Finance Bill, 1939—Second Stage.
Contributions 115–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1939 ›
And it will make no difference whatever to the answer the Minister is going to make—if he does bother at all to reply to what I am saying—whether I quote him verbatim or not. The Minister is now attempting to take shelter in the same way as his colleague from County Limerick attempted it a few minutes ago. I know, of course, that the Minister and the Deputy sitting behind him do not like to be reminded of, to use the Taoiseach's phrase, the fairy tales which they pitched to this country during three or four general elections. They do not like to have the contrast between promise and performance held up to-day. I am not going to encroach on Deputy Davin's preserves in regard to Deputy Cooney and Grangegorman——
Comment on this
Mind you, if I were to make any comment at all, and if my mind were to run on that establishment on which Deputy Davin's mind occasionally runs when he sees Deputy Cooney, I would say now, looking back on the last seven years, that it is a great pity those statements and the promises made by Fianna Fáil were not made from the most fitting place in this country, and that would not be outside the walls but inside them. I do not want to go over in detail the ground that was gone over in the debate on the general resolution. If I might put it that way, I do not want to stand between the House and the pleasure of listening to the Minister, but, in so far as I can, I do want to expose this humbug and nonsense about the social services. I want to show that, so far as at least £3,000,000 of that money is concerned, the people of this country are being taxed to provide it because the Government have not only failed to cure the evil of unemployment which they told us in 1932 they could cure, but have aggravated it to a very large extent. Further, I would say in conclusion that this Budget, far from helping in any way to reduce unemployment in this country, is going still further to increase it. It is going to bring a number of other people, who are to-day not in well-paid jobs but at least in permanent jobs, out of those permanent jobs and for the first time on to the starvation line represented by unemployment assistance in this country. That is the social service the Minister talks about. There is one way to reduce it, and that is to carry out the promises that were made. We are not asking them to do anything which we said they ought to do. We are asking them to do what they said they could and would do. When they were told they were not possible to do, when they were told it was at least almost impossible to provide full-time employment for every unemployed man in this country, they insisted—at the expense of a full-page advertisement in the daily papers—on saying that, although every other country in the world failed, Fianna Fáil had a plan which would succeed. The Taoiseach told us that there was no reason why any man who wanted to work in this country should be denied the right to work, and that, so far as he and his Party were concerned, if returned to power, they would not be denied that right.
Comment on this
As soon as you get out of that we will give it to you very quickly.
Comment on this
The Government and the Fianna Fáil Party, contrary to the promise made before coming into power that they would reduce taxation by at least £2,000,000, have year after year increased taxation to such an extent in this small and relatively poor country that it has now reached the unprecedented level of over £35,000,000, an increase of over £6,000,000 during their period of office. To my mind this crushing burden is one of the main causes of the present state of our primary industry, agriculture. Its depressed condition and its reduced output, I suppose, were mainly caused by the economic war, but the failure of the industry to recover since the settlement of the economic war is undoubtedly due to the crushing overhead charges caused by general and local taxation. The Banking Commission, having examined the financial position of the country, reported that there was a marked deterioration in recent years in the state of the public finances, and then they issued this warning: "That this deterioration should be checked is, in our view, a matter of urgent necessity." One would expect that the Government, having set up a commission to examine into the financial position of the country, would make some effort at all events to carry into effect the recommendations of that commission.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows very well the recommendations to which I refer. No attempt has been made to carry out any of the recommendations —I think the Deputy will agree with that at all events—either the majority recommendations or the minority recommendations. The Banking Commission has simply been waste of so much public money. The report has been pigeon-holed in some Government office and, so far as the Government are concerned, it is completely forgotten. The Minister has asked how can taxation be reduced or where can economies be effected. Wherever economies can be effected, we must realise that the country cannot stand the present burden of taxation. It is beyond the capacity of the country to bear that burden of taxation and it has to be reduced by some means or other. The private individual, in running his own household, if he is a wise man, is going to live within his means. Many of us, if we were rash enough, could take many services into our household that we cannot afford, but how long would we last if we did? The State is in the very same position. There is no getting away from the fact that at the present time this State is living far beyond its means and it is throwing on the people, particularly on our main industry, a burden that they cannot bear. It has the effect of reducing our output and reducing our productivity. This year I believe that the effect of the high taxation will be shown in a diminishing return from taxation and in a further reduction in output.
Deputy Childers had the temerity to warn the Government of the present dangerous financial situation. I admire him for his courage, but he made the excuse that this was an abnormal year. I pointed out here before that it was an abnormal year in one respect—that it should be a prosperous year for agriculture, taking general world conditions into account, and especially taking into account the conditions of the market in which we sell our produce. Since I made that comment on Deputy Childers' speech figures have been published in the daily papers showing the position of agriculture in Northern Ireland. Deputy Cosgrave has referred to these figures and I do not think they can be over-emphasised. They bear an extraordinary comparison to the position of agriculture in this part of the country. Since 1932 the agricultural output in Northern Ireland has been increased by £6,000,000. On a total output of £16,500,000, there has been an increase of £6,000,000 since 1932. Pig production has increased from £1,250,000 practically to £4,500,000, an increase of over £3,000,000. The excuse has been put forward by Ministers in this House that world conditions are responsible for the present depressed conditions and that what is happening here is similar to what is happening all over the world. How is it that there has not been that effect in Northern Ireland? How has Northern Ireland increased its agricultural output by that extraordinary figure since 1932? Side by side with that, in this part of the country we have had a reduction in gross agricultural output from £62,000,000 to £47,000,000, which is the latest available figure.
