We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Banking Commission Report and State Finances—Motion.

Contributions 143–268 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We will come to that in due time. I am just trying to see that there is agreement as to what we are talking about. When credit is given by a bank, whether it is a State bank or an ordinary commercial bank, something is given to the person who gets it, which he can utilise in procuring material things he may need or amenities. When it is given there is an expectation of repayment. That is what credit means. It is trust that you will get back again what you give. If the State does that, then the State has a trust in so far as it is utilising the credit of the nation or of the community. What I understand by it is that it is directing a certain portion of the community's wealth and handing it over to an individual, if you are thinking of private individuals, to be used. When I say a portion of the nation's wealth I do not mean to say that I am not thinking collectively, because the State has the power of direction. For instance, if it were good in the national interest to say that we were not going to put money into the building of picture houses, I think the State would have the right, if it considered that to be a social evil and that it was wrong that individual wealth should be used in that way, to say that it should not be done. We are exercising control like that every other day, not quite of course in that way, but sovereign control over say the use of private property for the general welfare. But whether we do it, or whether the banks do it, there is a diversion, a giving over of a portion of the nation's wealth, in the expectation that more is coming back to the pool. If that expectation is there, then, whether this is done by the State or in the other way that I have been speaking of, you have to ask: "If I give this individual or this corporation this thing to be used, will I get it back? It belongs to me and to other individuals, and will it be returned to the pool?" If it is returned there is no diminution of it, but the people who give it may well say: "If I had not given it I could have used it otherwise, and could have got more interest on it." The State, or the banks, taking other people's wealth may well ask, if compelled to use it in a particular way, what return should they get. They expect to get a certain thing back, but may say that if they used it otherwise they could have got more back. Therefore, when you consider all this you cannot eliminate the question of reasonable interest. What is reasonable interest is another question. Suppose you were to set up a State bank, in my opinion you would have to operate it on practically the same lines as the commercial banks. The argument is made that you will stimulate production by lending money or advancing credit to private individuals or private corporations. I think the advocates of social credit are thinking of what they call public work: something that would not ordinarily be done by private corporations.

Comment on this

Not exactly.

Comment on this

Generally.

Comment on this

That is if I understand what the Labour Party have in mind. They cannot blame me for thinking that because there has been no attempt on the part of the Labour Party to indicate what they mean by the phrases they use. These phrases are not always used by writers and other people in the same sense. When a political Party is committing itself to a programme of this sort, then they ought at least tell us what they have in mind.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach got an indication of it.

Comment on this

I am trying to get some clarification of it now. So far as public control is concerned, we have the right to have that at the moment. Take the question of a central bank which has been recommended in the report. We could take over the control of the volume of credit that is generally exercised by central banks, but the question is how are we going to use it. There is no question at all about our right to do that. We could set up a central bank to-morrow. This House could meet and, within a week, if we had our plans ready, we could do here everything that was necessary to be done in the matter of setting up a central bank. We could arrange it so that the control would be exercised at our own will, as we thought best in our interests, and not because of any compulsion exercised by any other machine under which we were operating. The trouble comes when you try to operate it. You have to ask yourselves, what is the best way to operate it in the interests of the community. I say that we ought to have here people who would be expert enough to manage a central bank if there was occasion for exercising control in a manner different from that in which it is being exercised at present.

Deputies on all sides will agree, I think, that if we wanted to do that we have the power to do it. They would probably agree with the report that it would be wise to set it up, but there might be differences of opinion between the Parties in the House when we came to consider the powers and the constitution of a central bank. As regards our right to set it up, nobody would question that. Whether we will do so or not is a matter that is under consideration by the Government; the manner in which it will be composed, the powers that will be given to it, and so on. All that naturally will have to be considered by the Government in connection with this report.

It is obvious that it is one of the things that will have to be dealt with immediately in connection with the report. Our relation with sterling will also naturally have to be considered. There have been some arguments given for keeping parity with sterling and some arguments against it. We will have to weigh up all those arguments and come here with our recommendations to the Dáil. There is no use, in matters of this kind, in going blindly along and refusing to see dangers— what the advantages are as well as the disadvantages. There is no use in going blindly in one direction because there seems to be a certain amount of propaganda in one direction or the other. These are very serious matters that require serious consideration. What I want to say at the moment is this: that I am not convinced by anything that I have read or seen so far that the method of the expansion of credit, which is suggested by Deputies, would achieve the results which they have in mind, or that they would achieve those results without danger and damage which they are not prepared to face or to contemplate. Surely with our responsibilities, we should not be asked to embark on schemes of that sort unless the arguments and the plans were certain, unless we were able to see fairly clearly how to meet the difficulties which we apprehend.

Comment on this

We agree that fundamental changes are necessary, and appreciate that.

Comment on this

Fundamental changes can be for good or for evil.

Comment on this

We know that.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not want us to produce a worse condition than that in which we are now?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

As one member of the Government, I can only say that I am not satisfied about that. I have tried to look at the matter with an open mind, and I am not satisfied that what has been suggested by the Labour Party would do the job or do it without evils which would have a far greater effect. There are people who think money will organise automatically for them; I think it will not. That is a fundamental assumption, that money will automatically organise, that if work is available somewhere people will go after that work.

I do not think so. I think that Clonsast bog can be developed and employment given on it, but there will still be workers here in the towns who are not fit for and would not do that type of work. You have people here who have been trained in one particular business, and if that business disappears they are not going to be found fit for any work that is much different. It may be said that that will be only a casual, an incidental, an intermittent stage, and cannot be prevented.

I can assure the Labour Party—who are thinking of the chronic unemployment—that there is no one feeling as keenly as I do about that problem, seeing the young men of 17 to 21 years of age going about without having an opportunity of earning their own livelihood.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It is terrible that that should still persist——

Comment on this

And increase.

Comment on this

——in a rational society and we cannot be satisfied whilst it does last. I only differ in this respect from the Labour Party's view in that I believe the remedy which they think they have is not a remedy. I do not believe that they have tried to examine all the consequences, or that they have kept an open mind in examining the consequences that may flow from that policy. If I am wrong, I would be one of the first here—as I wish well to New Zealand—to try to see the evils in the present economic system and have them removed. If there is available anywhere, in any part of the world, information that that problem is solved, I assure them that we will look with anxiety to see how it has been done. I wish well, and so does any member of the Government, to the New Zealand Government and to the people of New Zealand in their efforts. We are not to be asked, however, to accept that as having been a success. I do not think that it has been proved to be a success, though I do not want to say that it is a failure.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

There are people who are looking ahead, who are convinced and who say that it is a failure. We cannot deny them the right to do that. I am trying to preserve an open mind with regard to any solutions there may be for the evils from which we are suffering here. They are suffering also in the United States, in England and elsewhere. It is a terrible thing that there are people prepared to work at suitable work, who want to get the reward of their labour, and who, somehow or other, are not able to get the opportunity. We ought not to be content until we get some sort of solution. My anxiety, however, is to get a real solution. I would ask the Labour Party particularly to examine this question, not to go wildly about it, to see whether the consequences which I suggest would flow from the course they propose would, in fact, flow or not.

I was talking about credit for private and public purposes. We have used it in the case of housing and we know that we are putting a burden on the community. We are doing that with our eyes open and we intend to go on doing it. It is, however, our duty to see that the burden on the community, as a whole, is as light as possible, to see that building costs are cut down, to see that, by planning, houses are built at the cheapest possible rate so long as they are good and suitable houses. We want to get the workers, the building contractors, the builders' providers, the banks and any others concerned in the supply of credit, to come together and see to what extent their advantage will lie in, for example, having a continuous building programme for, say, five years.

Here in the City of Dublin houses are badly needed. Can they not, by seeing there are at least 2,000 houses produced every year, recognise an advantage to the workers in giving them continuous employment, an advantage to the contractors in that there will be a number of workers regularly employed at a definite task for which they will be able to equip themselves in advance, and an advantage to the builders' providers, too, who will know that they will have to supply material for regular periods and that they will not be either over-stocked or understocked?

We ask these sections of the community to get together and, in their own interest and in the common interest, to direct their efforts towards the provision of houses at prices which may not be as severe and as uneconomic as they are at the present time. To the extent to which they are uneconomic the community as a whole is bearing the burden; and the Banking Commission says we should not bear that burden or burdens of that sort. I say that we have the choice—either to allow the evil to continue or to use the whole national resources to remedy it. I am for using those resources, but I want it remedied with the least burden on the community. That is our duty. We are not going to stop doing it, but we are going to see that the work will be carried out as economically as possible.

There is a social duty devolving upon us to undertake that work and we are not hesitating to undertake it. We are adding to the rents that will be paid by the occupiers of these houses with a view to trying to make them economic. If we could make them economic through the rents alone, without addition, that would be the ideal situation, but we have to choose between not building these houses and using our national resources to build them. We have chosen to build and we do not propose to stop doing it—no more than we propose to stop land division or such other things, until we have finished the job. We are not going to blind the public and pretend that we are doing that without cost. We know that it is costly and the Banking Commission reveals that cost. We say, notwithstanding that fact, we will continue. We will do our best to make those costs as light as possible, but that is not going to deter us from continuing.

I am sure I have wearied the House, but this subject is so full of side issues that it is almost impossible to speak without referring to them. However, as regards the resolution, which really is a vote of censure on the Government, we are going to deal with it as we would deal with a vote of censure: we are going to oppose it. With regard to the amendment by the Labour Party, I am only able to guess at what they mean. I can only say that I see consequences at the moment which would follow upon the adoption of that amendment, which I would not be justified—and the Government would not be justified—in accepting. What they are trying to do by a particular method we are trying to do by other methods. I would, therefore, ask the House to reject the principal motion as being really a vote of censure on the Government. I ask them to reject the amendment as proposing a solution which, as far as we can see, we are not satisfied is a solution at all.

The more I hear these matters discussed the more confident am I that the policy which the Government has adopted is right in general. Undoubtedly, a great deal of tightening can be done in any organisation or in any

Government. As far as the Government can reduce the burdens on the community and reduce the overhead charges, which add to the cost of all producers, we are going to reduce them. As far as we can do that, without giving up the social services which are benefiting the country as a whole we shall do it.

Comment on this

I hope——

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

On a point of order, might I ask if there is any limit to the length of time for the speeches? There are several members who wish to speak for about five minutes each, and we know that the House is adjourning for three months.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may ask a question but may not make a speech.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Several members want to speak about Dublin conditions and the Dublin unemployed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no power to control the length of speeches.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I take the opportunity to protest against the length of the speeches that have been made, in view of the conditions of the Dublin unemployed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not make a speech. Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputies generally will realise that they are not muzzled when they leave the precincts of this House, and that there is many a spot in the country where the things that are said here should be re-echoed time and time again. I sympathise with Deputy Alderman Byrne on the question of the length of speeches, but I only sympathise with him from one particular point of view. I welcome, from another point of view, the length of the speeches that we have had on this subject; and I would welcome longer time to be able to discuss it, if that were possible. The type of speech that has been made on this debate from the Government Benches indicates to me that nothing very serious will be lost if this debate does conclude to-day.

The Taoiseach says that the motion on the Order Paper by Deputy Dillon and myself is a motion of want of confidence in the Government. The motion was put down on the offer of the Taoiseach that Government time would be made available to discuss certain aspects of the Banking Commission Report. The motion was put down for nothing but to provide the opportunity which the Taoiseach indicated he was ready to make available. The debate was opened on Wednesday, and no Government spokesman got into the debate until the last speaker at night. The contribution made by the one Government speaker to the debate on Wednesday was such that he had two hours more of his contribution to carry over until the next day, and, in so far as a reasonable, systematic and thoughtful discussion of the points raised in the motion is concerned, the Minister for Finance, and now the Taoiseach, have made it utterly impossible for the House to face up systematically to it. The motion was put down to have a reasonable and closely-argued discussion, and for no other reason. In the circumstances disclosed by the Minister for Finance and by the Taoiseach, certainly so far as I am concerned, this motion is, and the division which will be taken on this motion will be intended to be, a vote of very definite want of confidence in the Government.

What did we hear from the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach? The Minister for Finance, in discussing the report and the indications of conditions generally in the country found in some of the facts recorded there, said, "The condition is not so grave as it may have appeared," that is, to the members of the Banking Commission, and that the situation had changed. The Taoiseach said: "There is nothing worse in the position than is in these reports." The Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach implied that, when, in this month of 1939, we are discussing the effect of overtaxation, the effect of debt, the want of suitable productivity in the country, and the creation of poverty and unemployment and of a lowering standard of living here, the situation is not worse now than it was when the Banking Commission reviewed the situation and made their report. It is a very astonishing comment.

The Taoiseach indicated that what is wanted is the broad view, a fundamental consideration of the whole situation and he indicated that, very often, these things are done in the quiet of his own room. That is just what is wrong apparently. The Taoiseach may have his fundamental consideration, he may have his broad plan, but, inevitably, the broad plan operates on the individual man and woman trying to earn a livelihood here and trying to bring up their families. There obviously has been too much of the retiring to the quiet of Ministers rooms to consider the situation. So far from the situation being no worse, to say the least of it, than it was in 1937, the situation in nearly every respect of economic life that one can review here is substantially worse.

