We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Treason Bill, 1939—From the Seanad. - Tourist Traffic Bill, 1938—Committee (resumed—Section 10).

Contributions 1–142 of 279. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Treason Bill, 1939
Enacted

No. 3 of 1939 ›

On Section 11, can the Minister give us any information as to the number of officers to be appointed?

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I could not give any indication at this stage. Of course, a number of officers will be engaged in connection with the registration of hotels and so on, but the numbers engaged will depend to a large extent on the development of the board's other activities.

Comment on this

The Minister must realise that we are giving, in effect, a blank cheque for £20,000 to this board for administration purposes; and he must have had, from some source or another, some estimate of the requirements. Can he give us any idea now as to what will be the remuneration of the board itself—the four members and the chairman?

Comment on this

No decision has been made on the matter.

Comment on this

And no estimate has been made?

Comment on this

The matter of the remuneration of the board has not been considered.

Comment on this

No, but the type and size of the staff has been considered.

Comment on this

I have given a rough estimate, but that is all I could give.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what it will be?

Comment on this

I gave a rough estimate, and I emphasised the fact that it was only a rough estimate.

Comment on this

Well, a time will come, when the Minister gets this Bill through, when he will have to make up his mind as to what the expenses will be. I am not so much concerned with the question of the remuneration of the members of the board itself. I am more concerned with the question of what staff will be appointed.

Comment on this

We are giving to the board the duty of appointing whatever staff the board will require, but the board will have to do that within the limits of its financial resources.

Comment on this

Will not the sum of £20,000 cover the remuneration of the board and the staff?

Comment on this

Yes, and more.

Comment on this

Therefore, the time must come when the Minister must make up his mind as to how much of the £20,000 will be eaten into in that way. Will he be in a better position to tell us how much it will amount to then, than he is now? What factors would the Minister have to guide him then that he has not before him now?

Comment on this

None at all, except, as I say, that the matter has not been considered. That is a matter that has got to be considered, and it has got to be considered in consultation with the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Can I ask the Minister, in connection with sub-section (3) of this section, whether that sub-section is necessary, or whether the Local Appointments Commissioners could not operate in this way on request, if so desired? Take the case of a local authority which requires certain officials. It is bound to apply to the Local Appointments Commission for them. Here is a case in which you set up a board and, presumably, give very considerable fees to the members of that board. At the same time, we are allowing them a privilege which is not granted to a local authority. Can the Minister tell the House what is the reason for making an exception in this case as against a local authority?

Comment on this

Because this is not a local authority. This is a business undertaking which has got to be run upon the same general lines as any other business undertaking. Precisely the same consideration has influenced the form of this section as determined the insertion of a similar section in the Act establishing the Electricity Supply Board. Precisely the same section was inserted in the measure setting up the Electricity Supply Board. This section gives to the board the same right which the Electricity Supply Board have to fill their posts through the machinery of the Local Appointments Commission if they choose to do so but it does not impose upon them a statutory obligation to do so. There may be certain types of staff which could be more suitably chosen by the machinery of the Local Appointments Commission, but there are other types of staff in which the judgement of the board as regards individual personality would be of importance.

Comment on this

It might have been a good thing if this had been provided for in the early stages of the E.S.B. That was a manufacturing business. This is not. There is a difference. This may be a useful institution or it may be one of the Government's mistakes, of which there are many. In so far as its usefulness is concerned, it is quite possible that, from a Selection Board, you will get as suitable a person as would be chosen by the Minister or by this board. Presumably, the Minister has in mind the appointment of some member of the board. Is that person, whoever he is, experienced in business? Does the Minister think that his experience, in whatever business he is engaged in, qualifies him for this particular task? It appears to me strange that the Government should provide for appointment in this way since the Government itself is limited in the selection of its officials by an Act of Parliament. It has to get them through a particular channel. This, I presume, will be an expert institution. The board will have to do expert work. It is quite possible that those already engaged in the tourist industry would make as good a selection, as a board, as any other body but the House is concerned with the fact that it is committed to an expenditure of practically £20,000 each year. It may be less but, presumably, there is nothing to prevent its being more except a Vote. I should like to know whether, after 12 years, we cannot improve upon the phraseology embodied in a Bill passed in this House.

