We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1938—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 124–242 of 242. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1938
Enacted

No. 46 of 1938 ›

We agree with that.

Comment on this

That is what is frightening the bankers and injuring credit generally, because no man knows what his farm is going to realise. Very often, as I said before, the land is taken up, compulsorily, at a price that is tantamount to confiscation. What we want is that any land that is acquired for the purpose of division in this country ought to be acquired in a competitive market and at a competitive price in the open market, if necessary. Failing that, there is an alternative, and that is that the people who are going to fix compensation ought to be a body of people outside the Land Commission altogether—an independent tribunal.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The bank managers?

Comment on this

Does anybody pretend that the Land Commission at the moment is holding the scales fairly as between one citizen and another in matters of this sort? Is not every Deputy, on any side of this House, prepared to admit that, time and again, people have been robbed and plundered in this matter of the acquisition of land, and is it fair or just that that should be the case? There is a simple way of getting over this problem, and that is that an independent tribunal should be set up to deal with this matter of the fixing of compensation. It is an extraordinary state of affairs that any Department should get powers from this House to acquire property compulsorily and also should have the right to fix the compensation to be awarded. Yet, that is the position. I heard Deputy Corry, on a previous occasion, taking exception to a somewhat similar situation in connection with the fixing of the price of beet by a State-owned institution. This is on the same basis, or it is done practically on the same basis, except that it is on a much larger scale, because in the one case it would be only a matter of a few tons of beet whereas in this case it is a question of a person's whole property. As I say, the scales have never been fairly held or balanced by the Land Commission in this matter, and in each and every case, about which any Deputy knows, he must know full well that fair compensation has not been paid.

Now, I should like to mention one particular case of which I have knowledge. I am referring to the case of a widow who held two farms in the County Wicklow. One farm contained 234 statute acres and the other contained 161 statute acres, or a total of 395 statute acres. She was offered £3,000 on more than one occasion for these two holdings, but they now have been acquired compulsorily by the Land Commission for a sum of £1,227. That woman lost £1,800 as a result of the compulsory acquisition of her holdings.

Comment on this

Are there any other factors in the case?

Comment on this

In the case of the smaller holding, of 161 acres, the Land Commission came down and valued the holding at £1,750 and after stopping the redemption costs out of that she was entitled to draw £191 for a holding of 161 acres. On appeal, that was increased to £491.

Comment on this

Was the previous case appealed?

Comment on this

In connection with the 161 acres, on appeal, she got an increased price of £300, or £491 altogether. Now, I cannot understand the Land Commission acting in this respect like an ordinary commercial individual and trying to buy as cheaply as they can. They ought not to act in that way, but they ought to act fairly and justly as between one citizen and another in this country. That is their duty and their responsibility, but they have never done that. They have acted just like a commercial body in trying to buy at the lowest possible price and squelch the unfortunate individual and use the powers conferred on them and vested in them by this House to rob and plunder the individual concerned. Is it not the duty of the Minister's Department, or of any Department of State for that matter, to see that justice is done for every individual in this State, and that if land is to be acquired, the money for which is being provided by the State as a whole, no particular individual will be sacrificed in the acquisition of that land for the purpose of division?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give us particulars as to the first case he quoted, with regard to the widow?

Comment on this

It is all the same case.

Comment on this

Did she appeal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What was the result of the appeal?

Comment on this

I told the Deputy already. She had two farms, one of 234 acres and another of 161 acres, and she was offered £3,000, and finally the land was acquired compulsorily and she received, in bonds—4 per cent. bonds—£1,246, which, when realised, made £1,227, They were practically at par.

Comment on this

Did she appeal?

Comment on this

Yes. That is the final price she received in bonds, which she cashed.

Comment on this

What was the first price? My information is that she did not appeal.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know the woman I am talking about?

Comment on this

I do, and investigated the case.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows nothing at all about it, and I think he should not be making an ass of himself. He is not a walking encyclopaedia who knows everything that occurs all over the country.

Comment on this

Do not be losing time with him.

Comment on this

I am not minding him at all.

Comment on this

Nobody does.

Comment on this

There has been a good deal said about stability and progress. Is the state of affairs revealed by this Bill going to make for stability and progress? Can anyone blame the joint stock banks of the country for not advancing loans to farmers when the farmers can be pushed out of their holdings at any time by the Land Commission?

Comment on this

When they are not working the land.

Comment on this

The law is that, whether they are working the land or not, they can be pushed out. We do not want a situation of that sort. There is no use in Deputies saying that that is not being done. We are dealing with this Land Bill, and it is our responsibility to see that it is made watertight: to see that the citizen who ought to be protected and is an asset to the State is protected. He is not being protected at present.

It has been said that the Fianna Fáil clubs do not interfere in the division of land. Let me tell what happened to me three years ago. I may say that the whole trouble was started by the Fianna Fáil club. I possess approximately 250 statute acres of land. In that particular year I had 100 statute acres under roots and grain crop. Deputy Hickey can judge for himself from that whether I was working my farm properly or not. An inspector from the Land Commission came down and enquired from me how I was working my holding. I told him that was my job and to go to the devil: that it was no concern of his, and that I would give him no information. Finally, that man told me before he left—when I had cooled down a bit——

Comment on this

When it was safe to go near you.

Comment on this

He said, first of all to me that he could not understand how I handled that amount of tillage. He admitted that he had over 100 acres of land himself and that he tilled hardly any of it. Yet, we have people on the other side coming in here, blowing and boasting about tillage, about the working of land and all that sort of thing, and saying that the Fianna Fáil clubs are not interfering with the people's rights in this country. I say they did their damnedest to interfere with me and with my rights, but I defied them.

Comment on this

But the land was not taken from you.

Comment on this

What right had any inspector in the Land Commission to come down and ask me how I was working my holding.

Comment on this

And the land is yours still?

Comment on this

And will be.

Comment on this

The point that I want to make is, that if the activities of certain Fianna Fáil clubs in my county were put into effect the land might not be mine, notwithstanding the way I was working it. I want to put that to Deputy Hickey.

Comment on this

I am not a bit impressed by the Deputy trying to convince me.

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey has been throwing that bone of contention into my speech—how the land was worked.

Comment on this

I have some little knowledge of what is happening. I know all the land that Deputy Gorey has.

Comment on this

If the Government would manfully face up to the situation the problem to be dealt with is not a big one at all. If you want to negotiate loans to help farmers there is only one way in which that can be done: First of all, restore them their security of tenure. The matter has been dealt with in paragraph 328 of the Banking Commission's Report. It is pointed out that, notwithstanding the restoration of security of tenure it might be difficult to negotiate a loan if there is not good-will in the locality in which the farm is situated, and that in such a case you will not get any financial corporation or bank to advance loans. I admit that is the case. I contend that, where you are going to negotiate loans to farmers, a determined effort must be made to make our people recognise their liabilities and their responsibility to redeem the loans. The people will have to be taught that a recognition of that responsibility is a sacred thing, and that if money is loaned by individuals, by banks or by financial corporations, these loans will have to be redeemed.

I think that you would need to do more than restore security of tenure to farmers. Take the case where banks have advanced loans, and where they have failed to redeem them within a reasonable time, due perhaps to the fact that there was not the necessary good-will in the locality to allow of the free sale of a holding. In a case like that the Land Commission should go in and take that holding at its fair market value, pay off the mortgage and give the balance to the tenant. That, I think, would help to get over the difficulty about good-will. It would also have the effect of making our people respect their liabilities where debts are incurred. The sooner that something like that is put into practice the better for our people and for the country generally. The fact is that you have too many who are looking for something for nothing; too many who are looking to evade their just responsibilities and liabilities. I suggest to the Minister that he should withdraw this Bill and restore security of tenure to the farmers in a properly drafted measure. The doing of that will not hamper in any way the division of land. The principle that ought to be insisted upon is that if it is thought proper, in the public interest and for the public good, to disturb a man in his holding then he should get a just and a fair price for his land, and that price should be determined by an independent tribunal.

Comment on this

I, with the members of the Party, support this Bill. If it has the effect of speeding up land division and of ending what I may describe as the infernal uncertainty under which the entire agricultural community live, then I approve of the Bill. The Banking Commission Report, in its reference to land division, made what I consider a very wise suggestion to the Government, namely, that they should conclude the acquisition of the lands that have been accepted and scheduled, amounting to in or about 700,000 acres, and that, having done that, they should stop and examine the results—that they should see how far land division had succeeded and how far further land division was likely to succeed. If this Bill can speed up land division, if it can enable the Land Commission to make decisions quickly as to whether certain lands should be divided or not, and get those decisions announced in areas where the people are waiting to hear them, then I say "Every good wish to the Bill," because I agree with many people who have spoken on both sides of the House that, in places where there are estates which the people want divided, and which have not been divided owing to obstructions, the uncertainty is destroying to some degree the national spirit of enterprise and initiative which should ordinarily exist amongst the agricultural community.

Land division has arisen in this country through the necessity to right an historical wrong, and it has gone on from that to something which is supposed to be a cure for the social ills of the country. There certainly is nothing more democratic in the world than this Bill. There is no question of that. The people of this country desire the land to be divided. They do desire that land occupied by large land-owners, who are employing very few people and are living entirely on the simplest form of cattle rearing, should be taken from them—compensation being given—and that the land should be divided amongst the landless men in their areas. There is no question that the Bill is thoroughly and absolutely democratic, but the people themselves have not expressed to us any opinion with regard to how long that land division should take, or how quickly the whole question of what land is to be divided should be decided. Therefore, we can speak freely on this matter without any danger of opposing the wishes of our constituents, and I do say that if this Bill—as I imagine from reading its many complicated clauses—will enable the Land Commission to carry out the suggestion in the Banking Commission Report, to complete the scheduling of so many hundreds of thousands of acres of land and then to examine what has happened, then the Bill to my mind is an excellent one.

There is a feeling of tremendous restlessness all over the country, particularly in the central areas, wherever land is to be divided. I believe in speaking out about those things. I myself think that the pressure brought on Deputies of this House by those who want land is an entirely undesirable thing. I think the whole atmosphere in many parts of the country in which people are waiting for 300 acre estates to be divided—no one knows whether they are going to be divided or how soon—is entirely wrong. If this Bill, as I said before, can end that position of affairs, it will be to the immense advantage of the country. It will bring back the spirit of independence amongst our people. It will stop what might be described as the escape from reality which affects the minds of people who think that they may somehow get land and be relieved of all their difficulties. In the case of larger farmers, who are in the position that they think they are giving enough employment and that their husbandry is good enough, but who are not quite sure—their circumstances, perhaps, do not permit them to employ more than they are employing—and who are worrying about what is going to happen to their land, it will enable them also to look forward to the future with some kind of hope and some kind of feeling of stability.