The Taoiseach, for the purpose of pointing his argument, indicated that there was a substantial improvement within the last few years, that the Banking Commission Report showed the worst of the picture, and he was apparently consoling himself, that the economic war having passed, a position had been established now in which we have access to the British market—as a matter of fact, it is now boasted that we have a better position in the British market than we ever had before—and in which agricultural exports are rising. The Couéism which the Government have brought to bear on their own actions, and which they try to bring to bear on the people, is still operating on them, and they think that because they quote a few figures showing that agricultural exports have improved, everything else is all right. In some instances, the Taoiseach compares 1931 with the present day.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present—

Comment on this

Both the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach apparently adopt the attitude that because the futilities of the Government in the last few years have been stopped, in regard to a dispute over moneys with Great Britain, a dispute in the settlement of which it is very questionable on whose side the financial advantage lies, and a little more money is coming in now for agricultural produce, everything is bound to be all right. They have carried Couéism which has been one of their principal arms of construction in the country to the extent of saying that the situation is no worse now than it was two years ago. I wonder what do they mean?

The Taoiseach boasted, as one of the signs that things were bound to be better in the future, that we had a greater increase in crops than in 1931. But during the last two years the ploughed land in this country has declined by 52,000 acres. During the last two years the number of men, 18 years of age and over, employed on the land has fallen by 23,000; and in an attempted glossing over of the fact that there was a fall in the number of agricultural labourers, the Taoiseach indicated that we were dividing the land at a very substantial rate and more people were employed necessarily as farmers because of that division. But the facts during the last two years are that the number of farmers and the number of farmers' families employed on the land has decreased by 6,767; the number of permanent agricultural labourers has decreased by 8,874 and the number of temporary agricultural labourers by 6,626. That is the improvement that is supposed to be going on in the country so far as agriculture is concerned. There was a fall of 52,000 acres in the area under the plough and 22,267 less male adult people were employed on the land during the last two years.

During these two years hundreds of thousands of pounds were spent on dividing the land and this is the result. We complain of the huge taxation both direct and private that is creating that position on the land. While the Executive Council tell us through their spokesmen that things are better here, emigration in the last two years was up by 61,000 persons. The population fell by 30,000 in the last two years. During these two years the home assistance authorities throughout the country, not to talk of the unemployment assistance authorities, have been catering for an increasing number of unemployed men. Let us take the City of Dublin. During every single month this year there was a substantial number of persons unemployed over the number unemployed last year and over the number of persons unemployed the previous year. There is a substantial number of men receiving unemployment assistance over the number receiving unemployment assistance last year and very much more than the year before. The figures for May show that 4,964 more men had to be paid unemployment assistance than in the year 1937, and that 2,981 had to get unemployment assistance more than in the year 1938.

The Taoiseach indicated that things had developed in industry and he compared 1937 with 1931. I suggest to him that the figures in the Trade Journal for June which is now available to Deputies are worth examination. In the year 1938 there were eight different industries showing a substantial decline in their net output. But the total increase in the net output between 1931 and 1937 was £8,780,000 in the eight industries of which I spoke. There was a fall of £809,000 in the value of the net output in 1938 as compared with 1937. In all 16 industries had been reported on in the Trade Journal. We have the figures of their production for 1938. In some of them there have been increases and in some decreases but the net reduction in output in the whole 16 industries is £643,000. The net reduction in employment in the 16 industries is 2,301 persons. When the Taoiseach speaks of increased industrial production here, he speaks of the gross increase in industrial production between 1931 and 1937 of £33,000,000, but the actual working out which is the real definite production in the country on which wages arise, is £8,780,000. More than £600,000 of that figure disappeared last year.

The £33,000,000 means nothing but the accumulated raw materials that have been imported from outside and have been used here and the duplication of raw materials that have been supplied within the country. Every scrap of additional taxation as affecting raw materials is included in it. A million pounds worth of tobacco, and the excise duties on it, are wrapped up in the £33,000,000 the Taoiseach speaks about and which is used simply as a part of the Coué system.

When we were recording that in 1937 there was a net increase of £8,787,000 in industrial production here, the farmers were recording that £14,000,000 was the decrease in the value of agricultural production. Not only during this last year has there been recorded a substantial fall in the acreage under the plough, a substantial fall in the number of men employed in the area under agriculture, but there has been an increase in the number of men receiving home assistance and a substantial increase—in Dublin particularly, but Dublin conditions are only a reflex of the conditions in the country—in the number of persons unemployed and in receipt of unemployment assistance. There has been a substantial reduction within the past year in the numbers employed in industries here and a substantial decrease in the amount of our industrial output. There has been a reduction in the number employed in the brewing industry of 201, in bacon curing of 95, in shirt-making of 101, in hosiery of 280, in woollen and worsteds of 423, in boots and shoes of 183, in assembly and construction of motor vehicles of 476, and in railways and tramways of 487.

Some of the industries which deal with the necessaries of life, the natural industries for this country that the Taoiseach speaks about, also show a fall in the employment given. Not only has there been a fall in industries of a general character but also in the industries which the Taoiseach said he desired should produce things for the ordinary consumption of the people, such as the necessaries of life. He instanced bacon and bread. He wanted to develop the bacon industry, the production of pigs and the production of wheat. Bacon consumption, as already indicated, has been substantially reduced as the result of the price of bacon here.

The consumption of bacon had gone down by 255,000 cwts. in 1937 and, for the smaller amount of bacon consumed, the people had to pay £1,000,000 more than they had to pay for the larger quantity. In 1938 there was a further substantial reduction in the amount of bacon consumed by our people. To the 255,000 cwts. taken out of the mouths of the people as the result of overtaxation, there was an addition of 38,000 cwts. in the fall in bacon consumption last year. As regards bread, the people at the present time are consuming 13,000,000 2 lb. loaves less than they were getting before the Fianna Fáil Party started to look after the provision of bread for the people. In every aspect of life, there are indications to-day that the situation is worse than it was 12 months ago.

Our complaint is that down on top of that situation, a huge additional burden of taxation is being imposed. At a time when taxation should be lightened in order to give the people a chance of more profitably expending the moneys they are earning, a substantial increase in taxation is being imposed upon them. We had some very wide flung social and economic discussions in the four hours' talk by the Minister for Finance and the three and a half hours' talk by the Taoiseach. Out of the remarks of the Minister for Finance and of the Taoiseach, there does come the idea that they do now regard the amount that this country can get from exporting its agricultural produce as a matter of very vital concern to the people of the country. That is something, but they are not doing anything that would show that they realise the importance of it. In every part of the world, quickening steps are being taken to improve the technique of agricultural production and to improve the methods of marketing agricultural produce. Members of the Government know that during the last seven years, not only has every opportunity that offered to increase our agricultural exports been lost, but a situation has been created here under which nothing could be done to improve either the technique of our agricultural production or the organisation of our agricultural marketing. Everything that should have been done to maintain the market in Great Britain, in which, traditionally, and because of circumstances of the past, we had a right to expect preferential treatment, was simply left undone.

One would imagine, having regard to the claim of the Government, that we have now a better position in the British market than we ever had before, that something would be done to help our farming community to struggle out of the unfortunate position into which they have been forced during the last seven years and that some attempt would have been made to take advantage of the alleged better condition in which we are on that market.

What is the position? The farmers have been crippled. Their production has been interfered with. They were told that their type of production should be changed. Now, the British market has to be sought for exactly the same type of production as that for which our farmers organised themselves in the past, because they found it was the best paying type of production. There is no change in the views of the Government as to the type of agricultural produce should go into the British market. No attempt is being made to enable our farmers to take advantage of the condition of affairs that exists there. Why? Because the great majority of the people running individual farms in this country are reduced to a position in which they cannot run them on an efficient scale. Agricultural credit has been sought in order that, in the changed circumstances now, the farmers may put themselves in a position to send again to the British market the quantity and the type of products which they sent there in the past.

While we are told here and in the Seanad that nothing can be done to give the farmers special credit at the present time, there is money available for representation in Canada, which would have been more valuable if it could have been got in 1934; there is money to be made available for a school of theoretical physics, when what is wanted in this country is a school which would make it possible for political and economic arithmetic to be understood without being twisted in one way or another by the political Couéism of any particular Party in the country; there is money available to make it possible to promise us that our peat will be turned into electricity; there is money available for tourist development, but there is no consideration at all as to what credit could be given to the farmers to-day either without loss to the State, or, if there were any problematical loss possible in it, at a loss that would be no greater than the amount of money which had been scattered on schemes that certainly are most unproductive. Additional money has been promised to-day.

During the last few years £504,000 have been spent on turf. What is the result of it? The only result is that about 1 per cent.—not even 1 per cent. —more turf has been cut in the country than there was in 1931. But, after spending on turf in the last three or four years the sum of £504,000, none of which will in my opinion ever come back, the last two years have shown us a fall in the amount of turf that has been provided, but an increase in the alleged value of it. One of the economic circumstances is that in 1935 there were 3,659,000 tons of turf cut in the country, and the value placed on it was 17/- a ton. In the last year for which we have information, that is 1937, there were 70,000 less tons of turf cut in the country, but the value of the turf was 19/3 a ton, or 2/3 extra per ton. For the smaller amount of turf we had in the country we had to pay £346,000 more. That is what we got from Government expenditure.

Even if the Government were satisfied that during the next five years there would be a loss of £500,000 in the odd bad debts that might arise from giving the farmers credit to get themselves over their present position, and to seize the old position that they had in the British market, we would get something for that money. All we have got for an expenditure of £540,000 on turf is an increase in the cost of the turf which has been cut, and a diminution in the quantity in the last couple of years. We were able to spend £444,000 on industrial alcohol in the last three years. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in answer to a question the other day, gave particulars of the working of the factories during the last potato season. During the last potato season the sum of £444,000 was spent on the production of industrial alcohol. What happened? The industry paid £3,425 in wages, and £18,949 worth of potatoes were bought. That is the result of an expenditure of £444,000 on industrial alcohol. Now, when the economic and financial and political futility of the economic war has passed, and when some recognition should be given to the losses suffered by the farming community during that time, they are simply told: "You have a better position in the British market now than ever you had, and nothing else is to be done."

An Agricultural Commission is investigating the matter. Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party have themselves indicated what they think is going to come from the Agricultural Commission. Whatever is going to come from it, a period of time must elapse, and there is no time to let elapse in the face of the economic factors of the present position. It will take some time after the restoration of the agricultural industry before anything really substantial can be done to improve the unemployment situation in the City of Dublin. It will take some time after the restoration of the agricultural industry to get back to work on Irish land the 43,000 men whom the last four years have put off it. When talking of the value of the home market, Ministers must know that the only possible way of improving the position of the Irish farmer in the next year or two is to export more. The conditions brought about here have shown that while the industrial side can be developed here, and while the Pat Murphys of the town can be turned into a market for the Irish farmer inside tariff and quota walls, unless the earning capacity is there in the country they will be eating less bread and using less clothing.

What is the position in which we stand to-day when the statement is made that we are in a better position than ever in the British market? The figures for 1938, which have been quoted with approbation by the Minister for Finance as showing an improved position, indicate that on fat cattle, calves, sheep and pigs the Irish farmer is still losing £5,000,000 that he got before Fianna Fáil came into office. The present Government came into office in 1932, when the previous Government had decided to sit down with the British Government and see how the effects of the depression of 1929 and 1930 could be got over, and how the agricultural output of this country to Great Britain could be restored. It was the position of the farmer in 1931, when his income had been lowered, that induced the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce at that time to go to Great Britain in the beginning of 1932 and to come back with a preferential 10 per cent. protection for our produce in the British market against the Dutch and against the Danes. It was in order to better the 1931 position that we had arranged that Ministers representing this State would go to Ottawa to discuss with the British, with the Canadians, with the South Africans, with the Australians, and with the New Zealanders, how best to improve mutually our economic position.

When I say that the Irish farmer to-day is getting £5,000,000 less than he was getting in a particular year, I am relating it to the year in which things were so bad that we had to undertake special discussions. Those special discussions did not come to anything. The 10 per cent. preference went waste. The discussions at Ottawa did nothing except the reverse of what we might have anticipated.

The economic war was embarked on, although the chief representative of the Irish Government, when he returned from Ottawa and stood on the pier at Dun Laoghaire, told the people of this country that things were practically settled. Instead of things being practically settled, we have had five years of loss and futility. Now, when it is all over, the position is that in live animals alone our farmers are getting £5,000,000 less than they were getting in 1931. But there is a more serious side to it. The exports of fat cattle are down by £2,715,000. We have lost half of our fat cattle trade. Eight hundred factories have been established in this country, according to the Taoiseach yesterday; 900 have been established, according to the Taoiseach to-day.

How many factories does the wiping out of our finished cattle industry to the extent of one half represent? In calves we are done £500,000; in sheep, £796,000; and in pigs we are down nearly £2,000,000. Let not the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Education say that the reason we are down in pigs is because we are now sending more bacon to the British market. We are exporting £1,041,000 more of bacon, but we are exporting £1,060,000 less of pork. So that we can wipe out, as a book-keeping item in this particular argument, the increase in bacon as against the fall in pork, and we can say definitely that the losses of our farmers, as compared with 1931, even with last year's improved position, amount to £2,000,000 in the export of pigs and, between dead poultry and eggs, £1¼ million.

It would be easy for our farmers to get that position back if the statement of the Minister for Finance is true; that we are in a better position in the British market now as the result of the negotiations with Great Britain than ever we were. But has any consideration been given to the position of the Irish farmer with regard to the credit that he wants to enable his industry to be efficient? The man who has a ten-cow farm and who, as a result of the wastages of the last few years, is now left with six or seven cows, must get back to the ten-cow position before he can be efficient. The same applies in dozens of other directions. The farmer is also hit by the fact that £2,482,000 is being lost through the fall in the exports of beer. We did not hear anything in this debate as to what is being done to restore our fat cattle industry. Is it the position that our fat cattle industry is gone for ever in the way in which Ministers used to think of it before? What is being done to restore our fat cattle industry, the £2,000,000 we are losing on pigs, the £1¼ million we are losing on poultry? Is there any chance of doing something so to reverse the policy of the Government that we will get back some of the £2½ million we have lost in the export of beer?