Comment on this

It is not a question of improving the phraseology. Certain principles must apply in matters of this kind. When you set up a board to run a business undertaking— whether it is a manufacturing undertaking or has to do with tourist development matters little—it seems to me that you must give to that board the same authority over its staff and the same power in relation to its staff that a business concern would have. When it is a matter of appointing subordinate staff, this board of the E.S.B. might find it convenient to avail of the machinery of the Local Appointments Commission. If they wish to do so, they are empowered to do so but, in relation to the more important members of the staff, I think the experience of the E.S.B. has been that it is in a better position to select these officers than any other authority would be. It helps the discipline and efficiency of the organisation to have these appointments made by the board and I think the same thing will be found in the case of the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

There is a difference between this board and the Electricity Supply Board. The Electricity Supply Board was set up as a semi-public body and it paid back any money it got from the State. This body which we propose now to set up is financed under Section 15 and under Section 16 out of funds supplied by the State. It must be agreed that it would not be desirable to withdraw from the executive officers of this body—the tourist development board—the right to dismiss officials who were not equal to the tasks imposed upon them. But we are quite entitled, without unduly restricting the discretion of the executive, to require them to employ their staff in accordance with certain procedure. There is no use in putting your cap or coat upon it. The important thing here is that the tourist development board should not be made a refuge of jobbery. The moment this board is constituted, every camp follower of the Fianna Fáil Party will be clamouring for employment under it. The Minister himself knows that he himself will be besieged by applicants for jobs under this board.

Comment on this

They will be wasting their time. I shall have nothing to do with them.

Comment on this

That statement will be taken for what it is worth. Whether or not the Minister has anything to do with the board, under the law, he knows that he will be approached by thousands of people to use his influence with the board to get them jobs. Every member of the Fianna Fáil Party will be similarly approached to get them jobs under this board. There is no use in anybody closing his eyes to that fact because it is common knowledge to us all that every public man is besieged by people looking for jobs. It is natural that the Government Deputies, and Minister particularly, should be more besieged than any other Deputies.

The same was true of local authorities. When a position fell vacant, hundreds of obviously inelligible persons clamoured for the vacancy and pressed personal considerations why they should get it. There were widows, indigent persons, persons who had done good service in the past and people with a hundred excellent personal arguments to advance to show why their claims to the position should be preferred to that of anybody else. It was very often necessary, in the best interests of the local authority—and will often be necessary in the best interests of the tourist development board—to take somebody who had no claim ad misericordiam at all—to get a highly efficient person who was possibly in a very good job. That is the kind of person the board might be under a duty to appoint. There would be a dozen applicants who would have a strong case in compassion to get the appointment. The only way in which this board can be protected from irresistible pressure is to take these appointments completely out of their hands and put them in the hands of either the Local Appointments Commission or the Civil Service Commissioners.

That is common knowledge to us all. Fianna Fáil have their own experience. When they came into office, six years ago, they said they were going to restore to the local authorities their autonomy by requiring the Appointments Commissioners to send down three names instead of one. That reform lasted for exactly three months because they discovered that giving back the discretion to the local authorities to choose between three persons for one job gave rise to all the old, poisonous abuses that the Appointments Commissioners abolished. Everybody who has any knowledge of the working of local authorities in rural Ireland at the present time admits that one of the most valuable reforms that was introduced into this State was the institution of the Appointments Commissioners. Everyone in this House is aware that in certain semi-public institutions that have been established without the intervention of the Appointments Commissioners very grave dissatisfaction has existed as a result of appointments which did not appear to be made exclusively on the merits, appointments which it was felt were affected by political influence. Here is an opportunity to lift off the shoulders of the members of this board the loathsome task of filling jobs which will have to be filled under the board.

If the Appointments Commissioners should put forward a person who is wholly unsuitable—and that is an unlikely contingency—there is no suggestion that the discretion of the board should be limited in disposing of that individual and dismissing him, for reasons stated, if he was wholly incompetent to do his job. No such case that I am aware of has arisen in connection with the Local Appointments Commissioners or the Civil Service Commissioners since they were instituted 14 years ago. Why should we apprehend that such cases will now arise? If we extend the functions of the Appointments Commissioners to this board, there is not the least use in saying to this board that, where they think it desirable, they may refer the case to the Appointments Commissioners, because that does not protect them in the least degree from external pressure. I know, because if the local authorities have certain minor appointments which they may send to the Appointments Commissioners or which they may fill themselves, canvassing is merely subdivided into two stages. At first there is a general barrage from all sides not to send the appointment to the Appointments Commissioners. They all say, "Bring it into the arena and then we can all go down into the arena and, in blood and dust, battle for our respective candidates." Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Republican and everybody else link arms to bring pressure to bear on the local authorities not to send it to the Appointments Commissioners. Once united, they will achieve that objective and get the appointment restored to the arena of the local authority. Then they divide up into their various warring factions to bring influence to bear on the individual members of the Body to vote for their own particular candidate and you are back in just as rotten a situation as you were before the Appointments Commissioners were ever appointed.

