Treason Bill, 1939—From the Seanad. - Tourist Traffic Bill, 1938—Committee (resumed—Section 10).
Contributions 143–279 of 279. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 3 of 1939 ›
I can assure the Deputy that the number of such advances will be very few. They will be for such obvious purposes as I have mentioned.
Comment on this
That is the reason why Deputy Benson says that you should restrict sub-section (b). When you come to sub-section (b), which means the building of hotels, is there any objection to limiting that to loans and investments as distinct from grants?
Comment on this
Take as an analogy the Trade Loans Guarantee cases where the money guaranteed is put into some privately-owned business concerns. That money is lent upon a certain agreement as to the amount of interest to be paid and the repayment of the loan by instalments. But, time and again, in relation to individual cases it has been found necessary and desirable to postpone the repayments of the principal and waive the payment of the interest so that difficulties of an abnormal character can be got over. That is not unusually done. The power to do that exists. It is quite possible that the board may make loans of a character similar to Guaranteed Trade Loans to companies operating hotels, and they should have power to do it if circumstances justify it. We think it would be very undesirable that they should have no power whatever to let instalments of the principal remain outstanding for a period if there was difficulty in repaying it or otherwise dealing with difficulties that might arise.
Comment on this
Section 16 appears to apply in relation to the Minister and the board. It applies to loans between the Minister and the board. What sub-section (3) of 16 provides is that the Minister may release the board from the liability of paying interest on a loan. But that sub-section does not prevent the board from afterwards doing what the man in the Gospel did going out and throttling the man outside to whom the money was lent. That seems to me to be possible in the section as it stands. The second point I want to raise is that in sub-section (2) of Section 16, provision is made that this money that is to be advanced to the board is to be invested only in loans or works of a profit-earning character. Does that profit-earning character in the case of a loan mean a loan of a profit-earning character to the board or a loan to the hotel-keeper to expend in a work of a profit-earning character?
Comment on this
The board must give the money for works of a profit-earning character. That is from the point of view of the gentleman who is operating the works. In other words, if a swimming bath is set up the board are to give financial assistance to the person operating the swimming bath who is to make money by it? Therefore it is a work of a profit-earning character to that man but not a work of a profit-earning character to the board. Applying that to the loan, if that construction is correct, the work is the work of a profit-earning character to the owner of the swimming bath but not work of a profit-earning character to the board.
Comment on this
I think Section 14, 15 and 16 will not work together. They are extremely ambiguous and they will be found very difficult to work.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not think of the board having a large sum of money which they received from the Minister for Finance. In a proposal of this kind, a normal investment by the board or a loan for the purpose of some works, the board will have to come to the Minister for Finance and get sanction for that amount of money and when sanction is got that amount of money will be advanced to the board, just as the Electricity Supply Board at present get advances from the Minister for Finance. If the Electricity Supply Board want to carry out new works of any kind, they will come to the Minister for Finance with proposals for that work. They will specify the amount of capital required. Before that capital is provided finance will have to be satisfied that it is going to be a profit-earning investment, that it will bring profit which will enable it to meet the repayment of the principal and repayment of the interest on the capital. Now the money advanced to the Tourist Board will be advanced in the same way. The board will have to come with a particular proposal and show that the work proposed to be done is of a profit-earning character. On that basis it will get the advance, but the total advances must not exceed £600,000.
Comment on this
Capable of earning a profit which will meet the interest charges on the principal and the instalments repayable on the loan. In practice we hope that the board will have an income from these investments which will liquidate the advances.
Comment on this
If the board loans £100,000 at five per cent. for that purpose, then, it would be a profit-earning investment for the board.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear as to the powers that the Minister has, or that the board have, at the moment, but, taking the example the Minister gave, the building at one of the seaside places of a small pier, in what sense would that be profit-earning?
Comment on this
It might be profitable to the board in that they might go to the urban authority and say "We will lend you £1,000 at 3 per cent."
Comment on this
I gather it would be desirable in a number of cases like that to make, not merely a loan, but what may amount to a grant. Have they any power to do that?
Comment on this
But otherwise? Have they power to give a grant or what would amount to a grant? The Minister suggested that, with the agreement of the Minister for Finance, the Government may waive its claim to get back the money. But what power has the board to waive the getting of the interest from the local authority? It seems to me, as Deputy Costello pointed out, that all you have in Section 16 is power to waive to the advantage of the board. But surely the board itself has no power to go to a local authority and say, "We cannot give you a grant, but, with the consent of the Minister, we can do what is equivalent to giving you a grant, namely, with his consent, seeing the desirable nature of this work, we can waive payment of interest for any number of years, or the payment of the principal for any number of years." They cannot do that, but I gather from the Minister that it is his contention that they could do that.
Comment on this
I see the Deputy's point, and I will have it examined. Although the Minister for Finance has power to waive the payment of interest with the board, it is not clear that the board can waive the payment of interest by the borrowers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
To delete paragraph (e).
The purpose of this amendment is to delete the paragraph which allows the Tourist Board to set up an agency. My purpose in putting it down is that at the present moment many of the tourists who come to this country do so by virtue of the arrangements of a tourist agency of some sort. Those tourist agencies recommend this country to people, whatever town or country they may be in; they urge people to come here. If the tourist board sets up an agency in competition with existing agencies, one of the obvious effects will be to put all the existing agencies' backs up and they will encourage people to go anywhere but to this country. What exactly will be the useful purpose in setting up this agency, I do not know. Most likely it will do very much more harm than good.
