Finance Bill, 1939—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–114 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1939 ›
In moving the Second Reading of the Finance Bill, I must at the outset express my regret at the necessity for circulating a revised print of the Bill, occasioned by the fact that three typographical errors crept into the text in the course of printing. The errors in question occurred in sub-section (2) (a) of Section 2 (where the word "eight" appeared in line 8 instead of the word "three") and in Section 7 (where the word "of" appeared at the end of line 17 instead of the word "by", and the word "or" after the word "land" in line 18 instead of the word "of").
Apart from these corrections the revised text of the Bill is identical with that originally circulated. Most of the matter contained in the Finance Bill has already been before the House in the form of the Financial Resolutions. As the provisions of these Resolutions have been explained to Deputies, and as a further opportunity will be afforded on the Committee Stage of the Bill of obtaining additional information, should it be required, it is scarcely necessary that I should occupy the time of the House with a recapitulation of what they purport to do. Accordingly, I propose to confine myself to a short explanation of the provisions contained in the Bill other than those covered by the Resolutions.
In Part I of the Bill, which relates to income-tax and surtax, the sections which have not been included in the Financial Resolutions are 4, 5, 6 and 7.
Section 4 provides that the allowance in respect of earned income shall be one-fifth of the income and that the total amount of the allowance shall not exceed £300. This provision is, of course, a complementary element in the whole scheme for the revision of income-tax and surtax and is an essential part thereof.
Section 5 of the Bill brings up to date the exemption given by Section 3 of the Finance Act of 1931 in respect of certain profits derived from the Sweepstakes. At the time that section was passed all the surplus from the Sweepstakes went to the hospitals organising the Sweep, but, as is known, the position following the Public Hospitals Acts, 1933 and 1938 is that all surpluses are now payable to the Hospitals Trust Board. Without the amendment of the law which it is proposed to make by this section, the strictly legal position would be that the Sweepstake surpluses would be chargeable to income-tax in the hands of the organisers of a sweepstake or the Sweepstakes Committee appointed by them. As we already secure a stamp duty of 25 per cent. of such surpluses, it is as well to make it clear that these surpluses are exempt from income-tax.
Section 6 provides for an exemption from income-tax in respect of the one year beginning on the 6th April, 1937, on allowances payable under Section 3 of the Army Pensions Act, 1937, to relatives of the signatories of the 1916 Proclamation.
Section 7 alters the method of assessment of certain profits derived from stallion fees from Schedule D to Schedule B of the income-tax laws for the reasons I have already given in the Budget statement.
Part II of the Bill relates to customs and excise, and the new sections not contained in the Financial Resolutions are 12, 14, 15 and 17. Section 12, sub-section (a) exempts from duty under the conditions set forth in the section such films as are imported by societies formed mainly for the study of film technique and not conducted for profit. Sub-section (b) of that section exempts from duty films not exceeding seven-tenths of an inch in width which have been processed abroad by the reversion process, but which consist solely of pictures taken here, and which, having been exported for processing, are reimported.
Section 14, as will be seen from the marginal note, contains various amendments of the Customs Acts. Sub-section (1) abrogates the prohibition on the importation of essences, extracts, or other concentrations of coffee or chicory contained in Section 42 of the Customs Consolidation Act, 1876, and is rendered necessary by the imposition of a duty on extracts, essences, etc. contained in Reference No. 15 of the First Schedule to this Bill. Sub-section (2) exempts from customs entry duty entries for reimported goods in respect of which a bill of store has been issued. The object of the sub-section is to give the same concession to entries for certain reimported goods, chiefly goods which are manufactured here as is given in Section 8 of the Finance (Agreement with United Kingdom) Act, of last year to United Kingdom or Canadian goods. Sub-section (3) is merely a drafting amendment to substitute "13" for "12" in a reference in Section 12, of the Finance Act, 1934.
Sub-section 4 is intended to remove doubts regarding the rate of duty to be applied under Section 15 of the Finance (Agreement with United Kingdom) Act, 1938. That section gave legal effect to Article 7 of the Trade Agreement with the United Kingdom, which provides, inter alia, that where licences are issued for the admission of dutiable goods into Eire, either free of duty or at a reduced rate, and where United Kingdom goods are available then goods not produced within the British Commonwealth of Nations shall be subject to a rate of duty not less than 10 per cent. ad valorem. Doubt has been raised as to whether there is legal power to apply a particular rate calculated on an ad valorem basis to goods ordinarily liable to a specific rate of duty, and this sub-section removes the doubt. Sub-section (5) redrafts sub-section (6) of Section 15 of the Finance Act, 1938, for purposes of classification. It relates to the definition of an article manufactured in a particular country by reference to the labour content in the article. Sub-section (6) is merely a drafting amendment to substitute the correct title—the “Revenue Act, 1909”—for the incorrect reference—the “Finance Act, 1909,” in Section 24 (4) of the Finance Act of 1938. Section 15 makes provision for the importation under licence without payment of duty of certain classes of dutiable goods in respect of which no licensing powers exist at present. The classes affected are set out in the Fourth Schedule.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give any indication why power is being taken to issue licences without payment of duties?
Comment on this
The duties affected by Section 15 are of a protective nature, and experience in the administration of them has shown that a licensing provision is desirable either to alleviate cases of hardship or to facilitate importation of articles where such importation would not conflict with the protective nature of the duty. As the Deputy understands, a licensing provision has been a feature of these proposals and was omitted for one reason or other, but experience has shown, as in the case of other articles, that it would be desirable to have a licensing provision attached to these tariffs also.
Comment on this
Does that mean that the two Ministers may, in fact, license the importation of any article?
Comment on this
I am not in a position to say that. If the Deputy would like a little more information perhaps I could give an example.
Comment on this
Yes. It can be taken by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Section 17 is designed for the setting up of machinery which, we hope, will be more effective in preventing abnormally large clearances from revenue control of imported goods, and also prohibiting excessive deliveries of goods which are liable to excise duty, whenever such excessive clearances or deliveries appear unreasonable for the ordinary requirements of trade. The main use of the provision will be for the purpose of preventing forestalling in anticipation of an expected imposition of customs duty or an expected increase in the rate of a customs or excise duty.
Part III of the Bill relates to death duties and Section 18 (1) raises from £25 to £52 the initial limit for exemption from estate duty in respect of an insurance annuity payable to the widow or beneficiary of a deceased person. The present limit of £25 was fixed in 1894 and is considered too low. This section will give relief in a number of necessitous cases. Section 18 (2) also gives a measure of relief in a case where the first annuity contracted by a deceased person for the benefit of any one person does not exceed £104 per annum.
Part IV is Miscellaneous and General. Section 19 provides for the transfer of £150,000 from the Road Fund to the Exchequer, a matter to which I adverted in my Budget statement. Section 20 repeals to a limited extent enactments set out in the Sixth Schedule. Section 12 of the Licensing (Ireland) Act, 1833, and Section 22 of the Intoxicating Liquor (General) Act, 1924, relate to fees to be paid by publicans and clubs. As these have been superseded by recent District Court Fees Orders their repeal is necessary.
The repeal of Section 15 of the Finance (No. 2) Act of 1915, and Section 19 of the Finance Act of 1919, is a necessary consequence of the extended powers to refuse delivery of goods which it is proposed to take under Section 17 of this Bill. Section 3 (1) of the Finance Act of 1932 relates to income-tax allowances in respect of earned income, and its repeal is necessary owing to the new allowance provided for in Section 4 of this Bill.
Sections 21 and 22 are the usual sections relating to the care and management of the taxes and duties, as well as the Short Title, construction and commencement.
Comment on this
This Finance Bill appears to be one which is going to create a record in more regards than one. I think the House will be interested to learn, at an early date, whether, in fact, the Chair will determine that this is not a Money Bill at all, because it would appear that the terms of Section 17 clearly take it out of the scope of the rulings relating to Money Bills, and convert it into an ordinary piece of legislation to which the Seanad has the right to make amendments and to which the Seanad has the right to take exception. That is a matter which will be gone into in greater detail hereafter, and perhaps the Minister, when concluding this debate, may care to submit his views on that question, prior to the Chair reaching a final determination as to the character of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy should understand that neither the Minister nor the Deputy has any right to make representations to the Chair in that matter. The responsibility of deciding what is a Money Bill rests with the Chair, and the House is informed of the Chair's decision to issue his certificate only when all stages of the Bill in the Dáil have been completed.
Comment on this
Quite so, but it is surely proper for the House to take every precaution to ensure that a Bill is not presented to you which would impose upon you the necessity of ruling that it is not a Money Bill? While no one suggests that your judgment should be influenced by anything here said, surely it is right, when dealing with a wholly irresponsible Minister like that, to warn him of the pitfalls which lie ahead of him, and guide his steps so that he may be able to protect himself.
Comment on this
The Budget statement has been made and this Bill is the instrument whereby the policy laid down in that statement is to be carried into effect. The Budget statement was remarkable in many ways, first, as the statement of a man who had learned by bitter experience some things he did not know when he first became Minister for Finance in this State, and it ended with a paragraph which I do not think has attracted sufficient public attention, but which I believe deserves very careful perusal by everybody who is concerned with the future of this country. In column 1999, volume 75, No. 16 of the Parliamentary Debates, the Minister is reported as saying:
"Stringent and straitened as our position is, I believe that we can endure it so long as peace is maintained. If a widespread war comes, however, our difficulties will be intensified beyond measure. I speak now only of the reaction of such a disaster upon our finances. But there I know that with a much diminished real income, we shall be called upon to shoulder vastly increased public burdens. Moreover, the problem in that regard will be aggravated by the fact that existing sources of revenue will rapidly dry up. The stamp duties are a case in point. And it will no longer be possible to get so large a part of our requirement by customs duties upon imported goods, for we may take it that our imports will be drastically cut down. We shall have to tax what we can and where we can. Taxes upon home-produced commodities will, I feel, be greatly increased; as will the standard rates of income-tax and surtax; while all the allowances which at present mitigate the full impact of these latter upon the taxpayer will be drastically reduced."