Then compare the pig industry here with that in Northern Ireland, where the output has increased by over £3,000,000. There has been a serious falling off here in the same period. In that year we exported slightly over 500,000 cwts. of bacon and nearly 500,000 live pigs, as well as the pork trade we have into Northern Ireland. What is the position to-day? Our exports of bacon have been maintained, but the export of pork and live pigs has practically disappeared. The pork trade has gone. Exports of live pigs last year numbered only 66,000 instead of 500,000, while side by side with that in Northern Ireland the industry has increased its output by £3,000,000. We were told that world conditions had affected agriculture. It is obvious to any experienced farmer that it has been Government policy— taxation and overhead charges—that has destroyed the prosperity of agriculture and retarded its progress. There is no use in setting up a commission to find out how to improve or to increase agricultural production. The best and the only way to do that is to take the load off the farmer's back. That is all he asks.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce addressed the Dublin electors last week and stated that the Government had been asked to help agriculture. Agriculture, the Minister said, should be improved. He meant that the price of agricultural produce would have to be increased, and the natural corollary, of course, was that the foodstuffs the citizens had to buy would cost more. I suppose the speech was a grand one for some of the unfortunate people in the back streets who, with their mouths open, listen to that sort of stuff. I take it that some of them were incapable of analysing what was really meant. That is not what we suggest. We have pointed out, time and time again, that we have no control over the prices we receive for our agricultural produce, because we have to sell in an export market. I pointed out, in this House, also that the prices we received at present were relatively good, but that the cost of production was the problem. That is the burden that is affecting agriculture. It must be removed if there is to be prosperity in agriculture, or amongst any section of our people. The great source of wealth from which our people derive their purchasing power comes from agriculture. What is happening in Northern Ireland. We talk about bringing the people there into Éire, but there is, at present, no attraction for farmers to come in. The only way to bring them in is to make this country attractive for them. We are all anxious to do that. It is the duty of the Government to face up to this serious situation, and the way to do it is to cut down expenditure. A private individual, if he is wise, will live within his income. We have not been living within our means in this State for the past few years. The sooner we set down to tackle that problem the better. In his Budget statement the Minister said:
"The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance has already told the Dáil of the great difficulty which he is experiencing in securing work which, in respect of the requisite labour-content, justify themselves as proper charges on the Employment Schemes Vote."
I want to say something about relief schemes and the dole. Relief schemes administered by the Department of Public Works are costing approximately £1,500,000, and to that can be added another £500,000 contributed from local authorities, and then, as a direct dole to the Department of Industry and Commerce, another £500,000, or, in the aggregate, £3,500,000 spent on work of an unproductive nature. There is no return to the State from that money. For the last seven or eight years this country has been living on a form of artificial prosperity. Some £3,500,000 was spent on these schemes, and on water sewerage and housing schemes under the Department of Local Government. If the expenditure of that money was stopped what would be the position? In spite of that fact we have over 100,000 unemployed.
Comment on this
Some 80,000 people have gone to Great Britain, and compared with 1934 there are 43,000 less engaged on the land.
Comment on this
How is it the position is all right in Northern Ireland? Production in Northern Ireland increased by £6,000,000 while our output has decreased from £62,000,000 to £47,000,000 during that period. A crushing burden of taxation has been imposed on people who are living on the land, on people who are really carrying this country on their backs. When is the Government going to face the responsibilities of remedying that situation? I say that the £3,500,000 spent in that way is a scourge as the money is being wastefully spent.
Comment on this
It has been wastefully spent. Where is the return? I would prefer to see the amount doubled if it was spent on productive work. There would be some return then. There is nothing coming back now.
Comment on this
Where is the financial return? If an individual is running a company, a factory, or a farm and if there is no financial return from the money he invests, how long can he keep going? Is not the position of the State identical? We cannot keep on spending money on non-productive work. Notwithstanding what Deputy Davin thinks, that kind of work is not productive and is a drain on our financial resources.
Comment on this
I am engaged in productive work. I do not know if Deputy Davin is. Any man who works a farm or who produces food that can be sold and exported is engaged on productive work and is an asset to the State. Put more people on the land to engage in productive work.
Comment on this
No. I employ labour, and if the Deputy farms on the same basis as I do, he will be making a move towards a solution of our problems. Does the Deputy approve of the £3,500,000 that is being spent on Defence?
Comment on this
The Deputy thinks that it is wisely and judiciously spent in the interests of the community. I can tell the Deputy this, that the general public believe that it is being foolishly squandered, that it is being wasted, and that it serves no purpose whatever.
Comment on this
It is being squandered by the Government, who are spending over £3,000,000 in a stupid, silly way.
Comment on this
If the Government want to prepare for war, the best way they could prepare for any conflagration in Europe would be to spend the £3,000,000 on agriculture, equip agriculture so that it will be able to go into production and supply food when more food becomes essential. That would be the best way to spend it, not to be spending it stupidly on obsolete forts. We know very well that our ports will be used for sheltering the British Navy and British submarines. Deputy Corry knows Spike Island, and he knows the use it was made of during the war. It was one of the most important bases the British Government had, because it covered the principal food lines extending all over the world.
