Pigs and Bacon (Amendment) Bill, 1939—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–142 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 34 of 1939 ›
Deputy Norton, and also Deputy McGilligan, spoke on this amendment which, I think, can be accepted. I was going to say for Deputy McGilligan's benefit, however, that it is quite a different matter when we come to consider Orders, because some of these Orders are of a confidential nature. The regulations are such as could be published, but the Orders are not. Take, for instance, an Order for a sub-allocation quota, if such were made.
Comment on this
Production and, up to this, home sales. Theoretically, it is only the individual curer who knows what the quota is. They all have a fair idea of what is given to another curer but, in theory, the public do not know exactly what is the quota that a curer gets. In the same way, there is an Order made with regard to the yield of bacon from the weight of a pig. That is also confidential as between the factory and the board. I mention these merely to show that there is a distinction between regulations and Orders. We can lay regulations on the Table without any confidence being broken, but Orders, I think, would be in a different category.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy F. Lynch's amendment 33 (a), I think Deputy Lynch is accepting my amendment on arbitration.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:—
In sub-section (1) to delete paragraph (a).
This raises a rather technical question, but one of no little importance. This sub-section is designed to provide that the board can produce a document certified to be a true copy by the chairman of the commission, or the secretary of the commission, and once it is produced, there devolves upon the official of the board certifying it no obligation to prove it in the ordinary way. Ordinarily, if a company or a local authority desire to prove a document, one of their officers has to attend the court, go into the witness-box, and swear that he is a competent person, that the contents of the document are true, and that it is a true copy of whatever it is held out to be a copy of, whereupon counsel for the other party can cross-examine and question him, and apply further interrogatories, which not infrequently yield very useful information to the other party to the suit, to their great advantage. This procedure exonerates the officials of this commission from answering interrogatories.
The origin of this claim to exempt a Government Department from the obligations that would devolve upon the ordinary citizen engaged in litigation goes back to the prerogative claimed by the Crown, that you could not bring the King into court and treat him like a common man. Subsequently, the prerogative of the Crown became attached to every Government Department, and Government Departments claimed special privilege when they were at law with the ordinary citizen, but now we are going a step further, and trying to extend this old Crown privilege, not only to Government Departments, but to the semi-autonomous bodies like the Pigs Marketing Board and other semi-autonomous bodies created under Acts within the last ten or 15 years.
It is interesting to observe that they did not go this far when they were dealing with the Electricity Supply Board. I think there they made the seal of the board evidential of certain things, but they did not exonerate these officers from going down to the courts and proving the documents which they presented to the court. Now we are trying to take an extra step in respect of the Pigs and Bacon Commission, and I put it to Deputies that any one of us may be engaged in litigation at any time in defence of our rights against a Government Department, or against a semi-autonomous board of this kind, and we should not lightly vote away our legal rights against Government Departments. It is hard enough to fight the Government in litigation if it is your misfortune to have to do so, without arming the Government with additional weapons over and above those they have already, and I see no reason why the Pigs and Bacon Commission should be given privileges in litigation superior to those already enjoyed by any other independent corporation or company. Therefore I suggest that this paragraph (a) might be reasonably abandoned, as it merely sets a precedent for an undesirable new departure.
Comment on this
The Deputy may have given a correct history of the origin of a clause of this kind, but there is no doubt, at any rate, that it does appear in many Acts passed by the Oireachtas. There may be something in the point made by the Deputy that it does not appear in Acts dealing with companies of this kind. It may have only appeared up to this in Acts dealing with businesses managed by Ministers. I cannot see, however, what objection there could be to this provision. In fact, I think it would be a great thing if all companies had the same privilege, if it is considered a privilege. I do not see why this board, or any other company for that matter, should be put to the expense of sending down a chairman or secretary to say "That is my handwriting". If it is presented to the court and counsel appearing there says: "This is an extract from the minutes signed by the chairman", that should be taken as prima facie evidence that it is so. I do not see what objection there could be to that. I do not see why we should put the board to the expense of sending a chairman or secretary down to attend court, and perhaps losing a whole day, merely for the purpose of saying “That is my handwriting”. I do not think there is any great reason for it.
Comment on this
The reason is simply this, that you are trenching on the privileges of the citizen. The Minister will admit that if we take that out of the Bill, we withdraw from the chairman of the Pigs and Bacon Commission a privilege which this clause confers upon him. I think the Minister will agree that the average citizen at law with a Government Department is under a disadvantage.