I think, too, that the Government are bound to make it known in the course of the next five years that land division is a thing which can act only in a very limited way in the future as far as the promoting of prosperity is concerned; that, outside of areas of the Gaeltacht and special migration schemes it is going to be impossible to satisfy even 25 per cent. of the demand for increased amounts of land for compulsory division. The number of acres available is not sufficient, and by no system of mathematics, by no system of juggling, can it be conceived that you could divide land up so that, in a purely ideal way, every single person would have a natural minimum right to land. At any rate, when the present Bill has had its effect the same uncertainty will continue, and whatever Government is in office—whether it is ours or another—will be driven by political pressure to try to take further steps to divide land, knowing very well that those steps may not be economical in their results. Once again, I say that this Bill is a thoroughly democratic Bill, and is wanted by the people of this country. All I can say is let us get through with it. Let us get those lands throughout the country scheduled and divided, and then let us consider what we are going to do in the future.

I said that land division was democratic. Naturally, because of our history, we are bound to transfer the ownership of land taken from our people to the people who originally had it. We were bound to undo the effects of the conquest. Having undone the effects of the conquest, I do suggest, Sir, that in the course of the next five years the people must be given plainly and simply a statement of the results of land division; that the Government and the Land Commission ought to be able to give this country the same kind of information that is given by the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Industry and Commerce about the results of the agricultural policy or the industrial policy. So far, we have no information to speak of from the Land Commission on the subject of land division—no information of a social kind. Now that things are more stable, now that we have no economic war, no civil war, no conflict on the national position of this country, now that we have peace and stability on the land, I should like to see the Land Commission starting a new section to deal with a close examination of the social results of land division. This Bill will not have a good effect unless that is carried out. What I mean by the social results of land division is as follows: First of all, you have the fact that, of the £26,000,000 of land bonds issued, so far, only £11,000,000 bear interest. The rest is a debt of £15,000,000 imposed on the whole community. That is a very large burden, a burden that is very well worth while if it can be shown that the economic effects of the land division which arose as a result of that burden are worth while. That is the first big fence which has to be got over in order to prove that land division is successful, and that that money is worth spending.

Other facts which should be made plain to the people are, for example, the changes in emigration, the changes in unemployment assistance, the changes in the marriage rate, the changes in the total production of crops and cattle in areas where land division has been carried out extensively. Those facts are not given either by the Department of Agriculture or by the Department of Industry and Commerce, and they are not given in the Banking Commission Report. I submit that members of all Parties in this House who believe in land division must, if they are to be honest with their constituents, demand that those facts be placed before them in the course of the next five years. Those facts for the last five years would have been worth nothing because we had an economic war, we had a very rapid change in social conditions, we had a condition of instability, but those facts in the course of the next five years will be worth a great deal to our own people in judging what is to be the future of land division after this Bill has had its full effect. Another factor of extreme importance to the people in this country is the question of the state of land maintenance and land improvement in estates that have been divided; how does the land in the divided estates compare in quality, improvement and maintenance, with what it was before it was divided?

Notice taken that 20 members were not present.

House counted, and, 20 members being present,

Comment on this

This Bill should enable the Government to speed up land division at a rate at which it should be possible for an examination of the whole result of land division to date to be carried out. I am perfectly certain that that examination will reveal the fact that land division to a very considerable degree has proved effective. It has given people who have had absolutely no chance of making a livelihood for themselves a reasonable chance of making that livelihood and it has righted what was a very terrible social wrong in this country. I am also quite sure that that examination will reveal that, when the effect of the Land Acts of 1933 and 1936, together with this Bill, have been fully felt, the Government will definitely have to reconsider what they are going to do in future.

This is the only agricultural country in the world with more or less modern methods and a modern system of livelihood for the people in which credit based on land is not available to a large degree. I agree with Deputy Beegan when he stated that the principle reason for the lack of credit was the holding up of the sale of land when seized for the purpose of recovery of debt. I hope every Deputy will have the courage of Deputy Beegan, and that courage has been revealed on more than one occasion, to say these things not only in the House but outside, and to go around and explain to the people that the holding up of the sale of a farm of a man who has fallen by the wayside has no good social results in any sense. If Deputies take Deputy Beegan's advice and do what he has done, it will be much more easy to obtain credit on land.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Beegan will welcome his interpreter.

Comment on this

As far as credit on land is concerned in relation to this Bill, I see no way out of the difficulties. Ever since land division began in this country inevitably credit to a certain degree has been restricted through the uncertainty of the position of large farmers. I am aware of that myself through having gone into an examination of certain cases. where loans were requested from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. You should not blame the Agricultural Credit Corporation for refusing to give a loan on the ground that there was no evidence that they would not have the land taken away from them before they could collect the debt, if a debt arose to the corporation. To my mind the difficulty of obtaining credit on land due to that cause is one that there is no way of getting over at present. We shall have to wait until land division has been more or less finally disposed of as far as the 1933 and 1936 Land Acts and this Bill are concerned.

I heard one Deputy speak of the question of co-operative farming in relation to land division. There again I think we ought to be honest with ourselves in this House and state fairly and squarely that this is the only agricultural country in the world which is not increasing the degree of co-operative farming in the way of co-operative marketing of produce, co-operative transport, or co-operative purchasing of raw materials, and which is also at the same time decreasing the individual size of the farms. These are facts which should be made known to the people. You should not try to disguise these facts. If the people want to have land divided, let them have it divided, but warn them that in future they will have to face the circumstance that we are compelled to export one-third of our produce and that we are at present undertaking a course of economic activity which is contrary to the experience of any other agricultural country in Northern Europe which specialises in agricultural exports. It is well that the people should have that repeated to them and that they should know it. Then, if they desire to go in for co-operation or desire to increase profits through making a certain portion of their life co-operative in character, they will evince that desire and the Government can carry out their wishes.

If you take Denmark or Holland or France, co-operation amongst the people there, even among those who are intensely individualistic, at least in France, increases every year. In

France, I suppose, the number of people in co-operative societies must total 13,000,000 out of the total population. In Denmark, the farmer makes the entire profit on the pig up to the point where it leaves the port of Copenhagen. He makes that profit for himself through co-operative enterprise. I am not suggesting a form of co-operation which involves the sharing of land. I am suggesting simply the form of co-operation which deals with the co-operative purchase of raw materials, co-operative transport, and the co-operative sale of products. I am certain that the people of the country are sufficiently intelligent, if they are made aware of the trend of European policy in agriculture, to take advantage of the lead given to them by agricultural communities in other countries and that there will be a movement for greater co-operation in agriculture. To my mind, it is a very serious thing that we are going against what is a world trend at the present time. I think that is due to the disturbed character of our history, to the fact that co-operation has been impossible to a very large degree owing to differences of political opinion, etc. We should all speak about it in public and not attempt to deny the seriousness of the fact.

In conclusion I should like to say that I hope this Bill will proceed rapidly through the House, that the Land Commission will get rapidly to work, and that we can carry out one of the most useful suggestions in the Banking Commission's report—that we should conclude that section of land division provided for in the 1933 and 1936 Acts and create a feeling of certainty in the minds of the agricultural population by so doing, and then have an examination of the whole position in the light of what we are going to do in future.

Comment on this

This new Land Bill shows the lack of proper consideration in connection with the previous Land Acts because year after year it seems that we have to bring in new Land Bills. I think it is time that the best brains in the country should get together and devise one decent Land Bill. This legislation which we have been pouring out for years is sickening our people. It looks as if the lawyers had a vested interest in this matter. No ordinary countryman can interpret these new Acts. I feel that I have authority to speak on land division because I am the only man in the House, perhaps, who is living on one of those divided farms. In that respect I can speak more or less with authority. I have seen land divided for the last 15 or 20 years, and I am very glad of it. However, I am not afraid to say that I am sick of the gamble that is going on now. What I want the Government to do is to take stock of what has been done. I stated on a previous occasion that 50 per cent. of the land that was divided in my constituency is not being worked. On the Cullinan estate near Trim 800 or 900 acres were divided, and I know that a number of men who got land have let it on the 11 months' system at less rent that was being paid for it originally. In some cases the new ditches that were put up have been levelled and there has not been the slightest interference by inspectors to see that these farms were worked. It is unfortunate to see land that was divided being given back to the people from whom it was taken, and to see cattle roaming on it after the State had incurred huge expenditure in dividing it. That has happened in not only one ranch but all over the county.

For that reason it is time that the Land Commission took stock of holdings that were divided there to see how they are being worked. They might find out why they are not being worked. We have some men meeting at the crossroads looking for land, on the ground that they have a big family, or that their cattle are hungry, but as soon as they get holdings they are running around trying to get men to take them on the 11 months' system. That is not fair to the country. I am also aware that decent men who got land were unable to work it for want of capital. In order to put land division on a proper footing we will have to get cheap credit for farmers. A man who gets a holding of 30 statute acres would want, at least, £100 to work it. I do not want to spoon-feed these men. I want to see them paying back the loans they get as annuities. If that type of man got a loan of £100 or £200 which he could pay back in annuities he would be an asset to the country, as he would be able to keep a couple of horses and five or six young cattle. He would be in a position to make himself economically independent. Unless some facilities are given to that type of farmer land division will be a failure. I speak with authority on this question, because I live in the midst of land that has been divided, yet I see all around me a wilderness, and far less employment being given than when the land was in the ranchers' hands. I do not want that situation to continue. I fought and suffered so that the land might be divided amongst the common people, but I say that the Government is not acting wisely in accepting a happy-go-lucky attitude.

I tell the Minister that things are not going well in connection with the migratory schemes. The Minister will ask me why the Department should give any more to Meath men when there are so many people in the West crying out for land. I say that 40 or 50 per cent. of the people who got land are not working it as they should. I do not know how some of them got into these holdings. While I have nothing against them I would not give them land if I was dividing it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cleary was forbidden by the Chair to reply to a speech that the Deputy made on the Minister's Estimate, and the Deputy may not now refer to the character of migrants from Mayo or the West.

Comment on this

I find that there are complaints in my county about farms that were given to new tenants. Houses were built but there are no gates at the entrance to these holdings. If a man is put into a farm he should at least be given some protection on it. It is not right to leave gaps in the ditches after houses have been built, and to have no gates erected. The Minister should take power under the Bill to provide piers and gates. It would not cost much money to do so. When migrants come from the West they do not come to a wilderness. They find the ditches made up and nice piers and gates erected. There should not be any discrimination against Meath people. In connection with migration, I feel that it is my duty, as it is the duty of the Fianna Fáil Deputies, to protest against migration. It is all very well for Deputy Cleary and Deputies from the West of Ireland to talk about the greed of Meath Deputies, that want everything for their own people. We do not want everything for the County Meath, but we want justice. We have just as much congestion in County Meath as there is in Mayo. Deputy Cleary said that I must not be one of those who came from the land. I want to tell the Deputy that I am one of those who sprang from the land and who worked on it. I am the son of a small farmer who reared a family of ten children on 48 acres. I am also a small farmer, and I want to tell Deputy Cleary that he would not be a lawyer if the Meath farmers had not gone down to the West of Ireland in the past to buy cattle and sheep from his father.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These personal remarks do not contribute to the debate.

