Committee on Finance. - Vote 57—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 125–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am asking the Minister is it true that the Prices Commission considered the margin of profit on flour to be excessive?
Comment on this
Because the millers reduced their price. That is another explanation, but it did not occur to the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Deputy has to buy flour every day of his life, and he knows how the people in this country have been robbed and plundered in the last ten years. He has watched the labouring man, who earned 24 "bob" a week up to a few weeks ago, coming in and buying a cwt. of flour for his family, and he realises that 4/- out of that wretched 24/- is going to the flour millers in surplus profit, profit over and above the legitimate profit on that one bag of flour. I may tell you that when a shopkeeper has to act as a tax gatherer of that kind shop-keeping becomes an almost intolerable occupation.
Cement Limited are producing an extremely good article. They are producing good cement, but I think their inauguration should not be allowed to pass without comment on one of the most delightful manæuvres I have ever seen carried out by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I think the majority of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party at the moment believe that the reason Cement Limited was established in this country was to deliver this country from the danger of being exploited by the international cement cartel. The Minister used to tell us that. He admitted that the price of cement was lower in Ireland than it would be if cement were manufactured in Ireland, but he used to tell us: "Oh, but the cartel could force the price up as high as they liked, and what we have to do to provide against the day when the cartel would be attempting to raise the price is to establish our own native industry here, so that we can produce our own cement for our own purposes independent of the cartel." I wonder do the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party know who Cement Limited is? It is the cartel. The cartel have moved in bag and baggage, and they have got the monopoly. It is the international cartel.
Comment on this
Most emphatically. It is an Irish Company, established under Irish law, and owned as to two-thirds of its shares by Irish citizens.
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that on the Board of that Company there is a representative of the cement cartel?
Comment on this
The Minister knows what the cement cartel is just as well as I do. He knows its headquarters, and its board of control. Does he deny that sitting on the board of Cement, Ltd., at present is a member of the cement cartel, and does he not know in his own heart that that person is the nominee of the cement cartel?
Comment on this
He is not the nominee of anybody except the Danish company associated with the cartel. All the cement companies on the Continent are on the one cartel. This company, as to two-thirds of its shares, is owned by Irish citizens.
Comment on this
The cartel has moved in bag and baggage, and we are privileged to pay the company now — mind you for a good product, an excellent product, because the cement is really good, but not a bit better than any other cement: it is a good commercial product — I think 57/6 a ton for that product, and you can buy Continental cement delivered at Limerick quay for 28/6. Now, I only mention that. The business is done, and there is no use in going into it further. We will have to pay that price to the company for their cement, except for such quantities as they are allowed to bring in and make a profit on that for themselves. I simply mention that to warn the supporters of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that they would need to watch him as closely as they would want to watch the man with the thimble and the pea, because he is one of the most adroit persuaders of the innocent that ever stood up in this House. I would venture to swear that there are plenty of Deputies sitting up there who feel that we have the cartel by the throat. There is Deputy Allen, for instance. I am sure that he believes that we have really mastered them this time, and that we, standing on the shores of the Emerald Isle, can bid defiance to all comers, quite unconscious of the fact that the cartel have come in through the back door, making themselves at home in his kitchen while he is bidding them defiance on the threshold. The sooner the Deputy discovers that, and makes up his mind that he has got to live with them in peace, the better for him and for everybody else. Meanwhile, we will have to pay Cement Limited about £1 per ton more than we need pay for Continental cement.
Comment on this
It is true. I showed the Minister quotations from Spanish and Polish cement companies. Does the Minister deny that Polish cement companies were offering cement at £1 per ton lower than the price of Cement Limited?
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that there was offered in this country Polish and Spanish Cement at the port of Limerick at approximately 20/- a ton lower than the price quoted by Cement Limited?
Comment on this
You can get lump lots at a less cost at any time, but you cannot get a regular supply.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot deny it because he knows it is true. I am not going to go back over that whole story again because I laid all the facts before the House when the Cement Bill was last before us. I now come to the Carrick-on-Suir slate quarry. That industry has been wound up and, according to the information available in the public Press, which is all that we can get, the Killaloe slate quarries — I believe they are the persons associated with it — were profoundly interested in the Carrick-on-Suir slate quarry. There were common interests between the two quarries. The Carrick-on-Suir quarry had got a trade loan, I believe, many years ago from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government for the purpose of developing that quarry.
Comment on this
The Minister ought to be a little careful. Remember he is going to put his head in a halter if he is not careful. I have no desire to tie a halter around his neck because I believe he is being made a fool of. The Carrick-on-Suir slate quarries got a trade loan several years ago to develop what, in my judgment, was a most valuable slate deposit in Carrick-on-Suir. I am told that by builders. I have seen the slate myself, and I say that a better slate was never quarried in Ireland than the slate that was quarried at Carrick-on-Suir. That is the position. The discovery of that deposit, and its successful development, amply justified whatever loan was given many years ago.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce was then asked for certain grants out of the unemployment fund, or for some assistance the exact nature of which I do not know, to further develop this deposit and he gave it. I think that probably on the facts before him he was amply justified. He wanted to provide employment, and he wanted at the same time to facilitate the development of what he had reason to believe, and what he knew his predecessors believed, to be a valuable slate deposit. The money was forthcoming, and I presume was partially spent on the development and on clearing operations in the slate quarry with a view to preparing the slate face for further extraction of marketable slates. Then the management of the two companies becomes more or less identical — not absolutely — but there are common interlocking interests between the Killaloe company and the Carrick-on-Suir company. The next thing we hear——
Comment on this
I am simply stating the facts as I know them. I have no source of information but the public newspapers. The Minister has a vast array of public officials behind him. He is getting a large salary to look after these things and it is his business to look into them himself.
Comment on this
The Minister will have his chance of telling us the whole history of the Carrick-on-Suir transaction when answering on this Estimate. It will be his duty to do that. He has got a highly paid staff to help him to do it. I have no doubt that he actively interested himself in the matter.
Comment on this
I was simply asking the Deputy to repeat what he had said because I did not hear him.
Comment on this
We require information, and in respect of this we are going to get the information. There comes a time after all this money has been sunk in the enterprise when we are told that the deposit of slates is no longer there for exploitation, and that, accordingly, the Carrick-on-Suir company are going to fold up and walk out. There is then sold at public auction an immense amount of equipment.
Comment on this
I presume by the liquidator of the Carrick-on-Suir company. An immense amount of equipment is sold for about £104 — for a very triflng sum.
Comment on this
A considerable quantity of equipment was sold coram populo—there is no disguise or concealment about it — to the Killaloe slate quarries. In view of the common interests between the two enterprises, and the very fact that, I have no doubt, the authority and influence of the Killaloe slate quarry was used to secure for the Carrick-on-Suir slate quarry accommodation and assistance from the Minister, it would have been more becoming, before the assets of the dissolved Carrick-on-Suir quarry were purchased by the Killaloe company for a trifling sum that the Minister should have been consulted.
Comment on this
Did the Minister inquire into the circumstances surrounding the quarry before he put in the receiver? Did the Minister authorise the receiver —did he consent to the receiver—selling the entire assets, machinery and equipment of the Carrick-on-Suir company to the Killaloe company for £104?
Comment on this
A receiver's job is to sell the assets to the highest bidder. He cannot sell them to anybody else.
Comment on this
Maybe the Minister did his best. Remember, the Minister for Agriculture told us that the Roscrea factory was the best job that he could make of an industry, but they have got an action at present pending against the Minister for damages for that he failed to deliver to them a sufficient number of cows for nothing. I do not know whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce is involved in that.
