We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Pigs and Bacon (Amendment) Bill, 1939—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 143–286 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Pigs and Bacon (Amendment) Bill, 1939
Enacted

No. 34 of 1939 ›

I want to refer to the issue of the certificate. Assume the man says: "I do not owe them anything." Are you to take court proceedings against him? That would take much more than four weeks. The same difficulty applies in the other case. This certificate might be made out by a junior clerk working for the commission. You would not have the check and counter-check that you would have if it came from an accountant in the Minister's Department.

Question agreed to.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan, I move amendment No. 55:—

In sub-section (2), lines 15, 21, 24 and 25, in sub-section (3), lines 35, 40, and in sub-section (4), line 50, to delete in each line the word "Commission" and substitute in each case the word "Minister".

This amendment raises a rather interesting point and, on it, we can dispose of all the amendments coming within the particular category. In all these cases we are proposing to substitute the Minister for the commission in relation to the fixing of rates of subsidy and levy. We have advanced to the position where we now are by a series of steps. We began by giving Ministers power to make regulations under statutes, these regulations to have the effect of statutes. Our next step was to create bodies like the Electricity Supply Board and give them power to make bye-laws which would be binding. Now, we move a step further and we give the Bacon Commission power to levy taxes. Do we think it right to give a commission which is not directly responsible to this House at all, the right to levy taxes? Our neighbour, Great Britain, cut off the King's head before she would consent to that proposition—to somebody outside Parliament levying taxes on the people.

Much as I criticise the prospective chairman of the Pigs and Bacon Commission, I am not prepared to advocate that we should cut off his head. But I am prepared to urge that neither to him nor to either of his two distinguished colleagues should we remit our duty to levy such taxes as are right to levy and to answer to the country for having done so. I do not think that it is any defence if we, the elected legislators, go to the country and say: "We did not put that tax on your pigs; it was the Bacon Commission that did it." I think we ought to answer to the people for the levies made on pigs and the subsidies paid out of such levies. I put it to the Minister that it would be better in this case if he would fix the rate of levy and subsidy albeit on the advice of the commission. Then, if we disapprove of the levy, we can make him answer for it here. His responsibility and the responsibility of this House for taxation of all kinds would then be preserved intact.

Comment on this

I think that that is a very desirable suggestion.

Comment on this

I know that there is a good deal in what Deputy Dillon says. This House is so jealous about the collection of taxes that it would not even permit a Minister to have such power, and now we are passing on this power to a commission. If you take this power from the commission, they will not have very much to do. In regulating subsidies and levies, if such are necessary, it will be the duty of the commission to go into every little detail and make out the prices of pigs and bacon, both exported and sold at home. They are the only people who could make out what should be the levy on a particular class of bacon and what should be the subsidy.

Comment on this

Could they not advise you on that matter?

Comment on this

They might. The levy and subsidy Orders will be published and, in that way, will be, at least, made known to Deputies. There is no provision for immediate review by Deputies of this particular matter. Under the scheme we more or less agreed to to-day, they could only be reviewed at the end of the year, and it would only then be open to Deputies to say that a particular levy was not justified. I do not know that it is going to improve matters very much to makes these Orders subject to the Minister.

Comment on this

It is a fiction to which we all contribute that the Minister is responsible for everything done in his Department. We all know that the Minister for Industry and Commerce does a great many things the nature of which he does not himself know until his attention is directed to them by Parliamentary questions. Then he calls up his permanent advisers, who brief him and verse him in all that is done. He is their spokesman, and must accept responsibility for whatever they have done. It is quite true that the Minister would not be able in this case to watch these things from day to day, as the members of the commission will be able to do, but that is true of a hundred and one activities of most Departments of State. If somebody raises the matter in Dáil Éireann it will be the duty of members of the commission to explain to the Minister the grounds on which they recommended the rate of levy should be fixed, or the grounds on which they recommended the rate of bounty should be fixed. It would be up to the Minister then to come into the House and defend it.

If we do not do that, where are we going to end? Under the Butter Act, the Minister reserves that power to himself. He makes the Order. The accounts of the Butter Fund have to be submitted to the Comptroller and Auditor-General and, if levies are improperly made or improperly collected or improperly paid out, the Comptroller and Auditor-General will direct the attention of the Committee on Public Accounts to the matter. The Minister's accounting officer answers for what has been done and, as this Bill before us bears testimony, on occasion the Minister is required to take steps to regularise certain matters in connection with the administration of the fund. Is there any objection to the Minister doing this himself?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I do not want to rush the Minister if he would prefer to think it over.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it would be preferable for the commission to make these various Orders regarding levies and subsidies with the approval of the Minister to having the Orders made by the commission and laid on the Table of the House.

