We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Banking Commission Report and State Finances—Motion.

Contributions 1–142 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

A Chinn Comhairle, as I said, this whole debate is, in fact, an examination of our whole economic and financial position. The trouble is that the subject is so wide that stress is laid, now on one aspect, and now on another aspect, without any comprehensive view of the whole, and unless we do take a comprehensive view of the whole, we are bound to arrive at wrong conclusions. In speaking last night about external assets and their value, and the inferences that might be drawn from an apparent reduction in them; about the policy of trying to produce for the foreign market and policy of production at home for home consumption, I pointed out that as far as the Government were concerned, at any rate, we are unrepentant advocates of the pursuit of the policy we have been adopting and which was the old policy of Sinn Féin. We are trying to develop the resources of this country for the benefit of the people in this country: to employ the natural resources we have, and to employ, amongst these resources, the brains and brawn of our people to produce the material necessities of life and to provide for our people the amenities which are, as I said, necessary for decent living.

Now, there has been a good deal of sneers at "a plan," and people have been asking where is the plan. There has been pursued constantly a definite plan, and it is only in relation to that plan that you can estimate whether we are going on the right road or not. The plan has been this: We tried to catalogue the material necessities of our lives here. We took the fundamental necessities—of food, clothing, shelter, fuel both for domestic purposes and for power, and so on—and we saw, in the statistics of our imports, the import of large quantities of materials to meet these needs, materials that we believed we could produce here at home. We took the biggest items—I am talking in general now, because there have been exceptions to this general statement—we took the biggest items in our imports, and if possible the most unnatural items in them, and we set out definitely to cut these out. The biggest ones, and the most unnatural ones, were the ones which related to the most fundamental of our necessities. We started with food and said that, since we were an agricultural country it was ridiculous that we should not avail of the home market to the full for the produce of our farms, and that we should not be importing American bacon or a number of other things that we could produce here ourselves.

We set out, therefore, to produce these things and to limit the imports of things such as agricultural products which we could get here, such as bacon, and we said that that need not prevent us, in general, from taking any advantage we could of any external market which was open to us. You can see the result of that policy in what is happening in agriculture. We took one of the most fundamental necessaries, wheat. We said: "Though it is true that you can get wheat from the prairie lands of Canada, the United States and elsewhere, and dump it here at lower prices than our farmers can produce it, nevertheless it is good economy to produce as much of our own wheat as we can." If there is a crisis—a war, or anything else of that nature—we shall have, at least, a substantial element of our food here at home. To the extent that our farmers are producing wheat, and to the extent that we can give them an assured market here, we are giving them a thing which is safer than an external market, of which they may be deprived at any moment. We pursued that policy, and the result of pursuing it in respect of that single item has been to increase the area under wheat tenfold. There is still considerable room for improvement, and, in my opinion, we should move along the line we have been moving on in regard to the production of wheat. About three times the amount we are producing at present would be required to satisfy all our needs. We should not be content until we have got, at least, half-way, and when we have got half-way, I think the argument I am now using will still hold in respect of a considerable portion of the remainder. There is no doubt that we have a sufficiency of suitable wheat land for our purposes.

Then, there is the question of cereal foodstuffs for animals. We are in a certain difficulty there. The difficulty arises, perhaps, in more intensified form in that case than it does in regard to wheat and other things because, undoubtedly, we cannot produce these cereals at the price at which we can get them from outside. We must try to strike a balance. We cannot produce our wheat exactly at the price at which we can obtain it from outside. At certain stages, we may produce it just as cheaply as they do outside. I think that there was a period when we were able to produce it almost as cheaply as it could have been obtained from outside. If there is a war, we shall be able to produce it more cheaply than it can be purchased in the world market. However, I think it is true in general that we shall be able to purchase more cheaply outside than we can produce these foodstuffs and, if we are going to lose a certain amount in that way, will there, on balance, be a gain or a loss? Free traders will say that there is a loss, that we should concentrate on the particular products we can best produce, sell them in an external market and, with the produce of their sale, buy the things we need. That policy has been tried over a long period in Ireland and it was, obviously, a disastrous policy. The more there is increased production in other countries of agricultural produce for the English market, the worse it will be for our producers. The British market is really the principal market, if not the only market. The English might endeavour to protect their own industry and they might discriminate as regards supplies. They are as much at liberty to discriminate against Canada, Australia and these other countries as they are to discriminate against us. That will be the case no matter what position we may occupy in their regard politically. They are quite free to put up tariffs against us if they want to develop their own agriculture or to let in other countries. They can, in that way, make production here unprofitable unless we approximate somewhat to the prairie areas where they are able, with a very small population and by the use of mechanical methods, to produce food. That is the fundamental difference between free trade and the economy of self-sufficiency or protection.

We know that we cannot have it both ways. We cannot have the advantage of imported cheap food if we want to develop our industries and protect our own agriculture. Which is it to be? I know that economists have been divided on these things. If the world were one unit, if there were free passage not only of goods and capital, but of persons between all nations, then, in all probability, the free trade policy, as a world policy, would be the best policy. But that is not the world in which we are living. For that reason, whether wise or unwise, we are convinced that the policy of protecting our industries, in order to produce for ourselves the things we require, is good national policy. We have fought elections on that basis, and we have been returned. We are as convinced of that to-day—at least, I am and I think the other members of the Government—as we were at any time. I am not for a moment trying to pretend that, if we adopt a policy of that kind, we can give the farmer his bread at as low a price as if we were to import the flour from outside, but the community as a whole, which is our interest and not one section, is benefiting by the general plan we have pursued. When we talk about foodstuffs, we must not lose sight of the critical aspect. It is true that bread, clothes and boots must be regarded as items in the farmer's cost of production. To the extent that we protect our industries, it is quite true—I have to admit this—that we shall, in all probability, have some increase in price until we are able to produce as efficiently here as they produce elsewhere. I believe that we ought to set out to produce as efficiently here as they can produce elsewhere—with one limitation, that whereas we have only 3,000,000 of a population, other countries have a population of 30,000,000 or 80,000,000. That is the only limit there should be to our efficiency as compared with the efficiency of people outside. I am willing to admit to the farmer that his costs of production go up in regard to the things he has to buy. We try to give him a balance and, if he is dissatisfied, we have to say: "Though you are a most important section of the community, you are not the community as a whole, and you are going to benefit by the existence, side by side with you, of an industrial community." I am trying to argue these things as objectively as I can, without making Party capital out of them. I am endeavouring to argue them as if I were examining them quietly in my own room. The question becomes one of balance.

A critical point arises when the commodities are not food, clothes or boots, but the raw materials of the things which the farmer is producing and selling. Take, for example, the question of cereals—whether we should import maize or not. You have a really difficult question there, and one of your difficulties arises from the fact that our country—small as it is, relatively— is not uniform, that there are certain areas suitable for the production of cereals and certain areas that are not suitable. We have to consider the economic needs of the places that are not suitable. The ideal thing would be for our farmers, as far as possible, to produce the raw materials for themselves and not buy them from outside. But that question at the moment is a serious one. We recognised always that it was an important and serious question. It is engaging the attention of the Minister for Agriculture at the moment. There is a Bill to enable him to suspend the present arrangement. I will be greatly dissatisfied personally if it is not possible to find some method by which we will not have to import for the raw material things which we can substitute at home. I would regard it as a great loss. I recognise the vital part that animal food stuffs play in our economy, in view of the fact that agriculture is our principal industry. We are trying to produce food at home. I have mentioned wheat. Take sugar: sugar is a food necessity. Deputy Dillon will say you cannot produce it at the cost at which you could get it formerly from outside countries. I agree that you probably cannot get it at the cost at which it was being dumped formerly, at any rate when they were trying to get rid of agricultural produce at any time. I say that the growing of beet and the manufacture of it in our factories into sugar is a useful thing from the point of view of general economy. It gives work to the farmer; it gives him alternative crops. It is much better in any case not to have all our eggs in one basket. The farmer is getting fixed prices that he knows in advance, practically with certainty, except in so far as weather conditions may upset things completely. All agriculture is subject to vicissitudes arising from the weather, and I think much of the talk that we hear about the state of agriculture is mainly due to the bad harvest last year which was owing to weather conditions. You see what we are doing in regard to food. We are trying to produce the raw material from the land, whether it be wheat or sugar beet. We have been pursuing that policy definitely. We are trying to manufacture our requirements here at home. Our flour mills, before we came into office, were only half employed, and some of them were closed down. We were producing only about 50 per cent. of our requirements. Now, we are producing the whole of our requirements, and if we had the raw material in wheat, as far as that principal food is concerned, we could say that we do not care, in that regard, as far as war is concerned; we are not going to be short.

