Committee on Finance. - Vote 55—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).
Contributions 129–250 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The relationship between employers in industry and workers, with definite exceptions, shows an attitude of mutual suspicion, an attitude of boss versus worker, an attitude which has created dictatorships in many countries and paralysed industry in many countries at previous times. That is an absolute fact that cannot be denied. Moreover, in many cases neither the employers nor the workers have yet been made to appreciate, either by the Government or the House, their obligation towards the community at large and the fact that the output per worker and the price of the goods they sell are a vital consideration for agriculture. I suggest that if industry is to prosper in this country something should be done by the Government whereby the nation as a whole would have a right to present a view through some Government institution as to what the output of any industry should be, what the remuneration of its workers should be, and what the profit should be in that industry.
It is with a view to that, that I suggest to the Minister that the question of the formation of some kind of industrial court is one of supreme importance to this country. When one examines the human relations between employers and workers, as far as industrial disputes are concerned, the figures are disgraceful to a democracy. Taking the years 1934 to 1936, inclusive, the average number of persons on strike per year was 9,400, or 2.23 per cent. of occupied persons, other than those in agriculture, fishing or administration. Of the 9,400 persons on strike in every year, 3,600 were on strike for 11 days or less, and two-thirds of the total were on strike for more than 11 days. When these figures are compared with the position in England it will be found that the average number on strike per year in England was 240,000, or 1.1 per cent. of the persons I mentioned, or just about half the numbers here. What is far more important is that they were only on strike for an average of six days per worker during the whole of these years, compared with our case where two-thirds were on strike over 11 days. Taking the figures from 1934 to 1937, including the year of the building strike, the average number of days on strike worked out at 35 days in this country, and six days in England.
If we eliminate from the English figures, strikes in coal mines, an industry which has suffered from depression and bad conditions, because of the mental attitude of owners and workers, the figures in this country are infinitely worse. Taking the number of strikes per 10,000 workers in eleven of the principal countries it will be found that we have a worse record, with two exceptions, than any country in Europe for strikes. I submit that that is an appalling situation. A correct mental attitude of employers and workers towards industrial production is absolutely vital if output is to improve, and nothing but a drastic revision of that outlook can possibly improve our production. I speak as the representative of an agricultural constituency, and I agree with Deputy Hughes when he emphasises the low profits in agriculture, and the fact that although indutrial costs by themselves cannot wreck or make agriculture, they have an important effect on it.
Deputy Davin raised a question as to what is to happen with regard to industrial courts, and speaking again as the representative of an agricultural constituency, having no connection with any body or any organisation, I believe that we gravely lack some kind of education, which will eliminate a hot-headed and intemperate attitude as well as ill-considered thinking from our industrial relations. I do not believe compulsory arbitration would be acceptable here, or could be imposed, or be proved anything like an unqualified success, but I do know that three of the Northern democratic countries, most of whom have socialist or quasi-socialist governments, selected principally by the workers, have been carrying on constantly during the past 20 years with legislation to benefit the workers and to improve conditions. In these three principal Northern countries legislation exists which, while leaving the workers completely free to withdraw labour, definitely delays all strike action until an impartial court can deliver a verdict. I see no reason why we should not be willing to submit to a form of legislation like that when workers in Northern democratic countries have done so, and have shown the great example to the world of orderly government and good living conditions.
Those who speak against compulsory arbitration are merely confusing the issue, because no one who has favoured it has suggested that we should remove the sacred right of the workers to withdraw their labour. I believe that strikes in public utilities should be made almost impossible—if not quite impossible—save in most exceptional circumstances. Speaking on behalf of an agricultural constituency, I believe that if employers and workers in industry are going to quarrel, my constituents, who are principally farmers, should have the right to enter into any discussions to this extent, that they should have the right to representation at the industrial court through the State, and have their point of view, as to whether or not they are able to bear any particular increase in remuneration considered. Many countries have either gone bankrupt or have had to resort to makeshifts because a section of the community operated without due regard to other sections. At the present time industry in our present circumstances is operating in a vacuum without regard to the rest of the community and, to my mind, only State action can, possibly, change that situation. The development of an industrial court would do nothing to harm the ultimate independence of the workers but would enable workers and employers to forget the immediate position created by the division of opinion, and allow the whole weight of dignified conditions to operate when discussing wages and remuneration, as well as enabling the community to give some point of view about the whole question of their attitude in relation to wages and to industry.
The future of industry in this country is very uncertain, but we can be sure of one thing, that unless workers and employers are prepared to adapt their conditions to those which are acceptable to agriculture, industry will not survive. I close with this question to the Minister, on which I would like him to give an answer: why should the State not interfere regarding standard of output as it has interfered with practically every other section of our economic life?
Comment on this
In the course of, roughly, 18 years in this House I have listened to many speeches, but I doubt if I ever listened to a stranger speech than the one we have just heard. The Deputy, of course, was obviously in a difficulty. He was trying to play hot and cold, trying to speak for agriculture without any knowledge of it, while he disclaimed speaking for any industry of which obviously he has some knowledge. The Deputy was lucky. He was very fortunate that he was not making that speech five or six years ago. Let me assure him that the most polite expression that would be used—or, should I say, that would be hurled at him?—by some of his colleagues then was that he was sabotaging Irish industry. If the Deputy suggested five or six years ago that the whole question of production and prices must be examined there would be a howl from the benches on which he sits that he was sabotaging Irish industry. I am sure that that howl would be led by Deputy Kelly.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly, of Meath. Deputy Tom Kelly would have much more sense.
Comment on this
Deputy Childers told us that he wanted to make a balanced statement, that he was anxious to hold the scales evenly. The first contribution we got from the "balanced statement" was that, over a period of years, the net output of industry in money was £10,000,000. We were told what a great benefit that was to the nation. When the Deputy was asked to give the figure for the net reduction in the output in agriculture in £s, for the same period, he refused to give it. That is called a "balanced statement". Another of the Deputy's clear and balanced statements—a statement which purported to be a just and full statement—was that we should be proud that Irish industry in the past ten years had absorbed more than 50,000 additional persons. The Deputy left it at that. Those who would not take the trouble to analyse what he said would assume that we had 50,000 more persons in employment than we had ten years ago. Nobody knows better than Deputy Childers that that is nonsense—utter nonsense. In his balanced statement, the Deputy might have told the House that, over a shorter period, according to the Government's own figures, there are more than 40,000 fewer persons engaged in agriculture. Do Deputy Childers and Deputy Kelly think that the type of speeches they made here to-day will help Irish industry? I have not heard a statement made inside or outside this House more calculated to injure Irish industry than the statement made by Deputy Kelly. I acquit the Deputy immediately of any intention to injure Irish industry but that can be the only effect of his speech. He told us that we should have whole-hog protection, that everything in this country should be put behind a tariff wall and that the Irish people should be compelled to buy these articles whether they were 100 per cent. or 150 per cent. higher in price than articles which could be got outside.
Comment on this
Perhaps I was wrong in saying 100 per cent. or 150 per cent. but he did definitely say 50 per cent. or 100 per cent.
Comment on this
Now that it is re-repeated, the Deputy finds it so absurd that he is anxious to disclaim it. I do not blame him. Deputy Childers quoted figures from some abstract relating to output. He gave us the output per £ per person in this country as against the output in England. In the interest of fair play and balanced statements, he left the figures there and asked the House and the country to assume that there were no special factors that might account for the difference. Did the Deputy ever hear anything about difference in machinery having something to do with difference in output? A man with a bad set of tools cannot be expected, even though he be as good a tradesman, to give the same output as a man with a good set of tools. No purpose is served in quoting figures like those. A man with a bicycle will cover ten miles as against the two miles covered by a man walking. You could show, in these circumstances, that an Englishman travelled ten miles while an Irishman travelled only two miles. Why should we get all this balderdash? Some of us expected a more useful contribution to a debate like this from Deputy Childers than that which he made.
To come back to the speech of the Minister, he is a man charged with many responsibilities. His Department covers more of the nation's activities, perhaps, than any other Department of State. His office is a full-time job for any man prepared to do the job. The largest of the Minister's many responsibilities has to do with unemployment and the finding of employment. The Minister touched, very lightly indeed, on that subject in his speech introducing the Estimate. He did not give us any analysis to show what the position has been or what attempt has been made to deal with it during the past few years. The Minister did not commit himself in any way as to what he hoped or expected to be able to do during the coming year. He did not give us any detailed reasons—I doubt if he gave us any reason at all—for reducing the amount provided for unemployment assistance by £70,000. Let us face the fact that we have to-day more people unemployed than we have had, perhaps, at any time in the history of the country —and that notwithstanding Deputy Childers' figure of 50,000. Let me say this to the Minister—it gives me no pleasure to say it, but it is a fact known practically to every member of this House—that British industry and British agriculture have provided more jobs for Irish unemployed in the past three or four years than either Irish industry or Irish agriculture. It gives me no pleasure to make that statement. It is not a position of which any of us can be proud. But it is a fact. Notwithstanding a rapidly decreasing population, and notwithstanding the thousands that we are told have been absorbed into industry, we still have an army—no other word would describe it—queuing up every morning at the labour exchanges throughout the length and breadth of the country.
When speaking, Deputy Norton asked what was the Government's plan for dealing with unemployment. Deputy Norton knows as well as I do that the Government has no plan for dealing with unemployment, and never had a plan. I grant that they succeeded in deceiving the unemployed into believing that they had a plan, but the fact is that they do not even pretend to have a plan to-day. Perhaps it is hardly fair to blame the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, or to put all these sins on his shoulders, because he has only been a comparatively short time in this particular Department, but, as a member of the Government, he must bear a certain amount of the responsibility. The fact is that the Government have thrown up their hands and have said: "We cannot solve this problem. We cannot even reduce the number of unemployed." In fact, the position to-day is that there is less provision for the relief of unemployment and less provision for those who are unemployed in the Estimates for this year than there has been in any year since the present Government took office. The numbers of unemployed increase, the periods of unemployment become longer, but the amount of money made available to relieve the distress arising from that unemployment becomes less and less. Having come to that conclusion, as you must come to that conclusion, there is no necessity to ask what is the Government's plan. There is not a plan. There is simply a muddle. The Government, of course, when they started playing politics with the unemployment problem, only helped to make it more difficult than it was. They are now trying to repair that mistake, but in repairing it they are inflicting very serious hardship upon genuine unemployed people in order to get at those who should never have got assistance, who only got it because their political support was required, not because they were genuinely unemployed.
