Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 1–128 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
At the present time especially, and for that matter, at all times, the problem of unemployment, I am sure we all agree, holds the greatest interest for all of us. I consider it an appalling scandal that thousands of our people in an age of plenty should be deprived of the mere necessities of life. I believe that work should be found and found quickly for such people. Speaking with all seriousness, I am inclined to think that the Government, and indeed I must say most members of this House, are not facing the reality and gravity of the situation. I believe that if they were, we should now be trying to mobilise the resources of the country, by which means we might arrive at some solution of the problem. The Taoiseach in his broadcast recently to the people of the nation appealed for co-operation with a view to ending opposition to the institutions of the State and pleaded for ordered conditions in this country. I want to say to the Minister in all sincerity that I believe much of the disorder and unrest in this country is due to poverty and privations arising out of the unemployment problem. I have the experience daily of meeting men with large families who have been unemployed for two, four and five years with the exception of four or five days per week for some months of the year. I meet daily young men from 19 to 23 years of age who have not yet been given the opportunity of earning a week's wages. I have some knowledge of the thoughts that these men have and what they think about the present social system. I want to say to the Minister that with these rigid regulations, employment period orders and means tests, you are creating a revolutionary spirit amongst young men in the country. I have known a number of these men who are anxious to work and who cannot get work, and they are even taken off the unemployment lists because it is alleged that they are not genuinely seeking employment.
I want to point out to the Minister that some of the regulations are contrary to reason and justice. We have at the moment a large amount of casual unemployment in the building and shipping trades. I often wonder does the Minister or responsible people in his Department realise the irritation which these regulations create in the minds of our young men in cities and towns. Under the system at present in operation, if a man is employed on Monday and Tuesday, gets a half day's work on Wednesday and Thursday and is again unemployed on Friday and Saturday, he will get no benefit from unemployment assistance or the unemployment insurance fund. He can continue under that system of casual employment for a whole year and never draw as much as a solitary penny from the unemployment funds. If he works on Monday and Tuesday and is idle on the following two days, he can then draw six days' benefit in a period of two weeks. Will anybody say to me that a man who is anxious and willing to work and who is deprived of benefit when he cannot get work under the system which I have mentioned, can have any respect towards the State or the institutions of the State? We have also a regulation in unemployment insurance whereby a man has to sign and undergo a six days' waiting period without receiving any benefit whatever. If, on the sixth day, he happens to get a day's work he will lose any benefit for the previous five days for which he had signed. He will start all over again on the following week and will have to sign for six further waiting days. These regulations operate very harshly against dockers, builders labourers and men engaged in that seasonal kind of work. I want to suggest to the Minister that as long as we have that system of unemployment insurance benefit we shall have nothing but unrest and disregard and disrespect for the system that tolerates it.
The Minister stated recently in a letter to the Clare County Council that unemployment assistance was intended merely to help unemployed persons over a period, as far as resources of the State would permit. I want to say to the Minister and to the House that the theory underlying the Unemployment Assistance Act was that no person who was willing to work would be allowed to want for the necessaries of life. Clearly the necessaries of life mean food, clothing and shelter as a minimum. We have at the moment over 100,000 unemployed in the State, and how are we facing that problem? To keep a family of five or more persons, we allow 23/- a week. In other words we value family life on the basis of allowing for seven or more persons a mere pittance of 23/- or 25/- per week. I want to say that the Government and the people of the country generally, but particularly the members of this House, are not facing up to the realities of the situation. I think it is time for us to recognise that there is need for a new conception of economic life, not only a policy of action to meet the present situation but a new theory of social organisation to facilitate the evolution of a new social and economic programme to meet the changed circumstances of the present day. We had an illustration of that recently when Mr. Lloyd George, a man who has had a very wide experience of dealing with social problems, stated that all parties must fearlessly recognise that the old machinery of wealth production and wealth distribution had broken down and must be reconstructed and made new. I want to say to the Minister that we shall have to think very seriously along these lines in the near future. I think it will be admitted by any reasonable person that, given an efficient organisation of production and distribution, we could provide here adequate supplies of food, clothing and shelter for every section of the community. I know the Minister will ask me, how is that to be done. My answer is, that before we can tackle it with any hope of success we must have control of the credit of the country.
Comment on this
I expect I have been. We have to face the position that, at the moment, we have not control of our financial system. While that is so, I believe we cannot get rid of the crime, because it is a crime, of having thousands of people waiting to produce, and thousands of people waiting to consume. I can quote a very high authority for that statement, the chairman of the largest banking system in the world, a one-time war Chancellor of the Exchequer in England, Mr. Reginald McKenna, who said, in effect, that those who control credit hold the destinies of the people in the hollow of their hands.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy must hold that speech for the Second Reading of the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
The one serious position in the country to-day is that of the unemployed. I want to put their position in all seriousness to the Minister. I do not want to exploit their position. I am simply saying all this in order to bring home to the Minister the seriousness of the situation. I have a very clear realisation of what their position is, due probably to the fact that I hold a certain position. I have people coming to me day after day expressing their minds to me. Because of the fact that I want to see ordered conditions maintained in the country, I suggest to the Minister that he will have to face up to the present position and seek a remedy for it. We must all view with great concern the amount of irritation which the means test imposes on unemployment assistance applicants. When I spoke on this before, and urged that certain things should be done, the Minister gave a quotation from one of the Encyclicals of the late Pope—that the poor we shall always have with us. I can quote for the Minister words that were used by the Pope on another occasion when he said, in effect, that the despotic economic domination of the people would continue until such time as we had control of the currency of the country. Until we get control of that, I am afraid that our unemployment problem will remain with us.
I do urge on the Minister that something should be done to get rid of the irritating conditions imposed on applicants for unemployment assistance. In England the position is that an unemployed docker or builder's labourer can have three days' work in the week and still get three days' unemployment benefit at the labour exchange, while in this country a man may work four half-days or three half-days in the week and cannot get either unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance. The means test, as applied here, imposes, in my view, a cruel hardship on the unemployed. I ask the Minister to take serious notice of what I have said because I want to assure him that the position is much more serious than many seem to realise.
Comment on this
Two points of view seem to be expressed in this debate on the general industrial question. It would appear that the main Opposition Party realise now that the policy of self-sufficiency, in the light of present circumstances at any rate, is the only possible policy, and would seek to remove certain disabilities under which industrialists are labouring. On the other hand, Labour agrees with the policy, and always have so far as I know, of industrial expansion, and of protection generally. On Friday, however, Deputy Norton, when speaking on this Estimate, made the charge that nothing had been done during the present Government's tenure to increase employment. This viewpoint, to me at any rate, is not readily understandable, because we can all see for ourselves the number of factories which have been erected throughout the country since the present Government came into office. A cursory glance through official statistics shows that, during the year 1938, the gross industrial output was approximately £32,000,000 more than in 1931. I should also like to say that recent expressions of opinion at the annual meetings of industrial concerns go to support the contention that our factories have been doing good work and are producing products which can compare with the products turned out in any country in the world. At the ordinary general meeting of Messrs. Arnott & Co., Ltd., Dublin, on the 12th March last, Mr. William Nesbitt, the chairman, said:
"That while present conditions made the task of their buyers anxious and difficult, many of the new factories were rising to the occasion in a very creditable way. The quality, finish and variety of their products," he said, "are greatly improved, and indeed in the circumstances to-day we may feel grateful for the energy and perseverance of our late Minister for Industry and Commerce, as without those sources of supply we might well be in an awkward position."
At the ordinary general meeting of Todd, Burns & Co., Ltd., Dublin, held on the 28th March, Mr. L.G. Sherlock, LL.D., who presided, in the course of his statement, said:
"Attention should be directed to the fact that their factories had been more than successful. They were working at peak production, and, because of the quality of the work done and the excellent value offered, they were able to secure increasing orders from the wholesale trade."
These are only two of the many speeches of a similar kind delivered recently which Deputies can read for themselves in the Press. They pay high tribute to our industrialists and to the work that is being done in our factories generally. One thing, at any rate, is clear to me, and should, I think, be clear to all, namely, that our efforts towards self-sufficiency must at this juncture be more than ever intensified, and serious efforts made to remove any disability which affects maximum efficiency in industry. We must plan with a view to learning from our past efforts. Unrest in industry here has undoubtedly stemmed progress, and to obtain a better understanding as between employers and employed is, I suggest, the immediate task to-day. I hold that our industries have not had the chance that they should have had during the last ten years. When one consults the statistical abstract it is amazing to find that from 1931 to 1938 we had a constantly increasing number of industrial disputes in the country. In 1931 the number of such disputes was 60; in 1932, 70; in 1933, 88; in 1934, 99; in 1935, 99; in 1936, 107; in 1937, 145; in 1938, 137, making a total of 805 industrial disputes during a period of eight years—an average of 100 a year. In the face of that, the miracle to me is that there is any industry at all left in Ireland to-day. Of these 805 industrial disputes only 367 of them concerned questions of wages. It is obvious then that between the employer and the employee everything is not right.