Comment on this
The consideration which the Deputy has referred to will undoubtedly deter the board from exercising the power conferred in this paragraph, unless there was very good reason for it. I really think we should give the board this power, even though they may not find it necessary to exercise it. It might happen that the board will become dissatisfied with the existing agencies, the manner in which they are operating, and their general attitude towards this country and the development of its tourist trade. In these circumstances they may find it necessary to undertake the establishment of a new agency. I think the board should have the power, though I agree they would be ill-advised to use it unless there was clear need for it. To delete the paragraph, as the Deputy suggests, would be to deprive them of the power to establish a new agency. We can conceive circumstances in which it would be necessary for them to have that power.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that the Tourist Board, with the finances at its disposal, would be capable of setting up a tourist agency to compete with people like the American Express Company or Cooks?
Comment on this
It might be necessary for the board to assist by way of investment in the establishment of an agency in New York or some other centre from which tourist traffic might be attracted, if they found the existing agency services there were not functioning properly or in a manner completely satisfactory from their point of view. I think they should have power to undertake the establishment of an agency of that kind anywhere if the need for it was there. I would not like to see them deprived of that power. Of course, it is desirable that they should work through existing agencies so long as these agencies are prepared to work for them. I think that is likely to be the case for quite a long time to come, because their interests are the same.
Comment on this
Not necessarily. In addition to the £600,000, there are non-repayable advances up to a maximum of £45,000 a year which can be used for any of the general purposes of the board.
Comment on this
Does the Minister really envisage that the board would enter into business of a tourist agency?
Comment on this
And it could, I suppose, earn a very substantial liability instead of a very substantial profit. What is going to happen then? Who is going to foot the bill?
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce would in the ordinary course examine into the operations of the board in order to see that they would not be likely to run at a loss. Take the Electricity Supply Board as an example. Every now and again they come with proposals to extend the service or to undertake some new development. Time and again we examine into certain of their proposals and tell them that they are likely to be at a loss and, therefore, we could not agree to advance any capital. If a satisfactory case is put up and a proposal is likely to be beneficial, we express our satisfaction and we give the capital required. Our attitude towards this board will be somewhat similar.
Comment on this
Apropos Deputy Benson's remarks, I do not want it to be taken that they will get the £45,000. They can get an annual convention up to a maximum of £45,000, but the actual amount will be determined on the basis of an estimate.
Comment on this
And the actual details of the estimate will have to be approved by the two Ministers concerned?
Comment on this
In a general sort of way we will have to approve the proposals. Again, I will take the Electricity Supply Board as an analogy. In the case of a particular proposal of the board you do not go further than to examine the estimates of revenue that are likely to come in, relate them to the capital expenditure on the basis of a rough and ready system of calculation, and then determine whether or not the result will be profitable. In this particular case the projects that we are likely to get from the board will be more varied in character and they will cover a much wider field than the proposals of the Electricity Supply Board, but at the same time the method of approach to these proposals will be much the same.
Comment on this
As a member of the old Government, I must say that I have been touched in the last couple of months when I remember how near perfection we seemed to have reached in every walk of political life—in the protection of the State, in the prevention of treason and in the conduct of ordinary commercial undertakings. One might say the high mark was reached by us, beyond which one could not go further. I accept all that. I will now ask the Minister to consider the danger of giving power to a board which may only be exercised in exceptional circumstances. If you give power to set up an agency, it is an invitation to do so, and I am only asking the Minister to consider the chances there are of difficulties arising, rather than advantages coming from that principle. Would it not be better, if it was necessary to set up agencies, that the board would go to the Minister and ask him to pass an enabling Bill for that purpose, rather than, practically, inviting them to do so? If you give power the tendency will be to use the power on the part of the board. It is a matter of balancing up conveniences, and I suggest that the easier way would be to delete the section and, if it was found that we were not getting sufficient publicity in the United States, to see if an amending Act could be brought in giving that power.
Comment on this
I am not clear what is meant by "agency," and what Deputy O'Sullivan meant when he criticised this proposal. After all, an agency might consist in having a single representative in, say, New York or San Francisco. Surely it is not proposed to limit the board's power so that they will not be permitted to send a representative to New York with a view to organising, by means of suitable contacts, interest in tours in Ireland. Is it proposed to limit the power of such representatives? Further, I can see that the word "agency" has so wide a meaning that any proposal to take the clause out of the section would nullify a great deal of the obvious work that will be before the board.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider whether under that clause it would be lawful for the board to take part in the establishment of a company as a tourist agency?
Comment on this
A tourist agency then might be a tourist agency in competition with or in substitution for, say, Cook's or the American Express Agency.
Comment on this
There is such a variety of things that might happen it is very difficult to see where to stop. I know that the Government of Egypt voted £50,000 to be spent, I think, through Messrs. Cook or through a subsidiary of Cook's to advertise Egypt in Great Britain. We do not propose to do anything like that, and could not afford anything like that, but that type of development might be necessary in certain circumstances in certain countries, and we would like the board to have the power to do that if they felt that it would be an advantage to do so. As to Deputy O'Sullivan's remarks about complacency on this Bill, I should remind him that the powers he referred to were not provided in the Electricity Supply Act of 1927.
Comment on this
When in Egypt I went up the Nile and I remember getting a pot of jam, which I was told was supplied by the purveyors to His Majesty, the Khedive, and also to Cook's. I was not quite clear which title was the more important. Sometimes more important title is first and sometimes it is last.
Comment on this
I object to the clause in the section which gives power to erect hotels. There are obvious reasons why hotels should not be built generally. While a strong case could be made that it might be essential to have that power, the danger is that the moment it is given it might be exercised. For that reason I do not like power being given to erect hotels when people who are running hotels can be assisted under the Bill. The board is authorised to erect, equip and run hotels, and if they did that they would have it in their power to destroy the vested interests and the livelihood of other people. All through this Bill there is power of inspection and of grading of any hotel in the State. The body with that power can define the general status of any hotel. There is power to erect a hotel anywhere that the board thinks it necessary to do so. My objection to this section is strengthened by the example the Minister gave, as to places where it might be necessary to build hotels. The example about the aerodrome did not convince me. I understand the air base in Clare is only 12 miles from Ennis. Surely it is not suggested, in these days of fast transport and motor-cars that a distance of 12 miles from an aerodrome to a town where there is accommodation, and where there are people with vested interests, and with good hotels, is too far. If the hotels there are not good enough they can be improved by money that is being provided under the Bill. Surely no one suggests that the board would be justified in erecting new hotels in such places.