Comment on this

I am sorry, but the Deputy made remarks about the people of Meath. My answer is that unfortunately we have by far too many cross breeds in this country. In fact the Irish are becoming a mongrel race. That is what is wrong. We were told that the first migration scheme for Rathcarne was intended to assist in the preservation of the Irish language. What has been done by that migration for the preservation of Irish? What language is spoken in Rathcarne to-day?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Lands has nothing to do with that. That is for the Department of Education.

Comment on this

The Irish race is as good now as any other race.

Comment on this

If these people were brought there in order to preserve the Irish language, the language should be spoken there. At the present time the language is dying out there. Everyone knows that the language will die out any place where a few hundred people are put in amongst thousands of strangers. The Minister got away by saying that these people were brought up from the West to preserve the Irish language. He comes along now with a new migration scheme, but there is nothing at all about the language. The Minister on the last occasion read out the farm accounts of some of the new men who were brought to Rathcarne and Gibbstown.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now referring to the concluding speech that the Minister made on the Estimate. Let us hope it was the concluding speech.

Comment on this

Yes. The men in these colonies repudiate these statements, and say that they were either false or misleading. Five or six members of one colony say they were led to believe they would get certain advantages and markets for milk and vegetables. To-day these people are amongst the most poverty-stricken families in County Meath. They got seed potatoes to sow but they had to eat them. They are in absolute hunger and are crying out to be taken back to the West. I do not want to say that it is all sunshine in County Meath, when it is absolutely the reverse.

It is unfair for the Minister to quote four special cases. It is very easy to select them. Some of the men who came from the West of Ireland are men with British pensions of £2 a week. You may take a man like that and quote him, but he is not making the money on the land. If you are going to divide any land in my county you should make a special exception of it. I do not mean to stop dividing land there, but you must realise that it is a special county as compared with other counties in Ireland. The soil of Meath is worth preserving for one thing, the finishing off of the live stock of the rest of Ireland. Nearly all the live stock worth exporting come from the West and South to be finished in County Meath and then they are exported and we get the very highest prices. Do you want to kill that type of industry? If you do, it is unnatural and un-Irish. You do not want any special feeding stuffs beyond the bare grass of County Meath and you can export fully finished cattle, sheep or lambs and get the best prices.

In that connection I ask the Minister to make a special exception of County Meath and, when dividing land there, the Land Commission should give a better type of holding. There is no reason why they should not give 50, 60 or 70-acre holdings to men there. These places would be an asset to the country. The men in such holdings would be able to go to the West, to Athenry, Roscommon or Ballinasloe, and buy store cattle from Deputy Cleary's people and other people in the West, and give in return the money which the people there badly need in order to educate their children and make lawyers of them or, perhaps, put them in for some other occupations. We will give them the ready money. Do not, under any circumstances, divide Meath into small patches. If you divide land at all there, give the people economic farms, a decent house, a gate and a pair of piers so that they can really own it, and the stock wandering on the road will not be able to walk all over the land.

The Land Commission are far too easy in the matter of erecting houses. They gave out contracts for the erection of houses some two years ago and they are not yet built. In the meantime, the land has been let on the 11 months' system and there is no protection given to the new ditches. Perhaps one man will take 200 acres and his cattle will roam over the new farms, with the result that the new fences are destroyed in a few months. There should be an inspector left in charge of those estates during the period they are on the 11 months' system, so as to see that the ditches are protected. I am not speaking through my hat in this matter; I speak with knowledge, because I live within a few perches of these estates and I see what is happening. The work done a few years ago at great expense is being destroyed and the incoming tenant or the Land Commission will have to do that work over again.

There is also the question of water supplies for small farms. There are numbers of small farms without any water supply. That is an unnatural thing. The greatest scource of wealth to a farmer after the land is the water supply, and good fresh water means healthy stock and profits to the farmer. If you cannot get a natural water supply it is only fair that a pump should be erected on every farm. If, in a dry summer like this, a farmer has to draw water for ten or 20 cattle it means a hard day's work.

The burning problem at the moment in County Meath is the Craig Waller estate. At the last election the people in that area were predominantly Fianna Fáil. They were more or less following the Government, because they want this land divided. I warn the Minister that there is going to be serious trouble in that area if he does not hearken to the appeal of the people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not an Estimate; it is a Bill, and it is certainly outside the scope of the Bill to advocate the division of particular estates.

Comment on this

Arising out of land division, during the last few years a great deal of greed has sprung up amongst the people. Men will almost sell their old mothers in order to get a farm. That is unfortunate and I would like the Minister, when he takes over an estate, to divide it pretty quickly. He holds estates too long in hands, with the result that people are coming night and day to Deputy Kelly, Deputy O'Reilly or myself, and perhaps also to the Minister. One will say: "Jack So-and-So should not get a farm and, if he gets one, I should have one too." We are in the most desperate position because we are blamed for everything. If the Minister takes over an estate, he should deal with it right away.

A new game has been brought into being in County Meath by the Land Commission. They start building houses and spend about three years on them. Nobody knows who is to get them. The Minister is far away from the scene and the unfortunate Deputies for the constituency do not get a wink of sleep, either night or day, with the knocking at their doors. I would rather that the Minister would give out the land to the right type of person and have done with it.

One of the principal things that concerns the ordinary farmer is free sale and fixity of tenure. I know of a few cases in County Meath. There was one very small farm owned by a widow near Navan. It was 12 statute acres in extent. She needed the cash to pay little debts. I and several others made representations so as to give her a free hand to sell. She put the land up for auction and got a buyer, but the Land Commission stepped in and said: "No, that buyer will not do; he has too much land." He had only 50 acres. Nobody else could buy the farm, unless he had a farm adjoining, so that he would be able to absorb the 12 acres. That poor lady could not sell.

I know of another small farm of 60 statute acres which a lady tried to sell, but the Land Commission stopped her from selling. She was told she could not sell to one man who wanted to buy, but she might sell to somebody else. I think it is unfair to people who are struggling along to treat them like that. You cannot sell a small farm only to a neighbour who can absorb it in his own holding. There should be more facilities given to these people who are anxious to sell, because they have to sell and it is not merely because they want to get out. I hope this is the final Land Bill, that people will be able to interpret it, and that we will not have to pay an extraordinary amount to the lawyers. I cannot understand how any such trimmings should be attached at all to these Land Bills. I think that they should be put in plain language which would be understandable to all people. I think there are hardly six people in this House, outside the lawyer "guys," who could get up and talk on the different clauses and sections in this Bill. I would ask the Minister in future to give more attention to the matter of providing land for these tenants who have at least a little capital and who can work the land, and also to provide credit facilities. To a man with a 30-acre or 40-acre farm, that would be a considerable help.

As I have adready pointed out, Meath is an exceptional county, and you cannot divide lands up there on the same scale or in the same way as you would do in the West of Ireland or in other parts of the country. If you were to divide Meath into very small holdings you would do a very grave-injury to the County Meath, and, indeed also to the West of Ireland, because Meath is very largely the gateway for our live stock, cattle, sheep and lambs to the English market. I am not speaking now from the point of view of any political Party bias, but I have lived long enough to realise facts and I know what I am talking about, and the people understand me also; and what I say is that we must preserve the nation as a whole, and not individual units of it. We must preserve the export trade of our live stock, and in order to do that we must preserve the best land that you have got in fairly large holdings. I do not mean large ranches, but if you take a fairly large farm, that is chiefly used for fattening purposes, and divide that farm into very small holdings you will do a great deal of harm, not alone to the land itself, but to the tenants among whom that land has been divided. You must bear in mind the different quality of the land in different parts of the country. In County Meath the tillage is practically all used for the feeding of the stock. I have been tilling land for the last few years and I must say, that whether the weather was wet or dry, I nearly always lost my wheat and corn crops. Year after year the corn crop rotted, whether the season was wet or dry, and the reason for that was that the land there was too rich to grow that type of crops. A farm of that kind should be devoted to finishing off cattle, sheep and lambs. It is for that reason that I ask the Minister to treat the County Meath as a separate problem, and if you put the proper type of tenant on a 70-acre, 60-acre or 40-acre farm, you will find that you will benefit the people as a whole, but if you divide up the land in County Meath into very small holdings, it will only mean that in two or three years' time the sheriff will be at the doors of these unfortunate people because they will not be able to make good.

The problem is altogether different from what exists in other parts of the country. For instance, in Carlow you have a beet factory, and the farmers there are well off because they can grow their beet, cart it into the factory and get their price for it. We cannot do that in County Meath, however, because we have no industrial undertaking connected with agriculture. We have to live by the raising of cattle, sheep and lambs, and there is no such thing there as carting our oats and barley to a market. What we do, in County Meath, is that we feed these crops to our cattle and live stock. Accordingly, as I say, ours is a special problem and different from that of any other county in Ireland, and I think the Minister should treat Meath as a separate unit.

Comment on this

Very many Land Acts have been passed in this country, and they were always rather timid in their operations. The first Land Acts gave a sort of security to the tenants inasmuch as they could not be evicted unless they were compensated. Later on, a further step was taken, and half the money was advanced to purchase the holdings, but it was not until the 1923 Land Act that the whole amount of the advance was given to the tenants to purchase. The 1923 Land Act, of course, was considered a most revolutionary Act, and it was the first Act to destroy this credit, that was talked about so much here to-day, by injuring security of tenure, as it is called. That Act was automatic. It was a very praiseworthy Act. It was stringent and it was considered to be revolutionary. Why was that Act revolutionary? It was revolutionary, not because the former Government wanted to have it so, but because the people had reached such a stage at that point that, if the late Government did not take steps to pass that Act, the people themselves would have continued to operate for themselves and ultimately the greatest confusion would have been caused. Be that as it may, however, it was that Act that destroyed this so-called credit, and destroyed, or at least helped to destroy, what is supposed to be security of tenure.

Many people, previous to 1921 and 1923, borrowed money with which to buy a farm. They bought the farm for £1,000, or whatever the amount was, and continued to pay the rent. They were just ordinary tenants. Automatically, they came in under the 1923 Act, and the landlord's interest was bought out—one body concerned being the bank and the other the Land Commission—the bank taking second place. That was the beginning of this so-called destruction of credit, and I think it is time people should realise that. Now, this Bill does not interfere with that position at all. It does not interfere with credit. Whatever credit remains is still there to be availed of. Naturally, the credit on land is not what it was previously, but the real reason for that is that world markets are not what they were, and, no matter what we do, credit on land will depend largely on the sale of the produce of the land. If competitors increase in that market and if the ability of these competitors to sell cheaply increases and new kinds of subsidies are highly developed in other countries, that, naturally, tends to decrease the value of land here, so far as credit is concerned, but this Bill does not add anything in that connection. It simply explains many questions that have arisen since the passing of the 1933 Land Act. It proposes to give necessary facilities to the Land Commission to obtain lands that, in many cases, ultimately would have to be sold to somebody, and the bulk of these lands, if they were not sold to the Land Commission, would be sold by the banks, and the present owners, or at least quite a number of them, would benefit very little. I believe myself, however, that, in justice, some method ought to be adopted to give something more for land that is purchased, whether that land happens to be in the hands of the bank or whether it belongs to private individuals. I believe that that is only fair and just and that in a great number of cases the prices offered are extremely low. We find in the County Meath that the farms are purchased by the Land Commission at a much cheaper rate than they are purchased in the County Mayo. After all, when we come to examine the question, there is something not so very strange about that.