It should be our immediate task and it will be the immediate task of the Government I hope, if no other method is available or no other method can be found, to see that that state of affairs is not permitted to continue. I do not want anybody on the Labour Benches to misunderstand what I am saying. I know that the worker who has his labour to sell has the only ultimate redress against bad conditions in the strike weapon, but it is the last weapon that should be used and I believe that some system should be hammered out by which strikes and the prevalence of strikes could be minimised. I would like to point out to the Labour Benches that for the last 40 years there has been in New Zealand a system by means of which wages have been determined by judicial legislation. Disputes involving unions there must be referred for final settlement to the court of arbitration. I am not advocating compulsory arbitration. I would like to hear the views of the Labour Deputies on some points of compulsory arbitration in relation to New Zealand, a country that has been held up to us as a land flowing with milk and honey. It is a country we are told that we might well copy whenever there is any industrial legislation needed to be carried through here.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear the Lord Mayor of Cork saying "hear, hear." I would like to ask the Labour Party whether they consider that compulsory arbitration has not done good?
Comment on this
I interrupted no Deputy and I want to be allowed to proceed. Labour Deputies might remember that in New Zealand at one time compulsory arbitration had to be shelved and it was upon that that the Labour Government first got into power. No one can dispute that. What has been found to be good for us in one respect—borrowed from New Zealand—might be good in other respects. Consequently, I would like to hear Labour's views about compulsory arbitration in connection with the parallel between New Zealand and Ireland. I believe that there is need for an economic council for Ireland and I think that council might be well constituted first by a representative of the State; next by representatives of the employer; representatives of the workers and, lastly, representatives of the consumers. Whether that council would or would not solve these questions in relation to industrial disputes I do not know, but I think it should be given a trial, at all events, before we try what might at a later stage have to be adopted here. On this Vote I am not advocating legislation. It might work out towards obviating legislation in connection with industrial disputes.
I am glad that in his statement the Minister announced that a turf generating station was to be erected at Clonsast Bog. I think that is a tribute to the work of the late Sir John Purser Griffith, the man in whose writings many of us were keenly interested years ago. I believe the erection of that station is a sound idea. I believe that consequent upon the erection of that generating station we might yet develop on the lines that Sir John Purser Griffith indicated years ago. Other countries, particularly Germany, manufacture a number of by-products from peat. I cannot enumerate all these now. I would like to know if there is a proper research department in connection with peat and if there is any intention on the part of the Peat Board to deal with numerous by-products of peat?
There is just a matter in connection with the Dublin Labour Exchange that I want to mention. Recently I put down a question in relation to that Exchange; I suggested that it was incommodious and insalutary. Despite the Minister's reply, I am informed that the conditions in the exchange still are deplorable. I would like to make an appeal to the Minister in relation to applicants who live in the new corporation areas. Some of them have to travel three or four miles to get to the labour exchange. Remember that they have often to travel that distance on wet days. Of course we all can very readily realise what it would cost them in bus fares. The appeal I make to the Minister is to consider the question of regional exchanges.
I want to make another appeal on behalf of superannuated men. The average trade union member pays to a fund which provides through his society for superannuation. Such a man works until he can no longer work. When he attains the age of 70 he has to discontinue working. He does not get a pension; he retires on a very small allowance from his society. This is the point I want to make to the Minister and perhaps he would bear it in mind and discuss it with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. I suggest that together they might hammer out a scheme. When a man attains the age of 70 he is paid a small pension out of a fund towards which he has contributed over a period of 30 or 40 years. Because of that little help he is denied the benefit of the old age pension. I would like the Minister to examine what could be done about that matter. This man is not in the same position as the man who has a certain means or a man who can draw on a certain investment. I do not think that this little pension he gets from the society should be taken into account when computing his income. After all it only just amounts to the savings of 1/- or 2/- a week he might have put into a box over a period of 30 years. I feel that the Minister in collaboration with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health might hammer out some scheme by which cases of this kind, the little weekly pension from the trade union, would not be taken into account when computing the old age pension.
Comment on this
The Minister in his speech referred to strikes. At the present time these are very much in the public eye. I suggest that the employers and the workers should get together and see what they could do to obviate these strikes. I know for certain that no employer wants a strike. There is one aspect of the question that I am sure the Minister must have in mind, namely, the use and abuse of the Trades Disputes Act. There is another aspect of strikes, namely, that nobody would suggest that Labour embarks on a strike for fun. They suffer just the same as the employer suffers. There is no doubt about it that at the present time the rise in the cost of living is responsible for strikes. Just how much of that raising of the cost of living is due to Government action is a subject for controversy. Now, in other countries they have subsidised the cost of living. Of course, it may be argued that that is only a war measure—and, certainly, it is not a very desirable expedient— but the other alternative is that there should be a general lowering of the standard of living, and, inevitably, that would react on the lower-paid workers very unfavourably, not alone on their physical well-being but, ultimately, on the country at large.
There is another matter in connection with which I have been rather disappointed—and I did not see any reference to it in the Minister's statement. At the present time we are either cut off from a number of supplies or else these supplies are restricted or have risen enormously in price. In other countries a systematic effort is made to keep down waste, and such things as paper, glass, metal, and various other waste products, which are thrown out by the ordinary householder in a city of a population such as Dublin, are collected and carefully sorted out. On the other side, I understand, there has been some computation made as to the savings that have been made under this head, and I believe they amount to millions. I realise, of course, that over here in this country more difficulties would be encountered in connection with the cost of picking out the different articles. At the same time, however, nobody who travels through the City of Dublin in the early morning can fail to notice the number of people who go along and systematically search the dust-bins of the city. Very often, they leave half the contents of the dust-bins on the sidewalk, as a result of their search. I do not know to what extent the corporation is supposed to remove the contents of these dust-bins that are left on the sidewalks, but at any rate it leaves a very untidy city. Coupled with that, you can see children going along and taking a catalogue or some such book from a dust-bin outside a house, pulling off the leaves of the book, and casting them in the gutter or on the sidewalk. The result of all this is that it leaves a very untidy city—not forgetting, of course, the people who eat oranges in the street, and throw the orange peels on the sidewalk for people to slip on.
Comment on this
Well, I do not suppose the Minister will accept responsibility for an orange peel. However, I shall leave the suggestion at the Minister's door.
Comment on this
However, there is another matter that I should like to raise in connection with this Vote. Deputy Norton, when speaking the other day, wanted the Irish manufacturers to produce 100 per cent. of the requirements of this country. Now, that hope seems to be very prevalent in a number of cases, but when one looks into it, one realises that it is an absolute impossibility. That is one of the problems that we have to face in this country. Over here, manufacturing is complicated and rendered difficult by the fact—and I believe there will be no contradiction about this—that we have the same range of varieties of goods as is called for in England. In other words, practically every sort or kind of manufactured goods might be called for in this country that is called for in England.
However, the volume is very different. I do not know whether the incidence runs to one-fortieth or one-hundredth, as compared with England, but the fact remains that the manufacturer who starts in here to supply this market has to choose between selecting a very limited and narrow range of manufacture, and manufacturing that particular range of goods very efficiently, and going out and manufacturing or trying to manufacture a range of goods that will land him into bankruptcy. The reason for that is apparent. The reason is that no single manufacturer, on the other side, has a monopoly and he knows that, even in one particular line alone, there will be 20 or even 100 different competitors. Now, when one expects the Irish manufacturer to supply the whole range of commodities in such a connection, he immediately gets into difficulties. I am afraid that, in this connection, the Minister's Department has rather helped the manufacturers here to incur a great deal of odium with the purchasing public, which our manufacturers do not deserve. What has happened is that the Government has put on a tariff—a very high protective tariff in some cases—and I take it that the attitude of the Government is that they will give the manufacturer protection in order to enable him to manufacture goods here and that, even if he does not manufacture goods, the public will still have to pay the price for the imported goods and that, therefore the Government will get the revenue in any case. Now, in my opinion, that has been the cause of the rise in prices of a great deal of goods which are not actually manufactured in this country, on which protective tariffs have been imposed, and which, the manufacturer will tell you, if you approach him, he has no intention of manufacturing.
To my mind, therefore, there should be a good deal of revision as to what goods can be manufactured efficiently in this country, and as to what should be let into the country after that. That problem is still further complicated by the Irish manufacturer, in some cases, being too greedy and asking for protection for a line of goods which is really only allied with the line of goods he is manufacturing —the result being that people are forced, through the consequent rise of costs, to take the line which is manufactured here, at a greater price than they would have to pay otherwise. I suggest to the Minister that a wholesale revision is required to see what is tariffed legitimately for the protection of industry and what is merely tariffed to an enormous extent which the producer has to pay.
That brings me to another phase of industry to which I would direct the Minister's attention. It is, I think, properly the function of the Prices Commission; but I have some difficulty in that the functions of the Prices Commission seem to run in and out between the Department of Supplies and the Department of Industry and Commerce. Some of the functions come under this Vote and some under the Vote for the Department of Supplies and it would take a very intensive study to discover exactly just how much comes under this Vote and how much under the Vote for the Department of Supplies. But I am raising a matter which, whether it is common to both Ministers or not, is an evil which I think was not properly realised when the very considerable industrial tariffs were put on for the benefit of manufacturers.