Any member of the Fianna Fáil Party who is on a local authority will tell the Minister that you are asking this board to do an impossible thing if you ask them to send these appointments to the Appointments Commissioners if they are not compelled to do so. I have not the slightest doubt that no matter who the Minister nominates on the board they will be grateful to him if they are placed under statutory obligation to send all the appointments to the Appointments Commissioners. I am convinced that, unless he wants this board to be turned into a sink of patronage, he ought to impose a statutory obligation on the members of the board to refer all the minor appointments to the Local Appointments Commissioners or the Civil Service Commissioners, whichever he likes. I have not the slightest doubt that, far from resenting this limitation of their discretion, they will be most grateful to this House for protecting them from the usual kind of canvassing which it is the miserable fate of a member of a public body in the country at the present time to suffer whenever small appointments have to be made. Would the Minister consider an amendment on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

No. This is not a local authority. This is a business concern. There will be no political division on this board. Anyone who knows the first thing about the functions of the Local Appointments Commissioners or the running of a business concern would never make the suggestion.

Comment on this

This is a non-controversial matter. Let us assume that all members of the board are supporters of the Labour Party, apart from their membership of the board, and that it is known that Deputy Norton regards them as influential supporters of his, that he is in the habit of befriending them and having constant contact with them. Deputy Norton's supporters from Skerries will come to Deputy Norton and say, "You know the chairman of the board. He is a member of the Clontarf branch. Would you be good enough to go to that man and say to him that he ought to appoint John Dolan as medical inspector for Northeast Kerry?" To which Deputy Norton replies, "Certainly not. I will have nothing to do with it. That appointment will be made on its merits. I never interfere in public appointments." To which the Secretary of the Labour Party in Skerries will say, "Very well; when you want somebody to sit in the polling booth in Skerries at the next general election you can look elsewhere. I have been labouring for 40 years for the Labour Party in North Dublin and the first favour I ever asked is refused." That goes on and on and on. Thousands of similar appeals must have reached the Minister in his day. If the member of the board happens to be a friend and supporter of the Minister every Deputy of the Minister's Party living in the constituency where an influential person wants influence to be brought will come to the Minister and say, "It is all very well for you to be doing the `purist,' but this fellow commands 250 votes. If I cannot get this fellow's support on general election day I will not be able to get a single personating agent in that area. They are all Blue Shirts there. All I want you to do is to write a letter." The Minister must refuse loftily, stating that he never interferes in public appointments, which his own Deputies know is nonsense. The Minister has to say, "I do not care a fiddle-de-dee what happens to your constituents. I will not use my influence on behalf of your constituent's application." The Minister knows he cannot do that, that he will have to write a letter. If, on the other hand, the Minister can produce the Act of Parliament and say, "What can I do, the board has nothing to do with the appointment; it is going to the Appointments Commissioners, the members of which I do not know and will not know because they will not be appointed until the morning the appointment is made." Surely that would be a better position for everyone. It ought not to be necessary to go into all that. The Minister makes it necessary by pretending to deny it exists. There is no suggestion here that once the person is appointed the Tourist Board cannot dismiss him.

Comment on this

Can we appoint another person the next day?

Comment on this

No; refer the matter back to the Appointments Commissioners.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know how long that would take?

Comment on this

If the procedure is cumbersome or archaic or inefficient——

Comment on this

It is completely unsuitable to a business concern. It is suitable only to a local authority.

Comment on this

So that sub-section (3) is all eyewash?

Comment on this

I say that, conceivably, this board, like the Electricity Supply Board, could say: "We want a certain grade of clerical officer. We know we want, on an average, ten or 12 a year"—this board would not be in that position, but the Electricity Supply Board would—and they can arrange for a competitive examination which would give them a list of applicants from which they could draw. But, when it comes to appointing persons to carry out responsible duties, neither the Electricity Supply Board nor the Tourist Board would think of filling the vacancies by this machinery. It would be most unsuitable and much too slow in operation. Apart from that, it is essential, if you are going to get efficiency, that the authority of the board over the staff should be unquestioned, that they should be able to dismiss a man to-day if he is unsuitable for his work and appoint another man in his place the next day.

Comment on this

Why appoint the other man the next day?

Comment on this

Because the work must go on. If it were given to the Local Appointments Commissioners it might take three or four months to get a substitute. That system would not work. We have heard a lot about Deputies being asked to influence appointments. Of course, they will be asked. Deputies are asked to influence appointments under the Hospitals Trust, the railways, and in a thousand and one privately owned concerns with which the Government has nothing to do. I am sure I get at least a dozen letters a day asking me to try to get employment for people in the Hospitals Trust. You have many more people writing asking you to try and get them employment on the railways and in similar organisations. Does that influence the efficiency of those concerns? Not in the least.

Comment on this

The Minister says that nobody must limit the discretion of the board to dismiss their employees and to control their staff. Nobody wants to. Let their discretion to control the staff that has been appointed be as absolute as you care to make it in order to get efficiency, but it is idle to pretend that in any business which is efficiently run, the dismissal of one officer, no matter who that officer may be, could or should disrupt the whole working of a business enterprise. If such a situation ever arose then the business enterprise is not being properly run. If the whole efficiency of the organisation has to depend on the permanency of one individual, then it is clear that the business should not be so organised.

