, and see if it can be remedied so that that industry will not also go in the same way as the one in Sallybrook went. They had been on short time, or half-time, for some weeks previous to the general election, but with the general election the work started there and it is going on in some fashion. There are two mills in Douglas, O'Brien's and Morrogh's, and both have been on very slack, or short time, for some months. I want to draw the Minister's attention particularly to that industry, because if it is allowed to carry on as it is the danger is that these mills after some time will also go the way of the Sallybrook mill.

Another matter to which I should like to refer is the question of the unemployment in Passage West. Some few years ago Passage West was promised a tannery. The industry of tanning was to be set up there, and certain preparations were made. Unfortunately, however, that did not materialise. At one time Passage West was a very busy place. It was a hive of industry. There was a dock there, and as a result of the numbers of skilled men in employment there in former times, I think that Passage West now ranks as one of the places where you have more skilled men unemployed than any other place of its size in this country. Now, if anything is going to be done with regard to the establishment of industries suitable to the position, I think Passage West should be taken into account. It is on the riverside, the numbers of unemployed there are very large, and the position of the town as a result of unemployment is very bad. Some time ago — early this year — there was an inquiry into the condition of affairs of the urban council, the state of the rate collection, and so on. I think that a good deal of that condition there, with regard to rates and so on, was due to the fact that unemployment is so rampant in that locality. I especially mention that to the Minister in the hope that something may be done other than these rotational schemes that we have in operation around that district, but which do not give the kind of employment which is desirable in that locality.

On the other side of the river from Passage there is another dock, Rushbrooke, which had been in operation within the past two years. It was taken over by Mr. MacLysaght, of Mallow, with the intention of starting an industry there, something akin to the one that is being started in Haulbowline. For various reasons, the industry was not allowed to proceed in Rushbrooke. Mr. MacLysaght had made arrangements to sell the fittings of the dock, and to dismantle it in order to recompense himself in some way for his investment there, but just after the general election last year there was a meeting held of the people of the locality, in Cobh, and representations were made to Mr. MacLysaght not to take away the essential parts of the machinery which could be utilised if there were ever to be a dock there again. With very commendable public spirit, Mr. MacLysaght agreed, and the essential machinery is still in the dock. Now, it may be that there are other places in view with regard to this suggested scheme of defence, but if there is to be some scheme of defence, or other activities in connection with defence, in that area, I suggest that that dock could be utilised for the purpose for which it was intended, namely, for the repair, and in some fashion, the building of ships.

I have mentioned those places, Sir, where an industry had been and where an industry, without very much expense, could be restarted now. I wish especially to mention the wool industry in Douglas, and I hope the Minister will make inquiries into the position of the wool industry in the district. There are the Douglas, Blarney and Dripsey mills, and of the three mills I think Douglas seems to be in a very parlous condition. The position in Blarney was not very good for some time. It may be due to the fact that there was a certain amount of uneasiness about these negotiations with Britain, but now that these have been concluded, I think it would be no harm if the whole question of the woollen industry in that area were inquired into. I understand that we do not produce in this country anything like near the requirements of our population in woollen goods, and if such is the case there is no reason why those mills should not be going on full time. I think that these are the points I wish to make in connection with this debate, but I wish to ask the Minister very seriously to look into these things and see whether or not something can be done to remedy the position, especially with regard to Passage West and the unemployment there. As I have said, I raised this matter several times, but nothing seems to be done and the town seems to be left to its own resources, which are nil, and which give to the town a most deserted and dispirited outlook. That promise of a tannery, which did not materialise, probably caused an amount of despair and heartburning that made the people feel that nothing could be done for them. Now that we have the promise of so many new industries to be started, I hope that this place will not be forgotten. That is all I have to say and I put it forward in that spirit that the Minister will see if anything can be done for the places I have mentioned.

Comment on this

I intervene in this debate, Sir, solely because Sallybrook mill has been mentioned and also Mr. O'Shaughnessy's name. The Deputy who has just spoken, Deputy Hurley, spoke about the attempts that were made to keep the factory open. I can say fairly definitely from my conversations with Mr. O'Shaughnessy, and also from some particulars which I received from a gentleman who has since got a very big appointment in another firm, that the factory was closed down by reason of the unreasonable behaviour of some of the employees, and also the interfering busy-body method of a trade union. In small country industries you cannot have the same regularity about everything that there is in big industries in the city. In the circumstances, there was unreasonable behaviour on the part of the employees. The trade union, instead of making an effort to get the employees to pay some attention to the representations made by the management, took the other step. They went back on that, after giving the employees certain definite instructions. Mr. O'Shaughnessy himself stated — I will use his own expressive words —"You know, nobody can do anything with such tavern methods."

Comment on this

When the Minister is replying I should be glad if he would give a little more information than is obtainable from the Estimate on the question of the Industrial Research Council. As far as I can gather from the Vote here, it does not itself carry out any research, because there is no technician mentioned on the salary scale. Apparently it carries out its work entirely through other bodies. I should like to know what type of matter has been dealt with by the council. I should also like to know whether it has any liaison with the Department of Industrial and Scientific Research of the Privy Council. That body controls a vast number of research associations in Great Britain, and I am perfectly sure that there is valuable information to be got from that body, and that they would be quite willing to give it.

I should also like to refer to another point which I think is proper to this Vote, and that is the question of trolley buses. I am sorry that the Minister did not use whatever power he may have to get the trams in Dublin replaced by trolley buses rather than by petrol buses. He may say he has no power to do it, but I say that a conference between himself and the Minister for Finance and the tramway company on the question of remission of wayleaves would very quickly have made the matter attractive to the tramway company so that they would have provided trolley buses rather than motor buses, thereby using home-produced fuel, and supplying a much more rapid as well as a quieter form of locomotion. However, I am afraid it is too late now; the die has been cast. I suppose no section of the Minister's Department has received more praise than the statistical branch, and I think that praise is probably very well deserved. The only question I should like to ask is whether it would be possible to increase the speed with which the summary of figures from the census of industrial production is made available. We got the 1936 figures only some time this year. I do not know whether it is possible to make them available with any greater promptitude.

I should like also to refer to another matter which has been touched on by one or two speakers, and that is the fact that there seems to be a feeling amongst a lot of people that industry only started when Fianna Fáil came into power. Very many of us are connected with businesses which have been in existence for 50 or 100 years. Unfortunately, in most cases the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government has not been an encouragement to those businesses, but has rather inflicted disabilities on them. I should like the Minister to consider — possibly he does; I do not know — the ramifications of the various duties which are imposed, as affecting existing businesses which have given considerable employment, and given it without having to be nursed by any Government.

Comment on this

There is one point to which I should like to refer, and that is the working of the Road Transport Act. We have received numerous complaints in regard to the system now operating, and I would make a special request to the Minister to review the whole position so far as the operations of that Act are concerned. The principle of the Act and the underlying motives were excellent in so far as the railway companies and the transport services generally were concerned, but the main principle has been defeated. The private owners, and the lorry owners in particular, set out to evade their responsibilities, and through a very clever arrangement, were able to change from being private owners, people entitled to compensation under the Bill, and whose lorries were debarred from competing against the railway companies and so on. They came along at a later stage and advertised themselves as being entitled to act as distributors. I understand that in that way they were able to evade their responsibilities under the Road Transport Act. Consequently, they have become a menace to the railway company in particular and to traders all over the country. The position as we find it in Kerry is one that calls for immediate attention. It will eventually be a question as to whether the Department will come in and save an industry which caters for thousands of workers, as against a system which is being abused by a few people here and there throughout the country. As I have said, the position certainly demands immediate attention.