The same applies to sugar. We are in a position that if there were some crisis we need not go short. In regard to sugar there are two elements to be considered, the price which the farmer gets and the price which the consumer has to pay. It is a balance between those two. The farmer very naturally wants to get the most he can for his labour. The Government, looking after the interests of the community as a whole, has to ask what is the price which the community ought to give the farmer for the service which he is rendering the community in producing that food. There will always be a certain amount of conflict between the two, but they will settle themselves, on the one hand, by the desire of the community to get its sugar and, on the other, by the desire of the farmer to grow a profitable crop. If there was an attempt on the part of one section to profiteer at the expense of the other, then the Government would have to seek a remedy, and the remedy it would seek in a case like that would be to say to the farmer: "Very well; you have been given an opportunity of producing at a reasonable price. You want to exceed that price. We will open the door and allow sugar to be imported." That is the only weapon that the Government ultimately has at its disposal in order to prevent one section of the community from getting undue profit and undue reward for its service at the expense of the rest. I say that generally we could do that and that we are in a position to exercise control generally if we wanted to do so. I have shown that we are pursuing a definite plan in trying to get our food produced at home.

Let us consider clothing. A large quantity of clothing was being imported which we felt could be produced at home. If you look at the reduction in imports of wearing apparel and the increase in our industrial production you will see at once that we have made very rapid progress along that line. I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking some time ago, indicated that there was some £20,000,000 worth of imports which he felt could be substituted by home-made goods. Our progress along that line can be shown by the fact that there are 900 workshops and factories employing some tens of thousands of people producing goods which were formerly coming in from outside. I think last night I gave the figure as 800. It is really 900. It was an older figure I gave last night. Some people will say that these are foolish, mushroom industries. They are not mushroom industries. Do not tell me that the production of boots and of clothing are mushroom industries. There is always a demand here for these things. We cannot produce some of them at the rate at which they could be produced in Japan or at the price at which they could be obtained if we opened the ports and let in Japanese goods or goods from other countries. If we let goods in from other countries, undoubtedly our own industries would become mushroom industries, but there is no reason whatever for thinking that industries established for the purpose of meeting fundamental needs are mushroom industries.

We were told that the promoters of these industries are making undue profits, that the Government is not exercising proper care. The very people who are talking about undue profits talk about the agreement which we made and say that is going to cause our industries to close down. We made an agreement to take in on certain conditions industrial goods that we require, in return for the export to Britain of our agricultural produce. But we safeguarded our industries. We made it clear that a Prices Commission of Irishmen would look into the matter, would consider the relative costings here and abroad, and would fix the tariffs at such a level as would allow our home industries, having regard to our circumstances, our smaller numbers, and so on, to be carried on at a reasonable profit. We knew in accepting that that we were only accepting a certain check on profits, so that they would be examined. When we originally accepted the general plan of protection, we knew that when industries were established it would be necessary to have some machinery for examining prices and seeing that undue profits were not made under the shelter which we were providing. People have been talking about tariffs. We do not regard tariffs as of any value except as a shelter to enable our industries to carry on behind them and be saved from the attack of unfair competition from outside. We do not recognise any other particular virtue in tariffs. They do help the Minister for Finance, indirectly, to help the Exchequer, but that is not our purpose in it. That is not the aim of our tariffs, and the lower these tariffs are the better, we know, for the community. When I say the lower they are I mean whilst they are effective, because there is no point in putting up a wall if the wall is not high enough to afford the protection required. There is a difference of view as to what exactly is the height that is necessary in order to afford adequate protection.

As long as we have an individualistic economy, as long as we recognise the rights of private property, we must give the individual incentive to produce. The individual's incentive to produce is reasonable profit or return for what he is doing. It should be reasonable, and the business of the Government, in the matter of safeguarding the general welfare, is to see in so far as it can that that particular incentive is not contrary to the general welfare or to the common good.

We have got to watch over it from that point of view, but our views about private property are the views which are expressed in our Constitution. We acknowledge and recognise the right of private property, but we also recognise the right of the Government, as the guardian of the common good, to regulate the use that is to be made of that private property so that it will be in the general interest.

Now, I have referred to food and clothing. You have to look at the results, and you can see the progress that has been made in accordance with that plan. I repeat there is a plan, and that it has been pursued. The next thing of fundamental importance is that our people should be properly housed. We came in here and saw a terrible situation facing the people. In this city we saw one quarter of the people, roughly, housed with only one room as a home. That was a disgraceful condition from the human point of view, and from the economic point of view a completely unsatisfactory situation. We set out to try to remedy it. The result of our work in trying to remedy the situation about housing through the country as a whole has been that in our time some 100,000 houses have been either reconstructed or erected. You have only to go for a short motor drive through the country to see the results of that policy. We have not finished the job by any means. It is a fundamental job which we set ourselves to accomplish, and we are, by hook or by crook, going to see it pursued and finished, if possible. There is a rate of progress beyond which you cannot go. We have here our cement factories to produce the material required both for housing and for road construction.

Unfortunately, we have not one fundamental material, namely, timber. In the pursuit of our general economic ideal, it is our purpose to try to produce timber, to see that those generations which come after us—because unfortunately, timber cannot be produced overnight—will, at any rate, have that fundamental material here at home: that they will have their own home-grown timber. We have people who think that there is some special virtue in that particular line of afforestation. There is not, except in producing what we require—a fundamental raw material. Look at the progress that has been made. We have now gone up to the point at which about 8,000 acres are being planted every year. It is estimated that the planting of about 20,000 acres would meet our needs. We expect in a very short time to get up to 10,000 acres. There is a lot of fallacy talked about this whole question of afforestation.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

There is a lot of nonsense talked about it. I think nobody could have pressed harder than I have for the speeding up of afforestation. I pressed every successive Minister who has been in charge of that Department to speed it up for the simple reason that it is fundamental in the pursuit of this general plan which I have indicated. It was said that some officials were totally opposed to it: that they had some bias, and so on. I said, if that is so, then you are to try to get other people. I said that we should get the best advice—to go through the world for experts and get them. They have got an expert. I have asked him to make a survey: to give me his views as to the total amount of plantable land. When I say plantable land I do not mean that you are going to go into the lands of Meath and plant forests in them. What I mean by plantable land is land that, in his opinion, would be useful, and that is available for afforestation. He has given me an estimate. I want that estimate checked. I want to check the land that is good for afforestation and that would also be good for agricultural purposes.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

We have to ask ourselves a very common-sense question, keeping in mind that we are trying to be as self-sufficient as we can—because here, as in other things, it is again a question of balance—what should we do, for instance, about some mountain side? It is a sheep range at the moment. What is the annual value of it as a sheep range? How many people does it give a living to? If you put it under forestry what is going to be the return from it, estimate it any way you like? It has a certain economic value at the present time. What economic value will that land have if it is put under afforestation? How do the two figures compare? I am not going to give you the figures at the moment, because I want those things checked. They are not by any means easy figures to arrive at, but I can say that, looking at this from the cold economic point of view, afforestation is not nearly as attractive per acre as the devotees of afforestation will claim. I have seen absolutely absurd figures given about the value of afforestation. I want to be understood correctly on this, because I believe that every acre that can be more profitably used for planting should be so used. Timber is a fundamental product, and by hook or by crook we ought to try to plant as much as will supply our own internal needs and save us from the risk which we are facing at the moment if there should be war: the risk of being cut short of a fundamental material.

In any case, what we are doing there is in accordance with the whole general line of our policy, and so I want to tell the advocates of more afforestation that we are going ahead with it as rapidly as we can. In the matter of afforestation you cannot have that rapid development and production which you can look for, say, in the case of the pig industry. It takes time and there has to be a good deal of preparation. The preparation is slow. We are developing it as quickly as we can. If we go too fast there is bound to be more loss than if we go at a reasonable rate.

Someone may ask me "Are you satisfied with the present rate"? I am not satisfied. I am not satisfied about any of these things. I am anxious to push them faster. I suppose that, as human beings, we are not ever going to be satisfied. We all think that things could be done better, and we are all striving to perfect and improve as far as it is possible. I have dealt with food, clothing and shelter. I have spoken of the cement factories. Another very important thing is steel. There has been a considerable disappointment with regard to some of our explorations. We had hopes at one time with regard to Arigna. Employment was very badly needed there. We have had it examined and we find that there is no possibility of developing either coal or iron products. We would be very glad to develop them if there was any possibility of doing so. If we cannot get the primary, we hope at least to develop some secondary steel industries, and we are making a start in a certain sense at the moment.

The next fundamental thing that we come to is fuel. We are trying at the moment to make use of the native fuel supplies as quickly as possible. There is a difficulty about certain coal deposits. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has been for a long time anxious to get some of those deposits used. There has been difficulty at the moment but I hope that difficulty will soon be removed.

It is mainly in our bogs that we have a great fuel supply. We are developing those bogs and that raw material as quickly and as economically as we can without great losses. Take Clonsast bog, for instance: in about two years' time we will be capable of turning out 150,000 tons of fuel from that bog, and we hope to see an electrical power plant erected on that bog. We are developing these resources according to a definite plan, and we are trying to get these fundamental native fuels used at home.

I have heard talk about reclamation. When the fuel is cut off these big bog lands, there will be land left. The land can be reclaimed and, in all probability, will be useful for certain agricultural purposes. We have seen reclaimed bog used all over the country. There may be a quantity of land like that which can be brought into cultivation, and we are seeking it. The Department of Agriculture and the Department of Industry and Commerce will try between them to deal with that, and try to get it brought into cultivation. We have, of course, to consider costs and the relative value of the final result.