For years the land in thickly populated areas in the West of Ireland and in other thickly populated areas had a higher setting value than the setting value of land in the County Meath. Therefore, the people and the population had something to do with the credit and security of the land. Hence the efforts to induce a bigger population in the County Meath are certainly going to increase the value of land in that county. I would like to state here that the Land Commission has not any very great power over the price of land. I believe that price is arrived at in other ways particularly trade competition and markets. There are appeals in these cases; if the owner of the land is not satisfied with the price offered by the Land Commission, I understand he has the right of having a value himself, the court has the right to have a valuer and so also has the Land Commission. I believe, therefore, that if a higher price can be given it will be given under these conditions except there is something to prevent that happening. The real reason in these cases is that the value of the land to-day is not what it was. Unless we can increase our population here and have a larger home market which we can control, the price of land will not increase as long as competition in the markets with which we have to compete is so intensively keen.

I believe that there should be more co-operation between the Department of Agriculture and the Land Commission in order to bring about the desirable situation of having land made more valuable. Without that co-operation it may not be possible to achieve that desirable result. In the bulk of cases that I have examined I found that there was very little co-operation for agreement or contact between these two Departments of State. That is why there has not been so much progress in land division. In fact, the value of land has been decreased by the method of division. The layout is often entirely wrong and the layout is one of the most important aspects in the value of land. A farm must be laid out properly or it goes down in value. There are a number of excellent farms in Meath that have been very improperly laid out and the result is that they cannot be properly worked. There is no use in a man coming to me and saying that such and such a tenant is no good. The difficulty lies in the laying out of the land and when it was not properly laid out it could not be properly worked.

If they have not enough experts in the Land Commission they have them in the Department of Agriculture. It is the Department of Agriculture that directs the policy. If they are to direct the policy properly it is essential that they should be in constant consultation with the Department of Lands in order to advise them as to the proper lay-out, what should be produced on the land and the type of farm to produce the particular produce that is required. It is in that way that we could raise the value of the land and increase the credit of the owners of the land. There is no use in saying, as Deputy Hughes said, that the Government were bad boys and that it was they who destroyed the credit of the land. They did not. The credit in the land was destroyed by the Land Act of 1923 as far as the banks were concerned. Many of the banks found themselves in a most awkward situation on the day that Act became law. After the passing of the Land Act of 1923 they found that the debts on the farms were irrecoverable. They refused to lend any more on land. I want to call attention to that fact because I know of many cases where debts on farms of land arose through the operation of the 1923 Land Act.

It is to the advantage of the whole House and the country that land division be made a success. As long as we are able to divide the land and do so in a normal way it is something to be extremely thankful for, considering the situation that existed in this country in 1923. At that time, the greed for land was so acute that the people took the law into their own hands. If that situation were allowed to continue the credit of land would have sunk very low. But stringent and active steps were taken. The 1923 Land Act and other Land Acts were brought in. We are discussing this Bill to-day to rectify certain mistakes that arose in these Acts. Those were mistakes that could not be anticipated at the time. These were only discovered through the decisions of the courts. This is merely a Bill to rectify those mistakes. We made mistakes that could not be foreseen. Under this Bill the division of land is going to continue and this Bill will make that work more rapid. For some time there has been a hold up in land division. The Land Commission is now trying to repopulate the areas that were depopulated. Now, as I have already pointed out, the setting value of excellent land in the County Meath was actually lower than the setting value of land in the County Mayo. It was inevitable that some stringent and powerful steps should be taken to rectify such a position as that.

Many of us have long been looking forward to this amending Act. I am extremely glad now that it has been introduced. I do not anticipate in any way that as a result of this Bill the price of land is going to be less than it has been. I, in fact, anticipate that the price paid for land by the Land Commission will increase as the result of this Bill. I believe, and I am sure the Minister in his concluding speech will explain it to the House, that the Land Commission have no power over the price of land. Other circumstances over which the Land Commission have no control are the facts that settle the value of land.

Comment on this

I welcome this Bill and I rise merely because I wish to make a few points with regard to some of its sections. There is a question with regard to Section 51 which refers to the power to appoint limited administrators and nominate representatives of tenants and owners in certain cases. That is a section in relation to properties and estates where improvement schemes have been held up and where the tenants are in a difficulty on the matter of getting to agree as to one main scheme or to one main head of development. I am anxious that questions such as fishery rights and certain reservations made by former landlords in regard to what we call commonages, should be dealt with in this Bill. I am now referring to people whose cases were not dealt with under the 1923 Land Act. It appears that in so far as the fishery rights were concerned, simple cases of fisheries had been leased, that the Land Commission at that period did not deal with the matter and that subsequently the former landlord sub-let these fisheries. The tenants concerned were debarred from having any rights whatever over the fisheries. I quote one case here as an example of many. This is a case in the McGillycuddy Estate, in the County Kerry, where the tenants had been agitating for 40 years with regard to the fishery rights.

At the time of the 1923 Land Act, this whole matter was not dealt with and the tenant concerned had to pay the full original rent of £17 10s. If this question of fishery rights had not been in existence, that tenant would have had to pay only £7 12s. per year. This agitation went on and, under the 1923 Act, the tenant was compelled to purchase and lost the fishery title, for which he had been fighting for 40 years. This fishery is sub-let to other people. That type of case is not being dealt with by the Land Commission. They have taken no steps, so far as I can see, to give these tenants hope of redeeming the rights which they have lost over that period of 30 or 40 years. If powers are taken under Section 41 to deal with tenants who are holding up schemes and with the extinguishment of easements, rights and tenancies, why have they not taken power to give these tenants some legal right to regain these fisheries which were taken from them throughout the years through no fault of their own and through no fault of the Government in office at the time the 1923 Act was being put through? The explanation given was that the Land Commission do not deal with that type of case once the original lease has not expired or where the lease is the property of some other person. I am simply making the point that some opportunity should be given to these people to come in under this Bill.

Another point I want to make is in regard to untenanted land. You are making provision in regard to untenanted land in the Bill and you have dealt with people who are already vested or who have purchased under the Land Purchase Acts. It is only in these circumstances that you may, by order, extinguish certain rights. We have cases in which the former landlord reserved certain areas which were subsequently described as untenanted lands. They were taken over as sporting preserves and, even where it was proven that they were vital to the interest of the tenants concerned—in other words, that they were arable land retained by the landlord for that special purpose—the Land Commission did not come in and restore these lands to the tenants concerned.

I have another case where the landlord reserved a certain area as a sporting preserve and, in the adjustment that took place, lands were taken over from the tenants concerned. This woman produced a document and a map of the year 1860 showing that the portion of land taken in that estate was vital to her holding and was described as the arable portion of her holding. This tenant was denied the right to retain that portion of her holding which was really the only arable portion of land in the district. The Land Commission were asked to go in and reacquire that land on behalf of the tenant. The landlord, who had all the legal assistance and who was very well able to make his case, convinced the Land Commission that it was not arable land and, therefore, that it could not be restored. These are types of cases which I place before the Minister in the hope that an effort will be made to right an injustice that has been going on for 30 or 40 years. The case I make is that you are taking steps to make good certain defects in previous Land Acts and to remove anomalies. In doing that, you should examine the points I have made with regard to these fishery rights and these untenanted lands. We have experience in some of these areas of lands reserved for a special purpose where, as time went on, the landlord was able to avoid every type of legislation enacted so as to deprive these tenants of valuable fishery rights, in one case, and of sporting rights, in the other.

In Section 24, reference is made to commonages and owners in common. That question of commonages has been dealt with over and over again, but we are debarred from making our case since it is provided in the Bill that the only commonages to be dealt with will be those where there are owners in common. We have several cases in Kerry where the former landlord reserved areas as commonages. They were never given over to the Land Commission at any period and they are a source of agitation and trouble throughout the years particularly in regard to water-rights and privileges. There, again, I do not see why, if the Land Commission take power to go in and compel the ordinary tenant to sign certain agreements or to exclude a tenant who will not sign, they should not come in in a case like this and deal with the landlord who has, for some special motive, deprived these people of these rights. We have two or three cases of this kind in Kerry and I think we have made representations to the Department of Lands concerning them. In so far as water-rights are concerned, these commonages are vital to the tenants residing adjacent to them. I should like the Minister to consider that question. Even though I notice here that power is taken in Section 53 to deal with that type of case, still the fact remains that you have only dealt with commonages over which the Land Commission has already some jurisdiction. You have not indicated your desire to deal with commonages which were reserved under the previous Purchase Acts. I should like the Minister when replying to clarify the position so far as these cases are concerned.

Comment on this

I want to say a few words about this Bill. I want in the first place to indicate to the House that this Bill does two things. The first thing it does is to put an end for ever to fixity of tenure. I hope Deputies who are supporting the Bill will, some time in the future, congratulate themselves on having done that. The second thing the Bill does is to hand over complete power and control over the land of this country to the Land Commission. I hope the Deputies who are supporting a Bill which does these two things and who are so enthusiastically welcoming it, will be as enthusiastic about it five or ten years hence. I wonder did it ever occur to them, when they were welcoming it this evening, to consider what the history of the land question in this country was? Did it ever strike them to consider the sacrifices which their fathers and grandfathers made to secure fixity of tenure which they are so jubilantly sacrificing this evening in order to bring land administration in this country into the cesspool of politics so that the tenants' tenure will depend on the will of the dominant Party in this country irrespective of who they are? I wonder when they were sacrificing this asset, did they consider what asset they were going to put in its place so that the people who are engaged in agriculture will be able to find capital to put into their farms and keep them going? The dominant Party to-day passes out to-morrow and some other Party will succeed them and whatever fad they may adopt, in regard to land policy, will be put into operation so that you will have this vicious circle still going on. I wonder did it ever occur to the supporters of this Bill whether their fathers and grandfathers were wise in putting fixity of tenure as the first plank in their policy? Had they consciously or unconsciously a philosophy behind them when they pursued that policy and achieved that end? Did they go out recklessly to achieve that end? Had they a philosophy? Of course they obviously had a philosophy and they put that philosophy into practical effect.