Before the present industrial drive this country was very unequally weighted industrially. There were few manufacturing concerns and the distribution was carried out in a rather peculiar manner. Owing to proximity to the shores of Great Britain, a whole lot of wholesale and almost semi-retail people travelled the country for orders to be executed in other countries.
The position is that the distributors in this country form a very important body. They are probably second only to the manufacturers. I suggest to the Minister that they have been placed in an invidious position. Before the advent of very high tariffs, if a distributor, whether wholesale or retail, had to complain of the treatment which he received from a particular manufacturer, he had the remedy in his own hands; he could deal with another manufacturer. Probably, by reason of this, a system of economy was established which worked fairly well, namely, that if manufacturers did not conform to ordinary trading ideas they had to suffer the consequence. Now the position is quite different. In a great many cases there is only one Irish manufacturer in a certain line and he can establish what trading conditions he likes for the distributing trade, and if they do not like these conditions they have no remedy, because they have no other manufacturer to whom they can turn. I do not know how far the Minister might lend a sympathetic ear to stories such as this: that a distributor would say that formerly he was treated by manufacturers in a certain way and that now he was faced with conditions which amounted to "take it or leave it" by a local manufacturer; that he had to send goods by the railway which the manufacturer would deliver to his own customers at a cheaper rate. The Minister may ask how this comes under the Vote for his Department. I suggest that the Prices Commission, when considering a tariff or inquiring into the revision of a tariff or the prices to be charged, have consistently refused to hear what the retailer has to say about getting a proper return on the goods he has to sell.
One of the matters that are always exercising people in this country is how it is that so many people have, nominally, been put into industry and yet the total in employment does not appear to be increasing. I have made a list of a number of firms who were engaged in selling, amongst other things, one particular article, and who have gone bankrupt, gone out of business, or whose business has changed hands within the last 12 months as a result of the policy that I have been referring to. These firms all sold one particular commodity which I have in mind and I have marked them A, B, C, D, E, F, G. According to my computation, these firms had employees numbering 190. These employees have lost their employment or perhaps found other employment at a lower scale or something like that. The change-over along those lines for the whole country must be pretty considerable. I suggest that the Minister, I do not say deliberately, but probably without thinking of it, has brought in a certain number of foreign manufacturers, giving them a prohibitive tariff behind which they can manufacture in this country, and that he has delivered over his own nationals, who are engaged in the other section of that trade, bound hand and foot. I suggest to the Minister that he should see that unfair trading, or a radical departure from previous methods of manufacturers such as I have outlined in some instances, should be discouraged.
As a further instance of the kindliness of some Irish manufacturers towards those engaged in distributing their goods. I am going to read the gross profit allowed in one particular case, under a series of five items. On the first item the distributor, who has to pay all his establishment charges and make a profit, is allowed 13 per cent. gross, on the second item 9 per cent., on the third item 6 per cent., on the fourth item 3 per cent., and on the fifth item nothing. Is it any wonder that people are going out of business in certain lines? An alteration in prices may be brought about, either by a demand for the revision of the tariff which, I understand, might come from the other side of the Channel, and would be investigated under the Minister's Department, or revision by the Prices Commission, in which case it would come from the Minister for Supplies. I suggest to both Ministers that, in revising or looking into tariffs, people who have spent their lives in one section of a particular industry, and who are dealing with the public every day, are in a better position to give information than even the experts employed by the Departments. I heard once of an investigation by the Minister's Department and having listened to both sides of the case, the official concerned said: "I know one of you is lying, but I cannot tell which." I suggest to the Minister that, in a dilemma like that, the assistance of the distributing section of a trade would be a great help to the Departmental officials in making up their minds. I am raising these questions on the Minister's Vote, because I have an amendment down which dealt with only one aspect of the case.
Comment on this
In moving the Vote for £209,223 for his Department the Minister referred to the growing number of industrial disputes and resulting strikes, with great loss of time, less output and disorganisation generally of dependent industry, and said:
"I should prefer that, in this matter, employers and workers should themselves take the initiative and come together to consider and solve the problem."
This matter has been referred to by other Deputies, and I wish simply to say that the public generally would appreciate any effort which could be made towards a solution of such a very serious problem, but I am afraid pious wishes on the part of the Minister, that the two parties concerned would come together to discuss their differences, are not going to be very effective. I suggest that the Minister is in a position to take the responsibility upon himself of bringing the two parties together, and in trying to find a solution, and that some sort of industrial court or effective machinery should be set up to deal with disputes. Nobody wants to deny the right of workers to strike for their lawful and just rights, but I am sure workers generally, and their organisations in particular, will admit that strikes have very disastrous effects not only on employers but on employees. Within the last six months the present Minister for Industry and Commerce addressed two important bodies, the Federation of Irish Manufacturers and the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, and gave very clear expression to what he considered to be a very serious burden on agricultural production, namely the excessive prices charged here as a result of inefficiency and low output in some of the new industries. With your permission, Sir, I propose to read extracts from what the Minister is reported to have said.
Comment on this
No. Referring to the improvement in industrial output in the decade ending in 1936, which continued to expand in 1937 and 1938, the Minister stated:
"Agricultural production, there was reason to believe, had remained virtually stagnant over the same period, while agricultural incomes had substantially declined."
He asked:
"How is it that Irish agriculture continues to languish, that the rural population continues to drift to the towns, and that our social evils and social discontents continue to be aggravated thereby"?
He continued:
"How can Irish farmers hope to increase their output and to expand profitably their export sales in order to employ themselves and their labourers fully, if internal costs continue to rise steadily against them. This goes to the very root of the problem. To a certain extent industrial economy is out of step with our agricultural economy, not because of any fundamental weakness in the policy of industrial development, but because many, though not all, of those who had the chance to put that policy into practical effect have not sufficiently adverted to the position of the Irish farmer and his labourer.
"Many of our new industries are enjoying the protection of very high tariffs. These were granted to safeguard them from being crushed at the start by dumping from abroad. They were not granted to enable them to run up charges against the consumer. Unfortunately, this fact would appear to have been lost sight of in some cases, so that occasion has been taken by workers and employers alike to inflate costs grossly against the community, so that their undertakings carry charges which bear no relation whatsoever to what can be earned on the land in Ireland."
That was what the Minister said in the course of an address to the Federation of Irish Manufacturers on January, 16th. When addressing the Chamber of Commerce on November 1st, 1939, the Minister, according to the Irish Press said:—
"The farmer has to produce efficiently because he has to sell competitively. Most of those engaged in our other industries are more fortunate, for they are strongly protected against competition in our markets but that does not relieve them of the obligation of producing efficiently.
"Sometimes it would seem as if some of them thought it did. The other day I had occasion to examine the costings of an undertaking which for a number of years has had the advantage of a high tariff. I found that even to-day the cost of doing a certain important job which is part of the ordinary routine of the factory is at least twice as much here as it would be elsewhere; that factory wastage due to bad and careless workmanship represents from 30 per cent. to 50 per cent. of the finished and passable product and the gross output is only about 85 per cent. of what is customary in the trade. And this after four or five years working."
I do not think I need quote any further. I agree absolutely with what the Minister said. I was very interested in both speeches. The Minister, certainly, went to the root of the question. I referred to it on other occasions and I take this opportunity to do so again.
Our Party is not opposed to industrial development, nor am I. We support industrial development. We appreciate the necessity for developing industry, but I suggest that our industrial policy must be made fit into our agricultural policy. It must be developed in relation to agriculture and not apart from and outside agriculture. That is what has happened here for the past few years—since this Government came into office. We had a strong industrial drive by the Minister's predecessor and an attempt made to develop all sorts of industries without any examination as to the consequences to, or reactions on, our main industry—agriculture. One would imagine that if the industrial policy was to be a sound and sane one, the responsible Minister would have said to himself: "We have here, in agriculture, an absolutely sound, wealth-producing industry; on this industry we must depend for furnishing us with the means whereby to import our requirements; any industries we set up must be of such a nature that they will not detrimentally affect agriculture." Many of the industries established have had a very serious effect, even a disastrous effect, on agriculture, and the Minister rightly expressed the view that inefficiency and low output were the causes. What does he propose to do about that matter?
We are living in very serious times— in a world crisis. There are, probably, opportunities for development of our agricultural industry which ought to be availed of, and availed of immediately. Improvement of the agricultural industry cannot be brought about if the cost of the raw materials of agriculture and the cost of manufactured goods in this country are going to rise step by step with the prices of agricultural products. If that is going to happen, there will be no hope of improvement for agriculture. It looks like happening and that is why I have put the question I did to the Minister. In his reply, I hope he will tell us what he proposes to do. I suggest that there is an opportunity at present for lowering a number of these high tariffs. The most effective way to deal with inefficiency and low output is to reduce the high tariffs protecting the industries affected. I put down a question to the Minister for Finance with a view to getting some information about the number of tariffs in operation and their classification, in order to ascertain the extent of their impact on agriculture. I wanted to find out how many tariffs there were amounting to 40 per cent., 50 per cent., 60 per cent., or 75 per cent. The reply I got was that it was impossible to give the information required. This House is entitled to the information so that it may be given a picture of the real tariff position. It is a matter that ought to be seriously tackled by the Minister. I believe the Minister is sincere in what he said in addressing these two important bodies. If he is, I suggest that any tariffs that can be lowered ought to be lowered.