Comment on this

If the words were put in "with the approval of the Minister for Agriculture", that would remove the bulk of the objection.

Comment on this

Very well. We shall put the words in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:—

In sub-section (3), page 16, to insert after the word "exported", in lines 38, 41, 45 and 47, the words "on or".

This is largely a drafting amendment. Under sub-section (2) the commission must, within a certain time, fix the rate of subsidy on exported bacon. Sub-section (3) provides for revocation of such an Order. This particular section was taken out of the Act we had been drafting. At that time it looked as if a subsidy would have to be paid on exported bacon, but that position is now changed, and it is not likely, for some time at any rate, that any bounty will be necessary on exported bacon, and, therefore, this amendment is necessary.

Comment on this

On the section, Sir, I wish to refer to sub-section (2) (a), which says that the Commission may divide bacon into classes. I should like to know whether the word "classes" there means grades?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Deputy should read sub-section (4), at the end of the section.

Comment on this

Yes, but that only refers to bacon that is exported.

Comment on this

That sub-section says that, in defining any class of bacon for the purposes of this section, the commission may define such class by reference to the country to which the bacon is sent.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that it is not intended to put the grading system into operation again?

Comment on this

It will not be a question of grade or class anyway. If they are defining a class of bacon, for the purpose of collecting a levy, they will not say that the levy will be collected on one grade or another. That, however, was not what I had in mind. What I had in mind was that we might collect a different rate of levy on bacon consumed at home or exported to one country rather than another country. For instance, at one time, there was a fairly good trade for the export of hams to France, and it might be possible that that would bear a better levy than the export of hams to, say, Britain, America or some other country.

Comment on this

Yes, I see the Minister's point, but what I am aiming at is to try to protect the interests of the consumers as well as of the producers. I am sure the Minister will agree that, at the beginning, there were great difficulties with regard to this matter of classes or grades, and what I want to know is whether the same difficulty is going to operate again. For instance, we have bacon of different classes or grades, such as grade A, grade B and grade C, and now that the heavier pig is not going to be exported, that kind of pig must be made into bacon. Now, I suppose we may presume that the best of the bacon is going to be exported, and I want to protect the consumer, in some way or another, so that he will know what particular grade of bacon he is getting. I think that there should be some system of branding grades. We know that, at certain times, bacon of, let us say, grade C, was sold as grade A bacon, and that the same price was charged for it. We know that, even bacon of grade Z, if you want to go down the alphabet, was charged for at the same price as grade A bacon, and that it was sent out as food in this country and as very good bacon, and that it sold at very good prices. Now, presumably, we are going to export bacon to Britain for good prices, and I certainly do not want to see that market wiped out, but it must be remembered that it is the consumer who has to pay the piper, and I want to see the consumer safeguarded. In other words, I want to see that the consumer will know what bacon he is getting, and that he will not have to pay grade A prices for grade C bacon.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy's point arises here. We levy on certain classes of bacon, and these classes refer principally to the countries to which the bacon is exported. I think, however, that the Deputy is referring to the case of the curer who pays 84/-, 82/- or 75/- for certain grades of pigs, and that the Deputy wants the consumer to get the advantage of that difference.

Comment on this

Well, I think there is a certain difficulty there. I am told by the inspectors of my own Department that if you take, say, 100 pigs, some of which go into Grade A. or the first class, and some of which go into grade B or grade C, at 84/-, 82/- and 75/-, it is quite possible that, when they are taken out of cure, some of the pigs that were bought at the lowest price may produce the best bacon. All kinds of factors enter into this matter, such as the way the pigs were fed, and so on, but it is impossible to grade bacon exactly on the question of where the pigs came from.

Comment on this

My point is that there is the chance of that happening, but neither the consumer nor the producer of the pig shares in that chance.

Comment on this

Yes, but the opposite is also true.

Comment on this

Well, why not make something lower than the top grade? Why not make a general price, if you like, and let the chance be there for the consumer and the producer as well as for the factory? I want to see the consumer safeguarded, so that he will not get, let us say, No. 3 quality bacon, and have to pay No. 1 quality price for it.

Comment on this

Well, I think the curer will have no chance of making exorbitant profits now.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be surprised to know that what would be considered first-class, or Grade A bacon in England, would be considered too heavy for our Irish trade?

Comment on this

Yes, that is true.

Comment on this

And that what would be considered first grade here would be really delicate-looking and, you might say, emaciated pigs?

Comment on this

Yes, that is true.

Comment on this

That is where the question of grading comes in, and that is the real position.