Here we have the representatives of the State jubilantly gathered together this evening welcoming a Bill to impose a new form of absolute landlordism on the tenant farmers of this country. Let us not forget that is what we are doing, whether it be right or wrong. I am not going to pass any judgment on that now. I wonder what those who are gone would think if they could occupy the gallery this evening and look down upon this House and what it is doing. What is to be the future of this country? What hope is there of developing and making good the land when this Bill becomes law? What security is there for any man or woman taking up a farm in any part of this country when this Bill becomes law? What future is there for themselves and their families when, having put the best of their years into the land, their whole title may be swept away at some future date. Was not that the whole policy behind the agrarian trouble in this country, to place the people definitely and inseparably on the soil of the country? That was the philosophy behind the people who founded the Land League in this country. What inspired it? The conduct of the landlords towards them. Irrespective of the fate that they knew awaited them, land-holders and their families brought out picks and shovels and reclaimed the bogs of the country. When the landlord came along, in August and September, to shoot game over the sporting parts of the estate, he saw the reclamation work that had been done and he doubled and trebled their rents, yet they defied all that and, with their imperishable love for the land, they launched the agrarian campaign. The two things, the fight for fixity of tenure and the reclamation of the land, went hand in hand. Many of them did not wait until land reform was achieved. They proceeded contemporaneously with the fight for fixity of tenure to reclaim the land and at the time when fixity of tenure was secured they had reclaimed a very considerable amount of land. Now the fact that this Bill abolishes their security of tenure means that there will be in future no incentive for them to put their best into the land.

I wonder does the Minister believe himself that he is doing a wise thing to-day or is he sufficiently strong to resist the political influences that are driving him like a ship before a storm? Let us be clear about what we are doing. There are some of us here past the hey-day of our lives but we are yet young enough to live to regret what we are doing here this evening. I am as certain of that as I stand here this evening and I am here to protest against the passage of this Bill. There is the excuse trotted out by those supporting the Bill that its object is to place people on the land. That is crystallised in the tirade we had from Deputy Norton who completely ignored the causes of depopulation in this country. It is what is in this Bill, and what was in the Land Act of 1933, that was responsible for driving the young men and women off the land. Deputies who are acquainted with conditions in rural Ireland know that the son who should occupy the farm, get married and remain on it, has done so only because of the persuasion brought to bear on him by his neighbours. The entreaties of his father and mother would not be sufficient to hold him because he is so disgusted with the position in which he finds himself. But, by sheer force, some friend or neighbour may prevail on him to remain. That situation has been brought about by two converging policies pursued by the Government. Under the first the Government destroyed whatever prosperity the people were able to get from producing out of the land, as well as the capital assets which the farmer had in cash and in stock. Finally, under this Bill, the Government are destroying the security which the farmer had to get credit. Will the Minister tell us whether the Government, contemporaneously with what they are proposing in this Bill, are prepared to set up machinery to finance the farmers and supply them with credit. The Minister need not say that he will do it. I do not care whether he does or not.

If this country is so insane as to give the Government a mandate for the policy it is pursuing in this Bill, then I think it will live to regret the day that it did that. I do not believe that the tenant farmers of Ireland, who fought and made sacrifices for the benefits they enjoyed and for the rights which are being taken from them under this Bill, have a glimmer of what is being done in this measure. Or is it that the tenant farmers have reached such a pitch of pessimism that they are indifferent as to what happens to them in the future: that they say to themselves "Very well, we are destroyed anyway; the fruits of all that we fought for and achieved in the past are being destroyed, and it does not matter now what happens." If that is their attitude, it is a black day for Ireland.

I do not complain at all, and never did, about the Land Commission taking power to resume untenanted land. Attempts have been made on all sides of the House during the past two days to try and fence on this question: to segregate and create, as it were, areas and groups of tenancies that should be protected with regard to fixity of tenure. Let me warn the House that the moment you touch the edifice, the moment that you pull one brick out of it, then ultimately the entire edifice will come down. There are things happening in the world to-day, and you have people who seem to think that they are the growth of yesterday. They wonder how those things happen, whereas, in fact, they are the sort of things that happened three centuries ago and, through various stages, they have come now to their logical conclusion. The world has stood aghast during the last few years, for example, at the conduct of the Totalitarian States, but people do not appreciate what brought about that particular development. It is a development that came about when the world moved away from Christianity.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And the Deputy is moving a long way from the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

I am, and this House is moving very far away indeed from the principles of those who secured for the people the rights that are being destroyed under this Bill. You are destroying under it the peasantry of Ireland, and putting an end to the security they had on their land. I do not intend to say more on that because every section of this Bill will have to be considered very fully on the Committee Stage. Somebody has spoken about the explanatory memorandum that has been circulated. This is a bland document, a sugar-coated pill with the vitriol inside. Yet it is well worth reading. It says:

"The Land Bill is intended primarily to correct certain defects in the existing land code which have come to notice in the practice of land purchase operations. Some legal objections arising therefrom have been upheld by the courts...."

That is a shocking thing for the courts to do. I wonder what the courts are for. It goes on:—

"It is necessary, therefore, to restate clearly and put beyond doubt the powers which were intended to be given to the Land Commission by previous legislation, and particularly by the Land Acts of 1933 and 1936."

I am not a judge at all, but I think it is obvious from the language of the sections in respect of which decisions were asked that the decisions were correct. Of course, when the measures referred to were brought into this House the Minister in charge would not listen to anybody. This was not a deliberative Assembly. The Minister walked in with his proposals and used the majority that he has here to carry them through. He would not listen to anybody who attempted to put forward rational suggestions intended to help. Any Deputy who did that was told that he was sabotaging the Government. I am very glad that the courts put their foot on that sort of thing. The decisions involved are quite simple. The language in the sections is quite plain. The memorandum goes on to say:—

"The most important provision is contained in clause 14, which determines the quorum of the commissioners for the exercise of the powers of the Land Commission.... Next in importance is clause 39 of the Bill, which restates the law and the procedure in regard to the resumption of holdings of tenanted land by the Land Commission for the purposes of distribution."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should remember that the explanatory memorandum was supplied to Deputies at the request of the House, and I do not think it is consonant with proper procedure to read it through and paraphrase a memorandum so supplied.

Comment on this

I am only referring to two clauses. This memorandum would make it appear that this Bill is a perfectly innocent thing. I am suggesting that it is not. With regard to the concluding portion of the last extract I read, the meaning of it is quite clear. It is, that in future the Land Commission will hold absolute control over all the land in this country tenanted and untenanted. I know, of course, that we have been assured that nothing wild will be done—not until after the Bill has been got through. But when the Minister gets the Bill through and takes it across to Merrion Street the position in the future will be that, as regards anything done under it, there will be no right of appeal, so that the destiny of the farmers of Ireland is to be placed in the hands of those in authority in Merrion Street. Under this Bill—I do not know whether or not that will be so in its final form— there will be no appeal except with the permission of the appeal commissioners. They can, of course, state a case. They have the right to do it. If they have the right to do it, why should not the other parties to any proceedings have the right? Has the Minister got so careful about the financial interests of litigants that he will not let them spend their money? If they are prepared to spend their money, or—whether they have any money or not—if they think they have a right, why should they not have an opportunity to go further and get that right determined? Do not these two decisions in the Potterton and Maher cases show that it is only just that persons should have a right of appeal to a higher tribunal? In future, there will be no case stated for any court other than the appeal tribunal, except with the permission of the appeal tribunal. Why is that done? What logical basis is there for it? If it suits the appeal tribunal to state a case for the opinion of the court, they will state a case; if not, there will be no appeal to any court outside the appeal tribunal.

In regard to the amendment of lists, power is given, for example, in this Bill that on the original amendment it will not be necessary to serve notice. It never occurred to the Minister that that is a denial of natural justice. Is he not aware that there is a decision by the Supreme Court in this State that, where the civil law contravenes the natural law, the civil law is ultra vires, and the natural law will prevail. This House has no right to legislate to give power to any Minister to do something which contravenes the natural law. The Minister has been very much upset and the whole work of the Land Commission has been held up because the courts gave a decision, on a direct question from them, that the signature of all the Commissioners was necessary for any act they did. Did not anybody in the Department inform the Minister that in 1935 a case went to the Supreme Court in which he was semi-involved, and in which it was determined that an act of the Commissioners meant an act of them all. Apparently they were terribly shocked when this later case came along. But there was a decision in 1935—I think it was the case of the Minister for Industry and Commerce v. Sweeney—that where an act of the Commissioners was involved, either judicially or otherwise, it involved an act of them all, and not of any one, two or three of them. They had that before them, but apparently they completely overlooked it. The section of the 1936 Act refers to the act of the Commissioners. It never once refers, either in the section or any of the subsections, to the act of a Commissioner, or any number of Commissioners. Those two later decisions, so far as I can see, were uncalled for. It was obvious from the language of the section that it involved all the Commissioners. Certainly that is what the section intended. The Minister may have meant something else, but he should have said so.

This whole thing strikes me as a terrible perversion of the entire system of land tenure in this country. I am not going to accept the suggestion that those who fought for and won the land rights of this country were wrong. I believe they were right. I am convinced they were right and I believe that, when this Bill is in operation, time will prove that they were right. Of course there is a plea for landless men, for congests. It has been said thousands of times, and is still being repeated again and again, that there is not enough land in this country for all the landless men. We hear a lot about providing land for landless men, but the people who are on the land are running away from it. In the first three months of this year, 1,700 young people left the land; they did not leave the towns—a few of them may have, but in the main they left the land. Why, then, do we hear such wailing about putting people on the land, when the people who are on the land are running away from it? In the last few years about 150,000 people have left the land—left it in despair. There is no one left on the land now except those of such an age that, in a few years, they will not be able to keep the land in any sort of fertility. We hear about the congested areas in the Gaeltacht. Every young man and woman in the Gaeltacht is flying from it. Everybody in this House or outside it who knows anything about the country knows that no matter what we do in this House, and no matter what Government is in office, it must be admitted that there is not enough land to go round. We have heard here about places where there are farms of 400 or 500 acres. How many are there? Those people have not read the evidence given by Mr. Deegan before the Banking Commission. If they had, they would not talk like that. We will have something to say on this Bill on the Committee Stage. So far as I am concerned, I oppose it, because it involves two things which I have always opposed and will oppose.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

Whatever views one may hold on this Bill, once the question of security of tenure is raised I think in the national interests and in order to restore the credit of the country, the appeal made by Deputy Dillon in opening the debate on this question should be listened to in the House, and that that essential point should be agreed on by the House. But it was not to go into the merits of the Bill that I rose. The Bill has been strongly condemned, and has been equally vigorously supported. The sensible line to take is that the Bill is going to pass, having regard to the Government's majority; and what I am about to say is with a view to the consideration of essential amendments. There is a question involved which concerns the country very much, and particularly the portion of it from which I come. It is the question of submerged land—land which is inundated with water. Deputies on the opposite side who represent the same constituency as I do will support my view on this matter. We have lands there which have been submerged for four years. I know one farm of a reinstated tenant, 40 acres of which have been submerged for four years; the entire holding is 49 acres. But the annuities are still due. I am aware that the Land Commission, by way of concession, can give relief in those cases, but it ought not to be a concession. It ought not to be a question of patronage —it ought to be a question of right. In Section 54 of this Bill the Minister makes provision for land covered by sand which is no longer of use for agricultural purposes. I would suggest to the Minister that he should bring in an amendment, or accept an amendment tabled by me, that where land covered by water has been relieved by the revisor from local rates—which in itself is proof that it ought not to be liable for the payment of an annuity—it should automatically be relieved from that payment. The people concerned are in a position of uncertainty, and the annuities on these submerged lands are accumulating. It is bad enough to have their means of livelihood destroyed, but to have the annuities mounting up is also a very serious matter. The Land Commission has dealt reasonably, if you like, generously, with most of these cases, but they have dealt with them, if I may put it that way, on a sympathetic basis. Some people have been relieved of portion of their annuities, but I submit that they should be relieved of these annuities as a matter of right. It is not a question of sympathy. I am asking that they should be relieved of their annuities when the revisor gives his certificate that they are not liable for local rates. I would much prefer if the Minister would bring in an amendment for that purpose rather than I should table one. That would be only doing elementary justice to the people whose means of livelihood is taken from them by the flooding of their land.

