Land Bill, 1938—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–123 of 242. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 46 of 1938 ›
The Land Commission had, I understand, a number of schemes in course of preparation for the distribution of land when the Potterton and Maher cases were tried, and when the adverse decisions were given against them those schemes were held up. I should be glad if the Minister would indicate whether the schemes will be taken up by the Land Commission at the stage where they were left off, or whether the preliminary examinations will have to take place all over again, whether the usual notices will have to be served upon the land owners, and the usual length of time given for objections and appeals. This, of course, will make a great deal of difference in districts where no land division has been carried out up to the present. I am aware that the schemes were in an advanced stage; in fact they were so far advanced that the applicants had had their claims considered and the decisions taken as to whether they were to get land or not. It only needed the final signature or decision of the Land Commission to have those holdings distributed.
Section 30 of the Bill authorises the Land Commission to give housing assistance to persons where tithe rent charges are payable, but only in cases, I take it, where an addition has been given to such holdings. It is quite obvious that it is the correct thing to have housing assistance given in such cases. I am sure the powers given to the Land Commission will be welcomed by those people, and that it will be found more economical to erect houses at the old homesteads. There are solid foundations in the haggards and yards, and they are usually well sheltered. I do not find that in any of the Land Acts the Land Commission has power to make advances for housing or other improvements in the case of freeholds where tithe rent charges are being paid. I should be glad if the Minister would have this matter examined with a view to seeing whether it is possible to include in this section of the Bill an authorisation to the Land Commission to grant housing assistance to such people in freeholds where tithe rent charges are being paid.
In conclusion, I am satisfied that this Bill will ensure the smooth running of the Land Commission machinery. During the past few years we have had very many obstacles placed in the path of the Land Commission—perhaps I should say that many obstacles crept into the path of the Land Commission in their efforts to expedite the acquisition of land for distribution amongst the people. I hail this Bill as a measure that goes whole-heartedly to remove all those obstacles and impediments which lie in the way of the speedy land division.
Comment on this
This is an unusual Bill in many respects. In nearly all cases in which a measure is introduced into this House, there is a principle involved. There is no principle involved in this measure at all, unless I am very much mistaken. It is, more or less, a corrective of a series of other clauses, clarification clauses, I would not say new principles, but new systems, changing systems, and so on. It lacks one particular thing which the Minister has been pressed more than once in this House to consider, and in reference to which the Minister for Finance, speaking in the Seanad on the 22nd March last, said:
"Therefore, as Minister for Finance, who is concerned with the question of—or, at any rate, who is very often made responsible for—the provision or non-provision, not merely of credit for agriculturists, but of credit for every other section of the community, prima facie, I am in favour of security of tenure because it does mean, if effective, that credit will be made available at more favourable terms.”
In the course of an investigation of banking, credit, currency and other matters of that sort, the land purchase code came under observation by the Banking Commission. They were perhaps more informative in their report than ever the Minister has been in this House, because they inquired into the policy—if such a term can be applied to the functions—of the Land Commission. For more than one decade, possibly for two or three, the question of dealing with untenanted land for the purpose of relieving congestion was the main function of the Land Commission. In the course of the Banking Commission Report they present a figure showing the number of persons who are seeking land. They arrived at a total of approximately 500,000, made up of 250,000 persons who are at present in uneconomic holdings, and 250,000 which included labourers or persons employed on lands which are likely to be taken over and persons who have claims as being evicted tenants, landless men and so on. They pursued their inquiries in connection with what has been done by the Land Commission. In a paragraph in their report towards the end of their reference to this whole question, they show a variation in the manner in which land has been distributed. While it was the practice, if not the principle, to deal more with uneconomic holders up to a few years ago, it now appears that the percentage is going rather towards landless men than uneconomic holders. In the course of their examination of this problem they took up not only this question, but the whole question of the economy of agriculture. They considered and went to some pains to examine and get opinions upon the general question of agricultural economy in the country.
Some years ago here—I think it was on the occasion of the introduction of the 1933 Act—the late Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Hogan, dealt with that at some length. He pointed out that while on its face a very good case could be made for having a great number of small holdings, so far as agricultural economy itself is concerned it would be a very serious mistake to let your operations in that connection result in disturbing or breaking up all the large farms. He gave as his reason for that that the owners of these farms were the persons largely interested in the better quality of stock of all kinds, and said that from his own experience as Minister he was aware of that as were most people who had made a study of it. I have some figures here in connection with that. In 1935 the percentage of enlargements was 53.1 and new holdings 46.9. In 1936, enlargements had gone down by 10 per cent. to 43.5 and new holdings had gone up to 56.5. In 1937, enlargements had gone down to 35.2 and new holdings had gone up to 64.8. The problem, as I understand it, which faced the late Mr. Hogan in 1922-23 was that question of uneconomic holdings. They were already there. In so far as the operations of the Land Commission are concerned their main purpose was to deal with that problem. If it is not dealt with, and if the figures bear any relation to the true facts of the case which I have given, namely, 250,000 cases of that kind—I do not believe, however, that that figure is correct; it is an exaggerated figure, but it was given by the Banking Commission——
Comment on this
It probably would. I would say that the figure would be a little over 100,000, if so many. The commission which sat under the chairmanship of Lord Dudley in the early years of this century got a figure at that time of approximately 80,000. Having regard to the fact that some of these 80,000 must have been dealt with, it is unlikely that there would be more than 100,000 cases which would fall to be dealt with, and of that number it is more than likely that not much more than half could be efficiently and economically dealt with by reason of geographical and other conditions. However, that is the problem. In so far as the operations of the last few years are concerned it appears that the disposition has been to create new holdings rather than to deal with that problem, which the whole scheme of the distribution of land was inaugurated to deal with. We have that on the one hand, and then we have the uncertainty with regard to the occupation of land by the present holders who have purchased under the Land Purchase Acts. That question has not been dealt with.
This Bill certainly suffers from one serious infirmity. The Minister, I think, has scarcely ever put before the House lines of policy for the Land Commission. We have simply devised legislation to the best of our ability, and it is a very difficult proceeding, one which would require a person almost to be a lawyer and an agriculturist as well. Then we hand over whatever we have done to the Land Commission and tell them to work it. When they say after awhile that this section is unworkable or that that section requires to be amended, the Minister comes along and says, "I want these sections amended because the Land Commission requires it." We have no policy so far, except the policy I have indicated by the figures I have given to the House.
There are two paragraphs in the Banking Commission report dealing with security of tenure—No. 509 and No. 510. It is unnecessary to read them. They go, at any rate, in this direction: they say that unless there is security of tenure banks will not be disposed to give credit to agriculturists. But there is a worse feature even than that. Agriculturists themselves will not be disposed to sink their capital in the holdings unless there is security or, at any rate, some degree of stability about the holdings when they have done it. More than half of those at present engaged in agriculture have sufficient capital. The other half, unfortunately, have not. In so far as any action that we take here makes the situation more difficult for these 125,000 occupiers of land, then anything we do to make it more difficult for them in these difficult times is not good business.
It may be that one can point occasionally with a certain amount of satisfaction to the numbers who have got new holdings. That question raises quite a number of queries. The number of allottees from 1932 to 1937 was something like 40,000. We take it that it is the Lay Commissioners who selected these people and put them on the land. Giving the commissioners credit for having all the virtues and none of the vices, is that not rather a tall order for them, notwithstanding any advice they may get from every source possible? They are men who are in their offices from year's end to year's end and they take the advice of this inspector and that inspector. Even if they get suitable and hardworking men for these holdings, these men may be hampered by the fact that they have not got capital. The information at the disposal of the commission was that these men had from £200 to £500. Assuming they had not all the information, this whole scheme, no matter who speaks in favour of it, is an expensive one.
The Banking Commission states that there has been added to the deadweight debt of this country, by reason of the operation of the distribution of land, a sum of approximately £5,000,000 during the last few years. In addition to that, we have year after year, as the commission reports, an increasing sum being expended on estates and on improvements. From 1923-1924 up to 1926 £4,000,000 was spent in that way. It should be the responsibility in conscience of Ministers and Deputies to see whether or not the State is getting value for the money, to see whether every possible precaution has been taken to ensure that it not only gets value but that those who have got land are persons who required help. Let us take as an example two individuals, one who has not sixpence, but is a hardworking man, who is going to be thrown out of employment by reason of the fact that an estate is broken up. He applies and gets a holding. Assume that another man has £250, and that he may have £750 as well, making £1,000 in all, the House has not got any information as to whether a person in that position would be regarded as a satisfactory allottee. Supposing that man had £1,000 capital, are we in conscience right in supporting the expenditure of State money on behalf of a person in that position? I have doubts about it. I think that a person worth £1,000 should be able to buy a farm. If, by reason of the precautions taken in connection with the Land Acts, we are supplying land and holdings to persons in that position, is it not like taking a doctor's son out of Fitzwilliam Square and letting him in as tenant of a flat at 6/6 a week, the State paying £28, and the corporation, perhaps, another £30 in order to provide it? So far as the House is concerned it has got no information about the matter. The only answer given is that the Land Commission is charged with responsibility.
The Minister also tells us that there is no political interference, and that, as far as the law is concerned it does not allow any interference in this business. Is this Bill as urgent as the Minister would lead us to believe? According to the report of the Banking Commission there were some 600,000 acres available for distribution in 1936, or whenever the report was written. The average distribution is somewhat less than 100,000 acres. The largest distribution that ever took place was in 1935, when 97,000 acres were distributed. On that basis there is sufficient land acquired for distribution for six years.
Comment on this
It is not in hand. If it were not for the impediments it might or might not have been got. That is the total amount of land.
Comment on this
It may be that my recollection of what I read in the report is wrong, but I thought it said that 600,000 acres were available.