Deputy Hughes made a passing reference to a matter that has been raised here before. If the regulations dealing with temporary or casual employment were framed deliberately to discourage men from accepting employment, they could not be more successful than they are. Farmers and others, ignorant of the regulations governing unemployment assistance, often say—it has been said to myself—"What is the use in talking about these men being unemployed when they will not accept work when it is offered to them?" To the person ignorant of the regulations, that may appear to be true, but the fact is that, in a great many of these cases, a man, instead of gaining anything by accepting that work, is at a substantial loss. Let me give a case in point which happened in my own county. As a result of the Government's muddling with these so-called rotation schemes, they succeeding in disemploying or securing the dismissal of a great number of men who were always in permanent employment. Those men were unemployed for about three months, and they, with a number of "casuals," on the Friday week before Christmas, got instructions from the labour exchange to go out to work on the following morning. They did so. On that Friday morning they drew their unemployment assistance. They worked all the week before Christmas, for which they got neither wages nor unemployment assistance. They did not receive one penny until the 9th January following. Those men and their families had to go through Christmas without a penny of unemployment assistance or of wages, although they had worked for more than a full week. That is the sort of thing that is supposed to encourage men to seek work, and to accept work when it is offered to them. Let me take another case which occurs under this rotation work, for which the Minister is responsible. Just to illustrate my story, let me say that two men are living side by side in Dublin. They are both married men having, say, five children each. One man gets a note from the labour exchange to go to work in the quarry the following morning, and he goes out and works in that quarry for four days, working hard all the time. He may get at the end of the week, but probably it will be at the end of a fortnight, for his four days' hard work, £1, less 1/7—18/5. His next door neighbour does not go out to work at all, and on Friday morning he can walk into the labour exchange and get his 14/-. That is the sort of scheme, and that is the sort of regulations that we are supposed to accept as a serious contribution to this terrible problem. We hear a lot of talk about the problems this country has to face, the dangers to it, and everything else. If the members of this House, and particularly Ministers, cannot see a menace in 120,000 or 130,000 unemployed men, men who are now driven to believe that there is no hope of their securing work in this country, then there is very little use in talking here at all.
I can only come to the one conclusion, that the present Government have become quite reconciled to the existence of 120,000, 130,000 or 140,000 unemployed persons as just a normal thing, something that we cannot help, that we cannot remedy, and that, therefore, they are not going to take any steps to try to deal with it or to improve it. The Minister has not indicated that the position during 1940-41 is going to be any different. Of course, none of us knows what is going to happen, but, for the moment, I have to ignore the war situation.
Comment on this
The war, to everybody in this world, is a curse, but to certain Ministers here it is a Godsend as an excuse for a lot of the problems they are not able to solve. We had not a world war in any of the last ten years, and the attitude during that ten years or the effect upon unemployment were no different from what the attitude is to-day and what the effect is likely to be in the next 12 months.
I suppose I have spoken often, perhaps more often than any other member of this House, on this question of unemployment both during the lifetime of the present Government and of their predecessors, but I do not believe that I ever felt that the position was really hopeless until now. We get no lead from the Minister. We get no insight as to any possible schemes or plans which the Ministry may have. The unemployed are told, in effect, that, notwithstanding the fact that it is going to be more difficult for them to live, notwithstanding the very large increase in the prices of the necessaries of life, the Government cannot help them, that they must provide less money for them this year than was provided last year.
The Minister takes £70,000 off the amount for unemployment assistance, and we are told that £100,000 will be made available next year to encourage the purchase of artificial manures. Again, because of the muddling of the Government this year in the matter of artificial manures, it has cost the farmers who were able to get manure far more than £100,000. The farmers, because of that muddling, were not able to get the principal manures they required in time, and many crops were left unsown because super could not be purchased. When the Government woke up months too late and removed the restrictions, the farmers and others were told that manures, which they could have and should have purchased three or four months earlier, at £4 10s. and £4 15s. a ton, could then be purchased at £7 a ton. They could have manures at £7 a ton when it was too late to use them for this season. The money that has to be provided to try to repair that sort of muddling is to be taken from the unemployment assistance contribution.
The Minister, in his capacity as Minister for Industry and Commerce, has a certain responsibility for employment exchanges, and the finding of employment for the unemployed through those exchanges. Has he made any protest to the Minister for Finance about the raiding of the Road Fund for another £150,000? Does the Minister not know that one of the main sources of employment in rural parts of Ireland is road work, and would not the £150,000 taken this year and last year from the Road Fund provide a great deal of employment? I observe that the Minister is going to make a note, and I am sure the note is going to be: "Does the Deputy suggest we are going to put another tax on tea and sugar?"
Comment on this
I knew exactly what the Minister was going to put down. The only time the taxes on foodstuffs are ever trotted out is as a cover for robbing something from the unemployed. I knew what the Minister was going to put down.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows all the answers. That is what makes the Deputy's speech seem so hollow.
Comment on this
The Minister ought not to talk about hollowness—I would not advise him to. The Minister is too vulnerable. It would not require a 70-ton tank to deal with the Minister on that. The Minister will have to think up something a little more original than the old dodge of the tax on tea and sugar. Last year he could find a very big sum for the Army; he could find great sums last year for certain measures—sums far ahead of anything we are asking for.
Comment on this
I would be intensely interested in hearing the Minister's point of order. Usually his points of order are bad ones.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that this matter can be discussed without some relation to the Budget? I want to know where the Minister is going to get all the money that is set out in the Estimate we are discussing— where he is going to get even his own salary unless it bears some relation to the Budget? The Minister has improved lately and I would not advise him to revert to his old style.
Comment on this
It took the Minister a few years before he decided to follow my example. I am not discussing the Minister and I do not want to discuss him in any capacity except in the capacity of Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am going to invite him to repair the very glaring omission in his introductory speech. I should like him to tell us whether he has even tentative plans for dealing with the unemployed. I am not one of those who suggest that the present Minister or any other Minister can cure unemployment completely in a day, in a month, in a year, or even in five years. Nobody in this country with any sense of responsibility would suggest that. The only people who have said it are the Minister and his colleagues. We do say that they ought to be able, if not to reduce it, at least to keep it from increasing and there ought to be some reflection in our unemployed figures of the 50,000 that Deputy Childers says we ought to be proud of and of the 150,000 that have gone to Britain. I do not want to go into other aspects of this Estimate, although there are a number of matters to which I would like to refer. I should like to say a few words about turf development and recent experiences and so on, but I will leave that for another occasion. I should like some definite statement from the Minister. I would be much more satisfied if he does not promise too much. I suggest that a service such as this, costing the State so much money, is entitled to much more than a passing reference from the Minister.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey has adopted the old rôle of blaming the Minister and his Party for every grievance, real or imaginary. He has made great play with the misfortunes of the unemployed, and yet he objects when an honest attempt is being made by the State to see that money that is being given to the unemployed should be returned in the form of work. Deputy Morrissey was a member of another Party in this House which controlled the reins of government until 1932. While he has given lip service here to the unemployed, neither he nor his Government made the unemployment problem a live issue or made any effort to give the unemployed money or sustenance. I will leave it at that.
I think this country was exceptionally lucky in that this Government undertook the industrial development drive, and, although it is quite possible that there may be some shortcomings here and there, it is still a very good job for the people that we now have many industries which we had not got eight years ago. As Deputy Childers has pointed out, we are in the lucky position of being able to get raw materials where it is not easy to get the finished article. There is, however, a scarcity of certain raw materials, and I ask the Minister to see that every effort will be made to develop as much as possible certain raw materials at our disposal here at home. I know, and I am pleased to learn, that a great move is being made this year for the cutting and saving of peat, and I suggest that a minimum price be offered for a good standard turf in order to encourage the cutting and saving of turf this season. If that is done, to my mind, many of the men who are either unemployed or semi-unemployed would avail of the fine weather and get down to the saving of turf. That would help to provide fuel in a period when it is scarce, and, at the same time, would enable these people to get some cash with which to provide themselves with the necessaries of life.
As I am on this question of turf development, I should like to draw the Minister's attention to the high price of coal, and to point out that, down in Munster, in the constituency which I represent, there are large coal fields. While I agree that it may not be possible to raise coal economically in normal times there, owing to the changed situation, I suggest that the testing of these coal fields in North Cork might be considered. I was glad when a steel factory was erected last year at Cobh, but from what I can gather, owing to the upheaval caused by the war, there is a great scarcity of iron and iron ore at present, and I would also draw the Minister's attention to the fact that, in a certain area in North Cork, the Araglen area, iron was mined some years ago and sent across the Channel for smelting. In view of the increased cost of iron, and the difficulty of getting the raw material as well as the manufactured article, I think this is a matter which is worth examining.
There is, then, the other very important raw material, phosphate rock. Let Deputies not think that I am raising these matters because they all have to do with North Cork. There is no phosphate that I am aware of in North Cork, but I think there is some in Clare, and with the difficulty of procuring raw phosphate, and the scarcity of the manufactured article, both native and foreign, this, too, is a question which could well be gone into by the Minister's Department in the present situation. As I said, I am pleased that we have had this industrial development in the country, and, despite the difficulties created by the war, I appeal to the Minister's Department and to industrialists not to lose heart, because, in my opinion, now is the time for our industrialists to prepare for the period of normal conditions after the war. As I am anxious to see a fair balance between agriculture and industry, I think it may be wise for our industrialists, in order to stabilise our industry here, and indirectly to help our agriculturists, to try to organise for an export trade when settled conditions return to the unfortunate Continent of Europe.
I should like to allude to another matter in regard to Deputy Morrissey. He has said that the farmers could not carry on if they had not got superphosphate. I know that there was difficulty in this matter, and I know that it was not the fault of the Minister's Department that manures were not more easily obtainable, but I do not agree with Deputy Morrissey that the farmers were unable to go ahead with their tillage programme because they had not got manures. So far as North Cork is concerned, the farmers went ahead with their tillage programme, and I am proud to say that they are doing their duty to the State and to the people in carrying out the tillage policy of the Government, and they were not hampered because of lack of manures or anything else.
Comment on this
Listening to this debate, I am inclined to feel that it would be a good thing if industry and commerce, as well as every other department of our national life, could be removed from the atmosphere of Party politics. We have listened to a very impartial and non-Party outline of the position of industry by Deputy Childers. His statement should not have been criticised as it was—I think, unfairly—by Deputy Morrissey. Deputy Childers has directed attention to what the Minister has admitted in several speeches to be a danger facing industry —the danger that people engaged in newly established industries, whether employers or employees, may come to believe that it is the duty of the Government to support those industries whether the people engaged put forward the necessary effort or not. If that feeling is allowed to grow, it will be disastrous for industrial development; it will mean that those engaged in an industry may be led to believe that, since the Government has been responsible and has taken pride in that industry having been set up through protective tariffs, they must take an interest in it, even to the extent of increasing the tariff, if necessary. That would lead to ever-increasing inefficiency.