It would be a dreadful thing if this House gave power to any board to do such a thing, because the money being provided could be used to destroy the property and the means of livelihood of people who own hotels. In addition, perhaps hotels would be erected that would only suit a particular class, the wealthy class, and that their tariff would not permit ordinary persons going into them. The Minister claims that it is necessary for the board to have this power, but there was a sort of half promise that it would not be used. On principle, I do not think that it should be given. I do not think any case has been made for it. This is a small State but we have very big ideas. I hardly know of any place where such a necessity as regards hotels would arise in this State. If the necessity exists there is plenty of initiative to provide hotels. In putting in this section perhaps the Minister thought it wise to have power to ginger up people who would not toe the line. Is there not sufficient gingering power in the Bill already, by means of grading certificates? If hotel owners do not bring their hotels up to a fairly reasonable standard they would be graded accordingly and get no assistance. If a man has valuable property there is the threat that it is in the power of the board to construct a hotel somewhere in the neighbourhood. If I were asked about that power, I would say that they would never do such a thing. But they can do it, and that is the awkward thing. I do not see that we should hand over that man's money to a board which is given the power to put that man out of business with his own money. That is what we are doing in law. Are we right in doing so? Can we guarantee that the power will never be exercised? The Minister may reply, "Before they would do that, I would have them abolished," but the Minister himself might be abolished in the meantime.
Comment on this
I do not like this provision. The Minister may be convinced that it is necessary to have it, but, taking the Bill as a whole, I do not see that it is necessary. All power with regard to the status of hotels is to be in the hands of the board, and I think that is enough, without the threat of putting hoteliers out of business. In principle, I am opposed to it.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with most of what Deputy McMenamin has said, though possibly from a slightly different angle. I do see that there is a certain amount in what the Minister said on Second Reading, that it might be desirable to have a body which would build a hotel, not necessarily for profit, at places like Rhynanna and, particularly, as I understood that most of the flying there will be done by night. The very close proximity of a hotel in these circumstances is, I think, desirable. The point of view, however, from which I oppose this power of the board to build is that the one body should not have power to build and operate a hotel and, at the same time, the power given to them by the Bill to control every other hotel in the country. Every hotel and guest house is to come under the power of the board. They are to be inspected and graded, and yet that same body, according to the Bill, is to have power to build a hotel, not necessarily, admittedly, in competition with any of these hotels, but, at the same time, I do not think the two functions can go together. They cannot be an inspectorial body and, at the same time, an operating body, and if the Minister is convinced that the power is necessary, some different body from this should operate any hotel which, in his view, is necessary, and not this board. This board should confine itself entirely to inspecting and controlling hotels, and they should look at these hotels not as hotel keepers—and this will make them hotel keepers—but from the point of view of the tourist coming to the hotel, possibly late at night, and the facilities he will get. That should be their attitude to every hotel when they come to inspect it and to grade it, but if they are in the business themselves, it is going to be made much more difficult for them to look at these hotels from that point of view. If the Minister wants this power, he should set up some other body and not give it to this board.
Comment on this
On the point raised by Deputy McMenamin, I merely want to repeat what I said on the Second Reading stage, that it is not the intention that the board should enter into competition with private concerns, and I think the powers conferred under Section 16 will be sufficient to ensure that control will be exercised over the board in that matter, if it is necessary to do so. The term "competition" has, of course, different meanings in different circumstances. A hotel in Donegal might be in competition with a hotel in Kerry.
Comment on this
Possibly so, but hotels in widely different parts of the country may be in competition for a particular type of trade, and when I say that it is not the intention of the board to enter into competition with private individuals, what I mean is that the board will, in no circumstances, undertake commercial activities which it can prompt private enterprise to undertake. It will be the normal function of the board to interest itself in the development and expansion of hotels by means of loans and investments and not by building and operating hotels, but there are circumstances, which we can contemplate, in which the board might find it desirable, and even necessary, to proceed on its own. I gave the example of Rhynanna. It is only an example, and, as I made quite clear the other day, my words must not be taken as indicating that there is a definite intention already formed to construct a hotel there. Such a hotel will not be necessary until passenger traffic by air across the Atlantic is developed, but if it is developed and Rhynanna becomes of the importance which we intend and hope, namely, a junction between various air services, it is there, at the airport, that hotel accommodation will be required. Passengers waiting for a service, or staying overnight after a journey, will want the accommodation at the airport, and not at Ennis. They will not go to Ennis, and would prefer to continue their journey by plane to some other point. That, however, was only an illustration. Another which could be given would be the possibility of some locality being developed as a special kind of tourist resort.
Comment on this
Any place. The plan of development might embody hotel accommodation which no private concern was willing to provide, and, in such circumstances, the board might have to do it. There is another type of case which might arise, and it will probably be the type of case in respect of which the board will most frequently have to exercise the power to operate hotels, if it is to do so at all, that is, where it has advanced money on a debenture to a hotel. Because of circumstances, it may have to take over the hotel and operate it, until they can dispose of it to somebody else, or decide what they are going to do with it. It may frequently happen that the board in order to protect its own loans, may have to exercise whatever powers it may get under agreements with borrowers to supervise and actually undertake the management of a concern for a time.
Then, of course, there is another problem which is really a very big problem and one to which the board will have to give immediate consideration, that is, the provision of accommodation, other than hotel accommodation, for the poorer classes of holiday-makers, those who could not afford to pay the cost of any reasonably-sized hotel. As Deputies are aware, the development of holiday camps, holiday resorts, for short-term working-class visitors, has proceeded in other countries. If private enterprise will undertake that development here, well and good. The board will assist and encourage them, but if there is no indication of a development by private enterprise on these lines, or if it finds that it does not pay, the board will have to assist financially or, in certain circumstances, itself undertake the construction and operation of holiday camps of that kind.