Comment on this
It will be their base, the point from which they will be able to guard their food routes.
Comment on this
The Finance Bill does not afford an opportunity for re-opening the debate on different Estimates.
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out that this money is being wastefully expended on these forts and, in criticising the Finance Bill, I am suggesting that the money should not be spent in that fashion but could better be devoted to the improvement of agriculture. I do not know what navy we possess——
Comment on this
These were matters which were definitely raised on the Estimate for the Department for Defence and they may not be reopened now.
Comment on this
Speaking generally, I am suggesting that the money that is being uselessly spent in this connection could be more effectively spent on agriculture, in preparation for war.
Comment on this
It does not matter; we do not worry about the people who are going to fight, because we will not be able to stop them from fighting if there is a row on, no matter what money we spend. Then, again, you have the Road Fund being raided to the extent of £150,000 and the unfortunate country people will have to make good that amount. Motor users, people who pay road taxes, contribute to that fund and one would naturally expect it would be spent on the roads. Out of over £1,000,000 contributed to the Road Fund only £600,000 is spent on the roads. The ratepayers have to make five out of every six miles of road and even the one mile in every six is only partly met out of this fund. The agricultural people pay over 80 per cent. of local taxation and no attempt is being made to reduce that burden. Those people are completely ignored under the policy of the Government.
As regards customs duties, the Minister said that last year 38.8 per cent. of our revenue came from customs duties. Is that not an extraordinary tax on the essential commodities that are purchased by our people? Notwithstanding all the new industries that have been started in the country, that figure gives you an indication of what is being done to reduce imports. It is remarkable that the import duties are still yielding 38.8 per cent. of the total revenue. The sugar beet industry has been mentioned, and I was glad to see that Deputy Corry, in a letter that he wrote to the Press last week, put the Minister wise on certain points.
Comment on this
Evidently the Minister did not go to the trouble of finding out certain things. I referred to the sugar beet industry and apparently he took it for granted that I was a member of the executive of the Beet Growers' Association. As a matter of fact, the position is that Deputy Corry and two colleagues, including Senator O'Callaghan, who is the chairman of the Beet Growers' Association, are the people who are running the beet growers and not Deputy Hughes. I am glad that Deputy Corry put the Minister wise, and in another sense I am sorry that he has made him wise to the situation. He was letting the cat out of the bag.
I asked a question of the Minister and he did not go to the trouble of replying. I will repeat it. Is he satisfied, in an industry like the sugar beet industry, which is indirectly subsidised, the consumers having to pay for it, with the financial policy of the company and the actual working of the company? Is he satisfied to allow that company to depreciate its capital in a period of ten years, because its predecessor, Messrs. Lippens, had to do it under their contract here? They had a contract to manufacture sugar in the ten years' period and they had to depreciate their capital. This company is doing the same and they have depreciated their capital by £150,000. If the Government and the company believe there is a future for the industry, I think there is no necessity to depreciate the capital in a period of ten years. It might be done in a period of 20 years and that would make available £75,000 for the growers. I cannot understand why it costs 50 per cent. more to manufacture sugar in this country than in England.
Comment on this
I was told before when I raised it on the Agricultural Estimate that it concerned the Minister for Finance and, if I am not permitted to raise it on this Bill, then I will not be permitted to raise it at all. I am anxious to raise this matter.
Comment on this
The taxpayer has to contribute over a million of money towards the production of sugar. It is shown in that famous table where the Minister tells us that agriculture is benefiting by the Government's policy to the extent of £10,000,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy had an opportunity of dealing with this matter on the General Resolution.
Comment on this
The Minister has been informed with regard to that since, and I am sure he read Deputy Corry's letter putting him wise as to who were the members of the executive of the Beet Growers' Association. For instance, take into consideration Table VIII, (a) (5)—beet sugar industry—and compare that with the voted subsidy in 1931-32 with the year 1939-40. According to this table, agriculture benefits to the extent of £1,050,000.
Comment on this
All I am asking for is some accounting for this amount that appears here. Somebody should be responsible for this money.
Comment on this
Is it in the Finance Bill which is now before us, or is there any provision in the Finance Bill for the beet sugar industry?
Comment on this
There is certainly some return for sugar in the Vote.
Comment on this
I suggest, Sir, that the only way to raise this matter would be in connection with the Resolution concerned.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir, but I was anxious to inform the Minister that he was labouring under a misapprehension in saying that I was a member of the executive of the Beet Growers' Association, and I was also pointing out that, I think, Deputy Corry has put him wise in that regard. Let us hope that that is the last we will hear of that with regard to politicians down the country, so far as that is concerned. At any rate, it is time that taxation should be reduced if there is to be any prosperity in this country, and the sooner that things are done in a business-like way here the better. As I have already stated, the Minister has asked: Where can we effect a reduction? I suggest that the whole bulk of the Vote should be reduced— each and every one of them. I admit that there ought to be a reasonable amount spent on the Government of this country, but it must be remembered that the people who have got to find the money are not able to find it and that they are being put out of production. That is the real problem in this country.