There is one other point to which I want to refer — I have already referred to it on the Estimate for the Department of Fisheries — and that is the question of part-time fishermen being entitled to unemployment assistance. Time and again in past years we had occasion to draw the Minister's attention to the question of men working one day per week or one hour per day being debarred from obtaining unemployment assistance. In Cahirciveen and along the southern coast those men are employed for perhaps an hour per day or three hours per week. The employment officer arrives there at 7 o'clock or 8 o'clock in the morning to try to make a case against those unfortunate workers. I should like to ask the Minister if those employment officers from the labour exchanges are intended to act as detectives? Are they to go down there and query each fisherman as to whether he intends seeking work or whether he has been offered employment. That is the position in that part of the country, and certainly it is one that should be investigated. I make those points simply because they are urgent in so far as our area is concerned. I think it will be for the benefit of the people as a whole and of the workers in those areas if those matters are considered.

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Flynn has drawn attention to the question of evasion of the Road Transport Act. I do not think the Minister can be too frequently informed of the seriousness of the situation which has developed from those evasions. As Deputy Flynn pointed out, the Act was introduced for the purpose of saving from destruction one of our biggest industries, and preserving to the State a most important service. A decent attempt was made to give effect to that legislation, but unfortunately flaws have been found in it, and, as Deputy Flynn pointed out, its good intentions are being nullified to a very serious extent. At the moment, the position of the railways is becoming very precarious. If something is not done immediately, the employment of railwaymen will be seriously endangered. The legislation passed here is being rendered ineffective, to a very serious extent, by the road pirates who are using the money they got both from the railway companies and the Government to do that. Unless further remedial legislation is introduced, the position will become very serious indeed. I am sure the Minister must have had representations made to him about the matter. I thought it advisable to avail of this occasion to call his attention to the serious position that exists, and to urge on him that it ought to be dealt with with the least possible delay. The seriousness of the position is causing alarm in the country, because, if something is not done immediately, there may be a very grave collapse in our whole railway system. There is at the moment what amounts to an almost complete evasion of the provisions of the 1933 Act, and that is being done by people who got very big compensation from the railway companies. As I have said, the railway industry is threatened with very serious danger, and it is of the utmost importance that something should be done at once.

There is another important matter that I want to deal with, and that is the position of labour exchange staffs. I am aware that after a good deal of agitation an effort has been made to end the temporary nature of the employment of labour exchange staffs, and to give them some kind of permanency on passing a qualifying examination. I understand that an examination is to be held this year and that the number of vacancies to be filled is to be "not less than 20." At the present time the offices have become almost denuded of staffs because it is the custom at this period of the year, when an Employment Period Order is put into operation, to reduce the staffs to the lowest point possible. That position is likely to continue until October when the order ceases to operate. The complaint that I want to make is that the present staffs are altogether inadequate to deal with the claims made for unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit. The position becomes really acute when the list of unemployed persons is fictitiously reduced by the simple process of an Employment Period Order because then the staffs are almost completely automatically wiped out. Abundant evidence can be produced to show that there is not sufficient staff to give attention to the claims made by unemployed persons for unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit. I am anxious to know what the intentions of the Minister are on this matter and what the position is likely to be at the end of the Employment Period Order. If all the temporaries are to be wiped out, what is the position going to be in view of the fact that "not less than 20" vacancies are advertised to be filled? Surely, that number will not be sufficient to replace the temporaries who are being dispensed with. I want to put it to him that adequate staff, temporary or permanent, ought to be employed to give to the claims of unemployed persons in the country the attention that they deserve.

Under the Employment Period Order the unemployed are getting a raw deal. I do not want to go into that matter now because there is a motion on the Order Paper dealing with it. Before the order was put into operation the staffs employed were no more than sufficient to deal with the work in the offices, but when it was made the staffs were cleared out, and, unless some declaration is given to the contrary, there is no indication that they are likely to be re-employed even after October when the order ceases to have effect. What I am anxious to know from the Minister is what are his in tentions with regard to the temporaries who have been dispensed with. Are we to take it that only the 20 vacancies that I have referred to are to be filled or what is the position going to be? It will be a very serious matter if the employment exchanges are to be expected to carry on the heavy work they have to do with depleted staffs, thereby causing additional hardship to unemployed persons.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

The question raised by Deputy Dockrell is a very big question. In fact it is a bigger question than the Deputy actually represented it to be— the production in this country of an inferior type of article that enjoys very high protection. The Minister some time ago introduced a Bill setting up a new Prices Commission. It was heralded at the time by the Government Party as a safeguard for purchasers in this country. At the time we were not very much enamoured of it. We felt that even if there was an examination with regard to prices, there was no machinery being provided to test the value of the articles produced. I entirely agree with the remarks that were made by Deputy Dockrell, namely, that the agricultural implements that are being produced here are, for some reason or other, very inferior. I could produce not broken handles but broken heads of graips, forks and spades — very inferior stuff indeed. There is no machinery provided to see that the people get value in what they buy. The Prices Commission was set up with a great blow of trumpets. It was said that it would be a great safeguard for purchasers. People thought that, at least, there would be an examination as to price, and that we would see results from the work of that Commission. I am afraid that the results so far are not encouraging.

We now find that the Prices Commission is to be diverted from its original intention, as explained to this House, namely, to safeguard the purchasers of this country. The commission is now being put on to another work — to safeguard, to some extent, British manufacturers under the late Agreement. I understand that certain representations have been already made to the Government here by British manufacturers or their agents to have certain matters considered, so that under the terms of the recent Agreement they may have a full opportunity of reasonable competition in this country. I am told that the Prices Commission must take up these matters straight away. I believe it is the feeling of the Government that this work will occupy all the time of the Prices Commission, and that it will take them a long time to overtake it. If that is true, and I believe it is true, what prospects can there be of the Prices Commission safeguarding the purchasing public here with regard to the goods produced? There is no doubt whatever but that the remarks made by Deputy Dockrell are right. Inferior articles are being produced, and at a very high price. Everyone in the country, no matter what side he is on, wants to use and support the Irish article if he can get it, but we are entitled to a good article and ought to get it. In the case of agricultural implements we certainly are not getting it.

There was another matter raised last evening by Deputy Gorey which brings us back to the industrial policy of the Government and the security that it looks for, or ought to look for, when State moneys are advanced. If the allegations made by Deputy Gorey are correct, and I believe he can stand over them with documentary evidence, that transaction in relation to the Carrick-on-Suir slate quarries was tantamount to fraud.

Comment on this

What part of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Perhaps the Minister has not seen the documents. They will be given for the Minister and for the House to see.

Comment on this

The Deputy has used the word "fraud."

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

In connection with what?

Comment on this

The Carrick-on-Suir slate quarries. That went on for ten years. I am asking what part of it. The Deputy is accusing the slate quarries.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I am not accusing anybody. I am saying that if the allegations made by Deputy Gorey are true, and he is prepared to substantiate them by documentary evidence, it is tantamount to fraud.

Comment on this

What fraud? Who committed the fraud?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

The Minister will get an opportunity of appearing in the whole matter and the documents will be produced. We shall see what steps the Minister is taking to safeguard the moneys of this State. In this instance, certain moneys were given by way of loan and certain moneys by way of grant. We want to know what happened to that. We are entitled to know that and the Minister and every other Deputy will get an opportunity of examining the matter from the way we are going to put it.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not be able to avoid having that done.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

That is what we want. We do not want the Minister to be able to avoid it. We want to put the Minister in a position in which he cannot avoid it. If this State is going to lend money, and give money by way of grant, for the setting up of industries, there should be some examination of these matters both before and after the giving of the money. It is not good enough for somebody to say that he believes the project is a good one when, inside two years, from £5,000 to £10,000 of State money is lost and the whole concern goes bankrupt. There ought to be some examination, even then, to see if fraud has been committed. We want that matter cleared up. We want to know if any advances are being made on similar lines to other undertakings and what guarantee there is for the people in the use of their money in that particular way. I hope that, when the matter comes before the House and an examination of it takes place, the Minister will stand up to his responsibilities. Of course, he will have to do so, but we want to give him the opportunity, and we shall do so.