Comment on this
They will not, but they will be very close to institutions such as are referred to in this paragraph. I do not want to leave the House under any misapprehension with regard to this particular paragraph. While I think it is desirable that the board should have the power to build and operate hotels, and while I think the possession of these powers will strengthen its general position in relation to private interests and make it easier for it to get its main job done, I would regard it as definitely contrary to the public interest that the board should unnecessarily engage in any business enterprise of this kind. Their main function must be to stimulate private enterprise, and, if they do not succeed in stimulating private enterprise to provide better hotel and other holiday facilities which the country requires, then, they will have failed in their main job and we shall have to reconsider the position again, but the affording of that stimulus to private enterprise is their main function. It will be only when all attempts to secure the development desired through private commercial enterprise fails that they would contemplate exercising the powers conferred by the section.
Comment on this
There is one particular type of enterprise to which the Minister did not refer. I am sure Deputy Moore will agree with me that there are places much more tranquil than the North of Ireland, namely, certain portions of Kerry and Wicklow —Aughavannagh for instance. It would be very desirable to attract a certain type of tourist to these places, precisely because of their quietness and isolation. I do not know how far at the present moment if you rely upon private enterprise alone, there is any hope of development of hotels of that particular type. You may say: "If it will not pay commercially, what good is it?" It is good from several points of view, good advertising for the hotel industry as a whole and good for the country. Tourists would come not only to that hotel but to the country, and they would benefit the country as a whole. That particular type of a hotel may have to be run for a while at a loss. That is the kind of enterprise on the part of the board in building hotels that would be desirable, much more so than the case of Rhynana because people have to be carried three or four miles to hotels at most ports. I do not think the board would enter into any real competition with anybody in cases of that kind. I wonder if the Minister has in mind the development of that particular type of hotel, whether he has in mind catering for every type of tourist, not merely those who are poor but also those who are rich? After all, we are looking on this as a business and, therefore, it may be advisable to cater for that particular type of business which, if it be left to private enterprise, may not be catered for.
On the other hand, let us take the case of a townland in which there are a number of hotels. Let us say that it is not a port. Take the case of Woodford. I believe a predecessor of the Minister in the British Parliament on being asked a question concerning the erection of a pier at Woodford, said that the matter was receiving his full consideration and only then it was disclosed that Woodford was not a seaside place at all. Let us take a place like that and say that there are no proper hotels there. Even so, I take it for granted that in that particular case the board will rely on the other powers it has at its disposal to improve the place and, however inefficient these hotels are, I gather it is the purpose of the Minister that the board will not interfere in the way of building hotels, that in order to prevent what might be a public abuse in the way of undue competition with private enterprise, he is prepared to allow the situation to be dealt with by other means.
There was another point raised by Deputy Benson, namely, the grading of the hotels by the board. If they build hotels themselves they are bound to grade them in the very highest class, otherwise there would be no justification for their existence. There is, however, the danger that whereas these hotels may be very good for a period after they are opened, they may deteriorate. The board would then have an unfair advantage over other hotels and the system would throw doubt on the value of the grading of hotels. You have the difficulty mentioned by Deputy Benson that in some cases the person summoned to appear before the court may also be a member of the court which is to deliver sentence. I think there is a point there that should deserve further consideration from the Minister.
Comment on this
That point will definitely have to be considered if, in the course of time, it is found that the board is going for any reason into the hotel business to any extensive degree. If that should arise, we shall have to consider the matter afresh, but I do not contemplate any development of that kind. I remember when I was in Canada coming across one of these hotels built, not by the Government, but by a Government-owned railway in an area which they wished to develop. They built a very luxurious hotel and induced a number of millionaires to stay in the locality. As a result, after some time, these millionaires began to build residences there and the area was very quickly developed. The hotel never paid and was never intended to pay. It was erected merely to induce development in that particular district. Of course, we have no such vast tracts in this country, but I mention the matter merely as an illustration of the circumstances which might justify the board in undertaking the building of hotels in certain areas.
Comment on this
The Minister apparently thinks that it is better to leave the matter as it is until abuses develop. I think it would be much wiser to remove the possibility of such abuses arising. The Minister mentioned that he anticipated that a number of hotels which would be operated by the board for some time might be sold by the board to try to recoup themselves for money advanced on debentures. I can see no power here which allows the board to sell them.
Comment on this
There is no limitation on the part of the board to purchase or to dispose of the property. I do not know that it is necessary to have any special provisions to cover this point.
Comment on this
Would it not be better in that particular case to lie at the loss of the money that the board has advanced? Here is a case where the board might be anxious to try to save as much as possible out of that particular money. However, they are in competition with other hotels in the same town. Would it not be better to lie at the loss in that case?
Comment on this
If the board has to face the possibility of running that particular hotel indefinitely then it might be far wiser to cut their losses. The place might be going down through bad management and they might consider that under different management it would be a success. For a period they would carry on the concern until they got a new purchaser, but that would not be a long period. They should have power to do that in order to protect their interests.
Section 14, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 15.
Comment on this
There is a limitation of £45,000 on the amount to be advanced to the board under this section?
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce can decide that they will give less?
Comment on this
In practice, the amount will be determined on the basis of a budget. The board will prepare its budget for the year and estimate for its expenditure with regard to these advances, and it will come and get approval of that estimate. If that estimate is approved by the Dáil, the board may be provided to the limit of that advance, but what we are providing here is that, under no circumstances, will the amount exceed that £45,000 in any one year.
Comment on this
But there is no question of general conduct being taken into account here or being under surveillance?