Comment on this
To my mind, Sir, this Budget is very disappointing. I think it may have been a mistake that, now that there is a question of electing a new Leas-Cheann Comhairle, the Minister for Finance himself was not elected to that office. The Minister has asked us what plan we have to reduce taxation, or what we have to put forward with regard to the social services. Well, what plan had Fianna Fáil before the election of 1932? They told us at that time that they would reduce taxation by at least £2,000,000 a year, and they also told us that, as a result of their industrial policy, we would have to send to England and America to bring people back to work in our industries here. They also told us that the farmer here would have a sure home market. Now, I admit that I am not growing wheat, but I would tell the Minister that the reason I am not growing wheat, and the reason that the great majority of people here are not growing wheat is that they are not getting a fair price, and also because their land is being worn out for the want of proper manuring. Then, take the hundreds of thousands of calves that were slaughtered during the régime of the Minister for Agriculture. It is a very strange thing, notwithstanding that, that the Minister for Agriculture can still get people to back him up here in this House.
Comment on this
Well, the Minister for Agriculture is not here, but I will say this: That, down in his own parish, last Sunday night, a lion or a lioness got loose and slaughtered one calf, and about 15 bullets were needed to kill that animal. Now, think of the Minister's policy for the last few years. That is one item. Now, the Minister must know, in his heart and soul, that we were told that this was going to be one of the greatest and most prosperous countries in the world. As a matter of fact, standing on a Fine Gael platform down in that part of the country and listening to the statements of the Fianna Fáil members, I sometimes began to wonder whether I was right or I was wrong, and I often asked myself whether, in view of what was being said, we would ruin the country or make it prosperous. What has happened to-day, however? We can all see what has happened. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance ask us to tell them what solution we have for the problem. I ask them what has become of the solution they had in 1932 when they promised to reduce taxation by at least £2,000,000 a year.
There was another thing that I forgot to mention. In 1932 British tariffs were flung at the Irish farmers overnight, and I remember well being at the fair of New Ross and, when the people went to have their breakfasts there, the price had already gone up. Apart from that, at that particular time, prices were very bad for lambs and other agricultural produce. Those lambs were shipped to Britain, and you had the charge of 10/- a lamb and the overhead charges of 6/2, amounting to 16/2. It is no wonder that the young boys and girls are leaving the land, and it looks to me as if a lot of the "ould ones" are going also. I know, as a matter of fact, that along the Comeragh Mountains, when people were wanting to send their lambs to England——
Comment on this
I presume that the Deputy does not desire to go over the whole history of the economic war?
Comment on this
Well, the Minister for Agriculture talked about the bounty on stall-fed cattle, and I think it is nearly time for the people of this country to wake up to the facts of the case. I am sure that Deputy Corry is an intelligent man, but a gentleman on the other side wants to know whether or not we want to starve the people. We do not. As a matter of fact, we here in this House are getting more than we are earning, but the unfortunate people down through the country are starving. That goes for every Deputy in this House, and I say that it is nearly time to shake hands and try to save the unfortunate people of this country. To use the words of another Deputy, we have been "codding" the people of this country long enough, and the people know that we are "codding" them. I think that Deputy Davin knows that.
Comment on this
Yes, and every time they "cod" the people they succeed in getting more votes. However, Sir, I shall sit down now since I cannot speak on agriculture, and I thank you very much for allowing me to speak as long as I have.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the only speech which was really germane to the Bill was the very practical speech of Deputy Benson. He raised a number of points in relation to the Road Fund, the question of the free importation of films for educational purposes, and the duty-free re-importation of certain films used by amateur cinematographers. I do not propose to deal with all those points at the moment, but I shall communicate with the Deputy as soon as I have looked into the two questions in relation to films which he raised.
With regard to the Road Fund, Deputy Benson was apparently under a misapprehension. I think it was in the year 1935 that the Dáil approved of a proposal which I submitted in the Budget of that year, to the effect that £100,000, collected by way of motor vehicle duties and appropriated to the purposes of the Road Fund, should be transferred to the General Exchequer Account, and used for the general purposes of the Budget. It was found at the end of that year that the out-turn was much better than our anticipations of it had been, so that a large part of the normal expenditure, in fact, all of the normal expenditure, was defrayed out of normal revenue; but, at the same time, there were also considerable commitments in respect of that portion of the export bounties and subsidies for which we had proposed to borrow, and to reduce the borrowings for that account, and, therefore, to reduce the subsequent charges upon the Exchequer, the original decision of the Dáil was given effect to, and £100,000 was transferred from the Road Fund to, as I have said, the general account of the Exchequer. But that only happened in one year. There was another year in which we had the same authority from the Dáil to transfer money from the Road Fund, and that was acted upon, but it was acted upon in the normal course of the year. In the case to which I am referring, the case which is before the Public Accounts Committee, the transfer, I think, was made at the close of, or immediately after the close of, the financial year. The Deputy, apparently because of that, is under the impression that £100,000 is being transferred from the Road Fund every year for the general purposes of the Exchequer. I should like to disabuse him of that impression, because that in fact, is not the case. We have only taken money for the Road Fund whenever such a course has been sanctioned by legislation: sanctioned by such a proposal as is set out in Section 19 of the Bill.