We have been told about drainage. Now, we are pursuing a plan in regard to drainage. We have seen absurd drainage schemes pursued in the past, we have seen the upper reaches of rivers drained without any consideration as to whether the main channel could carry the extra water or not, where the draining of one part means the flooding of another part. Clearly we should not pursue a plan in that particular way. Apart from the legal entanglements with regard to maintenance and the burden of cost falling upon the people who are benefiting, there is also the question of a proper engineering survey. A commission has been set up in order to deal with drainage, so that we may start on the work in a comprehensive fashion. I hope that, in a short time, we will have ready a scheme which will enable us to proceed systematically with the drainage of the country and, by draining, the making of the land more profitable for our people.

Let people then not sneer when they talk about a plan. We are pursuing that definite plan which I am outlining and doing it "within the system" (to use a phrase which I have used already). The criticism we are receiving from the Opposition is, that the pursuit of this plan does not lead ultimately to the welfare of our people. There we divide with them: the issue is knit between us on that point. We believe the plan does lead ultimately to prosperity. If the country thinks otherwise, they can take the Opposition and put them in as a Government, to pursue whatever plan they put before the people. As far as we are concerned, we believe in this: we believe in it, even if we were to go out to-morrow. The position even then would be that the evils resulting from the Opposition policy would be so great and so apparent that the country would revert back to this policy of ours.

No policy is going to give perfection: there is going to be a certain amount of evil attached to every policy and it is a question of the balance of advantages and evils and the taking of the best from the national point of view. As I have said, the criticism is that it is costing too much. It is said that our principal industry, agriculture, is not going to be as flourishing as it would be if the Opposition ideas of economy were in operation. As far as the requirements of the farmer are concerned, his requirements are not very much different from the requirements of the people in the urban areas. The Opposition say it will not be as profitable for him if those requirements are met from inside, as if we open the ports and allow his requirements to be met from outside. I can only say to the farmer: "It is true you may have to pay for certain things a little more, but the people who are producing those things for you are a better market for you." They said they wanted to make a market for Pat Murphy. The idea, I take it, was that they wanted to make here at home a market for our own people, a market for the produce of our own people's labour. The farmer has a market in the men who produce his industrial goods, his clothes, boots, and so on. The industrialist is a market for the man who produces the fuel—if he is not in a position where he can use all the turbary on his own farm. The industrialist or urban dweller is a market for the farmer, and a better and surer market than the industrialist who is working in England and who is a market for the food which is being exported by us.

Comment on this

If he had any money.

Comment on this

Money is got by production. Money is only a claim on goods or on services, and it is the goods and the services that mean money. The man who is able to perform services—if he is let—for his neighbours, has money. If he is able to perform services for his neighbour, that neighbour must give him in return something for it. I will come to that subject, I hope, in the course of this talk.

I am concerned at the moment only in indicating the general economic policy pursued by the Government. I am admitting that one cannot have it both ways: if we go in for efficient production, the principal drawback is that we have not as big a market as people in other countries and therefore we cannot produce per unit as efficiently as they can. However, we have the brains and the skill to produce for ourselves. I remember a former Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking from one of these benches, said that because we had not got efficient management we could not produce boots. That is utter nonsense. We have the brain and the skill, and I do hope that we will be able to get here the desire for work, the desire to produce and to do things actively to keep ourselves.

I am not touching on the Labour Party motion yet, but I will come to it in due time. At the moment I am concerned rather with the difference between ourselves and the Opposition. Fundamentally the Opposition policy is a free trade policy, whilst ours is not. Theirs, if you like, is one that leans in that direction: it can neither be said to be completely free trade nor completely protectionist. The Opposition policy leans on the free trade side whilst our policy leans on the side of self-sufficiency. We believe that we are right and that that will be proved. If there should be a change of Government the principal thing about it is that it would be a test. We believe that there has been a test over a long period of years and it has shown results. We are pursuing a policy which is producing the results which we said it would of necessity produce. We have never denied that. We saw the disadvantages and yet we said that the disadvantages were worth while for the sake of the advantages. We do not mind if the commission reveals those disadvantages: we knew that they would exist. What we say is that the commission was only set up to examine the situation existing at the time at which the examination was made. We say that if we want to have a comparison, there must be an examination of what the results might have been under the other system.

It is a comparison of the two systems, and not merely revealing the evils, that matters. By all means, let us try to correct these evils, if we can, and I will come to some of them later, but, again, I say that the Opposition attitude is that these things are costing too much.

We went out also on the general principles that we had a duty to a section of the community, those who, under the existing system and in the existing circumstances, were not able to work and to maintain themselves, and we developed certain social services for that reason. These services have added to the cost. They have to be paid for. From what? From the wealth that exists, from the pockets of those who have and who are able to make that contribution to the welfare of the community as a whole. These things have to be met, but we still believe that these social services, notwithstanding the fact that they are, to the extent to which contributions have to be made by the individual in the way of taxes and so on, a burden— and they are a certain burden—constitute a burden which we ought to carry, which I believe we can carry and which I believe it is our duty to carry. Certain of the costs then—in fact, all of them—are due to the fact that we are to a certain extent interfering in the economic life of the country. We have to interfere in it because, if you adopt the old laissez faire policy, it is only certain sections who will be able to survive. The laissez faire policy, the free trade policy, and so on, are all of a part, and we have definitely turned our backs on them. In doing so, I know that we are sacrificing certain advantages and undertaking certain burdens.

By all means, it is the duty of the Opposition to examine expenditure, to criticise it, to try to keep it down. We do that, too. Let nobody think that we undertake new expenditure without a certain amount of heartburning, because we know that that expenditure is going to reveal itself ultimately, even from the narrow political point of view, in the imposition of burdens which the people will resent to a certain extent. No expenditure is decided on by the Government, or proposed to the Dáil after consideration by the Government, without the most careful examination to see whether it is worth while. Are we paying too much for our whistle at any particular stage, is a question which is naturally asked. The Minister for Finance, with his Department, is the principal watchdog in that regard.

As I am talking about this planning in general to those members of the House who may not understand the machinery, who have not had the advantage of being in a former Government, I want to point out to them that it is a mistake to think that one Department goes off on one road, while another Department goes off on another, and that there is no centralisation or no plan being followed. That is not true. When a proposal is put forward by one Department, the proposal, and the reasons for it, are circulated to all Departments concerned, and, if any Department is affected, the proposal is criticised from the point of view of that Department, and always before proposals of that sort are originated, the Government, as a whole, considers whether such a project can be undertaken, whether it is in the national interest that it should be undertaken, what is it going to cost and so on, and then there is a sort of general agreement. We will let that go ahead. The moment the general idea is agreed, the originating Department puts down its proposals, which are criticised from the point of view of their effect on the other Departments.

Every single proposal is examined carefully and minutely by the Department of Finance. Every other Department, naturally is, then, more or less antagonistic to the Department of Finance, because there is a desire, on the one hand, to do something, while, on the other, there is the check of what it is going to cost. One Department leans unduly on one side and the other Department unduly on the other, and sometimes it is very hard to know who is right and whether, in fact, the service is going to be worth the price, and at a time like the present, if there is any doubt, it simply is dropped. If there is, in fact, a doubt that it is really worth while, that the cost is worth while, it will not be proceeded with. There are hundreds or thousands of projects upon which we could to-morrow embark, were it not for the consideration of what it is going to cost.

Comment on this

That is the trouble with us all.

Comment on this

Exactly. That is the trouble with everybody, and, in the long run, public finance is not very much different from private finance, and the welfare of the community as a whole, and how its welfare is to be brought about, is not very much different, except that it is on a larger scale, from a very big family with a reasonably good estate to manage. The fundamental principles are not very much different, in my opinion, and perhaps when we come to consider questions of credit, illustrations of that kind may help us. It is a question of whether it is worth it, whether the benefit you think you are going to confer on the community represents value for the burden which that benefit is going to impose on any section of the community. As a rule, that is what it all works down to. Yesterday, for example, Deputy Dillon, notwithstanding that we are "burst," without hesitation, voted here for an increase—I think it is going to mean about £5,000 ultimately on public funds—in respect of the cost of representation in Canada. He even wanted us to go to Australia.

Comment on this

I think it is a very good thing.

Comment on this

I am merely pointing out to Deputy Dillon the very important point of whether he thinks it worth while.

Comment on this

Is it part of the self-sufficiency policy?

Comment on this

It is a question of whether it is worth while. It is a part of our self sufficiency as a nation, and I am not blaming Deputy Dillon for voting for it. I voted for it myself. What I want to point out is that, although Deputy Dillon comes in here and says that this nation is burst, although he says that we are on the verge of a precipice, and although he thinks that we are going bankrupt, and that we have to go hat in hand to John Bull and ask him, "For God's sake, take us over as you took over Newfoundland"——

Comment on this

You would need to take over a tall hat, though.

Comment on this

when I introduced a proposal for expenditure here, because he likes it and thinks it would be good, he says it is worth while. The difference between ourselves and the Opposition in this particular matter is that we think the things that we are doing worth while and worth the burdens they are imposing. We are not denying for a moment that they are imposing certain burdens.