Comment on this
Bear in mind that he is at the disadvantage that he knows that if he loses his case he will have to pay the costs. The officers of the Department know that if they lose their case they will not have to pay anything. It is quite open, in any litigation, for the Pigs and Bacon Commission to send to the solicitor of their opponent a list of documents and to say: "Are you prepared to admit these?" If the solicitor for the citizen sees that most of the documents are documents that should be admitted and that there is no advantage in having them proved, he can write back and say: "Yes, we are admitting these documents." That letter then proves all the documents contained in the schedule, but suppose he does not want to do that, suppose he wants to put the chairman of the commission in the box; suppose that he thinks that in cross-examination he can extract something from him of material value to his client, he can write back and say: "We are admitting documents A, B, C, D, E and F. These need not be proved, but documents G and H we do not admit, and these must be proved." It does not mean, if you take out this clause, that every document that is ever produced by the board must be proved. Not at all. I suppose in 70 per cent. of the cases the documents are never proved by the responsible officer going into the box. What usually happens is that you send a list of documents to your opponent asking if he admits them. In 90 cases out of 100 he replies: "Yes, we do", because he does not want to pile up costs on himself, if it should chance that he loses the action. Now, Sir, by your leave, there are several amendments of the same nature one after another.
Comment on this
Yes, amendments Nos. 39, 46 and 54, all deal with the same point. It might save time if all were discussed together.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 35, 36, 37, 39, 46 and 54 are all connected with this point. There is a fine difference but they are all of the same genre. Amendment No. 35 deals with paragraph (b) which states:
Prima facie evidence of any order made by the Bacon Marketing Board, the Pigs Marketing Board or the commission may be given by the production of a copy of Iris Oifigiúil.
We are moving that the words "of any order" be deleted, and for them that there be substituted the words: "that a particular order has been." We move that for the reason that it appears that the trend of judicial decision is to veer in the direction of declaring that the sub-section, as at present drafted, means that prima facie evidence of the contents of the order may be given by the production of the copy of the Iris Oifigiúil containing the Order. That was never the intention of the Legislature, nor do I think it is now our intention. The intention is to provide that evidence of the making of the Order may be given by producing Iris Oifigiúil, but that you should exonerate an official of the board from submitting himself to cross-examination as to the contents of the Order, is to go far beyond what the Minister would wish us to do. Surely you are entitled to put an officer into the box and ask him: “What did your commission mean by that Order? Did it mean this or that? Can you claim that the words used in this Order were interpreted to mean this or that?”
If that be accepted, there is a further matter arising out of line 55, paragraph (b), which reads: "Iris Oifigiúil purporting to contain such Order”. Surely that should read “containing such Order”? It either contains it or it does not contain it. If it does not contain it, fully and explicitly, it is not reasonable to treat it as a satisfactory publication. Suppose it is published under the heading “Pigs and Bacon (Amendment) Act Order”, and then sets out the by-laws of St. Stephen's Green, that should not be good publication for the purposes of this Bill. Nevertheless, what is here will clearly make it good publication, because though the contents of the Order were the by-laws of St. Stephen's Green, they would purport to be an Order made under the Pigs and Bacon Act, 1939, which would fulfil the conditions of sub-section (1), paragraph (b), “a copy of the Iris Oifigiúil purporting to contain such Order.”
Under sub-section (2), it is provided that a certificate purporting to be under the hand of the secretary, certifying that the person named in the certificate was during a specified period a licensee, shall be prima facie evidence of the matters so certified. Here is a nice point. The purpose here is to deal with a certificate certifying that the person named in the certificate was, during the specified period, a licensee. What we are asked to say is that the certificate is not only prima facie evidence of those facts, but is also prima facie evidence of any other matters referred to in it. Therefore, if you prepare a certificate declaring that a person was a licensee during a specified period, and then proceed to add to that declaration other extraneous matters, the certificate is not only prima facie evidence of the facts of which it is intended to be prima facie evidence, but also of the extraneous matters which you introduce into it. We are proposing to delete the word “matters”, and substitute therefor “person and period”. I think the Minister will have no objection to that. Sub-section (3) is one of those infernal sections which is by reference, so that you have to go rooting through the Pigs and Bacon Act of 1935. There is a long section—Section 112—in the Principal Act relating to the returns which curers may be required to make.
Section 151 of the Principal Act deals with returns by minor curers. These two sub-sections make a rather strange proposal. Suppose I made a return under Section 112 or Section 151 of the Principal Act to the Bacon Marketing Board, and if the board takes action against me under this Bill or, apparently, for any other purpose, although I can produce my return, it is at once clothed with a statutory prima facie value that it had not got until it is produced by the Pigs and Bacon Commission as a return made by me under Section 112 or Section 151.
Why they want to put that in, God only knows. Is it that they can yap at a person and say: "You are bound by the false return"? If there is a return made by somebody, then I submit the commission should be made go into court, in the ordinary way, and prove it, or disprove it, without traps of this kind. I think the Minister will agree with me that, if a person is brought into court and suddenly finds that a simple return he made to the Pigs and Bacon Commission is suddenly converted into a statutory declaration of quite a different type from what he ever intended it to be, that is not a good kind of law, because no ordinary citizen could possibly know anything about it. With regard to amendment No. 39, proposing to delete sub-section (4), this is the worst of the lot, because the sub-section provides that if the commission take proceedings against me and allege against me that I have failed to make to them the returns to which I have just referred under Sections 112 and 151 of the Principal Act, a certificate purporting to be signed by the secretary of the commission shall be prima facie evidence of the facts so certified, and no further proof shall be required.