Comment on this
When it is necessary in order to avoid imposing additional taxation, for then I think there is every justification for taking money from the Road Fund. People are under complete misapprehension as to the justification for this fund. When the proposal was first made to tax motor vehicles, in order to make that proposal acceptable to that very small class in the community, the wealthy and the leisured class who were then in a position to own and to run motor cars, the suggestion was thrown out: we are going to tax those vehicles, but the money which we get in taxation is going to be used to improve the roads for your vehicles. Well, now there is no more justification, in my mind, for appropriating the proceeds of motor vehicular taxation to that special category than there is, say, for appropriating the proceeds of the Excise duty on beer for the purpose of improving public houses.
Comment on this
Does the Minister know anything about the cost of the roads at the present time?
Comment on this
Of course, I know a good deal about the cost of the roads, but I am just saying that, to my mind, there is no basic fundamental reason for earmarking one particular tax for a specific purpose than there is for earmarking any other tax for a specific purpose. In fact, there is the objection to that procedure which experience has shown to be well founded in the case of the whole range of all other imposts which are put on in order to raise the revenue necessary to maintain the public services. The proof of that is this: that in the country where this particular system originated, it has been abandoned for some years, and there the proceeds of the tax on motor vehicles are appropriated for the general purposes of the Exchequer.
Comment on this
Of course they have derating there, and that makes all the difference in the world.
Comment on this
They have a number of taxes there which we have not here. But in any event, the system which I am dealing with now originated there, and for sound, practical reasons they have abandoned it.
Comment on this
Immediately the Minister gives us derating he can abandon it here.
Comment on this
I am not proposing that it should be totally abandoned here now, but what I do say is this: that in order to avoid the imposition of taxation upon other commodities perhaps more essential to life than petrol is, or motor transport is, then so far as I am concerned I think that the case for appropriating for general expenditure the proceeds of this tax, which were reserved for a specific purpose, has everything to commend it.
Comment on this
Precisely. "Why the Road Fund at all?" That position is going to come about here one day.
Comment on this
It may be some years from now, but inevitably it is going to come, and I think that it will be for the public good that it should come.
I was saying that the only speech which was really germane to this Bill was the practical speech of Deputy Benson. I do not know whether I should waste the time of the House in dealing with the speeches of, say, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. They seemed very like Monday's cold dinner: merely a rehash of everything that they had said on the general resolution. I think that I dealt very adequately with any points of substance which either of those Deputies made on that occasion. Deputy Dillon, of course, is a preacher of queer inconsistencies. He avowed his faith in what is known as the transfer theory of taxation, the equalitarian theory—take from those who have and give to those who have not. Let us, he said, be poor together or better off together. Let us, he said, approach a common norm of life in which we shall all be equally comfortable and equally happy. Then he proceeds with the same breath to say that if he had his way he would kill the beet scheme and kill the wheat scheme. That comes rather queerly from a Deputy who believes in the principle of equalisation of income, because, after all, what do we do when we promote beet and wheat? First of all, we give our country a certain assurance, an assurance which is not unwelcome in those very critical times. We have got no navy. I am sure no one will contend that we can ever hope to have a navy strong enough to render our overseas communications immune from interruption or the risk of severance in times of war. What then do those two schemes do in the first instance? They safeguard for our people a supply of two essential commodities of life. We can do without a lot of things much more easily than we can do without sugar, and we can certainly do without most things much more readily than we can do without wheat or bread. Those schemes then have, first of all, this general advantage, that if war were to break out in Europe to-morrow, and our supplies of foreign wheat and foreign sugar were to be cut off, we should have the home-grown article to fall back on, to the extent to which the production of that article has not been hampered during the last two years by the sort of speeches to which we have listened here from Deputy Dillon.
Leaving that on one side, what else do we do by means of those things? I suppose the Deputy agrees with me that it is of vital interest to maintain as many people on the land as possible? There will be two views as to what is the best way to do that. I do not hold myself out as being an expert on agriculture. I should be nothing more than candid if I said I knew very little about it. At any rate, there is a school of thought in this country—and, mind you, it is a school of thought which is representative of the majority of the people in this country—which holds very strongly that our general agricultural economy is benefited by the development of the sugar beet in dustry here, and by the fostering of wheat growing, and general tillage. As I say, I am not going to decide one way or the other; it is not my function to do so, but at any rate that belief would seem to be fairly commonly held. Therefore we have this position, that in order to help our people to maintain themselves upon the land according to the ideas and according to the theories which seem to be generally accepted here, we have asked the community as a whole to subsidise two sections of the agricultural community—those who are engaged in beet growing and those who are engaged in wheat growing. In that way we give effect to this principle which Deputy Dillon has admitted he accepts, the principle of utilising the powers of the Legislature and the powers of the Government to transfer, if you like, income from one section of the community to another, income from purposes the utility of which is more open to question than those which are represented by the wheat scheme and the beet scheme. By means of those schemes we have tried to improve the conditions——
Comment on this
Of a very large section of the farming population. Now there is a difference of opinion as to how right we have been; Deputy Dillon has been very emphatic as to what are his views on that matter. The point is that, after all, the Deputy is no more infallible than I am. He may know more about agriculture than I do, but I am not taking him as a judge, and he is not taking me as a judge. We all have to go to one common tribunal in this country, and that is the tribunal represented by the farmers and agricultural labourers of this country, because it is from that section of the community that the Fianna Fáil Government gets the greatest measure of support. They have tried these schemes, and know what these schemes mean to them. In the light of that, I am prepared to say that we ought to do a great deal to foster both wheat growing and sugar beet growing, bearing in mind, of course, that as a Government we have also responsibility to other sections of the people, and that we cannot improve the position of those who are interested in the production of those crops at an exorbitant expense to the rest of the community.