Comment on this

I resist the temptation to interrupt.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have every chance. Deputy Dillon proclaimed that he was not an obscurantist when it came to a question of expenditure in the neighbourhood of £5,000. Why? Because he thought it was going to be in the national interest that that expenditure should be incurred. I say that when the Government, notwithstanding the objections which will always be raised by Finance, because of the burdens which any new project is going to put on the country, decide that it is going to be undertaken, the Government have done what Deputy Dillon did in that precise instance to which I am referring—they have said that it is worth while. The country as a whole is going to benefit by it.

The social services which we have increased, the expenditure which we have urged upon Parliament to undertake and to place upon the country have been decided on and carried out after due deliberation and after due balancing of the advantages and disadvantages. We are only human. It may happen that our estimate is wrong. It may happen that Deputy Dillon and myself may be quite wrong in thinking that that expenditure of £5,000 is for the benefit of the country. We may be quite wrong in that. I am sure that I could find Deputies in all parts of the House who would tell me, if I had them out in the corridor, that that expenditure was quite foolish. There are Deputies on all sides of the House who would say that it was foolish. Yet Deputy Dillon and I, in our judgment, consider that it is worth while to put that burden upon the people in order to get the advantages, not immediately material advantages, but other advantages which if we come to examine them we would find would have material significance too. In the same way, we had a Vote on the League of Nations. There are people in this House who would say, "What is the use of Geneva now?" I see Deputy Belton over there——

Comment on this

Geneva has done all the damage it can.

Comment on this

Yes, people will say: "Why, in the name of goodness, keep it up any longer, to do more damage, after spending the sum of money that is being spent at present in being a part of that institution?" Deputy Belton has his view. The people on the Opposition Front Bench, because they are not obscurantists in that particular matter, consented, and I am glad that I was supported by the Front Bench in proposing that we continue representation at Geneva.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did not always hold that view. He did not hold it when in opposition.

Comment on this

What view?

Comment on this

The view of having representation in the League of Nations.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, I did.

Comment on this

My memory is very clear on that. That was not the Taoiseach's view always.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a statement. I would like to see some quotation in support of that.

Comment on this

I have a very clear memory of it.

Comment on this

I might object to the way in which things were done. I would like to see any quotation by the Deputy in support of his statement.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, I thought, has a very good memory.

Comment on this

I would like to have my memory jogged on that question by getting the actual quotation. However, the cost of our representation at the League of Nations is one of those elements which certain people would say are not to be cut down. What I say now to the Opposition is—do not do as Deputy Cosgrave does. Do not take the 21 items together and say "that should be reduced." What I want the Opposition to do is to show us the particular items that they want to see reduced. What are the particular services that these items are rendering to the community which Deputies think the community should forego? The community in general would have to forego these services. Which of these services does the Opposition want to cut out?

Comment on this

That is the Government's job.

Comment on this

Yes, so it is. We say that it is part of our daily duty to do it.

Comment on this

How does our credit stand?

Comment on this

Splendid.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Our credit is as good as the credit of any nation in the world.

Comment on this

Then use it.

Comment on this

We are using it. I will get my time at the Labour side in a minute. At the moment I am only interested in the issue between ourselves and the main Opposition, and I think I am saying what is fair when I say that we, supervising these things, are as anxious about this expenditure as is the main Opposition.

We say that the services on which the money is expended are worth while. Does the Opposition want to cut down the cost of the services or to get the services more efficiently managed? If the Opposition says: "We want to get the services more efficiently managed", I am at one with them in that. If there are three people in an office and two could do the work as efficiently as three, by all means cut the office down to two. There is nobody who has been more anxious about the growth in the numbers in the public service than I have been. I believe it is possible to get the work done with fewer people. It is one thing to believe that but it is quite another thing to be able to effect it and to get the work done by fewer people.

We wanted to increase the rate at which land was being divided. In order to do that we had to get extra inspectors. The training of these inspectors slowed down the work for a time. We have asked ourselves whether we will increase the rate at which the work is to be done or not. Somebody asked the other day what about the cost of the administration of the Land Commission. It is very high. It is so high that I would think myself that one of the things we ought to aim at is to try as soon as possible to get the work done more quickly so as to reduce the cost of administration.

The remarks that have been made lead Deputies on to side issues; there is the danger of getting away from the main facts. There is first of all this question of the credit of farmers. There is this statement that the farmer's credit is impaired through the danger that his property may be taken from him. Now, there is no property taken from the farmer without compensation and without a definite public reason for the taking of that property. The people who are likely to be interfered with know perfectly well the reason why land may be taken from them. No person who is attending to and working his land properly is in any danger of his land being taken from him. We have, however, the duty of seeing that the land should be properly employed and used to the best advantage for the country. When there is no other land for the relief of congestion and to repair that condition which has been the result of the past social economic system—a system which mainly persisted because of the existence of a foreign Government—then, in order to remedy that position, land that is not properly used must be taken. We have to relieve congestion and to do that we try to induce people with large holdings in congested areas to leave. It is as much a question of inducing them to leave as of compelling them to leave. But, ultimately, we want the power of compulsion. The Land Commission in these matters is proceeding with all due care.

If I were asked why the farmer's credit is not as good as it was, I would say that the farmers are a large section of the community, and there is the feeling that the farmer is not to be sold out because he cannot pay his debts. It is because the land cannot be sold in the public market for the mortgagee that the credit of the farmer from that point of view is diminishing. If you give your house as security for a loan, you give it on the understanding that if the loan is not paid, then the property which is given in pledge against that loan would be available to the lender. That is not so in the case of land. It is mainly because of that difficulty, and not because of the reasons stated in the debate, that it is difficult for some farmers to get credit. But, on the whole, that matter is exaggerated, just as other things are exaggerated. On the whole farmers are getting a reasonable amount of credit, and, perhaps, it is just as well for particular farmers that they cannot get credit too easily. Getting into debt and borrowing is not a thing that anybody should undertake too easily, because it is going to be a terrible burden to the farmer later on. If a farmer mortgages his land, it is no longer his own. The less the farmer mortgages and pledges his land, the better. Now, lest I be regarded as an obscurantist by the Labour Party, I just want to speak of that in passing. Most of these statements by the Opposition are only partial statements of certain things.

Well then, I say to the Opposition, we are doing as well as we can. We are doing the things that you want to have done, namely, the curtailment of unnecessary expenditure, the curtailment of unprofitable expenditure and we are attempting to get the administration of whatever public services we have carried out as economically as possible. That is our business. If you can prove to the country that we have failed, the country can have its alternative, but, if the country wants an alternative, I tell the people of the country that they will find that, while people may say it is easy to cut down expenditure, you can only cut it down substantially by cutting out important services. The Opposition were very eloquent in pointing out that some of the burdens entailed by these services would fall on the weaker sections of the community.

I say that these curtailments which the Opposition have called for will inevitably affect mostly the weaker sections of the community. The only way I can see to bring about a diminution of expenses is to get after the administration and to have the administration made more economic. When I say "administration" I mean administration in its narrow sense, the actual doing of the services. We can try to have these done as economically and efficiently as possible. I have been urging that on various Departments and Ministers, and if anything can be done in that direction we shall have it done, but these economies are not going to make very significant changes in the present position.

With regard to defence, we had statements in regard to the cost of defence, and if I were to go into them, again they would take me on a side issue. What I say in regard to defence is that it is very little use for us to be doing other things now if we are not going to put ourselves in a position in which we shall be able to maintain whatever liberties we have got. It is ridiculous for people to talk about "bombers" as if they were to be used for attack alone. They know perfectly well that they are not used for attack alone. They can be used for other purposes. Bombing machines can also be used as reconnaissance machines and they can be used for defensive purposes. To try to make out that we have some ideas about advancing to attack other people with those machines is all nonsense. Of course, weapons that are capable of being used in defence can also be used for attack. They would be very little use in defence if they were not equally available for attack. The sums we are spending compared with the sums other nations are spending on these services are very small.

Comment on this

Where are you getting all the money?

Comment on this

We are getting the money from the same source as we are getting all the other money spent on public services.

Comment on this

All of it?

Comment on this

Most of it. All of it in the sense that it has to be repaid. We are getting it from sections of the community who are in possession of most of the existing wealth of the nation. We are getting it because we have the credit of the nation behind us, the power of taxation behind us, the power to get from those who have, some of what they have. That is where we are getting it. As we go along, we can see whether there is any other way in which we can get it. However, I shall leave the Opposition side of the question. The issue is knit between us. We say we are doing the things that they want to do. We are not going to change our policy. The pursuit of that policy involves certain consequences. We think, on balance, that the consequences of that policy are better than would be the consequences of the opposite policy.

Before I leave that matter, I want to say that it is nonsense to suggest that we are facing an immediate catastrophe from the economic point of view. There may be a catastrophe but it will not be caused by our economic situation. There may be a catastrophe caused by a world war, a catastrophe which will bring danger and burdens to our people far beyond anything that was ever spoken of at the time of the economic war, but that is another matter. That is not the matter we are discussing in this motion. We are discussing the question on this motion as to whether the economic position of the country is such as Deputy Dillon describes it—I forget whether he used the remark himself but I heard it imputed to him—that we are "bust". We are nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

I did not use that observation.