This is a most pernicious document, because it is the same kind of trick as that of the Revenue Commissioners. The law of this country is that I am innocent until somebody proves me guilty. Now, this is a trick to bring me into court and make me guilty until I can prove I am innocent. That strikes at the most fundamental rights that our people have. The Revenue Commissioners are always at this game. They can come into your house, pick up any object, and say: "Prove to me that you paid duty on that; it is a dutiable article." This is a most extraordinary proposal—to drag me into court and allege against me that I have done something. That allegation creates a presumption of guilt, so that one is put in the position of having to rebut that presumption. I submit to the House that this is a lazy provision designed to spare the officers of the commission the necessary trouble of proving documents in court. As the State has always undertaken to prove that a person is guilty of the offence alleged against him, I urge strongly on the Minister to set his face sternly against what is proposed in this sub-section, and for that reason to consent to its deletion.
Comment on this
These amendments are all bound up with the question of the production of evidence. The Deputy has spoken on amendments Nos. 34 to 39. I have already spoken on amendment No. 34. The only thing involved there is whether the secretary or chairman should be present in court to swear that it is his signature that is to a document. The presentation of the document to the court is to be taken as prima facie evidence. It does not mean that it is to be taken as conclusive evidence. Amendments Nos. 35 and 36 go together. The wording of Section 18, sub-section (1), paragraph (b) follows exactly what is in the Documentary Evidence Act of 1925. I am not an authority on this, but the Draftsman naturally likes to stick to words that have proved to be correct, and that have stood the test of the attacks made on them since 1925.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise the danger that arises in this way: that the courts are beginning to interpret the production of documents in this manner as being prima facie evidence of the truth of the contents of them?
Comment on this
I have not heard that, and do not know if there is anything in it. So far as this section is concerned, if the Iris Oifigiúil is produced in court, that is taken as prima facie evidence that such a document was made. But with regard to the contents, I think the board would be open to cross-examination on the contents; but with this evidence that the order was made. We go on then to amendment No. 37.
Comment on this
I take it that amendment No. 35 and amendment No. 36 were linked together as one. What I say is that this is exactly the wording of the Documentary Evidence Act. Both amendments will be covered so far as that is concerned. The next amendment (37) seeks to amend (2) of Section 18. But it does not quite meet the case. I thought that that amendment was reasonable but the words "person and period" do not quite meet the case because we are referring here to "matters so certified". It is possible that all matters might not be covered by "person and period"
Comment on this
It was certifying that the person named in such a document was during a certain period the licensee.
Comment on this
No; when I looked at this first I thought there could be no objection to it, but after consultation with the lawyers I found they were somewhat doubtful whether this amendment would exactly cover the point. It is an amendment into which I would like to look again.
Now with regard to amendment Nos. 38 and 39—to delete sub-section (3) and to delete sub-section (4) of Section 18 respectively, I do not think there is anything unreasonable in these sub-sections. Deputy Dillon seems to think it is taking advantage of a person if the certificate is put in as prima facie evidence. It is quite, open to the person appearing for the licensee to say that the licensee has made a mistake, that the return made was not correct and did not quite fit in with the case before the court. All that is asked here is that it may be put in as prima facie evidence of the return which is the subject of litigation. The next amendment is somewhat on the same lines but not altogether. We are back again to where we started in amendment No. 34, that a certificate signed by the secretary of the commission can be produced and that there is no necessity for the secretary to appear after he signed the certificate. It is only as prima facie evidence. I think that on the whole all that these amendments seek to rectify is that Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Dillon who are arguing this point would prefer to have the chairman and secretary answer to the court that they really signed these documents. The section as it stands would absolve the chairman or secretary from being present. The documents would be handed in and accepted as the chairman's signature or the secretary's signature and the case would go on.
Comment on this
On what the secretary admitted on cross-examination would depend whether the case would go on.
Comment on this
I do not know whether much can be made of that point. In so far as (1) (a) or (4) is concerned, all we say is that the document must be taken as being signed by the chairman or the secretary.
Comment on this
The whole point is in this "has been duly signed". This Bill puts an obligation on the commissioners to consider certain matters, in fixing the price of pigs and so on. The chairman, say, is in the box and counsel asks: "Is that your signature?" and he answers: "Yes, I signed that, that is my signature." That is the evidence for the commission. Then it comes to cross-examination by the other side and counsel asks: "You say you signed that document?" and he answers: "I did." Then the next question is: "Before you signed that did you consider the matters you were bound by statute to consider, because if you did not consider those matters that you are bound to consider, the document has not been duly signed though you have actually signed it, that is because you did not discharge your full duty preparatory to signing it?" Has the Minister considered that the matters dealt with by the board or commission were duly considered? Does he believe that the cost of feeding-stuffs was, in fact, considered? I take leave to doubt it. But if we put a statutory obligation on somebody to do a certain thing, preparatory to signing that document, why should we withdraw the opportunity of questioning the chairman or secretary who were supposed to do these things, whether they did them or not? That is a good point.