The present crisis is, in great measure, a protection in itself. It affords ample protection to many industries without any tariff at all. With that measure of protection in operation and with a high tariff in addition, the consumer is very often being robbed. On one of the Financial Resolutions I asked the Minister a question about the 75 per cent. tariff on tiles and whether it was intended for protective or revenue purposes. He told me that the tariff was protective and that the effective amount was 50 per cent. because there was a 25 per cent. preferential rate. It is very hard for agriculture to improve if we have to carry industries with protection amounting to from 50 per cent. to 75 per cent. We have heard very interesting references by Deputy Childers to the position of agriculture here and to its lack of progress over a number of years. He has compiled statistics showing the relative position in this country and in many competing countries. I agree with Deputy Childers that it is absolutely essential to adopt up-to-date methods. In normal times, competition is so keen that any little increase in the impositions on agriculture is detrimental. I speak as an agriculturist, and I know that the margin of profit in agriculture, no matter whether the Government in power be Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael, is bound to be narrow owing to keen competition. It is only by the adoption of modern methods and by lowering the cost of production that we will secure a decent margin of profit in agriculture. Take one example of a modern idea—that the farmer's cart should be on pneumatics. If a farmer wants to buy a set of pneumatics on ball bearings, including axle and wheels, it will cost him £8 18s. 6d. more than it would cost him in Northern Ireland. The protective tariff payable in that case comes directly out of the pockets of a man who is in keen competition with the agricultural producing countries of the world.
If the farmer wants to buy a set of pneumatic wheels and axles complete for his car or, if he is a big farmer, if he wants to buy half-a-dozen sets, he has to pay at the rate of approximately £9 each more for that article. I ask the Minister is that fair or is it possible that he can carry that charge? Can agriculture succeed if we are going to continue that policy of imposing that charge on the farmer, regardless of the effects it is going to have? The result is that the farmer has been forced to use second-class articles, cast-off bus wheels and that sort of thing. The new article is what he should have and the farmer is entitled to it just as much as any other industrialist. He should not have to go to the scrap heap to get a substitute. That is what he is being forced to do at the present time, to dig up something that is good enough for the farmer but which may not be good enough for anybody else.
Very few people in this country keep motor-cars for pleasure only. Ninety per cent. of the cars are kept for business purposes.
Comment on this
At all events, I wish to point out that it is most unfair to expect any man engaged in agriculture in this country to pay 31? per cent. more for any motor tyre that he has to buy as against farmers in England, Northern Ireland or elsewhere. I question the utility or the national advantage of any industry that is going to impose these charges and these burdens on agriculture. While we may listen to Deputy McCann, talking purely from the city aspect, with a typical Fianna Fáil mind, I say to the Minister that we have started a lot of industries, without any regard to what effect they may have on the one great industry in this country, agriculture, completely ignoring that aspect of the case altogether. That does not matter from Deputy McCann's point of view. He is utterly indifferent to the welfare of agriculture provided that a few highly protected industries can survive. It is very easy to start an industry in this country. It is very easy for the Minister for Industry and Commerce or any individual to start any industry in the country. There is nothing to be proud of in setting up an industry that ignores the consumers' interests, which has a monopoly to produce any kind of article, whether it is good or indiferent, and charge their own price for it. That is the position that many industries in this country enjoy at the present time and that is what the Minister has stated himself is the position in many of these industries. There is no competition. The protective barrier is so high that it gives them the opportunity to be inefficient. Their output is low, and the price they charge for the article they manufacture is out of all proportion to the profit earned in agriculture. I take the Minister at his word and I expect the Minister to do something about it. I hope the Minister will make particular reference to it when he is replying.
My suggestion to the Minister is that the only really effective way to deal with inefficiency and low output in industry in this country is to lower the barrier and to allow a measure of competition that would secure efficiency and adequate output. Agriculture in this country has always had to compete against efficient and modern methods of production in the various agricultural countries in the world. It has had to compete in an open market. If we have failed within recent years to meet that competition it is because burdens have been placed on our shoulders that we cannot bear. The predecessor of the present Minister was very fond of making references to a balanced economy. As far as profit-earning goes, the balance in our economy at the present time is altogether in favour of industry, to the detriment of agriculture. In referring to the turf schemes, the Minister said —
"I should hesitate to say that it is as yet certain we shall succeed".
Are we to take it that this is still an experiment and that there is a possibility of failure in some of these schemes? We put £200,000 into Carbury Bog and had no hesitation in burying it there. When it came to affording help to agriculture by providing a subsidy for artificial manures, in the first year, we could only afford the miserly sum of £40,000 and it was only a couple of weeks ago that we were told that, for the coming year, we would get a subsidy of £100,000. If there is one thing on which you would get an immediate return for any money spent on it in this country, it is artificial manures. If there is one thing above anything else for which there is going to be a very definite return it is the increased use of artificial manures on the land. That is the type of encouragement we get from the Government. We have no hesitation in putting large sums of money into speculative industries, into foolish projects, such as alcohol factories and other industries, and we hesitate to put money into something which, it is obvious to any man, is a sound investment in this country. I would like to say to the Minister that he ought not to follow the lines of his predecessor in developing industries by a policy of experiment, trial and error methods, because we are not sufficiently wealthy in this country to proceed along those lines and by that method.
There is only one other point I wish to refer to, that is, shipping. The Minister referred to the small percentage of our exports and imports carried by Irish shipping and he told the House that there were some proposals for the development of Irish shipping. I personally welcome those proposals. I have seen various suggestions made in the Press and we have been told that there is a huge quantity of American tonnage hung up at the present time.
Comment on this
I do not think it could disappear like that in a few days. I do not know to where it could be gone. The bombs have not reached that shipping yet. I think it is an opportunity that should not be lost sight of.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy like to pay the price? He has been talking about all the money that we are sinking in other projects. Would he like to pay the price of developing that one?
Comment on this
I admit I know nothing at all about it. It looks feasible, and it seems that there is an opportunity there, possibly, to buy it cheaply.
Comment on this
There is another point to which reference was made by Deputy Hickey, and that is the hardship imposed on workers who are drawing unemployment assistance and who get casual work. He said that that hardship applied principally to dockers.
Comment on this
Yes, casual workers, but it applies to agricultural workers as well. A farmer often wants a man for a week and, under the present regulations, it is a hardship on a man who goes to work for that week because he loses six days later in the matter of drawing unemployment assistance. That is hardly fair, and it makes for dishonesty. There is no doubt that it is an encouragement to dishonesty, and the regulations are responsible for it. You will get men to do the work and to sign on at the same time rather than do an honest week's work and suffer the loss of six days afterwards. It is hard to expect a man in poor circumstances to do the week's work that may be offered to him if he knows that he will lose six days unemployment assistance. That is a matter that should be immediately attended to. We are sometimes very critical if men are offered a week's work and they fail to turn up. Under the existing regulations they can scarcely be blamed and the Minister should remedy that matter. If a man is required only for a week he should get the unemployment benefit immediately he becomes unemployed.
Comment on this
I had hopes that the assistant Minister was going to give me a further opportunity of listening to the Government defence in relation to the proposal to refer this Vote back for reconsideration. Apparently the Minister gave him the wink to sit down. It is quite true that the Minister has not, as he was in the habit of doing in the past, painted a rosy picture of the present or the future position of the country. He did not dwell on any proposals which the Government may have in mind for the solution of the unemployment problem or the reduction of the number unemployed. In my opinion, the position in the country, particularly in the towns and villages, is going to be worse—and it is bad enough at the moment. It is true that the increase in the area of land under tillage will call for additional agricultural labourers, but the employment that will be provided will mean only casual rather than continuous employment for whatever additional number of agricultural labourers are brought on the land.
There are many ways in which the number of registered unemployed could be reduced, if there is a desire on the part of the Minister and his colleagues to reduce them. On a number of occasions I have drawn attention to the fact—the last time was about a week ago, when we were discussing the Department of Lands—that registered unemployed were being refused work on schemes undertaken by the Department of Lands while people with other means of livelihood, people actually in other employment, were taken out of that other employment and given work. I suggest that is a wrong line of policy, if the Minister wants to reduce the number of registered unemployed and automatically reduce the amount of taxation that goes towards the payment of unemployment assistance.
I will not now go into the details of a very glaring case that I furnished recently to the Department. I gave all the essential particulars to the Minister in regard to that matter. It was in connection with a big scheme for the improvement of land in my area. I gave the names of individuals who were taken out of employment on the lands where they were working as agricultural labourers, and in one case I gave the name of an individual who was brought back from England; someone gave him the tip that work was available in the locality from which he had migrated. We are dealing with a very serious situation in the country and in all cases where Government grants are made available for the provision of employment, whether it is through land improvement work, housing schemes, the building of schools or any other work for which the taxpayers' money is provided, the first preference should be given to suitable unemployed people who are registered; that is, if there is a desire to reduce their number, and assume there is.