Comment on this
I want to know where the fraud in Carrick-on-Suir is that Deputy Brennan talked about.
Comment on this
If Roscrea is not part of the responsibility of the Minister for Industry and Commerce——
Comment on this
He was, in so far as the enterprise was partially designed to relieve agriculture, and, on the other hand, to promote industry. The product of the Roscrea meat factory was meat meal and, in some degree, canned meats which were, in fact, exported. I do not know if they received an export bounty on industrial products. They probably did, and, in so far as they did, would come within the ambit of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
I had nothing to do with it. The Deputy is trying to get away with a red herring. Deputy Brennan said that a fraud had been perpetrated at Carrick-on-Suir. What is the fraud?
Comment on this
If the Minister suggests that instead of bad fish we have rotten carcases, I agree. Both smell abominably, with the result that Roscrea meat factory and decomposing herring have one common quality. They both smell in an unsavoury way, and, in so far as they have a bad smell, I admit I am trying to bring Roscrea meat factory into the discussion——
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister for certain information in regard to a transaction that appeared in the public Press.
Comment on this
If it is permissible to describe the Minister's incompetence as a scandal, then I think the Deputy would be right. I think it is a scandal, but I do not like to proclaim before the world that the Irish people have endorsed a scandal. We cannot escape from the fact that to have an incompetent person in such an office is a scandal, and I think the Minister is a very incompetent person.
Comment on this
I think he is a very incompetent person and I think it is a scandal he should be where he is, but he has an undoubted right to be there because the people put him there. Another matter I wish to refer to in connection with the Minister's administration is the rather humiliating farce into which he has been forced in connection with the Shops Act and the Shops Hours Act. Nothing is more humiliating than to see a Minister so alarmed by the reaction of his own folly, in the middle of a general election, that he is compelled to run away, lick his wounds and say: "We will suspend the whole business until the election is over, but for God's sake, vote for us and we will do whatever you want us to do when the election is finished." The Minister had to do that in this case. I want to appeal to the House not to be frightened into abandoning the good parts of that legislation by the excitement caused by the Minister's incompetence. It was the Minister's own folly and ignorance of the task he was tackling that led him into the serious difficulties in which he now finds himself involved. I told him when this legislation was going through the House that he ought very clearly to distinguish between rural conditions relating to shops and urban conditions relating to shops. So far as the hours and the half-holiday provisions are concerned, they are an admirable reform. I believe they are welcomed by every responsible merchant in the country. When you come down to the question of Sunday trading, the special conditions which govern rural communities deserve special consideration. I am not going to deal with that now, but I do urge the Minister to hold some sort of inquiry before which country shopkeepers and shop assistants may state their view. The absolute close-down order on certain shops on Sundays throughout Ireland immediately affected the islanders who used to come in to Sunday Mass and make their purchases afterwards so as to avoid a second trip from the island to the mainland. When the islanders came across they found all the shops shut and were told that they would have to come across again. That is one case which must be provided for. Provision must also be made for another case. When people die in the country early on Sunday morning or on Saturday night the members of the household must get certain funeral requisites which are customary in Irish country houses. Provision must be made to permit merchants who ordinarily supply such things— tobacco, funeral habiliments, groceries and other things — to supply these goods on such occasions. There is no necessity to make any exception or exclusion in regard to intoxicating liquor because, happily, the use of intoxicating liquor on such occasions is now practically unknown. It has been strongly discouraged by the clergy, and it would be just as well if there were no facilities for supplying it because nobody wants it. But there are certain other things which country people buy on such an occasion and provision must be made for their getting them. That kind of difficulty does not arise in the city in the same way, because the ordinary shopping by the people is done in a different way. These are the kinds of emergencies for which provision must be made. There are many others which I could mention. They are known to people who live in the country, but they are unknown to a man brought up in the City of Dublin who has no understanding of the country person's way of life. These two problems are separate problems and ought to be separately dealt with. The difficulties which have manifested themselves in the rural parts of the country should not discourage the Minister in respect of the general framework of the conditions and hours provided for shop assistants. They require adaptation and the sooner adaptation is undertaken the better it will be.
I am principally concerned to see the doctrine of self-sufficiency publicly abandoned. When it is there will be scope for co-operation amongst us all, so that we may push this country forward, get it on its feet again and raise the standard of living of the people. So long as any vested interest can plead in justification that they are helping on the cause of industrial self-sufficiency by charging exorbitant prices, we can get nowhere and, instead of helping industry, we will injure it. We should make up our minds as to what industries we want and go all out to make a success of them. One of the first essentials is that the raw materials should be made reasonably cheap. If we can do that, we can get somewhere but, if we cannot, we shall get nowhere. Seeing that Deputy Norton is a convert, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is beginning to wobble and that —most significant of all—the Prime Minister has been writing him sharp letters telling him he will have to think out his economic policy again, I do not despair. During the general election, the Prime Minister said in Athlone that he had already warned the Minister in a confidential letter that he would have to review his economic policy in the future in order to see what required to be done. The sooner the Minister takes the Prime Minister's advice the better for this country and the better for the workmen who earn their living.
Comment on this
I read some time ago of an Englishman known as "The Admirable Crichton." He is supposed to have known something about everything; but so far as I can judge from the position here, the Admirable Crichton would be only carrying drinks of water to Deputy Dillon, because there is no subject which the human mind can conceive but Deputy Dillon speaks on it. He takes up the time of this House talking, talking and talking. I remember one day when I had nothing else to do a copy of the Official Debates came to my hand. I counted the leaves to see how many leaves Deputy Dillon occupied in that volume. I found they numbered 50. I do not know what the Oireachtas has to pay the printers, but the cost outside would be about 10/- a page, and, on that basis, the State had to pay £25 for that oration of Deputy Dillon's.
Comment on this
The Deputy may think so, but there is a different opinion elsewhere. No matter what the subject— mousetraps, cement, castor oil, flour, Machiavelli or some other political "chancer" he knows about — Deputy Dillon speaks on it and takes up time hour after hour. There is only one consolation I have. It is a smug consolation, no doubt, but I do believe that my reward hereafter will be great for the penitential time I go through here patiently listening to speech after speech. There is one thing, however, which Deputy Dillon is not much good at, that is, the gift of prophecy. Deputies on the opposite benches have the Fianna Fáil advertisements on how to do away with unemployment and how to bring about reductions in taxation and they produce them time after time. I have a prophecy here, issued and signed by James Dillon in 1934, to the effect that this country was going to ruin. He states:
"United Ireland — the new national organisation which includes Cumann na nGaedheal, Centre Party and National Guard, has been founded to build up a robust and disciplined national movement to save the country from impending ruin and to restore the political and economic stability of the State."