The Minister has been right in publicly drawing the attention of those engaged in industry to the fact that the Irish people cannot afford to carry an industry on their shoulders unless the people engaged make an effort to deliver the goods at a reasonable cost. In setting out on those lines the Minister has made a good beginning. The agricultural community has got to export goods to the British market and has got to sell them at competitive prices. They cannot continue to produce, if the cost of production is increased through the increase in the cost of Irish manufactured goods. Every section of the House and every section of the community should support the Minister in demanding that a fair return be given by those engaged in industry, both manufacturers and workers, for the protection which the agricultural community is giving them.
The principal failure of the Minister's Department is the failure to relieve unemployment. It is an extraordinary state of affairs that, in such a time of national emergency as this, when many commodities are urgently needed, we still have close on 100,000 people unemployed. The chief products urgently required at the present time are food and fuel. The Minister's Department does not deal to any great extent with the production of food, but it should certainly deal with the fuel question. Many suggestions have been made for an increase in the production of turf. I feel that the Minister has failed already to face up to this problem, as a considerable portion of the season has been allowed to pass without any real effort having been made to deal with it. In districts where there are adequate supplies of turf it is ridiculous to see men cycling five or six miles to the labour exchange to register as unemployed and draw the miserable allowance provided for them.
I agree that there are many difficulties in regard to turf development. There is a difficulty in securing the right to enter into bogs in certain districts, while in other districts bogs are owned by small farmers. They have been appealed to, in public statements by the Taoiseach and Ministers and by advertisements in the Press, to increase production, but for many reasons they cannot increase production to any great extent. The man who owns a small bog has practically no capital whatever. Probably he is carrying on a small agricultural holding in addition to the bog and he has very little time to devote to turf making except to make sufficient for his own needs. He has not the capital to employ extra labour. In addition to that we must bear in mind that turf saving is a very speculative type of enterprise and that very often a complete year's cutting of turf is lost through unfavourable weather. Naturally, the man owning a small piece of bog, even if he can find the necessary capital to employ labour, feels reluctant to take the necessary risk in cutting turf which may be lost through unfavourable weather. Since the State is paying men an unemployment allowance, I think it should take direct action and should employ these men to cut and save turf.
During the present Administration we have seen schemes developed in rural areas—minor relief schemes of various kinds for the improvement of lanes and roadways—and they have been comparatively successful. A scheme for the cutting and saving of turf, directed by the Department would, no doubt, be equally successful. I do not see any reason why it should fail. It is hoping too much to expect that the unemployed workers in the city can go out on their own initiative and secure the right to enter bogs and engage in the work of cutting and saving turf or, alternatively, to expect impoverished farmers in turf-cutting districts to find the necessary capital to extend their turf cutting. This is a work which could easily and profitably be undertaken and organised by the Department of Industry and Commerce direct. Wherever men are registered as unemployed they could be engaged in this work and thus increase our national supplies of fuel. It is absolutely criminal to maintain thousands of workers in rural areas completely in idleness while there is the urgent and pressing need for increased supplies of fuel.
I ask the Minister to give this matter his immediate attention because, as I say, time is passing, and the prospects of increasing our supplies of fuel, so far as this year is concerned, will soon be very limited. What I have said in regard to turf supplies applies with equal force to coal. I think that in certain cases it should be the duty of the State to undertake the development of coal deposits. I believe that the method of approaching this problem adopted by the Government in the past—the method of importing highly paid technical experts and expending large sums of money on various new developments in the manufacture of turf and peat—has been absolutely wrong. Having regard to the number of people that are unemployed, I think the first principle guiding the State should have been the labour content of any scheme. Instead of that, we find that most of the money spent on the development of peat has gone in purchasing machinery and in obtaining technical advice, while very little has been spent on the employment of workers. That is not a position which ever should have arisen, having regard to the number of workers available. Some controversy has arisen as to whether the work of cutting and saving turf is laborious. I hold it is undoubtedly laborious, but it is work which is healthy and useful. It is also work in which practically any worker who has ever been engaged in manual labour can very quickly become skilled. For that reason, it is a type of work to which a large number of our unemployed could be very easily and quickly directed.
Comment on this
If one were to take seriously Deputy Meaney's contribution to this debate, one would think that the present Government was the only Government that ever did anything for the unemployed in this country. He states that they paid out more in unemployment benefit than the previous Government. That is quite possible, but he did not tell us the number which the present Government drove into unemployment by their policy. It is therefore reasonable to expect that they should expend more in unemployment benefit, because the numbers of unemployed have grown every day since the present Government came into office. The position at present is that the taxpayer has to dip his hand more deeply into his pocket, at the one time that he is least able to do so, in order to provide funds for unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance. That is directly attributable to the policy of the Government. As Deputy Childers told us, the number engaged in agriculture has decreased inside the last five or six years. He also told us of the increased numbers engaged in industry for the last five years. Deputy Meaney also suggested that the unemployed should be provided with bogs, and that they should go out and cut turf. Did anyone ever hear a more foolish suggestion—that an unemployed man, on an empty stomach, should be sent out to cut turf? In the first place, where is the Government going to get all the necessary turf banks? There is another department which has thousands of acres of turbary on its hands which it has not divided, not to speak of making roads into the bogs. When we speak on questions of this kind, we should at least be serious, and not make use of wild statements which may carry away the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who himself does not know very much about turf cutting.
Deputy Childers made a rather remarkable speech, or one that would have been remarkable, if he did not remind us so often that he represented an agricultural constituency. If it were not for that reminder, one might believe that he was serious. He constantly reminded us when he spoke of the industrial policy that he represented an agricultural constituency. When he mentioned that there had been a decrease in the number employed in agriculture in the last five or six years whilst there had been an increase in the number employed in industry, one thing that struck me was that he was suggesting that there was inefficiency in agriculture and efficiency on the part of those responsible for our industrial policy. I have the opposite view. I think our farmers would be quite efficient in carrying on their industry in years past if they were not subjected to so much interference. They have been hampered in every way by Government policy. The Deputy talked about co-operation between employers and employees but he did not tell us of the inefficiency in the case of industrial concerns in this country established by the Government. He talked about output but, as Deputy Morrissey stated, you cannot have output unless you have efficiency at the top. There is no use in blaming the employee all the time. If you get a bad employer who does not know his business, no matter how efficient an employee may be, you cannot have a good output.
We should all like to see an industrial revival in this country but, judged by the numbers who have been provided with employment in recent years, that industrial revival is costing us too much. Deputy Childers' speech to-day reminded me of the promises that were made when the Fianna Fáil Government first came into office that we would not have an unemployed man in the country and that our exiles would have to be brought back. What is the position to-day? You have 110,000 unemployed and none of the exiles has been brought back. Over 70,000 of our people have left this country to seek employment in another country in recent years while the total number put into employment during these years owing to the industrial policy of the Government is only 50,000. With reference to this 50,000 the Deputy did not say where the factories in which these are employed are erected, whether there is inspection of these factories or what proportion represented boys, girls, men and women. Having regard to the heavy cost which is imposed upon the public, I would not say that our industrial policy could be regarded as a success, merely from the fact that 50,000 people had been employed.
I believe myself that the Government started at the wrong end in their industrial policy. There was plenty of room for the development of our natural resources if the Government had taken in hand, and followed, the policy of the previous Government which had laid a sound foundation. We had a few old industries which could have been revived. Take the woollen industry. In the county which I represent, a county which produces one-sixth of all the wool that is raised in Ireland, we had in the centre of it one of the best woollen mills in the country. It was closed down, and sold some time ago for a fraction of its value. Why was it not helped in some way by means of a subsidy? The Government are subsidising industries, the raw materials of which have to be imported. I think it was Deputy Meaney who talked of developing an export trade. Due to the war, I suppose, we are doing a fair export trade in woollens at the present time, but for a number of years the industry has been more or less at a standstill. While, as I have said, we raise in the County Galway one-sixth of all the wool that is produced in Ireland, the position of buyers and exporters of wool at the present time is that they do not know where they stand as regards the price of wool. They are only buying very small lots at a small price. Can the Minister tell us what the price of wool is going to be this season? Those buyers and exporters should be told that now. They have bought some small lots at 1/1½ per lb. I believe the highest price paid so far has been 1/2 per lb.
The slate industry is another that could be developed. I know very well why the Government do not want it developed—because there is one industrialist who controls one or two concerns. Due to that, as I say, with the Government's consent, the other slate quarries in the country are not allowed to be developed. Take the question of roofing for houses. What is the position of the tile industry? It is really no industry, because almost everything in it is of foreign manufacture—cement, dyes and machinery. The only thing native that is in it is the sand and the juvenile labour. The position with regard to the cement may be different now, but it was foreign cement that was being used.
Deputy Childers, in the course of his speech, told us that, while there was supervision in regard to some matters, if there was more of it in regard to our agricultural policy—at least that was what I understood him to say—the country would be much better off. He did not tell us about the supervision that had been exercised over the building of the houses in Castlebar; the houses that fell down, and the ones that did not fall down, and had to be pulled down; or about the houses in the County Kildare which Deputy Norton referred to on Friday last. There was not much supervision there, because, it appears, you could put your hands through the cracks in the walls. It would be well if we had more supervision in regard to our industrial policy. Due to lack of supervision the consumer is having a bad time of it. If we had more supervision there would be greater efficiency, and the cost of our products would be less than it is. We have too many at the head of affairs who, in relation to our industrial policy, apparently are going on the get-rich-quick principle.
We find in the Estimate the sum of £83,000 for turf development. The cost of administering that scheme is going to cost the country £15,000. That surely is a very high figure. I would like to see turf development undertaken at a reasonable cost to the taxpayer, but I do not like to see those wild-cat schemes, for which the country gets no benefit, being pursued. I should like to see the Minister's Department make an effort to develop the smaller bogs in which the hand-won turf is produced, of giving the people turbary in those districts, and making roads and drainage, instead of concentrating on the development of big schemes on which machinery has to be employed. I believe that in one of those big bogs the machinery got stuck, and I am not sure whether it was ever got out. The Fianna Fáil Party told the country that when they got into power they were not going to centralise industry. They were going to give everybody in the country a fair chance, and help in the development of small industries by encouraging local people to put money into them so as to give more employment. It is a policy of that kind that should be employed in the case of peat development. The Land Commission have thousands of acres of turbary in their hands for a number of years. The Minister should take steps to see that this turbary is divided up amongst the people who will make use of it. That would be much better than to allow it to lie idle as it has been for hundreds of years.