Comment on this

At any rate, there certainly is a lot in what Deputy Bennett said.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:—

In sub-section (4), page 17, lines 49 and 52, to insert after the word "pigs" the words "purchased by licencees".

As this sub-section was originally drafted, it was too wide, and would include for compensation pigs consigned to others than the curers. Of course, this fund is only meant to cover pigs that go into the curers, and although there might be a reason why a person who sends pigs to a dealer might be compensated, we cannot possibly compensate him out of these funds.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I move amendment No. 59:—

In sub-section (4) to delete all words from and including the word "any" in line 22 down to and including the word "person," in line 23, and substitute the words:—"the senior member of the managerial or clerical staff then present or to the foreman or other senior person in charge of the premises."

I think this amendment is an obvious one. It is to prevent a notice being handed merely to the door-keeper or carter or someone else like that.

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider it.

Comment on this

The clause was designed to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that there were some curers of pigs on the Bacon Marketing Board, and that they are no better qualified to remain curers than is the proposed chairman qualified to be chairman of the new commission.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment is ruled out of order.

Comment on this

It was declared out of order.

Comment on this

Was it? Be assured, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, I was not aware of that.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment is:

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

The Minister shall revoke the licence of any person who was at any time a member of the Bacon Marketing Board or a curer member of the Pigs Marketing Board, and shall not thereafter grant a licence to any such person.

The amendment is consequently out of order as being too wide in its scope.

Comment on this

No man on God's earth could know what this Part V is about. Every section refers to about five other statutes that have to be looked up. "A contravention of any provision contained in Part III or Part IV of the Act of 1937 or of this Act shall, for the purposes of Section 30 (which relates to alteration and revocation of licences) of the Act of 1935, be deemed to be a contravention of a provision of the Act of 1935, and the said Section 30——"

Comment on this

May I explain it to the Deputy, as references are very difficult. Section 30 of the Act of 1935 sets out the reasons on account of which the Minister will revoke licences. One of these is a contravention of the Act of 1935 itself. This section proposes to apply the provisions of that Section 30 to the Act of 1937 and this Act; that is, a contravention of the Act of 1935 or of the Act of 1937 or of this Act would make a person liable to revocation of his licence.

Comment on this

Any contravention?

Comment on this

Yes, but, of course there must be proof.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

This is a very illuminating section. It is bad enough as it is without any amendments at all.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:—

Before Section 47, to insert a new section as follows:—

Sub-section (2) of Section 40 of the Act of 1935 is hereby amended by the insertion of the words "or for reward" after the word "sale" and the said section shall be construed and have effect accordingly.

The provisions of Section 40 of the Act of 1935 made it unlawful for a person to cure bacon for sale unless he was the holder of a licence or was a registered pork butcher. It has been found that certain persons who were formerly curing bacon are still curing for farmers. When challenged, they say that the bacon is not for sale. This makes clear that they must not cure for reward or for sale. I think it is necessary to stop this, though I do not know if it has been done on a very big scale. It does not prevent a farmer killing his own pigs, but stops certain people from carrying on trade in that small way for reward.

Comment on this

Bear in mind that in certain parts of the country there are thatchers, weavers and itinerant persons who earn their living sometimes—not exclusively, but largely—by going around doing services for their neighbours; and in that category I think it is true to say that a certain number of men kill pigs.

Comment on this

Killing in the farmer's house is not an offence, but it is when killed on their own premises for a farmer.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Is that set out?

Comment on this

If you make it quite clear that the person who comes to my house, kills a pig, cures it, takes a cup of tea and gets a present, is not committing an offence, it would do.

Comment on this

This is not an offence, but killing on their own premises is.

Comment on this

Even though they may get a reward for killing on mine?

Comment on this

A man could be paid for killing pigs, certainly.

Comment on this

Where a man has curing plant at his premises, and cures for private individuals, is it an offence?

Comment on this

There are such cases, and they make the plea that they are not killing for sale, so we have to add the words: "or reward".

Comment on this

It seems to be unknown to persons in this country.

Comment on this

There are a few not so far from the Deputy.

Comment on this

In the case of a co-operative bacon factory, like the Cork Farmers' Union Abattoir, is it possible for them to kill pigs for one of their members?

Comment on this

The only complaint is that it formed part of their quota.

Comment on this

Is it possible for them to kill without it forming part of their quota?

Comment on this

No; it is part of the quota.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Does the Minister think that there is any grave interference with bacon curing from the fact that persons are doing this particular thing? Up to the moment there are possibly, in some villages and towns, men carrying on a very small business, they are not exporting bacon and are no danger to anybody. Their bacon is not leaving the country, they are curing it, and it is perfectly sound bacon. This is being done for neighbours. If it is not a practice that is being carried on to any serious extent, it is questionable whether the Minister ought to go further.