Comment on this
I remember being in court in a very important case where a local authority was concerned and where the minutes of the local authority were handed in as evidence. The secretary of the local authority was brought up to prove the minutes and incidentally he was asked about the sending out of his agenda. That was a very material point because if the agenda had not gone out in time it would invalidate the minutes. The secretary was subjected to a very close cross-examination and he got away with it, but very nearly he did not get away with it. His minutes would have been invalidated if he had not sent them out in time. There are a lot of surrounding circumstances of that type which the court very often will require to have cleared up. I do not see any reason why the commission should not be put in the same position as a local authority.
Comment on this
If sub-section (1) (a) and (3) and (4) are deleted as Deputy McGilligan's amendment seeks, what is the real disability from which the commission will suffer? Very little except that the commission will be amenable to the ordinary rules of evidence. On the other hand if the Minister insists on retaining these sub-sections there will be a hardship inflicted on the person taken to court by the commission. Deputy Dillon points out that a person is required to make a return and if he fails to make a return he is under certain disabilities.
The only thing that is needed to prove he did not make a return—his word is not to be taken that he made it or did not make it—is a certificate of the secretary of the commission. That is to be accepted, mind you, as evidence that the failed to make a return. It goes further than that; not only will the certificate of the secretary of the commission be accepted, but a certificate purporting to be made by the secretary will be accepted. It would be bad enough that the certificate of the secretary should be accepted, but we are asked here to accept a condition whereby a certificate purporting to be made by the secretary is to be evidence that a person committed an offence. As I said, whatever disability or inconvenience the commission may suffer by wiping out the whole three sections, the chance of a complete wrong being done to the individual by retaining the sections creates a very difficult situation.
Comment on this
The words "purporting to be a copy" are there; if they were not there, there would be no necessity for the thing at all. If it reads "a certificate under the hand of the secretary" that is enough, and you need go no further. I do not know if Deputies are clear about this point; we are putting into this section that, if a certificate is given that a certain return was made or a certain thing was done, the chairman or secretary need not be there to prove his signature, but it is quite open to the litigant, the person who is on the other side, to subpoena the chairman or the secretary for cross-examination. He cannot evade being there if the other side wish him to be there. I know that under the old Act those certificates were accepted in some cases, but where counsel wanted to cross-examine the chairman or secretary or both he took the precaution of serving a subpoena on them, and they were there to be cross-examined. I think we are really only putting in a very formal thing here—that in ordinary cases the certificate would be accepted without having the chairman or the secretary there to prove it.
Comment on this
Can you cross-examine your own witness? Suppose you subpoena the chairman of the Bacon Commission, can you cross-examine him?
Comment on this
No. Suppose you are the Bacon Board, and I am a litigant, and suppose I subpoena the chairman of the Bacon Board, can I cross-examine him?
Comment on this
You can examine him, but can you cross-examine him?
Comment on this
I am practically certain on that point. If I thought that by no means could you get the chairman or the secretary there I would certainly amend it.
Comment on this
Even if you do get him there, are you not prevented from cross-examining him on very material matters, as Deputy Dillon has pointed out? Once a minute is handed in it is prima facie evidence. I am afraid once that is handed in and accepted, if you do put him in the box you will not be allowed to cross-examine him.
Comment on this
There is no doubt whatever in my mind. All I am seeking to do here is that in an ordinary case where the person concerned is not interested to cross-examine the secretary or the chairman, they need not come down unnecessarily to prove the signature.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister understand that there must be some reason why those provisos are put in here, because in seven out of ten cases when a person comes before the courts of this country one of the regular preliminary proceedings is that the plaintiff submits to the defendant a list of the documents which he proposes to produce?
Comment on this
No sane defendant will ask the plaintiff to prove those documents if he knows that they can be proved and if he does not want to raise any point in regard to them, because, if he does, all the expense of proving them will be added to the cost of the action, and if he should be put down he would have to pay those expenses himself. Suppose all those sections are deleted and I take an action against the board, I will send in my list of documents and say: "Will you admit those?" They will admit some of them. They will send back a list of documents to me and say: "We intend to put those in. Will you admit them?" Unless I am a madman I am not going to pile the costs on to the board, when I know that by piling the costs on to the board I am not hurting any of the officials who have vexed me, because all the money is going to come out of the funds of the board and not out of the chairman's pocket or the secretary's pocket, or the commissioners' pockets. I think this is just a natural inclination of public servants to spare themselves trouble and time. They take a rough and ready view. "We are not going to victimise anybody," they think, "but we do not want to be dragged through all this interminable legal procedure. Let us take a short cut." Short cuts are all very well, but short cuts often lead to very undesirable tyranny, and though I cannot imagine that the Pigs and Bacon Commission are going to develop into an Irish Hitler, still I like to protect my rights and those of my neighbours wherever I see them assailed.