Comment on this
The extraordinary thing about the Minister's speech on Friday last was that such a small portion of it was devoted to the unemployment situation in the country, especially when we remember that, prior to the general election of 1932, and again in 1933, the importance of the unemployment situation was stressed repeatedly by the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. At that time, of course, they were endeavouring to secure the reins of government. They told the country then about the plan they had: that when they got into power there would be no more unemployed in the country. They have apparently completely forgotten all that now, and in so far as the unemployed are concerned, seem to accept it that the present situation is inevitable, and one that cannot be remedied. As I have said, it is extraordinary that so little attention should have been devoted to that question by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in his introductory speech, in view of the fact that we have more unemployed people in the country to-day than we have had at any previous period in the country's history. Notwithstanding that, the amount of unemployment assistance this year is being cut down by £70,000. One wonders why, in view of the fact that we have about 120,000 unemployed people in the country to-day. In that situation one would think that, instead of a reduction we should have an increase in the Vote so that additional provision might be made for the unemployed to meet the rise in the cost of food prices. It seems to me that it is inevitable that unemployment assistance will have to be increased in the very near future. Even people who are in receipt of a fairly decent weekly wage are finding it very difficult to live, so that everyone can realise how hard it must be on the unemployed to exist on the miserable pittance given to them in the form of unemployment assistance week after week.
The speech delivered by Deputy Childers this evening was a very extraordinary one. He reminded us repeatedly that he was speaking as the representative of an agricultural constituency. I think it was quite obvious that he was speaking as an industrialist representing an agricultural constituency. He dealt at great length with the question of strikes and of trade disputes generally, all the time speaking in such a way as to lead people to infer that it was always the workers who were to blame when a trade dispute of any sort occurred in this country. He pointed out that during the period between 1934 and 1936 about 9,000 people were on strike in this country. That may or may not be so. But there were a great many more people out of work during the same period and no effort was made, good, bad or indifferent, to secure employment for them.
The Deputy referred to the question of output and efficiency. He asked the Government to intervene to secure more efficiency and more output in industry. Again I think he emphasised the point that it was the workers who were to blame for inefficiency in industry; that it was they who were to blame for the lesser output that he considered there was. I do not think it is the workers who should be blamed for the smaller output or who should be blamed for the want of efficiency in the new industries. It has been shown time and time again that the management has been responsible in the case of a great many new industries for inefficiency, or smallness of output. Irish craftsmen can go over to England and secure positions there at a time even when English craftsmen are idle. Surely that goes to show that it is not the fault of the craftsmen or the workers that there is inefficiency or smallness of output. We know that in a great many cases when Irish industries were started here, a certain number of English people who had something to do with the initiation of those industries installed obsolete machinery. I have in mind one particular industry started in my own constituency where old second-hand machinery was brought in. The result was that inefficient goods were put on the market at the start and the output was considerably lower than it would be if proper machinery had been installed. The workers cannot be blamed for things of that kind. I have been told that that sort of thing has happened in other industries in different parts of the country so that Deputy Childers will have to look elsewhere than amongst the ranks of the workers to find out who is responsible for inefficiency or low output in this country. Notwithstanding the fact that there is a war in England at the present time, we have workers going across to the extent of 100,000. These have been able to secure employment. That conclusively shows that Irish workers are efficient and that they are anxious to work. They even leave their native country to seek employment in a country that is at war.
Deputy Childers, when speaking, stated that the new industries were responsible for putting 50,000 people into employment. It would be very interesting if we could have an analysis of that 50,000. It would be interesting to find out how many of these 50,000 were adults, how many were boys, how many were girls, and how many of them were in receipt of a decent wage. I think it would also be found that quite a number of people have been put out of employment by reason of the fact that some of these new industries were established. It will be admitted that a great many people were put out of employment in the transport industries. Many dock labourers have been put out of employment because of the starting of some of these industries. A very high-tariffed wall has been created to protect them, and people in general are paying for them because in every case the tariff has been passed on in its entirety to the consumers. If the whole question were examined it would be found that that is the situation—that the people are paying the tariff in its entirety.
I think the time has arrived when the Government should examine the position so far as tariffs are concerned, see to the operation of these tariffs and to what extent the people are being overcharged. On the matter of unemployment and industry generally, I noticed that the other day, when the Minister for Finance was replying to the Budget debate, he told us that there were certain towns and areas in this country that were in a very prosperous condition in consequence of Government policy. He mentioned the town in which I reside, Wexford. He said at the moment that that town was in a very prosperous condition. I would like the Minister to go down to the town of Wexford and to tell the large number of the unemployed there that their town was in a very prosperous condition. So far as the people of that town are concerned, I know very well the answer the Minister would get. There is a very large number of unemployed there, and they can see anything but prosperity staring them in the face.
There is a sum of £13,903 in the Minister's Estimate for the expenses of the Prices Commission. I am at a loss to know how that money is being spent, and what value the people are getting for the expenditure.
Comment on this
Well, this item is mentioned in the Estimate, and money is being provided for it. As a matter of fact, the Minister referred to it on Thursday or Friday last when introducing this Estimate.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Corish is not aware that there is an amendment down by Deputy Dockrell.
Comment on this
I prefer to speak on it now. I will not detain the House very long. There is here an item of £13,903 and we want to know what benefit is being derived by the people from that expenditure? I noticed that four inspectors are supposed to be operating. Do they ever operate outside the City of Dublin or the larger cities in this country? Do they ever visit the provincial areas? It is not apparent to anybody what particular purpose is being served by the appointment of these four inspectors. When people consider themselves being overcharged they are supposed to report to the Prices Commission. I am of opinion that these inspectors should be periodically sent into the different parts of the country in order to find out for themselves what prices are operating because we know quite well that day after day poor people are being overcharged. These people are not going to sit down and write a letter to the Minister that they were overcharged for a particular commodity. Sometimes they would not have even the 2d. for the stamp and in the second place because of their relations with the shopkeeper concerned they would be afraid to draw attention to the fact that they were overcharged. Would the Minister give the House some idea of what the Prices Commission are doing? What are the four inspectors doing? What part of the country do they visit or do they ever visit an establishment until somebody who considers himself overcharged writes to the Minister?
When are we going to have the legislation promised for the improvement of harbours? It is a good number of years since the Piers and Harbours Tribunal sat. That tribunal went all over the country and took evidence in the different centres where the tribunal was operating. It appears to me that the Government are only concerned with the larger harbours. A good many of the small harbours in the country have been neglected. Certain recommendations were made by that tribunal which would be for the betterment of the smaller harbours. I would like to know from the Minister when it is intended to implement by legislation the findings of that tribunal? I do not think I have anything else to say on the matter, but I should like to hear a little more from the Minister on the unemployment situation than he told us in his opening statement.
Comment on this
I can scarcely feel, from my own experience and from my own knowledge, that I could have anything in common with Deputy Meaney in offering bouquets to the Minister in regard to this question of industrial development. So far as the constituency of West Cork is concerned, I can only say that two industries there, which were very important so far as the farmers there are concerned, have almost entirely disappeared, one, due, to a great extent, I believe, to the policy, or lack of policy, of the Minister for Agriculture, but in regard to that I shall have something to say on another Estimate. At any rate, we have very little employment now in one particular industry. All I have to say is, that we have very little employment in these two industries down there. The slate quarries in West Cork have afforded very little employment for quite some time now. The Benduff quarries have turned out products that are well and favourably known not alone in this country but outside this country, and yet they have been working on a skeleton staff for quite a long time now, and I understand that, for some weeks past, they have been closed down.
I am informed that this is largely due to the preference given, either directly or indirectly, by the present Government to the tile-manufacturing industry, but I think that when the whole matter is examined, from the point of view of employment at any rate, it will be found that the amount of employment given in the tile industry, as compared with the amount of employment that would be given in the slate quarries, is comparatively small, and I think it is criminal neglect to allow these slate quarries to reach such a stage as not to be able to give any employment. I think it is criminal that, in view of the amount of employment that would be given by the working of these slate quarries, no effort should have been made by the Minister's Department to develop these quarries, and thereby give employment to a number of people who are in need of it.
There was one other industry, in an extreme portion of West Cork—or rather at the extreme end of the county—which gave a lot of employment. At one time, there were about 70 or 80 men employed there in the quarrying of granite, largely for export. Now, I am not indicting the Minister for what has happened with regard to that particular industry, which has also disappeared. I am not indicting him for the disappearance of that industry, but I am indicting him for his failure to do something towards providing employment in that district. During the last war there was a good deal of remunerative employment given in that district in the barytes industry. The barytes deposits in West Cork have been exploited, from time to time, over a number of years, and one would think that, in a situation such as we have at present, some indication of policy from the Government would be forthcoming in regard to the development of that industry, but there has been no such indication. I complain, therefore, that the two industries in that part of the country which, one might assume, could be relied upon to afford a fair measure of employment, have completely disappeared, and therefore, I suggest, that instead of being in the position of offering compliments to the Government on their success in industrial development or the success of industry under their regime, whatever industry we had, in that part of the country, at least, has completely disappeared.
That brings me to the question of the plight of the workers in this country. I wonder whether there is any realisation of the hardships that are being imposed as a result of the present situation. The hardships imposed by the present situation can hardly be exaggerated, and when one has knowledge of the large number of these cases, and the almost terrible physical efforts made by these people in order to barely exist on their present resources, one is compelled to wonder at the manner in which people seem to have become resigned, to a certain extent, to their difficulties. In that connection, I do not think it is unfair to suggest that the whole official attitude is one of indifference to the hardships of these people. There is no evidence of any policy in regard to the unemployment problem in this country or in regard to the administration of the measures designed, or alleged to be designed, for the relief of unemployment. The administration of the present Unemployment Assistance Act shows, as far as one can see, an attempt to move away from the position that was accepted when that Act was first put into force.
That Act was intended, and believed, to be a measure to provide help for people over a period of difficulty, and the expectation was that, when the unemployment position in this country would have been very substantially reduced—as seemed to be anticipated— the need for that Act would not exist any longer, or at least only to a very small extent. Now, the amounts paid in unemployment assistance, instead of being increased as a result of the increased unemployment and the present situation, are being reduced, and the whole policy of the Government seems to me to be reduced to one of paying less to the unemployed people. Now, I could not very well complain of that position if, at the same time, a corresponding effort was being made to increase employment. One would welcome anything that would tend to end the operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act, and welcome anything that would mean the provision of work for our unemployed. There is no evidence of that, however; and I complain very much, therefore, of this policy of attrition with regard to the operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act, and I think that there should be a revision of the working of that Act—particularly with regard to the complete secrecy which seems to surround the methods of dealing with people who are seeking unemployment assistance. The average unemployed person is not in a position to put up a case in the manner in which a case is prepared for a solicitor going into court. They are, to a very large extent, unaware of the rights under the Act. The only thing they know about is their need, and that is the most urgent and real thing for them at present. Without having an opportunity of uttering a word in their own defence, except in so far as they answer questions when the investigation takes place, certain means figures are arrived at in many cases, with a complete disregard or ignorance of the facts.