Five years after that prophecy, there is no sign of economic ruin so far as I can see, and so far as the political and economic stability of the State is concerned, I think it has been more firmly established as a result of the last election. There is only one thing can be said of his prophecies and it is that, as a rule, prophecies take a very long time to materialise. I have an illustration of that here in connection with one of the Deputies opposite. He produced from time to time here during debates on the economic war, the prophecies of Columcille and, in solemn form, read them out. He said that Columcille stated that the package should be worth more than the contents, and he related that to the policy of the Minister for Agriculture in connection with the slaughter of the calves and said that the skin was more than the calf. There is no evidence that Columcille was thinking about calves at the time. He lived in the year 450 or thereabouts, and the Minister for Agriculture did not flourish until this, the twentieth century, so that it took about 1,400 years for the prophecy to come true.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has one great gift. He has a placid temper and he is able to listen patiently to the various statements concerning him, and, I am sorry to say, to various attempts to damage his character and that of his Department. We had one of them here yesterday. I say that he carries on his shoulders a great national tradition, a tradition which our people have upheld through the centuries — an industrial campaign when military activities had rendered them otherwise useless. He carries on his shoulders the tradition of Swift and the Volunteers of 1782, and the teachings of economic leaders since. He has endeavoured to make this country self-sufficient and self-supporting, and in that I think he has achieved great success. Let us see what was happening a few years ago. I related this incident from a platform in James's Street, and there is no harm in relating it here. I presume the audience here is as intelligent as the audience in James's Street. In 1933, an enterprising commercial traveller established himself in the street in which I do business. I got to know him, and he became semi-confidential. He used to tell me of the materials he had for sale, their prices, and where they came from, and he introduced to me one day a bundle of pullovers. I said to him: "What are you selling those at?" and he replied: "Six and six a dozen." I asked him where were they made, and he told me Madagascar. I asked him from what they were made and he told me they were made from grass. I asked him: "What will they realise in the shops?" and he said it would all depend on the conscience of the owner of the shop; that the wholesale price was 6½d. each and some shopkeepers in the poorer streets might charge 11½d. or 1/1½, because drapers are very fond of halfpennies, and in the big shops in Grafton Street they might be exposed for sale at 5/6. That was the class of materials he sold throughout the country, and that is what the farmers were to buy. He also showed me ladies' suits. They were two-piece suits, beautifully made. I have some knowledge of cloth, because at one time in my varied career I used to sell cloth. These garments were very nice to look at and to handle. The ladies then were wearing two-piece suits. I do not know how many pieces they are wearing now. I asked him what the prices of them were and he said 9/6 but that they would fetch probably three or four guineas. I asked where they were made, and he said in factories in Central Europe. I then asked what wages would be paid to the makers in Madagascar and the factory hands in Central Europe, and he said: "What we would call starvation wages." The third item in his programme was suits of clothes. There happened to be in the papers at the time certain statements as to consignments of men's suits made in Russian jails and delivered here. I examined them. The colour was all right, but what the material, a hard substance, was, I could not possibly guess. I asked him what were the prices, and he said 9/6 for a suit. I asked if he was selling many, and he said he was selling a good deal. I said to him: "That material seems queer," and he said: "If it avoids the rain, it will be all right." He asked me if it rained very much in Dublin, and I said it did. I actually saw those suits exposed for sale in Mary Street here in the city. A very enterprising shopkeeper had a big notice in the window: "Buy two suits for the price of one!" Was it not time that the development of the Minister's policy should stop that class of trade?
What was worse, we were getting from Japan boots and shoes made by the unfortunate Japanese, who exist on a bowlful of rice and a bit of dried meat, and are probably paid a few shillings a week. We were getting boots made by these people which could be sold very cheaply, no doubt. That was the position until the Minister's policy stopped it. I cannot conceive how a man like him who has done such work can be assailed here in the manner in which he is assailed. If the Opposition are not going to accept the position that has been put before them by the voice of the country, if they will not try to do the work of the country in the right manner, if they are going to develop attacks on Ministers, such as have been developed against the present Minister — I know very well that he is well able to reply for himself—if that is going to be their policy, I would advise them to drop it and drop it quickly.
I have studied quite recently a work written by a man whose name I have heard mentioned here a number of times — namely "the Resurrection of Hungary". I have studied it quite recently to get an exact idea of the policy, which I knew very well in the old days and which I have not entirely forgotten yet. The policy of self-sufficiency was advocated mostly during the 18th century and it is in connection with that portion of the country's history that the "Resurrection of Hungary" was principally written. There was no war in the 18th century. Fighting had ceased in Ireland. The statement was made that the Irish were done, the Irish Catholics especially. There was no way to raise the drooping hopes of the people after the Boyne except by means of directing their attention to trade. Jonathan Swift successfully did that in his time and his policy was pursued all through the 18th century, as anybody acquainted with that period of our history knows well. What was the result of that?
In the official records of the Irish Parliament of that period you will find a report of a debate which was held in connection with the Catholic Relief Bill of 1792. Sir John Parnell, who was then Chancellor of the Exchequer, made a statement to the effect that if any of the Budgets which he had the honour of introducing into that House, contained articles calculated to advance the prosperity of the country and the happiness of the people, he was indebted for the inspiration of those articles to Mr. Edward Byrne. That was an exclusively Protestant Parliament where no Catholic dare enter. He was indebted to Mr. Edward Byrne of Mullinahack, the greatest and richest tradesman of Ireland at that time. He had arrived at a period of his existence when that could be said of him. He represented the Catholics of this country at that period. A policy of self-sufficiency was successfully pursued at that time. Swift's dictum "burn everything that comes from England except her coals" was acted on right through the whole century and with success. It was on the inspiration of that period that the "Resurrection of Hungary" was written in order to inculcate into the people's mind, the same doctrine that was in the minds of our forefathers in years gone by. Because our present Minister is carrying out that policy and has carried it out successfully to my mind, very successfully, he is now being made a target for all sorts of innuendoes and insinuations, but no direct charge. Why do those Deputies not stand up here and say to him "You are a fraud; you are backing up frauds?" Instead we have insinuations about this, that and the other thing.
It is because of the absurd protection that is thrown over members of this House by the law, preserving them against the legal consequences of their words, that these attacks are made possible. I have listened to them to-day quoting documents; I have seen them whispering to one another, and heard their insinuations that the Minister's Department had acted wrongly, but they did not say so in so many words. Then we heard the Roscrea factory being brought up again. There was another factory which got money from the Government, and I read their balance sheet the other day. The statement occurs in the balance sheet that they are not using the money given to them by the Government for the purposes for which it was given to them. I had that balance sheet in my pocket during the last election, in case anyone might stand up and accuse Deputy Briscoe of acting in any way dishonourably. If so, I would have something to say about it. He had to go through the election just as I had. We were colleagues in that campaign, and I was fortified with that document. I seldom go out to speak on a public platform now, because my memory is not as good as it used to be.
Comment on this
I demand an explanation in definite terms of what the Deputy means by mentioning that document.
Comment on this
Now, we have it. The man who brings in here all these documents is afraid now when any reference is made to other documents.
Comment on this
I read the balance sheet and if you are connected with it——
Comment on this
I am trying to do so for the past 20 minutes and have not succeeded. I heard the matter of the Roscrea factory being brought in here almost constantly for the last few days. When I stand up and mention another factory——
Comment on this
Another factory got money from the Government and in the balance sheet they state: "We are not applying that money to the purposes for which the Government gave it; we are applying it to another purpose."
Comment on this
I am not in a lunatic asylum. I am a Dublin citizen representing Dublin people in this House and unless the people believed I was right, they would not send me here. It might be a good job for myself if I had not been sent here.
Comment on this
Deputies on the other side think that the Minister should submit to all criticisms and that we should remain silent, that we should not say anything about them. Now we have to stand up for the purpose of showing you that the back-benchers here are as good as the back-benchers over there and maybe better. I am very glad to see here a young Deputy who spoke yesterday, as I look upon him as the rising hope No. 2 of that Party. Might I remind him of an incident which occurred during the debate on the recent Agreement. Deputy Brennan was after making a very sensible and statesmanlike speech and nobody rose to speak after him but Deputy Linehan opposite and he, with a war-whoop that could be heard in the valleys of Cork, got into it and with animated face and hands went over the whole gamut of the terrible things the Fianna Fáil Government had done. I was wondering what was the effect on Deputy Brennan, the elder statesman sitting beside him. First, Deputy Brennan put his hand to his face, then he sat with his head bowed, and finally he got up and went out. I see that Deputy Linehan has been promoted in almost threequarters of an hour. He was only a back-bencher a short time ago and now he is on the front bench. I would advise him not to mind the past. He should take my advice as an old hand and not be going into the past. If he wants to be a rising hope, he should look to the future and not mind the past.