That is the statement, at the end of seven years of Fianna Fáil control of our finances, and that statement may be fairly paraphrased in this way: There is impending a danger to Ireland which our Government have no power whatever to control. If that danger should eventuate, we are irretrievably ruined. We have laid nothing by; we have no nest-egg for a rainy day; we are barely living from hand to mouth. If the fortuitous results of a third party's act, over which we have no control at all, eventuate, we are faced with immediate ruin.
Now, I ask the House to compare that attitude, at the end of seven years of Fianna Fáil administration, with the attitude of the same Minister at the end of ten years of Mr. Cosgrave's administration. At the end of ten years of Mr. Cosgrave's administration the present Minister for Finance embarked upon an economic war which, he admitted, was going to put an unprecedented strain on the resources of our people. But he was able to come into this House and say: "Revenue is buoyant, money is circulating freely; everything looks well, and nobody is suffering unduly." That was his story, and it was true, that during the first four years of that disastrous struggle, when the people of this country were losing immense sums of money, the revenue actually was rising. Ample resources were spoken of by the Minister. Where were those resources? Where did he get them? He got them from the reserves that were built up by his predecessor. Although his predecessor began with nothing except a civil war, which imposed immense expenditure upon the Exchequer, his predecessor handed over the country to him with reserves adequate to finance five years of an economic war.
He, at the end of seven years of his administration, offers his country, or to anybody who may succeed him, stringent and straitened circumstances, the danger of which, according to himself, may be intensified beyond measure by the action of certain peoples, and by certain circumstances which we cannot control. Faced by that prospect, the Minister tells us that we may be forced into having to tax what we can and where we can, without regard to whether those taxes hit the rich, the poor, or the middle classes. Is not that a comparison which speaks volumes in regard to the two Administrations? It ought to bring home to the Deputies of this House the lesson, which there is still time for this country to learn, that a responsible Government, in addition to financing the day-to-day requirements of our people, is under a heavy obligation to make provision for reserves against contingencies that they cannot control in the future.
I have said on many occasions that, if the Government continues to pursue the policy it has been pursuing, this country will go bankrupt. I repeat that now. I say that if a country finds itself in a position in which there are no resources left, and if it finds that, by the action of a third party, it can be launched into irretrievable disaster, we are, in effect, bankrupt, because we have not got the reserves that a solvent institution should have. As things are, it seems to me, that if we do survive we only survive by grace of those who spare us the crisis which we ought to be able to meet out of our own resources and reserves without being under any obligation to anybody for sparing us from that test.
According to the Minister's own admission, we are able to continue to-day only on the suffrance of certain Continental countries which keep the peace. If these countries should break the peace, according to the Minister, we must tax where we can and how we can and, in that case, the disaster —which, in his judgment, is irremediable—is upon us, and that what will come upon us then he is not now in a position to foretell. The comparisons between that statement and the statement the Minister was prepared to make at the commencement of the economic war crisis, in the conditions that existed just after Deputy Cosgrave left office, deserve consideraation by those who are learning the elements of finance, and, in that category, I have no hesitation in including the Minister. I have said on many occasions, and Deputies on these benches here have pointed out repeatedly, that the level of taxation in this country was rising steadily and had become intolerable. When that case was made many a person, who felt that the logic of the case was unanswerable, still was constrained to ask: "Where is the money coming from? It is all very well to say that the taxes are too high, but they get the money." The answer is fairly simple. The money was coming from the savings that we had made in the years that went before. The difference between us and Fianna Fáil is that, four years ago, we foresaw that if you went on living on those savings, while you were earning nothing to add to your savings, your reserves one day would come to an end; and, four years ago, we said that if you continue until your reserves come to an end, that will mean bankruptcy—national bankruptcy. Fianna Fáil, on the other hand, said that as long as we have money let us spend it. On the one hand, you had the unpopularity of being conservative, economical, niggardly, as it was called, and, on the other hand, so far as Fianna Fáil was concerned, you had the popularity of being an off-hand spender and a slap-dash dispenser of your neighbours' goods. However, that so-called niggardly, saving, and economical Government handed over a solvent Exchequer to its successor, and that successor—that generous, off-handed, slap-dash Government—offers to its successor a straitened Exchequer which, in the stringent circumstances which now obtain, is constrained to tax where it can and how it can. I say, therefore, Sir, that when the present Minister for Finance must end his Budget speech with the words I have just quoted, the State in which he is a Minister is, in effect, bankrupt.
A great many people in this country forget when they are thinking of the burden of taxation, that, under modern practice, the burden of taxation as borne under the Budget, bears little true relation to the burden of taxation that the people are carrying actually. What we have got to consider, when we are considering the economic condition of the people of this country, is the actual taxable capacity of our people, and not the revenue apparently produced by the Budget taxes. Now, the taxable capacity of our people represents a certain sum which is the limit of what our people can find, and it consists, not only of the taxes raised by the Finance Act, but also of the indirect taxes which the people are called upon to pay—such as the indirect taxes on bread, flour, butter, bacon, petrol. All these are taxed also, and when they have been estimated accurately, or as accurately as they can be, you must then turn to the taxes on such articles as clothes and boots and on the one hundred and one other things which are being produced behind protective tariffs, the extra cost of each one of which constitutes a drain upon the taxable capacity of our people. On the Minister's own admission, in his Budget speech, we have reached a point where the sum of all these impositions has exhausted the taxable capacity of our people, and he says, in effect, that if any untoward event should take place, as a result of action taken by certain other countries, we will have no place to turn to, no nest to raid, and no emergency sources which we can tax temporarily. According to the Minister, in his statement, we are all out now producing the last taxable farthing that can be yielded from our peoples' taxable capacity, and we stand in danger of a crisis also that will require substantial additional expenditure.
Now, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking on the 29th May, 1939—column 262, volume 75, No. 2 Official Debates, said:—
"...I am sure they (Deputies) will agree with me that in the forefront of our immediate plans we must put proposals for the reduction of unemployment; that we must give those proposals priority over proposals for any other purpose—the reduction of unemployment must be our primary objective, getting consideration before any other objective whatever."
Add to that, the problem of housing in the City of Dublin, and add to that the problem of citizens of this city who are living in verminous rooms and who are sleeping in rooms disturbed as, I think, Deputy Tom Kelly said, by vermin falling on to their beds, whose children, as Deputy Tom Kelly described them in this House, are put to bed with clothes tied about thier faces to prevent them being eaten by vermin at night: add to that the inadequacy of our social services to meet the more urgent needs of the married poor about whom the Government Party are quite as solicitous as we are, and ask yourselves, where are we going to get the money to meet their needs?
We have three methods of getting it. We can borrow it; we can save it or we can print it. Can we borrow it? We can borrow it only if we can find someone to lend it. Now, it is important for this House to understand this; that those who have money to lend do not read the speeches that are made in this House. They go to the Revenue Accounts, and they examine the economic state of the country from the official returns. The economic statements, or the economic arguments, advanced in this House weigh little with them. They are skilled financiers, and their job is the examination of national accounts with a view to determining the solvency of any State which seeks money on the public money market. It is true, as was stated before the Banking Commission, that if some silly fool gets up and advocates riot and civil commotion, that may injure the credit of a country, because the prospect of civil commotion always injures the credit of a country, but even a dispassionate examination of the financial state of a country does not influence the judgment of financiers. They make their own decisions. They reach their own conclusions from their own researches. I put it to the Minister for Finance now, that that Budget statement being a true picture of our financial condition, where are we going to borrow for additional purposes when we owe £5,000,000 sterling in floating debt at the present moment which will have to be funded somehow or other pretty soon?
When that transaction is carried through, where can we hope to borrow? Does not the Minister know as well as I know, that when he finds himself in the position that he cannot borrow there will be found those who will want him to print. Does not the Minister know that if we do print the first reaction of printing will be very acceptable to the bulk of the people. It is only when the damage of uncontrolled inflation is well under way that the true consequences of that course of action will be become manifest, and it will then be too late to stop it. To bring any democracy within the reach of the strong temptation to inflate by printing currency is one of the greatest crimes that a Minister for Finance can commit, because he draws them into a temptation the dangers of which are absolutely impossible to explain in theory to the mass of the voting public —the full dangers of which the voting public can never learn except by experience. It would destroy the entire economic fabric of this State and make it impossible for any combination afterwards to re-establish our position. Is it not true that the longer you go on spending more than the national income permits, the harder it is to effect the savings that are necessary to restore stability? Who knows that better than the Minister for Finance? Remember, that saving to restore stability does not necessarily mean doing without many of the desirable things that we have. It may very well mean acquiring more, because one of the most evil aspects of the improvident administration of our national finances is not the waste in itself but the wicked improvidence with which money is spent on unnecessary things, while urgent necessary services remain unprovided for.
I have never hesitated to say in public, as an advocate of economic orthodoxy, that we ought to be able to provide in this country for our people family allowances. I hope I have always had that sense of responsibility to add that it could do no good to any section of the community, recipients or otherwise, if they were not provided out of annual revenue: that to borrow one penny for those services would be to ruin the pretended beneficiary. But I have no hesitation in advocating that, and at the same time advocating expenditure within our national income. We are spending at this minute £2,800,000 on the wheat scheme, £1,000,000 a year on the beet scheme, an indeterminate sum on the alcohol scheme, on the Roscrea meat meal scheme, on the peat scheme and on a hundred and one other futile schemes, including innumerable tariffs which are raising the cost of the people's commodities without any corresponding benefit to the community.