Comment on this
Personally, I do not think there is a lot in this. As far as I understand it, Deputy Dillon wants the board, as it were, to take the initiative by submitting documents to the other side, and saying, "We accept those"; but I say that the other side can take the initiative by serving a subpoena on the chairman or secretary. There is not a lot between us; in fact, it is hardly worth while arguing about it. That is as far as amendment No. 34 goes. I think Nos. 35 and 36 are in a different category.
Comment on this
Numbers 38 and 39 would be the same. If you will give me Nos. 34, 38 and 39, I will give you Nos. 35, 36 and 37, reluctantly.
Comment on this
I am not so sure about No. 38, that is, that the return might be submitted as prima facie evidence.
Comment on this
Number 39 is one of the most important of the whole lot.
Comment on this
It will be inserted in substance, but I should like to see the Draftsman as to the wording. He will probably agree.
Comment on this
There will be an amendment to cover Nos. 34 and 39. We got something out of our battle. We have vindicated the liberty of the subject; Magna Charta for ever.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 40 is born of the distrust we have of the individual whom the Minister is going to make chairman of this commission.
Comment on this
We dislike it, and would much sooner see the Minister in that position, not that we think he is any great shakes either.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:—
In sub-section (2), line 50, to delete the words "Chairman of the".
We do not think the powers which the chairman had under Section 68 of the Pigs and Bacon Act, 1937, should be continued in the chairman under the new Act. We think they could reasonably be transferred to the commission, and that whatever orders would be made should be signed on behalf of the commission and not by the chairman acting in his own right, because it appears to us that that is what he can do under the Act.
Comment on this
This is a very trivial matter. This is a section which was put into the 1937 Act, and which enabled the chairman to deal with pigs left in the producers' hands. If the producer were to write to the chairman and say he had pigs on hands, and could not dispose of them, the chairman could serve an order on some factory to take those pigs, and serve notice on the producer to deliver them to the factory.
That is the section. In that case the power is given to the chairman, naturally because there were curers on the board. There is no great objection to give that power to the commission instead of the chairman. There was no order made under that section, so far.
Comment on this
Would any difficulties arise in giving that power to the commission?
Comment on this
Are we to understand, again, that the Minister will be propared to make this the prerogative of the commission?
Comment on this
My amendment, No. 44, explains itself:—
In sub-section (1), line 24, to insert after the word "Board" the words "subject to the right of the Commission to revoke, annual or amend any such order continued in force or effect by this section".
Comment on this
That amendment is not necessary. The whole Act is for the purpose of putting the commission in place of the board, and they will change any orders that they may think fit. This amendment is really not necessary.
Comment on this
My amendment, No. 45, reads:—
At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—
(6) As soon as may be after its establishment the commission shall cause to be prepared a statement containing a valuation of all the property, whether real or personal, and including investments, and giving particulars of the various types of such property and of the composition of the funds mentioned in this section, and shall submit a report on such statement and the valuations contained therein, together with particulars of the liabilities of the abolished boards and the contracts of such boards transferred to the commission by the two following sections of this Act.
Has the Minister met this?
Comment on this
That is very satisfactory. There have been so many alterations with regard to reports and statements that I was not quite sure whether we had met this particular point.
Comment on this
And we will have the full details of the hypothetical prices, so that we can see if there is anything in them?
Comment on this
The Chair objects to accepting amendments until they have been investigated by the Parliamentary Draftsman. It has been found, in one or two instances, that there were consequential changes involved which had been overlooked in the hurried acceptance of amendments.
Comment on this
I agree it is necessary that the Draftsman should see this before it is finally accepted.
Comment on this
The Deputy will, I am confident, note that the subject matter of the amendment will be duly considered. The matter will come up again on Report.
Comment on this
The point in that amendment has been met already?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 46, in the name of Deputy McGilligan, proposing to delete sub-section (2), is similar to the series of amendments just discussed.
Comment on this
It is merely a continuing proviso. If you are going to allow the new commission to prove its own documents in a certain way, you are giving them the right to prove the documents of the old board in the same way as they would prove their own documents now.
Comment on this
There is a series of amendments proposed by Deputy McGilligan, which are out of order, namely, amendments Nos. 47, 49, 50, 52 and 53. They are quite at variance with the terms of the Financial Resolution which controls the money aspect of this measure. I had some doubt about amendments Nos. 55 and 57, but I am giving the Deputy the benefit of the doubt.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:—
In sub-section (1), page 13, line 51, to insert after the word "month" the words "for consumption"
There was some doubt about the section of the original Act where levies would be collectable. The wording was "bacon sold by such person during such month in the State". A person who is going to export bacon might hold, legally, that it was sold in the State because it was sold before being exported. I want to have that made clear by having the words "for consumption" inserted. It is, if you like, a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 51 reads:—
In sub-section (1), page 14, line 42, to insert after the word "fixed" the words "as the insurance allowance".