Comment on this

The one matter which I intended raising on this Bill has just been mentioned by my friend Deputy Broderick, and I wish to support him in asking the Minister to bring in an amendment to deal with land which has been flooded for a number of years. In my constituency the best portion of the land on a number of farms has been under water for four or five years, and yet these people are expected to pay annuities on this land. I am sure the Minister will realise the injustice of that. Provision is being made in the Bill for dealing with land which is covered with sand and other matters of that kind, and I think that land which is covered with water should also be dealt with. Some few years ago the Land Commission divided an estate on the banks of the Suir. Portion of that estate has been flooded and the tenants have not derived any benefit from the flooded portion, although they are expected to pay their annuities. I hope the Minister will look into this matter and bring forward an amendment to deal with it, which I am sure will have the support of all sections of the House, as I am sure this grievance is not confined to Waterford, but must extend to other counties. I am glad to be able to support this Bill and I know it will be welcomed throughout the country, particularly in counties where very little land has been divided up to the present. I hope that when the Bill becomes law no time will be lost by the Land Commission in expediting the division of land.

Comment on this

So far as I can see the reason for the introduction of this Bill is, in the main, that certain flaws have been found in Acts previously passed. Of course, Acts of Parliament are framed by the most eminent lawyers, but still some other lawyer often finds a loophole in an Act and takes advantage of it. The result is that this Bill had to be introduced to enable the Land Commission to proceed with the acquisition and division of many of the estates throughout the Twenty-Six Counties. Nobody can quarrel with that, because it would be impossible for the Land Commission to carry out their duties effectively unless they had these powers.

Sometimes I think there is a good deal of what one would call piffle spoken about land division in this country. So much so that I often wonder when the mythical millions of acres will be divided, or whether we shall ever arrive at the time when the work of land division will be near an end. Judging by the views expressed by some Deputies they would like to have a repetition of land division day after day, week after week, and year after year. They gave me the impression anyhow that to make a man prosperous all that is necessary is to give him a farm of land. Once he has acquired the land they seem to think that it is the easiest thing in the world for him to make a living. In my opinion they are leaving out of their calculation a most important factor, not alone in connection with the successful working of land, but with the successful working of any enterprise, and that is the human factor. There are thousands of small farmers in this country who are making a decent living and supporting large families on farms of from ten to 15 acres. It is very hard to reconcile that with the proposition put forward by several Deputies, especially Deputy Norton, that it is impossible to make a living on a farm of less than 30 acres. Incidentally I might remark that Deputy Norton also spoke about the necessity of putting more people on the land. I am not an authority on land, but I have always heard it stated that the best form of education is by observation. If the Land Commission carried out the suggestion made by Deputy Norton, I hold that no person would get land except those who have uneconomic holdings. These are small farmers, of which there are thousands in this country. It would exhaust all the available estates, as Deputy Norton stated, to make each of these 30-acre farms. I do not know what state the country would be in if that suggestion were put into practice. A suggestion made by several Deputies was that the land should be worked in what they called "the national interest." That is a great slogan recently,—"the national interest." I suppose they will say that the future of this country depends on working land in what they call "the national interest." I should like to put this question to Deputies: "Who is to determine, or what authority will be set up to decide whether land is being worked in the national interest or not?" I admit that there can be good arguments advanced in support of the contention that people who have land and let it should be deprived of it. Deputies who advocate that policy are assuming that land taken for conacre is being wasted. I wonder has it ever occurred to these Deputies to inquire what the position of thousands of small farmers would be if no land was available for conacre.

Most small farmers would find it almost impossible to live if land was not available in their localities to be taken for a year or on the 11 months' system. They do not take that land to waste it. They work it. I could advocate that by taking that land and producing crops, they are working in the national interest, and also in the interest of their families. While I do not agree that people who got farms from the Land Commission should be allowed to let them on the 11 months' system, or who do not till them as they are supposed to, still it is wrong to suggest that the land would be wasted, or that the people who take it are not working in the national interest. I stated that I was afraid there had been discrimination and differentiation exercised by the Land Commission in regard to that type of person. Sometimes you will see the claims of these people dealt with expeditiously and fairly in certain counties, while, as Deputy Kelly stated, many allottees in County Meath who got land from the Land Commission are letting it on the 11 months' system for years. Deputy Kelly stated that these people were not in a position to till the land. Why are these people so anxious to look for land if they do not intend to till it? When will they till it? I think the time has arrived when some examination should be made to see whether the money spent by the Land Commission on the acquisition of land has given proper results.

Some Deputies thought that when ranches are acquired they should be divided and the owners hunted away. I am not one who preaches class distinction. That comes generally from people who draw an unfortunate dividing line between people who own farms that are known as ranches and ordinary farms. It should be remembered that most of the income we derive from our exports, and which is absolutely necessary if we are to pay for imports, comes from the sale of cattle raised on grass land. That is part of our agricultural economy. No matter how people disagree with that position, it is bound to remain a very important factor in our whole agricultural economy, because from the statistics issued by the Department of Agriculture, and that appear in the daily papers, it can be said that the value of our exports have considerably increased as a result of the increased number of cattle we are exporting to the British market. I am not agitating for ranching, but I want to discuss this question in an impartial way. I have no very fixed ideas about it one way or another. It is a matter of opinion whether many of those who are referred to as ranchers are not giving as much or more employment on a given number of acres as another type of farmer with the same number of acres gives through the medium of tillage. It is a debatable point. Some people hold that those who go in for grazing and raising cattle, and especially for stall feeding during the winter months, give as much if not more employment as those who go in extensively for tillage. I might say, without departing from the question under consideration, that the experience of the last few years, notwithstanding the extensive campaign for increased tillage, has shown that there are less people on the land to-day than five or six years ago.

Deputies need not think that by making certain suggestions they are going to make things happy for farmers. The task is a very difficult one. I was very sorry to hear the flippant remarks that were made by certain Deputies about the Banking Commission. I wish to remind Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches that that Commission was set up by the Executive of their own Government and that it has cost this country something like £8,000. I am sure all Deputies agree that the members of the Executive Council in the discharge of their duties were not so foolish as not to see that they got value for their money by getting the best men. I think they did get good men for that commission, and it does not speak well, and makes one despair of the future, to hear responsible Deputies speaking of the report of that commission as if it were waste paper. Everyone who wants to build a house knows that a carpenter or a bricklayer must be consulted, and in the case of ironwork an engineer, a blacksmith or a fitter. In the same way, if a person wants to know anything about economics or finance he will go to a trained man. If that is not accepted there is an end to all progress. While I may not accept everything that appears in the report of the Banking Commission as sacrosanct, I have sufficient common sense to know that the members of that commission did their job to the best of their ability. They had experience, I believe, of many countries and of finance, and they made the report for what it was worth. As the report states, it is a question whether the people of this country are trying to live beyond their means. That was the position in a nutshell. I do not think it is right that Deputies should belittle a commission which was set up by their own Government and which cost this State something like £8,000.

In reference to the Land Commission taking certain powers under this Bill, there is one section to which I wish to refer. Deputy Broderick mentioned certain lands that are under water, and that are affected by sand being blown on to them. I should like to ask the Minister whether that section will cover lands that are subject to what is known as coast erosion. There is land along the East coast, down the Cooley peninsula, and I know that when I was a boy at least 400 yards out from where you can walk now there was a road, and the farmers told me that the people used it for their horses and carts when they were carting sea wrack. The sea has made such inroads on that part of the coast that acres and acres of land have been inundated. The result is that the people along that area are paying annuities still on the land which has been taken over by the sea. I would like to know whether this section will cover these lands adjoining the sea coast, and if not, perhaps the Minister will consider whether it would be advisable to submit an amendment on the Committee Stage to meet that particular point. My attention was drawn to the matter by many of the people whose lands adjoin the sea. They are paying annuities on land that does not exist. At one time it was arable land, but to-day it has disappeared through the causes I have mentioned.

Comment on this

I noticed during the debate that the members on the opposite benches tried to make a point that there is no fixity of tenure as far as the land of the farmers is concerned and, furthermore, that there is no security in land. I think the answer to the first point is found in the fact that no speaker named a specific case where a farmer who husbanded his land in a fair manner was served with a resumption order or an acquisition order by the Land Commission. As regards the second point, about the land being security for loans, members of the Opposition dealing with that matter were careful not to tell the House the exact year in which land was refused as security for a loan by the banks.

Members on the Government as well as on the Opposition Benches are well aware of the large borrowings from the banks by farmers during the boom years, in the days of the Great War and a few years afterwards. They are all aware of the outery raised in the country with regard to what were called frozen loans. They know as well as I do that if land is not readily acceptable to-day as security for loans to farmers, it is because of the blunders that bankers made in the boom years, lending vast sums to farmers and, when the depression came, the farmers were not able to pay. The banks were then faced with a problem which they found it difficult to solve, trying to get back the loans they had given. That is the position.

I am surprised at the attitude of some Deputies. One Deputy yesterday spoke very bitterly against the principle of land division. I am alluding to Deputy Dillon. I have read a report of a speech that Deputy Dillon made during the recent by-election. He stated then that he did not believe in a social system that allowed a man to have a motor car, wealth and comfort, while the children of his neighbours were hungry. He further stated that the charge on the national income of any Christian State should be provisioned to secure that children would get the nourishment that would preserve them against malnutrition and ill-health. Was he not giving expression to the Fianna Fáil policy when he said that?

He stated that at a by-election in the City of Dublin, but what is to apply to the electors and the people of Dublin generally was not meant, apparently, to apply to the small holders down the country. One would imagine that they had no children to provide for, that they were living in the lap of luxury, that there were not large land owners who had no regard for the maintenance or the proper working of their farms and no regard for the moral obligation on anybody who has wealth, namely, that what we have is God-given and that we should do with our wealth and our business something to help our fellow-creatures to live. The Deputy made that speech last evening, at a time when it was too late for the electors of Dublin South to hear him.