There was recently brought to the notice of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Department the case of a mason, aged 68 years, residing with his wife in West Cork, who received unemployment assistance occasionally, and who got certain short periods of work. The information was conveyed to the Minister's Department that since last September that man had not had one day's work. At the same time his case was examined in pursuance of this policy of reducing the amounts paid in unemployment assistance, and a means figure of 8/- per week was assessed, thus depriving him of unemployment assistance. His case came before the West Cork Board of Assistance recently, and he was granted home assistance. The official reply in that case was that a certain figure was arrived at and confirmed, and that the man had no further right of appeal. Is there no hope for people in cases of that kind? I should not wonder at the attitude of people who are the victims of that system if there is not some change of heart in the administration of the Act.
I suggest to the Minister that there is as good a case for the right of personal representation in connection with the assessment of means in respect of unemployment assistance as there is in the case of widows' pensions or old age pensions. I ask the Minister to consider giving unemployed people an opportunity of being represented or being present when their cases are under investigation, and of offering rebutting evidence to the official case that is made in matters of this kind. The Minister for Local Government conceded that right to widows under the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Act some time ago, and it is a recognised right in connection with old age pensions. I know of no reason why it should not be complied with in the administration of the Unemployment Assistance Act by giving to certain officials of the Minister's Department the function of referees for dealing with appeals of this kind and enabling the whole case to be examined in that way.
I ask for some more elaborate statements than we have had already from the Minister with regard to the unemployment problem, which constitutes a terrible menace at the present time. If the Minister consults any of the Church authorities or the social workers or the officials of local authorities, I think he will find a feeling growing up amongst such people who are constantly in touch with the poor people in this country that the position is getting extremely serious. One does not want to exaggerate the position here, but there is certainly a very serious situation developing when the average person, who is idle through no fault of his own, begins completely to despair of anything being done for him. It is a situation of that kind in other countries which is largely responsible for the world being in the condition in which it is to-day. It seems to me that the Minister and the officials of his Department would want to look very seriously at this whole question. If they have failed to provide any policy for substantially reducing employment, at least they ought to see that what is provided by the State for the unemployed is given to them without the official obstacles and impediments that seem to increase as time goes on in regard to unemployment assistance.
I should like to ask the Minister whether the intention is to scrap this Act, not publicly, but by a reduction of the amount paid under it, by reductions arising out of increases in the amounts assessed for means, by increases in the length of the Period Orders, and by this new system of forced labour which has developed recently whereby people are deprived of unemployment assistance if they refuse to go to work in a bog and receive at the end of a week's work the sum of 4/-. If that is the kind of turf development we may expect in the next 12 months, then I am afraid it is going to make the position worse instead of better. In that situation we had the funds provided for relieving and reducing unemployment raided and reduced in order to balance the Budget. That Budget is the most dismal reminder that we could have of how hopeless the position is with regard to unemployment assistance. At a time when the great armies of the world are being shattered to pieces, we make ourselves utterly ridiculous by the provision of large sums of money for an Army that, in the present circumstances, one could not see standing up to the difficulties of the situation even for one day. Money is being spent for that purpose while the people who are unemployed are being reduced to beggary and starvation.
I suggest to the Minister that we have reached a point in this country when the whole matter is becoming extremely grave and that discontent, restlessness, and the other things that ensue from that feeling may be expected if there is not some change in this whole position. One does not want to exaggerate the position, but contact with those who have responsibility, not only for the general wellbeing of the citizens in the physical sense, but also in the spiritual sense, makes one realise how seriously people in that position have come to regard the present degree of poverty and unemployment that prevails. I am afraid there is very little knowledge of that position officially. In this city and in its surroundings there are evidences of wealth and luxury that, to a great extent, cloud the real position, but there is no mistaking the situation in the heart of the country, and I hope that the Government and the House will be able to make some contribution before it becomes dangerous.
Comment on this
Having heard a great deal about what has been described as the critical state of the country, I propose to say a few words on the constructive side, in support of the views put forward by the Minister when introducing this Estimate, in regard to the necessity of those in a position to do so to help in providing fuel supplies during the coming season. Now is the proper time to be up and doing in that regard. One of the great founders of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society speaking at an inaugural meeting in 1885, said:
"If I were asked what is the most important lesson we Irishmen of to-day have to learn, I should say it was to distinguish clearly between what we ought to do for ourselves, and what the State ought to do for us."
These words are applicable to the present situation, and I emphasise them in regard to providing an alternative to the fuel that normally comes from across the Channel. If this war develops, there may be a great deal of poverty that has been complained of, but while I do not agree with the picture that was painted here, I urge that we should make sure to have an adequate supply of fuel for our people. The Minister stated the other evening that if we were to deal with the shortage of fuel during the emergency, we must rely on the producers of hand-won turf to make good the probable deficiency of imported fuel. I come from a constituency in the midlands in which there are large tracts of bog developed, partially developed, and undeveloped. As to what we can do for ourselves, to secure supplies of fuel, I may point out that there are available to help thousands of members of co-operative turf societies that were formed in recent years. While there has been a change of policy on the question, the latent enthusiasm is still there, and in the national emergency that faces us the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Turf Board should be able to get these societies working again. While their efforts should go far to supply the needs of our people, the Government and the State should be more active in regard to providing access to the bogs. I know several bogs held by private landlords where so much per perch is extracted for the right to cut turf. The result is that some people are unable to supply their own needs, much less have a surplus available for sale to their neighbours. In an emergency like the present that is work to which the Land Commission might apply itself.
I suggest that the Land Commission has bogs under its supervision, or that it has inquired about bogs on which work could be undertaken now. I know bogs that have been inspected by representatives of the Peat Development Board in recent years, where road-making and drainage could be undertaken, so that the turf could be got out to the roadside during the coming harvest. I suggest that some of the unemployed could be engaged on that work. Probably in two or three seasons out of ten, when turf is ready to be brought home after being reared and clamped on the bog, farmers and rural workers who are finishing the harvest find when the weather breaks that they have to carry it out long distances in sacks. I do not think anybody could criticise a Government Department or the Turf Board if the improvement of the roads, and also drainage, were undertaken. If even £50 was spent on roads on some of these bogs, that expenditure would ensure more turf being available for the local people and for markets as far away as Dublin. Over 160 cooperative turf societies were established some years ago, representing a membership of 13,000 or 14,000. I know something about the formation of those societies, and speaking for at least 15 or 16 of them, I know that if they receive consideration at the hands of a Government Department in the carrying out of work that would have been finished now but for a change of policy, there is a willingness to have more turf cut than is required locally and sold to the community.
Should the present deplorable war that is scourging Europe continue, it would be a good thing for the countryside to have clamps of turf in the compounds that were prepared by some of these societies, where they would be accessible to lorries and could be sent to districts in which fuel was required. In that connection there may be a difficulty as regards the transport of the turf. In the present emergency, with petrol likely to be scarce, the assistance of the railways should be invoked. Societies whose bogs are situate within two or three miles of railway stations or sidings could deliver their turf there for long-distance transport. In that way the transport problem would be eased. The Minister, in his opening speech, said that all the hand-won turf saved would find a market, probably at very handsome prices. I am inclined to think that if, in the case of a reasonably drained bog with any depth of turf, the producer knew that he would get from 15/- to £1 per ton, according to quality—quality makes a big difference in price—it would encourage him to produce more. If the people concerned were told immediately by the Turf Board or by the Minister that they would get the co-operation of the State, that when the season for turf-cutting had expired at the end of June or early in July, some of the unemployed would be turned on to the improvement and repair of the roads and certain necessary small-drainage jobs, it would be a great advantage.
I have in mind some bogs which were drained and partially developed a few years ago when turf societies were functioning. Certain unemployment moneys were diverted to this purpose and spent partially under the control of the county council engineers in co-operation with the engineers of the Turf Development Board. Extremely good work was done in that way. People can bring their horses miles into the bog now where, before, they could not bring them more than half a mile from the roadside. In some cases, the work then done would require to be overhauled in the case of bogs where good production of turf could be expected.
I have, I think, said enough to emphasise that, in the midlands, there is a great opportunity to absorb quite a large number of men on this work. I disagree with the Deputy who said a short time ago—I dislike mentioning the names of individuals in debate— that this particular work is no good to the unemployed. I know quite a number of unemployed men who had the pluck to join up with their neighbours who also happened to be unemployed, get a few perches of bog and produce turf for sale over and above their own requirements. The unemployed men walking the countryside would be much better employed on the bogs. We all regret that so many men are unemployed. Finding fault with this Government Department or that Government Department will not bring a solution of the unemployment problem one day sooner. If everybody would contribute some suggestion, it might go a long way towards helping matters. On the bogs of the area I have the honour to represent, I am satisfied that, if we got certain State co-operation, we could get a couple of hundred men going between now and next October on work of national importance. These men would be much better engaged on that work than in drawing moneys for which they give no return and which they would prefer not to take in the circumstances. I hope that what I have tried to say will be treated as a sincere effort to be constructive and helpful to the Minister and as support for his plea for the supply of all our fuel needs from native sources this year.
Some people have suggested that conditions in connection with machine-won turf were not as desirable, from the employment point of view, as one would expect. I live within six or seven miles of the development works at Clonsast. I know something of that scheme. I know something, too, of good rural workers, brought up in the art of using spade and shovel. As one brought up from boyhood on the bogs and fields of rural Ireland, I do not agree with those who speak with a superiority complex about our rural workers. The agricultural worker—I refer to the man who is a decent worker and not a shirker—is really a skilled artisan. The man who knows how to use a slean in the bog and who knows how to turn a furrow straight or do any other class of agricultural work efficiently is a skilled worker. It would be ridiculous for me to say that I could pilot an aeroplane and, when I hear people talk about the rural worker, I am reminded of the old and true saying, "Let the cobbler stick to his last". There are large numbers of Clonsast workers earning from 35/- to 48/- a week on the development works there. I want to say, frankly, that work on bogs is hard work. Everybody in rural Ireland knows it is hard work. Men accustomed to similar work are able for it when they get in on the knack of things.
No man need expect that he will become accustomed to that kind of work in a week or two. He will have to harden himself to it, and he will have to be satisfied to persist in it for a little while until he has developed the knack of doing the job. I have recently made special inquiry into the matter, and I find that the average wage of men working in the drains is between 38/- and 44/- or 45/- a week. A newcomer cannot expect to do the job well or to earn as much as a man who has been doing that work for some years. Anyone who knows farming conditions knows what used to be done in years gone by when drainage work on the farms was set by so much a perch. Very often, before the harvest, when the field drains would be dry, rural workers would take on that work at so much a perch. They would work hard at it and would be content with what they would earn.