Comment on this
Not in hand. That is land which might be expected but only a fraction of it is in the hands of the Land Commission. There are about 60,000 acres, I understand, in hand.
Comment on this
That means that land for a year's operations is available. Assuming that we take the figures the Minister gave, is there anything to prevent the Land Commission for the next six months getting the six Land Commissioners together to sign these documents? In difficult circumstances we do some very difficult things if that is the only obstacle. I say that for six months the Minister would be well advised to tell the six Commissioners that they will have to do this, until he sees what has been done. Surely the Minister will agree to that if persons are getting land at present who could afford to buy it.
Comment on this
I hope not, but it strikes me as likely in some cases. Although this Bill has 58 sections, it does not deal with the question of security of tenure. It brings us back to the Act of 1933, which entitles a person to be left in possession of a holding worth £2,000. He may be given an alternate holding. If he works it well they must leave him there or give him a holding of equivalent value elsewhere. I think that is the law. Would the Minister go into that question with some of those who have larger holdings? It is worth it, because a small holding to a man accustomed to doing business in a big way is of no use. If there be anything in what the former Minister for Agriculture said in connection with these big farms, and the better quality of stock on them, it is a nice consideration as to whether, with their disappearance, the quality of our live stock which has earned its own reputation, not only here, but in all parts of the world, is going to suffer by reason of that. Notwithstanding the considerable distribution of land which has taken place since 1923-24, there were fewer persons employed on the land last year and the year before than six or seven years ago.
There is another aspect to which the Banking Commission Report referred and it is this, that assuming you have 250,000 applicants, with all the steps that are going to be taken, at best you can provide only 10 per cent. or 20 per cent. with land. It is also stated in the report, and it stands to reason, that the provision of holdings for that 10 or 20 per cent., through the taxation of the other 80 per cent. or 90 per cent. who want land, and will not get it— because it is not there—will make their position, by reason of the costly proceedings, be worse than before. In the normal course when you see so many applications for land how many will get any? The last case of those who are looking for it will be worse, while the idea of making it possible for those who have land to employ more people, and to provide regular occupation for them, will not be realised. It is a most desirable thing to see new holdings, but the question arises can we afford them? I will not give an expression of opinion on that, but I will take the opinion of those who were selected by the Government to examine this question. The view of the majority is that we cannot afford it as it is too expensive, and not only that, but that by reason of the operation of the Land Acts as they stand it is made more difficult for the very much larger number of people engaged in agriculture to carry on the industry.
This Bill is objectionable to persons who take a considered view that there should be maximum security for those in occupation of land. They do not say to be in occupation of land, irrespective of the use to which they put it. They do say that where persons work it to the best of their ability and get value out of it, they should have that security. It is not impossible to harmonise the acquisitiveness of the Land Commission with the desire, the necessity, for dealing with the other cases.
I think the Minister ought to withdraw the Bill and see whether it would not be possible to get agreement on that point. It is desirable that there ought to be the maximum support and co-operation for a measure of this kind. There are parts of the Bill with which I disagree; there are parts of it with which I agree. Within the last two years I brought under the Minister's notice one special case. I do not represent a rural constituency and those cases of complaint, if there are any, may not always come to the surface. I think the Minister would not stand over injustice to persons, whether they are in occupation of land or not. It is our duty, so far as membership of this House is concerned, to hold the balance evenly between the citizens and distribute justice in accordance with equitable principles.
This measure is giving almost unlimited power to the Land Commission. Once they get it, we cannot sit in judgment upon them as to how it should be made operative. They will say, "We are merely carrying out the law." It is our duty to see that no power, other than that which is absolutely necessary, should be given. In my opinion, there is too much power given in this Bill, and I could not support it as it stands.
Comment on this
I agree with the point of view which has been expressed in connection with this Bill, that it is largely a machinery Bill, and introduces no new principle so far as our land legislation is concerned. But that in itself does not make the Bill objectionable, if the purpose of it is to remove obstacles to the acquisition of land which have been made possible by the mass of legal jargon which has surrounded our land legislation. I think we have to take our stand on the basic principle is land division desirable and necessary, or is it not? Do we want to continue a situation where we have large ranches in the midst of poverty-stricken cottiers who are unable to get grass for a cow, or do we want to use our large ranches for the purpose of settling thereon as many people, in relatively comfortable circumstances, as the land, and its reasonable proximity to the markets which require our produce, make possible?
I think that, faced with a choice of that kind, anybody who desires to maintain the stability of our agricultural position, and who desires to ensure as high a measure of prosperity for our agricultural workers as we can give them, will have no hesitation in deciding that the only sane and sensible policy in circumstances of that kind is to plank for the policy of the acquisition and division of large holdings. We know that in this country we have a very serious emigration problem. In the ten years from 1926 to 1936 we exported 165,000 of our people, although during that period the increase of births over deaths was represented by the figure of 162,000. In those ten years, not only did we export what is regarded as the normal increase of population in every country in the world, but we threw a few thousands in addition into the emigrant ship.
Comment on this
And while the Party with which you now sit was in office, they closed down many industries during that period.
Comment on this
If Deputy Belton went through the country when he was not in that Party, and if he saw the derelict mills and factories, he would have no hesitation in saying that they gave colour to the views he expressed at that time.
Comment on this
What is the use of talking? Do we not know quite well, and has not the complaint been voiced by many Deputies, that during the period in which Deputy Dillon now apparently takes so much pride, and in which others under new circumstances and with new affiliations take pride, there was absolute industrial stagnation? But that is aside from the purpose of this discussion and I do not imagine the Chair will allow me to ramble from the subject-matter.
Comment on this
I appreciate how handy he is sometimes when I hear Deputy Belton speaking. At any rate, we are presented here with the problem of whether we can afford to continue to export the most virile of our manhood and womanhood, or try to break up the ranches in the rural areas and settle on them as many families as possible. Every sensible person concerned with the well-being of the nation will insist that the policy of the Government, no matter what its political complexion may be—and I think a matter of this kind transcends all Party affiliations— should be to continue the policy of breaking up the ranch lands and settling on them as many people as possible. We are a small nation, with approximately 3,000,000 people. We are exporting more people than the increase of births over deaths indicates, according to official records, and we are the one white nation in the world which is losing its population.
In a situation of that kind, is there anybody, other than a person who is interested in the preservation of vested interests, prepared to say that we should allow a drift of that type to continue and not avail of opportunities presented to us to try to induce our people to remain on the land in their own country? One of the ways in which we can correct the tendency of our people to emigrate is by offering them inducements to remain on the land. What inducement is there offered to two or three young men, from 20 to 25 years of age, sons of a farmer who has 20 acres, to continue to remain in rural Ireland when they know that the only prospect before them is, perhaps, employment on a rotational relief scheme for three or four days a week, or the kind of casual employment to be got in agriculture for a few weeks or months?
There is no inducement to remain there, and there is less inducement because of the fact that we are situated close to an industrial nation which is a substantial outlet for the brawn which Irish people can afford to sell in the markets of unskilled labour throughout that country. One of the ways in which we can correct that tendency to emigrate, and correct the appalling depopulation of our rural areas, is by breaking up the untenanted ranch lands, lands often owned by absentee landlords, and settle thereon as many families as it is possible to sustain in our agricultural economy.
Comment on this
I say that, at any rate, we have by no means reached the limits of our ability to divide land, and I suggest that if Deputy Gorey, in the course of some of his hunting expeditions in County Kildare, would survey the lands that are available there for distribution, if he would take notice of the way these lands are being used, or rather not being used, he himself would say, as a practical farmer, that it would be very much better if these lands were divided than to leave them as they are at the moment.
Comment on this
I know, of course, that there is only a certain amount of land in the country and that, once you reach a certain point, there would be no more land left to divide unless you could rail in the sea, but I also know that we have by no means reached the end of our resources in the matter of land acquisition.
Comment on this
The trouble is that the Deputy speaks about so many things, of which he professes to know everything, that in the end it generally transpires that he knows nothing. However, as I was about to say, I think that one of the ways in which we can correct the tendency to emigrate is by keeping the people on the land and making occupation on the land as attractive as possible for them. I do not say that the giving of a holding to every person is going to make life in rural Ireland attractive when, every day in the week, through the medium of the moving picture, newspapers, and various other agencies, life in other countries, and particularly in English-speaking countries, is held out to be much more attractive and alluring. Nevertheless, I say that if you can manage to anchor as large a number of people as possible on the land here, you do ensure that the tendency to emigrate will not be as great as in the case when, as it is at present, they can pack up their worldly goods in a two-and-sixpenny fibre case and take the next train to some industrial city in England in order to scour that industrial city in the hope that they can manage to get employment as unskilled labourers at any rates that their brawn can command.
We have, of course, in the country —and I see it particularly in my own constituency—very substantial holdings of untenanted land, of 300, 400 and 500 acres, used in a rather perfunctory manner for ranching purposes, and used very indifferently even for ranching purposes, with the owner in many cases probably not living in the country, and probably not having lived in the country for 20 years or so; and yet, side by side with that, you have a whole lot of penniless, poverty-stricken cottiers wondering where they will get the next week's work or when they will be able to induce the board of health to give them a few shillings a week to sustain them and their families until such time as work might arrive. That is not good agricultural economy, and I think that good agricultural economy would demand that, in circumstances of that kind, we ought to take the land from such ranchers who are wastefully using their 200 or 300 acres of land, and divide that land up amongst as many of these impoverished cottiers as possible.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy seriously say that there are several 500 acre farms in County Kildare, the owners of which have been living abroad for the last 20 years?
Comment on this
Well, I should like the Minister to give us some particulars in regard to that when he is replying.