None of these things appears in the Revenue Accounts at all, but all of them are a burden on the taxable capacity of our people. Now, whether you trench upon the taxable capacity of the people in the Budget or outside the Budget, the ultimate results are the same, and all these things, including the tariffs, constitute a burden on the taxable capacity of our people, which, if it was not there, would enable us to get revenue to furnish services which would abolish very great evils: evils so great that they are a menace to the stability of the State, and enable us to institute services which might very easily stimulate the productive capacity of our fundamental industry, and substantially increase the national income as a whole. Instead of being in a vicious circle of increasing expenditure and increasing deficits, if we could only turn the wheel and get into an ascending spiral of increasing public services with increasing national income, we would then be on the right road. But the Minister knows as well as I know that at this moment we are in a descending spiral of diminishing income and an increasing burden. He realises just as vividly as I do that we are getting to the danger point, but in public finance you cannot afford to get to the danger point because if you do no action by democratic politicians will get the country out. Everyone knows that if we reached financial crises such as they had in Newfoundland, we would have civil commotion in this country. If you got civil commotion arising out of an excessive tax burden, the economic fabric of the State could not be maintained, and you would be in the vicious circle at once that while the remedy for the situation was to be found in economy, the civil commotion would demand extra expense.
In endeavouring to restore order you would throw your finance into more wild confusion, until eventually you would be in a state of absolute chaos. Out of that there is no redemption by democratic method, and you are then in the hands of a dictatorship either of an individual in this State, which would be bad, or—what would be infinitely worse—of an outside individual. That would reopen for this country an endless period of ruin and desolation which I am simply horrified to contemplate.
If we can get it the other way, if we can get the national income, the combined produce of our people's profitable production increasing, and deliberately declare that it is our intention to establish in this country a system under which we would not have millionaires on the one hand and paupers on the other, if we deliberately adopt the Irish way of running Ireland and resolve to be all well-off together or all poor together, if we deliberately recognise that the first charge upon the national income is the equation of a minimum standard of comfort for every honest citizen in this State, and a distribution of the remaining balance as a reward for enterprise, I think the Minister could then come before the House with a very formidable tax bill, if he was in a position to say "The national income is rising." I admit that my proposals constitute a certain measure of income distribution. I do not deny that; it is the Irish way, and so long as we can get the national income in the upgrade we have no reason to be afraid of it. I think the Minister would get a hearty welcome. But that is not what is happening. Your productive capacity is going down. You are putting burdens on the people that are reducing many of them to destitution and misery, and you are doing that when the national revenues will not meet the essential services, and when there is the menace of civil commotion, and the problems it represents, not to the Minister for Finance but to the Government and to any Parliament that is sitting in this country.
I do not believe in getting up and preaching panic, but I do not conceal the fact that I am alarmed. I consider that our economic state at the present moment is truly alarming, and I believe the Minister agrees with me, although he does not consider it politic to say so. I want to emphasise again that no useful purpose is served by holding your tongue when you see danger ahead. If we are to have democratic institutions in this country, the right thing to do when you foresee danger is to say so, and to ask the Government to take appropriate measures to avert it. If we once create the impression at home or abroad that when we get scared we run for cover, throw our hands up in despair and say: "Let's be merry while we may, disaster is inevitable," then we sacrifice all right to confidence, and justify those who decry parliamentary institutions. The whole value of Parliament in the counsels of the nation is that those who foresee danger have the right to say so, to give their reasons and to advocate remedies. It is up to Parliament then to determine whether those who sound the note of warning are right or wrong. I submit that every warning we have given to date has been amply justified. The only trouble is that we have seen too far ahead, because in the ranks of our Party we have experienced financial administrators who saw the logical conclusions of the things that were being done. I believe the Minister now agrees with us, though I do not think he did four or five years ago. What is the remedy? The first remedy is to increase the profitable production of our people. A lot of people leave out the word "profitable." They think that, if you can raise production on any terms, you are serving the interests of the State. That is nonsense. Subsidised production in this country, far from being a source of wealth, is a luxury we cannot afford.
Comment on this
I do not want to make sharp replies to the Deputy, and I beg of him not to interrupt me. I am trying to do a difficult thing now, and I beg of him not to interrupt me but to intervene hereafter. If he does interrupt, he will have to excuse me if I give him the rough side of my tongue, as I will, because I will lose my patience. We want to increase profitable production. If we want to increase production that will yield our people profits, we have got to have exports, and we have got to export to the British market. The Minister knows as well as I do that an elementary economic principle is that if you want to make profits on exports you must have cheap raw material. We do not want in agriculture, and we do not want in industry, high prices. What we want is high profits, and that is what a lot of people cannot remember. They think that, if you give a man a high price for something, he ought to be happy. A high price can do more harm to a man than a low price. The essential matter for investigation is not the price but the difference between the price he gets for his finished product and the price of his raw materials and the labour he put into producing it. In this country, we are losing sight of that element altogether. We are riveting every man's attention on the ultimate price, which is of minor importance. The essence of profitable production is the difference between the price of the finished article and the cost of production. The costs of production in this country are very largely the costs of our raw materials.
There are farmers in Armagh who walk into Monaghan town, buy bonhams in Monaghan, take them out to Armagh and feed them on cheap feeding stuffs, then bring them back into Monaghan and sell them at the high price there. The Monaghan farmer buys the same type of bonhams on the same day, feeds them on the dear feeding stuffs, sells them on the same day as the Armagh farmer and gets the same price for them as the Armagh farmer. But the Armagh farmer has made a profit and the Monaghan farmer has made nothing. That is the key to our whole problem, and it does not apply only to agriculture. It applies to industry, too, and for this reason: the fundamental industries in this country, if they are to expand, must export. Guinness exported, Jacob's exported; the linen industry exported, the shipbuilding industry exported, the woollen and textile industry exported, and all those industries grew great because they exported and had a chance of unlimited expansion. There may be some small secondary industries which in my opinion are mere luxuries, social services of, I think, very questionable value, but not worth bothering about. But the fundamental, the main industries upon which the industrial revival in this country ought to be founded, should be industries that have a prospect of acquiring export markets, so that their expansion and their capacity to employ would be limitless, measured only by the competition they encounter abroad and their own enterprise and efficiency. You are absolutely ham stringing those industries if you start them off with a burden of costs on their raw materials. If you do not say to those industries in the beginning "You will be permitted to get raw materials as cheaply as any competitor," you are telling them from the day they start that they must never expand, that when they reach a certain size they stop, and stop for ever. You will never get truly profitable production in this country until you can revive the spirit of Guinness and Jacob to conquer the markets of the world, and remember they did it when there were no tariffs at all.
Comment on this
That they secured the markets of the world when there were no tariffs either here or elsewhere.
Comment on this
That is our position to-day. We have a market for 97 per cent. of our goods in which no tariff will be raised against us. You have a market which you can multiply by two in the morning with a guarantee that you will have no tariff against you. That is the point I am making. We are in the unique position here that we have got a market, unlike one hundred and one other countries which are surrounded and cloistered in by those who will not deal with them; we have a market guaranteed in perpetuity from tariffs and restrictions, with actual invitations to send more than we can supply. That is our unique position. What I want the Minister to do is to let us take advantage of it. It is because we have that position that we can get for our people a higher standard of living than any other agricultural country in the world.
Comment on this
That is irrelevant. What I am trying to point out is that the essence of an expanding industry is that it must export. I point out to the Minister that we are in the unique position in the world that we have a market where we can export and where we can expand our exports; that we can use our influence in the Commonwealth to secure an opportunity for expanded imports all over the Commonwealth.
Comment on this
In ships and linen and stout? Is there a market for these? These are the industries which the Deputy cited.
Comment on this
I assume the Minister is accustomed to listening to a coherent speech. I tried to give certain his torical examples. I explained the nature of an expanding market and its effect upon an industry. The Minister can dismiss that from his mind now, and address his mind exclusively to agriculture and to the new industries we are trying to build up here, in addition to the historical examples to which I have referred. Over and above the old established industries that we knew in the past, we want to add to these industries. I am saying to the Minister that if we are going to have industries we must get fundamental industries to which we can promise an opportunity for expansion. There is no use regarding an industry which is for ever cribbed, cabined and confined within Éire as an industry upon which we can base our industrial development in the years to come. We have secondary small industries to which we will say: "You must content yourself with the home market and you cannot hope to get any more." But the main industries, which ought to be the foundation of the industrial development, should have held before them the right to seek out the markets of the world and to challenge competition anywhere and try and get their share of the world expanding trade.
I agree that economic nationalism made that unthinkable and makes it unthinkable for many countries on the Continent of Europe. But we are in the Commonwealth, and we have a free market in England as a result of the Agreement made with the British Government last year. We can make our voice felt and our influence felt in the Commonwealth. We can be the individual within the Commonwealth which will call to our aid the pronouncements of Mr. Cordell Hull, Secretary of State of the United States of America, and say: "That man admits that economic nationalism is an error; that the United States was responsible for leading the world into it, and he is prepared to help in leading the world out of it." Let us in the Commonwealth show the world an example by freeing trade within our own borders and inviting others to join us in the spreading and freeing of trade the world over. We are not going to do it overnight. We are not going to do it in five years, or a decade perhaps; but we can walk in the right way. If we can do that we increase profitable production.
I do not take this occasion to repeat the arguments so often made for the urgency of making agricultural production pay. It is the only source of wealth we have got. There are hundreds of thousands of acres to-day under crops which are not paying, but which are a burden on the public purse. Every acre of that land which is at present a burden on the public purse could be made a contributing factor. The wheat land, instead of collecting £2,800,000 a year in subsidies, could be made to contribute a substantial sum to the national income, of which part might be properly segregated to help the less fortunate and to establish a standard of living for all our people which would be tolerable. The same can be said of beet and of many another scheme that we have at present. We know of the extravagance which exists in the administration of the State largely from lack of co-ordination, largely from the want of a clear philosophy to guide our financial activities.