Comment on this

When I was speaking a few moments ago, I am told that I referred to "demands" of the trade unions. I should have said "attitude" instead of "demands."

Comment on this

This Estimate is, in many respects, the most important Estimate on which the House is asked to pass judgment because it refers to a wide field of national and economic endeavour such as affects the lives and livelihood of large sections of our people. It is right, therefore, that the Estimate should be examined critically and with a desire to indicate to the Government the weaknesses which reveal themselves and the opportunity which presents itself to apply renewed energy and greater enthusiasm to the task of repairing the economic ravages which are visible to all of us to-day. I should like to ask the Minister what his intention is in respect of the application to other grades of workers than industrial and shop workers of the legislative code intended to regulate the hours of work in industry, to provide holidays with pay and to impose other restrictions on the conditions under which industrial workers and shop assistants at present toil. Is it the Minister's intention to extend these codes to the transport services, to offices and to commerce? What is the general plan for removing the difficulty which reveals itself when you remember that certain types of workers are covered by that legislation while other workers are completely ignored? We had from the Minister the statement some time ago that it was his intention to introduce legislation for the purpose of securing to all workers the right to holidays with pay——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Legislation may not be advocated on Estimates.

Comment on this

I am not advocating legislation. I am asking the Minister what he intends to do in connection with the statement he made that legislation would he introduced. Can the Minister, at this stage, give the House more definite information than he gave at that time?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister would not be in order in doing so.

Comment on this

I understand you to rule that it is not in order for me, on the Minister's Estimate, to ask whether he can supplement the statement he previously made that legislation would be introduced in connection with this matter?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy need not paraphrase the Chair's ruling. Legislation may not be discussed, as such, nor may it be advocated in a debate on the Estimates. That ruling requires no paraphrase.

Comment on this

I submit that I have not advocated legislation. I have asked the Minister what he intends to do to bring about a position of equality as between worker and worker.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If that is not advocacy of legislation by the Deputy, I am much mistaken.

Comment on this

If you rule that it is out of order, I shall pass from it, but I submit it is a rather rigid ruling on a matter of this kind, when I am merely asking the Minister to give the House more definite information than he gave on a previous occasion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has now repeated the request for legislation.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister intends to do anything in connection with the transport service in the City of Dublin for which he is responsible under existing legislation, and for which he has a special responsibility as Minister for Industry and Commerce. We used to be told, at one time, that it was the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party to nationalise the railways, and to municipalise the city transport service. We have had no evidence, so far, of a policy to nationalise the railways or to municipalise the city transport service. There is widespread complaint in Dublin in regard to the inadequate transport service. The Press contains letters almost every day from citizens who complain that they are seriously inconvenienced by the inadequacy of the service. Recently, a demand was made on the Minister by the Dublin Corporation to exercise his power and call a conference to discuss this whole question of inadequate transport services in the city. The Minister has not seen fit to do that. He takes the view that everything is all right in regard to the municipal transport service. Everybody who has to use these services knows that they are far from being right, that they are all wrong in many respects, and that they are less adequate than the services which people enjoyed five or six years ago. On top of that, the transport service to-day is much more costly than it was five or six years ago. There has been a very substantial increase in the bus and tram fares. That increase has not been imposed as a result of any impartial examination of the claim for increase by the tramways company before a body of persons who have some interest in maintaining an efficient and less expensive mode of conveyance than exists to-day. The Minister is quite prepared to allow the present unsatisfactory service to continue and, apparently, he does not propose to do anything in connection with the frequent rises in transport charges in the city. It is not merely a case of one increase. There have been a number of increases, and a number of hidden increases, by means of a scheme of shortening the stages, and consequently increasing the charge for a long-distance run.

Comment on this

There was also a very long strike and a very substantial increase in the rates of wages paid.

Comment on this

Is that the Minister's justification for it?

Comment on this

I do not say that it is a justification, but it is at least an explanation.

Comment on this

What is the case for refusing an impartial examination of the whole position of transportation charges and inadequate transport services in the city? The Dublin Corporation is being forced, as part of its housing scheme, to purchase virgin sites on the outskirts of the city, and workers are being asked to move from their present insanitary accommodation into the new houses being erected by the corporation there. No sooner have they taken up residence in their new houses, for which they are probably paying a higher rent, for, I admit, very much better accommodation, than they find transportation charges over these routes substantially increased. These increases, coupled with the increase in rent and the heavy obligations which fall on them in endeavouring to equip their new homes, mean a greatly increased tax on the workers. The enterprise and energy of the corporation in providing virgin housing sites is being availed of by our city transport company to increase fares and thus impose a very heavy tax on those who live in these areas. Is there nothing to be done by the Department to prevent workers so circumstanced from being held up to ransom by a private transport company which has apparently no responsibility to the citizens and into whose activities the Minister is apparently not prepared to direct a searching inquiry?

I think the people who are living in these housing areas ought to know, before they move out to them, what they are likely to be committed to in respect of transportation charges. It is obviously unfair that people who move out to Kimmage, Crumlin or Drimnagh should, shortly afterwards, find that transportation charges are increased and no guarantee that there will not be further substantial increases. It is just another way of reducing their income. The Minister ought to tell us whether he has any proposals for dealing with that situation and what he intends to do to ensure that the citizens will not be held up to ransom as they have been held up, during the past few years, in particular.

This, Sir, is a suitable opportunity for reviewing the policy of the Government in respect of unemployment. We used to be told that the Government had a plan which would solve the unemployment problem, and some people were so entranced by that plan that they even visualised the possibility that we might not be able to get all the unemployed workers who would be necessary and that it might be necessary to send to America for the emigrants. The Minister apparently believed in that condition of affairs in 1931, because during a by-election in the constituency of Kildare in that year, he declared, at Monasterevan:—

"There is no reason why there should be any unemployment in the Twenty-Six Counties."

There was no reason in 1931 why there should be any unemployment in the Twenty-Six Counties, but, in 1938, before the two recent Employment Period Orders were made operative, we had approximately 100,000 unemployed, that is, seven years after that hopeful prophecy was expressed. That kind of statement by the Minister is an indication of the enthusiasm with which the Government believed it would be possible to cure unemployment and their optimism is symbolised in that flamboyant statement, which is typical of a number of other statements.

Since 1932, we have seen efforts by the Government to deal with the unemployment problem by means of the development of home industries and we have seen efforts made by the imposition of tariffs, quotas and restrictions to assist in the building up of native industries here. I concede at once, and I say it again now, even though I am sure I shall be misrepresented by the Minister when he is replying, or when he is speaking elsewhere, that I believe it is essential that we should protect our industries against foreign dumping because in this country, with its small population and its lack of a well-rooted industrial tradition, it is obvious to anybody who takes any time to study the matter that we cannot establish industries and compete in the open market with the products of industries in countries which have a long industrial tradition, which have reached a high degree of mechanisation, which have enormous capital resources and which have the ability to produce for a large market. In circumstances such as these and surrounded by competitors of that kind, one would be foolish to imagine that one could develop industries here without the imposition of tariffs, quotas and other restrictions necessary to protect the home market. While I say that the imposition of tariffs and resort to quotas and restrictions are necessary as part of a scheme of development, my complaint is that the Government's policy in respect of these items takes the form merely of imposing a tariff, or applying a quota or restriction, and not effectively supervising development and production in the industry which it is sought to protect.