The only interpretation that can be put on the long rambling speeches of the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach is that they want to keep away from these definite points because nothing is going to be done. It is because nothing is going to be done in respect of these that we say that the burden must be taken off the backs of our agricultural community in some way, and they must be allowed to do their work without interference. It is quite right in modern circumstances that the Government here should concern themselves with the general wellbeing of the community and the relief and assistance of those people who cannot provide for themselves in the present economic circumstances. But, no scheme, however well planned, for social services, for relief of any kind, or even for the carrying on of the ordinary machinery of Government here, can be maintained except in relation to the value of the production in the country. We can help to make firmer the foundations on which both the social and Governmental structure is reared by assisting agriculture at present; but that is the one thing for which we are told there can be no assistance by way of credit at present. There can be State concern for industry. One of the things that is sticking out particularly at present is the Government's concern for industry. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking on a Financial Resolution in connection with the Budget said:

"A great part of our future development depends on the willingness of the people of this country to entrust to the State their savings or their capital for expenditure on capital undertakings."

Here we have a position in which, during the last seven years, about £34,000,000 has been spent by the Government more than they would have spent if they had kept to the 1931-32 position. Who would think, after a review of some of the things I have mentioned as showing the bad trend of things in 1938, that we are at the end of a period in which the Government, thinking nobody can spend money better than themselves, had collected or borrowed in one way or another and distributed through this country £34,000,000 above the expenditure of seven years before?

Now we are told that unless savings are accumulated and entrusted to the State for further development, development here will be checked. The Taoiseach smiled the other day when Deputy Cosgrave mentioned the fall in the contributions for Savings Certificates and in savings banks last year, as showing, in the nature of things, that the position was getting worse. The amount of money put into the savings banks last year fell from £900,000 the year before to £500,000. The Taoiseach denied that Deputy Dillon was right when he said that in the beginning of last year bank directors had complained that the farming community were living on savings. Speaking in January, 1938, according to a report in the Irish Press, the Governor of the Bank of Ireland said:—

"I must confess to a measure of misgiving with regard to the shrinkage which occurred last year, and, indeed, during the years immediately preceding it, more particularly at our country offices, in the smaller deposits of over £2,000 in amount.

While, no doubt, the amounts withdrawn have been devoted to restocking lands in some cases, I find it difficult to resist the general conclusion that those who live on the land have not yet been able to adjust themselves completely to the altered conditions in agriculture, and have found themselves obliged to make inroads upon savings accumulated during better times."

At a time when a farmer is deprived of the necessary capital, and when the urban population have their standard of living reduced, when less bread is consumed, less bacon consumed, and less money put into savings that the ordinary people tend to put them into, the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us that substantial savings must be put into the hands of the Government by the people in order to carry on capital development. Is it the Government is going to run industry here? Agriculture is thrown aside. It has to look after itself, except in so far as it might be interfered with by the Government. Apparently on the industrial side the Government is going to take a directing hand. Before they further injure the credit of this country, we ask the Government to indicate the steps they are going to take. If they are going to handle such savings of the people as they can lay hands on, one way or another, to bolster up industrial development in the unnatural way in which they have done it on recent occasions, we ask them to review some of the industries that they have been responsible for setting up here. In every country technical efficiency is being aimed at in industry and in agriculture. It would be time enough for the Government to threaten to take capital for industrial development when they had assured themselves that some of the industries that had been established here had, either by Government assistance or otherwise, been made technically efficient.

We had industries before the present industrial development, and they were able to export without subsidies or assistance of any kind. When we look at an industry like woollen tissues we find that not only is there a very substantial fall in the quantity exported now as against 1931, but the tendency to fall still further is there. Exports in 1931 amounted to £110,000, but these figures have fallen to £51,000. In 1931 we exported apparel value for £159,000 but it is down now to £26,000. Exports of shirts fell from £83,000 to £3,000, and the export of newspapers and books fell from £224,000 to £98,000. We were also able to export polishes and pictures. When will some of the newer industries that have been established be brought to the efficiency of the older ones, and when will they be able to check themselves with world prices? Unless we have efficiency in agriculture and efficiency in industry we cannot carry on our social services or the additional high class learning that is being provided for in the new institute of which we heard yesterday; we cannot be a credit either to the nationalism or the nationality that we boast we have, nor can we bring any credit to ourselves in relation to the duties we owe as a country, in trying to work out machinery, under which the social principles of the encyclicals, so much talked of here, must be worked out.

We have command of all the resources of the country, the brawn and intelligence. The brawn that the Taoiseach spoke of is there to be used. The brains of the country have been interfered with by the political and economic policy of members of the present Government for the last 17 years. The brawn has been interfered with too. We had remarks from the Minister for Finance and from the Taoiseach which show that they wanted to avoid this discussion. They said it was a vote of censure on them, and they applied to the vote of censure the kind of political dope and rambling from China to Peru, to New Zealand and to the United States, to which we have been treated. We are concerned with conditions in this country, to see them clearly and objectively, and to take definite action, either to help the people to develop their industries or to stand aside and let them help themselves. Nobody is going to solve the agricultural problem but Irish farmers standing over their farms and doing their own work. Nobody is going to build up Irish industries but Irish industrial organisers and Irish workers. There is going to be no chance for farmers or industrialists to make progress as long as they are crushed down by the weight of taxation that is there at present. A burden is falling on our people in the matter of debt, and the more that burden is increased, the more taxation will ultimately fall upon people later on, taxation during which there will be no production.

We had Deputies speaking of the position in other countries with regard to debts, where they complained that these debts were piled up in the past, and that there were suggestions that they should be repudiated. We should be careful to know whether we are leaving for people in ten or 16 years' time a burden of debt about which they may say to themselves: "This debt was created by futile, wasteful people who laid their hands on this country ten or 16 years ago, and we have no moral responsibility for repaying it." It is not so easy for us to face a situation like that, or to get away from it, and with a view to the possibility of improving the present situation or securing that there will be an improvement, it is for the Government to open its eyes to the trend of things and not to sit back in the calm way in which their spokesmen in this debate suggested when they said that things are no worse than they were in 1937. Things are worse in every way that can be imagined; more unemployment, more emigration, less production, less tillage, less employment on the land, falling production in our essential industry and falling employment there. As we said in the early days of the economic war, it is because the things that were bound to happen did happen that we intend to keep pointing out to-day the essential facts of the people's lives, and the essential difficulties that are confronting them.

The Executive Council shut their eyes in the past, and even at the present day they turn a kind of poker face to the difficulties that surround them. They seem to be paralysed, in so far as any type of real, effective action that will help the situation, is concerned. The situation cannot last. The unemployment position, the number of people in Dublin living on home assistance, cannot continue to remain as they are without serious difficulties being created for the Government. The people cannot melt out of this country and they cannot melt off the land without very serious difficulties arising here. That is why we say that one thing that requires to be done is to relieve the country of some of the burden of taxation that has been piled on it this year and that was piled on it last year. Stop the system by which private taxation imposes on bacon, flour, wheat and butter alone, £5,000,000 a year. That is the taxation that is going into private pockets, and I ask you to stop that.

Review the position in which debt is being piled on here, and in my opinion, it would be better to cease for a year both house building and land division and apply some of the savings towards assisting agriculture. If money is not spent on agriculture to-day to give the farmers the credit they require to get on their feet, then the people who will live in the houses that will be built to-morrow will not have anything to keep them there. There is no use in dividing land and putting people on the land when the situation of the agricultural industry generally is that it is only capable of giving less employment. Putting more people on farms means putting other agriculturists out of work and means putting people on farms at a time when they cannot make a success of their farms.

Comment on this

It was not my intention to participate in this debate except in the capacity of a patient listener. I was going to leave it to my betters, to the intellectuals, the industrialists, the political economists and the experts on high finance. Into none of these realms did I feel fit to intrude. I must confess, however, that we on the back benches have had very few pearls of wisdom cast before us. Very little of a constructive nature has emerged from this debate, which has been carried on quite obviously in an atmosphere of unreality and insincerity.

If the Banking Commission Report brought anything home to the minds and hearts of the ruling classes here, it should have been that this country is perilously near economic and financial ruin. It should have made them realise that agriculture is our major industry and, as such, it needs careful nursing and treatment. The lion's share of our national income is derived from agriculture, and yet what are the characteristic features of our national life? Drift from the land, emigration, a low birth and marriage rate, extensive unemployment and last, but by no means least, the concentration of the masses of the people in the cities and towns. Look at Dublin, the capital city of our country. Its principal employing units are the Sweepstakes, Guinness's Brewery and the Civil Service. Yet we have one-sixth of the population of this country concentrated in the City of Dublin.

I have no hesitation in saying that there was never such distress, that poverty was never so widespread or rampant in the City of Dublin, with the possible exception of the years following the Act of Union and, later, the Famine. We are rapidly, in this city, approaching a state of affairs simulating that which existed in Vienna at the termination of the Great War. Vienna could be likened to an unfortunate, malformed child, a monstrosity, whose head was too heavy for its body. What have we got here? The Opposition cry is "What are you going to do?" and the Government retort "Show us the way." The Opposition say "Reduce taxation," and the Government retort "Would you have us reduce taxation by curtailing the social services?", and so on ad nauseam.

Recently we had the bland spectacle of the Minister for Finance, in this House, blaming every Deputy outside the Government Benches for the depressing state of the country. I would like to hear from the Government, seeing that they have attached responsibility to the Opposition and to all Deputies outside their own Party, on what occasion have they ever consulted any member of the Opposition with regard to impending legislation?

Have they on any occasion, in any political or economic crisis in this country, called the Leader of the Opposition or the Leader of the Labour Party and asked his advice, his opinion or his cooperation? Has the Prime Minister on any such occasion ever done that? The facts are that the Government, like their predecessors, just before they relinquished office, have lost the common touch.

My suggestion to restore our national economic equilibrium is a simple one. Put agriculture on a paying basis. I may well be asked how is that to be done. Well, it is very simple, in my opinion. Next door to us, at gun's range from us, throbs the heart of the British Empire. Great Britain, with its teeming millions, stands at the crossroads, faced with the gaunt spectre of famine in the event of what now seems to be the inevitable greater war. England will want food in quantities beyond all our dreams. The British Navy will be faced with the difficulty— the impossible difficulty to my mind—of fighting in five or six seas and oceans. It will be impossible for the British Navy, in those circumstances, to defend the long sea route. Here is our opportunity to step in. The British pocket is long and deep. I recognise the fact— I believe the fact that we have not sufficient capital here to restock our farms and to stimulate intensive agricultural activity, but I repeat that the British pocket is long and deep, and our slogan should be: England's difficulty is Ireland's economic opportunity.

Comment on this

In the course of his very lengthy and eloquent speech, the Taoiseach, both last evening and to-day, gave expression to such very sound policy, principles and aims, that I think it would be difficult for anyone of good will to quarrel with his speech. He pointed out that the policy of the Government is aimed, has been aimed, and will continue to be aimed at the creation of greater social improvement for the vast majority of the people in this State. He said that it was the intention and determination of his Government to continue to utilise all the natural resources of this State for that purpose. These are certainly laudable ideals and very laudable aims, and I am accepting at once that the movers of the motion and of the amendment, and in fact all Parties in this House have at least one thing in common, and that is that they are all honestly and earnestly desirous of doing the best thing possible for the people of this country. The previous Government, I am sure, were in their time equally imbued with an equally honest desire to do the best they could for the people of this country. That brings us, then, in the short summary which I propose to make in the course of my brief remarks, to inquire how far, in the course of 17 years in which two Governments, Cumann na nGaedheal and Fianna Fáil, both equally zealous and determined to try to secure, as far as in them lay, the best possible results for the people of the country, these Governments have succeeded in their aims. We have got to ask ourselves whether or not they have, cumulatively or separately, succeeded in their aims for the betterment of the people of this country, or if we have reached a stage in which we can be satisfied that the efforts made by the two native Governments, to produce the best results for the people, have been successful.

Listening to the discussions here, one would be inclined to feel a little mixed as to what the condition of our country is. According to the Minister for Finance, he is satisfied that everything in the garden is lovely, that we are prospering, and that there is no room for a motion or an amendment of this kind, since everything is going so well. The Taoiseach tells us that 1934 was unquestionably the peak—or rather, the lowest point—in the depression, both internationally and, particularly, here when, at that time, we were engaged in the economic war; and that, when founding his Banking Commission, he was not unmindful of the fact that we were then at the lowest ebb, and the Taoiseach gave very excellent reasons for the choosing of the personnel of that tribunal.