I think that disposes of that portion of Deputy Dillon's speech. He seems to think that the future of this country lies in the development of its export trade, but he was rather unfortunate, I submit, in the examples which he cited. He ultimately came down to this, that our future welfare was going to be determined by our ability to increase our export trade, and that the only industry upon which we could rely to expand our exports would be the agricultural industry. Like Deputy Dillon, I too, feel that we have to expand our agricultural exports. I feel that we must do that in order, as I said before, to compensate ourselves for the loss of externally derived income which results from the fact that we have had, for one reason or another, to realise our investments abroad. If we are to maintain our general economy here, if we are to maintain our existing social services, we have got, by increasing production, to compensate ourselves for the loss of income derived from investments. As I say, bearing in mind that agriculture is our main industry, and that we can produce very much more than we can possibly consume, there seems to me to be, in fact, only one market in which it is possible for us to secure an increased sale of our products on a scale which would be proportionate to our needs. Bearing that in mind, we have got to watch the British market and satisfy the needs of the British market——
Comment on this
——we have also got, in relation to this matter, to bear in mind that the British market is not an unlimited market, that there are other people who have claims on that market as well as ourselves——
Comment on this
——and that there are other people who, in regard to that market, are in a very different position to ourselves. We are a creditor nation in regard to Great Britain. We have to buy from Great Britain in order that she may pay the interest upon our investments with her. The position is somewhat different between Great Britain and certain of our competitors. Great Britain is in the same position with regard to New Zealand as we are in with regard to her. This position then arises, that in order that New Zealand may be able to honour her financial commitments to Great Britain, the New Zealanders must find a place in the British market—I think it will be found that the British are not going to crush out New Zealand just simply for love of Deputy Dillon and the philosophy of life and trade which he expounds here in this House. Therefore, we have always to bear that in mind, even while, as my own view is, we ought to export up to the limit of our productive capacity, after meeting the needs of our own people. It is necessary, undoubtedly, in order to meet some of their needs for the things which we cannot produce here, that we should have a substantial volume of exports. While I believe that there is only one market that can absorb them on an adequate scale, we also have to bear in mind that the capacity of that market to absorb these products, notwithstanding what Deputy Dillon has said, is not unlimited.
Comment on this
It would not be an advantage for us to be a debtor nation to any country. If the Deputy wants to know my view about it, we are in a much better position to maintain our standards of living here and to provide our people with the services they want if we can get these out of the products and the fruits of the labour of other people, as we do when other people are indebted to us. It makes for greater leisure and for easier standards of life here, and no matter what Deputy Belton may think about it, it makes all that difference between the easy, suave conditions of life that exist in most of the country parts of Ireland and such conditions as exist in Manchester, in the Black Country, and in the other industrial centres in England.
Comment on this
I think I have shown at any rate, that it would be regretable if the great experiment which the Government has undertaken should fail, and that is to try, out of our own soil and by the labour of our own people to feed our own people, to supply them with all these articles of food which are necessary for life. That is why I took the opportunity, when replying to the debate on the general resolution, to point out to those who are engaged in these industries how much the people were paying in order that these industries might be maintained. I put it to them that they ought to approach these questions, not from the point of view of their own immediate personal interests—I am not going to say that they should completely submerge them—but that they should bear in mind that the community is doing a great deal in order that these industries should be established here, and that they ought, at any rate, meet the community by being satisfied with a fair and just return for what they themselves put into those industries.
It would be a sad thing for me if a debate upon a financial question, whether a question of the Budget or the Finance Bill, were to take place without a contribution from Deputy Cosgrave, because there is no Deputy in this House who supplies one with such beautiful material for a reply. Deputy Cosgrave professes to be a precisian in regard to this question of public finance. He always begins by the laying down the law, like one of the prophets and then proceeds to take figures and to say: "Now, if that is so, then this ought to be such". But, if a person is going to take up that pose, he at any rate ought to secure himself against the charge either of misquoting or of not being able to understand the figures which he quotes. He opened his attack on the Budget by saying that the present Bill is schemed to collect £32,000,000. I have here the table explanatory of the Budget and it shows that, so far from being schemed to collect £32,000,000, the amount of taxation which we will collect as a result of the provisions of this Bill and the provisions of the existing tax law will be, not £32,000,000 as Deputy Cosgrave suggests, but £26,700,000. I admit that it is a considerable sum, but it is at least 20 per cent. lower than Deputy Cosgrave stated.