I am satisfied that on the bogs and in the fields of rural Ireland the biggest contribution to the final solution of the unemployment problem of this country will be found. I do not like to hear people saying that Irishmen have to flee to England. I do not think that class of thing helps us in any way. I think every member of this House should contribute something by trying to approach the matter in a constructive spirit and not simply to blame it on the Government or on somebody else, and leave it at that. From experience, I know what I am talking about, and I definitely state that in the fields and bogs of our country, and in a general rural development, we can deal with a big percentage, not all, of our unemployment difficulty. Many former rural residents of Ireland to-day only require some encouragement to come from the cities instead of queuing up outside the labour exchanges. If they would come back into the countryside and admit that they had failed in their quest for better conditions elsewhere, and settle down to the normal life there, it would be better for them. I have in mind men who, for no reason whatsoever, who were not unemployed but who, in pursuit of high wages and better conditions in the farming fields of England and Scotland, two or three years ago— and, undoubtedly, better conditions for rural workers did prevail there as regards wages, etc.—were lured away from their homes. In recent times they have been very glad to come back and settle down in their own neighbourhoods again. I ask the Minister to consider the remarks I have made. I join with Deputy Davin in the plea as regards the bogs around Mountrath, which we knew the Land Commission had in hands a couple of years ago, and where there is a shortage of bogs for the local people. If the Land Commission could speed up the matter there, and also in other places, I think that would have a very useful effect.
Comment on this
Before the Minister rises I wish to outline the procedure. The Minister will conclude the general debate which covered both the Vote and the motion to refer back the Estimate. When the Minister has concluded, a question will be put on the motion to refer back. Deputy Dockrell's motion will then be taken, and any questions on items in the Vote. The general debate will not flow over into the discussion on items. When Deputy Dockrell's motion has been disposed of the question will be put on Vote 55. The Minister to conclude.
Comment on this
In the wide range and variety of this discussion the principal ground for criticism—if there was any ground for criticism at all in the address which I delivered—was that I neither professed to be a prophet nor to hold myself out as a superman. I was attacked because, in the words of Deputy Morrissey, "the Minister did not commit himself as to what he was going to do in the coming year." During the day and a half, almost, that I have listened to this debate, I have wondered whether Deputies have forgotten what are the conditions existing in Europe to-day, the conditions under which we have to carry on, the conditions which determine and govern and make and shape our problems. One thing that is clear is that this world is a much more dynamic world than it was a week ago, or it was in the latter days of last August. We here are now faced with a situation in which, from hour to hour, the whole basis of economic life in this country is being changed, and is being changed by forces which are completely outside our control; and yet all the speeches that have been made in this debate have been made by men who seem to have swept that fact from their minds, and who speak as if they thought that we here, sitting in this House, could ride the whirlwind and control the storm. Let us, at any rate in these days, be realists, and instead of Deputies glibly asking us how we are going to solve the unemployment problem, how we are going to put another 120,000 men to work, let them ask themselves how we as a community are going to keep in employment the 19 out of every 20 persons in this country who at the moment are in a position to earn their bread.
That is going to be our main problem, and it is going to be a problem that is made by Providence much more difficult in present circumstances because of the fact that ours is, as I have said so often, a dependent economy, that a very large proportion of the secondary industries that have been set afoot in this country depend upon our ability to secure and to maintain the ordinary course of supply in this country. As for our primary industry, it depends entirely, in the present world circumstances, on the ability of our neighbours to purchase from us. If any person were to hold himself out as being so omnipotent that he could deal with that situation, the first thing he would have to ask himself is: "How can I help our principal customer to maintain his position as a buyer for my produce? How am I going to secure for myself, from him or from any other source, the things which are essential in order to maintain our ordinary industrial economy here?"
Throughout this debate, which ought to have been made an occasion for helpful suggestion and advice, with the exception of a speech from Deputy Hughes and from Deputy Cogan, I did not receive from the sides of the House that are not associated with Government policy in this country one helpful suggestion.
Instead, I was told that my salary was on the Vote, and my job was to provide employment for every unemployed man. I was told I ought to tear up the unemployment regulations, or that I ought to amend these regulations in order to make it easier for people to draw unemployment assistance and continue to be a burden on this community. The suggestion I got from some Deputies is that by amending these regulations, and relaxing the restrictions which govern the administration of unemployment assistance, I should remove the last sanction that remains to make a man go out and seek work.
Comment on this
On Friday last a junior member of this House—I do not use that in a sense of disparagement, but rather to denote the fact that he is a young member in age and experience—complained that the unemployment officers are now enforcing somewhat rigorously the statutory condition for the receipt of unemployment assistance to this effect, that applicants are expected to go round all day and every day looking for work. I want to say emphatically that so long as I am Minister for Industry and Commerce, and so long as the ordinary private citizens who earn their bread by the sweat of their brow are compelled by the State to contribute to the upkeep of other people who do not happen to be in work, I expect such people to go round all day and every day looking for work. The one justification, the one right or claim or title that any man, young or old, in this country has to receive unemployment assistance, is that he is genuinely seeking work, and if he is not genuinely seeking work and does not make a genuine effort—and I do not mean a mere formal request for a job—to get work then, in my opinion, he is not entitled to be a burden upon his neighbours who have themselves got jobs. Life has not been easy in this country for the people who have jobs. They did not find it easy to get the jobs, but the great majority of them went out and got jobs for themselves, and, having got them, they held them, and are entitled to the utmost of what they earn because of that fact.
One of the things I deplore most of of all in relation to this unemployment problem is the way in which the constant harping upon the regulations relating to the unemployed is sapping the whole moral fibre of our people. There is no person who has greater sympathy than I have for the man who is in want through no fault of his own, the man who genuinely wants a job and cannot get it; but I have no sympathy for the slacker or the shirker, and we must be careful, in relation to a matter of this kind, that we do not encourage the slacker or the shirker. We must be careful lest, out of concern for the people in genuine need, we relax the sanctions which are necessary to compel every one of us to work. Work is not such an enjoyable thing that the great majority of us would not be glad to avoid it if we could. That is a basic feature in human nature, and we must be careful, all the time we are talking about unemployment and so on, that we do not encourage and develop that as a failing in our people.
Comment on this
Quite frankly I do. I do think that, quite unwittingly, there are members of the Labour Party and the Opposition Party—not all of them—and I suppose there are members of my own Party—I do not want to single out one Party more than another in regard to this matter—who have made speeches from time to time in this House in which that basic fact has been lost sight of—that you must give men some urge to work; that it is not the natural inclination of a man to slave from morning till night; that he likes to bask in the sun, just as I would like to, if I could do it.
Comment on this
I have been asked what do I think of the Clonsast experiment. We heard a great deal about that. Deputy Murphy talked about the men who were sent down to work on the bog and who got 4/- a week. These men were brought down and housed in good, comfortable quarters. I went through the camp myself. I saw it and I can tell you this, that I spent some of the best years of my young life in very much worse surroundings, in much less comfortable beds, and I certainly had not the good food that was provided there. Here was this camp with comfortable accommodation for every man, simply furnished but comfortable, good and clean beds and plenty of fresh air, facilities for amusement and recreation and plenty of good food. They were provided with tool money and the use of boots, and on top of that, during the period when they were learning the job —it is a skilled job, as Deputy Gorry told us—they were given, in addition, 4/- a week pocket money.
These were young men who had been medically examined to ensure that they were physically fit, fit for physical labour. They were taken out of slum surroundings in Dublin and sent to where they had plenty of fresh air, good healthy work and plenty of good healthy food. On top of that they had in their pockets 4/- a week while they were learning the job. Nobody expected that they would earn their keep in the first week or even the first three weeks, but there was a scale of remuneration laid down for them and within a short time they would have been earning 35/- or 36/- a week, the same as the rest.
What happened? Perhaps I had better tell the House the history of this experiment from the beginning. Out of those who were on the live register of unemployment in the Dublin Exchange, after a careful search and scrutiny of the records, a list of 200 men, who seemed to be of the right age and young and healthy so far as one could see, was compiled. Out of that list of 200, 100 men were selected to go for medical examination. One of them did not present himself for medical examination; 11 were rejected as not being physically fit for work of the type that was to be carried out on the bog. There were 88 passed as fit for work and they were presumed to be genuinely seeking work. The 88 were told to report themselves and, of the 88, 31 did not even turn up to see what the job was like.
Comment on this
On the Saturday 57 went down to the bog, and on the following Monday morning 31 of them left the bog.
Comment on this
They said they did not like the job. I shall leave that aspect of the matter until a little later. Of the 26 who remained, within, I think, a fortnight or three weeks, ten more had deserted, and only 16 out of the original 100 submitted to the doctor for medical examination now remain at work. Of course, I shall be told by some people that it is hard work. There are men earning 27/- and 30/- a week throughout the countryside who do just as arduous work and who, because they are at work, are not according to the demands of some people are to have the privilege of paying for these men who would not stay at work on the bog. I will be told that it is hard work and that you have to be inured to it. That fact was recognised from the start.
I am asked why did these men leave the bog. They left it because they did not like the job, and, of course, naturally, they are no longer in receipt of unemployment assistance. We have an agitation here in Dublin to allow them to qualify again for unemployment assistance, and we have, I regret to say, that agitation sponsored by the organ of the Dublin Labour Party, so that we are now getting to the stage that not merely must the State provide work or maintenance, but it must provide the sort of work that we like. There are men cleaning drains and sewers and doing scavenging work in this city; there are men doing lots of dirty and unpleasant jobs throughout the country; but these men cannot down tools and say: "We do not like the job", walk off and expect to be treated as men genuinely seeking work. But, mind you, that would appear to be the attitude now being inculcated throughout the country in the minds of a very large number of our people, and particularly our young people, by the sort of talk that goes on here in this House and throughout the country to the effect that the Government has done nothing for the unemployed.
There is no Government in Europe has done as much, according to its means, as this Government has done for those who are out of work. There is no other country in Europe can point to an Unemployment Assistance Act like ours, applied to the great mass of the people and giving unemployment assistance to people who are even admitted to have means. Almost 60 per cent. of the people on the live register in receipt of unemployment assistance are people with means, with some source of steady income—not people who are dependent upon casual employment for their means, but people who own land, who have small pensions or some other source of steady income. On top of that, we have the remaining 40 per cent. who are people without means who might normally be upon the labour market in this or any other country. In addition, we are spending enormous sums on the Land Commission; we have been spending enormous sums on employment schemes, on building programmes and on development work of one sort or another; and here at this moment, when the whole community is put to the pin of its collars to meet its everyday obligations, the only matter which can be discussed here on the Vote for the office of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is the allegation that this Government is not doing enough to relieve unemployment.