I put it to the Minister that we are face to face now with this issue— we must save or perish. These are grave words, but I use them deliberately. I say deliberately that we are in economic danger to-day greater than this State has ever known. I say that to-day the very disaster which those who hated our country loved to prophesy is threatening us. There are many Deputies who care little about the history of the 19th century. But those of us who have good reason to know it well remember how many men staked their reputation on the contention that the Irish people, the people who live on the small farms and in the cottages of Ireland, would choose a better government for Ireland than ever the British House of Commons could. The enemies of Ireland in England and the enemies of Ireland in Ireland always prophesied two things. The first was: "They will tear one another to pieces like Kilkenny cats"—and we very nearly did. But, by the mercy of God, out of that great evil we brought great good. Instead of destroying the State, we demonstrated to the world that a country once torn by civil war could, by the public spirit of its leaders, overcome it. We demonstrated something that no other State in the world has been able to demonstrate since—that the antagonists in a civil war could bury the hatchet and sit down together for the common good, and so we confounded the detractors of Ireland. The other prophesy they made was, that if we did not destroy ourselves in conflict, we would, by our ineptitude, our inexperience and our peasant ignorance, destroy public finance and the British treasury would have to come to our aid. I deliberately say now that that danger is upon us.
Fianna Fáil has four more years of office before it. Nothing would gratify me more than that they should take such steps as now are necessary to ensure that they would leave office at the end of that period with a solvent exchequer, and with a complete answer to that second attempt to traduce our people. All the help they want they will get from the Opposition, but not the help of silence—no conspiracy of silence to pretend that things are other than what they truly are. If they are prepared to face the situation and to grapple with it, they will get all the help they want. If they are not, then unrelenting war to save this country and protect it from a real and insidious menace, and worse than that if we should fail to carry, fail to succeed in this great experiment. I am convinced now that we need not fail, that we ought not to fail and that we should be able to produce in this country an economic life which would be an example to every other country in the world, and a standing rebuke to the industrial horrors of England and the United States of America and many other countries which have given themselves over to black countries and to wide disparities of income that are a disgrace. I believe it would show the world that there is something good in these philosophies of Europe which prefer to be poor altogether, than to have some people hungry and others superfluously rich. I am profoundly convinced that truth will prevail. I should be long sorry to think that it could only prevail in a political system such as is at present in operation in the Totalitarian countries of Europe. I want to see democracy achieve this. I believe our democracy could be and should be the first to do it. If they do the world will follow. I would sooner have the world following Ireland in such a crusade of social justice than to have Ireland following Britannia as a beggar at her gate.
Comment on this
I suppose, under somewhat different circumstances, the Budget that this Bill puts into operation might be called a victory budget. It is, after all, the first opportunity the Minister for Finance has had since the abnormal circumstances brought about by the economic war to frame a Budget after what he and his colleagues have celebrated as the victory won in that particular war. If, as most people and most countries do, we are to regard the annual budgetary statement and the annual Finance Bill of this kind as an index to the conditions of the country, surely we are entitled to ask what have the people, what has the country, what has the State to show in the way of gain, not merely from the policy of the Minister for the last seven years, but as some recompense for the privations that they were asked to suffer when they were asked to wage that economic war to what some Ministers call the final issue—if necessary, the bitter end. If this is the best Budget, if this is the best Finance Bill he can produce—the Minister having won, as he proclaimed, that particular victory —what prospect is there for the future? Undoubtedly that is something that has perturbed the minds of many people. There were occasions when I felt that, possibly, there was a deal to be said for the view that there was more than even the policy of the Government responsible for bringing about a state so lamentable as revealed by the present Budget that, so to speak, the economic curve was going against us, going against the principal source of our economic life and that there would be very little chance, even with a change of Government policy, of remedying this situation. If that were so, I think the outlook would be black indeed, but if it were so, all the greater the responsibility of the Government for avoiding any measure or any policy that would further depress the country. When I heard the Minister's statement I said, when speaking on the Budget, that I did gather an element of hope from it because I felt that there was some evidence, possibly for the first time, that at least some members of the Government were waking up to the situation this country has really to face. If that were so, and if we could be assured that, within the next three or four years of the Government's lease of life, of which they so constantly remind us, something would be done in accordance with the new light breaking in upon them, then something might be gained—if we got some assurance that the Government was ready to face that very heavy task that will face any Government, either Fianna Fáil or any other entrusted with the welfare and control in the coming years. If, as I say, the Government could wake up to that responsibility, then at least I should have some ground for hope so far as the future is concerned. "The victory Budget!" Did not the country expect, and was it not justified in expecting as a result of the Agreement so loudly trumpeted by the Government a year ago, an Agreement—as a result of which they were able to snatch a general election——
Comment on this
Before the people had an opportunity of realising precisely the state to which the Government had brought the country— I am not referring to the occasion selected by the Government to go to the country, but to arguments they were able to put forward before the country and the strength of the argument that they had made the Agreement. Everyone who knows the country is perfectly well aware of the fact that it was the hopes produced by that Agreement that led to the Government victory and now, 12 months afterwards, we are facing this situation that—in a time of peace, in a time when crises are threatening other countries, crises in which we may be involved, and when a wise Government would take every step to conserve its resources— we have this additional taxation. Does anybody believe that 12 months ago the country believed that that would be one of the immediate fruits of the particular victory referred to. In this which ought to be one of the most favourable years since the Government took office, the country is presented with this Finance Bill and its taxes and with the speech of the Minister for Taxation. That use of the word taxation was a slip—but not quite so inapt.
Comment on this
Minister for Finance. This is a year in which there has been an abnormal expenditure of money, and a circulation of money, on the part of our main and, to a large extent, almost our sole foreign customer, and yet we have not been able to take advantage of that.
I do not intend to call attention— Deputy Dillon has done so—to the closing paragraph of the Minister's Budget Statement. Like Deputy Dillon, I wish the country would weigh that paragraph. What I should like to put to the House is this, that, considering the black picture that the Minister has painted for the House and the country, do the Government think it a good preparation to raid the feserves of the country before that catastrophe comes upon us? Are there people in the Government who believe that the country will be in a better position to face the horrible situation that the Minister has so luridly depicted, if we eat into our resources as we are doing? What will there be left to meet that situation? In a time of peace, in a time when there is no interference with its trade, either export or import, the savings of the country, savings piled up, not during the régime of the Minister and his colleagues, but before their time, are being eaten into. What will be the position should the state of war pictured by the Minister arise? Is it wise to eat into these savings now and have to face a situation like that depicted by the Minister, a situation over the coming of which we have no control?
Surely, with a picture of that kind before their minds, the Government should have hesitated before they took this step, in a time of peace, of putting on these additional burdens? I wonder whether I am justified in saying that the Budget is, to a large extent, the Budget of the Government and the tone of the speech is, to a large extent, the tone of the man responsible for finding the money, the man who possibly knows better than the other members of the Government what is the financial situation facing this country? This ought to have been the first really normal year that we have had since 1932, owing to the disappearance of the economic war, and owing to the fact that there is such an expenditure and a flowing of money across the Channel. And yet, at this period, the Minister finds it necessary to raid the savings in the country.
What is the justification the Minister tried to "get across" for the extraordinary character of his Budget? Is it not that it is really a war Budget at a time when we are enjoying the full benefits of peace? Preparations for war, the Minister might say. I will deal with that subsequently; but before the crisis comes upon the country, we are budgeting as if we were plunged into the crisis already. We have to face that particular position painted by the Minister and read out by Deputy Dillon this afternoon. Therein the Minister refers to increased taxation burdens that the country will have to face. Where does he propose to get them with the disappearance, which he himself indicates, of our revenue from customs, and so forth owing to the difficulties of international trade? If war really comes, whether we are involved in it or not is to a large extent a secondary matter from this particular point of view. Where is the revenue to come from to keep this country going? Has not the Minister already, as a result of his policy over the years, cut the ground from under the feet of any Government that will be called upon to face such a situation as he himself has visualised?
I have no doubt the Minister must have made that clear to his colleagues, but they overbore him. Hence the contrast between the gloomy tone of the Budget speech, on the one hand, and the provisions of the Budget, on the other hand. If the man responsible for the gloomy tone of the Budget Statement had full responsibility for framing the taxation system that is contained in that statement, then he is suffering from a disease of double personality, two different people speaking in him.
What can we say of the description of the Minister that the past year was a year that had betrayed all hopes? Supposing it had betrayed all hopes, has the Minister asked himself why? Was it on account of the European crisis? The Minister hinted that that was so. Deputy Childers, speaking on the last occasion, also hinted that was so. But what neither the Minister nor his follower has pointed out to us is how that European crisis last September affected the trade of this country (not the trade of Europe as a whole), and the purchasing power of certain classes in Great Britain who buy our agricultural goods. Does the Minister really pretend that the crisis affected us and our trade to the extent that it justifies the imposition of these taxes or justifies the description of the year as a year that betrayed all hopes? Admitted it betrayed all hopes; I think it is time the Government should ask themselves, apart from any Party questions whatsoever, why the year betrayed all hopes.
Why was it that when, after the economic war, you returned to a normal position, the first year of that normal position betrayed all your hopes? Does it not call for a revision of the whole policy of the Government? Is it not time they asked themselves whether the policy they are pursuing is sound; whether the country can bear it much longer? Is not the Budget itself an indication that the country cannot bear it much longer? I put it to the Minister again, is it sound policy to subsidise all our industries and have to continue to subsidise them? If that is to continue to be our policy, where are the subsidies to come from? It is a plain question. It seems to me an incredible thing that the Government has not faced it. Economically it seems obviously unsound that a Government should be in the position of subsidising everything.
The Minister referred the last day to the subsidy of £10,500,000 that he alleged he was giving to agriculture. Leaving aside the fantastic nature of this statement due to the manner in which the Minister juggles with figures, if you are in the position of having to subsidise your main source of wealth out of taxation to the extent of £10,500,000 per annum, where are the subsidies to come from? It is a problem the Government may postpone for a year or two years, but it is not a problem the consideration of which the country can postpone for ever. Is there any indication, either in the case of that industry or in the case of the other industries that we have, with a great deal of trouble and cost to the consumer, set up in this country, that these industries can continue without a subsidy?