The Minister made a statement with regard to what has been done in connection with turf development. Previous to the Minister's speech on that very important matter, there was a reference to the same subject by the Taoiseach when he was speaking last Saturday week in Galway. He referred to the necessity for producing more turf instead of relying on imported coal, which naturally will come in decreasing quantities while the war continues. The Taoiseach, speaking on that subject, and apparently not too well informed, made an interesting statement. I am quoting from the Irish Press report, and no one opposite will contradict the statement, because it is published in the paper that does not make any mistakes when it reports Ministers, and particularly the Taoiseach. He said that everyone cutting turf in the coming season should cut three times as much as usual and wherever there were bogs around large towns and cities the people would, in his opinion, have a profitable market for turf.
That statement was, in effect, repeated by the Minister. Referring to the same subject, the Minister said that if they were to deal with an emergency shortage of fuel they must rely on the producers of hand-won turf to make good the possible, and, he should say, perhaps probable, deficiency in imported fuel. I quite agree with the Minister and the Taoiseach in giving encouragement to the people in the rural parts—and to the people in the towns if they are in a position to do so—to double or treble the quantity of turf formerly produced for the purpose of selling it locally. I am certain, so far as my constituency is concerned, that there will be a keen demand for it in the near future, if not at the present time.
I should like to know from the Minister and the Taoiseach whether they are aware of the conditions under which town tenants secure turbary rights convenient to towns, especially in the midland areas. Is the Minister aware that, in the majority of the towns in my constituency, and particularly in towns where there is a great deal of unemployment, the output or the production of turf is limited by the landlords who own the bogs? The landlords who own the bogs around thickly populated towns in many of the midland counties let only a very limited number of perches per year to the tenants on the estate, and particularly a very limited number to people living in the small towns.
Before this Government came into office, and since, I have repeatedly raised questions here concerning the activities of the Land Commission in connection with this matter. I should like the Minister to inquire, for instance, how long the Land Commission have been dealing with proposals for the acquisition of the Coote bogs around Mountrath, where there is a considerable amount of unemployment, and where there is no hope of providing work for the unemployed, except through small grants allocated by the county council for road repair work or through the Road Fund for the repair of trunk or main roads. Would the Minister also inquire how long the Land Commission have been making inquiries in connection with the acquisition of bogs on the Ross estate convenient to Birr, where at the moment there is a considerable amount of unemployment, and would he make the same inquiries in regard to the bogs around Mountmellick, Edenderry, Tullamore and other towns in these areas? I think he will be satisfied as a result that the bogs are owned by landlords who make only limited lettings and that there cannot, under existing circumstances, be the increased output which the Taoiseach and he demand, and with which I agree.
It is a serious matter for every citizen and it is a serious thing to have to state here that there is an avenue for increased employment through turf development, but that the people who want to produce more turf cannot get the letting on the bogs which they might be able to secure if the bogs were owned by other persons. I suggest that the Minister, when making these inquiries, or when getting his colleague, the Minister for Lands, to make these inquiries, should ask for information as to the extent to which the bad condition of bog roads makes it impossible for large numbers of people to get turf out of the bogs when it has been cut, and particularly if the weather is wet. These are lines which, I think, can be pursued with effect, if the Department of Lands would get a little busier and make it possible for the people, for the unemployed and for all classes of people who want to use turf, to get turf from the bogs, in the immediate vicinity of towns and, especially, towns in the midland areas.
I should like to hear from the Minister, also—and nobody can give us more reliable information on the subject—what his opinion is of the recent experiment of bringing down young single men from Dublin for employment on Clonsast Bog, the conditions under which they were employed there and the reasons, if any, which they gave for leaving, together with a statement as to the number out of the total taken down at present working there. We are entitled to that information, and I am sure that the Minister, who must have it at his finger tips, will have no hesitation in giving it. I was personally rather surprised to see the Department looking for single men from Dublin for the purpose of experimenting under certain conditions with turf-cutting on Clonsast Bog. Since my childhood days, I know that turf-cutting is a very laborious kind of work.
Comment on this
The Minister says it is not? The next time he is near Clonsast bog, let him have a look at the type of work being carried on there.
Comment on this
Was the Deputy ever on a Monaghan bog and did he ever see the people who were doing the work there?
Comment on this
No, I confess I was not; but I can tell the Minister that I have watched people cutting turf in a bog since my childhood, and 34 or 35 years ago in my native part of the country, where the people have always relied upon turf for fuel purposes, turf cutting was always regarded as laborious work and was paid for in those days at a far higher rate than any other kind of work in connection with agricultural employment, if it could be called agricultural employment. I can tell the Minister that, 30 or 35 years ago, men employed by farmers to cut turf in my part of the country were never paid less than 5/- a day and that some were paid up to 7/6 a day. The fact that they had to be paid such high rates in those days must be some evidence that the work was more difficult and laborious than ordinary agricultural labour.
I am interested to learn the reasons why the Department, or the Turf Development Board, for whose activities the Minister is responsible, sought single men from Dublin for carrying out certain experiments at Clonsast. The reason I ask is that I thought that, in the ordinary course of events, if they were looking for men who would continue to work on a bog, men with knowledge and experience of turf-cutting operations, they would have gone to the areas where men were unemployed in the parts of the country in which they know something about the business. I am interested to hear why they came to Dublin to look for young. single men to come down there, the majority of whom, I am informed; have returned to Dublin.
The Minister in his statement also dealt with the position of his Department in connection with mineral development. I am glad to recognise the fact that his Department, and particularly quite recently, has been giving evidence of its desire to encourage the development of our mineral resources. I know that a small sum of money was provided for boring purposes in Wolfhill, a coal-bearing area, which has been the subject of many discussions in this House, and I should like to hear from the Minister whether he has yet received from his official advisers any report on the results of the borings carried out for some time past in that area, whether he has come to any decision and what assistance he proposes to give to those who are prepared to put private capital into the development of that coal-bearing area, if there are people available who are prepared to risk their money in mineral development there.
I am reliably informed that such people are available and I would be glad to hear from the Minister as to what assistance he is prepared to give to them. Would he say what evidence he has in his possession regarding the results of the work already carried out there? I have looked recently at certain work being carried out there in fairly difficult circumstances, and notice that a considerable quantity of coal has been secured in the rough-and-ready way in which the work has been carried on.
In one of the areas where this coal is being obtained the work is being hindered seriously as a result of the refusal of somebody—the Board of Works, the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the local authority—to provide a reasonably small grant to make roads into the place where these mining operations are being carried on. Would the Minister look into that matter sympathetically and see if a grant can be made for the making or repair of roads under the control of the local authority? An application was made, in the first instance, to the local authority and it was turned down, the person in charge saying that it was a matter for the Board of Works. The Board of Works, in turn, referred the applicants to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the application has has been going in this way on an excursion from one person to another. I wonder if it has yet arrived at the proper centre for sympathetic consideration and if the Minister will say whether he is prepared to recommend the allocation of a small grant to enable work to be carried on under better circumstances than those which I have observed recently. The case has been put very well to the Department concerned and it has been pointed out that, as a result of this boring work in the centre to which I refer, 45 men are getting work. These men would otherwise be unemployed and in receipt of unemployment assistance. There should be some money available in the coffers of some Government Department to make proper roads into places where this work is being done.
I am not sure of the exact position, but would ask the Minister whether he has received any representations regarding the possibility of developing the mineral resources at Killeshin and Rossmore in Laoighis, convenient to Carlow. I understand that, in years gone by, certain Departmental officials made a survey in that area. People are prepared to put money into its development and it appears to them that, with some Government assistance and encouragement, good-class coal can be mined there and that a good quantity can be produced there per week, with considerable employment as a result. If the matter has not been brought under the personal notice of the Minister, I should be glad if he would inquire into it and see what can be done.
There is another matter which I have raised in this House by way of public question on more than one occasion, namely, the refusal of the Minister and his predecessors to publish the report of the Transport Tribunal, or to give some understandable reason for the failure to do so. On the 8th November, 1939, and again on 21st February, 1940, I raised this question in the House. The Minister informed me that the failure to publish the report of this public tribunal up to the 21st February last was due to the fact that certain consultations were going on between certain Department officials.
Comment on this
In the reply to the question addressed to the Minister on 21st February last, the Minister said:
"I am not yet in a position to indicate when the reports received from the Transport Tribunal will be published, as the consultations with other Departments to which I referred in my reply to the Deputy's question on 8th November last have not yet concluded."
Comment on this
I should not like the Deputy to get the impression that it was merely consultation between Departmental officials which was holding up this matter.