Comment on this
I have directed the attention of the Land Commission to dozens of these cases, and I must confess to Deputy Dillon that I am thoroughly disappointed with the slothfulness of the Land Commission in proceeding with the acquisition and division of lands of that kind.
Comment on this
No, because the Deputy does not represent that constituency, but I can tell him that, if he goes down there, he will have no hesitation in realising that those lands are there. If he does not believe me, he can put down a Parliamentary question with a view to getting the information from the Minister.
Comment on this
Maybe so, but who can possibly defend a position where you have a large holding of that kind, improvidently and uneconomically used, and at the same time, situated around it, a substantial number of impoverished cottiers who are unable to get work, who are unable to get grass for a cow, and who are unable to get anything like regular employment? On a holding of 300 acres of land I hold that it is possible to settle, relatively—and I use the word "relatively" advisedly —approximately ten families. Is it not better that these ten families should be settled on such a 300-acre ranch rather than be compelled to exist in circumstances such as I have described? I cannot imagine how any Deputy here, who is concerned with solving the problem, and who looks at the problem objectively as distinct from his vested interests, can possibly defend a policy of leaving untouched the uneconomically used grass lands in this country while you have competent landless agricultural workers craving for an opportunity to operate their abilities on the grass lands that are at present held by ranchers of that type.
I do not mean to suggest, of course, that the only way in which you can divide land is by taking, for instance, a 300-acre farm and settling thereon about ten families. There is another way. Perhaps this is an issue upon which Deputy Dillon may agree with me. I do not think that it is always desirable to break up a large holding and parcel it out among a number of persons who, although they are agricultural workers and impoverished, may not be able to use the land, so divided, to the utmost advantage. I should like to see some experiments carried out by the State, under State supervision and under the direction of the people competent to give directions in the matter, by way of testing out the co-operative development of land in this country. It might be very much better for us in certain cases, and, when we think we have the right material, the most suitable land and other favourable factors present, it might be better, instead of dividing up a 300-acre holding and settling thereon, let us say, ten families, as individual holders, to settle them thereon as a co-operative undertaking and encourage those families to work the land co-operatively under Governmental direction. Such an experiment would enable us to ascertain whether or not it is better to work the holdings co-operatively in those circumstances than to hand them over to individual owners.
Comment on this
I can tell Deputy Dillon that, long before he ever sat on those benches over there, that was advocated by Labour Deputies.
Comment on this
Yes, before Stalin's time, and even before Deputy Belton had changed around to the number of Parties he has been in.
Comment on this
At any rate, I think there is considerable merit in operating a substantially-sized holding on a co-operative basis. It has been done in other countries. Deputy Belton, probably, will say: "Yes, in Russia." I understand that it has been done in Russia, but it has also taken place in other countries than Russia, such as the Scandinavian countries, and in the Scandinavian countries the experiments carried out have been marked by a very high degree of success. Now, our development in arts, crafts and sciences has not yet reached such a pinnacle as that we can afford to disregard the experiments of other countries in such matters, no matter what the political ideologies of these new countries may be.
Comment on this
I believe that one of the best ways of inculcating a spirit of independence in our people is to give them the ownership of their homesteads, because no matter how adversity may cross their paths, that, at least, will be a rallying place for them. The home has always been a substantial rallying place for the Irish people. There are advantages, I think, in co-operative farming. It enables the farm to be used comprehensively. It is possible, by the use of large areas of land on the basis of co-operative farming, to introduce tractors, reapers and binders, a thing you cannot do on a 20 or 30 acre holding. Besides, the operation, as a corporate unit, of a substantial holding would enable seeds, manures, implements and the various other requisites for agricultural pursuits to be purchased on much more favourable terms than it is possible to purchase them if the ability to purchase is related to income or to the skill of the small individual holder. I would urge, therefore, that the Minister who used to be a radical—possibly, free from the cares and machinery of office he would revert to his former status—should try to impregnate the Land Commission with a little of his earlier radicalism. Believe me, even if the Land Commission could get 99 per cent. of the Minister's radicalism it would reduce its conservatism by 1 per cent. I think it is necessary for some Minister, at some time, to make a stand and say: "Well, this is a field of activity which I would like to see explored and exploited."
I would like to see the present Minister who has commendable industry and enthusiasm for what he thinks is right, requiring the Land Commission to carry out some experiments in co-operative farming in this country so that we could know the results. It may be said that it does not suit our temperament. It may be said that the individualistic tendencies of our people are such that you cannot overcome their prejudices against anything in the nature of co-operative farming or communal enterprise. One has only to go to the country to realise how deeply ingrained is individualism in our people. Nevertheless, I suggest that it is well worth while, whether our people lend themselves temperamentally and vocationally to co-operative farming or not, carrying out an experiment of this kind, thereby giving to the House and to the nation generally the results of such an experiment. After all, we established four or five industrial alcohol factories within the past few years, and there is not one of them working now.
Comment on this
And if I would not be accused of infringing the copyright of the Minister for Finance, one might describe them now as "five gloriously white elephants." It is not likely that they will ever operate in this country unless the value of agricultural produce is so low that the farmer will be prepared to take almost any price for his potatoes.
Comment on this
I am drawing this comparison, though I do not intend to dwell on it in this Bill. I am drawing the comparison that if we can spend hundreds of thousands of pounds on industrial alcohol factories, then I say, let us spend a few hundred pounds in making an experiment more closely associated with the traditions and outlook of our people, namely, co-operative farming instead of entering into the domain of industrial exploitation in which we have no tradition and in which the best paid jobs are given not to our own people, but to people that we have to bring from another country. I do not believe that an experiment, even on a large scale, in the case of co-operative farming in this country, could possibly bring us the ghastly results that have been associated with industrial alcohol production in this country.
Comment on this
I propose to pass from them now, having quietly laid a wreath on the grave of five of them. In the course of the discussion on this Bill the question of the farmer's security of tenure has been raised. I profess a complete inability to understand the point of view of those who expressed themselves on that. I cannot see any insecurity of tenure in the case of the man who farms his land in a beneficial way from a national point of view. Any persons in the country who own even a substantial sized holding, and there are members of this House who are the owners and occupiers of such holdings, know perfectly well that their security is unquestioned once the holding is used in the national interest and in accordance with some kind of ordered national policy. I think, however, that the case can be made that many farmers in the country are unable to get the credit facilities which they require. That is not because of the fear of insecurity. It is because the banks have been bitten badly on the policy they adopted of shovelling out money in 1917, 1918 and 1919—at a time when they thought that the last War was going to be another Seven Years' War. On that assumption, they proceeded to shovel out money to people for the purchase of farms at artificially high prices. The banks have now reacted from that situation, so that the position to-day is that a burglar is as welcome in a bank as a farmer. That is not due to any legislation which was passed through this House. It is the natural revulsion of the banks against the policy of imprudence which they adopted towards the end of the European war and immediately after. They have reacted from that position now, so that a man can get no money on his holding. Here is where I quarrel with the Government: that, realising what the policy of the banks is on this matter, they ought to establish some kind of credit facilities for farmers who use their land economically. I think it is the Government's duty to do that. That is not done by the machinery of the Agricultural Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
The Minister for Lands does not deal with credit nor with the Agricultural Credit Corporation.
Comment on this
I am afraid that is a very severe ruling if you take the position that you find in any parish in the country. There you have thousands of the best agriculturists in the world all bursting to be able to buy seeds and manures to exploit their land and with nobody to give them seeds and manures. They hold their land from the Land Commission. Surely, the Minister for Lands has some responsibility for lubricating a situation of that kind, and of enabling those people to go and exploit their land, seeing that, unless they do so, they cannot pay the Minister their annuities. In any case I do not pretend to invade that domain too deeply beyond saying to the Minister, and appealing to his latent radical instincts, that he ought to try to induce the Government to do for farmers who use their land prudently and economically what the banks will not do for them, and what that effete machine, known as the Agricultural Credit Corporation, will not do for them, unless their financial circumstances are such that anybody will lend them money. The point of view was noticeable in Deputy Dillon's speech last night that there should be security for almost everybody who holds land, irrespective of how he uses it, or whether it is necessary for his requirements or not. I want to be frank on that matter, and to say that personally I do not believe that a rancher with 400 or 500 acres of land, using it imprudently and improvidently, should be given security on his holding if, in the national interests, it is possible to acquire that holding from him on the basis of fair compensation, and to settle on the holding as many families as can economically be settled there.
Comment on this
I would give fixity of tenure to every farmer in the country who required the land for his own personal needs, ascertained by some previously agreed standard, and to any person who held a very substantial holding so long as that land was being used in the national interests and not wastefully for ranching purposes.
Comment on this
I am not being converted at all. Those men to whom the Deputy now refers have no fixity of tenure at present.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not had the heartbreaking experience, in a big ranching county, of trying to get the Land Commission to acquire holdings of land that are improvidently and uneconomically used to-day, and of hearing from the Land Commission that they do not propose to acquire that land because—when he knows there is a fear of its being acquired— the man holding about 250 acres sows for one year five or ten acres of his land in barley and oats. Deputy Harris knows that perfectly well.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to agree with Deputy Dillon or anybody else—it is quite an accident that I agree with Deputy Dillon on the matter—that security of tenure ought to be given to every person who owns land sufficient for his needs. But somebody must ascertain what his needs are, and I do not want this House or any politician in or associated with this House to decide that. I would give security of tenure even to a man owning a very substantial holding if that holding was being used and exploited in the national interests, doing the nation's work and providing the maximum amount of employment. I think it better to give security, and to recognise security in these cases. But to the man who has 300 or 400 or 500 acres of ranch land, which he is using inadequately, I would not give security, and I do not think any legislation which we pass in this House should ever consolidate a person in a holding of that kind when the national interests demand that the holding should be acquired and given to other people. As a matter of fact, I would go even further. If we have got to put up with a class of that kind, until such time as our slow moving machinery enables us to eliminate them, I would give preferential rating to the man who uses his land for tillage purposes, as distinct from the man who uses it for the purposes of raising stock, bearing in mind that one man takes considerable risks, with the very uncertain climate here, while the other man does not at all expose himself to similar risks.