That personnel was such, he said, that no stone could be flung, at the Government which appointed them, by anybody from the point of view of showing up the worst that they could find, and he said, in effect, that he was satisfied to know that the worst that could be said of our position had been said, in the hope of doing better in the future. He said that, in setting up the commission, the Government were anxious to get as close an examination of the financial and economic position as they could get by people who were not likely to have any particular Party point of view. That was a very laudable aim and ideal, and, presumably, the Taoiseach should be admired for appointing the personnel in that particular form, but there is another aspect of their appointment since they were going to report in accordance with the old financial standards to which it is to be presumed they were loyal devotees, and their standards must be taken that Ireland was at a low ebb in the financial world judged by these old, antiquated rules and measures. The Banking Commission made their report according to the old financial framework that has held this country in enslavement in the past, and we are told that the aim and object of the commission, as a result of their report, was to put the nation into financial health, but I am afraid that the result of their report will not be to put the nation's stomachs into good health— certainly, not if the practices prescribed by the Banking Commission were to be adopted. Luckily, however, as the Taoiseach said, the Government is not bound to accept the findings of that commission, and I trust that they are not likely to accept the findings, because, if they do, it only means going back to the old tale of trying to do something inside a ring where, no matter what you do, you are bound in advance to fail. The acid test that I am trying to apply, if we accept the view, as I am sure we all do, that both the previous Government and the present Government have been and are doing their best for the betterment of the people of this country, is: whether or not we are satisfied that we have achieved a measure of prosperity commensurate with the efforts made by native Governments in the last 17 years.

I think it should be unnecessary for me, at this late stage of the debate, to start recapitulating all the evidence that has been put forward as to the mass of unemployment, the mass of emigration, the numbers of our people on home help, and the depression in agriculture. That welter of evidence cannot be challenged or denied, irrespective of all the figures that may be read out by the Minister for Finance as to the increase in the export values which he gave us here last night. Those figures, when divorced from the facts relating to them, are capable of playing old Harry with the truth, because I think that a short examination of the success alleged by the Minister would show that, apart from the tariffs, the actual fact is that the volume has decreased and that the volume of our agricultural produce has decreased and appears to be decreasing.

Now, I am more conversant with the position of the working classes and with the unemployment problem generally, and I am sure that neither the Taoiseach nor the Government nor any member of the Government can express satisfaction with the position as it exists to-day. Giving them credit for the very best intentions, I think it will have to be admitted that they have failed to solve the unemployment problem, and is it not time that they should examine carefully and impartially the statement that the Taoiseach himself made some time ago when he said that, if he could not find a solution inside the present system, he would not hesitate to go outside the present system? He said that, if necessary, he was prepared to go outside the present system to find a solution, but does he think that it is too early yet until they had tried out the present methods? Now, there may be differences and disagreements between the Fine Gael Party and the Fianna Fáil Party on the question of quotas and bounties, free trade, protection, tariff reform, and all that sort of thing, but I contend that, no matter whether it be a Fine Gael Government, a Fianna Fáil Government or any other Government that might be set up, it will be impossible to achieve the measure of success that is desired by all citizens of goodwill inside the present financial system.

The Fianna Fáil Government is being reduced to a state in which they are not distinguishable from their predecessors. Having got caught up inside the same ring, they are chasing around after the fashion of the interesting but fatuous pastime of the dog which chases his own tail. We were told by speakers on both benches that the experiment as regards public credit was being made by a country analogous in many ways to our country. The Minister for Finance cuts that analogy very short. Speaking in the precincts of this House the other day, he said that the analogy held practically in only one respect— that we had a common market. That is a very short and insufficient picture of the analogy obtaining between this country and New Zealand, with its small population of 1,500,000 as against our 3,000,000, with a climate similar to ours and with the same market that we have, save that they are 12,000 miles removed from it. Surely what is good for New Zealand should be worthy of careful, sympathetic analysis by this country with a view to seeing whether it could be utilised for our benefit. There is no use in shouting that the experiment in New Zealand is "bust". It seems to be the habit of many people who are tied slavishly to the old system to strain their eyes and necks looking for the collapse of the New Zealand experiment. Thank God, there is no sign of that collapse yet. The Standard of Friday, July 7, has the following:—

"His Grace, the Archbishop of Wellington, assuring Mr. Savage, New Zealand's Labour Prime Minister, of his goodwill, on the eve of that country's last general election, told him:—`You have done more to raise up the masses and improve the lot of the working man's family than any previous Government of New Zealand.' This was recounted to a Standard Special Representative in Dublin on Tuesday evening last by the Hon. Walter Nash, New Zealand's Finance Minister.”

Mr. Nash was our guest in this city. He has given of his best to his country and he explained what has been done by his Government so that it might be emulated by us and get us out of difficulties similar to those which he experienced when he came into office in 1935. The Standard says:—

"He explained the monetary and economic policy which enabled New Zealand to abolish unemployment and is now enabling that British Dominion to build decent houses for every family and achieve internal social stability and family security. They have been told New Zealand is `bust.' New Zealand is not `bust,' nor won't be in spite of the English financiers' efforts to `bust' her. Unemployment can be totally abolished. New Zealand has proved it. Homes can be built and food grown for every family in the country. New Zealand has proved that also. Asked why New Zealand had embarked upon a national monetary policy separated from that of Britain and took over control of currency and credit. Mr. Nash said: `New Zealand left parity with sterling in order to make sure that the standard of living of the people would be maintained. On the production of the country and with every rise in the volume of production—that is, with every increase in the amount of food or goods produced by New Zealanders—the standard of living of every worker in the country would be raised.' Asked whether it was true that New Zealand had to restrict her imports from England; if so, how that affected the standard of living, Mr. Nash declared emphatically that every family in New Zealand had sufficient. Every sort of food and clothing needed by the people was produced in plenty in New Zealand. New Zealand had to restrict her imports from Britain in order to pay the interest and other charges on the enormous debt borrowed on the London market by previous administrations."

New Zealand Government's predecessors had borrowed £89,000,000 in 12 years in London. The Labour Government has borrowed no money outside the country. Their 4 per cent. loan of £4,500,000 at £98 for ten years and at £99 for 20 years was oversubscribed. That is a good picture. New Zealand is not so remote that we cannot check up and obtain details of what the position there really is. The Government came into office in a country laden with heavy debt. One of the reasons we were told why that country was not analogous to our own was that they were a debtor nation whereas we were a creditor nation. If the difference between a debtor and creditor nation is, on the part of the creditor nation, poverty, unemployment, emigration and misery and, on the part of the debtor nation, teeming prosperity and abundant employment, then I should not object to a transfer and the label of the bottle would not appreciably affect me.

I was glad to notice the tone of the speech of the Taoiseach to-day and I trust that he will take his courage in his hands and deal with this question. I believe him to be a man of goodwill and if he is satisfied, as he ought to be satisfied, that the present situation calls for desperate remedies, then I suggest to him that breaking from the financial system, while it might be unique, would not be in any way desperate. We have got a lead from the hardy pioneers of New Zealand, with a small population. The Government were guided by only one idea and one instinct when they came into office. Their country was practically on the rocks. They said, in effect, "We have in the soil of this country, given to us so prolifically by God, the necessary means to produce a full and fruitful life for our population. It is our job to provide for our people and we are going to do it irrespective of how our efforts square with the financial system." They took office in 1935 and they were re-elected in 1938. They introduced the Social Security Act on top of what they undertook to do in 1935. They increased the standard of pensions for the blind, for widows and orphans, for the infirm and for others, and they ended unemployment. They had, as a matter of fact, to withdraw some of their men from development schemes in order to put them to work in the factories, as Mr. Nash explained in an interview. They had to transfer the men to the factories in order to manufacture the things which they had been previously importing from Great Britain. We cannot ignore the fact that there is a strong analogy between the position in New Zealand and the position in this country. Why should we be so slavishly wedded to the system which has been the cause of our subjugation up to now? Why hesitate any longer? Why should we have all this carping criticism and all these attempts to bore holes in a system which has given proof of its capacity to do the job we want to do?

I suggest that the motion tabled in the names of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Mulcahy does not make any attempt to rescue us from the old, vicious circle. They want to give effect to the advice contained in the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. That advice, if taken, may lead us back to the type of financial health which they envisage but that is a type of health from which I should like to get away. In the amendment by Deputy Norton, Deputy Davin and myself, we are asking the Government to take their courage in their hands and follow the example set by New Zealand—an example profitably used in Sweden and other countries. I am not so concerned with the places mentioned by the Minister for Finance who dealt at great length with the position in Germany, Italy and Russia. I want to point to countries similar to our own such as Denmark, Sweden and New Zealand. The time for hesitation is long past. The Government should make up their mind and it will have the backing and support of every man of goodwill if they say that the soil of Ireland is the wealth of Ireland and that we are not going to be slavishly tied to this old fetish—the old financial system—but that we will do what New Zealand has done. Within three or four years of taking up that position, I am sure that Ireland will be in as happy a situation as New Zealand is able to boast to-day.

Comment on this

The Front Opposition Bench made a complaint about the lack of desire displayed by the Ministers on the Government Bench to interest themselves in this debate. Deputy Mulcahy, who has just spoken, complained that when they were afforded the opportunity they talked too long. I can assure the Deputy that he will have no such complaint to make against me. In the forefront of what I am going to say I think it right to remove some misunderstanding, perhaps, in some instances, misrepresentation, of what is contained in the minority reports of the Banking Commission. At one stage of the debate, listening to the Minister for Finance yesterday evening, I decided that there was very little purpose in participating in the debate. I, at least, adduced from what he said that the Government had already arrived at decisions on the main issues as between the Majority Report and the Minority Reports. Therefore, I satisfied myself that the whole object and purpose of this motion and the attitude on the Government Benches was to produce something of an academic debate; that there was no real interest in the outside conditions that prevail. Deputies on the Opposition Benches and the Minister for Finance last night would give an impartial listener the impression that the recommendations embodied in the Minority Reports of the Banking Commission suggested confiscation of the wealth of the people of this country. I want to categorically repudiate any such representation being made in any of the reports. Those who signed the Minority Reports of the Banking Commission are as jealous of the safety and security of the credit of this State as those who signed the Majority Report.

Comment on this

Perhaps more so.

Comment on this

We gave a considerable amount of thought to the question; we spent more time on the commission than some of those who signed the Majority Report and we brought all the intelligence that God bestowed upon us to endeavour to understand the problem. We presented a report that represents our honest convictions and convictions that cannot be changed by anything that has been said in the Majority Report, notwithstanding the distinguished individuals whose names appear beneath it. We recognise that this country is one of, I believe, seven creditor nations in the world and we made no suggestion in any of our reports that would in any way militate against continuing that credit so established.

Reading the motion that stands in the names of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Mulcahy, I am prompted to ask whether the Deputies really believe in the national wisdom of those who signed the Majority Report of the Banking Commission and have they tabled this motion implicitly relying upon that belief? Reading the third line of the motion, I see that it purposes to abolish poverty within the State. I have listened to most of the debate and I have paid particular attention to those who spoke in support of the motion and I have not heard one practical proposal made by the supporters of the motion that would either abolish poverty or remove unemployment in this State. I am tempted to ask, therefore, what is the real purpose of the motion. In my opinion, the motion was tabled, not in the interest of any person outside this House, but was tabled for the purpose of affording Fine Gael an opportunity of flaying the backs of Fianna Fáil with the findings of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission and indirectly, perhaps, affording an opportunity of propagating and promoting the charge of squandermania already made against the Government by the Leader of the Opposition.

The English language is a splendid medium for concealing the real intention of words spoken or written and when you remove the outer coverings from the recommendation of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission what do you find? That is the report that Fine Gael have hitched their wagon to now. You find, number one, that they say that it is not the duty nor is it within the power of the State to provide for full employment in this country.

Comment on this

Are not they right?

Comment on this

I deny it.

Comment on this

Have they done it for the past seven years? I have held that view and I have worked harder than any man in this country. Unemployment is worse to-day than ever it was, after seven years of Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

I would remind the interrupter that a former Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Cosgrave Government said the same thing when he occupied those benches.

Comment on this

And he was right.

Comment on this

And at a subsequent election the people took him from those benches and dropped him, unemployed, over there. That gives you an idea of what would be the people's attitude to that finding of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission.

Comment on this

I have been saying that at every election and I am still here.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order.

Comment on this

The second recommendation is——

Comment on this

Give us your own views now; not so much of the encyclicals.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must be allowed to proceed with his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

The second recommendation is——

Comment on this

I hope he will not speak for three and one-half hours.

Comment on this

I will resume my seat if this interruption continues. The second recommendation is that social considerations should not be allowed to interfere with what they describe as the unchangeable law of economics. You find professors and economists throughout the world who dispute that. The third recommendation is that housing in this country should cease. Housing should cease. The removal of slum areas should no longer be considered or replaced by the Government with sanitary dwellings.

Comment on this

On a point of order, has the Banking Commission specifically said that? Let the Deputy read out the Banking Commission remarks on that, because I happen to know something about housing.

Comment on this

They have said the same thing in the deceptive English language.

Comment on this

Deputy Hugo Flinn stated the same thing last night, that no more houses were to be built or land divided according to the report of the Banking Commission. I want the Deputy to read out what the Banking Commission said in giving their views on that.

Comment on this

I would appeal to Deputy Coburn not to interrupt the Deputy but to allow him to continue. He may misrepresent the Banking Commission Report or he may represent it. That is his lookout. I suggest to Deputy Coburn that he cannot interrupt the Deputy because he may think, and firmly believe that the Deputy who was speaking is misrepresenting the report. He should allow Deputy O'Loghlen to proceed.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

Chair!

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Chair be allowed to rule on the point of order that was raised? I want to tell Deputy Coburn that it was not a point of order, and I must ask him to allow Deputy O'Loghlen to proceed without further interruption.

Comment on this

With all respect I want to say that, when a Deputy purports to give the opinions of the Banking Commission, he should read its report dealing with the specific things that he refers to in order to prove that what he says is correct.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is within the province of a Deputy to quote what he wishes from a report, and it is the province of the Chair to decide whether what he says is in order or not.