A very obvious feature of the Government's policy is that they merely impose a tariff to assist an industry and wait to see what will happen. There is no effective State supervision in the meantime and no effective inquiry as to the degree of progress being made by the factory which it is sought to help. Apparently the factory can carry on supplying 20 per cent., 30 per cent., 40 per cent. or 50 per cent. of the home market requirements and no effective steps are taken by the Department to ensure that that factory is equipped and organised to supply the entire requirements of the home market at the earliest possible moment. There seems to be a complete absence of any plan of supervision, or any plan to stimulate development, in relation to some of these new industries. The proof of that is to be found in the fact that there is still an enormous amount of imports coming into the country for which the consumer here is paying, because our home factories are not capable of supplying the entire home demand, and when you impose a tax —let us face it frankly—on foreign goods, it is the consumer, and not the exporter, of these goods who pays the tax. It may be necessary that the consumer should pay that tax for a while because of the difficulty of devising some machinery by which he can be exempted from doing so, but commonsense surely demands that if the consumers' need, nationally expressed, cannot be satisfied from home production, steps should be taken to accelerate home production and to insist that factories which have been established here with the benefit of tariffs and quotas should at the earliest possible moment equip themselves to supply the entire home market.

That type of supervision, however, does not apparently find any place in the outlook of the Department or of the Minister in respect of these new industries. I know that many of them which are supplying 40 per cent of the requirements of the home market, and have been doing so for years, show little evidence that they will ever supply 100 per cent. of those requirements, even in respect of standard commodities in which there is no great variation and in respect of which the home product could be made as good as the imported product. I think a considerable portion of the Minister's efforts in respect of the development of industries is being wasted and thwarted by the slothfulness of some of the new industrialists to take advantage of the very considerable assistance they have got in the form of tariffs and quotas. They seem to be prepared to jog along in the present position, not realising that in respect of these industries, not merely in law have they a degree of responsibility, but that they are also trustees for the people in the matter of manufacturing goods of that type. I said before, and I will say it again, that I do not believe that in a small country such as this, with a large population, which might be described as a peasant population, that it is possible to develop a policy of complete self-sufficiency.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

A new alliance.

Comment on this

You will be converted shortly too.

Comment on this

You are embarrassing Deputy Norton considerably.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I have never believed it possible, because I think the physical, financial and productive impediments are so great as to prevent anybody achieving that situation. You can do it only by producing certain commodities for which you will have to charge famine prices. If you do that, then you immediately worsen the standard of living of those who have got to purchase at famine prices. That does not mean that you cannot develop in this country large-scale industries which are indigenous to the country, or which can be suitably carried on in this country with adequate facilities and with adequate supervision from the State. I notice that the Minister for Industry and Commerce in a speech at a dinner which he attended recently threw over completely the idea of entire economic self-sufficiency. To that extent, therefore, we are at one, that you cannot in the circumstances of this country concentrate upon, and hope to bring to fruition, a policy of complete self-sufficiency. It can only be done by debasing the standard of living of large sections in the country. You cannot live in the conditions of this country if you produce all you need for your own requirements and to be able to sell in some other market your surplus produce. If you are entitled to seek complete self-sufficiency, every other nation is entitled to do the same. When you get eventually to that state of complete national self-sufficiency throughout the world you have got a position of hair-shirt economics that the world would be well rid of. I think anybody who seeks an objective of that kind is travelling along the wrong road for the development of our industries here. But I do believe there are many industries, very important from the point of view of supplying the goods our people require, very important from the point of view of providing employment for our people, and very important from the standpoint of utilising the raw materials of the country, which can be developed here and which can be developed to a greater extent than they are to-day.

I think the Minister and his Department ought to survey the economic position of the country and determine in respect of the large scale industries which are suitable to this country, which have a tradition rooted in this country, that there should be an extensive State supervision to ensure that these industries will be encouraged to produce to the maximum possible extent to supply the home market. Our industries so far have got all encouragement possible from the Legislature by the imposition of high tariffs. They have got all the asistance possible from the community who have had to bear heavy taxes on imported articles and it is not too much to expect that these industries should respond to an urge from the State, that they should equip themselves to supply in the shortest possible time all the requirements of the home market. I am making all due allowance for all that has been done within the past six years. Some of the things that have been done have been praiseworthy. The ideas which inspired some of these achievements have been admirable, but when you have said that, you still see a vast field of thwarted endeavour, a vast field of things undone, an enormous amount of work which still awaits to be done.

We were told in 1931 by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce that there was no reason why any unemployment should exist in the 26 counties, yet we have to-day 100,000 unemployed after the plan has been in operation for six years. When we consider that in a small State of 3,000,000 people, we have 100,000 unemployed people, I think we must come to the conclusion that the fact that you have that large number of unemployed really means that you have an idle State within the State itself, because the dependents of these unemployed people are not taken into the calculation in reaching that huge figure.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that figure?

Comment on this

From the Minister's own statistics.

Comment on this

The Deputy could not get any such figure from my statistics.

Comment on this

I shall quote them for the Minister.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy quoting the current figure?

Comment on this

I am quoting the figure for the week ending 30th May last.

Comment on this

Why go back to the 30th May? This is July.

Comment on this

There has been an Employment Period Order since.

Comment on this

The Minister would not say that there are many generations between May and July.

Comment on this

Take May. Go on.

Comment on this

If the Minister would suppress his impatience I shall give him the figures. The Minister asks why I do not take the month of June instead of the month of May. The Minister has been dealing the cards in the meantime. I want to give the position of the cards before the Minister got his deal.

Comment on this

Is there a joker in them?

Comment on this

Why not go back to February?

Comment on this

I shall tell the Minister.

Comment on this

There was another Employment Period Order made in March.

Comment on this

Before the Employment Period Order was made, that is, in the week ending May 30th, there were 97,571 registered as unemployed.

Comment on this

They were not registered as unemployed.

Comment on this

If the Minister is going to throw doubts on the accuracy of the figures supplied by his own Department it is impossible to pursue the discussion with him.

Comment on this

The Deputy is confusing two things.

Comment on this

Let me explain the figures to the House, even if the Minister disagrees. According to the Department of Industry and Commerce, there were 97,571 persons registered as unemployed and seeking work at the employment exchanges in the week ending the 30th May. Before that the Minister had issued an Employment Period Order, under which approximately 3,000 persons ceased to be registered at the exchanges because there was no purpose in their registering there. Is that not 100,000 people? Under the recent Employment Period Order, another 24,000 will be knocked off the figure of 97,000. That does not prove that they have got employment. It only proves that they are not qualified now to receive unemployment assistance benefit. They may be just as hungry as they were in March or April, but they will get no benefit during the currency of the order. It is quite clear, notwithstanding the talk about all that has been done, that all that has been done has made no effective impression on the unemployment problem in the country. In my opinion, the Government now realises that, notwithstanding all the talk of plans and of all that has been done for the past six years, they are now in the position of really having no effective plan for dealing with the unemployment problem.

This is what the Taoiseach said on the subject when he addressed himself to it last month at Blarney, after someone had suggested that £10,000,000 should be made available:—

"Ten millions would not solve the unemployment problem. They could spend the money and it would only keep the wolf from the door. In a little while they would have to look for another £10,000,000, and still another £10,000,000."