Comment on this
I do not wish to say that, as I know that they are not doing so. This tribunal was set up by resolution in this House on the 7th December, 1938. In moving the motion to set it up the then Minister for Industry and Commerce said he expected that the report of the tribunal would be available for Deputies on resumption of the Dáil after the Christmas Recess, that is to say, on the 8th February, 1939 As the report of the debate will show, I indicated that I was doubtful personally whether such a very important matter could be disposed of satisfactorily inside a period of two months. However, it turned out that the commission furnished its report in six months, instead of in two months as anticipated by the Minister, and the report or reports are in the hands of the Minister for ten months. In the Minister's opinion they should have reported in two months: they reported in six. In spite of the fact that we were told previously—as far back as 1931— that the Government had a clear policy on this question, they have not yet seen fit to publish that report and have not announced to the House or to the country what they propose to do arising out of its submission.
The Minister does not require me, I am sure, to remind him of the public pledges given by himself and his predecessor —particularly by his predecessor—in regard to Government policy for the solution of the transport problem.
Comment on this
The Minister was committed by his colleague and the Minister, having collective responsibility, surely is not going to repudiate the policy which was put before the House as far back as the 9th December, 1931.
Comment on this
On the 9th December, 1931—reported in the Dáil Debates, column 2645—Deputy Lemass said:—
"I think there are no Deputies who will deny that preservation of the railways is essential to the industrial development of the country."
I should like to hear Deputy Childers' comment on that. Deputy Lemass continued:—
"If we are seeking unified control we must also make up our minds that public ownership of these services is desirable, if not essential."
That is a fairly clear-cut sentence. However, the Minister came into office in the early part of January, 1932, and the next thing we heard of Government policy in regard to transport was the introduction of the Railways and Transport Acts in 1933. Speaking on the conclusion of that debate, the Minister's predecessor said that the position created by this policy would ensure that traffic will be carried on the railways and roads at the lowest economic rates which would be sufficient to give a reasonable return on the capital invested. He wound up with a remarkable prophecy—which has not turned out to be true:—
"That is what we are aiming at and that is what we will achieve."
That is definite language. He announces a policy in 1931 and implements it in 1933, and I should now like to hear from the Minister who has succeeded him—accepting his share of responsibility for Government policy —whether he is satisfied that nothing further requires to be done to patch up our transport system or to put it on a sound financial foundation. In other words, is it the opinion of the Government that nothing further requires to be done in regard to the present position of the transport industry? When introducing the motion in this House on the 7th December, 1938, the then Minister— Deputy Lemass—said:—
"The Government are satisfied that a major decision on transport policy must now be taken."
I am tracing the history of Government policy from 1931 to 1933, and then on to the 7th December, 1938. Apparently the Minister does not know what to do.
Comment on this
Has the Minister read the evidence given by the General Manager of the Great Southern Railways before the National Railway Wages Board, or has he any information regarding the financial position of the Great Southern Railways? In opposing a recent application before that board for an increase in the rates put forward to meet the increased cost of living, the general manager, amongst other things, said in his opening remarks:
"The applications are opposed on three main grounds in the following order of importance: (1) the absolute inability of the company to meet essential expenditure and fixed charges, if labour costs are further increased."
Dealing with that aspect of the matter later on in his remarks and after submitting to the members of the tribunal up-to-date evidence of the financial position in a confidential way—I am not quoting the document, but it would be quite easy to get it—he said:
"It will be noted that in our revenue estimates for the current year we perforce have had to leave out all provision for renewals of rolling-stock notwithstanding that a large number of wagons particularly are urgently required."
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy is getting into a general discussion of railway policy, a matter which is outside the Minister's Department.
Comment on this
I was attempting to give some information to the Minister which I thought, from the way in which he looked around, he had not in his possession.
Comment on this
For what reason, if you do not mind telling me, Sir? I am not challenging your ruling.
Comment on this
I do not think it is a matter for which the Minister is responsible. The Deputy is dealing with the administration of the railway company.
Comment on this
When the Ceann Comhairle was in the Chair, I attempted to raise this matter on the Budget Resolution and I was definitely informed then that I would be allowed to raise it on this Vote.
Comment on this
I want to attach responsibility to the Minister's Department for railway policy in this country.
Comment on this
He can get that control and he has the power, if he has the will and courage, to use it. Does the Minister suggest that he has no existing power to deal with the precarious position of our railways.
Comment on this
If the Deputy can relate his remarks to the Minister's responsibility in connection with the Department, I have no objection.
Comment on this
I am relating it to the proposal of the Government so long ago as the 7th December, 1938, to set up a tribunal to inquire into transport at the public expense and their refusal to furnish us with a copy of the report of that tribunal. If the Minister or his predecessor comes and asks the House to set up a tribunal at the public expense to inquire into that matter, surely the people are entitled to demand and to get the reasons for withholding the report of that tribunal?
Comment on this
Are we not entitled to get a statement from the Minister as to whether he has any intention at any time during the lifetime of the present Government to put the transport industry on a proper foundation? I could give him a good deal of information but, Sir, in deference to your ruling, I shall leave it over until some future date.
Another question which I want to ask on this Estimate is whether the Minister is in a position, as I understand he should be, to give the House any information regarding the future of the malting industry. With other colleagues of mine, I have been engaged for a period of a year and a half in endeavouring to persuade a particular brewing concern in the country not to close down one of the oldest malthouses in my constituency, situated in the town of Mountmellick. The Minister's predecessor made representations to the firm concerned over a year ago and the brewery, the biggest in the country, notwithstanding all the representations made by the Minister, decided to close down that malthouse after the work, connected with last year's malting season, had finished. However, representatives of the local authority in the town and of all parties interested in preserving that concern which gave valuable employment, though not full-time employment, for about six months of the year to about 80 families, succeeded in getting an extension of the time until this year for carrying on the business in Mountmellick. Notwithstanding the fact that further pressure was brought to bear on the firm to carry on for at least another year, or until somebody could see daylight in regard to the future not alone of this country but of the world, the firm, I understand, definitely decided recently to close down the malthouse at Mountmellick. That is a serious matter for the 80 families who will be affected.
I am raising the matter because I was given to understand that the present Minister had been consulted on this whole question quite recently. I am not giving anything away when I say that it was definitely indicated in a public statement issued last year that a considerable number of other malt-houses were likely to be closed down in other parts of the country in the very near future or as opportunity offers, as the statement said. A statement published in the Press last year, and issued by the firm of Messrs. Guinness, gave the reasons for the closing down of the malthouse at Mountmellick. Included in that statement was this paragraph:
The excess malting capacity is so great that it cannot be allowed to continue indefinitely, and from time to time malthouses must be closed as opportunity offers.
Comment on this
People can come along and consult me, but I have no function in regard to malthouses. I cannot compel people to keep them open if they feel that they must close them.
Comment on this
But surely the Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned with the unemployment that will be caused by the closing down of these malthouses?
Comment on this
I may be concerned with that, but I have no power to run people's businesses for them. The Deputy knows that is a silly idea.
Comment on this
I know perfectly well that you have no power to suspend the operations of this House and close it down. Apply that to every activity affecting the individual life of the citizens and you come to the conclusion that there is no necessity for a Government, no necessity for Parliament. You can shut down this House——
Comment on this
The Minister has power, with the clear majority that is behind him who will vote for anything, to take whatever steps are reasonable to prevent public concerns from closing.
Comment on this
I admit that the Minister is a sort of superman, and that we have not any such men in the Labour Party.
Comment on this
That is sticking out, especially to the Minister. At any rate, I want to ask the Minister to state to what extent he has consulted and to what extent, if any, he has endeavoured to use the influence which his Ministerial position gives him to persuade Messrs. Guinness not to proceed any further with this kind of policy under existing circumstances. Nobody on the board of Messrs. Guinness, or, indeed, in the Ministry can say what the position of this country, or of the malting industry or any other industry, will be this day 12 months.
Comment on this
For that reason the Minister might be able to use his well-known eloquence with the directors of Messrs. Guinness and Co. to stay their hand, not to pursue this policy any further, until they are able to see, so to speak, daylight in regard to the internal as well as the international situation.
Comment on this
The Minister committed himself, in writing, to the statement that he could not do anything further last year to prevent this firm from closing down this malthouse at Mountmellick. But, last year, a deputation representative of all classes of the local people, and of the Parliamentary representatives for the constituency, succeeded where, apparently, the Minister had failed.
Comment on this
They succeeded, as the Deputy knows well, upon terms: that a certain sum was to be placed at the disposal of the people employed in Mountmellick on condition that the malthouse was closed.
Comment on this
That is what the success was, and the Deputy should be frank with the House and say that. The Deputy was on the deputation, and, I believe, he knows what the conditions were.
Comment on this
I want to be quite frank with the House and with the Minister and to say that that question was never discussed: the question of accepting monetary compensation in lieu of continued employment in the malthouse. I stated, speaking for myself, that I should prefer to see the money that was offered used for the purpose of continuing employment there.
Comment on this
It was not offered in compensation. It was offered as an ex gratia grant to relieve hardship. What is the use of the Deputy putting it that way?
Comment on this
I want to assure the Minister—my colleagues in this House who accompanied me can contradict me if I am wrong—that we did not accept, although it was offered, compensation as an alternative to the continuance of employment in the malthouse.