Then, having started with the erroneous statement that we proposed to collect £32,000,000 in taxation, the Deputy turned and compared that with the figure for 1931-32, and said there was a difference of £7,000,000. The actual tax revenue collected in 1931-32 was £21,286,000. Undoubtedly, we are collecting £5,414,000 more than we were collecting in 1931-32 by way of taxation. But, in the course of the Budget statement, I was at pains to explain to the House why it was necessary that we should collect this £5,414,000 more this year than in 1931-32. If the House will look at the first 12 items of Table VII—Issues for Supply Services 1938-39—I have taken that year, 1938-39, in order that I may be able to speak as exactly as possible on the matter—they will see there that the Exchequer issues in 1938-39 for these 12 services, which I have called "Social Services Proper" were £9,780,000, as against £4,551,000 for the same services in 1931-32. So that the whole of that £5,414,000 of additional taxation, with the exception of £185,000, is accounted for by the increase in those 12 items of public services which I have classed under the heading "Social Services Proper." If we are taking more from the people in taxation, we are spending an equivalent amount on social services.
Deputy Cosgrave, commenting upon my classification of public services, referred in particular to item 10, which sets out the figures for Miscellaneous Public Health and other Grants and Expenses of Local Government and Public Health and he asked rather facetiously did I regard the payment of the salary of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government as a social service. Of course, as I said, it was a rather facetious remark. If the Deputy really understood the Table, he would have seen that it is not necessary for me to write down item 10 in order to allow for the fact that the salary of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government is included within the figure, because the figures are given for 1938-39 and 1939-40 for the purpose of making the comparison, and in 1931-32 the figure for the then Minister for Local Government (General Mulcahy) and for the then Secretary to that Department, who, I think, was Deputy Seamus Bourke——
Comment on this
Very well. Deputy Bourke was Parliamentary Secretary of that Department at one time.
Comment on this
Not in 1931-32. In any event the Parliamentary Secretary was not included, but the Minister for Local Government was. There is no pretension here in Table VII that we do not include in the cost of social services the cost of administering them. We were at pains indeed to draw the attention of the House and the people to the fact that included in all services is the cost of administering them. We took that cost out and segregated it in a footnote at the end of the Table. If Deputy Cosgrave had been concerned about a matter of that kind he would, if he wanted to make a comparison and to be as exact as he pretended, have made a simple deduction instead of making that finicky point.
I suppose I am unduly flattering the Deputy when I say that broad principles do not inform Deputy Cosgrave's speeches on questions of public finance.
Comment on this
We had a further example when the Deputy dealt with the expenditure on the Gárda Síochána, on the Department of External Affairs, on the Department of the Taoiseach, and the other Departments, and suggested that taking all these we could secure economies extending over £2,000,000, which would enable us to provide additional employment for a considerable number of men. When he was making that point I asked the Deputy if he was really putting that forward as a considered suggestion. We have to look at the matter in a number of ways. Strange as it may seem, we are not responsible for the present scales either for the Gárda Síochána or the Civil Service. We have made no significant changes in the general format of Civil Service scales of pay or of the Gárda Síochána. We inherited them from our predecessors.
Comment on this
I am talking about the scales. They stand as we inherited them from our predecessors. As far as the Civil Service is concerned, while there has been an expansion, I think I could say that 90 per cent. of the personnel was there when we came into office. There has been in certain Departments an expansion in numbers, due to the increased activity and the increasing value which, I believe, these Departments are giving the community. In regard to the Gárda Síochána, I do not think we have increased the strength of the Gárda by 3 per cent. But there has been considerable increase in the cost of the Guards, an increase of almost 12½ per cent. How does that increase arise? It arises because we inherited the scales of Gárdaí pay that were laid down by our predecessors. When they were maintaining this force they were paying the Guards at a lower rate; since then the expense every year for serving Guards has gone up by the amount of the increments laid down in the scales. The same applies to the Civil Service. We inherited a Civil Service for which these scales had been laid down, and 90 per cent. of the civil servants accepted service here on scales laid down by our predecessors. In the case of those who were transferred officers we had scales laid down from £100—I am only dealing with two of the larger classes; I am not dealing with those at the top.
Comment on this
They form so small a proportion of the whole that they do not have any significant effect on the cost of the Civil Service. The great bulk of the Civil Service is as we found, represented by the lower grades. In the case of the Junior Executive Officers in the transferred class we inherited a scale rising from £95 to £380 per annum with bonus. That is the case of those who were transferred officers. In the case of those who joined since 1923 we inherited scales ranging from £90, for women and unmarried men, to £250, and ranging in the case of married men from £90 to £350. In the case of clerical officers the scales range from £57 to £237 in the case of men who were transferred male officers, and from £60 to £150 in the case of unmarried men and new entrants, that is of post-1923 entry, and from £70 to £200 in the case of married men. Every year in respect of 90 per cent. of the Civil Services, due to circumstances which were not of our creation, and not within our control, the cost of the Civil Service has been rising. I am not using that argument in order to make the case that the principle of allowing an annual increment for zealous and efficient service should not be given effect to. I am merely citing the failure to show that in that large range of services which Deputy Cosgrave put forward, there is no room for the economies which he suggested could be made—except we make them in one of two ways. We can either dismiss some of the civil servants, or we can reduce their scales of salary.
Comment on this
We can reduce the salaries of these civil servants or, as I say, dismiss some civil servants or Guards, or some of the officers and men of the Army, or we can reduce their scales of pay.
Comment on this
There are 30,000 more civil servants now than when you came in.