The Party opposite should take the commonsense point of view of backing up the Government when it deserves to be backed up, and not be always criticising and, what is the worst of it, making speeches directing public odium against the Ministers and their Departments for no substantial reason. All I can say is, if they continue in that way, on their own heads be their fate. So far as I am personally concerned, I am satisfied that the Minister's policy is the best policy for this country. I believe in it all through, and I am perfectly satisfied that he is a capable and able man, and up to this, at any rate, he has shown the spirit that is in him.
Comment on this
I should like to say a word with regard to the question of licences and monopolies because I look upon the Minister more than any other Minister as being responsible for the creation of these monopolies. With regard to the monopoly given to the railway companies, a situation has developed to which I want to refer. A carrier was drawing milk to a creamery and the railway company objected, with the result that the Minister refused to grant a licence to that man, as it was said he did not comply with the regulations. Because of this little technical point that man was deprived of a licence. When the matter came into court the railway company gave an undertaking that they would provide the same service at the same remuneration as this man who was applying for the licence had been giving to the district. There were 36 small mountainy farmers involved. The average daily supply of milk was 120 gallons. The railway company undertook to draw that milk to the creamery and the Minister refused a licence to the man who had been carrying the milk for a number of years.
Notwithstanding that undertaking, which was given in 1935, in the beginning of 1938 the railway company demanded £2 per day for carrying this 120 gallons of milk, and they discontinued the service because they did not get that sum. The value of that 120 gallons of milk per day was 50/- at the present price of milk. The railway company demanded £2 out of that 50/-, leaving the people who produced the milk with 1d. per gallon for the milk after paying 4d. per gallon to the railway company. Yet the Minister refused to grant a licence to the carrier who was prepared to carry the milk for 7/6 or 10/- and who has been carrying it from January last for nothing. Is that a situation that can be defended? I should like to know what Deputy Kelly has to say to it. Will he tell us that this is not a matter that should be brought before the House, and that conditions like these should be continued? Of the 36 families concerned, three-fourths of them are supporters of the present Government. Even Deputy Smith told us in this House that they were all supporters of the Government at one time, and he knows the district. Yet were it not for this carrier they would be deprived of the means of getting their milk to the creamery, or getting their cheques, small as they are, if the milk was not carried gratuitously.
What is the position now? This man again applied for a licence, and here is the reply from the Minister, dated 27th June last:
"I am directed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to refer to your letter of the 13th instant relative to grant of a merchandise licence under the Road Transport Act, 1933, to Mr. Peter O'Hara, Lannanariagh, Bawnboy, County Cavan, and to inform you that, as the Great Southern Railways Company are prepared to provide merchandise road transport facilities for the carriage of milk in the areas from which Swanlinbar and Ballinamore creameries desire their supplies, the Minister is precluded by the Act from granting a merchandise licence to your client.
I am to add that the Minister is not satisfied that the existing merchandise road transport facilities are inadequate in the area concerned or that there is any adequate demand for increased facilities having regard to the failure of the creameries and their suppliers to co-operate with the Great Southern Railways Company towards the successful organisation of the company's merchandise road transport service now withdrawn."
What explanation has the Minister to give the House now that these services are withdrawn, although an undertaking was given that services equally good as those given by Mr. O'Hara would be provided and at the same remuneration? Because they would not get £2 a day for carrying milk they withdrew the services. Where the producers only got 50/- for their milk at the creamery they would then be left with only 10/- after paying the freight. Thirty-five small farmers in four townlands are now left without any means of conveying their milk to the creamery, yet the Minister refused to grant another licence, stating that he was precluded from doing so under the Act. As I understand, the Act was prepared under his own supervision and steered through this House by him, so that it is up to him to have it amended.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not advocate that now. He cannot advocate legislation or amendment of the law now.
Comment on this
I do not want to do so, but something should be done for these people. In his letter the Minister stated that the railway company was prepared to provide a service. The company is not doing so. I was speaking to a representative of the railway company two days ago and I asked him if they were prepared to do the work. He said the cost would be so much, and that they would have to send six miles from Ballinamore, and then go a further six miles, and that ¾d. a gallon for delivering milk would not pay them. Even if it was four times the amount, he said, it would not pay them. I asked him why the company was playing the dog-in-the-manger policy by preventing a man who was entitled getting a licence and who would draw the milk at the usual rate. He said they were not adopting the dog-in-the-manger policy, and that they had no objection to the granting of a special licence. Despite that we have the letter from the Minister of June 27th saying that he is precluded from granting the licence.
This is a serious matter for 35 families. More than half or some member of each family are on the dole. To ask small farmers to pay fourpence to the railway company for delivering their milk is out of the question. I do not think that position can be defended. Something should be done, and I ask the Minister to look into it again. I was told that the railway company have no objection to the granting of a special licence. Perhaps the Minister will say why he will not grant it.
Deputy Kelly referred to things that I consider are irrelevant. I do not propose to follow him in that direction. The Deputy talked about starvation wages being paid for certain things that were sold here. I will only refer to one of the industries recently started, the alcohol factories, to which potatoes are supposed to be supplied at 2¾d. or, at the outside, 3d. per stone. I understand that the economic price at which alcohol can be produced from potatoes means that they would be supplied at 2¾d. per stone. Is not that a starvation price? Are farmers able to produce potatoes at 2¾d. per stone? I should like Deputy Kelly or someone else to tell the House what it costs to produce potatoes. As a great deal has been said about the cost of production, I do not propose to cover the ground again, but, taking that specific instance, I ask anyone who understands anything about the growing of potatoes to say if 2¾d. or 3d. a stone is an economic price. These factories were put up on that supposition, but eventually, when agriculture is restored to its proper position, and when proper prices can be obtained for agricultural products, farmers will discontinue growing potatoes at that price. Then these factories will become white elephants the same as the Roscrea factory.
Comment on this
May I appeal to Deputies to have a little discretion and a little consideration in these matters. I have no objection to Deputies referring to the Roscrea factory, but I should like them to tell the truth. A considerable amount of money is invested in the Roscrea factory, and it is not a white elephant. That factory is going to continue and to give employment.
Comment on this
If factories are put up that cannot be carried on economically, then this country will be well rid of them. If the Roscrea factory was built on the assumption that cows will be supplied for nothing, then that factory should not be started. I say the same with regard to the industrial alcohol factories. If they were started on the basis that potatoes would be supplied at 2¾d. or 3d. per stone they cannot continue and will become white elephants. The country would be better without such industries if they cannot be carried on economically. I intervened only to draw attention to one glaring instance. I do not know whether it is caused by muddling in the Minister's Department, or because of some unforeseen difficulties that have arisen under the Railways Act. It is a matter that the Minister should look into, because it is only one of many instances that have arisen out of the licensing system and the granting of monopolies to certain firms. The Minister should get away from the licensing system, and replace it by a system of more individual freedom. A great deal has been done to acquire national freedom, but national freedom is very little good if there is not individual freedom. The Minister should get away from the system of licensing, because it hampers business people, farmers and others. I hope he will try to make amends in the instance I mentioned.