The arrangement in this Bill, as it stands, is that nothing will be deducted from the producer except the insurance levy. It is further provided that if that levy is in any way increased, it will be collected from the curer so that there will be a certain levy on the producer and that levy cannot be increased in any way. This amendment is merely a drafting amendment, to make that perfectly clear. I do not think it is necessary to go exactly into the words. I think if Deputies realise what the principle of the section is it will be sufficient. The insurance levy cannot be increased as far as the producer is concerned. It can be increased as far as the curer is concerned. If there is an increase, it is taken from the curer.
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us at this stage how the question of licences is going to be operated? This raises the question of licences. We want an indication from the Minister as to what the policy would be with regard to these export licences. The ordinary curer is a curer, not an exporter at the same time. We are a co-operative concern. We have been both curers and exporters, but on account of the operations of the Pigs Marketing Board and the fact that the curers had to obey certain rules and regulations, to a large extent, we ceased to be exporters from that time on. Owing to the scarcity of pigs we had to transmit what normally we would have exported to other curers, or kill them for them in some cases. I understand that the Minister will only give export licences on the basis of the 1938 performance. That would put us out altogether. Our position is that we must cater for our shareholders if they send us pigs. Some pigs that would be utterly unsuitable for killing must be exported.
Comment on this
Live pigs. What I suggest is that there should be a statement now, and there should be a free issue of licences to anybody who demanded them, to all shippers who shipped pigs previous to the time the control came. We have been shipping to the extent of up to 5,000 pigs, and nearly 6,000 in some years, but since the operations of the Pigs Marketing Board the number dwindled down to hundreds and less. If it is based on the 1938 performance it would be altogether unfair to a firm in our position who are catering for our shareholders, and must do so according to our rules. The other curers would not be in the same position. They are curers, pure and simple.
Comment on this
I would like to add a word to what Deputy Gorey has said. Deputy Gorey has spoken from the point of view of the co-operative curing factory. What about the point of view of the ordinary small pig producer? Suppose I bring in a pair of pigs to the fair of Ballaghaderreen and there are two buyers on the Square, one a buyer for an Irish bacon factory and the other a buyer who intends to export pigs to Birmingham. At the present moment, to-day, the buyer for the Irish bacon factory will tell me, if my pig is over-weight, that he will give me at the rate of 74/- for my pig. And standing beside him is a man who is prepared to bid me 85/- to 90/- for the same pig. But, because the Minister for Agriculture will not give that man a licence to export my pair of pigs I am fined on the Square of Ballaghadereen about 30/- to £2 on the pair of pigs. I do not think that is right.
I do not want to be unreasonable. I do not want to recommend that degree of regulation which the British quota has made necessary and at the same time seek to impose upon the Minister conditions which are inconsistent with the whole scheme. But I do think that when we have determined the proportion of bacon which we intend to send to Great Britain to fill the quota we ought to do our best to make provision in that quota for so much bacon in the shape of live pigs as will absorb all the overweight pigs available in the State and if we err at all we ought to make the quota of live pigs a little too big instead of catering for all the possible exports of the factories and then giving the live pig producer, whose pigs are a little over weight, just the tail-end of whatever quota has been taken in the particular month for Great Britain.
I think it is time the Minister told us what he intends to do in that matter. Everybody knows that there were some licences given to pig buyers recently for the shipping of live pigs to England and I saw in Ballaghaderreen four or five buyers at the last fair, on Tuesday, and I think the Minister would have been astonished at the difference it made to the whole atmosphere of the town that those buyers were there. Fat pigs were no longer a drug on the market. They were eagerly bought and at good prices. The lean pigs went, I suppose, to the Irish factory and everyone was catered for and everyone was happy. I know it has been the purpose of the Minister to abolish the fat pig out of our economy altogether. I am convinced that experience must have taught the Minister that that is not good policy. It is legitimate to try to get the bacon factories a fair share of pigs of a standard size for their particular trade but the fat pig suits our people in certain parts of this country, not only their economy of production, but the fat pig suits the countryman who wants to cure a pig for himself. A man buying a pig to cure for his own household, will never buy what a factory would call a bacon pig. He wants a big, fat 2-cwt. pig. The demand for those is never sufficient to consume all the available supplies. The case I am making is over and above Deputy Gorey's case that a co-operative concern that was exporting large quantities of pigs in the past should get their share of the licences in the future. I am making representations to the Minister that the producers of pigs in this country, if they are to get an economic price for their output, ought to be afforded an adequate opportunity of shiping live pigs to Great Britain. My suggestion is to give the dealers who were shipping pigs to England sufficient licences to go out to the fairs and compete with the Deputy and with other curing companies for pigs.