Comment on this

I think the Minister must have a case in mind. In our case we are usually pressed by shareholders to cure a pig for them.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite entitled to do that.

Comment on this

In fact, we would welcome this provision, because we have found it very inconvenient.

Comment on this

I am afraid it does not cover a case like that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 62:—

Before Section 47, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) On or after the transfer date, the Minister may, whenever and so often as he thinks fit, by order (in this section referred to as a suspending order) declare that sub-section (2) of Section 98 (which relates to production periods and quotas) of the Act of 1935 shall be suspended.

(2) Whenever the Minister makes during the currency of a production period a suspending order, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2) of Section 98 of the Act of 1935, the commission shall not, so long as such suspending order is in force, make, on or after the date of such suspending order, a production order:

(b) if the commission has before the date of such suspending order made, in pursuance of the said sub-section (2), a production order appointing a period to be the next production period, then—

(i) such production order shall be deemed not to have been made, and

(ii) anything consequential on the making of such production order done in relation to such next production period by the commission in pursuance of Sections 21, 22 or 23 of the Act of 1937 shall be deemed not to have been done.

(3) Whenever a suspending order is in force the Minister may by order under this sub-section revoke such suspending order, and thereupon such suspending order shall cease to be in force.

(4) Where—

(a) the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 98 of the Act of 1935 are not complied with, and

(b) such non-compliance was occasioned by the restrictions imposed by paragraph (a) of sub-section (2) of this present section.

the provisions of sub-section (3) of the said Section 98 shall apply in respect of such non-compliance.

(5) Every order made by the Minister under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution annulling such order is passed by either such House within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which such House has sat after such order is laid before it, such order shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such order.

This is the section dealing with the production quota.

Comment on this

A most important section.

Comment on this

The effect of this amendment would be that the Minister could, by order, authorise the commission to suspend the production quota and he could, if he found for any reason that it was better to come back to the existing arrangement, revoke that order. I think that is really the whole point, and there is no use in going further into it.

Comment on this

If that marks the end of the production quota system, it is a great blessing for everybody.

Comment on this

I was asked what the section meant. Section 102 of the 1935 Act refers to home-sales. This section has the effect of abolishing the home-sales quota.

Comment on this

Glory, Halleluiah. I would refer the Minister to my observation at the Special Committee on Section 102, when I warned him that the home-sales order would be an unmitigated blunder.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 63:—

Before Section 49, to insert a new section as follows:—

Section 23 of the Act of 1937 shall cease to apply in respect of any production period commencing on or after the transfer date.

Section 23 of the 1937 Act provides for a penalty for underproduction. If we propose to do away with the production quota we have to do away with the penalties also.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I move amendment No. 64:—

In lines 29, 31 and 35, to delete in each line the words "Pigs and Bacon".

Comment on this

This is a drafting amendment which I think is all right.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

I move amendment No. 65:—

Before paragraph (c), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

(c) the reference in sub-section (4) of the said section to the Chairman of the Bacon Marketing Board and two other persons to be arbitrators shall be construed as a reference to three persons none of whom is or has been a member of the Commission or has been a member of the Bacon Marketing Board or of the Pigs Marketing Board to be arbitrators.

I believe there was very considerable difficulty and dissatisfaction with regard to arbitration questions.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

When a matter came before one board, the chairman presiding, and an appeal was taken to another board, the people seeking redress found themselves up against the same chairman and practically the same people again. Can the Minister give us any way out of that difficulty?

Comment on this

My next amendment, No. 66, is the solution I propose. The position is that the present arbitration board, sitting on these cases for quite a long time, is composed of a chairman and two others. There is a doubt as to whether a majority decision can be accepted. Legal opinion on one side says it must be unanimous and, on the other, that a majority decision is sufficient. We are making it clear in the next amendment that a majority decision will be effective. If we fail to get two to agree, I can select one person of the three, not being the chairman, and say: "I will take your decision," and we will end it in that manner one way or another.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Any claims lying over will come before the new board?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the reason for excluding the chairman?

Comment on this

Deputies opposite thought that the chairman would not be kindly disposed towards people looking for compensation.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

He could not possibly be.

Comment on this

Is that because you are going to reappoint the existing chairman?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:—

To insert at the end of the section the following sub-section:—

(2) Where all or a majority of the arbitrators appointed to fix compensation under Section 39 of the Act of 1937 have, before the passing of this Act, been unable or are, after the passing of this Act, unable to agree upon the amount of such compensation, the amount of such compensation shall be fixed by such one (not being, in case such appointment was made before the transfer date, the Chairman of the Bacon Marketing Board, or in case such appointment is made on or after the transfer date, the Chairman of the Pigs and Bacon Commission) of the said arbitrators as the Minister may nominate, and the decision of the person so nominated shall be final and conclusive.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:—

At the end of the section in page 20 to insert the following new sub-section:—

(2) In this section and in the Acts of 1935 and 1937 the expression "appointed price" means minimum price.