Comment on this
I wish to intervene to counteract a false impression which was created by statements made yesterday by Deputy Hughes in reference to Tuam beet factory. As a beet-grower, and one who is in a position to represent the beet-growers in the West, I deny the allegations of Deputy Hughes. He said that the four factories were carrying one factory on their backs. When he was asked which one that was, he said Tuam.
Comment on this
I challenge him on that. He also said that the land in that part of the country was unsuitable for beet. If he looks at the returns of the yield per acre, he will find that the results from the West bear favourable comparison with other areas where beet is grown. On one occasion the returns for the Tuam factory were better than those from Carlow. Mallow was better because it was supplied from Wexford. The Deputy also said that the man who established a beet factory in the West should be in a mental hospital. I think the Deputy should not make such statements, and should not try to kill an Irish industry that is of great importance to the farmers and to the people in the West. If we are going to have tillage, the best type of farmer is the man who works with his team of horses and plough, and with the shovel, and not mass production as in Carlow. We may be small farmers in the West, but we are decent, honest people, and we are able to stand up against any type of farmer in this country, particularly people who have swelled heads, and certain ideas about their own type of farming.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister for some information in connection with the closing down of the railway from Tuam to Sligo and from Claremorris to Ballinrobe.
On the 28th April I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if his attention had been called to a statement made by Mr. W.H. Morton, on behalf of the Great Southern Railways, that with the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce about 120 miles of unremunerative railways had been closed and further branch lines were under consideration for similar treatment, and if he would state if the railway company had made applications to his Department for his consent to close further branch lines and where such lines are situate. I want to ask the Minister whether his Department has received an application from the Great Southern Railways Company for the closing down of additional branch lines and if it is the intention of the Government to give them that permission. I think the railway company has certain obligations and certainly should not be allowed to get away with that. The railway company, after all, may have some branch lines that are unremunerative but they have got other lines which are paying propositions, and are they going to be allowed to escape their responsibility to carry on all the lines? I think it is the duty of the Minister and of the Government, if the Great Southern Railways Company want to close down any more lines, to immediately nationalise the entire railway system in the country.
Nothing short of that should be done. The railway company, as you are all aware, have increased their freights and fares since the 1st January last by substantial amounts. I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce should take steps immediately to see that there will be no more increases anyway. What we should get is a reduction. As far as the people of this country are concerned, the merchants and traders in the West of Ireland and all over the country are practically bled white by the railway company charges.
A great deal has been said to-day in regard to the high cost of living in this country, particularly the cost of flour. On 1st June, a proposition was made by a merchant down in Balla called Mr. Higgins, to import 2,000 tons of flour into Westport Quay, which he would import for 11/6 a cwt. —£11 10s. a ton. The proposition was sent to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We have heard nothing about it since. We will probably never hear anything about it. The offer was made that he would import 2,000 tons from Liverpool at a cost of £11 10s. a ton. That would be sold retail for 12/- a cwt. all over the County of Mayo and when that 2,000 tons would be sold he would get the same amount again, and so on. The saving on 2,000 tons alone would be, roughly speaking, about £10,000 to the people of Mayo. The Minister for Industry and Commerce should give the opportunity to these people to reduce the cost of foodstuffs in this country. We have heard nothing about it since and I suppose we will not hear any more about it, not as long as Messrs. Ranks have almost control of the Minister's Department.
We heard some of the disclosures here made by Deputy Gorey with regard to the Carrick-on-Suir slate quarries. I think, after all, when disclosures are made, it is the duty of the Minister to immediately hand over the facts to the Attorney-General and have these people indicted who are responsible for robbing this State of about £10,000.
Comment on this
That is exactly the amount of the loss to this State and I think something should be immediately done. I think it is the duty of the Minister to investigate this matter as soon as possible.
With regard to the alcohol factories, we built alcohol factories and spent £225,000 on them in this country. How much have we got out of them since they were built? The alcohol factory in Mayo was built five miles from the nearest railway station. Therefore if you want to get any potatoes brought there, you must bring them to the station first, carry them there, and take them to the factory — send them out five miles to the alcohol factory and when the alcohol is manufactured, carry the stuff back five miles again to the station. That is the kind of humbug the Minister for Industry and Commerce is responsible for, or at least the Government is responsible for. I suppose it is like a lot of the other factories we have had erected in some parts of the country. There are not many in my part of the country. We are glad there are not. We do not want factories of that description which are giving no work to anybody, not relieving unemployment and which are no good to anyone. I think the quicker the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Government wake up and shut up half the factories which they have built, the better it will be for everybody concerned in this country.
Comment on this
I understand Deputy Nally attended a meeting in Claremorris quite recently with the representatives of the railway company, at which members of all Parties were present, and where the question of closing down branch lines was discussed. He knows what took place there, and he has spoken here for the purpose of wasting time and getting publicity for himself.
The motion which was moved by Deputy Pattison to reduce the amount of this Estimate was apparently inspired by certain objections which he had to the manner in which the unemployment assistance scheme was being administered. He and the Deputy who followed him and who seconded the amendment spoke upon that matter, but very few other Deputies have referred to it. The general criticism of the administration of that Act which was voiced will be dealt with by the Parliamentary Secretary on the appropriate Vote. I propose here to deal with the matters of major importance which were raised concerning the general policy and administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Deputy Dillon said that my being Minister for Industry and Commerce was a scandal, and he referred to my ignorance and folly, and describes people who had invested money in Irish industrial enterprises as carrion crows and highway robbers. Remarks of that kind made in conjunction with the reckless charges and wild misstatements for which the Deputy was responsible are irritating, and I was provoked into interrupting the Deputy, for which I am sorry. I say that because I am anxious that we should consider in a somewhat calmer atmosphere than that created some of the more important questions of policy which were raised during the course of the discussion. I propose to deal with the more serious speakers from the Opposition Benches first. I will deal with the jokers afterwards.
Deputy Mulcahy thought that I should have, in my introductory statement, taken the House into my confidence concerning the general lines which it was proposed to follow in industrial development arising, he said, out of the British Agreement. There was in Deputy Mulcahy's query an implication that some change in industrial policy was necessitated by the provisions of the British Agreement. Deputy Belton, of course, who spoke also on that matter, was much more dogmatic, as Deputy Belton usually is, and he asserted that we were forced by the British to abandon our policy. In fact, Deputy Belton had some difficulty in finding a word to convey his exact meaning. I think "compelled to crawl in the dust" was one of the terms he used, but the general sense of his remark was that we were forced in London to abandon our industrial policy. Any Deputy or member of the public who read the terms of the British Agreement with ordinary intelligence would have seen at once that no change in industrial policy was necessitated by it. Certainly no change is intended. It has always been the policy of the Government to foster the industrial development of this country by every practicable means, including the imposition of tariffs and the imposition of import restrictions. Deputy Norton spoke as if the Government had no other idea in its mind for the promotion of industrial growth than the imposition of tariffs. Tariffs and import restrictions are, of course, an essential weapon for the solution of our industrial problems, but they do not in themselves constitute an industrial policy. The industrial policy of the Government is still what it always was. A properly planned tariff policy must necessarily take into account and must necessarily make provision for the different circumstances existing during the earlier development stages of new industries, and the circumstances which may be expected to arise when such industries have become fully established. During the earlier period it is not reasonable to expect our new industries to reach maximum efficiency, or that their products can compete in respect of price or of quality, or of variety, with the products which we can import from other countries. The protection granted to these industries must necessarily be higher than fully established industries would require and, furthermore, it must be so graded as to ensure that despite whatever deficiencies there are in their productions they will still be able to dispose of their products, and thus secure for both the management and the workers the skill and the experience which are the basis of efficiency.