The objection that the Minister takes to delay is really not one of substance. Anybody who has had experience knows what actually happens. After all, county administration is just as grave a matter as the administration of the Tourist Development Board. Suppose a county engineer drops dead, or is dismissed, on a Monday morning, you have the position that the whole of the public services in that county are directed by that one man. What happens? You appoint one of the assistant engineers to act as county engineer while the filling of the office is being passed over to the Appointments Commissioners and they appoint a substitute. The filling of the office may take a month or three months. It may even take nine months to get the right man. The first man chosen may, in fact, not take the job at all, so that the work of filling the office has to be gone all over again. The work of the county goes on under the direction of the temporary officer. When the permanent officer is appointed he takes over, and the work goes on as before.

Here, doubtless, a situation might arise in which a member of your staff is dismissed and where it may take a couple of months to replace him. How does the Minister think you are going to get a suitable candidate for a responsible office without a couple of months' enquiry. You are not going to pick responsible men off gooseberry bushes. The whole danger is that someone will be brought along and that pressure will be brought to bear on the board to appoint someone who will be said to have a national record: one who will fit very nicely into a job if there is very little work to be done and a large salary attached thereto. The job will be made for him, and irresistible pressure will be brought to bear on the board to make the appointment. Suppose a vacancy turns up, and there is no candidate in view, could the Minister himself—I am sure he looks upon himself as a paragon of efficiency—undertake to fill any responsible position in his Department without a couple of months' enquiry into a person's credentials and records, a person who very probably, if he is a suitable candidate, will also be in remunerative employment. If not, it is highly likely that he will not be a suitable candidate. The best men already have good jobs, and you will have to seek out a good man to fill a good job. You will not get him in three or four days.

There is always some measure of delay in getting a really high class man to fill a highly responsible job. My experience of dealing with the Local Appointments Commissioners is that there is never any undue delay. On every occasion on which a very long delay appeared to arise it was due to the fact that a candidate who applied for the job and was recommended for it by the Local Appointments Commissioners refused to take it up, whereupon it had to be referred back a second time to the Appointments Commissioners. In cases where candidates recommended for appointment by the Appointments Commissioners have taken up the positions, there has never been, in my opinion, any unreasonable delay on the part of the Appointments Commissioners. That system has undoubtedly been an unqualified blessing to those responsible for the appointment of persons in the public or semi-public service.

Comment on this

The Minister has not attempted to show why, because this is not a local authority, which does responsible work, or a central authority like the Civil Service, but is a commercial undertaking, that, therefore, the recruitment of staff ought not to start through the Local Appointments Commissioners. The Minister says that the system of the Appointments Commissioners is unsuitable. If he will cast his mind back on the grounds he gave for unsuitability, then I suggest they are grounds for the abolition of that method of recruiting staff for anybody. The Minister says the Appointments Commissioners are not a suitable body to appoint people because the job to be filled is a responsible position. But, surely, you cannot get more responsible positions than some of the high positions which have to be filled under a county council. The only other reason the Minister gave, beyond repeating that it was a commercial enterprise and that, therefore, this particular method of recruitment was unsuitable, was the want of control over the staffs. Has anybody ever suggested that the system of the Civil Service Commissioners and their functions has given the Government less control over the Civil Service, or that the use of the Local Appointments Commissioners has given the local authorities less control over their staffs? I think the Minister might indicate why it is that he thinks this method is unsuitable. As to the point dealt with by Deputy Dillon, the Minister relies on the alleged delay. Unless the Minister can show much stronger grounds than the mere repetition of the fact that this is a commercial body: that there is a difference between the character of this body and a county council, then I submit that he has said nothing to justify a different method of recruitment of staff. That is so, unless he goes on the other line: that for responsible positions the method of recruitment through the Local Appointments Commissioners is unsound, and would interfere with the authority which the board would have over its servants. But with regard to the other position, he has given no ground to show that the difference he alleges exists between the functions of this body and the functions, say, of the local authority justifies a different method of recruitment of staff.

Comment on this

We may take it that sub-section (3) is just eye-wash. What the Minister thinks about it is shown by what he has said. What leaves me completely blank with regard to an understanding of the section here is that the Minister tells us he wants £25,000 a year for the administrative expenses of this board; he told us he was going to have a board of five, or that it is not exceeding five; that is all he will tell us about the board. He asks the House under this section to give power to the board to appoint so many officers and servants as it shall from time to time think proper. The Minister tells us he wants a board; he wants £25,000 to spend on the administrative expenses of the board and its officers. Surely the House ought to be assisted by the Minister in getting some kind of picture as to what type of staff is required. He made no attempt to explain the type of headquarter staff that will be required, or the type of staff that will be required on inspectorial of other work. As far as the Bill is concerned, the £25,000 may be spent on any kind of officer from the secretary in charge of the headquarters institution to a charwoman down in one of the hotels which the new board may or may not build. I think it is absurd that the Minister should simply say that he wants £25,000, that he wants a board, and that he wants that board to have all the officers it requires. We ought to have some kind of idea as to the type of organisation that will exist under the board, so that we can have some reasonable chance of seeing what type of organisation is going to cost us £25,000 a year.