Comment on this

I only heard somebody impute it to the Deputy. We are not, in fact, facing a catastrophe in the economic sense. We are not facing a crisis. There are difficulties no doubt. We do not fight a war, even an economic war, without losses but, again, there were losses and gains. There was a demand for £5,000,000 a year which would continue for another generation at least. You would have to be sending out £5,000,000 worth of cattle and other native products annually in order to pay that money. We felt that it was not due. We fought to retain it and the settlement, leaving out the items, meant that we settled at £10,000,000 a claim of £100,000,000. That is what the economic war ended in.

There have been losses, and no doubt, these losses added to the losses which the farmers were suffering as a result of the depression in agriculture. It is true to say that to the extent to which our farmers suffered losses during this period we did our best to recoup them in other ways. I think if you look at what was done you will find that it was not a question of all losses and no gains whatever. There was a gain in the stabilisation of butter prices far above the world market price, in the halving of the annuities and in our schemes for wheat and beet. These did give back something to the farmer in return for what he was losing, but he did lose. I am not going to say that he did not lose.

I am not going to attack the general proposition made here that it was the poorer sections of the community suffered most, but I do say that there has been an exaggeration of the whole thing. It is true to say that the farmers would be able to take advantage of the improvement which has taken place if their farms were better stocked and if they got more capital. There is a commission sitting at the moment to inquire into the whole agricultural position and with a view to making recommendations which may benefit that particular industry, having in view all the time the general welfare of the country as a whole. When that commission reports, and when we have examined their recommendations, we shall see in fact whether we can agree with them and whether their recommendations will benefit that particular section of the community or will benefit the community as a whole. People have been talking about derating and about providing unlimited credit at low rates of interest. The members of the commission are doing work which could not be done in any Department. They may not have power to initiate a proposal as the Department of Agriculture would have, but they have power at least to consider something about the the cost of these schemes. We believed that, in making available the assistance that we promised, it would be very much better to have that made available by way of halving the annuities than by simple derating.

However, as I have said, there is a commission inquiring into the agricultural situation. I hope they will be able to bring forward proposals which it will be possible for us to accept, having regard to the general state of the community.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

Their recommendations are already in the bag.

Comment on this

Are they?

Comment on this

Indeed they are.

Comment on this

I will be glad to see them.

Comment on this

And everybody knows it.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy means. Is there being put forward already—as was done in the case of the Banking Commission—a suggestion that it is a packed commission?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Deputy Corry told us it was all a "cod". He told us that here in the House, with the apparent approval of the Minister for Finance, too.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry is captain of his own soul in the matter. I do not know what Deputy Corry said, but I am sure he believed it.

Comment on this

He is blushing quite prettily.

Comment on this

I am quite willing to admit that, after the severe situation through which agriculture has passed, if we are to take full advantage of the situation we would want to have our farms somewhat better stocked. But again, people are inclined to think of the easy way for doing those things— get it from somebody else, or something of that sort. A person may not be able to do it in a year; he may have to forego the profits of a year, but, as I said a few moments ago, you can begin small and grow up. In the case of recouping oneself for losses, the best way to proceed may be to go carefully and slowly. Before I finish with that, I want to examine—the Minister for Finance has done it, but it may be no harm to examine it a bit further—what is the evidence of this catastrophe, this crisis, which Deputy Dillon seemed to suggest was in the offing. I cannot see any, except the catastrophe of war, which I take it this discussion is not about. In 1934, from the agricultural point of view, even in outside countries, we had come to the bottom of the agricultural depression. That coincided with the economic war. But from 1934 or 1935 there has been evidence of a constant increase, so it is not into a depression we are going, leaving out again the question of war. There is obviously an upward trend. We hear a good deal about increased production. The increased production is there. It is obvious from the statistics.

Comment on this

In beet?

Comment on this

In regard to beet, that is not our fault.

Comment on this

What is wrong with its being in beet?

Comment on this

There is not an increase in production there.

Comment on this

We are not at fault.

Comment on this

I am not saying that.

Comment on this

The point is that, taking our agricultural and our industrial output as a whole, there is an increase. There is a steady increase as far as I can see, from 1934-35 on, taking it as a whole. If you want to talk about beet, you are up against the question as to whether or not one section of the community is going to give its services to the community as a whole at the price which the community is prepared to pay. I would be very glad to eliminate strikes of all kinds——

Comment on this

Is that the cause of it?

Comment on this

——but if there is a strike on the part of the beet growers I cannot help it. It is a strike between the producers who are giving a certain service to the community, and the community who want to buy. That will have to regulate itself in that particular way. We tried to regulate it. I think the Minister for Agriculture intervened at some stage, and I think there was an arbitrator appointed to settle the price. The price which was agreed upon was given, and as far as I know they agreed to grow the beet. If they do not grow it, then the farmers are going deliberately to forego a profitable crop. It may be a difficult crop. There may be hard work with it, but on the whole it is profitable use for their land, and it is a general public service. Are we going to compel the growing of it? Are we going to take over an area, and put in people to grow beet on it? Are we going to adopt a collectivist economy or not? I do not know whether the Labour Party are interested in having a collectivist economy?

Comment on this

We will leave that to the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance and I, and other members of the Government, would like very much to know definitely from the Labour Party what is their programme in regard to these matters. I will come to the Labour Party's programme in a moment. Let me finish by saying that there is no indication that we are going into a crisis. We are coming out of a crisis, obviously. All the indications show that, and we are having increased production. Our industrial output, comparing 1931 and 1937—I have been given, I think, the latest figures that are available——

Comment on this

The 1938 figures, published in the Trade Journal of June last, are worth looking at, too.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

I will let the Minister for Industry and Commerce deal with those in detail, and the House can see what inferences are to be drawn from the figures that are there. There is one thing that occurs to me in connection with it: the prospect or the possibility of war, all the talk about depression, all the statements that are made by people on the opposite benches and other people speaking like that throughout the country without a single tittle of foundation for their jeremiads, have had an adverse effect.

Comment on this

I am only saying that the 1938 figures are worth looking at too.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce will deal with the 1938 figures. I got these figures; I did not ask them to supply special ones. I have here those figures for 1931 and 1937, and I find that the gross industrial output was nearly £54.9 millions in 1931; it had gone to £87.3 millions in 1937, so there was an increase of £32.4 millions in the gross output.

Comment on this

Some of it being substantial taxation and duplication.

Comment on this

There is no denying the meaning of those figures. They indicate the progress that has been made in industrial development.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think this debate is regarded by the whole House as of major importance, and it should be conducted with the calm deliberation that it merits. Interruptions and the raising of side issues disturb the theme of the debate, and will not make for a debate worthy of the motion.

Comment on this

The net figure was £25.6 millions in 1931, while in 1937 it was nearly £34.4 millions—an increase of £8.8 millions. In those figures there is no evidence of a diminution in production. There is increased production. I am not saying it is as much as we could get. By all means, press forward for more. Good luck to everybody who presses on for more production. I am delighted to see it. If people press on for more and harder work I will not object to it. Unfortunately, I think there is not enough.

I am talking of those who are in a position to produce more. I am not satisfied by any means that any of us is working half as hard as it would be good for us to work. With regard to agriculture, I have here the figures of production for 1936-37 and for 1934-35. In 1934-35 it was nearly £39,000,000— it was £38.9 millions—and in 1936-37 it was £47.3 millions. There is, again, a substantial increase in agricultural production. If you take our exports —I think the Minister for Finance pointed to this—in 1935, when we were obviously at the bottom of the depression, the agricultural exports were £13.8 millions. In 1938 they were £19.6 millions. Those who are interested in our exports, therefore, will see that there is an increase in exports.

The trade balance has been spoken of. The adverse trade balance at the bottom of the depression was £21,000,000—that was about 1934. In 1938, it was £17,000,000, and up to 31st March this year was £15.9 millions. So that, as far as external trade is concerned, we have an improvement in the adverse balance. Of course, we are always likely to have an adverse balance of trade as long as we are a creditor country, unless in exceptional circumstances—I am taking it over a very long period. There is no decrease in our live stock population—it is going up. There was an increase on the 1st June, 1938, as compared with 1937. The Minister gave these figures. He pointed out that cattle had gone up by 2.6 per cent., sheep 6.6, pigs 2.6, and horses 2.9; so that our live stock has increased.

Comment on this

Is the Taoiseach making a comparison with 1931?

Comment on this

No. I am pointing out that there is no indication that we are faced with a crisis. I am pointing out that we are coming obviously out of a crisis, that there is an upward trend which ought to inspire confidence and optimism, leaving out a world war situation, and not a depression. I do not see why people should try to cause depression when they must know perfectly well, they have the interests of the country as a whole at heart, that all attempts to do that are going to have the effects they are pretending to deplore, or which they are deploring, if they think the thing is true. I am trying to get them out of that mood of pessimism by pointing out that all the indications show an improvement. So far as the acreage under crops is concerned there was an increase between 1931 and 1938. With regard to the index of prices, it has gone up. At the bottom of the period it was 83.4; it has gone up to 111.9, practically 112. So far as agricultural wages are concerned, the average wage has gone up from 24/3 to 27/3. I am asking where are the indications that we are going into a catastrophic depression or crisis? I cannot see it.

Comment on this

That wage is only on paper.