Comment on this

You have heard them, if they did not hear you.

Comment on this

There was some inconsistency in the Deputy's attitude in that he did not apply that system which he advocated so loudly and praised so much, to other portions of the country; that he did not accept it as a principle for land division as well. Further, not alone did he act contrary to that principle to which he has given expression, but he called the men in the country who stood for that principle, a lot of grabbers. We must remember that any citizen of the State who legally advocates the policy of the Government of the day should not be open to attacks of that kind. If people down the country send in reports that there are congests in certain areas, and that in the midst of those areas there is land going derelict and available for distribution, it is very unfair that these people should be attacked by men who are privileged in this House.

There are some suggestions I should like to make to the Minister in relation to a few sections. One has reference to Section 24, which is meant to deal with the condition of holdings held in commonage. I would like to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that there are still certain holdings in connection with which there is but one receivable order for two names. It may happen that the amount that these people pay individually is not equal. Each has his apportioned share to pay. It came to my knowledge that you might have the case of one man inclined to pay his portion and the other man disinclined to pay his share. That leaves both of them in the position that the Land Commission may try to recover the amount, and it is a case where the innocent may suffer with the guilty. I would like the Minister to attend to cases of that sort and try to get that bone of contention removed somewhat in the same manner as he proposes to deal with the commonages.

In regard to Section 52, dealing with the power to make new water-courses and drains, I should like to suggest that these powers should be extended to cover the erection and maintenance of embankments to prevent flooding, as well as the provision of new water-courses and drains. These are two suggestions that I have to make.

I welcome this Bill, and I think it was long overdue, but I should also like to urge on the Minister that, when this Bill becomes law, men whose holdings were listed by the Land Commission for acquisition, and who shoved them over to somebody else in the meantime while this legislation was pending, should not be allowed to escape from the full effects of this Bill, and I trust they will not be allowed to escape. Furthermore, when this Bill becomes law, I hope that the County Cork, and particularly the constituency of North Cork, will have a lot more land division than has been the case in the past.

Comment on this

Practically every Deputy who spoke on this Bill said that this was not a Second Reading Bill, but they made it one themselves. I could not possibly reply to all the Committee Stage points that were raised here, such as those raised by Deputies Meaney and Broderick, and other Deputies. However, as Deputy Broderick has remained in the House, I shall deal with the point he made. There is power already, under Section 37 of the 1933 Act, to deal with these submerged lands, but the point is that the Land Commission are not going to use it until somebody else would decide when the land ought to be relieved from annuities. What Deputy Broderick wants is that we should accept the certificate of the County Council.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

No, the certificate of the reviser.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

At any rate, the power is there already, and if the Land Commission is satisfied that the land is permanently submerged, then the land annuities can be remitted. The same applies to coast erosion, to which Deputy Coburn referred, in cases where the land has been washed away.

Comment on this
Mr. Broderick

Perhaps I might be allowed to intervene for a moment. My point is that I think it places the Land Commission in a very awkward position to leave the Land Commission as the sole arbitrator in these cases. It leaves them open to the implication of patronage. If an independent official comes in, as is the case in connection with the local rates—a reviser, a Government official, who is above reproach or, in any case, above suspicion and certifies that the land is not able to bear its liabilities to the local authority, I think that that would relieve the Land Commission from any ugly implications that might be made. I am not making any implication, but I say that that leaves the Land Commission open to such implication.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, the Land Commission feel that they are above reproach in these matters, and I am certain that where there is permanent coast erosion or permanent flooding, these things are taken into consideration and remission is given. Of course, in some cases there is temporary flooding, and there are some cases where people claim that, because of summer flooding, they should be granted the same relief as in the case of total submersion. That is different from the case of permanent submersion. Deputy Dillon, of course, came along with his usual charge that we were destroying the security of the farmers and destroying their credit, and spoke as if fixity of tenure, free sale, and so on, were no longer there.

Comment on this

And Deputy Cleary agreed with me.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

He may have agreed with the Deputy in some cases but the point is that where people are making any attempt to work their farms, and especially where they are living upon them, there has been no case where they have been interfered with; and the promise that was made by the Minister for Lands during the passage of the 1933 Act was carried out both in the spirit and in the letter. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney opened the debate by saying that that promise had been entirely ignored and broken. I challenge any Deputy here to give any particular case where any farmer who had made any attempt to work his land properly—any residential farmer—had been interfered with. There has not been one case. Of course, there have been all sorts of general charges made by Deputies, but there has not been one definite statement of even one particular case, and I am satisfied that there has not been one.

Comment on this

What about the Gerrard estate in County Meath, where 53 men were employed?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Is it the Gerrard estate to which the Deputy is referring?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As far as I understand, that was offered by the owner.

Comment on this

The balance of it was.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I understand that the estate was offered by the owner. However, I do say that the point that practically all the speakers of the Opposition tried to make here, to the effect that we are interfering with the hard-working farmer—the man to whom Deputy Gorey referred as the man who has put his sweat into his farm—is a charge that is going to do, and has already done, great damage to this country; and, if continued, it will do still more damage. There was never the slightest fear at any time that a man of that type would be interfered with. He has not been interfered with, and no Government will interfere with him except to help him. Another Department, the Department of Agriculture, is there for the purpose of encouraging such farmers and helping them to get on. Of course, there has been a lot of talk here about this question of credit. Everybody here knows that credit has not been influenced to anything like the extent that has been alleged here, or even, I should say, to any extent at all, by the operations of the Land Commission. Everybody knows that, and Deputy Dillon knows it quite well. Deputies on this side of the House have dealt with that question quite correctly, and they were able to trace it back to the time—and every one of you over there knows it—when money was advanced and afterwards there was a big fall in prices, and the agricultural depression that set in after the Great War. Prices fell, and the farmers, unfortunately, were not able to pay the debts they had incurred, but it was not due to the operations of the Land Commission, and Deputies all know that.

This Bill is a Committee Bill. It was brought in because the intentions of the Oireachtas, apparently, were not being carried out with regard to the two Acts we did pass. It was the intention of the Oireachtas that the practice that had obtained in the matter of appointing a quorum of Commissioners should continue. I admit that on reading that section it does not appear to be that way, but one would have thought that where there were two Commissioners debarred by reason of the fact that they were Appeal Commissioners, at least they would not be included in this, but the judge ruled otherwise, and accordingly we had to bring in this Bill to make that matter right, amongst other things. There was also the conflict between Section 11 and Section 31 of the Act of 1933. The Judicial Commissioner held that, as there was a conflict between these two sections, one of them should prevail, and since it was the intention of the Oireachtas that Section 31 should prevail, we are bringing in this Bill to ensure that it will. All the other provisions of the Bill, as everyone will see, are designed to deal with difficulties that have arisen and to make provision for the working of the Land Commission and to help them in their work.

Questions have been raised here, such as that raised by Deputy Meaney about commonages. That brings me to a suggestion made by Deputy Dillon during the Estimate debate, and raised again by Deputy Norton; and that is the question of trying an experiment in co-operative farming. I myself would love to see it succeed, but I am very sorry to say that the experience of the Land Commission has been that it simply has not worked. In this Bill we are actually taking power to divide land held in common. Deputy Meaney referred to a case where there were only two people who held land under the one receivable order, but I know of another case, in my own constituency, where there are about ten people holding land under the one receivable order. One of these people will not pay. The other nine people always want to pay, but if they pay there is something short every time, and we can get nothing done, although every effort has been made by all sorts of influential people to try to get that one person to fall in line. It has not succeeded, however. I myself think it is a great pity that agricultural co-operation should not have got on better than it has in this country.

Comment on this

There would be the other difficulty also.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Unfortunately, we are individualists in this country. I am one myself, and I think everyone here insists on his own point of view. Until we change that I am afraid we will not achieve co-operation. Maybe I am too pessimistic. In this particular Bill we are providing for the partitioning of those commons and also dealing with the remains of an old problem that was left over from the 1927 Act, where the committees bought land in 1917 up to 1920. There was one case that we knew of, in which several Deputies are interested. They asked us to try and deal with that. There was a case where those people thought that their purchase had taken place before the date set out in Section 42 of the 1927 Act. As a matter of fact, that was not so. They really could have come in. That section was repealed by the 1936 Act, and we are providing time for those people—a three months' period—to apply again. We are doing things of that sort. Unfortunately, the attempt at co-operation so far has not been successful. I, personally, regret it very much, because, like Deputies Dillon, Norton and others here, I would like to see some of these things succeeding. I do hope that a spirit of co-operation will be shown amongst farmers, because I believe something like that will be necessary. I do not mean holding in common, but I mean co-operative selling and buying, and other things that have been suggested here. That, of course, has nothing to do with this Bill at all, but it was mentioned. In the Bill itself we are making provision for dissolving attempts that had been made to work co-operatively.

I think the debate has centred around the statement that we were interfering with the fixity of tenure of hard-working tenant farmers. We have never done any such thing. There is a type of landholder with whose security we certainly are interfering and with which we intend to interfere. If Deputy Dillon by "free sale" means that we are to revert to the position where, say, a wealthy merchant in a town can buy up any land he likes, maybe land owned by people who got into debt with that merchant—as we all know has happened—or with professional people or wealthy people, and that they should be allowed to buy land to any extent they like and then allow the land to revert to the ownership of one or two people and not be properly worked, this Government will not stand for it and I do not think any government that is likely to be elected would stand for it.

Comment on this

The Minister is a reasonable man.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I hope so.

Comment on this

And we can differ in good faith but there is no use in misunderstanding one another. The problem I adverted to there is a problem well-known to the Minister's own officials and to his colleagues, that is if a man bona fide puts up his farm for sale, meaning to marry his daughter into another home, and go into the town and retire from farming, almost invariably there is a request sent to the Land Commission to go down and inspect it, and the inspector goes down. The fact that that happens results in the sale being boycotted because although I might know and the Minister might know that the Land Commission would never recommend acquisition of that land, the fact of the inspector going on the land frightens people off bidding for the land.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I would like to deal with that very point. Deputy Dillon has done me the credit of saying I am reasonable. I hope I am, and I say that Deputy Dillon himself ought to try and be fair. In dealing with that question he compares most unfavourably with Deputy MacEoin because Deputy Dillon said that the people who started these agitations, who got these "grabbers," as he called them, to try and grab the property of these people, were the Fianna Fáil Cumann. Deputy MacEoin said that he was not going to say that because he knew it was not the case because Fine Gael as well as Fianna Fáil were concerned in these matters. I think Deputy Dillon knows that that is the case, too; that it is not a political organisation; that it is something that happens which we cannot help. The Land Commission is not responsible for it. It is a problem that has to be tackled and the people have got to be educated by all parties. I do not think it is serving any useful purpose for Deputy Dillon to insist that it is confined to our Party. I know it does happen that farms do come in and that farms are sold at less than their market value without the Land Commission interfering.