Comment on this

Thanks. I have said that the third recommendation in the Banking Commission Report was that the housing operations of the Government should cease. The report does not say, in so many words, that housing should be discontinued. It says the same thing in what I have called the deceptive English language because it says to the Government: "You can only proceed with that housing which you can finance from revenue" which would mean nothing. In other words, the removal of the slum dwellers from their insanitary houses in the cities, towns and villages of the country is not to be undertaken. They are to remain where they are. What reason do the Banking Commission give for that recommendation? That the Government are to wait until we get what they describe as sound money conditions. What is to happen to the dweller of an insanitary house in a slum area? He is to be crucified on the cross of British sterling.

The fourth recommendation is that compulsory land purchase should cease. In that part of the country that I come from there are thousands of acres of land owned by men who reside 40 and 50 miles away from it. The sons of local small farmers have been waiting for some of that land for years, patiently hoping that the Land Commission would see to the division of it. If the fourth recommendation in the report of the Banking Commission is to be given effect to, what will it mean? That those men who have been waiting for some of that land will be driven across St. George's Channel. There you have, in all their nakedness, what the findings of the Majority Report amount to. I submit that the adoption of the Majority Report of the Banking Commission by the Government should mean the repeal of Article 45, Section 2, of the Constitution. It lays down:—

The State shall, in particular, direct its policy towards securing

i. That the citizens (all of whom, men and women equally, have the right to an adequate means of livelihood) may through their occupations find the means of making reasonable provision for their domestic needs.

ii. That the ownership and control of the material resources of the community may be so distributed amongst private individuals and the various classes as best to subserve the common good.

iv. That in what pertains to the control of credit the constant and predominant aim shall be welfare of the people as a whole.

v. That there may be established on the land in economic security as many families as in the circumstances shall be practicable.

If you take the Majority Report of the Banking Commission and place it beside Article 45, Section 2, of the Constitution you will clearly see that the two cannot live together. It would be as reasonable to expect that fire and water would live in the same container.

It is not my intention to travel over the social, economic or financial fields which have been traversed by a number of Deputies who have spoken in this debate from both sides of the House. I shall confine myself to pointing out what, in my opinion, are the abnormalities that prevail in this country: abnormalities that do not exist in any of those countries that were quoted by the Minister for Finance or by other Deputies. We have abnormalities here that do not exist in any of those countries with which a comparison has been made. In the first place, we in this country export more human beings in proportion to our population than any other country in the world. We have the lowest marriage rate of any white race in the world.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Notwithstanding that mass emigration of our people, we also have somewhere about 100,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Now, these are abnormalities that do not prevail in most other countries. They are abnormalities that are certainly an evil growth. They are abnormalities that, in my opinion, have within them a germ which, if allowed to grow unchecked, may easily cause the decay, if not the death, of this nation. We are in one respect more favourably situated than most other countries in proceeding to remove these abnormalities. In most other countries where they have a huge unemployed roll, we find that they are highly specialised industrial countries. Even if they have the machinery, the men and the raw material they cannot put their people into employment unless they are assured of a market for the products of their factories.

With us, 90 per cent. of our emigration would be from the rural areas. Somewhat the same percentage— slightly less—of our unemployed would exist in those same areas. We have in the areas where the unemployed and the emigrants come from works waiting to be carried out and works—not-withstanding anything that has been said to the contrary—of a reproductive character. Commissions—perhaps I should say, to make it more pleasant to Deputy Dillon's ear, Royal Commissions—sat in this country and made reports on questions of afforestation and drainage. The report that is available said that in this country we have millions of acres of marginal land that could be used for afforestation. That report also said that our climate and soil are suitable for the growing of wood. It is rather amazing since the time those experts examined that problem, that the soil and climate of Ireland should have changed or that the land should have disappeared. We are told by experts here to-day that wood cannot grow in this country. When I hear the word "expert" I always become suspicious, as one hears people say "I have consulted an expert". We hear about experts who have reported on matters of forestry, but we have not heard who they were. It would be reasonable to ask these experts what was the position of Ireland in the 16th and 17th centuries in so far as the growing of timber was concerned. How did it grow then? How did our extensive forests come to exist and what has happened to make a change in the meantime?

I am reminded of what occurred when British experts were sent to report on the possibility of constructing the Suez Canal. They came back and reported that it could not be done. French experts went out and did it and the Suez Canal is there to-day. I am very much afraid that the experts who are reporting against the possibility of planting timber in this country are to a large degree of the same type as the British experts who were sent out in connection with the construction of the Suez Canal.

We have the men in this country— the men and the work are there. In other countries there are cries of "Back to the land," and in other countries they are failing to induce the people to go back to the land. We have our people on the land to-day and our first purpose should be to endeavour to keep them there. Rural Ireland is the foundation on which the cities and the towns rest, and if that foundation disappears it will only be a short time until the cities and the towns must crumble.

Comment on this

We are all saying that for the last ten or 12 years—at every election.

Comment on this

In addition to afforestation, we have vast tracts of land waiting to be drained. We have the finest land in the world under water from January to December, awaiting the completion of main drainage schemes. These two works alone—apart from reclamation—would absorb every unemployed man, and they are works of a reproductive character. Can anybody show that they are not? If we bring the people back to the land and reclaim the land that is now under water, do we not increase the productivity of the country? If we plant our marginal lands with timber, is it not real wealth that is being produced in the country? If it were done 30 years ago there would be no need for us to be importing timber to-day.

Most of the reasonable people we talk to will admit that we have the work to give the unemployed to do. The men are there, the work is there; but then we reach the cry: "Where is the money to come from?" That is the controlling factor in bringing together these two elements in the life of this country—the work and the worker. Let us be honest with ourselves. It is because of the fact that we have not got the money that we cannot bring these two elements together. Under the Currency Act of 1927 our unit of value here is on a parity with the British pound. Our pound is on a parity with the British pound. There are a few facts in connection with that which I want to state as clearly as I may. In the first place, we are the only country in the world whose unit of value is on a pound-for-pound parity with the British. The British unit of value was determined without consultation with us: they determine their unit of value to suit themselves. Their law was made to suit England.

I can recollect hearing the Leader of the Opposition, Mr. Cosgrave, speak in the elections of 1917, 1918, 1919, and he always conveyed to the people the advisability of placing their trust in Sinn Féin and electing a Parliament here at home to make laws for this country. He always dwelt on the unsuitability of laws made by the British Parliament for this country. As he said, England is an industrialised country and we are agricultural, and the law that is made at St. Stephen's in Westminster is wholly unsuitable for our country. It is quite extraordinary that whilst he favoured that change and obtained authority to do it, the most important of all laws operative here is still the law made at St. Stephen's in Westminster. Orthodox countries that we hear so much about—Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Portugal—are on a sterling basis, but their relation to sterling is decided and determined by themselves. They did not blindly switch their parity or their currency on to the currency of England or the British pound. They determined their own currency in relation to sterling and did that in the interests of their own internal economy.

The placing of our pound on a parity with the British pound has other implications. This is a major one, that, if our Government to-morrow decided to finance an undertaking, involving the expenditure of say, £1,000,000, they must satisfy themselves beforehand that they are in a position to deposit sterling assets with the Bank of England to meet that outgoing expenditure, and, unless they can do that, they must call a halt to that expenditure. From that, it is obvious that the operations of any Government in this country, in the matter of financial expenditure, are governed by an institution foreign to this country. In that connection, let me quote, as clearly as I remember, a contribution made by one of the distinguished signatories to the Majority Report of the Banking Commission, Professor Gregory. Writing in the London Daily Telegraph in July, 1935, he set down that

"we must not ignore the fact that it would be difficult to conceive the United States of America or France being willing to subordinate their domestic currency to the views of either the Bank of England or the British Treasury, for that is what association with the sterling group means."

Those were the words of Professor Gregory in 1935, but, in signing the Majority Report of the Banking Commission, in 1938, he had no hesitation in ignoring a fact which he said should not be ignored then.

Comment on this

He had more sense then.

Comment on this

I have no hesitation in asserting that this country at present has not financial freedom. I care not whom it offends. We have the means of obtaining that freedom, if we make use of it, and I remind the House that this Dáil, for the first time, has the opportunity of doing that, and that if it fails to make use of the opportunity, it may never come its way again. Deputy Dillon threw up his hands in despair and said: "If you part company with sterling, you ruin this country and you are burst." Other countries have done it as I pointed out—Sweden and Norway, Denmark, Portugal and New Zealand. These have all parted from parity with the British pound, and they have done it in their own interests, mind you. Since that is the considered judgment of the Ministers for Finance and the Governments of these countries, although I have a very high estimation of the Minister for Finance in our Government, and of the Cabinet associated with him, I think that the balance of opinion, taking all these countries on one side, would go to show that their pooled financial wisdom must be somewhat more convincing than the wisdom of one Cabinet in one country.

Apply a simple test to the position as it exists at present. If any Deputy in this Assembly had power to issue currency and credit to finance his undertakings, would he go to his neighbour for authority to do it and place a burden on the shoulders of his family? Would he not do it himself? In like manner, this authority, which surely is the prerogative of the State, under the present monetary system is passed over to a purely private profit-seeking institution to be used by them as they think right in their own interests and in the interests of their depositors. Again, I want to say that I make no complaint whatever about the commercial banks of this country. I want to allow nobody the opportunity to say that I said anything detrimental to these institutions. They are there, and they have a useful function to discharge in the commercial life of the country, and in financing the other undertakings that exist there, but it is not the duty of the banks to solve the social or economic problems of this country. It is the duty of the State. Until the State clothes itself with authority to take control of the currency and credit of the country, the State cannot discharge the duties that are expected from it. That control does not aim at inflation as has been suggested here, but it aims at and certainly can achieve, by wise direction full employment and full economic activity. We have proceeded along the lines of solving the unemployment problem by the payment of doles, unemployment assistance. If that were a solution of the problem, these other countries would long since have solved their problems. Other countries tried that before there was a Government formed here, and they have that same evil with them still, and it will prove no solution here. One forecast I make, that, while we endeavour to proceed to solve our social and economic difficulties, to discharge our obligations within the social sphere, upon the foundation of interest-bearing, we are never going to succeed.

We have had attempts made to establish analogies between this country and other countries. I think I have given the House to understand that the analogies were not correct, and that, in making those analogies, and in seeking to establish them, for the purpose of stampeding people away from any movement in this country to reorganise the monetary system of the country, the picture against these countries was overdrawn by Deputies and by the Minister for Finance last night. We were already told about conditions in New Zealand. Deputy Dillon had already described New Zealand in this House on two occasions as being "bust". I will not characterise the opinions he expressed by his own fishy word. I will pass it over. But in that condemnation of other countries other Deputies joined. During the debate on practically this same subject at a previous meeting of the Dáil, Deputy Childers joined in, and he showed that the efforts of the President of the United States to solve this problem were unavailing. He described these efforts as pump priming. Then he moved across to France. Last night the Minister for Finance dealt for a considerable time with the position of New Zealand. In dealing with the figures, he showed that one item alone in the exports from New Zealand had fallen considerably last year. I think he could have reasonably told the House that one item of exports, namely, wool, from New Zealand had dropped in value by £7,000,000. One can easily understand how much that upset the exports from New Zealand. There was one other item which I think he might have given to the House in connection with New Zealand. That was the figure of unemployment in New Zealand. Now, the number of unemployed persons in New Zealand at the end of December, 1938, was 1,200. Only 1,200 people were receiving relief through unemployment channels. On the basis of our population our figure for unemployment should stand at 2,400, that is taking our population as double that of New Zealand. I think that was a comparison that he should not have excluded from the other comparisons he made.

Comment on this

The Deputy would also want to exclude the comparison in wealth and resources with New Zealand.

Comment on this

In dealing with this country we should in reason first of all be able to keep to the problem of our own people in the country. It is highly undesirable that other countries should be attacked solely because it may suit the purpose of those who are promoting a particular viewpoint on this matter. As I have told the House Deputy Dillon attacked New Zealand, Deputy Childers attacked America and France and the Minister for Finance——

Comment on this

Attacked them all.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance attacked New Zealand also. Is it not a pity that those Deputies, who have got so much wisdom that they can coolly proceed to direct the President of the United States of America, the President of France and Mr. Savage, the Prime Minister of New Zealand, would not pool their wisdom and use it for dealing with the problem confronting them here, that of dealing with the 3,500,000 people in this country?

Comment on this

That would not be politics.

Comment on this

I have been thinking it is a pity that we could not get those countries to accept those Deputies at their own value so as in some way to balance the fall there has been in our invisible income. If we exported them to those countries we would certainly be in receipt of an invisible income and I doubt like some of our other exports that it would cause any loss to this State as a whole.

Comment on this

Why the blazes Deputy O'Loghlen stays in the Fianna Fáil Party if he hates them so much, I do not know.

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

Deputy Dillon ought to be able to solve that.

Comment on this

During the debate here on the last occasion I was standing behind Deputy Childers when he was reading a book on Portugal, translated by Antino Ferro. I pointed out to Deputy Childers when he had finished that there was some information in that book that should be given to the House. He asked me what it was and I said Dr. Salazar who had taken complete control of the monetary organisation including the commercial banks in Portugal.

Comment on this

These intimate revelations are very embarrassing.