The purpose of the amendment is to alter "fixed price" to "minimum price". Obviously, it would make for more competition and afford a better opportunity to the producer. In practice, I think it is difficult to operate a fixed price, and I am sure that the inspectors of the Department and others concerned would have to admit that, in many cases, the fixed price is the minimum price. I cannot prove that, but I believe, from a good deal of contact with people, that it is very difficult to have this rigidly imposed fixed price. I cannot see the advantage of it, but I can see advantages in having a minimum price, because, as I say, it is going to give a better opportunity for competition and, in that way, favour the producer of the pig. There are certain districts which are not prolific in pigs, and if there is no opportunity for bacon curers, for instance, to settle in the areas in which pigs are prolific, they will have no chance of going outside to buy them. The area from which I come is a big bacon-curing centre, employing a good many men, but Limerick and Tipperary adjoining, are not very big pig-producing counties and, in the past, before any of this interference by legislation took place, our men had the privilege of curing pigs at Limerick from counties far removed from Limerick. I am afraid that if we are going to have a fixed price, with production quotas excluded, there is a danger that my area would be likely to lose. I can see some of the employees walking around idle, at a time when there should be an opportunity to buy these pigs in fair competition, and give an advantage to the producer, rather than that we should stick to the rigid fixed price which, I believe, in practice is scarcely attainable.

Comment on this

I do not agree that, in present circumstances, at any rate, we should change from a fixed price to a minimum price. That was one of the questions that was very fully considered when drafting the Bill which we drafted as a result of the findings of the Prices Commission and the Agricultural Commission. If we depart from the production quota, I think we are running one risk, that the bigger curers may take advantage of the opportunity, with their better organisation and so on, to try to get more pigs than they are getting at present, and to leave the smaller curers with somewhat fewer. If, in addition, we make a minimum price instead of a fixed price, I think we are almost certain to give that big advantage to the bigger curers. Apart from that, we are aiming at a certain thing in this Bill. I do not know whether we can achieve it or not, but we are aiming at getting the best we can for the producer and the consumer out of the bacon business. We can, I hope, after getting the costings of bacon production, fix what might be regarded as a fair margin for bacon production for the curer. We know what he is going to pay for his pigs because the price is fixed. We allow this margin to the manufacturer and we then know what the ex-factory price should be. If we tell the Prices Commission what that price ought to be, the Prices Commission can look after the bacon as it goes to the wholesaler and the retailer, and make known to the purchasing public what the price of bacon ought to be.

Again, I say on that point that if we depart from the fixed price to the minimum price, the bacon curers will say that they have paid so and so for pigs—not the fixed price, but something over—and it will make it extremely difficult to get down to this matter of costings, to a fair margin for the curer and a fair price for the curer, and afterwards put the bacon through the wholesaler and retailer, and get the best possible results for the consumer. I ask the Deputy not to press this amendment at the moment. If we had some experience of working this scheme without a production quota, we might say that we could go further in decontrol and could fix a minimum price. If we did reach that stage, I think all other things might go.

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree that it is desirable that curers in all parts of the country should get pigs, and will he do something to meet the possibility that in certain parts they may not be able to get them?

Comment on this

I do not think we can do anything to help the curer where there are no pigs near him, but I do not think we ought to do anything positive here that would give an advantage to the larger curers as against the smaller curers, and I am afraid that this would give a definite advantage, or, anyway, give them an opportunity.

Comment on this

In speaking of a minimum price, if a particular curer pays more than the minimum price, it means that he is going to have less profit. The Minister, in giving a final price for bacon, would be influenced by the minimum price fixed, and surely at this stage it is not going to be suggested that the curer should be saved from further expenditure, if he is good enough to spend something more on a pig?

Comment on this

I see the Deputy's point. The Deputy says that, in fixing that margin for the curer, we say: "You need not pay more than the minimum price, but if you do, it is out of your own pocket".

Comment on this

That is my point.

Comment on this

I think we ought to remember the other point for the present at any rate. If things go smoothly after removing the production and home sales quotas, I think we might come to this, but let us see how it works for a while with the fixed price.

Comment on this

Would the Minister take this into consideration? It is desirable, I take it, and the Minister will probably agree, that curers in all areas should get a sufficiency of pigs? The object of this amendment is not to give the pig curer an advantage, but to enable the small curer to get a sufficient supply of pigs at all times. The Minister takes the view that it may have a different reaction altogether.