Surely, that is a matter requiring the gravest consideration on the part of the Minister and of the Government? Take our principal industry, or any other industry. You have two methods of helping it. Of course, again, our main source of wealth must come from our principal industry. We may regret that we have not other great industries as well as that industry, but we have not. Which, then, is the sounder policy?—either to get yourself into such a position that you have to subsidise every industry, and continue to subsidise every industry, or try, as far as you can, to remove the shackles that you have put upon agriculture and other industries, to remove the various obstacles that have been put in the way of their success. If the country is to get into a healthy financial condition. surely the latter policy is the saner policy in the long run.
One class after another have felt the whip of the Government. Take the case of the farmer. Does anybody pretend—even on the Fianna Fáil Benches —that the condition of the farmer at the present moment is a satisfactory one? If that is not pretended, how then do you intend to come to his help? Is it by still keeping the shackles on his industry, by compelling the State to help him by way of subsidies? Where are these subsidies to be got from? They are only to be got through taxation, and that taxation must be got from industry or from production; it cannot in the long run come from anywhere else. It must come from industries that, themselves, are subsidised, and therefore it all must come or all must depend on taxation that comes from subsidised industries. Can anything be more vicious than a policy of that kind? Does the Government, on serious consideration, think that these industries themselves can continue to exist if everything must depend on the provision of subsidies? How long can they continue to exist? They can only continue to exist so long as there is money in the way of savings to be raided, and no longer. That is what you are doing. You are raiding the savings and the reserves that were built up in the past, and we have only been able to carry on during the economic war, and we can only now afford this so-called victory Budget, because of those savings.
There is no indication, however, of a change in policy by the Government. nor is there any indication that conditions are becoming better so far as the main industry of this country or even the smaller industries of this country —at least, not to the extent necessary that one was led to believe would take place as a result of the improvement of relations with Great Britain. You have to remember, of course, the low level to which things were brought. One would take it for granted that, so low was the level to which things had been brought, that there must be some improvement of conditions resulting from a change of circumstances due to the Agreement—that Agreement was bound to bring about some improvement in conditions. It seems to me, however, that we are very far yet from reaching the level of what I may call pre-war years—and when I say war, I am referring to the economic war. We are very far from reaching that level. I know that, besides Government policy, other factors are responsible for that, and I know, equally well, that the Government stresses these other factors, and stresses these other factors unduly to the exclusion of the results of their own policy. If I thought that these other factors were really as dominant factors as the Government would like to lead us to believe, then I should say that there was no future for this country. But, in fact, these other unfavourable factors are not near so important as Government supporters pretend—and this is shown by returns that have been recently given by Northern Ireland. There was a return, published the other day, by the Northern Ireland Government. It covers the time when the Government here was defending its policy by pointing out that the widespread depression in trade in the world generally, was responsible for the decline in our agricultural exports and for the decline in their value, as well as the decline, generally, in both our import and export trade as a whole. It was held that this decline was due to world-wide conditions of depression. But these same conditions must have prevailed in Northern Ireland, yet there they had not been the same general bad effect. In effect, the fact is that, whereas we are still very far behind the pre-economic war conditions, Northern Ireland which, under similar conditions of world depression, ought to have been as much affected as we were, is considerably ahead of the pre-economic war position—i.e., better than its position in 1932. That shows that there must be some factor peculiar to these TwentySix Counties that is hitting us and that did not hit our Northern neighbours, who happen to live in a portion of our country. Now, what was the difference? The main difference was the policy of the Government. It is not a question of the character of the produce, because the export of even agricultural produce increased during those years in Northern Ireland, whereas ours went down catastrophically. It is not a question of the character of the agricultural produce, because the value of the exported cattle there went up during those years, whereas the value of similar exports in our case went down. There was the difference between the policies of the Governments concerned —not merely the policy, as carried out during the economic war, for which we have had to pay so dearly, and of the victory Budget, for which we now have to pay so dearly—but the whole policy of the Government in making the costs so heavy on the farmer as to make his position practically impossible.
You may describe this Budget, if you like, as a popular Budget. I have seen it so described. I do not care whether you describe it as a popular or unpopular Budget; I am more interested in finding out whether or not it is a sound Budget. Does it indicate a change of heart on the part of the Minister for Finance or on the part of the Government? The farmer has been hit and sorely by the policy of the Government. We want a change there. I realise that the industrialists must in the long run—and not too long a run at that—be hit also because the industrialist cannot live on tariffs alone unless the country is capable of paying the tariffs. The realisation of this truth is just as necessary for him as for the farmer. As I have called attention in the past so I now call attention, not merely to the condition of the farmer, but to the condition of the traders in the country towns. Their situation is bad, and their outlook is deplorable. I do not know whether it is the policy of the Government to drive out of existence the ordinary town trader in the country towns, but that is happening, and I believe that it is happening as an indirect result of the policy of the Government.
Then, we hear talk about economies. Take the case of the labourer. Will he not be hit also? What is the only place where the Government thinks of making economies? Employment schemes—and that is at a time when there are so many people unemployed and at a time when there is so much emigration from this country. That is the principal economy the Minister has announced to this House.
Comment on this
That is the principal economy the Government has produced. I am only dealing with their statements.
Comment on this
I could offer plenty of alternatives, but I will say that, at a time when there is so much unemployment, which the Ministry has not been able to cure, and at a time when there is so much emigration the existence of which the Ministry for a long time has tried to deny, but now is forced to acknowledge, this is the one economy that the Minister puts before us. Did he make economics in the cases where he said again and again, when he was on these benches, he would make them—in the police force and in the Army?
Comment on this
I have said on many occasions in this House that the sums provided in the present defence programme really represent a pure waste of money. Again and again I have pointed out to the Minister that our objection to that was that it was spending money for which no return was being got.
Comment on this
I am referring to the fact that while the Minister is putting on extra taxation for it, neither he nor any of his colleagues has shown that there is the slightest justification for their defence policy. The high cost of living is hitting everybody, rich and poor alike. This Budget is the solace and the balm that the Minister for Finance has for the people who were asked to bear the scourge of the economic war for such a long time. These are the fruits of victory.
There is one change, a welcome change I will confess. We all remember the Minister's first Budgets, especially the first one. We all remember, shall I call it the malicious joy—perhaps I had better say joy and leave out malicious—with which he imposed extra taxes on that occasion. Those who were present in the House on that particular day can recall not merely the words but the whole attitude of the Minister. Since then he has learned that the imposition of taxes in a country like this is not the gay pastime that he apparently thought it was when he entered on office. What I regard as the most serious thing of all—more serious in my opinion than the acutal material losses inflicted on the people, serious though these may be—is that the Government of which the Minister is a member have killed hope to a large extent in one class of the community after another. That is the really serious thing; the fact that the people have now resigned themselves to whatever may come. They are bearing these burdens and facing the fact that there is to be no improvement in their condition. The result that they had hoped for from the settlement with Britain did not come. I do not like to see the despair that follows from that grow on the people, but I am afraid that is what is occurring.
Deputies will remember that we on this side begged the Minister and the Government in this House to settle that dispute while the country was still in a position to make the most of a settlement. I believe that the settlement was delayed too long, so that we are now reaping the result of the failure of the Government to wake up in time to the seriousness of the situation as it then was. In view of these facts we urge the Minister and the Government to face the situation that confronts them to-day. Possibly they are going to be faced with a much more serious situation tomorrow, but the strange thing is that they act as if they failed to see it in all its seriousness.
With regard to taxation, I am not denying that at the beginning it may cause a circulation of money which gives the appearance of increased prosperity. That is at the start, but how long is that going to continue? At the beginning, you get that kind of a false sense of prosperity. The circulation of money is good in its way, but if it has to be continually financed out of eating into savings, then I have not much hope that it can be long continued.
The Minister dealt with the debt of this country: with local taxation and central taxation. I venture to suggest that it is a matter not of primary importance whether the Central Government or the local bodies have thrust on them the unpopular task of imposing fresh burdens on the people. In any event it is the people who will have to bear the burden. The shifting of the burden on to the local authority, or by the local authority back on to the Exchequer does not get us any further. What I do put to the Minister is this: That for the enormous sums of money which the State gets, whether from the central body or the local body, it should ask itself: Is it getting value for that money? I suggest that is the much more important question. It is a problem that the Government should seriously tackle. So far as local taxation is concerned, the thought has often been brought very clearly before me, that people—I am speaking now of the time when I became first interested in question of public finance, local and otherwise—in those far-off days—paid a great deal more attention to the question whether the rate was to be 7/6 in the £ or 7/8 in the £ than they did to the question whether they were getting anything approaching even a moderate return for the money spent. I put it to the House that it is the business of the Government and of the local authorities to see that good value is got by the public and the country for the immense burden that the country is bearing.
We know that the Minister did refer in his Budget statement to the burden of local taxes, but he was completely silent as regards other taxes. He was significantly silent about the various sums that have to be provided by the public to support the beet industry, the butter and bacon schemes and so on. These are taxes which the people have to bear. Up to a couple of years ago they appeared in the form of taxes. A mere change in a bookkeeping transaction does not make them less a burden on the people and does not make them less taxes on them. But the Minister was significantly silent about them, with the result that the country is not told what the real burden is. I admit that portion of the burden is incalculable. What do the ordinary charges following tariffs amount to in the way of increased costs to the public? A certain portion at all events of the sum of money ought to have been referred to by the Minister, namely how much the beet factories and so on get out of the public to keep them going. We refer to those hidden taxes year after year. We can legitimately complain that in what professes to be a statement of the financial position of the country there is no mention of this— in the Budget.