When industries become fully established, and by the term fully established we mean in a position to get the maximum output from their staff, machinery and organisation generally, they must not expect, and certainly should not need, protection to the same extent as in their earlier stages. It was never the intention of the Government that they should get it. That was the Government's policy in the past, and it is its present policy. The Agreement we made with the Government of the United Kingdom necessitates no modification of that policy. The Agreement does not restrict the Government's power to impose new duties, despite Deputy Belton's emphatic declaration to the contrary, except in respect of certain named products. It makes special arrangements for industries not fully established, and provides that when tariffs are reviewed in the case of fully established industries, they will be fixed on a basis which will make suitable provision for British exporters while still affording to Irish manufacturers adequate protection.
On the general question of industrial development, I need say little more than this, that the need for industrial development here is as great as ever it was and this country could not afford to abandon its industrial programme. Deputy Dillon describes the self-sufficiency policy as all cod. The only thing about the policy that is reminiscent of that fish were the various attempts made by Deputy Dillon to misrepresent what was intended by it. When the term self-sufficiency was used by members of the Government Party, or by ordinary intelligent members of the public, a very definite idea was conveyed, not a state of affairs in which there would be no imports of any kind, in which we would, by all sorts of artificial means, endeavour to produce goods for which our climatic conditions or other circumstances would be unsuitable. The term was intended to convey the idea of developing such resources as we have and establishing such industries as could be established economically, having due regard to the reactions which their establishment would have on the general circumstances of the country.
In the early days of the industrial revival the protagonists of the self-sufficiency policy, those who advocated the adoption of a programme to promote the industrial development of the country, always directed their arguments against a certain type of individual who was supposed to regard the sole economic function of this country to be the production for export of a limited range of agricultural products and who condemned out of hand every Irish industrialist as a crook and every Irish industrial product as rotten. I always regarded that person as a figment of the imagination; I never thought such a person existed. I am glad to say that I have met one, although perhaps it is a bit belated. Deputy Hughes is that person. Until he spoke here yesterday, I regarded the suggestion that such a person could be found in this country as a purely imaginative statement. Such a person actually does exist, and Deputy Hughes has the honour to be that person. But even Deputy Hughes made no attempt to follow his arguments to their logical conclusion. Many of his arguments were reminiscent of the ones we have heard from Deputy Dillon, and occasionally from Deputy Belton.
At first I thought that Deputy Hughes was going to be somewhat more consistent than they proved themselves to be in the past. They are completely illogical. What they say in one sentence they contradict in the next. What they say here in speeches they contradict outside. What they say in speeches outside, in rural areas, they contradict in speeches delivered in urban areas. All hope of consistency in argument from Deputy Dillon, Deputy Belton and their colleagues is out of the question. I thought Deputy Hughes was going to be a consistent supporter of the policy of producing entirely for export to the British and other markets and buying materials abroad for use at home, wherever we could get the cheapest industrial and other products we require. In the end Deputy Hughes did not prove to be consistent. He said industrial development was too much of a burden; it involved the farmers buying rotten products at excessive prices. I gathered from his remarks that the ideal Ireland would be one inhabited by a certain limited number of farmers like himself, who would export all their available products and import whatever would be their requirements, industrial and otherwise. I think his ideal is unattainable and he should make an endeavour to realise that fact.
The Irish people will refuse to be exterminated merely to serve his interests, and that being so, the Government policy must make some provision for the maintenance of those people. The policy outlined by Deputy Hughes is impracticable. He is nothing more than a rainbow chaser, a man who will not face the cardinal fact that the great number of people who cannot get employment on the land must still be preserved and must be occupied in production of some kind. I have no desire, I never expressed a desire, and I certainly never attempted to defend inefficiency in Irish manufactures. Deputy Hughes says he can buy a cheaper mowing machine from America than he can get in Ireland, and he can buy a better spade or fork of foreign manufacture than he can procure here. That may be so, but I do not think it is generally the case. Deputy Dockrell produced a broken spade, which he said was of Irish manufacture. I could produce a dozen broken spades of British manufacture, if it would serve any purpose.
I admit that there are occasionally produced here products of inferior quality. There are individual firms that have not come up to a certain standard, but to suggest, because of one or two instances, that all Irish firms are inefficient and that all Irish products are rotten, as Deputy Hughes would seem to suggest, is absolutely indefensible. He has shown that he is influenced by the opinions of other members of his Party, because his arguments were re-echoed by certain members of the Party to-day. He claims that he should be allowed to keep his cost of production down, that he should be facilitated in procuring his mowing machines and his spades and forks wherever he can get them cheapest. He points out that they may be got cheaper in Japan, Germany, Russia or anywhere else, and the farmers here should not be compelled to use only what is manufactured in Ireland.
I wonder what Deputy Hughes' attitude would be if the workers in the factories where these mowing machines and spades and forks are made were to adopt a similar line of argument from their own point of view. They might say that they could work for lower wages and reduce the costs of their products and even get to the position where they could export those products if they were faciltiated by the Government in the sense that they could import various necessaries from different parts of the world, such as Argentine wheat, Czecho-Slovakian sugar, Chinese eggs and so on. If they were to agitate for the free import of foodstuffs from abroad it would represent the height of folly because, of course, the success of their agitation, by destroying the Irish farmers, would also destroy the best market for the goods they are making. If that is true of these workers in the factories, it is equally true in relation to the farmers. Apparently that idea never occurred to Deputy Hughes. The home market is the best market for the Irish farmers. It is the only market of which they could be certain in all circumstances, a market in which they can be guaranteed a price which will secure to them a return on their capital and, at least, will cover the cost of production. It is, of course, the policy of the Government and the wishes of the Government to maintain the export of agricultural products to the maximum extent. They are working to secure a preferential position for the farmers in the home market by guaranteeing them profitable prices there and subsidising prices on exports. Deputy Hughes told us that the export prices were not economic and that the prevailing prices would not return to the farmers the cost of production. How does the Deputy think that these should be subsidised?
Comment on this
I am trying to impress upon Deputy Hughes as a new member the importance of thinking before he talks. There is no use in impressing that on Deputy Gorey, but Deputy Hughes is a new member and he may learn. There is no conflict of interest whatever between Irish farmers and Irish industrialists. There is no conflict between a sound agricultural policy and a sound industrial policy. The best thing that can happen to farmers in this country is the success of the industrial policy. Deputy Hughes said that our industrial development was not properly planned and, as an example of that contention, he mentioned the sugar factory which was established at Tuam. Certain Deputies who spoke on that matter have more knowledge of the immediate concerns of that factory than I have.
Behind the industrial policy there are more than economic needs. The industrial policy has been designed not merely to serve an economic purpose. It has been designed to serve a social purpose as well. It is because we have these social needs in view as well as the economic needs that we are endeavouring to scatter industrial concerns throughout the country. All the industrial activity in this country would have been centralised in one or two large cities and there would be no factories established throughout the country if we had only in view the economic outlook. But from the social angle it was necessary for the Government to force the spread of industrial activity from the cities to the rural towns. It was because its aims were not merely economic aims but social aims that this was done. We knew it would be more difficult to make the beet factory a success in Tuam than in some other part of the country. But we said, nevertheless, that the benefits of this industry must be secured for the people of Connacht. Purely economic considerations would have dictated its being established somewhere else. It was not party political motives that suggested that. It was a sound economic policy. It will take harder work and a longer time to make the beet factory a success in Tuam than if it were established in some other agricultural centre. But the harder work will be put into it and the success of the factory will be secured.