Comment on this
General conduct, yes, but in my opinion, the question of whether or not the board should have made a loan to a particular hotel or a particular body or association for local development would not arise properly here.
Comment on this
Yes, but I want to point out that there is a certain danger there, and I think there are cases in which that matter might properly arise. Roughly speaking, of this £45,000, £20,000 will go for the cost of administration, and therefore, anything that the board does comes before this House for discussion in any detail.
Comment on this
Well, take the case of the Turf Development Board. That is in precisely the same position. There is a provision in the annual Estimate for advances by that board. Of course, we could discuss, and in a few cases we have discussed, some of the matters of that kind relating to that board, but, in practice, we have not done so.
Comment on this
Yes, but I suggest that we are very much more likely to have that kind of thing in connection with this matter.
Comment on this
I think it might be better to have some other method of providing the money here, because once the matter is discussed here in the House a great deal of the utility of the board in such cases will be nullified or, at least, hampered. If the board feels that anything it may do, as a business concern, or that its conduct generally, is liable, as it may be, to be the subject of detailed discussion, or even general discussion, in this House, the board will tend to behave as a Civil Service department and think less of developing as a business than of just carrying on. That is the danger that I foresee.
Comment on this
Yes, that is true, but I do not think there is any alternative. I think that our law and Constitution provide that moneys of that kind must be voted by the Dáil.
Comment on this
This section provides for advances to the board out of the Central Fund and for the repayment of such sums, with interest, as provided by later provisions of the Act, by the board to the Minister; but so far as I can see there is nothing in the Bill about the repayment to the board of this £600,000, or whether part of it may be advanced to hotel keepers or whatever other bodies the money may be advanced to, nor, it seems to me, is there any direction as to what the board will do with the money when it is repaid to them. Will they treat it as a capital fund, or in what way will they treat it? It seems to me that all these sections need overhauling in order to make these things clear. Surely, if the board receives a maximum of £600,000, and if it makes advances to certain bodies, any of the money that is repaid to the board should be put to capital account and not to revenue account. So far as I can see, however, there is nothing to prevent the board adding such repayments to their annual revenue.
Comment on this
I shall look into that matter, but so far as advances made by the board to hotel-keepers and other bodies of that kind are concerned, the provision for the repayment of these advances, and the manner in which they shall be repaid, will be determined by the agreement which the board will make with these people prior to making the advance. The board will make whatever terms it can or whatever terms it desires, and it will get these terms agreed to before advancing the money. Sub-section (3) of this section provides that sums advanced to the board shall be repayable with interest, and I should imagine that an arrangement would be made with the board for the establishment of some account which would be periodically cleared for the benefit of the Exchequer or for wiping out the board's liability for these advances. You have a similar thing in connection with the Electricity Supply Board. They have not repaid the capital, so far; in theory, it is being used for that purpose, but in practice it is being used for the purpose of financing fresh capital commitments.
Comment on this
Yes, but I do not think the same thing can be done here, because you are limited here.
Comment on this
If the Minister for Finance gives £600,000, he cannot give any more, and if a loan is given by the board to, let us say, a local authority, and that loan is paid back to the board, I presume that must be given back to the Exchequer?
Comment on this
No; not without fresh legislation. Of course if this thing should be developed, it is quite possible that, in some future years, another Minister may produce a Bill to amend this Bill by increasing that amount of £600,000, just as we have had to do in the case of half-a-dozen other Acts in connection with electricity supply, telephone and telegraph services. Each of these Acts fixed a maximum limit to the advances that could be made—whether for electricity, or telephone or telegraph service, or whatever the service might be—and that limit cannot be changed without fresh legislation; the idea being that the State must determine whether or not it will invest more money in the enterprise concerned. I do not suppose that we will get to the point of wanting to increase the amount concerned in this Bill for quite a considerable time to come, but the point might arise at some future time.
Comment on this
I suggest that, as the section stands at the moment, the board can get that £600,000 right off if they can produce schemes to justify it?
Comment on this
And there is no provision with regard to the repayment of advances to the board. Of course, they have to repay a certain amount to the board, but supposing that a surplus comes in, has that to be handed into the Exchequer? If they drew the £600,000 at once, I presume they are finished as regards drawing from the Exchequer, but if the repayments are greater than the amount they drew, or at a greater rate than the Minister anticipated, as they might easily be, what would be the position there?
Comment on this
If they got a repayment of capital in respect of which they had a liability to the Exchequer they could not lose that sum.
Comment on this
I do not think it is necessary to have it provided here. The question of the manner of the repayment will be between the board and the people to whom the advances are made.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15, standing in the name of Deputy Fionán Lynch:
In sub-section (1), line 59, to delete the words "fishing rights."
We put down this and the following amendment to delete the words "fishing rights" and "sporting rights."
Comment on this
Yes, but the purpose of the amendments is to remove the words "fishing rights" and "sporting rights" from the places or things that the word "land" may include under this Bill. As far as sporting rights are concerned I think the same argument would apply as for fishing rights. There is a general feeling of unrest amongst sporting people at the inclusion of sporting rights in this Bill. Sporting rights are generally associated with shooting rights. They constitute a very technical industry, if I may put it that way, and it is thought that they should not be brought within the ambit of a Bill of this type. We do not say that the State ought not, at some time, to take control of shooting rights. What applies to fishing might be done under a properly constituted board or department in the case of shooting and some good might come of it but that is another question. I believe that is in the offing. The possibility of doing something in connection with shooting rights has, I understand, been considered by various Ministries but we do not think that shooting rights should be brought within the framework of this Bill because it may lead to abuse. We do not know what the composition of the board will be, nor does the Minister at present know that. It is obvious that the majority of the board will be chosen because of their capacity to advance the tourist trade—to entice people from other countries to come here for their holidays and to entice people from one part of the country to go to another part of the country for their holidays. We do not think that the facilities offered to visitors should include the right of free shooting. If shooting is to be properly developed it must be properly protected and it would be necessary to put a great deal of effort into it in order to develop it properly. Something must eventually be done to put our shooting rights on a par with those of other countries but the board which it is proposed to set up under this Bill should not be given power compulsorily to acquire shooting rights. The Minister may say that there is no intention of doing that. We are sick of assurances like that from every Minister. It has been my experience in this House that most of the things which we were assured could not happen under legislation did happen. I do not want to see the board in this case come in and compulsorily acquire shooting rights for the purpose of offering them to tourists from other countries. Let these people by all means come in and take advantage of what nature supplies in the way of sport. We are all heartily glad to see them do so but, where private enterprise is attempting to develop shooting, the board should not be at liberty compulsorily to interfere. The same applies to fishing. That is, in part, covered by a Bill which is passing through the House but shooting rights are not covered by any such Bill and I do not think that there is any proposal to bring in legislation to cover them. People who approached me objected to the inclusion of sporting rights in this Bill.