Comment on this
The Deputy is misusing the word "compensation". It was not compensation. It was a grant which the firm, at their own discretion, proposed to give in order to relieve the possible hardship that would ensue on the closing down of the malthouse. It was not compensation, and if the Deputy wants the matter to be dealt with he ought to be frank and clear about it.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's correction—that the sum offered was the equivalent of one year's wages or salary to every person employed in the concern in the previous year. I can quote from the document if the Minister wants any further argument on that.
Comment on this
I am raising the question for the purpose of asking the Minister whether he can do anything to prevent this firm from pursuing this policy under present circumstances. I think that he could use considerable influence with the board of Messrs. Guinness & Company in a matter of this kind, and I want to give him every encouragement. I would urge him, in view of the existing circumstances in the towns concerned, to use his influence in that direction. This is the fourth malthouse that has been closed by this firm in my constituency. We do not want any more of them closed. There are some still there.
There is one other matter that I want to refer to. It was raised, in the course of the discussion this evening, by Deputy McCann, who more or less encouraged the Minister to proceed to introduce legislation for the establishment of industrial courts: in effect, encouraging the Minister to say that he was in favour of compulsory arbitration. I should be interested to hear what Deputy Childers has to say on that matter. I hope that he will speak on this before the debate concludes. I should like to hear from Deputy Childers quite frankly the reasons, if any, why he favours compulsory arbitration. There has been a good deal of talk about uncalled-for strikes, lightning strikes, but there has been no reference from the people who have been making these statements in this House to those who lock-out workers. I should like to hear from the Minister what is his opinion, if he has any opinion or information, in connection with the dispute that has been going on for a number of weeks at the Castlecomer collieries. Is it a fact that the man who is in charge of the Castlecomer collieries refused to agree to arbitration for the purpose of settling the dispute which has been forced on the workers—the miners working in Castlecomer? I know something about the conditions of the miners employed in the Castlecomer collieries. With a very prominent member of the Minister's Party, who is now a member of the other House, I helped to settle a strike that took place in the Castlecomer collieries about nine years ago. I know the conditions under which it was settled. These conditions are in writing, and I imagine that a copy of them is in the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Has the Minister made any inquiries concerning the reasons which have led up to the present stoppage, and does he agree that the employer concerned in this case is justified in refusing to submit the issues in dispute to arbitration? What is the case on the other side? I am sure Deputy Childers knows something about this case because he is one of the most influential men in the Saorstát Federation of Industries, and surely the dispute in the Castlecomer collieries has been the subject of serious consideration by the executive of that organisation. The Minister—in this everybody agrees with him—is giving every encouragement, I am prepared to admit, to those who are prepared to cut more turf and produce more coal. Yet, in spite of that we find those workers walking about Castlecomer for the last five or six weeks simply because the man who owns the mines, mines which should be the property of the nation if things were right, refuses to submit the issue in dispute to arbitration. The price of the coal sold in Castlecomer is now about 3/6 per ton more than what it was when the last dispute was settled, while the men are earning less to-day than they were at that time. The man who owns the mine refuses to cough up any of the increased profits which he is getting out of the working of that mine to the people who have helped him to make that increased profit. Let us have a word on this important matter from Deputy Childers and the Minister.
Comment on this
In the discussions on the Estimate for this Department in previous years we have been told by the members of the Opposition of the advantages of buying in the cheapest market and of the madness of putting a protective policy into operation.
Comment on this
I have asked the Deputy who made the statement.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy now quoting what Deputy Hughes said?
Comment on this
Deputy Hughes asked the Minister to lower the tariff barrier.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say if he is quoting Deputy Hughes?
Comment on this
I simply wanted to call the bluff of the Minister.
Comment on this
Deputy Hughes spoke of inefficiency, due to low output, as he said, in a number of our industries——
Comment on this
What Deputy Hughes said was that it was the Minister who said that.
Comment on this
——and that all that was having a disastrous effect on the agricultural industry.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now suffering from the effects of making a stock speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Hughes, of course, made very general charges against the inefficiency of our industries. He did not give us any proof that would lead us to identify any of these industries. There are very many industries supplying the farmer with his agricultural implements. I would like to know the particular industries to which the Deputy refers when he says that there is inefficiency and lower output and that these are having a disastrous effect upon agriculture.
Comment on this
The Deputy told us that they had to pay more for motor tyres here than in Northern Ireland. I do not see how he could put that down to the manufacturers here.
Comment on this
Motor tyres. We have efficiency in our factories although we have been told here year after year about inefficient factories closing down. Nevertheless, they are standing up now, or at all events a majority of them are standing up, to strong world disturbances. That cannot be denied, even though the cost of raw materials where the raw materials have to be imported, and the cost of transport during the past year have enormously increased, they are standing up satisfactorily to it all. The price of commodities—the price of the manufactured article here—has not been increased to any considerable extent. There has been one statement made in connection with the matter of producing 100 per cent. of our requirements here. The trouble is that we are up against the mentality of certain people who believe that foreign goods are better than Irish-manufactured goods. These are people with the mentality that they are prepared to pay a higher price for the foreign goods. In the face of that I would say that imported articles should not be allowed into this country if similar goods are manufactured here, because it is unfair to those who purchase Irish-manufactured goods. The greater the amount of goods manufactured in any particular industry the lower will be the price of the manufactured article. We usually find that overhead charges in industries and in factories would be about the same for the production of double the amount or double the output ordinarily produced. Practically the same overhead charges are incurred if a firm is manufacturing for the whole market, as if it were manufacturing for portion of that market. If Irish goods are good enough for the majority of our people, I think they should be good enough for the minority. I believe that people should not be given an opportunity of purchasing foreign goods at 50 per cent. or 100 per cent. increase in the price as compared with the native goods——
Comment on this
That sort of speech injures Irish industries.
Comment on this
——as this has the effect of increasing the cost of the Irish article. The larger the output of the Irish article the lower necessarily will be the price. That in itself is an important consideration. We are all agreed, I think, that we require more industries. The agricultural industry, even though it is the chief industry of the land, will be found incapable of giving employment to all our workers. Consequently, it is necessary to supplement the agricultural industry by having manufacturing industries running alongside it. The need for the expansion of our industries is still very large. There may be difficulties in the way of having an export market at present, but let us remember that there is still a very large field for expansion in the home market. We know that there are a number of articles that can be manufactured under mass-production methods in other countries that could possibly be manufactured here. These could not compete in price with the article coming in from the foreign country, produced under the mass production methods. On the other hand, money spent on purchasing foreign goods is money lost to this country. Consequently, we should examine the position and find out if it would be possible to avert such a loss. As we are aware, there are some industries that are uneconomic and could not be undertaken here by private enterprise and with the amount of local capital that would be available. I think it would be advisable in such cases to consider whether such industries should be assisted by the State. We should not calculate the gains to the country by reference to the ordinary balance sheet of an industry. Rather should we have regard to the amount of money kept at home and expended amongst our own people. I believe that the time has arrived for a definite drive towards producing all our requirements here. I must say that a good deal has been done during the two years that Fianna Fáil has been in office. Our people expect that more will be done in the future. A reference to the volume of our imports will give us to understand that such expansion is possible.
When the Minister was speaking he stated that home investments by our citizens were as likely to be as stable and safe as any investments on earth. Irish investors have over £200,000,000 invested in foreign stocks and shares. Most of that money is helping foreign industrialists to manufacture goods for other countries and for our own country. We should strive to obtain some of this money for investment in production here at home. It would be a patriotic thing for those men who own foreign securities and foreign shares to bring back the money and invest it here——
Comment on this
However, patriotism is one thing and it is always necessary to consider the financial aspect of the situation. I suppose it would be impossible at the moment to bring these investments home. However, there may be some money that the investors could make available for home investments. It strikes me that it might be advisable for the Minister to consider the possibility of offering a guarantee of a small dividend for any money invested in new industries in this country which might possibly afterwards turn out uneconomic. That may be a new idea. But under the eye of the Government and under proper control and management it is not likely that this guarantee would have to be paid, at least not to any great extent. The money that would be subsequently saved as a result of the saving of grants and doles would more than make up for such deficiencies in dividends and the country would benefit. We would have a good market for our stock exchange transactions, the capital could be realised at any time and new capital would be secured. I believe the time has arrived when we should have a broad survey of the whole problem. I believe the Minister, who is very anxious to see our industrial position improved, will give the country the necessary lead. This would enable us to withstand the conditions during the war and enable us also to stand up to the aftermath of the war.
Comment on this
One little matter has been referred to here by Deputy J.P. Kelly and that is the very serious question of the production of turf. It is evident that fuel is going to be a difficult problem for this country in the coming winter, and going to be a more difficult problem as the war goes on. In this connection, the Taoiseach, very properly, has warned everybody to cut and stack up as much turf as possible; but in this connection also there is some evidence that a certain amount of gross profiteering has been going on. A reference has been made by, I think, Deputy Davin, to the effect that certain landlords in possession of turbary rights, to which poor people have access, have increased the prices for access to turbary enormously. Now, I do not know whether these people hold these bogs from the Land Commission or otherwise, but it may be thought that the poor people to whom I refer have access to these bogs without any kind of charge. That is not so. The poor people, in County Cork at least, usually pay 30/- per season, and I believe that that has been very much increased, by the present landowners, even by as much as 100 per cent.