Comment on this
And will the Deputy please indicate to the Chair how this could be related to levies in respect of pigs purchased by licensees?
Comment on this
It is equally irrelevant on any section. I presume the Deputy has nearly finished the irrelevancy?
Comment on this
I am just finished, Sir. There was some important point I wished to make. It has slipped my memory.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will remember his point later. I want to explain the position here. I do not want it to be thought that I am unsympathetic to the live pig exporter. When a regulation was brought in by the British, in 1934 or 1935, whenever it was, we had to bring in an Act to regulate the export of bacon by quota and also the export of pigs that were going to factories in England. For the first three or four years that we were working under that Act the British Government was all the time pressing us to keep the live pigs down. Apart from that, of course. pigs went out, without licence, that were not consigned to factories, pigs that were sent to pork butchers, etc., and which were quite free to go out without any licence. Take the present position. We are now in the position that no live pigs can go out without a licence. There is no such thing as pigs going to pork butchers, or anything like that; they must all have a licence. The only thing that the British are trying to enjoin on us is that we keep a fair proportion the whole year round. I am quite sure that if we went to the British and said: "We will export half live pigs and half bacon", that for the present they would say: "That is all right". But we are in this position, that for the months, say, from about February to August, we get no live pigs out.
That is our experience for the last three or four years. That is the trouble. We cannot put too high a proportion, because we know that we cannot fill our quota of live pigs during those months. Now we put a fairly high quota so as to absorb all we can in those other months, even though we may fail in the months referred to. In addition to that, during November we asked the British Government to take 2,000 more, and they did take them. That is all we can do, I am afraid, during the autumn months. We will have to leave the proportion fairly low for live pigs, but try to get them to take some extra during those months.
Comment on this
I think that is the sensible thing to do. I think it is the wise thing to do, to go to the British Government in the months of surplus and say: "Here are pigs; take them away if you want them." I put this to the Minister: Great Britain is to go on four ounces of bacon per person in January. Why do we not go to the British now and say: "There is one matter in which we can apparently reach almost self-sufficiency, and that is pigs, bacon and hams. If you are prepared to co-operate with us in tempting our people into this business, and hold out the prospect to us that after the war the bacon and pig market here, for strategical reasons, will in future be primarily reserved for the English and Irish farmer"; that we do not make any economic representations at all, but simply say: "Here is one kind of agricultural production admirably suited to the big man, but equally admirably suited to the very small man —it is the only form that has that peculiar quality—and we can get started now on a 20-year plan to build up our bacon output to meet the potential requirements of these two islands —to go as near it as we can." There are a number of matters which I do not propose to raise now, because they go a little further afield than the sub-section would permit, but the main point is this: If you go to Great Britain and say, "Let us make a 20-year plan", the ultimate objective of which —though we might not reach that ultimate objective—would be to provide all the bacon and hams to be consumed in these islands, surely we have an unprecedented opportunity, and it would mean that we never would have too many pigs for the potential market.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy may rest assured that these things are being put up. One is surprised, if you like, at the lack of foresight shown by the British Government at present in not seeing our case for supplying plenty of bacon; but I suppose they are very busy, and perhaps are confused in connection with a lot of these issues at present. I think that after a little time we will have a better opportunity of looking into and discussing these matters, and we will probably be able to get somewhat in the direction the Deputy wishes.
Comment on this
The Minister did not refer to my point with regard to the co-operatives. What we ask simply is, with all this control and all the rest, that that should not be taken as the basis for licences to export. The real basis should be the time previous to control.
Comment on this
It is difficult to get a basis on which to manage these things. The basis that the Export Committee took with my approval was that the pigs exported, say, in November, 1938, would be taken as the basic figure for November, 1939. When that was put up by the Export Committee I thought it was a fair basis to go on. I suppose it might be argued that if we took some period before control it would be better still. I do not know, however, Whatever basis you take, I am afraid some people will be victimised and there will be hardship. We have to do the best we can.
Comment on this
Whoever is victimised, do not victimise the farmers. They have been victimised already.
Comment on this
We have been driven into this position by your Act and its operation. The position is that we took 5,596 pigs in 1931 and 5,000 odd in 1930. They were down to 12 in 1937 and 36 in 1938. If you take 1938 as the basic, we are only entitled to 36 pigs, although we are catering for a share-holding public spread over seven counties and, according to our rules, we are definitely committed to taking their pigs.
Comment on this
I would say then that probably you did not fill your licences in 1938. We can examine that case anyhow. We had better go on to something more relevant.
Comment on this
I think that sub-section (5) will have to be looked into in view of the other amendments promised. It will possibly require amendment in view of the other amendments I promised.