Comment on this
I should like to make reference to the policy of the Land Commission in respect of the kind of holdings they have given to allottees when it comes to a question of acquiring lands for division. I made reference to this on a previous occasion, and I should like to emphasise my point of view now. It seems to me to be a highly mistaken policy for the Land Commission to give out a small holding of land—18, 20 or 22 acres of land— and imagine that when they have done that they have made the landless man a small farmer. My experience indicates that, when you give 20 acres or thereabouts to a person who is seeking a holdings of land, you have not made him a small farmer, and you have not prevented him from entering into competition with unemployed workers for employment on any relief schemes or county council work that may be available in the area in which he resides. I think it would be a better policy for the Land Commission, having, of course, regard to the area in which they are dividing the land, and particularly having regard to the conditions in eastern counties, to decide that the holdings to be allocated should not be less than 30 acres. It is quite impossible for a man to sustain himself and his wife and family on a holding of 18 or 20 acres, and it is almost impossible to get more than 20 or 22 acres from the Land Commission in eastern counties like Kildare, for instance, unless a substantial proportion of that holding is non-arable land. I think, therefore, that the Land Commission should reconsider their whole policy in respect of the allocation of those holdings. A small holding of that kind does not make a man a small farmer. Every time there is a relief scheme in his area the man who has got a holding of 20 acres or thereabouts from the Land Commission is a keen competitor for work on that scheme.
I think it is the failure of the Land Commission in this direction which causes so much difficulty in regard to the people not using their holdings. A man who may have some casual employment gets a holding of 18 or 20 acres of land from the Land Commission. He knows that holding will not be sufficient to sustain him. He is reluctant to give up such employment as he has, or such casual employment as he may be able to get. What is happening is that that man is letting the land for grazing purposes, and not using it in the manner desired by the Land Commission. I think the policy of the Land Commission should be directed towards trying to make each holder a small farmer, relying on the productivity of the land and his own industry, and to taking him definitely off the labour market so that he will not compete with other persons who are not in the same position as he is.
Generally speaking, I want to say that this Bill has our support. It is largely, of course, a machinery Bill, but we need machinery for almost any task in life to-day. In so far as it means the acceleration of land acquisition and division, I am wholeheartedly in favour of the Bill. If I have any complaint on the matter it is not about the Bill; it is about the slothfulness of the manner in which the machinery works in the Land Commission. I do not think we can afford to regard the question of land acquisition as one which we will pass on in perpetuity to those who come after us. In our circumstances, it is necessary that land division should be speeded up, because, unlike other countries which yield a substantial surplus of population each year, we cannot afford to ignore the constant drift from the land, the constant decline in the number of young people, and the abnormal number, relatively, of older people left in the community. A situation of that kind can only be corrected in the rural areas by the speedy acquisition and distribution of land. A speeding up of that policy would be calculated, I think, to arrest the tendency of our people to emigrate, and encourage them to remain at home. By converting our ranch lands into tillage lands, and by improving our methods of agricultural economy, we can help to strengthen the nation agriculturally, help to strengthen it economically, and to provide for our people at home the employment which at present they are compelled to seek in other lands.
Comment on this
I am one of those who believe that this measure is long overdue. Listening to the speeches from the Opposition Benches yesterday I also thought that that was their belief, because we had Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney saying that the Bill did not lend itself to Second Reading speeches, that it was really a Bill to be dealt with in Committee. It was only to-day when the Leader of the Opposition spoke that I found there was really objection to it. That did not appear from the first part of his speech, because he said there was no new principle in it. But he had not gone very far in his speech when he referred to the dead-weight debt which was being incurred by this country owing to the activities of the Land Commission. I was rather amazed to hear him mention dead-weight debt, when I recalled the time when all the fat beasts finished in this country and which were shipped to England did not realise the amount of the annuities we were sending over there. I think that was a more serious dead-weight debt than any debt caused by the activities of the Land Commission in spending money and putting it into circulation on the improvement of estates and planting the people on the land. He wound up by appealing to the Minister to withdraw the Bill for the reason that it gave unlimited powers to the Land Commission. Have we not had cases held up by judicial decisions for four or five years? There is the case of one estate in my own county which has been going on for eight years and it is not settled yet. Surely it is time for the Land Commission to have it settled one way or the other and, if they have not the powers to do it, the House should give them the powers. There is no use in having them waiting like that if they cannot do the work.
Coming down to details, I heard speeches in the House yesterday, mostly from people who make their living from the land, and I was very interested in listening to them. It seems to be the general complaint that, some time ago, land was worth more in the open market than it is now, and the argument was that fixity of tenure had something to do with that. I remember the time when 5/6ths of the money that was paid for farms sold in the open market, or even business places in the towns, came from relatives living abroad who sent the money home. That money is not coming in here to-day; it is dried up. There is no account taken of that. Then we were also told of the time when land was regarded as good security by the banks, but that it is not now. There was a time when we had inflation here, when banks were looking for the security of the land for the use of their money, and when they actually made men take more money on loan than they asked for. Now we have a period of deflation and, coinciding with that, we have a world depression. Of course, some of the loans advanced by the banks in the inflation period were never repaid, because the people could not be expected to pay £1 for 10/-, as that is what, in effect, it meant.
Comment on this
The Deputy has already made his speech. I welcome the Bill because I believe that it is necessary to do something to expedite the proceedings of the Land Commission. We have inspectors down the country making investigations and recommending the acquisition of certain lands. Then we have a decision given by some court, and another decision given by another court, and the whole thing is held up. That is not good for the country and does not make for stability. We should have some definite plan and go ahead with it. Taking the country as a whole, I believe that to a great extent all these Land Acts were debated during two general elections, and the policy attached to them, and that this House as a whole had responsibility for them, because, remember, we had similar statements made from the Opposition on these occasions. I do not deny that in Committee there may have been a serious difference of opinion even between individuals on both sides of the House.
I suggest to the Minister, however, that it is time, by some means or other, to get rid of these tithe rent charges and that they should be consolidated with the annuities. They are a very vexatious thing in many districts and I know of one case in my own county. I ask the Minister to look into that matter very carefully and see if anything can be done to remedy it. I welcome the Bill, which I believe is long overdue. I had hoped that it would be welcomed on all sides of the House and that there would be only differences about it in Committee. Speaking for my own constituency, I can say that it is long overdue, and I hope the Minister will give effect to its provisions as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I really intervene only to make one or two observations, especially on one particular aspect of this matter. Personally, I may say that, as a result of experience, I should hesitate very much in increasing any power which the Land Commission has for what often practically amounts to confiscation of property. I think the price often offered for farms is both highly ludicrous and highly unjust. It may, in the national interest, be necessary; it may seem to a government necessary to acquire land for sub-division, though that is a matter for which I shall ask for a little further consideration afterwards. But I think there should be a proper effort made on the part of the Government, and of the Land Commission as the instrument of Government policy, to give a reasonable price for that land—to give something more than the ludicrous price for the land which has very often been forced on the owner. The Minister must know that it is a constant source of worry and a cause of panic on some occasions that when people have land to sell and are about to sell it and are coming to an agreement about the price, the Land Commission should indicate a tendency to step in; because it is immediately felt that the price that might have been realised by the ordinary sale of the land is going to collapse. The Minister must have any number of cases of that kind brought to his notice. Whether that makes for the stability of which Deputy Victory spoke and on which he seems to be so keen I should think the House ought to be in a position to judge as a result of experience. Whatever else it makes for it does not make for confidence or for stability. Under such conditions how can we expect farmers to improve their lands or even keep them in good heart? Could we expect improvement in any business?
I need not stress what has been stressed so much in this debate, the importance that a number of people who have done a great deal to build up this country attach to the principle of fixity of tenure. Interference with it may be occasionally necessary, but it should be limited as much as possible. What I want to stress is this: if it is determined that it is necessary to interfere with that principle, then I say that it should be done in accordance with some general national policy framed for the country as a whole; not a policy of the Land Commission, but a policy of the Government. I am very much afraid that in the effort to secure what in itself seems very desirable, namely, the creation of a number of new holdings of moderate size, that the Land Commission in trying to put as many people of that kind on the land as possible, in order to carry out this side of Government policy, have not considered how that must affect the general agricultural economy of the country. I gathered from the report of the Banking Commission that the Land Commission actually disclaimed any regard to general agricultural economy. That is precisely what I am afraid of. In paragraph 558 of the appendix to the majority report it is stated:
"Moreover it is plain from the evidence of Mr. Deegan that it has not been part of the recognised task of the Land Commission to evolve an economic policy which might serve as a basis for directing the exercise of its statutory power."
In other words, the business of the Land Commission apparently, as seen by the Land Commission—and I think anyone who knows it will agree—is to divide the land. What effect that division of land, or the pushing it to the length now proposed, is going to have on the general agricultural welfare of the country is, apparently, not the custom of the Land Commission to consider. Possibly the House will remember that some time ago we had a debate about what was to be one of the greatest industries for bringing salvation to this country. I do not know whether it belonged to the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Defence, but the Minister for Defence was in charge of the turf industry then and what was revealed to the House was that we had two Departments of Government, one the Departments of Industry and Commerce, promoting the turf industry, and the other, the Department of Local Government promoting the building of a number of houses with grates that were suitable for coal. The idea that the two Government Departments should consult beforehand, and bring their activities into harmony, had not dawned on the Departments or the responsible Ministers. I am afraid that we shall have something of the same kind happening here. We have the open confession of the Land Commission that it is not their job. In other words, in connection with land you have the Department of Agriculture promoting a policy or a different one every year, while another Department deals with land which really, with a normal Government, ought to have some connection with agriculture. Apparently it does not care what the policy of the Minister for Agriculture is.