I do wish, as I said before, that we would remember what the world around us is like to-day, that when we come in here to discuss these matters, we would at least approach them with some sense of the reality of things, and that, instead of complaining because we have not been able to get more money out of the pockets of the people who are at work, we would make up our minds that, in future, we are going to tell those who are out of work that they have to try for themselves and see what they can do to help us out. I should be quite willing, so far as Government action can help them in relation to the need for cutting turf or anything like that, to approach my colleagues who are more immediately concerned in this matter than I am, and to ask them to place all the facilities possible at the disposal of men who think they can turn the present emergency to their own use and advantage by trying to provide us with fuel and other commodities which we may want; but, for God's sake, let us get out of this intolerable habit of thinking that it is the Government's job primarily to put bread in every man's mouth, and to give him jam along with it. It is the ordinary private citizen who has the first and primary obligation for his maintenance, and until we become seized of that fact, and until we stop making our people mendicants upon the Government, there is going to be no hope for the future progress or prosperity of this country.
I was asked by Deputy Mulcahy what steps we propose to take in relation to the conservation of coal supplies. That is a problem which is receiving the attention of the Minister for Supplies and of myself, in so far as my efforts will be ancillary to his. It will be, I think, generally recognised that the problem in relation to the coal supplies became really acute only comparatively recently. I think we shall be able to deal with the problem, and in order that we may eke our supplies out so far as we can, and to give every encouragement to people who own turbaries to produce turf, I feel that we shall be able, when the need for it arises, to enforce the provisions of the Turf Act in relation to certain districts. Deputy Mulcahy wanted to know whether I did propose to take action under the Turf Act. As I say, that is a matter for consideration, and, when the need arises, I think that we will invoke our powers under that Act, but I am glad to see that at least the foresight of my predecessor, who put that Act on the Statute Book in spite of opposition, has now been recognised, and that we have ready to our hand an instrument for the regulation of fuel consumption in the country. With regard to the problem which Deputy Davin, and other Deputies also, mentioned, the problem which arises from the fact that the greater part of the bogs in this country is in private ownership, it may be necessary, in order to get the turf production under way, to bring in a measure to ensure that unreasonable conditions will not be exacted by the owners of these turf banks, where it appears that they can be properly utilised for the production of turf.
Comment on this
It will have to be for next year. This is a matter which cannot be dealt with by emergency regulation, because, as the Deputy is aware, it does touch the rights of property. People who have these bogs have paid for them in most cases, and we cannot just simply ride in roughshod over them, but in relation to bogs under Government control we may be able to make regulations which will, at any rate, enable them to be available to those who wish to work them.
Comment on this
I am not so sure that they are available precisely in the way in which they are required now.
Comment on this
I am not the Minister responsible for the Land Commission, and I am not going to answer for him. I will represent to him what Deputies have said here in the course of the debate. It is a matter to which my attention has already been drawn. We have been making representations, and I will reinforce my representations by what the Deputy has already said.
Deputy Davin has raised the question of the Castlecomer strike. The position there is that the price of Castlecomer fuel has been fixed by the Prices Commission, based upon certain wage rates which have prevailed in the mines for some time. I understand that the dispute has been occasioned by the demand on the part of the miners for increased wages. I am not going to enter into the merits or demerits of the dispute, but that is a fact. We have been told by the Deputy's leader about rising prices and about the cost of living going up. If wages go up, naturally profits go up proportionately and—worst of all—the cost of the commodities to the consumer goes up, not merely in proportion to the increase in wages but in proportion to the increase in profits as well. Members of the Labour Party cannot have it both ways: they cannot have high wages and low prices at the same time. They have got to make up their minds as to the leg on which they are going to stand—whether they want a rising cost of living or a cost of living at least remaining as close as possible to the present level.
Comment on this
To the present level, which Deputies never tire of representing to this House as already too high for their satisfaction. I cannot do more than say—as I have said already in the House—that we cannot hope to prevent a rise in the cost of living if we allow all other costs to go up indiscriminately. I have to consider the interests of the community as a whole in relation to these matters, and accordingly I cannot be expected to make an attempt to drive up rates of remuneration in the interests of one section of the people only.
I was asked what was the position in relation to the report on transport and railways. That report is still under consideration in certain of the Government Departments, including my own. Deputy Davin, I think, said that the report has been in my hands for ten months. As a matter of fact, it has been in my hands only for nine months. The inquiry was a very difficult one, as the Deputy knows. Certain conclusions were arrived at, and I have now to form my own conclusions from them. In doing that, naturally, I have to consult the other Departments of State concerned in this matter and try to form, as a result, a balanced view. The Deputy seems to have forgotten that since I got the report the European war has broken out and that a very large part of the nine months which has elapsed since the report came into my hands has been devoted —and necessarily so—to other matters of more pressing and more urgent importance. The Deputy has asked whether the statement made by the General Manager of the Great Southern Railways before the Railway Wages Board was true. In the main, it is true that, if an increase were granted, the Irish railways would not be able to meet their overhead charges. What is the Deputy and his Party going to do about that?
Comment on this
And the Deputy has an obligation. If the railways are in the position represented by the general manager, what does Deputy Davin suggest I should do? Am I to must other people in order to meet the increased demands? If not, what am I to do? There is the position of the railways, and those who are engaged in that work will have to look into it and consider it very carefully. Otherwise, there may be a breakdown which would involved them and us— involve the railways and the community as a whole—in disaster. When considering a problem of that sort, naturally, I would like to be guided by the advice of so experienced a railwayman as Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
Deputy Crowley referred to the position of the woollen trade. Whether he meant to do so or not, I think he gave the House the impression that the woollen industry had been treated very shabbily by the Government since they came into office. I would like to disabuse Deputy Crowley of that impression. Probably no single industry has received more protection here than the woollen industry. This protection has taken the form of quotas and duties governing all classes and types of cloth made in the Irish mills or capable of being substituted for Irish cloth. The proof of that is the fact that, since 1932, the production of the Irish mills has been doubled. The balance of the cloth imported into this country is of very light and cheap cloths for both men and women either of weight, type and price that could not in any circumstances be fairly substituted by Irish cloth.
It has been suggested that I ought to shut out artificial silks and rayon and all cheap cloths. That would be an attractive proposal from the point of view of manufacturers and of those engaged in the woollen industry, but it must be remembered that they by no means represent all the people and that the majority of the people here might have a great deal to say. While it is true that some of us in the House can gratify our tastes with regard to the Irish cloths and by what we like to wear, the fact remains that there are a great many people who cannot afford to pay for the higher quality cloth turned out by the Irish mills. We have got to think of them. We have also got to remember, this as a basic fact of existence: a person is entitled, as a natural right—while one may limit him in certain ways in the interests of the community—to have an article, if the article is available and if he is able to buy it. In developing Irish industry, I do not think we can start from the point of view that a person is only entitled to buy what the Irish manufacturer is able to supply, because very soon we would find that ours would be a drab and sordid existence, indeed, for suppliers on occasion can enforce very rigid control of the market.
I should like, therefore, to ensure that, while we are doing everything possible to encourage our industries, there will be a certain latitude allowed for the gratification of personal tastes. I think that is the best way to make the industrial development policy more easily acceptable to the general mass of the people. This idea that a manufacturer has a right to turn out a certain article, that he has a right to insist that other people will buy it, use it or eat it, is one of the things that raise the gorge in everyone of us. We like to go into a shop and to be allowed to select our purchases with some sort of choice. Naturally, because the majority of us are patriotic, we give a preference to the Irish manufactured article, but it is our job to see that, within reasonable limits, the same element of choice is given to the consumer in this country as in most other countries.
Comment on this
It may be strange, but that is my philosophy in the matter and I think it is going to help us in getting ahead with our industrial programme in a much better and more expeditious fashion than if we were to adopt the rather rigid attitude which has been suggested in regard to woollens.
Comment on this
I have gone into shops and asked for Irish articles. They were not displayed, and when I insisted on getting them, they had to go to the back of the shop to get them for me.
Comment on this
The best course the Deputy could have taken in that case was to have walked out of the shop. I am perfectly certain that if he had taken the trouble to walk out, he would have found another shop ready to produce the Irish article, and to put it into the window. I know there are shops in Dublin which are disinclined to put Irish products in their windows, but it is equally true to say that there are other shops which take a pride in featuring Irish-manufactured commodities. These are the shops which have gone ahead. You can do the same thing in Cork as an influential public man——
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to his view, but, mind you, there may be others who have another view. I am only suggesting that the more the people you can convert to your view, the greater demand there will be for Irish products. By that means, we can get more easily a willing acceptance of the Irish article amongst the great bulk of the Irish people than by simply attempting to ram it down their necks.
Deputy Morrissey, in the course of his speech, alleged that we had bungled the fertiliser position, because we had not allowed fertilisers to come in when they were available. If my recollection is right, I think there has not been any duty on fertilisers for some considerable time. There was quota control, and there had to be quota control for certain reasons.
Comment on this
So far as the quota was concerned, the quota was so large and it was so easy to get a licence, that it represented almost free import. On that basis, I do not think there was any justification for the criticism which Deputy Morrissey levelled against us in relation to fertilisers.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is incorrect in saying that there was no duty on fertilisers because, so far as superphosphates are concerned, you could not import superphosphates without paying a duty up to six or seven weeks ago.
Comment on this
There was no duty on British fertilisers. There was, I think, a duty on foreign fertilisers.
Comment on this
One of my clearest recollections after my becoming Minister for Industry and Commerce—the matter had been in train before I took over the portfolio-was that one of the first things I had to do was to fix a wider quota, so as to allow the import practically free of restriction. As I say, the matter had been in train, and I only completed the job by affixing my signature. The size of the quota now really means that there is no restriction on imports. I am advised that since the Agreement of 1938, there has been no duty on British fertilisers.
Deputy Meaney referred to the question of phosphate rock in Clare. That matter has been engaging the attention of two or three departments for some time. The position has not been an easy one, because it has been very difficult to get a really experienced person to advise us in regard to these deposits; but we are now, I think, taking steps which will ensure some practical results in as short a period as possible.
Deputy Murphy suggested that we had killed the slate quarry industry in West Cork. My information is, that so far from killing the industry, we placed financial resources at the disposal of quarry owners for the development of their quarries. A large number of slate quarries have had the benefit of guaranteed loans under the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Acts. Some of the slate quarries in West Cork, in fact, got free grants of moneys provided for the relief of unemployment. There was also a duty on imported slates. Short of simply telling the people that they would have to use slates, willy nilly, for the roofing of houses, I do not see what more we could have done.
Comment on this
Naturally that is one of the penalties we have to pay for certain advantages. If the slate industry has been affected in consequence of the utilisation of tiles, it must be remembered that the use of tiles has made houses cheaper for the people.