Comment on this

People will produce figures from some volumes, and when we produce them from official publications, which are not cooked, and ask you to draw your conclusions from them, of course they are said to be all wrong. In savings certificates and savings banks returns there is no indication of any decrease. The amount has gone up from £17,000,000 in 1934-35 to £22.7 millions. If you look for other indications, either in the traffic on the railways or the bank clearances —I will not weary you with them—or any other of the usual indices by which one judges what is the trend, there is nothing that I can see to indicate that we are facing a catastrophic crisis— there is nothing of the sort.

There are, undoubtedly, evils which we would like to remedy—many of them. I should like to see if it were possible to come to the help of the agricultural industry immediately by trying to put all farmers in a position to have the necessary capital to carry out their undertakings and to produce more. I am as appreciative as anybody on the Opposition Benches of the retarding effect of increasing overhead charges on the farmers. But, again, we have to balance that with the good of the community as a whole and the need there is for looking after other sections of the community. The principal evil we have to face is that we have got a considerable unemployment problem. We set out to try to remedy that by providing profitable employment—and when I say profitable, I mean productive employment; profitable in itself and profitable to the community, so that they would be able to produce more than they consumed, if at all possible. We did that by finding industrial employment. It is said by the Opposition: "You have increased industrial employment; we do not deny that"—it cannot be denied that there are 47,000 more employed in protected industries—"but you are doing that at the expense of employment on the land." That is a thing we deny. We do not agree that it was at the expense of employment on the land. We believe that if that employment was not given there would not be employment for those people at all. We deny that our policy is of the type that it gives employment at one end and causes unemployment at the other. I do not think it does.

Whatever truth there is in what is called the flight from the country, whether it be from the rural parts to the towns, or from our country to neighbouring countries, I think that that is something that would have occurred very much more definitely and certainly if the policy of our opponents had been continued. That is a matter nobody can prove; it is a matter of opinion between us. I believe that the past is proof of it, because, in my opinion, the policy of the Opposition is not very much different from the policy that had been tried under the old British régime and by themselves over a period of ten years in which they had an opportunity of working to the full their own policy. I think there was during that time a change from country to town—it is world wide—and that there was also emigration. That emigration stopped, not because of the circumstances here, but because of conditions which prevented emigration to America at the time. There is emigration of another sort taking place now, but I think it is only temporary. I think it is mainly due to the fact that there are very attractive wages being paid across the water, because of the special situation there, due to the rush to rearm. With regard to the flight from the land, that is a more fundamental matter, and is much harder to deal with in reality. If anybody is able to stem that flood we would be very glad to hear of it.

Comment on this

Better agricultural prices will stem it.

Comment on this

Better agricultural prices may do it, but they are not within your control.

Comment on this

But the Government has done nothing about it.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that that is not true.

Comment on this

When the Taoiseach finishes I will deal with it.

Comment on this

We will be very glad to hear the Deputy.

Comment on this

What about the rates of exchange?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy not wait? Give us a little time and do not destroy the satisfaction that is in anticipation. Unfortunately the flight from the land is a fact. It is from the rural areas, and it is very difficult to see how people can be kept on the farm. As a matter of fact, there are not many farmers leaving, because if there were, numbers would be willing to take their places. We are putting more people on the land and increasing the number of farms. Certainly that is an attempt to keep people there. We want to see as many people as possible on the land. It is said agricultural labourers are not taking as kindly to that work now, and that we have not as many agricultural labourers employed on the land. Of course, if you are going to have people working on small farms, and doing the labour themselves, with the help of their families, there would not be so many agricultural labourers. They will not be needed. A big holding employs a large number of agricultural labourers, but if a large farm is made into independent holdings, there will not be as many agricultural labourers needed.

They will be replaced by the people on these holdings, the farmers, that we are planting on the land. When there is talk of the flight from the country, and that the people are being taken from the land, that requires much closer examination than has been given to it, to see how many people are leaving. That would be very difficult, but it can be examined.

Comment on this

What about farmers' sons?

Comment on this

There is a big flow from villages, small towns and urban areas into the bigger centres. The smaller centres are diminishing. They carried on under a different system in the past. There was not the opening up of the country that has taken place in recent years by modern methods of transport and other things, which have tended to bring the people to work and to business in larger centres. There was a time when you had in a village beside a town or a farm—and I am thinking of a small village that I knew —two or three tailors, a couple of bootmakers, and harness-makers. Going back to an earlier period I remember that we had mills, stone dressers, a blacksmith and people employed in services which were more or less ancillary to farming. These people are no longer there, and the work is done in a different way. That is a tendency for which I am sorry, but there is no use in hoping that we can put back the clock. From the purely philosophical point of view that might have been a better existence, because when all is said and done contentment is the thing that matters most. If we are content we are happy, and we feel that we are living a reasonable existence. No matter what wealth or conditions we have if we are discontented we are unhappy. If a person is unhappy he is unhappy. That is all there is about it. Material things will not help.

One of the things the Government has to examine is, as to what method could be employed by which country life would be made more attractive for our own people. We want to make it attractive. It is difficult to see how these things will work out. At one time I had the idea that it would help to make country life more enjoyable if we had radio sets made available cheaply for the people. I said that to someone and his remark was that that was the curse of the country, because it was giving the people there ideas about town life, and painting visions of town life. He said that was the principal cause of the attraction that was pulling people away from the country. There was the opposite point of view. It is not easy, sometimes, to be quite sure of the effect of a policy that may be tried in that regard. To make country life more attractive, as far as the Government can do it, is the aim they have in mind, if they can achieve it by any means.

We are considering how country life can be made more attractive, and we have, at some loss, brought industries as near to the land as possible. We have tried to prevent the overgrowth of large towns, by doing everything we could to get industries established outside larger centres, where they would naturally grow, because if there was an economic urge people would go to the larger centres. We try to keep them in the country. We admit that the departure from the country areas, which is common to us and to other countries is, from our point of view, a national evil and a social loss, and if anyone can suggest anything effective that can be done about it, I am sure the Government will give it consideration, and, even if it put a little burden on the community, we would be glad to undertake that burden. A still more serious question is the late marriage rate. I regard that as the most serious of all.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Not the happy marriage we heard of this week.

Comment on this

I did not hear of any.

Comment on this

We heard of it here.

Comment on this

At any rate, it is an evil. It is a great pity that such are the conditions. I think it is a matter of mind more than material conditions, and I would like to put a thumping good tax on bachelors, and to let them carry more of the burden than they are carrying at present. I am afraid there would be difficulties about that. I do know what the Minister for Finance would have to say about the general effects of it. I do not know if it would induce them to marry if a tax were put on. It is more a psychological matter. To tell the truth, I think people are a bit too careful in these matters. They want to be too well off. If we could get the idea of having a little more courage into the minds of our people, if they felt that they would be much better off if they got married—and I tell them that they would be much better off—and if we got the proper outlook there, we might be able to remedy the position. I do not think it is due absolutely, as the Labour Party suggested, to the economic position.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

I would not say so. I think you have early marriages, not amongst the wealthier classes, but more frequently amongst those that well-off people would regard as struggling. I cannot get to the root of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Unemployment.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

A fair share of it.

Comment on this

It may be, to a certain extent, but I do not think it is the thing that is fundamentally responsible. It is very hard to find out why it is so with us. I thought of the farmers, the farming position, and of those who are going to get the farms afterwards. I thought of the position where the old man or woman would stay too long in control and there is no opportunity given to the man who is going to succeed them in the possession of the farm, to get married. I was wondering was there any way in which that position might be remedied. I was told by somebody who has watched conditions in Canada that they had a system in one province there by which the farm is given to the youngest son. The others were to leave as quickly as possible, those of them who had to leave the farm. There was only one man to continue on the farm. The idea was that they got rid of the older children by sending them to professions, to business, and so on. They got away and they left the farm to the youngest son and that enabled the old pair to continue longer on the farm, and it did not prevent the young man from marrying at a reasonable age.

There are difficulties of various kinds in regard to that. They had the idea that when the young man came into possession of the land the old pair repaired to the neighbouring village, near the Chapel, and they got their vegetables, and so on, every Sunday, brought to them by the young man who succeeded to the farm. A single example like that shows how certain things are operating. Whether that was a complete picture or not, I do not know, but I do know that there would be difficulties in getting into a practice of that kind here. We have these evils in regard to the land, we have certain hardships, we have a low marriage rate, and we have the problem of unemployment.

To my mind, the question to which we should primarily address ourselves, as one which we ought to remedy, is the question of unemployment. It is the most baffling problem with which we have to deal. So far as I am concerned, I can say that I had hopes that the development of our industries would absorb most of the people who were unemployed and were prepared to work. I do not think we have got a true picture of the unemployment situation as it is. The Labour Party would say to us, "You do not know it; you have not got a true picture; your picture is not as bad as the reality." On the other hand, I am told that our figure, our picture, is worse than the reality; that the reality is not so bad as is represented by our statistics. I am just giving you what I am told by people who have gone into the matter, that our statistics include a large number of people who are not unemployed in the ordinary sense, that they are people who, like most people in business, could be employed to a fuller extent.