Comment on this

I suppose this discussion must come to a conclusion at some time. I do not question the suitability of the Local Appointments Commissioners to make local appointments, but that is an entirely different business to that which is at issue here. I am quite prepared to amend the section by taking out sub-sections (3) (4) and (5) if Deputy Mulcahy objects to them.

Comment on this

I am taking the Minister at his word.

Comment on this

If the board wanted to avail of the Local Appointments Commissioners, there is no reason why they should not. I was struck by the fact that the Electricity Supply Board, in whose Act a precisely similar section appears, have never availed of it.

Comment on this

They have got a selection board of their own. Will there be a selection board in this case?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the board itself, as it was a matter for the Electricity Supply Board. When you set up an organisation of this kind to carry out certain business operations, you put on the board the obligation of getting that done. You give them power to recruit staff to do it, and you give them full authority over that staff. They must have in relation to that staff precisely the same powers of control and discipline as the board of a privately-owned business house. You cannot run an undertaking of this kind on any other basis. I certainly do not propose to try it. It would be a completely foolish thing to do, and would make it impossible for this board to function efficiently. The responsibility is on the members of the board. If they have not got in relation to the staff the authority which a business man would expect to have over his staff, they cannot carry out that responsibility efficiently. Therefore, I think we must put them in precisely the same position as the board of a privately-owned company, subject only to the provisions of this Act which make them removable by the Minister if they themselves fail in their duty, and make them liable to submit certain reports, to submit accounts for audit, and so forth. Within those limitations, I gave them a free hand to do the job.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us any idea, however elementary, of the type of organisation and the class of officers that are going to be appointed?

Comment on this

I do not know what information the Deputy wants. I think a reading of the Bill will give the Deputy as much information as I have.

Comment on this

The Minister deceives himself. A reading of the Bill shows that this board may build, equip, establish and operate hotels; it may provide services, sports, amusements, or other facilities; it may improve and maintain amenities; it may engage in any kind of publicity; it may establish tourist agencies; it may provide schemes for training people; it may prepare guide-books, itineraries and other publications; it may take over land, fishery rights, sporting rights, and all other kinds of rights. Does that convey in any way what type of organised staff is going to be set up?

Comment on this

The type of organised staff is going to be determined by the board.

Comment on this

I am correct then in putting it this way: The Minister says he wants £25,000; he wants a board: he wants that board to appoint as many officers as they think fit; and he wants us simply to shut up?

Comment on this

No. If I were the person chosen to be the executive officer of this board, I have a general idea of the type of organisation which I think would be best. I am sure, if Deputy Mulcahy would imagine himself in that position, he also could quite easily determine for himself the outlines of the organisation he would require. But of what value is it to the House that I should give my opinion or that he should give his? The board may say: "We have a different idea altogether. We have been given the responsibility, and we are going to set up the type of organisation which we think best." What the type of organisation is going to be I do not know, because the board has not yet been appointed.

Comment on this

Does the Minister tell the House that, in asking us to pass this Bill, to provide £25,000 administrative expenses, and to give statutory authority for the other moneys that may be spent here, he has not contemplated in any way the lines upon which the board are going to run their business?

Comment on this

That is a different question altogether. The Deputy asked about staff organisation.

Comment on this

Has the Minister not considered the lines upon which the board will organise their staff? Does he mean to say that he has approached the House without having had any conversations on that subject?

Comment on this

With whom?

Comment on this

With the people he has in mind to run this board?

Comment on this

I certainly have had no conversations with anybody.

Comment on this

Then I think that, in the financial circumstances of the present day or in any financial circumstances, the Minister should not ask Parliament to pass moneys to this extent without giving them some assistance along the lines of understanding what kind of organised staff this board is going to use for the purpose of carrying on its work and spending this money.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to make clear how the adoption of the Appointments Commissioners would interfere with the control of the staff, once appointed?

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary to go into that subject now. The Deputy knows as well as I do that the appointment of staff by the Local Appointments Commissioners would put the officers of this board in precisely the same relationship to the board as civil servants have to the Minister. That is no way to run a business concern. In the case of a business concern an officer—even a most prominent officer of the organisation—can be sacked for incompetence

Comment on this

And a civil servant cannot?

Comment on this

A civil servant will not be, as the Deputy well knows. If he gets drunk, or hits his superior, or turns up late in the morning, he will be sacked, but, if he merely makes mistakes or proves not to be efficient enough for his job, he will be transferred somewhere else—not sacked.

Comment on this

That is a new light on the Civil Service.

Comment on this

If a civil servant insults his Minister he may be sacked, but if he costs the country £100,000 he will get promoted.

Comment on this

He will be changed to another Department where he will have a softer job.