We all know that a heroic and radical effort was made to get out of the cattle trade and many know what it cost. At one time the slogan of one Minister, the Minister for Agriculture, was: "More tillage, less cattle." That has been dropped. At least, it was dropped and taken up, then dropped and again taken up. At the moment I understand it is dropped. Has the Land Commission considered, with the addition of these new powers, whether the use it is going to make of them is likely to help the promotion of what ought to be and is at the moment the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, the promotion of a better cattle trade? Deputy Norton spoke of the national interest. How far national interest should override the claims of ordinary justice is, I am afraid—as is illustrate by some of the transactions of the Land Commission—a big question. Leaving that moral question aside, what are the national interests in this particular case? The Deputy spoke of a new agricultural policy. Where is it? If you had the foundation, or if, at least, an effort was made to build up this radical change in our agricultural policy, so as to fit in with the disappearance of the grass farm—to speak of ranches is absurd—if I had any conviction that efforts were being made to co-ordinate these two things I would take a somewhat different view of the matter. But one of them is, I fear, non-existent; I do not see any such effort to have a new and revolutionary agricultural policy in the south-west put into force. And is that not necessary if you are to be justified in your present policy.
What I feel is that the Land Commission is going along with one policy, careless of what the general effect would be on the economic life of the country as a whole. May I point out that in the Report of the Banking Commission it is stated that there are important considerations of that kind left out of account. It is really to stress that particular matter with the Minister that I intervened. Let us, if you will, consider broad national interests alone, leaving the important question of justice on one side, but do not consider that you are promoting national interests if you are merely attacking the symptoms, whilst, at the same time, you undermine the general main national economy of the country. That is what I am afraid is being done. To relieve congestion is desirable. Increase the wealth of the country with tillage, but do not, as we begged you before, when the question of destroying the cattle trade and killing calves was on, wipe out the sources of wealth you have got before you are sure of having something else to put in their place. It took us some years to convince the Government that it was necessary to adopt that particular point of view. They were convinced in the end and the country ought to rejoice. Let them take the full implications of anything they are doing into account, how that will affect the general national agricultural and economic interests. We are now asked to give new powers to a Department that says it is not its business to consider the implications of its actions, or the repercussions of its actions on general policy and the general economic position. That is really the one thing I wished to stress. There are certain other very important aspects of the question to be considered, but I want to confine myself merely to that one, because while I think it is now the general desire to do what seems to be good in itself, that might result in a great deal more damage unless we are more careful.
Comment on this
I want to say that this Bill is one of the greatest need of the present time. It is well known that possibly for three years there has been scarcely any acquisition of land, and were it not for the fact that the Land Commission had illegally acquired land on an extensive scale there would be no land to divide during those three years, and they would not have been able to place families on the land as apparently is the policy put forward by members of all Parties. Acquisition has been held up. It is time that the Government introduced this measure which, I hope, when passed into law will be given drastic effect to without any great delay. As to the talk about the rights of people and fixity of tenure in my opinion you must either have fixity of tenure in all its implications or you cannot have it at all. You must have reason in the matter. If you are to give fixity of tenure how can you exclude wealthy ranchers who can graze the lands at will or allow half of it to go derelict? How can you deny that to them and give it to neighbours who would probably have smaller-sized ranches, but who use them in the best interests of the nation, both from the housing and tillage point of view? How can you deny fixity of tenancy to a man with an uneconomic holding who may be living in America, and who may set that holding and allow it to become to all intents and purposes derelict land, with a fee-simple interest in a holding? You must have reason in the matter as far as fixity of tenure is concerned.
I do not hold there is anything sacred in this fixity of tenure. The rights of the nation, of the community, should go before the interests or the folly of an individual in whom fixity of tenure is vested, and the national outlook, as Deputy O'Sullivan was shrewd enough to bring in, in order to save the things he did say from being construed in a way he would not like them to be construed for political reasons, is an important consideration. He said the national interests came before fixity of tenure. With that I thoroughly agree. I do not approve of Deputy O'Sullivan saying the other things in order to have it both ways in this matter.
I approved of the statement made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney yesterday. I thought his line, his attitude, was one that would be adopted by other members of his Party, but from the statements made by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy O'Sullivan, it would seem that they are running counter to the opinions expressed by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I think it is unfortunate that they should divide forces in this matter in expressing their opinions. Deputy Cosgrave asked can we afford to have any more land division—can the country afford it? I would ask, as against that, can the country afford not to have more land division. I would say the country cannot.
You have slums in other places than the City of Dublin. You have land slums throughout the country, particularly throughout the West of Ireland. That is a matter that is crying out for a remedy. You have destitution, you have disease and all kinds of social wrongs in those areas because of the land slums that are there. Surely they should be remedied, and how can they be remedied unless you go ahead on a much larger scale with the division of land?
Deputy Cosgrave based his argument in favour of the slowing up of land division on the Report of the Banking Commission. I have not much respect at all for the Report of the Banking Commission, although I must admit I am no authority on the matter. The Banking Commission, to my mind, recognise the existence of money and its right to rule and control our existence, but they deny the right of existence to human beings. That is the way I sum up the Banking Commission's Report and, I think, from my point of view, looking at it from the land slum aspect, the crowded populations we have in parts of the West of Ireland, and the blank areas we have, from the population point of view, in other places where there is rich land, I am summing it up correctly from the community's point of view.
It is a false doctrine to claim that we must slow up land division, leave people living in land slums and force people to migrate to try to earn a living abroad, simply because the Banking Commission think, from their outlook, that it is not an economic proposition. There is no such thing as a flight from the land. A lot of people who live far from the atmosphere of the land, who till land by reading books and who study farming from the book-keeping aspect only, far from the land, have been talking about the flight from the land. There never was such a land hunger in this country as there is now. There never were more people anxious to get possession of land, and till and work it, than there are now. Land value was never higher than it is now, if we except the war years.
Taking all things into consideration, in connection with the sales of farms of land, prices are being realised now greater than were realised heretofore. And you must consider that the money paid now for land is money hard earned here at home, not money earned abroad, as in former years, and sent back by people to their relatives to buy the land. That money is not coming in now to purchase land here. When you consider that, and when you consider the price land is fetching, I hold that the money now being paid for the land is in excess of that formerly paid. I repeat that you must consider that the money paid for it is taken out of the earnings of the people here at home.
I would say, therefore, that the need for this Bill is great. The need for land division is great. I would be inclined to give the Land Commission, provided their operations are directed from the national point of view, through the Government, almost unlimited powers. They have been grudgingly given powers all over the years. The intentions of the 1923 Act were good, but the powers were not there. The intentions of other Acts down to the present day were good—all parties welcomed them—but the powers were not there. They will have to get almost unlimited power in order to settle this land problem, which has gone on for generations and which has been the fad and the plank of almost every political platform. It is time we finished with it and it is time this House agreed that the Land Commission should get the necessary powers to settle this problem finally.
I think in this Bill they are getting the extra powers they need, and if those extra powers interfere with this supposed fixity of tenure that has been spoken about here, I do not regret it one bit. In the past years even the 1923 Act did seriously affect fixity of tenure. Every Act passed during the previous Government's regime did seriously affect fixity of tenure and it is rather late in the day for the Leaders of the Opposite Party who sponsored those Acts to complain now about fixity of tenure being interfered with. If fixity of tenure is being vitally affected by this Bill, I welcome it if, as Deputy O'Sullivan wisely said, the operations of the Land Commission take into consideration the national requirements of this country.
Another thing was mentioned by Deputy O'Sullivan. The Deputy mentioned the statement made by Mr. Deegan before a commission of inquiry and the statement was to the effect that in dividing land it was not the business of the Land Commission to bother about its use afterwards, from the national or any other point of view. I think there was no such point of view expressed by that official of the Land Commission, but if there were such a view expressed, I think it is entirely wrong. I hold it is not the business of the Land Commission alone to divide land. There is a greater responsibility on the Land Commission and if they do not feel that responsibility it should be impressed on them. Dividing land in a haphazard fashion is a foolish policy. I am afraid to some extent it has been done during the terms of office of both Governments. It has been done in particular by the previous Government, but it may be, perhaps, that I was more critical of what was done by the previous Government than I am of the present Government.
I know it was done on an extensive scale in the Midlands. Lands were given to men who did not want land, except to have something to sell or to set. Land was given then to men who have never gone into occupation of it up to the present day, so far as living on it or working it is concerned. It was done to some extent during the term of office of the present Government and that is a thing I want to object to strongly. Land should not be given by any Government to good-for-nothings. Land should not be given by any Government to landless men, while you have in all parts of the country cottiers, uneconomic landholders, living on a few acres of bog, trying to rear a family and forced to send them abroad to earn money to pay rents and rates at home. Why should we create more homes on the land that are economic homes, and still leave uneconomic homes and homesteads that are always crying out for home assistance, either through the dole or through some other source? Why not make, so far as we possibly can, all the present uneconomic holdings into economic holdings first, and, having done that, then try and meet, so far as we possibly can, the requirements of the landless men? There is a ramp in certain parts of the country at the present time the effect of which is that nothing should be done with regard to land settlement in the areas concerned until all the landless men in these areas, including the good-for-nothings, should get land first. Now, I do not think that anybody on any side of this House would subscribe to that policy, and I think that the Land Commission should not allow itself to fall into that trap, no matter what pressure may be brought upon it by any Party in this House or by any individual. Land should be provided for the uneconomic holders first. They have been waiting long enough for it, and now that special powers are being conferred under this Bill, I think relief should be given to these people first.