Comment on this
I join with Deputy Bennett in opposing the inclusion of fishing rights and sporting rights in Section 19. I wonder if the Minister considered the general position with regard to these two items. As Deputy Bennett said, there is a Bill at present going through the House—we finished the Committee Stage only last week —dealing with fisheries. We had an undertaking that a Bill to consolidate the law would come afterwards. That is as regards fishing. As regards sporting rights other than fishing, we may take it that they are divided between the Minister for Lands, on the one hand, and private ownership, on the other hand. Here we are going to insert a power to take these rights compulsorily. I admit at once that, if you are going to do this at all, it would be useless to attempt it without compulsory powers but, in my opinion, the Bill should not touch this matter. Anybody who has been reared up with this question knows that, so far as visitors are concerned, no problem arises.
The question of partridge and pheasant shooting has, in this connection, no significance at all. You have grouse, snipe and woodcock to deal with. These are the three things that come under the heading of "sporting rights." Your sporting rights are, in the main, in the hands of small farmers. On an average, throughout the entire country, the moorland adjoining the tillage area would be about 50 acres. If the Government were to put up a capital sum of between £50,000 and £100,000 for the destruction of vermin, I should give the proposal my enthusiastic support. I should be much more impressed by that than by the proposal to give this board these powers. If these two things are to be put into the definition, the section would require to be redrafted. If you are to give these rights, it is vital that we should impose duties on the board, because if we do not impose duties on them, the last position will be worse than the first. They can, for the purpose of some hotel, compulsorily acquire sporting rights in an adjoining district. They can turn out a number of guns on the 12th August. A number of young people may come to the country for sport and some of them may never have shot a grouse over dogs. For the first two days, or, perhaps, for the whole time, they do not catch on to the covering of a bird rising before a dog. All the birds on the moor are wounded and, in that way, destroyed for breeding purposes although one of them may not be instantly killed. A number of them may die subsequently.
Comment on this
I know more about this than the Minister does. I have wasted some ammunition myself. I have seen hundreds of rounds of ammunition wasted in one day and not one bird coming down. A week afterwards you would get the birds lying dead. Nobody in this House can give an instance of where any trouble has arisen with regard to these small farmers accommodating the owner of a hotel and affording sporting and shoots facilities to the visitors to the hotel. The owner of the hotel enters into contracts with the small farmers as to what he will pay per head or per brace for the grouse.
There may be cases where large tracts of country are a sort of common waste and in the winter time it would be useful to have them for rough shooting, such as snipe shooting, but, in the main, my experience of it is that no question arises. If there is a hotel in the district the owner goes around and says to the farmers in that area that he will take these tracts for snipe shooting in the winter for his visitors. There is no trouble about that at all. My experience is that these small farmers get far better terms if they are left in the hands of the hotel proprietor.
Unless very rigid duties are imposed on the board with regard to the preserving of game they may well destroy these things for the small farmer who is now getting a reasonably good price —10/- to 14/- a brace. Fourteen shillings a brace is a very good price. During the winter the farmer would look after the destruction of sparrow-hawks, magpies, scaldcrows and whitebacks. The small farmer would do all that. It would not cost anybody anything. Unless those duties are imposed there is no use in giving the board this power. The moors of this country from north to south are infested with scaldcrows and whitebacks. There is general destruction by sparrow-hawks. It is calculated that a scaldcrow would destroy 300 grouse in one season. The number of scaldcrows in the country is beyond counting. Therefore, the destruction done by vermin in this country is enormous. At the same time, this Bill is introduced under which power is given to the board to take shooting and fishing rights.
I would rather see £100,000 of this money allocated to the destruction of vermin. That is one of the very first things you must do because there are going to be no visitors if there is no game or fishing. All our moors and shoots are destroyed with vermin. Nothing is done to put it down. If the Minister insists upon retaining that power I would suggest that he should impose conditions. I well appreciate that it would have to be left to the discretion of the board in the matter of sending a man over a particular shoot from the 1st to the 12th August and getting an approximate calculation of the number of birds on it and then to permit only a limited number to be shot off, leaving for the next season sufficient to stock it for the following season. In that matter you would have to rely on the discretion and judgment of the men or man that the board would send to do that. Over and above all that, the most important question with regard to sporting rights, as distinct from fishing rights—which was well looked after—is to put up a sum of money to destroy vermin throughout the country. The Land Commission are now taking over, in the main, all the monntains, either for the general purposes of the Land Acts or for afforestation. Whatever protection the old landlords gave through the gamekeepers is practically all gone. There is no destruction now of vermin. Neither the Land Commission nor the Forestry Department are destroying vermin. We have a Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, and they are doing nothing.
I think the question of fishing rights and sporting rights should be entirely excluded from this section and should be dealt with in some other Bill or in the consolidating Bill referred to by the Minister in the Second Reading of the Fisheries Bill, which has passed through the House. There is a Department of Agriculture, a Department of Lands, the Tourist Traffic Board and private individuals all interested in this matter. Between all these stools the sporting rights are going to come to the ground. There is not a hope on earth for them.