Many references were made to the boot and shoe industry. The boot and shoe industry at the moment, it is true, is not working to its full capacity. That situation has arisen, partly because of the false impression created by the boot and shoe manufacturers and partly by the foolish statements made by Deputies from time to time in this House. It is also due to the many foolish statements made by people outside the House to the effect that the British Agreement would mean the resumption of boot and shoe imports. There were references to the possibility of boots and shoes being dumped in here at cut-throat prices. I do not blame the trader who, reading these statements, sat back and said: "I will not order any goods from the Irish manufacturers." Even though the trader would prefer to support the Irish factories, he could not afford to do so if his competitor across the street were to be in a position to offer cheap boots in competition with his. That was because it was anticipated that a flood of dumped goods in boots and shoes was to be let loose on the market in this country. Because of these reasons orders to Irish boot and shoe factories ceased.
I want to say now that there will be no change in respect of boots and shoes for some time to come. That change cannot commence before November next. The present quota expires in the end of October and the new quota begins then. Some of our boot and shoe manufacturers fear that the traders who have let their stocks run low will send simultaneous orders to the Irish factories, orders which cannot be immediately filled. Irish manufacturers fear that then the traders will base upon the inability of the factories to supply their orders at once an agitation to increase the quota. The quota will not be increased on that account. It is just as well that the traders should be clear as to the position.
Some boot and shoe factories got into difficulties before the London negotiations commenced. These difficulties were sometimes due to bad management and sometimes the difficulties were caused by over-production of certain lines of goods. Deputy Brodrick spoke yesterday as if the Department of Industry and Commerce were responsible for the management of individual concerns even where they were privately owned. That is nonsense. The Department is responsible for creating conditions under which efficient concerns will be a success. It is nonsense to suggest that for the average day to day management of privately-owned concerns the Department is responsible. For some time back they have been actively discouraging the starting of new factories for boots and shoes. There are certain lines in boots and shoes that are not made here yet in sufficient quantities. It does not follow that the requirements in each class of boot can be produced here to the fullest extent necessary. Deputy Brodrick made special reference to the boot factory at Ballinasloe. That firm is producing very high-grade quality in ladies' shoes which no other factory in this country is able to make. They are receiving from the Department of Industry and Commerce special facilities not given to other firms.
We have had many references made to the position of the slate quarries. Deputy Belton yesterday in his usual style said that he had gone out that day to place orders for Irish slate and could not get Irish slate. He announced most dramatically that if I could tell him where to get Irish slates he would place an order at once for 100,000 slates. I thought it no harm to inquire to what extent it was possible to get supplies. He told us yesterday he could not get Irish slates and, if he could, he would order 100,000. The agents for the Drinagh and other West Cork slate quarries stated in reply to inquiries that they were in a position to execute any orders promptly. The Donegal slate quarry say they can supply the orders from stock and the Killaloe Slate Quarries Company say they will have no difficulty in executing any order at once if it is given. Deputy Belton is not here now but it is quite clear that he was talking the usual nonsense, doing his little bit of damage to Irish industry, trying to give it a last kick down which it was hoped would finish it. He was following the example of his betters in the Fine Gael Party. He is not accustomed to them now very long. He has not long been back with them this time. I have no doubt that in due course he will learn finesse from Deputy Dillon.
It is true there has been a decline in the output of the slate industry recently, due to a number of causes. There has been a falling off in orders for natural slates, mainly, I think, because of the increased cost of building arising from the higher wages, and the increased cost of materials, naturally, has forced builders to consider the possibility of using cheaper roofing materials. Of course, the concrete-tiled roof, or a roof covered with asbestos slates, is very much cheaper than a roof of natural slate. We have had complaints also concerning the West Cork quarries to the effect that on occasions in the past they have supplied slates of an indifferent quality. The main difficulty of these quarries is, I feel certain, due to the fact that, in the main, they were under-capitalised, and they were depending on a steady output and turnover to enable them to meet their outgoings and to pay the instalments on their machinery, most of which was purchased on the hire-purchase system. The cessation of activities owing to the building strike also created difficulties for them. Then there has been a reduction in the grants with regard to certain classes of housing, which also made builders turn to the possibility of getting cheaper roofing material. We are very anxious to develop that industry, and we have already spent a very great deal of money upon exploration work and assisting private interests to get slate quarries opened. I do not think, however, that we can go on indefinitely giving grants to private people for purposes of that kind, but the industry is one which has considerable possibilities and is particularly useful in so far as it provides the right type of employment in areas where such employment is badly needed. Therefore any action that the Department can take to promote that industry and ensure the success of these quarries will be taken.
Now, we had this case of the Carrick slate quarry, to which Deputy Gorey referred. He said that it had got a trade loan, and said that it was a scandal.
Comment on this
Apparently he has discovered now that the company got the trade loan from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government three years before this Government came into office. Deputy Gorey said, undoubtedly, that it was a scandal.
Comment on this
That is not what I said. What I said is on the records. I should be allowed to explain what I said.
Comment on this
The position is that I said that the wrecking of the quarry was a scandal, and the selling of the plant.
Comment on this
I shall deal with the question of the wrecking of the quarry. At any rate, a company was formed in 1928 to work the Carrick slate quarry. A substantial amount of private money was put forward by individuals for the purpose of forming that company. That money has been lost, and Deputies who referred to Mr. O'Driscoll here in the House and to other persons associated with that company should bear in mind that the private money they invested was lost, and it is difficult to understand how they could gain anything by wrecking an enterprise started by their own capital. However, we had Deputy Belton also referring to an industry which was flourishing here in 1929, 1930 and 1931, and which closed down when the Fianna Fáil Government came into office. Did he not say that? I am certain he did, and it is on the records of the House. The position is this. The company got this trade loan in February, 1929. Up to the 31st March, 1929, it had lost £492. In the year ended the 31st March, 1930, it lost £422. In the year ended 31st March, 1931, it lost a further £220, and in the nine months to the end of the year 1931, it lost £542. It made a first profit in 1932, after Fianna Fáil came into office, but it would have continued to make profits were it not for the fact that the vein of slate on which they were working developed faults. The company encountered a vein of quartzite in the slate deposit, with the result that it was impossible to get slates in that part of the quarry which was being worked, with any reasonable prospect of profit. When that happened the company had to face the prospect of closing down immediately. Naturally, I was very concerned about that, because a substantial number of workers were concerned, and on that account we made available money, out of the relief of unemployment grant, for the purpose of exploring the possibilities there and in the vicinity of that quarry and other parts of the neighbourhood with the object of discovering another deposit of slate which would enable the machinery to be utilised in production which could be recommenced on a profitable basis. That exploration work proved unsuccessful. It was not possible to discover a vein of slate of a quality which would permit of large scale commercial work being engaged in.
Comment on this
I am giving the history of the company to the Deputy. It was formed in 1928 by Mr. J.B. O'Driscoll, Mr. Isaac Beckett and Mr. McQuillan. There were two other shareholders, as well as the Bank of Ireland and the Industrial Trust Company of Ireland— not to be confused with the Industrial Credit Corporation—that has since been wound up. These held shares to the amount of about £4,500. There was a trade loan guaranteed from the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in February, 1929, and the company continued to operate until 1931, making in every year a substantial loss, until 1932 was reached, when a profit was made for the first time. A profit was also made in 1933. And then this difficulty arose in respect of the vein of slate. The quarry was inspected by an economic geologist from my Department, on whose report I place the utmost reliance, and it was clear that, on the basis of the vein of slate on which they were working, commercial large-scale work could not be continued. We went out, then, spending money with a view to discovering a new vein of slate in the vicinity, but no such vein was found. The National City Bank then asked me to concur in a proposal to appoint a receiver over the assets of the undertaking, in which I concurred. What happened after that was a matter for the receiver, and it was his duty to get the maximum he could for the assets of the company. Accordingly, the receiver proceeded in the ordinary way to realise the assets and put up the property for sale.