There is a vast difference between the sentiments expressed there and the enthusiasm of the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he spoke in Monasterevan in 1931. The Taoiseach was talking in the light of realities showing they had no policy. He said that they could spend £10,000,000, then another £10,000,000, and a third £10,000,000 on unemployment, and that it was only going to keep the wolf from the door. That is the position we have now drifted into from the optimism of 1931-32. The Government has thrown up the sponge on the question of unemployment. There is no policy whatever for dealing with it, except to try to deal the cards and put in unemployment orders, but the figures then do not represent the true facts of the situation. Bad as the problem is now, it would be worse but for the fact that there is an armament boom in Britain to-day. Every ship leaving this country taking passengers or stowaways is taking men and women to England, trying to get the employment there that they cannot get here. The returns during the last five years show that 75,000 of our people have gone abroad looking for employment that they cannot get here. The Taoiseach told the House yesterday that the paying of £5,000,000 to Britain was equivalent to giving that country all our fat cattle for nothing. Now we are making a present of 75,000 adults, the flower of our manhood and womanhood, to Britain, and getting nothing in return, although it is estimated that the cost of rearing and educating an adult man or woman is approximately £1,000. We are giving Britain 75,000 men and women and we have no policy whatever for stopping that drift or dealing with the situation when the tide turns. It is generally conceded by those qualified to judge, that the prospects of a European war have now somewhat receded, for the time being at all events, and that a calmer situation exists in Europe. That may have an effect on Britain's armament proposals and these may not be as extensive as was at first contemplated.

In any case, there is a limit even to Britain's armament proposals and the amount of work provided under them. When the armament plans of Britain are completed or slowed down, Irish workers who went to England will find themselves unemployed. It is quite possible they will try to carry on under the scheme for unemployment there, by existing on the rates of benefit provided under the various Acts under which they are eligible, but quite a number may drift back here trying to find employment. When that drift back takes place we will then be in the position of having a vast army of unemployed people for whom we have made no plans for the provision of work, and no proposals to deal with the returned exiles who will then be clamouring for the opportunity to get work. There is not a feature of the present Government policy calculated to deal with a situation of that kind. Obviously, if we are to avoid the evils which will arise from it someone should be thinking about formulating a policy to reduce the numbers unemployed, and stop the wasteful drift of men and women to England seeking employment. Unemployment will be bad in any circumstances, but it is much worse when you find unemployed workers compelled to exist on rates of unemployment assistance which take no cognisance whatever of human needs. There are three scales of unemployment assistance benefit. One applies to large cities, one to towns with a population of 7,000 or over, and the other scale to towns with less than 7,000 and rural areas. As everyone knows, the bulk of our towns have a population of less than 7,000, and it is there, probably, that the greatest degree of hardship exists under the Unemployment Assistance Act. A man, his wife and five children are expected to exist on a benefit of 14/- a week in these towns. Supposing he had not to pay rent, buy clothes, for himself, his wife or children, boots, medicine, fuel, light, school books, or any of the commodities which enter into the budget of any ordinary household, no matter how poor the standard of living, and that those commodities were supplied free — of course, we know they are not — we find that a family of seven people have 14/- to live on.

Comment on this

The rates are fixed by the Dáil and are not varied by me.

Comment on this

I know that. I am not saying that the Minister has power to vary the rates, but I am asking him what he proposes to do as Minister for Industry and Commerce whose office is a charge on this Estimate, to deal with a situation that necessitates thousands of our people existing on that pauperised scale of benefit.

Comment on this

It is in the Act which the Dáil passed.

Comment on this

The Minister now, in accordance with his usual petulance, wants the Dáil simply to pass anything he asks, and to ask no questions or direct his attention to an obvious situation. So long as there is freedom of expression in this House I will try to ask the Minister what he intends to do as Minister for Industry and Commerce —even though he does not like it. That is the one benefit of democratic government, that we can at least put the impact of one point of view against another.

Comment on this

At the right time. This is not the right time.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the point raised by the Minister, on Estimates administration is discussed. If, however, there is a motion to refer back even an item in the Estimate, intention is indicated to discuss the policy of the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been referring to rates of unemployment assistance payable which were fixed by an Act of the Dáil. I refuse to take responsibility for that. The Government as a whole is responsible, and any question affecting that legislation, or proposing to alter it, can be raised here, but I submit not on this Estimate.

Comment on this

May I submit that changes in legislation may be advocated, and facts that follow from that may be adduced to strengthen such arguments, which is a different thing. That, I take it, is what Deputy Norton wants.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I took the remarks made by Deputy Norton to refer to the policy of the Government in regard to certain matters, with certain results, as seen by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister should be so peevish if I direct attention to the fact that so many of our people have to exist on that amount.

Comment on this

I have been sitting here for two days.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's idea of democratic institutions.

Comment on this

It is because the Minister has been sitting here for two days, but under the sub-head a salary is provided for him. That is why we pay the Minister a salary — to sit here and listen to these things, and, after all, the Minister has only just come back from an election in which he asked the people to enable him to sit here for another five years and deal with this matter. Now the Minister gets impetuous because his attention is directed to some facts which ought to concern him as Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am pointing out hard facts that cannot be overlooked — that a man, his wife and seven children have got to exist upon 14/- a week under the Unemployment Assistance Act.

Comment on this

Five children.

Comment on this

Five children, or seven, or ten — no matter how many a man has — he still only gets 14/- per week. If you assume that a number of commodities will be purchased for him and given to him free, such as rent, fuel, light, clothes, boots and shoes, school books, medicine, and a whole lot of things of that kind, then the man is driven down to the position that he has 14/- per week upon which to feed a family of seven for seven days; that is 2/- per week per person. In seven days he has got to provide 21 meals for each person out of the 2/-, and if you work it out on that basis you find that each person in that family can spend five farthings on a meal, notwithstanding the fact that they have no money whatever for a whole range of other commodities which necessarily enter into the budget of a working-class family. Yet, in spite of that, we have the most glib references to prosperity and the most irresponsible references to returning prosperity. If that prosperity does exist why is it not possible to share some of it with a section of the community that is suffering as harshly as these recipients of unemployment assistance benefit are suffering? If the Minister feels disposed again to talk about prosperity at functions let him keep these hard facts before him, and I think they will prove a very effective antidote to irresponsible talk about prosperity when conditions of that kind are the conditions which tens of thousands of our people know to their cost throughout the year. The fact that that situation exists, the fact that we have 100,000 at least unemployed people in the country, the fact that our new industries are not giving the productivity which they should give and would give under adequate State supervision and direction and stimulus, indicate that, so far as our industrial development is concerned, it has not reached a degree of efficiency and is not fortified by any planned outlook in respect of industry. I advocated before — the Taoiseach used to advocate it in other days — the establishment of an economic council which would deal with matters of that kind in some kind of planned way. Since then I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce may have persuaded the Taoiseach that it is quite unnecessary, that he can do all the planning, all the thinking and all the long-range view in respect of industrial development. We can see the catastrophe that is attending the attempt by the Minister to carry out functions of that kind — a large number of unemployed, low rates of unemployment assistance benefit and a very serious stratum of poverty throughout the country. If that position is to be corrected, then there is need for more thinking and for more vision in the Department of Industry and Commerce and more evidence of a real determination to push those phases of industrial development which will yield the best results in the shortest possible space of time.

I, therefore, have availed of this opportunity to direct the Minister's attention to these problems in the hope that anything I have said on that mat ter may stimulate thought in the direction of realising that even though certain progress has been made here in this country during the past 16 years a lot remains to be done. And here we are not doing as much, radical though we foolishly imagine that we are, as other progressive countries in Europe and throughout the world are doing in this age of rapid change.