Comment on this

Very good. They have their purpose. They have a mesage for this country. Deputy Dillon might, for the moment, withhold his interruptions. To continue, Deputy Childers in reply to me said:—"That is quite true". I said: "You describe that as orthodox finance. Do you not think that you should have told the House that Dr. Salazar has had control of the commercial banks in Portugal?". "Oh, yes, that is very true but that is a control with which I would not trust our people with", was Deputy Childers' reply. Now, there, in my opinion you have the real reason for the opposition to the monopoly. That is the outlook of many of the intelligentsia who seek to put over their views on us here.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil as a Government has endeavoured within the limits at their disposal to solve the problems with which they have been confronted. They have endeavoured to build an arch on which to maintain a sound social economic structure.

Comment on this

Without the key.

Comment on this

Quite true. The key in the arch was the control of currency and credit and until that key is taken control of by the Government, this arch will never be completed. I will make a prediction now and tell you that the nation that parts with the control of its currency and credit will find that it is immaterial to the people who live within the country's borders who makes that nation's laws.

Comment on this

While I do not agree with everything that has been said by Deputy O'Loghlen, I am glad to live and see the day and be a member of the Dáil when a speech like the one just delivered has been given to this House. What is freedom? Deputy O'Loghlen defined it in his closing remarks. I said myself a few weeks ago here that this House is nothing better than a talking shop if the control of money and credit in this country is vested in the Bank of England. I do regret that this Banking Commission Report comes up here as a kind of side wind to a motion. It should not have been brought up in this matter. I agree with the Taoiseach when he said yesterday that this Banking Commission was appointed to investigate various aspects of our economic life, but that there was no assurance and no undertaking given that this House was going to accept that report. But the Dáil should have got an opportunity before now of considering it, not on a side wind but as a main question brought before the House. Now, I understand that an agreement has been come to that many more Deputies will not speak except the mover of the motion, who has a right to reply. Others, therefore, will be debarred from participating in this debate. That is very unfair in connection with a matter like this, and I would suggest to the Taoiseach that within the next three months during which we are going to retire into private life that a day would be fixed and the Dáil assembled to debate this Report of the Banking Commission until nobody has any more to say about it.

Comment on this

What a long debate it would be.

Comment on this

Yes, it would be a long debate, but to the Minister for Defence I would put this view—that it is a long, weary road for the man out of work looking for a job. Here is material which, if properly arranged, could solve the unemployment problem. There is no other road to its solution. I was surprised at previous speakers dragging in conditions in New Zealand here. They need not drag in anybody. Take September, 1931, when we had world-wide depression and when all countries that were on the gold standard found themselves in the position that they were not able to sell their goods. Great Britain was up against the greatest depression in her life. Great Britain had plenty of gold in the gold reserves in the Bank of England. It was not want of gold that made England go off the gold standard on the 15th September, 1931, but the necessity to depreciate her currency so as to enable her to reduce costs and sell her goods in the world market.

I am glad the Taoiseach is here and I hope he will forgive me if he thought my remarks, when he was speaking, were in the nature of interruptions. I did not then think that I would get the golden opportunity of speaking when he would be here and of addressing a couple of questions to him. He made a long, exhaustive speech on the position, and the questions I wanted to put to him then I should like to put to him now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, of course, is aware that the Taoiseach is not entitled to reply.

Comment on this

I want to give him information, A Chinn Comhairle, and I hope he will take it in the spirit in which it is tendered. Great Britain in order to be able to sell her goods in the world market got off the gold standard. She had to depreciate her currency, and, of course, it is a well-known law of finance and trade that countries on the gold standard cannot carry on a profitable trade in selling with countries working on a depreciated currency. Countries with a depreciated currency, selling to countries on an appreciated or gold standard currency will make money hand over fist. When Britain went off the gold standard we, who were on a sterling standard, automatically slipped off the gold standard just the same as sterling. What did our competitors, Denmark, New Zealand and the Argentine do? They were then on the gold standard, but they slipped off the gold standard at the same time, but much further than Britain did. What do we find here? This is the position that should be known to every farmer and should be examined by every farmer in the country. The Dane is our competitor on the British market. His unit of currency, the kroner, had a parity with sterling of 18:159 to the £. To-day it is between 23 and 24 to the £, which means that if he sells £1 worth of butter in the British market and brings that £1 back to Denmark, it is worth 25/- to him. If we sell £1 worth of butter in the British market and take back that £1 here, it is worth only 20/-.

Comment on this

Suppose he spends it on British coal?

Comment on this

I can argue that. That is why I said, as a preamble, that we would want longer to debate this question than is provided by a makeshift debate on an adjournment motion, because that is what it means. What the Minister has said is quite right, but it has got to be examined. I am not arguing positively. I am showing the position created by a depreciated or an inflated currency and the impossibility of agriculture in this country competing in the British market with Danish agriculture, New Zealand agriculture or Argentine agriculture. The Minister is aware that what drove British cotton prints out of the Chinese market was the depreciated Japanese currency which enabled the Japanese mills to undersell the British mills in the Chinese markets. He is aware that that was a subject of long negotiations and strained relations between the two countries—the depreciation of the Japanese yen. I am surprised above all to find lined up or the side of financial Imperialism the Minister for Defence.

Comment on this

I am only trying to line you up properly.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Loghlen suggested something that to my mind bordered on social credit. I am not a believer in social credit. I just take the stand with regard to finance that I took in regard to nationality when this was a crown colony. Let us get control of whatever type of currency we think best for the country and let us adopt that. If it is in the best interests of the country to remain hitched to sterling, let those who are the Government, and who have means and sources of information that Deputies have not got, keep hitched to sterling and good luck to them but let them control credit. It would be very interesting to examine the amount of currency in circulation in this country during the war years. Remember, it is the amount of currency that affects prices. Increased prices mean an increase in the money value of goods and diminished prices a reduction in the money value of goods. During the Great War and around the years 1918 to 1920, we had circulating in what is roughly the Free State now about £21,000,000. At that time Britain had something over £500,000,000 in circulation. To-day Great Britain has over £500,000,000 circulating but we have not £10,000,000 circulating.

The question of credit arises on this motion and on the Report of the Banking Commission. It is admitted that there is a shortage of credit here, but, as a businessman. I agree with the Press report which I read of Deputy Dowdall's speech on this motion. He said substantially that, as a businessman, he found the banks of this country always accommodating for a sound business proposition. As one who has borrowed largely from banks, and paid them back, I can endorse what Deputy Dowdall has said. I can repeat here what I said before the Banking Commission a couple of years ago, that I have never been refused accommodation by my bank when the accommodation was good for me. I have been refused. That is a cryptic way of putting it but where I have been refused I have found afterwards that, as things worked out, the banks saw better into the future than I did.

I should like to put this to the Taoiseach. The British Government made representations to the Japanese Government about their trading in China produced by the depreciation of the yen. Has the Taoiseach, either as Taoiseach or as Minister for External Affairs, made any representations to the British Government to give Irish agriculture a preference that would equate with the advantages that our competitors are getting in the British market, because of their working on currencies depreciated in relation to sterling while we are hitched on to sterling?

Personally, if it meant no loss to our trade, I should like to see the link with sterling maintained. It would make for the sympathetic working of trade between the two countries. But I am afraid we are losing by it. I am certain that our competitors in agricultural produce in the British market are having a decided advantage over us. I should like to know if the Taoiseach has ever made a case to the British Government to give us preferential treatment which would equate with the advantages that those countries have over us there.

Agriculture is not an asset on which money can be borrowed in this country. The Taoiseach, in addressing himself to that aspect of the matter when speaking on this motion did not dwell very long upon the case made from these benches, and made in the country, that the loss of freedom of sale acted detrimentally on land as a security in getting accommodation. He said that the objection to the sale of those lands by the banks when defaults occurred has had an effect. I agree that there is that objection to selling out a farmer. That is a survival from the landlord days; it is part of the old boycott system. It has survived, and it is really a loss to agriculture that it has survived. Although we would all sympathise with the person who would find himself in those circumstances, it is a loss to his neighbour. The banks must protect themselves, and if they get stuck in one case they are not going to lend money in similar cases in future. There are millions of frozen debts in the banks in the name of the farmers. What has produced them? Was it not the deflation of the currency from 1919 to 1925? Are they not a legacy of that period? What was the deflation of the currency? Was it not a simply working back to the gold standard? Britain did it for British interests and to suit British purposes. It bankrupted agriculture in this country. People say that the banks gave out foolishly during the war years. They did not. They gave out freely, and when they gave out freely you had business going well in this country. You had no unemployment and you had good wages. It was about the only time—certainly the only time during our lives—when there was adequate currency in this country to do the business of this country.

If there had been a full dress debate on this whole question of national currency and national credit, it would have paid us to go back 150 years, and examine each crisis that took place and the periodical famines that took place in this country from the Act of Union down to the present time. It would be found that what led to every famine was a shortage of currency. Compare the currency that was here in 1845 with the currency that was here in 1850; it was only one-third of what was here in 1845. The shortage of currency was the direct cause of the famine. One could only touch those things in spots in a short debate of this kind, and I should be glad if some more suitable occasion could be found for going exhaustively into this whole report, the issue being: "Shall we take control of our credit and currency here, or shall we not?" This debate has not gone on stereotyped or orthodox Party lines. That is as it should be, because this a a very important issue. Whether the Taoiseach sees it or not, or whether he believes it or not, I am convinced— I am not issuing a Partyism when I say this—that this country is up against a very acute national financial crisis. The Taoiseach, in his address to this House on this motion, said that we have all building materials here except timber. That is substantially correct. We have practically all. We have the men, skilled and unskilled; we have the demand for houses. Why are we not assembling the materials and making houses?

Comment on this

If you get the return, in rates and so on.

Comment on this

Asbestos slates.

Comment on this

You closed up Deputy Gorey's quarries.

Comment on this

They did not happen to be mine.

Comment on this

I was sorry that the Taoiseach did not develop that point, and tell us why we are not assembling the material. Is it his case that the cost is too much? I agree with him to a certain extent—I do not go the whole of the way with him—but he is in a position to call a conference of all the interests concerned.

Comment on this

I have met them individually.

Comment on this

He should get them to gather around a table, and, if a builder says to a worker: "You are not doing enough, and you are asking too much for it", let the worker answer that. If the financial people will not give the accommodation, if, as is alleged, they will not help in borrowing money, and are throttling business, let them be accused of that across the table, and let them answer the accusation. We would get a lot nearer to realities in a conference like that than in any inquiry. In an inquiry, one man goes in and gives his point of view; then another man with a different point of view gives his opinion, and those who are conducting the inquiry are puzzled as to how they are to reconcile the conflicting statements. You get no further. The whole thing is pigeon-holed. The other is more in the form of a debate. You come to a finding, and a lot of petty opinions that people had about those who are in other walks of life will be knocked down. You will get something nearer to realities.

Comment on this

Would you allow the ratepayer near the table at all?

Comment on this

I would. He would need to be there. The builder, I think, is a kind of a ratepayer. I hope that the Taoiseach will try and get some setoff for agriculture that will equate with the loss that agriculture is sustaining or, to put it the other way, the advantage that our competitors have by working on a depreciated currency in the British market. I also think that the time has come for a very careful consideration of the question of taking control of our currency and credit. It is a very serious thing that the principal industry in this country has no credit. Nobody can deny that, whatever the causes may be, whether the boycotting of sales of land even for an ordinary debt, or the denial of free sale. The Taoiseach said that everybody knows the law; that land can be taken but that the occupiers will get a fair price for it. I personally cannot see why a man's land should be taken from him any more than a man's factory or a man's shop should be taken. He has his money invested in it. We all know that the proper draining and cultivation of the land dates from the time that fixity of tenure was granted. The hands of the clock are being put back by destroying that fixity of tenure which is a man's estate in his land.

I wonder would it be possible to get a meeting within the next three months and to debate in detail all these various reports. No matter how anybody pretends to gloss it over, the position is serious. The Taoiseach said that national credit stood high. We know that at the last attempt at floating a loan in this country one quarter of it was not subscribed.

Comment on this

What loan was that?

Comment on this

The Dublin Corporation loan.

Comment on this
Andrew Fogarty Mr. P.J. Fogarty Fianna Fáil

That was your fault and the fault of a lot of others in the corporation.

Comment on this

We had not a financial magnate like Deputy Fogarty there or we would have been all right.

Comment on this

I put more into it than you put, and that is a challenge. It is you and your statements that have injured the credit of the country.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach asked me what loan that was and I told him.

Comment on this

I thought you said it was a State loan.

Comment on this

The State was not far away from that loan.

Comment on this

The last national loan was over-subscribed.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin stated yesterday that the Dublin Corporation wanted £3,000,000, and that was true. We wanted £3,000,000, but it was cut down to the bare margin that would pay for our commitments. We were told that the present was not a time for public borrowing. That statement was made by the banks and was agreed to by two Ministers. We were told that only £1,500,000 would be sanctioned to meet our commitments on housing contracts and a couple of other contracts, like the Poulaphouca contract, already placed. Although we got that £1,500,000, we did not get £1 to put a single additional man working. That is the position to-day. To say now that our national credit stands high is not in accordance with the facts. If we are not facing a national financial crisis, I cannot read the signs of the times. That money was for direct housing in the City of Dublin. Six months before that, the indirect aid for housing in the City of Dublin was withdrawn, that is, loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. Prior to that being withdrawn, the amount advanced was cut down from 90 per cent, to 70 per cent. of the market value of a house, while there are British insurance companies operating in this city advancing loans up to 85 per cent. of the market value. How can the Taoiseach say that the credit of the country stands high when the capital city cannot borrow money for the housing of the people? We should face the real facts of the situation.