Under the Ashbourne Act, the Wyndham Act, the Birrell Act, fishing and sporting rights were given to the tenantry. These were not given to them under the 1923 Act. In townlands of eight or twelve holdings some of the tenants hold under the Ashbourne Act, some under the Wyndham Act and others under the 1923 Act. The position in regard to sporting rights of those 12 tenants may be different. There can be nothing but chaos in such a situation. This matter should be taken up in some Bill, such as a Consolidating Bill in respect of the game laws and sporting rights, such as the Minister referred to in connection with the fishing rights. I do not like this section in the present Bill. I think it will only add further chaos to the present position of sporting rights in this country. In its present form it will not get us anywhere. If it is thought wise to insist upon putting it in this Bill I think it should be entirely redrafted. In that matter, any assistance I can give will be gladly given. I was called in on an occasion when this matter was being discussed by men who should have known this question very well. I was certainly not impressed by them. They had ideas about it, but everyone had a sectional idea of it. There should be a national idea in this matter. I say—but I do not mean it in any offensive way— that the sporting rights of landlords are gone, in the main. An entirely new condition of affairs has been created. The State that brought about that position has not done anything to look after the valuable national asset of which they took possession. Nothing whatever has been done. The Government has not paid for the destruction of one scaldcrow, one magpie and one whiteback. They took over this valuable national asset. In the general hurry, and as part of the political hysteria to get land and to get that land divided, this important asset was overlooked.
That is the position to-day with regard to sporting rights. You are proposing to confer on a body power to take over those sporting rights. In the main, they have nothing to take. You have got to start building them up, and that is going to be a bit of a problem. Irreparable damage has been done by vermin. That has been intensified by the afforestation scheme in places where forests are being planted in the middle of moors. These new forests are going to be a regular breeding ground for vermin. On the estimate of his Department each year. I have asked the Minister for Lands if he was going to have that matter attended to. I could never get an answer from him. He simply passed over my question when replying, and has never told me whether his Department was attending to the matter or not. So far as I know, the Department has not destroyed one head of vermin in these new forests. In view of that, we are simply wasting our time here arguing about this. We are wasting the taxpayer's money as well —the £600,000 and the £45,000 annually. We are voting that money with the object of attracting tourists. You can attract them all right, but if they come once, will they come again if they find that there is nothing for them to get?
Visitors are not going to come here simply for the purpose of seeing us. We are not better looking than any other race. I suppose we are not any worse looking either, but if we want to attract visitors to the country we must give them something more than that. It will not do to give them good hotels or offer them sporting facilities on paper. You must give them these facilities in fact. If a man comes here to fish, he is not going to trouble us again if he finds that there are no fish in our rivers. The same will apply to our shooting rights. If a man takes a "shoot," and puts his dogs over it and finds that there are no game there, he is not going to take that "shoot" again. That is the general position. There are, of course, exceptions. A lot of this trouble was caused by the desperate hurry to acquire and divide land. There was the cry to acquire land, and then a tug-o'-war followed with regard to the division of it. In this tug-o'-war the sporting rights were neglected.
I ask the Minister to delete these sporting and fishing rights from the section. Let the care of both be put in the hands of one Minister. It will be that Minister's duty to come to the House and ask for a substantial sum of money for the destruction of vermin all over this State, because vermin are to be found on land all over the country. They are to be found on George Bennett's hills in Limerick, as they are on the hills of Donegal. I have travelled over the moors in the County Limerick until the sweat poured off me. I have travelled over them with two dogs, and all we saw in two days were six grouse. What is proposed here is ridiculous. I think I have said enough to impress the Minister with the importance of what is at stake so far as this section is concerned.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear that Deputy McMenamin and Deputy Bennett are completely misinformed as to the intentions of the section. I am sorry I cannot promise them that this board is going to reorganise and develop our sporting facilities. Naturally, of course, the board will have an interest in their development. It will assist any organisation that may be concerned in the matter, but it is not going to undertake that work itself. Sub-section (1) of the section says that the word "land" includes "fishing rights, sporting rights and other rights over or in respect of any land or water." These words are put there to make it clear that if the board acquires land it can also acquire any rights that go with the land—"easements, way-leaves, water-rights, fishing rights"—and so on. We want to make it clear that the board can do that. We have the compulsory acquisition clause as well.
Comment on this
I am not saying that the board wants rights at all. What I have said is that if they acquire land they can acquire whatever rights go with the land. In the ordinary course, the board will acquire any land or rights which they want by negotiation and purchase. Experience, however, over a number of years has taught us that State organisation of this kind cannot acquire by voluntary agreement, by negotiation and purchase, on fair terms, property of any kind unless they have compulsory powers in the background which they can use. In practice, these compulsory powers are not availed of except in exceptional circumstances. There may be cases like the Shannon works or some other big undertaking in respect of which the use of compulsory powers would be essential, but, generally speaking, one may say that quite a number of Acts which contain a similar section to this are operated without recourse to the section, because the mere existence of these compulsory powers puts the board or organisation concerned in a position to bargain on fair terms. In the great majority of cases the bargain is concluded on the basis of a voluntary arrangement without recourse to the elaborate procedure laid down for compulsory acquisition.
The only point that arises on this section is whether we should give the board power to use these compulsory powers of their own volition. I have been considering that point since we discussed the Bill on Second Reading, and have come to the conclusion that it is undesirable that the board should have these compulsory powers and should be able to exercise them without reference to anybody. On the next Stage, I propose to introduce a provision requiring them to get the consent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce before they can use these compulsory powers. Deputies understand that the board can purchase property by negotiation voluntarily if they wish in connection with any approved project on which they may be engaged, but if they propose to use these compulsory powers I intend proposing that they will have to get the prior consent of the Minister before doing so. Again, I want to point out that I am doing that not because I think the judgment of the Minister is likely to be better than that of the board, but because he is a public officer and, therefore, must account for his conduct. In that way, the Dáil can question the giving of his assent.