I do not know whether or not it is the Minister for Industry and Commerce who has to deal with that matter, but I do suggest that it is a matter that calls for attention by the Minister or by some other Minister. I think that the Minister could deal with this matter through the Prices Commission and I also believe that, no matter by whom the matter may be dealt with, an order should go forth as soon as possible to make it a penal offence to charge more than the 1938 price for turbary rights of this kind. I am putting this matter forward in order to show that these landlords, holding these bogs, are carrying on in this rapacious way, and I think it would be a very serious crime and a grave infliction on the people living close to these bogs if these increased prices for turbary rights are to be inflicted on them by the land owners.
Comment on this
In connection with the Estimate for the Department of Industry and Commerce, I think it is very gratifying to notice that we no longer generalise so violently, as we used to do in this House, on the question of the benefits to be achieved as a result of industrial development in this country. Industrial development has now come to be regarded as a national problem, not only as a Party problem. We no longer regard ourselves either as free traders or as protectionists, from the Party point of view, but realise that the whole question must be regarded from the really national point of view, and I think it is necessary that, in discussing any Estimate such as this, we must preserve a very balanced point of view. Quite obviously, a high tariff policy alone cannot wreck or impede a policy of production in this country. Such a policy could not wholly prevent an increase in agricultural production, or be responsible for a diminution in agricultural production in the country. Quite obviously, the price of goods sold in this country has a bearing on agricultural production in this country. It is a remarkable fact that, since 1926, the net output of industry in this country has steadily increased— increased very slowly from 1926 to 1931, and very rapidly since then. It is also a remarkable fact that, while there has been that increase in industrial production, the agricultural output of this country has not increased to any degree and, in fact, has diminished to a certain extent in the last few years. As a matter of fact, our agricultural output decreased during the first years of the present Administration and recovered afterwards. At any rate, it is rather extraordinary that industrial production in this country has increased to a great extent since 1926, and that agriculture has not increased. We, on this side of the House, at any rate, can say that, as a result of our efforts, there has been an increase in net output— covering wages, salaries, profits and the general cost of manufacture—of something like £10,000,000. I mention that sum, because it is the net output — which is the important factor—and not the gross output.
Comment on this
I think I have already dealt with that, and I am only trying now to make a balanced statement.
Comment on this
At any rate, I can say that, so far as the present crisis is concerned, we have every reason to believe that the present Government's policy is the right policy. It is far easier at the present time to procure raw materials from abroad than to procure the finished article, and I think that therefore, the Government's policy of encouraging the production of as great a proportion of the raw materials of industry as could be produced here has been proved right ten times over since the war started. Anyone connected with trade or industry can tell the House that, in the case of the majority of raw materials of any industry, it is much easier to get in the raw materials than to get in the finished article—in other words, that it is much easier to procure shirtings than to procure shirts, or to procure hides than to procure boots or shoes. Now, when we come to commodities, of which the raw materials are native products, the Government's policy has been proved to be more than right. I refer to such commodities as bricks, tiles, cement, and so on, where most of the raw materials are native. There we have a tremendous advantage in having these industries already created. As far as the future is concerned, and as far as the possibilities of future industrial development in this country is concerned, we have to divide that problem into two parts: first, the question of industries which, in the "ersatz" sense, would be described as industries that would be useful during the war, and for nothing else, and, secondly, the long-term industries that would be useful to the country, apart from the war. So far as an industry that would be useful during the war is concerned, quite obviously, turf is the most important at the moment, from the point of view of fuel, and I should like to hear from the Minister whether he has any plans for the further development of turf in this country and whether he has taken into consideration the question of the time factor. There is no question that all of us in this House should advertise the fact that, when coal reaches £3 or over £3 a ton, hand-won turf, at its present price, has the same calorific value as coal.
Of course, as far as what one might call long-term industrial development in this country is concerned, I agree with the Minister's statement that the possibilities there are definitely limited, or at least limited to a certain degree. I very much doubt, however, if we can increase the net output of this country by very much more than £3,000,000 per annum in that particular regard, and therefore we have to develop, as far as possible, an extension of our existing industries and also try to increase the consumption of the goods produced by these industries. I think that there again arises the question as to what is going to happen to our industrial progress when the present hostilities end and when agriculture in this country is going to be faced with a very severe deflation in prices. Quite obviously, when hostilities end, we shall have to consider the whole question as to whether we are producing sufficient per worker in this country, whether our production is sufficient to enable the farmers to go on competing in a market where competition will be fiercer than ever and prices lower than ever.
I think it is just as well that the House should examine realistically the position of our industries. Our industries might be described as being on the border-line as regards consumption. There are a great number of them for which there is only just an adequate population to consume their goods at an economic rate. A great number of them quite definitely would like to see a very much larger consumption of their products before they can regard themselves as being economically sound. A great number of them find that a very small shift in the price of a product immediately diminishes consumption. To give an ordinary common example. If you increase the price of a certain type of mattress commonly used in this country by as little as 2/- on the original price of 19/-, you will practically cut out the sale of these mattresses, because the people will buy a mattress of an inferior quality at a lower price. The whole question of consumption and price must obviously be studied to the greatest possible extent if industry is to prosper.
When we examine the return from industrial development and revival, and the dividends paid by new industries, we find that we must speak guardedly in many cases. Generally speaking, it may be described as variegated. Some of the larger industries with a virtual monopoly have not paid a proper dividend on their ordinary shares; others have managed to do so. In some of the small industries, there is evidence of great prosperity; in others, there is a failure to pay dividends. I think the whole matter is connected with consumption and price, and with the ability of the agricultural community to consume the products of industry when they are produced for them.
We have the position that we have given employment to 50,000 more persons in industry as a result of protection and, to my mind, it is a question as to whether the Government have gone far enough in securing for this country an adequate output at adequately low prices for the goods produced in our industries. I speak more or less in a speculative vein. I speak principally as a representative of an agricultural constituency. The Government have interfered in private commerce in this country to a very considerable degree in the past eight years. They have interfered through tariffs and quotas in a variety of things that people consume. They have interfered very drastically in the social conditions under which our working people operate. They have interfered in the degree to which capital can be used for the promotion of new industries. They have interfered in the general position in regard to revenue by obtaining large sums in revenue through tariffs on our industries. They have insisted that conditions for workers should be adequate. In other Departments of State they have insisted that houses, when they are made the subject of a grant, should be built efficiently and finished properly. They have insisted, when improvement grants are given to agriculturists, that the work should be done adequately and finished properly. But they have never yet interfered, so far as private commerce is concerned, by insisting on sufficient output in our industries. They have never yet examined the question of output. They have never yet made the standard of output an absolute sine qua non for the continuance of protection. The reason is quite obvious—that it is a very difficult thing to do.
But I myself question whether we are not living in a vacuum created by high tariffs; whether we can continue to allow the whole question of output in an industry to be regulated by the industry alone without regard to the national economy as a whole and without great harm being done to our agricultural production. I should like the Minister, if he wishes to speak, let us say, speculatively and not to commit himself, to let the House know whether there is some particular reason why there should be interference in pratically every aspect of our economic life and no interference in the question of the standard of output of our industries and in the standard of the output of the workers themselves and in relating industrial output, profits, wages and salaries to the nation's economy as a whole.
Comment on this
I think I have already indicated that the principal lack of output is due to the fact that agricultural output has never shown an adequate expansion in this country. If we had a larger consuming power in our population we would be able to absorb far more of the products of industry.
Comment on this
As far as industrial output is concerned, responsibility is shared between the workers and the employers definitely and absolutely, and shared in proportions that it would be hard for the House or anyone not acquainted intimately with industry to determine. That output is an essential factor in our future prosperity is evident from examining the figures for output in this country as compared with England. We cannot escape from the fact that the farmers produce the raw materials for industry, and they will have to go on doing that as long as this country is in its present position and as long as we lack the essential raw materials for our industrial workers.
The output of industrial goods in this country should be on the same basis of comparison as the output of industrial goods in England. That situation, as far as we know, will continue, no matter what circumstances come on us. The figures for output per person in this country and in England show that something needs to be done about this matter. The figures, as given in the Census of Production for 1936, give a series of examples. For example, in the woollen and worsted industry, the output per person in Ireland is £134 worth per annum, and in the United Kingdom £179. In the fellmongery and leather industry it is £181 here, and in the United Kingdom, £213. The figures vary; some of them are fairly satisfactory; but most of them show a very definitely inadequate production in this country per worker. Obviously we can never have mass production such as there is in the large scale industries in England, but the fact remains that the discrepancies are too wide and, somehow or other, they will have to be narrowed.
There is no possible way by which the output in this country can increase except by the personal effort of employers and workers; and the personal relations between employers and workers, I venture to say, having regard to the fact that we call ourselves Christian, could scarcely be worse than they are at present.