I think the Minister ought to take the House into his confidence and give us some indication of what are the Govern ment's proposals for dealing with the very serious unemployment problem and for dealing with an emigration problem which is as serious as the unem ployment problem because it is reducing the population of the country; it is bringing down the standard of virility in the country and giving us the unenviable reputation that there is a lower marriage rate in this country— always an unhealthy symptom — than in any other white country on the face of God's earth to-day.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton has come round to the view that economic self-sufficiency is a cod. Is not that a great blessing? How long is it going to be before the Minister for Industry and Commerce has the moral courage to come out and tell the people that he also has come round to the point of view that economic self-sufficiency is a cod? Every rational man in this country knew that six years ago. In the glorious days when the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party were stumping this country over economic self-sufficiency and denouncing anybody who criticised that as a West Briton and as a saboteur of Irish industry, I remember that when we pointed out that economic self-sufficiency could never be got and that it would only involve the poor of this country in frightful hardships Deputy Norton and the Minister for Industry and Commerce used to get choleric with rage.

Comment on this

Quote me once as backing complete economic self-sufficiency.

Comment on this

I hear all sorts of adverbs and adjectives being dragged out of the bandbox now in order to provide some kind of loophole for escape. Economic self-sufficiency was the policy of the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party for the last six years. Now they have got sick of it, but they have only got sick of it after they have made our people suffer bitterly for six years. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is taking up the adjectives and the adverbs too. He is explaining that he never meant real economic self-sufficiency; that he never said entire economic self-sufficiency; that he only meant partial economic self-sufficiency. When will both of these gentlemen have the moral courage to get out and say: "We have made fools of ourselves and now we want to work back to get back as fast as we can out of the mess into which we have dragged the country." Mind you, when they do it they will do that in good company because it was a remarkable thing that the Secretary of State for the United States of America got up at Geneva two or three years ago and stated publicly that he was obliged to confess that the United States of America had led the world into the morass of economic self-sufficiency and stated "for our responsibility for that error we feel the duty heavy upon us in now leading the world out of that bog." And one voice was heard. One voice in the councils of the nations of the world was heard to say that he still believed in economic self-sufficiency, and that was the voice of Seán Lemass, the Minister for Industry and Commerce from Saorstát Eireann, as it then was. And since then he has been taking up the adjectives and adverbs in order to prove that when he spoke of economic self-sufficiency at Geneva and in the country here he did not mean complete economic self-sufficiency; he meant only partial economic self-sufficiency. When can we clear the decks of all the rubbish that has accumulated in the political and economic past of the Fianna Fáil Party and get down to work in order to mend the damage that has been done in the futile search for economic self-sufficiency? The sooner the Minister for Industry and Commerce comes out and announces his readiness to take the necessary steps to repair the damage that he has done the sooner we will be able to get on with the job. I suggest to him that he will find in the Banking Commission report a very good hobby horse to ride off upon. He can put all the blame for jettisoning his own economic past on the Banking Commission. I think when he gets time to read that document — he has had it for three months now, but he has not got down to reading it yet — but when he does get time to read it, and strength to read it, he will find in it all the arguments he wants to justify abandoning the fraud and folly of economic self-sufficiency.

There are one or two urgent evils arising out of that fraud, however, that require correction at once, even before the Minister for Industry and Commerce has mustered the requisite moral courage to reject the doctrine as a whole. Deputy Benson to-day pointed out that, to judge from many of the speeches made by Fianna Fáil supporters, one would imagine that they believed there was no industry in this country before Fianna Fáil came into existence. Deputy Benson added that, far from that being so, the best industries in this country were in existence before Fianna Fáil was ever heard of or thought of. And those are the industries that gave good employment, steady employment, produced goods at an economic price, and asked for no tariffs or subsidies at all. They find themselves, far from being helped by Fianna Fáil economics, gravely embarrassed by them. You had good industries established in this country. They were growing in efficiency, they were improving their products, they were improving their conditions of employment, and they were reducing costs to the consumer.

In that state of affairs the Minister for Industry and Commerce arrived upon the scene and announced his intention of producing in this country, not only the finished article, but the raw materials of the existing industries in Ireland. Then he proceeded to tariff these factories' raw materials in order to get them manufactured here, whereupon these well-established factories had to pay exorbitant prices for their raw materials and these exorbitant prices that they had to pay resulted in their having to raise the price of their own finished product. Not infrequently they have been obliged to incorporate in their finished product a raw material which they knew to be inferior, but they were forced to take it because they would not be allowed to buy the best raw materials, which were not obtainable in this country at all.

The necessity that was put upon them of incorporating second-class raw materials in more than one case has injured the good name of their product, which up to then had always been regarded as first-class, and in addition to reducing the quality of the finished product, the higher cost of the raw materials thrust upon them by the Minister raised the cost of the finished article to a point in some cases where the consumers' purchasing capacity does not permit them to buy the same quantity as they used to buy. The well-established factories giving good and steady employment at decent rates of wages are being forced on to part-time because they have been obliged to raise the price of the product and reduce its quality as a result of tariffs inadvisedly put on by the Minister on the raw materials that these old-established businesses were obliged to buy.

That is all the logical working out of the doctrine of economic self-sufficiency, and where I find fault with Deputy Norton is this, that he urges the Minister to operate the policy of economic self-sufficiency, the Minister takes him at his word and proceeds to operate that policy, and when the obvious flaws and follies of that policy manifest themselves, the first man to protest, and most vigorously, is Deputy Norton. There is no use urging the Minister to prosecute the policy of economic self-sufficiency and then complain bitterly when he does it. He cannot help it. If his riding instructions are to produce in this country everything that it is physically possible to produce, then the difficulties of which Deputy Norton complains are absolutely inevitable. They are going to force costs up and up until the old-established industries find the consumers are no longer able to pay the price of their product, and the consumers simply have to do without that product. It puts the factory on halftime and incidentally reduces the standard of living of the people.

The difference between a high standard of living and a low standard of living is whether a farmer down the country can buy boots for his children or has to send them out bare-footed. If you keep the price of boots reasonably low, then the farmer can afford to buy them for his wife and himself and his children. The labouring man earning a weekly wage can afford to buy boots for himself and his wife and family. That can be regarded as a high standard of living. If you raise the price of boots unduly, the time will come when he can afford boots only for himself, his wife, and the children who are going to school; the younger children go bare-footed. That is a low standard of living. You may lower it further to the point where the children have to go bare-footed all the time. The lowest degree is where, if you raise the price of boots to so high a level that they become luxury, we must go back to the 1848 standard, when the labouring man and his wife and children all went bare-footed.

And that happened. There was a time when the landlord class in this country thought it right that it should happen, that the dirty Irish should go bare-footed. They were not entitled to a high standard of living. It was presumption on the part of the dirty natives to want to have boots. They had strong feet designed to walk on stones, and they ought to walk on them, and they made them go bare-footed. We got liberty in this country in order to provide these people with a reasonable standard of living, and give them the right to dress and live as well as their neighbours. That is what the whole struggle was about. Now, having got to that stage, we are sedulously taking it away from them, not for the benefit of the landlord class, but for the benefit of certain individuals who come in here and, behind sky-high tariffs, mulct the people. I refer now to the warriors who have landed here from Czecho-Slovakia and the world beyond in order to plunder our people. The sooner they go back to Czecho-Slovakia the better pleased will I be, and I have never disguised that. They are no damn good to us or to anybody else.

The well-established and well-run industries controlled by Irish companies have given good service to the Irish people, and, if they were allowed to carry on their business in the way they always did, they would improve their efficiency and give a better article as time passed by. They were doing that when Fianna Fáil came into office. It is only since Fianna Fáil came into office that the highway robbery that is going on behind tariff walls began. There is no use in Deputy Norton complaining when he himself voted for every tariff, when he encouraged the Minister to bring in the fly-by-nights and carrion-crows that have flocked here from the four corners of the world to fatten on our people.