As I say, you have increased taxation at a time when there is no indication of increased prosperity in the country, and no indication that that taxation imposed by the Government is producing good and lasting results. Redistribution of money? There is something to be said for that; I am not denying it, but it is not in itself necessarily productive.
As Deputy Childers pointed out the last day—I would ask the Minister for Finance to take to heart what he did say the last day—it is all very well to put on certain taxes but they are bound to go down through the people, no matter who pays the first, and they are bound to be a burden on industry. Taking that statement, I do not know how he was able to support the Minister in his present Budget. He did it on the plea that this was an abnormal year. I pointed out that it is, in the sense of being a much more favourable year than we are likely to encounter in the immediate future. If there is war, I put it to Deputies to read the last paragraph of the Minister's statement and see what the prospects are so far as revenue for this country is concerned. If there is peace—if there is any kind of assured peace, with the reduction of armaments in different countries—then what are the prospects? Will our principal market, the market to which we export most of our goods, be in a better purchasing condition in the years immediately after the cessation of expenditure on armaments? On the question of armaments, the Minister did not show, any more than his chief, the Taoiseach—who was at one time acting Minister for Defence—or the Minister for Defence, that the proposed increased expenditure on defence is likely to produce any satisfactory results so far as the defence of this country is concerned. He used abusive terms to certain members of this House. I know the Minister would not consider them abusive——
Comment on this
——but other people would. Standards vary, in finance as in other things. But what was his own policy? First of all, he objects to the idea that Great Britain would defend this country. That is in column 2,591. In column 2,592 he realised it is the business of Great Britain to defend this country, but when that suggestion came from friends behind me they were described as "poltroons." Not abusive—gentle stroking, so to speak? The Minister said: "We have secured our absolute sovereignty over five-sixths of our ancient territory. There is a danger that, in certain circumstances, our territory or our commerce or those communications which are vital to us might be endangered." I waited, in vain, for an answer from him or from his colleagues how the additional expense which the country is asked to foot this year is likely to conduce to a better defence of our territory. Still more, perhaps, he might tell us how it is going to help us to defend our commerce? This, remember, is immediately after repudiation of the idea that the British were going to defend those things. Will he tell us how this additional expenditure will help us better to defend our commerce and our communications? Not one of those things will be helped by the extra expenditure. If the members on this side of the House thought there was any justification for this additional expenditure or that it would help to maintain the independence of this country, then we should be prepared to face it, but not a single line that we could consider a justification has come from the Minister. It is not merely what we are in for this year. A policy of this kind involves further expenditure in the future. I do not take the optimistic view that the Minister took when he said that certain supplies would last a lifetime. Surely it is characteristic of modern war supplies that they do not last a lifetime, and that Governments are lucky if such supplies are up-to-date in a few years' time. Few things can get out-of-date so quickly as modern war supplies, and yet it was on that basis that the Minister justified at least portion of his borrowing under that particular head.
His defence policy merely means the expending of money. He has not told us against whom he is going to employ the forces that he is going to secure by this particular money, or how he is going to employ them. Those problems were put up to the Government, and the Government—perhaps wisely—has refrained from answering. Personally, I am not convinced that there is any justification for any such increased expenditure. I do not know what is involved in another statement of the Minister where he envisages the effect on another power, namely, Great Britain, of our not providing those services. He discussed, later on, what the British might say if we did not provide this extra money: "Might they not say `the Irish want to have it both ways; they want to be free but they will not accept the obligations of freedom," and so on. I wonder is it in order to please that particular power that we are making this gesture? That is the only thing that I can read out of the statement at the end of column 2,592 and the beginning of column 2,593 of the Debates of May 17th. I suggest that is all it is—a very costly gesture, but no more useful for real purposes of defence than a gesture.
If I were convinced that there were forces—forces with which we cannot deal—working against the economic prosperity of this country to anything like the extent that is sometimes alleged from the Government benches, then I should regard the future as hopeless; but I am convinced that a great deal of the trouble is due to the policy of the Government, and I think, now that the economic war has ended, now that at last the Minister for Finance seems to have wakened up to the seriousness of the situation, it is time that the whole policy was subjected to a radical examination.
Comment on this
There are two or three small points of detail in connection with this Bill that I should like to mention at this stage, although possibly they may be gone into more fully on the next stage. The first is in connection with Section 12, which permits of the free importation of cinema film by certain organisations. I wonder would the Minister consider the extension of that to cover organisations of an educational nature. The particular matter I am thinking of is the question of life-saving. There is a film in existence demonstrating the correct method of saving a person from drowning. That film has been in this country, but so far as I am aware, duty had to be paid upon it. I may be wrong in that. There may be a provision which allows films of that kind to come in free of duty. Perhaps the Minister would look into that matter before the Committee Stage.
I noticed a picture in a newspaper the other day of the Minister taking ciné-camera pictures at a race meeting. I should hesitate to suggest that the latter part of that section has any connection with that. What I really want to raise is the interpretation which is likely to be put on the word "solely" in line 13. Many people who possess these ciné-cameras go away for holidays and naturally wish to make a pictorial record of their holidays. If this word "solely" is retained in the section, it seems to me that if they bring the films in here and despatch them from here for processing, they will be liable to duty, whereas, if the camera was used solely in this country, they would be admitted free. Possibly the Minister will look into that question before the next Stage.
As to the provision for the transfer of £150,000 from the Road Fund, it has been, I think, the custom in the past to make a grant from the Road Fund also for unemployment assistance. At the Committee of Public Accounts recently, it transpired that £100,000 was transferred for that purpose, none of which was expended; but at the end of the financial year that amount was surrendered to the Exchequer. I should like to know whether £150,000 is the full limit or whether there is still to be what one might describe as a cancealed raid on the Road Fund to the extent of £100,000 on top of that £150,000. I also want to draw attention to Item No. 4 in the First Schedule. This is a matter to be raised on the Committee Stage and I take it the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be present to deal with it. I merely mention it now so that the Minister may be prepared to deal with the matter on the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
In the early part of the Minister's Budget speech he dealt with the balancing of last year's Budget, and in the course of his speech as reported in the Official Reports, he gave what is called a "Comparison between Budget estimates and Exchequer receipts and issues in 1938-39." According to this the deficit last year was £527,500. But, in making up that sum, the Minister allows himself borrowings in respect of unemployment relief schemes amounting to £215,000, and for export bounties and subsidies amounting to £335,000. The sum provided in last year's Budget for unemployment relief schemes was £1,500,000. The practice, of which we have had experience, has generally been that where you borrow a proportion of a sum which is provided, you at least take responsibility for what is left of the sum. In that case, £1,250,000 would stand to be provided for out of last year's Budget in respect of that service. In that case only £40,000 could be borrowed in respect of the £1,290,000. The same applies to the export bounties and subsidies.
Finance is a matter upon which most people affect either to have no knowledge or to portray as something which is beyond the ordinary person to understand. So far as the case for this particular deduction by the Minister is concerned the fact is that the taxpayers were taxed to provide £1,250,000 last year in respect of unemployment relief schemes. How and by what process the Minister takes £215,000 off £1,290,088, to make his deficit only £527,000 needs some explanation. The taxpayers were taxed also in respect of export bounties and subsidies. It is not a question of juggling with figures; it is not a question of misunderstanding. There is nothing in it except one thing, that instead of having a Budget deficit of £900,000 odd, the Minister produces one of £500,000. It is that sort of thing which damages the credit of the State and which must make it more and more difficult to borrow money because no reliance can be placed upon figures presented in that form. That is not the presentation of the Ministry of Finance. It is the presentation of the Minister for Finance. If it is an attempt to deceive, it is an unworthy attempt. If it be pure innocence we can overlook it. But it is inconceivable that the Ministry of Finance would not have informed the Minister that he could not stand over this figure.
The Minister, in the course of his reply to the Budget debate, stated that the Government had saved £2,000,000; that the sums in dispute with Great Britain, amounting as they did to £5,000,000, were roughly £3,000,000 for Land Commission annuities and £2,000,000 for pensions, local loans and other sums of that sort. No one except the Minister could read into the promise that had been made by him and his Party in connection with the saving of £2,000,000 in taxation that that was the £2,000,000 concerned. Their statement ran: "We have examined the Estimates very carefully, we have gone through them, and we find that £2,000,000 can be saved without interfering with efficiency."
Comment on this
Very good; you saved it. He saved £2,000,000, so that in contrast with his predecessors he had £2,000,000 more to spend. This Bill is schemed to collect £32,511,000 this year from the taxpayers. In the last year of office of the Minister's predecessor the amount collected was £25,496,000. The difference is £7,014,000. The Minister told us just now that he had saved £2,000,000. Therefore, he has £9,014,000 more money to spend than his predecessors had in their last year of office. When criticised in respect of this enormous burden on the people, they ask: "Do you want us to save on social services. We will not do it." Let us examine what the social services are costing. Take in this case this political statement with figures which the Minister has circulated for the benefit not only of the Dáil but of people outside it. In Table 7 there is a comparison between 1931-32 of what is described as "audited expenditure," and Estimates for 39-40. These are the Minister's figures. The difference between the two sums amounts to about £5,500,000. The social services according to his figures are costing £5,500,000. He is collecting £7,000,000, and says he saved £2,000,000, therefore he is getting £9,000,000. What has become of the additional £3,500,000? Where are they being spent? They are not claimed in respect of social services.
If there are any economies to be made is it not easier to examine how far it would be possible to save in respect of the £3,500,000, rather than the £5,500,000 with which I will deal later? What reliance can be placed on the figures presented to us? There are various reasons for this enormous addition of £3,500,000 to expenditure not connected in any way with the social services of the State. In this table there are 24 separate supply services—not social services—the expenditure on all of which has advanced since 1931-32. The very first one concerns the President of the Executive Council. The Estimate—not the audited expenditure—for 1931-32, was £11,543, and this year it amounts to £14,259. There is a difference of £2,716. It is a much more expensive office than in 1931-32.