I would be very slow to approve of juggling with our currency. There was a time when we could have made millions by adopting a national currency. At one time we could have taken £20,000,000 worth of paper and placed it on the counter of the Bank of England and, by the law of England, we are entitled to get £20,000,000 in bullion for it. We did not do that. The currency was backed as to one-third by gold and as to two-thirds by paper, and we exchanged our paper money, for which prior to then we could have got bullion, for that paper. Now, after fighting an economic war—whether we won or lost it is immaterial—the credit position of this country is so poor that in this city the housing of the working classes and private speculative building, which formerly got that help from the State, are brought to a standstill. Some weeks ago 300 carpenters went over to jobs in Great Britain and had their fares paid for them by British trade unions operating here, because they were refused benefit, if they did not take jobs that were available in England. The work is here to be done. The Dublin Corporation have about 400 acres of land developed for building but they have no money to build.

What is the use of "codding" ourselves by saying that we have credit? If we have credit why do we not borrow? The Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government will not sanction borrowing. They have refused to sanction it. How, then, can the Taoiseach tell us we have credit and tell us about the houses built, and so on? We know that. Thanks to the co-operation of the local authorities and the Government—and, to do him justice, the Minister for Local Government has always shared the thanks between the local bodies and the Government—that has been done. It was owing to that co-operation, and the drive of the last few years, that the houses were built. But we are brought to a stand-still now, at a time when we are considering credit and the financial position. With full knowledge of the position, I say that we are up against a national financial question when the City of Dublin cannot borrow money to build houses. There are representatives of the corporation in this House, and I challenge any of them to contradict that statement. I wonder will the Taoiseach, or any members of his Party who may intervene in the debate, tell us where our credit stands high? Is it not time to look around and to consider the proposals outlined in the motion and the amendment. Progress can be made if either of them are considered. The motion asks that steps should be taken to reduce the burden of direct and indirect taxation.

If we remain hitched to sterling there is no alternative but to reduce direct and indirect taxation. It is for the Government to decide what services will have to be curtailed. That cannot be suggested from this side of the House. The difficulty of getting finance to run the country will be a compelling force on the Government to reduce taxation. The Taoiseach studied his economics well lately, which shows that the situation is compelling the Government to look closer into things with which they previously went straight ahead. In effect, the Taoiseach said that if it cost £2 a week to put a man to work, and if what he produced was worth only 35/-, that was no relief of unemployment. I agree. The problem before the Taoiseach and the Government is not to have that man idle but to have him absorbed into our ordinary economic life.

The claim was also made that 45,000 people had been put into employment as a result of tariffs and the present industrial policy. But there are still 100,000 unemployed. There is something wrong when 100,000 people cannot be absorbed into our ordinary industrial, commercial, and agricultural life. It is costing the State a good deal to keep these people, and to give them temporary relief in the way of three days work now and then. The loss to the country, by not having them at work, means further economic loss, because of the fact that they are being rendered useless, as far as full utility value goes, for production in future. Another problem concerns the thousands of young people, many of them approaching manhood and womanhood, who have never worked and who are passing on to the dole or to some kind of home assistance. The Taoiseach wrings his hands and sheds tears about the low marriage rate and birth rate. He does not agree with what the Labour representatives suggested—that the low marriage rate is an economic question. I believe it is an economic question.

Comment on this

How can the Deputy say that when well off people do not get married?

Comment on this

You find people who are well off who never get married. I am not talking of the exceptions or the freaks. I am talking about ordinary people. The Taoiseach like myself got married early in life. When I got married my ambition—and I suppose it was his—was to have enough to keep us. Tastes were moderate in those days.

Comment on this

They have grown very big since then.

Comment on this

If they had developed many people would not get married as early as they did. I am sure the Taoiseach would not advocate marriages between young people who are on the dole. When young people cannot get married because of the economic situation the remedy is to bring about a situation on which they can afford to get married. The alternative is to let young people get married on the dole or be brought up on poor law relief. Would it not be better for the country not to have people existing under such conditions? No matter how the Government attempts to get out of it, the responsibility is theirs. The hard facts are staring them in the face. A case has been made here that if the currency must be inflated in order to create work, the effect would be to depreciate the savings of the people. I agree with that view. That is a fact. Remember that rentiers who had money on deposit found that their savings were greatly depreciated during the years of deflation. I have a fair amount of fixed property and if inflation started, it would devalue that property. I am prepared to have it devalued, because the inflation of the currency means, in effect, devaluation of fixed assets. What I would lose on the swing boats I would gain on the roundabouts. I do not think there is anything in the point about the currency being inflated. I must not be taken as advocating inflation or deflation, but I am a strong advocate in this respect, that if we want freedom, or consider that we should have a free choice, we ought not only have the right to freedom, but should exercise it. We have not financial freedom, but we have the power to be financially free. This is all I advocate, and I am in a miscellaneous collection, so to speak, who advocate it. It is a good thing to see Party barriers of all kinds broken down on this common platform.

In conclusion, may I say I reciprocate what my old friend, Deputy Dowdall, said here. I hope there will be a union of all forces in this House, and outside it, a union of the forces of goodwill, a union that will lead to the establishment of a national force that will help to bring the country out of its present terrible plight, that will rehabilitate its credit and help to relieve unemployment, and not only to have the will to be free, but to be actually free. We have the whole mechanism of freedom. Nobody is keeping us from enjoying the full fruits of freedom but ourselves, and we should not stand in the way any longer. I would be glad if an opportunity could be given for a full-dress debate on this Banking Commission report. I think the motion around which the whole discussion should gather should be a motion asking this House to give its authority for the taking over of the control of credit and banking in this country. By that I am not to be taken —although I have read pretty well everything that has been written on social credit—as an advocate of social credit. I advocate taking control of our currency and banking, just as England has control of it in England, just as France has control of it in France, America in America, and so on. Whatever is the best machinery for that control, when we have got it, let us adopt that machinery, but we will only know what is best when we have taken control and when we have tried to work it.

Comment on this

I am not going to take up much time, because I think the Taoiseach has already got an indication from our side of the House as to what we mean in our motion. I expect it will take some time before the Government will be prepared to do anything in connection with the findings of the Banking Commission, but I think in the meantime the Taoiseach should try to get something done with regard to the question of giving credit for the building of houses. I listened with interest to what Deputy Belton said about the Dublin situation. The Cork situation is no better. The building of houses for the workers in Cork City has not cost the ratepayers in Cork a penny so far. For the number of houses built in Cork City during the past five years there is a sum of £19,000 to the good side of the rates instead of there being any burden on the rates in Cork.

We asked for a loan of £250,000 last November and we issued a 4 per cent. loan 15 months previously at £99. The loan was more than doubly subscribed on that occasion. Fifteen months later we asked for £250,000, and the bank that offered us £20,000 on the earlier occasion, and the insurance company that offered us £8,000 on the same occasion, did not subscribe. Strange to say, three of the directors of the bank were also directors in the insurance company. Out of the £8,000 offered by the insurance company we were able to give them only £2,600. After 15 months not as much as a solitary £ was offered by these two corporations for the building of houses, even though we offered 4 per cent. on the money. I am quite satisfied that that was due to the Majority Report of the Banking Commission. Such is the position that has been created, that we are not able to proceed with the building of houses because we cannot find the money, even though we are offering 4 per cent. for it. I submit that offering 4 per cent. for money to-day for the purpose of building houses is not asking money for nothing.

It is because of these facts that we have indicated to the Government that they should be in a position to control the credit and currency of the country. It would be better to have a position like that rather than have our people rotting in slums. Who can estimate properly the dreadful conditions in which people are living to-day? I am glad to be able to say that I very much appreciated the spirit in which the Taoiseach discussed the matter this morning. I feel that he is inclined to do the right thing. I hope that it will not be very long until he submits proposals here to take over the control of credit and currency in this country. I submit that there is not a Government anywhere in the world that is in a more favourable position to tackle this problem and relieve the evils from which we suffer. You have the backing of the masses of the people, you have the backing of the Church, and the support of anybody who is worth anything in the country. They are all with you, 100 per cent., in dealing with the social evils with which we are confronted.

The Taoiseach asked to-day what did we mean by saying that the Government should utilise the credit of the nation. To-day we have not alone the need for houses, but we have thousands of people on the verge of starvation. I took some trouble recently to find out the weekly income of 709 families living in 709 houses built by the Cork Corporation. I ascertained that 163 families were living on an income of 20/- a week; 110 were living on sums ranging from £1 to 30/-, and 83 were living on amounts ranging from £2 to £2 10s. In the 709 houses the average number in each family was six. We discovered in the course of that inquiry that there were over 2,500 persons living on 4/- a week per person. That was the amount they had for food and clothing and to give the warmth necessary for life.

These are matters I am very concerned about. This is a Christian country and I suggest to our leaders, and I do not mind on which side of the House they are, that that sort of thing should not be allowed to continue for 24 hours. I am not trying to make Party capital out of this. I am speaking as one who witnessed the grim realities of the situation. I could, if I wished, talk about things that would stir the heart of anybody. We are not worthy of being called semi-statesmen while that type of thing is allowed to continue. I trust that when we reassemble in October we will have some proposal from the Government to deal with such pressing problems as I have outlined.

Comment on this

In view of what I consider the unreasonable amount of time monopolised by the Taoiseach, and as there are other Deputies anxious to express their views on this most important matter, I think the agreement which was entered into between the leaders of the big Parties should not be strictly adhered to. As it is unlikely that we shall have, for some time at least, the opportunity which Deputy Belton suggested of debating this question further, I think any Deputies who desire to speak on this matter should be permitted to do so, at least briefly. I do not think it is quite proper that there should be any attempt to restrict the debate on a question so important as this.

We know that in this country at the present time feeling is becoming very hostile to Parliamentary institutions. In a recent election in Dublin we saw it demonstrated that over 50 per cent. of the people abstained from voting. Why was that? It was because the people came to the conclusion that the Parliamentary institutions in this country are not being used to serve the best advantage of the people, but are being used simply for Party purposes. I cannot be accused of having any Party interest in this matter, as I am not attached to any political Party, and I think that, if the leaders and the members of both political Parties in this House realise the gravity of this problem, they will come together and seek a solution of the tremendous financial and economic difficulties which face this country and which members of the Government, in common with members of th Opposition Party, agree are absolutely desperate.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

I want to join with the protest that has just been made, Sir. Several times during the course of this debate I wanted to talk about the conditions in Dublin, and I think that we ought to be permitted to have a few words to say, in regard to Dublin, on this important question. The conditions outside are awful.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

A direction was made by the House this morning, and, as it was a direction made by the House, the Chair has no discretion in the matter.

Comment on this
Mr. A. Byrne

Yes, but the Minister for Finance took four hours of our precious time, and we did not get five minutes.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that the House will give a further opportunity to Deputies to discuss this matter, and I think I observed the Taoiseach noding his head to Deputy Belton when Deputy Belton suggested that another opportunity should be given.

Comment on this

I think it is quite clear that we shall have to deal with this whole question of the recommendations, in one form or another, at a later stage.

Comment on this

Quite, and therefore I hope that Deputies will not assume that any attempt is being made to prevent them from taking part in this discussion, but I am sure it will be agreed that debates must come to an end some time. However, I must say that I have sympathy with Deputy Byrne when he comments on the fact that the Minister for Finance addressed the House for three and a half hours, to be followed, I think, by the Taoiseach, for about four hours. I appreciate very much the Taoiseach's desire to cover the ground in the most comprehensive way, and if he had occupied his four hours in applying his mind acutely and closely to the economic problems confronting this country, I would have listened to him with respect—as, indeed, I always do—for two and a half hours, but when he began to talk about the practice of gavelkind in the State of Saskatchewan in Canada, I must confess that my interest began to flag. Then, much as I have enjoyed in the past the pleasure of a chat with the Taoiseach in his informal moments, when he began to brood on his childhood, and on his neighbours, the tailor and the blacksmith, at home although, as I say, I enjoyed it, since the Taoiseach is ever a gracious companion and a charming speaker—when he took up the limited time at our disposal in discussing these weighty matters, I am afraid that I thought that that charming reminiscence might have been postponed to another day. I cannot help thinking that, on reflection, the Taoiseach will come to feel that to-day he was rather in the mood of the Right Honourable Stanley Baldwin, under an umbrageous English oak, dwelling on the characteristics of the Irish nation and his reactions to livelihood here.

Although Deputy Hickey seemed to like listening to the Taoiseach, I frankly felt—and I listened as closely as I could—that the more I listened, the more befogged and bemused we were becoming. Now, I do not want anything from the Taoiseach but to inform me as to what they propose to do, but when the Taoiseach took up the position of the foolish crowd who looked at the Chinese Emperor and admired his clothes, it seemed to me that Deputy Dowdall played the role of the child who got up and said that the Emperor had no clothes at all and that it was time to cover his nakedness. There is no use in the Taoiseach telling us that this nation is arrayed in the golden vesture of national solvency when the fact is that it is nearly naked, and I think it is time for the Taoiseach to consult the seamstress in order to devise some raiment, however simple, to cover its nakedness.