What I want to make clear is that the section does not mean that we are going to set out upon a general acquisition of sporting rights all over the country—that we are going to reserve sporting rights for tourists, or do anything else with those sporting rights. We are not even undertaking to do what Deputy McMenamin wants done, that is to finance the development or improvement of those sporting rights. Another Department of Government may undertake that. Private associations and organisations already established for that purpose may be assisted by the Tourist Board to that end, but the board itself is not proposing to do so. If it acquires fishing or sporting rights, it will acquire them merely in connection with land acquired by it for some specific purpose.
Comment on this
We will amend the section by ensuring that the use of those compulsory powers will require prior Ministerial sanction.
Comment on this
There is one point on which I was not quite clear from listening to the Minister. Will the board acquire sporting and fishing rights where the land to which those sporting and fishing rights are attached are not taken over?
Comment on this
It can do something like the following: The board will acquire land, for instance, for the building of a hotel. It will naturally acquire the fishing rights so far as all the land it gets is concerned, but it can also compulsorily acquire fishing rights in the neighbourhood, even though those rights attach to land which it does not take over?
Comment on this
It is not the intention that they should do so, except to this extent: in regard to fishing rights or other rights which they might desire to purchase, and which they found themselves in a difficulty about obtaining at a reasonable price, it might be necessary to use compulsory powers. Except to the extent that the use of compulsory powers is necessary in order to ensure that there will be a fair deal, I think they should not be used at all to acquire those rights, certainly not where those rights have been developed by their present proprietor. There will be cases, of course, where it might be held by everybody that the sporting rights or fishing rights in a particular area should be acquired by the board or somebody else for the purpose of development, and there will be no real opposition to it except on the part of some crank or other who is himself doing nothing about it, but who might refuse to sell, and against whom compulsory powers might have to be utilised. But where those rights have been developed by the present proprietor, where they were being looked after and good use made of them, I would be opposed to giving the board powers of compulsory acquisition at all. Certainly, I would prevent them from using those powers of compulsory acquisition other than in very exceptional circumstances. In the ordinary course, when they want rights of that kind they should go out and negotiate for them, and buy at fair value. The only case where compulsory powers might be used would be where fair value could not otherwise be obtained.
Comment on this
This section has been read to mean that we are proposing that the board should embark upon a campaign of acquiring sporting rights all over the place, and following some development plan in relation to them. It is not intended that the board should do that.
Comment on this
It is not a question of intention. It is a question of the legal power we are conferring on them.
Comment on this
We are conferring on the board legal power to acquire all those rights. In order to ensure that there will be no misunderstanding or difficulty in giving effect to what I have now said, I am proposing to amend the section so that Ministerial sanction will be required before those compulsory powers can be utilised. I think that will meet the point, having regard to the intention to which I have given expression.
Comment on this
The Minister's last reference to the restrictions he is going to put on compulsory acquisition will apply more to a subsequent amendment than to this particular one. The Minister has lost the point that perhaps Deputy McMenamin, in his enthusiasm for sporting development, has gone outside what was intended by the amendment. I do not at all propose that the board should undertake the development of shooting rights in this country. I say that there is necessity for the preservation of those rights, and their proper development as an asset to this country. I do not at all say that the present board should do that. I believe they are the last body to which that should be entrusted.
Comment on this
The second last, if you like to put it that way. I do believe that some time soon—the Minister rather hinted that some Government Department might help—we must have a development of shooting rights. Before that happens, I do not want the Tourist Board or any other board to acquire tracts of land that might be made a valuable asset to this country under proper development. I do not think it is desirable that they should get compulsory powers of acquisition of such land. It might be necessary that those powers should eventually be given to somebody, but certainly not to this board.
Comment on this
What I am proposing now is that we will ensure that the board cannot use those compulsory powers except in accordance with public policy. Public policy for the development of fishing, for example, is laid down in the Fishing Bill which was before the Dáil recently. Similar legislation in regard to other sporting facilities and rights may come at some stage, and this board will not act contrary to whatever may be determined as in the general national interest. In order to ensure that, we will keep Ministerial control over the exercise of those powers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (2), page 8, line 7, after the word "Section" to add the following words "provided always that the board shall not compulsorily acquire any land greater in extent than one rood in any townland."
This, Sir, is a still more important amendment. It covers the whole question of the acquisition of land. Outside of any argument which we have put forward in regard to shooting rights, we must protest against this particular section as it stands. The board may acquire practically any land that they desire in the country. They may interfere with the rights of numerous private citizens. They may take land contiguous to a town, land of great value for building sites or anything else you like. In the last amendment I was concerned only with the words "sporting rights"; this amendment covers the whole question of the acquisition of land. The board may acquire land from any individual in any place in this State. There is only one exception. There was one particular board here which could acquire land, and that was the Land Commission. It was the only body which could take land compulsorily.
Comment on this
They were the one big body. This new grabbing body may not grab land from the Land Commission. They can grab it from anybody else.
Comment on this
Under a sub-section of this Bill the Land Commission are protected from the grabbing propensities of this particular body, but any other individual can and perhaps will have his land acquired. I say "perhaps." The Minister may mark the word. I do not say it is very probable, but perhaps they can acquire land anywhere, including land belonging to any member of this House. Practically no rights are given to the individual. There is no right of appeal if they propose to take such, land. The board, mind you, having acquired your land, may, if they wish, institute an inquiry. The people who seized land compulsorily may institute an inquiry, and the composition of the inquiry itself is rather vague. The Minister should appoint a fit and proper person, and such person is authorised to do various things, and it is not said to whom he is to report, or what the finality of his decision is going to be.