Comment on this
We will deal with that. It happens that the same Minister is responsible for the Department of External Affairs. The Estimate in 1931-32 was £59,879, this year, £90,931. There is a difference of over £30,000. For what? Style, I suppose. To lift up our prestige. About 300 men could be employed at £100 a year each for that expenditure and it would probably be better for the country. In 1931-32, the Estimate for the Department of the Comptroller and Auditor-General was £18,111, the Estimate for 1939-40 is £19,861, an excess of £1,750. The Estimate for the Minister for Finance, the man who is supposed to be the custodian of every fraction that comes into or goes out of the Exchequer, is £12,892 over and above what it was in 1931-32. The Estimate for the Revenue Commissioners is increased by £214,061; Commissions and Special Inquiries by £1,966; Public Works Office by £31,654. I have not checked the figures. They may be £32,000. Expenditure on the State Laboratory increased by £1,245; the Civil Service Commission by £12,449. Rates on Government Property, by reason of the policy that is being pursued for the last seven years, increased by £37,500; Secret Service by £10,000; Miscellaneous Expenses by £2,825; Stationery and Printing by £31,228; Law Charges by £8,406; Department of Justice by £3,060; Gárda by £279,125; Supreme Court and District Courts by £362; Department of Education by £21,795; Science and Art by £16,734; Department of Industry and Commerce by £201,484; Marine Service by £3,510; the Army by £1,815,158; External Affairs by £31,052; League of Nations by £1,451. In the Department of Local Government and Public Health, salaries, and wages, increased from £79,600 in 1931-32 to £132,988, a difference of £53,388; in the Department of Agriculture, salaries and wages increased by £61,939; in National Health Insurance, salaries and wages increased by £20,433; in Forestry, salaries and wages increased by £7,235; in the Land Commission, salaries and wages increased by £105,470. The same people incurred all this extra expenditure under these various headings amounting to £2,971,942.
Would it not have been worth while to have gone through these Estimates to see how it might have been possible to make savings? We have been asked to point out where money can be saved. Surely representations must have been made to the Minister in his Department repeatedly. I had experience of that during a longer term of office than the Minister, with regard to any possible indication of a rise in expenditure. These are not social services, but they are headings under which it was the special responsibility of the Minister for Finance to have saved the taxpayers every possible penny that could have been saved. The Minister gets an occasional compliment from the Irish Times. That newspaper stated that the Minister had done his work. Taking the figure of practically £3,000,000, it does not look as if he had. Even that newspaper, which is quoted by the Minister's organ, goes on to say that if there are to be savings they have to be on social services. I say that there are possibilities for saving where I have indicated, and if the Minister had paid attention to them rather than making political speeches——
Comment on this
Has the Deputy fully considered that, and is he putting it forward as a considered suggestion?
Comment on this
The Minister wants to know where are the savings to be made, and I say they are to be made in the figures I gave. Does the Minister want more information on his policy from top to bottom? The more pronounced and the more marked the Ministers, the greater the cost they have been to this State. I will take the three Ministers who spoke on this Budget, the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Education, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The former Minister for Industry and Commerce had an estimate of £106,000 here in 1931-32 and the Estimate for the same Department this year is £307,000. Are we to be told that that is efficient and economic public administration? Why, on its face it is condemned. All the Minister has done is to make some senseless interruptions. He asks if certain things are put forward as sensible, constructive suggestions.
Comment on this
Considered? Not at all. I am quite sure this is put forward without a moment's consideration. I expect it is to be assumed from that statement that it is compiled without a moment's consideration, that all the information is got without a moment's consideration; that one simply looks at the book and makes a subtraction without a moment's hesitation—that the whole thing is done merely as an amusement. The Minister asked the last day where were savings to be effected. Here they are. Here is every evidence of the extravagance, the squandermania, the thing for which the Minister is responsible.
Comment on this
That is where you were going to make the savings—on the Guards and on the Army.
Comment on this
The Minister and his colleagues were not long in office before the Guards Estimate went up. Let us understand one another on this matter.
Comment on this
I think the best thing for the Minister to do would be to resign. I think that his statement is the greatest confession of incompetence that this country will ever see. It is a very serious situation. The situation, when I had compiled these figures, made me regret being a member of this House.
Comment on this
I never shirked a responsibility. I never attempted to hoodwink the people of this country. I put before them at all times what the situation was. What is the situation we now have to deal with? I will take Table VII. It is the Minister's figure, and upon that figure depends that particular sum I have mentioned, £3,500,000, which has been very largely squandered. I will take the first item, the Department of the Executive Council, and the excess in that case is £2,716. It is up largely because of propaganda. You have a newspaper and you have radio and now you want another propagandist in the President's Department. Comparable figures are what we would expect from anybody, Minister or otherwise. We have here in Table VII Estimates compared with Exchequer issues and audited expenditure. There is a negligible difference in items No. 1 and No. 2. No. 3 deals with unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance. I will let those pass. Then we come to National Health Insurance, and I will allow that to pass.
Comment on this
I merely want to save time. I will come now to No. 5, Relief Schemes and Employment Schemes. There was a sum of £1,290,088 spent last year and the Estimate this year comes to £1,500,000. That figure has been affected in two ways. In the first place, there has been a deduction in the Budget of £100,000, and there is no indication of the deduction there. In the second place, it is affected by the fact that the Minister proposes to borrow £350,000. Therefore, so far as that column is concerned, it falls for a deduction of £450,000. I come now to the item dealing with miscellaneous public health and other grants and expenses of Local Government and Public Health. That represents the entire cost of local government. Surely it is not contended that Dr. Conn Ward is a social service—and his salary is on that. If it be, it is a new order of social service.
Surely, the Minister for Local Government does not regard the administrative charges in connection with the local authorities as a social service. If it is, is not everything a social service? Is the case going to be made that every single penny of expenditure here, if it is reduced, is off the social services? Those particular items in relation to local government, with a total of £372,055, should go out. The Land Commission expenditure is not a social service and it could not be brought in there but that there happens to be a figure of £625,000 in respect of the halved Land Commission annuities. Is that a social service? I suggest it is not. The whole of the Land Commission Vote should go out, because it is not, by any stretch of imagination, a social service. Then there is an item for the Gaeltacht Services, other than housing grants. I wonder did it strike the Minister that Fisheries and Gaeltacht Services were together in 1931-32? We can let that pass, and, presumably, the item for 1931-32 should have been up.
I am taking out what are properly described as social services. I omit items 10, 11 and 12. I make a comparable figure with last year and I deduct the Minister's proportion of £1,000,000 out of the £35,000,000. He did the same thing last year. In order to get the Estimate more in keeping with the comparable figure of audited expenditure, £220,000 should come off for over-estimation, and then there is a sum of £450,000 not provided for in taxation. The Minister is not going to provide it out of taxation and, therefore, it is not a cost to taxation. We get a net figure of £7,240,992, and the corresponding figure for 1931-32 was £3,640,983, leaving the actual net cost of social services at £3,600,000. We are saving and collecting £9,000,000 to discharge that, and if there are economies to be made, they fall to be made out of the larger sum, and they fall to be made out of the sum which will affect least those who are unable to bear the burden. That is the situation with regard to the general question of the Budget.
The Minister wants to know what can be done. If this amount of money had not been squandered, if every precaution had been taken to ensure that value for the money would have been got for the people, it would have been possible to have derated agricultural land on this balance of £5,500,000. It would have been possible to wipe out this £1,169,000 that we are now adding to the taxation already imposed. It would have been possible not to have recourse to borrowing in respect of the £350,000 connected with unemployment and relief schemes. It would have been possible to have provided £350,000 more for the Army, but the Army Estimate should be reduced by £1,000,000, and you would have a better balanced Budget and better results for the people than we have by reason of this policy of squandermania.
We are told the industrial policy that has been pursued is equivalent to a fairy tale. I never heard a policy better described. Looking over the returns in connection with National Health Insurance, I find that the Minister and his Government did not keep pace with the expanding employment that was in operation in this country from 1926 to 1931. Notwithstanding this enormous expenditure of money, and going further on with this table, and looking at the last page, in which the Minister says that farming has been benefited to the extent of £4,167,000, I add that to the £9,000,000, and get over £13,000,000, and I then take out the figure of the additions to unemployment insurance, £250,000—also arising out of the policy pursued by the. Ministry—and take out the cost to local authorities also, £229,000, and with £150,000 Road Fund get a figure of approximately £13,800,000. It would be possible, reckoning it at £100 a year to give employment to 138,000 persons. Has that been done? No, nor anything approaching it. What has been the principal reason? The principal reason has been what has already been referred to this evening by two other speakers and that is that the agricultural industry in this country has undergone a greater onslaught than it has ever experienced in its entire history. The year 1931 was by no means a prosperous year, having regard to the people's standards of living by comparison from 1914 to 1931, or, if one wishes, from 1922 to 1931: and that was one of the principal reasons that was adduced for effecting a change of Government. Looking back now, it seems very much like a fairy tale that year 1931 as compared with what we were told about the industrial expansion that was to take place in this country. Those were very prosperous times, notwithstanding the fact that we thought they were not prosperous times, and a change in Government was effected because it was thought that they were not prosperous times. We were told that, as a result of electing a new Government, and putting into effect this change of policy, we would have prosperity. There was to be much more tillage and, even if the cattle trade suffered to a large extent, we were told that that loss would be compensated for by an immense increase in tillage and also by limiting imports of agricultural produce into this country. What has been the result? The net exports of produce of agricultural origin in this country, in the year 1931, amounted to £23,348,670, and the net imports of goods of agricultural origin amounted to £9,923,413—a balance of exports over imports of £13,425,257. In 1932 the net exports were £15,963,483 as against net imports, of £9,900,667—a balance of exports over imports of £6,062,816. In 1933 the net exports amounted to £11,522,106 and the net imports amounted to £6,936,795—a balance of £4,585,311. And so on. I shall give the net figures later on. Now, it so happens that there is a relatively stable consumption sale of agricultural produce in the home market. Of course, it would be of advantage to me to go through all those figures, but I have not bothered about them. I prefer to go to the end of the figures with regard to exports and imports for 1932, 1933 and the succeeding years. In the year 1932, the net exports of agricultural origin from this country amounted to £15,963,483, as I have said before, and the net imports amounted to £9,900,667, representing a balance of exports over imports of £6,062,816. Perhaps it would save the Minister's time if I were to adopt the Ministerial practice of just handing in the tables, or should I give the actual figures?