Comment on this
For the time being. If the time comes when artificial tiles are as dear as slates, and when it becomes economic to reopen slate quarries, they will be reopened. One other factor which Deputy Murphy mentioned as being responsible for the closing down of the West Cork slate quarries was the fact that they had an export market formerly and had lost it. Of course that export market ceased, but what can we do about it, or what can anybody do about it? If people in Glasgow who used Irish slates for the roofing of houses are no longer building, how can the responsibility be fastened on us? You may say that we should have done something, but is there any Deputy on the Labour Benches who can tell us, if an export market falls off, and if our customers outside the country for one reason or another do not want to purchase our commodities, what alternative we have? We cannot coerce our former customers. The sooner people face up to that fact, the better for themselves.
What I have said in relation to slates applies also to cut granite. There was a time here when cut stone was largely used for building, but the expense of building out of cut stone has increased so enormously that you cannot even get it around Dublin or anywhere else, whereas 60 or 70 years ago stone was very largely used for the building of ordinary private dwellinghouses. Again I ask, what are we going to do in a situation like that? To come back to what I said at the beginning, if costs in any industry, for any reason, are driven up so high that the people stop buying, what remedy is there for it, whether you are buying transport, buying slates or buying granite? Instead of coming and complaining because certain factors have made the position what it is, those who are interested in, and intimately acquainted with, those matters ought to try and put their heads together and see how the few natural resources which we once had in this country, and which were of economic value to the community, can be made worth while to the community again. That is a fundamental problem in this whole matter. When we see our slates and granite dying out, when we see even our export trade in beer and spirits dying out, what are we going to do?
Deputy Davin referred to the fact that the maltings at Mountmellick were being closed. Why? Because the output of the brewery on which those maltings depend has been dwindling. If there is no custom for your trade and no custom for your commodities, what are you going to do about it? This idea that everything in the world is going to be cured by a subsidy cannot be applied at any rate to the brewing industry, because even Deputy Davin, I think, has strong views on the encouragement of temperance.
Comment on this
Well, I think they are stronger than mine might be. But again, is not that the foundation of the whole matter? What are we going to do if, as I have said, our export market falls off for a number of things and if our internal market falls off for them? We cannot go on, and no concern can be expected to go on maintaining uneconomic factors in its production. Otherwise it is going to perish. This country cannot remain static. Our producers, who have to produce for a competitive market, must get a chance in relation to that market, if we are even to preserve the remains of our industries here, let alone start to develop them. That is one of the facts which I would like Deputy Davin to turn over in his mind. While I feel like him for the position of those who are thrown out of employment by reason of what has happened at Mountmellick or elsewhere, nevertheless the only thing we can do, instead of going along and getting the Government to try and do something which in the nature of things it would not be justified in doing, is to see what use can be made out of the small grant which has been offered to the people who are engaged in that industry. I have said, a small amount, but it was some thousands of pounds, and if Deputy Davin is interested in the matter he should try and see whether the £6,000 could not be employed reproductively, even in Mountmellick. I think it would be much better to take that line of approach to a problem of this sort than to ask me to make representations where I know representations would be vain and useless, because the people who are responsible for maintaining that great undertaking which gives employment within the City of Dublin to thousands of people as well as to thousands through the country districts have decided that they must close the Mountmellick maltings.
Comment on this
It is not, but does it solve the problem to say that it is not the only one? Is it not far better to face up to what the facts are, when the demands for brewing and malting accommodation have been considerably reduced because of a change in the habits of our people, and because of the fact, perhaps, that their export trade is not as flourishing as it used to be?
Comment on this
Who put Park Royal there? Can the Deputy give me some way of bringing it back if the costs of production are to remain lower in Park Royal than they are in Dublin? Who is going to bring back Park Royal? Is not the sort of talk which we have had in this House for the last one and a half days going to make a few more Park Royals in relation to other industries in this country? It is because Park Royal is an omen and a warning to us that I have spoken on that aspect of the problem in the way in which I have to-day and why I have tried to insist on my view that the only future and the only hope for industrial progress in this country is along the lines of striving for increased output and increased efficiency in regard to all our productive industries. When we have solved that problem, when we are able here in our own country to face the competitor on fair terms and able to beat him, then we can say that the work of Arthur Griffith has been completed: that we have an Ireland in which her two arms, industry and agriculture, have been equally developed.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say what immediate further assistance is likely to be given to the people who are prepared to develop the coal resources of Wolfhill and Killeshin, and whether the promised legislation the Minister has referred to is likely to be introduced and passed before the end of the summer session?
Comment on this
In relation to the promised legislation, I am hoping to have it introduced and passed before the present session concludes. As regards the people to whom the Deputy has referred, the Government would expect them, if they are going into this thing as a business proposition, to put their own money into it, because they are going to get ordinary profit out of it. I certainly am not going to put Government money into it and allow them to get all the profit out of it. That is the beginning and the end of the situation so far as I am concerned. There have been grants of money given to some people to open up coal resources down there. I think that the grants already given were generous.
Comment on this
In another country this is the sort of work the private investor would have to undertake at his own expense.
Comment on this
In this atmosphere, I think the Minister should extend his generosity to North Cork.
Comment on this
I will look into the question of the Cork mines, which the Deputy referred to, later. In relation to the Mines and Minerals Act, I want to say that it is essential that the Bill should go through before we can foster any large scale development of coal mining in this country, and I hope, as I have said, to be able to get the Bill through before the end of this session.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether the proposed legislation is to be an amendment of the Mines and Minerals Act?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the miners in Castlecomer offered arbitration before the men ceased work? Is he also aware that, while the price of coal has been increased by 3/6 per ton, the men are receiving 2/8 per ton less than they had before the increase went on?
Comment on this
I am not aware of that. My information is not that the men offered arbitration, but that they asked for a conference, and the owners said that there was no prospect of a conference being of any use on the basis on which it was asked.
Comment on this
I am officially informed by the men themselves that they offered arbitration before they ceased work, and that they are now getting 2/8 a ton less at a time when the coal is 3/6 a ton more to the consumer, in other words, that there is an advantage of 6/2 a ton to the owners now as compared with the position in 1938-that they offered arbitration and it would not be accepted.
Comment on this
If it is the case that the men are prepared to submit the matter to arbitration, will the Minister use the offices of his Department in an endeavour to secure a settlement?
Comment on this
Will the Minister hold out any hope of an immediate settlement? I want to tell the Minister that there is a very serious shortage of coal.
Comment on this
How would the Deputy like to have it settled? Would he like to have the price of coal dearer?
Comment on this
My information is that the price of coal has been fixed by the Prices Commission, and that there has been no increase in the price that would justify a departure from the existing wage agreement.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That the Estimate be referred back for re-consideration."
Do you agree with this result?
I move:—
That the Estimate be reduced by £14,238 in respect of sub-head K.
In proposing this amendment, I wish to point out that it only serves to bring out the extraordinary similarities between the functions of the Minister for Supplies and those of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I do not want to go into the similarities between the two Ministries but, apparently, they have divided the functions of the Prices Commission between them, and the part that is retained by the Minister for Industry and Commerce is that of an inquiry into an alteration in tariffs. I understand that that is the only function retained by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and that all other matters, under the Prices Commission, come within the scope of the Minister for Supplies. Now, earlier in the debate I raised a point—and I raised it purposely, because it seemed to run in and out between the Minister for Supplies and the Minister for Industry and Commerce—that a major blunder had been made by the Government, in their industrial policy, in not tying up, with the process of manufacture, the proper linking up of the distributing part of the trade. I do not wish to enlarge on the case I have already adverted to, namely, that the distributing trade, in certain cases, had been handed over to the control of a manufacturer who had been brought in here and supported by heavy tariffs. I also mentioned that the reason why the Government should take notice of that was that, in the old days, the distributor had the remedy in his own hands; but now, through Government action, it behoves them to see that what they have given to one section of the community they have not given to another.
One of the things that strikes one in connection with the sub-head about which I have put down this motion is that it is very possible that there will be no inquiries this year and, consequently, no expense. Yet, there is a whole paraphernalia here with regard to officials, such as the chairman, principal officer, secretary, technical adviser, superintending officers, higher executive officers, senior inspector, junior executive officers, accounts and costing investigators, and so on. I suppose that the Minister may reply to me to the effect that that is part of the whole Prices Commission, and that that is the part he took over, and that it really does not matter whether it is put under the head of Industry and Commerce or of Supplies.
Comment on this
That is not the explanation. The explanation is that the formal transfer of these functions to the Minister of Supplies only took place recently, although, in fact, he has been operating these functions since his Ministry was set up.
Comment on this
Well, if that is the position, I take it that that sub-head, in so far as it affects industry and supplies, will be radically altered?
Comment on this
Yes; the provision now in my Estimate for these will be transferred to the Vote for Supplies.
Comment on this
Well, if the functions are going to be less, then, presumably, there will be less on the Minister's Vote?
Comment on this
There will be an allocation of these expenses, in due course, as between one Vote and another.
Comment on this
My point was to see how far the Minister, or the Ministers, feel that they have any responsibility to set right the position that has been created in the distributing trade. I suppose one could argue the matter from the point of view of the pure question of finance, and I am satisfied, from the Minister's statement, that there is going to be some transfer, but I am interested to find out how far any investigation could be undertaken, or how far any alleviation could be given by either one Minister or the other, along the lines I have suggested, without having to chase the two Ministers with the same energy that I have had to use in chasing them in this connection, because, remember, I was, so to speak, thrown out by one Minister and told to go to the other, and so on.
Comment on this
Yes, it was; but in the interval you have changed clothes, so to speak, and it is only Providence that, having raised the matter with the Minister for Supplies, I was told that he had not yet assumed his official garments, and that, having raised it with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, he said that he had divested himself of them. At any rate, between the two I was left out in the cold. The distributing trade in certain industries has a grievance. I should like to know whether, provided a case is made, the Minister will take an interest in it, or whether it is a question for the Minister for Supplies. I want the Minister when replying to pay attention to this point: whether the question I have raised is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Supplies. The grievance of the distributing trade might legitimately arise under either of the headings. It might arise as the result of an investigation into the price of a commodity or an investigation into a tariff.
Comment on this
I think that if the Deputy had come to me before he put down this motion, we might have had a more useful discussion. So far as I can follow him, what the Deputy is concerned about is the internal arrangements which are made by the producers in relation to their distributing agencies. Am I right in that?
Comment on this
Yes, the terms which are offered, shall we say, by the producers to the internal distributing agencies, the agencies which formerly used to distribute largely, I should say, imported commodities. I am not certain that a matter of that sort could come for review before the Prices Commission. At first sight, it seems to me that it would not. If the Deputy would permit me to look into the matter, I will communicate with him, and let him know what I think is the right line to take. It may possibly be a responsibility of my Department rather than a responsibility of the Department of Supplies.