We have got to face this. Our national income in this country depends upon the profitable exploitation of the land of this country. But the profitable exploitation of our land depends upon the success of the farmers and the labourers who live on that land selling the produce of their labour profitably in the British market. All the cod about the alternative markets has gone up the spout now. Nobody believes in that sort of thing any more. It is just like one of the cheap election cries of sending to America and bringing back our emigrants from America to fill the positions in this country that we could not fill ourselves. Our success eventually depends upon making a profit out of the agricultural produce that we sell in the British market. We have got back eventually the British market with some restrictions. But we have got it back. We cannot, however, control prices in the British market because we have no power to do so. We have got to take for our agricultural produce whatever that price will fetch in the British market.

Our profit and our national income depend on the difference between the cost of production of agricultural produce in this country and the price at which we can sell that produce in Great Britain. That is the profit and on that profit the entire national income and ultimately the standard of living of our entire people is going to depend. I repeat again that we cannot raise the prices that are to be had in the British market, but we can reduce the cost of production in Ireland. It is just as effective for us to reduce the cost of production in Ireland as it would be to raise correspondingly the prices in Great Britain. If it was in our power in Dáil Eireann to-day to increase the price of every beast and every pound's worth of agricultural produce that we send to the British market would we not do it if we could by Act or resolution of this House?

If we could get for every farm and every farm labourer in this country 20 per cent. more for his work than he gets at present would we not do it at once? Yes, it would be done unanimously. We cannot increase the profit of our agricultural workers in that way, but we can do it just as effectively by reducing the cost of production as we could by raising the price of our produce in the British market. We would pass that resolution unanimously in ten minutes; we can add to the profits of our farmers and farm labourers just as effectively by reducing the cost of production as if we were to pass a resolution raising the prices of our goods in the British market. The profit for our farmers can be made by taking steps to reduce the cost of production.

At the present time there is a tax on Indian meal, there is a tax on artificial manure, a tax on farm implements and, indeed, on every single thing the farmer has to use. In the production of agricultural produce every tax reduces the profit of the people living on the land. Every penny put on by tariffs reduces the profits. Every penny that you take from the farmer in tariffs represents one penny off his profits. Every penny of relief that the farmer gets increases his profits. As I have already said, if a resolution of this House could raise our prices in England we would all be unanimous in that. At the present moment if you want to buy any artificial manures to spread on your land you find that you have to pay 4/6 a cwt. for superphosphate as against 3/- per cwt. in Northern Ireland. Can you imagine what that 1/6 on 3/- represents to the farmers? If you want to buy a cwt. of Indian meal you have to pay 2/- more for it than you do in Northern Ireland. It is the same if you want to buy a fork, graipe, rake or anything else that is required on the farm. If the productivity of your land is to be fully developed you have to put on artificial manures.

If you raise the price of so simple a commodity as boots the point will be reached when people cannot go on wearing them. If the prices of artificial manures are raised too high the farmer must stop using artificials on his land. The quality of the land will go down. Now, remember that the land is not only the farmer's property. It is a national asset. If the custodian of the national asset is excessively taxed and is forced to give up caring for his land as he had been caring for it in the past, not only is the property of the individual farmer being deteriorated, but the national asset is being deteriorated. Will any man who knows the country deny that the land has in several regions deteriorated so much that scutch grass and weeds have spread through it in the course of the last four years? Why is that? It is because the people are not putting into the land anything to replace what they are taking out of it. The farmers are not able to buy artificial manures. They are not able to properly feed their stock because of the tariffs on feeding stuffs and because the tariffs make feeding of live stock uneconomic. The result is that the farmers are not only losing their profit, but they are dissipating the wealth which was buried in the land in the time of our fathers and grandfathers since the farmers got fixity of tenure. That was one of the great revolutions in this country; when the people got fixity of tenure they put their savings into improving the land instead of keeping their savings in old stockings or putting them in the bank. The people went on improving their land and steadily as a result of that the standard of living of the people was raised and their wealth grew. These things resulted from the improvements the people were able to carry out on the land.

Now if the Dáil is going to make the cost of artificial manures and foodstuffs too high so that it is uneconomic to use them, the standard of living of the country is as certain to go down as it went down in the days of the rack-renting landlords and the reign of the bailiffs between 1800 and 1848 and again between 1848 and 1881. There is no escape from that. There is not a Deputy in the House who would oppose a resolution raising the price of our produce in the English market by 20 per cent. We would be all unanimous on that. If we take the tax off the raw materials which the farmers have to use, the Dáil can increase their profits just as effectively as by passing that resolution increasing the price in the British markets. There surely is no need to labour the necessity of casing the pressure on the farmers.

The Minister at present is harassing our old established industry by reason of the high cost of the raw materials the farmer uses. Every small farm in this country is, in a sense, a small factory in which the man and his wife and two or three children are employed. He brings on to that land raw materials in the shape of bonhams and feeding stuffs. His livestock is used as the machinery through which the feeding stuff, the raw material, is turned into the finished product. He brings the finished product to the fair and sells it. That is how he makes his profits. Surely we ought to take the burden off the backs of this old-established industry that has been giving good employment and did good work long before Fianna Fáil was ever heard of. After all, many of the farmers had a good standard of living and were able to amass money before the advent of Fianna Fáil to office. The Minister for Industry and Commerce would sooner produce alcohol from potatoes rather than milk, beef and pork out of Indian meal. There is of late growing up in this country and in most other countries a most extraordinary economic fallacy. That is that there is abundance of everything for everybody and that the time has come when we can all sit back and take things easy. They tell us there is too much for everybody. That is a most insane illusion. The fact is that if we are to maintain our standard of living even as it is, much less improve it, we all have to work like blacks.

It will put us to the pin of our collar in the next ten or twenty years to maintain our existing standard of living. It is going to be extremely difficult. Remember, the output of the agricultural industry in this country has fallen in the last few years by over 30 per cent., and that means a reduction in our national wealth. Far from contemplating further reductions, I warn this House that we will have to strain at the collar to maintain the existing standard of living as we all desire to do, but it is going to be mighty difficult to do. Remember, we have enjoyed for so long a time safety and the sense of security resultant from being members of the Commonwealth of Nations that we have forgotten what it means, what it could mean, if that security were ever jeopardised. Deputies here forget that the Chancellor, Von Hitler, of the German Reich, asked his people whether they preferred to have guns or butter, and then announced that anyone who preferred butter to guns was a traitor and would be put in a concentration camp and that they had damn well better prefer guns to butter; and they are doing without butter there in order to finance the purchase of guns.

Now, I do not want to see the day in this country when we are going to be asked to choose between guns and butter; when we are going to be asked whether we would elect to finance the defence proposals of the Government or reduce our employment bill or any of the other social services at present in operation. If we are not to do that, however, we have got to face the fact that hard work is vital for us all and that there can be no question of anybody lying down on the job. Now, under our system, the only way to get hard work is to make hard work profitable, and if you are going to leave the major industries of this country in such a condition that the harder you work the less you earn, the people will stop working them altogether and, instead of working on the land, they will simply register as unemployed, because they will come to the conclusion that the dole, which comes in regularly once a week — even it is only 8/- —is more than they can hope to get slaving on the land. They will let the land go to waste and collect the dole instead.

I wonder if any Deputies in this House have read a book called "The Irish Countryman"? Did they ever realise how rural life in this country really functioned? Did they ever ask themselves why the farmer's son ever worked on the land at all? All of us who live in the West of Ireland, near where the small congests live, are familiar with the way in which the small 20-acre farm is worked. The farmer is able to work his small farm because his sons work for him. He does not employ labour, but his boys help on the farm. The reason they helped was because they had to get their pocket-money from their father. He could not put them out of the house because that would cause a scandal in the neighbourhood, and when they came for money for cigarettes, dances or amusements, they depended on the father's approval of the help they had given in the past week in order to get the money and, signs on it, they took very good care to keep on the right side of the head of the house because, if they did not do so, they knew that they would find no softness in him and there would be no pocket-money.