Comment on this
Yes. I do not want to weary the House by reading out all the figures with regard to the net exports and imports for each year; so perhaps it would be better if I gave the net balances. I have already read out the figures with regard to exports and imports for some of the years, and now I propose to read out the balances of exports over imports from 1931 to 1938. They are as follows: In 1931, £13,425,257; in 1932, £6,062,816; in 1933, £4,585,311; in 1934, £3,417,444; in 1935, £6,401,463; in 1936, £8,079,290; in 1937, £6,454,513; in 1938, £9,986,915. The average sum received for our exports for those seven years was £6,426,822, as against the last year of our administration, which amounted to £13,425,257; and, mind, the economic war cost a lot of money. If there are difficulties in this country at the present moment, I hold that they are largely traceable to the policy that presented that unfortunate experience to the farmers of this country. I say that it is significant that, although we were told that our policy here was to be self-supporting, self-sufficing and self-sufficient, the result of all this policy has been that the lowest sum to which we could reduce our net imports was, in 1935, to £5,846,951, increased in 1936 to £6,072,507, in 1937, to £7,638,464 and, in 1938, to £7,618,958. According to that, it would appear that the more we export, apparently, the more we must import, and yet that is the kind of policy that we were told was going to make this country more self-sufficient—that policy that is costing the country so much, and that has been so dearly bought. While that policy has been in operation, it must also be remembered that the number of persons employed in agriculture has been reduced. It has been reduced at a figure favourable to the Minister. The figure is something like 25,000 persons. This relates to persons employed in agriculture in this country. That figure is favourable to the Minister because a difference was introduced in 1934-35 which sent up the numbers, and, had the same scheme been in operation in 1931-32, it might be more likely that the figure would be 40,000 rather than 25,000. While that is the case here, we read in the papers of 27th May, 1939, that the value of the gross output of agricultural produce in Northern Ireland, in the year 1937-38, reached a record figure of £16,413,000 and that it exceeded the sum for the year 1932-33 by more than £5,000,000. If State subsidies are taken into account the gross value in 1937-38 is £16,700,000. The total amount of subsidies paid to the farmers between 1932-33 and 1937-38 was £1,551,791. The income from live stock products in 1937-38 increased by approximately £5,000,000— from £9,157,000 to £14,288,000. Since 1932-33 there has been an increase attributed principally to a rise in the value of pig's output. The increase is put at £3,000,000—from £1,236,000 to £4,405,000. This certainly is an amusing country. The Northern Pigs Board has been fired. It was successful, apparently, according to that. Ours has not been a marked success. If we had a Peerage, I suppose the members of it would be raised to it.
Comment on this
I think that is probably enough to say on this Budget and on the policy of the Ministry. As I said before, having gone through that case and seen those figures, I have to express regret that I am a member of this House.
Comment on this
The Minister and his colleagues have met every argument from this side of the House on this Budget by the old cry: "Are we to reduce the social services; if we do not increase the income-tax and the petrol tax and if we do not put a tax on tobacco and so on, then we shall have to tax tea and sugar and other things that are required by the very poor." I want to ask the Minister one question regarding the cost of the social services. The biggest single item in the increase which the Minister tries to justify is in respect of unemployment. When the Minister and his colleagues boast of the amount of money they are providing in this Budget either for the relief of unemployment by way of relief works, or by unemployment assistance, they are merely saying: "We have fallen down on the job because we have failed to do what we promised to do; we deluded and fooled the people when we told them that we had a solution for unemployment. We now have to call upon the people for approximately £3,000,000." Yet, the Minister for Finance and his colleagues have the audacity to seek for praise and for commendation from the people for what they call the social services they are providing. They do that in this House and on public platforms outside. Instead, the Minister and his colleagues should be asking pardon from the electorate as a whole, and in particular from the 100,000 people who are still signing the register, and from the other 100,000 people who have been forced to cross to the other side and seek for the work that they could not get at home.
The Minister could save this £3,000,000 in this Budget by carrying out the promises that his colleagues and himself made publicly to the people. When they were seeking office they told the people that they had a carefully thought-out plan; that they had a solution for the unemployment problem in this country such as no other country in the world had, a solution that was going to put into employment every unemployed man. They said they were going to provide so much money and jobs that we would have to send for and bring home the exiles. These are the sort of promises that deserve to be described as a fairy tale. Certainly, they are more deserving of that description than the one the Taoiseach is so fond of talking about. The Fianna Fáil Party told many fairy tales to the people in 1932 and 1933. The answer to all this talk about the social services that the Government is forced to provide is this: that they are forced to keep the people of the country in existence because of the rotten policy they have pursued over the last seven years, and because of the effects of that policy. That, I submit, is the real answer to all the clap-trap we hear from the other side of the House when they taunt us with the question: "Do we stand for a reduction in the social services."
Comment on this
I am perfectly certain the Deputy knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
What did the Deputy tell the people in the Country Limerick in 1932. Did the Deputy not tell them: "If you vote No. 1 for me and send me back I will provide a job not only for every idle man in the Country Limerick and in the City of Limerick but in the whole country"?
Comment on this
Am I to take it that the Deputy is now repudiating the policy put forward by Mr. de Valera in 1932?
Comment on this
Not at all. Will the Deputy tell us how he and his Party are going to cure unemployment.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy now denying that he ever said he was going to provide jobs for all the idle people in the country, or is he admitting that he secured election to this House under false promises?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy believe that Fianna Fáil ever had a plan to provide work for all the unemployed in the country?
Comment on this
In other words, it was a fairy tale, but it was good enough to put across the people of this country in 1932 and 1933?
Comment on this
At the moment I am dealing with the solution that the people on the opposite benches offered the people when they were asking the people to give them responsibility.
Comment on this
It is the obligation of the Deputy's Party just as much as ours.
Comment on this
The Deputy must be forgetting all the promises made by his Party.
Comment on this
The Deputy must be forgetting that Fianna Fáil begged, prayed, promised and cajoled the people of the country into putting responsibility on their shoulders on the promise that "We have a solution for unemployment; we have a solution such as no other country in the world has."
Comment on this
The Deputy may not have said it, but I am sure he will agree that a much more important man than he said it. The Taoiseach said it.
Comment on this
That promise must have cost the Fianna Fáil Party tens of thousands of pounds. They had it printed in every newspaper in the country and posted up on every blank wall.
Comment on this
The Deputy will get the quotation from the 100,000 unemployed.
Comment on this
On a point of order. When the Deputy states that the Taoiseach made a statement to the effect that we had a cure for unemployment am I not entitled to ask him to give the quotation?
Comment on this
It only shows, Sir, the straits to which the Deputy is reduced in trying to get away from those very awkward promises.
Comment on this
I have not a shadow of doubt that that very promise, apart from all the others that were made, contributed very largely to securing the Deputy his seat in this House.
Comment on this
Mind you, it worked for a time. I am now pointing out that after all their years here in this House as the Government, with all the opportunities they have had, far from providing jobs even for those who were idle in this country there are to-day 100,000 signing the register. Far from bringing back the unfortunate exiles, in the last seven years we have sent another 120,000 to Great Britain. Would the Deputy tell us why that 120,000 went across to the enemy?
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know. Let me tell the Deputy something which perhaps he does know— that the reason the figure is not greater than 120,000 is that a considerable number of the 100,000 who are still unemployed in this country have not even enough to pay their fare across to the other side. The Deputy ought to go down to his constituency and talk to some of the married men with five, six or seven children, who are trying to exist and rear that family on 14/- a week unemployment assistance. The Deputy might concern himself, and so might other members of his Party, with this problem, that, as a result of the policy of the last seven years, we have youths in this country of 17, 18, 19, 20 and up to 22 years of age who have not get an opportunity of doing one day's work.
Comment on this
They would not work? Is that the Deputy's allegation?
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a statement at which I am very much surprised. Unfortunately, there is a very big number of unemployed in the Deputy's constituency, both in the city and the county, and I am sure they will be enlightened, to say the least of it, when they find that at the end of seven years the result of all the promises is to tell them they do not want to work. If the Deputy will show me the jobs, I will guarantee to give him 100 men for every job he can offer. Coming back, Sir, to the point about the social services, the Minister asked Deputy Cosgrave during the course of his statement if Deputy Cosgrave was suggesting that any economies should be made in the Gárda Vote. Deputy Cosgrave pointed out that the Gárda Vote is somewhere between £200,000 and £250,000 over and above what it was in 1931. The Minister and his colleague sitting immediately behind him had something to say in 1931 about the cost of the Guards and the cost of the Army.
Comment on this
And in 1932. The Minister was satisfied at that time that on those two services alone he could save most of his famous £2,000,000.
Comment on this
In 1932 and 1933, I had a great deal to say about the Gárda, and the Deputy had something to say on the opposite side.
Comment on this
The Minister had a great deal to say about the Gárda. In 1931 and 1932 the Minister said many things about the Gárda, and the duties they had to perform, which I am sure he would like to forget to-day. The Minister on many occasions said things about the forces in this country and the State Departments in this country that I am sure he would like to forget to-day. I am not going to remind the Minister of them, beyond saying that on those two Votes alone he told this country that after careful and minute examination he was satisfied he could save a very big portion of his £2,000,000.