Comment on this

This section seems to me to be too wide in the powers which it confers on the officers of the board. It says that the board may exercise any of the powers and perform any of the functions conferred and imposed on the board by this Act through or by any of its officers or servants authorised by the board in that behalf. I should like to know what the Minister means by that— that they can delegate any of their duties, if in their opinion it is prudent to do so, to the officers of the board?

Comment on this

That is the normal provision which appears in most Acts of this character.

Comment on this

That is merely a copy of some other section?

Comment on this

It is a copy of a section which appears in similar Acts. At the same time, I think it may be desirable to reconsider it. We will have later on some discussions upon the question of appeals from decisions of the board. While I do not see my way at present to accept any of the amendments that have been proposed, I think, having regard to them, we may find it desirable to amend this section so as to make it clear that a decision upon, say, an application for registration, will be a decision of the board and not a decision of an officer of the board; so that there will be, in fact, an appeal from an inspector or whoever has a particular job under the board to the board as a whole. I am prepared to consider amending that section.

Comment on this

As the section stands, I gather that the board—and I think the Minister indicated that the personnel of the board would be a really important factor—can delegate its authority and its functions to one of its officials.

Comment on this

As the section stands, it can. When I am prepared to take out of that section the power of the board to delegate to its officers the final decision on questions of registration or other similar matters which may arise under the Bill, an appeal would lie to the board also on the questions of grading of hotels and so on.

Comment on this

The reason I ask the Minister to consider this question is that it seems to me that, unless he is prepared to go further in the matter, the tendency will be to let the civil servants of the board—who are chosen in the competent manner we have heard discussed—run the whole thing; and the board would fade away, leaving simply the civil servants, not the business men who are on the board, really running the whole thing. I am not putting this in a controversial manner, but I want the Minister to consider the particular danger that unless he goes further than he proposes he will be making the board a mere court of appeal.

Comment on this

No function will be delegated to an officer except that which will be subject to a decision of the board itself.

Comment on this

But those who will be working under the board will be permanent civil servants.

Comment on this

As Minister for Industry and Commerce, I delegate to many officers authority to do certain things, and the fact is well known that the signing of various classes of documents and the conclusion of certain forms of agreement are altogether too numerous to be dealt with personally.

Comment on this

And which are probably illegal or are almost certainly illegal.

Comment on this

On that question the Deputy found no one to agree with him.

Comment on this

Three judges of the High Court agreed with me on that point.

Comment on this

Certainly none of the members of Deputy Cosgrave's Government agreed with Deputy Costello when he was Attorney-General. It has been done in the past, and is done now, that a Minister delegates to particular officers of his Department powers to carry out certain functions which are by statute conferred upon him. The board can do precisely the same thing, that is to say, authorise the secretary to purchase land or sign a lease or do some other work of that kind for it, with its authority, in a manner which would be binding upon the board. I am prepared, however, to amend this section to make it clear that those decisions which affect private interests must be decisions of the board and may not be decisions of the officers of the board. That, I hope, will go some way to meet the representations that have been made.

Comment on this

A lot will depend on the character of the amendment. I can assure the Minister that his predecessors when in office went personally into all these things that they were required by statute to do. I remember myself delegating authority, and yet, as a matter of fact, I had to hear a case and come to a decision formally. But there may have been changes since then.

Comment on this

I think it is quite clear that the Minister has not really considered the scope of this section as it stands at the moment. The members of the board can irrevocably delegate all their functions to one particular officer and there is no provision by which such power may be—if I might use the word—undelegated.

Comment on this

The Minister could remove the board.

Comment on this

The Minister has not yet seen the point. The powers could be irrevocably delegated and once there is an irrevocable delegation the Minister can do what he likes about removing the board.

Comment on this

I invite the Deputy to re-read the section.

Comment on this

I invite the Minister to read the section, not to talk of re-reading it.

Comment on this

There is nothing about irrevocable delegation.

Comment on this

Where is the means of taking back such delegation of power?

Comment on this

There is no means of making such irrevocable delegation, such as is suggested.

Comment on this

Of course there is.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy read the section again:—

"The board may exercise any powers and perform any of the functions conferred and imposed on the board by this Act through or by any of its officers or servants authorised by the board in that behalf."

I am not an eminent lawyer, but I interpret that section more accurately than the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have no doubt the Minister would try.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

Before Section 13 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The board shall not enter into any contract, provided for under Part II of this Act, with any company or concern in which a member of the board has any interest.

(2) A member of the board who has any interest in any contract contemplated by the board shall disclose to the board the fact of such interest and the nature thereof, and such member shall take no part in any deliberation or decision of the board relating to such contract, and such disclosure shall be recorded in the minutes of the board.

I have drafted a new section in order absolutely to protect the dealings of this board with any body or any corporation or company that might have an interest in it or be interested through a member of the board. I am not saying that this is a better section, but what I intended to do was to guard the board so far as the public is concerned, to assure people that there would be no allegation of corruption as regards dealings with any company in which they had an interest.