Now, that brings me to the migration problem. I have seen in the newspapers where slurs have been cast upon people who have been migrated from the West to the Midlands.
Comment on this
Surely, that is a matter that should have been raised on the Estimate? It is not relevant to this Bill.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir, but I submit that this has as much to do with the transferring of landholders from the West and planting them in the Midlands as in the case of co-operative farms, which has been suggested.
Comment on this
The Deputy's direct questioning of the Chair's ruling does not appeal to the Chair. The question of migration has not been ruled out by the Chair, but some remarks made on the Estimate as to the type of the migrants from the West, may not be replied to, now.
Comment on this
Well, I shall not discuss the remarks, Sir, but I should like to say that I think the policy of migration is good national policy, and one that should be adopted by all Parties in the House. Migration will improve the social standing, or perhaps I should say the lack of social standing, in some of what I might call the bullock areas of the Midlands. It will create a social standing where there is none at the moment, and I think the policy of migration should be adopted and encouraged by all Parties in this House. Now, with regard to the suggestions of co-operative farming, again I suggest that those suggestions are made by people who live on the land only in theory. I am afraid that the people of this country are not built or are not born to work co-operative farms. We are making demands for fixity of tenure; why, then, should there be a demand for co-operative farming? Fixity of tenure and co-operative farming do not go hand in hand, and if you have fixity of tenure you will not require co-operative farming in the sense of the word in which, I think, it has been used. Of course, you always have a certain amount of co-operative farming in the real sense of the word. You have it in the West of Ireland on a large scale, where the farmers cooperate in lending their horses to one another, swopping implements or swopping or borrowing seeds. That is co-operation in the real sense of the word, and you have that in every case where farming is carried out on an extensive scale among small farmers, and particularly in the West. You cannot have, in this country, co-operative farming of the kind that has been suggested here, and I think it would be foolish to try to introduce it here—except, of course, that the Government might carry it out as a kind of experiment to see how much could be made on one farm; but you cannot extend it on any greater scale, and it is my opinion that it would be foolish to try to do so and that it would not work. That is my opinion.
Now on the question of the administration of the Land Commission, I am afraid that, no matter what powers are given, the administration will be bad. Some of the Acts are very good, but the administration of the Land Commission seems to spoil everything. I do not say that it is the fault of the individuals who do the work or of those who give the instructions for the work to be carried out. I am afraid that it is some general principle in connection with the Land Commission that is wrong. Take the question of the parcelling out of land. I think it is wrong, in parcelling out land, to give a holding of land to a small farmer a mile or a mile and a half, and sometimes two miles, away from where he lives. Of course, it may seem to be all right for him to get that parcel of land. He has been running after it and demanding it, but in many cases he will find, after two or three years, that the parcel of land is not an economic proposition, because it is too far from his home for him to be able to till it or to manure it properly, or to drive his cattle there in the mornings and take them back in the evenings, as in the case of milch cows. That is a system that has been adopted to some extent by the Land Commission and I hold that it is a wrong system. I think that they do not tackle this problem properly in all its aspects, and I hold that, instead of parcelling out land in that way, they should endeavour to create one or two homes or homesteads and transfer the people from the local area into these holdings. That would go a long way towards settling the problem, but as things are at present it only means that you are creating another problem with regard to the land, that will have to be solved again in another twenty years' time or so.
A remark was made yesterday by Deputy Dillon with regard to land in the Ballyhaunis area. As usual, that Deputy is most voluble and most intelligent on subjects about which he knows nothing. That was the position yesterday. If Deputy Dillon would confine his remarks to something nearer home, and to any land trouble that may exist in his own particular area, and about which he knows more than I do, he might be more helpful. Now, in the Ballyhaunis area there is trouble, but that trouble, in my opinion again, is principally because of the administration of the Land Commission, which is faulty. The people who are looking for land there are not good-for-nothings, and what is happening is that some of the best farmers there are not getting land, just because the Land Commission has a system of parcelling out land, principally on a valuation basis. Anybody who has experience of rural Ireland knows that, very often, a man with a valuation of £7 has a holding that, from a tillage point of view or any other point of view, is very much inferior to that of a man with a valuation of £3: the reason being that the man with the valuation of £3, within the past 25 or 30 years, might have reclaimed and improved 30 or 40 acres of bog and, as a result, might have a much more productive holding that the man with the valuation of £7. In dividing up land, I think the Land Commission should take cognisance, first, of the area of the land, and then of its productivity, and parcel it out on that basis, instead of parcelling it out on the valuation basis. If the Land Commission would do that I think that a great justice would be rendered to the people concerned, and if this Bill is passed I hope that the Land Commission will seek to improve their present methods of administration in that regard. If they do so, I think they would be meeting one of the most important requirements in this country at the present moment.
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary, it would appear, has little respect for fixity of tenure, and that is not surprising coming from men across the Shannon. He said that fixity of tenure was undermined by the 1923 Act. The position in 1923 was pretty similar to what it was now, and our attitude in 1923 was the same as what it is to-day. We considered then, as we consider now, that fixity of tenure is a sacred thing: that if a man had land and it had to be taken from him for the public good, then we hold it should be taken at the public expense and at its market value. That was the principle which we agreed to on the 1923 Act, and if that principle was not enshrined in the Act it was due to an oversight. I understand that the difficulty mainly responsible for the introduction of this Bill covers some technical point about the use of the word "commissioner" or "commissioners," but whatever those technicalities may be, our intention in 1923 was the same as it is now, namely, that there should be full compensation for disturbance.
Fixity of tenure has been treated as a light thing here by some people. I say that if there is to be any infringement of that principle of fixity of tenure, then, in so far as we depart from it, we are a nation of robbers. Nothing in this State, or in any State, should be more sacred than property or land. There is certainly no other industry in this country into which more sweat or labour have been put. The people have suffered more hardship for the land than for almost anything else. It is an astonishing thing that there seems to be more respect for foreigners, many of whom have only been in the country for a few months, and who own property in the City of Dublin, than there is for the people who have been on the land here for 2,000 years. All property must be treated on the same basis. We are told that 65 per cent. or 67 per cent. of the rateable value of Dublin is in the hands of foreigners, people who have been here only a few years. That ought to set the people of this country thinking about the rights of property and fixity of tenure.
The speech made here this evening by Deputy Norton was much on the lines of the speeches made in previous debates by his predecessors. The language he used was much the same as that used in other days by the then Deputy Johnson, the leader of the Party at that time. We had those pronouncements from those armchair farmers, office chair farmers—who know nothing at all about farming. We had talk here to-day about the people who use the land by tilling it as opposed to those who use it for cattle production. That is one of the old cods of attitudes that has long since been exploded. Every Minister for Agriculture here has said that cattle production must be the mainstay of this country. That has always been so, and must continue to be so.
I would like to ask this question: What class of national production must we engage in in order to balance our imports? Surely our national production must be directed towards producing the articles that we must sell outside, and thereby help to balance our imports. In the absence of being able to do that, what would be the end of this country inside of ten years. It ought to be our aim to produce that which the country can produce to the best advantage, and, equally important, what our customers will want to buy from us. There seem to be two lines of thought in this House—the one expressed by the Minister for Finance who says that national credit must be preserved. That is a doctrine that every Minister must subscribe to. Then there is the line of thought expressed by Deputies who seem to be animated not by the national interest or the national credit, but by the votes they expect to get in their own constituencies: by the thought as to whether they will get returned at the next election or not.
Comment on this
One Deputy said that, as regards farms of 20 acres, there should be no doubt of free sale in their case. I wonder what about the farms over that acreage? Deputy Allen told us last night that there had been no interference as regards the price of land because of the operations of the Land Commission. Everybody knows that in the case of farms of 50 and 60 acres there was no interference as between buyers and the people willing to sell because the people in a particular county knew that farms of that size were under the danger line. But what was the position in the case of farms that were over the danger line? You could go to the auctioneers in any county in Ireland and be told that they had 100 or 50 or 40 farms on their books, and that they could not get a bob for them. Deputy Allen must have knowledge of that as every other member of the House has. Yet, he got up last evening and made the brass faced speech that we listened to. I had some knowledge of what the Deputy could do during election time so that I was not surprised at some of the stuff he poured out here last evening.
Comment on this
Everybody knows the damage that has been done in connection with the sale of land and the value of property by the operations of the Land Commission. There was no sale at all for farms of 80 or 100 acres. They were all in the auctioneers' hands and could not be sold. Deputy Allen told us that some of them went to the Land Commission and sold voluntarily because they were the best buyers. What I want to say on that is, that they went because the Land Commission were the only buyers.
Comment on this
And they sold to them because they were the only buyers. There was no one else on the market who would buy them.
Comment on this
The position created was that the sale of those farms was destroyed in the country where the local clubs were active. Nobody had a chance of selling that class of farm at all. You had this position of which I can speak from my own knowledge. In my county the craze for land is not very acute because it is a type of county that does not need much change. But I knew fellows there who, before they sold their farms, were applying for land elsewhere. I knew two of them. One got a farm from his aunt. Another agreed with his brother to sell off the farm. As soon as they got the members of the Fianna Fáil Club going, I knew two others who were claimants for land and were prepared to sell their own farms. In spite of what we know is going on, Deputies get up here and say that there is no interference with fixity of tenure.