I am told that the unemployed, in the proper sense, do not form as large a number as is given in our statistics and that the statistics exaggerate the situation. Even making deductions for that, it is still a position which we ought to try to remedy. We had hopes that we would get a remedy through industrial production, through a better market for the farmers. We had hopes that there would be more employment on the land to supply our industrial population and that there would be more work for our industrial population in supplying the rest of the community with commodities formerly brought from outside countries. That was a reasonable hope and our figures have not proved, in effect, to be far wrong. The number in increased employment does correspond to the number who were stated to be unemployed when we came into office.

But other things have gone on at the same time, and we have still with us an unemployment problem. I do not think that even the Labour Party will say it is relatively worse with us than it is in other countries, but at the same time I admit it is a serious problem which we ought to try to solve. Mind you, if I could see a real solution for it, I would not mind saying to the rest of the community that they should bear the burdens which would enable us to get the solution within a reasonable time. The moment these people are put into productive employment, if we can find it for them, they will be the makers of wealth and not merely the consumers of it.

As far as our social aims are concerned, we are at one with the Labour Party. When I say our social aims, or our social objectives, I mean our effort to find for every member of the community as high a standard of material comfort as it is possible for us to get, as it is possible for the resources of our country to give. I said some time ago that I believed in the social principles, or the social objectives, which were indicated in some of the minority reports, and I mentioned particularly the Third Minority Report.

I read that report carefully, so far as the social objectives are concerned, and I think I could subscribe to practically everyone of them. In fact, I think in every speech which I have made in regard to the aims of Fianna Fáil and the purposes we have in mind, you will find them almost parallel in that report. Ours may not be so elegantly phrased, or so definitely expressed, but if you read over the speeches we made as to our economic policy you will find that the social objectives were practically the same as those contained in that report.

A difficulty arises in regard to how we are trying to achieve these objectives. We have been trying to achieve our aims by using the national credit —and when I call it the national credit I mean the resources of the country— in order to bring about the conditions that we require. We have been doing it in the social services and the development services—and we have been developing, in many directions. If there are large schemes of productive work that can be done—and by productive work I mean that what comes out as a result of the labour is more than goes in, and even if it came out equal we would be happy-we will endeavour to undertake them. But if you are putting into work more than comes out of it, if the value of the goods consumed by the workers in doing the work is more than the value of what is produced, then it is not productive.

Comment on this

Does that kind of argument apply to pensions and defence?

Comment on this

I am talking of productive work.

Comment on this

But you are spending money on pensions?

Comment on this

I did not say pensions were productive and I did not say defence was, and neither did the Minister for Finance. I think there was a misrepresentation or a misunderstanding of what he said, so far as I could read in the report. We are talking about productive work. If there is productive work to be got, that is, work the fruits of which will be greater than the amount of existing wealth consumed in the production, we will undertake it. If the results are equal to what has been put into it, it is not unproductive, but if they are less, then it seems to me the existing wealth of the community is being diminished.

We have accepted it as a duty to the community to see that no member of the community will starve. We have accepted the responsibility of preventing that, and there is no question that that would be voluntarily and regularly borne by our people if you could separate the sheep from the goats. The trouble that imposes itself on our social services is that it is impossible to separate the sheep from the goats. When there is a question of important work to be done, we have to proceed in the same way as when we see the cockle growing up amongst the wheat —we have got to let it grow and try to deal with it otherwise. The difficulty in our social services is that there are people availing of them who should not avail of them, and for whom they were not intended, and by administrative methods you are not able properly to eliminate them. There is nobody in the community who would not willingly bear the burden, and sacrifice some of his individual wealth—and the wealth of the community as a whole can be classified into two parts, that of individuals and whatever community wealth we have—there is nobody, either the State regarded as the community as a whole, or the individuals in it, who would hesitate to sacrifice that, in order to help those who are genuinely in need of it and to provide work for those who are willing to work. I have been informed—I do not know whether it is true, and I have asked for further examination of the matter—that there were 110 men required for a particular job, that 103 reported for it and seven others, supposed to be unemployed, did not report, and that a number of others left the job after a very short time, although the rate of pay, I think, was about 35/-.

Comment on this

Where was that?

Comment on this

I said I do not know whether it is true. I am having it examined, but if that is true one does not want, and the community does not want, to support people of that kind.

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

I quite agree with the Deputy, and I know that the Labour Party do not want it.

Comment on this

All I am saying is that I should like to know the area.

Comment on this

I am only saying if it is true. I asked somebody—an official—the question and I got this answer, and I am having it examined, but I do say that I have heard reports of all sorts about the same kind of thing, and I have heard reports even from farmers to the effect that people will not work for the farmers if they can get money from the State, and that even though the money is relatively small they prefer to do other work rather than work on the farms, or to take whatever they can get on what is called the dole. As I say, the trouble there is to separate the sheep from the goats. I know that the Labour Party does not want, and that no Party wants, to help those who do not want to work if they can get out of it. Of course, I know that the Labour Party may not agree with us on the question of whether a wage is remunerative of not, just as—Deputy Davin mentioned —the farmers may differ with us about the price of beet. That is natural, but there is one thing that the community does not want to do, and that we as a Government do not want to force the community to do, and that is to support people, for whom work is available, and who will not work, if there are any such people.

Now, the ideal type of work within our economy—I am talking now of individual economy and not purely collectivist economy—is work in which a person gives labour in return for the services and goods which he gets back. If we could achieve that, that is the ideal type of work, and our industries are valuable in helping to provide that type of work. If you could provide that, the difficulties would regulate themselves, but in providing State work you have to consider whether you are making the community richer in terms of wealth or whether, by giving that work, you are only providing amenities and luxuries and leading to a situation in which we may be living beyond our means.

Now, I may be wrong in regard to my way of looking at certain economic questions. I have been in the habit of eliminating money in my economic speculations. I know, of course, that you cannot do that, and that it is a partial view, but no matter what view you take, I can only see this ultimately in it: that money is an equivalent for what it can get, namely, an equivalent for goods and services. Therefore, if you eliminate money for the moment and think in terms of goods and services, no matter what money you have or what you do with it, in the long run, it is only to be regarded from the point of view of its effect on the volume of goods and services. The limits of our resources are the existing wealth of the community. That wealth is in various forms, and includes, for instance, our external assets—that is, their equivalent in goods.

When you say: "Pledge the nation's credit to do this, that or the other thing", what you mean is: "Make all the existing resources of the country available for these purposes." In so far as they are used up, there is a diminution of the wealth, but if there is an adequate return in increased production then you have increased the total wealth, and whenever you are able to do that, in my opinion, you can get the money and the resources will be made available for you.

Comment on this

You had better talk to the bankers about that.

Comment on this

If it should happen at any time that the control of the use of wealth, which we are by right enabled to exercise, should be denied, we would not hesitate to use our fundamental right to control it and to see that it was made available, but we will have to be reasonable in regard to it, and we cannot ask that wealth should be lost; we cannot ask that it should be put into things that are unprofitable and that will diminish our resources instead of increasing them. That is the test, and if there is, in any direction, one in which you can show that there is going to be more wealth for the community produced from the expenditure of the existing wealth, then I am all for it and I do not think you will have any difficulty whatever in getting resources.

Comment on this

Why is building held up now?

Comment on this

Because building, according to the cost of production, and so on, is not productive in that sense. It is not productive in that sense, and we are undertaking, to a certain extent, to assume it as a State burden and pay for it, to some extent, because it is not productive of itself, just the same as we are paying old age pensions. We are paying for old age pensions because we are taking from a section of the community who have wealth and handing it over to people who have not got it, because we regard it as a social obligation on us to maintain these people. As I say, you will get money if you are able to show that the purposes for which it is going to be employed are going to be productive.

Comment on this

Show who?

Comment on this

Housing is not productive in that sense, and it will only be productive in that sense when you are able to show that people are prepared to pay for the use of their houses and the wealth in that way produced is able to cover the costs involved in the erection of the houses. If the housing was productive in the sense that it was able to give a return, then the people who occupy the houses by their labour would be producing wealth which would be paying in rents the equivalent of the building cost.

Comment on this

Let them go to hell and do without them.

Comment on this

I do not adopt Deputy Gorey's view at all. I say that we have a social obligation to see that houses are built, but we must endeavour to carry that out with the least possible burden on the rest of the community. We are undertaking it, not in the ordinary sense as an economic service, but as a social service, and we are paying for it, and paying fairly severely. We ought to try to make building economic, if we can. It was for that reason that I had an informal meeting of labour and other sections involved in the building trade. I said: "Cannot you come together so as to make the burden on the community less than it is and make it possible for the individuals who occupy these houses to pay the rents and give a return for the cost involved in the building of the houses?" That was an attempt to bring down the social burden which we are carrying, but I have tried during all my time to keep an open mind on this matter and to see if there was any way in which this work could be done more effectively, more justly and more economically than it has been done. I have not found any way by which that can be done yet. I think that there is a fundamental fallacy in the belief that you can do this by creation of credit. To me, it comes down to a demand on existing goods and services. If you do not get more in return than you expend in producing or building, you are diminishing the wealth of the community. When you do that with your eyes open, as we are doing in the case of housing, well and good. You can balance the advantages and disadvantages.