Now, however, you have the dole, and a very considerable number of these boys have registered for 8/- a week. They cannot be put out of the house because, as I have said, that would mean a scandal in the neighbourhood and would cause a rift in the family and general disgrace. They have three square meals in the day and their bed, and they draw the dole as well. The result is that there are a great many small farmers in this country who find it extremely difficult to get their sons to do any work at all on the farm, and they are not able to put up any competitive bid against the dole for the services of their sons because they are not getting enough out of the land to enable that to be done. Ask the people who live in rural Ireland if that is not true, and you will find that in large parts of rural Ireland the young people would much prefer to get the dole than to work on the land, and can make a much better living out of the dole than if they worked on the land without it. Now, we have got to correct that, and the only way to correct it is to make the land profitable.

Comment on this

Farmers' sons are not getting the dole.

Comment on this

They do not get it at certain times of the year — during the employment period — but they do get the dole at other periods of the year. As I was saying, the only way to make it possible for the farms, as organised in this country, to work as economic units, is to make farming pay. You cannot make them work on the land. There is no method of getting them to work unless you can make agriculture pay; and, remember this: you must either have the system of individual liberty and free competition, such as we have here in this country, or a system of slavery such as you have in Germany and Russia. There is no halfway house between the two. Either you induce people to work on the land by the prospect of profit, or you will have to conscript them into labour camps and make them work and say that it is their national duty to do so. Now, I want to preserve the system of individual liberty and capitalism such as we have in Ireland at the present time. The only way to preserve that system is to make it pay, and we can make it pay if we go the right way about it.

There was some discussion about the price of bread here yesterday. It is at a prohibitive level at the present time in this country, and the millers are plundering the public. Of that, there is no possible doubt. On every sack of flour milled in this country at the present time, the consumer of this country is robbed of 10/-. Of that, there is no conceivable doubt.

Comment on this

That is utter nonsense.

Comment on this

It is absolutely and certainly true. There is a miller working in this country at present. He has a mill in Limerick and one at Liverpool. He can buy a cargo of wheat 500 miles off the coast of Limerick, and he can bring half the wheat into Limerick and mill it there, and half of it into Liverpool, to be milled in Liverpool, and on every sack brought into Limerick he will get 10/- more from the Irish consumer for a sack of flour than he can get from the English consumer for the flour manufactured out of the same wheat in Liverpool.

Comment on this

A gross misrepresentation of the known facts.

Comment on this

It is an indubitable and unquestionable fact. Every cwt. of flour, purchased by a countrywoman in this country, for the manufacture of a cake of bread in her own kitchen, carries on it a tax of 4/- per cwt., the bulk of which is going to swell the profits of the flour millers in this country. The Minister knows that. They slipped the quickest one across on him that ever was slipped across in the history of this country. They got him to go out bleating around the country about his resolve to maintain the rural mill, and the boys all sat in together and acquired a rural mill — each one of them —and at the same time they built a mill at the port — each one of them. Then the question was: "At what level will we fix the price of flour to make it economically possible to operate the rural mill?" Then they said: "We are not saying that that is the best way, but we know that it is the desire of the Taoiseach, and the Minister's desire, to maintain these rural mills, and we are naturally anxious to cooperate."

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party agreed to it here yesterday.

Comment on this

Wait a minute. They went on to say: "We are determined to keep those mills open, because you want us to do it. Of course, it means that flour is going to cost a little more, because we cannot make it as efficiently there as we could make it at the port." That representation was sympathetically listened to; the bugles were blown and the triumph was proclaimed. Mills in rural Ireland that had not turned a wheel for years were set revolving by the magical hand of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He went down with a gold scissors and cut threads; the mills started to grind; everybody sat back, and there was no more talk. Then the boys came around again and said: "By the way, Minister, we are in a little difficulty. Those rural mills are going to cost more than we thought. They are even more uneconomic than we felt they were in the beginning. Of course, we could close them down, but, seeing that you had opened them with a golden scissors, we did not like to close them without asking your leave." There had been so many speeches made, and so many bugles blown, and so many golden scissors used, that it was deemed politically inexpedient to close them. The boys gathered round the Minister again and said: "To keep those mills open, we will want a price for flour in this country approximately 10/- higher than in Liverpool." The Minister said: "Look, boys, you keep the mills open and I will keep the telescope to my blind eye." Accordingly, the price was fixed at 10/- a sack over the Liverpool price, in order to make it possible to operate uneconomic units, leaving a reasonable margin of profit. But the boys had up-to-date and highly economic mills at the ports of Limerick, Cork and Dublin, and they proceeded to collect on the entire output of those mills 10/- per sack in excess of a reasonable profit. There are 3,000,000 sacks of flour consumed in this country every year. That represents £1,500,000 levy on the people's bread every year for the benefit of the miller. The uneconomic units are producing about 10 per cent. of the total flour. Ninety per cent. of it is produced at the port mills, which are some of the most modern and up-to-date mills in the world. But the Minister is in this dilemma if he insists on bringing the price of flour to a fair level; the boys have all built those great mills at the ports out of the profits they have been making, and they do not give a fiddledee-dee whether he closes the rural mills or not. They have made enough profit in the last six years to keep them going for the next 160 years. They do not care whether he burns them or blows them up, or what he does with them, but they will put in their claim for compensation if he insists on a price which would make those units uneconomic. Now, what is a reasonable price for flour? Would a difference of 5/- per sack between the Liverpool price and the price in Ireland make it uneconomic to run those mills? It would not. The inland mills could be perfectly economic mills on that price.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy discovered that since?

Comment on this

Discovered what?

Comment on this

That the inland mills were in existence before Fianna Fáil came into office?

Comment on this

Exactly, and kept efficiently running because the Minister's predecessor never allowed the wool to be pulled over his eyes. When those boys came around with highfalutin schemes to protect milling he kicked them out, and told them he was not going to be sold a pup by them or anybody else. But when the Minister came in, it was not a pup they sold him but a Saint Bernard dog.

Comment on this

The Deputy said those inland mills were all opened deliberately since Fianna Fáil came into office.

Comment on this

I said no such thing. The history of this transaction is well known to the people of this country. Certain of those millers tried to blackmail the previous Government by threatening to close down the inland mills if they were not allowed to plunder the public, but they got kicked down stairs, and told that that kind of codology would not work. The history of that transaction is well known to the people of this country. The Minister's predecessor was described as the bondsman of Joseph Rank. He was held up to public odium on that account. I say here that Joseph Rank made in the last 12 months in Ireland more money than he made in the entire period of Deputy McGilligan's Ministry. If the Minister can disprove that I am prepared to withdraw all I have said.

Comment on this

The fact that the Deputy says so does not mean it is true.

Comment on this

It is true, and the Minister cannot disprove it. He made more money in the last 12 months than in the ten years of Deputy McGilligan's Ministry, because Deputy McGilligan had the measure of that combine, and kept them in their place.

Comment on this

How did he do that?

Comment on this

But this Minister has been completely fooled, and, as a result, our people are paying 10/- a sack in excess of the price obtaining in Great Britain for flour. That is one of the principal reasons why the price of flour is prohibitive in this country at the present time. The Minister has been told by his own Prices Commission that the margin of profit on flour is excessive.

Comment on this

That is not true. The Prices Commission's report has been published.

Comment on this

Did not the Prices Commission tell the Minister that in their opinion the margin of profit on flour was excessive?

Comment on this