Apart from the present system, there is another way in which the land question could be solved, though there would have to be, I think, considerable disadvantages from it. I do not think myself that it is a good one but I will mention it. It is that where the Land Commission think there is a large farm that is not well managed, if they have the power let them take it, divide it into 30-acre holdings and put it up for sale by public auction. In that case you would, I think, have plenty of buyers. You would perhaps get people with means and some experience to bid for it. On the other hand, there would be this disadvantage that it does not meet the case of the man who has no means and who would otherwise be a good man to have land and own it. At any rate, that system would have the merit that it would tend to preserve the national credit. It would preserve free sale and it would avoid State expenditure. There would be no question of redemption values. The procedure of the Land Commission is what I take exception to. They send down their valuer and they agree to fix a price for a particular farm. In every case that we know of it has been less than the market value, or about the market value but, having fixed that price, they then make out what the redemption value of the annuity was, and they deduct that from the price. There is nothing like free sale there. There is nothing like market value. We heard of a case here where, I think, £5 eventually represented the occupier's interest. There are plenty of cases where larger sums are given but, unfortunately, the figure is far below what the farm would fetch in the market. The Land Commission has no compunction about seizing property which should not be seized except at market value. But I want to make this distinction. I do not adhere to the mad prices which obtained during the war as a fair standard of value. I want to be quite fair all round. The mad prices that were paid in 1916, 1917 and up to 1922 and 1923 should not be accepted as the standard. The prices which obtained before 1915 should be gone back to as the standard of value. One of the great faults in the 1923 Act was that purchases of untenanted land at that time were based on the value they were getting then. I argued that that should not be so, and that the matter should be delayed until such time as the price came back to the normal level, but the pressure was there from people who wanted to get the land divided, and they got it, but at more than it was worth.
Deputy Norton talks about inducements to remain on the land. What inducement is there for the son of a farmer with 20 or 24 acres to remain on the land. Deputy Norton ought to remember that we are not dealing with a question which will be solved in the next four or five or ten years. We are dealing with a question which is going to affect this State forever, and, although it may take Deputy Norton out of a difficulty at present and secure him a few votes in his district, we ought to take the longer view and ask ourselves what will the problem be in 25 or 30 years when a new generation will have been bred on the land, and will be looking for inducements to remain on the land. I have nothing to say on the question of co-operative farming. I myself think it is impossible; I do not know whether or not that is due to the fact that our Irish mentality is different from that of other people. I do not believe it could be a success anywhere without force. It is full of pitfalls. It may be possible, but I do not think it is.
I was rather pleased with the attitude of Deputy Norton with regard to the larger farmers who really farm their land and employ labour—either their own people or people receiving a wage—because in managing his land the larger farmer has advantages which three or four smaller farmers would not have. He has the advantage of better education perhaps; he is a better manager, and has more expert knowledge. There is nobody, I think, getting more advantage out of land in this country to-day than the larger farmer who has that expert knowledge. Deputy Norton talked about Kildare. One has only to travel through that county, on the railway or on the roads, and see the farms divided there and the use made of them in the last three or four years, and compare that with the use made of them before, even in the worst ranching days, to be able to decide which produced the more national wealth. Anybody seeing the picture for the last five or ten years, and comparing it with the picture to-day, will have no difficulty in deciding when more national wealth was produced. It is not now. All this talk about tillage as compared with cattle production is the greatest "cod" the people ever heard. Last year, you had a drought from Christmas until the end of May, and from the end of May until February you had a deluge. In the one year you would need two distinct things if you wanted to continue tillage farming here. You would want an irrigation system from March until the end of May, and you would want a glass house all over the State for the rest of the year. But there is no sympathy for the people who lost everything they had. There is no sympathy for the people whose crops rotted. What is their position, compared with that of people in business? The latter have guaranteed profits over their counters; they are compensated to the extent of 150 per cent. if there is any interference with anything they have got, and their employees are compensated for any loss of employment. Everybody is considered in this country except the farmer, and the people living on the land, because they are inarticulate, and because hitherto they have been the playthings of political Parties in this country
There was a case which occupied some attention recently; perhaps I do not know all the facts, but the case appeared in the Press. I think it was a County Galway case. A man and his son were put to jail because they resisted the acquiring of a 60-acre farm. The young man was 20 or 21 years of age, and the father had not made the farm over to him. He had five sons, and had no other means of putting them to a profitable occupation. The Land Commission comes along and takes the farm which that boy was to get. I think there is something wrong there. There must be something wrong. Perhaps I have been misinformed on the facts, but I am only taking what the newspapers reported. It seems to me a most extraordinary thing that that land, which the owner had in his possession for God knows how long and which he wanted for his sons, should be taken from him, and that he could go to the devil or to England—that country about which all this hypocrisy is being talked. We are told there is no influence by Fianna Fáil Clubs. Of course there is. In some cases, were it not for the commonsense of the Land Commission, if the claims that were made were acceded to we would have had an era of the greatest tyranny this country has ever known.
There ought to be a departure from the present system, if the State in its wisdom decides to carry out a certain policy, a policy to which we have all subscribed since 1923. I was as much responsible for the provisions of the 1923 Act, and far more so, than any man living to-day. There was one man more responsible than I was, but he is no longer with us. After him, I was more responsible for the provisions of that Act than any man living to-day. But the settlement of the land question should not be done at the expense of the individual in occupation. He was to get market value—whatever price it would fetch in accordance with the times. This national question should be settled at the national expense, and not at the expense of the men in occupation. It has been done at the expense of the men in occupation for the last seven years, and that should not continue. It is a clear shame and a scandal that it should continue. If the nation in its wisdom decides that this should be done, let it be done at the expense of the nation, and not at the expense of the individual in occupation of the land. I did not intend to speak at all on this Bill, as it is merely enlarging a principle. What induced me to speak was that I wanted to express my disagreement with some of the things that have been said. That is all I have to say on the matter, but I hope that this will mean the end of Land Bills in this House.
Comment on this
I hope this Bill will do what the previous Bills intended to do and that we will not be disillusioned as we have been up to the present by the 1933 and 1936 Land Acts. I say that coming from a county where the land question has been a subject of agitation for a very long time, and also a county where the Congested Districts Board, the Estates Commissioners, and the Land Commission have done as much if not more than in any other county to improve the lot of the people. But a good deal yet remains to be done. I have heard people from the Midlands stating in this House from time to time that if congestion has to be relieved in the West the land available in the West should be acquired and the experiment tried on there. It may be news to them that there are thousands and thousands of acres of land even in County Galway that could not be touched or interfered with until this Bill becomes law.
As to the fixity of tenure we have heard so much about, as a farmer I have respect for fixity of tenure; but there is a type of fixity of tenure that I am very glad is being interfered with in a legal way rather than by other methods, as it certainly would have been were it not that these people to whom I am referring had hopes that a native Irish Government would bring about the acquisition of these lands. The fixity of tenure I am referring to is that which was brought about in 1923. A number of people who came in on the Pollock and Daly estates as graziers under the 11 months' system got leases and after holding the land for some years on the lease they were made judicial tenants in 1923, not of 100 or 200 acres, but of several hundred acres. The State at that time was called upon to pay the landlord for his interest in that land, and now the State will again be called upon to pay these judicial tenants for their interest in that land. That is a double burden imposed upon the State owing to what was enacted in the Land Act of 1923. I am sure that the people who did that at the time did it with the best intentions, but, at the same time, the grievance remains, and people are eagerly awaiting the enactment of a law to set aside that condition of affairs.
As I said, a good deal was done in County Galway for the past 36 years by the various Departments interested in the resettlement of the land. A number of people in County Galway gave up land voluntarily even before there was any native Government here. They were people who had the full advantages of the British market as it then was, but they farmed their land in such a way that even then it was not profitable. Even though there was no pressure brought to bear on them, they were willing to hand it over to the Congested Districts Board, the Estates Commissioners, or the Land Commission.
I do not believe that fixity of tenure, such as has been put forward from the Opposite Benches can ever be interfered with in this country while you have a democratic system of Government obtaining here and while there is a responsible Government which, from time to time, has to face the people for any glaring injustice of that kind. If land is taken from a person working it properly in the interest both of his own family and the nation generally and an attempt of that kind is made, any Deputy has the right to put down a question here, and if he does not get a satisfactory reply he can raise it on the adjournment. I am sure that a storm of indignation will arise in that particular district which would prevent any Government from attempting to interfere with fixity of tenure such as has been put forward by the people on the Opposite side.
Another thing that has been mentioned here is that the jeopardising of fixity of tenure has interfered very much with credit being given by the banks. We all know that that is not so. The credit that was given by the banks and the hardships which have accrued therefrom was given by the banks in circumstances that were abnormal and unusual. If there is anything more than another which would interfere with credit it is the kind of fixity of tenure that has its roots in this country for half a century at least and perhaps longer, in the days of the agrarian trouble. It is well known that if a small farmer or even a large farmer gets into difficulties with the bank or a local shopkeeper or anybody else there is a considerable amount of sympathy for him and it all has its roots in that. It is not easy to break that tradition. If it were possible for a bank or a shopkeeper or anybody else as is the case in other countries to put up that man's farm for sale and have a free sale in that way without any interference I firmly believe that I as a farmer would at any time get from a bank sufficient credit to carry on. But rightly or wrongly that tradition is there. If a man in 1919 or 1920 succeeded in getting from a bank a considerable sum of money by way of loan and things went against him, as certainly they have gone against farmers from 1921 up to the present time, it did not matter whether he was a good farmer or as Deputy Dillon would describe him a jolly good fellow, he certainly got and even at the present time would get the sympathy of a considerable number of people. The banks have tried in many instances to collect their money but they have failed because they know quite well that if they put up the land for sale by auction nobody would buy it.
That is the very reason why the banks are now very reluctant to advance credit to farmers. It is because of the tradition that is there, and it is so, not merely in respect to banks, but local shopkeepers and everyone else. That is the situation that faces us. If credit is to be given to anyone by any corporation, or by any set of individuals, that is the situation that will have to be faced, because land security is neither negotiable nor convertible owing to the tradition of sympathy that is there with "the down-and-out," irrespective of whether he is good or bad.