The Land Commission does not interfere in these cases unless it may happen that the people try to defeat the Land Commission. Then they would interfere, but in any ordinary sale they have not done it. I admit that there is agitation, but if Deputies would be fair and admit that the agitation is not confined to one Party we may get somewhere. We may get some public spirit on this question. If that is not what Deputy Dillon meant by "free sale", I misunderstood him. I thought he meant that we should allow anyone to buy as much land as he liked. It would be a great thing if this House were in agreement that the person who works his land properly, and who gives a reasonable amount of employment, has not been and will not be interfered with. As far as the acreage is concerned, that is a question which does not arise—it is just a matter of how he works the land. If he is making good use of a very big farm he will be left with it.

Comment on this

Even a farm of 600 acres?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

If he were making proper use of it and doing what would be for the good of the agricultural economy of the country, he certainly would. As far as I would be concerned, anyway, I would say he ought to be left with it.

Comment on this

Even if he had a farm of 600 acres?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think it would be better not to go to limits, but I would say that a big farm which would be well worked, which would be a model to the district, in which a man could keep pedigree stock which would help his small neighbours, should not be interfered with. The Land Commission has always approached the problem from that point of view. There is no doubt whatever about it. There is no intention of parcelling the country up into small farms of 30 acres. The new farms we are giving out are only that size, but these well-worked farms are going to be left there and not interfered with.

Comment on this

That is a very important pronouncement.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It represents the position, and I would like to know if there is any Deputy in the House who would deny it.

Comment on this

That removes a great cloud.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I want this matter to be as clear as possible. Deputies opposite can vote against the Bill if they like, but let us be clear on that point, because we are all concerned about the credit of the country. If Deputies on the other side of the House believed that hard-working farmers who had put their life-work into improving their place were liable to have them snapped up, they would be perfectly justified in saying that we were making the people insecure and that there was no fixity of tenure. But there is no fixity of tenure for the other people who have holdings going derelict, on which they do not reside, which are let year after year and not looked after. Where there is congestion of the kind we have in this country, it is the duty of the Government to try and relieve that. I think it is accepted by every side that that type of people ought not to hold the land.

On the question of price, that is not a matter for the Minister, but of course due notice is taken of everything said here. You have on this question difference of opinion too. Deputy Gorey said he was not going to ask that the mad prices that were paid during the War period should be given. As far as I know, the Land Commission tried to do what was laid down in the 1923 Act in regard to price, that is, to give a price that is fair to the owner and fair to the Land Commission. That is the wording of the provision dealing with price, and they tried to do that. There is an appeal to the Appeals Tribunal on the question of price. There have been cases, especially the case that has been mentioned here so often—the fee farm grant case in County Meath, which resulted in a small amount going to the owner. We are making provision in Section 46 of this new Bill to prevent a recurrence of cases of that kind, to provide for a more equitable distribution of the purchase money between the owner and the people who have the fee farm grant. I know that a lot of cases have been held up because it was believed that something like what happened in that case might happen again. I am personally very sorry for what happened there. Deputy Cosgrave asked me if anything could be done, but I am afraid it was one of those cases where we did not know what other cases it might open, and we might not be able to deal with all the claims that might arise.

Comment on this

Would that be one of the cases dealt with under this faulty legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Well, it could have been faulty legislation; we are trying to amend it now. It was done under Section 44 of the 1931 Act. I am not trying to put the blame on the other Government for that.

Comment on this

I am trying to make a case for the unfortunate woman.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It was not legislation passed by this Party that was responsible for that. It was passed— sponsored—by the last Government. It was the 1931 Act, and we are amending that section now in such a way as to see that in future the net result will be more equitable distribution of the purchase money. We could discuss that more on the Committee Stage.

All the sections, except these two, will improve the position as far as the Land Commission is concerned, and make for the better working of the Land Commission in several ways. We are taking powers now regarding turbary and grazing rights. I know cases myself where one or two people have held up very big schemes of division of turbary, simply through cussedness and nothing else. There was no question of expropriating them: it was simply the rearranging of a big bog. One was held up for 12 years; it is ten years since the Land Commission told me that they were going to rearrange this bog. It was in some part of County Roscommon, and there were two people whom nobody could move. The parish priest saw them, several other people saw them, and I saw them, but they could not be moved. That is a ridiculous position, and I think everybody will agree with me that we ought to take powers to extinguish these rights in cases of the kind.

I think we gave a fairly good explanation in this memorandum. I do not know whether I am expected to deal with everything; I could not possibly deal with all the points that have been raised. There is just that big point, and I have cleared away any doubts about it. No one who works his land reasonably well at all is going to be interfered with. The working farmer will not be interfered with, but the people with non-residential neglected holdings certainly will.

Regarding the landless men several Deputies on the opposite side of the House did not want landless men to be considered at all. We have the same position on this side of the House, and I myself feel I would agree with Deputy Fagan that farmers' sons would be the best men, but the trouble is that so little land remains and the big problem of congestion has not been settled at all. I think most of the land that still remains to be acquired ought to be, and probably will be, used in relieving chronic congestion in different parts of the country. The Banking Commission's Report has been referred to but I will not discuss that now, but as far as my recollection goes the report said it was a good social work, and I think everybody will agree with me. We do intend to divide most of the land that remains: there will be a certain amount for landless men, but the big bulk will go to relieve this congestion.

On that question, some Deputy here —I think it was Deputy Cleary—said, instead of giving land to people one mile and a half or two miles away, we should take them out of these congested districts and give them new holdings. I am surprised to hear that the Land Commission has given land to people a mile and a half or two miles away.

Comment on this

It is good business in many cases.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As a general rule, it does not work out well, but there may be exceptional cases. As general policy I think it will be admitted that it is very bad: it is very difficult to get people to migrate even a short distance. When they are in these holdings and have grazing rights, and when their holdings are at low charges, they are rooted there for years and it is hard to get them to move; in some cases, it is practically impossible. That is the problem. There is trouble—and there generally will be trouble—when there are more applications for land than can be provided for by the amount of land that is available. For instance, there is the Ballyhaunis case, where there was an attempt by the Land Commission to do the best they could to relieve congestion in the best possible way.

I saw the scheme, and I did not see what more they could do. On the other hand, you had people who were also as badly off as those who got the land, and eventually that led to all the trouble. I do not see what we are going to do about it. If these people would agree to migrate, there may be some way of settling it, but apart from that, I do not see what to do. It is a very difficult problem to solve. In my opinion, I would like to see a certain type of landless man put on the land; but he has not a great chance in view of the small amount of land available.

Comment on this

There are a lot of landless men living beside big estates that should be divided.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Deputy Cosgrave asked would we give a farm to a man who we knew had £1,000. We certainly would not, but if we had given one it would be rather difficult to take it back again. Regarding the point raised by Deputy Lynch, I think I had better wait until the Committee Stage, as it is really a Committee Stage point—as indeed most of them were. I have dealt with the general question, the one that certainly disturbed me, that we were simply shirking the farmers' questions and expropriating them, and all the rest of it. I am glad to know exactly what Deputy Dillon was after, because I did not think he wanted free sale. I would ask Deputies not to put all the blame on our Party. We tried to discourage interference, but you will find that it is not confined to one side of the House, and everyone can help in trying to bring in a better spirit.

Comment on this

I said, when I was speaking, that I believed we might arrive at a formula whereby fixity of tenure might be restored. There is no use reproving us for being apprehensive, if we are just apprehensive. We may be unreasonable, but the thing is to set people's minds at rest. Does the Minister believe that, on the lines of his statement here to-day, we could work out a formula which could properly be incorporated in a Constitutional amendment?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot understand that point.

Comment on this

I will tell the Minister what the point is. I take the Minister's word that, so long as he is Minister, that is the spirit in which the Act will be interpreted, but I have no guarantee that his successor will take the same view, and the Minister's supporters have no guarantee that, if we came into office, we would administer it in the same spirit. If we are all agreed that we mean to go no further than that with the legislation we pass here, we can fix that limit by a Constitutional amendment, which cannot be altered without a further appeal to the people. No Act of Parliament, no Ministerial statement is unalterable in that way. I have no doubt that the Minister does mean what he said to-day, and I believe that, on the basis of what he said to-day, we could arrive at an agreed formula for that purpose. I am not asking him to answer that now, but will he consider, in consultation with his colleagues, as to whether a Constitutional amendment might not be resorted to in order to remove public apprehension?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

If we deal with the problems we have to deal with to-day, and let the next Government deal with theirs, we will be doing fairly well. I do not see any necessity for this, and I am satisfied that no Government which is likely to come here will interfere with the people about whom Deputy Dillon, Deputy Gorey and Deputy Hughes seemed to be apprehensive. I think we can leave it to the people of the country as a democratic people. We will go out of office in a few years' time, and the people can then consider the whole thing again, and deal with the situation, if there is any change.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not admit that it is necessary in the interests of credit for farmers?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I agree that anything I say can be changed, but it is unlikely to be changed. The Labour Party now is not a very big Party, but we do not know what might happen at the next election, and we have had Deputy Norton saying the very same thing with regard to farms of that type. Deputy Gorey admitted that he was pleased with what Deputy Norton said, so we have the whole House agreed that, so far as farmers of that type are concerned, nobody would dream of interfering with them, and I think we ought to be satisfied with that.

Comment on this

And the Banks know it, too.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not think there is any use in my saying that I will consider the matter, because I do not think there is any necessity for it, and, personally, I think that is going to remain the situation.

Comment on this

There is one point which the Minister has forgotten. If an assurance like that were put beyond all question, it would end for all time these activities, these demands by irresponsible local organisations, which have been taking place down the country for the last four or five years. I do not know whether the practice has operated in other districts, but in the particular portion of the country I know, it was confined to certain clubs of a certain political tinge. There is no question at all about that. They were in session every month. It has died down within the last three years almost to nothing, because of the action of the Land Commission and the sensible action of the Minister, but it was very strong some years ago, for the first two or three years of the present Government's régime. If the assurance that Deputy Dillon suggests could be put into the Constitution, it would do wonders to restore the credit of the country, and of the land as a security. That is the point Deputy Dillon is aiming at. It would be of immense benefit.

Comment on this

It is worth thinking over, anyway.

Comment on this

Will you take me as dissenting, Sir?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Very well.

Comment on this

We will divide on the appropriate section of the Bill in Committee.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

With regard to the Committee Stage, I should like to get it as soon as I could. Could I get it next week, or would that be asking too much? It is a question of when we will adjourn. I think that, with the explanatory memorandum, Deputies are fairly familiar with the provisions of the different sections, and if it were agreed to take it this day week I should be very pleased.

Comment on this

Give a day extra and take it to-morrow week.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that if the Air Raid Precautions Bill, Second Stage, is not concluded to-day, the House will meet on Tuesday next. That is just an announcement.

Comment on this

It is something more, considering that it is now 9 O'clock.

Comment on this