Comment on this
The highest offer was £465 10s., which was accepted by the receiver — which he was bound to do by law.
Comment on this
Of course the machinery had cost more. The putting down of a railway track is expensive, but if you try to sell that track, in situ, to somebody who has to take it up and transport it, you will find that it is a very different matter and that you will get very much less. Anybody could have told the Deputy that. Anyhow, that was the highest price offered, and the receiver was bound by law to accept it. That is the end of that.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that is the end of that? I want to know about the buildings and——
Comment on this
I have no doubt that it is possible to win slates by some hand-method to a limited extent. That is not contested. What is contested is that the large-scale commerical work for which the company was formed, and for which the machinery was purchased, was impracticable. I am not offering that as a personal opinion, but as the opinion of the experts employed by me.
We have had a lot of talk here about unemployment. I think the speech made here to-day by Deputy Norton was a disgrace. He is the leader of the Labour Party, and as such purports to make unemployment his special concern. He came in here to-day and made a speech on unemployment, a prepared speech — not a speech that he made on the spur of the moment, not a speech that he was provoked into making by some statement from this side of the House. It was a prepared speech, and that speech consisted of nothing else but a series of political gibes, misrepresentations of the facts, and attempts to score purely debating points against the Government. Is that the Labour Party's contribution towards the solution of the unemployment problem? On many occasions I have appealed to Deputies on the opposite benches to face up to the fact that unemployment is a serious problem. It is not as serious here as in other countries but, nevertheless, it is serious enough to justify, not merely the serious attention of Deputies, but the mobilisation of all the resources of this country to the fullest extent that is practicable for the purpose of dealing with it. If we are going to get unemployment dealt with properly here, we have to take it out of this atmosphere of political controversy. We have to have a serious attempt by Deputies on all sides of the House to contribute to the sum total of all the constructive suggestions we can get. Those attempts to score purely debating points against the Government are of no service whatever. That is the type of thing which lost the Labour Party four seats in the last election and will lose them four more at the next election. That is why I suggest, as I have often done, that Deputies should come into this House, not merely as representatives of a faction, but as Deputies elected by the people to a council of Deputies for the purpose of evolving a constructive plan to deal with what is our most urgent social problem.
There is no solution for the problem of unemployment except the provision of permanent constructive work. It is true, of course, that there are wild plans for the provision of permanent employment in agriculture and industry. It is necessary to provide State schemes of work to cope with the situation, but I can assure Deputy Cogan that we will never get to the point at which it will be possible to realise the ideal he has in mind, where every worker losing employment can go to the labour exchange and be employed on a State scheme within two days. Human ingenuity is not capable of devising a scheme of public works capable of producing that result. The scheme has to be planned in advance; engineers have to work on it; the finances have to be examined; managerial problems have to be solved; and it can be brought into operation only as circumstances permit. It is not possible to have such a scheme of work that every man who leaves private employment can be immediately absorbed on a Government scheme. That is an ideal; it is not practicable, but we can attempt, and are attempting, to distribute throughout the country public works which will at least ease the problem considerably. We have gone a long way in imposing burdens on the people that such a scheme of public works might be made possible. In each year in which the Fianna Fáil Government has been in office we have provided a larger amount for the financing of public works than our predecessors thought fit to provide during their whole ten years in office. That was not done easily. It was only done through increased taxation — increased taxation which is being constantly opposed in this House by the very people who are demanding more and more public works. Moreover, we have provided public services which are designed to protect the unemployed against the possibility of destitution.
Deputy Norton can make as many speeches as he likes about the inadequacy of the unemployment assistance rates to maintain the unemployed people and their families. We know they are not capable of maintaining the unemployed and their families during protracted periods of unemployment. They were not designed for that purpose. They were designed, as the name implies, to assist unemployed people during temporary periods of unemployment. The rates were fixed, not in relation to the needs of those people, but in relation to the total amount of money that could be made available for the service. The cost of that service exceeds £1,000,000 per year. In the year 1934, when that service was instituted, taxation had to be increased by £1,000,000, and that increased taxation produced an uproar in many parts of the country. We had to face that uproar. We had to convince the people that not merely was it a wise policy to provide money for that service, but that it was the fulfilling of what is an essential part of the functions of Government, to erect those barriers against destitution amongst the unemployed or the partially unemployed people of the country. We could, of course, if we liked exaggerate our unemployment problem. That is perhaps to be expected during election periods. Those who are against the Government will naturally try to represent existing conditions as worse than they are, but here in this House the facts are known, and those attempts at exaggeration and misrepresentation can have no purpose except to mislead the people who are outside this House. They certainly will not mislead anybody here who has the same access to the facts as those who speak in that way.
At the labour exchange there is a register in existence. That register is sometimes called the register of unemployed. It is nothing of the sort. It is a register of people who are available for employment. On the date that Deputy Norton said we had 97,000 people unemployed, there were upon that register 45,000 people who were described as having means. There were 29,000 people described as without means, and there were 19,000 people with claims to unemployment insurance benefit. Of course there will always be a certain number of people who are not really unemployed, who do not regard themselves as part of the unemployment problem, but are merely passing from one job to another. The worker employed by the building trade employer, who finishes work on one job, may have to wait a week or ten days before getting another. The docker working on the quay may work only two days, and get enough to keep him for a week, although he is not working during the other four days. There is always a certain number of people of that kind who are not part of the unemployment problem. Their total number at any one time is 20,000 or 25,000, and the more employment we get in the country the larger that number will become. In trying to estimate the size of the unemployment problem we can deduct that figure from the total number on the register. There are all those farmers' sons about whom Deputy Dillon was speaking. Even when the census of 1926 was published, the Minister of the day would not include those people in the total of the unemployed as calculated on the register, even though they described themselves as unemployed.
There was justification for that attitude. They are not unemployed. There is work which they can do on their fathers' farms, but they are available for work, if they can get it, on the roads or on forestry schemes in their areas. They are, in a sense, part of the unemployment problem, but to represent the figure to which they total as a measure of our unemployment problem is completely inaccurate. Even if there were 97,000 people unemployed in the sense that Deputies use that phrase, that is, people without means or the possibility of occupying themselves profitably, our unemployment position would still be substantially better than that in Northern Ireland. The population of Northern Ireland is about one-half the population of the Twenty-Six Counties, and the register of the unemployed there for this week exceeded 91,000. I am not saying that the fact that we are not as bad as others is a reason why we should neglect any opportunity for trying to improve the position. On the contrary, I say that our position is sufficiently grave to justify this Dáil in contemplating even increased burdens on the people in order to provide the means for removing the possibility of hardship arising from unemployment. But if we come here with proposals to put those new burdens on the people, proposals to raise by new taxation extra sums to be devoted to the financing of public works, or to some scheme for the permanent improvement of the unemployment position in agriculture or industry, or to increasing the social services and consequently protecting the people against hardship, will we get the support of the Party opposite? Nothing of the kind. We never got their support for that purpose.
This debate, I understand, is to adjourn at 7.30. I do not want to carry the discussion on the Estimate over until to-morrow. I do not think any of the other matters that were raised need necessarily be dealt with on this occasion. Other opportunities for dealing with them will occur, and consequently I move that the question be put.
Comment on this
It is now after half-past seven, and the arrangement was that other business would be taken at this hour.