Comment on this

I am afraid so.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give some assurance that these activities of the commission will ensure that there will be a sufficiency of pigs for curers in various parts of the country? Otherwise there is a danger that where the production of pigs is on a large scale, the big bacon curers may buy all the pigs and the small curers, either in that area or in some distant place, may not be able to get any pigs. Will the Minister think over that and try to deal with that situation on the Report Stage? Will he give some kind of assurance that as far as he and the commission are concerned they will try to get an even distribution of pigs?

Comment on this

That is a point to which we have given a great deal of consideration, and I cannot see any solution for it. That is why I am proposing here in the Bill to make the abolition of the production quota only experimental. I do not know if we can go back to that again if the big curers injure the smaller curers. It is very difficult to guarantee what Deputy Norton asks. Suppose we say that every curer must get a fair number of pigs. It will be possible then for a curer in some part of the country to take things easy and to say: "I am guaranteed a certain number of pigs and I do not see why I should have to go out and look for them." It is very difficult to give a guarantee of that kind in legislation. All we can do is to watch things, to watch how the scheme will go after the abolition of the production quota. If we see any unforeseen hardship arising, we shall have to mend our hand.

Comment on this

Could the Minister get a declaration from the commission that they intend to distribute pigs as equitably as possible and not to allow the distribution to get into the hands of a small number of people? That is the point in the amendment. Will the Minister think it over between now and the Report Stage?

Comment on this

I shall think it over certainly. It is a matter we have been thinking over all the time.

Comment on this

Would the Minister have power at a subsequent stage to vary the price from a fixed price to a minimum price?

Comment on this

We have no power to vary it.

Comment on this

I think you should provide for that. If you find after the abolition of the production quota that a minimum price would be desirable, you should at least give yourself power to do that.

Comment on this

There is another aspect of the question to which I do not think that Deputy Keyes has adverted. There are two separate theories in connection with the price of pigs. It may be that you are going to fix a minimum price and invite cut-throat competition between curers. That may be a very good thing, but it is open to certain dangers. Henry Denny may make up his mind that he is going to clear up the County Kerry. He will do two things. He will send all his buyers down into Kerry and he will tell them to pay 5/- per cwt. more for pigs than any other curer in Kerry. He will keep on doing that until he makes the fairs of Kerry very unpopular with all other buyers, and then, when he has the whole field to himself, he will cut down prices. At the same time he will go into the Kerry area and sell bacon at 10/- per cwt. less than the price at which the Kerry factories can sell it. He will keep on doing that until the Kerry factories say to him: "Take us over; we are done for; we cannot stand the racket any longer." Then, when he has got all the factories and dominates all the fairs in the area, he pulls down the price of pigs and shoves up the price of bacon. The reason the Minister retains the production quota is that when he sees that happening he will step in and say: "Whoa! We cannot let you cure more than a certain number of pigs. We are going to give the Kerry factories a certain number of pigs to cure, and if necessary we are going to give them a quota sufficient to consume all the bacon which we allow them to produce." If the Minister has to use that power, it will be a great misfortune, but the fact that he can use it is the most potent deterrent you can possibly get to prevent the big combine trying to smash the small local unit.

There is another aspect of the situation of which we have lost sight altogether. Rather than getting an abnormal profit for a lucky farmer at a particular season of the year. I should like to be able to say to all farmers who produce pigs at all seasons of the year: "You are going to make a fair profit on all the pigs you put in." Therefore, we should prescribe a fixed price for pigs on the 1st August which will bear a certain relation to the price of the standard ration for a pig— which will bear, if I may say so, a certain relation to the pigs cost-of-living figure. With this, the farmer will have the assurance that the fixed price on the 1st December will bear the same relation to the pigs cost-of-living figure over a four-month period, as the fixed price on the 1st August bore to the cost of living or of feeding stuffs on the 1st August. That means to say that you can tell the man who puts in six pigs: "If none of your pigs die you will have a profit on the 1st December. It is not going to be an immense profit. but you are absolutely certain that you are not going to be at a loss."

Deputies may have heard me plead to the Minister to make a ten or 20 years' agreement aimed at supplying all the bacon and ham requirements of these two islands out of the joint resources of Great Britain and Ireland. If we can do that, and we have at the same time a fixed price in strict relation to the cost of feeding stuffs, we could guarantee for every farmer in this country one branch of agriculture on which he would never fail to make a profit. Therefore, what I am asking the Minister to do, in preference to Deputy Keyes' proposal, is to consider the desirability of accepting an amendment which I propose to submit to him on recommittal, analogous to that to which reference is made at column 139 of the Pigs and Bacon Bill Special Committee Report. I then submitted an amendment to the original Bill which I knew was too rigid and which I knew would have to be withdrawn. Instead of it, the Minister did put in a proviso that when the Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board were fixing prices for pigs they were bound to consider the price of feeding stuffs.