I dwell on what the Taoiseach said because, in fact, his was the only contribution from the Government Benches that had any significance at all. The contributions of Deputy O'Loghlen and Deputy Dowdall, when stripped of the verbiage and passion and the claim to speak on behalf of the Encyclicals, simply amount to this: Let us turn the handle of the printing press and produce whatever money we require. Now, that experiment has been tried in every country in the world. Two thousand years B.C. that experiment was tried in China, and you have got a classical example of the terrible consequences of resorting to that expedient in the history of China at that period, and all through the history of the world, from the dawn of time until to-day, you will find muddleheaded and woolly-minded people breaking down under the stress of public life in difficult times and trying to find an easy way out by resorting to such methods and then sinking deeper into the bog and morass of insolvency than they were before and then clamouring to those whom they denounce as the bankers' friends to pull them out of the mess into which they have got us all. Let us, for Heaven's sake, while bearing no ill-will against those well-meaning and warm-hearted men, which, no doubt, they are, tell them that while they are free—because this is a free country— to talk their silly minds as much as they like in public, they are not going to drag us down to the misery and destitution that the course they advocate would bring them, just because they are wrong. We know they are wrong, and we are not going to have our people harrowed and afflicted just in order to satisfy Deputy O'Loghlen's mind that he has made some economic error in the calculations to which he has been addressing his mind for the past two or three years.

The Taoiseach spoke of standing fast upon the policies he advocated seven years ago. He said that he attached prime importance to the home market if agriculture was to be revived, and he said that the object of the Fianna Fáil policy was to build up here at home for our farmers such a market as would render them more or less independent of the markets outside, or at least much less vulnerable to them than if they were dependent mainly on them for the profits required to maintain the State. What are the facts? The Taoiseach has been for seven years at the head of the Government, and he has had that particular aspect of his economic policy much accentuated and much accelerated by the impact of the economic war. By the impact of the economic war he was driven back on the home market much more drastically than he would have been without the advent of that struggle. Even under that extra urge of untoward events on his natural inclination, what is the result? The home market has not expanded at all. I have the figures for 1929-30 which show that £31,000,000 worth of agricultural produce produced on the farms was consumed by persons living in Eire not engaged in farm work. In 1936-37, we consumed in this country £31,000,000 worth also exactly the same amount of money. So that the expansion of the home market during that period of intensive development by the Government has been precisely nil.

Comment on this

In volume?

Comment on this

In volume the figures are practically the same. I have not got the figures here with me at the moment, but the Minister will find that these are the facts, that the consumption by our people of agricultural produce is practically stable, and that any increase that might have taken place, owing to the peculiar circumstances in which we found ourselves when it was necessary to distribute free beef and so on, which might have been expected to raise substantially the consumption of agricultural produce, has been offset by our declining population. These are the facts, and they cannot be got away from. They are not things to be argued about. I am not trying to make a case now; I am only setting out the figures, and these are taken from the Irish Trade Journal of September, 1938. I have been trying to get more recent figures, but they do not appear to be in the official publications yet. I presume that they are not printed and we must wait for them, but the figures I have given are sufficient for the moment to show what is the state of affairs.

Now, the Taoiseach spoke of the impact of tariffs and said that he admitted that tariffs raised the cost of the raw materials of the agricultural industry, and he spoke of boots and shoes; but there is something very much more vital than that. What the Taoiseach seems to forget is that every farm is a factory. But each of these factories has its market—the world market or the British market. If you raise the cost of the raw materials that we bring on to a farm to convert into the finished product, we are going to get precisely the same price for that product in Great Britain as we would get if you had not raised them and, when you raise the cost of the raw materials, what you are doing is simply eating our profit. You are taking out of the farmer's pocket the money he would otherwise have to spend on clothing his children, feeding his children and maintaining his standard of life. In short, what you are doing is simply reducing the farmer's standard of living in order to provide protection for some particular, individual industrialist whom you want to establish. I do not mean that you want to establish industrialists who are personal friends of your own or that you are acting with any corrupt motive. But you want to establish certain industries, no matter what the results, and you blind your eyes to the fact that, by establishing those industries you may deprive the farmer of the standard of living that we all want him to enjoy. While you are doing that in the hope of raising the industrial output of the country, you close your eyes to the fact that those parts of our industrial economy which were truly profit-making and which were primarily concerned with the use of raw materials produced in this country are dwindling away.

Have any Deputies here recently adverted to the output of the greatest industry in Ireland—the brewery industry. In 1931, our exports of porter amounted to 1,400,000 barrels value for £4,687,000 and our output to-day is 794,000 barrels value for £2,205,000. This is an industry which was consuming the raw materials of the country, which was giving the best employment in the country, which was inposing no extra charge on the people of Eire, which was paying the highest rate of wages of any industry in Ireland and which was keeping dozens of malt-houses going. These malt-houses are now closing. That is the kind of thing about which we are alarmed. Do you not realise that your industrial loss in that one instance more than outweighs the value of dozens of the workshops which fascinate your mind?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would indicate what Government action has been responsible for that?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has had four hours and, on occasions, I was strongly tempted to interrupt him but I restrained myself. Perhaps he will be good enough to give me the fifteen minutes that remain. A colleague of the Taoiseach waxed eloquent on the subject of pigs. He explained that there was a rising tendency in the pig-products industry. What are the facts? It is quite true that we are exporting more bacon than we exported before but have we forgotten that "pigs is still pigs" and that pork is still pigs. While I freely admit that we increased the value of our exports of bacon by £1,041,000 in the period referred to by the Minister, our export of pigs decreased by £1,965,000 and our export of pork decreased by £1,060,000, giving us a net decrease in our export of pig products of £1,900,000. Is that the kind of evidence of increasing production that appeals to the mind of the Taoiseach? If we are to discuss these questions objectively it is not honest—it is disingenuous at best—to tell the House that there is an increasing output of bacon when the truth is that the pig industry, which is the means of the farmers' livelihood, reveals a decrease represented by £1,900,000.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy forgotten the import of pig products in 1931.

Comment on this

I am just going to talk about that. That is why I mentioned the matter. The Taoiseach asks why should we bring American bacon into the country when we can make bacon ourselves. The answer is simple. Suppose we like American bacon, why should we not bring in American bacon? Suppose I am making 1,000,000 cwts. of bacon, which I can sell at a handsome profit abroad, why should I not use American bacon if I like American bacon? If you put American bacon on one side and Irish bacon on the other side, for the purpose of dressing cabbage, I prefer American bacon and I can get it at 6d. per lb. Why should I be forced to buy Irish bacon, which I do not want, and pay 1/3 for it when I can get American bacon for 6d. and sell my Irish bacon in England at 1/4? Why should I be made to take a loss on my pig when my natural inclination is to consume another product and, when by consuming another product, I can make a better profit for the community to which I belong?

We speak of wheat. The Taoiseach seemed to justify the expenditure of £2,500,000 on the production of wheat on the ground that it provided a guarantee for us against starvation in time of war. Our problem in time of war will be to get food out of the country. Does not the Taoiseach realise that 5,000,000 acres of arable land will feed all the people of the country, even if you ram food down their stomachs with a ramrod. We shall be smothered, stiffled and buried in a rotting heap of foodstuffs in the event of war. That is the deadly blow that the enemies of Ireland can deliver against us—to suspend our outgoing traffic. We shall be buying shovels and shovelling food into the sea. With that vast, immense, unconsumable accumulation of food, we are to pay £2,500,000 to protect ourselves against a scarcity of wheat. I lived on oaten bread in my schooldays. I never got wheaten bread from one end of the year to another and I weigh 14 stones to-day. We are paying £2,500,000 per annum for the growing of wheat. We have 220,000 acres under this crazy, futile crop, every acre of which could be growing a profitable crop which would provide for our people a higher standard of living. That is Fianna Fáil economy.

We are told that we can get sugar at dumped prices. I stood in the sugar fields of Honolulu and watched the workers—coloured men—engaged on the crop. They were receiving four times the wages that an agricultural labourer in Ireland receives. They were working shorter hours than the agricultural labourer in Ireland works and that sugar was being shipped at 8/- a cwt. Here it costs 27/- to grow it and the agricultural labourer receives 27/- a week. We wonder why the labourers in this country do not get married. Where is the man in this House who will marry and support a wife and four children on 27/- a week? I have seen them trying to do it. I have seen their children gradually starving under their eyes. I have seen them just kept alive and growing weaker and more miserable with the passage of every year. Instead of adding to their strength, every year tended to make them leaner, thinner and poorer than they were before.

That is life for a family on 27/- a week. Let those Deputies who talk about dumped sugar remember that sugar produced in the islands of the Pacific Ocean, deliverable in this country at 8/- per cwt., can afford to pay black men four times what we pay the agricultural labourer in this country. There is no use wagging your head about it. I have been there and have seen it and I have talked to them.

I have only a few moments left. The Opposition as conducted by this Party since this Parliament sat has been one, so far as I am aware, both within Party councils and in this House, designed to do one thing only and that is to serve the best interests of this country. Everybody knows that we are confronted by a grave financial crisis and I said with the full authority of the Party for which I speak, at the opening of this debate, that anything we can do to help the Government to protect the country from the consequences of that disaster we will be glad to do. That has been interpreted in certain circles as an invitation from us for a coalition. It is not. People who think of coalitions often indulge in wishful thinking. They imagine that if you take men whose political outlooks are completely different, and put them around a table a miracle occurs and they all start to agree. There can be no coalition between honest public men unless there is identity of purpose amongst them. This is a democratic country. We went to the country with our policy and the Taoiseach went with his and he won. He has the right and his colleagues have the right to form the Government of this country and to maintain it until they go to the country again and the people pass judgment upon them.

They sought the suffrage of the people and they got it. Very well. There is no Party in this House that desires to interfere with the constitutional right they have to form and maintain the Government of this country. But, while they may enjoy the privilege of forming the Government of this country, they are bound by solemn duty to accept responsibilities at the same time. They have no right to let this country drift along the path leading to her destruction, to drift along the path which brings honest and well-intentioned men into this House to advocate the turning of the handle of the printing press. Their duty is to safeguard the economy and the wealth of this country in such a way as to prevent developments of that kind, because, if those developments once get under way and are put in practice, neither that Government nor any Government this House can put up will be strong enough to stop them.

We have presented the views of the minority. We have made it clear that we are prepared to do all we can to help the Government to take the requisite steps to meet this situation and overcome it. It is not our job and it is not our right to dictate to the Government the policy that they are to pursue. Our duty is to point out to the Government where their policy goes wrong. Our duty and our privilege is to lay before the people our policy and that we shall continue to do. We put our policy before the people at the last election. It was rejected. The policy of the Government was accepted instead. Let the Government now meet the crisis that they have brought upon this country with some policy and, if they are not prepared to do it, let them go out and tell the country that we will present a policy to the country and ask the country's suffrage to give us authority to do what Fianna Fáil has not the courage to do.

This is the last word. There has grown up in this country recently a practice among certain guttersnipes to refer to those in public life in terms of contumely and insult, to fling mud and suggest that no man enters in public life in this country except for private profit or gain. If that thing continues a day will dawn in this country, as it has elsewhere, when those who are not prepared to submit to that beslobbering with dirt by those who have not the courage to undertake responsibility themselves, will get out of public life. There is no man sitting on these benches who could not make at his own profession far more than this State will ever offer him for his services. It would be very easy for most of the people on these benches to quit public life and leave it to those who would be prepared to take such rewards as it has to offer in exchange for the abuse and misrepresentation and slanders that are heaped upon them by certain irresponsible individuals at the present time. I would be sorry to see that happen in this country but, if it is not to happen, then those who sympathise with me should realise that, totally as we may disagree with one another in public affairs, we have a bounden duty at least to recognise the dignities of one another and jointly to resent encroachment upon the personal honour or integrity of those who are asked to do the nation's business. It is time that was said because I have seen democracies in this continent and in another in which that kind of scurrilous abuse which I was sorry to hear Deputy Cogan for Wicklow refer to in words of apparent approval to-day——

Comment on this

I did not approve of it.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy considers with me that scurrilous abuse of Parliamentary institutions and public men can destroy democracy in the country in which it is allowed to go unchecked. It ought to stop, because whatever Parliament the people have got is the Parliament they themselves chose. If it is not good enough for them let them get a better one. If it is good it will not be long before they get a worse one. I think this fairly represents our belief, and I am not ashamed of it. If the critics do not like it let them produce something better. We have got a big job before us. I do not expect the Prime Minister to get up in sack cloth and ashes and confess that he made a mistake and that he made a mess of it all. That would be more than human nature could expect, and I am not sure that even if he were swept with an unprecedented humility it would be a wise thing to do. I do not so much despair as Deputy Belton of the good this debate may have done. While it may not have been exhaustive, it made the Taoiseach talk for four hours to prove he was right, and when you hear a man talking for four hours to prove he is right it is a very good sign that there is some little something stirring in his mind. It made him pursue a course which resulted in certain individual Deputies of his Party being left in a sickly silence. That would suggest to me that something was stirring in the minds of others. If that be so, thank God for it.

Let me conclude on this note. Let him rest assured that if during the three months before us he will cogitate the motion we have discussed to-day and finds that he has difficult things to do in the service of this State, he need not be one bit afraid of this Opposition. They will help him. That does not mean that they abandon the principles for which they stand. He fairly described them as on our side, leaning slightly towards free trade, on his, leaning wildly to protection. I misrepresent him only just so much as tried to misrepresent us. We will maintain those positions. We will argue them before the people, and I think we will ultimately convince the people that we are right. But in the meantime there is urgent work to be done and I think it may be work which will require the co-operation of us all. If it is wanted, that Government or any other Government the Irish people will put in will get it from the members of this Party. I only hope and pray that that Government will have the moral courage to face their responsibility and save our people both here and scattered all over the world as they are from an unprecedented humiliation in the eyes of their enemies.

Comment on this
Division

The Dáil divided:—Tá,

Tá 94
·
Níl 8
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Motion put.

Tá 38
·
Níl 67
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?