Comment on this

I think that my intention in putting in this section and the intention of the Deputies who signed the amendment are the same; but the amendment that they have moved is altogether too restrictive. It would prevent the board entering into a contract with a company in which a member of the board is a shareholder. For instance, if a member of the board is a shareholder in Guinness's, I suppose the board could not order Guinness's stout. The amendment is entirely too restrictive.

Comment on this

It is not intended to cover such ridiculous things as that.

Comment on this

I think the provisions of the Bill are sufficient safeguard against any such dangers. The section reads:

The board may exercise any of the powers and perform any of the functions conferred and imposed on the board by this Act through or by any of its officers or servants authorised by the board in that behalf.

I think that is sufficient.

Comment on this

Supposing a member of the board does not discharge his duty, the duty which is purported to be imposed upon him by that section, what is to happen?

Comment on this

What is to happen under the amendment? Nothing! If the Deputy wants sanctions I am prepared to listen.

Comment on this

I do not want anything of the kind. It is an absolutely absurd provision, which means nothing.

Comment on this

I might make the suggestion that at least ten Bills drafted in the Deputy's time contained exactly the same provision.

Comment on this

Produce them; produce any one single instance that there was something in the nature of sanctions.

Comment on this

The Electricity Supply Act.

Comment on this

Nothing may happen if the provisions that are in this section are disregarded?

Comment on this

Except that the member would probably cease to be a member of the board.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

Administrative action.

Comment on this

I do not know where the power is going to come from for that. Here was a case where an obvious slip was pointed out to the Minister. Instead of receiving it in the normal way, he regards it almost as an insult and refuses to consider it. This is very harmful from the Parliamentary point of view. An amendment has been put down by Deputy McMenamin. He has pointed out the objection to the present section that supposing a man is a member of the board and is engaged in some occupation—building, painting, or anything of that kind—and there is a question of a contract to be placed, this member apparently cannot give his advice to the board. He cannot join in the deliberations even if he has more expert knowledge than other members of the board. However, so far as the point raised by Deputy Costello is concerned, whether it was or was not in previous Acts, I have still to learn that the absence of sanctions from any previous measure makes a case for the absence of sanctions here. After all, that is what we are discussing; not any previous Act, but the present Act. If the Minister produced one Act or ten Acts, the Electricity Supply Act, or any other Act, it is irrelevant so far as interpreting the meaning of this particular section is concerned. It might be quite good for the kind of controversy the Minister goes on with, but for interpreting or helping legislation it is a waste of time.

Comment on this

It may be necessary to have some form of penalty provided for a breach of the provisions of the section, but what form of penalty you can have other than removal from the board is difficult to see. My controversial spirit was aroused by Deputy Costello's description of the section as absurd and ridiculous. I think these are the words he used. I merely retorted by saying that he himself was responsible for Acts containing a precisely similar section. He asked me to produce one and I produced the Electricity Supply Act. Section 10 of the Electricity Supply Act is word for word what is here.

Comment on this

No other connecting link with it?

Comment on this

If I had the Act before me, I am pretty sure I would produce it.

Comment on this

It is an irrelevant waste of time on the part of the Minister.

Comment on this

However, I will have the point considered. There is no good in debating it now. Personally, I think that the mere mention of punishment will be of little use because the only effective punishment is removal from the board.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider dealing with this matter in the way it is dealt with in the case of local authorities? I refer the Minister to the Application of Enactments Order, 1898, Article 12, under which a member of a local authority, who has any connection with a contract, taking part in the proceedings of a local authority is guilty of an offence. Will the Minister consider dealing with the matter from that aspect? I think that would be sufficient to prevent any member of a board not disclosing the fact that he is interested.

Comment on this

I will consider whether we can impose any form of punishment on a member who breaks the regulation.

Comment on this

The Minister is looking into the "deliberation" point?

Comment on this

If a man is an expert in business and happens to be in touch with the board he cannot give advice.

Comment on this

He must clear out.

Comment on this

It is not that he cannot vote, but he cannot even give the result of his experience.

Comment on this

At the same time, it could happen that there might be some contract in connection with which a member of a board might have a definite interest and in which he might possibly seek to influence other members of the board unduly in favour of the firm in which he was interested.

Comment on this

I do not see how you can avoid that sort of thing if you put experts on the board or people in business.

Comment on this

The Deputy's suggestion is that we should allow members to take part in the deliberations but not in decisions. I shall consider that.