Though I have tried to understand it, I have not been satisfied that those who talk about the creation of credit are on the right lines. I am not going to talk about what has been done elsewhere. I do not want to talk about New Zealand. I should like very much if New Zealand were successful in trying out a certain principle. However, I should like to see it tried by other countries than ourselves before adopting it.

Comment on this

New Zealand did not go "burst".

Comment on this

I do not want to be led, by any interruption, into discussing that question. What I say is that there has been no experiment yet which has proved the contention of those who say that you can, by the creation of credit, get rid of all these problems. A priori, I approach the matter in the way which has been mentioned by Deputy O'Sullivan—that it is just a little bit too easy. If you could do this, you could do all sorts of things and reduce the position to an absurdity. However, it is right in principle that the State should have control of the use of wealth—in other words that it should be in a position to say that wealth should not be used in a particular way if it is to the public detriment. If it is to the public interest that it should be used in a particular way, it should be capable of regulating it in that way. We shall have to come to decisions on these proposals. At the moment, I am giving a personal view. My own belief is that we have at present the right of control. We can pass a law at any time to control the banks or to sever parity with sterling. We can do all these things. It is merely a question of whether it is wise or unwise to do them. We have the power. There is no question whatever about that. To that extent, it is all nonsense to say we are merely the creatures of the banks. If we saw good reason for it, we could exercise the sovereign rights which we possess. In the past, we have, I think, shown that we were ready to face any obligations of that sort when we saw our way clear to do so. But before you embark on projects such as this, you want to see your way very clearly.

Comment on this

You may wait too long.

Comment on this

The finest work of art can be smashed with a hammer or a hatchet in a moment although it may have taken a very long time to produce. I do not say that our economic system is, by any means, a work of art, but its development has taken a long time. I should have more admiration for it if there were not so many evils attaching to it, but my fear is that we may go from one set of evils into another of a much more dangerous kind—evils which we shall not be able to remedy and which would impose far greater burdens and sacrifices upon us than would the remedying of the unemployment problem. It would be a heavy burden and it would reduce the standard of living of many of us but, if we wanted to do it, we could take the thousands of people who are out of work and give them a couple of pounds a week. That would involve a very heavy cost. The Labour Party say that we should do it the other way— by putting the people to work. I say "Show us the productive work and we will do it. Give us an indication as to where productive work is to be got." We are told about afforestation. We have examined that and are going ahead with it but Deputies should examine it as coldly as we have to do. It would add to our prestige to do these things. We should gain by solving these problems. Why do we hesitate? Is it suggested that I am or that other members of the Government are creatures of the banks or have an interest in them? Nothing of the kind. We are anxious to get these things done and we will not be happy until they are done.

Comment on this

Delays are very dangerous when dealing with human elements.

Comment on this

The change that the Deputies advocate might produce worse conditions than those which exist. I can assure Deputies that I am trying with my whole heart and soul to solve these problems in the best possible way and that I am not tied to any system. I think that the same is true of the other members of the Government. The point is that, in the existing system, you see where you are, you know its methods and you know its evils. You can try to cut off these evils or remedy them. I believe that, at the moment, heavy as the burden would be, great as the economic strain would be, it would be possible to give these unemployed people the wherewith to live and that it would be better to do that than to adopt a system which might produce evils of another kind—evils which Deputies on the Labour Benches will not face up to. I am merely asking them to try to meet the arguments put up as to the consequences that would follow from this plan for the creation of credit. Let them think of the increase of prices which would result.

Comment on this

Our competitors are doing it—Denmark, the Argentine and New Zealand.

Comment on this

Doing what?

Comment on this

Look at the exchange rates—they have a 5 per cent. advantage over us.

Comment on this

I am keeping away from New Zealand at the moment. I wish its Government and its people well and I hope they will succeed.

Comment on this

Somebody else has said otherwise.

Comment on this

Nobody has said so.

Comment on this

What about the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

He said nothing different from what I am saying.

Comment on this

He damned the system.

Comment on this

No. The Minister for Finance had to do his duty in meeting arguments from the other side and showing that this experiment was not, in his opinion, an unqualified success. The Minister for Finance, any more than I, is not tied to any system but he and I and every member of the Government have to face the situation and try to reason and we cannot blink facts as some of the people on the opposite benches are trying to do. As I say, there is no place that I have yet seen where this scheme has been successfully carried through. It is too early yet to talk about either its success or failure, in my opinion. There was a time, during the economic war, when people were saying we were finished. We were not finished.

Comment on this

We did not say that.

Comment on this

I am not saying Labour did. I am only saying that there are two sets of people involved in this particular matter—the protagonists on one side and the antagonists on the other, each one of them shouting, one that it is a success and the other that it is a failure. I keep my mind open and I keep my judgment open and I say it is too soon yet because we will have to wait a much longer period than has elapsed so far to know whether it has been a success or failure.

Comment on this

Do the job under your own plan then.

Comment on this

If we can, but I say, as far as we are concerned that is the way we are trying to do it

Comment on this

You will have the support of anybody who is worth anything in the country.

Comment on this

I know. Let us examine it and see whether we are able to do it and to what extent we are able to do it. We hear the expression "productive work" used constantly by the people who are in favour of social credit. I say, show us in what direction the productive work is to be done. They will tell us that it is to be found in afforestation. Yes, but production in afforestation does not begin for a certain period. It is not productive at the moment. At the moment the existing wealth has to be utilised in order to get it going. We will not get return from that work for many years, and although it may be productive and although it may be in the interests of the nation, the nation existing over a long time, and not the individual, it is not productive at the moment. I believe it may be in the nation's interest to live within its income at the moment or to tighten its belt to enable these future assets to be built up but I would not call it productive in that sense at the moment. It will ultimately be productive but, "live horse and you will get grass" is a very old proverb. The nation can do it as a whole and we are doing it to a certain extent, but there is a limit to that also.

We were told we could develop in other directions, for instance, in the reclamation of land. We are doing it, but the trouble at the moment is that we are not using even the land we have got to the fullest advantage. There is probably more productive work in ordinary industry than there would be in afforestation, speaking from the point of view of strict productivity. If we can get plans we will have no hesitation in embarking upon them. We are developing our forests. There is an examination of any mineral resources we have in order to try to develop them and in so far as these can be developed at all and are found to be productive we pursue it, but the moment we pass from productive to unproductive work we, ultimately, have either the production of goods in one form or another or our effort is passed on to the production of amenities. We are willing to pay a good deal and to give a good deal of labour in order to get these amenities and services.

We are prepared to provide water supplies. Our people are prepared to give the other services which are represented by money and to give of their wealth in order to get water supplies and amenities of various kinds such as better roads. Good roads to a certain extent are obviously and definitely economic because they lighten in one form or another the cost of transport and in that sense may be regarded as enabling production to be carried on. But there are other things which are not of that character and the moment we go into that sort of production we are somewhat in the position (though this may not be a good analogy) of a family with a large estate where some members would be employed on the estate making fish ponds or something of that sort. They might say that this would be a finer estate if this thing is done. We have a choice of either to give those members their material needs from the community resources or put them to work, but the moment we put them to work there is something else: we have got to get materials for them and these materials have to be secured from existing wealth. Therefore we are putting into whatever we are doing other materials as well as labour.

I say then that we have a certain amount of resources. If these resources can be turned, by any method, into more productive channels, all right. If they cannot, let us face the loss with the knowledge that the things we are doing are worth the loss but let us remember that we are producing amenities and that we are losing some of the existing wealth. I was trying to talk not in terms of money but in terms of concrete wealth other than money, but when we talk about money, what is it? If I have money it is no good to me unless it is a claim on a certain amount of goods or services or the things that we ordinarily can secure by means of money. In so far as it secures these it is the equivalent of them, and in so far as credit is used for productive purposes it is of two kinds, first for private enterprise and secondly, for public works. If we use it for private enterprise, even if we have control of it, if we set up a State machinery to do what the commercial banks are doing, we have to operate in practically the same way as the commercial banks are operating.

We have set up the Industrial Credit Company and we have got the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The complaint is that these are operating exactly as the others. Yet, they are not out for gain in the ordinary sense; they are not merely a trading firm simply out to make profits as such. They are there for a public purpose and a public utility. Yet they have to operate in the main, if they are going to continue without losing the wealth which they control at the moment, very largely on the same principles as those on which commercial banks are operating. One of the things which I think the Labour Party will admit is that the commercial banks as such, dealing with commercial transactions and the ordinary commercial business of the country, have no very grave complaints against them. I do not think they have. Certainly there is no complaint against them in any of the reports I have seen.

Comment on this

They are doing their job efficiently and well.

Comment on this

Exactly. If the State had control of credit for the stimulation of production that is carried out by private individuals, private corporations, and so on, I think it would have to operate on, roughly, the same principles as the commercial banks and probably would not operate any better because the principle on which it would have to work would be the same—that what it gave it would expect to get at least that amount back—that it would cover its losses. I do not know what the Labour Party may mean by credit. I know the general derivation of the word and its general connotation mean belief, trust, confidence in repayment—repayment by getting back at least as much as is taken away.

Comment on this

Why should not the State or the Government have control of that credit?

Comment on this