In England they went further than that because they based the price of pork on the price of feeding-stuffs. What I am asking the Minister now, instead of accepting Deputy Keyes' proposal to fix a minimum price, is to relate the price of pigs to the price of feeding-stuffs hereafter so that he can say to small farmers who get into pig production: "There is one branch of agricultural in which you are bound to make a profit." I think that is a better scheme than Deputy Keyes' plan.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has introduced a regular Juggernaut attached to the very mild proposal of mine. He thinks that this proposal to fix a minimum price is going to flatten and steam-roll the pig-rearing industry, that some foreign combine is going to go into Kerry and buy all the pigs by paying 10/- per cwt. more than anybody else is prepared to pay. The Deputy visualises a nightmare of that kind arising out of this proposal. But for the hard working, industrious pig rearers in this country we do not want either fixed prices or the monster that Deputy Dillon has conjured up.

Comment on this

And which did come to Sligo. The Deputy had better ask them about it.

Comment on this

What we want is competition and fair buying that will give satisfaction to the producers. I am reminded that last week Deputy Dillon complained that if the fair had been held at Knockcroghery it would have put at least £2,000 into the pockets of the pig rearers of that district, in which I am sure he is interested, because it would have given them the chance, as he said, of sending their pigs across to England. What I am suggesting to the Minister is that if he adopts my proposal and agrees to have a minimum price that will lead to competition at the fairs and will bring increased revenue to our pig rearers. The buyers will be prepared to pay a couple of shillings above the minimum price for pigs of the first grade which are required to meet the demands of a particular trade.

Does Deputy Dillon want to stand in the way of his people down in Knockcroghery getting an extra few thousand pounds for their pigs? He seemed to be very much concerned about them the other night, but here is a way to confer a benefit on them, and it is surely the Deputy's business to try and serve the interests of his people. I am not a bit afraid of this terrible nightmare which Deputy Dillon has pictured for us of some Continental firm coming along here and buying, at fabulous prices, all the pigs in the County Kerry, with the result, as he thinks, that activity in the pig industry will come to an end there.

I do not believe for a moment that anything of the kind is likely to happen, and I suggest to the Deputy that we should approach this matter in a commonsense way. The farmers surely are entitled to get every opportunity of securing the best price available for the pigs they have to offer. That situation will be brought about if you have a minimum price. There will be keen competition at the fairs because the buyers who want to secure top-grade pigs will be quite ready to pay a few shillings extra for them so that they may be able to fill the demands of the factories they represent. I hope the Minister will not be influenced by what Deputy Dillon has said to depart from the attitude that he indicated earlier. I believe that the introduction of the principle of a minimum price would produce the most beneficial results, and therefore I would appeal to the Minister to give it a chance. The Minister should not allow himself to be tied up under any Act of Parliament, but should leave himself in the position in which he will be able to introduce, if he finds it necessary, a minimum price as against a fixed price.

Comment on this

If the time comes when we can do that, then I think we can say that we have been very successful. I am afraid, however, that is going to take some time. I think that other big changes will be necessary, but at the same time I am almost certain that a stage will be reached when we can get a consolidation of all the pigs and bacon legislation properly done.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to consider the matter of relating prices to the cost of feeding stuffs?

Comment on this

As regards the conditions that we had previously, the only one now left to be taken into consideration is the cost of feeding stuffs.

Comment on this

Could we have an assurance from the Minister that all the curers will be able to get an adequate supply of pigs to cure. That is the real point. This amendment may, perhaps, not be the best way of meeting that, but I am not too sure that Deputy Dillon's method is the way to meet it. You may have a situation in which curers, in certain areas, will not be able to get pigs because of the fact that some big combine in the industry may come along and buy pigs in that area for reasons known to itself, and may export those pigs elsewhere for curing. I think we should have some indication from the Minister that, so far as the activities of the commission are concerned, all curers will be able to get an adequate supply of pigs, so that you will not have a situation of that kind arising. We do not want to have a situation in which an octopus in the industry may collar all the pigs available over some particular area, pigs of a particular type, while other curers cannot get a sufficient supply of pigs. If such a situation did arise it would have the effect of throwing a number of people out of employment in the bacon curing industry in certain parts of the country.