Comment on this
There was an addition of about 10 per cent. There were 12,000, excluding the Post Office and the industrial employees. There are 12,000 more in the Post Office, and that made a total of about 24,000 civil servants all told. But Deputy Brennan has told us —and it is typical of the sort of language used throughout the country— that we have recruited 30,000 since we came into office. We have not done anything of the kind. I believe the total personnel in the Civil Service, including those who are Post Office employees and part-time Post Office employees, is about 25,000 or 26,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy can get that information by putting down a parliamentary question. At the moment I propose to go on with my speech. I want to treat Deputy Cosgrave's words more seriously, and give them more consideration that he appears to have done. I asked him, when he was suggesting that we could make economies on the branches of the public service to which I have referred, whether he was putting this forward as a considered suggestion, and he assured me he was. He waved in my face four or five typed sheets and said he would not have gone to the trouble of putting down his figures unless he had thought all these matters out. If the Deputy does sincerely believe that he can make economies in these branches of the public service, he can only do it in one or other of two ways. He either proposes to reduce the personnel of the Civic Service and the Gárda and the Army—that is, he proposes to dismiss serving officers in all of these services— or else he proposes to reduce the scales of pay and the emoluments which the officers of these services already enjoy. That comes very strangely from Deputy Cosgrave, particularly when it is applied to the Guards.
In 1933, we introduced a Bill to enforce certain economies in the public services. I had great difficulty in getting that Bill through this House particularly because of the provisions relating to the pay of the Gárda. The Bill went to the Seanad and certain amendments were made in it there. When it came back to this House I had to acquiesce in these amendments made in the Seanad because Deputy Cosgrave and the Labour Party were in a position to influence by their votes legislation in this House. The Labour Party then happened to be in a position very strongly to affect legislation in this House. As it was I had to submit to the virtual abandonment of the Bill. I had to do that in the light of the opposition offered to the Bill by those very Deputies who at the moment are clamouring that we should cut down public expenditure upon these services.
Comment on this
The Public Economies Bill of 1933. Not only did Deputies in 1933 oppose any economies in the public service but we had something of a like nature before the General Election of 1938. Deputy Cosgrave has told us about the economies that he would make in order to obviate the need for putting taxation upon the people. In May of 1938, Deputy Cosgrave helped to defeat the Government upon a proposal which if accepted would have meant that the control of expenditure upon the Civil Service would have been taken out of the hands of the Government entirely and vested in an independent arbitration tribunal whose decisions would have had to be accepted by the Government of the day. I wonder what would be the position of our people if we had accepted Deputy Cosgrave's point of view in regard to that very critical matter. What would have happened if the demands of the Civil Service had been referred to an arbitration board and this Government had been tied hand and foot by the decision of that board? The Government would have had to come to the House, not alone to ask Deputies to increase the rate of existing taxation so as to make good a deficiency of £1,160,000 in the public revenue, but on top of that to ask them to tax the people further, to tax their tea and sugar and even put another 6d. on the income tax in order to give effect to a decision of the arbitration tribunal which Deputy Cosgrave and his Party voted for in 1938. When this issue was before the House on another occasion—and it was an issue which did vitally affect the question of public expenditure—Deputy Cosgrave took up the attitude that the Minister for Finance, who, as he told the House to-day, should scrutinise very carefully every penny piece of expenditure, should not be able even to look at or question the decision which would be handed down to him from the arbitration tribunal, but should have to rush off to the Dáil to ask it to provide him with the wherewithal to honour the award. That was the position of Deputy Cosgrave just 12 months ago. It suits his book to get up here, having clamoured for additional expenditure and make a purely factitious case for economy in the public services. So far as expenditure on them is concerned the services to which he referred are incapable of reduction except in one of two ways, either by dismissing personnel or reducing remuneration. If that issue were put to Deputy Cosgrave and he had the responsibility, I am sure he would say, as I have had to say, that a contract of service has been made with the Civil Service and the Gárda and the officers and men in the Army and it cannot be broken except in dire need. "Stringent and straitened" though the position is it is not such that I believe we would be justified in refusing to honour the commitments into which our predecessors entered with the great bulk of the public servants. We have accepted that and we propose to honour it. I do not think there is anything more I need say on the matter.
Comment on this
Last year on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill an amendment was moved by Deputy Costello with regard to a particular case of persons living outside the country but who come here during certain periods and who are liable to income tax. I am sure the Minister will recollect the case, as it was taken up with his Department since. He promised to consider the matter. What does he propose doing? The Minister can have the reference if he wishes. It is in Volume 72, col. 920. Although the Minister expressed great sympathy I do not think he took any steps to deal with the matter. Does he propose to deal with it before we reach the Committee Stage?
Comment on this
Well, I have been talking to Commissioner Carey on that matter, and he informs me that the matter is under consideration but that it is full of difficulties. I cannot undertake, therefore, to have an amendment inserted in time for the Committee Stage of this Bill.
Comment on this
Would the Minister be able to make a statement in connection with that matter on the Committee Stage so that it would then be open to the Opposition to put in an amendment for the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I had intended to put it down for this day week, Sir, but I understand, from Deputy Dillon, that there is a possibility of amendments to certain sections being put down; and if, after consideration of what I was able to say, it is still considered necessary to put down these amendments, I am prepared not to take the Committee Stage on Wednesday, but I should like to say that I should prefer to take it on Wednesday.