I wish to refer also to the compulsory powers of the Land Acts. I am not aware if the Land Commission have compulsory powers to acquire turbary. If so, well and good. If not, I believe an amendment should be inserted in the Bill giving that right, because turbary in many parts is just as valuable and as useful as land. A number of tenants who were given holdings on estates are still without turbary. In parts of the country hundreds of acres of bogs have been left in the hands of owners who sold their estates, and they are deriving big incomes from turbary, irrespective of whether they are living in this country or outside of it. I hold that 30/- an Irish perch is too high a price to have to pay for turf. The Land Commission in many areas have taken over turbary and given it to other people, the price working out at 8/4 yearly for three perches. I consider that people that have to pay 30/- are being unjustly treated and that their grievance should be removed.
When the Land Commission is carrying out a migration scheme they acquire land in order to relieve congestion. I know districts where people are living on non-arable land that is considered suitable for afforestation purposes, but for some reason these people's claims will not be considered for exchange to holdings elsewhere. There is a lack of arrangement between the afforestation section and the Land Commission. There should be some arrangement whereby persons living on land of a non-arable character, which is only suitable for afforestation and where no suitable land is available for them, should be provided with land elsewhere and not to be condemned to live in such places for all time. They should be treated as landless men and given holdings of arable land in some other part. Their holdings might then be given to the Forestry Department. These people should not be left in the condition under which they have been living for generations. I think the Minister stated on a previous occasion that the claims of very few landless men would be considered for land in future. If that is applied generally I have no fault to find, but if it only applies to the western or congested areas where land is scarce I will certainly find fault with it. If landless people are to be considered as applicants for land simply because they are in a locality where land is available that would be a bad principle to follow. It would be a bad principle if landless men in other districts were not to be considered if they were suitable allottees. The position of all landless men should be taken into consideration and the best selected as tenants. There was some talk that the price paid for land by the Land Commission was not the market price. There might be something in that statement. I know some cases where land in County Galway was sold by auction by order of the courts in recent months, but the Land Commission could not come in. They were prevented entering into competition because of some regulation. I am quite sure that if they had been allowed to make an offer, they would have paid a very much greater price than was got for the land by public auction. I do not say that there is very much in that complaint. I believe that it is only right and reasonable that a fair price should be given for land. I do not think anybody in any part of the House is in favour of anything like confiscation. I believe the Land Commission could give a good price for land and that at the present time people are prepared to pay a reasonable and a decent annuity on it. One of the big problems that I have to contend with is the number of people who are coming forward to ask me to make representations so that they will get land. I do not think the extent of the flight from the land is anything like what we have been listening to. I am glad that this Bill has been brought in. It is long overdue. I hope we will have more faith in it after it is working for three or four years than we experienced under previous Acts that burst up when brought before the courts. If it fails to do what it is intended to do, then the sooner we try to forget about land division and land settlement the better.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear at the outset that I am not opposed to the division of land. I believe that there are certain types of land that should be divided, but I am firmly convinced that the powers vested in and exercised by the Land Commission for the acquisition and resumption of holdings at the present time is disastrous to agricultural interests. The Act of 1923 gave limited compulsory powers of acquisition to the Land Commission, but the various Acts passed since then by the present Government, culminating in the measure now before the House, give absolute powers to the Land Commission. There are no obstacles whatever. In fact the powers given are tantamount to confiscation. I believe these various Land Acts are undermining and destroying, from the very foundation, the roots of our agricultural people in the security of their holding. They are a menace to the prosperity of the country, because they tend to destroy, to a great extent, the right of ownership that our people fought so hard to secure. They have destroyed in a very effective manner the greatest medium of security for agriculture, that is, the collateral security of the land. It will be a very bad day for this country when our great agricultural industry is crushed and broken. We are facing that situation at the hands of the present Government. This Bill, along with the other Land Acts, is bringing about a position when no man will be able to raise a shilling on land. And this is at a time when it is imperative that the farmers should be supplied with loans.
I listened to Deputy Allen yesterday evening, and I was amazed, because I believed that Deputy Allen was a very intelligent Deputy—at least, that he was above the average in his Party— and I thought that he would be capable of analysing the implications and reactions of this Bill and its predecessors on the security of land tenure and its use as a method of securing loans for farmers. The Deputy is a member of the Agricultural Commission.
Comment on this
One of the biggest problems that the commission will have to deal with is the finding of means to put loans in the hands of farmers. I think, from the views Deputy Allen expressed here yesterday evening, he is altogether incapable of examining the real implications of those measures. I do not think he is fit to sit on that commission.
Comment on this
Perhaps I was foolish enough to believe that he was capable of raising himself above the level of an ordinary political back. We have been told in the Banking Commission Report of the importance of this matter. We have been told by many prominent and astute public men of the necessity of restoring the security of tenure to our farmers, especially for the purpose of raising loans. Paragraph 509 of the Banking Commission Report says:
"Great importance attaches to the question of security of tenure. This, as is well known, was one of the primary objects of the early land legislation and it must always remain a fundamental factor in a healthy agricultural system. It is in particular the best type of farmer who thinks of adding to his capital investment in agriculture that is most affected by this consideration. The extensive compulsory powers which are now vested in the Land Commission deserve serious notice from this point of view."
Comment on this
The majority report of the Banking Commission will, I am afraid, in a short time become our bible.
Comment on this
What was the commission set up for? Was it a fraud or what? In paragraph 514 the report says:
"It is especially open to objection when, as at present, it can be effected under standing powers of the Land Commission on repeated occasions in respect of the same land."
The commission attach great importance, from the credit standpoint, to terminating the compulsory powers of acquisition vested in the Land Commission. It means, in other words, that a man can be put through the mill time and again by the Land Commission. He can be troubled over and over again. If he wins his case in the first instance, in six months' time they can come back at him again. Paragraph 514 proceeds:
"So far as the banking and credit situation is concerned, the uncertainty affecting the ultimate value of charges on land, in view of the wide powers vested in the Land Commission, threatens to prejudice the credit position of the farmer in an increasing degree. This power of the Land Commission is not allowed to prejudice charges in favour of the Board of Works or other State charges, or even permanent improvement charges of the Agricultural Credit Corporation under Section 28 of the Agricultural Credit Act, 1920.
The discrimination against charges other than these is an inconsistency for which there does not seem to be a satisfactory explanation. If continued, we fear that it will tend increasingly to hamper the granting of credit to farmers."
That is the position. In another paragraph, paragraph 328, the report says:
"Not only is there the danger that a farm may be acquired by the Land Commission at a price which, perhaps for temporary reasons, may be materially below the value as estimated on a long view for the purpose of a bank loan, but experience has shown the existence of a considerable risk that agitators may use wrongful pressure to exploit the powers of the Land Commission, by creating conditions for which there is no ready solution other than sale to the Land Commission."
Comment on this
Evidently Deputy Corry does not like that report and Deputy Cleary told the House he had no belief whatever in it. With the permission of the Chair, I will read a statement made by the Minister for Finance. I expect the Deputies on the other side will recognise the Minister as somewhat of an authority on this matter.
Comment on this
I hope this has reference to land purchase?
Comment on this
Of course it has. The Minister for Finance, speaking in the Seanad on 22nd March, on the Central Fund Bill, said:
"...and it would have been of very great value indeed if, before this debate had commenced, the Seanad had adverted to the fact that the Minister for Lands has already received the permission of the Dáil to introduce a Bill amending the existing Land Acts, in the course of the discussion upon which, no doubt, this question of security of tenure— as a factor—particularly, I think, in determining the terms upon which agricultural credit may be made available for agriculturists could have been raised. Then it might have been thought, perhaps, that a much more valuable discussion could take place upon the Land Bill than, possibly, in the light of my reply, the discussion here will be."
Evidently, the Minister for Finance was expecting that this would be raised and, if possible, some section introduced into the Bill securing the rights of the tenant farmer. He goes on to say:
"This question of security of tenure in land does complicate a great many of our social and economic difficulties. Undoubtedly, it is a very large factor in determining the terms upon which credit may be made available for farmers. Naturally, if a lender thinks that a prospective borrower is not secure in his title to his land, which is generally the only security that borrower has to offer—if the lender feels that the borrower is not secure in his title, that his title is faulty or that he is likely to be disturbed for some reason other than that he wilfully fails to meet his obligations, the lender is going to be slow in making any advance to such a borrower. Therefore, as Minister for Finance, who is concerned with the question of—or at any rate, who is very often made responsible for—the provision or non-provision, not merely of credit for agriculturists, but of credit for every other section of the community, prima facie, I am in favour of security of tenure because it does mean, if effective, that credit will be made available at more favourable terms.”
As I have pointed out the biggest problem that confronts this country is that of supplying loans to farmers. It has been stated from all sides of the House that this is a vital necessity if the farmers are to be rehabilitated, put into an economic position. If they are to be enabled to work their land, these loans are absolutely necessary. We were told by many Deputies from the Government Benches that there was nothing in this idea of security of tenure and that it has not affected credit. Deputy Allen said that it had not.
Comment on this
It is a well-known fact. How is this question of loans going to be solved? How can it be solved except on this basis? Do Deputies opposite suggest that State moneys should be shovelled out without any security, as has happened in the case of the Carbury Bog scheme and similar schemes in other places? Can the State afford to shovel out money indiscriminately without any security, and what type of security has the farmer of this country to offer? He has none, except the security of the land, and that is a sound security if his title to that land is restored by the State.
Comment on this
It is not sound, as things are at the moment, and if the Deputy, or any other Deputy, goes to any bank at the present time he will find that he will not be able to raise a "bob" on the security of his holding.
Comment on this
I suppose the only fellow who has security is the fellow with the 5,000-acre farm? He will not be shifted ever.