Comment on this

I do not see how an undertaking of that kind could be given. I have already said that the reason why we are making the abolition of the production quota experimental is this: that if anything of the kind suggested by the Deputy should occur, then we will be able to go back to the production quota again. That is the only way I think in which you could meet that situation.

Comment on this

But is that the only way the Minister has of meeting a situation of that kind?

Comment on this

It is the only way we have at the moment.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that the Minister acknowledges that the only relevant factor for fixing prices now is the cost of feeding stuffs, will he consider taking steps to relate the price of pigs to the cost of feeding stuffs. What I suggest to him is that he should strike out a cost-of-living figure for the pig: that he should fix a basic price for pigs and give the pig producer a cost-of-living bonus, as the pig's cost of living rises or falls. I think the Minister should consider that. If he does not, then I am afraid that his best laid plans may "gang aft a-gley" by the intervention of the Minister for Supplies or the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

For what period ahead does the Minister propose to get prices fixed?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will read the clause in the original Act he will find set out there all the various considerations which the board had to take into consideration before fixing prices. None of them now arise except the one relating to the price of feeding stuffs. All those conditions were put in because of the fear of over production. There is no such thing as over-production now.

Comment on this

I put it to the Minister that he ought to fix a cost-of-living figure for the pig. Let us suppose that to-day it is 100, and that the price on that basis is 84/- for top grade. On every point of a rise in the cost-of-living figure the price of pork could be raised by, say, 2/-. If the cost-of-living figure went up to 104 the price of pork would go up by 8/-, leaving the price for top grade pigs at 92/-. I admit at once that that would involve some kind of agreement with Great Britain whereby we would keep the cost-of-feeding stuffs in strict relation to prices. There is, of course, a difficulty there, but if we are going to make pigs one of the biggest factors in our agricultural industry, surely that is a difficulty that we ought to tackle and try to fix up. A further point that I want to impress on the Minister is this: the urgent necessity of telling me to-day what he will give me for my pigs—not now, when I have no pigs to sell—but on the 1st March, when my pigs will be ready for sale. If I am to go out and buy bonhams at the next fair, and if I am to be tempted to go into the business now, I must be told what my pigs will be worth when I have them finished. I must also be told that the price of feeding stuffs will remain at a stable figure during the period that I am fattening the pigs, or that the Minister's fixed price will fluctuate up and down with what the price of feeding stuffs turns out to be on the average between now and the 1st March.

Comment on this

Yes, I think that is the point.

Comment on this

Will the Minister think that over?

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

Is there any hope of there being an amendment put in by the Minister in that form?

Comment on this

I do not think it could be done.

Comment on this

At present all that is required is to consider the prices. I want to relate the two things together.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

In fixing the prices we carry over the provisions of the relevant section of the Pigs and Bacon Act of 1935? Is not that so? There is also the danger of the supply of pigs likely to be available.

Comment on this

If the Deputy could throw his mind back he would probably remember that that section was put in to give the board a chance of decreasing the price of pigs if there were too many going on the market. There is no danger of that now.

Comment on this

I would like to press the Minister with regard to the latter part of Deputy Dillon's suggestion. If you are to have an industry here you have to proceed on some such lines as that which succeeded in the Minister's own scheme of wheat—that is to promise a future price. I would like if the Minister would give some consideration to the possibility of fixing a price for four months or so ahead.

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Yes, four months ahead.

Comment on this

Well that can be brought up at a later stage.

Comment on this

I am not moving amendment No. 68 now as I want that amendment changed slightly to the substituted amendment on the White Paper. I beg to move the substituted amendment, which reads:—

In page 21, to delete line 29 and substitute the words "and all other products derived from pigs."

This section enables the commission to get the nett costings of the production of bacon in the factories; these costings when ascertained can be published. After putting down amendment No. 68 we felt that the section would not, perhaps, be wide enough and we proposed not only to include "and all other products derived from the carcases of pigs," but to go farther. The amendment now says, "and all other products derived from pigs." That would include black puddings.

Comment on this

And the cases of black puddings?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 69 is not moved because the principle in that amendment by Deputy McGilligan has been accepted in another amendment.

Comment on this

Is not Section 54 made necessary by the report of the Public Accounts Committee?

Comment on this

Yes, that is right.

Comment on this

The eternal vigilance of the Public Accounts Committee required the Minister to introduce that section.

Comment on this

I propose to take the Report Stage on Tuesday next, the 5th December. I hope to get all stages on Tuesday because I want the Bill to go to the Seanad on Wednesday next.

Comment on this

Is the Minister going to recommit the Bill on Tuesday?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That is to say it will be recommitted on Report?

Comment on this

Yes.

The Dáil adjourned at 10.25 p.m. until 10.30 a.m. on Friday, 1st December.

Comment on this