Comment on this

Anything you like like that. I do not want to sacrifice the value of the man's knowledge.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 10, 11, 12 and 13, do not lend themselves to successive decisions after amendment No. 9. I suggest that amendments No. 9 be considered and if carried that Deputy Benson and Deputy McMenamin should study the section as amended, and re-submit, with necessary alterations, their amendments on the Report Stage. It would be the most satisfactory procedure.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

To delete lines 5 to 9 and substitute:—

(a) assist, financially (including by way of loan) or otherwise, in the provision, extension, or improvement of accommodation for tourists;

(b) build, establish, equip, or operate hotels, guest houses, holiday hostels, holiday homes, youth hostels, and holiday camps or assist, financially (including by way of loan) or otherwise, in the building, establishing, equipping, or operating thereof;

(c) provide or assist, financially (including by way of loan) or otherwise, in providing.

The adequacy of the phraseology in the brackets in the section, by which the board had power to assist financially by way of loan in the activities stated here was questioned during the Second Reading debate, and in order to remove any doubt as to the board's ability to grant loans for these purposes the wording has been altered, as Deputies will see, in the amendment. There are one or two other slight alterations in these paragraphs also— the insertion of a reference to youth hostels and so forth which appear to be desirable: but the main purpose of the change is to clear up the doubt about the ability of the board to make loans for these purposes.

Comment on this

Then there is the general power in the section. I think some Deputies objected to that.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say why he is giving the board power to make grants, which I think is given by the insertion of the words "(including by way of loan) or otherwise"? It seems to me that if any assistance is given to a hotel the only reasonable and fair way would be by way of loan and not by way of grant.

Comment on this

The board cannot make a grant in fact without the prior sanction of the Minister as provided in the Bill. But the importance of including these words is to indicate that the board can assist in these activities by way of lending money rather than by directly investing its own money in the enterprise.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say where is the provision for making a grant?

Comment on this

The board must invest the money advanced to it in profitable enterprises. Section 16 (2) provides that the money advanced to the board shall be expended by the board solely on works, investments, or loans of a profit-earning character. But sub-section (3) gives the Minister power "to waive altogether or to postpone for such time as he thinks proper the repayment of any sum or a part of any sum so advanced or any instalment of any such sum or any part of any such instalment," or "to waive altogether or to postpone for such time as he thinks proper the payment of interest on any sum or part of any sum so advanced." In other words, the board is restricted, so far as the payment of a grant is concerned, to investing in undertakings of a profit-earning character. It cannot give that money by way of grant. It can in effect make a grant only in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (3), which means that it makes an investment; but the collection of interest on the investment may be waived, or the repayment of the amount advanced may be postponed, with the consent of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I think that is Deputy Benson's difficulty. If I understood Deputy Benson's intervention, he wants to confine the operations of the board in this particular matter to loans which would be paid back and would pay a reasonable amount of interest. He failed for the moment. What is the justification in individual cases for the Minister and the board combined giving a grant? I gathered from the Minister's exposition that the Minister and the board combined can make a grant. It amounts to that. What is the justification for that as distinct from helping by means of a loan—giving a grant to a private individual who may be in competition with other private individuals?

Comment on this

I should imagine that in such a case consent would not be given. But it need not necessarily be a private individual. It can be a local authority and will in most cases be a local authority. It might be for the purpose of providing some such amenity as a swimming pool——

Comment on this

Quite, I see.

Comment on this

——or a promenade or something of that sort which would not be of a profit-earning character.

Comment on this

I understand.

Comment on this

It is only in such cases that that would be given.

Comment on this

I can conceive the desirability of what the Minister has stated. Would the Minister be able to provide an amendment—perhaps it is only a question of draftsmanship—to limit it in any way to matters of that kind so that it cannot be given for the purpose of giving a grant to hotel proprietors who are in competition with other hotel proprietors?

Comment on this

It is hard to say how you could put in a limitation of that kind. It would be desirable if there was a rule or something by which you would have impartial treatment of individuals by the board. In practice we could do it; it would be to say that the board will not do it without getting the prior consent of the Minister. It is not that the judgement of the Minister would be better but that he can be questioned here. He is accountable for giving his consent, and that brings public opinion to bear upon the opinion of the board.

Comment on this

Paragraph (b) of the amendment provides for its being spent on hotels, guest houses, holiday hostels, etc. Assuming that it is already provided for under paragraph (a) of the amendment, then paragraph (b) is somewhat difficult to understand.

Comment on this

There is an amendment down here which would enable it to be discussed. It is not intended to confine the board's investments to loans only. It is intended that the board should have powers to invest.

Comment on this

I want to stop the giving of a grant to hotels.

Comment on this

Section 16 stops that. It says the sums advanced to the board shall be expended by the board only on works or loans of a profit-earning character.

Comment on this

The Minister can override that.

Comment on this

The Minister can override it. He can waive altogether or postpone the payment of the interest or any part of the sum advanced.

Comment on this

If the Minister will give me a sum of money I will be quite indifferent whether it is a grant or loan if he will consent to waive altogether or to postpone the repayment of the sum advanced or postpone the repayment of the interest for 100 years. On these conditions I would be quite willing to receive money as a loan, not as a grant.

Comment on this