Comment on this
This is very extreme. I think if you accept amendment No. 39 you ought to accept this.
Comment on this
I think some amendment may be necessary here to bring it into line with the others, but I am not sure.
Comment on this
That is what we are talking about. There is an amendment to delete sub-section (5). It is a very bad sub-section. It provides that a certificate of indebtedness shall be prima facie evidence of the existence of a debt. That ought to go.
Comment on this
I think it is taken from the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act, and that particular section has come in for very severe criticism.
Comment on this
Let us not overlook this one. This is the amendment I move on behalf of Deputy McGilligan: "To delete sub-section (5)". It is proposed there that the board could march into court with a certificate of indemnity, and the moment they did that they ceased to be under any obligation to prove that they are owed anything. Upon the person against whom they issue the certificate is thrown the obligation of proving that he did not owe anything. That is really going beyond the beyonds, that the Department should have the right to put it on a man to prove that he was not in their debt. There can be no justification for it. I need not remind Deputies that in the regulation of a business such as this, these levies involve, the preparation of pretty considerable returns. I admit freely that it is not easy to prove a curer owes these levies, but I put it to the Minister that sub-section (5) should be deleted, and the board restored to the position that any other litigant would be in, if he sought to prove that his neighbour was in his debt.
Comment on this
This sub-section is unsustainable. This board is a semi-Government Department and, in fact, is an ordinary commercial institution. Is there any other commercial organisation to which this House would give such power? Any district justice will feel insulted if a document from the board is handed to him, and if he has to take it as evidence. It might be produced by a subordinate servant of the board. In a Bill of this kind it is positively ridiculous to have such a proviso, and the Minister should at once agree to have it taken out. This is a simple contract debt and we should not put this board in a better position than any other litigant. If there is a debt let them go to the court and prove it in the usual way. The board is getting sufficient privileges. As Deputy Dillon stated, it would be a monstrous thing if a man who did not owe a debt could be brought to court and put to legal expense in order to prove that he did not owe anything. In this case the onus of proof is on the plaintiff. These provisions were in the Slaughter of Animals Act and I then objected to them. It is a bad thing to have them in any Bill, as they simply wipe out the law of evidence and the onus of proof. All the Department has to do here is to prepare a document which need not be signed by the Minister. If the certificate had to be handed to the Minister for signature something could be said for it. In this case some junior clerk in the office of the board may make out a document and send it down to the court where a solicitor produces it saying: "There is my proof. So much is due. Give me a decree." Would any Deputy take that as evidence? Yet that is what we are asked to do in this sub-section. There should be no contest about this. The sub-section should go.
Comment on this
I direct the attention of the Minister to sub-section (3), because I think there is something there that he may wish to amend:
If any licensee fails or neglects to pay the amount certified by a certificate of indebtedness to be payable by him within four weeks after the service of a copy of such certificate on him, the Minister may revoke the licence in relation to which such amount is payable, but such revocation shall not relieve such person from liability to pay the said amount.
Is not that going very far? Surely the Government that has a right to go in and recover a levy by way of judgment ought not to have the right to impose a penalty of such immense gravity as to revoke a licence? That is going a very long way indeed. If you revive the production quota and its functions again it is a very valuable asset and is negotiable, by the Minister's leave. Is not that so?
Comment on this
It is a grave thing to give the Minister the right to impose a penalty, far in excess of what any normal court would impose, over and above the amount of the levy claimed. Surely if the Minister gets his levy and can prove no other malfeasance against the licensee, he ought not to have the right to take away the licence. I observe that the sub-section does not say if the licensee declines or fraudulently attempts to avoid payment, but if he fails or neglects to pay. If you put in these words and if the licensee falls down or neglects to pay, he is in the hands of the Minister, who can take his licence from him. Surely that is wrong?
Comment on this
I do not remember exactly, but I think in the original Act, and in all the other Acts, the Minister had power to revoke a licence if there was any commission or omission. Certainly all the Acts read in that way. Personally I do not mind very much about this particular power. I think it is very unlikely that any Minister would act as precipitately as Deputy Dillon fears. We have fairly drastic powers to revoke licences, such as fresh meat licences, and for creameries and egg exporters, but these things are very carefully considered if any case is made. In this particular instance if a man said he was not able to pay, or wanted time to pay in a couple of months, or showed any inclination to comply with the regulations, I am quite sure the licence would not be revoked by the Minister for Agriculture, whoever he might be.
Comment on this
That is probably true. It is not necessary to conceive a Minister as being an ogre when holding this power. I would withhold this power from any Minister. I do not want to have to go with my hat in my hand to a Department or to anyone else and to ask them in their bounty or goodness to spare me from a penalty which I do not think we ought ever have had power to inflict.
Comment on this
That is fair. Therefore, if the Minister feels that this sub-section is rather super-elevated I think he ought to try to expunge it and get on without it. Is the Minister prepared to say that he will do that on the next stage?